49

Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� ������������ �������������������������! "�$#&%(')'+*,��-���,�.���!/ �0�21��������435�6�21)����*�����7

8:9<;>=@?BADCE?�F-ADCEG�H"A�=JIDKELMADNPOBQER-FSNTADUWV�XYV�N�IDKELMADNPZ0[B\]A^QE\JCEV,N]_BKEADCa`+b�;cADQaR8:V�XYCEV�NP\]_d�egf<hji�[email protected],rtsSq,lJovu-wxfzya{zs2kP|z},lJovu~kPf<o2q�r��q�u6|<wBovkPl��^�JhjkPfB�]k�{���f<rcq,lJu~}�onh��.����{�������^� sSq,lJovu-wxfzya{��2kJlJu�},f<p��� },fz�P�z},rv{ � lJ}�u�kJhjkPl]���2��m ����� �Tm � wxf<h��@yxq�lJovu�w<fEy � y<k

� egf<hji�[email protected],rtsSq,lJovu-wxfzya{z�B}��Jwx�jo@p�q,rt�.k]���z},f<hj�T},�� fB¡�h�fBkTkJlvh�fB¡<{ �YfBmvonhjonwzovk6q�r�.}��v�xh�f<h�fz¡.¢ kT���<fzq,�jq�¡�p�{ �������D� sSq,lJovu-wxfzyE{E�2kPlJu�}�f<p� mvov}�wBonfzkPl�{E£$kPh�fzkPlJoJ���ghjmnr � u � � w<fxh��@y<q,lJovu-wxfzy � y<k

¤ ¥ ¦)¦�§B¨T©xª �2kPfzkTonhj�.|xlJq�¡,lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡¬«@�2­$®�y<kPfBq�ovkTm�}+i,}�lvhj},f<o.q�r¯kTi�q���wBonhjq�fB}�lJp°}��j¡�q,�lvhjon�zu�m�on�B}�o � lJkTk]yxmSmvq,��wzonhjq,fzm-ovq�|<lJq � �jkTu�m2h�f�on�Bk2rcq�lJu±q,r²�Tq�u6|<wzovkPl�|xlJq�¡,lJ}�u~m � ��f�lJkJ��TkJf<o2p�k]},lJm2¡�kPfzkTonhj��|xlJq�¡,lJ}�u~u6h�fB¡��z}�m � kT�Tq�u�k6h�fz�PlJkT}�mnh�fB¡��jpWhju6|Eq�lJov},f<o-rcq,lSlJkT},���@£$q�lv�jy}�|x|<��hj�T}�onhjq�fBmT{Bh�fz�P��wzy^h�f³¡�kJfB¡�h�fBkTkJlvh�fB¡�ov}�mn�<m´h�f0|z},lJonhj�Pw<�j},l � ¢��<hjm��Tq,f<onlvh � wzonhjq,f.h�f<ovkT¡�lJ}�ovkTm� q�on�.rYw<lJon�BkPl¯y<kTi�kP�jq,|zu�kPf<o¯q,ron�Bkµ�2­¶|B}�lJ}�yDhj¡�u·},fzy�hjovm-}�|x|<��hj�T}�onhjq,fzm�ovq0�v�B}����jkPfz¡,h�fz¡|<lJq � �jkTu�m�h�f:u~}��v�xh�f<h�fB¡¸ovkT�v�xfzq,�jq�¡�p � sgh�¹EkPlJkJf<o�i�},lvhj}�f<ovm�q�r2|<lJq�¡�lJ}�uºlJkP|<lJkTmvkPf<ov}�onhjq,fzm}�lJk6h�f<i�kTmvonhj¡�}�ovkTy �t» �<h��jk�|<lJq � �jkTu6�ch�fzyxkP|�kPfzy<kPfBo0u�k]on�BqDy<m6}�lJk6h�f<onlJqDyDwB�Tk]y¼r�q,l¯}���h�fzkT}�llJkP|<lJkTmvkPf<ov}�onhjq,f�{�|<lJq � �jkTu6�@mn|EkT�Ph�½z�2}�yx}�|Bov}�onhjq,fzm$},lJk�Tq,fzy^wz�TovkTy~£�hjon�~on�zk$onlJ}�yDhjonhjq,fz},�EonlJk]kmvonlvwz�Tonw<lJk �

¾�¿J¾ À<Ág³ÃaÄ-ůƯÇ"ÂEÈPÄ�Á

ÉvC�\PHEV�Ê�NPRJ\-Ë�A^NJ\-9D=�\PHEXYR-Z]H"ADËE\PV�N-ÌSV6=@9BZ�QaR¯9<C)AD`EÍ<A^CEZ�V�`)Z�9xCEZ�V�Ëa\JR�9D=$;ÎXYCEV�ADN¯Ï0Ð$ÑÒ XYCEV�A^N$?<V�CEV,\JXYZ¯ËENP9<?xN]ADUWU�X>CE?0Ó@Ò´Ï0Ð�Ô´`EV�CE9x\JV�R-A�Í<A^NJXcADCB\t9^=ÕÏ�Ð$KDÌ-HEV�NPV¯ËENP9<?<NTADUWR9D=�ADCMXYU�Ë"V�NTAD\JXYÍxV¯ËENP9<?<NTADUWU�XjCa?~;cA^CE?<Q�A^?<V�9<N¯A�U+A^Z]HaXÎCaV¯;cADCE?xQ�AD?xV~A^NJV0V�Íx9<;YÍ<V,`tÑ8:V�ADC"AD;YÖBG�V0`�A^\]A�×"9ḎÌ-XÎ\PHEXYCM;YXYCEV�ADN6?<V�CaV�\JXYZ.ËENP9<?<NTADUWR¯ADCE`MV,ØzËa;Î9xXY\¯RJ\PNJQEZ,\JQENTAD;ADRPË�V�Z,\JR¯9^=�\JHEV0;YXYCEV�A^NSNPV�ËENPV�RJV�CB\TAD\JXY9xCM=@9xN-`EV�\PV�Z�\JXYCE?WCE9<CaVTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V�Z�9B`EV<Ñ Ú$ØB\JNTADZ�\�ÛXYCE?�\PHEXYR¯Z�9B`EV�=@NP9<UÜËENP9<?xN]ADUWR-Ý�V�=@9<NPV�Ê�\JCEV,RJR0Z�A^;YZ�QE;cAD\PXÎ9xCM;YV�AD`aR~\P9+AWRJXY?xCEX>Ê�Z�ADCB\ADZ�Z,V�;YV�N]A^\JXY9<C)9D=tNPQECB\JXYU�VxÑ<Þ-HEV�XYCB=@9xNJU)AD\JXY9xC�A^Ý�9xQE\SÌ-HaV�\JHEV,N~ADCWXYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<C)XYRSVT=ßÛ=@V�Z�\PXYÍ<V�9<N2CE9<\-XYRg=@QENP\JHEV�N6QERJV,`�=n9<N-`EV�RPXY?<CEXYCE?�VTà�Z�XYV�CB\-Í<ADNPXcAD\JXY9xC.9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9<NPR�Ñaá¯V�NPVÌSVWËENJV,RJV�CB\MAMÍ<A^NJXcADCB\�9D=�;ÎXYCEV�ADN.Ï0Ðâ\JH�A^\.XÎR�Ý�A^RJV�`¬V�ØBZ�;YQERPXÎÍxV�;YÖ59xCãU.Qa\]AD\PXY9<CER�ÑÐ$NJ9x?<NTADU�RP9<;YQE\PXÎ9xCER�`EV�ÍxV�;Y9<Ë"V�`5Ì-XY\JH¶\JHaXÎR�ADËEËENP9zA^Z]H:H"A�Í<V�CE9<\09xCE;YÖMÝ"V�V�C:=n9<QECE`\J90Ý"V¯UW9<NPV-RJQEZ�Z,V�RJR�=@QE;tÝaQE\S;YV�RPRSZ,9<U�Ëa;ÎV,Ø�XYC.RJXYG�VxÑEäEQENP\JHEV,NJU�9xNJV<KBA�RP\JNJQaZ�\JQENTAD;´`EXYRvÛ\]A^CEZ�V2U�V�\PNJXYZ�XYRt`EV�Ê�CEV�`.\PH�AD\´NJV�ÍxV�AD;YR�Z�A^QER]A^;BZ�9<CECaV�Z�\JXY9xCER�Ý"V�\vÌSV,V�C.ZTH�ADCE?xV�R$9D=�\PHEV;YXÎCaV�ADN6?<V�CE9x\vÖBË�V.ADCE`¶ZTH�ADCa?<V�R�9D=2\JHEV.ËEHaV�CE9<\vÖBË"V+Ó�Ê�\JCaV�RJRTÔ�Ñ´å¯RJXYCE?)\PHEXYR~`aXÎRP\]A^CEZ�VXYCB=@9<NPU+A^\JXY9<C�AD;Y;Y9DÌ-RÍ<A^NJXcAD\PXY9<C�RJ\PV�Ë�RPXÎG,V¯ADCE`.`EXYÍxV�NJRPXÎ\vÖ�\J90Ý"V-Z�9<CB\PNJ9<;Y;YV�`�V�ØBËE;YXYZ�XY\J;YÖ9<CW\JHEV0;YV�ÍxV�; 9D=$VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV�Z�9B`EVxÑ

Þ-HEV2RJV�Z�9xCE`.Ë�A^NJ\$`EV�A^;ÎR$Ì-XY\JH�\JHaV¯ADËEËE;YXYZ�A^\JXY9<C�\J9�ËENP9<ÝE;YV�UWRt9^=²U)ADZTHEXYCEXYCE?2\JV�ZTHECE9x;>Û9<?xÖzÑ,á¯V�NPV¯U�9B`EV,;ÎXYCE?-?xV�CEV�NTAD;"Z�9<NPNJV�;cA^\JXY9<CERg9<QE\$9D= `�A^\]A6?<XYÍ<V,C�9xCE;YÖ~ÝBÖ�9<ÝERPV�NJÍ<A^\JXY9<CXYR¯A.`EX>à�Z�QE;Y\-\TADRJO Ñaæç;Y9<\-9^=�OBCE9DÌ-;YV�`a?<V0ADÝ"9<QE\6\JHEV�V�ØEADU�XYCEV,`+ËaNJ9BZ�V�RPR~XYR6CEV�V�`EV,`

Page 2: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

\J9�V�ØB\JNTADZ�\-\PHEV�Z�9<NPNJV�Z�\6Z�9<HaV�NJV�CaZ�V�R�9<QE\-9^=\PHEV�?<XYÍ<V�C.`"AD\]AaÑEÚ$RJË"V�Z�XcA^;Î;YÖ.Ì-HEV,C+\PHEXYRËENJ9BZ�V,RJR�H"ADR�\J9:Ý"V+`a9<CEV)ÝBÖ:H�ADCa`tÑ$Þ$9MRJQEËaË�9xNJ\�\PHEV)RJZ�XYV�CB\PXÎRP\.XYC5\JHaXÎR.ËaNJ9<Ýa;ÎV,UZ�9<UWËEQE\TAD\JXY9xC�AD;´XÎCB\PV�;Y;ÎXY?xV�CEZ�V¶Ó��2ÉJÔ�UWV�\JHE9B`ER�KtHaV�NJVWRJÖBU.Ý�9x;YXÎZ�NJV,?<NJV,RJRJXY9xC5\JHaNJ9<Qa?<H?<V�CaV�\JXYZ�ËENJ9x?<NTADU�UWXYCE?�KDADNPV0A�ÌSV�;Y; OBCE9DÌ-CWË�9xRJRJXYÝEXY;YXY\vÖ.\J9.HEV,;ÎË´Ñ

¾�¿�� ��ÈPÁ���$Ã���´Á�� ÂEÈPÇ � ÃEÄ��SÃ������ ÈJÁ��

Ï�V�CEV,\JXYZ�ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�UWXÎCa?����aK������²A^ËEËE;YXYV�R¯ADC)V�Íx9<;YQE\PXÎ9xC�ADNPÖ�AD;Y?<9xNJXY\JHaU \PH�AD\6RJQEÝ���V�Z�\JRZ�9<UWËEQE\PV�NtËENP9<?xN]ADUWRt\P9~V,Í<9<;YQE\PXY9<CtÑ,ÉvC�Z�9xCB\JN]A^RJ\�\P9�\JN]A^`EXY\JXY9<C"AD;zÏ�ÐMÌ-HEXYZTH�QERJV�RgV�ØxÛËENJV,RJRJXY9xCERS9^=A�=nQECEZ�\PXÎ9xC�AD;aËENJ9x?<N]A^U�UWXÎCa?-;�A^CE?<Q"AD?<VxKD;YXÎCaV�ADN-Ï0жV�Íx9<;YÍ<V�R2ËENP9<?<NTADUWR9D=tADC.XYU�Ë"V�NTAD\JXYÍxVS;cADCa?<Q�A^?<V<ÑD8 HEXY;ÎV2XYC.\JHEV�=@9<NPU�V�N$Z�A^RJV�\JHaV-ËENJ9x?<N]A^U RJ\JNPQEZ�\PQENJV0XYRA�\JNPV�V<K"XYC+\PHEV0;cAD\P\JV�N-Z�ADRJV�\JHaV0NJV�ËaNJV�RPV�CB\]AD\PXY9<C¶XÎR-;YXYCEV�A^N�KaÌ-HEXYZ]H)`EV,NJXYÍ<V�R�=@NJ9xU&\PHEVRJV �BQEV,CEZ�V�9D=XYUWË�V�NTAD\PXÎÍxV-XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CER6RJQEZTH¸A�?<V�CaV�\JXYZ0ËENP9<?xN]ADU XÎR-Z,9<U�Ë"9<RPV�`�9^=]Ñ

! NPXY?<XYC�AD;Y;YÖBK�;YXYCEV�A^N�?<V,CEV�\JXYZ6ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�UWXÎCa?-Ì�A^R�XYCz\PNJ9B`EQEZ,V�`)Ì-XÎ\PH�A�ÝEXYC�A^NJÖ�U+A�ÛZTHEXYCEV0;cADCE?xQ�AD?xV0RJ9W\JH�A^\¯\PHEV�?xV�CEV�\PXYZ�ËENP9<?xN]ADUWR¯Z�A^CMÝ"V�V�ØBV�Z,QE\JV�`:`aXÎNPV�Z�\P;ÎÖ Ì-XÎ\PHBÛ9<QE\6Ë�ADRPRJXYCE?)A.\JXYUWVTÛ Z,9<CERPQEU�XYCE?0XYCB\JV,NJËENPV�\]A^\JXY9<C¶RJ\PV�ËMÊ"NJRJ\"�����#�JÑBæ¯Ë�A^NJ\6=@NJ9xU&\PHEXYRRJË"V�V�`¸A^`EÍ<ADCB\TAD?<VxKBÌSV0XYCBÍ<V,RJ\JXY?BAD\JV�UW9<NJV�?xV�CEV�NTAD;tZTH�A^N]A^Z�\JV�NPXYRJ\JXYZ�R�9^=�;YXYCEV�A^N-NJV�ËaNJVTÛRJV�CB\TAD\JXY9xCER�XÎC¶\JHaXÎR�ZTH�A^ËE\JV�N�Ñ ! CEV.ËaNJXYCEZ�XYËE;YV�`EX>Ù²V�NPV�CEZ�VWZ�9<UWË�ADNPV�`¶\J9)\JNPV�V.NJV�ËaNJVTÛRJV�CB\TAD\JXY9xCER¯XYR-\JH"AD\¯QaCzQaRJV�`¶Z�9B`EV�Ë�ADNP\JR¯9BZ�Z,QEN0ADCE`MNPV�U+A^XYC�Ì-XY\JHEXYC);YXYCEV�ADN6?<V�CaV�\JXYZËENJ9x?<NTADU�R6ÓcRJV,V�[BV�Z�\PXY9<C$�xÑ �aÑ%��Ô�Ñ

ÉvC¸9xQEN0;YXYCEV�ADN0Ï0бA^ËEËENP9zADZTH&� '(�JK ADC:XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�AD;$ËENP9<?xN]ADU(XYR~NPV�ËENPV�RJV�CB\PV�` ÝBÖA0Í<A^NJXcADÝa;ÎV�Û ;YV�CE?x\JH.RPV �BQEV�CEZ�V�9D=$RJXYU�Ëa;ÎV�� XYCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<CER�ÑEÞ-HEV�XYCERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<C)RPV�\-U+A�ÖXYCEZ�;YQE`EV-9xË�V�NTAD\PXÎ9xCER-RJQaZ]H)ADR�) *,+-)/.10-2DK^=@QECEZ�\PXY9<C�Z�AD;Y;YR3) *,+-4´Ó�)/.<Ô�Kx9<N2ÝENTADCEZTHEV�R5�4´Ó�)/.&67)98<Ô.\PH�AD\.U)A�Ö¸RPOBXÎˬ\PHEVMRJQaZ�Z�V�V�`aXÎCa?ãCa9<CBÛvÝEN]A^CEZTH¬XÎCaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xCtÑ2æ¯;Y;-XYCBÛRJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CER29<Ë"V�N]A^\JV�9<C.9xCEV¯9xN�\vÌ290XYCE`EV�ØBV�`WÍ<ADNJXcA^ÝE;YV�R¯ÓcNPV�?<XYRP\JV�NPR]Ô�)/.�9<N�Z�9xCERJ\TADCB\JR22=@NP9<U·ËaNJV�`EV�Ê�CEV�`¶RJV�\PR~A^CE`+A^;Î; XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCER�KaÝEQE\-ÝENTADCEZTHEV�R�ADRPRJXY?<C)\JHaV~NPV�RJQa;Î\6\J9A6`EV�RJ\PXYC�AD\PXÎ9xC.NJV�?xXYRJ\JV,N�) *JÑxÞ-HEV6XÎCa`EXYÍzXY`EQ"AD;EÒtÏ0Ð:A^ËEËENP9zADZTH.H�A^R�Ý"V�V�C)V�ØB\JV�Ca`EV�`)\J9\JHEV�V�Íx9<;YQE\PXÎ9xC�9^=ËENP9<?<NTADU·\PV�ADUWR-XYC:�����JÑ

;=<%>?<@; ACB3D�EGFIHKJ=DML�N,O&PRQ=N�DSB3D�E(F�HKJ=DMTUN,V F�W(X,E(F�H�QYN,V

ÉvC5;YXYCEV�A^N.?<V�CEV,\JXYZMËENP9<?<NTADUWR0\vÌS9:\vÖBË"V�R�9^=~Z�9B`EV Z�ADC¬Ý"V+`aXÎRP\JXYCE?xQEXYRJHEV�`¬9xCã\PHEVRJ\PNJQEZ�\PQEN]A^;$;ÎV,Í<V�;vKBVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV�A^CE`)CE9<CaVTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V�XÎCaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xCER�Ñaæ¯CMXYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xC+XYR-`EV�ÛÊ�CEV�`.ADR´VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV¯AD\$XY\JRtËaNJ9<?xN]A^U±Ë�9xRJXY\JXY9<C�Xj="XÎ\´U+A^CEXYËEQE;cAD\PV�R²A^C�V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V-NPV�?<XYRJ\PV�N�ÑæçNPV�?<XYRJ\PV�N�KÕXÎC¶\JQaNJCtK"XYR¯VTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V�AD\0A�Z�V�NJ\TADXYC¶Ë�9xRJXY\JXY9<C Xj=-A.U+A^CEXYËEQE;cAD\PXY9<C.9D=2XÎ\PRZ�9<CB\PV�CB\tZ�A^C�VTÙ V�Z�\g\JHEV�Ý"V�H�A�ÍBXY9<N�K�X Ñ V<ÑYK,\JHEV�9xQE\JËaQE\�ÓßR]Ô�K^9D=E\JHEV2ËENP9<?<NTADU¶Ñ ! \PHEV�NPÌ-XÎRPV<K\JHEV�NPV�?<XYRJ\PV�N0ADR-Ì2V�;Y;A^R-\JHEV0U)ADCEXYËEQa;�A^\JXYCE?�XYCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<C¸A^NJV0Ca9<CEVTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V�=@9xN-\JH�A^\Ë�9xRJXY\JXY9xCtÑ<[BQEZTH)CE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV~XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCERS`a9�CE9x\SZ,9<CB\JNPXÎÝaQE\JV6\J9�\JHEV�`�A^\]A6×�9DÌ XÎCA0ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U&ADCE`MA^NJV�NJVT=nV�NJNPV�`¸\P9�ADR-RP\JNJQaZ�\JQENTAD;$XYCB\JNJ9xCER-9<N2`�A^\]A�×�9DÌ XYCB\JNP9<CER�Ñ

ÉvC.\JHEV�=@9<;Y;Y9DÌ-XYCE?¯V�ØBZ�V,NJËE\-9^=A�;YXÎCaV�ADN�?xV�CEV�\PXYZ¯ËENP9<?<NTADU¶K�9xCE;YÖ�\PHEV¯XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCER\JH�A^\�ADNJV6U+A^NJO<V,`0Ì-XY\JH�ADC�V�ØBZ�;cADU)AD\PXÎ9xC0Ë"9<XYCB\Z�ADC.H�A�ÍxV¯ADC�XÎC³×�QEV�CEZ,V¯9<C.\PHEV2Ê�C�A^;9<QE\PËEQE\�KBÌ-HEXYZ]H)XYR-HEV�;Y`)XYC�NPV�?<XYRJ\PV�N�ZC[]\S^.HEV�NPV<Ñ

Page 3: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ �

A��?L������KD ; Ó��� ������������������� ������! ����"��#�Ô$�%'&�(*)�+-,�.�/(�%103254367.98�:3;9<

=

>3>3>

.98@?�;*A�.98�B�;DCE?�<.98�B�;*A�.98@F�;DGH.98�B�;9<

I .98@?�;*A�.98�B�;DJH.98@K�;9<.98@K�;*A�.98�B�;DCLB�<.98�B�;*A�.98@F�;DGH.98@K�;9<.98�B�;*A�.98@K�;DGH.98�B�;9<

I .98@K�;*A�.98@F�;*ME.98@F�;9<.98@F�;*AE+5%�N9,�.98�B�;9OP.98@K�;�/�<

I .98@F�;*A�.98@K�;*ME.98@?�;9<I .98@K�;*A�.98@?�;DCLB�<I .98�B�;*A�.98@F�;DCH.98@K�;9<I .98@?�;*AE+5%�N9,�.98@K�;9OQF'/�<I .98@F�;*A�.98@F�;*ME.98�B�;9<.98@K�;*A�.98�B�;*M�R�<.98@K�;*A�.98�B�;DJH.98@?�;9<

I .98@K�;*A�.98@F�;DGH.98@F�;9<I .98@F�;*A�.98�B�;DGH.98@?�;9<I .98@K�;*A�.98@K�;*ME.98@F�;9<S

Þ-HEV�RP\JNPQEZ�\JQaN]AD;2CE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV�Z�9B`EV.XYCM;YXYCEV�A^N~XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;YR¯XYR�CE9<\�`EXYNJV,Z�\J;YÖM`EV�ÛË�V,CE`EV�CB\29<C.\JHaV¯RJV,\S9^=²XYCERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<CW9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xNJR�Ñxá¯9DÌ2V�ÍxV�N�KB\PHEV-U�9xNJV-NJV,?<XYRJ\PV�NJR2\JH�A^\ADNPV�ËENP9DÍBXÎ`aV�`tKE\PHEV.V�A^RJXYV�N�\JHEV�Z�NPV�AD\PXÎ9xC¸9^=S\JHaXÎR�Z�9B`EV�Ì-XY;Y;tÝ"V�Z�9<UWV0=n9<N¯V,Í<9<;YQE\PXY9<CtÑÉn=¯9<CE;YÖM9xCEV�NPV�?<XYRP\JV�N�XYR�A�Í<A^XÎ;cA^ÝE;YV<KE\PHEXYR�\vÖBË"V�9D=-Z�9B`EV)Z�A^CECE9<\�9zZ,Z�QEN�AD\�AD;Y;vKtADCE`Ê�CE`EXYCE?.A�RJ9<;YQE\PXY9<C)XYRSÍxV�NJÖW`EX>à�Z�QE;Y\�Ñ

[BV�U+A^CB\JXYZ�Óc9xN�9<Ë"V�N]A^\JXY9<C�A^;cÔ-XYCB\JNJ9xC¸XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCER0U+A^CEXYËEQE;cAD\PV�VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V.NPV�?<XYR�Û\JV�NPR)Ì-XÎ\PHE9<Qa\�A�Ù V�Z�\JXYCE?¬ËENP9<?xN]ADU RJV,U+ADCB\PXÎZ,R�Ñ�ÉvC 9<NJ`aV�N)\J95NPV�RJ\PNJXYZ�\M\PHEVMNTAD\JV¶9D=RJV�U)ADCB\JXYZ�XYCB\JNP9<CER2ADCE`�\JHBQER�K<\P9~OxV�V�Ë.\PHEV¯RP\JNJQaZ�\JQENTAD;"VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV¯;YV�CE?x\JH.9D= ËENP9<?<NTADUWRRJU)AD;Y;vK�ADC:XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xC:RJV�\�Z�ADC:Ý"V�ZTHE9xRJV�C°Ì-XY\JH:A)U�XYCEXYU�AD;´\JV�Ca`EV�CEZ�Ö:\P9MZ�NPV�AD\PV\JHEV,RJVMXYCB\JNP9<CER�Ñ ! CE;YÖ:X>=µ\PHEV)Z�NJV�AD\JXY9xC 9D=�RJ\JNPQEZ�\PQEN]A^;~XYCB\JNP9<CER.XYR.V�A^RJXYV�NW\JH�A^Cã\PHEVZ�NJV�AD\JXY9xCM9D=SRPV�U+A^CB\JXYZ�XÎCB\PNJ9<CaR�K"RJV�U)ADCB\JXYZ0Ca9<CEVTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V�Z�9B`EV.Z�ADC Ý�V�V�ØBË�V,Z�\JV�`°\J99BZ�Z�QEN-;YV�RPR-=@NPV �BQEV�CB\J;YÖBÑ

;=<%>?<�> TVUXWYTZ��[YQ=W(HKF]\��

æ¯;Y?<9xNJXY\JHaU ��RJHE9DÌ-R6\JHEV�RJË"V�Z�X>Ê�Z�V�Íx9<;YQE\JXY9xC�ADNPÖ+AD;Y?x9<NJXY\PHEU·QERPV�`MXYCM9<QaN¯ÒtÏ0Ð A^ËBÛËENJ9BADZTHtÑDÉvC.RPQEZTH+A�RP\JV�A^`EÖxÛ RP\]A^\JV0Ú$æ�KxCEV�Ì-;YÖ�Z�NJV�AD\JV,`�XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�AD;YR$NJV,ËE;cADZ�V6V�ØBXÎRP\JXYCE?XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;YR-XYCM\JHaV.R]ADUWV0Ë"9<ËEQE;cA^\JXY9<CtK"Ì-HEXY;YV0\vÖBËEXYZ�A^;Î;YÖBKE\P9<QENPC�ADUWV�CB\¯RJV,;ÎV,Z�\JXY9<C:XYRADËEËa;ÎXYV�`´Ñ

Page 4: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

TZ��[=QYW(HKF]\�� ; Ó������ ��� �� ��1 ���� #~Ô�<Ñ2ÉvCEXY\JXcAD;YXYG�V�A0Ë"9<ËEQa;�A^\JXY9<CW9D=$XÎCa`EXYÍzXY`EQ"AD;"ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�R2N]A^CE`E9<UW;YÖzÑ�EÑ-[BV�;YV�Z�\ ��� XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;YR$=@NP9<Uº\JHEV�Ë"9<ËEQa;�A^\JXY9<CWÌ-XY\JHE9xQE\SNPV�ËE;cADZ,V�U�V�CB\�Ñ�EÑ-дV�Nv=@9xNJUº\vÌS9�Ê�\PCEV�RJR�\P9<QENPC�ADUWV�CB\JR29D=RPXYG�V $Ñ'�Ñ��-V�ËaNJ9B`EQEZ�V2\JHaVSÌ-XYCECEV,NJRt9^=�\JHaV�\vÌS96\J9xQENJC�A^U�V�CB\PR ÝzÖ�NPV�ËE;cADZ�XYCE?6\JHEVg\vÌS96;Î9xRJV�NPRÌ-XY\JH)\JV�UWË�9xN]A^NJÖ.Z�9xËEXYV�R-9D=�\JHaV~Ì-XYCECaV�NJR�Ñ

�EÑ-L)9B`EX>=@Ö¶\JHEV)\vÌ29¸Ì-XYCECEV,NJR�ÝzÖ:9xCEV�9xN�UW9<NPV.Í<ADNJXcA^\JXY9<C:9xË�V�NTAD\P9<NJR�K$XYCEZ�;YQE`EXYCE?U.QE\]A^\JXY9<C�A^CE`)NJV�Z,9<U.ÝEXYC�A^\JXY9<CtK^Ì-XÎ\PH)Z�V�NJ\TADXYC)ËENJ9xÝ�ADÝaXÎ;YXY\JXYV�R�Ñ

�EÑ-Ú$Í<AD;YQ�A^\JV6\JHEV�Ê"\JCEV�RPR¯9^=�\PHEV�9DÙ RJËENPXYCE?�Ñ�EÑ2Én=t\JHEV-Z,QENJNPV�CB\J;YÖ.Ý�V,RJ\vÛnÊ�\2XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;xXÎRgNJV�ËE;cA^Z�V�`�ÝBÖ09xCEV-9D=t\PHEV-9DÙ RJËaNJXYCE?0\PHEV�CÍ<AD;YXY`�AD\PV¯\PHEV�CEV�̱Ý"V�RJ\6ËENJ9x?<N]A^U¸Ñ

�EÑ��-V�Ë"V�A^\.RJ\JV,ËER ����� QECB\JXY;-\PHEV)U+ADØBXYU�QEU�CBQEU.Ý"V�N�9D=~?xV�CEV�NTAD\PXÎ9xCER.H�A^R.Ý�V�V,CNJV�A^ZTHEV�`tÑ

�EÑ2Þ$V�RJ\6\JHEV0?xV�CEV�NTAD;YXYG�AD\PXY9<C�Ë"V�N�=@9<NPU+ADCaZ�V�9D=�\JHEV�ËENJ9x?<N]A^U·Ì-XY\JH)U�XYCEXYU�QEUçÍ<A^;YXjÛ`�AD\PXY9<C�V,NJNJ9xN�Ñ

���EÑ2FS9x\JH \JHEV¶Ý"V�RJ\MËaNJ9<?xN]A^U�`EQENJXYCE?°\JNTADXYCEXYCE?ãA^CE` \JHEV¶Ý�V,RJ\MËENP9<?xN]ADU�`aQENJXYCE?Í<AD;YXY`�AD\PXY9<C.`EVTÊ"CEV0\JHaV~9xQE\JËaQE\-9D=$\JHEV�A^;Y?<9<NPXY\JHEU¶ÑÞ-HEV-Ê�\PCEV�RPR�Óc\PN]A^XÎCaXÎCa?0V�NJNP9<NTÔ29D=�A^C.XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;EËaNJ9<?xN]A^U���XYR29D=@\PV�C�Z,9<U�ËaQE\JV�`

ÝBÖ¼A^C¸V,NJNJ9xN�=@QECaZ�\JXY9<C´K�VxÑ ?"ÑYKE\JHaV.RJQEU(9D=SV�NPNJ9xNJR0Ý"V�\vÌ2V�V�C:\JHaV.ËENJV�`aXÎZ,\JV�`5A^CE`¸\PHEV`EV�RPXÎNPV�`:ËENP9<?<NTADUÜ9xQE\JËEQa\JR�=@9xN~AW?<XYÍxV�C¸RPV�\09^=�:\PN]ADXYCEXYCE?WV�ØEADUWËE;YV�R�ÓnAD;YRJ9)Z�A^;Î;YV�`Ê�\JCaV�RJR6Z�ADRPV�R]Ô

4Y5������ ! xÓ"�"Ô�+ #$8�% I'& �tÓK5 8 Ô)(+* 8 & Ó/�<Ñ%��Ô

FSV,\J\JV,N2Ê�\JCEV,RJR2U�V�A^CER�RJU)AD;Y;YV�N$V�NJNP9<N-ADCE`.\PHEV¯UWXYCEXYU�QEU Ê�\PCEV�RJR-XYR�G,V�NJ9�\JHEV,CtÑBÞ-HEV`�AD\TA-`E9xU+A^XÎC�=@NJ9xU±Ì-HEXYZTH�\PHEVSXYCEËaQE\vÛv9<QE\PËEQE\$V�ØEADUWËE;YV�RSÓK5 8-, * 8 Ô$ADNPVS`ENTA�Ì-C�`aVTÊ�CEV�R\JHEV�ËENP9<ÝE;YV�Uº\JH"AD\2RJHE9xQE;Y`+Ý"V0RP9<;YÍ<V�`W9<N¯A^ËEËENJ9DØBXYU+A^\JV�`.ÝBÖ)Ï0Ð$Ñ

Þ-HEVM?<V,CEV�N]A^;YXÎG�AD\JXY9xC A^ÝEXY;YXÎ\vÖ¶9D=�Ò´Ï0ÐâRJ9<;YQE\PXY9<CER.XYR.ZTHEV�ZTO<V,` `EQaNJXYCE?:\JNTADXYCEXYCE?ÝBÖ:Z�AD;YZ�QE;cA^\JXYCE?¶\JHEVMÍ<A^;YXÎ`"AD\JXY9xC:V�NJNP9<N.9D=0\PHEV)Z�QENJNPV�CB\J;YÖ¬Ý�V,RJ\vÛnÊ�\)ËENP9<?<NTADU¶Ñ Þ-HEXYRNJV �BQEXYNPV�R$\JHEV2QERJVg9D=�QECaOzCa9DÌ-C0`�AD\TA�ÓcÍ<A^;ÎXY`�A^\JXY9<C6`�AD\TA<Ô,K�Ì-HaXÎZTH0XYR´R]ADUWËE;YV�`-=nNJ9<U±\PHEVR]A^U�V-`�A^\]A�RPË�ADZ�V0A^RS\PHEV�\JN]A^XYCEXYCE?0`�A^\]AEÑBä´XYC�AD;Y;YÖzKDA^U�9<Ca?µA^;Y;E\JHEV�Ý"V�RJ\-XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;YRV�U�V,NJ?<XYCE?W9DÍ<V�N�A)NJQEC:\PHEV.9<CaV.Ì-XÎ\PH:U�XYCEXYU�QEU·Í<AD;YXY`�A^\JXY9<CMV,NJNJ9xN+ÓßË�9xXYCz\�9^=�Ý"V�RJ\?<V�CaV�N]A^;ÎXYG�A^\JXY9<C"Ô�XYR-\JV,RJ\JV,`M9<CMA�\JV�RP\¯`�A^\]A�RJV,\~AD?BADXYC.9<CaZ�V�A�=n\JV�N-\PN]ADXYCEXYCE?�XYR-9DÍ<V�N�Ñ

¾�¿/. 0 � �·Ä�1,�320Ä)4�5 Ä�Á ��6 �´Ç"³È713�98¸Ä-Å �

Þ-HEV2U�9<RP\ \JXYU�V�Û Z�9xCERJQaU�XYCE?2RJ\JV,Ë.XÎC�Ï0Ð)XYR$\JHEV2V�Í<AD;YQ�A^\JXY9<C�9^=²XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�A^;ÎR�ÑTå¯RPQ�AD;Y;YÖ\JHEXYR�RP\JV�Ë)XYCEZ�;YQE`aV�RSU.Qa;Î\PXYËE;YV�V�ØBV�Z�QE\PXY9<CER-9^=A0?xV�CEV�\PXÎZ6ËENJ9x?<NTADU¸Ñ^ÉvC � � �U� V�ØBV�Z�QE\PXY9<C

Page 5: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ �

PopulationIntron

EliminationFitness

Evaluation

Effective Program

Individual

����

����

��

�� ��"ª��xª��xª ��f<onlJq�f.kP��hju¯h�fB}�onhjq�f)h�f�� �2­ ��� fx�jp�kP¹EkT�]onhji�k¯�TqDyxk0« � �j}��v�z®�hjm2k��DkT�PwzovkTy �\JXYU�V.H"ADR�Ý"V�V�C NJV�`EQaZ�V�` ÝzÖ:V,Í<9<;YÍBXYCE?¶ÝEXYC�ADNPÖ5U+A^ZTHEXYCEV�ËENP9<?xN]ADUWR0\JH"AD\�`a9¸CE9x\NJV �BQEXYNPV¸XYCB\JV�NPËENJV,\]AD\PXY9<CtÑ-ÉvC \JHaXÎR)RPV�Z�\JXY9xC Ì2V¸XYCB\JNP9B`EQEZ�V5A^CE9<\PHEV�N)Ë�9xRJRPXÎÝaXÎ;YXY\vÖ¬\J9RJË"V�V�`MQaË+;YXYCEV�A^N�Ï�Ð$Ñ

Þ-HEV�XYUWË�V�NTAD\PXÎÍxV0ËENP9<?<NTADUÜRP\JNJQaZ�\JQENPV�XYCM;YXYCEV�A^NµÏ�ЬË�V,NJU�XY\PR~Ca9<CEVTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V.XYCBÛRJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CER2\J90Ý"V�XY`EV�CB\JX>Ê�V�`.V�à�Z�XYV�CB\J;YÖzÑxÞ-HEXYR�XYC.\JQaNJC+A^;Y;Î9DÌ-R$\PHEV¯VTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V�Z�9B`EV�\J9Ý�V2V�ØB\JNTADZ�\PV�`.=nNJ9<U A6ËENJ9x?<N]A^UçADCE`.\P9�Ý�V-Z�9xËEXYV�`�\J90A6\JV�UWË�9xN]ADNPÖ0ËENP9<?<NTADU±ÝEQ³Ù²V�N9<CEZ,V¯Ý"VT=@9<NPV�\JHEV6Ê�\PCEV�RJR-9^=\PHEV�ËENJ9x?<N]A^U XÎR2Z�A^;ÎZ,QE;cAD\JV,`¸ÓcRPV�V�ä´XY?<QENPV �xÑ���Ô�ÑxFSÖ.9xCE;YÖV�ØBV�Z�QE\PXYCE?�\JHEV-VTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V-ËENP9<?<NTADUâÌ-HEV�C�\JV�RP\JXYCE?0V�A^ZTH0Ê�\PCEV�RPRSZ�A^RJV<K^V�Í<AD;YQ�A^\JXY9<C0Z�ADCÝ�V.ADZ,Z�V�;YV�N]A^\JV�`°RJXY?<CaXjÊ"Z�ADCB\J;YÖ � '(�JÑEÉv\�XYR�XYU�Ë"9<NJ\TADCB\-\J9WNJV�A^;YXÎG,V.\JH�A^\~\PHEV�NJV�ËENPV�RJV,CBÛ\]A^\JXY9<C)9D=2\JHEV�XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;YR-XYCM\JHaV�Ë"9<ËEQa;�A^\JXY9<C)XYR¯Ca9<\~A�Ù²V,Z�\JV�`:ÝBÖ)\JHaXÎR0A^Z�\JXY9<C´ÑEÉvC\JHEXYR2Ì�A�ÖBKBCE9�Ë�9x\JV�CB\PX�A^;t?xV�CEV�\PXÎZ�U)AD\JV,NJXcAD;"?<V�\PR¯;Y9<RP\�Ñ

æ¯;Y?<9xNJXY\JHEU �M`EV,\JV�Z�\PRMAD;Y;-RJ\PNJQEZ�\PQEN]A^;�XÎCB\PNJ9<CaR�XYCãA¶;YXYCEV�A^N.?<V�CEV,\JXYZ)ËENJ9x?<N]A^U¸Ñ�¯9x\JV�\JH�A^\¯Ì-HEV,\JHEV�N�9xN-CE9<\¯A�ÝEN]A^CEZTHMXYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<C)XYR~ADC)XYCB\JNP9<C)9<CE;YÖW`EV�Ë"V�CE`ER�9<C\JHEV6RJ\TAD\JQaRS9^=t\JHEV�9<Ë"V�NTAD\JXY9xC.\JH�A^\S`EXYNPV�Z�\J;YÖ�=@9x;Y;Î9DÌ-R�Ñ(�29<ËBÖBXÎCa?�AD;Y;EU)ADNJOxV�`.XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�Û\JXY9<CaR�A^\-\JHEV�V�CE`¼=@9<NPU�R�\PHEV0VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV0ËENP9<?<NTADU¶Ñ

TZ��[=QYW(HKF]\�� >9 Ó�� �]�����]�� � ��H �� �� �������� ���� ��]�Z ��! ���#"'���� � ��! JÔ�<Ñ-Ò V�\W\JHEV¶RJV,\%$'&)(*(ãA^;ÎÌ-A�ÖBR.Z�9<CB\TADXYC AD;Y;-NJV�?xXYRJ\JV,NJR)\JH�A^\+A^NJVMVTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V:AD\�\PHEVZ�QENPNJV�CB\¯ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U&Ë"9<RPXÎ\PXY9<CtÑ$'&)(*( +,+ ) * & ) * XYRS9xQE\JËaQE\-NJV�?xXYRJ\JV,N.-[B\]A^NJ\¯A^\-\JHEV0;cA^RJ\2ËENJ9x?<N]A^U·XYCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<C¸A^CE`�UW9DÍ<V6Ý�ADZTOBÌ�A^NJ`ER�Ñ

�EÑ-LMADNPO�\PHEV�CEV�ØB\¯9xË�V�NTAD\PXÎ9xC)Ì-XÎ\PH�`EV,RJ\JXYC�A^\JXY9<C)NPV�?<XYRJ\PV�N )9*0/1$�ÑÉn=�RJQEZTHMADC)XYCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<C)XYR-CE9<\2=n9<QECE`´K32 �EÑ

�EÑ2Én=²\PHEV-9<Ë"V�NTAD\JXY9xC.`EXYNJV�Z�\P;YÖ�=@9<;Y;Y9DÌ-RAµÝEN]A^CEZTH�9xNSA6RJV �BQEV�CaZ�V�9D= ÝEN]A^CEZTHEV�R�KxU+A^NJO\JHEV,RJV0XYCERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<CaR¯\J9B9"KB9<\JHaV�NJÌ-XYRJV�NJV�UW9DÍ<V )9*´=@NJ9xU4$ &)(*( Ñ

'�Ñ2ÉvCERJV,NJ\�\JHEV�9<Ë"V�N]A^CE`MNJV,?<XYRJ\PV�N�ÓßR]Ô�9^=�CaV�̱U+A^NJO<V,`�XYCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<CER�XYC1$'&)(*(�X>=CE9x\AD;YNJV�AD`EÖWZ�9<CB\]A^XYCEV�`tÑ32 �aÑ

�EÑ-[B\J9xËtÑBæ¯;Y;´QECEU+A^NJOxV�`.XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CER�ADNJV�XYCB\JNP9<CER�ÑÞ-HEV¯AD;Y?<9xNJXY\JHaU±CEV�V�`ER2;YXYCEV�ADNgNJQECB\JXYUWV65.Ó/ ÔgAD\�Ì29<NPRJ\�K^Ì-XÎ\PH .Ý"V�XYCE?0\PHEV-U+A^Ø<Û

XYU.QEU ;YV�Ca?<\JH.9^=t\JHEV6;YXÎCaV�ADN$?<V,CEV�\JXYZ6ËENJ9x?<N]A^U¸Ñ�æ¯Z,\JQ�A^;Î;YÖBKD`EV�\PV�Z�\PXÎCa?�A^CE`.NJV�UW9DÍBXÎCa?

