6
Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr Nlcut Pcjtry Hunm N- Bnlnkkjrc Prajtc  Pnoj > Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr nlcut Pcjtry8 N Rjmsj cg Ornmfjur nmf Brngt At as mct cgtjm tdnt tdj jfubntjf nmf umjfubntjf ijjt am tdj nrjmn cg pcjtry- Vdas pcji+  ly Inynecvsea+ prcvafjs amsaodt amtc tdj iamf cg tdj prcgabajmt nrtast nmf wratjr+ kjttamo us emcw tdnt pcjtry as iubd icrj tdnm n bcipcsatacm cg wcrfs+ at as nrt infj tdrcuod bnrjguk bcmsafjrntacm nmf pknbjijmt- Djmbj+ tdj pcjt as n wcrejr ns mjbjssnry tc tdj stntj ns nmy ctdjr- Zsamo tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcr nmf das futajs ns n bcmtrnst+ Inynecvsea luakfs n ijtnpdcr usamo ainojry tdnt pjcpkj cg das taij wakk umfjrstnmf watdcut tdj mjjf gcr iubd djrijmjutabs- Vdj bcipkjxaty cg tdj pcji as infj saipkj+ ag cmky supjrgabankky+ ly ats strubturj- Jnsaky rjnf+ nmf  hust ns quabeky+ Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr Nlcut Pcjtry’ as tdj quamtjssjmtank bcipknamt cg tdj nrtast nonamst tdj iumfnmj nmf pjfjstranm wcrkf cg tdj mcm)nrtastab amfavafunk5 am ats wcrfs wj gamf n wcrkf infj up cg wcrkfs+ ag cmky tc sdcw tdj pcjts truj umfjrstnmfamo+ das mjjfs tc lj bukturjf+ nmf kjnvj am jvafjmbj tdj knbe cg tdj snij am tdj iamf cg jvjrycmj jksj- Wknfaiar Inynecvsea wns lcrm Huky 1 td >412 $f- Npr- >6 td + >120! am Lnodfnta+ \ussan5 dj wns n suppcrtjr cg tdj Lcksdjvae \jvckutacm tdnt tcce pknbj am >1>?+ tdcuod dj wcumf up quatj fasnppcamtjf watd tdj Bciiumast afjckcoy nmf cppcsjf das bcmtjipcrnry wratjrs nmf nrtasts- Vdj pcjt wcukf jmf up eakkamo daisjkg am >120- > Vdj rjnscms gcr das suabafj nrj cmky spjbukntacm+  lut pjrdnps wj bnm gamf scij ijnmamo am das jnrky fasnppcamtijmt watd tdj stntj cg nggnars am tdj Rcvajt Zmacm- Am Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr Nlcut Pcjtry’ Inynecvsea ljoams ly das nffrjssamo cg tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcr+ nmf nssjrts tdnt das lusamjss as cg n fjkabntj mnturj8 nlcut tdj > Fjtnaks tnejm grci mctjs am bknss

Conversation With a Tax Collector (a Sense of Grandeur and Craft)

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

7/23/2019 Conversation With a Tax Collector (a Sense of Grandeur and Craft)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conversation-with-a-tax-collector-a-sense-of-grandeur-and-craft 1/6

Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr Nlcut Pcjtry Hunm N- Bnlnkkjrc Prajtc 

Pnoj > 

Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr nlcut Pcjtry8

N Rjmsj cg Ornmfjur nmf Brngt

At as mct cgtjm tdnt tdj jfubntjf nmf umjfubntjf ijjt am tdj nrjmn cg pcjtry- Vdas pcji+

 ly Inynecvsea+ prcvafjs amsaodt amtc tdj iamf cg tdj prcgabajmt nrtast nmf wratjr+ kjttamo us emcw

tdnt pcjtry as iubd icrj tdnm n bcipcsatacm cg wcrfs+ at as nrt infj tdrcuod bnrjguk

bcmsafjrntacm nmf pknbjijmt- Djmbj+ tdj pcjt as n wcrejr ns mjbjssnry tc tdj stntj ns nmy ctdjr-

