3
COORDINATE SYSTEM COMPARISON FOR WISCONSIN DIFFERENCES BETWEEN DATUMS WHICH COORDINATE SYSTEM/PROJECTION IS APPROPRIATE? A datum is a mathematically-defined reference surface used to represent the size and shape of the Earth. A horizontal datum is defined by an ellipsoid, and its fixation with respect to the surface of the earth. The two most commonly used horizontal datums in Wisconsin are the North American Datum of 1927 (NAD 27) and the North American Datum of 1983 (NAD 83). NAD 27 was based on Clarke's 1866 model of the earth's surface. It was used for original surveying of state/county/township lines and over the decades many mapping measurements have been referenced to NAD 27 by local, state, and federal agencies. NAD 83 was a revision based on a more accurate understanding of the earth's surface and has replaced NAD 27 as the datum of choice throughout Wisconsin. Significant distortion on the local level that had accumulated over the years in NAD 27 was removed, making it more compatible with modern survey technologies and practices. There is no mathematical correlation between NAD 27 and NAD 83 because each was computed from differing sets of measurements referenced to different ellipsoids. However, transformation software is available to interpolate the differences. With the introduction of high-precision instruments, another adjustment was made, creating the High Accuracy Referenced Network (HARN), also known as NAD 83 (1991). The difference between NAD83 and NAD 83 (1991) varies roughly from zero to seven centimeters for most of Wisconsin. Due to this, comparisons of NAD 83 (1991) and NAD 83 are not given in this document. It is the preferred system in use by the Wisconsin DNR. The accuracy of a projection is given as a ratio such as 1:10,000. This means for every 10,000 units (it doesn’t matter whether it’s inches, feet, meters, etc.), the actual measurement could fall anywhere between 9,999 and 10,001 units. The following coordinate systems are listed from least accurate to most accurate. The Universal Transverse Mercator (UTM) coordinate system was developed by the Department of Defense and is a global coordinate system with 60 north-south zones. Wisconsin falls within UTM zone 15 and 16 about equally. Each zone width is 6 degrees, which creates a scale difference of no more than 1:2,500. UTM parameters are the same for NAD 27 and NAD 83, making datum adjustment information critical. In Wisconsin, UTM coordinate differences for the two datums are approximately 200 meters in northing, and less than 10 meters in easting. The Wisconsin Transverse Mercator (WTM) was developed by the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources to avoid problems caused by having the state divided into two UTM zones. This system centers a UTM-like zone on the 90th meridian (west), thereby covering the state with one zone. The distortion in the projection increases from the center toward the eastern and western extremes of the state. A false easting of 500,000 meters and a false northing of -4,500,000 meters are used. WTM was redefined for the NAD 83 datum and has a different false easting and northing than WTM 27. WTM 83 coordinates are based on a false easting of 520,000 meters and a false northing of -4,480,000 meters. The State Plane Coordinate (SPC) System was introduced nationally in the 1930’s and is based on both the Lambert conformal conic and transverse Mercator projections. In Wisconsin there are three Lambert projections comprising North, Central, and South State Plane Coordinate zones. The system maintains an accuracy of at least 1:10,000. When NAD 83 was developed the SPC parameters were redefined. SPC 83 was assigned a different false easting than SPC 27 so that coordinate values in the two systems could easily be distinguished by a six mile difference in easting. At the federal level SPC 83 uses the meter as a unit of measure, but in the Wisconsin Statutes, Chapter 236 specifies the U.S. Survey Foot as the official unit of measure for Wisconsin. The Wisconsin County Coordinate System (WCCS) was created by the Wisconsin Department of Transportation (WisDOT) and became available in 1995. It uses metric units and has a maximum distortion of 1:30,000 in rural areas and 1:50,000 in urban areas. There are also distinct numeric differences between adjacent county coordinate systems to avoid confusion. The WCCS is mathematically based on, and related to NAD 83. WisDOT wanted to eliminate the need for ground-to-grid conversion of distances, which could vary by as much as one foot per mile in other coordinate systems. In order to do this each county coordinate system used its own enlarged and elevated local reference surface, effectively creating its own unique horizontal geodetic datum. This created usage problems as WCCS was more widely adopted. The Wisconsin Coordinate Reference System (WISCRS) was created in 2004 by the Wisconsin Land Information Association (WLIA), who analyzed the existing usage problems with WCCS. WLIA concluded the best solution available was to redesign the system, and WISCRS was the result of their efforts. In WISCRS all county coordinate systems now use the same reference ellipsoid. The largest difference in coordinate values between WCCR and WISCRS is 5 millimeters in four counties, with most counties averaging a difference of only three millimeters or less. The information above was adapted from the Wisconsin Coordinate Reference Systems (2nd Edition) handbook, published in 2009 by the Wisconsin State Cartographer's Office of the University of Wisconsin - Madison. This publication is available online at the Wisconsin State Cartographer's Office website through the following link: http://www.sco.wisc.edu/images/stories/publications/WisCoordRefSys_January2012.pdf Lambert conformal conic projection transverse Mercator projection POSITIONING SHIFTS DUE TO DATUM CHANGES Datum & Coordinate System Amount of Change (approx.) Difference between UTM 27 and UTM 83 projected positions 200 meters in northing and less than 10 meters in easting Difference between WTM 27 and WTM 83 projected positions Difference between SPC 27 and SPC 83 projected positions 20,000 meters (13 miles) in northing and easting 6 miles in easting

