Cooperation between European countries through the Geothermal … · 7th Geothermal ERA NET meeting Trieste, Italy 10-11 September 2014 ... Pisa 2nd EGIP Workshop Pisa 3rd meeting

Geothermal ERA NET Coordination Office

Orkustofnun, Iceland

Cooperation between European countries through the

Geothermal ERA NET

Guðni A JóhannessonDirector General, Orkustofnun, Iceland

Geothermal ERA NET Coordination Office7th Geothermal ERA NET meeting

Trieste, Italy10-11 September 2014

Morning Session

The Geothermal ERA NET is supported by the European Union's Seventh Programme, for research, technological development and demonstration

under grant agreement No 291866



I. The Geothermal ERA NET

II. Process of implementation

III. Theme of the Meeting and Next steps

Overview



IS Orkustofnun (National Energy Authority),

NL Rijksdienst voor Ondernemend Nederland

CH Swiss Federal Office of Energy (SFOE)

I National Research Council of Italy (CNR)

D Jülich (PTJ)

F ADEME ( BRGM as third party)

IS Icelandic Centre for Research (RANNÍS)

TR TÜBITAK (Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey)

SVK Slovak Ministry of Education, Science, Research and Sport

MFIG Hungarian Geological and Geophysical Institute

SED Slovenian Energy Directorate

EAD Electicidade dos Acores

The Geothermal ERA-NET Consortium

Lead partner is Orkustofnun operating the

Geothermal ERA NETCoordination Office

Good geographical balance(North-West to South-East Europe) Partner countries chosen a.o. on basis of their 2020/2050 geothermal ambitions

New partners



Objective

Highlight barriers and

recommend practical solutions

Exchange information on the status of geothermal energy

Recommend measures to

Strengthen European Geothermal Development,

for

Economic Opportunities, Energy Security

and Mitigate Climate Change

Lay groundwork to create a

European Geothermal Information Platform



Objective

Communicate with principal stakeholders and enhance

public awareness on the added value and benefits of geothermal scientific and policy issues

Increase transnational collaboration in

research training and mobility

Prepare Policy and Implementation for a Common European Geothermal Action Plan

for geothermal energy technology research, development, deployment and innovation supported by member states

Prepare and Implement Joint Geothermal Activities (e.g. transnational funding activities)



Analysis -> Assessments -> Joint Activities –> Implementation –> Future Policy

Objective and Task



EU / EEA - Vision

Source: Presentation of J.M. Barroso President of the European Commission, to the European Council of 20-21 March 2014

Xuse



EU / EEA - Vision

Sources: EU




Power generation capacity by sourcesRenewables is the biggest < 10 years

Sources: EU




Getting Geothermal on the Radar

Sources: EU




GEOTHERMAL ENERGY offers major opportunities for

• Economic opportunities and savings

• Improve energy security in Europe

• Reducing greenhouse gas emissions

• Reducing dependence on fossil fuels for energy use

• Improving quality of life

• Growing the low-Carbon technology industry and creating employment opportunities

For the future of our European cities

For the future of our Food supply

For our Industry and Power supply

11

Benefits of Geothermal



• “Renewables for heating and cooling could save EUR 11.5 billion per year within EU”

• Statement from AEBIOM, EGEC and ESTIF representing the biomass, geothermal and solar thermal sectors respectively, which addressed an open letter to the Heads of State and Government, ahead of their spring meeting in Brussels 19th of March 2014.

• “Renewables for heating in Iceland is already saving up to 7% of GDP or equivalent 3000 US $ per capita per year”

• According to assessment done within Orkustofnun, Iceland 2014

• “Geothermal District Heating has the potential to alleviate Europe’s energy security crisis “

• Is stated in a press release from Geothermal District Heating (GeoDH) in Brussels, 15th May 2014.

• It is therefore important for policymakers and others to recognize the great opportunity regarding geothermal heating for savings for countries, improve the energy security and mitigate climate change

Economic Benefits of Geothermal



Kick-off meeting Reykjavík

D 1.7 - M Periodic Report to the EU

1st EGIP Workshop Reykjavik

2nd meetingPisa

2nd EGIP WorkshopPisa

3rd meetingReykjavik

4th meetingPisa 5th meeting

Budapest

6th meetingGstaad

D 1.2 Newsletter

D 1.3 Newsletter

D 1.1 Website

D 6.1 Report with an inventory of existing mobility and programmes

D 3.1 Report on the state of the art and needs in regarding geothermal data and existing tools to manage them.