Zsamo tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcr nmf das futajs ns n bcmtrnst+ Inynecvsea luakfs n ijtnpdcr usamo

ainojry tdnt pjcpkj cg das taij wakk umfjrstnmf watdcut tdj mjjf gcr iubd djrijmjutabs- Vdj

bcipkjxaty cg tdj pcji as infj saipkj+ ag cmky supjrgabankky+ ly ats strubturj- Jnsaky rjnf+ nmf

 hust ns quabeky+ ‛Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr Nlcut Pcjtry’ as tdj quamtjssjmtank bcipknamt

cg tdj nrtast nonamst tdj iumfnmj nmf pjfjstranm wcrkf cg tdj mcm)nrtastab amfavafunk5 am ats wcrfs

wj gamf n wcrkf infj up cg wcrkfs+ ag cmky tc sdcw tdj pcjt‑s truj umfjrstnmfamo+ das mjjfs tc lj

bukturjf+ nmf kjnvj am jvafjmbj tdj knbe cg tdj snij am tdj iamf cg jvjrycmj jksj-

Wknfaiar Inynecvsea wns lcrm Huky 1td

>412 $f- Npr- >6td

+ >120! am Lnodfnta+ \ussan5 dj

wns n suppcrtjr cg tdj Lcksdjvae \jvckutacm tdnt tcce pknbj am >1>?+ tdcuod dj wcumf up quatj

fasnppcamtjf watd tdj Bciiumast afjckcoy nmf cppcsjf das bcmtjipcrnry wratjrs nmf nrtasts-

Vdj pcjt wcukf jmf up eakkamo daisjkg am >120->

Vdj rjnscms gcr das suabafj nrj cmky spjbukntacm+

 lut pjrdnps wj bnm gamf scij ijnmamo am das jnrky fasnppcamtijmt watd tdj stntj cg nggnars am tdj

Rcvajt Zmacm- Am ‛Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr Nlcut Pcjtry’ Inynecvsea ljoams ly das

nffrjssamo cg tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcr+ nmf nssjrts tdnt das ‛lusamjss as cg n fjkabntj mnturj8 nlcut tdj

> Fjtnaks tnejm grci mctjs am bknss

7/23/2019 Conversation With a Tax Collector (a Sense of Grandeur and Craft)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conversation-with-a-tax-collector-a-sense-of-grandeur-and-craft 2/6

Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr Nlcut Pcjtry Hunm N- Bnlnkkjrc Prajtc 

Pnoj < 

 pknbj cg tdj pcjt am tdj wcrejr‑s rnmes-’< Vdas afjn+ strnaodt cg cut tdj pcjt‑s iakaju+ rjamgcrbjs

tdj gnbt tdnt scijcmj mjjfs tc nffrjss n vjry pnrtabuknr prclkji8 tdj pcjt as mct ljamo vnkujf am

tdj wcrejr)fravjm rjvckutacm cg tdj Lcksdjvaes-

Ly nffrjssamo tdj tnx bckkjbtcr+ umfcultjfky cmj cg tdj gaourjs wdc stccf tc ljmjgat tdj

icst grci tdj rjvckutacm fuj tc tdjar aiijfantj rasj tc pcwjr nmf icmjtnry onam+ Inynecvsea as

 pjrscmnkazamo tdj ocvjrmijmt nmf tdj rjvckutacm dj dns bcij sc fasnggjbtjf watd am tjris cg nm

afjn tdj pjcpkj cg tdj Rcvajt Zmacm bnm umfjrstnmf- Vdj tnx bckkjbtcr+ djmbj+ sjrvjs n funk

 purpcsj8 dj as lctd ijtnpdcr nmf nmtdrcpcicrpdab pjrscmagabntacm- Dcwjvjr+ wdc as tdj pcjt3 As

at Inynecvsea daisjkg3 Nrj wj spjneamo cg n ojmjrnk nrtast+ cr as at tdj pjrscmnk orufoj cg nm

amfavafunk ljamo rjgkjbtjf am n pcji wrattjm ns n pjrscmnk bcipknamt3 _j bnmmct amgjr tdnt tdj

 pcjt as spjneamo cmky gcr daisjkg+ gcr ag tdj bknai as tdnt tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcr rjprjsjmts tdj wcrejr 

nmf stntj+ tdjm+ Inynecvsea iust ijnm tdnt ‛tdj pcjt’2

as lctd tdj nrtast nmf tdj rjvckutacmnrajs-

Vdj rjnscms gcr tdas sdcwfcwm nrj clvacus+ ns tdj wratjr sjjs n prclkji am tdj vnkuj pjcpkj

 pknbj cm tdcsj cg das brngt- _rattjm am >1<7+ cmky gcur yjnrs ljgcrj das fjntd+ Inynecvsea as

ineamo n bnsj gcr tdj mjjf nkk pjcpkj dnvj cg nrtasts-

Ngtjr jstnlkasdamo tdnt pcjts pny tnxjs ns jvjrycmj jksj+ nmf stntamo tdnt tdj wcre cg tdj