COORDINATE SYSTEM COMPARISON FOR WISCONSIN · COORDINATE SYSTEM COMPARISON FOR WISCONSIN DIFFERENCES BETWEEN DATUMS WHICH COORDINATE SYSTEM/PROJECTION I S A PPROPRI ATE? A datum is

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: COORDINATE SYSTEM COMPARISON FOR WISCONSIN · COORDINATE SYSTEM COMPARISON FOR WISCONSIN DIFFERENCES BETWEEN DATUMS WHICH COORDINATE SYSTEM/PROJECTION I S A PPROPRI ATE? A datum is

CO O R D I N AT E S Y S T E M CO M PA R I S O N F O R W I S C O N S I ND I F F E R E N C E S B E T W E E N D AT U M S

W H I C H C O O R D I N AT E S Y S T E M / P R O J E C T I O N I S A P P R O P R I AT E ?

A datum is a mathematically-defined reference surface used to represent the size and shape of the Earth. A horizontal datum is defined by an ellipsoid, and its fixation with respect to the surface of the earth. The two most commonly used horizontal datums in Wisconsin are the North American Datum of 1927 (NAD 27) and the North American Datum of 1983 (NAD 83).NAD 27 was based on Clarke's 1866 model of the earth's surface. It was used for original surveying of state/county/township lines and over the decades many mapping measurements have been referenced to NAD 27 by local, state, and federal agencies.NAD 83 was a revision based on a more accurate understanding of the earth's surface and has replaced NAD 27 as the datum of choice throughout Wisconsin. Significant distortion on the local level that had accumulated over the years in NAD 27 was removed, making it more compatible with modern survey technologies and practices. There is no mathematical correlation between NAD 27 and NAD 83 because each was computed from differing sets of measurements referenced to different ellipsoids. However, transformation software is available to interpolate the differences.With the introduction of high-precision instruments, another adjustment was made, creating the High Accuracy Referenced Network (HARN), also known as NAD 83 (1991). The difference between NAD83 and NAD 83 (1991) varies roughly from zero to seven centimeters for most of Wisconsin. Due to this, comparisons of NAD 83 (1991) and NAD 83 are not given in this document. It is the preferred system in use by the Wisconsin DNR.

