Upload
others
View
7
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
COVID-19 Trials Designs and Tools
for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 1
1 2 3 4 5
The webinar will begin shortly
Panel and presentation order
4272020 Cytel Inc 2
Edward Mills - (Moderator) SVP Cytel
Srinivas Murthy - Critical Care Physician University of British Columbia
amp Co-Chair SOLIDARITY trial from WHO
Craig Rayner - President Integrated Drug Development Certara
Louis Dron - Director Cytel
Kristian Thorlund - SVP Cytel
Randomized Embedded Multifactorial Adaptive
Platform trial for Community-Acquired Pneumonia
Srinivas Murthy
University of British Columbia
Outcomes
Int A1
Int A2
Int A3hellip5
Antibiotic trial
Outcomes
Int B1
Int B2
Macrolide trial
Traditional RCTs ndash serial testing of single hypotheses
REMAP ndash a self-learning system
Randomized Embedded Multifactorial Adaptive Platform
Int C1
Int C2
Steroid usetrial
Outcomes
Empiric antibiotic
Macrolide duration
Steroid use plan
OutcomesEligibility
Adaptive Randomisation
Over 50 sites in 13 countries
wwwremapcaporg
REMAP-CAP
bull Randomisedbull Rather than random clinician choice
bull Embeddedbull Recruitment by clinical staff (and or research coordinators)bull Deliver intervention using usual clinical processes
bull Multifactorialbull Simultaneously assess different aspects of treatment
bull Adaptivebull Frequent Bayesian adaptive analysesbull Response adaptive randomizationbull Add subtract domains and intervention
bull Platform Trialbull All ICU patients with CAP included
Pandemic Appendix to Core Protocol
bullPandemic strata designed as a sleeping stratabull Activated by the REMAP-CAP trial steering committee
13 March 2020
bullActivation of Pandemic Strata results in a number of changes to
bull Eligibility criteria
bull Primary end-point
bull Statistical model
bull Frequency of RAR
bull New pandemic-specific domains
Changes to eligibility
Does the patient have clinically suspected or proven pandemic infection
bull Clinically suspected = treating clinician believes that pandemic infection is a likely diagnosis
bull That testing is being done is not sufficient must think pandemic infection is likely
bull Response to this question drives a number of changes to eligibility CRF randomization and primary end-point
bull Suspected or proven hospital-acquired pandemic infection are eligible
Changed definitions
ICU
bull During a pandemic an ICU is defined as an area that is capable of providing ICU-level carebull [NIV with a sealed mask] invasive mechanical ventilation or
vasopressors via continuous infusion
bull Existing wards which provide sealed mask NIV which do not have expanded capabilities do not qualify
bull May be a physical ICU or an area not usually designated as an ICU which has been re-purposed
Primary end-point
Days alive and out of ICU at Day 21
bull Censored at hospital discharge (no need to follow-up after hospital discharge until usual D90)
Statistical Model
bull Domains considered relevant to the pandemic are analyzed using a separate statistical model
bull RAR occurs separately for patients with and without pandemic infection
PISOP patients = Pandemic Infection Suspected or ProvenPINSNP patients = Pandemic Infection Neither Suspected Nor Proven
Analysis and RAR during pandemic
bull Statistical model evaluates all pandemic domainsbull Evaluates patients who are confirmed COVID-19
and not confirmed COVID-19 separately with borrowing between stratum as appropriate
bull Reduction in statistical trigger from 099 to 095 probability of superiority
bull RAR driven off confirmed COVID-19 for future suspected and confirmed patients
bull Assesses safety in suspected patients who turn out to be non-COVID patients
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Panel and presentation order
4272020 Cytel Inc 2
Edward Mills - (Moderator) SVP Cytel
Srinivas Murthy - Critical Care Physician University of British Columbia
amp Co-Chair SOLIDARITY trial from WHO
Craig Rayner - President Integrated Drug Development Certara
Louis Dron - Director Cytel
Kristian Thorlund - SVP Cytel
Randomized Embedded Multifactorial Adaptive
Platform trial for Community-Acquired Pneumonia
Srinivas Murthy
University of British Columbia
Outcomes
Int A1
Int A2
Int A3hellip5
Antibiotic trial
Outcomes
Int B1
Int B2
Macrolide trial
Traditional RCTs ndash serial testing of single hypotheses
REMAP ndash a self-learning system
Randomized Embedded Multifactorial Adaptive Platform
Int C1
Int C2
Steroid usetrial
Outcomes
Empiric antibiotic
Macrolide duration
Steroid use plan
OutcomesEligibility
Adaptive Randomisation
Over 50 sites in 13 countries
wwwremapcaporg
REMAP-CAP
bull Randomisedbull Rather than random clinician choice
bull Embeddedbull Recruitment by clinical staff (and or research coordinators)bull Deliver intervention using usual clinical processes
bull Multifactorialbull Simultaneously assess different aspects of treatment