Page 6: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

\JHEV�CE9<CEV�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V.Z�9B`EV�=@NP9<UÜA.ËENP9<?<NTADUÜ9xCE;YÖ�NJV9�zQaXÎNPV�R0ADÝ"9<QE\6\JHEV�R]A^U�V�\JXYUWVµA^RZ�AD;YZ�Qa;�A^\JXYCE?09xCEV6Ê�\JCaV�RJR�Z�A^RJV<Ñ

FSÖ°9<U�XY\P\JXYCE?M\PHEVMV�ØBV�Z�Qa\JXY9<C 9^=0CE9<CEV�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V¶XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CERW`EQENJXYCE?:ËaNJ9<?xN]A^UXYCz\PV�NJËaNJV�\TAD\JXY9xC A¶;cA^NJ?<VMA^U�9<QaCz\�9D=~Z,9<U�ËaQE\]A^\JXY9<C°\JXYU�VWZ�ADC¬Ý"VMR]A�ÍxV�`tÑ�æÜ?x9B9z`V�RJ\PXYU+AD\PV¯9^=\JHaV09DÍ<V�NTAD;Y; ADZ�Z�V,;ÎV,N]AD\PXY9<CMXYC�NPQECB\JXYU�V6XYR-\JHEV6= A^Z�\J9xN

������� + �� (�� * # ��� #

Ó/�<Ñ��<Ô

Ì-XY\JH ��* # ���� # `EV,CE9<\PV�R�\JHEV�A�ÍxV�N]A^?<V0Ë"V�NPZ�V�CB\]A^?<V�9D=�XYCz\PNJ9xCMZ�9B`EV0XYC¸A�?xV�CEV�\PXÎZ�ËENJ9^Û?<NTADU�ADCE` � ( � * # ��� # \JHEVWNJV�RPË�V,Z�\JXYÍ<V Ë�V�NPZ�V�CB\]A^?<VM9^=¯VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV+Z,9z`aV<Ñ$ÉvC � '(�¯ADCA�Í<V�NTAD?xV�XYCB\JNJ9xC5NTAD\JV)9^=~ADÝ"9<QE\ � � Ë�V,NJZ�V�CB\WXÎR�`E9BZ�QEUWV�CB\JV�`°=@9xN�RPV�Í<V,N]AD;-Z,;�A^RJRPXjÊaÛZ�AD\PXY9<CMËENP9<ÝE;YV�UWR�KaÌ-HEXYZ]H Z�9<NPNJV�RPË�9xCE`ER0\P9¼A^C¸A�Í<V,N]AD?xV0`EV�Z,NJV�A^RJV�XYCMNPQECB\JXYU�V�ÝBÖ¸A= ADZ,\J9<N �aÑBÉvCM?<V,CEV�N]A^;vKE\JHaV0ËENJ9xË�9xNJ\PXÎ9xC)9D=V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V.ADCE`)CE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV�XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCERXYC�;YXYCEV�A^N�ËENJ9x?<NTADU�R´`EV�Ë"V�CE`ER-9xC.Ý�9x\JH.\PHEV¯ËENP9<ÝE;YV�U ADCE`.\PHEV¯Z,9<CBÊ�?xQEN]A^\JXY9<C�9D=t\PHEVÒtÏ0Ð RJÖBRJ\PV�U¸K"XYCEZ�;YQE`EXYCE?W\JHEV�ËENP9DÍzXY`EV,`¸ËENP9<?xN]ADUÜZ,9<U�Ë"9<CaV�CB\JR.ÓcRPV�V�[BV�Z�\PXY9<C&�<Ñ��<ÔADCE`W\JHEV�Z]Ha9<XYZ�V�9D=$Í<ADNJXcA^\JXY9<CW9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9<NPR0ÓcRPV�V�[³V�Z�\JXY9xC �xÑ �<ÔgXÎCWË�ADNP\JXYZ�QE;cA^N�Ѿ�¿� Ã������ÜÀ<Ág �´Ã��¯Ã � Â��´Â³ÈPÄ�Á

Þ-HEV.XYU�Ë"V�N]A^\JXYÍ<V�NJV�ËENPV�RJV,Cz\TAD\PXÎ9xC¬9D=¯A�;YXYCEV�A^N�Ï0Ð ËENJ9x?<NTADU Z�ADC:Ý"V.\JNTADCER�=@9<NPU�V�`XYCz\P9+AWRJV,U+ADCB\PXÎZ�AD;Y;YÖ�V �BQEXYÍ<AD;YV�CB\�=@QECEZ�\PXY9<C�A^;�ËENJ9x?<NTADUÜ?<NTADËEH´Ñ Þ-HEV�=@9<;Y;Y9DÌ-XYCE?.æ¯;>Û?<9xNJXY\JHEU �MADZTHEXYV�ÍxV�R�\JHEXYR�=@9<N�A^C:VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV+;YXYCEV�A^N0ËENP9<?<NTADU¶Ñ�Þ-HBQER�K$\JHEXYR0UWV�\JHa9z`NJV �BQEXYNPV�R�\JHEV.`EV,;ÎV,\JXY9<CM9^=SXYCB\JNJ9xC¸XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCER�ÝzÖ)QERPXYCE?)æ¯;Y?<9xNJXY\JHEU �EKaÊ�NPRJ\�Ñ Þ-HEV`EXYNJV�Z,\JV�`�RJ\PNJQEZ�\PQENJV69D=E\JHaVSNPV�RJQE;Y\PXÎCa?~?xN]A^ËEH0Ý"V�\J\PV�N�NJV�×�V�Z�\PR$=@QECEZ,\JXY9<C�A^;<Z�9xCECEV�Z,\JXY9<CERADCE`�`�AD\TA2×�9DÌ°XÎC�;ÎXYCEV�ADNt?xV�CEV�\PXYZ-ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�R�Ñ�Þ-HEV2?<NTADËEH0XYR$Z�9xCz\PXY?<QE9xQER´=@9<N´\vÌS96NJV�A�ÛRJ9xCER Ê�NJRP\�KxÝBÖ�CE9x\�\JNTADCER�=@9<NPU�XYCE?6RJ\JNPQEZ�\PQEN]A^; XÎCB\PNJ9<C.XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCERSADCa`tK<RPV�Z�9xCE`tKBÝBÖADRPRJQEUWXÎCa?0\JH�A^\-\JHEV,NJV0XYR-9<Ca;ÎÖ.9xCEV�9<QE\PËEQE\-NPV�?<XYRJ\PV�N�Ñ"ä´XÎC"AD;Y;YÖzKx\JHEV�?xN]ADËaH+XYR-ADZ�ÖBZ�;YXYZX>=�XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CER�KDRJQEZTH�A^R�;Y9z9xËER$9<N$Ý�A^Z]OBÌ-ADNP` �TQaU�ËER´`E9�CE9<\$9BZ�Z�QEN2XYC�\PHEV2ËENJ9x?<N]A^U¸ÑÉvCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<CER�KBRJQEZTH)ADR2Z�9<CE`aXÎ\PXY9<C�A^;EÝEN]A^CEZTHEV�R-NPV�RJQE;Y\2XYC�?<NTADËEH.RP\JNPQEZ�\JQaNJV�R6\JH�A^\�A^NJVCE9<\�AD;YÌ�A�ÖBR�ÍBXYRJXY\JV�`:`aQENJXYCE?MV,ØzV,Z�QE\JXY9xCtÑtF29<\PH5NTAD\JHaV�N�RPË�V,Z�XcAD;2Z�ADRPV�R.9D=-ËENJ9x?<NTADU.ÛU�XYCE?�Z�9xCEZ�V�ËE\PR�KaXÎ\PV�N]A^\JXY9<CaR�A^CE`�ÝENTADCEZTHEV,R�KERPH�AD;Y;"Ý�V�V�ØBZ�;YQE`aV�`W=@NJ9xU \PHEV6=@9<;Y;Y9DÌ-XYCE?`EXYRJZ�QaRJRJXY9xC�=n9<N2RJXYU�ËE;YXYZ�XY\vÖBÑ

TZ��[=QYW(HKF]\����9 Ó�� �!���! �� ��1# ���� � �� �� ���E���������� �]� � �� � ��� ��! ����!��# ����� � ���!� ���xÔ�<Ñ-[B\]A^NJ\-AD\2\JHEV�;cADRP\SXYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xC�XYC.\JHEV�ËENP9<?xN]ADU¶ÑDÉv\JR2`EV�RP\JXYC�A^\JXY9<CWNJV�?xXÎRP\JV�N�)�� &�� �XYR�\PHEV)9<QE\PËEQE\�NJV�?xXÎRP\JV�N.9^=~\PHEV)ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�ADCE`°;�A^Ý�V,;ÎR�\JHaV+RP\]A^NJ\.CE9B`EVW9D=~\PHEV?<NTADËEH:ÓcRPXYCEO�CE9B`EV0A^\-\JHEXYR-RJ\TAD?xV�Ô�Ñ

�EÑ-Ï�90\P90\JHEV6RJXYCEO.CE9B`EV6XYC.\JHEV6?<N]A^ËEH.\JH"AD\2HE9<;Y`ER�\PHEV¯`aV�RJ\PXÎC"AD\JXY9xC�NJV,?<XYRJ\PV�N )�� &�� �9D=$\JHEV0Z,QENJNPV�CB\¯XYCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<CMADR¯A�;cA^Ý�V�;vÑ�EÑ2æ¯RPRJXY?<C)\JHaV0XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<C)9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xN-\J9.\JHaXÎR-Ca9z`aV<Ñ'�Ñ-äE9xN�V�ADZTH:9<Ë"V�NTADCE`:NPV�?<XYRJ\PV�N") �� Ó@A^CE`:Z�9xCERJ\TADCB\]Ô�9^=�\PHEV.Z�QENPNJV�CB\�XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CNJV�Ë"V�A^\¯RJ\PV�ËER �����

Page 7: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ �

�EÑ2Én=�\JHEV�NPV0XYR-CE9�RJXYCEO�Ca9z`aV~Ì-XY\PH+;cA^Ý�V�;) � KEZ,NJV�A^\JV0XY\�Ñ�EÑ��29<CECaV�Z�\ )�� &�� � ADCE`M) �� ÝBÖ�A�`EXYNPV�Z�\JV,`MV�`E?xV<ÑtÓK)�� &�� � Ý"V�Z�9<UWV�R-XYCECEV�N-Ca9z`aV<Ñ�Ô�EÑ2Én=SCE9x\¯AD;Y;t9xË�V�NTAD\PXÎ9xCER~A^NJV0Z,9<U�U.Qa\]AD\PXYÍ<V-;cADÝ"V�;t\PHEXYR¯V�`a?<V�Ì-XÎ\PH ��Ó��xÔ2X>= ) � XYR\JHEVµÊ�NJRP\0ÓcRJV,Z�9<CE`"Ô¯9xË�V,N]ADCa`tÑ�EÑ2Én=�\JHEV�V�CE` 9D=ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U·XYR-NJV�A^Z]HaV�`tK 2 �!�aÑ�EÑ-Ï�9�\J9.\JHaV~CaV�ØB\¯ËENPV�Z�V�`EXYCE?WXYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<C)XYC�ËENP9<?<NTADU¶Ñ�2 �EÑ

���EÑ-[B\J9xËtÑ��6V�;YV�\JV�AD;Y; NJV�?xXYRJ\JV,N¯;cADÝ"V�;YR�=nNJ9<UºXYCECEV�N-Ca9z`aV�R�ÑÚ�ADZTH�ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xC�U+A�Ö�Ý�V�XYCB\JV�NPËENJV�\PV�`¸A^RSA0RPU+A^;Î;aRJQEÝE\PNJV�V�9^=`EV�Ëa\JH

9<CEVxÑ ÉvC¸\PHEV.VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV.ËENJ9x?<NTADU�?xN]A^ËEH¸NPV�RJQa;Î\PXYCE?W=@NJ9xU�æ¯;Y?x9<NJXY\PHEU �EK"V�A^Z]H:XYCECaV�NCE9B`EV�NPV�ËENPV�RJV�CB\PR+ADC°9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xN�A^CE`5H�A^R�A^R�U)ADCBÖM9xQE\J?x9<XYCE?MV�`a?<V�R�A^R�\PHEV�NJVMA^NJV9<Ë"V�N]A^CE`ER-XYC)\JHEV�Z�9xNJNPV�RJË"9<CE`aXÎCa?�XYCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<CtKaXvÑ VxÑÎKx9<CaV~9xN-\vÌS9"Ñ>I

[BXYCEO.CE9B`EV�R�K�XvÑ V<ÑYKxCE9B`EV�R¯Ì-XY\PHE9<QE\¯A^CBÖ.9<QE\P?<9<XYCE?�V�`E?xV�R�K A^NJV�;cADÝ"V�;YV�`)Ì-XÎ\PH)NJV�?^ÛXYRJ\JV,N~XY`EV,Cz\PX>Ê�V�NJR�9<N�Z�9<CaRJ\]A^CB\JR�Ñ$[BXYCEOMCa9z`aV�R�\JH�A^\0NJV�ËaNJV�RPV�CB\�AWZ�9xCERJ\TADCB\�ADNPV�9xCE;YÖZ�NJV�AD\JV,`¸9xCEZ�V�`EQENJXYCE?.\PHEV�Z�AD;YZ�QE;cA^\JXY9<C)9D=�\PHEV�?xN]A^ËEHtÑ ! CE;YÖ)RJXYCEO)CE9B`EV,R~\PH�AD\6NJV�˳ÛNJV�RPV�CB\�A¼Í<ADNJXcA^ÝE;YV+ÓßNJV�?xXÎRP\JV�NTÔ�A^NJVWNJV�ËE;cA^Z�V�`5NPV�?<Qa;�A^NJ;YÖMÝBÖ¶9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9<N�CE9B`EV�R�XÎC:\PHEVZ�9<QaNJRJV.9^=S\JHaV�A^;Î?x9<NPXÎ\PHEU¸ÑxÞ-HEV�RPV�ADNPV.\JHEV�9<CE;YÖ)Ë"9<XYCB\JR~A^\�Ì-HEXYZ]H \JHEV.?xN]ADËaHMU+A�Ö?<NP9DÌ0Ñ�[BXYCEZ�V.;Y9B9<ËaR~ADNPV�Ca9<\�Z�9<CaRJXY`EV�NPV�`5\PHEV�9xCE;YÖ)RJQEZ�Z,V�RJRP9<NJR.9^=SRJXYCEO CE9B`EV�R�U+A�ÖÝ�V,Z�9<UWV¯9<\PHEV�N2RJXYCEOWCE9B`EV�R-9<N2CEV�Ì CE9B`EV�R�ÑBæ-=@\PV�N-V�A^Z]H)XY\JV,N]AD\PXY9<C�9^=t\JHEV0A^;Î?x9<NPXÎ\PHEUAD;Y;BCE9<CaZ�9<CERP\]A^Cz\gRJXYCEO�CE9B`EV�R�Z�9xNJNPV�RJË"9<CE`)V�ØEA^Z�\J;YÖ�\J9�\JHEV6VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV¯NJV,?<XYRJ\PV�NJR-AD\�\PHEVZ�QENPNJV�CB\2ËENJ9x?<N]A^UçË"9<RPXÎ\PXY9<CtÑDF2V�Z�A^QERJV6\JHEV6CBQEU.Ý�V,N9^=²V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V6NJV�?xXÎRP\JV�NPR-XYR�;YXÎUWXY\JV�`ÝBÖ�\PHEV¯\P9<\]A^;�CBQEU.Ý"V�N�9^=tNJV�?xXYRJ\JV,NJR�KB9^=tZ�9<QaNJRJVxKE\JHaV¯CBQEU.Ý"V�N�9D=tRPXYCEO�Ca9z`aV�R�A^CE`�\PHEVU+A^ØzXYU�QEUºÌ-XÎ`a\JH:9D=¯\PHEV�?xN]A^ËEH:NJV�RPË�V,Z�\JXYÍ<V,;ÎÖ¬ADNPV.;ÎXYUWXÎ\PV�`:ADR0Ì2V�;Y;vÑ æ¯R.A)NJV,RJQE;Y\�K\JHEV�ËENP9<?xN]ADUº?<NTADËEH)XYR-RJQaËEË�9xRJV�` \J9.?<NP9DÌ XYC)`EV�Ëa\JHtÑaÞ-HEV0`EV�Ëa\JH)XYR-NJV�RP\JNJXYZ�\PV�`:ÝBÖ\JHEV);YV�CE?x\JH°9D=~\PHEV)XYU�Ë"V�N]A^\JXYÍ<VWËENJ9x?<N]A^U Ý�V�Z�ADQERPV¸V�A^ZTHãXYUWË�V�NTAD\PXÎÍxV.XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CZ�9<NPNJV�RPË�9xCE`ER.\P9MV�ØEADZ�\P;YÖ:9<CEV.XYCECEV,N�CE9B`EVWXYC:\JHEVW?<N]A^ËEHtÑtäa9<N�\JHE9xRJV�NPV�ADRP9<CER.\PHEV?<NTADËEHWRJ\JNPQEZ�\PQENJV�U+A�Ö�Ý�V�NJVT=@V,NJNJV,`M\J9�A^R-;ÎXYCEV�ADN�KB;YXYO<V6XY\JR-XYU�Ë"V�N]A^\JXYÍ<V6V �BQEXYÍ<AD;YV�CB\�Ñ

Þ-HEVMADZ�\PQ�AD;-Ì-XY`E\PH59D=~A¶ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U ?xN]A^ËEH5XYCE`EXYZ�A^\JV�R.\PHEV)CBQEU.Ý�V,N�9^=~Ë�A^N]AD;Y;YV�;Z�AD;YZ�Qa;�A^\JXY9<C Ë�AD\PHER0XYC AW;YXYCEV�A^N~?xV�CEV�\PXYZ�ËENP9<?<NTADU¶ÑEÉv\0Z�A^C:Ý�V.`aV�\JV�NPU�XYCEV�`¶ÝBÖ¸\PHEVU+A^ØzXYU�QEUÜCBQEU.Ý"V�N�9^=~NPV�?<XYRJ\PV�NJRW\JH�A^\�ADNPV+V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V:AD\.A¶ËENJ9x?<NTADU�Ë"9<RPXÎ\PXY9<CtÑ´Év\XYR0XYU�Ë"9<NJ\TADCB\6=@9<N�\JHEV)Ë"V�Nv=@9xNJU)ADCEZ�V.9^=¯;YXÎCaV�ADN.Ï0Ð \J9¶ËENP9DÍzXY`EV.V,CE9<QE?xH5NPV�?<XYRJ\PV�NJR=@9<N-Z�AD;YZ�QE;cAD\PXY9<CER0ÓßZ�AD;YZ�QE;cA^\JXY9<CWNJV�?xXÎRP\JV�NPR]Ô,K XYC¼A^`E`EXY\JXY9xC+\P9.\JHEV�NJV�?xXÎRP\JV�NPR�\JH�A^\¯HE9x;Î`\JHEVWXYCEËEQE\�`�AD\TAEÑ$Þ-HEXYR�XYR�V�RPË�V,Z�XcAD;Y;YÖ:\JNJQaVMX>=¯XÎCaËEQE\�`EXYU�V�CERPXY9<C:XYR�NTAD\PHEV�N.;Y9DÌ0ÑtÉn=\JHEV6CBQEU.Ý�V,NS9^=tNJV�?xXÎRP\JV�NPR¯XYR2CE9<\2RJQBà�Z,XÎV,Cz\-\PHEV�NPVµA^NJV�\J9B9�U+A^CzÖ�Z�9<CB×"XÎZ,\JR-\JHaNJ9<Qa?<H9DÍ<V�NPÌ-NJXY\JXYCE?�9^=²NPV�?<XYRJ\PV�N2XÎC³=@9<NPU+AD\PXY9<C�`EQENPXÎCa?~Z�AD;YZ�QE;cAD\PXY9<CtÑDÞ-HaV-U�9<NPVSNPV�?<XYRP\JV�NPR�A^NJVËENJ9DÍBXY`EV�`´KBHE9DÌSV,Í<V�N�KE\JHaV~UW9<NPV¯XYCE`EV�Ë"V�CE`aV�CB\¯ËENP9<?<NTADU·Ë"AD\JHaR¯U+A�Ö�`EV�ÍxV�;Y9<ËtÑ

Év\SAD;YRJ96=@9x;Y;Î9DÌ-R´=@NP9<Uâ\JHEV�ADÝ"9DÍ<V-9<ÝaRJV�NPÍ<AD\JXY9xCER�\JH"AD\�\PHEV¯NPQECB\JXYU�V29D=tæ6;Î?x9<NPXÎ\PHEU�-XYR�5.Ó����  ÔtÌ-XY\PH �XÎR$\PHEV-CBQEU.Ý�V,Nt9D= VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV-XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CERSA^CE`��0XYR$\JHEV-CBQEU.Ý"V�N9D=ENJV,?<XYRJ\PV�NJR�Ñzäa9<N´ËENJ9xÝE;YV�U�R´Ì-XÎ\PH�A-NTAD\PHEV�N�;Y9D̶XÎCaËEQE\$`EXYU�V�CaRJXY9<CtKTXvÑ V<ÑYK�Ì-XY\PH�A6RJU+A^;Y;CBQEU.Ý�V,NS9^=XYCEËEQE\-NPV�?<XYRP\JV�NPR�K"NJQECB\PXÎUWV-XYR¯AD;YU�9xRJ\�;YXYCEV�A^N-XÎC $Ñ

Þ-HEV)ËENJ9x?<N]A^U ;YXYRJ\PV�`¬XYCãÚ$ØEADUWËE;YV:�WZ�9<NPNJV�RPË�9xCE`ER)V�ØEADZ,\J;YÖ¬\J9¶\JHEVM?xN]A^ËEH¬XÎCä´XÎ?xQENJVM�<Ñ��WA�=@\PV�N0ADËEËE;YÖBXYCE?�æ6;Y?<9<NPXY\JHEU �aÑ�F29<\PHtK \PHEV.XYU�Ë"V�N]A^\JXYÍ<V0NPV�ËENPV�RJV�CB\TAD\JXY9xCd ¢$�Bk-u~}*��hju-wBu±fDwBu � kPl�q,rtq�|EkPlJ},fzy<mgh�f�},f�h�fBmvonlvwz�Tonhjq�f)hjm�on£$q �

Page 8: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

ADCE`:\PHEV�=@QECaZ�\JXY9<C"AD;�NPV�ËENJV,RJV�CB\]A^\JXY9<C¬Z�9xCERJXYRP\�9^=�VTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V)Z�9B`EV�HaV�NJVW\JH�A^\�XYR�=@NPV�V=@NJ9xUÜQECBQERJV,`¸XYCERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<CaR09<N�QECBÍBXYRJXY\JV�` ?<N]A^ËEH¶Z�9<UWË�9xCEV�CB\JR�K�NPV�RJË"V�Z�\PXYÍ<V�;YÖBÑ Þ-HEXYRXYR-Í<AD;YXY`�X>=Ì2V�ADRPRJQEUWV�\JH�A^\-\JHEV09xQE\JËaQE\¯9^=\JHaV0XYU�Ë"V�N]A^\JXYÍ<V6ËENJ9x?<N]A^U&XYR-RP\J9<NPV�`¶XÎCÍ<ADNPX�A^ÝE;YV,ZC[]\�^�AD\$\JHEV6V�CE`.9^=²V�ØBV�Z,QE\JXY9<C´Ñ<æ-\$\JHaV¯Ý"V�?<XYCECEXYCE?�9^=²ËENP9<?xN]ADUâV�ØBV�Z�QE\PXY9<C\JHEVWXYCEËEQE\PR�A^NJV�HaV�;Y`:XÎC°Í<ADNPX�A^ÝE;YV�R ZC[ \S^¶\J9 ZC[��S^ Ñ ÉvC°\JHEVWZ�9<NPNJV�RPË�9xCE`EXYCE?:?<NTADËEHNJV�ËaNJV�RPV�CB\]AD\PXY9<CM\PHEV0XYCEËEQE\PR¯`EV,CE9<\PV0Í<ADNPX�A^ÝE;YV¯RPXÎCaO�CE9B`EV�R�K"Ý�V�RPXY`EV�R�\JHEV�RPXÎCaO+Ca9z`aV�R\JH�A^\SHa9<;Y`)Z�9<CERP\]A^Cz\PR�Ñ

Variable Sinks

Constant Sinks

pow

*

/+

*

+

+ −

+

2

1

r[1] r[0]r[2]

r[2]

r[1]r[2]

r[0]

r[0]

r[2]

r[3]

r[0]

r[3]r[0]

�� ��"ª��xª��aª �glJ},|<��k���wxhji�}��jkPf<o-q,r²on�Bk-kP¹³kT�Tonhji�k-��h�fzkT},l-|<lJq�¡�lJ}�u±�TqDy<k2h�f�� �D}�u6|<�jk ���!� |<�kPlJ}�ovq,ltfBqDy<kTmt},lJk$�j} � kP�jkTy�£$hjon��on�zkgy<kTmvonh�fz}�onhjq�f�lJkT¡�hjmvovkPlJm$q,r�on�zk��Tq,lvlJkTmn|³q,fzy^h�fz¡6h�fzmvonlvwB�P�onhjq�fBm-«cmvkTk��g�j¡�q�lvhjon�Bu �D® ��� wzon|xwzo$lJkT¡,hjmvovkJlgl � ��u�}�lv�<m�on�BkSmvov},lJo$fBqDy<k � � wBov¡�q,h�fz¡�k]yx¡�kTm}�lJk2fBq�o��j} � kP�jkTy.�zkPlJk � wzog|<lvh�f<ovkTy�h�f�on�zk2lvhj¡,�<oSq,lJy<kPl �

¾�¿�� ��ÈPÁ���$Ã���´Á�� ÂEÈPÇ�� �1�´Ã��´ÂEÄ�Ã��

Þ$N]AD`aXÎ\PXY9<C�A^;Î;YÖ<KaNJV�Z,9<U.ÝEXYC�A^\JXY9<CMXYR�A^ËEËE;YXYV�`¶XÎC¶?<V,CEV�\JXYZWËENJ9x?<N]A^U�UWXjCE?�=@9xN0Í<ADNPÖBXÎCa?\JHEV�;YV�CE?x\JHER�9D=2ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�R�ÑEÉvC¶\JHEXYR�RJV�Z,\JXY9<C:Ì2V�XYCB\JNP9B`EQEZ�V.ADC¶VTà�Z�XYV�CB\�Í<ADNPX�A^CB\¯9D=;YXÎCaV�ADN¯Ï0Ð \JH�A^\¯Ì29<NJOBR6V�ØBZ�;YQERJXYÍ<V,;ÎÖ)Ì-XY\JH)U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9xCER�ÑB8:V�Ì-XÎ;Y; `EV,U�9<CaRJ\JNTAD\PV0\JH�A^\

Page 9: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ �

;YXÎCaV�ADN ËENP9<?xN]ADUWR²A^NJV2U+A^CEXYËEQE;cAD\PV�`¯UW9<NJV´ËENJV,Z�XYRJV�;YÖ0ÝBÖ�QERJXYCE?-U.Qa\]AD\PXY9<CER"9<CE;YÖBÑTÞ-HEXYRÌ-XY;Î;"AD;YRJ9�Ý�V6U�9x\JXYÍ<AD\PV�`�ÝBÖ.UWV�ADCERg9D=\PHEV6=@QECEZ,\JXY9<C�A^;�XYCB\JV,NJËENPV�\]A^\JXY9<CW`EXYRJZ�QERPRJV�` XÎC[BV�Z�\PXY9<C �<Ñ '�Ñ

Þ-HEVS;YXYCEV�A^NtZ�NP9<RPRJ9DÍ<V,N�9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xN�V�ØBZTH�ADCE?xV�R$\vÌS90A^NJÝEXY\JNTADNPXÎ;YÖ�;Y9<CE?-RPQEÝERPV �BQEV�CEZ�V,R9D=$XÎCaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xCER-Ý"V�\vÌSV,V�CM\vÌ29�XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�A^;ÎR�ÑDÉn=�\JHEV�9xË�V�NTAD\PXÎ9xC�Z�A^CECE9x\-Ý�V�V�ØBV�Z�Qa\JV�`Ý�V,Z�ADQERPV�9xCEV�9^Ù²RPËENJXYCE?MÌ29<Qa;Î`:V,ØzZ,V�V�`5\PHEV�U)ADØBXYU.QEU·;YV�CE?x\JHtK´Z�NP9<RJRP9DÍ<V�N.XYR0Ë"V�N�Û=@9<NPU�V�`�Ì-XÎ\PH.V �BQ�AD;Y;YÖ0;Y9<Ca?~RPQEÝERPV �BQEV�CEZ�V,R�Ñ LMADZ,NJ9DÛvU.QE\TAD\JXY9xCERt`EV,CE9<\PV¯`EV�;YV�\PXY9<CER�9xNXYCERJV�NP\JXY9<CaRt9D=ERPXÎCa?<;YV$=@QE;Y;DXYCERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<CaRHaV�NJV<Ñ�F29<\PH�Z�NP9<RPRJ9DÍ<V,N�A^CE`�U+A^Z�NJ9^Û U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9xCER9<Ë"V�N]A^\JV�9<C)XYCERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<C);YV�ÍxV�;tADCE`)Z�9xCB\JNJ9x; ËENJ9x?<NTADUº?<NJ9DÌ-\PH¸ÓßU+ADZ,NJ9DÛvÍ<ADNPXcAD\JXY9xCER]Ô,ÑL)XYZ�NJ9^Û U.Qa\]AD\PXY9<CER�ÝBÖ:Z�9<UWË�ADNPXYRJ9<C´KtNTADCE`E9xU�;YÖMNPV�ËE;cADZ�V XÎCaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xC¬Z�9<UWË�9xCEV�CB\JR\JH�A^\SZ,9<U�ËaNJXYRJV�RJXYCE?x;YV¯9<Ë"V�NTAD\J9xNJR�K�NPV�?<XYRP\JV�NPR�K"9<N2Z�9<CaRJ\]A^CB\JR�Ñ

;=<��?<@; � L�W(H�L FIHKQ=N��?FID'���?H���D�VÉvC0?<V,CEV�\JXYZ2ËENJ9x?<NTADU�UWXYCE?�ZTH�ADCa?<XYCE?~A�RJU)AD;Y;DËENJ9x?<NTADU±Z�9xU�Ë"9<CEV�CB\´U+A�Ö¯;YV�A^`0\J9�AD;>ÛU�9xRJ\A^NJÝEXY\PN]ADNPÖ�ZTH�A^CE?<V,R�XYC�ËENP9<?xN]ADUâÝ�V,H�A�ÍBXÎ9xN�Ñ2ADNJXcA^\JXY9<C09xË�V,N]AD\P9<NPRS\PH�AD\�XYCE`aQEZ�VRJU)AD;Y;YV�NtRP\JV�ËWRJXYG�V�R�Ì-XY\PH�A¯HaXÎ?xH�ËaNJ9<Ý"ADÝEXY;YXY\vÖ�AD;Y;Y9DÌ5A6U�9<NPVSËaNJV�Z�XYRPV~ADËaËENJ9DØBXYU+A^\JXY9<C\J9.;Y9BZ�AD;Y;YÖ.9<Ëa\JXYU+A^;�RP9<;YQE\JXY9xCER�ÑBÞ-HEXYR6NJV�;YXYV�R¯9xC)\JHEV�A^RJRPQEU�ËE\PXY9<C�\PH�AD\�K"9<CMA�Í<V�NTAD?xV<KRJU)AD;Y;YV�N-RJ\PNJQEZ�\PQEN]A^;SÍ<A^NJXcAD\PXY9<CER69D=S?xV�CEV�\PXÎZ.ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U�R¯NPV�RJQa;Î\�XÎC¶RJU)AD;Y;YV�N-RJV,U+ADCB\PXÎZÍ<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<CaR¯ÓcRPV�V�AD;YRP9�[BV�Z�\PXÎ9xC �<Ñ��<Ô,Ñ

ÉvC0\JNPV�V-ËENJ9x?<NTADU�R�K�Z�NP9<RPRJ9DÍ<V,N�A^CE`�U.QE\]A^\JXY9<C6Ë�9xXÎCB\PRtZ�A^C�Ý"VSV,ØzË"V�Z�\PV�`.\J9�Ý"VS\PHEVU�9xNJV-XYCB×�QEV,Cz\PXcAD;"\JHEV6Z�;Y9<RJV,N-\JHEV�Ö)ADNPV~\P90\JHaV~NP9B9<\�ÑBÉvCaRJ\JV�AD`tKBXYC+A�;YXYCEV�ADNgËENJ9x?<N]A^U¸KV�ADZTH.Ë"9<RPXÎ\PXY9<C09^=ÕA^C.XÎCaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xC�U)A�Ö�H�A�Í<V-A�U�9xNJV�RPXYU�XY;cADN XYCB×�QEV,CEZ�V¯9xC�ËaNJ9<?xN]A^URJV�U)ADCB\JXYZ�R�Ñ ��V�Z�AD;Y;´\JH�A^\¯\JHaV�;YXYCEV�A^N-?<N]A^ËEHMNPV�ËENJV,RJV�CB\]A^\JXY9<C:XYR6NJV�RP\JNJXYZ�\PV�`:XYCMÌ-XY`E\JH\JHENP9<QE?xH�\PHEV0CBQEU.Ý"V�NS9^=NPV�?<XYRJ\PV�NJR�ËENP9DÍBXÎ`aV�`:ÓcRJV,V�[BV�Z�\PXY9<C �<Ñ 'zÔ,Ñ

L)9<NPV�9DÍ<V�N�K"XÎC)\PNJV�VTÛvÝ�A^RJV�`5Ï0Ð$KaZ�NJ9xRJRP9DÍ<V�N�9<Ca;ÎÖ)A�Ù V�Z�\PRµA�RJXYCE?x;ÎV�Ë�9xXÎCB\-XYCM`�A^\]A×�9DÌ0K"Ì-HEXYZTH¸XYR�\JHEV.NP9B9<\09^=S\JHEV.V,ØzZTH�A^CE?<V,`:RJQEÝE\PNJV�VxÑ$8 XY\JHM;YXYCEV�A^N~Z,NJ9<RPRJ9DÍxV�N�\PHEVZ�9<CB\PV�CB\JR09^=SU+A^CzÖ)VTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V.NJV,?<XYRJ\PV�NJR�U+A�ÖWZ]H"ADCE?xV<K XvÑ V<ÑYK�RPV�Í<V,N]AD;2Ë"9<XYCB\JR�XYC¸`�A^\]A×�9DÌ ADNPV~UW9B`EX>Ê�V�`.RJXYU.QE;Y\TADCEV�9xQERJ;YÖBÑ�Þ-HEV¯NPV�ADRP9<C);YXÎV,RSXYC�\PHEV¯NTAD\PHEV�N¯C"ADNJNP9DÌ ?<NTADËEHRJ\PNJQEZ�\PQENJV�9^=t;ÎXYCEV�ADN2?<V�CEV,\JXYZ¯ËENP9<?xN]ADUWR�ÑDÞ-HaXÎR2?<NTADËEH.XYR2`EXYRJNPQEËE\JV,`�V�A^RJXY;YÖ.Ì-HEV�C+A^ËBÛËE;YÖBXÎCa?-;ÎXYCEV�ADNtZ,NJ9<RPRJ9DÍxV�N�9<C�\JHEV-XYU�Ë"V�NTAD\JXYÍxVRP\JNPQEZ�\JQaNJV<Ñxæ¯R�A6NJV�RPQE;Y\�KDZ,NJ9<RPRJ9DÍxV�N$RJ\JV,ËRJXYG�V�R�U)A�Ö�Ý"V�Z�9<UWV1�BQEXY\JV�;cADNJ?xV<K"9<C¸A�ÍxV�N]A^?<V<ÑÕá¯9DÌ2V�Í<V�N�K"XÎ\6H�ADR�\P9+Ý"V�Z�9<CERPXY`EV�NJV,`\JH�A^\�K�\J90A�Z�V�NJ\TADXYC.`EV�?xNJV�VxKD\JHEV-XYCB×"QEV�CEZ�V-9^=�;YXYCEV�ADN´Z�NJ9xRJRP9DÍ<V�N�9xC�\PHEV2VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V6Z�9B`EVXYR~NPV�`EQEZ,V�`¬XÎUWËE;YXYZ�XY\J;YÖ�ÝBÖ:A)HEXY?<H¶N]A^\JV�9^=�RP\JNPQEZ�\JQaN]AD;-XYCB\JNP9<C:Z�9B`EVW\JH�A^\0V�UWV�NJ?xV�RÌ-XY\JH�\PHEXYR-9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xN�Ñ

æ UW9<NPV0V�ØBËE;YXYZ�XY\¯Ì-A�Ö+9^=SNJV,`EQEZ�XYCE?M\PHEV�VTÙ²V,Z�\�9^=S;YXYCEV�ADN�Z�NP9<RPRJ9DÍ<V,N0XYR¯\J9);YXYU�XY\\JHEV2;YV�CE?x\JH09^=�\JHEV2V�ØBZTH�ADCa?<V�`.XYCERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<C�RJV,?<U�V,Cz\PR�Ñ�8:V�V�ØBË"V�NJXYV�CaZ�V�`�\PH�AD\´N]A^\JHEV�NRJU)AD;Y;EU+A^ØBXÎU�QEUâRJV�?xU�V�CB\2;ÎV,CE?<\PHER¯ËENP9B`EQEZ�V0\PHEV�Ý�V,RJ\¯NPV�RJQa;Î\PR � ���JÑ

Þ-HEVSADÝ"9DÍ<VgNJV�A^RJ9<CaRRPQE?<?xV�RJ\$\PHEV�QERPVS9^=�U+A^Z�NJ9^Û U.QE\TAD\PXj9<CaREXYCERJ\PV�AD`�9D=EZ�NP9<RJRP9DÍ<V�N=@9<N2U+A^Z�NJ9^Û Í<A^NJXcAD\PXY9<CER$XYC�;YXYCEV�A^N�Ï0Ð$ÑBL)QE\TAD\PXÎ9xCER-?<Q"ADN]A^CB\JV�V0A�RJQBà�Z�XYV�CB\-Í<A^NJXcAD\PXÎ9xCRJ\PNJV�CE?x\JH±ADCE`°=@NPV�V�`E9xU�9D=0Í<ADNPXcAD\JXY9xCãXYC¬;YXYCEV�ADN�Ï�Ðâ=@9<N.\PHEV =@9<;Y;Y9DÌ-XYCE?MNJV�ADRJ9xCER�Ñä´XÎNPRJ\�K�XYC¶;YXÎCaV�ADN0Ï0Ð A^;YNJV�A^`EÖMRJXYCE?x;YV�UWXÎZ,NJ9DÛvU.QE\TAD\JX>9<CER-\PH�AD\�V�ØBZTH�A^CE?<V.AWNJV�?xXÎRP\JV�NXYCE`EV�ØMXYC:ADC¶XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<C:U+A�ÖWZTH�ADCE?xV.\JHEV.`"AD\]A�×�9DÌ Ì-XY\JHaXÎC¶A�;YXYCEV�A^N�ËENJ9x?<N]A^U¸ÑÞ-HEXYR�XÎR�\PNJQEVWÝ�V�Z�ADQERPV�RJV,Í<V�NTAD;2XÎCaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xCER0\PH�AD\0ËaNJV�Z�V,`EV�\PHEV.U.QE\]A^\JV�`¶XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�Û\JXY9<C)U)A�Ö�Ý"V�Z�9<UWV0VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV.9<N6CE9<CEV�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V.NPV�RJË"V�Z�\PXÎÍxV�;YÖãÓßRJV�V.[BV�Z,\JXY9<C&�<Ñ��<Ô,Ñ ! C

Page 10: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

\JHEVW?<NTADËEH:;YV�ÍxV�;¯A)RJXYCE?x;YV�V�`E?xV�XYR�NJV�`EXYNPV�Z�\JV,`5=nNJ9<U�A^C5VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV)RJQEÝE?xN]A^ËEH5\P9 A=@9<NPU�V�N$CE9xCEZ�9xCz\PXY?<QE9xQER$Z�9<UWË�9xCEV�CB\�ÑDÉvCW\JNPV�VTÛvÝ�ADRPV�`+Ï0жUWXYZ�NJ9^Û U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9xCER QERPQ�AD;Y;YÖU+A^CEXYËEQE;cAD\PV-\JHEV0Z,9<CB\JV�CB\PR¯9D=�RPXÎCa?<;YV�CE9B`EV�R¯ÝaQE\¯`E9.Ca9<\-ZTH�ADCa?<V0V�`a?<V�R69D=�\JHEV�\JNJV,VRJ\PNJQEZ�\PQENJVxÑ

[BV�Z�9xCE`tK´\JHEV.;YXYCEV�A^N~ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U��D?xN]A^ËEH)RJ\JNPQEZ�\PQENJV)Z�A^C:Ý�V.U)ADCEXYËEQE;cA^\JV�`)Ì-XY\JH5AHEXY?<H�`EV�?xNJV�V�9D="=@NPV�V�`E9xU¸ÑDÉvC.\PNJV�V�ËENP9<?<NTADUWR�K�ÝBÖ�Z�9xU�Ë�A^NJXYRJ9xCtK�XY\�XYR�N]A^\JHEV�N2`EX>à�Z�QE;Y\\J9.`EV,;ÎV,\JV�9<N-XYCERJV,NJ\0A�?<NP9<QEËM9^=�CE9B`EV�R~A^\~A^C¼A^NJÝEXY\PN]ADNPÖ)Ë�9xRJXY\JXY9<C´Ñ��29<U�Ëa;ÎV,\JV�RJQEݳÛ\JNPV�V�R�U�XY?<HB\-Ý"V.NJV�UW9DÍ<V�`:AD;Y9<Ca?+Ì-XY\PH¸\PHEV.9<Ë"V�N]A^\JXY9<C:\P9)R]AD\PXYRv=@ÖM\PHEV�Z,9<CERP\JN]A^XYCz\PR9D=t\PHEV�\JNJV,V~RP\JNPQEZ�\JQaNJV �%�!� �JÑ<Þ-HEXYR2XYRSÌ-HBÖ.\JHaV¯\JNPV�V0RP\JNJQaZ�\JQENPV0XYRS;YV�RPR-RJQEXY\TADÝE;YV¯\P9�Ý"VÍ<ADNPXÎV,`0ÝBÖ0RJU)AD;Y;YV�N U+A^Z�NJ9^Û U.QE\TAD\PXj9<CaR�RPXÎCaZ�V-U�9B`EX>Ê�Z�A^\JXY9<C�9^=�QEËEË"V�N�ËENP9<?xN]ADU±Ë"ADNJ\PRCEV�Z�V,RJR]A^NJXY;YÖ�XÎCBÍx9<;YÍ<V´ÝEXY?<?<V,NtË�A^NJ\JR´9D=EZ�9B`EV<Ñ�ÉvC0;YXYCEV�A^NtÏ0Ð$KT`EV�Ë"V�CE`aXÎCa?¯RJQaÝERJ\PNJQEZ�\PQENJV,R`E9�Ca9<\¯?xV�\�;Y9<RJ\6Ì-HEV�C¶`EV�;YV�\PXÎCa?�9<N6XYCERJV�NP\JXYCE?MADC XÎCaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xC¸ÝaQE\¯NPV�U+A^XÎC)Ì-XY\JHaXÎC\JHEV-;YXYCEV�A^N�NJV,ËENJV�RPV�CB\]A^\JXY9<CMADR2RJ\PNJQEZ,\JQENTAD; CE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV~Z,9z`aV<K<XvÑ V<ÑYKDQECBÍBXYRJXY\JV,`�?<NTADËEHZ�9<UWË�9xCEV�CB\JR�Ñ