nrtast as wcre tdj snij ns nkk ctdjr wcre+6  ‛tdj pcjt’ icvjs cm tc fjsbralj dcw at as tdnt dj

nrravjf tc tdas bcmbkusacm ly nmnkyzamo dcw tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcr $tdj wcrejrs nmf tdj stntj! dnmfkj

 pcjtry- Vdj nkkusacm as infj bkjnr wdjm+ icbeamo tdj rdyij cg nvjrnoj amfavafunks+ tdj pcjt

stntjs tdnt am tdj afaci cg tdj pjfjstranm ‛rdyij# as n lakk cg jxbdnmoj# tc lj dcmcrjf am tdj tdarf

kamj.) tdnt‑s tdj rukj’:

Vdj pcjt as jxprjssamo daisjkg am bcmbjpts tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcr wakk

< P- >1>2 P- >1>6 P- >1<: P- >12

7/23/2019 Conversation With a Tax Collector (a Sense of Grandeur and Craft)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conversation-with-a-tax-collector-a-sense-of-grandeur-and-craft 3/6

Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr Nlcut Pcjtry Hunm N- Bnlnkkjrc Prajtc 

Pnoj 2 

umfjrstnmf+ gcr tdj gcrijr as wjkk nwnrj cg tdj ijmtnk kaiatntacms cg tdj knttjr- Jxprjssamo

daisjkg am tdj ‛afaci’ cg tdj wcrejr nmf tdj pjcpkj as mct cmky n tcck gcr umfjrstnmfnlkj

ijtnpdcr+ lut nksc n mjbjssaty5 gcr dcw wakk tdjy+ wdc cmky bnrj nlcut icmjy+ umfjrstnmf nm

nkkjocry tdnt fcjs mct dnvj icmjtnry bcmmctntacms3

Gurtdjricrj+ tdj wcrejr nmf tdj stntj+ snys tdj pcjt+ umkaej tdj nrtasts+ nrj mctdamo icrj

tdnm lutbdjrs wdc dumt gcr pkjnsurj ‛gcr tdj sinkk bdnmoj cg suggaxjs nmf gkjbtacms’ am n iamf

jipty cg tdji+ iassamo emcwkjfoj cg ‛bcmhuontacm nmf fjbkjmsacms-’ _j sdcukf lj rabd+ tdj

 pcjt sjjis tc sny+ watd tdj bcmumfruis cg knmounoj5 nmf yjt wj dumt+ kaej infijm nmf

 lutbdjrs+ gcr sinkk onij am taijs cg gniamj+ wj dumt gcr sinkk vabtcrajs am taijs cg rjvckutacm-

Vdj bcmstrubtamo cg pcjtry+ am tdj nrtast‑s jyj as tdj fjkabntj wcre cg n surojcm- Vdj wcrejr+

bkuisy+ stnrts ‛sdcvamo n wcrf amtc tdj kamj+ lut at‑s n taodt gat-’ Cg bcursj+ tdj inm watd tdj

ijttkj pusdjs dnrf+ dj prjssjs+ nmf tdj kamj ‛lrjnes-’ Vdj usj cg cmcintcpcjan as bkjvjr djrj+ gcr 

tdj nrtast bcipkaijmts das ijtnpdcr watd ‛sdcvamo+’ ‛prjss+’ nmf ‛lrjnes+’ nkk wdabd scumf kaej

tdj nbtacm tnejm pknbj- Vdj bkuisamjss faspknyjf ly tdj wcrejr nttjiptamo tc inej pcjtry as

jvafjmt+ nmf sc as tdj grustrntacm cg tdj nrtast-

Ruffjmky+ tdjrj as n pnrnfaoi sdagt+ gcr tdj pcjt nlnmfcms tdj rjnki cg tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcr+

tdj wcrejr+ nmf tdj stntj+ tc prcvafj nm jxpknmntcry bciijmt cm dcw nrtasts sjj tdjar cwm wcre-

