Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
COPD Performance Improvement Teleconference
Roy C. Blank, MDRoy C. Blank, MDDennis E. Niewoehner, MDDennis E. Niewoehner, MD
Learning Objectives
Describe inhaled pharmacotherapy options for stable COPD
Explain optimal management strategies for acute exacerbations
Accreditation Statement
Boston University School of Medicine is accredited by the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education (ACCME) to provide continuing medical education for physicians.Boston University School of Medicine designates this educational activity for a maximum of 1 AMA PRA Category 1 Credit™. Clinicians should only claim credit commensurate with the extent of their participation in the activity.In order to receive CME/CE credit for this teleconference, complete the Program Evaluation and Claim for Credit forms that are on our Website at www.mentorqi.com. Click on the EVENTS tab at the top and look for Teleconference #1.
Target AudiencePrimary care physicians, nurse practitioners, and physician assistants
Grant SupportThis program is supported by an educational grant from Boehringer Ingelheim and Pfizer Inc.
Planning Committee Disclosures
Julie White, MSAdministrative DirectorContinuing Medical EducationBoston University School of MedicineBoston, Massachusetts
Julie White has nothing to disclose.
Lara Zisblatt, MAAssistant DirectorContinuing Medical EducationBoston University School of MedicineBoston, Massachusetts
Lara Zisblatt has nothing to disclose.
Elizabeth GiffordProgram ManagerProgram ManagerContinuing Medical EducationContinuing Medical EducationBoston University School of MedicineBoston University School of MedicineBoston, MassachusettsBoston, Massachusetts
Elizabeth GiffordElizabeth Gifford has nothing to has nothing to disclose.disclose.
Faculty Disclosure Information
Roy C. Blank, MDSouthern Piedmont Primary CareMonroe, North Carolina
Roy C. Blank, MD, has nothing to disclose.
Dr. Blank plans to discuss off-label/investigational uses of tiotropium for COPD exacerbations and inhaled steroids for certain patients with severe COPD symptoms.
Faculty Disclosure
Dennis E. Niewoehner, MDProfessor of MedicineUniversity of MinnesotaMinneapolis, Minnesota
Dennis E. Niewoehner, MD, is on the speakers’ bureau for Boehringer Ingelheim and Sepracor and serves as a consultant for GlaxoSmithKline and AstraZeneca.
Dr. Niewoehner plans to discuss off-label/investigational uses of ipratropium, aminophylline, antibiotics, prednisone, prednisolone, or budesonide for managing exacerbations of COPD.
COPD Performance Improvement: Overview
Lara Zisblatt, MALara Zisblatt, MAAssistant DirectorAssistant Director
Continuing Medical EducationContinuing Medical EducationBoston University School of MedicineBoston University School of Medicine
Boston, MassachusettsBoston, Massachusetts
Participants in the Program
224 people registered
42 finished baseline chart review
29 submitted their action plans
4 completed the program
Performance Improvement
Enrolling in this PI program is the 1st step in improving care for your patients
Key component to improvement is chart review– Simple way to look at baseline measures of your
practice
– Very act of reviewing charts can be illuminating
Chart Review Challenge
Biggest challenge = Time
Ways to overcome this barrier: – Requirement lowered from 10 charts to 5 charts for review
– Ask support staff to review patients seen in the past month with any ICD 9 code for COPD and pull charts or review EMR
– Complete the chart review with another member of your team
– Make a plan to complete this chart review
Schedule 2 one-hour sessions over the next week using administrative time or your lunch hour
COPD Project
Make a commitment to yourself and to your patients to work toward improving care
Complete the chart review as soon as possible as your first step toward improvement
If you are having trouble completing the chart reviews, please let us know. We can help!