bull Adaptivebull Frequent Bayesian adaptive analysesbull Response adaptive randomizationbull Add subtract domains and intervention
bull Platform Trialbull All ICU patients with CAP included
Pandemic Appendix to Core Protocol
bullPandemic strata designed as a sleeping stratabull Activated by the REMAP-CAP trial steering committee
13 March 2020
bullActivation of Pandemic Strata results in a number of changes to
bull Eligibility criteria
bull Primary end-point
bull Statistical model
bull Frequency of RAR
bull New pandemic-specific domains
Changes to eligibility
Does the patient have clinically suspected or proven pandemic infection
bull Clinically suspected = treating clinician believes that pandemic infection is a likely diagnosis
bull That testing is being done is not sufficient must think pandemic infection is likely
bull Response to this question drives a number of changes to eligibility CRF randomization and primary end-point
bull Suspected or proven hospital-acquired pandemic infection are eligible
Changed definitions
ICU
bull During a pandemic an ICU is defined as an area that is capable of providing ICU-level carebull [NIV with a sealed mask] invasive mechanical ventilation or
vasopressors via continuous infusion
bull Existing wards which provide sealed mask NIV which do not have expanded capabilities do not qualify
bull May be a physical ICU or an area not usually designated as an ICU which has been re-purposed
Primary end-point
Days alive and out of ICU at Day 21
bull Censored at hospital discharge (no need to follow-up after hospital discharge until usual D90)
Statistical Model
bull Domains considered relevant to the pandemic are analyzed using a separate statistical model
bull RAR occurs separately for patients with and without pandemic infection
PISOP patients = Pandemic Infection Suspected or ProvenPINSNP patients = Pandemic Infection Neither Suspected Nor Proven
Analysis and RAR during pandemic
bull Statistical model evaluates all pandemic domainsbull Evaluates patients who are confirmed COVID-19
and not confirmed COVID-19 separately with borrowing between stratum as appropriate
bull Reduction in statistical trigger from 099 to 095 probability of superiority
bull RAR driven off confirmed COVID-19 for future suspected and confirmed patients
bull Assesses safety in suspected patients who turn out to be non-COVID patients
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Randomized Embedded Multifactorial Adaptive
Platform trial for Community-Acquired Pneumonia
Srinivas Murthy
University of British Columbia
Outcomes
Int A1
Int A2
Int A3hellip5
Antibiotic trial
Outcomes
Int B1
Int B2
Macrolide trial
Traditional RCTs ndash serial testing of single hypotheses
REMAP ndash a self-learning system
Randomized Embedded Multifactorial Adaptive Platform
Int C1
Int C2
Steroid usetrial
Outcomes
Empiric antibiotic
Macrolide duration
Steroid use plan
OutcomesEligibility
Adaptive Randomisation
Over 50 sites in 13 countries
wwwremapcaporg
REMAP-CAP
bull Randomisedbull Rather than random clinician choice
bull Embeddedbull Recruitment by clinical staff (and or research coordinators)bull Deliver intervention using usual clinical processes
bull Multifactorialbull Simultaneously assess different aspects of treatment
bull Adaptivebull Frequent Bayesian adaptive analysesbull Response adaptive randomizationbull Add subtract domains and intervention
bull Platform Trialbull All ICU patients with CAP included
Pandemic Appendix to Core Protocol
bullPandemic strata designed as a sleeping stratabull Activated by the REMAP-CAP trial steering committee
13 March 2020
bullActivation of Pandemic Strata results in a number of changes to
bull Eligibility criteria
bull Primary end-point
bull Statistical model
bull Frequency of RAR
bull New pandemic-specific domains
Changes to eligibility
Does the patient have clinically suspected or proven pandemic infection
bull Clinically suspected = treating clinician believes that pandemic infection is a likely diagnosis
bull That testing is being done is not sufficient must think pandemic infection is likely
bull Response to this question drives a number of changes to eligibility CRF randomization and primary end-point
bull Suspected or proven hospital-acquired pandemic infection are eligible
Changed definitions
ICU
bull During a pandemic an ICU is defined as an area that is capable of providing ICU-level carebull [NIV with a sealed mask] invasive mechanical ventilation or
vasopressors via continuous infusion
bull Existing wards which provide sealed mask NIV which do not have expanded capabilities do not qualify
bull May be a physical ICU or an area not usually designated as an ICU which has been re-purposed
Primary end-point
Days alive and out of ICU at Day 21
bull Censored at hospital discharge (no need to follow-up after hospital discharge until usual D90)
Statistical Model
bull Domains considered relevant to the pandemic are analyzed using a separate statistical model