The accuracy of a projection is given as a ratio such as 1:10,000. This means for every 10,000 units (it doesn’t matter whether it’s inches, feet, meters, etc.), the actual measurement could fall anywhere between 9,999 and 10,001 units. The following coordinate systems are listed from least accurate to most accurate.The Universal Transverse Mercator (UTM) coordinate system was developed by the Department of Defense and is a global coordinate system with 60 north-south zones. Wisconsin falls within UTM zone 15 and 16 about equally. Each zone width is 6 degrees, which creates a scale difference of no more than 1:2,500. UTM parameters are the same for NAD 27 and NAD 83, making datum adjustment information critical. In Wisconsin, UTM coordinate differences for the two datums are approximately 200 meters in northing, and less than 10 meters in easting.The Wisconsin Transverse Mercator (WTM) was developed by the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources to avoid problems caused by having the state divided into two UTM zones. This system centers a UTM-like zone on the 90th meridian (west), thereby covering the state with one zone. The distortion in the projection increases from the center toward the eastern and western extremes of the state. A false easting of 500,000 meters and a false northing of -4,500,000 meters are used. WTM was redefined for the NAD 83 datum and has a different false easting and northing than WTM 27. WTM 83 coordinates are based on a false easting of 520,000 meters and a false northing of -4,480,000 meters.The State Plane Coordinate (SPC) System was introduced nationally in the 1930’s and is based on both the Lambert conformal conic and transverse Mercator projections. In Wisconsin there are three Lambert projections comprising North, Central, and South State Plane Coordinate zones. The system maintains an accuracy of at least 1:10,000. When NAD 83 was developed the SPC parameters were redefined. SPC 83 was assigned a different false easting than SPC 27 so that coordinate values in the two systems could easily be distinguished by a six mile difference in easting. At the federal level SPC 83 uses the meter as a unit of measure, but in the Wisconsin Statutes, Chapter 236 specifies the U.S. Survey Foot as the official unit of measure for Wisconsin. The Wisconsin County Coordinate System (WCCS) was created by the Wisconsin Department of Transportation (WisDOT) and became available in 1995. It uses metric units and has a maximum distortion of 1:30,000 in rural areas and 1:50,000 in urban areas. There are also distinct numeric differences between adjacent county coordinate systems to avoid confusion. The WCCS is mathematically based on, and related to NAD 83. WisDOT wanted to eliminate the need for ground-to-grid conversion of distances, which could vary by as much as one foot per mile in other coordinate systems. In order to do this each county coordinate system used its own enlarged and elevated local reference surface, effectively creating its own unique horizontal geodetic datum. This created usage problems as WCCS was more widely adopted.The Wisconsin Coordinate Reference System (WISCRS) was created in 2004 by the Wisconsin Land Information Association (WLIA), who analyzed the existing usage problems with WCCS. WLIA concluded the best solution available was to redesign the system, and WISCRS was the result of their efforts. In WISCRS all county coordinate systems now use the same reference ellipsoid. The largest difference in coordinate values between WCCR and WISCRS is 5 millimeters in four counties, with most counties averaging a difference of only three millimeters or less.

The information above was adapted from the Wisconsin Coordinate Reference Systems (2nd Edition) handbook, published in 2009 by the Wisconsin State Cartographer's Office of the University of Wisconsin - Madison. This publication is available online at the Wisconsin State Cartographer's Office website through the following link: http://www.sco.wisc.edu/images/stories/publications/WisCoordRefSys_January2012.pdf

Lambert conformal conic projection transverse Mercator projection

P O S I T I O N I N G S H I F T S D U E T O DAT U M C H A N G E SDatum & Coordinate System Amount of Change (approx.)Difference between UTM 27 and UTM 83 projected positions

200 meters in northing and less than 10 meters in easting

Difference between WTM 27 and WTM 83 projected positionsDifference between SPC 27 and SPC 83 projected positions

20,000 meters (13 miles) in northing and easting6 miles in easting

Page 2: COORDINATE SYSTEM COMPARISON FOR WISCONSIN · COORDINATE SYSTEM COMPARISON FOR WISCONSIN DIFFERENCES BETWEEN DATUMS WHICH COORDINATE SYSTEM/PROJECTION I S A PPROPRI ATE? A datum is

