Upload
xinto
View
112
Download
3
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
This is a powerpoint presentation done with another student, Patricia Hiller that discusses the issue of: Is There a Crisis in the Education of Boys?
Citation preview
By Joseph BergerImage: The New York Times, May 16, 2007
Juan Jacinto Hernandez - Patricia H. Hiller ED 7511 - Issue 23
aha! Process, Inc. – Video – Yes, An Apparent Ruby
Payne Disciple
Juan Jacinto Hernandez - Patricia H. Hiller ED 7511 - Issue 23
Juan Jacinto Hernandez - Patricia H. Hiller ED 7511 - Issue 23
DISCUSSION – Gurian & Stevens Boy Friendly Classrooms?
Boys: More impulsive,
Increased spatial,abstract &
Mechanical functioning,Less oxytocin (primary human
bonding chemical),Compartmentalize learning,
Rest states (prefer fewer words),Need more physical space,
Need to move around, Create more noise,
Spatial techniques to draw out “feelings”
Girls: 15% more blood flowto areas of the brain,
Verbal-emotiveBetter listening skills, More detailed writing,
More adept at Language Arts,Adept at multitasking,
Recharge w/o rest states,Need to see relevance of
Becoming Tech-savvy
Michael Gurian
Kathy StevensThe Gurian
Institute
Yes! Check out the Stats!
Juan Jacinto Hernandez - Patricia H. Hiller ED 7511 - Issue 23
DISCUSSION – Mead What is the bigger issue?
1. Race & socio-economic issues the big issue.2. Interpreting test results too complicated;
• Few constant measures to individual achievement• Tests are too new
3. Respected test: National Assessment of Educational Progress(NAEP), “The Nation’s Report Card (US Dept of Education)” • Only way to measure national trends in boy/girl performances.• Does not support that “boys’ academic achievement is falling.”
• Grades 4-8 – improved; Grades 9-12 – not so clear• Race factor: Whites 10x more successful than
Blacks & Hispanics (low, but not getting worse)
Sara MeadNew America Foundation
Juan Jacinto Hernandez - Patricia H. Hiller ED 7511 - Issue 23
No! Check These Out!
SOURCE: National Center for Education Statistics GRAPHIC: The Washington Post - June 26, 2006
Juan Jacinto Hernandez - Patricia H. Hiller ED 7511 - Issue 23
Questions from Gurian and Stevens Article
What are the benefits of teachers receiving training in the differences in male/female brains? [See p. 427: Nature- based approach]
Is the fact that there are more female teachers in public schools having a bearing on the statistics given? [See p. 426: “Who’s Failing?” Major factor for failure: reading/writing scores]
Juan Jacinto Hernandez - Patricia H. Hiller ED 7511 - Issue 23
What role does ethnicity and socio-economic roles – race & class - play in boys’ educational accomplishments? [See p. 436: “We Should Be Worried About Some Subgroups of Boys” and “The Source of the Boy Crisis…”]
Is there a hidden agenda by conservatives to derail feminism and progressive education? Why or why not? [See p. 440-441: “A number of conservative authors…”]
Questions from Mead Article
Juan Jacinto Hernandez - Patricia H. Hiller ED 7511 - Issue 23
Additional QuestionsIs there a correlation between poor
academic performance among black, Hispanic and impoverished boys and the absence of fathers in the home?
Are there any other participant questions related to this issue?
Discussion/ConclusionJuan Jacinto Hernandez - Patricia H. Hiller ED 7511 - Issue 23