bull RAR occurs separately for patients with and without pandemic infection
PISOP patients = Pandemic Infection Suspected or ProvenPINSNP patients = Pandemic Infection Neither Suspected Nor Proven
Analysis and RAR during pandemic
bull Statistical model evaluates all pandemic domainsbull Evaluates patients who are confirmed COVID-19
and not confirmed COVID-19 separately with borrowing between stratum as appropriate
bull Reduction in statistical trigger from 099 to 095 probability of superiority
bull RAR driven off confirmed COVID-19 for future suspected and confirmed patients
bull Assesses safety in suspected patients who turn out to be non-COVID patients
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Outcomes
Int A1
Int A2
Int A3hellip5
Antibiotic trial
Outcomes
Int B1
Int B2
Macrolide trial
Traditional RCTs ndash serial testing of single hypotheses
REMAP ndash a self-learning system
Randomized Embedded Multifactorial Adaptive Platform
Int C1
Int C2
Steroid usetrial
Outcomes
Empiric antibiotic
Macrolide duration
Steroid use plan
OutcomesEligibility
Adaptive Randomisation
Over 50 sites in 13 countries
wwwremapcaporg
REMAP-CAP
bull Randomisedbull Rather than random clinician choice
bull Embeddedbull Recruitment by clinical staff (and or research coordinators)bull Deliver intervention using usual clinical processes
bull Multifactorialbull Simultaneously assess different aspects of treatment
bull Adaptivebull Frequent Bayesian adaptive analysesbull Response adaptive randomizationbull Add subtract domains and intervention
bull Platform Trialbull All ICU patients with CAP included
Pandemic Appendix to Core Protocol
bullPandemic strata designed as a sleeping stratabull Activated by the REMAP-CAP trial steering committee
13 March 2020
bullActivation of Pandemic Strata results in a number of changes to
bull Eligibility criteria
bull Primary end-point
bull Statistical model
bull Frequency of RAR
bull New pandemic-specific domains
Changes to eligibility
Does the patient have clinically suspected or proven pandemic infection
bull Clinically suspected = treating clinician believes that pandemic infection is a likely diagnosis
bull That testing is being done is not sufficient must think pandemic infection is likely
bull Response to this question drives a number of changes to eligibility CRF randomization and primary end-point
bull Suspected or proven hospital-acquired pandemic infection are eligible
Changed definitions
ICU
bull During a pandemic an ICU is defined as an area that is capable of providing ICU-level carebull [NIV with a sealed mask] invasive mechanical ventilation or
vasopressors via continuous infusion
bull Existing wards which provide sealed mask NIV which do not have expanded capabilities do not qualify
bull May be a physical ICU or an area not usually designated as an ICU which has been re-purposed
Primary end-point
Days alive and out of ICU at Day 21
bull Censored at hospital discharge (no need to follow-up after hospital discharge until usual D90)
Statistical Model
bull Domains considered relevant to the pandemic are analyzed using a separate statistical model
bull RAR occurs separately for patients with and without pandemic infection
PISOP patients = Pandemic Infection Suspected or ProvenPINSNP patients = Pandemic Infection Neither Suspected Nor Proven
Analysis and RAR during pandemic
bull Statistical model evaluates all pandemic domainsbull Evaluates patients who are confirmed COVID-19
and not confirmed COVID-19 separately with borrowing between stratum as appropriate
bull Reduction in statistical trigger from 099 to 095 probability of superiority
bull RAR driven off confirmed COVID-19 for future suspected and confirmed patients
bull Assesses safety in suspected patients who turn out to be non-COVID patients
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Over 50 sites in 13 countries
wwwremapcaporg
REMAP-CAP
bull Randomisedbull Rather than random clinician choice
bull Embeddedbull Recruitment by clinical staff (and or research coordinators)bull Deliver intervention using usual clinical processes
bull Multifactorialbull Simultaneously assess different aspects of treatment
bull Adaptivebull Frequent Bayesian adaptive analysesbull Response adaptive randomizationbull Add subtract domains and intervention
bull Platform Trialbull All ICU patients with CAP included
Pandemic Appendix to Core Protocol
bullPandemic strata designed as a sleeping stratabull Activated by the REMAP-CAP trial steering committee
13 March 2020
bullActivation of Pandemic Strata results in a number of changes to
bull Eligibility criteria
bull Primary end-point
bull Statistical model
bull Frequency of RAR
bull New pandemic-specific domains
Changes to eligibility
Does the patient have clinically suspected or proven pandemic infection
bull Clinically suspected = treating clinician believes that pandemic infection is a likely diagnosis
bull That testing is being done is not sufficient must think pandemic infection is likely
