8/13/2019 Critique & Rebuttal

1/2

"#$%&'(

")$&(

!"#$#%&'*+, -./ -01/2 3+ 4.5356,/ 37/ 8./0/93-35+9 :+, -./ -;+,3 3+ 7/-.< =>-?59/ :+, +9 - 4+>>533// 3+ -@-.2

A,9259? A+. ./0/-.47B -92 37/ ?.+,8 ;/A+./ :+, 50 4+>8/359? A+. 37-3 >+9/:< =9 +.2/. 3+ C,2?/

5>8-.35-DD:B :+, +83 3+ 4+>8D/3/ 37/ A+DD+@59? A+.>E

) *+, -../, 0 1/,.*-23 !"#$%&'()* , -(./01')F G7-3 6,/035+9 -92 3+854 2+/0 37/ ./0/-.47 ?.+,8 -22./00 59 37/5.

03-350354-D 03,2:H

2.03'*/F G7-3 0->8D59? >/37+20 -./ />8D+:/2 59 37/ @+.1 -92 -./ 37/./ -9: 8+3/935-D

0+,.4/0 +A ;5-0H

4 *+, *,.* 456'03././F G7-3 -./ 37/ 9,DD -92 -D3/.9-3/ 7:8+37/0/0 +A 37/ 03,2:B /I8./00/2 59 0:>;+D54

A+.> 59 3/.>0 +A 37/ ./D/J-93 8-.->/3/.H

7"81*105 '9 03. :./0F K52 37/ ./0/-.47/.0 /03-;D507 37/ -88.+8.5-3/9/00 +A 37/ >+2/D ,0/2 3+

3/03 37/ 7:8+37/050H

5 *+, 6, -.-23 0 23 7/.-23 ;./(80/ , 37/ +88+.3,953: 3+ 4+>8D/3/ 37/5. 8./0/93-35+9 ;/A+./ -0159? 6,/035+905959? A+.

-90@/.0 3+ 37/ -A+./>/935+9/2 6,/035+90T ./>/>;/.B :+, -./ -DD U/I8/.30V 9+@E

8/13/2019 Critique & Rebuttal

2/2

"#$%&'(

")$&(

8'9&$$:;=>-?59/ 37-3 :+, -92 :+,. 3/-> -./ 59 0/.5+,0 4+93/935+9 A+. 37/ A,9259?< R7/ 4+>>533// 7-0

./3,.9/2 37/5. 4.5356,/0 +A :+,. @+.1 -92 ?5J/9 :+, 37/ +88+.3,953: 3+ 500,/ - ./;,33-D< *+,

/-47 3-1/ +9 - 8+.35+9 +A 37/ 4.5356,/0 3+ -00/00 37/5. -44,.-4: ;/A+./ 8,3359? A+.37 - A+.>-D

./8D:E

) *+, -../, 0 1/,.*-23 !"#$%&'()* , -(./01')F K52 37/ 4+>>533// 4+../43D: 52/935A: 37/ 3+854 -92 530 4+93/I3H

2.03'*/F K52 37/ 4+>>533// 52/935A: 37/ >/37+20 />8D+:/2H K52 37/: -419+@D/2?/ :+,.

2504D+0,./ +A 0+,.4/0 +A ;5-0H

4 *+, *,.* 456'03././F K52 37/ 4+>>533// ,92/.03-92 37/ 9,DD -92 -D3/.9-3/ 7:8+37/0/0 ;: /I8./0059?

37/> 59 37/ 4+../43 0:>;+D54 A+.>H

7"81*105 '9 03. :./0F K52 37/ 4+>>533// >-1/ 9+3/ +A 37/ 03-3/2 -00,>835+90 +A 37/ 03-350354-D

3/03H

5 *+, 6, -.-23 0 23 7/.-23 ;./(80/ , >533// ,92/.03-92 37/ 8.-4354-D 05?95A54-94/

+A 37/ +,34+>/ -92 7+@ 37/ A59259?0 +A 37/ 03,2: ./D-3/ 3+ 37/ 3+854H

8'>533//B :+, 07+,D2 0,>>-.5W/ -92 -.354,D-3/ :+,. -00/00>/93

+A 37/5. 4.5356,/0B 45359? -9: 2504./8-945/0 :+, A592 -92 4+../435+90 +. 4D-.5A54-35+90 :+, 2//>/00/935-D< R7/ ./8D: 07+,D2 ;/ 0,445943B :/3 4+>8D/3/