D 5.1 Report with the inventory of principal stakeholders and classification of stakeholder on a national level

D 3.2 Feasibility study for a European Geothermal Database

D 2.1 Report with an inventory of existing support and funding schemes

D 2.2 Report with an inventory of RD&D projects highlights

D 1.4 Newsletter

7th meetingTrieste

D 2.3 –Report on technical & non technical barriers

D 2.4 – Report on future RD & D needs

D 5.2 Report –inventory principal stakeholders and classification of stakeholder on European level

D 6.2. Recommendation for collaboration in the area of HR, mobility and training

Progress from last meeting

Geothermal ERA NET Process of implementation

8th meetingOffenburg, Germany2-4 MarchGeoTerm Expo



New Report - Comparison on International Geothermal Energy Statistics

• The name of the report: International Geothermal Energy Statistics Reporting

• The aim of the report is to provide an overview of the international collection of geothermal energy statistics by various international organizations.

• The overview can assist the Geothermal ERA-NET in evaluating how they can contribute to the geothermal community without further duplicating the work that is already multiplicated across various international bodies.

• It can also be used by energy agencies to enable interoperability of geothermal energy statistics, increase reliability and decrease fragmentation.

• The report is in process and will be soon ready for a review



Comparison of data statistics from countries Total use of Geothermal Energy



Newsletter, information,promotion and awareness raising



Newsletter, information,promotion and awareness raising



Geothermal ERA NET 2012 - 2016

Timing of work packages and their components

List of Deliverables (D - reports) 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4

and Milestones (M - events)ERA NET Coordination, August 2014 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48

WP1 - Coordination, Management & Dissemination (OS)Kick off meeting Annual meeting Annual meeting Annual meeting Annual meeting

D 1.1 Websites M

D 1.2 - 6 Newsletter and other information leaflets D D D D D

D 1.7 Periodic and final activity and management report for the EC M M D M M D M

D 1.8 Publishable final report D

WP2 - Information exchange on national incentives Website launched

and status of geothermal energy (RVO)

D 2.1 Report with an inventory of existing support and function scheme D Proposed actions to promote the use of geothermal energy in Europe

D 2.2 Report with an inventory of RD&D projects highlights D

D 2.3 Report on technical & non-technical barriers M D

D 2.4 Report on future RD&D needs D

D 2.5 Report on required actions D

D 2.6 Updated and extended report on collected information D

WG3 -Towards a European Geothermal (CNR)Database workshop 1

D 3.1 Report on the state of the art and needs in regarding geothermal data and existing

tools to manage them D Database workshop 2

D 3.2 Feasibility study for an European Geothermal Database M M D

D 3.3 Report on the implementation of the European Geot.Datab. D

WP4 - Development of joint activities (Julich)

D 4.1 Report on possible schemes and barriers for the joint activities D Action Plan for joint activities

D 4.2 Report on common interests D

D 4.3 Action plan for joint activities M D

WG5 - Cooperation with stakeholders (SFOE)

D 5.1 Report with the inventory of principal stakeholders & classification of stakeholders on national level D Communication and engagement plan

D 5.2 Report including the inventory and classifications of stakeholders on European level D

D 5.3 Communication plan with key message to principal European and national stakeholders D

D 5.4 Delivery of a comprehensive plan to successfully engage stakeholders to the

development of a strategic roadmap for geothermal energy RD&D in Europe D M

WP6 - Transnational Mobility and Training (RANNIS) Recommendation of joint actions

D 6.1 Report with an inventory of existing mobility and programmes D

D 6.2 Recommendations for collaboration in the area of HR, mobility and training M D

D 6.3 Report form expert exchange scheme, including rules and guidelines D

WP7 - Implementation of joint activities (CNR) Implementation of joint activities

D 7.1 Report on development tools for joint activities D

D 7.2 Proposals for transnational activities M D

D 7.3 Evaluation Report from transnational activities D

D 7.4 Analysis report with proposals on future programme collaboration (incl. stakeholders collaboration) D

Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016



Implementation - DeliverablesTable 1.3 b: Deliverables List

No Deliverable Name WP No.Lead

participantNature

Dessimination

Level [3]

Delivery

Date [4] Calander date

D 1.2 Newsletter and other information leaflets 1 OS O PU 1 May 2012

D 1.1 Website for the project continuously updated 1 OS O PU 3 July 2012

D 6.1 Report with an inventory of existing mobility and programmes 6 RANNIS R PU 8 December 2012

D 3.1Report on the state of the art and needs in regarding geothermal

data and existing tools to manage them. 3 CNR R RE 9 January 2013

D 1.3 Newsletter and other information leaflets 2 OS O PU 12 April 2013

D 5.1Report with the inventory of principal stakeholders and

classification of stakeholder on a national level5 SFOE R CO 12

April 2013

D 2.1Report with an inventory of existing support and funding

schemes 2 Agentschap R RE 15

July 2013

D 2.2 Report with an inventory of RD&D projects highlights 2 Agentschap R RE 15 July 2013