If you have any questions, please e-mail us at [email protected] or call us at 617.638.4605
Inhaled Pharmacotherapyfor Stable COPD
Roy C. Blank, MDRoy C. Blank, MDSouthern Piedmont Primary CareSouthern Piedmont Primary Care
Monroe, North Carolina Monroe, North Carolina
Case Study: Patient Presentation
Rob C is a 71-year-old man who presents for follow-up of COPD
Past history– COPD: known diagnosis X 15 years
– Carotid artery disease
– Peripheral vascular disease
– Dyslipidemia
– Hypertension
– Hyperthyroidism
Case Study: Patient History
Social history– Smokes 1 pack per day and has done so for 50 years
• Will quit when “hell freezes over”
Medications– ASA 325 mg / day– Propylthiouracil 50 mg po TID– Simvastatin 40 mg po daily– Lisinopril 20 mg po daily– Tiotropium 88 mcg daily inhalation since 5/1/08
• Previous treatment with ipratropium bromide + albuterol sulfate
– Continuous O2 at 2 liters / minute / 24 hours– Albuterol HFA PRN for symptoms
ASA = acetylsalicylic acid; TID = three times daily; po = oral; HFA = hydrofluoroalkane; PRN = as needed.
Case Study: Diagnostic Testing
ECG– RBBB
CXR– Flattened diaphragms
– Emphysematous changes
– Scattered fibrosis
Cardiac echo– Moderately dilated right ventricle
– Pulmonary pressures not estimated
– Ejection fraction 50%
ECG = electrocardiogram; RBBB = right bundle branch block; CXR = chest x-ray.
Case Study: Pulmonary Function Tests
Pulmonary Function Tests 2008– FVC: 1.41 L 34%
– FEV1 1.0: .63 L 21%
– FEV1 1.0 / FVC 45%
– FEF 25%-75% L/sec 0.27 12%
– No significant change with bronchodilators
– O2 sat with oxygen 93%
Pulmonary Function Tests 2009– FVC: 1.74 L 48%
– FEV1 1.0: .65 L 22%
– FEV1 1.0 / FVC 38%
– FEF 25%-75% L/sec 0.27 10%
– No significant change with bronchodilators
– O2 sat with oxygen 94%
FVC = forced volume vital capacity ; FEV = forced expiratory volume; FEF = forced expiratory flow; O2 = oxygen.
Patient Follow-up
Follow-up visit– Symptoms: chronic shortness of breath unchanged over the
past year; no new symptoms• Previously attended pulmonary rehabilitation
– No exacerbations over the past year and no hospitalizations
– Vital signs stable
– BMI 16.5
– Pulse oximetry 94%
– Examination: reduced lung breath sounds with no bronchospasm; no respiratory distress; no findings for congestive heart failure
BMI = body mass index.
Spirometry Interpretation –Obstructive Defect(s)
Obstructive disease– FEV1/FVC <70%– Severity classified as FEV1 % of predicted normal– PEFR — NOT used to diagnose or monitor COPD
8 6 4 2
10
5
Flow
(L/s
ec)
Severe
Mild
Normal
Thoracic Gas Volume (liters)
FEV1 = forced expiratory volume in 1 second; in 1 second; PEFR = peak expiratory flow rate.
SpirometryObstructive Disease, WHO Classification
SeveritySeverity FEVFEV11/FVC/FVC FEVFEV11 ImpactImpact
Stage 1 Stage 1 ““MildMild”” <70%<70% Normal Normal
((≥≥80%)80%)
Majority of patientsMajority of patientsMinimal impact on HRMinimal impact on HR--QOLQOLModest expenditureModest expenditure
Stage 2Stage 2““ModerateModerate”” <70%<70% 50%50%--80% 80%
predictedpredictedMinority of patientsMinority of patientsSignificant impact on Significant impact on HRHR-- QOLQOL
Stage 3Stage 3““SevereSevere”” <70%<70% 30%30%--49% 49%
predictedpredicted
Stage 4Stage 4““Very severeVery severe”” <70%<70% ≤≤29% 29%
predictedpredicted
Large expenditureLarge expenditureMinority of patientsMinority of patientsProfound impact on HRProfound impact on HR--QOLQOLVERY large expenditureVERY large expenditure
WHO = World Health Organization; HR-QOL = health-related quality of life.Executive Summary: Global Strategy for the Diagnosis, Management, and Prevention of COPD. Updated 2006. http://www.goldcopd.org.
SpirometryFEV1 and Survival Prognosis
100
Anthonisen N, et al. Am Rev Respir Dis. 1986;133:14-20.