Price

Clark

Dane

Polk

Vilas

Grant

IronBayfield

Rusk

SawyerOneida

Marathon

Sauk

Forest

Taylor

Douglas

Iowa

Dunn

Marinette

Rock

Oconto

Wood

Dodge

BarronLincoln

Burnett

Jackson

Ashland

Monroe

VernonJuneau

Portage

Chippewa

Buffalo

Adams

Shawano

Langlade

Door

Green

Pierce

Brown

Columbia

Waupaca

Lafayette

Richland

St. Croix

Jefferson

Waushara

Walworth

Eau Claire

Fond du Lac

Outagamie

Florence

RacineKenosha

Washburn

Crawford

Tremp

ealeau

Manitowoc

Waukesha

WinnebagoCalumet

La Crosse MarquetteSheboygan

Pepin

Washington

Kewaunee

GreenLake

Menominee

Ozaukee

Milwaukee

UTM Zone 15 UTM Zone 1690°0'0"W

90°0'0"W

300,000

300,000

400,000

400,000

500,000

500,000

600,000

600,000

700,000

700,000

200,0

00

300,0

00

300,0

00

400,0

00

400,0

00

500,0

00

500,0

00

600,0

00

600,0

00

700,0

00

700,0

00

U N I V E R S A L T R A N S V E R S E M E R C AT O RW I S C O N S I N T R A N S V E R S E M E R C AT O R

Wisconsin Transverse Mercator 1927NAD 27Transverse Mercator0.999690°W (-90°)0°500,000 meters-4,500,000 metersmeter

Coordinate System:Datum:

Projection:Scale Factor at Central Meridian:

Longitude of Central Meridian:Latitude of Origin:

False Easting:False Northing:

Unit:

Wisconsin Transverse Mercator 1983 (1991)NAD 83 HARN (aka: NAD 83/91 or HPGN)Transverse Mercator0.999690°W (-90°)0°520,000 meters-4,480,000 metersmeter

UTM Zone 16 NorthNAD 83Transverse Mercator0.999687°W (-87°)0°500,000 metersnonemeter

UTM Zone 15 NorthNAD 83Transverse Mercator0.999693°W (-93°)0°500,000 metersnonemeter

300,000

300,000

400,000

400,000

500,000

500,000

600,000

600,000

700,000

700,000

200,0

00

200,0

00

300,0

00

300,0

00

400,0

00

400,0

00

500,0

00

500,0

00

600,0

00

600,0

00

700,0

00

700,0

00

500,000

500,000

600,000

600,000

700,000

700,000

800,000

800,000

900,000

900,000

1,000,000

1,000,000

4,800

,000

4,800

,000

5,000

,000

5,000

,000

5,200

,000

5,200

,000

100,000

100,000

200,000

200,000

300,000

300,000

400,000

400,000

500,000

500,000

4,800

,000

4,800

,000

5,000

,000

5,000

,000

5,200

,000

5,200

,000

W I S C O N S I N C O O R D I N AT E R E F E R E N C E S Y S T E M S

VERNON

600,000

600,000

700,000

700,000

800,000

800,000

900,000

900,000

0 0

100,0

00

100,0

00

200,0

00

200,0

00

300,0

00

300,0

00

BROWN

0

0

100,000

100,000

200,000

200,000

300,000

300,000

400,0

00

400,0

00

500,0

00

500,0

00

600,0

00

600,0

00

700,0

00

700,0

00

For more information on a specific county's WISCRS visit the following link:http://www.sco.wisc.edu/images/stories/publications/WisCoordRefSys_January2012.pdf

WISCRS, Vernon CountyNAD 83 HARN (aka. NAD 83/91)Lambert Conformal Conic1.000040815890°47'00.000000"W43°34'30.118583"N730000.000 U.S. Survey Feet155944.768 U.S. Survey FeetU.S. Survey Foot

WISCRS, Brown CountyNAD 83 HARN (aka. NAD 83/91)Transverse Mercator1.000020000088°00'00.000000"W43°00'00.000000"N103674.333 U.S. Survey Feet15091.833 U.S. Survey FeetU.S. Survey Foot

Coordinate System:Datum:

Projection:Scale Factor at Central Meridian:

Longitude of Central Meridian:Latitude of Origin:

False Easting:False Northing:

Unit:

W I S C O N S I N C O U N T I E SP R E D O M I N A N T

U T M Z O N E S

Zone 15Zone 16

Page 3: COORDINATE SYSTEM COMPARISON FOR WISCONSIN · COORDINATE SYSTEM COMPARISON FOR WISCONSIN DIFFERENCES BETWEEN DATUMS WHICH COORDINATE SYSTEM/PROJECTION I S A PPROPRI ATE? A datum is

