1
CORE CONCEPTS Core Concept: Ergodic theory plays a key role in multiple fields Steven Ashley Science Writer Statistical mechanics is a powerful set of mathematical tools that uses probability the- ory to bridge the enormous gap between the unknowable behaviors of individual atoms and molecules and those of large aggregate sys- tems of thema volume of gas, for example. Fundamental to statistical mechanics is ergodic theory, which offers a mathematical means to study the long-term average behavior of complex systems, such as the behavior of molecules in a gas or the interactions of vi- brating atoms in a crystal. The landmark con- cepts and methods of ergodic theory continue to play an important role in statistical mechan- ics, physics, mathematics, and other fields. Ergodicity was first introduced by the Austrian physicist Ludwig Boltzmann in the 1870s, following on the originator of statisti- cal mechanics, physicist James Clark Max- well. Boltzmann coined the word ergodiccombining two Greek words: ργo ¸ ν (ergon: work) and δς (odos: pathor way)to describe his hypothesis. Although some formulations of his hypothesis were not com- pletely accurate, his ideas seeded an impor- tant set of principles and tools. Boltzmann, working with gases, suggested that the spatial average values giving rise to macroscopic features also arose as averages over time of observable quantities that could be calculated from microscopic states. He realized that this might hold if a system passed through all of the possible microscopic states. This strongform of Boltzmanns ergodic hypothesis was, however, later seen to be too strong in practice on topological and measure theoretic grounds, says Nándor Simányi, pro- fessor of mathematics at the University of Alabama at Birmingham. Ergodicity was loosely defined. It was an assumption made about the time-evolution of a dynamical sys- tem that worked, but the idea that a system goes through every state, that a system goes through every point in the phase space, is impossible; mathematically, its nonsense,he says. It was, however, satisfactory for a physical understanding of systems.The path toward greater theoretical rigor, explains University of Warwick mathematics professor Tom Ward, reached a key milestone in the early 1930s when American mathema- tician George D. Birkhoff and Austrian-Hun- garian (and later, American) mathematician and physicist John von Neumann separately reconsidered and reformulated Boltzmanns er- godic hypothesis, leading to the pointwise and mean ergodic theories, respectively (see ref. 1). These results consider a dynamical sys- temwhether an ideal gas or other complex systemsin which some transformation func- tion maps the phase state of the system into its state one unit of time later. Given a mea- sure-preserving system, a probability space that is acted on by the transformation in a way that models physical conservation laws, what properties might it have?asks Ward, who is managing editor of the journal Ergodic Theory and Dynamical Systems. The measure on a mathematical space assigns weights to parts of the space. Measure theory provides a precise formu- lation, saying that while a system doesnt lit- erally pass through every point in the phase space, it may come arbitrarily close to every point,he explains. That is, theres no fa- vored part of the space.This formulation gives rise to a notion of ergodicity weak enough to hold for many systems and strong enough to have significant consequences. After decades of relative quiescence, efforts to devise ergodicity models underwent a re- vival in the 1960s, notably including work by Yakov Sinai, a mathematician now at Prince- ton University, Simányi says. In 1963, Sinai introduced the idea of dynamical billiards, or Sinai Billiards,in which an idealized hardparticle bounces around inside a square boundary without loss of energy. Inside the square is a circular wall, off of which the par- ticle bounces. He proved that for most initial trajectories of the ball, this system is ergodicthat is, over infinite time, the time average of an observed quantity will equal its average over the space. For any part of the space, the proportion of time the system spends in that region will be proportional to its size. If the system spends 3% of the time in a region of its phase space, that region is 3% of the total phase-space volume; they are proportional in size,Simányi says. It was the first time that someone had rigor- ously proved that a dynamical system that seemed related to a real physical situation was ergodic. Ergodic theory continues to have wide impact in statistical physics, number theory, probability theory, functional analysis, and other fields. One prominent example is the GreenTao theorem. In 2004, Ben Green of the University of Oxford and Terrence Tao of University of California, Los Angeles, building on the work of American-Israeli mathematician Hillel Furstenberg, fused methods from analytic number theory and ergodic theory to prove a folkloreconjec- ture dating back to the 1770s that the se- quence of prime numbers contains arbi- trarily long sequences of numbers in which the difference between consecutive terms is a constant (for example, 3, 5, 7 is such a se- quence of length three). Tao went on to earn the 2006 Fields Medal. 1 Moore CC (2015) Ergodic theorem, ergodic theory, and statistical mechanics. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 112:19071911. Austrian physicist Ludwig Boltzmann laid the foundation for modern-day ergodic the- ory. Image courtesy of Goethe University Frankfurt. 1914 | PNAS | February 17, 2015 | vol. 112 | no. 7 www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1500429112

CORE CONCEPTS Core Concept: Ergodic … CONCEPTS Core Concept: Ergodic theory plays a key role in multiple fields Steven Ashley Science Writer Statistical mechanics is a powerful set