;=<��?<�> ACB3D�EGFIHKJ=D�� X�F�L�FIHKQYN Væ¯Z�Z,9<NJ`aXÎCa?M\J9M\PHEV�`aVTÊ�CEXY\JXY9xC¸9^=¯VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<VWZ�9B`EV�XYC5[BV,Z�\JXY9<C �xÑ��EK ;YV�\�A^C:VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVÍ<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<C°`EV�CE9x\JV¸A ?<V�CaV�\JXYZM9xË�V�NTAD\PXÎ9xC \JH"AD\�UW9B`EX>Ê�V�R�\JHEV¶VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV¸Z�9B`EV¶9D=�A?<V�CaV�\JXYZ�ËENP9<?xN]ADU¶Ñ �¯9x\JV�\PH�AD\´V�Í<V�C�Xj=E\PHEVSV�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V2Z�9B`EV2XÎRtA^;Y\JV�NPV�`tK�\JHEV2ËENPV�`EXYZ�\JXY9xCER9D=S\PHEV.ËENP9<?<NTADU =@9<N0AWZ�9<CaRJXY`EV�NPV�`5RPV�\09D=2Ê�\PCEV�RJR�Z�A^RJV�R�U�XY?<HB\-Ý"V.\JHEV.RTADUWV<Ñ"æ¯CVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV0Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<C.XYR2U�V�NPV�;YÖ.U�V�A^CB\S\P9�ÝENPXYCE?�ADÝ"9<QE\-A�RJ\PNJQEZ,\JQENTAD;$ZTH�ADCE?xV�9D=\PHEVVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV+ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U�Z�9B`EV<Ñ$Þ-HEV,NJVMXYR�CE9¸ZTH�A^CE?<V)9^=¯ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�RJV,U+ADCB\PXÎZ,R+Ó�Ê�\JCEV,RJR]Ô?<Q�A^N]A^Cz\PV�V�`MÌ-HaXÎZTHMXYR-`EQaV�\P9�RJV,U+ADCB\PXÎZ�XYCB\JNP9<C)Z�9B`EV<Ñ"ÉvCM?xV�CEV�NTAD;vK"`EV�Z�NPV�ADRPXÎCa?+\PHEVCBQEU.Ý�V,N~9^=�Ca9<CEVTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V)Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<CaR~XYR�V�ØBË"V�Z�\JV,` \J9MNPV�`EQEZ,V�\JHaV�N]A^\JVW9D=-CEV�QE\PN]AD;Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<CaR�Ñ æÜ?xV�CEV�\PXÎZ)9xË�V�NTAD\PXÎ9xC5XYR�CEV�QE\PN]AD;6X>=~XY\�`a9zV,R.CE9<\�ZTH�ADCE?xV)\JHEVWÊ�\PCEV�RJR9D=SA.ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U¸Ñ3�69<\PV�\PH�AD\6ÝzÖ)`EV�Ê�CEXY\JXY9<C´K�\PHEV�\JV�NPUÜCE9<CEV�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V.XYR¯UWV�ADCB\6\J9�Ý"VNJV�;cA^\JV�`)\J9.\PHEV�Z�9B`EV0;YV�ÍxV�; 9<CE;YÖBÑ

8:V¯Z�9xCERJXY`EV�N6\vÌS9�`EX>Ù V�NJV�CB\�ADËEËENP9zA^Z]HaV�R-\J9.VTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V0U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9xCER�Ñ ! CaV~Í<A^NJXcADCB\Ó������ ���<ÔµQERJV�R�U+A^Z�NJ9^Û~ADCE`:UWXYZ�NJ9^Û U�QE\]A^\JXY9<CaR-\J9M9xË�V�NTAD\PV�9<C:V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V)XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�Û\JXY9<CaR0V�ØBZ�;YQERJXYÍxV�;YÖ¸ÝEQa\�;YV�A�ÍxV�R�\PHEV�Ca9<CEVTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V)Z�9B`EV)QECB\J9xQEZTHEV�`tÑ$Þ-HEXYR0XYR�U�9x\JX>ÛÍ<AD\PV�`)ÝzÖW\JHEV0A^RJRJQaU�ËE\PXÎ9xC�\PH�AD\-U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9xCER29D=Ca9<CEVTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V�XÎCaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xCER¯U)A�Ö�Ý"VU�9xNJV-;YXYO<V�;YÖ.XYCBÍ<ADNJXcA^Cz\gXÎCW\JV�NPU�R29D=SAµÊ�\JCEV,RJR¯ZTH�A^CE?<V�\PH�ADC)U.QE\TAD\JXY9xCER�9D=$VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVZ�9B`EV<ÑBÞ-HEV�9x\JHEV�N-Í<A^NJXcADCB\�Ó������ �JÔ2AD;Y;Y9DÌ-RSRPXÎCa?<;YV¯CE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV�XÎCaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xCER-\J9.Ý"V`EV�;YV�\PV�`tÑ"ÉvCM9<NP`EV�N�\J9.?xQ�ADNTADCB\JV,V�\PH�AD\6\JHEV0V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V.Z�9B`EV�XÎR�AD;Y\JV,NJV�`tK A^CMVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVXYCERJV�NP\JXY9<C�U+A�Ö-`EXYNJV,Z�\J;YÖ6=@9<;Y;Y9D̶RJQEZTH0XYCB\JNP9<C0`EV,;ÎV,\JXY9<CER�Ñ�æ5\JHaXÎNP`�A^ËEËENP9zADZTH0UWXY?<HB\�Ý"V\J9�`EV�;YV�\PV�AD;Y; V�UWV�NJ?xXÎCa?�CE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV0XYCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<CER-`aXÎNPV�Z�\P;ÎÖ)A�=@\PV�N¯\PHEV�Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<C´Ñ _

Þ-HEVM`EV�;YV�\PXY9<C¬9D=�ADC¬XYCERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<C¬XYC¬?<V�CaV�N]A^;~XYR.CE9x\.Z�9<UWËE;YXYZ�AD\PV�`tÑ$Én=�ADC¬XYCBÛRJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<C)XYRSXYCERPV�NJ\PV�`tKEXY\PRS`EV,RJ\JXYC�A^\JXY9<CWNJV�?xXYRJ\JV,N¯XYRSZTHE9xRJV�C)XYC�RPQEZTHMA0Ì-A�Ö�\PH�AD\-\PHEVXYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<C¶XÎR6VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV�AD\�\JHEV�Z�9xNJNJV,RJË"9<CE`EXYCE?)ËENP9<?xN]ADU(Ë�9xRJXY\JXY9xCtÑEF2ÖM`E9xXÎCa?�RJ9"KXYCERJV�NP\JXY9<CaRt9D=ECE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV-XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CER2ÓcXYCB\JNJ9xCER]Ô$A^NJVSA�Íx9<XY`EV�`�V�ØBËE;YXYZ�XY\J;YÖBÑ�Ò XYO<V�\PHEVVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV¯Z�9B`EV<KBV�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V6NJV�?xXÎRP\JV�NPR-Z�ADCWÝ�V-XY`EV,Cz\PX>Ê�V�`�V�à�Z�XYV�CB\J;YÖ�XYC.;YXYCEV�A^NNPQECB\JXYU�V5.Ó/ Ô � ���JÑ�-¢$�xhjm-�z}�m � k]kPf)rcq�wxfzyMovqDq�lJkTmvonlvhj�Tonhji�k�r�q,l-|<lJq�¡,lJ}�uº¡�lJq,£�on� � kT�T},wzmvk�q�rSmnw � mvov},f<onhj}���jq�mvmSq,rt¡�kPfBk]onhj�6u�}�ovkPlvhj},� �

Page 11: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ ���

;=<��?< � W W(D�O H EGFIHKQ=N W D W��]QYW3� L�N,E(DÉvC¸\PHEV�CEV�ØB\0\vÌ29+RPV�Z�\PXÎ9xCER0Ì2V�Ì-XY;Y;$Z�9<UWË�ADNPV�\PHEV�Ë�V�N�=@9<NPU+A^CEZ�V�9D=-;ÎXYCEV�ADN�?<V�CaV�\JXYZ9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xNJR+A^CE` \PHEV�XYN�XYCB×�QaV�CEZ�V¶9<C RP9<;YQE\PXÎ9xC¬Z�9<UWËE;YV�ØBXÎ\vÖ:QaRJXYCE?5\vÌ29:NJV,?<NJV,RJRJXY9xCËENJ9xÝE;YV�U�R�ÑBÞ-HEV�Ê�NJRP\~ËaNJ9<Ýa;ÎV,UÜXÎR6NJV�ËaNJV�RPV�CB\JV�`°ÝzÖ)\PHEV�\vÌ29DÛv`EXYU�V,CERJXY9<C"AD; U�V,ØzXYZ�A^CH�AD\g=@QECaZ�\JXY9<C)\PH�AD\-XYR-\J9�Ý"V�ADËEËaNJ9DØBXYU+AD\PV�`

4�� &�� * ��� # � � � Ó�� ,� Ô,+� � ( �"_' ( � _

' � ����������� ��� ���� Ó/�<Ñ �<ÔÞ-HEV-RJV,Z�9<CE`.\PV�RJ\2ËENP9<ÝE;YV�U¶K�C"ADU�V,`0\vÌS9�Ë"9<XYCB\JR�KDZ�9<UWËEQE\PV�`.\JHEV-R/�BQ�ADNPV-NJ9B9<\�9^=²\PHEVRJZ�A^;cADN2ËENJ9B`EQEZ,\¯9D=�\vÌ29�\PHENJV,VTÛ `aXÎUWV�CERPXÎ9xC�AD; ÍxV�Z�\P9<NJR �+A^CE`��

4 ��� �� * # � ��Ó"� I , � _ , ��� , � I , � _ , � ��Ô +"! � I �#� I 0 � _ �#� _ 0 ��� �#�$� Ó/�<Ñ 'zÔÞ�ADÝE;YV�R��xÑ%�¯ADCE` �xÑ���Z�9<UWË�ADNPV2Ê�\JCaV�RJR¯A^CE`�?xV�CEV�NTAD;YXYG�AD\PXÎ9xC.Ë�V,Nv=@9xNJU+A^CEZ�V�=@9<N�`aXjÙ V�N�ÛV�CB\6=@9<NPU�R¯9^=SU+A^Z�NJ9^Û Í<A^NJXcAD\PXY9<C Z�NP9<RPRJ9DÍ<V,N+Ó&%�')(+*,*TÔ�K"=@NPV�V.U+A^Z�NJ9^Û U.Qa\]AD\PXj9xCER0Ó �� �JÔADCE` \vÌS9WÍ<ADNJXcA^Cz\PR¯9^=SVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV.U+ADZ,NJ9DÛvU.QE\TAD\JXY9xCER~ÓßRJV�V�A^Ý�9DÍxV�Ô�Ñ"ÉvC¶\JHEV�R]A^U�V0NPQECU�XYZ�NP9DÛvU�QE\TAD\PXÎ9xCER-ADNJV�A^ËEËE;YXYV�`M\P9<?<V,\JHEV�N�Ì-XÎ\PH¸9xCEV.9D=2\JHEV�=@9xQEN�U+A^Z�NJ9.9xË�V�NTAD\P9<NJRÌ-XY\JHMA�ËENJ9xÝ�ADÝaXÎ;YXY\vÖ.9D=�� ��Ë"V�NJZ�V,Cz\�Ñ ! CE;YÖ�9xCEV0?<V,CEV�\JXYZ�9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xN�K"HE9DÌ2V�Í<V�N�KEXYR~A^ËBÛËE;YXYV�`+A^\¯A0\PXÎUWV¯\P9.Í<ADNJÖ�A�Z,V�NJ\TADXYC)XÎCa`EXYÍzXY`EQ"AD;"ËENJ9x?<N]A^U¸Ñ

ätXYNPRJ\�K^ÌSV-Z�A^C.RJV�V6\JH�A^\�ËENPV�`EXYZ�\JXY9xC.V�NJNP9<NJR2NJV,`EQEZ�V�\J9x?<V�\PHEV�N�Ì-XY\PH.\JHEV-Í<A^NJXcAD\PXÎ9xCRJ\PV�Ë�RPXÎG,V�R-Ì-HEV�CWQERJXYCE?�U+A^Z�NJ9^Û U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9DCaRXYCERP\JV�A^`�9^=tZ�NJ9xRJRJ9DÍxV�N�ÑBÉvCB\PV�NJV�RP\JXYCE?x;ÎÖBKEADCAD`E`aXÎ\PXY9<C�A^;zRPXY?<CEX>Ê�Z�A^CB\�XYU�ËENP9DÍ<V�UWV�CB\tZ�A^C.Ý�V69<ÝERPV�NJÍxV�`)Ì-XÎ\PH.VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV~U.Qa\]AD\PXY9<CER�Ñ! CEV�V,ØzËa;�A^C�AD\PXY9<CMXYR�\JH�A^\�VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V.U.Qa\]AD\PXY9<CER�KEÝBÖM`EVTÊ"CEXY\JXY9<CtK"NPV�`EQEZ�V.\PHEV.CBQEU.ÛÝ�V,N.9D=¯CEV�Qa\JN]A^;¯Í<A^NJXcAD\PXÎ9xCER�RJXY?<CaXjÊ"Z�ADCB\J;YÖ:Z�9xU�Ë�A^NJV�`:\P9¸U.Qa\]AD\PXY9<CER0\PH�AD\.ADNPV�CE9x\NJV�RP\JNPXÎZ,\JV�`:\P9�\JHaV0VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV.Z�9B`EV<Ñ"ÉvCM\JHaXÎR6Ì�A�ÖBKEV,Í<9<;YQE\PXY9<C)XYR¯AD;Y;Y9DÌSV�`)\P9�ËENP9<?<NPV�RJR= ADRP\JV�N-Ì-XY\PHEXYC�\JHaV0R]A^U�V¯Ë"V�NPXÎ9B`)9D=$\JXYU�VxK<XvÑ V<ÑYKBCBQEU.Ý�V,NS9^=?<V,CEV�N]A^\JXY9<CaR�Ñ

-´§/.1032 �xª �xª �.k ��hj�T}�fW�z}�o$|<lJq � �jkTu54��Si�kPlJ}�¡�k-|xlJkTyDhj�Tonhjq�f)kPlvlJq�lSq,i�kPl � �6lvw<fBm �6 },lvhj}�onhjq,f ¢"lJ},h�f<h�fB¡ 6 },��hjy<}�onhjq�f ¢ k]mvo 72kPwzonlJ},�� lvlJq,l � lvlJq,l � lvlJq,l 6 },lvhj}�onhjq,fzm8 93:<;�; � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � �=?> @ � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � �ACBD=?> @ ��� � � ��� � � ��� � � �*�ACBD=?> @FE ��� � � �^� � � �^� � � � �

ÉvCM\JHEV����� ����V�ØBË�V,NJXYU�V�CB\PR~V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V�U.QE\]A^\JXY9<CaR�A^NJV�NJV�RP\JNJXYZ�\PV�`:\J9WVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVXYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CER�Ñ$æ¯;Y\JHE9xQE?<H¬CE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV)Z�9B`EVMXYR�Ca9<\.\J9xQEZTHEV�`¬ÝBÖ5\PHEXYR.Í<ADNJXcA^Cz\�KtXY\U+A^XÎCB\TADXYCERAµU.QEZTH�;Y9DÌ2V�N�XYCB\JNJ9xC.N]A^\JV¯\PH�ADCWRJ\TADCE`�A^NJ`WU+ADZ,NJ9DÛvU.QE\TAD\JX>9<CER2Ó �� �JÔ�A^RZ�ADC�Ý"V-RJV�V�C�=nNJ9<U ä´XÎ?xQENJV,R �xÑ ��� �xÑ��EÑ�ÉvCaRJ\JV�AD`tKD\PHEV-9<\PHEV�N�Í<A^NJXcADCB\´9D= VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V-U.Qa\]A�Û\JXY9<CaR�Ó ���� �JÔSA^;Î;Y9DÌ-R´`EV�;YV�\JXY9xCERS9^=²Ca9<CEVTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V¯XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCER~ÓßRJV�V�[BV�Z�\PXY9<C �<Ñ �aÑ �xÔ�KÌ-HEXYZTH5NJV,`EQEZ�V�R)\PHEVMN]A^\JVM9^=~CE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxVMZ�9B`EV)=nQENJ\PHEV�N�ÑgÞ-HEVMXYCB\JNP9<C5Z,9z`aVMU+A�Ö

Page 12: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

��� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

-´§/.1032 �xª �aª ¢�£$q6|Eq�h�f<ovmg|<lJq � �jkTu54��Si�kPlJ}�¡�k-|xlJkTyDhj�Tonhjq�f)kPlvlJq�lSq,i�kPl � ��lvw<fBm �6 },lvhj}�onhjq,f ¢"lJ},h�f<h�fB¡ 6 },��hjy<}�onhjq�f ¢ k]mvo 72kPwzonlJ},�� lvlJq,l � lvlJq,l � lvlJq,l 6 },lvhj}�onhjq,fzm8 93:<;�; � � �^�j� � � �x� � � � �x� � �^� �=?> @ � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � �x� �ACBD=?> @ ���x� � � �^� � � � � � ���ACBD=?> @FE � �x� � ���T�x� � ��� � � � � �

=@QECEZ,\JXY9<C¬ADR�A ËENJ9x\JV�Z�\PXY9<C UWV�ZTH�ADCEXYRPU \PH�AD\.Z,9<U�Ë"V�CERTAD\PV�RMÓcNPV�`EQEZ�V,R]ÔW\JHEV XÎC³×�QBÛV�CEZ�V�9^=t\JHEV�QERPV�NvÛv`EVTÊ�CaV�`M`EV�;YV�\PXY9<C�NTAD\PV�Ó/� �0Ë"V�NPZ�V�CB\¯HEV,NJV�Ô29xC�\JHaV~V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V�Z�9B`EV<ÑÞ-HEXYR0Z�9xQE;Y`:V�ØBËE;cADXYC:\JHEVWRJ;YXY?<HB\J;YÖMÝ"V�\P\JV�N.ËENPV�`EXYZ�\PXÎ9xC:Ë�V,Nv=@9xNJU+A^CEZ�VWZ�9<UWË�ADNPV�`:\J9���� ���¶RJ9<;YQE\PXY9<CER�ÑSF2Ö ADËEËa;ÎÖBXYCE?:XYCERPV�NJ\PXÎ9xCER�\vÌ295\PXYU�V�R.UW9<NJVW=@NPV �BQEV�CB\J;YÖ¬\JH"ADC`EV�;YV�\PXÎ9xCER�K-A RJQBà�Z�XYV�CB\)Z�9B`EV¶?<NP9DÌ-\JH XYR�?xQ�ADNTADCB\JV,V�`tK2V�RJË"V�Z�XcA^;Î;YÖ Ì-XY\PH VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVU+A^Z�NJ9^Û U.QE\TAD\PXj9<CaR�Ñ

ÉvC ?<V�CaV�N]A^; K�Ì-HEV�C QERJXYCE?°U+ADZ,NJ9DÛvU.QE\TAD\JXY9DCER�K$ÌS9xNJRPV¸Ë"V�Nv=n9<NJU)ADCEZ,VMU+A�Ö¬AD;YRJ9NJV�RPQE;Y\$=@NP9<UçCaV�?zA^\JXYÍ<V-VTÙ V�Z�\PR�KaXÎC�Ë�A^NJ\JXYZ�Qa;�A^N�Kx;cADNJ?xV�N�U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9xC�RJ\JV,Ë�RJXYG�V,R�KBÝBÖ�NPV�ADZ�Û\JXYÍ<AD\PXY9<C09^=tXÎCB\PNJ9<C.Z,9z`aV<Ñ �69<\PV¯\JH"AD\�CE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV¯Z�9B`EV6H�ADNP`E;YÖ�V,Í<V�N2V�U�V,NJ?<V,RSÌ-XY\JH\JHEV ����� �2Í<ADNJXcA^Cz\�Ñ

;=<��?<�� � QYNF�W(Q �,Q ��� QO D�URW(Q�� F�\

ä´XÎ?xQENJV,R �<Ñ 'MADCE` �xÑ���`a9zZ,QEU�V�CB\0\PH�AD\�VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V);YV�CE?x\JHER�ADNJV)ADNP9<QECE`+� �)Ë"V�NJZ�V,Cz\RJU)AD;Y;YV�NtX>= RJ9<;YQE\PXY9<CER�ADNPV-`EV�ÍxV�;Y9<Ë"V�`�Ì-XY\JH�VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV�U.QE\]A^\JXY9<CER2Ó������ �JÔ$\PH�ADC.Ì-XY\JHCE9<NPU+A^;�U)ADZ�NP9DÛvU.QE\]A^\JXj9xCER¯Ó � �JÔ�ÑEL)9xRJ\¯ËaNJ9<Ý"ADÝE;YÖ.XY\-XYR-U�9<NPV�`EX>à�Z�QE;Y\�=n9<N-V�Íx9<;YQBÛ\JXY9<C \J9)ËENJV,RJV�NPÍ<V)RJHE9xNJ\PV�N0VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV�Z�9B`EV.XYC¶\JHEV.ËaNJV�RPV�CEZ�V)9D=-U+A^CBÖ�CE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVXYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CER�Ñ ÉvCM?<V,CEV�N]A^;vKtAWNJV�`EQaZ�\JXY9<C¶9D=2VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<VWËENJ9x?<NTADUÜRJXYG�V.AD;YÌ-A�ÖBR¯U�V�ADCERADC.ADZ�Z,V�;YV�N]A^\JXY9<CW9D=tËENP9zZ,V�RJRPXÎCa?�\PXÎUWVS\P9B90Ý�V,Z�ADQERPV�9<CE;YÖ0VTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V¯Z,9z`aV¯XYR�V�ØBV�Z�Qa\JV�`XYC�9<QaN-;ÎXYCEV�ADN-Ï0аRJÖBRJ\PV�U�ÓcRPV�V�[BV�Z,\JXY9<C �<Ñ �xÔ�Ñ

äE9xNtQECE;YXYU�XY\PV�`¯RP\]ADCa`�ADNP`�Z�NP9<RPRJ9DÍ<V,N�\JHEV-ADÝaRJ9<;YQE\PVS;YV�Ca?<\JH�ADËEËENP9zA^Z]HaV�R$\JHEV2U+A^Ø<ÛXYU.QEU RPXYG�V-;YXÎUWXY\ 9D=� � �6XYCERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<CaRSÌ-XY\JHaXÎC�\JHaV2Ê�NJRP\ � � �¯?xV�CEV�NTAD\PXÎ9xCER2XÎC.ä´XY?<QENPV�R�<Ñ �2ADCE` �xÑ �EÑT8 XY\JH6=@NPV�V�U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9xCER"\JHEXYR VTÙ V�Z�\�XYR V�ØB\PV�CBQ�AD\PV�`�ÝBÖ6NJV�A^Z]HaXÎCa?¯\JHaV�U+A^Ø<ÛXYU.QEU&;cA^\JV�N�Ñ ! ÝBÍBXÎ9xQERJ;YÖBK ËENP9<?<NTADU ?<NP9DÌ-\JH:XYR0RP;Î9DÌ2V�N0ÝBÖ¶QERJXYCE?¶U.QE\TAD\JXY9xCER¯9xCE;YÖzÑ�¯V�ÍxV�NJ\PHEV�;YV�RPR�KBÝ"9<\JH.Í<A^NJXcAD\PXY9<C�=@9xNJUWRXYCE`aQEZ�V¯A�= ADRP\�XYCEZ�NPV�ADRPV¯9D= \JHaV~ADÝaRJ9<;YQE\PV-Z�9B`EV;YV�CE?<\PHtÑ Þ-HEXYR�VTÙ V�Z�\�XYR0NJVT=nV�NJNPV�`5\P9¼A^R0ÝE;Y9zA^\0ADCE`¶XYR~9xÝERJV,NJÍ<V,`5XYC¸\PNJV�V�Û Ý�A^RJV�` Ï0Ð\J9B9:���S���JÑEÉn=-ÌSV�Z�9xU�Ë�A^NJV0\PHEV�`aV�Í<V�;Y9xËEU�V�CB\69D=¯ADÝERP9<;YQE\JV�;YV�CE?x\JHER�Ì-XY\JH¶\JHEV�VTÙ V�ZTÛ\JXYÍ<V-;YV�Ca?<\JHaRSXYC+ä´XY?<QaNJV�R �<Ñ��0A^CE`:�xÑ '�XÎ\gÝ�V�Z,9<U�V,RS9xÝzÍBXY9<QaR�\JH�A^\S\PHEV�ÝE;Y9zA^\�VTÙ V�Z�\¯XYRU�9xRJ\J;YÖ.NPV�;cAD\JV,`¸\P9+A.?xNJ9DÌ-\PHM9D=S\PHEV�RJ\JNPQEZ�\PQEN]A^;�CE9<CaVTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V.Z,9z`aV�XYCM;YXYCEV�A^N~Ï0Ð$ÑFSV,Z�ADQERPV.CE9<CaVTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V.Z,9z`aV�`E9BV�R�CE9<\6XÎC³×�QEV�CEZ,V�Ê�\JCEV,RJR0`EXYNPV�Z�\J;YÖBK"\JHEV�NPV.XYR¯CE9)RJV�Û;YV�Z�\JXY9xC.ËENJV�RPRJQENPV09<CW\JHEXYR�Ë"ADNJ\29D=A�ËENP9<?<NTADU¶Ñ<L)9<NPV�9DÍ<V,N�Kx\JHEV�N]A^\JV69D=tCE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVZ�9B`EV0Ì29<NPOzR¯A^R~A^C+XYUWËE;YXÎZ,XÎ\gZ�9<CB\JNP9<;´9D=�Z�NJ9xRJRP9DÍ<V�N�RJ\PV�ËMRPXÎG,V�R�Ñ"Én=�Z�NJ9xRJRP9DÍ<V�N�XYR-QERJV,`\JHEXYR2ËENJ9x\JV�Z,\JXY9<C)=nQECEZ�\PXÎ9xC.=@9xNJUWR�A^C¼A^`E`EXY\JXY9xC�AD;"`ENJXYÍxV¯=n9<N2Z�9B`EV0?<NP9DÌ-\JHtÑ

Page 13: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 200 400 600 800 1000

Leng

th

Generation

crossmut

effmuteffmut2

�� ��"ª��xª��aª �.k���hj�T},fM�z}�o2|<lJq � �jkTu54ts2kTi�kP�jq,|zu�kPf<o~q,r�} � mvq���wBovk0|xlJq�¡,lJ}�uç�jkPfB¡�on�Mrcq,l¯yDh�rY�rckJlJkPf<o´rcq�lJu�m�q,rti�},lvhj}�onhjq,f � �Si�kPlJ}�¡�k2½z¡,w<lJkTm2q�i�kJl � ��lvwxfzm �

0

50

100

150

200

0 200 400 600 800 1000

Effe

ctiv

e Le

ngth

Generation

crossmut

effmuteffmut2

�� ��"ª��xª��"ª �.k ��hj�T}�fM�B}�o�|<lJq � �jkTu54 sSkTi�kJ�jq,|zu�kPf<o0q,r�kJ¹EkT�Tonhji�k�|<lJq�¡,lJ}�u �jkPfB¡�on�Mrcq,l¯yDh�rY�rckJlJkPf<o´rcq�lJu�m�q,rti�},lvhj}�onhjq,f � �Si�kPlJ}�¡�k2½z¡,w<lJkTm2q�i�kJl � ��lvwxfzm �

Ú´Ù²V,Z�\JXYÍ<VgU.QE\]A^\JXY9<CER"NJV,`EQEZ�V2\JHEVgXÎCB\PNJ9<C�Z�9B`EVSADCa`~\PHBQER�K�\JHaV�ÝE;Y9zA^\�VTÙ V�Z�\gRJXY?<CEX>=cÛXYZ�ADCB\J;YÖBK�V�Í<V�CWÌ-XY\JHE9xQE\�AD;Y;Y9DÌ-XÎCa?¯`EV�;YV�\PXY9<CER29D= CE9<CaVTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V�XYCERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<CaR�V�ØBËE;YXYZ�XY\J;YÖÓ������ ���<Ô,ÑEÉvC)\JHaXÎR6Ì�A�ÖBKBVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV�U.Qa\]AD\PXY9<CER2XYCEZ�9<NPË�9xN]A^\JV�A^CMXYU�ËE;YXYZ�XY\�Z�9xCz\PNJ9x;t9D=Z�9B`EV�?<NP9DÌ-\JH�XYC);YXYCEV�ADN2?<V,CEV�\JXYZ�ËENP9<?<NTADUWU�XYCE?�Ñ�ÉvCWZ�9<CB\JNTADRP\¯\J9�Z�NP9<RJRP9DÍ<V�N�K"U+ADZ,NJ9DÛU.QE\]A^\JXY9<CaR~`a9MCE9<\�NJV9�zQaXÎNPV)CE9<CEV�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V)Z�9B`EVW=@9xN�XYCE`EQaZ�XYCE?MVTà�Z�XYV�CB\�RJ9x;ÎQa\JXY9<CER�KCEV�XY\JHaV�N2=@9<N-Z,9<CB\JNP9<;Y;YXÎCa?0Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<CWRJ\PNJV�CE?x\JHMCa9<N2=@9xNSËENPV�RJV,NJÍBXYCE?�Z�9B`EV�`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖzÑ

Page 14: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

�]� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 200 400 600 800 1000

Leng

th

Generation

crossmut

effmuteffmut2

�� ��"ª��xª��aª ¢�£$q$|Eq�h�f<ovm"|xlJq � �jkTu 4�sSkTi�kP�jq�|Bu~kPf<o´q�rB} � mvq���wBovk$|<lJq�¡�lJ}�u:�jkPfB¡�on��rcq�l yDh�¹EkPlJkPf<orcq�lJu�m$q�rti,}�lvhj}�onhjq�f � �2i�kPlJ}�¡�k2½B¡�wxlJkTmSq�i�kPl � ��lvw<fBm �

0

50

100

150

200

0 200 400 600 800 1000

Effe

ctiv

e Le

ngth

Generation

crossmut

effmuteffmut2

�� ��"ª��xª��aª ¢�£$q´|Eq�h�f<ovmÕ|<lJq � �jkTu54DsSkTi�kJ�jq,|zu�kPf<otq,rzkP¹EkT�Tonhji�k$|xlJq�¡,lJ}�u5�jkPfB¡�on��rcq�l yDh�¹EkPlJkPf<orcq�lJu�m$q�rti,}�lvhj}�onhjq�f � �2i�kPlJ}�¡�k2½B¡�wxlJkTmSq�i�kPl � ��lvw<fBm �

¾�¿�� 8¸Ä�Á�ÂEÃEÄ 2.Ä)4�� �$ÃEÈ]�´ÂEÈJÄgÁ��SÂ�� ���È�?�

æ¯C�XYU�ËE;YXYZ�XY\�Z,9<CB\JNP9<;E9^=�RJ\PNJQEZ�\PQEN]A^; Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<C�`EXYRP\]ADCaZ�V-U+A�Ö6Ý�V-NPV�AD;YXYG�V�`�ÝBÖ0XYU�Ë"9<RvÛXYCE?�NPV�RJË"V�Z�\PXYÍ<V.NJV,RJ\JNPXYZ�\JXY9<CaR¯9<C \JHEV0Í<A^NJXcAD\PXY9<C.9<Ë"V�NTAD\J9xNJR�Ñ�Þ-HaXÎR6H�ADR-Ý"V�V�C¶`EV�UW9<CBÛRJ\PN]AD\PV�`+A^Ý�9DÍxVSÝBÖ�QERJXYCE?�U+ADZ,NJ9DÛvU.QE\TAD\JXY9xCER XYCERJ\PV�AD`.9^=tNJV�Z�9xU.ÝEXYC�AD\PXY9<C0XYC.9<NP`EV�N2\J9Í<ADNPÖ�ËENP9<?<NTADUº;YV�CE?<\PHtÑ�L¼9<NJV,9DÍ<V�N�K�ÝBÖWZ�9<CEZ,V�CB\JN]A^\JXYCE?)Í<ADNPXcAD\JXY9xCERS9xCM\JHaV0VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVZ�9B`EV<KgRJ\JNPQEZ�\PQEN]A^;¯Í<ADNPXcAD\JXY9xCER0Ý"V�Z�9<UWV)U�9<NPV�Z�;Y9xRJV�;YÖ:NJV,;�A^\JV�`¬\P9:RJV�U)ADCB\JXYZ�Í<A^NJXcA�Û\JXY9<CaR�Ñ��-V�Z�AD;Y;$\JH�A^\~9xCE;YÖ)\JHEV.`EV,?<NJV,V�9D=2Í<ADNJXcA^\JXY9<C)9<C¶\JHaV.VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V.Z,9z`aV.`EV�Z�XY`EV�R\JHEV�`EX>Ù V�NJV,CEZ�V�XÎC�Ê�\JCaV�RJR�Ñ�å6CB=@9xNJ\JQaC�AD\PV�;YÖzKEA�Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<C.9xË�V,N]AD\P9<N�KEV�ÍxV�CMX>=XY\2XÎR-9xËBÛ

Page 15: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �V�N]A^\JXYCE?�9<CW\JHEV0V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V0Z,9z`aV~V,ØzZ,;ÎQaRJXYÍ<V�;YÖBKBZ�ADC)9xCE;YÖ.?<Q�A^N]ADCB\PV�V6=@9<N2\JHEV0A^ÝERJ9x;ÎQa\JVËENJ9x?<NTADU RP\JNJQaZ�\JQENPV-\JH�A^\A2Z�V,NJ\]A^XYC0U+A^ØzXYU.QEU°Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<C6RJ\PV�Ë0RJXYG�V2XYR CE9<\´V�ØBZ�V�V�`aV�`tÑSADNPXcAD\JXY9xC�RJ\PV�ËER�9<C \JHEV0V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V�Z�9B`EV�XÎCaRJ\JV�AD`MU)A�Ö.RJ\JXY;Y;tÝ"V�U.QEZTH+ÝaXÎ?x?<V�N�KEV�ÍxV�C\JHE9xQE?<HW\JHEXYR-Ì-XY;Y; H�ADËaË�V�C)Ì-XY\JHMA�;Y9DÌSV�N-ËaNJ9<Ý"ADÝEXY;YXY\vÖzÑ

Þ-HEV2=@9<;Y;Y9DÌ-XYCE?-V�ØEADUWËE;YVSNPV�ËENPV�RJV�CB\PR¯\JHaV-NJV�RPQE;Y\S9^=ÕA^ËEËE;YÖBXÎCa?~A�UWXÎZ,NJ9DÛvU.QE\TAD\JXY9DC\J9M\PHEV�ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U V,سA^U�ËE;YV�=@NJ9xU�[BV�Z�\PXÎ9xC �xÑ �aÑ ÉvC:\JHaV�XYCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<C°9<C5;YXYCEV �)\PHEV9<Ë"V�N]A^CE` NJV�?xXÎRP\JV�N Z3[ �S^5H"ADR)Ý�V,V�C±V�ØBZTH�ADCE?xV�` ÝzÖ NJV�?xXÎRP\JV�N Z3[��S^ Ñ�æ6R¼A Z�9<CaRJVTÛ�BQEV�CEZ�VxK$Ê�ÍxV�ËENPV�Z�V�`EXYCE?"K$=@9xNJUWV�NJ;YÖ¶CE9<CEV�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V<K2XYCERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<CaR.Ý�V�Z,9<U�VWVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVCE9DÌ0KBÌ-HEXYZTH�Z�9xNJNPV�RJË"9<CE`aR~\P9�ADC)VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV0`EXYRJ\TADCEZ,V~9^=$Ê�Í<V.ÓcRPV�V0Ý"V�;Y9D̯Ô�Ñ

A��?L������KD >9 Ó�� "'��������� � �������� ���! ����"��#�Ô$�%'&�(*)�+-,�.�/(�%103254367.98���;9<

=

>3>3>

.98@?�;*A�.98�B�;DCE?�<I .98�B�;*A�.98@F�;DGH.98�B�;9<I .98@?�;*A�.98@F�;DJH.98�B�;9<I .98@K�;*A�.98�B�;DCLB�<I .98�B�;*A�.98@F�;DGH.98@K�;9<I .98�B�;*A�.98@K�;DGH.98�B�;9<I .98@K�;*A�.98@F�;*ME.98@F�;9<I .98@F�;*AE+5%�N9,�.98�B�;9OP.98@K�;�/�<I .98@F�;*A�.98@K�;*ME.98@F�;9< �3C�����6� ���&�$�6��30�������& %�� +5%'&����I .98@K�;*A�.98@?�;DCLB�<I .98�B�;*A�.98@F�;DCH.98@K�;9<I .98@?�;*AE+5%�N9,�.98@K�;9OQF'/�<I .98@F�;*A�.98@F�;*ME.98�B�;9<.98@K�;*A�.98�B�;*M�R�<.98@K�;*A�.98�B�;DJH.98@?�;9<

I .98@K�;*A�.98@F�;DGH.98@F�;9<I .98@F�;*A�.98�B�;DGH.98@?�;9<I .98@K�;*A�.98@K�;*ME.98@F�;9<S

ÉvC:9<NJ`aV�N.\J9¸A�Íx9<XY`:RJQaZ]H°ÝEXY?<?xV�N0Í<ADNPXcAD\JXY9xC¸RP\JV�ËER.9xC5ËENP9<?xN]ADU RP\JNJQaZ�\JQENPV<K�Ì2VËENJ9xË�9xRJV.ADCMV,ØzËa;ÎXYZ�XY\-Z�9xCB\JNJ9x;$\JH�A^\~NPV�Ë"V�AD\PR�A.Í<A^NJXcAD\PXÎ9xC�QECB\PXÎ;$\PHEV0RJ\PNJQEZ,\JQENTAD;2`EXYRvÛ\]A^CEZ�V0Ý"V�\vÌ2V�V�C¶Ë�ADNPV�CB\~ADCa`M9DÙ RJËENPXYCE?.= A^;Y;ÎR2Ý"V�;Y9DÌçA�U+ADØBXYU�QEU \JHENPV�RJHE9x;Y`$� �EK ���JÑ �ÉvC0Ë�A^NJ\JXYZ�Qa;�A^N�KDÌ2V2Ì�A^Cz\´\J96Ê�CE`�9<Qa\Ì-HaV�\JHEV,NSA2=@QaNJ\JHaV�N�NJV,`EQEZ�\PXÎ9xC.9D=�V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V-U.QBÛ\]A^\JXY9<CMRP\JV�Ë°RJXYG�V.U)A�Ö+RP\JXY;Y;�XYU�ËENP9DÍ<V�NJV,RJQE;Y\JR�Ñ$Þ-HEXYR�NJV �BQEXYNJV,R�U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9xC)`EXYRJ\]A^CEZ�V�R\J9)Ý"V.U�V�A^RJQENPV�`¸V,ØzËa;ÎXYZ�XY\P;ÎÖ)9xC¸\PHEV.VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV�Z�9B`EV<ÑÕÉvC:\JHEV�=@9<;Y;Y9DÌ-XYCE?.RJV,Z�\JXY9<C:Ì2VÌ-XY;Î;BXY`EV�CB\PXj=nÖ�RPQEÝERJ\PNJQEZ,\JQENPV�R¯9^=t;ÎXYCEV�ADN�?xV�CEV�\PXÎZ6ËENJ9x?<NTADU�R$\PH�AD\SA^NJV6RJQBà�Z�XYV�CB\2\J90Ý"V`EXYRJ\PXÎCa?<QEXYRJHaV�`�ÝBÖ+A�RP\JNPQEZ�\JQaN]AD;´`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V�U�V�\PNJXYZ<Ñ

å¯RJXYCE?)ADC)V�ØBËE;YXYZ�XY\¯Z�9xCB\JNJ9x;$9D=�RJV�U)ADCB\JXYZ0`aXÎRP\]A^CEZ�V�Ó�Ê�\JCEV,RJR0`EXYRP\]ADCaZ�V�Ô6Ý�V,\vÌSV�V,CË�ADNPV�CB\0ADCE`¶9DÙ RJËENPXYCE?)XÎCaRJ\JV�AD`:Ì29<QE;Y`MNPV �BQEXYNJV�ADC:AD`a`EXY\JXY9<C�A^; Ê�\PCEV�RPR0Z�AD;YZ�Qa;�A^\JXY9<C��� kPrckPlJkJfB�Tk � ��hjm�},f�k �DovkPfzy<kTy.i�kPlJmnhjq�f�q,r � � �

Page 16: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

��� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

=@9<N6V�ADZTH:NPV�Ë�V�AD\JV,`5Í<ADNPXcAD\JXY9xC¼A^CE`¶Z�ADC:Ý"V�Z�9xU�V�Z�9<UWËEQE\]A^\JXY9<C"AD;Y;YÖ.V�ØBË�V�CaRJXYÍ<V<K´V�R�ÛË�V,Z�XcAD;Y;YÖ.Xj=SA�;�A^NJ?xV�N-CBQEU.Ý�V,N-9D=$Ê�\JCaV�RJR�Z�A^RJV�R�XYR-XYCzÍx9<;YÍ<V,`tÑBæçRP\JNJQaZ�\JQENTAD;�`aXÎRP\]A^CEZ�VH�ADR�\P9+Ý"V�NJV�Z�A^;YZ�QE;cAD\PV�`5A�=@\PV�N�V�ADZTH:XY\JV,N]AD\PXY9<CMÌ-HEXY;YV�XÎ\PR�Z�9<UWËEQE\]A^\JXY9<C"AD;tZ,9<RJ\PR0`E9CE9<\2`EXYNJV,Z�\J;YÖ�`aV�Ë�V,CE`¸9xC�\PHEV0CBQEU.Ý"V�NS9^=tÊ�\PCEV�RPR~Z�ADRJV,R�ÑEÉv\-XYR¯A^;ÎRP9�`aXjà�Z,QE;Y\S\P9�Ê�CE`ADËEËaNJ9<ËaNJXcAD\PV�U+A^ØBXÎU�QEUº\JHENPV�RJHa9<;Y`ER�=@9xN0Ê�\PCEV�RPR.`EXYRJ\]A^CEZ�V)Ý"V�Z�ADQaRJVM\PHEV�Ö5ADNPV�CE9x\ËENJ9xÝE;YV�UçRPË�V,Z�X>Ê�Z<Ñ�ä´XYC�A^;Î;YÖBK�XY\�XYR�CE9x\�RJV,CERJXYÝE;YV¯\P90NJV,RJ\JNPXYZ�\2Ê�\JCaV�RJR-XYU�ËaNJ9DÍ<V,U.V�CB\JR�AD\AD;Y;vÑ

;=<��?<@; �?FIW(X,E(F�X�W(L���W W(Q [=W(L����RH�V F�L�N,E(DÞ-HEV�RJ\JNPXYCE?)V�`EXY\�`EXYRJ\]A^CEZ�VM�%�I����UWV�ADRPQENJV�R�\PHEV�`aXÎRP\]A^CEZ�V.Ý"V�\vÌSV,V�C:\vÌS9)ADNPÝEXY\JN]A^NJXY;YÖ;Y9<CE?0ZTH�A^N]A^Z�\JV�N6RJ\PNJXYCE?<R-ÝBÖ.Z�9xQECB\JXYCE?�\JHEV�CBQEU.Ý"V�N29D=Ý"ADRJXYZ69<Ë"V�N]A^\JXY9<CER�KBXYCEZ�;YQE`EXYCE?XYCERJV�NP\JXY9<C�ADCE`0V,ØzZTH�A^CE?<V29D="RJXYCE?<;YV�V,;ÎV,U�V�CB\JR�K�\JH�A^\ADNPVSCaV�Z�V�RPR]ADNPÖ.\J96\JN]A^CERv=n9<NJU±9xCEVRJ\PNJXYCE?-XYCB\J9¯ADC�9<\JHaV�N�Ñ�8:V�ADËEËa;ÎÖ6\JHEXYR´`EXYRJ\]A^CEZ�V2U�V�\PNJXYZ$\J9-`EV,\JV�NPU�XYCEV�\PHEV�RJ\PNJQEZ,\JQENTAD;`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V2Ý"V�\vÌSV,V�C�\PHEV-VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV-Ë�ADNP\�9D=�Ë"ADNJV,Cz\2ADCE`�9DÙ RJËENPXYCE?.ÓcVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV¯Í<A^NJXcAD\PXÎ9xC`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V�Ô Ý"V�Z�ADQaRJV-A-`EX>Ù V�NJV�CaZ�VSXYC�VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxVSZ,9z`aVSU)A�Ö-Ý�V�UW9<NPVt`EXYNJV,Z�\J;YÖ�NJV�;cA^\JV�`�\J9A0`aXjÙ V�NPV�CEZ�V0XYCWËENJ9x?<N]A^U·Ý"V�H�A�ÍBXY9<N�ÑBÉv\2XYRSXYUWË�9xNJ\]A^CB\�\J9.NPV�AD;YXYG�V¯\PH�AD\-\PHEV�VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V2Z�A^CECE9<\$Ý"V-Ë�ADNP\$9D= \JHEV-ADÝERP9<;YQE\PVS`EXYRP\]ADCaZ�V<Ñxæ¯Z�\PQ�AD;Y;YÖzK,\vÌS9�ËENP9<?xN]ADUWR U+A�ÖH�A�Í<V¯A�RJU)AD;Y;�A^ÝERJ9x;ÎQa\JV¯`aXÎRP\]A^CEZ�V�Ì-HEXY;YV-\JHEV�XYN2VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV0`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V�XYR�Z�9xU�Ë�A^N]A^\JXYÍ<V�;YÖ;cADNJ?xV<KBADR-H�A^R�TQERJ\2Ý"V�V�CM`EV,U�9<CaRJ\JNTAD\PV�`MAD\2\JHEV�V�ØEADUWËE;YV-ËENJ9x?<NTADU&A^Ý�9DÍxV<Ñ ! C+\PHEV9<\PHEV�N-H�A^CE`tKE\vÌ29.V �BQ�A^;Î;YÖ.VTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V0ËENP9<?xN]ADUWRSUWXY?<HB\�`EX>Ù V�N¯RPXÎ?xCEX>Ê�Z�A^Cz\P;YÖ.XÎC)\PHEV�XYNCE9<CaVTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V�Z�9B`EV<Ñ