Surv
ival
(%)
Years
Normal>50% predicted40%-49% predicted30%-39% predicted<30% predicted
FEV1
0 1 2 3
90
80
70
60
Goals of COPD Management
Prevent disease progression
Relieve symptoms
Improve lung function
Improve exercise tolerance
Improve health status
Prevent and treat complications
Prevent and treat exacerbations
Reduce mortality
Global strategy for the diagnosis, management, and prevention of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Updated 2006. http://www.goldcopd.org
Treatment of COPD by Stage
Active reduction of risk factor(s); influenza vaccinationActive reduction of risk factor(s); influenza vaccinationAddAdd shortshort--acting bronchodilator (when needed)acting bronchodilator (when needed)
• FEV1/FVC <0.70• FEV1 ≥80% predicted
Add long-term oxygen if chronic respiratory failureConsider surgical treatments
Add inhaled glucocorticosteroids if repeated exacerbations
Add regular treatment with one or more long-acting bronchodilators (when needed); Add rehabilitation
• FEV1/FVC <0.70• 50% ≤FEV1
<80% predicted
• FEV1/FVC <0.70• 30% ≤FEV1 <50%
predicted
• FEV1/FVC <0.70• FEV1 <30% predicted
plus chronic respiratory failure
I: MildI: Mild II: ModerateII: Moderate III: SevereIII: Severe IV: Very SevereIV: Very Severe
NHLBI/WHO Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung DiseaseNHLBI/WHO Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease.. November 2006.November 2006.
Salmeterol for Stable COPD
SalmeterolSalmeterol
IpratropiumIpratropium
PlaceboPlacebo
22 44 66 88 1010 121200
0.10.1
0.50.5
0.40.4
0.30.3
0.20.2
∆∆FE
VFE
V 11(L
)(L
)
Time (hours)Time (hours)
FEVFEV1 1 = forced expiratory volume in 1 second.= forced expiratory volume in 1 second.
Mahler DA, et al.Mahler DA, et al. Chest. Chest. 1999;115:9571999;115:957--965.965.
Prevention of Exacerbations:Inhaled Long-acting Beta Agonists*
*Off*Off--label indication.label indication.
Relative Risk (95% CI) of ExacerbationRelative Risk (95% CI) of Exacerbation
Favors LABAFavors LABA Favors PlaceboFavors Placebo
0.20.2 110.50.5 22 55
Mahler 2002Mahler 2002BrusascoBrusasco
Calverley 1Calverley 1CelliCelli
ChapmanChapmanRennardRennard
Van NoordVan NoordMahler 1999Mahler 1999
BoydBoydSubtotal
SalmeterolSalmeterol
Subtotal
0.82 (0.76 0.82 (0.76 –– 0.90)0.90)0.84 (0.74 0.84 (0.74 –– 0.97)0.97)
0.81 (0.73 0.81 (0.73 –– 0.90)0.90)Calverley 2Calverley 2
AalbersAalbersRossiRossi
WadboWadboDahlDahl
SzafranskiSzafranskiSubtotal
FormoterolFormoterol
Subtotal
TotalTotal
LABA = longLABA = long--acting beta agonists.acting beta agonists.
Wilt T, et al.Wilt T, et al. AHRQ Report 05AHRQ Report 05--E017E017--2, 2005.2, 2005.
Tiotropium AM Dosing: Improvement in FEV1 Over 24 Hours
0.70.7
0.80.8
0.90.9
1.01.0
1.11.1
1.21.2
1.31.3
––33 00 33 66 99 1212 1515 1818 2121 2424
Tiotropium (Tiotropium (nn=37)=37)Placebo (Placebo (nn=33)=33)
FEV
FEV 11
(L)
(L)
Time (hours)Time (hours)9 9 AMAM 3 3 PMPM 9 9 PMPM 3 3 AMAM 9 9 AMAM
FEVFEV1 1 = forced expiratory volume in 1 second.= forced expiratory volume in 1 second.Calverley PM, et al. Thorax. 2003;58:855-860.
VA Tiotropium Trial:Primary Outcomes*
>>1 Exacerbation (%)1 Exacerbation (%) >>1 COPD Hospitalization (%)1 COPD Hospitalization (%)
PlaceboPlacebo TiotropiumTiotropium
P = P = .037.037
32.232.227.927.9
PlaceboPlacebo TiotropiumTiotropium
P = P = .056.056
9.59.5
7.07.0
Niewoehner DE. Ann Intern Med. 2005;143:317-326.
*Off*Off--label indication.label indication.VA = Veterans Administration.VA = Veterans Administration.
