Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Monday, 14 May 2012

  • Upload
    -

  • View
    222

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    1/44

    A-9;/9, Cjejsma, WM-JJ

    195 I. Y. Dulmnronn Ytrnnt

    WH? Lhffakar, Ejst? Mhhkm`y

    [nst Cnfka`, WJF? ;13 39>

    Eatne? Umurseay, Day 17, 3713

    Yrj Oyhtj Yaflar Dhfea`

    IEH (Mnaequartnrs)

    Ih-hpnratjhf Ejrnithratn, Mhhkm`y Safkn Hbbjin

    Mhhkm`y _j``a Warjsmae Cuj`ejfk (H`e), 1

    st B`hhr

    W7? Imjfsuram, Ejst? Mhhkm`y

    [nst Cnfka ;13 171.

    Yrj Fnn Lada Yjfkm

    IEH (Mnaequartnrs)

    Ih-hpnratjhf Ejrnithratn, Mhhkm`y Safkn Hbbjin

    Mhhkm`y _j``a Warjsmae Cuj`ejfk (H`e), 1

    st

    B`hhr

    WH? Imjfsuram, Ejst? Mhhkm`y

    [nst Cnfka ;13 171.

    Umn Enputy Snkjstrar hb Ihhpnratjvn Yhijntjns

    Ih-hpnratjhf Ejrnithratn, Mhhkm`y Safkn Hbbjin

    Mhhkm`y _j``a Warjsmae Cuj`ejfk (H`e), 1

    st

    B`hhr

    W7? Imjfsuram, Ejst? Mhhkm`y

    [nst Cnfka ;13 171.

    Umn Ynirntary

    Ih-hpnratjhf Enpartdnft

    [rjtnrs' Cuj`ejfks

    Lh`lata ;77 771

    Umn Snkjstrar hb Ihhpnratjvn Yhijntjns

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    2/44

    Fnw Ynirntarjat Cuj`ejfk

    1 L. Y. Shy Shae

    Lh`lata ;77 771.

    Umn Ynirntary

    Rjkj`afin Ihddjssjhf, [nst Cnfka`

    Cjlasm Cmawaf

    Ya t @aln Ijty

    Lh`lata ;77 7:1.

    Snb? Nfqujry jfth tmn abbajrs hb tmn Cjejsma Ihhpnratjvn Mhusjfk Yhijnty @te., 195

    I. Y. Dulmnronn Ytrnnt, WH? Lhffakar, Ejst? Mhhkm`y, [nst Cnfka , WJF? ;13 39>.

    Yuc?

    . Ihfstruitjhf hb Iyi`n Ytafe.

    3. Ihfstruitjhf hb B`akph`n casn.

    3. Wurimasn hb khehwf afe rnfhvatjhf hb tmn sadn bhr usjfk as

    Ihddufjty Ma``.

    Enar Yjrs,

    Af nxtrait js kjvnf cn`hw puc`jsmne jf Umn Un`nkrapm hf 1> Oafuary, 3713.

    Kh cy `aw, fht daohrjty hpjfjhf, says imjnb oustjin

    Umn ihuftry's thp ouekn theay aevjsne tmn ouejijary th whrl as jfenpnfenft`y hb

    puc ji snftjdnfts as hb ph jtjis, strnssjfk tmat ihurts smhue en jvnr ru jfks

    aiihrejfk th tmn `aw afe fht tmn daohrjty hpjfjhf.

    "Apart brhd jfenpnfenfin brhd ph`jtjis, tmn ouejijary a`sh fnnes jfenpnfenfin

    brhd phpu ar jftnrnst, WUJ quhtne Imjnb Oustjin hb Jfeja (IOJ) Y.M. Lapaeja as

    sayjfk wmj n prnsjejfk hvnr tmn Fafj Wa lmjva a Dndhrja Urust @niturn jf

    Dudcaj.

    "Umn `aw js fht snparatn brhd dhra`jty. Jf hur (ouekns') tmjfljfk afe cnmavjhur,

    3 1

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    3/44

    wn fnne th kjvn jdphrtafin th jftn nitua jftnkrjty. [mnf pnhp n say tmnrn arn

    snvnra hhpmh`ns jf tmn aw, J akrnn, cut tmn prhc`nd arjsns wmnf tmnrn arn

    `hhpmh`ns jf hur (ouekns') imaraitnr thh."

    (Wmhthihpy hb tmn Fnws js affnxne mnrnth.)

    [n mhpn tmat tmjs wj fht cn a dnimafjia jfvnstjkatjhf hf`y cut af

    nbbnitjvn/jdpartja` jfvnstjkatjhf whu`e kh hf th ch`stnr hur p`na.

    A Iyi`n Ytafe mas cnnf ihfstruitne

    1.

    vjh`atjfk tmn dafeathry prhvjsjhf hb tmn Ya`n Enne,

    3.

    vjh`atjfk tmn Ynitjhf 25 hb tmn Cyn-`aw hb tmn Yhijnty,

    9.

    enstrhyjfk tmn Hrkafjsne Krnnf,

    afe tmn sadn js af hbbnfin ufenr Jfejaf Wnfa` Ihen ? Ynitjhf 57>, 572 ? Irjdjfa`

    Crnaim hb Urust.

    A B`akph`n cas mas cnnf ihfstruitne -

    1.

    vjh`atjfk tmn dafeathry prhvjsjhf hb tmn sa`n Enne,

    3.

    vjh`atjfk tmn Ynitjhf 25 hb tmn Cyn-`aw hb tmn Yhijnty,

    9.

    enstrhyjfk tmn Hrkafjsne Krnnf,

    afe tmn sadn js af hbbnfin ufenr Jfejaf Wnfa` Ihen ? Ynitjhf 57>, 572 ? Irjdjfa`

    Crnaim hb Urust.

    Dhrnhvnr, tmn sadn mas fht ynt p`aine jf afy AKD afe eu`y passne cy tmn AKD.

    Umn ihddufjty Ma`` js khjfk th cn ihfstruitne afe/hr mas cnnf ihfstruitne

    1.

    vjh`atjfk tmn dafeathry prhvjsjhf hb tmn Ya`n Enne,

    3.

    vjh`atjfk tmn Ynitjhf 25 hb tmn Cyn-`aw hb tmn Yhijnty,

    9.

    enstrhyjfk tmn Hrkafjsne Krnnf,

    afe tmn sadn js af hbbnfin ufenr Jfejaf Wnfa` Ihen ? Ynitjhf 57>, 572 ? Irjdjfa`

    Crnaim hb Urust.

    Umn En`ta?

    1. Umn Enputy Snkjstrar hb Ih-hpnratjvn Yhijntjns, Ih-hpnratjhf Ejrnithratn,

    [akn

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    4/44

    Mhhkm`y Safkn Hbbjin, Mhhkm`y _j``a Warjsmae Cuj`ejfk (H`e), 1

    t

    B`hhr, W7?

    Imjfsuram, Ejst? Mhhkm`y, [nst Cnfka` ;13 171.

    3.

    Umn Jfspnithr hb Ihhpnratjvn Yhijntjns, Ynradphrn Ijri`n, Ynradphrn,

    Mhhkm`y.

    9.

    A. Umn Ynirntary, Cjejsma Ih-hpnratjvn Mhusjfk Yhijnty @te., 195 I. Y.

    Dulmnronn Ytrnnt, W7? Lhffakar, Ejst? Mhhkm`y, [nst Cnfka`, WJF ;13 39>.

    C. Umn Cjejsma Ih-hpnratjvn Mhusjfk Yhijnty @te., 195 I. Y. Dulmnronn

    Ytrnnt, WH? Lhffakar, Ejst? Mhhkm`y, [nst Cnfka`, WJF ;13 39>.

    Af nxtrait js kjvnf cn`hw brhd tmn Ya`n Enne wmjim js daen abtnr tmn purimasn hb

    b`at(s) cy nvnry a``httnn-dndcnr(s)?

    "9.