bull Response to this question drives a number of changes to eligibility CRF randomization and primary end-point
bull Suspected or proven hospital-acquired pandemic infection are eligible
Changed definitions
ICU
bull During a pandemic an ICU is defined as an area that is capable of providing ICU-level carebull [NIV with a sealed mask] invasive mechanical ventilation or
vasopressors via continuous infusion
bull Existing wards which provide sealed mask NIV which do not have expanded capabilities do not qualify
bull May be a physical ICU or an area not usually designated as an ICU which has been re-purposed
Primary end-point
Days alive and out of ICU at Day 21
bull Censored at hospital discharge (no need to follow-up after hospital discharge until usual D90)
Statistical Model
bull Domains considered relevant to the pandemic are analyzed using a separate statistical model
bull RAR occurs separately for patients with and without pandemic infection
PISOP patients = Pandemic Infection Suspected or ProvenPINSNP patients = Pandemic Infection Neither Suspected Nor Proven
Analysis and RAR during pandemic
bull Statistical model evaluates all pandemic domainsbull Evaluates patients who are confirmed COVID-19
and not confirmed COVID-19 separately with borrowing between stratum as appropriate
bull Reduction in statistical trigger from 099 to 095 probability of superiority
bull RAR driven off confirmed COVID-19 for future suspected and confirmed patients
bull Assesses safety in suspected patients who turn out to be non-COVID patients
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
REMAP-CAP
bull Randomisedbull Rather than random clinician choice
bull Embeddedbull Recruitment by clinical staff (and or research coordinators)bull Deliver intervention using usual clinical processes
bull Multifactorialbull Simultaneously assess different aspects of treatment
bull Adaptivebull Frequent Bayesian adaptive analysesbull Response adaptive randomizationbull Add subtract domains and intervention
bull Platform Trialbull All ICU patients with CAP included
Pandemic Appendix to Core Protocol
bullPandemic strata designed as a sleeping stratabull Activated by the REMAP-CAP trial steering committee
13 March 2020
bullActivation of Pandemic Strata results in a number of changes to
bull Eligibility criteria
bull Primary end-point
bull Statistical model
bull Frequency of RAR
bull New pandemic-specific domains
Changes to eligibility
Does the patient have clinically suspected or proven pandemic infection
bull Clinically suspected = treating clinician believes that pandemic infection is a likely diagnosis
bull That testing is being done is not sufficient must think pandemic infection is likely
bull Response to this question drives a number of changes to eligibility CRF randomization and primary end-point
bull Suspected or proven hospital-acquired pandemic infection are eligible
Changed definitions
ICU
bull During a pandemic an ICU is defined as an area that is capable of providing ICU-level carebull [NIV with a sealed mask] invasive mechanical ventilation or
vasopressors via continuous infusion
bull Existing wards which provide sealed mask NIV which do not have expanded capabilities do not qualify
bull May be a physical ICU or an area not usually designated as an ICU which has been re-purposed
Primary end-point
Days alive and out of ICU at Day 21
bull Censored at hospital discharge (no need to follow-up after hospital discharge until usual D90)
Statistical Model
bull Domains considered relevant to the pandemic are analyzed using a separate statistical model
bull RAR occurs separately for patients with and without pandemic infection
PISOP patients = Pandemic Infection Suspected or ProvenPINSNP patients = Pandemic Infection Neither Suspected Nor Proven
Analysis and RAR during pandemic
bull Statistical model evaluates all pandemic domainsbull Evaluates patients who are confirmed COVID-19
and not confirmed COVID-19 separately with borrowing between stratum as appropriate
bull Reduction in statistical trigger from 099 to 095 probability of superiority
bull RAR driven off confirmed COVID-19 for future suspected and confirmed patients
bull Assesses safety in suspected patients who turn out to be non-COVID patients
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Pandemic Appendix to Core Protocol
bullPandemic strata designed as a sleeping stratabull Activated by the REMAP-CAP trial steering committee
13 March 2020
bullActivation of Pandemic Strata results in a number of changes to
bull Eligibility criteria
bull Primary end-point
bull Statistical model
bull Frequency of RAR
bull New pandemic-specific domains
Changes to eligibility
Does the patient have clinically suspected or proven pandemic infection
bull Clinically suspected = treating clinician believes that pandemic infection is a likely diagnosis
bull That testing is being done is not sufficient must think pandemic infection is likely