4040 1212
3030 99
2020 66
1010 33
00 00
UPLIFT Trial: Long-term Tiotropium Improves QoL, Reduces Exacerbation
In 5,993 patients with COPD, therapy with tiotropium versus placebo was associated with improvements in lung function, quality of life, and exacerbations during a 4-year period
Therapy did not significantly reduce the rate of decline in FEV1
Tashkin DP, et al. N Engl J Med. 2008;359:1543-1554.
Reduction in Hospitalizations:Inhaled Long-acting Anticholinergic
Reference Favors Tiotropium Favors Comparator
Adapted from Barr RG, et al. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2006;(2):CD002876(A).
0.2 10.1 5.0 10.0
Casaburi et al, 2002
Niewoehner et al, 2004
Vincken et al, 2002
Brusasco et al, 2003
Brusasco et al, 2003
Summary effect—placebo 0.65 (0.50, 0.85)0.65 (0.50, 0.85)
Summary effect—salmeterol 0.59 (0.29, 1.23)0.59 (0.29, 1.23)
Summary effect—ipratropium 0.59 (0.32, 1.09)0.59 (0.32, 1.09)
Relative Risk
Prevention of Exacerbations:Inhaled Corticosteroids
ICS = inhaled corticosteroids.ICS = inhaled corticosteroids.Wilt TJ, et al. AHRQ Report 05-E017-2, 2005.
Relative Risk (95% CI) of ExacerbationRelative Risk (95% CI) of Exacerbation0.20.2 110.50.5 22 55
Burge Burge Calverley 03 Calverley 03
Mahler 02 Mahler 02 van der Valk van der Valk
Paggiaro Paggiaro SubtotalSubtotal
Bourbeau Bourbeau Calverley 04 Calverley 04
Szafranski Szafranski Vestbo Vestbo
SubtotalSubtotal
FluticasoneFluticasone
BudesonideBudesonide
Weir Weir SubtotalSubtotal
TotalTotal
BeclomethasoneBeclomethasone0.64 (0.41 0.64 (0.41 -- 1.00)1.00)
0.78 (0.66 0.78 (0.66 -- 0.91)0.91)
0.81 (0.68 0.81 (0.68 -- 0.95)0.95)
0.78 (0.70 0.78 (0.70 -- 0.88)0.88)
Favors ICSFavors ICS Favors PlaceboFavors Placebo
Consider Inhaled Steroidsin These COPD Patients*
Patients who have:– Severe symptoms with FEV1 <1 L
– Need for frequent antibiotics, prednisone, or hospitalization to treat exacerbations
*Off*Off--label indication.label indication.
Niewoehner DE, Wilt TJ. Am J Respir Crit Care. 2007;175:103-104.
Combined ICS and LABA to Prevent Exacerbations - TORCH
Exac
erba
tions
/Ex
acer
batio
ns/
Patie
ntPa
tient
-- Yea
rYe
ar
**P P <<.05 compared with placebo.05 compared with placebo††P P <.05 compared with salmeterol or fluticasone<.05 compared with salmeterol or fluticasone
00
0.20.2
0.40.4
0.60.6
0.80.8
11
1.21.2
1.41.4
PlaceboPlacebo SalmeterolSalmeterol FluticasoneFluticasone SalmeterolSalmeterol++
FluticasoneFluticasone
**** ** ††
TORCH = TOwards a Revolution in COPD Health.Calverley Calverley PM, et al. PM, et al. N N Engl Engl J Med. J Med. 2007;356:7752007;356:775--789.789.
Combination Inhalers for Preventing Hospitalizations
PP <.05<.05
Aaron SD, et al. Ann Intern Med. 2007;146:545-555.
00
1010
2020
3030
4040
5050
6060
4949
3838
2626
TiotropiumTiotropium TiotropiumTiotropium++
SalmeterolSalmeterol
TiotropiumTiotropium++
SalmeterolSalmeterol++
FluticasoneFluticasone
NSNS
No.
CO
PD
No.
CO
PD H
ospi
taliz
atio
nsH
ospi
taliz
atio
ns
NS = not significant.