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • CORE CONCEPTS

    Core Concept: Ergodic theory plays a key rolein multiple fieldsSteven AshleyScience Writer

    Statistical mechanics is a powerful set ofmathematical tools that uses probability the-ory to bridge the enormous gap between theunknowable behaviors of individual atomsandmolecules and those of large aggregate sys-tems of thema volume of gas, for example.Fundamental to statistical mechanics is

    ergodic theory, which offers a mathematicalmeans to study the long-term average behaviorof complex systems, such as the behavior ofmolecules in a gas or the interactions of vi-brating atoms in a crystal. The landmark con-cepts and methods of ergodic theory continueto play an important role in statistical mechan-ics, physics, mathematics, and other fields.Ergodicity was first introduced by the

    Austrian physicist Ludwig Boltzmann in the1870s, following on the originator of statisti-cal mechanics, physicist James Clark Max-well. Boltzmann coined the word ergodiccombining two Greek words: o (ergon:work) and (odos: path or way)to describe his hypothesis. Although someformulations of his hypothesis were not com-pletely accurate, his ideas seeded an impor-tant set of principles and tools.Boltzmann, working with gases, suggested

    that the spatial average values giving rise tomacroscopic features also arose as averagesover time of observable quantities that couldbe calculated from microscopic states. Herealized that this might hold if a system passedthrough all of the possible microscopic states.This strong form of Boltzmanns ergodic

    hypothesis was, however, later seen to be toostrong in practice on topological and measuretheoretic grounds, says Nndor Simnyi, pro-fessor of mathematics at the University ofAlabama at Birmingham. Ergodicity wasloosely defined. It was an assumption madeabout the time-evolution of a dynamical sys-tem that worked, but the idea that a systemgoes through every state, that a system goesthrough every point in the phase space, isimpossible; mathematically, its nonsense,he says. It was, however, satisfactory for aphysical understanding of systems.The path toward greater theoretical rigor,

    explains University of Warwick mathematics

    professor TomWard, reached a key milestonein the early 1930s when American mathema-tician George D. Birkhoff and Austrian-Hun-garian (and later, American) mathematicianand physicist John von Neumann separatelyreconsideredandreformulatedBoltzmanns er-godic hypothesis, leading to the pointwise andmean ergodic theories, respectively (see ref. 1).These results consider a dynamical sys-

    temwhether an ideal gas or other complexsystemsinwhich some transformation func-tion maps the phase state of the system intoits state one unit of time later. Given a mea-sure-preserving system, a probability spacethat is acted on by the transformation ina way that models physical conservation laws,what properties might it have? asks Ward,who is managing editor of the journal ErgodicTheory and Dynamical Systems. The measureon a mathematical space assigns weights toparts of the space.Measure theory provides a precise formu-

    lation, saying that while a system doesnt lit-erally pass through every point in the phasespace, it may come arbitrarily close to everypoint, he explains. That is, theres no fa-vored part of the space. This formulationgives rise to a notion of ergodicity weakenough to hold for many systems and strongenough to have significant consequences.After decades of relative quiescence, efforts

    to devise ergodicity models underwent a re-vival in the 1960s, notably including work byYakov Sinai, a mathematician now at Prince-ton University, Simnyi says. In 1963, Sinaiintroduced the idea of dynamical billiards, orSinai Billiards, in which an idealized hardparticle bounces around inside a squareboundary without loss of energy. Inside thesquare is a circular wall, off of which the par-ticle bounces. He proved that for most initialtrajectories of the ball, this system is ergodicthat is, over infinite time, the time average ofan observed quantity will equal its averageover the space. For any part of the space,the proportion of time the system spendsin that region will be proportional to its size.If the system spends 3% of the time in a

    region of its phase space, that region is 3%

    of the total phase-space volume; they areproportional in size, Simnyi says. Itwas the first time that someone had rigor-ously proved that a dynamical system thatseemed related to a real physical situationwas ergodic.Ergodic theory continues to have wide

    impact in statistical physics, number theory,probability theory, functional analysis, andother fields. One prominent example is theGreenTao theorem. In 2004, Ben Green ofthe University of Oxford and Terrence Taoof University of California, Los Angeles,building on the work of American-Israelimathematician Hillel Furstenberg, fusedmethods from analytic number theory andergodic theory to prove a folklore conjec-ture dating back to the 1770s that the se-quence of prime numbers contains arbi-trarily long sequences of numbers in whichthe difference between consecutive terms isa constant (for example, 3, 5, 7 is such a se-quence of length three). Tao went on to earnthe 2006 Fields Medal.

    1 Moore CC (2015) Ergodic theorem, ergodic theory,and statistical mechanics. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA112:19071911.

    Austrian physicist Ludwig Boltzmann laidthe foundation for modern-day ergodic the-ory. Image courtesy of Goethe UniversityFrankfurt.

    1914 | PNAS | February 17, 2015 | vol. 112 | no. 7 www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1500429112

    http://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1073/pnas.1500429112&domain=pdfwww.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1500429112