äE9xN�A^C�V�à�Z�XYV�CB\�`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V-Z�AD;YZ�QE;cAD\PXY9<C�ÌSV2Z�9<CaZ�V�CB\JNTAD\JV69<C.NPV�ËENJV,RJV�CB\]A^\JXYÍ<V6RJQEݳÛRJ\PNJQEZ�\PQENJV,R~9^=�;ÎXYCEV�ADN2ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�R-ADCE`)NPV�?zA^NJ`)\JHEV�RJV �BQEV�CaZ�V�9^=�9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9<NPR2=@NJ9xU&\PHEVVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV~XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCER�Ñ"äE9xN�XYCERJ\TADCEZ�VxKE\JHaV~9xNJ`EV,N-9D=tVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV09<Ë"V�NTAD\J9xNJR-9^=\JHaV¯?<V�ÛCEV�\PXÎZ�ËENP9<?xN]ADU =@NJ9xU&[BV�Z�\PXY9<C$�xÑ ��XYR

Ó�0 ,�� ,�� , 0 , � *�� , ( , ( , 0 , 0 ,� ÔÌ-HEV�C°RJ\]A^NJ\PXÎCa?:Ì-XÎ\PH5\PHEV�;cADRP\�XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCtÑ�Þ-HEVW`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V)9^=~VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxVM9<Ë"V�NTAD\J9xNRJÖBU.Ý"9<;YR�H�A^RSÝ"V�V�C)=n9<QECE`WRJQBà�Z,XÎV,Cz\P;YÖ.ËENJV�Z,XÎRPV0\J9.`aXjÙ V�NPV�CB\JXcAD\PV~Ý"V�\vÌ2V�V�CMËaNJ9<?xN]A^URJ\PNJQEZ�\PQENJV,R�K ËENP9DÍBXÎ`aV�`)\JH�A^\¯\JHaV0QERJV,`M9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xN¯RJV,\~XYR-CE9x\-\J9B9.RJU)AD;Y;vÑ<Þ-HaXÎR6XYR-`EQEV\J9¶\JHEV¼= ADZ�\.\PH�AD\.XYC¬U�9xRJ\�Z�ADRPV�R�\PHEVMUW9z`aXjÊ"Z�AD\PXÎ9xC¸9^=�ADC¬VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVMXYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CZTH�ADCE?xV�R2\JHEV6VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍBXY\vÖ�RJ\TAD\PQERS9^=SÓ@A^\S;YV�A^RJ\]Ôg9<CaV¯XYCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<C¶ÓcRJV,Vµ[³V�Z�\JXY9xC:�<Ñ��aÑ �xÔ�Ñ�¯9x\JV-\JH"AD\�XYC�Z�9<CB\JNTADRP\S\P9~\PHEV¯V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V6`EXYRJ\]A^CEZ�V6\JHEV¯A^ÝERJ9x;ÎQa\JV-9<Ë"V�NTAD\J9xN�RJV9�zQaV�CEZ�VÌS9xQE;Y`�CE9x\SÝ"V�A^;Î\PV�NJV,`+ÝBÖW\JHEV0V,ØzZTH�A^CE?<V�9^=RJXYCE?x;YV~NPV�?<XYRP\JV�NPR�Ñ

Ú´Ù²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V U.QE\]A^\JXY9<CER�ÌS9xNJO:Z�;Y9<RPV�;YÖ5Ì-XY\JH°\JHEV VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V `EXYRJ\]A^CEZ�V)U�V,\JNJXYZ<Ñ$æ6R`EVTÊ�CaV�`±XYC [BV�Z�\PXY9<C��<Ñ �aKSU)ADZ�NP9DÛvU.QE\]A^\JX>9<CER.9xË�V�NTAD\PV:9<C =@QE;Y;�XÎCaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xC ;YV�ÍxV�;vKÌ-HEXY;YVSUWXÎZ,NJ9DÛvU.QE\TAD\JXY9DCER´Í<ADNPÖ0RJU)AD;Y;YV�N$Z�9<UWË�9xCEV�CB\JR$Ì-XY\JHEXYC�XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CER�ÑBÉvC.9<NJ`aV�N\J9¶?<Q�A^N]A^Cz\PV�V+A RJQ³à�Z�XYV�CB\.?<NJ9DÌ-\PH59^=~ËENP9<?<NTADUWR�K´HE9DÌSV,Í<V�N�K$\JHEV)HEXY?<HaV�N�CBQEU.Ý"V�N9D=-Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<CaR~XYR0Ë"V�N�=@9<NPU�V�`:9xC:U+ADZ,NJ9);YV�Í<V�;vK XvÑ V<ÑYK Z�9xU�ËENPXYRJV�R0U)ADZ�NP9DÛvU.QE\]A^\JXY9DCER�Ñ[BXYCEZ�V<KÕXÎC \JHEXYR�Ì�A�ÖBK"\JHEV�A�ÍxV�N]A^?<V�RJ\PV�Ë:RJXYG�V.XYR�CE9<\6=@QaNJ\JHaV�N0NJV,`EQEZ�XYÝE;YV�=@NP9<UÜ9<Ë"V�N�ÛAD\P9<N0RPXÎ`aV<K$U�V�A^RJQENPXYCE?)\JHEVW`EXYRJ\]A^CEZ�V)Ý"V�\vÌSV,V�C°=@QE;Y;�VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxVMËENP9<?<NTADUWR~`a9zV,R�CE9x\CEV�Z�V,RJR]A^NJXY;YÖMËENP9<U�XYRPVµA�HEXY?<HEV,N~ËaNJV�Z�XYRPXÎ9xCtÑ"Þ-HEXYR¯XYR~A^CE9<\PHEV�N�NJV�ADRJ9xC¸Ì-HBÖ)9<Ë"V�NTAD\J9xNRJV �BQEV,CEZ�V�R0NPV�ËENPV�RJV�CB\�A�RPQBà�Z�XYV�CB\¯Ý"ADRJXYR�=@9<N-`EXYRP\]ADCaZ�V0Z�A^;ÎZ,QE;cAD\JXY9xC+Ý"V�\vÌ2V�V�C¶;YXÎCaV�ADN

Page 17: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �

?<V�CaV�\JXYZ.ËENP9<?<NTADUWR�Ñ"FSV,RJXY`EV�R�KA)NPV�?<XYRP\JN]A^\JXY9<C¶9D=¯ADÝaRJ9<;YQE\PV�;YÖMV�ÍxV�NJÖ:RP\JNJQaZ�\JQENTAD;2`EX>=cÛ=@V�NPV�CEZ�V�RJHE9xQE;Y`MCE9x\¯Ý"V�CEV,Z�V�RJRTADNPÖ¸X>=�ÌSV�\]A^O<V0XYCB\J9�A^Z�Z�9xQECB\~\PH�AD\6\JHEV�Z�9<NPNJV�;cAD\PXY9<CÝ�V,\vÌSV�V,C+RPV�U+A^CB\JXYZ~A^CE`�RP\JNJQaZ�\JQENTAD;´`EXYRJ\]A^CEZ�V�XYRSËaNJ9<Ý"ADÝEXY;YXYRJ\JXYZ0ÓßRJV�V�[³V�Z�\JXY9xC:�<Ñ��aÑ �xÔ�Ñ;=<��?<�> W W(D�O H EGFIHKQ=N W D W��]QYW3� L�N,E(D

æ¯R0A�Ê�NJRP\�Ý"V�CEZTHEU)ADNPOMËENJ9xÝE;YV�U�Ì2V�\JV�RP\�\PHEV�ADÝ"9DÍ<V�CE9<\PXY9<CER�Ì-XY\JH¶\JHEV.XYNPXÎR�`�A^\]ARJV�\�\JH"AD\0Z�9xCB\]ADXYCER�Ë"9<ËEQE;cA^N0NJV�A^;>Û Ì29<NP;Î`:`"AD\]A+=@NJ9xU�\JHaV�å �2É�LMADZTHEXYCEV)Ò V�A^NJCEXYCE?�-V�Ë"9<RPXY\J9<NPÖ � ���JÑzä´XY\JCaV�RJR6XÎR2\JHaV~Z,;�A^RJRPXjÊ"Z�AD\PXÎ9xC)V�NJNP9<N�KaXvÑ VxÑÎKx\JHaV~CBQEU.Ý"V�N29D=$Ì-NJ9<Ca?<;YÖZ�;cADRPRJX>Ê�V�`MXYCEËaQE\JR�Ñ Þ-HEV�RJV�Z�9xCE`¶\JV�RP\0ËENJ9xÝE;YV�UÜXYR~A�Ë�ADNPXÎ\vÖW=@QaCEZ�\JXY9xCM9D=S`aXÎUWV�CERPXÎ9xCV�XY?<HB\¯ÓßV�Í<V�C³Û7��Û Ë�A^NJXY\vÖEÔ�ÑBÞ-HEXYR$=nQECEZ�\PXÎ9xC�9xQE\JËEQa\JR1�-X>=t\JHaV~CBQEU.Ý"V�N�9^=RPV�\-XYCEËEQE\�ÝaXÎ\PRXYRSV�ÍxV�CtKa9<\JHaV�NJÌ-XYRJV�\JHEV09xQE\JËaQE\-XYR��aÑ-´§/.1032 �xª��Eª � kTmvonlvhj�Tonhjq�f�q,r�kP¹Ek]�Tonhji�k-u-wBov}�onhjq,f�y^hjmvov}�fB�Tk � �2i�kPlJ}�¡�k2kPlvlJq�l�q�i�kPl � � �-lvw<fBm ��Dov}�onhjmvonhj�T}��Bmvov}�fBy<},lJy~kPlvlJq,l h�f¯|B}�lJkPf<on�zkTmnhjm � ­ kPlJ�TkJf<ov}�¡�ky^h�¹EkJlJkPfB�]kgrYlJq�u � }�mvkP��h�fzk$lJkTmnw<�jovm �6 },lvhj}�onhjq,f �.}*��hju-wzu h�lvhjm k]i�kPf<� � �c|B}�lvhjonp

sghjmvov}�fB�Tk ��������«�����® â«���® �������0«������® â«���®ACBD=?> @ � � � � ��« � � � � ® � ��� « ��� � ® �

� � � � � � « � � � � ® � � � ��« ��� � ® � �� � � � � « � � � � ® � � ��� « ��� � ® � �� � � � � « � � � ��® ��� ��� « ���j� ® � �� � � � � « � � � ��® � � ��« � � �D® ���

-´§/.1032 �xª �"ª �2i�kPlJ}�¡�k�fDwzu � kPl�q,r2hjovkJlJ}�ovkTy¸u�wzov}�onhjq�fBm�w<f<onh��-}�u�}*��hju-wBuÜyDhjmvov},fz�Tk.hjmu�k]o �6 },lvhj}�onhjq,f �.}*��hju-wzu �ßovkPlJ}�onhjq,fzm

sghjmvov}�fB�Tk h�lvhjm k]i�kPf<� � �c|B}�lvhjonpACBD=?> @ � ��� � � ��� � �� � ��� � � ��� � �� ��� � � ��� � �� ���j��� ���j���� ���j��� ��� � �

Þ�A^ÝE;YV��<Ñ �2Z�9<UWË�ADNPV�RA�ÍxV�N]A^?<V$ËENPV�`EXYZ�\JXY9xC�V�NPNJ9xNJR´=@9<N `aXjÙ V�NPV�CB\U)ADØBXYU.QEU5U.Qa\]A�Û\JXY9<C�`EXYRP\]ADCaZ�V�R�Ñ^Þ-HEVSU)ADØBXYU�QaUãË"9<RPRJXYÝE;YV�`EXYRP\]ADCaZ�VSV9�zQ"AD;YRt\PHEVSU)ADØBXYU�QaUãËaNJ9<?xN]A^U;YV�CE?<\PH+ÓK� � �¯XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCER]Ô2ADCE`.XYUWË�9xRJV�R$CE9�NJV,RJ\JNPXYZ�\JXY9<CaR�ÑEäa9<N$Ý�9x\JH.ËENP9<ÝE;YV�UWR�KD\PHEVÝ�V,RJ\�NPV�RJQE;Y\PR�A^NJV-9<Ýa\]ADXYCEV,`.Ì-XÎ\PH�\PHEV-RJU)AD;Y;YV�RJ\´VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV¯`EXYRJ\TADCEZ,V�Óc9xCEV�Ô,Ñ<Þ-HEXYR$XYRSAD;Y;

Page 18: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

\JHEV6U�9xNJV-XYCB\JV�NPV�RJ\PXÎCa?�X>=Ì2V¯Z,9<CERPXÎ`aV�N-\JH�A^\�AµNJV�RP\JNJXYZ�\PXY9<C)9D=tÍ<A^NJXcAD\PXÎ9xC.`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V�AD;>ÛÌ�A�ÖBR�XYUWËE;YXÎV,R�A�NJV,RJ\JNPXYZ�\JXY9<C)XYC�Í<A^NJXcAD\PXY9<C�=@NJV�V,`E9<U·\P9B9�ÑEL)9xNJV¯RPË�V,Z�X>Ê�Z�AD;Y;YÖBKBZ�V�NJ\TADXYCU�9B`EX>Ê�Z�A^\JXY9<CaR~UWXY?<HB\¯CE9x\�Ý"V)V�ØBV�Z�QE\PV�` A^\0Z�V�NP\]ADXYC¬ËENP9<?<NTADU Ë"9<RJXY\PXÎ9xCER�Ý�V�Z�ADQERPV\J9B9�U+ADCBÖ�9<\PHEV�N¯XYCERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCER-ÌS9xQE;Y`�Ý"V�A�Ù V�Z�\PV�`tÑ

æ¯R0Ì2V�Z�A^C:;YV�ADNPC¶=@NJ9xU�Þ�ADÝE;YV �xÑ '"K"\JHEV)A�Í<V�NTAD?<V.CBQEU.Ý"V�N09^=�XY\PV�N]A^\JXY9<CER�QECB\JXY;A�U+A^ØzXYU�QEUçV�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V�`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V�XÎR6U�V�\-XYCEZ,NJV�A^RJV�R�9<Ca;ÎÖ.RP;YXÎ?xHB\J;YÖ�X>=\PHEV�U+ADØBXYU�QEU\JHENPV�RJHa9<;Y`5XYR�;Î9DÌ2V�NPV�`tÑ ! C¬A�Í<V�NTAD?xV<K$9<CE;YÖ�� �����)XY\JV,N]AD\PXY9<CER.ADNPV�CEV�Z,V�RJRTADNJÖ¬Ì-XY\JH\JHEV6RJU)AD;Y;YV�RJ\�\PHENJV,RJHE9x;Î`´KEADCE`W\JHEV6U+ADØBXYU�QEU±CBQEU.Ý�V,N�9D=$XÎ\PV�N]A^\JXY9<CaR¯Ó]���0HEV,NJV�Ô2H�A^RH�ADNP`E;YÖ0V�ÍxV�N�Ý"V�V�C�V,ØzZ,V�V�`EV�`´ÑEF29<\JH�A^RJË"V�Z�\PRSV�UWËEH�A^RJXYG�V2\JH�A^\$=@NJV,V�`E9<U 9^=²Í<A^NJXcAD\PXÎ9xCXYRSNPV�RJ\PNJXYZ�\JV,`¸9xCE;YÖ.RJ;YXY?<HB\J;YÖ.HEV�NPV<Ñ

;=<��?< � �RH V9FIL N EGD �RH�V F�W(H���X�F H@QYN L�N,O � QYW(W(D'��L FIHKQ=NÞ-HEV�NJV�RPQE;Y\JR6XÎC)Þ�ADÝa;ÎV �<Ñ '.Z�9xNJNJV,RJË"9<CE`M\P9.\JHEV�`EXYRJ\JNPXYÝEQE\JXY9xC�9D=�VTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V�U.QE\]A^\JXY9<C`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V,R.XÎC5ä´XY?<QaNJV:�xÑ �EK´Ì-HEV�NJV)9xCE;YÖ A^Ý�9xQE\�� �)Ë"V�NJZ�V,Cz\W9D=0AD;Y;�U�V�ADRJQaNJV�`°RJ\JV,ËRJXYG�V�R�ADNJV.;cA^NJ?<V,N~\PH�ADC¶9<CaV<Ñ ! ÝBÍBXY9<QERP;ÎÖBKE;cA^NJ?<V,N0`EXYRJNPQEËE\JXY9xCER�9D=-VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<VWZ�9B`EV<KtA^R`EV�UW9<CERP\JN]A^\JV�` Ì-XÎ\PH¬\JHEV¶V�ØEADUWËE;YV+ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U XYC [BV,Z�\JXY9<C �<Ñ��EKg9zZ,Z�QEN);YV�RJR);YXYO<V�;YÖBÑÚ´Ù V�Z�\JXYÍxV�ËENP9<?xN]ADUWR¯V�UWV�NJ?xV0\J9WÝ�V"�BQEXY\PV0NJ9xÝEQERJ\0A^?zADXYCERP\¯;cADNP?<V�N�U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9xC�RP\JV�ËERÝ�V,Z�ADQERPVM\JHaV�XYN�RPQENJÍBXYÍ<AD;-ËENP9<Ý�A^ÝEXY;YXÎ\vÖ XÎR.HaXÎ?xHEV�N�XYC5\JHaXÎR.Ì-A�ÖBÑ ÉvC¬Ë�ADNP\JXYZ�QE;cADN�Kt\PHEXYRXYR�ADZTHEXYV�Í<V,`ãÝBÖ°\JHEVMV�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍBXÎ\vÖ¬9^=�A^C¬XÎCaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xC \JH"AD\.U+A�Ö:`aV�Ë�V,CE` 9<C¬UW9<NJV\JH�A^C.9<CEV�RPQEZ�Z�V�V,`EXYCE?.XYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<C�XYCWËENJ9x?<N]A^U¸ÑDF2V�Z�A^QERJV�\JHEV6N]AD\PV�9D=tCE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVXYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CER2\JH�A^\SV,U�V�NP?<V-Ì-XY\JHWVTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V�U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9xCER$XYRSZ�9xU�Ë�A^N]A^\JXYÍ<V�;YÖ�;Y9DÌ0K<UW9<RP\VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV¯U.QE\TAD\JXY9xC0`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V,RSNPV�RJQE;Y\g=@NJ9xUç`EV�ADZ�\PXÎÍ<A^\JXY9<C�9D=tV�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V6XÎCaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xCER�Ñ

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

0 5 10 15 20 25

Fre

quen

cy (

x 10

0000

)

Variation Distance

Effective Mutations

�� ��"ª��xª��aª sghjmvonlvh � wzonhjq,f5q,rSkP¹³kT�Tonhji�k�u�wzov}�onhjq�f:yDhjmvov},fz�TkTm6r�q,l¯h�lvhjm6|xlJq � �jk]u(«cmnhju6h��j}�l�ovqkTi�kPf<� � �c|B}�lvhjonp<® � �2i�kPlJ}�¡�k2½B¡�wxlJk¯q�i�kPl � � ��lvwxfzm �

�29<CB\JNP9<;Y;YXÎCa?0Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<CWRJ\PV�ËMRJXYG�V�9<C)VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV�Z�9B`EV�;ÎV,Í<V�;´CEV�Z�V�RPR]A^NJXY;YÖ+NPV �BQEXYNJV�RA-`EXYRP\]ADCaZ�V-U�V�\PNJXYZ�\PH�AD\$U�V�ADRJQaNJV�R$Z�A^QER]A^;EZ�9<CaCEV�Z�\PXÎ9xCER�Ý"V�\vÌ2V�V�C.ËENP9<?<NTADUâZ]H"ADCE?xV�R

Page 19: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �

ADCE`�Ê�\JCaV�RJR6Z]H"ADCE?xV�R-RJQBà�Z,XÎV,Cz\P;YÖ.ËENJV�Z,XÎRPV�;YÖzÑEÚ�Í<V�C)X>=�A^;ÎNPV�AD`aÖ.RJU+A^;Y;EU�9B`EX>Ê�Z�A^\JXY9<CaR9D=$\JHEV�ËENP9<?<NTADU·RP\JNPQEZ�\JQaNJV�U+A�Ö�NJV�RPQE;Y\¯XYC+A^;ÎUW9<RP\SADNPÝEXY\JN]A^NJÖWZ]H"ADCE?xV�R¯XYC�ËaNJ9<?xN]A^UÝ�V,H�A�ÍBXÎ9xN�KDRPU+A^;Î;YV�N´Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<CaR9^=²\PHEV¯?xV�CE9x\vÖzË"V¯RPHE9<Qa;Î`.;YV�A^`�\P90RJU)AD;Y;YV�N$Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<CaR9D=t\PHEV¯ËEHaV�CE9<\vÖBË"V-=@9xN�AµHEXY?<HEV�N2ËENP9<Ý�A^ÝEXY;ÎXY\vÖBÑ�ÉvC:�%�!� ��\JHEXYR2H�ADRgÝ�V�V,C+`aV�U�9xCERJ\PN]AD\PV�`ÝBÖãADËaËE;YÖzXYCE?¶\JHaV¸V�`aXÎ\W`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V U�V�\PNJXYZ)\J95ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U \PNJV�V�R�ѯä´XY?<QENPV$�<Ñ �¶Z�;YV�A^NJ;YÖRJHE9DÌ-R2A�Ë�9xRJXY\JXYÍxVSZ�9xNJNPV�;cAD\JXY9xC.Ý�V�\vÌ2V�V�C)\PHEV-U.QE\]A^\JXY9<C�`EXYRJ\]A^CEZ�V69<C.Z�9B`EV6;ÎV,Í<V�; ADCE`\JHEV6U.QE\]A^\JXY9<C�`EXYRJ\TADCEZ,V�R-9<C�Ê�\PCEV�RPR¯;YV�Í<V,;E=@9xNS9xQEN�Z�9B`EV�Û RPV�;YV�Z�\JXYÍxV0U�V�\PNJXYZ-9<CW;YXÎCaV�ADN?<V�Ca9<U�V,R�ÑDÞ-HEV6Z�9<NPNJV�RPË�9xCE`EXYCE?.`EXYRP\JNJXYÝEQa\JXY9<C.9^=tU.QE\]A^\JXY9<C�`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V,RSXYC+ä´XY?<QaNJV1�<Ñ �Z�9<C³Ê�NJUWRS\PHEXYR-\J9.Ý"V~\PNJQEVµ=@9<N2\JHEV�Í<ADRJ\-U)A �T9xNJXY\vÖ09D=$9BZ�Z�QENPNJXYCE?�`aXÎRP\]A^CEZ�V�R�Ñ

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0 5 10 15 20 25

Fitn

ess

Dis

tanc

e

Program Distance

Effective Mutations

�� ��"ª��xª��aª �$q,lvlJkJ�j}�onhjq,f � kTon£kTkPf¯|xlJq�¡,lJ}�uãy^hjmvov}�fB�Tk},fzy�½zonfBk]mvm y^hjmvov}�fB�Tk$rcq�lEh�lvhjmÕ|<lJq � �jkTu«cmnhju6h��j}�l¯ovq�kTi�kPfx� � �ß|z},lvhjo@p<® � �2i�kPlJ}�¡�k2½B¡�wxlJk¯q�i�kPl � � ��lvwxfzm �

Þ-HEV.Ê�NPRJ\.9xÝERJV�NPÍ<AD\PXÎ9xCtK´\JH�A^\�RPU+AD;Y;�U.Qa\]AD\PXY9<C¶RJ\JV,ËER.9BZ�Z�QEN.UW9<NJV�=nNJV �BQEV�CB\P;ÎÖ\JH�A^C�;�A^NJ?xVU.Qa\]AD\PXY9<C¯RP\JV�ËaR�K,=@QE;>Ê�;Y;YR�?xQEXY`EV�;YXYCEV�L��29D=�A2UWV�\JNPXÎZ�Û Ý�A^RJV�`�V�Íx9<;YQE\PXÎ9xC�ADNPÖAD;Y?<9xNJXY\JHaU ÓnL)F�Ú�æ�KxRJV�V�[BV�Z�\PXÎ9xC����<Ô�ÑxÞ-HEV-RJV,Z�9<CE`.9xÝERJV,NJÍ<AD\PXY9<CMÓcZ�ADQERTAD;YXY\vÖ³ÔÕ=@9xNJUWRA-CEV,Z�V�RJRTADNPÖ�ËENPV�Z�9xCE`EXY\JXY9<C�=@9xNt\JHaVSRPQEZ�Z�V�RPRS9^=�V�Íx9<;YQE\JXY9xC�ADNPÖ~AD;Y?x9<NJXY\PHEU�R XYC0?xV�CEV�NTAD;vÑ

¾�¿�� 8¸Ä�Á�ÂEÃEÄ 2.Ä)4 �2³ÃaƯÇ"ÂEƯÃ��32�� È 1C�tÃ��BÈvÂ

Þ-HEVMVTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V¶`EXYRJ\]A^CEZ�V¶U�V�\PNJXYZ)Ý�V,\vÌSV�V,C±ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�R�=@NJ9xU [³V�Z�\JXY9xC �xÑ �aÑ%��XYR+A^ËBÛËE;YXYV�`)HEV�NJV�=n9<N¯ADC V�ØBËE;YXÎZ,XÎ\6Z�9<CB\PNJ9<;$9^=S?<V�Ca9<\vÖBË�V�`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖzKaÌ-HEXYZTH¸XYR¯\PHEV�A�ÍxV�N]A^?<VRJ\PNJQEZ�\PQEN]A^;�`EXYRJ\TADCEZ,V�Ý"V�\vÌ2V�V�C¶XÎCa`EXYÍzXY`EQ"AD;YR-XYCM\JHEV�Ë"9<ËEQE;cA^\JXY9<C � ���JÑBÞ-HEV�NPVT=@9xNJV<K Ì2VXYCz\PNJ9B`EQEZ,V+\PHEV)\vÌS9^Û ;YV�ÍxV�;-\J9xQENJC"ADU�V,Cz\�RJV,;ÎV,Z�\JXY9<C¬RPHE9DÌ-C¬XÎC ä´XY?<QENPV:�xÑ �aÑ ! Cã\PHEVÊ�NJRP\�;ÎV,Í<V�;vK"XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;YR~A^NJV�RJV�;YV�Z,\JV�`°ÝzÖWÊ�\PCEV�RPR+Ó�Ê�\JCEV,RJR0RPV�;YV�Z�\JXY9xC�Ô�Ñ ! C¸\PHEV�RPV�ZTÛ9<CE`¬;YV�ÍxV�;vKS\PHEVM\vÌ295XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�A^;ÎR�Ì-XY\JH U)ADØBXYU�QaU `aXÎRP\]A^CEZ�V:ADNJV Z]Ha9<RJV,C A^U�9<Ca?\JHENPV�V�Ê�\P\JV�N-XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;YR¯Óc`EXYÍxV�NJRPXÎ\vÖWRJV�;YV�Z,\JXY9<C�Ô,Ñ�L)9xNJV�ËENPV�Z�XYRJV�;YÖBKEÌ2V�RJV�;YV�Z�\�=@9<N-\PHEV

Page 20: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV�V�`aXÎ\6`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V.UWXYCzQaRS\PHEV�`aXÎRP\]A^CEZ�V�9D=SVTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V�;ÎV,CE?<\PHER�Ñ ��FSÖ)`E9xXÎCa?�RJ9"K\JHEV�?xNJ9DÌ-\JH)9^=VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV0;YV�CE?x\JH)XYR-CE9<\-NPV�Ì�A^NJ`EV,`M`EXYNJV�Z,\J;YÖ�`EQaNJXYCE?�RJV�;YV�Z�\PXY9<CtÑ

8 HEXY;YV+ADC¬ADÝERP9<;YQE\PV+UWV�ADRPQENJVxK�RJQaZ]H A^R�Ê�\JCEV,RJR�U)A�Ö¸Ý"VMZ�9xU�Ë�A^NJV�`°Ý�V,\vÌSV�V,C\vÌS9�XÎCa`EXYÍzXY`EQ"AD;YR�K�RJV,;ÎV,Z�\JXY9<C)ÝBÖ.A0NPV�;cAD\JXYÍxV-U�V�A^RJQENPV<K<RPQEZTHMADR�`EXYRP\]ADCaZ�V�9<N2`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖCEV�Z�V,RJR]A^NJXY;YÖMNJV9�zQaXÎNPV�R0A.UWXÎCaXÎU�QEU 9D=2\JHENPV�V�XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;YR�ÑBÉvCM?xV�CEV�NTAD;vK"\vÌS9�=@NJ9xU XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;YR�ADNPV¯RJV,;ÎV,Z�\JV�` Ì-XÎ\PH.\JHEV�?xNJV�A^\JV�RP\-RJQEU 9D=$`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V,R-\J90\PHEV ( �69<\JHaV�NXYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;YR�ÑD[BV,;ÎV,Z�\JXY9<CWËENJV,RJRJQaNJV09xC.\JHEV�Ê�NJRP\S;YV�ÍxV�;�`aV�Ë�V,CE`ER-9<CW\JHEV6RJXYG�V69D= Ê�\PCEV�RJR\J9xQENJC�A^U�V�CB\PR�ÑBÐ$NJV�RPRJQENPV�9^=�`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖ.RJV�;YV�Z,\JXY9<CM9xC�\PHEV0RJV,Z�9<CE`);YV�ÍxV�;tXYR-Z�9xCz\PNJ9x;Î;YV�`ÝBÖ¸\PHEV�CBQEU.Ý"V�N09^=¯\JHEV�RPV�\P9<QENPC�ADUWV�CB\JR�Ñ´æ¯`a`EXY\JXY9<C�A^;Y;ÎÖBKEÌ2V�QaRJV+A RJV,;ÎV,Z�\JXY9<C°N]A^\JVË�ADNTADUWV�\JV�N�XYC¶9<NJ`aV�N0\J9)\PQECEV.\JHaV.RJV�;YV�Z�\PXY9<C5ËaNJV�RPRJQENPV�9<C:\PHEV.RJV,Z�9<CE`:;YV�ÍxV�;�UW9<NJVËENJV,Z�XYRJV�;YÖBÑ

Fitness Selection

Diversity Selection

(1. Level)

(2. Level)

Winner

Tournament

Variation

�� ��"ª �<ª��aª ¢�£$q��ß�jk]i�kP�²ovq,w<lvfB}�u�kPf<o2mvkJ�jkT�Tonhjq,f �Þ-HEV�\vÌS9^Û ;YV�ÍxV�;�\P9<QENPC�ADUWV�CB\�RJV,;ÎV,Z�\JXY9<C)Z�9xCERJ\PXY\JQE\PV�R~A�U.QE;Y\JXY9<Ý���V�Z�\JXYÍxV-RJV�;YV�Z�\PXY9<C

U�V�\PHE9B`�\PH�AD\�Ê�CE`ER-XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�A^;ÎR2\JH"AD\~A^NJV6Ê�\P\JV�N0ADCa`+UW9<NPV~`aXÎÍxV�NJRPV0XYC)NJV�;cAD\PXY9<C)\J99<\PHEV�NJR6Ì-HEXY;YV~RPV�;YV�Z�\PXÎ9xC)=@9xN-Ê�\PCEV�RJR�OxV�V�ËER6\JHEV0HaXÎ?xHEV�N6ËENJXY9<NPXY\vÖzÑE[BV,;ÎV,Z�\JXYCE?WXÎCa`EXYÍzXY`BÛQ�AD;YR69<CE;YÖMÝBÖM`EXYÍxV�NJRPXÎ\vÖ¼=@9<N0AWZ�V�NP\]ADXYC:ËENP9<Ý�A^ÝEXY;YXÎ\vÖWXYCERJ\PV�AD`:`E9BV�R�CE9<\�CEV�Z,V�RJRTADNJXY;YÖNJV�RPQE;Y\�XYC.U�9xNJV2`EX>Ù²V�NPV�CB\SRPV�ADNPZTH�`EXYNJV,Z�\JXY9<CaRSADUW9<CE?6Ý�V�\P\JV�N-RP9<;YQE\PXÎ9xCER$XYC.\JHEV-Ë"9<ËEQ³Û;cAD\JXY9xCtÑ �6XY\J\JNPXYZ]HWV�\-AD;vÑ=�%�S�U� NJV�Ë"9<NP\-9<C+A�RJË"9<CB\TADCEV�9xQERg=@9<NPU+AD\PXY9<C�9D=?xNJ9xQEËER2Ì-HEV�CRJV�;YV�Z,\JXYCE?0\PHEV-U�9xRJ\t`aXÎRP\]A^Cz\g9D= \JHENPV�V¯XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�A^;ÎRÕ=@NJ9xU A6Ë"9<ËEQE;cA^\JXY9<C09^=²NPV�AD;"CBQEU.ÛÝ�V,NJR�Ñ

Þ-HEV�CzQaU.Ý�V�N-9^=$Ê�\JCEV,RJR¯Z�AD;YZ�QE;cAD\PXY9<CER¯A^CE`)\JHEV0ËaNJ9BZ�V�RPRJXYCE?�\PXYU�V<KBNPV�RJË"V�Z�\PXÎÍxV�;YÖzK`E9.CE9x\-XÎCaZ�NJV�A^RJV�Ì-XY\JH)\JHEV�CzQaU.Ý�V�N29D=�\P9<QENPC�ADUWV�CB\JR-X>=\PHEV�Ê�\PCEV�RJR�9^=�XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;YRXYR0R]A�ÍxV�`ãA^CE`:XYR�QEË"`�A^\JV�`°9<CE;YÖ:A�=@\PV�N�Í<A^NJXcAD\PXY9<CtÑ ! CE;YÖ:`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖ¶RJV�;YV�Z�\PXY9<C¬XY\JRJV,;j=Ý�V,Z�9<UWV�R�U�9xNJV2Z�9<UWËEQE\TAD\JXY9xC�AD;Y;YÖ¯V�ØBË"V�CERPXÎÍxV�\JHEV6U�9<NPVSXYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;YRtË�A^NJ\JXYZ�XYË�A^\JV6XÎC�-¢$�xhjm"hjm"|³q�mvmnh � �jk � kT�]},wzmvk � q�on�~u�kT}�mnw<lJkTmT{�kTyDhjo y^hjmvov}�fB�Tk�}�fBy-�jkPfz¡�on�0yDhjmvov},fz�Tk�{Dq�|EkPlJ}�ovkq,f�h�fBmvonlvwz�Tonhjq�f)�jkTi�kJ�"�zkPlJk �

Page 21: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ �^�

XY\�Ñ�¶XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;YR¯NPV �BQEXYNJV�� # _�� `EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V.Z�AD;YZ�QE;cAD\PXY9<CER�ÑEá¯V,CEZ�V<K´ËENJ9x?<NTADU�`aXÎRP\]A^CEZ�VRJHE9xQE;Y`�Ý"V0VTà�Z�XYV�CB\P;ÎÖWZ�9<UWËEQE\TADÝE;YV<Ñ

æ¬Ê�\JCaV�RJR-;cADCa`ERJZ�A^Ë�V69<C.\PHEV¯RPV�ADNPZ]HWRJË�A^Z�V�9D= ËENJ9x?<NTADU�RgXÎRg`EVTÊ�CEV,`�ÝBÖ�AµRJ\JNPQEZTÛ\JQENTAD;�`aXÎRP\]A^CEZ�V.U�V,\JNJXYZ0Ý"V�\vÌ2V�V�C°ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�R�ADCE`:A�Ê�\JCEV,RJR�=@QECEZ�\PXY9<C¶\JH�A^\~NPVT×�V�Z,\JR\JHEVC�BQ�AD;YXY\vÖ¯9^=�ËENP9<?<NTADU±RPV�U+A^Cz\PXYZ�R�Ñ,Þ-HEV¯ADËEËa;ÎXYZ�A^\JXY9<C�9^=²A-?xV�CEV�\PXÎZ29<Ë"V�NTAD\J9xN$Z�9<NPNJVTÛRJË"9<CE`aRS\P90Ë�V,Nv=@9xNJU�XYCE?69<CEV6RJ\PV�Ë�9xC.\JHEXYR�;cADCa`ERJZ�A^Ë�VxÑBÞ-HEV¯ADZ�\PXYÍ<V¯Z,9<CB\JNP9<;"9D= RJ\JNPQEZTÛ\JQENTAD; `EXYÍxV�NJRPXÎ\vÖ.XYCEZ,NJV�A^RJV�R6\JHEV0A�Í<V,N]AD?xV¯`EXYRP\]ADCaZ�V�9D=XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;YR�Ñ<Ï�NTADËEHaXÎZ�AD;Y;YÖzKD\PHEVXYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;YR-RJËaNJV�A^`5U�9xNJV�Ì-XY`EV�;YÖ)9DÍ<V�N0\PHEV�Ê�\PCEV�RJR�;cADCE`aRJZ�A^Ë�V<Ñ´Þ-HBQER�KÕ\JHEV�NPV�XYR�A;Y9DÌSV�N´ËENJ9xÝ�ADÝaXÎ;YXY\vÖ�\JH�A^\$\JHEV-V�Íx9<;YQE\PXÎ9xC�ADNPÖ�ËENJ9BZ�V�RPR�?<V,\JR�RP\JQEZTO�XÎC.A-;Y9BZ�A^;EU�XYCEXYU�QEUADCE`WU�9xNJV¯`aXjÙ V�NPV�CB\¯RJV�ADNJZTHM`aXÎNPV�Z�\PXÎ9xCER-U+A�Ö�Ý"V0V�ØBËE;Y9<NPV�`)XÎC)Ë�A^N]A^;Î;YV�;vÑ�¯9<\PV0\JH"AD\-\JHaV0\vÌS9^Û ;YV�ÍxV�;tRPV�;YV�Z�\PXÎ9xCMËENP9zZ,V�RJR�Z�A^C¸AD;YRJ9.Ý"V0QERPV�`)=@9xN~A^C+V,ØzËa;ÎXYZ�XY\Z�9<CB\PNJ9<;´9D=SZ,9z`aV�?xNJ9DÌ-\JH°ÓcZ�9xU�ËE;YV�ØBXY\vÖ�RPV�;YV�Z�\JXY9xC�Ô�Ñ"Þ-HEV�NPVT=@9xNJV<K XYCM;YXYCEV�A^N~Ï0Ð A.RJV�Û;YV�Z�\JXY9xC.ËENJV�RPRJQENPV0U+A�Ö�Ý�V6XÎUWË�9xRJV�`�RJË"V�Z�X>Ê�Z�AD;Y;YÖ.9<C�\PHEV¯RPU+A^;Î;YV�RP\$VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V�9xNSCE9xCBÛVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV0ËENJ9x?<NTADU·;YV�CE?x\JHtÑ

;=<��=<@; W W(D�O H EGFIHKQ=N W D W��]QYW3� L�N,E(DäE9xNt\PHEVS\vÌ29-\JV,RJ\�ËENP9<ÝE;YV�UWR XYCz\PNJ9B`EQEZ,V�`.XYCµ[³V�Z�\JXY9xC �xÑ �aK�Þ�ADÝa;ÎV �<Ñ �2RJQEUWU+A^NJXYG�V�RtA�ÍxÛV�N]A^?<V-V�NPNJ9xNSNTAD\JV,RS9xÝE\]A^XÎCaV�`.Ì-XY\JH�ADCa`.Ì-XÎ\PHE9<Qa\�RJV�;YV�Z,\JXYCE?�=@9<N$RJ\PNJQEZ,\JQENTAD; `EXYÍ<V,NJRJXY\vÖBÑ�6XjÙ V�NPV�CB\~RPV�;YV�Z�\PXÎ9xC¸ËaNJV�RPRJQENPV�R.H�A�Í<V�Ý�V�V,C:\JV�RP\JV�`tÑ$äa9<N¯\PHEV�U�XYCEXYU.QEU CBQEU.Ý�V,N¯9D=Ê�\JCaV�RJR$\J9xQENJC"ADU�V,Cz\PRSÓß\JHENPV�V�ÔgÌSV�QaRJV�`.RPV�;YV�Z�\JXY9xC�ËENP9<Ý�A^ÝEXY;YXÎ\PXYV�R � ��Ë�V�NPZ�V�CB\-ADCE` ��� �Ë�V,NJZ�V�CB\�Ñ á¯XY?<HaV�N¯RPV�;YV�Z�\JXY9xCMËENJV,RJRJQaNJV�R�A^NJV�XYCE`EQEZ�V,`MÝBÖ+XYCEZ,NJV�A^RJXYCE?�\PHEV0CBQEU.Ý"V�N-9D=\J9xQENJC�A^U�V�CB\PR¯ÓcQEËW\J9�=@9<QaN�HEV�NPV�Ô�Ñ"äE9xN�V�ADZTH)ËENP9<ÝE;YV�U·ADCa`�Í<ADNPXcAD\JXY9xC�9xË�V�NTAD\P9<N�KB\PHEVË�V,Nv=@9xNJU+A^CEZ�V�XYCEZ�NPV�ADRPV�R0Z�9xCz\PXYCzQa9<QERP;ÎÖWÌ-XY\JHM\PHEV0XYCB×�QEV,CEZ�V�9D=�`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖ)RJV�;YV�Z,\JXY9<CtÑÞ-HEV�HEXY?<HEV�RP\0RJV,;ÎV,Z�\JXY9<C:ËaNJV�RPRJQENPV+\PH�AD\�H�A^R0Ý"V�V�C:\JV,RJ\JV,`5NJV,RJQE;Y\JR�XYC A^Ý�9xQE\0AM�)\J9�0\PXYU�V�R�Ý"V�\P\JV�N�ËENPV�`EXYZ�\JXY9xC�V�NPNJ9<N69<C)A�Í<V�NTAD?<VxKB\JH�A^C+Ì-XY\PHE9<QE\2XYCEZ�NPV�ADRPXÎCa?.`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖADZ�\PXYÍ<V�;YÖBÑ

æ¯?zA^XYCtKzA^R�A^;YNJV�A^`EÖ.`EV�UW9<CERP\JN]A^\JV�`WXYC+[BV�Z,\JXY9<C �<Ñ �6=n9<N2NJV�?xNJV�RPRJXY9<CM\TADRPOzR�KB;YXÎCaV�ADNÏ0аË�V,Nv=@9xNJU�R-RPXY?<CEX>Ê�Z�A^CB\J;YÖ.Ý�V,\J\JV,N~ÝBÖWQERJXYCE?.VTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V�U+ADZ,NJ9DÛvU.QE\TAD\JXY9DCERgXÎCaRJ\JV�AD`9D=�Z,NJ9<RPRJ9DÍxV�N�Ñ ! ÝBÍBXY9<QERP;ÎÖBK�\PHEV2;ÎXYCEV�ADN$ËENJ9x?<NTADU±NJV,ËENJV�RPV�CB\]A^\JXY9<C.XYRtUW9<NPV�RJQEXY\TADÝE;YVg=@9<NÝ�V,XÎCa?¯`EV�ÍxV�;Y9<Ë"V�`�ÝzÖ�U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9xCER 9<Ca;ÎÖBKTV�RPË�V�Z,X�A^;Y;ÎÖ�Xj="\JHE9xRJV2Z�9<CEZ,V�CB\JN]A^\JV-9xC0VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVXYCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CER�Ñ �¯9xCEV�\JHaV�;YV�RJR�K<\PHEVSV,ØzË"V�NPXÎUWV�CB\JR$Ì-XY\JH�;YXÎCaV�ADN´Z�NJ9xRJRJ9DÍxV�N�RPHE9DÌ5\PH�AD\$`EX>ÛÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖ�RJV�;YV�Z,\JXY9<C.`E9BV�R$CE9x\$`EV�Ë"V�CE`.9<C.A-RPË�V,Z�XcAD;E\vÖBË"VS9^=�Í<ADNPX�A^\JXY9<C´Ñ�L)9xNJV�9DÍxV�N�KD\PHEVADËEËa;ÎXYZ�A^\JXY9<C 9D=¯\JHaXÎR�\JV�ZTHECEX%�BQEVWXÎR�`EV,U�9<CaRJ\JNTAD\PV�`:Ì-XY\JH5A)Ë"9<ËEQa;�A^\JXY9<C³Û `EV,Ë�V�Ca`EV�CB\9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xN�Ñ