Pharmacotherapy Performance Improvement Goals
Increase bronchodilator performance in COPD patients with FEV1 <60% predicted
Obstacle: Medication initiation• Intervention: Clinic flow sheet for medications and interventions
Obstacle: Patient noncompliance due to no immediate effect of medication
• Intervention: Educate to set patient expectations – Have patient education materials on hand
– Discuss medication effects and outcomes
– COPD education at all follow-up visits
Summary
Initiate a long-term bronchodilator(s) for moderate or more severe COPDProvide appropriate patient education at the onset of therapy– Discuss medication mechanisms and expectations
Obtain baseline pulmonary function dataMonitor clinical and therapeutic response– Exacerbations– Hospitalizations– Deterioration of symptoms or PFTs– Adjust therapy if clinical response is unfavorable
PFTs = pulmonary function tests.
Management of COPD ExacerbationsDennis E. Niewoehner, MDDennis E. Niewoehner, MD
Veterans Affairs Medical CenterVeterans Affairs Medical CenterUniversity of Minnesota University of Minnesota
MinneapolisMinneapolis
COPD Exacerbations: Definition
“A sustained worsening of the patient’s condition from steady state and beyond normal day-to-day variation that is acute in onset and necessitates a change in regular medication”
Rodriquez-Roisin R. Chest. 2000;117(suppl 2):398-401S.
COPD Exacerbations:Adverse Impacts
Human misery
Economic factors
Progression of underlying disease
Adverse effects of treatment
COPD Exacerbations: Treatment by Severity
MILD MODERATE SEVERE
Increase BDs
Antibiotics Antibiotics,Steroids
Hospitalization,Oxygen
ICU,Assisted
ventilationw/wo unscheduled medical visit
BDs = bronchodilators; ICU = intensive care unit.
COPD Exacerbations:Treatment Modalities
Bronchodilators
Oxygen
Antibiotics
Systemic corticosteroids
Noninvasive positive pressure breathing
Short-acting Bronchodilators for COPD Exacerbations
Favors Favors beta agonistbeta agonist
plus ipratropiumFavors Favors
ipratropiumFavorsFavors
beta agonistFavorsFavors
beta agonistipratropium plus ipratropiumbeta agonist beta agonist
TotalTotal 0.00 (0.00 (--0.19 0.19 -- 0.19)0.19)
Backman 1985Backman 1985
TotalTotal 0.02 (0.02 (--0.08 0.08 -- 0.12)0.12)
Lloberes 1988Lloberes 1988
Lloberes 1988Lloberes 1988
Rebuck 1987Rebuck 1987
Karpel 1990Karpel 1990
Shretha 1991Shretha 1991
Rebuck 1987Rebuck 1987
-1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1
Weighted mean difference (L)Weighted mean difference (L) Weighted mean difference (L)Weighted mean difference (L)
McCrory DC. Cochrane Database System Rev. 2003, Issue 1. Art. No.: CD003900. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD003900
Effects of Aminophylline in Hospitalized COPD Patients
Days from AdmissionDays from Admission
FEV
FEV 1
1 (L
)(L
)
1.01.0
0.80.8
0.60.6
0.40.400 11 33 55
Placebo
Aminophylline
PP = 0.49= 0.49
1.01.0
0.80.8
0.60.6
0.40.4
0.20.2
Prop
ortio
n U
nfit
for D
isch
arge
Prop
ortio
n U
nfit
for D
isch
arge
PP = 0.19= 0.19
Aminophylline
Placebo
00
Day Fit for DischargeDay Fit for Discharge
00 44 88 1212 1616 2020 2424
Duffy N. Thorax. 2005;60:713-717.
FEV1 = forced expiratory volume in 1 second.in 1 second.
COPD Exacerbations:Treatment Modalities
Bronchodilators
Oxygen
Antibiotics
Systemic corticosteroids
Noninvasive positive pressure breathing
COPD Exacerbations:Treatment Modalities
Bronchodilators
Oxygen
Antibiotics
Systemic corticosteroids
Noninvasive positive pressure breathing
COPD Exacerbations:Antibiotic Therapy
Favors Favors antibiotic
Favors Favors placeboantibiotic placebo
Alonso 1992Alonso 1992
Anthonisen 1987Anthonisen 1987
Elmes 1965Elmes 1965
Jorgensen 1992Jorgensen 1992
Pines 1968Pines 1968
Pines 1972Pines 1972
TotalTotal 0.67 (0.56 - 0.80)
0.10.1 11 22 55 10100.50.50.20.2
RR (RR (95% CI95% CI) of Treatment Failure) of Treatment Failure
Ram FSF, et al. Cochrane Database System Rev. 2006, Issue 2. Art. No.: CD004403.