‛Am cur afaci+’ dj snys+ ‛rdyij as n ejo’ cg fymniatj5 tdj kamj n gusj wdabd lurms tc tdj jmf nmf

tdjm jxpkcfjs am rdyij- Mct cmky tdnt+ sulsjqujmt kamjs brjntj n strcpdj tdnt lkcw ‛tdj tcwm se y

daod-’ Vdj rnraty cg tdas jxpkcsavj bcipcsatacm inejs at dnrf tc gamf+ nmf tdus tdj nrtast iust

trnvjk gnr nmf wafj+ rjnf nvafky+ wcre gcr fnys+ icmtds+ nmf yjnrs+ nmf ambur fjlts tdnt lco fcwm

das nlakaty- Mcw+ dnvamo put fcwm tdj stykj cg tdj wcrejr+ nmf pknbjf am us tdj bcmtrnst cg tdj

nrtast+ tdj pcjt icvjs cm tc jxpknam+ am tjris tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcr bnm umfjrstnmf+ dcw pcjtry as

7/23/2019 Conversation With a Tax Collector (a Sense of Grandeur and Craft)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conversation-with-a-tax-collector-a-sense-of-grandeur-and-craft 4/6

Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr Nlcut Pcjtry Hunm N- Bnlnkkjrc Prajtc 

Pnoj 6 

infj- ‛Pcjtry as kaej iamamo rnfaui+’ wcreamo n yjnr gcr tdj snej cg n wcrf+ wnstamo n tdcusnmf

tcms cg ‛vjrlnk crj-’ Vdj gamnk wcre wakk knst gcrjvjr+ dcwjvjr5 ljbnusj wdakj vjrlnk crj bnm lj

gknij amfubamo+ tdj vjrlnk prcfubt as ‛sickfjramo-’ Vdj ainojry as ns fjkabntj ns tdj wcrfs+ gcr 

garj+ snys tdj pcjt+ lurms quabeky+ lut at nksc fajs quabeky- Vdj wcrfs cg tdj nrtast ‛wakk icvj

iakkacms cg djnrts gcr tdcusnmfs cg yjnrs’ ljbnusj+ am n sjmsj+ tdjy nrj wdnt rjinam grci tdj

 lurmamo+ tdjy nrj tdj kcmo)knstamo bcnks tdnt nrj kjgt+ sickfjramo+ gcr nojs- Gurtdjricrj+ am bkjvjr 

nkkusacm+ tdj nrtast stntjs tdnt tdjrj nrj bcrrupt pcjts ns iubd ns tdjrj nrj bcrrupt cggabanks+ nmf

tdnt tdjy nrj tdj ‛cvjrdjnf jxpjmsjs’ cg wdnt n gjw dnvj nbdajvjf + tdas jxbusj infj ns n rjnscm

tc kcwjr tdj spjneamo pcjt‑s tnxjs- Vnxjs nrj tnxamo+ nmf tdjy damfjr tdj orcwt d cg nrtasts nmf

truj rjvckutacmnry tdcuodt- Vdj occf nrtasts nmf tnx bckkjbtcrs dnvj tdj bciicm futy tc stnip

cut tdj bcrruptjf nmf cvjr)nilatacus-

Bcmtamuamo+ tdj pcjt fjgjmfs das usj ns n pulkab sjrvnmt+ nm nrtast+ nmf n kjnfjr5 dj snys dj

as tdj vcabj cg tdj wcreamo bknss+ cg tdcsj wdc wjrj mct ljmjgatjf ly tdj rjvckutacm- Vdcsj wdc

nrj subbjssguk am tdj rjvckutacm+ tdcsj daod)jmf wcrejrs nmf tdj stntj+ ‛wjnr cut tdj inbdamj cg 

tdj scuk-’ Vdj bcmtrnst ljtwjjm wnriamo tdj djnrt nmf wjnramo cut tdj scuk as tdj rjnkaty tdj pcjt

sjjs sjpnrntamo dai grci tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcr5 dj sjjs das wcre stagkjf ly umwnrrnmtjf tnxjs+ nmf n

guturj lkjne gcr tdj pjcpkj ag+ ljbnusj cg tdjsj lurfjms+ dj as mct nlkj tc rjnbd tdcsj wdc iny

mjjf n lat cg wnritd am tdjar kavjs- ‛Frnw up iy pcstduicus lnknmbj.’ tdj nrtasts lkurts+ gcr tdj

wcre cg tdj pcjt bnmmct lj ijnsurjf am das kagjtaij+ nmf ag scijcmj wjrj tc kcce nt tdcsj

 ljmjgatjf gcr das jxpkcsavj rdyijs+ bcipkjxaty+ nmf amgkujmbj+ tdcsj gjw amfavafunks wcukf lj

 pnaf rabd favafjmfs- Cmky tdj umavjrsj as cwjf+ snys tdj nrtast+ tdj rjst as ijrjky supjrgabank

umfjrstnmfamo-

7/23/2019 Conversation With a Tax Collector (a Sense of Grandeur and Craft)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conversation-with-a-tax-collector-a-sense-of-grandeur-and-craft 5/6

Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr Nlcut Pcjtry Hunm N- Bnlnkkjrc Prajtc 

Pnoj : 

Vdj pcji mcw ljoams tc jsbnkntj+ garst tc nmojr+ tdjm tc rnoj- _j rjnf cg nm nrtast

wrcmojf nmf cg nbbusntacms ly ctdjrs- Vdj pcjt wratjs tdnt tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcrs‑ guturj as nssurjf+

gcr dj wakk lj rjijiljrjf $rjsurrjbtjf nmf aiicrtnk! am tdj wrattjm wcrf- Vaij bnm lj turmjf

 lnbe+ afjns rjvasatjf+ nmf n mjw fnwm infj am tdj ‛stjmbd cg ame-’ Inynecvsea as nfninmt8 tdj

wcre cg tdj nrtast as amvnkunlkj+ gcr dcw tc pny nm amfavafunk wdcsj wcre wakk jnrm pnyijmt

‛cvjr tdrjj dumfrjf yjnrs’3 Ns tdj pcji orcws am amtjmsaty+ tdj pcjt ljoams das rnmt5 dj nssjrts

das strjmotd+ das amgkujmbj cvjr tdj guturj nmf tdj prjsjmt- Nonam+ tdj ainojry as jxpkabat+ ns tdj

nrtast rjnbdjs gcr tdj bckkjbtcr‑s gcri nmf brcssjs cut ‛nkk cg tdj zjrcjs ngtjr tdj gavj nmf pny tdj

rjst-’ Ljbnusj cg das amgkujmbj+ tdj pcjt+ fjinmfs tc lj tnxjf hust cvjr tdj pccr pjnsnmts- Ns dj

bcmbkufjs+ Inynecvsea pknbjs+ am tdj wcrfs cg tdj umemcwm pcjt+ tdj cutrnoj cg bknais infj

nonamst tcc inmy cg das brngt+ tdnt cg pknoanrasi nmf saiakatufj- Ns tdj samouknr tcmj cg tdj inm

nonamst tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcr as bdnmojf tc n pkurnk tdnt nffrjssjs jvjrycmj rjnfamo+ tdj pcji

bkcsjs8

Nmf ag 

Qcu tdame 

Vdnt nkk A dnvj tc fcAs prcgat

Ly ctdjr pjcpkj‑s wcrfs+ 

Vdjm+

Bcirnfjs+

Djrj‑s iy pjm- 

Vnej

N brnbe nt at

Qcursjkvjs-7 

Nt mc icijmt as tdj nmojr nmf grustrntacm icrj jvafjmt tdnm djrj5 tdj wcrfs usjf nmf tdj

ainojry suoojst n pcjt sc grustrntjf dj tdrcws das pjm nt tdj Vnx Bckkjbtcr+ tjkkamo dai tc try+ ag 

 pcssalkj+ tc prcfubj jvjm tdj skaodtjst lat cg pcjtry- Vdj fasnggjbtjf Inynecvsea jxprjssjf das

afjns am n wny tdnt bcukf lj umfjrstccf ly jvjry rjnfjr cg das taij+ das grustrntacm+ tdcuod

7 P-<0?

7/23/2019 Conversation With a Tax Collector (a Sense of Grandeur and Craft)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/conversation-with-a-tax-collector-a-sense-of-grandeur-and-craft 6/6

Bcmvjrsntacm watd n Vnx Bckkjbtcr Nlcut Pcjtry Hunm N- Bnlnkkjrc Prajtc 

Pnoj 7 

jvafjmt+ as nksc tdj wcre cg bnrjguk nmnkysas nmf jvjm icrj bnrjguk ijtnpdcr- Nkkusacm nmf

nkkjocry pkny wjkk am tdj pajbj+ ns tdj wratjr sjjis tc pknbj us am n fculkj lamf8 ag ycu kcvj

 pcjtry+ ycu iust kcvj tdj pcjt- Am tdj jmf+ ns at dns ljjm infj jvafjmt+ pcjtry as iubd icrj tdnm

n bcipcsatacm cg wcrfs+ at as nrt infj tdrcuod bnrjguk bcmsafjrntacm nmf pknbjijmt- Djmbj+ tdj

 pcjt as n wcrejr ns mjbjssnry tc tdj stntj ns nmy ctdjr-