;=<��=<�> �RD JYD'��Q ��� D NF Q � �RHKJ=D W�V9H�F��ä´XÎ?xQENJV,R �<Ñ%�!� � �<Ñ%����XY;Y;YQERJ\PN]A^\JV�\PHEVM`EV,Í<V�;Y9<ËaU�V�CB\09^=~RJ\PNJQEZ,\JQENTAD;�`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖ5`aQENJXYCE?NJQECaR2=@9<N2`EX>Ù²V,NJV�CB\¯RPV�;YV�Z�\PXÎ9xCMËENPV�RJRPQENJV�R0A^CE`)`EX>Ù²V�NPV�CB\¯Í<A^NJXcAD\PXÎ9xC.9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xNJR�Ñ ! ÝzÍBX>Û9<QERP;YÖzK�\JHaV-HEXY?<HEV�N$\PHEV-RJV�;YV�Z,\JXY9<C.ËENPV�RJRPQENJV�XYR�AD`I��QERJ\PV�`tKx\JHEV-HEXY?xHEV�N$XYR\PHEV-`EXYÍ<V,NJRJXY\vÖBÑÚ$Í<V,C�Ì-XY\JHE9xQE\-ADËEËE;YÖBXYCE?0`EXYÍxV�NJRPXÎ\vÖ�RJV,;ÎV,Z�\JXY9<C´KE\JHaVµA�ÍxV�N]A^?<V6VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V�ËENP9<?xN]ADU `EXYRvÛ\]A^CEZ�V�`E9BV�R-CE9x\-`ENJ9xË�\J9DÌ-ADNP`ER-\JHaV~V,CE`)9D=NPQECER�ÑE8 HEXY;YV¯\PHEV�`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖ.9D=$VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVZ�9B`EV0XYCEZ�NPV�ADRPV�R0Ì-XY\JH Z�NJ9xRJRJ9DÍxV�N�QECB\JXY;A�Z�V�NP\]ADXYCM;YV�ÍxV�;�ADCE` RJ\]A�ÖBR6N]AD\PHEV�N�Z�9xCERJ\TADCB\\JHEV,CtKE`EXYÍxV�NJRPXÎ\vÖ.Ì-XY\PH+V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V0U.Qa\]AD\PXY9<CER�XYCEZ,NJV�A^RJV�R�U�9xNJV6;ÎXYCEV�ADNJ;YÖBÑ

Page 22: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

��� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

-´§/.1032.�xª��aª �DkT�Tq�fByD�c�jkTi�kP�³mvkP�jkT�Tonhjq�f�rcq,l²mvonlvwB�]onwxlJ}��ByDhji�kPlJmnhjo@p6£$hjon�~y^h�¹³kPlJkPf<o |xlJq � } � h���hÎonhjkTm}�fBy�y^h�¹³kPlJkPf<o6fDwzu � kPlJm6q�r$½zonfBkTmvm¯ovq,w<lvfz}�u�kPf<ovm�«��6¢S® � �2i�kJlJ}�¡�k0kPlvlJq�l¯q�i�kPl � � ��lvw<fBm ��Dov}�onhjmvonhj�T}��Bmvov}�fBy<},lJy~kPlvlJq,l h�f¯|B}�lJkPf<on�zkTmnhjm � ­ kPlJ�TkJf<ov}�¡�ky^h�¹EkJlJkPfB�]kgrYlJq�u � }�mvkP��h�fzk$lJkTmnw<�jovm �6 },lvhj}�onhjq,f �^kJ�jkT�Tonhjq,f h�lvhjm k]i�kPf<� � �c|B}�lvhjonp

� �¯¢ ��������«�� ��® â«���® ��������«�� ��® â«���®8 93:<;�; � � �D�>��� « � �j� ��® � � � «�� � � ® �� � � ��� ��� « � � � � ® �]� � ��« �D� � ® � �� � � � ���>� ��« � � � ��® ��� � ��« �D��� ® � �� � � � ��� � ��« � � � ��® � � � ��« ��� � ® � �ACBD=?> @ � � � � ��� « � � � � ® � � ��« ����� ® �� � � � � � ��« � � � ��® � � ��� « ��� ��® � �� � � � � � � ��« � � � ��® � � � ��« ���>� ® �]�

� � � � � � �]��« � � � � ® �<� ��« � � � ® � �

Þ-ÌS9.U)A �T9<N-NPV�ADRP9<CER�Z�A^CMÝ"V0=@9xQECE`M\P9�V�ØBËE;cA^XÎC)\PHEXYR¯Ý"V�H�A�ÍBXY9<N ä´XYNJRP\�K"?<V�CaV�\JXYZËENJ9x?<NTADU�UWXjCE?)XYR�Ì29<NPOBXÎCa?¸Ì-XY\JH A¶Í<ADNJXcA^ÝE;YV�;YV�CE?x\JH NPV�ËENJV,RJV�CB\]A^\JXY9<C \JH"AD\.?<NP9DÌ-RZ�9<CB\PXÎCBQE9xQERJ;YÖ�`EQENPXYCE?0A¯NPQECtÑDÉvC�;YXYCEV�ADN�Ï0Ð \JHaXÎRgXÎR$V�RPË�V,Z�XcAD;Y;YÖ0\JNPQEV2=@9<N$\PHEV-VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxVËENJ9x?<NTADUç;YV�Ca?<\JH´K<Ì-HEXYZTH.U+A�Ö�RJ\JXY;Y;E?xNJ9D̬V�Í<V,C�X>=²\PHEV~A^ÝERJ9x;YQE\JV-;YV�CE?x\JHWH�ADR�NPV�ADZTHEV,`\JHEV¶U+A^ØBXÎU�QEUMÑ´Þ-HEV¶;Î9xCE?<V,N�VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV:ËENJ9x?<NTADU�RWÝ�V,Z�9<UWVM\JHEV:ÝaXÎ?x?<V�NWVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V,R¼A^NJV¶Ë�9xRJRPXÎÝa;ÎVxÑ�æ¯Z,\JQ�A^;Î;YÖBK�\PHEV¸?xNJ9DÌ-\PH 9D=�V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V¶Z�9B`EV¶XÎRWNJV�RP\JNPXÎZ,\JV�`V�ADNP;YXÎV,N�Ì-XY\JH°Z�NJ9xRJRP9DÍ<V�N.Ý"V�Z�A^QERJVM9^=µA)U.QaZ]H:HaXÎ?xHEV�N.ËENP9<Ë"9<NP\JXY9<C°9D=¯CE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500

Str

uctu

ral D

iver

sity

Generations

0% (2T)50% (3T)

100% (3T)100% (4T)

�� ��"ª��xª����Eª ��lvhjm�|xlJq � �jk]u54"s�hji�kPlJmnhjo@p.£$hjon�)�PlJq�mvmvq�i�kPl�},fzyWyDh�¹EkPlJkPf<o-mvkJ�jkT�Tonhjq,f�|<lJkTmvmnwxlJk]m ��DkP�jkT�Tonhjq�f�|<lJkTmvmnw<lJk-�Tq,f<onlJq����jkTy � p�mvkP�jkT�]onhjq,f�|<lJq � } � h���hÎonp�}�fBy�fDwzu � kPlSq,rE½BonfzkTmvm�ovq,w<lvfz},�u�kJf<ovm�«c¢S® � �2i�kPlJ}�¡�k2½B¡�wxlJk]m2q�i�kPl � � ��lvwxfzm �

Page 23: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500

Str

uctu

ral D

iver

sity

Generations

0% (2T)50% (3T)

100% (3T)100% (4T)

�� ��"ª��xª��!�<ª ��lvhjm2|<lJq � �jkTu54 s�hji�kPlJmnhjo@p)£$hjon�MkP¹EkT�]onhji�k0u�wzov}�onhjq�fBm¯},fzy)yDh�¹EkPlJkPf<o¯mvkP�jkT�]onhjq,f|<lJkTmvmnw<lJkTm � �^kJ�jkT�Tonhjq,f�|<lJkTmvmnwxlJk¯�Tq�f<onlJq,���jkTy � p0mvkP�jk]�Tonhjq,f)|<lJq � } � h���hjonp�},fzy�fDwzu � kJl-q,r ½zon�fzkTmvm�ovq,w<lvfB}�u�kPf<ovm¯«c¢2® � �Si�kPlJ}�¡�k-½B¡�wxlJkTmSq�i�kPl � � �6lvw<fBm �

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

0 50 100 150 200 250

Str

uctu

ral D

iver

sity

Generations

0% (2T)50% (3T)

100% (3T)100% (4T)

�� ��"ª��xª�� �Eª �ti�kPf<� � �c|B}�lvhjonp.|xlJq � �jk]u54"s�hji�kPlJmnhjo@pW£$hjon���PlJq�mvmvq�i�kPl¯}�fBy�y^h�¹³kPlJkPf<o-mvkP�jkT�]onhjq,f|<lJkTmvmnw<lJkTm � �^kJ�jkT�Tonhjq,f�|<lJkTmvmnwxlJk¯�Tq�f<onlJq,���jkTy � p0mvkP�jk]�Tonhjq,f)|<lJq � } � h���hjonp�},fzy�fDwzu � kJl-q,r ½zon�fzkTmvm�ovq,w<lvfB}�u�kPf<ovm¯«c¢2® � �Si�kPlJ}�¡�k-½B¡�wxlJkTmSq�i�kPl � � �6lvw<fBm �

Z�9B`EV�\JH�A^\SV,U�V�NP?<V�R-Ì-XY\JHW\JHEXYR29<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xN0Ó@ADËaËENJ9DØBXYU+A^\JV�;YÖ � ��\J9 � ��Ë�V,NJZ�V�CB\�HEV�NPV�Ô�ÑÉv\�XÎR�XÎUWË�9xNJ\TADCB\¯\P9+Ca9<\JVW\JH�A^\�\JHEV)A�Í<V�NTAD?<V�VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV�ËENP9<?xN]ADU ;YV�CE?x\JH¶XYR0H�ADNP`E;YÖXYCB×�QEV�CaZ�V�`5ÝBÖ¶\JHEVW`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�VWRJV�;YV�Z,\JXY9<C°XÎC:Z,9<U�Ë"ADNJXYRP9<C¶\J9¶\JHEV)A�Í<V�NTAD?<V.ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�VxÑ

[BV�Z�9xCE`tK"Ý�9x\JH =@9<NPU�R29D=SÍ<A^NJXcAD\PXY9<CtKB;YXYCEV�A^N¯Z�NP9<RJRP9DÍ<V�N0A^CE`MVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV.U.QE\]A^\JXY9<C´KU+A^XÎCB\TADXYC�ËENP9<?xN]ADU(`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖM9DÍxV�N0A�NPQEC:XYU�ËE;YXYZ�XY\J;YÖ.XYC¶\JV�NPU�R�9D=S\PHEV.RJ\PNJQEZ,\JQENTAD;`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V�UWV�\JNPXÎZxÑ<Þ-HEXYR2XYRS\PNJQEV�V�ÍxV�C)Ì-XÎ\PHE9<Qa\S\PHEV�V�ØBËE;YXÎZ,XÎ\2RJV,;ÎV,Z�\JXY9<CW=@9xN�`EXYÍ<V,NJRJXY\vÖBÑ

Page 24: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

��� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

0 50 100 150 200 250

Str

uctu

ral D

iver

sity

Generations

0% (2T)50% (3T)

100% (3T)100% (4T)

�� ��"ª��xª�� �Eª �ti�kJfx� � �c|z},lvhjo@p¶|xlJq � �jkTu 4�sghji�kJlJmnhjonp¶£$hjon�5kP¹³kT�Tonhji�k�u-wBov}�onhjq,fzm�},fzy¶yDh�¹EkPlv�kPf<o¯mvkP�jkT�]onhjq,f¶|<lJkTmvmnw<lJkTm � �DkP�jkT�Tonhjq�f:|xlJk]mvmnwxlJk��Tq,f<onlJq����jkTy � p�mvkP�jkT�Tonhjq�f¶|<lJq � } � h���hYo@p¶}�fByfDwzu � kPlSq,r ½zonfBkTmvmSovq,w<lvfB}�u�kPf<ovm¯«c¢2® � �Si�kPlJ}�¡�k-½B¡�wxlJkTm�q�i�kJl � � �6lvw<fBm �

äE9xN�;YXYCEV�ADNgZ�NJ9xRJRJ9DÍxV�N-\JHaV~NPV�ADRP9<CWU�XY?<HB\$Ý�V�XYC.XY\JR2HEXY?<H.Í<A^NJXcAD\PXÎ9xC�RP\JNPV�CE?<\PHtÑEæ6`E`EX>Û\JXY9<C"AD;Y;YÖzKT\PHEVSHaXÎ?xH�A^U�9xQECB\ 9D=�CE9xCEVTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV¯Z�9B`EV-Z,9<CB\JNPXÎÝaQE\JV�Rg\J90A-ËENPV�RJV,NJÍ<AD\PXY9<C.9D=VTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV¯Z�9B`EV6`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖ�Ì-XY\PH.\JHEXYR�9xË�V�NTAD\P9<N�Ñx8 HEV,C.QERJXYCE?0U.Qa\]AD\PXY9<CER´V�ØBZ�;YQERJXYÍ<V,;ÎÖXYCERJ\PV�AD`tKEA�HEXY?<H.`aV�?<NPV�V09D=tXYCECa9DÍ<AD\JXY9xC.XÎR2XYCB\JNJ9B`EQaZ�V�`)Z�9<CB\PXÎCBQE9xQERJ;YÖ�XYCz\P9�\PHEV�Ë�9xËBÛQE;cAD\PXÎ9xCtÑxÞ-HEXYRS;YV�A^`ER-\J9�A�HEXY?xHEV�N2`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖ�9^=VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV�Z,9z`aV~\PH�ADC)XY\29zZ,Z�QENJR�Ì-XY\JHZ�NJ9xRJRP9DÍ<V�N¯ÓßRJV�V0ä´XY?<QENPV�R��xÑ������?�<Ñ%�!�xÔ"XÎC�Z�9xCERJXY`EV�NTAD\PXÎ9xC.9D= \JHEV�= ADZ,\\PH�AD\g\JHEV¯A�ÍxV�N]A^?<VVTÙ V�Z�\JXYÍxV0;YV�CE?<\PHMXYR¯ADÝ"9<QE\-\PHEV0RTADU�V�HEV,NJV�=@9xN-Z�NJ9xRJRP9DÍ<V�N0ADCa`+V�Ù²V�Z,\JXYÍ<V�U.QE\]A^\JXY9<CaRXYC�\JHaV¯Ê"C�AD;´?<V�CEV,N]AD\PXY9<CtÑ

Þ-HEV�RP\JNP9<CE?xV�N09<CaV�RPV�;YV�Z�\JRµ=@9<N�`EXYÍ<V,NJRJXY\vÖBKEHE9DÌ2V�ÍxV�N�K \PHEV.U�9xNJV�`EXYÍ<V,NJRJXY\vÖM?BADXYCER?<NP9<QECE`¶XYC¸Z,NJ9<RPRJ9DÍxV�N0NJQaCER�Ñ ! ÝzÍBXY9<QaRJ;YÖzK"AWRJ\JNP9<CE?xV�N0XYCB×�QaV�CEZ�VW9<C¶Ë�9xËEQE;cAD\PXÎ9xCM`EX>ÛÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖ0Z�A^C.Ý�V-9xÝERJV,NJÍ<V,`�Ì-XY\JH�Z�NJ9xRJRP9DÍ<V�N2\JH�A^C.Ì-XY\JH�VTÙ²V,Z�\JXYÍ<V6U.QE\]A^\JXY9<CaR�Ñ�ÉvC.Z,9<U.ÛË�ADNPXYRJ9<C)\P9.U.QE\]A^\JXY9<CW\JHEV0RPQEZ�Z�V,RJR09^=�NPV�Z�9xU.ÝEXYC�AD\PXÎ9xC�`EV,Ë�V�Ca`ER�U�9<NPV¯RP\JNJ9xCE?<;YÖ)9<C\JHEV-Z,9<U�Ë"9<RPXY\JXY9<C09^=²\PHEV-?<V,CEV�\JXYZ-U)AD\JV,NJXcAD;BXYC�\PHEV¯Ë"9<ËaQE;cAD\JXY9xCtÑ�Þ-HEV-U�9xNJV�`EX>Ù V�NJV,Cz\\vÌS9�NPV�Z�9<U.ÝaXÎCaV�`.RJ9x;ÎQa\JXY9<CER2ADNJVxK<\PHEV¯HEXY?xHEV�N�XYR�\PHEV¯V�ØBË"V�Z�\PV�`)XÎCaCE9DÍ<AD\PXÎÍBXY\vÖ�9D=t\PHEV�XYN9DÙ RJËENPXYCE?�Ñ

ÉvC5\JHaV+ËaNJV�ÍBXY9<QER.RPV�Z�\PXÎ9xCER�Ì2V)H�A�Í<VWZ�9<CaZ�V�CB\JNTAD\JV,` 9xC5XYU�ËENP9DÍBXÎCa?+\PHEV);YXÎCaV�ADNÏ0Ð5A^ËEËENP9zADZTHtÑaÉvC)Ë�ADNP\JXYZ�QE;cADN�KE\PHEV0`EV�ÍxV�;Y9<ËEUWV�CB\S9^=UWV�\JHE9B`ER-H"ADR-Ý"V�V�C¶Ý�ADRPV�`M9<C\JHEV�`EXYRJ\PXYCEZ�\JXY9xCMÝ�V,\vÌSV�V,C5QERPV�` A^CE`¶QECBQERJV�`:Ë"ADNJ\PR�9D=S\PHEV.;YXÎCaV�ADN6NJV�ËENPV�RJV,Cz\TAD\PXÎ9xCtÑÉvC�\PNJV�V0ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U�R�KBÝBÖ.Z�9xU�Ë�A^NJXYRJ9xCtKxNJV�`EQaCE`�ADCB\6RJQEÝERP\JNPQEZ�\JQaNJV�R0U)A�Ö0V�UWV�NJ?xV~9xCE;YÖ=@NJ9xU·ËENP9<?<NTADU·RPV�U+A^CB\JXYZ�R�KBCa9<\2=@NP9<U·ËENP9<?xN]ADU RJ\JNPQEZ�\PQENJV<Ñ

ÉvC¸\PHEV�=@9<;Y;Y9DÌ-XYCE?.RJV,Z�\JXY9<CaR�Ì2V.Ì-XY;Î;�A^ËEËE;YÖ)?<V�CEV,\JXYZ�ËENP9<?xN]ADUWU�X>CE?0=n9<N�RJ9x;ÎÍBXYCE?`EX>Ù²V,NJV�CB\.ËENP9<ÝE;YV�UWR�=@NJ9xU�U+A^ZTHEXYCEXYCE?)\JV�ZTHECE9x;Y9<?<ÖBÑ$Ú$Í<V�C¬X>=]K´XYC5ËENPXÎCaZ�XYËE;YV<K$;YXÎCaV�ADNÏ0аU+A�Ö.Ý"V�QaRJV�`¸A^R¯Ì2V�;Y;A^R¯\JNPV�VTÛvÝ�ADRPV�`5Ï0ЬXYC)\JHaXÎR6ËENJ9xÝE;YV�Uº`E9<U)ADXYCtKxÌSV�H�A�Í<V`EV�Z�XY`EV,`59<C:\PHEV�;cA^\J\JV,N�ADËEËaNJ9zA^ZTH5HEV�NPV<Ñ$æ¯C:XYCB\JNP9B`EQEZ�\PXÎ9xC:\J9M\PHEXYR�RP\]A^CE`�ADNP`ãÏ0Ð

Page 25: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �Í<ADNPX�A^CB\ XÎR´?<XYÍ<V,C�AD;Y9<Ca?-Ì-XÎ\PH0A-`EV�RPZ�NJXYËE\PXY9<C�9D=�\PHEVSËaNJ9<Ýa;ÎV,U±RJË"V�Z�X>Ê�Z2Z�9<CBÊ"?<QENTAD\JXY9xCER\JH�A^\SH"A�Í<V�Ý�V,V�CMZTHE9<RPV�CMHEV,NJV<Ñ

¾�¿�� ��´Á�� ÂEÈPÇ � ÃEÄ��SÃ������ ÈJÁ��çÈPÁ�� �Ç �¯ÈJÁ6ÈJÁ ��� �tÇ �¯Á¯Ä 2JÄ��

L)9B`EV�;YXYCE?�\PHEV.ZTHEXYËBÛvÝEQEXY;Y`EXYCE?�ËENP9BZ�V�RJR�XYC¸Z,QE\J\PXÎCa?MH�ADR�Ý"V�V�C°XÎC¶\JHaV.Z�V�CB\JV�N�9D=-XYCBÛ\JV�NPV�RJ\�=@9xN�AW;Î9xCE?)\JXYU�VxÑ Þ-HEV.ZTHEXYË:?<V�9xU�V�\PNJÖBK"\JHEVWU+AD\PV�NJXcA^;UW9DÍ<V�UWV�CB\¯ADCE`:\PHEV\JHEV,NJU+A^;$ËENJ9BZ�V�RPRJV�R.\PH�AD\�\]ADOxV�Ëa;�A^Z�V�AD\�\JHEV.Z�V,Cz\PV�N�9D=-\JHEV.Z�Qa\J\JXYCE? G�9<CEV�A^NJV.`EV�ÛZ�XYRJXYÍ<VW=@9xN�HEXY?xH �BQ�A^;YXÎ\vÖ°U+A^Z]HaXÎCaXÎCa?�K´NJV�`EQaZ�\JXY9<C 9D=0U+A^Z]HaXÎCaXÎCa?¸\PXÎUWV�R�K�A^CE` \P9z9x;ÌSV�ADN�Ñ�L¼9<RJ\�V�ØBXYRJ\PXÎCa? A^ËEËENJ9BADZTHEV�R.XYCEZ,9<NJË"9<NTAD\PV�Ê"CEXY\JV)V�;YV�U�V,Cz\�9<N.U�9x;YV�Z�QE;YV.`EÖxÛC�ADUWXYZUWV�\JHa9z`aR�A^R$ÌSV�;Y;EADR2ADC�A^;ÎÖB\PXÎZ�AD;<\PV�ZTHECEX%�BQEV�R2Ý�ADRPV�`.9<C�Z�QE\J\PXYCE?�=@9xNJZ�V2U�9B`EV�;YR�%�<K%� '"K � �EK � �EK � �aK ��� �tÓcRJV,V�ä´XÎ?xQENJV"�xÑ��9'zÔ,Ñ��2ÉSUWV�\JHa9z`aR�A^NJV�QERJV,`�=n9<N-\JHaXÎR2ËENP9<ÝE;YV�U&A^R

�� ��"ª��xª�� ��ª �"h�f<hjovk2kP�jk]u�kPf<o2«Y�jkPr�oJ®P{Du�q,�jk]�Pwx�j}�lSyxp�fz}�u6hj�]m�«c�]kPf<ovkPl]®´}�fBy�}�fB}��jpDonhj�T},�«Ylvhj¡,�<oJ®u�k]on�BqDy<m �

ÌSV,;Î; � � ���JÑ�Þ-HEV�RPV~ADËaËENJ9BADZTHEV�Rg=@9BZ�QER29<C�CEV�QENTAD;"CEV�\vÌ29<NPOzR�Ñ!�¯V�QaNJ9<C"AD;"CEV�\vÌ29<NJOBR�Z�ADCU�9B`EV�;$\PHEV.?<V�CaV�N]A^;SÝ"V�H�A�ÍBXY9<N�9D=-Z�9xNJNJV,;�A^\JXY9<CaR�K´ÝEQE\0\PHEV.U�9B`EV�;YR6Z�ADCECa9<\0Ý"V.QERJV,`ADRPXÎ`aV¯=nNJ9<U CEV�QENP9<C�A^; CEV�\vÌ29<NJOBR�=@9<Ng=@QENP\JHEV�N6QER]A^?<V�9<N-XYCBÍ<V,RJ\JXY?BAD\JXY9xCER�Ñ

æ¯CE9x\JHEV,N��2É�U�V,\JHE9B`:XYR�RPÖBU.Ý�9x;ÎXYZ�NJV�?xNJV�RPRJXY9<C°ÍBX�A¼?<V�CEV,\JXYZ)ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�UWXjCE?"Ñ�[BÖBU.ÛÝ�9x;YXÎZ)NPV�?<NPV�RJRPXÎ9xC XYR)A¶Ì-XÎ`aV�;YÖãQaRJV�` UWV�\JHa9z`°=@9xN�NPV�Z�9<CaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎCa? U+A^\JHEV�U)AD\PXÎZ�AD;Z�9<NPNJV�;cA^\JXY9<CER�Ñtá6V�NJV)AMCaV�Ì ?<N]A^ËEHEXYZ�A^;SNPV�ËENJV,RJV�CB\]A^\JXY9<C¬9^=¯\JHEVWXÎCa`EXYÍzXY`EQ"AD;YR�XÎR�AD;YRJ9ËENJV,RJV�CB\JV,`tÑ"Þ-HEXYRSCEV,Ì \PHENJV�V�Û `EXYUWV�CERJXY9xC�AD; NPV�ËENJV,RJV�CB\]A^\JXY9<C¶AD;Y;Y9DÌ-R�\JHEV�QERPV�N¯\P9�NPV�ZTÛ9<?xCEXYG�V�Z,V�NJ\TADXYC:Ë�9xRJRPXÎÝaXÎ;YXY\JXYV�R�\P9+XYUWËENJ9DÍxV0\JHEV.RPV�\JQaË59D=2\JHEV.ËENP9BZ�V�RJR.Ë"ADN]A^U�V�\PV�NJR�ÑäEQaNJ\JHaV�NJUW9<NJVxK \JHEXYR0CaV�Ì NJV�ËENPV�RJV,Cz\TAD\PXÎ9xCãA^;Î;Y9DÌ-R�\JHaV.ÍzXYRPQ�AD;YXYG�AD\PXY9<CM9^=�\PHEV�?xV�CEV�N�ÛAD\PV�`¸\PHENJV,VTÛ `aXÎUWV�CERPXÎ9xC�AD;$9xÝ��TV�Z�\PR0Ì-XY\JH¶CEV�ADNP;YÖMV�Í<V,NJÖ �2æ � ËENP9<?xN]ADU =@9<N�=@QENP\JHEV�NQERJVxÑ

Þ-HEV¯ADËaËENJ9BADZTH�9^=²RPÖBU.Ý�9x;ÎXYZ�NPV�?<NPV�RJRPXY9<C�QaRJXYCE?�?<V�CaV�\JXYZ¯ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U�U�X>CE?-XYR��zQaXÎ\PV-RJXYU.ÛXY;�A^Nt\P90\JH�A^\�9D=tA�HBQEU)ADC09xÝERJV�NPÍ<V�N ��� � �³Ì-AD\PZTHEXYCE?�A6Z�V�NP\]ADXYCWËENJ9BZ�V�RPR�A^CE`.\JNPÖBXÎCa?0\J9`EV�RPZ�NJXYÝ"V¯XY\tXYC�ËEHBÖzRPXYZ�AD;E\PV�NJUWR�Ñ<äaQENP\JHEV�NPU�9xNJV<K�\JHaV-RJÖBRJ\PV�U U+A�Ö�ËENJ9B`EQaZ�V-RJ9xU�V�QEC³ÛV�ØBË�V,Z�\JV�`)ÝEQa\SÍ<A^;ÎXY`�NJV�RPQE;Y\JR�KBÌ-HEXYZ]H.`a9�CE9x\�Z�9xNJNJV,RJË"9<CE`)\J9.ADCBÖ�OBCE9DÌ-C.ËENJ9xË�V,NJ\JXYV�R9D=S\PHEV�ËENJ9BZ�V�RPR�Ñ$Én=SRPQEZTH:ËEHEV�Ca9<U�V,C�A.9BZ�Z�QaN�K CEV,Ì OBCE9DÌ-;YV�`a?<V�A^Ý�9xQE\�\JHEV.ËENP9BZ�V�RJRH�ADR2Ý"V�V�CM?xV�CEV�NTAD\JV,`tÑEÞ-HEXYR2OBCE9DÌ-;YV�`E?<V6U+A�Ö�Ý�V�HEV,;Î˳=@QE; XYC�RPQEËEË"9<NJ\PXYCE?�\PHEV�`EV�ÍxV�;>Û9<ËEUWV�CB\S9^=�CEV�̱RJXYU.QE;cA^\JXY9<C.\P9z9x;YR�KBÌ-HEXYZTH¸ADNPV�ADÝa;ÎV�\P9�XYCEZ�NPV�ADRPV0\JHEV�ËENP9z`aQEZ�\JXYÍBXY\vÖ

Page 26: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

9D=t\PHEV¯ËENP9BZ�V�RJR¯A^RSÌ2V�;Y; ADR2XÎ\PRSNPV�;YXcADÝEXY;YXY\vÖzÑ�ÉvC.ZTHEXYË�UW9z`aV�;YXÎCa?�K�\JHEV,RJV�U�9B`EV�;YR�Z�ADC�Ý"V`EV�RPZ�NJXYÝ"V�`MXYCMA0\vÌ29.`EXYU�V�CaRJXY9<C�A^;EÌ-A�Ö.ÝzÖWNJV�;cA^\JXY9<CER-9^=\PHEXYR-\vÖzË"V

� Ó �]Ô,+ 4 � Ó��]Ô4��"Ó��]Ô � Ó/�<Ñ �<Ô

Þ$90RJQEZ,Z�V�V�`MXYC.\PHEXYRS9xÝ��TV�Z�\PXÎÍxV<KBRJ9xU�V-ËENP9<ÝE;YV�UWR$H�A�Í<V6\J9�Ý�V6RJ9<;YÍxV�`tÑxÞ-HEV6Ê�NJRP\S\TADRJOXYR�\J909xÝE\]A^XYC.\JHEV6\JN]A9�TV�Z�\P9<NJXYV�R-9^=t\JHEV6Ë�ADNP\JXYZ�;YV�R2XYC�\JHaV¯Z�NPÖzRP\]A^;Î;YXYCEV-RP\JNJQaZ�\JQENPV09D=t\PHEVU�V�\TAD;BÌ29<NJOBËEXYV�Z,V<K<RPHE9DÌ-C�XÎC�[³V�Z�\JXY9xCER��<Ñ ��ADCa` �<Ñ%�!�aÑ�Þ-HaV-RJV�Z�9xCE`�XYR$\J9µÊ�CE`�A6RJQEXY\�ÛADÝE;YV�UW9B`EV�;<`aV�RJZ�NPXYÝEXYCE?0\JHaVSËEHBÖBRJXYZ�A^;BZ�9<NPNJV�;cAD\PXY9<CER$\JH"AD\$;YV�AD`�\J96\JHEV�RPV-\JNTA �TV�Z�\P9<NPXÎV,R�ÑäE9xN-\JHEXYR6\]ADRPO)\JHEV0UWV�\JHa9z`)9^=SRJÖBU.Ý"9<;YXYZ¯NJV,?<NJV,RJRJXY9xC¸ÍBXcA�?<V�CaV�\JXYZ0ËENP9<?xN]ADUWU�XYCE?0XYRQERJV,` ���aK������JÑxÞ-HEXYRSXYR-RJHa9DÌ-C+XYC)[BV�Z�\PXÎ9xC$�<Ñ%�S�<Ñ

¾�¿�� ��� � �tÃEÈ/���tÁgÂ�� 2 � �Õ³Æ��Þ-HEV�ËENPXYU+ADNPÖ¯?x9zAD;x9D=E\JHaVSV�ØBË"V�NJXYUWV�CB\JR$Ì�A^Rt\P9¯?zA^\JHEV,NRP9<UWVV,ØzV,U�ËE;cADNPÖ¯`�A^\]A�=@NJ9xU\JHEV2ËENP9zZ,V�RJRPV�R�ÑBÉvC09xNJ`EV,N�\J96RJHE9DÌ°\JHEV2Ë�9DÌ2V�N$9D="\JHEV-`EV,Í<V�;Y9<Ë"V�`.AD;Y?<9xNJXY\JHaU�R�KTRPV�Í<V,N]AD;`EX>Ù²V,NJV�CB\0ËENP9BZ�V�RJRPV�R�ADCa`¸UWV�\JHE9B`ER�9^=�XYU+A^?<V�ËENP9zZ,V�RJRPXÎCa?¸H�A�ÍxV�Ý"V�V�C°\JNPXÎV,`tÑ Þ-HEV�ÖAD;Y;BH�A�Í<V¯AµRJXYU�XY;cADN´ËENJXYCEZ�XYËE;YV-RPV�\JQEËWXYC�Z�9xU�UW9<CtÑ,Þ-HEV-Ê�NPRJ\2RJ\PV�Ë�Z�9xCERJXYRP\JR29D= \]ADOBXYCE?ËEXYZ�\JQaNJV�R69D=\PHEV0ËENP9BZ�V�RJR�Ì-XY\JHa9<QE\-`EXYRP\JQENPÝEXYCE?.\JHEV�Z�Qa\J\JXYCE?.ËaNJ9BZ�V�RPR~9xN-XYCB×�QEV�CaZ�XYCE?\JHEV6ZTHEXYË�=@9<NPU+AD\PXY9<CtÑ�Þ-HEXYR�RP\JV�Ë)XYR�`E9xCEV¯9xC.\vÌS90`aXjÙ V�NPV�CB\-V�ØBË�V�NPXYU�V�CB\]A^;�RPV�\JQaËER-\J9?zA^\JHEV�N�A.Ì-XY`EV0NTADCE?xV09D=�`�A^\]AaÑEÞ-HEV�RJV�Z,9<CE`¶RJ\PV�˸XYR6\J9�\PN]A^CERv=@9xNJUÜ\PHEV�RJV�ËEXYZ�\PQENJV�RXYCz\P9�A�`EXY?<XY\TAD;a=@9<NPU¸Ñ

;=<�?<@; A��?F�W(L=E(F�HKN-[�W L�W(F�H E ��D� W(L���D�E(F�QYW(H�D�V �]W(Q � L X W(N�HKN�[DW W(QE(D�V�VÞ-HEV.Ê"NJRJ\.V,ØzË"V�NPXÎUWV�CB\]A^;SRPV�\JQEˬÌ-ADR�QERJV,`ã9xC:\JHEV)\PQENJCEXYCE?¶9D=~A^;YQEU�XYCBQEU�AD;Y;Y9DÖBR�ÑÞ-HEXYR�RJV,\JQEË)Ì-ADR2RJXYU�XY;cADN´\J9�\JH�A^\S`EV,RJZ�NPXÎÝ"V�`)ÝBÖ.85ADNPCEV�ZTO<V � � ���JÑ�ÉvC�Z�9xCB\JN]A^RJ\-\P90HEXYRRJV�\PQEËtKBCE9�U�XYZ�NP9<RPZ�9<Ë"V¯XYR2QERJV�`´ÑBÉvC�\JHaXÎR2V�ØBË"V�NJXYU�V,Cz\-A�HEXY?<H.RJË"V�V�` Z�ADUWV�N]AaKD8:V�XYCBÛÝ�V,NJ?<V,Nµ[³Ë�V�V,`EZ�ADUM0ÜK"Ì-HEXYZTH¸\TADO<V,R~Qa˸\P9 ' � � ��ËEXYZ�\JQENPV�R0Ë"V�N�RJV�Z,9<CE`tKÕÌ�A^R~QaRJV�`tÑæ·RJZTHEV,U+AD\PXYZ.ÍzXYV�Ì 9^=�\PHEXYR0RJV�\PQEˬXYR0RJHE9DÌ-C:XYC5ä´XY?<QENPV �<Ñ%�!�aÑ�æÜÏ�NP9<ݶF�� [xÛ]� � �\JQENPCEXYCE?)U+A^Z]HaXÎCaV�Ì-ADR�QERPV�`:=@9xN�\JHEXYR0ËENP9BZ�V�RJR.\P9)Z�QE\�\JHEV�A^;ÎQaU�XYCBQEU&NPXYCE?<R�Ñ Þ-HEVÌ-HE9<;YV�ZTHEXYËBÛ ÝaQEXY;Î`aXÎCa?.ËENJ9BZ�V�RPR.Ì�A^R6Ê�;YU�V�`MÌ-XY\PH¸\PHEV.HEXY?<HBÛvRJË"V�V�`:Z�ADU�V,N]AEÑ"æ6Ý�9xQE\��RJV�Z,9<CE`ER�9D=�V�Í<V,NJÖMNPQECMÌ2V�NJV�NJV�Z,9<NJ`aV�`tÑ´Þ-HEV0V�ØBË"V�NJXYU�V,Cz\6Ì�A^R¯Z�A^NJNPXÎV,`¸9xQE\¯Ì-XY\JHÍ<ADNPXÎ9xQER�ËENP9BZ�V�RJR6Ë�ADNTADUWV�\JV�NPR�ÑBÞ-Ì29�`aXjÙ V�NPV�CB\¯AD;Y;Y9DÖzRgÌSV�NPV�QERJV�`MA^RSÌ29<NPOzËaXÎV,Z�V�U+A�Û\JV�NPXcAD;vÑ$Þ-HEVMÌ29<NPOzËaXÎV,Z�VMÌ-ADR�A¶NJXYCE?^Û RPH�ADË"V�` ËaNJ9DÊ";ÎVxK�Ì-HEXYZTH¬Ì�A^R.NJ9<\TAD\PXÎCa?:Ì-HEXY;ÎV\JHEV�\P9z9x;�Ì-ADR2Ê"ØzV,`tÑBÞ-HEV�Z�QE\P\JXYCE?.RJË"V�V�`�� � � ��C* #

��KB\PHEV6=@V�V�` 4 ����� �JK"ADCE`W\JHEV�Ý�A^Z]OV�CE?BAD?<V,U�V�CB\29D=\PHEV�Z�QE\P\JXYCE?.V�`E?xV0XYC�� � �������tÌSV�NPV0Í<ADNPXYV�`tÑ

;=<�?<�> A��?F�W(L=E(F�HKN-[�W L�W(F�H E ��D� W(L���D�E(F�QYW(H�D�V �]W(Q � L �RW(H����KH�N [ W W(QE(D�VIVÞ-HEVMRPV�Z�9<Ca`±RJV�\PQE˱\J9°NJV�Z�V,XÎÍxV:`�AD\TA¶=@NP9<U�A Z�QE\J\PXYCE?¬ËENJ9BZ�V�RPRMÌ-ADRMA:UW9z`aXjÊ"V�``ENJXY;Y;YXYCE?-ËENJ9BZ�V,RJR�ÑBæ RJHE9xNJ\�K^NJXY?<XY`tKDADCa`�\P9<NJRPXY9<CBÛvNJV�RPXYRJ\]A^CB\�`ENJXY;Y;EÌ-ADR$QERPV�`tÑxÞ-HEV�NJV�=@9<NPV\JHEV-Ì29<NPOBËEXYV�Z�V�R-Z�9xQE;Y`.Ý�V2=n9<NJUWV�`.ADR2Z�ÖB;ÎXYCE`aV�NJR2Ì-XY\JH.A�RJ;YXY?<HB\J;YÖ0NPV�`EQEZ,V�`)`EXcADU�V,\JV�NZ�9<UWË�ADNPV�`.\J9�\JHEV�`EXcADUWV�\JV,N�9D=t\PHEV�`ENJXY;Y;vÑDÞ-HBQER�KB\PHEV¯HEXY?xHBÛ RPË�V,V�`)Z�ADUWV�N]A�Z,9<QE;Y`�Ý"V

Page 27: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �

�� ��ª �xª�� �aª � ��|EkPlvhju�kPf<ov}����DkTonw<|.rcq,lSonw<lvfxh�fz¡0q,rt}���wBu6h�fDwzu }����jq,pDm �

-t§ .1032 �<ª��aª ­ },lJ}�u�kTovkPlJm$wzmvkTy�rcq,lSon�zk-onwxlvf<h�fz¡µ|<lJqD�TkTmvm ���fzyxk��D} � �jk0��fzmvkPlJo-«@�^k]�TqD® £$q�lv�D|xhjk]�Tk � � �������

�� � � ��� �� �

s 7S��� � � � � � � �@�.� � ¢�­ � � � ���^��f � � � � � � �<{ � � �s 7S��� � � � � � � �@�.� � ¢�­ � � � ���^��f � � � � � � �<{ �� �s 7S��� � � � � � � �@�.� � ¢�­ � � � ���^��f � � � � � � �<{ � � �s 7S��� � � � � � � �@�.� � ¢�­ � � � ���^��f � � � � � � �<{ � � �s 7S��� � � � � � � �a� � ���S� ���Î�wz�.¡�­ � �� � �<{ � � �s 7S��� � � � � � � �a� � ���S� ���Î�wz�.¡�­ � �� � �<{ � � �s 7S��� � � � � � � �a� � ���S� ���Î�wz�.¡�­ � �� �<{ � � �s 7S��� � � � � � � �a� � ���S� ���Î�wz�.¡�­ � �� �<{ � � �s 7S��� � � � � � � �@�.� � ¢�­ � � � � � � �� �<{ � � �

Ë�9xRJXY\JXY9xCEV�`¸A^\¯\JHaV�RPXÎ`aV�9^=�\PHEXYR�Z�ÖB;ÎXYCE`aV�N¯\P9�V�C�A^ÝE;YV�\PHEV�Ê�;YU�XYCE?�9D=S\PHEV�ZTHEXYË)×"9DÌAD\�\JHEV)Z�Qa\J\JXYCE?:V,`E?<V)9D=�\JHEV)Ì29<NPOzËaXÎV,Z�V<Ñ�ä´XY?<QENPV �xÑ%�I�)RPHE9DÌ-R�AMRPZTHEV�U+A^\JXYZ)ÍBXÎV,Ì9D=S\PHEXYR¯RPV�\JQEË5A^R�ÌSV�;Y;�ADR0A�ËEHE9<\P9)9D=S\PHEV�U)ADZTHEXYCEV�Ó �¯F2á � �.=nNJ9<UÜá��QE;Y;YV�NvÛvá¯XY;Y;YV�Ô�Ñ�6QEV¯\P9.XÎ\PR-NJXY?<XY`W`EV�RJXY?xCtKB\JHEXYR-U)ADZTHEXYCEV¯AD;Y;Y9DÌ-R2Í<V�NPÖ�;Y9DÌ \JQaNJCEXYCE?�RJË"V�V�`ER�Ì-XY\JHa9<QE\;Y9z9xRJXYCE?.ËENPV�Z�XYRJXY9xCtÑ ÉvC¶\JHEXYR�RJV�\PQE˶9<CE;YÖM\PHEV0=nV�V�`¶Ì�A^R~Í<A^NJXYV�`tÑ ! CEV.`EX>à�Z�Qa;Î\vÖWÌ�A^R\J9¶`EV�\PV�NJUWXÎCaV+9xËE\JXYU)AD;�Ë�A^N]A^U�V�\PV�NJR�=@9xN.\JHEV)Z�A^U�V�NTAMRPV�\JQaË \J9:9xÝE\]A^XÎC°\JHEV)Ý"V�RJ\Ë�9xRJRPXÎÝa;ÎV2XYU+A^?<V�R´9D=�\PHEV-ËENJ9BZ�V,RJR�ÑEäa9<N$\PHEXYRËaQENJË"9<RPV-\JHEV-Ë�A^N]A^U�V�\PV�NJR�9^=�\JHaV-Z�ADUWV�N]AÌSV,NJV0AD;YRJ9.Í<A^NJXYV�`¶ÓcÞ�ADÝE;YV �EÑ��xÔ�ÑxÞ-HEV0Ë�A^N]ADUWV�\JV,NJR-ADNJV�\JHEV6=@NPV �BQEV�CEZ�Ö)9^=�\PHEV�XYU+AD?xVNJV�Z,9<NJ`aXÎCa?µA^CE`0\PHEVSXYCB\JV,CERJXY\vÖ09^=�\JHEV2XY;Y;ÎQaU�XYC�AD\PXY9DC¯ÝBÖ0\JHaVSRP\JNJ9xÝ�9xRJZ�9xËEXYZ-;YXÎ?xHB\JR�Ñ,Þ-HEVËEXYZ�\JQaNJV�R�\JH"AD\�ÌSV,NJV�\]ADOxV�C¶XÎC \JHEXYR�`ENJXY;Y;YXYCE?�V,ØzË"V�NPXÎUWV�CB\�ÌSV�NPV�V,`EXY\JV�`:A�=@\PV�NJÌ-ADNP`ER�KQERJXYCE?6XYU+AD?xVtËENP9BZ�V�RJRPXYCE?�RJ9D=n\vÌ�A^NJV2\J9¯XYCEZ,NJV�A^RJV2Z�9<CB\JNTADRP\�A^CE`0\PHEV�NJV,ÝzÖ�\JHaVSÍBXYRJXYÝEXY;YXY\vÖ9D=E\JHaVSZTHEXYË�×�9DÌ0Ñ�Þ-Ì29¯`EX>Ù V�NJV,Cz\$\vÖBË"V�R$9D=�ZTHEXYËER´9zZ,Z�QEN�XYC�\JHEXYR$RJV,\JQEË�Ý�V,Z�ADQERPV-9D=�\PHEV\vÌS96Z�QE\P\JXYCE?�V�`E?xV�R�9D= \JHaV-QERJV�`.`aNJXY;Y; Ñ�ä´XÎ?xQENJV �<Ñ%���-RJHa9DÌ-R3�2=@NTADUWV�RtV�ØB\PN]ADZ,\JV�`�=@NJ9xU\JHEV.ËaNJ9BZ�V�RPRJV�`°U�9DÍBXYV<Ñ"æ¯;Y;$ËEXYZ�\JQENPV�R�RJHE9DÌâ\JHEVWÌS9xNJOM9^=�\PHEV.XYCECEV�N0Z,QE\J\PXÎCa?+V,`E?<V<ÑÒ 9D̬Z�QE\P\JXYCE?.RPË�V�V,`¸AD\2\JHEV�XYCECEV,N-Z�QE\J\PXYCE?.V�`E?xV~;YV�A^`ER2\J9�A�RJHEV�A^N-ZTHEXYË.=@9xNJU+A^\JXY9<C´ÑÉv\�Z�A^C�Ý"V¯RJV,V�C)HE9D̬\JHEV6Z]HaXÎË.XYR�RPHEV�A^NJV�`MADCa`.ËEQERJHaV�`)\J9<?xV�\JHaV�N�ÑBÞ-HEV6VTÙ V�Z�\-9D=t\PHEVZTHEXYËEÝENJV�ADO<V,N-9<C)\JHEV�ZTHEXYË)Z�ADC)Ý"V0RJV,V�CtÑ