D 1.7 Periodic activity and management reports for the EC 1 OS R PU 18 Ocotber 2013

D 3.2 Feasibility study for a European Geothermal Database 3 CNR R RE 18 October 2013

D 5.2 Report including the inventory and classification of stakeholders on European level5 SFOE R CO 24 April 2014

D 7.1 Report on developed tools for joint activates 7 CNR R RE 24 April 2014


D 2.3 Report on technical & non-technical barriers 2 Agentschap R RE 26 June 2014

D 2.4 Report on future RD&D needs 2 Agentschap R RE 26 June 2014

D 6.2 Recommendations for collaboratin and proposals for joint actions 6 RANNIS R CO 29 August 2014

D 2.5 Report on required actions 2 Agentschap R RE 30 September 2014

D 4.1 Report on possible schemes and barriers for the joint activities 4 Jülich R RE 28 August 2014

D 4.2 Report on common interests 4 Jülich R RE 30 Ocotber 2014

D 5.3Communication plan with key messages to principal European

and national stakeholders5 SFOE R PU 30

Ocotber 2014


D 1.8 Periodic activity and management reports for the EC 1 OS R PU 36 April 2015

D 4.3 Action plan for joint activities 4 Jülich R RE 36 April 2015

D 5.4 Delivery of a comprehensive plan to successfully engage stakeholders for the development of a strategic roadmap for geothermal energy RDD&I in Europe5 SFOE R PU 36 April 2015

D 7.2 Proposals for transnational activitie 7 CNR R RE 36 April 2015

D 6.3 Report from expert exchange scheme, including rules and guidelines6 RANNIS R CO 42 Ocotber 2015

D 3.3Report on the implementation of the European Geothermal

Database3 CNR R RE 45

January 2016

D 7.3 Evaluation Report from transnational activities 7 CNR R RE 46 February 2016

D 7.4 Analysis report with proposals on future programme collaboration (incl. stakeholder collaboration) 7 CNR R RE 46 February 2016


D 1.8 Publishable Final activity and management reports for the EC 1 OS R PU 48 April 2016

D 2.6 Updated and extended report on collected information 2 Agentschap R RE 48 April 2016

Implementation - Deliverables



Implementation - Milestones

Milestone

numberMilestone name

Work

package

Lead

beneficiary

Delivery date

from Annex ICalander date

MS1 Kick Off meeting WP 1 OS 1 May 2012

MS2 Website WP 1 OS 3 June 2012

MS3 Annual project meeting WP 1 OS 9 January 2013

MS8

Database workshop 1: European

Geothermal Database: State of the art and

needs

WP 3 CNR 10 February 2013

MS9Database workshop 2: European

Geothermal Database: Feasibility studyWP 3 CNR 15 July 2013


MS12Proposals for joint actions in HR, mobility

and trainingWP 6 Rannis 29 August 2014

MS7Propose actions to promote the use of

geothermal energy in EuropeWP 2 Agentschap 30 September 2014

MS5 Annual project meetingWP 1 OS 33 January 2015

MS10 Action plan for joint activities WP 4 Julich 36 April 2015

MS13 Joint transnational activity WP 7 CNR 36 April 2015

MS11 Communication and engagement plan WP 5 SFOE 42 October 2015


Table 1.3 c: List of milestones

Implementation - Milestones



The financial results from the Geothermal ERA-NET’s first reporting period (01/05/12 - 31/10/13), as well the financial data from all the beneficiaries for the following 6 month period (01/11/13 – 30/4/14)

Finance



Estimated eligible costs* of the project during the project lifetime over four years

ParticipantCoordination /

Support (A) Management (B) Other (C) Total A+B+COS 458.321 61.500 - 519.821

RVO 388.726 10.800 - 399.526

SFOE 181.560 10.440 - 192.000

CNR 278.823 9.434 - 288.257

Jülich 237.378 8.760 - 246.137

ADEME 12.480 9.600 - 22.080

BRGM 84.480 - - 84.480

Rannis 181.800 5.850 - 187.650

MFGI 98.640 3.600 - 102.240

TUBITAK 102.900 4.200 - 107.100

MESRS 136.080 5.520 - 141.600

2.161.187 129.704 - 2.290.891*

* Please note that this is the total estimated eligible costs, not the max requested EU contribution.