    Wursuaft th af app jiatjhf daen cy (fadn afe aeernss hb tmn a` httnn-

    dndcnr(s) afe tmnjr aeernss) (mnrnjfabtnr rnbnrrne t as tmn saje

    a` httnn(s)/ihfbjrdjfk party) bhr tmn purimasn hb b`at as bu` y dnftjhfne afe

    ensirjcne jf tmn Ynihfe Yimneu`n mnrnufenr wrjttnf (mnrnjfabtnr rnbnrrne th as

    tmn saje bat ) afe akrnnjfk th ihdp`y wjtm tnrds afe ihfejtjhfs prnsirjcne cy

    tmn Chare bhr tmn sa`n hb tmn saje bat jf tmn abhrnsaje prhonit afe hf tnfenrjfk a

    sud hb Ss. 31,777/- (Supnns twnfty hfn tmhusafe hf`y) hf`y a`hfkwjtm tmn saje

    app jiatjhf,

    tmn Chare mas akrnne th a``ht afe sn`` tmn saje b`at wjtm af ufejvjene

    jftnrnst afe smarn jf tmn ihddhf arnas afe baij`jtjns/adnfjtjns as bu``y

    ensirjcne jf tmn Umjre Yimneu`n mnrnufenr wrjttnf th tmn saje a``httnn tmrhukm

    tmn Yhijnty bhr a prjin sntt`ne at Ss. 9,7:,577/- (Supnns tmrnn `ai fjfn tmhusafe

    bhur muferne) hf`y.

    `.i)

    Umn knfnra ihddhf arnas afe baij jtjns prhvjene bhr tmn purimasnrs hb bat jf

    tmn nstatn dnftjhfne jf tmn Umjre Yimneu`n mnrnth sma` at a` tjdn cn mn`e cy tmn

    purimasnr afe/hr a`httnn dndcnr(s) a`hfk wjtm htmnr purimasnrs hb b at jf tmn

    saje prhonit afe sma` cn usne afe nfohyne cy tmnd jf ihddhf adhfkst

    tmndsn`vns afe fnjtmnr tmn a`httnn/hiiupjnr fhr afy htmnr purimasnr hb afy bat jf

    tmn abhrnsaje nstatn sma` afy tjdn cn nftjtne

    hf afy krhufe wmatshnvnr

    th daln

    partjtjhf hr ejvjsjhf tmnrnhb hr th i`ajd th mavn nxi`usjvn rjkmt

    jf afy daffnr

    wmatshnvnr

    th afy phrtjhf hb suim knfnra ihddhf arnas afe baij jtjns/adnfjtjns

    afe tmat tmn purimasnr a`hfk wjtm tmn htmnr purimasnrs hb ejbbnrnft b ats jf tmn

    5

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    5/44

    abhrnsaje nstatn sma` usn tmn saje knfnra ihddhf arnas afe baij jtjns/adnfjtjns

    bhr tmn purphsn bhr wmjim tmny arn nftjt ne th wjtmhut mjfenrjfk hr nfirhaimjfk

    uphf tmn awbu rjkmts hb htmnr purimasnrs afe hiiupjnrs hb htmnr bats jf tmn saje

    Wrhonit.

    1.

    W`nasn fhtn tmn dnafjfk hb tmn whres "hf afy krhufe wmatshnvnr" afe "jf

    afy daffnr wmatshnvnr".

    3.

    Umn nka pnrdjssjcj jty hb tmn suconit dnftjhfne Iyi`n Ytafe js th cn

    ihfsjenrne jf rnspnit th tmn abhrnsaje dafeathry i`ausn hb tmn Ya`n Enne.

    9.

    Umn nka pnrdjssjcj jty hb tmn suconit dnftjhfne B akph n Casn js th cn

    ihfsjenrne jf rnspnit th tmn abhrnsaje dafeathry i`ausn hb tmn Ya`n Enne.

    5.

    Umn `nka` pnrdjssjcj`jty hb tmn suconit dnftjhfne Ihddufjty Ma`` js th cn

    ihfsjenrne jf rnspnit th tmn abhrnsaje dafeathry i`ausn hb tmn Ya`n Enne.

    Umnrn js fh Iyi`n Ytafe afe/hr B`akph`n casn afe/hr Ihddufjty Ma`` jf tmn entaj`s

    hb ihddhf arna afe baij`jtjns prhvjene jf tmn Cjejsma Mhusjfk Wrhonit, Lhffakar,

    Wmasn-JJ wmjim js dnftjhfne ufenr Umjre Yimneu`n. Umn sadn js ensirjcne as Hpnf

    Ypain wmjim js spnijbjia``y dnftjhfne >:=9.;35 Yqd.

    (Wmhth ihpjns hb tmn pakn fh. 3, 5, 2, ; afe = hb tmn Ya`n Enne arn affnxne

    mnrnth.)

    Af nxtrait js kjvnf cn`hw brhd tmn Cyn-@aw hb tmn Cjejsma Ih-hpnratjvn Mhusjfk

    Yhijnty @te.?

    "Ihddnfindnft hb [hrl

    25. Cnbhrn taljfk up afy ihfstruitjhf wjtm rnpajr, rnfhvatjhf & dajftnfafin

    whrl tmn Chare hb Ejrnithrs..."

    Umn whre 'ihfstruitjhf' mas cnnf enntne brhd tmn Cyn- aw sh tmat jt ehns fht

    ihftraejit wjtm tmn dafeathry prhvjsjhf hb tmn Ya`n Enne, as dnftjhfne achvn.

    1.

    Umn nka pnrdjssjcj jty hb tmn suconit dnftjhfne Iyi n Ytafe js th cn

    ihfsjenrne jf rnspnit th tmn abhrnsaje snitjhf 25 hb tmn Cyn-@aw.

    3.

    Umn nka pnrdjssjcj jty hb tmn suconit dnftjhfne B akph n casn js th cn

    ihfsjenrne jf rnspnit th tmn abhrnsaje snitjhf 25 hb tmn Cyn-@aw.

    9.

    Umn `nka` pnrdjssjcj`jty hb tmn suconit dnftjhfne Ihddufjty Ma`` js th cn

    ihfsjenrne jf rnspnit th tmn abhrnsaje snitjhf 25 hb tmn Cyn-@aw.

    [akn

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    6/44

    (Wmhth ihpy hb tmn pakn fh. 3> hb tmn Cyn-@aw js affnxne mnrnth.)

    Af nxtrait hb tmn Ynitjhf 57> hb Jfejaf Wnfa` Ihen (JWI) js kjvnf cn`hw?

    [mhnvnr, cnjfk jf afy daffnr nftrustne wjtm prhpnrty, hr wjtm afy ehdjfjhf

    hvnr prhpnrty, ejsmhfnsty djsapprhprjatns hr ihfvnrts th mjs hwf usn tmat

    prhpnrty, hr ejsmhfnst y usns hr ejsphsns hb tmat prhpnrty jf vjh`atjhf hb afy

    ejrnitjhf hb `aw prnsirjcjfk tmn dhen jf wmjim suim trust js th cn ejsimarkne, hr hb

    afy nka ihftrait, nxprnss hr jdp jne, wmjim mn mae daen thuimjfk tmn ejsimarkn

    hb suim trust, hr wj`bu``y subbnrs afy htmnr pnrshf sh th eh, ihddjts 'irjdjfa`

    crnaim hb trust'.

    ? =7 NzjbD ?

    I -"B

    i j Y S W Y J

    [

    U a w r

    -

    9

    vJte [@

    5

    C U

    P

    U ) P : 1

    >

    1

    s t

    : r i z r

    :

    Bbbbb-

    P : 1 d 1 )

    -JD

    ;

    U

    : 1 ; 1

    < 5 1 1 R 1 5 1 ? 1

    rb

    z z i 4 r b b

    -

    9

    -

    srt-c-d>

    P:7(.11 rhi

    i l K

    1

    -B:bb

    B

    v(

    -9 D J 9992 tmn ASIY jssune a `nttnr

    aeernssne th tmn Yhijnty as bh``hws?

    ...tmjs hbbjin hb tmn ufenrsjkfne js fht jf a phsjtjhf th aiihre afy shrt hb

    pnrdjssjhf jf tmjs rnspnit rjkmt fhw, cniausn, hut hb 5>7 fhs hb nxjstjfk dndcnrs

    hb yhur shijnty (mavjfk >57 fh. hb bats), tmn fh hb dndcnrs jln`y th cn cnfnbjttne

    brhd tmn prhphsne iyi`n stafe js fht eu`y burfjsmne (dhrn prnijsn`y, tmn iapaijty

    hb tmn prhphsne iyi`n stafe js fht dnftjhfne).

    Fhw, yhu arn mnrncy rnqunstne th fnnebu` bhr sucdjssjhf hb tmjs rn`atne

    ehiudnfts jf tmjs rnkare bhr burtmnr ihursn hb aitjhf brhd tmjs nfe.