bull Response to this question drives a number of changes to eligibility CRF randomization and primary end-point
bull Suspected or proven hospital-acquired pandemic infection are eligible
Changed definitions
ICU
bull During a pandemic an ICU is defined as an area that is capable of providing ICU-level carebull [NIV with a sealed mask] invasive mechanical ventilation or
vasopressors via continuous infusion
bull Existing wards which provide sealed mask NIV which do not have expanded capabilities do not qualify
bull May be a physical ICU or an area not usually designated as an ICU which has been re-purposed
Primary end-point
Days alive and out of ICU at Day 21
bull Censored at hospital discharge (no need to follow-up after hospital discharge until usual D90)
Statistical Model
bull Domains considered relevant to the pandemic are analyzed using a separate statistical model
bull RAR occurs separately for patients with and without pandemic infection
PISOP patients = Pandemic Infection Suspected or ProvenPINSNP patients = Pandemic Infection Neither Suspected Nor Proven
Analysis and RAR during pandemic
bull Statistical model evaluates all pandemic domainsbull Evaluates patients who are confirmed COVID-19
and not confirmed COVID-19 separately with borrowing between stratum as appropriate
bull Reduction in statistical trigger from 099 to 095 probability of superiority
bull RAR driven off confirmed COVID-19 for future suspected and confirmed patients
bull Assesses safety in suspected patients who turn out to be non-COVID patients
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Changes to eligibility
Does the patient have clinically suspected or proven pandemic infection
bull Clinically suspected = treating clinician believes that pandemic infection is a likely diagnosis
bull That testing is being done is not sufficient must think pandemic infection is likely
bull Response to this question drives a number of changes to eligibility CRF randomization and primary end-point
bull Suspected or proven hospital-acquired pandemic infection are eligible
Changed definitions
ICU
bull During a pandemic an ICU is defined as an area that is capable of providing ICU-level carebull [NIV with a sealed mask] invasive mechanical ventilation or
vasopressors via continuous infusion
bull Existing wards which provide sealed mask NIV which do not have expanded capabilities do not qualify
bull May be a physical ICU or an area not usually designated as an ICU which has been re-purposed
Primary end-point
Days alive and out of ICU at Day 21
bull Censored at hospital discharge (no need to follow-up after hospital discharge until usual D90)
Statistical Model
bull Domains considered relevant to the pandemic are analyzed using a separate statistical model
bull RAR occurs separately for patients with and without pandemic infection
PISOP patients = Pandemic Infection Suspected or ProvenPINSNP patients = Pandemic Infection Neither Suspected Nor Proven
Analysis and RAR during pandemic
bull Statistical model evaluates all pandemic domainsbull Evaluates patients who are confirmed COVID-19
and not confirmed COVID-19 separately with borrowing between stratum as appropriate
bull Reduction in statistical trigger from 099 to 095 probability of superiority
bull RAR driven off confirmed COVID-19 for future suspected and confirmed patients
bull Assesses safety in suspected patients who turn out to be non-COVID patients
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Changed definitions
ICU
bull During a pandemic an ICU is defined as an area that is capable of providing ICU-level carebull [NIV with a sealed mask] invasive mechanical ventilation or
vasopressors via continuous infusion
bull Existing wards which provide sealed mask NIV which do not have expanded capabilities do not qualify
bull May be a physical ICU or an area not usually designated as an ICU which has been re-purposed
Primary end-point
Days alive and out of ICU at Day 21
bull Censored at hospital discharge (no need to follow-up after hospital discharge until usual D90)
Statistical Model
bull Domains considered relevant to the pandemic are analyzed using a separate statistical model
bull RAR occurs separately for patients with and without pandemic infection
PISOP patients = Pandemic Infection Suspected or ProvenPINSNP patients = Pandemic Infection Neither Suspected Nor Proven
Analysis and RAR during pandemic
bull Statistical model evaluates all pandemic domainsbull Evaluates patients who are confirmed COVID-19
and not confirmed COVID-19 separately with borrowing between stratum as appropriate
bull Reduction in statistical trigger from 099 to 095 probability of superiority
bull RAR driven off confirmed COVID-19 for future suspected and confirmed patients
bull Assesses safety in suspected patients who turn out to be non-COVID patients
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Primary end-point
Days alive and out of ICU at Day 21