Page 28: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

�� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

�� ��"ª �xª�� �aª ¢$�zk2wBmvkTy�u�}��v�<h�fBk�«Y�jkJrcoJ®$},fzy.}�mv���zkTu�}�onhj�6i�hjk]£°q�rton�Bk-mvkTonw<|M«Ylvhj¡,�<oJ® �-´§ .1032%�xª��aª ­ },lJ}�u�kTovkPlJm$wzmvkTy�rcq�l2on�zk-yDlvh�����h�fB¡�|<lJqD�TkTmvm �

� � �� � �� � � � � d

��

� � �<{ � � � � � �� � �<{ � � � � � �� � �<{ � � � � � �� � � �<{ � � � � � �� �� �<{ � � � � � �� �� �<{ � � � � � �� �� �<{ � � � � � �

¾�¿J¾�� ��´Â����´ÃEÈJÁ � � �´Â��

æ-=@\PV�Nt?BAD\PHEV�NJXYCE?6\JHEV2XYU+A^?<Vt`"AD\]A�=@NJ9xU±\JHEVg`EX>Ù²V�NPV�CB\�Z�QE\P\JXYCE?6ËENJ9BZ�V�RPRJV�R2RJXY?xCEX>Ê�Z�ADCB\\JNTA �TV�Z�\P9<NPXÎV,R~9^=Ë�A^NJ\PXÎZ,;ÎV,R¯XYC)\JHEV0U)AD\PV�NJXcAD; CaV�V�`M\P9�Ý"V0V�ØB\JNTADZ�\PV�`tÑ"Þ-HEXYR¯Ì-ADR-`E9xCEVXYC�\vÌ290RJ\PV�ËER�ÑEätXYNPRJ\�KEAµRJV�?xU�V�CB\]A^\JXY9<C�9D=t\PHEV¯Ë"ADNJ\PXYZ�;YV�R�XYC.\JHEV�Ê�;YU�V�`�U+A^\JV�NPXcAD;BÌ�A^RZ�ADNPNJXYV�`¬9<Qa\�Ñ$æ-=n\JV�NPÌ�A^NJ`ER�K�\JHaV+\PN]A ��V�Z�\J9xNJXYV�RW9D=~\PHEVMË�A^NJ\PXÎZ,;ÎV�×�9D̺ÌSV�NPV)\JN]A^ZTO<V�`tÑÞ-HEXYR�Z�A^C.Ý�V6`E9<CEV6V�XY\JHEV,NSU)ADCBQ�AD;Y;YÖ¯9xN�A^QE\J9xU+A^\JXYZ�AD;Y;YÖ<K,`EV�Ë"V�CE`EXYCE?�9<C.\PHEV¯\vÖBË"V¯9D=\JHEV�U)AD\JV,NJXcAD;vÑ�ÉvCWÊ�;YU�V�`.RPV �BQEV�CEZ�V,R�K ADCMADQa\J9<U)AD\PXÎZ2\JNTADZTOBXYCE?�UWV�\JHa9z`WXYRSQERPVT=@QE;´\J9NJV�`aQEZ�V0\PHEV0U+A^CBQ�AD;EV�Ù²9xNJ\�Ñ

;=< ;�� <@; �?D'[ � D N FIL FIHKQ=N

Þ-HEV�\]A^RJO.9D=$`EV�\PV�NJUWXÎCaXÎCa?�Ì-HEXYZTH�ËaXÎØBV�;YR-9^=�ADCWXYU+AD?xV-Ý�V,;Î9xCE?�\J9.A�RJXYCE?<;YV6V�;YV�U�V�CB\9D= \JHEV2Ê";ÎUWV�`09xÝ��TV�Z�\�XYR�Z�AD;Y;YV�`�RPV�?<UWV�CB\]A^\JXY9<CtÑ�á6V�NJV<KBRPXYCE?<;YV2Ë�ADNP\JXYZ�;YV�R�9^=ÕA6U�V,\]AD;Y;YXYZÌS9xNJOBËEXYV�Z�V-H"A�Í<V2\J90Ý"V-;Y9zZ�AD\JV,`.\J90RPXÎUWËE;YX>=@Ö-\JHEV6\JNTADZ�XYCE?�9D= \JHaV-×�9DÌ°XÎC�\JHaV-Z�QE\J\PXYCE?ËENJ9BZ�V,RJR�Ñ$Þ-HaV�ËENP9<ÝE;YV�U�XYR0\P9)Ê�CE`°RJV�\PR.9D=¯Ë"9<XYCB\JR0XYC:\PHEV�XYU+A^?<V�\JH�A^\0Ý"V�;Y9<CE?¶\J9AWRJXYCE?<;YV.Z�NPÖBRJ\]A^;Y;ÎXYCEV�9<N�ADCE9x\JHEV�N�RJ9x;YXÎ`¶Ë�A^NJ\0XYC¶\JHEV�×�9DÌ0Ñ"Þ-HEXYR0Z�ADC:Ý"V+A^CBÖMË�ADNP\

Page 29: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �

�� ��"ª��xª�� �Eª ���zkT},lS�v�xh�|.rcq�lJu�}�onhjq�f�}�o$on�zk2h�f<fBkPl�kTy<¡�k-q,rton�zk2yDlvh���� ½<�ju�kTy.}�o � � � � ��������� �

9D=S\PHEV�Z]HaXÎË´Ñ�æ6;Y;Ë"ADNJ\PXYZ�;YV�R�XÎC \JHEV�×�9ḎÌ-HEXYZTHM=n9<;Y;Y9DÌ RJXY?<CaXjÊ"Z�ADCB\¯Ë"AD\JHaRµA^NJV�RJQEXY\�ÛADÝE;YV<ÑxÞ-HEV�NPVT=@9xNJV<Ka\JHEV6U+ADXYC�`EX>à�Z�QE;Y\vÖ�XÎR2\J9�Ê�CE`W\JHEV6R]A^U�V¯ADNPÝEXY\JNTADNJXY;YÖ�Z]Ha9<RJV,C+ÝaQE\RJXY?<CaXjÊ"Z�ADCB\2Ë�ADNP\JXYZ�;YV�XÎCWV�Í<V,NJÖW=@N]A^U�V69D=\PHEV6Ê�;YU�V�`W`�AD\TAEÑ

;=< ;�� <�> T X�FIQ � L�F�H E"AP�?FIW(L=EGFIHKQYN

æ¯QE\P9<U)AD\JXYZ6V�ØB\JN]A^Z�\JXY9xC¸9^=�\PN]A ��V�Z�\J9xNJXYV�R�=nNJ9<U Ê�;YU�V,`+U)AD\PV�NJXcAD; NPV �BQEXYNJV�R0A�Z�V�NJ\TADXYC�BQ�AD;YXY\vÖ-9D=�\PHEV$Ê�;YU±RPV �BQEV�CEZ�V,R�\J96V�C�ADÝa;ÎV-A2RJ9^=@\vÌ-ADNJV2\J9-\PN]A^Z�V-\JHEVgË�ADNP\JXYZ�;YV�R�Ñ�Þ-HEV,NJVTÛ=@9<NPV<K�\JHEV2RJ9^=@\vÌ-ADNJVgQERJV�`�=n9<Nt\PHEXYRt\PN]ADZTOBXYCE?�CEV�V�`aR\P9�Ý�V-ADÝE;YV�\P9�NJV�Z�9x?<CEXYG�V2\JHaVSRTADU�VË�ADNP\JXYZ�;YV�XÎC:`aXjÙ V�NPV�CB\�=@N]A^U�V�R�9^=�\PHEV�Ê�;YU�V�` U+AD\PV�NJXcA^; Ñ"Þ$N]A^Z�V�`:Ë�A^NJ\PXÎZ,;ÎV,R0CEV�V�`°\J9

Page 30: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

Ý�V69<CW\JHEV6Ê�;YU�V,`.RJQEN�= ADZ�V�`EQaNJXYCE?�\JHEV�Ì-HE9x;ÎV6ËENJ9BZ�V,RJR¯9^=\PN]ADZTOBXYCE?�Ñ ! \JHEV,NJÌ-XYRJV0\PHEVË�ADNP\JXYZ�;YV�R-CEV,V�`M\J9.Ý"V�RJV�?xU�V�CB\PV�`)9<C)V�Í<V,NJÖ.=nN]ADUWV¯9^=\JHaV�Ê�;YU�V�`.U)AD\PV�NJXcAD;vÑ

ÉvC 9B`EV�N)\J9°V�ØB\JN]A^Z�\M\PHEV¸Ë"ADNJ\PXYZ�;YVM\JNTA �TV�Z�\P9<NPXÎV,R�K6\JHEV¶ËENJ9x?<NTADU 8 É)�¯æ6C�AD;YÖBG�V=@NJ9xU L)XYOBNJ9xU+A^O+Ì-ADR�QERJV�`´Ñ�Ð$NJ9DÍBXY`EV�`:\PH�AD\0\PHEV�XYU)AD?<V,R~H"AD`5A)Z�V,NJ\]A^XYC$�BQ�AD;YXY\vÖBK\JHEV-RP9D=@\vÌ-ADNPV¯Ì-ADRSA^ÝE;YV-\J9�=n9<;Y;Y9DÌãA�RPV�?<UWV�CB\JV�`.Ë�A^NJ\PXÎZ,;ÎV�ADQE\P9<U)AD\JXYZ�A^;Y;ÎÖxÑ�æ RJZ�NPV�V�CBÛRJHE9x\09D=¯\PHEV�RP9D=@\vÌ-ADNPV�Ë"V�Nv=n9<NJUWXYCE?MAW=@QE;Y;SA^QE\J9xU+AD\PXYZ�RPV�?<UWV�CB\]AD\PXY9<C¶XÎR�RJHE9DÌ-C°XÎCä´XÎ?xQENJV"�xÑ����EÑ

�� ��"ª �<ª���aª ¢$�zk-mvq,rco@£$},lJk » �&7��gfz},�jpD�Tk¯i �>� �.«c��h��DlJq�u�}��z® �

Þ-HEV)ËENJ9x?<NTADU�?xV�CEV�NTAD\JV,R�æ~[ �2ÉJÉ�\JN]A^Z�V)Ê�;YV�R�K�Ì-HEXYZTH¬Z�ADC A^C�AD;YÖBG�V�\PHEVM\PN]A �TV,Z�\J9^ÛNJXYV�R�9^=²\PHEV¯Ë"ADNJ\PXYZ�;YV�RSÝBÖ0\PHEV~Ï�жRJÖBRJ\PV�U¸ÑDÞ-HaV-Ë�9xRJXY\JXY9<CaR�9D= \JHEV6Ë�ADNP\JXYZ�;YV�R2Z�ADC.Ca9DÌÝ�V�XYCB\JV�NPËENJV,\JV�`:ADR-\PHEV�Í<AD;YQEV�R-9^=�A�\vÌ29DÛv`EXYU�V�CERPXY9<C�A^;zNPV�;cAD\PXÎ9xCtÑ

ÉvCµA^`E`EXY\JXY9xC~\P9-\JHEV�=@QE;Y;YÖ~ADQa\J9<U)AD\PXÎZ UWV�\JHa9z`´K�U+A^CBQ�AD;�RJV�?xU�V�CB\TAD\JXY9xC¯Ì-ADRtQaRJV�`tÑÞ-HEXYR-U�V�\PHE9B`�Ì-ADR6QERJV�` Ì-HEV�CtK"`EQEV�\J9.9<Ëa\JXYZ�AD;´9<N-U)AD\JV,NJXcAD;"`EVT=@9xNJU)AD\JXY9xC�VTÙ V�Z�\PR�KXY\�Ì�A^RSCa9<\�Ë"9<RPRJXYÝE;YV¯\P9�;Y9BZ�AD\PV¯9xCEV¯RPXÎCa?<;YV-Ë�ADNP\JXYZ�;YV¯XYC.V�ÍxV�NJÖ�=@N]A^U�V-ADQE\P9<U)AD\JXYZ�A^;Y;ÎÖBÑæ-=@\PV�N0\PHEXYR~RP\JV�Ë´Kt\PHEV.RJ9^=@\vÌ�A^NJV.Z�A^C:Z�ADNPNJÖ¶9<QE\�\PHEV�ADQE\P9<U)AD\JXYZ0V,Øz\PN]A^Z�\JXY9<C:9^=�\PHEV\JNTA �TV�Z�\P9<NPXÎV,R�Ñ�Þ-HaXÎR.RPV�U�X-ADQa\J9<U)AD\PXÎZ.UWV�\JHa9z`°Ì�A^R�QaRJV�` 9xC5\PHEV)`�AD\TA¶V�ØB\JN]A^Z�\JV,`=@NJ9xU·\JHaV~\PQENJCaXÎCa?.ËENJ9BZ�V�RPR0ADR-`EV�RPZ�NJXYÝ"V�`MXYCM[BV�Z�\PXY9<C �<Ñ �EÑ%�xÑ

Page 31: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �

;=< ;�� < � � L NX�L���A��?F�W(L=E(F�H�QYNæ¯R¯A�RPV�Z�9<Ca`MU�V�\PHE9B`tKEA�U+A^CBQ�AD;"\JNTADZ�XYCE?.UWV�\JHE9B`WÌ�A^R-QERJV�` \J9.V�ØB\JNTADZ�\�\PHEV�Ë�ADN�Û\JXYZ�;YV¯\PN]A ��V�Z�\J9xNJXYV�R�Ñ�Þ-HaXÎR2Ì-ADR-QERPV�`)XÎCWZ�ADRPV�R¯Ì-HaV�NJV0\PHEV�V�ØB\JNTADZ�\PXÎ9xC)9D=\PHEV�Ë�ADNP\JXYZ�;YV`EÖBC�ADUWXYZ�R$Z�9<QE;Y`WCE9<\2Ý�V69<ÝE\TADXYCEV�`)ADQE\P9<U)AD\JXYZ�A^;Y;ÎÖ�`EQaV¯\J9�9<Ëa\JXYZ�AD;"9<N2U+A^\JV�NPXcAD;E`EV�Û=@9<NPU+A^\JXY9<CWVTÙ²V,Z�\JR�Ñ$Þ-HEV�RJVW`�AD\TA�=@NJ9xUÜ\JHEV.`ENPXY;Î;YXYCE?WËENJ9BZ�V�RPR�K2Ó-RJV,V�[BV�Z�\PXÎ9xC �<Ñ �EÑ��xÔH�AD`)\P9.Ý�V�ËENJV,Ë�ADNPV�`MÌ-XY\JHM\PHEXYR2=@QE;Y;YÖ.U+A^CzQ"AD; U�V,\JHE9B`tKB`EQaV0\J9.\PHEV�RP\JNP9<CE?.`EV�=@9<N�ÛU+A^\JXY9<C.9^=�\PHEV0ZTHEXYËMÍx9<;YQEU�V,R�A^CE`)\JHEV0;Y9DÌ XYU+AD?xV¯NPV�RJ9x;ÎQa\JXY9<C)NJV,RJQE;Y\JXYCE?�=@NJ9xU&\PHEVHEXY?<H�=nN]ADUWV$N]AD\PVS9^=�\JHaVSUW9DÍzXYV�R�ÓßQEË�\J9 ' � � �2XYU+A^?<V�R Ë"V�N�RPV�Z�9<Ca`�Ô�KDRPV�V¯ä´XY?<QENPV �xÑ����EÑ

�� ��"ª �<ª�� �aª ¢$�zk-u�},fDwz},���jp�},fz},�jpD�]kTyW�v�<h�|�i�q,��wzu�kTmS¡�kPfzkPlJ}�ovkTy�h�f�on�Bk-yDlvh�����h�fz¡�|xlJqD�Tk]mvm �

¾�¿J¾g¾ ��à ���� � � �´Å �� 4�Ä�à � ����0Ä 2JÈJÇ 0&�?�2Ã�� � �BÈJÄ�Á

[BÖBU.Ý�9x;YXÎZ$NPV�?<NPV�RJRPXÎ9xC�ÍBXcA�?<V,CEV�\JXYZ-ËENP9<?xN]ADUWU�XYCE?2Ì�A^R�QERPV�`�\P90U�9B`EV�;B\PHEV¯ËEHBÖBRJXYZ�A^;Z�9<NPNJV�;cA^\JXY9<CERW\JH�A^\�QECa`EV�NJ;YXYVM\PHEV¸ËaNJ9BZ�V�RPRJV�RMRPHE9DÌ-C XYC [BV,Z�\JXY9<C �<Ñ �EÑgÞ-HEVMXYU�ËE;YVTÛU�V�CB\TAD\JXY9xC+9^=S\JHaV.?<V�CEV,\JXYZ�ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U�U�XYCE?�O<V,NJCEV�;gZ�9<CB\]A^XYCER�RJV�ÍxV�N]A^;SADRPË�V�Z,\JR�=@NJ9xUV�Í<9x;YQE\JXY9<C.RP\JNTAD\JV,?<XYV�R ���G'(�ADCa`+?xV�CEV�\PXYZ~ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U�U�XYCE? �%�I���A^R-ÌSV,;Î;vÑ

;=< ;=;Y<@; U W � �V F�D'�Þ-HEV2V�Í<9x;ÎQa\JXY9<C�RJ\TADNP\JR�Ì-XY\JH�A¯NTADCE`a9<U�;YÖ-?xV�CEV�NTAD\JV,`.RJV�\�9^=E=@QECaZ�\JXY9<CaR�ÓßXYCEXY\JXcAD;DË"9<ËEQ³Û;cAD\JXY9xC�Ô�Ñ �6QEV2\J96\JHEVg= ADZ,\\PH�AD\´\JHEV-AD;Y?x9<NJXY\PHEU H"ADR$\J96V�Í<9x;ÎÍxV�Ë�A^N]ADUWV�\JNPXYZ$=@QECEZ,\JXY9<CER�K\vÌS9)RPÖzU.Ý"9<;YXYZ0NPV�ËENJV,RJV�CB\]A^\JXY9<CaR.H�A�Í<V.\P9MÝ�VW?<V�CaV�N]A^\JV�`°XÎC:Ë"ADN]A^;Y;ÎV,; Ñ"Þ-HEVW?<V�CaV�\JXYZ9<Ë"V�N]A^\JXY9<CaR�A^NJV¸A^ËEËE;YXYV�`5\P9¸\PHEXYR�Ê�NJRP\�?<V,CEV�N]A^\JXY9<C°9D=�=@QECaZ�\JXY9<CaR�A^CE` AMRPQEZ�Z�V�V,`BÛXYCE?M?<V,CEV�N]A^\JXY9<C°XYR�ËENP9B`EQEZ�V�`´K¯ÓcRPV�V¸ä´XY?<QENPV:�xÑ � �<Ô,ÑtÞ-HEV�Ê�\JCaV�RJRW9D=~ADC°XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;XYR¯U�V�ADRJQaNJV�`M`aXÎNPV�Z�\P;ÎÖ ÝzÖ)V�Í<A^;YQ�AD\PXÎCa?.\JHEV�V�Í<9x;YÍ<V�`)=n9<NJU.Qa;�A^V0ADCE`MZ,9<U�Ë"ADNJXYCE?.\PHEV?<V�9xU�V�\PNJXYZ0RPH�ADË"V�9^=S\JHaV�RJVWË�ADNTADU�V,\JNJXYZ�=nQECEZ�\PXÎ9xCER�Ì-XY\JHM\PHEV�?xXYÍ<V�C¶Ë�9xXYCz\6RJV�\�X Ñ V<ÑYK\JHEVW\JNTA �TV�Z�\P9<NPÖã9^=¯\JHEV)ZTHEXYËtÑ$Þ$V�ZTHECEXYZ�A^;Y;ÎÖ¶\JHaV�=n9<NJU.Qa;�A^V�A^NJV)NJV,ËENJV�RPV�CB\JV�`±ADR�XYCBÛRJ\TADCEZ�V,R~9^=�A.\PNJV�V�Û Ý�A^RJV�`:`"AD\]A�RJ\PNJQEZ�\PQENJVxKtÌ-HEXYZTH¶XÎR6XYU�ËE;YV�UWV�CB\JV�`WXÎC ��0 0 QERJXYCE?\JHEV0[B\TADCE`"ADNJ`WÞ$V�U�ËE;cA^\JV¯Ò XYÝENTADNPÖ � � ���JÑDá6V�CEZ�V<K"\PHEV6Ê�\JCEV,RJR-=nQECEZ�\PXÎ9xC�Z�A^C�Ý"V�V�Í<AD;>ÛQ�AD\PV�`¬XYCãA¼= ADRP\�ADCE`°VTà�Z�XYV�CB\.Ì�A�ÖBÑ´Év\.XÎR�A^;YRJ9¶Ë�9xRJRJXYÝE;YV)\J9¶QERPV¸ADC°XÎCB\PV�NJËENPV�\JV,N�KÌ-HEXYZTH5U+A�Ö Ý�V)U�9xNJV�×�V,ØzXYÝE;YV)XYC5RP9<U�V.Z�ADRJV,R¸ÓcVxÑ ?"ÑYK =@9xN�`aV�ÝEQE?x?<XYCE?¶\]ADRPOBR]Ô�K$ÝaQE\

Page 32: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

�� ��ª �xª�� �aª �2kPfzkPlJ},��2­¸mv���zkTu�k �

RJ;Y9DÌ-R2`E9DÌ-C�\PHEV0V�Í<A^;ÎQ"AD\JXY9xCtÑ<Þ-HaV~RP\JNPQEZ�\JQaNJV�9D=\PHEV�ËENJ9x?<NTADU =@9x;Y;Î9DÌ-R2A�Ý�ADRPXÎZ0Ï0ÐRJZTHEV�UWV �%���EK%�!�aK������vÑBÞ-HEV.ËENJ9xÝ�ADÝaXÎ;YXY\vÖ�9^=�ZTHE9B9xRJXYCE?MA.Z�9xCERJ\TADCB\0`EQaNJXYCE?)U.QE\]A^\JXY9<C´K\JHEV�U)ADØBXYU�QEUâRJXYG�V�9D=�ADC)XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�AD;"9<N2\JHaV0ËENJ9xÝ�ADÝaXÎ;YXY\vÖ�9D=ZTH�A^CE?<XYCE?.A�=@QECaZ�\JXY9<C9<N¯A�\PV�NJUWXÎC"AD;tADCa`M\JHEV�CzQaU.Ý�V�N-9^=�Z]H"ADCE?xV�R¯XYR-`EVTÊ"CEV�`¶XÎCMA�Ë�ADNTADU�V,\JV�N2Ê�;YV<ÑaÞ-HEV`�AD\TA0RP\JNPQEZ�\JQaNJV.ADCE`)\JHaV~?xV�CEV�\PXYZ09<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xNJR¯Ì-XY;Y;"Ý�V0`aV�RJZ�NPXYÝ�V�` CEV�ØB\�Ñ

;=< ;=;Y<�> �RL�F�L � F�W(X,E(F�X�W(D

ÉvC�A^C�AD;Y9x?<Ö�\J9�\JHaV-XÎC³Ê�Ø�CE9<\TAD\JXY9xC�9^=�U+A^\JHEV�U)AD\PXÎZ�AD;�=@QECaZ�\JXY9<CaRSA6\JNJV,V-Ý�ADRPV�`.NJV�ËaNJVTÛRJV�CB\TAD\JXY9xC¯=n9<NJUWR�\PHEV�?xV�CE9<\vÖBË"V<Ñ�æ5RTADU�Ëa;ÎV´XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;vKPZ�9<CERPXYRJ\JXYCE?-9^=E\vÌS92=@QaCEZ�\JXY9xCER4 � Ó �]Ô¯ADCa` 4 � Ó �]Ô�K"XYR¯RJHa9DÌ-CMXYC¸ä´XÎ?xQENJVM�<Ñ�� �<ÑBÞ-HEV�ËENJXYU)ADNJÖW?<9BAD;t9^=S9<Ýa\]ADXYCEXYCE?.\PHEVU+A^\JHEV�U)AD\PXÎZ�AD;ENPV�ËENJV,RJV�CB\]A^\JXY9<CaR~9^=�\vÌS9^Û `EXYUWV�CERJXY9xC�AD;EZ,QENJÍxV�R�;ÎV�AD`ER-\P9.\JHEV0ËaHEV�CE9^Û\vÖBËEXYZSNPV�ËENJV,RJV�CB\]A^\JXY9<CW9D=tADC�XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;EADRg?<N]A^ËEHER�9^=ÕA6Ë�A^N]A^U�V�\PNJXYZ�=nQECEZ�\PXÎ9xCtÑ�Þ-HEXYR`EX>Ù²V,NJV�CEZ,V~Ý"V�\vÌ2V�V�CW?<V�CE9x\vÖBËEXYZ~ADCa`.ËEHEV�CE9x\vÖBËEXYZ-NJV�ËENPV�RJV,Cz\TAD\PXÎ9xCMADCE`.\PHEV¯CEV,V�`W=@9<N?<V�CaV�\JXYZ)9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xNJR�XYC¬Ì-HEXYZTH¬RJU+A^;Y;�ZTH�ADCE?xV�R�XYC¬\JHaV+?xV�CE9x\vÖzË"VMNPV�RJQE;Y\PR�XYC¬RJU+A^;Y;ZTH�ADCE?xV�R�XYCM\JHEV�ËEHEV,CE9<\vÖBË"V�ÖBXYV�;Y`ER�\vÌS9WËENJ9xÝE;YV�U�R�Ñ�ä´XYNJRP\~AWRJV�\�9^=S?<V�CaV�\JXYZ�9<Ë"V�N]A�Û\J9xNJR�Ì-HEXYZTH A^;Î;Y9DÌ-R6\J9MË"V�Nv=n9<NJU(\JHEV,RJV�RPU+A^;Î;´ZTH�ADCE?xV�R09xC¸\PHEV.?<V�Ca9<\vÖBË�V�U.QERP\~Ý"VQERJV,`tÑ[³V�Z�9<Ca`5AWÊ�\JCaV�RJR�=@QECEZ,\JXY9<C:Ì-HEXYZTH¶Z�9<NPNJV�Z�\P;YÖ:V�Í<AD;YQ�A^\JV�R0\PHEV.Ê"\JCEV�RPR�9^=�9xCEVXYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;EH"ADR-\J9.Ý"V0`EV�Ê�CEV�`tÑ

Page 33: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ ���

��� ��� ��� «��@®���B«��@®����«��n® �

mnh�f «�� �$�Tq�m�«������n®v®� � �������´mnh�f «c�Tq�m,«��@®�� � ���n® « ��� � ®

�� ��"ª��xª�� �<ª �D}�u6|<�jk2mvonlvwz�Tonw<lJk2q�r"}-mnh�fz¡,�jk2h�fzyDhji�hjyxwB}��t},fzy0on�Bk��Tq�lvlJkTmn|Eq,fzyDh�fB¡�rYw<fB�]onhjq,fzm �

;=< ;=;Y< � URD N�D F�H E�� �,D W(L�FIQYW�V

Þ-HEV0?xV�CEV�\PXÎZ�9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9<NPR0ADNJV�OBCE9DÌ-CMADR6U.QE\]A^\JXY9<C)ADCE`)NJV,Z�9<U.ÝEXYC�A^\JXY9<C´ÑEL)QE\]A^\JXY9<C\]A^O<V�R�ËE;cADZ,V09<C:A.RPXÎCa?<;YV0XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�AD;$ADCE` Z]H"ADCE?xV�R09<CaV09<N�U�9xNJV�Ë"9<RJXY\PXÎ9xCER�9D=S\PHEVXYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;vKDHEV,NJV<K A�RJXYCE?x;YV~Ca9z`aV09D=�\JHaV0\JNPV�V<Ñ"ÉvC)Z�9<CB\JNTADRP\~\P9.Z�;cADRPRJXYZ�AD;$Ï0Ð �����tXYCBÛCEV�N-CE9B`EV,R2Û�ADR-Ì2V�;Y;tADR-\PV�NJUWXÎC"AD;"CE9B`EV�R-Z�A^C+Ý"V�U.QE\]A^\JV�`WXYC�NJV�AD;vKEÍ<A^;ÎQaV¯RJ\PV�ËER�ÑEÉvCä´XÎ?xQENJV"�xÑ �S�0U.Qa\]AD\PXY9<C.XYR-XY;Î;YQERP\JNTAD\JV,`+ÝBÖ)A0RPXÎCa?<;YV�U.QE\]A^\JXY9<C�A^;E\JNPV�V�XÎCaRJV�NP\JXY9<C)9D=SA\JV�NPU�XYC�A^;ECE9B`EV0Ì-XY\JHWÍ<AD;YQEV �EÑBÞ$9�A^;Y;Î9D̬XYCERPV�NJ\PXÎ9xC�9^=CEV�Ì CE9B`EV�R6Ì-XY\JHE9xQE\SV,N]ADRPXYCE?9<;Y`EV�NgCE9B`EV�R2\JHEV-NTADCE`E9xU�;YÖ.Óc9xQE\�9D=A^;Y;EË�9xRJRPXÎÝa;ÎV-9xË�V,N]AD\P9<NPR]ÔgZ]Ha9<RJV,C�9<Ë"V�NTAD\J9xNSØ�06GÌ�A^RSXYCERPV�NJ\PV�`)\J9x?<V�\PHEV�N-Ì-XY\JHW\JHEV�CEV�Ì CE9B`EV<ÑBÞ-HEV�RJV,Z�9<CE`)?xV�CEV�\PXÎZ�9xË�V�NTAD\P9<N-XYRS\PHEVNJV�Z,9<U.ÝEXYC�A^\JXY9<CWÝ�V�\vÌ2V�V�C:\vÌ29MADNPÝEXY\JN]A^NJÖ)XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�AD;YR0ÓßRJV�V�ä´XY?<QENPV �xÑ�� �<Ô,ÑEÞ-HEV�?<V�ÛCEV�\PXÎZ6NJV�Z,9<U.ÝEXYC�A^\JXY9<C�9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xN-RJV�;YV�Z�\PR¯ADC)ADNJÝaXÎ\PN]A^NJÖ.CE9B`EV�XYC.\JHEV6Ê�NPRJ\2XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;ADCE`:NPV�ËE;cADZ,V�R�XY\0ÝBÖ:ADC5A^NJÝEXY\JNTADNPXÎ;YÖMRPV�;YV�Z�\PV�`¬CE9B`EV�=@NJ9xU \JHEVWRJV�Z�9xCE`5XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;vÑÞ-HEV�RPV.\vÌS9W?<V�CEV,\JXYZ.9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xNJR0AD;Y;Y9DÌçA.ZTH�A^CE?<V�XYC¸\PHEV�?xV�CE9x\vÖzË"V<K ÖBXYV�;Y`EXYCE?WRJU+A^;Y;ZTH�ADCE?xV�R.XYC5\PHEV)ËEHEV�CE9x\vÖBË�V)9D=�\JHEV)XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�A^; ÑÕÞ-HEVMADU�9xQECB\�9D=~ZTH�A^CE?<V)XYC5\PHEVËEHEV�Ca9<\vÖBË�V�Z�ADC)Ý"V0NJV�`aQEZ�V�`:ADCE`)XYCEZ�NPV�ADRPV�`MÝBÖ�RPV�\J\PXYCE?�\PHEV�ADUW9<QECB\�9^=�U.QE\]A^\JXY9<CÓcV<Ñ ?"ÑÎKxCBQEU.Ý"V�NS9^=�CE9B`EV�R-\J9.Ý"V0ZTHE9xRJV�C�Ô,Ñ

æ Z,;Î9xRJV�N6;Y9z9xO�AD\-\PHEV�RJV�9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9<NPR¯XYR-?<XYÍxV�C�XYC:� � �<K ���aK �G'�K ��� � Ñ;=< ;=;Y<�� �RD F�D W3� HKN�H V#FIH�E � Q=W(W(D�E(F�HKQ=N Q � F]\�D TUN,O H�J?H�O XL���V

ÉvC�9xNJ`EV,N�\J9�XYU�ËENP9DÍ<V$\JHaV-VTà�Z�XYV�CEZ�Ö�9D= \JHaV-C�ADXYÍ<V2ADËEËENP9zA^Z]H´KDRJ9xU�V2Í<ADNJXcA^\JXY9<CER´H�A�Í<VÝ�V,V�C)XÎUWËE;YV�U.V�CB\JV,` � ���#�JÑ<Þ-HEXYR2;YV�AD`ER2\J9.A6= A^RJ\PV�N¯AD`�A^ËE\JXY9xC.9D=\PHEV¯Z,QENJÍxV�R¯Ì-XY\JHa9<QE\AD`E`aXÎCa?�A^CzÖ.V,Øz\PN]A�OBCE9DÌ-;YV�`E?xV�\J9.\JHaVµA^;Y?<9<NPXY\JHEU¶Ñ

Page 34: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

�� ��ª �xª�� �aª ��wBov}�onhjq,fz},� h�fzmvkPlJonhjq,f+q,f�}6h�fzyDhji�hjy^wz},� �

�� ��"ª �xª � �aª � kT�Tq�u � h�fz}�onhjq,f¼q,r h�fzy^hji�hjyDwE},� � £$hjon�.h�fzy^hji�hjyDwB}�� �^�

�6QEV0\J9W\JHEV�= A^Z�\�\JH�A^\¯U+A^CBÖ�RJ9x;YQE\JXY9<CaR¯9D=�\PHEV�Ï�Ð A^;Î?x9<NPXÎ\PHEU·RPHE9DÌçRPH�ADË"V�R�\JH�A^\ADNPVSRPXÎUWXY;�A^N \J9�\JHaV-Z�9<NPNJV�Z�\2RJ9x;YQE\JXY9<C�ÝEQE\�`EX>Ù V�N�9xCE;YÖ~XYC�9<NPXÎV,Cz\TAD\PXÎ9xC�ADCa`.RJXYG�V<K<A6`EV�Û\JV�NPU�XYCEXYRJ\PXYZ~AD`"ADËE\TAD\JXY9xC�RJ\PV�ËMXYR2XÎCaRJV�NP\JV�`¶Ý�V,\vÌSV�V,CM\JHEV�U.QE\]A^\JXY9<C�A^CE`�\PHEV�Ê�\PCEV�RJRZ�AD;YZ�Qa;�A^\JXY9<C.9^=�\JHEV�XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�AD;vÑ

ätXYNPRJ\�K2A:\PN]ADCaRJ;cAD\PXÎ9xC¬Í<V�Z�\P9<NWXÎR.`aV�\JV�NPU�XYCEV�` ÝzÖ°ËE;cADZ�XYCE?:\PHEVMRP\]ADNP\JXYCE?°Ë�9xXÎCB\9D=0\JHaV¸XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�A^;¯AD\�\PHEV¶Ë�9xRJXY\JXY9<C 9D=0\JHEV Ê�NPRJ\)Ë�9xXYCz\W9D=�\PHEV¶\JN]A9�TV�Z�\P9<NJÖBÑ2Þ-HEV

Page 35: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �\JNTADCERP;�A^\JXY9<C�XYRSË"V�N�=@9<NPU�V�`.ÝBÖ.AD`E`EXYCE?�\J90V�A^ZTH�Ë"9<XYCB\�9D=t\PHEV¯?xV�CEV�\PXÎZ�AD;Y;YÖ�?xV�CEV�NTAD\JV,`=@QECEZ,\JXY9<CtÑ´ÉvCãA RJV,Z�9<CE`¬RP\JV�ËtK$\PHEV)XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;�Ì-XY;Y;2Ý�VWRJZ�A^;ÎV,`ã\P9¸\PHEV�RPXYG�V)9D=~\PHEV\JNTA �TV�Z�\P9<NPÖ�Z�QaNJÍ<VxÑBÞ-HEV-RJZ�A^;YXÎCa?~Í<A^;YQEV�RSA^NJV-`EV�\PV�NJUWXYCEV�`.ÝBÖ0RJV,\J\JXYCE?�\JHaV-U+ADØBXYU�A29D=\JHEV-XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;B\J9�\JHEV-RTADUWVSÍ<A^;ÎQaV�A^R�\JHEV-U)ADØBXYU+Ag9D= \JHEV6\JNTA �TV�Z�\P9<NPÖ�Ë"9<XYCB\JR�ÑDÞ-HEXYR;YV�AD`ER2\J9�Aµ= A^RJ\JV,N¯AD`�A^ËE\JXY9<CW9D=$\JHEV�Z�QENPÍ<V�R6Ì-XY\JHE9xQE\�A^`E`EXYCE?.ADCBÖ.V�ØB\JNTA�OBCE9DÌ-;YV�`E?<V\J9�\JHEV�AD;Y?<9xNJXY\JHEU¶Ñ

;=< ;=;Y< � � X��KFIH � � ��D�E(F�H�JYD � HKFIN�D�VIV � X�N,E(F�H�QYNá¯V�NPV�ÓnätXY?xQENJV �EÑ��('BÔ�A�U.QE;Y\JX>Ûv9<Ý��TV,Z�\JXYÍ<VgÊ�\PCEV�RJR2=nQECEZ�\PXÎ9xC.\JH�A^\SZ,9<U�Ë"ADNJV,R�\JHEV�=@QECEZ�Û\JXY9<C¶Í<AD;YQEV,R~9^=¯\JHEV.XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;$Ì-XÎ\PH¸Z,9<NJNPV�RJË"9<Ca`EXYCE?¸Ë"9<XYCB\JR�9D=-\JHEVW\JN]A9�TV�Z�\P9<NJÖ:XYRQERJV,`tÑtÉn=~A^;Y;�Ë�9xXYCz\PR09D=¯\PHEV�\PN]A ��V�Z�\J9xNJÖ:;YXYV.9<C:\PHEV.=@QaCEZ�\JXY9xC:ËE;Y9<\0\PHEXYR0XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;Ì-XY;Î;$NPV�ËENJV,RJV�CB\+A¼Ë�V�N�=@V�Z�\.RP9<;YQE\PXÎ9xC:\J9M\PHEV�ËaNJ9<Ýa;ÎV,U¸Ñ"Þ-HEV.Ê"\JCEV�RPR.Í<AD;YQEV�R�Ì-XÎ;Y;�Ý"VNJV�ËaNJV�RPV�CB\JV�`)ÝBÖ�A6ÌSV,XÎ?xHB\JV�`.Ë"9<XYCB\vÛv\J9^Û Í<A^;ÎQaV�`EXYRJ\TADCEZ�V-RPZTHEV�U�V0Ó/�<Ñ �<Ô,KDADCE`.\PHEV�Ö�Ì-XÎ;Y;Ý�V�RPQEU�UWV�`.QEË)ÝBÖ+A�NJ9B9<\-UWV�ADCWR]�BQ�ADNPV�RJQEU¶Ñ

� � � ��� ������ �$���

«� � ���� ® « ��� ��®

�� ��ª �xª�� �"ª ¢$�Bk2wzmvkTy�|Eq�h�f<o2ovq�i�}���wBk¯y^hjmvov}�fB�]k�mv���zkTu�k �

;=< ;=;Y< � �-D H�[ \ FIHKN�[MF]\�D �?H �SD Q���F�\ D TUN,O HKJ?H O X�L���VÉvCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�AD;YR0XYC°?<V�CEV,\JXYZ)ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�UWXÎCa?�Z�A^Cã?xNJ9DÌ·ÍxV�NJÖ°N]A^ËEXY`E;YÖ �%�I�aK%�!���JÑ Þ-HaXÎR.XYRNJVT=nV�NJNPV�`¸ADR2Z�9B`EV�ÝE;Y9zA^\�A^CE`�Z�ADC�Ý"V�9<ÝERPV�NJÍxV�`MXYC�;YXYCEV�A^NS?xV�CEV�\PXYZ~ËaNJ9<?xN]A^U�U�X>CE?¯9xNXYC¸\PNJV�VTÛvÝ�A^RJV�`°?<V�CEV,\JXYZ�ËENP9<?xN]ADUWU�X>CE?�Ñ��6Q�A^`EN]A^\JXYZ �%�!���-ADCE`¶V�ØBË�9xCEV�CB\JXcA^;S?xNJ9DÌ-\JHADNPV�`E9BZ�QEUWV�CB\JV�` ���S���JÑTÞ$9¯RJ\P9<Ë0XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;YR"=@NJ9xU ?xNJ9DÌ-XYCE?¯ADCa`0\JHBQER�K�=nNJ9<U±RP;Y9DÌ-XÎCa?`E9DÌ-C)\JHEV�V�Í<AD;YQ�A^\JXY9<CtKEA^C)V�ØB\JN]A�ÌSV,XÎ?xHB\JXYCE?�=@QECEZ�\PXY9<CMXYR-XYCERJV,NJ\JV,`¸XYCB\J9.\PHEV�Ê�\PCEV�RJR=@QECEZ,\JXY9<CtÑ´F29<\JH Ê�\JCaV�RJRWÍ<AD;YQEV�R�Kt\PHEV�Ì2V�XY?<HB\JV,`ãË"9<XYCB\0\P9¸Í<A^;ÎQaV.`EXYRJ\]A^CEZ�V)RJZTHEV,U�VÓ]�xÑ �xÔSA^CE`�\PHEV0Ì2V�XY?<HB\JV,`+CBQEU.Ý"V�N29D=$CE9B`EV�R�K A^NJV�Z�9<U.ÝaXÎCaV�`BÛ �xÑ �

� * # � *� +���� * � � ��� � (�� # ��& ��� � Ó/�<Ñ �<Ô

Page 36: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

�� ��"ª��xª�� �aª �YfByDhji�hjy^wz},�k �Donlvwzyxk]y�h�f�}�mn|B}��TkP�@onhju�k6|<�jq�o �

� * # � *� +� ��� �$� %�� Ó &

(2��� & Ô ��� � (ãÓPÓJÓ � Ô�(ãÓ � & ÔJÔ � Ô ��� � Ó/�<Ñ �<Ô

-t§ .1032 �<ª��aª ¢$�Bk2|z},lJ}�u�kTovkPlJmS},lJk2�zkPlJk �|z},lJ}�u�kTovkPl y<kTmv�Plvh�|zonhjq,f

��� yDhjmvov},fz�Tk6£kPhj¡,�<o ��� � �� � fDwzu � kJl2q�r fBqDy<kTmS£$kPhj¡,�<o � � � � fDwzu � kJl2q�r fBqDy<kTmSq,rt},f�h�fByDhji�hjyDwE},��� � �

� kTmvonhju�}�ovkTy.q,|zonhju�}�� fDwBu � kPlSq,r fzqDy<kTm � � �

Þ-HEVMV�RP\JXYU+A^\JV�`¬CBQEU.Ý"V�N�9^=µCa9z`aV�R)XÎR�A^`E`EV�` \J9:\PHEV =@QECEZ�\PXY9<C \P9¶=@9<NPZ�V¸\PHEVRJ9x;ÎQa\JXY9<C¬XYCB\J95\PHEV¶?<;Y9<Ý�A^;¯9xËE\JXYU.QEUMÑ´Þ$95Í<V,NJX>=@Ö¬\JHEXYRWËENJ9BZ�V�`aQENJV¬A:RJV,\+9^=�\JV,RJ\JRH�A�Í<VWÝ�V,V�C Z�A^NJNJXYV�`¬9xQE\�Ñ$Þ-HEV,RJVM\PV�RJ\PR�H�A�ÍxV+Ý"V�V�C¬Ë"V�Nv=n9<NJUWV�`¬\J9¶`EV�\PV�NJUWXÎCaV+\PHEVRJQBà�Z,XÎV,Cz\�Ì2V�XY?<HB\JXYCE?M9^=~AMËaQECEXYRJHEUWV�CB\09D=~A CE9B`EVWZ�9<QECB\�Ñ$Þ-HEV�NPV�RJQE;Y\PR�9D=¯\PHEV�RPV\JV�RP\JR�ADNJV�RPHE9DÌ-C)XÎC)[BV�Z�\PXY9<C$�xÑ����EÑ �EѾ�¿J¾ � à � ���¯ÈPÇ?� 2 0&� �¯Ã�� � �´Á�Â��´ÂEÈJÄ�Á

�6QEV�\J9.\JHaV�= ADZ,\-\JH�A^\-Z]Ha9z9xRJXYCE?.\PHEV0NJXY?xHz\-Ë"ADN]A^U�V�\PV�NJR2=n9<N-RJV,\J\JXYCE?.Qa˸A�=vADRJ\�ADCE`R]A�=@V�NPV�Z�9<CaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xC 9^=~\PHEV)V�RJ\PXÎU)AD\PV�`°=@QECEZ�\PXY9<CER�XYR.`EX>à�Z�QE;Y\�K�A CEV�̺?<NTADËEHEXYZ�A^;NJV�ËaNJV�RPV�CB\]AD\PXY9<C 9^=µA Z�9<UWËE;YV�\JV)Ï0бNPQEC¬Ì�A^R.`EV�Í<V,;Î9xË�V,`tÑ$ÉvC¬9<NJ`aV�N.\J95A^;Î;Y9DÌ·ADC9DÍ<V�NPÍBXÎV,̱9D=�\JHEV�Ì-HE9x;ÎV�Z]HaNJ9<Ca9<;Y9<?xÖ�9D=2\JHEV0NPV�Z�9xCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<C:ËENP9zZ,V�RJR � � ���JKEA.\PHEXYNJ``EXYU�V�CaRJXY9<C¶Ì�A^R�AD`E`aV�`¬\J9¶\JHEV)\vÌ29:`EXYU�V�CERPXY9<CER�Ó�=@QECEZ,\JXY9<C°Í<AD;YQEV�R.9^= 4���Ó �]Ô.ADCE`

Page 37: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �

4��EÓ��]ÔPÔ-9D=�\PHEV0Z�QENPNJV�CB\�Ý"V�RJ\6XÎCa`EXYÍzXY`EQ"AD; 9D=�\PHEV0NJQaC5ÓcRPV�V�ä´XY?<QENPV �<Ñ�� �xÔ�ÑBÞ-HEXYR-\PHEXYNJ``EXYU�V�CaRJXY9<C)XYR�\JHEV�XYCE`EV�ØMXYC¶\JHEV�9<NP`EV�N09^=S\JHaV�ADNJNPXYÍ<AD;t9^=�\PHEV�Ý�V�RP\0XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�AD;YR6XÎC\JHEV�NJV,Z�9<CERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCtÑ Þ-HEXYR�XYR~ADZTHEXYV�ÍxV�`¶ÝzÖ `EQEU�ËaXÎCa?�A^;Î;$Ý"V�RJ\�XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�A^;ÎR-XYCM\PHEXYRZ�QENPNJV�CB\¯NPQECtK"9<NP`EV�NPV�`MÝBÖ)\JHEV0\PXYU�V¯9^=�\JHEV�XYN¯A^ËEË�V�ADN]A^CEZ�V<ÑÕÞ-HEV�NJV�=@9<NPV<K A�RJ\]A^CE`�A^NJ`�2æ �âÛ]�2æ~L Ê�;YV�=@9<NPU+A^\¯Ì-ADR0QERPV�`tÑ$Þ-HEXYR0RP\JV�NPV�9¶;ÎXY\PHE9<?xN]ADËaHzÖ°Ó@[BÞ¯Ò´Ô6=@9<NPU+A^\~XYRÌSV,;Î;$`EV�Ê�CEV�`¬ADCE`:Z�A^C:Ý�V.QaRJV�`:XYC¶Í<ADNJXY9xQER1�2æ � Û �2æ�L�RPÖzRP\JV�UWR09<N�Z�9<UWËEQE\JV,NvÛ?<NTADËEHEXYZ�RPÖBRJ\JV,U�R�Ñ�Þ-HEXYR$9<Ë"V�CER$Í<A^NJXY9<QER´Ë�9xRJRPXÎÝaXÎ;YXY\JXYV�RÕ=@9<N´NJV�Ca`EV�NJXYCE?0A^CE`0;cAD\PV�N$QER]A^?<V9D=¯\PHEV)?<V�CEV,N]AD\PV�`¬9<Ý��TV,Z�\JR�Ñ�Þ-HEVW`�AD\TAMXYR�?<V�CEV,N]AD\PV�`¬ÝBÖ:ÝEQEXY;Y`EXYCE?)\JNJXcA^CE?<;YV�R�\JH�A^\H�A�Í<VW\vÌS9¶9D=�\JHEV,XÎN�Í<V,NJ\JXYZ�V,R�XYC5\vÌ29¸Z,9<CERPV�Z�QE\PXÎÍxVMË"9<XYCB\JR.9D=¯9xCEV)XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;-ADCE`9<CEV�Í<V,NJ\JV,ظXYC:ADCE9x\JHEV�N�CEV,XÎ?xHBÝ�9xNJXYCE?�XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;vÑEÞ-H�A^\~XYR�K�9xCEV.\JNPXcADCE?x;ÎV�Z�9<CERPXYRJ\JR9D=�\JHEV)Ë"9<XYCB\JR ���5 �]� � ��A^CE` ���5 � � � 0 �U�¯XYC¬\JHaV+XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;SXYCE`aXÎZ�AD\JV,`ãÝBÖ&5/ADCE`)A�\JHEXYNP`+Ë"9<XYCB\3���5/ ( �U�]� � � XYC+A�RJV,Z�9<CE` XÎCa`EXYÍzXY`EQ"AD;"XÎCa`EXYZ�AD\PV�`�ÝBÖ 5 ( �xÑBÉv\XYR09<ÝBÍBXY9<QER�\JH"AD\�K´XYC:9<NP`EV�N�\J9M?xV�\�A)Z�;Y9xRJV�`°RJQEN�= ADZ�VxK$\JHEV�=@9<;Y;Y9DÌ-XYCE?�\PNJXcADCE?x;YV�H�A^R\vÌS9¶Ë"9<XYCB\JR.XYC¬\JHEVMXYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;SXYCE`aXÎZ�AD\JV,`ãÝBÖ&5/ ( �xKSA^;Î;-\PHENJV,VMË�9xXYCz\PR�=@9<N.\PHEXYRXYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD; ADNPV ���5 ( �U�]� � �JK����5 ( �U�]� � 0 �#��A^CE` ���5 �]� � 10 �U�JÑBÞ-HEXYR-RJZTHEV,U�VXYR-RJHE9DÌ-C)XYC+ä´XY?<QENPV �<Ñ����aÑ<ÉvC¸ä´XY?<QaNJV"�<Ñ�� ��A�R]A^U�ËE;YV6NJV�CE`aV�NJXYCE?W9D=RPQEZTH¸A�ËE;Y9<\-XYR

�� ��"ª �xª�� �aª ¢$�zk-mv���zkTu�k2rcq�lSon�Bk-onlvhj}�fB¡�wx�j}�onhjq,fM}�ogo@£$q�onlvhj}�fB¡��jkTm �

RJHE9DÌ-C´Ñ<Þ-HEV�NPV�CE`EV�NPXYCE?.Ì�A^RSZ�ADNJNPXYV�`)9<QE\2QERJXYCE?.A�\JHEXYNJ`WË�ADNP\vÖ.RJ9^=@\vÌ�A^NJV6Z�AD;Y;YV�`�� �Ú$ØBËE;Y9<NTAD\JXY9xC)=@NJ9xU ��XÎ?xHB\JHEV�UWXYRJËEHEV,NJV<K"ÉvCEZ<ÑÕÞ-HEV.\JXYU�V,;ÎXYCEV�?x9zV,R�=@NJ9xU�;YVT=@\.ÓßÝ�ADZTOEÔRJXY`EV.9^=¯\JHEV�Ê�?<QENPV�\P9)Ê�C�A^;SRP\]AD?xV+A^\0\JHEVWNJXY?<HB\0H"ADCE`BÛvRJXY`EVMÓ�=@NJ9xCB\]Ô�Ñ´ÉvC5\PHEXYR�Ê�C�A^;RJ\TAD?<V-\PHEV�XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;BH�A^RSNPV�ADZTHEV�`MA6Ê"\JCEV�RPR-9D= � � � �EÑ ! CEV�\JHEXYCE?�\JH�A^\�Z�ADCWÝ�V6RJV�V,C=@NJ9xU±\JHEXYR$ËEXYZ�\PQENJV-XYRt\PH�AD\$9xCE;YÖ�A-RPU+AD;Y;xCzQaU.Ý�V�N´9D= RJ\PV�ËER�XYR$CEV�V�`aV�`.\J9�NJV,Z�9<CERP\JNPQEZ�\\JHEV�?<V,CEV�N]A^;�RJH"ADË"V.9D=S\PHEV.XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;$ADCE`¶\JH�A^\0A�=@\PV�N�\JHEXYR�ËEH�A^RJV�\JHEV�A^;Î?x9<NPXÎ\PHEUÝ�V,H�A�Í<V�R-UW9<NPV¯;YXYO<V~A^C)V�Í<9x;ÎQa\JXY9<CWRJ\JNTAD\PV�?<Ö � �G'(� =@9xNSNPV�ADZTHEXYCE?.\PHEV�Ê�C"AD; RJH"ADË"V<Ñ

Page 38: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

¾�¿J¾). 0&� �BÆ 2� �:Ä 4+Â���� ���� �tÃEÁ � 2;=< ; � <@; D�V F � X�N EGFIHKQYN

ÉvC�\PHEXYRSZ�A^RJV0A�OzCa9DÌ-C.=@QECaZ�\JXY9<CMÓ/�<Ñ%�!�xÔ�Ì-ADR2QERPV�`)XÎC.9xNJ`EV,N-\J9�XÎ;Y;YQERP\JN]A^\JV6\JHEV�9<Ë"V�N�ÛAD\PXÎ9xC�9^=\JHaV~RPÖBU.Ý�9x;ÎXYZ-NPV�?<NPV�RJRPXÎ9xC A^;Y?<9<NPXY\JHEU

� Ó �]Ô,+ 4 � Ó��]Ô4 � Ó��]Ô � + RPXÎC´Ó��I�� � � �]Ô � �I �Z�9xR�Ó��I�� � � �]Ô � �I � � Ó]�xÑ����<Ô

Ñ�Þ-HEV2RJH"ADË"VS9^=�\JHEV2?<NTADËEH�9D= � Ó��]ÔÕNJV�RPV�U.ÝE;YV�R�A-ZTHEXYËtÑ�Þ-HEV2Í<AD;YQEV�R´9D=�\PHEV2Ë�ADNTADU�V,\JV�N�0N]ADCa?<VW=@NJ9xU �)\J9 ��� �EÑ$äE9xN�RPXÎU.Qa;�A^\JXY9<C ËEQENJË"9<RPV�R.\JHaXÎR�=@QECaZ�\JXY9<C°Ì�A^R�RTADUWËE;YV�`ÖBXÎV,;Î`aXÎCa?-`EXYRJZ�NPV�\JV6Ë�9xXÎCB\PR�KDÌ-HEXYZTH�NJV�ËENPV�RJV,Cz\2Ë"9<XYCB\JR$\JH�A^\$Z�9<QE;Y`�H�A�Í<V2Ý"V�V�C�RTADUWËE;YV�`=@NJ9xU&AµÊ�;YU·RJV �BQEV,CEZ�V<Ñ Þ-HaV¯Ê"C�AD;´RJ\]A^?<V�9D=$\JHEV�NJV�Z�9xCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<CtK"\PHEV0ËE;Y9<\-ADCa`+\PHEV?<NTADËEH¶9D=S\PHEV.Ý"V�RJ\�XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;vKEXYR�RJHa9DÌ-C¸XYC:ätXY?xQENJV �xÑ � �EÑaÉvC:RJËEXY\JV.9^=SÌ2V�XY?<HB\JXYCE?

�� ��"ª �xª � �aª ¢$�zk2½xfz},�tmvov}�¡�k-q,rton�zk2lJkT�Tq�fBmvonlvwz�Tonhjq�f)q�rton�Bk-ovkTmvo$rYw<fz�Tonhjq,f �

\JHEV.;YV�Ca?<\JH¶9D=-\JHaV.XÎCa`EXYÍzXY`EQ"AD;$XYC¸\PHEV�Ê�\JCaV�RJR�Z�AD;YZ�Qa;�A^\JXY9<C´K�\PHEV.NJV,;�A^\JXY9<C =@QECaZ�\JXY9<CÓ]�xÑ��S��Ô69D=¯\PHEV)Ý�V,RJ\�XÎCa`EXYÍzXY`EQ"AD;SA�=@\JV�N�\JHaXÎR�NJV,Z�9<CERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCãZ,9<CB\]A^XÎCaR�UW9<NJV.Ca9z`aV�R\JH�A^C�\PHEV09<NPXY?<XYC�AD;a=@QECaZ�\JXY9<C¶Ó]�xÑ����<Ô,Ñ

� Ó �]Ô,+� � � �������� ���������� �� ��� � ���F�� ��� _���� �! � #" �Z�9xR�Ó � � � ��� I �! !� � _ �� �$� %#%� � Ô � ��� ��� � �!� � RPXÎC´Ó@' � � � ��� �<Ô � �

�� � " � �'& Ó]�xÑ��S��Ô

æ-=@\PV�N�\PHEVMNPV�RJQE;Y\PXÎCa?¶=@QECEZ�\PXY9<C H�A^R.Ý�V,V�C RPXYU�ËE;YX>Ê�V�`°ÝzÖ°H�ADCa` Ó/�<Ñ%�I�xÔ�XY\.Z�ADC Ý"VRJV�V,C+\PH�AD\-\PHEV�NJV�A^;tRP\JNJQaZ�\JQENPV�9^=\PHEV�RJV�A^NJZTHEV�`MNPV�;cAD\PXÎ9xC.=@QaCEZ�\JXY9xC+XYRg=@9<QaCE`�ÝBÖ�\PHEVAD;Y?<9xNJXY\JHaU¸ÑxÞ-HEXYR~Ý"ADRJXYZ�RJ\PNJQEZ�\PQENJV.Z�ADC¶Ý�V.QERPV�` =@9<N6=@QENP\JHEV,N~V,Øz\PN]A^Ë�9x;�A^\JXY9<CaR�Ñ"Þ-HEVNJV�`aQEZ�V�`)=n9<NJU XÎR

4 � Ó �]Ô4 � Ó��]Ô + RPXYCtÓ/� � � �!� � � �]Ô � � � � � � �S� �Z�9xRDÓ/� � � �!� � � �]Ô � � � � �%�!� � � � Ó]�xÑ����<Ô

Page 39: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �

æ¯CE9x\JHEV,N0Ì�A�Ö¶\J9¶ADC�A^;ÎÖBG�V�\JHaV�Ý"V�H�A�ÍBXY9<N09^=�\PHEV�Ë"9<ËEQa;�A^\JXY9<C¶XYR0\J9 RJ\J9xNJV)A�RPC�AD˳ÛRJHE9x\�9^=~\PHEV�Ì-HE9x;YV�Ë"9<ËEQE;cA^\JXY9<C:XYCB\J9¶9<CEV�Ê�?<QaNJV<Ñ$æ6;Î;-XYCE`aXÎÍBXY`EQ�A^;YRµA^NJV)RJ9xNJ\PV�`¬XÎC9<NP`EV�N¯9^=�\JHEV�XYN�Ê�\JCEV,RJR�Í<AD;YQEV�R6\J9.V�C"ADÝE;YV�A�Z�;Y9xRJV�N�;Y9B9<O+A^\-\JHEV�ËENJ9x?<NJV,RJRJXY9xC¸9^=�\PHEVRJ9x;ÎQa\JXY9<CMÌ-XY\PHEXYC¸\PHEV.Ì-HE9<;YV�Ë�9xËEQE;cAD\PXY9<CtÑ ä´XY?<QENPV �xÑ � �.RPHE9DÌ-R0RJQaZ]H5AWËE;Y9x\~9^=�\PHEVNJV�Z,9<CERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<C:9^=S\JHaV�\PV�RJ\6=@QECaZ�\JXY9<C¶AD\�Ë�ADNP\JXYZ�QE;cA^N¯\JXYUWV�R¯9^=S\JHEV�NJV,Z�9<CERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCËENJ9BZ�V,RJR�ÑBÞ�A^ÝE;YV1�<Ñ ��RJHa9DÌ-RS\PHEV¯Ë�A^N]A^U�V�\PV�NJRg=@9<Ng\JHEXYR2\JV�RP\SNPQECtÑBÉv\�Z�A^C�Ý"V¯RPV�V�C)\JH�A^\`EQEV.\P9+\PHEV+A^ËEËE;YXYZ�AD\PXY9<CM9^=�A:Ó�� 0��"ÔnÛvRJV,;ÎV,Z�\JXY9<C°RJ\PN]AD\PV�?<Ö:\TADOxV�CM=nNJ9<U(V�Í<9x;YQE\JXY9<CRJ\PN]AD\PV�?<XYV�R ���('(�tXYCM\PHEV0NPV�?<NPV�RJRPXÎ9xC¸ËaNJ9BZ�V�RPR�K \PHEV0Ý"V�RJ\�XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�AD;"ËENP9<Ë�A^?zAD\PV�R¯ÍxV�NJÖ= ADRP\�\JHaNJ9<Qa?<H�\PHEV¯Ì-Ha9<;YV-Ë�9xËEQE;cAD\PXY9<CtÑDÞ-HaV¯QERPV~9^=A�\vÖBË�V69D=A�Ë�ADNTAD;Y;YV�;EU.QE;Y\PXEË�9xËBÛQE;cAD\PXÎ9xC:RJ\PN]AD\PV�?<Ö°U+A�Ö¶;YV�AD`°\J9:A¶HEXY?<HEV�N�?<V,CEV�\JXYZM`aXÎÍxV�NJRPXY\vÖ ÓcRJV,V¸[BV�Z�\PXY9<C-�<Ñ%� 'BÔ�Ñ

-´§/.1032 �xª��Eª ­ }�lJ}�u�k]ovkPlSov} � �jk�rcq�lSy^hji�kPlJmnhjonp.ovkTmvo �i�},��wzk6|B}�lJ}�u�k]ovkPl� � � 7gwzu � kPlSq,r |z},lJkPf<ovm�|EkPlS¡�kPfzkPlJ}�onhjq,f �� � � 7gwzu � kPlSq,rt�v�xh��jyDlJkPf�|EkPlS¡�kPfzkPlJ}�onhjq,f �� � � � �-» kJhj¡,�<o2q�rton�Bk2fzqDy<k6�Tq�wxf<o$½zonfBk]mvm2ovq�q�i�kJlJ},��� ½zonfBkTmvm �� » kJhj¡,�<o2q�rton�Bk-yDhjmvov},fz�Tk-½BonfzkTmvmSovq�q�i�kPlJ}���� ½BonfzkTmvm �� � �´mvonhju~}�ovkTy � k]mvo�fzqDy<k6�Tq�wxf<o�h�f.on�<hjmglJkT�]q,fzmvonlvwB�Tonhjq�f �

Page 40: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

�� ��"ª��xª�� �Eª ¢$�Bk�|Eq,|<wx�j}�onhjq,f+}�o$yDh�¹EkPlJkJf<o2¡�kJfBkPlJ}�onhjq,fzm2q�r on�zkglJkT�Tq�fBmvonlvwz�Tonhjq�f � �t}��v��|<hj�P�onw<lJk-mn�Bq�£�m-q,fzk¯�Tq�u6|<�jkTovk6|³q,|<wx�j}�onhjq,f¸}�o�yDhjmv�PlJkTovk�i�},��wzkTm-q�r$on�zkPh�l-q�i�kPlJ},���t½BonfzkTmvm � ¢$�zkh�fzy^hji�hjyDwz},�Îm.},lJk�mvq�lJovkTy¶}��T�Tq�lJy^h�fz¡MovqWon�zkPh�l0½BonfzkTmvm�rYlJq�u �jq�£$kPl0½zonfBkTmvm~}�o0on�Bk0�jkPrco�ovq¡�lJkT}�ovkPl�½zonfBk]mvm2}�o�on�zk2lvhj¡,�<oSmnhjyxk¯q,rton�zk���s mn�z},|EkTm � s�wxlvh�fz¡�on�zk-mvov},lJonh�fz¡�|x�z}�mvk¯£$�BkJlJk�jq�£ ½zonfzkTmvm�i,}���wBk]mg}�|x|³kT},l�}¯mvonlJq,fz¡¯y^hji�kPlJmnhjonp0q,r²on�Bk$h�fzy^hji�hjy<wB}��Ym�h�f.on�zk�|³q,|<wx�j}�onhjq,f+�T},f� k~q � mvkPlJi�kTy ��» hjon�)h�fz�PlJkT}�mnh�fB¡W½zonfzkTmvm6i�}���wBkTm¯on�zk6|Eq,|<w<�j}�onhjq,f¸�jqDq�mvkTm-hjovm-yDhji�kPlJmnhjo@p � �goon�<hjm�mvov}�¡�k0on�Bk�u�},h�fMlJkT�Tq�fBmvonlvwz�Tonhjq�f5£$q,lv��hjm6|EkPlvr�q,lJu�kTy � p)i�}�lvhj}�onhjq,f q,r�on�Bk0mnhju6h��j}�lh�fzy^hji�hjyDwz},�Îm �

Page 41: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ �x�

;=< ; � <�> �"D L�� �-Q=W3��O �RL�FILæ-=@\PV�N.\JHaVMÍ<V�NPX>Ê�Z�AD\PXY9<C¬9D=0\JHaV¸Ï0ÐâRJZTHEV�UWV)QERJXYCE?5A¶OBCE9DÌ-C¬\JV,RJ\.=nQECEZ�\PXÎ9xCtK�\PHEVAD;Y?<9xNJXY\JHaUçXYR¯ADËEËa;ÎXYV�`W\J9�`�AD\TA0V,Øz\PN]A^Z�\JV�`¼=@NJ9xU&A�Ê";ÎUWV�`.RJV9�zQaV�CEZ�V�9D=t\PHEV0\JQaNJCEXYCE?ËENJ9BZ�V,RJR�K A^R¯`EV�RPZ�NJXYÝ"V�`¶XÎCM[BV,Z�\JXY9<C �<Ñ%�!�aÑBÞ9.?xV�\¯XYCB=n9<NJU)AD\PXÎ9xC�A^Ý�9xQE\¯\PHEV0ËEHBÖBRJXYZ�A^;Z�9<NPNJV�;cA^\JXY9<CER�\JH"AD\�;ÎV�AD`:\J9¶\JHaV+RPH�ADË"V�9^=~\PHEV�ZTHEXYË5XYC:\PHEV)\JQENPCEXYCE?MËENP9zZ,V�RJR�KS\PHEVË�9xRJXY\JXY9xCER 9D=�\PHEV2Z]HaXÎË�ADNJV2U+A^CBQ�AD;Y;YÖSRPV�?<UWV�CB\JV�`WÓcRJV,V¯ätXY?xQENJV��xÑ�� �<Ô,Ñ ! CEV�`aXjÙ V�NPV�CEZ�V

� ��"ª �xª�� �Eª �.},fDwz},���jp�onlJ}��Tk]y�|z},lJonhj�P�jk��zq�£ «Y|<hj�Tonw<lJk6mnhj�]kQ� ��u�u � p � ��u~u0® �XYC+\PHEV�ËENJV�Z,V�`EXYCE?M\PV�RJ\6=@QECaZ�\JXY9<C XÎR�\PHEV�;cA^Z]OW9D=SOBCE9DÌ-;YV�`a?<V09^=S\JHEV�V�ØEADZ,\~CBQEU.Ý"V�N9D=�CE9B`EV�R�CEV�V�`EV,`:\J9�9xÝE\]A^XYC¸A.?x9z9B`MUW9B`EV�;$9D=�\JHaV.ËEHBÖzRPXYZ�AD;$ËENP9zZ,V�RJR�ÑtÞ-HEV,NJVT=@9xNJV<K\JHEV.CBQEU.Ý"V�N69D=-CEV�Z�V�RPR]A^NJÖ5Ca9z`aV�R0H�A^R0\J9)Ý"V.V�RJ\PXÎU)AD\PV�`tK ADCE`5A^R0A�Z,9<CERPV �BQEV�CEZ�VxK\JHEV�Ì2V�XY?<HB\JXYCE?µ= ADZ�\P9<N-9^=\JHaV~CBQEU.Ý"V�N29D=$CE9B`EV�R-XYC�\PHEV�Ê�\PCEV�RJR6Z�AD;YZ�Qa;�A^\JXY9<C.H"AD`)\J9Ý�V�NPV�`EQEZ�V,`tÑEÞ-HEV�Ë�A^N]A^U�V�\PV�NJR2=@9xNS\PHEV�V�RJ\PXYU+AD\PV�`�Ý"V�RP\-CE9B`EV�Z�9<QECB\¯A^NJV�XYCEZ�NJV�ADRJV,`\J9 � � CE9B`EV�R�K�ADCE`¬\JHaV¼A�ÍxV�N]A^?<VWXÎCaXÎ\PXcAD;2RJXYG�V)9D=�\JHEV)XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�AD;YR�XYR.XYCEZ�NJV�ADRJV,` \J9� ��CE9B`EV�R�Ñ"Þ-HEV,NJVT=@9xNJV<K´\JHaV�NPV�RJQE;Y\PXÎCa?+NPV�;cAD\PXÎ9xC)=@QECaZ�\JXY9<CaR�Ó]�xÑ%�!�<Ô6ADNPV�CE9x\~A^R~RPHE9<NP\ADCE`)H�A^CE`EÖMADR-\PHEV�NJV�RPQE;Y\JR6=@NJ9xU&\PHEV0\PV�RJ\6=@QECaZ�\JXY9<C´Ñ�ä´XY?<QENPV��xÑ � ��RJHa9DÌ-R¯\JH"AD\¯\PHEVAD;Y?<9xNJXY\JHaU H�A^RA6\JV,CE`EV�CEZ,Ö�\P9~RPU�9B9<\PH�\JHEV2\JNTA �TV�Z�\P9<NPXÎV,R�ÑxÞ-HEV�A^ËEËENP9DØzXYU)AD\JXY9xCER�Z�ADCÝ�V�XÎUWËENJ9DÍxV�`);Y9zZ�AD;Y;YÖ.ÝzÖ)XYCEZ�NPV�ADRPXYCE?)\JHEV�CBQEU.Ý�V,N-9D=SRTADU�Ëa;ÎXYCE?�Ë�9xXÎCB\PR�Ñ"Þ-HEXYR¯Ì-A�Ö\JHEV.NPV�Z�9xCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<CER)ADNJV�=n9<NJZ,V�`5\P9)=@9<;Y;Y9DÌ A^;YRJ9)RJU)AD;Y;$Ý�V�Ca`EXYCE?<R�9D=-\JHEVWË�ADNP\JXYZ�;YV×�9DÌ0Ñ

� Ó �]Ô,+

�������Z�9<R

���� � � � �! � #�� � ���� ���� � � ���������� � � � ���F� �� ��� � � ����� �

����� � �0 � � � � RJXYC � � � ������� � � I % � � 0+� � �S� � � � �

� � � � �30 ��� � ��� � � � � � � � �� � I�%������ � � � � �� � � � � � I ���$� � � � � ( � � � �����G' 0 � � ' ���

��������Ó/�<Ñ%�!�xÔ

Page 42: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

��� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

�� ��"ª �<ª�� �aª ¢$�xlJk]k-y^hju�kJfBmnhjq�fB}��´|<�jq�oSq,r � kTmvo$h�fzy^hji�hjy<wB}���},fzy�on�zk-q,lvhj¡�h�fB}��$y<}�ov} �

;=< ; � < � \ D � D'�,D N,O D N E �:Q���F�\ D PRX�� � D W"Q�� PRQO D V

Þ$9MV�Í<AD;YQ�A^\JVMADCa`ã\P9¸ÍxV�NJX>=@Ö:\PHEVMRP\JN]A^\JV�?xÖ59^=~Ì2V�XY?<HB\JXYCE?¶\JHEV);YV�CE?x\JHER.9^=0\JHEV)XYCBÛ`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;YR�ÓßRJV�V¸[³V�Z�\JXY9xC �xÑ%���<Ñ��xÔ�K´RJV�ÍxV�N]A^;¯\JV,RJ\JRWÌSV,NJVMË"V�Nv=n9<NJUWV�`tÑ�äa9<N�\JHEV)\PV�RJ\PR�K\vÌS9�`EX>Ù²V�NPV�CB\-\]A^NJ?<V,\2=@QECEZ�\PXY9<CER2\J9�\JHEV�Ë�A^N]A^U�V�\PV�NJR2ÌSV,NJV�QERJV,`tÑEæ6Ý�9xQE\3' � ��RJXYCE?x;ÎVNJV�Z,9<CERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<C NJQECER6ÌSV,NJV0Z�A^NJNPXÎV,`+9xQE\-Ë"V�N¯RPV�NJXYV�R�Ñ

-´§/.10321�xª����aª ­ },lJ}�u~kTovkPl-ov} � �jk-rcq�l � q�on��ovk]mvogmvkJlvhjkTm �i�},��wzk�|z},lJ}�u�kTovkPl� � 7�wBu � kPlSq,r |z},lJkJf<ovm�|³kPl-¡�kPfBkJlJ}�onhjq,f �� � 7�wBu � kPlSq,rt�v�<h��jy^lJkPf�|EkPlS¡�kPfBkJlJ}�onhjq,f �� » kPhj¡,�<oSq,rton�zk-y^hjmvov}�fB�]k�½zonfBk]mvm2ovq�q�i�kJlJ},��� ½zonfBkTmvm �� � �tmvonhju�}�ovk]y � kTmvo$fBqDy<kT�Tq�wxf<o2h�f�on�<hjm$lJkT�Tq�fBmvonlvwz�Tonhjq,f �� � � �¬�.}���hju�wzu�fDwzu � kPl-q�rt¡�kPfzkPlJ}�onhjq,fzm �� � �Si�kPlJ}�¡�k-mnhj�Tk¯q,r�fBkT£:h�fzy^hji�hjyxwz},�Îm �� � � ­ lJq � } � h���hjonp�q,r�h�fBmvkPlJonh�fz¡.}6fzqDyxk �� � � ­ lJq � } � h���hjonp�q,r²yxkP�jk]onh�fB¡.}6fzqDy<k �� � � ­ lJq � } � h���hjonp�q,r²u�wzov}�onhjq�f)}6h�f<fzkPl2fzqDyxk �� � � ­ lJq � } � h���hjonp�q,r�h�fBmvkPlJonh�fz¡.}�i�},��wzk �� � � ­ lJq � } � h���hjonp�q,r�h�fBmvkPlJonh�fz¡.}6rYw<fz�Tonhjq,f �� � �Su�q,w<f<o�q,rtu-wBov}�onhjq,f�ovq�}�i�}���wBk �� � � �·�.}���hju�wzuâi�}���wBk¯q,rt}6fzkT£5i�},��wzk�fzqDyxk �� � � ��h�f<hju�wzu i�},��wzk¯q,r }¯fBkT£5i�},��wzk6fzqDyxk �

Þ-ÌS9°Ë�ADNTADU�V,\JV�NPR�Ì2V�NJV¶Í<ADNPXÎV,` \J9°V�ØEADU�XYCEV)\PHEV�XYN)XÎC³×�QEV�CEZ,V¸9xC \JHEV Ê�\PCEV�RJRV�Í<AD;YQ�A^\JXY9<C´ÑDÞ-HEV�Í<AD;YQEV�=@9<N2\JHEV�V�RP\JXYU+A^\JV�`WÝ�V,RJ\¯CBQEU.Ý"V�N29D=$CE9B`EV�R-Ë"V�N-XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;Ì�A^R0Í<ADNPXYV�`¶=@NJ9xU �)\J9:� �EÑ Þ$9MV,سA^U�XYCEV�\JHEVWXYCB×�QEV�CaZ�V)9D=¯\JHaV�Ì2V�XY?<HB\JXYCE?)9D=¯\PHEVCBQEU.Ý�V,N�9^=~CE9B`EV�R�K�\PHEV)ÌSV�XY?xHz\PXYCE?M=vADZ�\P9<N.XYC5V�ÍxV�NJÖ¬NPQEC¬Ì�A^R.V�RJ\PXÎU)AD\PV�`5ÝBÖ5\PHEVNJV�RPQE;Y\�9^= � ��� Ì-HEV�NPV � Ì-ADR�XÎCaZ�NJV�A^RJV�` =@NJ9xU �M\P9:� �)9DÍxV�N0\PHEV)Ì-HE9<;YV.\JV,RJ\�NJQECtÑÉvC ä´XY?<QaNJV �<Ñ � ��\PHEV�Ê�NPRJ\�\vÌS9)ËE;Y9<\PR0AD\0\PHEV.\J9xË5ADNJV.\TADOxV�C¶=@NJ9xU�9xCEV.\JV�RP\�RPV�NJXYV�R

Page 43: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �

\JH�A^\¯Ì-ADR�`E9xCEV�QaRJXYCE?)\JHEV.OBCE9DÌ-C \JV�RP\�=@QECEZ,\JXY9<CtÑ"Þ-HEV�\vÌ29+Ëa;Î9x\JR0AD\6\JHEV.Ý"9<\P\J9xUADNPV�\]A^O<V�C°=@NP9<U�A RJV�Z�9xCE` NPQEC¬Ì-XÎ\PH5\PHEV)NJV�A^;jÛvÌ29<NJ;Y`:NPV�;cAD\JXY9xC5V�ØB\JNTADZ�\PV�` XYC5\PHEVV�ØBË�V,NJXYU�V�CB\2`EV�RPZ�NJXYÝ"V�`¸XYC)[BV�Z�\PXÎ9xC$�<Ñ �aÑ��xÑ

�� ��"ª��xª�� �<ª �"hjonfBkTmvm.q�r�on�zk�ovkTmvo�rYw<fz�Tonhjq,f±«covq�|E®0},fzy°on�zk.lJkT},���@£$q�lJy°y<}�ov}:« � q�ovovq�u0®P{yDhjmvov},fz�Tk-½BonfzkTmvm � � � ��� «Y�jkPr�oJ®P{Bq�i�kPlJ}����"½zonfBk]mvm � � ��� � � «Ylvhj¡,�<oJ® �

¾�¿J¾ � �$Ã��32 2/� 2PÈ ?�´ÂEÈJÄ�ÁÞ$909DÍ<V�NPZ�9<UWV-\JHEV�ËENP9<ÝE;YV�U 9D=;Y9D̬`EXYÍ<V,NJRJXY\vÖ.XYC�A�Ë�9xËEQE;cAD\PXÎ9xCtKBA0`EXYRP\JNJXYÝEQa\JV�`WË�ADN�ÛAD;Y;YV�;tADËaËENJ9BADZTHMÌ-ADR¯XYUWËE;YV�U.V�CB\JV�`WXYCz\P9.\JHEV�RJÖBU.Ý"9<;YXYZ¯NPV�?<NPV�RJRPXÎ9xC A^ËEËENP9zADZTHtÑaÞ-HEV\]A^RJO¶HEV�NJVWÌ�A^R0\J9)ËENP9DÍ<VW\JHEV.Ë"9<RPRJXYÝEXY;YXÎ\vÖ 9D=-RJË"V�V�`¬XYU�ËENP9DÍ<V�UWV�CB\-\JH�A^\0Z�9<Qa;Î`:Ý"VADZTHEXYV�ÍxV�`)ÝzÖ.U.Qa;Î\PXYËE;YV-Z�9<UWËEQE\JV,N-RJÖBRJ\PV�U�R-9xNSËENP9BZ�V�RJRP9<NPR ��� ���JÑÞ-HEV)?<V�CaV�N]A^;¯XY`EV�A 9D=0\JHaV+Ë"ADN]A^;Y;ÎV,;ÎXYG�A^\JXY9<C:XYR.Ý�A^RJV�`¬9xCã\PHEV)V�ØBË�V,NJXYV�CEZ�V,RM9D="� � ���ADCE`-� � � �JÑäa9<N.\PHEXYR�NJV�ADRJ9xC A¶RJ\PNJ9xCE?5RPXÎUWXY;�A^NJXY\vÖMÝ"V�\vÌ2V�V�C \JHEV¸A^;Y?<9<NPXY\JHEUWR0QERJV,`

Page 44: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

��� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

XYCMÝ�9x\JH5A^ËEËE;YXYZ�AD\PXÎ9xCER¯RPV�V � ���xK �G'(�$Ì�A^R~ÍxV�NJÖ¶QERPVT=@QE;$=n9<N�\JHEV.XYUWËE;YV�U.V�CB\]A^\JXY9<CtÑBæ6RÌ�A^R�`E9xCEV¯XYC � � � ��KxA�ÝE;cADZTOBÝ�9BADNP`.Z�9<UWU.QECEXYZ�AD\PXY9DC0U�9B`EV�;aH�ADR2Ý�V,V�CMADËEËE;YXYV�`tÑxÚ�ADZTHXYCERJ\TADCEZ�V)9^=~\JHaV+Ë"9<ËaQE;cAD\JXY9xC:Ë�9xRJ\JR�A¶Z,V�NJ\TADXYC¬CzQaU.Ý�V�N 9^=~XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�AD;YR�\J9:\PHEVÝE;cADZTOBÝ�9BADNP`.V�Í<V�NPÖ���?xV�CEV�NTAD\JXY9xCER�ÑaÞ-HEV¯Ë�A^N]A^U�V�\PV�NJR MA^CE`��+A^NJV�RJË"V�Z�X>Ê�Z�\J9�V�ADZTHË�9xËEQE;cAD\PXY9<CtÑ�[B9�\JHEV-UWXÎ?xN]A^\JXY9<C6N]AD\PV-Z�ADC�Ý"V-Z]Ha9<RJV,C�ADZ�Z�9xNJ`EXYCE?�\P9~\PHEV-RJË"V�V�`.9^=²\PHEVZ�9<UWËEQE\PV�N0\JH"AD\0Z�A^NJNPXÎV,R�\PHEV�Ë"9<ËEQa;�A^\JXY9<C´Ñ Þ-HEV.XYU�ËE;YV�UWV�CB\]A^\JXY9<C)XYR0Ý�A^RJV�`°9<C¶Ê�;YVRJH�A^NJXYCE?�U�V�ZTH�A^CEXYRJUWR�ÑxÞ-HEXYR�A^;Î;Y9DÌ-R-A�`EV�Z�V,Cz\PN]A^;ÎXYG�V,`¸ADCE`W×�V,ØzXYÝE;YV6Ë�ADNTAD;Y;YV�;YXÎG�AD\JXY9xCtÑ

;=< ; � <@; D�V F(V�6QEV0\J9W\JHEV�RJËa;ÎXY\P\JXYCE?.9D=2\JHEV�Ë�9xËEQE;cAD\PXY9<CtKB\PHEV�ËaNJ9<Ýa;ÎV,UÜ9D=�;Y9Ḏ`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖ)Ì�A^R¯NJV�Û`EQEZ�V,`tÑSä´XYNJRP\�\JV,RJ\JRWRJHE9D̺CE9x\JXYZ�V�A^ÝE;YÖ5HEXY?<HaV�N.Z�9<CBÍxV�NJ?xV�CEZ�V¶N]A^\JV�R�ÑSæ6R�XY\�Z�ADC Ý"V

�� ��ª �xª�� �aª ��q�f<i�kPlJ¡�kPfz�Tk6ovk]mvovmgq�f.on�zk-y^hjmvonlvh � wzovkTyWhju6|<�jkTu�kPf<ov}�onhjq,f �

RJV�V,C:XÎC5ä´XY?<QaNJVM�<Ñ ���aK�Z,9<CBÍ<V�NP?<V�CaZ�V)XÎCaZ�NJV�A^RJV�R�KA^CE`:\JHaV.9DÍ<V�NTAD;Y;�Z�9xU�ËEQE\PXYCE?�\PXÎUWV`EV�Z�NPV�ADRPV�R�Ñaæ RJXYUWXÎ;cA^NtÝ"V�H�A�ÍBXY9<N�Z�A^C.Ý�V6RJV�V,C�XYC � � ���JÑ�Þ-HEV6Ë�ADNTADU�V,\JV�NPR$=@9<N2AD;Y;ENJQaCERADNPV0V �BQ�AD;vK"ADR¯RPHE9DÌ-C¶XÎC)Þ�ADÝa;ÎVR�<Ñ%���xÑML)XY?<N]A^\JXY9<CW=@NPV �BQEV�CEZ,ÖzK"XvÑ V<ÑYKE\JHaV�CBQEU.Ý"V�N-9D=?<V�CaV�N]A^\JXY9<CER�A�=@\PV�N¯Ì-HaXÎZTHMA�Z�V�NP\]A^XÎC¶CBQEU.Ý"V�NS9^=�XÎCa`EXYÍzXY`EQ"AD;YRSUWXY?<N]A^\JV<KBRPHE9<Qa;Î`)CE9x\Ý�VWHEXY?<HEV,N0\JH�A^C � � �!� � �W\J9 RJ\J9xË5?x9z9B`:XYCE`EXYÍBXY`EQ�A^;ÎR6=@NP9<U(RJËENPV�AD`EXYCE?:ADNP9<QECa`ãAD;Y;Ë�9xËEQE;cAD\PXY9<CER�ÑDÞ-HEXYRSXYR2RJXYU�XY;cADN´\J9�Z�9<CaZ�;YQERJXY9<CaR �-A^Cz\PQBÛJÐA^G¯H�A^RSËaQEÝE;YXYRJHEV�`WXYC � � �JÑDÉv\