    = 1

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    9/44

    Hf 97.13.377: tmn Yhijnty rninjvne nttnr brhd tmn ASIY afe hf tmn sadn eay

    ufenr rnb. CJEJ/Iyi`n stafe jf para 5 tmn Ynirntary hb tmn Yhijnty rnp`jne th tmn

    ASIY tmrhukm tmn IJ as bh``hws?

    5. Fhw achut tmn iapaijty hb tmn prhphsne stafe wn day say tmat tmn iapaijty hb

    tmn stafe js 117 bt x = bt. Hur nstjdatn js tmat arhufe 377 iyi`ns iaf cn p`aine jf

    tmn prhphsne iyi`n stafe.

    1.

    Umn Ynirntary eje fht prhvjen afy va`je ehiudnft rnkarejfk tmn iapaijty hb

    tmn Iyi`n Ytafe.

    3.

    Umn Yhijnty eje fht p`ain afy ehiudnft rnkarejfk tmn iapaijty hb tmn Iyi`n

    Ytafe jfth afy AKD tj`` eatn.

    9.

    Umn Yhijnty eje fht p`ain afy safitjhf p`af hb tmn Iyi`n Ytafe jf afy AKD

    tj`` eatn.

    5.

    W`nasn fhtn tmat hf tmn Ynirntary hb tmn Yhijnty jfbhrdne th tmn CHE hb tmn

    Yhijnty tmat fht assnssne as jt enpnfes hf tmn way hb p aijfk hr lnnpjfk

    iyi n. cut jfbhrdne th tmn ASIY tmat Hur nstjdatn js tmat arhufe 377

    iyi`ns iaf cn p`aine jf tmn prhphsne iyi`n stafe." Umn twh statndnfts arn

    ihdp`ntn`y ejbbnrnft th naim htmnr.

    >.

    Umn jfbhrdatjhf js thta``y casn`nss afe fht vnrjbjne cy afy @CY.

    2.

    Jt was a sthry wmjim tmn Ynirntary hb tmn Yhijnty dafubaiturne oust th

    jfb`unfin tmn ASIY bhr hctajfjfk safitjhf bhr tmn Iyi`n/Uwh-wmnn`nr Ytafe

    jf tmnjr bavhur.

    Aiihrejfk th tmn ijvj` sijnfin tmn iapaijty hb tmn iyi`n stafe js 55 fhs. iyi`ns hf`y,

    wmjim mas cnnf eu`y aiinssne cy a @CY hb Lhffakar Dufjijpa`jty.

    Brhd tmn achvn wn cn`jnvn tmat tmn Yhijnty prhvjene tmn sthry hb iapaijty th tmn

    ASIY oust bhr hctajfjfk safitjhf bhr tmn Iyi`n/Uwh-wmnn`nr stafe jf tmnjr bavhur.

    (Wmhth ihpy hb a W`af rnkarejfk iapaijty hb tmn suconit-dnftjhfne iyi`n stafe js

    affnxne mnrnth.)

    Hf 91.13.377: ufenr rnb. Dndh Fh. 1;:/7: tmn IJ, Ynradphrn Ijri`n bhrwarene

    tmn `nttnr hb tmn Yhijnty a`hfk wjtm bavhurac`n ihddnfts wmjim js kjvnf cn`hw?

    :1 Wakn

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    10/44

    ...Yh tmat ihfstruitjhf whrl bhr tmn iyi`n stafe ihu`e cn startne as nar`y as

    phssjc`n.

    1.

    Umn abhrnsaje `nttnr js akajfst tmn dafeathry prhvjsjhf hb tmn Ya`n Enne.

    3.

    Umn abhrnsaje `nttnr js akajfst tmn dafeathry prhvjsjhf hb tmn Cyn-@aw.

    9.

    Umn abhrnsaje `nttnr mas mn`pne th enstrhy tmn Hrkafjsne Krnnf.

    5.

    Umn abhrnsaje `nttnr mas mn`pne th hiiur af hbbnfin `jln Irjdjfa` Crnaim hb

    Urust as pnr tmn Yni 57>, 572 hb tmn Jfejaf Wnfa Ihen.

    Hf 75.71.3717 ufenr rnb. Dndh Fh. 31 1-9992 tmn ASIY jssune a `nttnr aeernssne

    th tmn Ynirntary hb Yhijnty wjtm af hpnf pnrdjssjhf bhr ihfstruitjhf hb iyi n

    stafe afe tmn ASIY wrhtn as bh``hws?

    ...yhu day ihfstruit tmn Iyi`n Ytafe prhvjene a` tmn dndcnrs (afe tmnjr badjy)

    hb yhur shijnty iaf knt tmn cnfnbjt hb jt jrrnspnitjvn hb iastn, irnne, ih`hur afe snx

    bhr rnkjstnrjfk pnain afe trafquj jty wjtmjf hur shijnty.

    At tmn sadn tjdn, yhu arn a`sh rnqunstne th taln fninssary dnasurns bhr

    ihfstruitjhf hb hfn hr dhrn fh. hb Iyi`n Ytafe bhr burtmnr (jb afy) th dnnt up tmn

    fnne as wn` as endafe hb tmn dndcnrs (Knfnra chey) hvnr afe achvn tmn

    nxjstjfk iapaijty hb tmn prhphsne Iyi`n Ytafe...

    1.

    Umn abhrnsaje `nttnr js akajfst tmn dafeathry prhvjsjhf hb tmn Ya`n Enne.

    3.

    Umn abhrnsaje `nttnr js akajfst tmn dafeathry prhvjsjhf hb tmn Cyn-@aw.

    9.

    Umn abhrnsaje `nttnr mas mn`pne th enstrhy tmn Hrkafjsne Krnnf.

    5.

    Umn abhrnsaje `nttnr mas mn`pne th hiiur af hbbnfin `jln Irjdjfa` Crnaim hb

    Urust as pnr tmn Yni 57>, 572 hb tmn Jfejaf Wnfa Ihen.

    >.

    Umn abhrnsaje `nttnr mas cnnf jssune wjtmhut mavjfk afy shrt hb ehiudnft

    as jt was aslne vjen dndh fh. 31>91 9992 eatne 3:.71.377:.

    Hf 19.73.3717 ; fhs a``httnn-dndcnrs kjvnf `nttnr th tmn Imajrdaf / Wrnsjenft /

    Ynirntary rnbnrrjfk nar`jnr `nttnr hb eatne 19.13.377: rnkarejfk Iyi`n afe/hr Uwh

    [mnn`nr Ytafe wjtm a rnqunst hb shdn jfbhrdatjhf, as bh``hws?

    a) wmntmnr yhu mavn rninjvne afy rnphrt brhd ihdpntnft autmhrjty rnkarejfk tmn

    strnfktm / iapaijty hb tmn abhrnsaje stafe. Jb sh, ljfe`y arrafkn th prhvjen us wjtm

    a ihpy hb tmn sadn.

    17

    J

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    11/44

    Uj tmn eatn, tmn `nttnr mas cnnf jkfhrne afe fh rnp`y mas cnnf kjvnf th tmn

    app`jiafts rnkarejfk tmn iapaijty hb tmn Iyi`n Ytafe.

    Hf 19.73.3717 a nttnr was kjvnf th tmn Imajrdaf rnkarejfk tmn ihfstruitjhf hb

    tmn B akph n casn.

    Uj tmn eatn tmn nttnr mas cnnf jkfhrne afe fh rnp y mas cnnf rninjvne.

    Ihfsjenrjfk tmn nttnrs brhd 19.13.377: th 19.73.3717 yhu wj ufenrstafe twh

    para``n` systnds arn ruffjfk jf Cjejsma.

    1.

    Umn autmhrjty hb Cjejsma js ihftjfuhus y jkfhrjfk th shdn hb tmn a` httnn-

    dndcnrs afe fht prhvjejfk afy jfbhrdatjhf.

    3.

    Umn autmhrjty hb Cjejsma js prhvjejfk jfbhrdatjhf th tmn ESIY afe tmn IJ

    cypassjfk tmn AKD as wn`` as shdn hb tmn a``httnn-dndcnrs.

    Hf 1=.73.3717 as nttnr was kjvnf th Umn Imajrdaf / tmn Ynirntary / tmn Urnasurnr

    as wn` as ihpy th varjhus mjkmnr autmhrjtjns wjtm a rnqunst th savn tmn

    endhiraiy.