Antibiotics for COPD Exacerbations
100n = 354 n = 114
n = 174n = 88
Moxifloxacin Clarithromycin
% C
linic
al S
ucce
ss
Cefuroxime-Axetil
80
Amoxicillin
60
40
20
0
Wilson R, et al; MOSAIC Study Group. Chest. 2004;125:953-964.
COPD Exacerbations:Treatment Modalities
Bronchodilators
Oxygen
Antibiotics
Systemic corticosteroids
Noninvasive positive pressure breathing
Systemic Steroids and COPD Exacerbations: SCCOPE Trial
6060
% T
reat
men
t Fai
lure
% T
reat
men
t Fai
lure
Days on StudyDays on Study
PlaceboPlacebo22--week steroidweek steroid88--week steroidweek steroid
6060 120120 18018000
4040
2020
00
Niewoehner DE, et al. N Engl J Med. 1999;340:1941-1947.
Systemic Steroids for OutpatientTherapy for COPD Exacerbations
100
Prednisone(n = 74)
% P
atie
nts
Rel
apse
-free
80
60Placebo(n = 73)P = 0.04
40
5 200 15 25 3010
Days on StudyAaron SD, et al. N Engl J Med. 2003;348:2618-2625.
Systemic Steroids and COPD Exacerbations: Meta-Analysis of Treatment Failures
Odds Ratio (95% CI)Odds Ratio (95% CI)
Aaron 2003Aaron 2003
Davies 1999Davies 1999
Maltais 2002Maltais 2002
Niewoehner 1999 Niewoehner 1999
Thompson 1996Thompson 1996
Wood-Baker RR. Cochrane Database System Rev. 2005, Issue 1. Art. No.: CD001288. DOI:10.1002/14651858.CD001288.pub2.
Summary estimateSummary estimate 0.46 (0.310.46 (0.31--0.68)0.68)
Favors Favors treatmenttreatment
Favors Favors placeboplacebo
11 1010 100100 100010000.10.10.010.010.0010.001
Steroid Therapy for COPD Exacerbations: Inhaled vs Systemic
Placebo
Nebulized budesonide(2 mg q 6h)
Oral prednisolone(30 mg q 12h)n = 62
n = 71
n = 66
1.2
Post
-BD
FEV
1(L
)
1.1
1.0
0.9
0.8
BD = bronchodilator.Maltais F, et al. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2002;165:698-703.
Hours on Study
12 480 36 60 7224
Systemic Steroids for Exacerbations:Dose Response
Daily PrednisoneEquivalents35
Ster
oid
Effe
ct ∆
FEV 1
%
60 mg1
30 mg3
640 mg4
190 mg2
Study Day
1. Maltais F, et al. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2002;165:698-703. 2. Albert RK, et al. Ann Intern Med.1980;92:753-758. 3. Davies L, et al. Lancet. 1999;354:456-460. 4. Niewoehner DE, et al. N Engl J Med. 1999;340:1941-1947.
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
1 20 3
COPD Exacerbations:Treatment Modalities
Bronchodilators
Oxygen
Antibiotics
Systemic corticosteroids
Noninvasive positive pressure breathing
Effects of NPPV on Mortality During COPD Exacerbations
0.010.01 0.10.1 11 1010 100100
Favors NPPVFavors NPPV Favors ControlFavors Control
RR (95% CI)RR (95% CI)
Bott 1993Bott 1993
Servillo 1994Servillo 1994
Brochard 1995Brochard 1995
Kramer 1995Kramer 1995
Angus 1996Angus 1996
Celikel 1998Celikel 1998
Plant 2000Plant 2000
Dikensoy 2002Dikensoy 2002
CRC 2005CRC 2005
Dhamija 2005Dhamija 2005
Keenan 2005Keenan 2005
0.45 0.45 ((0.300.30--0.66)0.66)Pooled summaryPooled summary
Quon BS, et al. Quon BS, et al. Chest.Chest. 2008;133:7562008;133:756--766.766.