bull Censored at hospital discharge (no need to follow-up after hospital discharge until usual D90)
Statistical Model
bull Domains considered relevant to the pandemic are analyzed using a separate statistical model
bull RAR occurs separately for patients with and without pandemic infection
PISOP patients = Pandemic Infection Suspected or ProvenPINSNP patients = Pandemic Infection Neither Suspected Nor Proven
Analysis and RAR during pandemic
bull Statistical model evaluates all pandemic domainsbull Evaluates patients who are confirmed COVID-19
and not confirmed COVID-19 separately with borrowing between stratum as appropriate
bull Reduction in statistical trigger from 099 to 095 probability of superiority
bull RAR driven off confirmed COVID-19 for future suspected and confirmed patients
bull Assesses safety in suspected patients who turn out to be non-COVID patients
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Statistical Model
bull Domains considered relevant to the pandemic are analyzed using a separate statistical model
bull RAR occurs separately for patients with and without pandemic infection
PISOP patients = Pandemic Infection Suspected or ProvenPINSNP patients = Pandemic Infection Neither Suspected Nor Proven
Analysis and RAR during pandemic
bull Statistical model evaluates all pandemic domainsbull Evaluates patients who are confirmed COVID-19
and not confirmed COVID-19 separately with borrowing between stratum as appropriate
bull Reduction in statistical trigger from 099 to 095 probability of superiority
bull RAR driven off confirmed COVID-19 for future suspected and confirmed patients
bull Assesses safety in suspected patients who turn out to be non-COVID patients
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Analysis and RAR during pandemic
bull Statistical model evaluates all pandemic domainsbull Evaluates patients who are confirmed COVID-19
and not confirmed COVID-19 separately with borrowing between stratum as appropriate
bull Reduction in statistical trigger from 099 to 095 probability of superiority
bull RAR driven off confirmed COVID-19 for future suspected and confirmed patients
bull Assesses safety in suspected patients who turn out to be non-COVID patients
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Current Domains in pandemic model
bull Corticosteroid strategybull Sites can choose different set of interventions for
pandemic and non-pandemic patients
bull Macrolide durationbull Important given French uncontrolled case-seriesbull Only accessible if allocated to a beta-lactam + macrolide
combination in antibiotic domain
bull Can still get assignment for antibiotics and antiviral analyzed in non-pandemic statistical model
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
COVID-19 Specific Domains
bull COVID-19 Antiviral Domainbull No antiviral for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Lopinavirritonavir (ldquoKaletrardquo)
bull Hydroxychloroquine
bull COVID-19 Immune Modulation Domainbull No immune modulation for COVID-19 (no placebo)
bull Interferon-β-1a
bull Anakinra (Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist - not available at launch in all regions)
bull Tocilizumab + sarulumab in UK
bull COVID19 Anticoagulationbull Therapeutic Heparin
bull Routine thromboprophylaxis
bull Vitamin C
bull Convalescent Plasma
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Consent processes during pandemic
bull Have requested permission to use phone electronic confirmation of agreement to participate from person responsible
bull Verbal consent from participant if competent to consent
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Role of DSMB
bull Granted more flexibility
bull Can ask for additional analyses that might be relevant
bull Permitted to contact public health authorities direct with any information that they believe is important to public health response to COVID-19
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
REMAP-COVID
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
SOLIDARITY
ldquoMultiple small trials with different
methodologies may not give us the
clear strong evidence we need about
which treatments help to save livesrdquo ndash
Dr Tedros
March 18 2020
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
A global lsquomegatrialrsquo with the aim of enrolling (tens of) thousands of patients with a common analytic sethttpwwwisrctncomISRCTN83971151Population Hospitalized adults with confirmed COVID19Randomized to one of 1) Remdesivir + Optimized supportive care2) Hydroxychloroquine + Optimized supportive care3) Kaletra+ Optimized supportive care4) Kaletra + IFN-B1a + Optimized Supportive care5) Optimized supportive carePrimary outcome of hospital mortality
SOLIDARITY
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
bull No sample size
bull No pre-specified stopping rules
bull No pre-determined interim efficacy analyses
bull Embedded within care as much as possible
Data collected Baseline demographics Minimal baseline severity Drug given Outcome at discharge