    Uj tmn eatn, tmn nttnr mas cnnf jkfhrne afe fh rnp y mas cnnf rninjvne.

    [n mavn sucdjttne snvnra ihdp`ajfts eurjfk `ast 3-9 ynars rnkarejfk tmn

    nfirhaimdnft jf Cjejsma cy vjh`atjfk tmn Ya`n Enne th tmn bh``hwjfk autmhrjtjns.

    1.

    Umn Ihhpnratjhf Enpartdnft, [rjtnrs' Cuj`ejfk, Lh`lata.

    3.

    Umn hbbjin hb tmn Snkjstrar hb Ihhpnratjvn Yhijntjns, Lh`lata.

    9.

    Umn hbbjin hb tmn Enputy Snkjstrar hb Ihhpnratjvn Yhijntjns, Mhhkm`y Safkn.

    5.

    Umn hbbjin hb tmn Ihhpnratjhf Jfspnithr, Ynradphrn Ijri`n.

    Uj tmn eatn, fh aitjhf mas cnnf talnf akajfst tmn vjh`atjhf tmn Ya`n Enne

    purphsnbu``y.

    Uj tmn eatn, fh aitjhf mas cnnf talnf akajfst tmn vjh atjhf hb tmn Ynitjhf 25 hb

    tmn Cyn @aw purphsnbu `y.

    Uj tmn eatn, fh aitjhf mas cnnf talnf akajfst tmn enstruitjhf hb tmn hrkafjsne

    krnnf purphsnbu` y.

    11JWakn

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    12/44

    Hf 1=.79.3717 ufenr rnb. fh. ==;-Ihhp/A/9W->/17 tmn Asstt. Ynirntary th tmn

    Khvt. hb [nst Cnfka jssune a nttnr aeernssne th tmn Snkjstrar hb Ihhpnratjvn

    Yhijntjns wjtm a ihpy th tmn ASIY, Mhhkm`y as bh``hws?

    "...J

    ad ejrnitne th rnqunst yhu ljfe`y th iausn af nfqujry jfth tmn dattnr afe

    burfjsm a rnphrt tmnrnhb th tmjs enpartdnft at af nary eatn...

    Uj tmn eatn, fh aitjhf mas cnnf talnf akajfst tmn hbbnfenrs/tmn aiiusne

    purphsnbu``y.

    Hf 75.7>.3717 ufenr rnb. fh. 1935-Ihhp/A/9W->/17 tmn Asstt. Ynirntary th tmn

    Khvt. hb [nst Cnfka jssune a nttnr aeernssne th tmn Snkjstrar hb Ihhpnratjvn

    Yhijntjns wjtm a ihpy th tmn ASIY, Mhhkm`y as bh``hws?

    ... ad ejrnitne th rnqunst yhu ljfe`y taln apprhprjatn aitjhf jf tmn dattnr afe

    burfjsm af aitjhf talnf rnphrt th tmjs enpartdnft at af nar`y eatn as a`rnaey

    shukmt bhr ufenr tmjs Enptt's dndh vjen ==;-Ihhp. et. 1=.79.3717...

    Uj tmn eatn, fh aitjhf mas cnnf talnf akajfst tmn hbbnfenrs/tmn aiiusne

    purphsnbu``y.

    Hf 75.7=.3717 ufenr rnb. fh. 393>-Ihhp/A/9W->/3717 tmn Enputy Ynirntary th

    tmn Khvt. hb [nst Cnfka` jssune a 3

    f e

    rndjfenr nttnr aeernssne th tmn Snkjstrar

    hb Ihhpnratjvn Yhijntjns wjtm a ihpy th tmn ESIY, Mhhkm`y afe tmn IJ, Ynradphrn

    Ijri`n, rnbnrrjfk Dndh hb tmn JKW, Rjkj`afin Ihddjssjhf, [nst Cnfka` cnarjfk Fh.

    17;9-R1'H'-In``/WNS(FAS)-532/3717, eatne 7=.7;.3717, as bh``hws?

    ...afe taljfk fninssary aitjhf, as a`rnaey cnnf aslne bhr twjin vjen tmjs

    Enpartdnft's nar jnr Dndh Fh. ==;-Ihhp., eatne 1=.79.3717 & 1935-Ihhp. eatne

    75.7>.3717. Cut surprjsjfk`y fh jfbhrdatjhf mavn ynt cnnf rninjvne cy tmjs

    Enpartdnft brhd yhur nfe.

    Zhu arn, tmnrnbhrn, hfin akajf rnqunstne th burfjsm tmjs enpartdnft wjtm tmn AUS

    as a rnaey aslne bhr wjtmjf a bhrtfjkmt brhd tmn eatn hb rninjpt hb tmjs `nttnr...

    W`nasn fhtn tmn whre 'surprjsjfk`y'. Uj`` tmn eatn, fh aitjhf mas cnnf talnf akajfst

    tmn hbbnfenrs/tmn aiiusne purphsnbu``y.

    Hf 1>.73.3711 ufenr rnb. fh. 55;-Ihhp/A/9W->/17 tmn Asstt. Ynirntary th tmn

    13 J

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    13/44

    Khvt. hb [nst Cnfka jssune a nttnr aeernssne th tmn Snkjstrar hb Ihhpnratjvn

    Yhijntjns wjtm a ihpy th tmn ESIY, Mhhkmy afe tmn IJ, Ynradphrn Ijri n, as

    bh``hws?

    ...tmjs Enptt. mavn hcsnrvne tmat (1) a iyi`n stafe / Uwh [mnn`nr Ytafe afe a

    bakph`n casn mavn cnnf daen jf tmn brnn spain hb tmn Knfnra ihddhf arnas hb

    tmn shijnty vjh`atjfk tmn dafeathry prhvjsjhf hb tmn sa`n enne. (3) tmn shijnty mas

    jkfhrne tmn Yni. 57 hb tmn [.C.I.Y. Ait, 1:=9, ihrrnsphfejfk tmn prnsnft 51 hb

    [.C.I.Y. Ait hb 3772 as wn as tmn 2= hb [.C.I.Y. Su`ns, 1:=; ihrrnsphfejfk tmn

    prnsnft 2;A hb [.C.I.Y. Su`ns, 3711 bhr ejsa`hwjfk tmn dndcnrs th imnil & vnrjby

    tmn chhls afe ehiudnfts.

    Jf vjnw hb tmn achvn, yhu arn rnqunstne th snfe afe A.U.S. as a rnaey shukmt bhr

    ufenr tmn Enptt's Dndh. Fh. ==;-Ihhp. et 1=.79.17 afe 1935-Ihhp. et 75.7>.17

    sucsnqunft rndjfenr Fh. 3937-Ihhp. et 75.7=.3717...

    W`nasn fhtn tmn whre 'tmjs Enptt. mavn hcsnrvne'. Uj`` tmn eatn, fh aitjhf mas cnnf

    talnf akajfst tmn hbbnfenrs/tmn aiiusne purphsnbu``y.

    Fh aitjhf mas cnnf talnf p`ain nvnf abtnr snvnra` rnqunsts / ihdp`ajfts brhd tmn

    rnkjstnrne dndcnrs, wmjim js euy apprhvne cy tmn ESIY hbbjin as wn as tmn

    Ihhpnratjhf Enpartdnft.

    Fh aitjhf mas cnnf talnf p`ain nvnf abtnr tmn `nttnrs jssune brhd tmn Ihhpnratjhf

    Enpartdnft.

    As a rnsu`t, tmn Yhijnty js ihftjfuhus`y nfkakne snvnra` j``nka`/uf`awbu` whrls. Jt

    snnds tmat sjfin tmny cn jnvn tmat fh aitjhf wj cn talnf brhd tmn mjkmnr

    autmhrjty.

    Hf 7:.79.3713 wn mavn kjvnf a `nttnr th tmn Yhijnty afe th tmn mjkmnr autmhrjtjns

    a`sh th jfbhrd hur hconitjhf akajfst tmn Ihddufjty Ma``.

    Uj`` tmn eatn, tmn `nttnr mas cnnf jkfhrne afe fh rnp`y mas cnnf rninjvne.

    Umn Iyi`n Ytafe afe tmn Ihddufjty Ma`` wj`` irnatn a dassjvn shija` prhc`nd.

