42
CADGME 2012 Novi Sad 22-24 June 2012 Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia Sima Pastor, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

  • Upload
    donhi

  • View
    218

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad 22-24 June 2012

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software

in the analysis of cycloid meshing

Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia Sima Pastor, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 2: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 2

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

CONTENT

Page 3: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 3

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Introduction

The problem

Cycloid Laboratory

Cycloid meshing

Cycloid Gearing

Questions

Content

Page 4: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 4

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Part 1

..: Problems in engineering education

..: Innovations in engineering education

INTRODUCTION

Page 5: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 5

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Introduction Problems in engineering education

Multidisciplinary approach

Natural human need for progress

Complexity of systems in

engineering

Development of technology

Low interest for studying engineering

Development of new methods in

education

Page 6: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 6

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Introduction Innovations in engineering education

Multi-disciplinary Approach

Blended learning

Virtual and Augmented

reality

Video games

Applicative software

Page 7: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 7

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Part 2

..: Motivation

..: Basic knowledge - Theory of mechanisms - Basic Math - Application software

THE PROBLEM

Page 8: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 8

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

The problem Motivation

Actuality of the graduation papers - Higher complexity of the assignments - New problems - Problems from real world Introducing new teaching methods

- Multidisciplinary approach - Efficiency of acquainted knowledge Why cycloid meshing?

- Frequently applied in practice - Basic theoretical experiment - Richness of different solutions - Complex example - Adequate with non classical methods of learning - Suitable for analysis in GeoGebra laboratory - Demanding CAD model

The 18-by-10-foot multimedia wall in the Collaborative Visualization Environment (CoVE) will be used in the new

Professional Master’s Degree in Applied Systems Engineering

Page 9: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 9

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

The problem Basic knowledge

Theory of mechanisms Pedagogical view

Basic theory

Basic Math Trigonometry

Analytic geometry in plane Cycloids

Application software Math CAD

Page 10: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 10

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

The problem Theory of mechanisms

Leonardo da Vinci Madrid Codices I, 1493

Antikythera mechanism, early 1st century BC

Roloff Matek Maschinenelemente, 2007

Pedagogical view - Part of few core subjects of study

during all four years - Students usually have learning problems - Teachers have teaching difficulties - Long and rich history - Science literature is not adequate for secondary level - School books are not enough

Page 11: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 11

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

The problem Theory of mechanisms

Basic theory Communication of Motion by Contact 1. In the communication of motion by contact

- the angular motions of the pieces are inversely as the segments into which the common normal divides the line of centers

2. In rolling contact - the point of contact is always in the line of centers - the angular velocities are inversely as the

segments into which the point of contact divides the line of centers

- if the velocity ratio is constant, the segments must be constant, and the curves become circles, revolving round their centers, and whose radii are the segments

by Sliding Contact

by Rolling Contact Willis, Principles of Mechanism, 1841.

Page 12: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 12

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

The problem Theory of mechanisms

Basic theory Communication of Motion by Sliding Contact 1. The axes being supposed parallel 2. The angular velocities are in the inverse ratio of the segments into which the normal

of the curves, at the point of contact, divides the line of centers 3. Any curve then being assumed for the edge of one revolving piece 4. If we can assign such a form to the edge of another revolving piece that the common

normal of the two curves shall divide the line of centers in a fixed point, in all positions of contact, then will these curves preserve a constant angular velocity ratio

Willis, Principles of Mechanism, 1841.

First solution Second solution Third solution Fourth solution General solution

Page 13: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 13

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Trigonometry, Analytic geometry in plane Both are parts of the curriculum Cycloid

Although, parametric equations of the curves are not part of the curriculum by

the use of GeoGebra students except them easily It is known that the so-called mechanical curves are not the subject of study at

the secondary level. However, by the use of GeoGebra, analysis of these curves is qualitatively possible and acceptable for students

The problem Basic Math

𝑥 = 𝑟 𝑡 − sin 𝑡𝑦 = 𝑟 1 − cos 𝑡

Page 14: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 14

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

The problem Application software

CAD softwere

Creo Elements/Pro (formerly Pro/ENGINEER) parametric, integrated 3D CAD/CAM/CAE solution for design and manufacturing