1,500,000

1,500,000

2,000,000

2,000,000

2,500,000

2,500,0000 0

500,0

00

500,0

00

1,000

,000

1,000

,000

1,500

,000

1,500

,000

State Plane Coordinate System (SPC) - SouthNAD 27Lambert Conformal Conic1.042° 44’44° 04’-90° 00’42° 00’2,000,000 U.S. Survey Feet0U.S. Survey Foot

State Plane Coordinate System (SPC) - SouthNAD 83Lambert Conformal Conic1.042°44' 44°04' -90°00'42°00'1,968,500 U.S. Survey Feet0U.S. Survey Foot

State Plane Coordinate System (SPC) - CentralNAD 27Lambert Conformal Conic1.044° 15’45° 30’-90° 00’43° 50’2,000,000 U.S. Survey Feet0U.S. Survey Foot

State Plane Coordinate System (SPC) - CentralNAD 83Lambert Conformal Conic1.044° 15' 45° 30' -90° 00'43° 50'1,968,500 U.S. Survey Feet0U.S. Survey Foot

1,500,000

1,500,000

2,000,000

2,000,000

2,500,000

2,500,000

0 0

500,0

00

500,0

00

1,000

,000

1,000

,000

1,500

,000

1,500

,000

1,500,000

1,500,000

2,000,000

2,000,000

2,500,000

2,500,000

-500,0

00

-500,0

00

0 0

500,0

00

500,0

00

1,000

,000

1,000

,000

1,500,000

1,500,000

2,000,000

2,000,000

2,500,000

2,500,000

-500,0

00

-500,0

00

0 0

500,0

00

500,0

00

1,000

,000

1,000

,000

Price

Clark

Dane

Polk

Vilas

Grant

IronBayfield

Rusk

SawyerOneida

Marathon

Sauk

Forest

Taylor

Douglas

Iowa

Dunn

Marinette

Rock

Oconto

Wood

Dodge

BarronLincoln

Burnett

Jackson

Ashland

Monroe

VernonJuneau

Portage

Chippewa

Buffalo

Adams

Shawano

Langlade

Door

Green

Pierce

Brown

Columbia

Waupaca

Lafayette

Richland

St. Croix

Jefferson

Waushara

Walworth

Eau Claire

Fond du Lac

Outagamie

Florence

RacineKenosha

Washburn

Crawford

Tremp

ealeau

Manitowoc

Waukesha

WinnebagoCalumet

La Crosse MarquetteSheboygan

Pepin

Washington

Kewaunee

GreenLake

Menominee

Ozaukee

MilwaukeeS O U T H Z O N E

C E N T R A L Z O N E

N O R T H Z O N E

Coordinate System:Datum:

Projection:Scale Factor at Central Meridian:

1st Standard Parallel:2nd Standard Parallel:

Longitude of Central Meridian:Latitude of Origin:

False Easting:False Northing:

Unit:

State Plane Coordinate System (SPC) - NorthNAD 83Lambert Conformal Conic1.045° 34'46° 46'-90° 00'45° 10'1,968,500 U.S. Survey Feet0U.S. Survey Foot

1,500,000

1,500,000

2,000,000

2,000,000

2,500,000

2,500,000

-1,00

0,000

-1,00

0,000

-500,0

00

-500,0

00

0 0

500,0

00

500,0

00

1,500,000

1,500,000

2,000,000

2,000,000

2,500,000

2,500,000

-1,00

0,000

-1,00

0,000

-500,0

00

-500,0

00

0 0

500,0

00

500,0

00

C E N T R A L Z O N E

State Plane Coordinate System (SPC) - NorthNAD 27Lambert Conformal Conic1.045° 34' 46° 46' -90° 00' 45° 10' 2,000,000 U.S. Survey Feet0U.S. Survey Foot

Coordinate System:Datum:

Projection:Scale Factor at Central Meridian:

1st Standard Parallel:2nd Standard Parallel:

Longitude of Central Meridian:Latitude of Origin:

False Easting:False Northing:

Unit:

S TAT E P L A N E C O O R D I N AT ES Y S T E M Z O N E S

N O R T H Z O N E

S O U T H Z O N E