    19 J W a

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    14/44

    Catmrhhd, Cnerhhd, Ljtimnf afe Ejfjfk Shhd hb shdn b`ats arn nxtrndn`y i`hsn

    th tmn nxprnssne ihfstruitjhf afe =7% vjsjcj`jty (jfsjen) hb tmn nxprnssne rhhds js

    nxtrndn`y i`nar brhd tmn saje ihfstruitjhf. Wnnpjfk jfth rhhds' jsphssjc`n, wmjim

    wj`` irnatn a snrjhus prhc`nd, nspnija``y th tmhsn whdnf afe/hr imj`ernf wmh arn

    `jvjfk jf tmhsn b`ats.

    Jf tmn `ast Auejt rnphrt tmn Auejthr hb Cjejsma mas dnftjhfne tmn bh``hwjfk?

    "...Jf tmn krjnvafins daen cy tmn dndcnrs jt was phjftne hut tmat tmn cyn-`aws hb

    tmn shijnty tmn whre 'ihfstruitjhf' mas cnnf en`ntne cut tmn shijnty js stj`` khjfk

    hf wjtm tmn ihfstruitjhf whrl a sh phjftne hut tmat prnvjhus ynar's nxpnfejturn

    ufenr tmjs mnae hb aiihuft js j``nka`. Mhwnvnr tmn baits crhukmt th tmn fhtjin hb

    tmn enpartdnfta` hbbjinrs."

    Uj`` tmn eatn, fh aitjhf mas cnnf talnf akajfst tmn vjh`atjhf hb tmn Cyn-@aw.

    (Wmhthihpy hb pakn fh. 9 hb tmn Auejt Snphrt as pucjsmne cy tmn Yhijnty affnxne

    mnrnth.)

    Jf iasn hb B`akph`n Casn, wn mavn hcsnrvne tmat fh pnrdjssjhf mas cnnf kraftne

    cnbhrn nxniutjhf brhd tmn ESIY hr brhd tmn mjkmnr ihdpntnft autmhrjty as pnr

    tmn snitjhf 15>(1), 15>(3) hb tmn [CIY Ait.

    Uj`` tmn eatn, fh aitjhf mas cnnf talnf akajfst tmn j``nka` afe uf`awbu` whrl.

    Jf iasn hb tmn Ihddufjty Ma` wn whu`e `jln th jfbhrd yhu tmat?

    1.

    Fh ihfstruitjhf iaf cn daen jf tmn Hpnf Ypain wjtmjf tmn pnrjpmnry hb tmn

    ihdp`nx as pnr tmn Umjre Yimneu`n hb tmn Ya`n Enne.

    3.

    Umn 'rnfhvatjhf' whre js app jiac`n th a 'ihfstruitjhf' hf`y. Jb tmnrn js fh

    ihfstruitjhf, rnfhvatjhf js jdphssjc`n.

    9.

    Jf tmn @ay Hut W`af prhvjene cy tmn [nst Cnfka` Mhusjfk Chare ([CMC) tmn

    `afe, as wn`` as tmn Knfnra` Ihddhf Arna, as wn`` as tmn Hrkafjsne Krnnf,

    as wn as tmn Hpnf Ypain mas a rnaey cnnf sh`e hut jf tmn prhphrtjhfatn

    rjkmts th tmn a httnn-dndcnrs. Eurjfk tmat trafsaitjhf wjtm tmn a httnn-

    dndcnrs tmn [CMC eje fht ejsi`hsn jf a `nka way tmat tmnrn js afy

    ihfstruitjhf nxjsts.

    15 J W k

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    15/44

    5.

    [jtmhut `afe, fh ihfstruitjhf iaf cn sh e th tmn cuynr. Umn cuynr iaffht

    purimasn afy suim ihfstruitjhf wjtmhut afe.

    >.

    [mnf tmn Yhijnty js purimasjfk a khehwf brhd tmn [CMC, jt wj`` cn trnatne

    as tmn ihfstruitjhf wmjim mas cnnf daen bhr tmn Yhijnty cy tmn [CMC.

    Mnfin tmn [CMC mas p ayne tmn rh n as a prhdhtnr. Mnfin prhdhtnr cuj es

    tmn ihfstruitjhf hf cnma b hb a cuynr. Abtnr ihdp`ntjfk tmn purimasn

    prhinss a` nka jacj jtjns hb tmn ihfstruitjhf wj cn chrfn cy tmn Yhijnty

    hf`y. As wn mavn purimasne a` nka jacj jtjns hb tmn ihfstruitjhf hb a b at

    afe knfnra` ihddhf arna brhd tmn [CMC.

    2.

    Mnfin tmn Yhijnty iaffht avhje brhd nka jacj jty hb ihfstruitjhf cy usjfk

    tmn whre "Wurimasn" rnkarejfk tmn Ihddufjty Ma``.

    ;.

    [n mavn hcsnrvne tmat fh pnrdjssjhf mas cnnf kraftne cnbhrn nxniutjhf

    brhd tmn ESIY hr brhd tmn mjkmnr ihdpntnft autmhrjty as pnr tmn snitjhf

    15>(1), 15>(3) hb tmn [CIY Ait.

    Uj tmn eatn, fh aitjhf mas cnnf talnf akajfst tmn j `nka afe uf awbu whrl.

    Uheay?

    A.

    Umn Ait, wmjim js af hbbnfin u/s 57>, 572 hb Jfejaf Wnfa Ihen, tmat mas

    cnnf p aine jf tmn AKD afe mas cnnf passne cy tmn daohrjty vhtn as pnr

    tmn [CIY Ait afe tmn Suns, afe tmn sadn mas cnnf apprhvne cy tmn hbbjin

    hb tmn IJ afe tmn ESIY,.

    Uj tmn eatn, tmn hbbnfenrs arn fht baijfk afy ouekdnft bhr tmnjr hbbnfin Fh

    aitjhf mas cnnf talnf jf bavhur th tmn @aw afe hrenr.

    Jf tmn sjdj ar way, wmat day mappnf jf buturn8

    C.

    Umn Ait, wmjim js af hbbnfin u/s 977 hb Jfejaf Wnfa Ihen, wj cn p aine,

    passne afe apprhvne.

    I.

    Umn Ait, wmjim js af hbbnfin u/s 9;> hb Jfejaf Wnfa Ihen, wj cn p aine,

    passne afe apprhvne.

    Umjs day mappnf jf buturn Jb theay tmn hbbnfenrs arn fht baijfk afy ouekdnft bhr

    tmnjr hbbnfin.

    1>

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    16/44

    Afy typn ihfstruitjhf jf tmn hpnf spain js a dhfntary `hss bhr us sjfin wn mavn

    jfvnstne hur mare-narfne dhfny bhr Hpnf Ypain hf`y jf tmn Knfnra Ihddhf

    Arnas jf Cjejsma.

    Yjrs, eurjfk `ast tmrnn ynars wn arn ihdp`ajfjfk rnkarejfk tmn vjh`atjhf hb tmn Ya`n

    Enne, vjh`atjhf hb tmn Cyn-@aw afe Enstruitjhf hb Hrkafjsne Krnnf th snvnra`

    ihfinrfne mjkmnr autmhrjtjns cut tj`` tmn eatn, fh oustjin mas cnnf rninjvne.

    [n rnqunst yhu th ihfsjenr tmn ihdp`ajfts as pnr tmn aw afe fht daohrjty

    hpjfjhf.

    [n mhpn tmat `nka` prhineurn wj`` cn erawf akajfst tmn hbbnfenrs afe oustjin th

    cn prhvjene wjtmhut burtmnr en`ay.

    Zhurs bajtmbu``y,

    l

    o - A j

    \Ywarup DhealT

    Nfi`hsurns?

    1.

    Wmhthihpy hb Umn fnws puc`jsmne jf Umn Un`nkrapm hf 1> Oafuary, 3713.

    3.

    Wmhthihpy hb Wakn fh. 3, 5, 2, ; afe = hb tmn Ya`n Enne

    9.

    Wmhthihpy hb Wakn fh. 3> hb tmn Cyn-@aw.

    5.

    Wmhthihpy hb Wakn fh. 395 jfi`uejfk ihvnr pakn hb tmn chhl fadne "Wh`jin

    Mafe Chhl" wrjttnf cy Dr. Y. L. @amjrj.

    >.

    Wmhthihpy hb @ay Hut W`af.

    2.

    Wmhthihpy hb a pakn hb tmn Ynirntarja` Snphrt eatne 7:.7=.377:.

    ;.

    Wmhthihpy hb pakn fh. W-1; hb djfutns hb>tm AKD.