Page 45: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �-´§ .1032%�xª��!�xª ­ }�lJ}�u�kTovkJl2ov} � �jk-rcq�l2}����"|z},lJ}����jkP�$ovk]mvogmvkJlvhjkTm �

i�},��wzk wzmv}�¡�k¯q,rton�<hjmg|z},lJ}�u�kTovkPl� � � 7gwzu � kPl-q�r"|z},lJkPf<ovm�|EkPlS¡�kJfBkPlJ}�onhjq,f �� � � 7gwzu � kPl-q�r �v�xh��jyDlJkPfzm�|³kPlS¡�kPfzkPlJ}�onhjq�f �� � � � � � � �-» kPhj¡,�<oSq,rton�zk2fBqDy<kT�Tq�wxf<o2½zonfBk]mvm2ovq�q�i�kJlJ},���"½zonfzkTmvm �� » kPhj¡,�<oSq,rton�zk-y^hjmvov}�fB�Tk¯½BonfzkTmvm2ovq~q,i�kPlJ},����½BonfzkTmvm �� � �tmvonhju�}�ovkTy � kTmvogfzqDyxk]�Tq,w<f<ogh�f�on�<hjmglJkT�]q,fzmvonlvwB�Tonhjq�f �� � � � � � �.}*��hju-wzuâfDwBu � kPlSq�rt¡�kPfzkPlJ}�onhjq�fBm �� � �2i�kPlJ}�¡�k6mnhj�]k-q,r fzkT£ h�fzyDhji�hjy^wE}��Ym �� � � ­ lJq � } � h���hjonp�q,r h�fzmvkPlJonh�fB¡�}6fzqDyxk �� � � ­ lJq � } � h���hjonp�q,rty<kP�jkTonh�fz¡�}6fzqDyxk �� � � ­ lJq � } � h���hjonp�q,rtu-wBov}�onhjq,f�}6h�f<fBkJl-fBqDy<k �� � � ­ lJq � } � h���hjonp�q,r h�fzmvkPlJonh�fB¡�}�i�},��wzk �� � � ­ lJq � } � h���hjonp�q,r h�fzmvkPlJonh�fB¡�}6rYw<fB�]onhjq,f �� �2u~q,w<f<o2q,r²u�wzov}�onhjq�f)ovq~}�i�},��wzk �

XYRËaNJV�RPQEU�V�`.\PH�AD\g\JHEXYR$Ý�V,H�A�ÍBXÎ9xNSAD?BADXYC0U)A�Ö~NPV�RJQa;Î\�=@NJ9xUç\JHaV¯QERTAD?<V-9^=²\PHEV0Ó ��0 �"ÔRJ\PN]AD\PV�?<Ö¶ÓcRPV�V�ä´XY?<QENPV��xÑ�� �<Ô,ÑäEQaNJ\JHaV�N�XYCBÍ<V�RP\JXY?zA^\JXY9<CaR�Ì-XY;Y;-Ý�V Z�ADNPNJXYV�` 9xQE\�\P9:V�ØEADU�XYCEVW\JHEV Ý�V�H"A�ÍzXY9xN.9D=0`EX>=cÛ=@V�NPV�CB\�Ë�A^N]ADUWV�\JV,NJXYG�AD\PXY9<CER�XYCãV,Í<V�NPÖã`aXjÙ V�NPV�CB\+Ë"9<ËaQE;cAD\JXY9xCtÑ[³95\JHaVMXYCB×�QEV�CaZ�VM9D=`EX>Ù²V,NJV�CB\�CE9B`EV.Ì2V�XY?<HB\JXYCE?.Ë�A^N]A^U�V�\PV�NJR�U+A�ÖWÝ�V�XYCB\JV�NPV�RJ\PXÎCa?�Ñ æ6`E`EXY\JXY9<C"AD;Y;YÖzKBRP9<U�VV�ØEADUWXÎC"AD\JXY9xCER-Ì-XY;Î;gÝ�VWU+AD`aV�NPV�?zA^NJ`EXYCE?M\PHEV.Ý"V�H�A�ÍBXY9<N09^=~A�Z,9<U�U)A.RP\JN]A^\JV�?xÖ:\J9RJ\P9<Ë)\JHEV�`EV,Z�NJV�A^RJXYCE?W`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖzÑ

¾�¿J¾ � 8¸Ä�Á¯Ç�2PÆ �BÈJÄgÁÞ-HEXYR�ZTH�ADËa\JV�N2NJV�Ë"9<NP\JV�`)9xC.?<V�CEV,\JXYZ�ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�UWXjCE?-XYCEZ�;YQE`aXÎCa?�AD`EÍ<A^CEZ�V�`.UWV�\JHa9z`aXÎZADRPË�V�Z,\JR¯ADCa`¼A^ËEËE;YXYZ�AD\PXY9<CER�\P9�U)ADZTHEXYCEXYCE?^Û \PV�ZTHECE9<;Y9x?<Ö�ËENJ9xÝE;YV�U�R�Ñ �6V�ÍxV�;Y9<ËEUWV�CB\�9D=U�V�\PHE9B`ER0Z�9xCEZ�V�CB\PN]AD\PV�` 9xC5\JHaV+;YXYCEV�A^N0ËENP9<?<NTADU�NPV�ËENPV�RJV�CB\TAD\JXY9xCtÑ�ÉvC°Ë�ADNP\JXYZ�QE;cADN�K\JHEVWXY`EV�CB\JX>Ê�Z�A^\JXY9<C°9D=¯VTÙ V�Z�\PXYÍ<V¸A^CE`5QECBQERPV�`¬Ë�ADNP\JR�9D=�Z�9B`EV)Ì�A^R�A^`E`ENJV,RJRJV,`tÑ ! C\JHEV-Ý"ADRJXYR29D=t\PHEXYR�XYCB=@9<NPU+A^\JXY9<C�Ì2V¯Z�9xQE;Y`�ADZ�Z�V,;ÎV,N]AD\PV�ËENJ9x?<N]A^U V�Í<9x;ÎQa\JXY9<CtK^CE9<\�9xCE;YÖXYC:Z�9<UWËEQE\JXYCE?)\PXÎUWV.ÝEQE\.AD;YRJ9 9<C5\PHEV�;YV�ÍxV�;-9D=¯?xV�CEV�NTAD\PXÎ9xCER�Ñ�Úà�Z�XYV�CB\.U.QE\]A^\JXY9<C9<Ë"V�N]A^\J9xNJR¯Ì2V�NPV0`EV�ÍxV�;Y9<Ë"V�`)=@9xNS;YXYCEV�A^N-ËENJ9x?<N]A^U�R2\JH�A^\-XYCEZ�NJV�ADRJV,`¸RPË�V�V,`M9D=$Ê�\PCEV�RJRZ�9<CBÍxV�NJ?xV�CEZ�V�RJXY?xCEX>Ê�Z�ADCB\P;ÎÖBÑDÚ$Í<V,C�\JHa9<QE?xH.\JHEV6U.QE\]A^\JXY9<CBÛvÝ�A^RJV�`�Ò´Ï0жÍ<ADNPXcADCB\$ËENJ9^ÛÍBXÎ`aV�R¯A�RJQBà�Z,XÎV,Cz\-ËaNJV�RPV�NJÍ<A^\JXY9<CM9^=Z�9B`EV�`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖ+A^;ÎNPV�AD`aÖ.XÎUWËE;YXYZ�XY\J;YÖzK�XYCEZ�NPV�ADRPXYCE?\JHEV�;ÎV,Í<V�;´9D=�`EXYÍ<V�NPRJXY\vÖ)V�ØBËE;YXYZ�XY\J;YÖ.ÝBÖ¼A�U.Qa;Î\PXY9<Ý��TV�Z,\JXYÍ<V6RJV�;YV�Z�\PXY9<CMUWV�ZTH�ADCEXYRPU·=@QaNvÛ\JHEV,N¯XYU�ËENP9DÍ<V�`WËENJV,`EXYZ�\JXY9<C Ë�V�N�=@9<NPU+A^CEZ�V<ÑaÉvCM?<V�CaV�N]A^; K"U.QE\TAD\PXÎ9xCBÛvÝ�ADRPV�`�Í<A^NJXcAD\PXÎ9xCÌ�A^R =@9xQECE`0\P9¯Ý"VSU.QaZ]H�UW9<NJVgRJQEZ�Z,V�RJR�=@QE;"\JH�A^C0Z�NJ9xRJRP9DÍ<V�N�Û Ý�A^RJV�`.Í<A^NJXcAD\PXY9<C�XYC0;YXÎCaV�ADNÏ0Ð$Ñ�Þ-HEV2U+ADXYC�NJV�ADRJ9xC.XYR\PH�AD\gU.QE\]A^\JXY9<CER XYCE`aQEZ�V-RJU)AD;Y;YV�N RJ\PV�Ë�RPXYG�V�R�9xC�\PHEV-;YXÎCaV�ADNËENJ9x?<NTADUºRJ\JNPQEZ�\PQENJV�\JH�A^\~A^;Î;Y9DÌ A�UW9<NPV~Z,9<CB\JXYCBQE9<QaR~ADËaËENJ9DØBXYU+A^\JXY9<C�\J9WRJ9<;YQE\PXY9<CER9D=SHaXÎ?xHEV�N �zQ"AD;YXY\vÖzÑaæ¯`E`EXY\PXÎ9xC�AD;Y;YÖBKzAWZ�9B`EVTÛvRJV,;ÎV,Z�\JXYÍ<V.`aXÎRP\]A^CEZ�V�U�V�\PNJXYZ0Ì-ADR0ADËEËa;ÎXYV�`XYC�9<NP`EV�N6\J9�NJV�`EQaZ�V�U.Qa\]AD\PXY9<C.RJ\PV�Ë)RJXYG�V�R6U�9xNJV¯ËaNJV�Z�XYRPV�;YÖ+9xC)\JHEV�VTÙ V�Z�\PXÎÍxV�Z,9z`aV<Ñ

Page 46: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

��� � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

Év\�H"ADR�Ý�V�V,C RJHE9DÌ-C°\JH�A^\.\JHEV)QERPV)9D=~RPÖBU.Ý�9x;ÎXYZ�NJV�?xNJV�RPRJXY9<C XÎR�RJQaXÎ\TADÝE;YV�=@9<N�Z�9<C³ÛRJ\PNJQEZ�\PXYCE?+A^CE`M`EV�ÍxV�;Y9<ËEXYCE?W`EV�RPZ�NJXYËE\PXÎÍxV�UW9B`EV�;YR�=n9<N¯ËaHzÖBRPXÎZ�AD;$NJV�;cA^\JXY9<CER�ÑEÞ-HEV�ËENJ9^ÛZ�V�RPR�9D=0NPV�Z�9<CaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xC Z�ADC¬Ý�V¶ADQE\P9<U+A^\JXYG�V�`´Ñ�Ú$ØBË�V�NPXYU�V�CB\JR.H"A�Í<V)ËENJ9DÍxV�`¬\JH�A^\\JHEV-NPV�Z�9xCERJ\PNJQEZ�\PXY9<C)9D= Z�9<NPNJV�;cA^\JXY9<CER2\JH"AD\�\TADO<V-Ëa;�A^Z�V-XYC�\PHEV¯ZTHEXYË.ÝEQaXÎ;Y`EXYCE?�ËENP9BZ�V�RJRXYC+UWV�\]A^;tZ�Qa\J\JXYCE?WXYR¯Ë"9<RJRPXYÝE;YV<Ñ"Þ-HEV�NJV�A^NJV�A^;YRJ9�NPV�RJQa;Î\PR�RJHE9DÌ-XYCE?W\JH�A^\¯\JHaV �BQ�A^;ÎXY\vÖ9D=-\JHEV�=n9<QECE`:NPV�;cAD\PXÎ9xCER0AD;Y;Y9DÌ-R�\JHEV.NPV�Z�9<CaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PXÎ9xC¬9D=-9<\JHaV�N�K´CE9<\�9<CE;YÖMËEHBÖBRJXYZ�A^;Z�9<NPNJV�;cA^\JXY9<CER�Ñ<Þ-HaV¯Z�9xNJNJV,;�A^\JXY9<CaRSU)A�Ö0Ý�V6\]A^O<V�C�=@NJ9xU 9x\JHEV,NSRPZ�XYV�CB\JX>Ê�Z6Ê�V�;Y`ER2Ì-HEV�NPVËENJ9BZ�V,RJR�UW9z`aV�;YRtRJ\PXY;Î;x`E9�CE9<\´V�ØBXYRJ\$9<N$RJHa9<QE;Y`0Ý"V-NJV�CaV�ÌSV,`tÑDÞ-HEXYR$U+A�Ö-Ý"V-XYC�ADËEËa;ÎXYV�`RJ9BZ�XcAD; RP\JQE`aXÎV,R¯9<N¯A^ËEËE;YXYV�`)V�Z�9xCE9<UWXÎZ,R�Ñxæ¯CE9x\JHEV�N6Ë�9xRJRPXÎÝa;ÎVµÊ�V�;Y`)XÎR-\PHEV�NJV�Z,9<CERP\JNJQaZTÛ\JXY9<C�9D=�RPXÎ?xC�AD;YR�K�RPQEZTH�ADR�ADQa`EXY9¯RJXY?xC�AD;YR�K�9xN\PHEV2\]ADRPO�9^=EÊ�;Y\JV,NJXYCE?�`EXYRJ\PQENJÝ�A^CEZ�V�R�=@NJ9xU?<XYÍ<V,C�RJXY?xC�AD;YR29D=;Y9DÌ �BQ�A^;YXÎ\vÖBÑDÞ-HEV �BQ�A^;ÎXY\vÖ�9D=$\JHEV0UW9B`EV�;YR$=@9xQECE`�XYR-?x9z9B`WV�CE9<Qa?<H\J9�QERJV�\JHEV�U =@9xN-V�ØB\JN]A^Ë�9x;cAD\JXY9xC�9<N2=n9<Ng=@QENJ\PHEV�N�ADC�A^;ÎÖBRPXÎR�Ñ

æçCEV�ÌâU�V�\PHE9B`)=@9xN~ADC"AD;YÖBG�XYCE?.\JHEV�Ý"V�H�A�ÍBXY9<N¯9^=SNJV,Z�9<CERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xC:ËENJ9BZ�V�RPRJV�R�9D=U+A^\JHEV�U)AD\PXÎZ�AD;x=@QECEZ,\JXY9<CER2ÝBÖ.RJÖBU.Ý"9<;YXYZSNPV�?<NPV�RJRPXÎ9xCMÍBXcA�?<V�CaV�\JXYZ0ËENP9<?xN]ADUWU�X>CE?¯H�A^RÝ�V,V�C¸`aV�Í<V�;Y9xË�V�`´Ñ�Þ-HaXÎR�?xN]ADËaHEXYZ�AD;´NJV�ËENPV�RJV,Cz\TAD\PXÎ9xC:9D=S\PHEV�NJV�Z�9xCERJ\PNJQEZ,\JXY9<C:ËENP9BZ�V�RJRZ�ADC�Ý�V2QERJV,`�XYC0U.QE;Y\PXÎËa;ÎV´Ì�A�ÖBR´\J9�9<ËE\PXYU�XYG�Vt9xN$ÍzXYRPQ�AD;YXYG�V�\PHEVSÌ-Ha9<;YV�NJV,Z�9<CERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCËENJ9BZ�V,RJR�Ñ äaQENJ\PHEV�NPU�9<NPV<KBXY\-Z�ADC)Ý"V�QERJV�` \J9.XYCBÍ<V�RP\JXY?zA^\JV�RJË"V�Z�X>Ê�Z0Ë"9<XYCB\JR-XYCW\JXYU�V6XÎC\JHEV�NJV,Z�9<CERP\JNPQEZ�\JXY9xCtÑ æ¯`a`EXY\JXY9<C�A^;tZ�9xCERJXY`EV,N]AD\PXY9<CER�Z�A^C¸Ý"V�U)AD`EV�\P9+XYCB\JV,?<N]A^\JV0\PHEXYRRJÖBRJ\PV�UºXÎCB\P9�RP\]ADCa`�ADNP`MRJÖBU.Ý"9<;YXYZ-NJV�?xNJV�RPRJXY9<CM;YXYÝENTADNJXYV�R�Ñ

Þ-HEV.RJÖBU.Ý"9<;YXYZ�NJV�?xNJV�RPRJXY9<C¬ADËEËE;YXYZ�A^\JXY9<CMÌ-ADR�QERJV�`¶=n9<N�AW`EXYRJ\PNJXYÝEQE\PV�`:Ë�A^N]AD;Y;YV�;SA^ËBÛËENJ9BADZTH5\P9:RJË"V�V�` QaË5\JHaV+NPV�?<NPV�RJRPXY9<C A^CE`5\P9:XÎCaZ�NJV�A^RJV)\JHaV+Z,9<CBÍ<V�NP?<V�CaZ�V¸ËaNJ9<Ý"A�ÛÝEXY;YXÎ\vÖBÑ<ä´XYNJRP\-XÎCBÍxV�RJ\PXÎ?BAD\PXÎ9xCER2RJHE9DÌ \JHEV�VTà�Z,XÎV,CEZ�Ö)9D=�A�ÝE;cADZTOBÝ�9BADNJ`WË�ADNTAD;Y;YV�;YXYG�AD\PXÎ9xCU�V�\PHE9B`tÑ�Þ-HEXYRSAD;Y;Y9DÌ-R�A6HEXY?<H.?<NTAD`EV-9^=²Ë"ADN]A^;Y;ÎV,;ÎXYG�A^\JXY9<C�Ì-XÎ\PHE9<Qa\�?<V�\P\JXYCE?0\P9B90U.QEZTH9DÍ<V�NPHEV�A^`�=nNJ9<U Z�9<UWU.QECEXYZ�AD\PXY9<CtÑ�Þ-HEV�A^ËEËE;YXYZ�AD\PXY9<C.XYR-Ë�9xNJ\TADÝE;YV0ADCE`W×�V,ØzXYÝE;YV<K"ADCE`Z�ADC:Ý"V�QaRJV�`:9xC:Í<ADNJXY9xQER0\vÖBË�V,R�9^=�RPÖzRP\JV�UWR�Ñ$äEQaNJ\JHaV�N�V,سA^U�XYC�A^\JXY9<CER6CEV�V�`°\J9MÝ"V`E9<CaV~9xC)\JHEV09xËE\JXYU)AD;"Ë�ADNTADU�V,\JV�NPXÎG�AD\JXY9xC�9D=�\PHEV0U�XY?xN]AD\PXY9<C.N]A^\JV�A^CE`)\JHEV�Ë�ADNTADU.ÛV�\JV,NJR¯9^=\PHEV0Ë"9<ËEQE;cA^\JXY9<CtÑ

ÉvC)9<NJ`aV�N¯\P9�`EV�ÍxV�;Y9<˸A�ËaHzÖBRPXÎZ�AD;tUW9B`EV�; 9D=�\PHEV0\JQaNJCEXYCE?WËENJ9BZ�V�RPR�KtA^`E`EXY\JXY9xC�AD;"Z�9<C³ÛRJXY`EV�NTAD\PXÎ9xCER0H�A�ÍxV.\J9MÝ"V.U+A^`EV<Ñtäa9<N�V�ØEADU�Ëa;ÎVxK²A^`E`EXYCE?)Ë�A^N]ADUWV�\JV,NJR�K´RJQaZ]H¬ADR0\PHEVZ�QE\P\JXYCE?)RJË"V�V�`:9xN~\PHEV�\J9B9<;�ADCa?<;YV�\P9)\JHEV�NJV�Z,9<CERP\JNJQaZ�\JXY9<C°ËENJ9BZ�V,RJR�Ñ$äaQENJ\PHEV�NJUW9<NPV<KNJV�RP\JNPXÎZ,\JXY9<CER2H�A�ÍxVS\P90Ý�V6`EV�ÍxV�;Y9<Ë"V�`.\J90Z,9<CERP\JN]A^XYC.\JHEV6;ÎV,CE?<\PH.9D= \JHEV-NPV�Z�9<CaRJ\JNPQEZ�\PV�`XYCE`EXYÍBXÎ`aQ�AD;YR�Ñ

0&� 4I�tÃ��´Á¯Ç?� ���� s �����},�<lJk�{<� � � �w<���jkPl�{B}�fBy�� �<» },lvfzkT����k �=� }�mnhj�-�v�B}�lJ}��TovkJlvhjmvonhj�Tm2q�f��JwBovonh�fz¡�kP¹Ek]�Tovmh�f.�Tq�lvlJkP�j}�onhjq�f�ovq6y<p�fB}�u6hj�¯kP¹EkT�Tovm � ��f � ����� ������� � ��� ��� ����� �� ��� ��������������� ������ ������"! ����#������ $#%��� ��&(' ���*),+-���*����� � �����T{"|z}�¡�k]m �D��.^� � {��Eh�fB�]q,��f�{ 6 ¢-{ � � .^� �M�.}�p� � � � �

�^�S»°�I� },fz�P�z},rv{�­ � 72q,lJyDh�f�{ � � � ��/ kP���jkPl�{D}�fBy¯� � s � �xlJ}�fB�]q,fzk �10 � � � $��-�2�3��&�� ������� �4&5 � �76�� $�3� ��# � 8�9����);: � �� ���<# $������$��>=2?����# $����7���,+-���>�@# ����>�>�A��&������ � ��� �,� ������B������$���� � yD|xw<f<�<o�C,�.q,lJ¡�},f / },w<rcu�}�fxf�{ �2kPhjy<kP� � kPlJ¡4C��D},f+�xlJ},fz�Phjmv�Tq<{E� �6{ � � � �x�

Page 47: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �

� � � � � ��� �j},��k�},fzy+� ���x� �.kJlJ� � e-��� � kP|³q�mnhjovq,lJp+q,r�.}��v�xh�fzk0�"kT}�lvfxh�fz¡.s2}�ov} � }�mvkTm �<ovon| 4 C C,£�£�£ � hj�Tm � wz�Ph � k]y^w C��2u6�jk]},lvf C,�.� � kP|�q�mnhYovq�lJp � �<ovu¯� � �

�x� � ��� lJ}�u�kPhjkPlt}�fBy »°� � }�fB�P�z},r � �M�Tq�u¯|B}�lvhjmvq,f0q�rB��h�fBk]},l¡�kPfzkTonhj�$|xlJq�¡,lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡6}�fByfBkPw<lJ},�tfzkTon£$q�lv�<m2h�f)u~kTy^hj�]},�yx}�ov}�u6h�f<h�fB¡ � 6�=1= = � � ��� ���� $���� ����� =2?����# $���� �����+-�����@# ���$����x{ �^« � ®C4 � � .<� � { � � � ���� � � �Y� lJ}�u�kPhjkPl~},fzy »°�=� },fz�P�z},r � �Õ¹Ek]�Tonhji�k���h�fzkT},l�|<lJq�¡�lJ}�u h�fzy^wz�Tonhjq,f � ¢ kT���<f<hj�T},�� kJ|Eq,lJot����� � � � C� � {D�$q,���j} � q,lJ}�onhji�k � k]mvkT},lJ�v�0�$kPf<ovkJl �1� � {�egf<hji�kPlJmnhjo@p6q�rBsSq,lJovu-wxfzyE{� � � ���

�x� � �(� lJ}�u~kPhjkPlS},fzy »°��� }�fB�J�B}�r � �´i�q,�ji�h�fz¡0ovkT}�u�mq,rE|xlJk]y^hj�Tovq�lJm$£$hjon�0��h�fBkT}�lS¡�kPfzkTonhj�|xlJq�¡,lJ}�u~u6h�fB¡ � 0 � � � $��7�2�3��&�� ������� ��& ��� � =>?����? ���* � ! ������� � ���P{ � « � ®C4 � �<��.D� � �D{� � � ���

� � � ��� lJ}�u�kJhjkPl¯},fzy »5��� },fz�P�z},r � � ��|x��hj�Phjo~�Tq,f<onlJq��tq,ry^hji�kPlJmnhjonp�},fzy.kP¹EkT�]onhji�k0i�},lvh��}�onhjq,f5yDhjmvov},fz�TkWh�f:��h�fzkT}�l�¡�kPfzkTonhj�.|xlJq�¡,lJ}�u~u6h�fB¡ � ¢ kT�v�xf<hj�T},� � kP|Eq,lJo������ ��� ��C � � {��q����j} � q�lJ}�onhji�k � kTmvk]},lJ�v�+��kJf<ovkPl �1� � {Be�fxhji�kPlJmnhjonp.q�rts2q,lJovu-w<fByE{ � � � ���

�x� � ��� lJ}�u�kJhjkPl¯},fzy »5��� },fz�P�z},r � � ��|x��hj�Phjo~�Tq,f<onlJq��tq,ry^hji�kPlJmnhjonp�},fzy.kP¹EkT�]onhji�k0i�},lvh��}�onhjq,f¼y^hjmvov}�fB�Tk¯h�fW��h�fzkT},l~¡�kJfBkTonhj�¯|xlJq�¡,lJ}�u~u6h�fB¡ � �Yf"�>�A����������� �4& � ������ ��1� ��� =>#� �3��� ����� +-���*������� � ��� ��� 0 � � � $����>�A��& �������,� ��&�3=2#%�A� 0 � A� �������,{ / h�fzmv},�jk�{��YlJkP�j},fzyE{� . � ��|xlvh�� � � � �^� « �2�]�TkP|zovkTyB® �

� � � � ��}�f<onwx�@­ }�� � ��hj¡,lJ}�onhjq�fW|³q,��hj�PhjkTm-}�fBy.ov}��DkTq�i�kPlSonhju�kTmgh�f�¡�kPfzkTonhj�¯},�j¡�q,lvhjon�zu�m � ��f»°�?� }�fB�J�B}�rv{ �x� s2}�hjyx}<{ � � � � � h � kPf�{t� � � � �2}�lJ�Tq,f�{ 6 � �2q�fB}�i�},l�{ � ��� },�DhjkP�j}<{},fzy � � � � �^u¯hjon�"{<kTyDhjovq,lJmT{@�>�A����������� �4& �1��� �� � 0 � � � $�� ��� ��=2?����# $���� ������+-�����@#� ��$���� + ���*����� � ������ 0 = +>+>:�� ������{Bi�q���wBu~k � {<|B}�¡�k � �*� � �.q�lJ¡�}�f / },w<rcu�},f<f�{ �D},f�xlJ},fz�Phjmv�Tq<{�� �¯{ � � .z� � � w<�jp � � � � �

� � � /�� �´�BkJ���j},|<h����Y} � �´i�q,�ji�h�fz¡��Tq�u6|<wBovkPl-|<lJq�¡�lJ}�u�mS£$hjon�Bq�wBoSmnw � onlJkTk¯�PlJq�mvmvq�i�kJl � 6�= =1=� � ��� ����� $���� �����(=2?����# $���� �����7+-���>�@# ��$����<{ � «��D®C4 � � � .<�D��� { � � � � �

����� ­ � sghjovonlvhj�v��{ � � �Eh�� �vkPlJq�mT{ � � �^q�wx��hjkJl�{´}�fBy »°�=� },fz�P�z},r � ��|Eq,f<ov}�fBk]q,wzm�¡�lJq,w<|)rcq�lv�u�}�onhjq�f.h�f�on�Bk-mvkT�]kTyxkJl-u�qDy<kP� � � ��� � ������' ��?�� ����� � ����� �J{ ��� 4 � � � � . � � � � { � � � � �

���^� s � �gwBmn½zkP�jy � � &������ �� � �1���� 8��� ��& ��� � � ����� ��� ��� ����# � � ����� � �$}�u � lvhjyx¡�k�egf<hji�kPlJmnhjo@p­ÕlJkTmvmT{/72kT£ �tq,lv�E{ � � � � �� � � � � �c¡�kP�t}�fBy /�� �´�BkJ���j},|<h����Y} � ��f<i�k]mvonhj¡�}�onh�fz¡�on�Bk6h�f �<wBkPfz�Tk0q,ry<kP|Bon�+},fzy�yxkT¡�lJkTk�q�r

¡�kPfzq�o@p�|xhj�¯���z},fz¡�k-q�f�½zonfBk]mvm�h�f�¡�kPfBk]onhj��|<lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �Yf »5��� },fz�P�z},rv{ �x� s2}�hjyx}<{� � � � �Õh � kPf"{�� � � � �2}�lJ�Tq,f�{ 6 � �Sq,fz},i�}�l�{$� �!� },�DhjkP�j}<{�},fzy � � � � �Du6hjon��{$kTyD�hjovq,lJmT{��2�3����������� ��& � ��� �� � 0 � � � $�� ��� � =>?����# 8�9��� ����� +-���>�@# ���$���� + ���*����� � ����� 0 = +>+>:�� �����,{zi�q���wBu�k � {B|z}�¡�k]m � � �x��.B� � � �<� �.q�lJ¡�},f / },w<rcu�}�fxf�{²�^}�f��xlJ},fz�Phjmv�Tq<{� �¯{ � � .z� � � w<�jp � � � � �

�]�x� ¢ � ��fz}�u-w<lJ} �"� lvhjovon�jk C,yDwB�Tonh��Îk�|<�BkPfzq�u~kPfB}+q � mvkPlJi�kTy)h�fM�]q�u6|<wBovkJl0mnhju�w<�j}�onhjq�fBm0q�ru�}��v�xh�f<h�fz¡)yxkJrckT�Ton�crYlJkTk¯u�q�fBqD�PlJpDmvov}�����h>fzk.mnh���hj�Tq�f � � � � �� ����� �� � + 6�'��´{ ��� 4 � ��. � � {� � � � �

� � � � � � � / kP���jkPl�{ �x� �.kP�<fzkPf"{ »°��� }�fB�P�z},r {B},fzy /���» kPh�fzkPlJo � �B# ���������' ������� ��$��#%� $�����*�3���#"�$ �>��� � %$ ����&�-� �� � 0 � � � $����2�3��&�� ������� �4&('�=2?����# $�� �)� $���� �A&��+*,�-����� ��{���z},|zovkPl � {$|z}�¡�kTm �x��. � � � �Syxi�},fz�TkTm�h�f �2kPfzkTonhj�)­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡�� � ���c¢â­ lJkTmvmT{��}�u � lvhjy<¡�k�{E� �¯{ � � � � �

���x�.�x� � � / q��T} ��0 � � � $�� �2�3��&�� ������� ��& � ���c¢°­ lJkTmvmT{E�$}�u � lvhjyx¡�k�{E� �6{ � � � �D�� � �S»°�,�2� �"},fz¡�y<q,f �0/ wz}�yDlJ}�onhj� � �jq�}�o�h�f5¡�kPfzkTonhj�W|<lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � ��f s ��» �xhjon�jkTp�{

s � �2q��jy � kJlJ¡x{¯� � �$},f<onw<�@­ }���{-� � ��|EkT�]ovq,l�{¯� � ­ }�lJu�kTk�{-}�fBy � � �v� �3� kTp�kPl�{-kTyDh��ovq,lJmT{,�>�A����������� �4& � ��� �� � 0 � � � $�� ��� �"=>?����# $���� ����� +-���>�@# ��$���� + ���*����� � ����� 0 = +>+>:1 3� ��������{a|z}�¡�kTm � � ��.�� � �<� �.q�lJ¡�},f / }�wxrcu~},f<f"{�D},f:�<lJ},fz�Phjmv�Tqx{� �6{ � � .����� wx�jp � � � � �

Page 48: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� � � },fz�P�B}�rv{ � lJ}�u�kPhjkPl�{³�^ov}�wBonfzkPl�{E},fzy » kPh�fBkJlJo

� �x�S»°� �S� �"}�fB¡�yxq�f"{E¢ � �^q�wx�jk�{ � � ­ q,��hc{E},fzy � }�u�kTm�� � �Bq�mvovkJl � ¢$�zk-kTi�q���wBonhjq�fMq,r²mnhj�Tk},fzy.mn�B}�|Ek � ��f�� � ��|³kT�Tovq,l�{ »°� �2� �"},fz¡�y<q,f�{Ee � �@� � ��� � kJh����jp�{E},fzy.­ ���x� ��fB¡�kP��h�fBk�{kTy^hjovq�lJmT{1� ��? ����������� � 0 � � � 8�9�<�2�3��&�� ������� ��& "D{E���z},|zovkPl � {B|z}�¡�k]m ��� � .z� � � � ���c¢­ÕlJkTmvmT{³�$}�u � lvhjy<¡�k�{E� �¯{ � � � � �

� � �.�x� �.kP�<fBkJf � �´i�q,��wzonhjq,f �},lJk)�"� �}����zkPf<lJkP�Dq�fBmvonlvw<�<onhYq�f � ­ �Bs·on�zkTmnhjmT{�egf<hji�kPlJmnhjo@p¶q�rs2q,lJovu-w<fByE{ � � � � �

� � � � � � �w<���jkPl � ­ lJq��Tk���hjyxkJf<onh�½x��}�onhjq�f � kPhju s�lJkP�BkJf�u6hjo ��h���rck�� �w<fzmvon��hj���zkPl¯fBkPw<lJq,fz},�jkJl72kTov�Tk � ����� ��2�3� ��#� $���� �� ����� ��� ����� �� �������� ���{ ��� { � � � �x��D��� ­ � 72q,lJyDh�f � �:�Tq�u¯|xh���h�fz¡0¡�kPfzkTonhj�2|<lJq�¡,lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡�mvpDmvovkTu on�B}�o´yDh�lJkT�Ton�jp�u�},f<h�|xw<�j}�ovk]mon�BkSu�}��v�xh�fzkP�@�TqDy<k � �Yf /�� � � / h�fxfzkT},l�{zkTyDhjovq,l�{ � ��? ���������>� � 0 � � � $��>�2�3��&�� ������� �4&�{

|B}�¡�kTm � ����. �]� � {E���c¢°­ lJkTmvmT{³��}�u � lvhjy<¡�k�{z� �6{ � � � �x����^� ­ � 7Sq,lJyDh�f0},fzy »°�I� },fz�P�z},r � �$q�u6|<�jk ��hjo@p6�Tq�u6|<lJkTmvmnhjq,f�},fzy¯kTi�q���wBonhjq�f � �Yf¯� � �tmn�BkP���u�},f�{�k]y^hjovq�l�{ 0 � � � 8�9� � &������ �� � ��� �2�3����������� ��& �@��� �� � �B�� ����6�� ������ ��$���� �� +-���*������

� � ��� 6�+ 0 �+������{,|z}�¡�kTm � � � . � � �^{E�.q,lJ¡�},f / }�wxrcu~},f<f"{³�^}�f��xlJ},fz�Phjmv�Tq<{�� �¯{ � � � � �� � � � � �D���Dw<�j�2}�fBy /��I� hju�mv�v�B}�m � � |zonhju6hjmv}�onhjq,f�q,rE|<lJkT�Phjmnhjq�f.u�}����<h�fxh�fz¡ � p6mnhju-w<�j}�onhjq,f

q,rton�zk-�PwBovonh�fz¡�|xlJqD�]kTmvm � � � � �� � ��� �� �7+ 6�'��t{ � � ��� ����x� � � �n­ � �D���<£$kJrckP� � =>?����# $���� ��� � :;� $� �,# � � ������� ��& �E» h��jkTp�{ 72kT£ �´q�lv�E{ � � � � �� � � � � ���xhju~}�y<}x{�7 � ����}�£$}<{ � � ¢ }�fB}���}x{�},fzy �x� e2�v�<h��Dq�mn�<h � �Donlvwz�TonwxlJkq,rzu6hj�PlJq�u~}��v�xh�fzkTy

mnwxlvrc}��Tk¯mnhju�w<�j}�ovkTy � p0u�q,�jk]�Pwx�j}�l¯yxp�fz}�u¯hj�Tm-},fz},�jpDmnhjm � � � � �� � ��� �� � + 6�'��´{ � � � �<�� �x� ¢ � �^q�wx�jk�{ �x� � � �zq�mvovkPl�{D}�fBy �x� sghj�v�Dh�fBmvq�f � �$qDy<k2¡,lJq�£�on��h�f�¡�kJfBkTonhj�2|<lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u¯h�fB¡ �

��f �x� � � / q��]}x{�s � � � �2q,�jy � kPlJ¡x{�s �I�2� �Bq�¡�kP�c{�},fzy � � � � � hjq,�jq<{xk]y^hjovq�lJmT{%�2�3����������� ��& ���� �� � 0 � � � 8�9�<�2�3��&�� ������� ��& +-���*������ ����� 0 �+� ������{D|B}�¡�kTm �D� � .<��� �x{����ߢ¬­ lJkTmvmT{��}�u � lvhjy<¡�k�{E� �¯{ � � � �<�

� � �.�x� ��|<lJ},i�k � �Õh�f�kPh�f<�BkPhjon��hj�v�EkTm-�.qDy<kP����r �wxl�­ q,|<wx�j}�onhjq,fzmPmvonlvw<�<onwxl]kPf�h�f.kTi�q,��wzonhjq,f �},lJkPf�g�j¡�q�lvhjon�Bu~kPf � ­ �zs on�zkTmnhjmT{Ee�fxhji�kPlJmnhjonp�q,rts2q�lJovu�w<fzya{ � � � � �

��x�3�2� �DonlJq,wzmvonlvw<| � � � � +��� �>�A��& �������,� ��& � ���4& # ��&�� � �2y<y^hjmvq�fx� » kTmn�jkTpD{ � k]}�yDh�fB¡<{� �6{ � � � �x�� � � � � » }�lvfBk]����k � ��� �������� ��#��4&)����� ��� ����� � ��� � ��� ����� �$��� � � � ¢ kT�v�xf<hjmv�v�BkPl 6 kPlv�j}�¡

� k]mv����{��gl �},rckJ��½xfz¡x{ � � � �<�� � � /�� » kJh�fBkPlJoT{ �x� �.kP�<fBkPf�{ }�fBy¸� � � wzyxq���|x� � sSp�fB}�u6hj��fzkPhj¡,� � q,lv�zqDqDy:mvonlvwB�Tonw<lJkTm

h�f�|z},lJ},���jkJ� kTi�q,��wzonhjq,f�mvonlJ}�ovk]¡,hjkTm � ¢ k]���<fxhj�]},� � kP|³q,lJo������ ���T� C� � {B�$q����j} � q�lJ}�onhji�k � kP�mvkT},lJ�v�+�$kPf<ovkPl �1� � {Be�fxhji�kPlJmnhjonp.q�r sSq,lJovu-wxfzya{ � � � ���

� ��� /��x» kPh�fzkPlJo�},fzy�� � �Dov},wzonfBkPl � � kT�Tq�fBmvonlvwz�Tonhjq�f�q,r"|z},lJonhj�J�jk��Bq�£:u�k]���z},f<hjmvu�m2£$hjon�mvpDu � q���hj��lJkT¡,lJkTmvmnhjq�f)i�hj}�¡�kPfzkTonhj�6|<lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u¯h�fB¡ � �Yf�� � ��|EkT�]ovq,l�{E� � s � �2qDqDyxu~},f�{� �B» w�{ »°���2� �"},fz¡�y<q,f�{ � � � � 6 q�hj¡�oT{E� � �2kPf"{�� � �DkPf�{E� � sSq,lvhj¡�q<{ � � ­ kT�Tk]mn�x�E{� � � � �2},lJ�Tq�f"{�}�fBy:� ��� wxlv��k�{�kTyDhjovq,lJmT{,�>�A����������� �4& � ��� �� � 0 � � � $�� ��� � =>?��� �# $���� ����� +-�����@# ���$���� +-���*����� � ������ 0 = +>+2: 3� ��������{D|B}�¡�kTm �T� � � .z�T��� � � �.q�lJ¡�}�f/ },w<rcu�},f<f�{��^}�f.�xlJ}�fB�Phjmv�]qx{�� �6{ � .z��� � w<�jp � � � ���

� �^� /���» kPh�fzkPlJot},fzy6� � �Dov},wzonfzkPl � � k]�Tq,fzmvonlvwB�]onhjq,f�q,r<|x�<pDmnhj�]},�E�Tq�lvlJkP�j}�onhjq�fBmtwBmnh�fz¡-mvpDu6�� q,��hj��lJkT¡�lJkTmvmnhjq,fzm � ¢ kT�v�xf<hj�T}�� � kJ|Eq,lJo��g�Y� ����� C � � {��$q,���j} � q,lJ}�onhji�k � kTmvk]},lJ�v�+��kJf<ovkPl�1� � {Be�fxhji�kPlJmnhjonp.q�rts2q,lJovu-w<fByE{ � � � ���

�]� � /���» kPh�fzkPlJot},fzy6� � �Dov},wzonfzkPl � �)fzkT£)i�hjkT£Mq,f~mvpDu � q,��hj��lJkT¡,lJkTmvmnhjq�f � ��f �2�3����������� ��& ���� �� � �1� ���� =2# �3��� ����� +-��� ����� � �����(��� 0 � � � $����2�3��&�� ������� ��& =2# �3� 0 �1 3� ��������{/ h�fBmv}��jk�{ �YlJkP�j},fzyE{��g|<lvh���� . � � � � �D� « �2�]�TkP|zovkTyB® �

� �x� /��B» kPh�fBkJlJoT{B¢ � ��w<lJu�},f<f�{E},fzy �x� �.kJ�xfzkPf � �ti�q,��wzonhjq,fz},lJp�mnw<lvrc}��Tk2lJk]�Tq,fzmvonlvwB�]onhjq,fwBmnh�fz¡¸�g�<�g��72e � � ���c�<p � lvhjyxm � ��f¸� � ��|Ek]�Tovq,l�{� � s � �2qDqDyxu�}�f"{ � � » w�{ »5��2��"},fz¡�y<q,f�{ � � � � 6 q�hj¡�oT{E� � �2kPf�{E� � �DkPf"{E� � sSq,lvhj¡�q<{�� � ­ kT�TkTmn�<�E{E� � � � �2},lJ�Tq�f"{},fzyW� � � w<lv�Dk�{BkTyDhjovq,lJmT{1�>�A����������� ��& �������� � 0 � � � 8�9� ��� �7=>?����# 8�9��� �����7+ �����@# ��� 8�9���(+-���*������� � ���! 0 = +>+>:1 3� ��������{P|z}�¡�k �T� � �x� �.q,lJ¡�},f / }�wxr�u�},f<f"{��D},f~�xlJ},fz�Phjmv�Tq<{� �¯{ � .B��� � wx�jp � � � ���

Page 49: Computer Science | Department of Computer Science ...banzhaf/papers/CI-book-chapter.pdf8 % '& 8)(+* & / % -, * /. , 98

� �2kPfBk]onhj�6­ lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡ � �

� � � /��2» kPh�fzkPlJoT{-¢ � ��w<lJu�}�fxf�{-},fzy �x� �.kP�<fzkPf � ­ }�lJ},���jkP��mnw<lvrc}��]kWlJkT�Tq�fBmvonlvwz�Tonhjq,f ���f �>�A����������� ��& � ��� �� � �1� ���� =># �3��� ����� +-��� ����� � ����� ��� 0 � � � $�� �2�3��&�� ������� �4& =2#%�A� 0 � A� �������,{ / h�fzmv},�jk�{ �YlJkP�j},fzya{�� . � ��|xlvh�� � � � �^� « �2�T�]kP|Bovk]yB® �

� �x� /��D» kJh�fBkPlJo�}�fBy � ��� } � kP� � �.qDy<kP����h�fE¡0�v�xh�|<� � w<h��jyxh�fE¡�h�f�q,lJon�zq�¡�q�fB}����PwBovonh�fz¡ � p6wzmn�h�fB¡¯}-�TkP����w<�j},lS},wzovq�u~}�ov}�C�¡�kPfzkTonhj�2|<lJq�¡�lJ}�u�u6h�fz¡�}�|x|<lJq�}���� � ��f�� � � p�k�{�kTyDhjovq,l�{B�2�3�� ��������� ��& ����� �� ��� ������� �<6�+ � + � � �>� � �*�# � ��� = ��&�� � ������� ��&���� 6�� ��*�� &�� � �� � ���� � �= 6 � � ������{�egf<hji�kJlJmnhjonp�q�rE­ },hjmn�jkTp�{B�D�Tq�on�j},fzya{ � wxfzk � � . � � � � � � � �n���<�M��f<ovkPlvfz}�onhjq�fB}����q�u6|<wBovkPl��^�JhjkPfB�]k��$q,f<rckPlJkJfB�Tk �

� � �.�x� /6� �ghjk�{ � � � �,� },p�q,wzu6hc{S},fzy � � � ��� � h � � �BkT}Mu�qDy<kP��h�fB¡:}�fBy:mnhju-w<�j}�onhjq,fq,r-mn�zkT}�l��jqD�]},��hj�TkTy5�v�xh�|¸rcq,lJu�}�onhjq,f¸h�f:u�kTov}��S�PwBovonh�fz¡ � 6�� ������ ��8�9��� �������# ��� ��>���! ������� � � � ���� � ��� �7! ����#������ $#%���T{ � � 4 � � � � .B� � � �D{ � � � �<