Review – the Budget



Beneficiary

6 month period (01/11/2013-

30/4/14 )

Claimed first reporting period (01/05/12-

31/10/13) Total Total budget Actual

cost/Budget

OS 44.103 103.220 147.323 519.821 28%

RVO 21.200 57.738 78.938 399.526 20%

SFOE 8.941 12.742 21.683 192.000 11%

CNR 67.532 122.170 189.702 288.257 66%

Jülich 8.828 22.286 31.114 246.137 13%

ADEME 2.840 11.412 14.252 22.080 65%

BRGM 22.389 22.844 45.233 84.480 54%

Rannis 9.075 18.818 27.894 187.650 15%

MFGI 12.110 919 13.029 102.240 13%

Tubitak 4.550 20.579 25.129 107.100 23%

MESRS 14.065 44.904 58.969 141.600 42%

Total 215.634 437.631 653.265 2.290.891 29%

Total Cost vs. the Budget

For the first 24 months (out of total 48), approximately 29% of the estimated cost has been incurred.



Total Cost broken down on Work Packages

Work Package Total (€)

WP1 191.484

WP2 153.284

WP3 168.105

WP4 24.118

WP5 59.056

WP6 46.337

WP7 10.882

Total 653.265



1. Two new partners have accepted to participate

1. SED Slovenian Energy Directorate

2. EAD Electicidade dos Acores (Portugal)

Validation ongoing and documents in preparation.

2. DoW updated 1. Agentschap -> RVO (Netherland)

2. Merges / new deliverables / changes in timing

3. General items – updated text

4. A revised version will be circulated soon

5. The goal is to have the amendments ready for EC approval before the end of the month

Grant Agreement Amendments



ERA NET Agenda10th September 2014

8:50 Welcome by Host Country

9:00 Overview by the Coordinator, Guðni A Jóhannesson,

9:15 Introduction to the Project Review and presentation of the experts - EC

9:20 Information exchange on national incentives and status on geothermal energy

WP2 – RVO, Presentation (15’) – Discussions (45’)

Executive Summary – Main Challenges & Opportunities - Next Steps

D2.5, entitled “Actions to bridge gaps, overcome barriers and promote the use of geothermal energy in Europe ERANET Geothermal Energy”.

10:20 Coffee / Break

10:40 Towards a European Geothermal Database - WP3 – CNR, Present.(15’), Discus. (15’)


11:10 Development of Joint Activities - WP4, – Julich, Present.(15’), Discus.(30’)


11:55 Cooperation with Stakeholders - WP5 – SFOE, Present.(5’),Discus. (10’)


12:10 Transnational Mobility and Training - WP6 – RANNIS, Present. (15’), Discus. (15’)


12:40 Lunch at Restaurant La Delizia (just in front of the Hotel Victoria)

14:00 Implementation of Joint Activities, - WP7 - Present. (30’), Discus. (45’)


15:15 Project Review – Discussions – Summary, Main Findings & Future Policy

16:00 Coffee / Break

16:15 The ERA-NET Instrument in H2020 (EC Research Programme Officer, Susanna Galloni) 16:30 Final remarks - Delivering the Main Objectives - ERA NET+, Present. (15’),Discus. (30’)

ERA NET Coordinator Guðni A Jóhannesson,

16:45 Preparation & Policy for the Bilateral meeting with EERA-JPGE (30’)

20:00 Dinner Restaurant Menarosti, (5’ walking distance from the Hotel Victoria)



EERA / ERA NET AGENDA11th September 2014

9:00 Welcome coffee 9:30 Welcome by the EERA-JPGE Coordinator (Ernst Huenges) 9:45 Presentation of Geothermal ERA-NET by Coordinator (Gudni A. Johannesson) 10:00 Recent EERA Activities / Reports – Main Challenges & Opportunities 10:15 Technical and Non-technical Barriers & Future R&D Needs WP2 – RVO - Actions to bridge gaps, overcome barriers and promote the use of

geothermal energy in Europe ERANET Geothermal Energy 10:30 Coffee / Break 10:45 European Geothermal Information Platform (EGIP):

WP3 / WP7 - CNR – EGIP Pilot version developed as Joint Activity by ERA-NET

11:00 Roundtable Discussions - Potential Joint Activities Moderator, ERA NET, Coordinator, Guðni A Johannesson 12:30 Final Remarks and Next Steps - Ernst Huenges & Gudni A. Johannesson 13:00 End of meeting



Joint Activities – Implementation

and Future Policy

Opportunities, Challenges and Policy

Defining Joint Activities

Plan for Implementations

Future Strategy – ERA NET +

Theme of the meeting

Documents

Cooperation between European countries through the Geothermal … · 7th Geothermal ERA NET meeting Trieste, Italy 10-11 September 2014 ... Pisa 2nd EGIP Workshop Pisa 3rd meeting