    12J

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    17/44

    =.

    Wmhthihpy hb `nttnr rnb. fh. CJEJYMA/7:/7= eatne 35.17.377:.

    :.

    Wmhthihpy hb `nttnr rnb. fh. CJEJYMA/51-11/9 eatne 35.17.377:.

    17.Wmhthihpy hb `nttnr hb 17; fhs. a``httnn-dndcnrs kjvnf th tmn Yhijnty hf

    eatne 19.13.377:.

    11.Wmhthihpy hb ijvj` p`af rnkarejfk iapaijty hb Iyi`n Ytafe.

    13.Wmhthihpy hb pakn fh. 9 hb tmn Auejt Snphrt.

    1;JWakn

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    18/44

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    19/44

    N` jAC@N@

    Brhft Wakn 6 Ythry

    Mjfkjfh

    daw j

    Umn fnxt Knf j17

    `naes tmn way.

    I`jil mnrn th

    lfhw mhw

    hntzhrjdn.i.h.jfrMyufeajjj7

    Aes cy I , 3713

    "J b af hrenr js fht jf bavhur hb a part jiu `ar krhup, tmnf tmn ouekn bains a cail`asm. A f

    atdhs pmnrn js irnatne wmnrncy prnssu rn js nxnrtne hf tmn ouekn," mn aeene , ensirjcjfk

    tmn rna`jty hb puc` ji hpjfjhf putt jfk ihurts ufe nr prnssurn.

    ;eays

    ust jin Lapae ja 's rndarls ihjfi je ne w jtm a pnrinpt jhf tmat tmn `hwnr ihurts, wmj`n

    Krapmjtj

    nije jfk caj` , wnrn cnjfk jfb `unfine cy ihd d ufjty snft jdnfts, nkkne hf cy mjkm-vh`takn

    Lfhwmhw

    R ihvnrakn. Umn Yuprnd n Ihurt mae rninft `y rndjfene ihu rts tmat caj ` was tmn ru `n afe

    Ohcs

    nfja` tmn nxinpt jhf, bh ` `hwjfk wmjim d afy hb tmn 3K siad aiiu sne w nrn rn`nasne brhd

    Un`nljes

    aj ` , pnfejfk tr ja .

    Iarnnrkrapm

    Wnrshfa` UU Umn imjnb oust jin 's statndnft theay wj` ` a `sh eraw attnft jhf jf Ia`iutta wmnrn snvnf A DST

    I J U JN Y A F E S N K J H F Y

    j rnithrs mavn cnnf rnpnatne`y e nfjne caj` bh ` `hwjfk tmn Enind cnr : b jrn tmat l j `ne :1

    Dntrh

    nhp`n afe st jrrne phpu `ar afknr.

    Fhrtmnast

    Omarlmafe

    h shd n, Oust jin Lapae ja 's ihd d nfts appnarne th rnb `nit a shrt hb shu`-snarimjfk wjtmjf

    Cjmar

    oueji jary tmat mas jfirnasjfk`y p`ayne af ai t jv jst rh `n jf rninft ynars, ndch`e nfne cy

    He jsma

    hpu`ar hpjfjhf, a khvnrfafin e nb ji jt afe a e jv je ne `nkjs`aturn.

    A S I M J R N Y

    sjd u`tafnhus d neja nxp`hsjhf, tmny saje, thh put acfhrda` prnssu rn hf tmn khvnrfdnft

    Yjfin 1st Darim, 1:::

    fe tmn oueji jary. Wrnssurn krhups arhsn, tmn WJ@ iu`turn b `hurjsmne afe oueji ja ` hvnrrnaim

    appnarne th aiqujrn shd n `nkjtjd aiy cniau sn hb tmn ph`jt jia` i `ass's e wjfe` jfk irnejcj ` j ty.

    U M N U N @ N K S A W M

    - Achut ^s f mjs b jrst ynar jf hb bjin, Lapae ja mae mjd sn`b ihftrhvnrsja ` y jfvhlne tmn " jfst jtut jhfa`

    - Aevnrt jsn

    ftnkrjty" ehitrjfn th quasm W.O. Umhd as's apphjftdnft as tmn imjnb v jk j `afin

    - Bnnecail

    hdd jss jhfnr.

    - Ihftait ^s

    Cu t sjfin tmnf, mn mas smhwf a lnnf awarnfnss hb tmn eafknrs hb oueji ja ` hvnrrnaim

    Ia`iutta

    [ n a tm n r fenr phpu`ar prnssu rn afe mas cnnf i aut jhfjfk tmn ihu rts akajfst upsntt jfk tmn ca`afin

    Rn

    Dax ? 33.3"I (5)

    f Fhvnd cnr 32, tmn IOJ mae puc`ji `y ailfhw`ne kne tmn nxniut jvn's ihfstrajfts afe tmn

    .n

    5.

    5.,,, Djf ? 17.3I (-

    5)

    Undpnraturn

    b phwnr jf a end hiraiy.

    ihu rts' fnne th nxnri jsn rnstrajft.

    Sn`atjvn Mudjejty?

    D a x ? : 5 % D j f ? >1 %

    Yufrjsn ? 2?1: AD

    Umn

    oue ji jary fnnes th whrl jf tmn arna end ariatne cy tmn Ihfst jtut jhf. Awarnfnss achu t

    Yufsnt ? >?19 WD

    jkmts mas krhwf wmj`n rnernss b rhd tmn nxniut jvn mas cnnf rneui ne. Umn nxniu t jvn mas

    Uheay

    ts hwf ihd pu`sjhfs? mu kn phpu`at jhf, ail hb rnshurins, mjkm jfb `at jhf, k `hca` nihfhd ji

    Dajf`y i `nar sly

    nashfs," mn mae saje.

    Mjs w hres theay iad n at a tjd n tmn ihurts mavn cnnf irjtji jsne bhr stnppjfk hf tmn

    I J D

    xniut jvn's thns cy hrenrjfk bhrd nr ouekns th taln hvnr a c`ail dhfny prhcn.

    Ynfjhr ihufsn` Saonnv Emavaf, mhwnvnr, rnbusne th jftnrprnt tmn spnnim as hfn mnra`e jfk

    af nra hb oue ji ja ` rnstrajft . Mn saje O ust jin Lapae ja 's v jnws appnarne th cn d hrn hb a

    `JFU-111hr

    11171,17.171[ .., AHWJI1.

    J F U H E A Z ' Y W A W N S

    Brhft Wakn

    Fatjhf

    Ia`iutta

    Cnfka`

    Hpjfjhf

    Jftnrfatjhfa`

    Cus jfnss

    Yphrts

    Y u e h l u

    Y u e h l u F n w C N U A

    Irhsswhre

    O u d c ` n

    Ka``nry

    Mhrsn Sai jfk

    Wrnss Sn`nasns

    Uravn`

    [ N N L @ Z B N A U ^ S N Y

    Whpu`jsd iautjhf th ouekns

    - Kh cy `aw, fht daohrjty hpjfjhf, says imjnb oustjin

    W U J A F E H ^ S @ N K A @ I HS S N Y W H F E N F U

    Oaf. 15? Umn ihuftry's thp ouekn theay aevjsne tmn oueji jary th whrl as jfenpnfenft`y hb

    puc`ji snft jd nfts as hb ph jt jis, strnssjfk tmat ihurts smhu`e en` jvnr ru ` jfks aiihrejfk th

    tmn `aw afe fht tmn daohrjty hpjfjhf.

    "Apart b rhd jfe npnfenfin brhd ph`jt jis, tmn oue ji jary a`sh fnnes jfenpnfe nfin brhd

    phpu`ar jftnrnst," WUJ quhtne Imjnb Oust jin hb Jfeja (IOJ) Y.M. L apaeja as sayjfk w mj`n

    prnsje jfk hvnr tmn Fafj Wa`lmjva`a Dnd hrja` Urust @ni turn jf Dud caj.

    mttp?//www.tn nkrapmjfeja.ihd/113711>/osp/brhftpakn/sthryX1>77=1;1.osp

    13.7>.3713

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    20/44

    Whpu jsd iautjhf th ouekns

    akn 3 hb 3

    Aevt @jfls?

    Imnap [neejfk Ernssns

    Qujt Dntmadpmntadjfn

    Imjfa Uraen @naes

    smhp hf jfn

    iau t jhf aka jfst y jn `e jfk th d a oh rj ta rjaf jsd .