PTC Creo

Math softwere

Mathcad is computer software primarily intended for the verification, validation, documentation and re-use of engineering calculations

Mathcad

GeoGebra GeoGebra is an interactive geometry, algebra, and calculus application, intended for teachers and students

Page 15: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 15

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Part 3

..: with GeoGebra

..: Examples

..: Conclusion

CYCLOID LABORATORY

Page 16: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 16

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

When a straight line rolls along a stationary circle a point on the line traces a curve called an involute When a circle rolls along a stationary straight line a

point on the circumference of the circle traces a curve called a cycloid When a circle rolls along another circle then a point

on the circumference of the rolling circle traces out a curve called an epicycloid (if the rolling circle rolls on the outside of the stationary circle) or a hypocycloid

(if the rolling circle rolls on the inside of the stationary circle). In all these cases of rolling circles points not on the

circumference trace curves called trochoids

Cycliod Laboratory with GeoGebra

Page 17: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 17

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012 Page 17

Example 1

Page 18: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 18

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012 Page 18

Example 2

Page 19: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 19

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012 Page 19

Example 3

Page 20: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 20

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012 Page 20

Example 4

Page 21: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 21

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Cycliod Laboratory Conclusion

The aim of GeoGebra laboratory is for student to - To spot kinematic connections - To spot trajectory of the fixed point - To grasp the mining of the ratio - To grasp the correlation between the given ratio and the form of the curve - To grasp the mining of proportions being integers

Page 22: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 22

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Cycliod Laboratory Conclusion

The aim of GeoGebra laboratory is for student to - To spot kinematic connections - To spot trajectory of the fixed point - To grasp the mining of the proportions - To grasp the correlation between the proportions and the form of the curve - To grasp the mining of proportions being integers

GeoGebra Mathcad PTC Creo

Page 23: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 23

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Part 4

..: First Solution

..: Second Solution

..: Third Solution

..: Application

CYCLOID MESHING

Page 24: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 24

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012 Page 24

Cycloid meshing

First Solution Second Solution Third Solution

Willis, Principles of Mechanism, 1841.

Page 25: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 25

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012 Page 25

First Solution

Page 26: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 26

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012 Page 26

First Solution

Page 27: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 27

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012 Page 27

Second Solution

Page 28: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 28

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012 Page 28

Second Solution

Page 29: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 29

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012 Page 29

Third Solution

Page 30: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 30

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012 Page 30

Third Solution

Page 31: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 31

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Cycloid Meshing Application

Cycloidal drives Cycloidal gears Cycloid hydraulic motor

Cycloidal flow meters Cycloidal propeller Wankel rotary engine The Reuleaux polygon

MEMS

Page 32: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 32

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Part 5

..: GeoGebra Laboratory

..: PTC Creo CAD Assembly

CYCLOID GEARING

Page 33: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 33

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Cycloid Gearing GeoGebra Laboratory

1 3 2 4

5 6 7

Page 34: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 34

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Cycloid Gearing GeoGebra Laboratory

1 2

Page 35: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 35

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Cycloid Gearing GeoGebra Laboratory

1 2

Page 36: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 36

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Cycloid Gearing GeoGebra Laboratory

1 2

Page 37: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 37

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012 Page 37

Cycloid Gearing

Page 38: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 38

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Cycliod Gearing PTC Creo CAD Assembly

PTC Creo CAD Assembly

Page 39: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 39

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Cycliod Gearing PTC Creo CAD Assembly

Page 40: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 40

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Thank you! Questions...

Page 41: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 41

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Contact

Kaja Maricic e – mail: [email protected]

Sima Pastor e – mail: [email protected]

Page 42: Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing · in the analysis of cycloid meshing Kaja Maricic, Mechanical Engineering High School , Novi Sad, Serbia

Page 42

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia

June 2012

Correlation of GeoGebra and CAD software in the analysis of cycloid meshing, Maricic, Pastor

CADGME 2012 Novi Sad, Serbia 22-24 June 2012