COSIA 2010

Communicating Ocean Communicating Ocean SciencesSciences to Informal to Informal

AudiencesAudiencesWeek 6: Conversations &

Questions

COSIA 2010

Quick WriteQuick Write

• What is the role of conversation in learning? i.e., why is talking important for learning?

• Describe a time when you felt you were engaged in a learning conversation in a class or informal learning environment. What were the characteristics of the conversation that made you feel it was a real learning opportunity? (e.g., who was talking, what kinds of questions were used, and what kind of responses were elicited?)

COSIA 2010

What is the role of conversation in learning? i.e., why is talking important for learning?

COSIA 2010

Ideas from Research Ideas from Research JigsawJigsaw

• Each person in your group is responsible for carefully reading one card. (Everyone has a card with different information on it)

• Take turns explaining the information from your card to your small group. Share your thoughts about your card. Lead a brief discussion about your card, including:– Anything people find confusing about the topic on the card– Questions or issues about the topic on the card– How classroom teaching might be structured to take that

piece of information into account

COSIA 2010

Kinds of QuestionsKinds of Questions

COSIA 2010

Kinds of QuestionsKinds of Questions

BroadA statement or question that anticipates a variety of acceptable and generally unpredictable responses.

FocusedA statement or question that anticipates a particular, predictable response planned by the educator.

COSIA 2010

Small Group DiscussionSmall Group Discussion

• What are advantages & disadvantages of broad & focused questions?

• Provide examples for when it would be effective to use each type of question.

COSIA 2010

Role playsRole plays

•Who is asking questions?

•What is the question prompting from the other person?

COSIA 2010

Role of the EducatorRole of the Educator

Guide on the sideSage on the stage

COSIA 2010

Role of the EducatorRole of the Educator

• Views self as facilitator of learning

• Focuses on thinking, or cognition, of the learner

Sage on the stage Guide on the side

• Views self as transmitter of knowledge

• Educator is the recognized authority and repository of information

COSIA 2010

Ponder thisPonder this

• How do you think the educators in each of the skits saw themselves as a “sage on the stage” or as a “guide on the side?”

• Can you think of any time when it would be appropriate to be a sage on the stage?

COSIA 2010

Ideas from ResearchIdeas from Research• Inquiry-oriented teaching is driven by learner questions.• The opportunity to generate questions places the

learner in an active, initiating role in the learning process, & situates them as producers of knowledge not just consumers.

• Asking questions in discussions (whole or small group) develops a good habit of mind that is practiced in the social space and can become part of individual thought.

• 75% of the questions teachers ask are of a factual or literal nature.

• Teachers ask an average of 70 literal or factual questions in a 30-minute lesson.

COSIA 2010

“Inquiry alone does not suffice. Children can construct rich meanings when presented with rich materials, but the meanings they construct, without reflection and discussion, are often diffuse, mysterious and laden with misconceptions.”

-Karen Gallas, Talking Their Way Into Science, 1995, p. 54

COSIA 2010

Purposes for Broad and Purposes for Broad and Focused QuestionsFocused Questions

• In general, focused questions are not good for starting discussions.

• In general, broad questions are not good to wrap-up a discussion, or if the educator is looking for a specific answer.

• Broad questions lead to divergent answers; Focused questions lead to specific answers.

COSIA 2010

Being purposeful about Being purposeful about asking questionsasking questions

• Stimulate learners’ thinking • Generate feedback for educator about

learners’ understanding• Evaluate what learners know• Elicit what learners think & encourage

learners to extend their ideas• Scaffold learner thinking as they help learners

build knowledge

COSIA 2010

Discussion MapDiscussion Map

• Ask a Broad Question• Listen to responses and thinking• Ask for evidence or explanations• Ask for alternative opinions or ideas• Ask a question leading back to the main

discussion topic• Help to organize and summarize the

ideas

COSIA 2010

Discussion Map ExampleDiscussion Map Example• Ask a broad question:

– How would you describe the interaction between the educator and the visitors in the first skit?

• Listen to response and thinking.• Ask for evidence or explanation:

– What about what the educator said or did makes you think that?

• Ask for alternative opinions or ideas:– Does anybody have a different idea or viewpoint?

• Ask a question leading back to the main topic– How do you think the educator saw his/her role as an educator?– How do you think the educator used questions to facilitate the

conversation?

• Help to organize and summarize the ideas.

COSIA 2010

AdaptationAdaptation

COSIA 2010

Quick WriteQuick Write

• How have your ideas changed?• What do you think made your ideas

change?• How might you use this in your

science teaching?

COSIA 2010

HomeworkHomework• Online discussion• Reading

– Baker, B. (2000). Recruiting Minorities to the Biological Sciences. Bioscience, 50(3), 191-195.

– Jolly, E.J. (February 2002). Confronting Demographic Denial: Retaining Relevance in the New Millennium. ASTC Dimensions. Association of Science and Technology Centers, Washington, DC.

• Activity Development– Receive feedback on presentations.– Be ready to present your activity next week if you do not

present this week.– Content paper (2 pgs, 1 per person) about the science

content and concepts in your activity. Upload to Bspace by Mar 5.