    "A b tn r a `` , tmn ihur ts a rn tmn cu `warl aka jfst da oh r j ta r jaf jsd tmn whr `e hvnr , " Emavaf sa je .

    Umn IOJ a `sh aslne m js i h ` `nakuns th `hhl jfwares.

    "Umn aw js fht snparatn brhd dhra`jty. Jf hur (ouekns') tmjfljfk afe cnmavjhur, wn fnne th

    kjvn jdphrtafin th jftn``nitua` jftnkrjty. [mnf pnhp`n say tmnrn arn snvnra` hhpmh`ns jf

    tmn aw, J akrnn, cut tmn prhc`nd arjsns wmnf tmnrn arn hhpmh`ns jf hur (ouekns')

    imaraitnr thh."

    Ous t j in Lapae ja sa je o ue kns w j tm " o ue j i ja ` jf tnkrj ty" smhu `e fh t whr ry achut `nk js `at jhf suim

    as tmn o ue j i ja ` aiihuf tac j ` jty c j ` `, wm jim mas cnnf tac `ne jf War ` jad nft afe mas apparnf t`y

    upsnt a bnw ouekns.

    Mn a`sh aevjsne bn``hw ouekns th lnnp tmndsn`vns acrnast hb iurrnft abbajrs. "Umn ihurts

    smhu`e rna`jsn tmn ihfsnqunfins hb tmnjr ouekdnfts. Jf theay's tjdn, tmn aw iaffht cn

    snpara tne b rhd ni hfhd jis afe b jfafin . "

    Oustjin Lapaeja rnkrnttne tmat snfjhr `awynrs wnrn fht ihftr jcutjfk th tmn b jn `e hb `aw.

    "Ynfjhr awynrs arn cusy daljfk dhfny brhd Dhfeays th Brjeays. Umny ehf't ihftrjcutn

    th tmn envn`hpdnft hb tmn `aw cniausn hb wmjim tmn curenf ba` s hf tmn ouekns. Umn

    ouekns mavn th ba`` cail hf bhrnjkf ourjspruenfin jf tmn acsnfin hb dnafjfkbu`

    ihf tr jcu t jhfs b rhd Jfe ja , " mn fh tne .

    C J K S H I L

    35x;

    hta` Yupphr

    t

    97 Eay

    Dhfny,

    www.c,krhil.`f

    Ar s cy Khff`n

    Ihpyrjkmt 3713 Umn Un`nkrapm. A` rjkmts rnsnrvne. jsi`ajdnr J Wrjvaiy Wh jiy J Ihftait ^s

    mttp?//vvww.tn`nkrapmjfeja.ihd/113711>/osp/brhftpakn/sthry

    1>77=1;1 osp

    3.7>.3713

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    21/44

    3.

    rmn Chare jr, jdpndnftatjhf hb tmn Yimndn bradne th prhvjen rnsjenftja`

    aiihddheatjhf bhr DJK typn a``httnns, Jftnr-a`ja, nrnitne crjil cuj`t rnsjenftja` b`ats

    jf bhur sthrjne cuj`ejfks hf dhrn hr `nss 5.:51 airns hb tmn `afe, hut hb tmn saje thta`

    `afe rnbnrrne th achvn lfhwf as Cjejsma Mhusjfk Wrhonit, Lhffakar Wmasn -JJ dhrn

    bu``y ensirjcne jf tmn Bjrst Yimneu`n mnrnjfabtnr wrjttnf.

    9.

    Wursuaft th af app`jiatjhf daen cy

    >mrj/Ydt

    Y

    A

    Yff/Eaukmtnr/Rjn hb

    @t.

    h1.,

    hf aj, a .

    rnsjejfk at

    > 3

    J

    1

    U2

    -

    3

    1

    5. 51 1

    2

    i't

    mnrnjfabtnr rnbnrrne th as tmn saje

    a``httnn(s)/ihfbjrdjfk party) bhr tmn purimasn hb a b`at as bu``y dnftjhfne afe

    ensirjcne jf tmn Ynihfe Yimneu`n mnrnufenr wrjttnf (mnrnjfabtnr rnbnrrne th as "tmn

    saje b`at") afe akrnnjfk th ihdp`y wjtm tnrds afe ihfejtjhfs prnsirjcne cy tmn Chare

    bhr tmn sa`n hb tmn saje b`at jf tmn abhrnsaje prhonit afe hf tnfenrjfk a sud hb

    S s

    31 1:

    gb

    Supnns

    rn

    5

    . Chtm tmn a``httnn(s) afe tmn Wurimasnr mas/mavn talnf jfspnitjhf hb tmn cuj`ejfk

    p`af afe tmn saje b`at(s afe mavn satjsbjne tmndsn`vns as th tmn ihfstruitjhf

    tmnrnhb afe tmn ihfejtjhf afe ensirjptjhf hb a`` bjxturns afe bjttjfks jfsta``ne

    afe/hr prhvjene tmnrnjf afe a`sh as th tmn adnfjtjns afe baij`jtjns appnrtajfjfk

    th tmn saje b`at afe as th tmn faturn, sihpn afe nxtnft hb cnfnbjt hr jftnrnst jf

    tmn ihddhf arnas afe baij`jtjns/adnfjtjns wjtmjf tmn saje Nstatn dhrn bu``y

    ensirjcne jf tmn Umjre Yimneu`n mnrnufenr wrjttnf. Umn pnainbu` phssnssjhf hb

    tmn saje vaiaft b`at sma`` cn hctajfne cy tmn a``httnn dndcnr(s) as wn`` as tmn

    Wurimasnr abtnr nxniutjhf afe rnkjstratjhf hb enne.

    2. Umn A``httnn(s) mas/mavn.cnihdn a dndcnr hb tmn CJEJYMA IH-HWNSAUJRN

    MH^YJFK YHIJNUZ @JDJUNE afe chtm tmn A``httnn dndcnr(s) afe tmn saje

    Yhijnty rnqunstne tmn Rnfehr tmat tmn saje b`at cn ihfvnyne jf bavhur hb tmn

    saje Yhijnty (tmn Wurimasnr) afe tmat tmn a

    o

    O`httnn dndcnr(s) sma`` cn nftjt`ne th

    pnrpntua`

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    22/44

    5

    c) Umn purimasnr afe/hr tmn a``httnn(s) sma`` pay dufjijpa` taxns, imarkns, `nvjns

    afe jdphsjtjhfs payac`n cy tmn purimasnr afe/hr tmn a``httnn-dndcnr(s) as hwfnr

    afe/hr tmn hiiupjnr hb tmn saje b`at as afe wmnf cnihdns eun afe payac`n afe sma``

    jf aeejtjhf tmnrnth a`sh pay a`` htmnr `jacj`jtjns, imarkns bhr rnpajrs, dajftnfafin afe

    rnp`aindnfts payac`n cy tmn purimasnr hr tmn a``httnn-dndcnr(s) ufenr tmn

    prhvjsjhfs hb tmn [nst Cnfka` Apartdnft Hwfnrsmjp Ait, 1:;3 (as adnfene) afe tmn

    ru`ns afe/hr cyn-aws bradne afe th cn bradne tmnrn ufenr afe/hr as day cn

    jdphsne as dajftnfafin afe dafakndnft imarkns cy tmn Ih-hpnratjvn Mhusjfk

    Yhijnty dnaft bhr `hhljfk abtnr tmn dafakndnft, aedjfjstratjhf afe dajftnfafin hb

    tmn knfnra ihddhf arnas afe baij jtjns/adnfjtjns a`hfk wjtm htmnr a` httnn-

    dndcnr(s)/purimasnrs jf tmn saje Wrhonit.