Will adapt to new interventions as they become available Others dropped for harmfutility
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Mapping the evidence
4272020 Cytel Inc 22
1 2 3 4 5
Craig Rayner President Certara
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 24
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
The 5 Lessons Apply what we have learned from history
4272020 Cytel Inc 25
Know what weare up against
Begin with multiple audiences in mind
A strategy an integrated team amp agile implementation are essential
Smarter drug development is necessary to accelerate therapeutics
We must build and sustain collaboration and coordination
1 2 3 4 5
Refer to Accelerating Therapeutics for COVID-19 Webinar httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=aXpBjfemexQ
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Itrsquos like weather forecasting with global consequences
4272020 Cytel Inc 26
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
In the chaos of COVID-19 who is thinking about optimal dose regimen
4272020 Cytel Inc 27
Optimal dose regimen
- Every mg above optimal is less for others
- Every mg below optimal potential for resistance
Clinical translational and
quantitative pharmacology
is foundational to the
ldquosciencerdquo of dosing
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
2
8
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
C19 Peloton
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
Clinical Proof of Concept amp Dose Determination
Clinical Confirmation amp Real World Application
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
C19 Peloton Ivermectin
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
C19 Peloton Ivermectin is unlikely to be clinically effective
Pharmacology Plausibility amp Proof of Hope
IC50 gt21-fold lung tissue Cmax
Simulated concentrations in plasma
(black) and lung tissue (blue) following
ivermectin 600microgkg QD for 3days
Yeo K et al Antiviral Research 2020 (accepted)
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Improved ldquosamerdquo is not enough - Smarter drug development is
required to accelerate therapeutics for COVID-19
4272020 Cytel Inc
Make use of diverse approaches and evidence to drive faster and higher
quality decisions on optimal dose regimens for COVID-19
PKPD enriched HECT RCT run-in and Compassionate Use
PK to define dosing in subpops comorbidities DDI disease course
Pharmaco-epi models to explore impact on transmission
RWE registry examining associations on dose regimens
Many quant methods to ldquointerrogaterdquo gray data amp simulate scenarios
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Covid-19 clinical trials tracker
wwwcovid-trialsorg
4272020 Cytel Inc 34
Louis Dron Director Cytel
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
4272020 Cytel Inc 35
Global tracker wwwcovid-trialsorg
Global data
sources
Visualization
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
4272020wwwcovid-trialsorg
Cytel Inc36
Ways to filterhellip By included treatment(s)
By countries
Filtered data
download
By participant context
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
A fragmented landscape
4272020 Cytel Inc
bull ~50 of these trials are
investigating one intervention only
(2-arm trials) with sample size lt100
participants
bull Certain treatments are particularly
often investigated and repeated
bull For example chloroquine or
hydroxychloroquine (HCQ) features
as a treatment in 118 separate trials
0
50
100
150
200
10 or less 11 to 30 31 to 100 101 to250
251 to500
501 to1000
1000 ormore
To
tal n
um
ber
of
tria
ls
Anticipated sample size
Distribution of planned sample size
020406080
100120
232020 332020 432020
Cu
mu
lati
ve
tri
al
N
Date
Trials with HCQ
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Regions of interest ndash United States
38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative US trials over time
The United States is the country with the
second largest number of registered trials
at 77 (with 47 trials actively recruiting)
More than half of the trials registered in the
United States have done so within the first
weeks of April
Close to a third of registered trials with
sites in the US (32) include
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Regions of interest ndash China
39
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Cum
ula
tive t
rial num
ber
Date
Cumulative trials in ChinaChina is the country with the largest number
of registered trials at 318
Of trials in China a substantial proportion
(n=100 31) involved the use of
Traditional Chinese Medicine
Other interventions of interest include
lopinavirritonavir (n=29 9) stem cell
therapies (n=25 8) and
hydroxychloroquine (n=20 6)
The flattening of newly added trials over
time appears to reflect the reduction in
reported active cases
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Geographical Spread of registered COVID-19 trials
4272020 Cytel Inc 40
North America 94
Europe 114
East Asia 334
Middle East 41
Africa 11
South Asia 7 South America 12
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Dynamic Trial Designs for
COVID-19 Interventions
4272020 Cytel Inc 41
Kristian Thorlund SVP Cytel
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Cytel Inc 42
The Evidence Lines between treatments indicate
direct comparisons in clinical trials
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Cytel Inc 43
Representation of Outcomes
- Viral LoadClearance (140)
- Mortality (126)
- Invasive Ventilation (109)
- Clinical Improvement (102)
- ICU Admission (93)
- Fever (91)
- Hospitalization 86)
- Non-invasive Ventilation (84)
- Pneumonia or ARDS (68)
- Radiographic findings (64)
- Inflammatory biomarkers (62)
- Organ failuredysfunction (40)
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Cytel Inc44
Hospitalized Healthcare
Workers
Healthcare
Workers
Outpatients HealthyProphylaxis
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Cytel Inc 45
Three parallel clinical trials embedded as a triage platform trial
Trial I Exposed patients
Trial 2 Lower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Trial 3 Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19
outpatients
H
H
HH
H
H
H
Eligible individuals or patients permitted to enter different sub-trials established within the
master protocol ndash this offers benefits of capturing patient journey throughout
Transfer to
collaborator trial
Once eligible patientrsquos can be
transferred to other trials on
hospitalized or ICU admitted
CoVID-19 populations
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Last updated April 27 2020
46
PICOS criteria
Criteria Sub-trial 1 Sub-trial 2 Sub-trial 3
Population Exposed individualsLower-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
Higher-risk PCR+ Covid-19 outpatients
InterventionsAny post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Any treatment therapeutics
Comparator Placebo or standard-of-care as they become available
Primary outcome
bull Any outcome bull Any outcome bull Any outcome
Study design A triage platform clinical trial
Stratification of PCR+ Covid-19 into lower-risk and higher-risk can be defined by the clinical experts
Up to three arms simultaneously evaluated at once
Primary outcome of each sub-trials will be defined by the clinical experts
Patients from this trial can be transferred to other key master protocols evaluating hospitalized Covid-19 patients if and when they
become eligible
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Cytel Inc 47
Your 2-arm Stem Cell
Therapy Trial
Assess External + Interim Data
- Stop if the answer is already in
- Bayesian Predictive Probabilities
- Sample Size Reassessment
NIH advises against
Hydroxychloroquine +
Azithromyzin combination
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Cytel Inc 48
Master Protocols and Platform Trials CoViD vs non-CoViD
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Basket trials Umbrella trials
Platform trials
Number of Master Protocols over Time
Basket Trials Umbrella Trials and Platform Trials
Non-CoViD
Master Protocols
Umbrella
Platform
Basket
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Examples of registered master protocols in COVID-19
4272020
Trial name (ID) Master protocol
category
Therapeutic area(s)(listed as of mid-April)
Countries Patient context
ACOVACT
(NCT04351724)
Basket trial RAS blockade antiviral
immune modulation
Austria Outpatients renal
impaired critically ill
(separate sub studies)
PRINCIPLE
(ISRCTN86534580)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine United Kingdom High risk patients
primary care
REMAP-CAP
(REMAP-COVID)
(NCT02735707)
Platform trial (sub-
platform)
Antiviral immune
modulation macrolide
corticosteroid
Thirteen countries Critically Ill
SOLIDARITY
(ISRCTN83971151)
Platform trial with
umbrella component
Vaccine antiviral
immune modulation
Thirteen countries five
continents
Multiple planned
U-WASH
(NCT04354428)
Platform trial Hydroxychloroquine
azithromycin
United States High risk outpatients
U-DEPLOY
(NCT04331665 ndash single
sub trial registration)
Umbrella trial Cellular products
immune modulation
Canada Critically ill non-critically
ill
Note this is not intended to be an exhaustive list of master protocols in COVID-19 It is intended to demonstrate several efforts identified through routine surveillance of clinical trial registries as of April 19 2020
Design description not taken from study investigators
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
Cytel Inc 50
Concluding Remarks
Consider what has been accomplished in such a short timehellip
hellip let us not forget how much non-CoViD patients will benefit from
upholding this new standard
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA
COVID-19 Trials Designs and
Tools for Promising Results
4272020 Cytel Inc 51
1 2 3 4 5
Panel discussion
Audience QampA