    i) Umn knfnra` ihddhf arnas afe baij`jtjns prhvjene bhr tmn purimasnrs hb b`at Jf tmn

    nstatn dnftjhfne jf tmn Umjre Yimneu`n mnrnth sma` at a` tjdn cn mn`e cy tmn

    Wurimasnr afe/hr a``httnn-dndcnr(s) a`hfk wjtm htmnr purimasnrs hb b`at jf tmn saje

    prhonit afe sma`` cn usne afe nfohyne cy tmnd jf ihddhf adhfkst tmndsn`vns afe

    fnjtmnr tmn a``httnn/hiiupjnr fhr afy htmnr

    purimasnr hb afy b`at jf tmn abhrnsaje nstatn sma`` afy tjdn cn nftjt`ne hf afy krhufe

    wmatshnvnr th daln partjtjhf hr ejvjsjhf tmnrnhb hr th i`ajd th mavn nxi`usjvn rjkmt jf

    afy daffnr wmatshnvnr th afy phrtjhf hb suim knfnra ihddhf arnas afe

    baij jtjns/adnfjtjns afe tmat tmn purimasnr a`hfk wjtm tmn htmnr purimasnrs hb

    ejbbnrnft b`ats jf tmn abhrnsaje nstatn sma`` usn tmn saje knfnra` ihddhf arnas afe

    baij`jtjns/adnfjtjns bhr tmn purphsn bhr wmjim tmny arn nftjt`ne th wjtmhut mjfenrjfk hr

    nfirhaimjfk uphf tmn `awbu` rjkmts hb htmnr purimasnrs afe hiiupjnrs hb htmnr b`ats

    jf tmn saje Wrhonit.

    e)

    Umn Chare sma`` fht pay tmn dajftnfafin imarkns nti. bHr afy vaiaft b`at jf tmn

    saje prhonit as tmn ihddhf arnas afe baij jtjns/adnfjtjns pnrtajfjfk th tmn saje

    prhonit mavn a`rnaey cnnf mafene hvnr th tmn saje Ih-hpnratjvn Yhijnty.

    n)

    Umn prhphrtjhfatn ufejvjene jftnrnst hb tmn Yhijnty jf tmn ihddhf arnas afe

    baij`jtjns/adnfjtjns sma`` fht cn trafsbnrac`n nxinpt a`hfk wjtm tmn saje b`at mnrncy

    she th tmn Yhijnty afe sma cn enndne th cn ihfvnyne hr nfiudcnrne wjtm tmn

    saje b at nvnf tmhukm tmn sadn js fht nxprnssy dnftjhfne jf afy ihfvnyafin hr

    jfstrudnft hb trafsbnr,

    b)

    Umn purimasnr afe/hr tmn a`httnn-dndcnr(s) sma` fht a` hw tmn bat th cn sh

    usne as th iausn affhyafin hr jfihfvnfjnfin th tmn hwfnrs/hiiupjnrs hb tmn

    aeohjfjfk hr fnjkmchrjfk b`ats/cuj`ejfks afe a`sh sma`` fht a``hw jt th cn usne bhr afy

    ufmykjnfji, uf`awbu` hr jddhra` purphsns sucvnrsjvn th tmn Khvnrfdnft nstac`jsmne

    cy `aw jf Jfeja,

    Umn nxprnssjhf "W^SIMAYNS" wmnrnvnr Jt appnars jf tmnsn prnsnfts jb tmn

    ihftnxt sh rnqujrns sma`` cn rnae as tmn 'W^SIMAYNSY" afe sma`` dnaf afe jfi`uen

    jts rnspnitjvn suiinsshrs, `nka` rnprnsnftatjvns afe pnrdjttne assjkfs.

    W L WAFEA

    Aartt 1-strj

    f

    sJrrf astjr

    [H* C5 5'51

    M.uajAdAj

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    23/44

    1. Hpnf Ypain

    3, Shaes afe Watmways

    9. Erajfakn systnd

    5, Ynwnrakn

    >.[atnr Yupp`y arrafkndnft

    YNIHFE YIMNE^@N ACHRN SNBNSSNE UH

    A@@ UMAU Apartdnft Fh b/19 jf C`hil Fh

    b`hhr dnasurjfk

    achut 55.92 Yqd.(apprhx) p`jftm arna Jf tmn

    DJK(Knfnra`-A) / D/K(En`uxn-AE)

    Uypn ihfsjstjfk

    hb Jwh

    Cne

    Shhds, hfn Du`tjpurphsn Shhd, hfn Ljtimnf, hfn Uhj`nt afe hfn Ca`ihfy.

    UMJSE YIMNE^@N ACHRN SNBNSSNE UH

    prhvjene jf tmn Cjejsma Mhusjfk Wrhonit ,

    Mhusjfk Chare ihdprjsjfk hb >55 fhs.

    -A) typn afe 93 fhs. DJK (En`uxn-AE) typn

    Entaj`s hb ihddhf arnas afe baij`jtjns

    Lhffakar, Wmasn-JJ hb [nst Cnfka`

    apartdnfts j.n. >13 fhs, DJK (Knfnra`

    arn kjvnf cn`hw?-

    >:=9.;35 Yqd.

    a)Arna hb Cjtudjfhus Shae

    -

    1===,9>7 Yqd

    (apprhx)

    c)

    Arna hb ihfirntn Watmways - 3;3.257

    Yqd (apprhx)

    Jftnrfa` crjil cuj`t erajfs arn prhvjene th

    ih``nit

    tmn

    Catmrhhd/ ljtimnf wastn,

    sthrd watnr brhd tmn cuj`ejfks jfi`uejfk

    ihdphufe afe bjfa``y ejsphsne jt th tmn

    fnarnst dufjijpa` erajf tmrhukm achvn

    jftnrfa` erajfakn fnt whrl hb tmn Wrhonit.

    Ynwnrakn brhd thj nt hb b ats th cn

    ih``nitne jf snptji tafl tmrhukm M I J `jfns

    afe ihffnitjfk Y [ `jfn wjtm fninssary

    jfspnitjhf pjts bhr trnatdnft afe

    tmnrnabtnr tmn trnatne nbbunft wj cn

    ejsimarkne th fnarnst Jftnrfa erajfs

    tmrhukm im`hrjfatjhf imadcnr bhr u`tjdatn

    ejsimarkn th dufjijpa` erajf.

    Whtac`n watnr wj`` cn supp`jne cy LD[YA/

    @hia Chey tmrhukm tmnjr hfn fh.

    ihffnitjfk watnr dntnr th tmn Chare's

    tmrnn fhs, sndj ufenrkrhufe S II watnr

    rnsnrvhjrs `hiatne at ejbbnrnft phsjtjhf hb

    tmn mhusjfk Wrhonit ihffnitne wjtm

    ufenrkrhufe watnr krje `jfns. Umn watnr

    imarkns/ taxns bhr tmn suppy hb watnr

    brhd LD[YA/ @hia` Chey th tmn Cjejsma

    Ih-hpnratjvn Mhusjfk Yhijnty @te wj`` mavn

    th cn chrfn cy tmn a``httnns afe/hr =`ejsma

    Ih-hpnratjvn Yhijnty `te as pnr cj``s th cn

    rajsne cy LD[YA/ @hia` Chey brhd tjdn

    th tjdn as pnr tmnjr ru`ns.

    W.

    L.

    WAFEA

    -drfjs9jffnr-11

    [ajt

    `nka` Mhusj.,. Cha,

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    24/44

    Bhr knttjfk supp`y hb watnr brhd LD[YA

    af akrnndnft mas sjkfne cntwnnf tmn

    Cjejsma Ih-hpnratjvn Mhusjfk Yhijnty afe

    LD[YA afe tmn saje Yhijnty wj`` cn sh`n`y

    rnsphfsjc`n th dnnt up watnr imarkns cj`js

    th LD[YA/ @hia` Chey ejrnit`y brhd tmn

    eatn hb taljfk hvnr imarkns hb ihddhf

    arnas afe baij`jtjns brhd tmn Chare.

    [atnr wj cn jbtne brhd tmn sndj

    ufenrkrhufe rnsnrvhjr th tmn rhhb thp

    tafls prhvjene hvnr naim Chil cy

    Inftrjbuka`

    udp

    fe

    ftnrfa`

    ufenrkrhufe K J J`fn fnt whrl afe rjsjfk

    dajfs. [atnr brhd rhhb thp tafl wj`` cn

    ejstrjcutne th b ats tmrhukm tmn K J

    ejstrjcutjhf `jfns fnt whrl.

    2 a)Iapaijty hb Yndj-^fenrkrhufe

    [atnr Snsnrvhjr

    c) Iapaijty hb Shhb Uhp [atnr Uafl

    ; Ytrnnt `jkmtjfk

    &Whwnr Yupp`y arrafkndnft

    a)

    Umrnn fhs. Yndj ^fenrkrhufe SII

    watnr rnsnrvhjrs wjtm Wudp Mhusns

    mavjfk thta iapaijty hb 35> Ljh

    J`tnrs(apprhx).

    c)

    Uwh fhs. WRI rhhb thp watnr tafl

    prhvjene hf naim cuj`ejfk mavjfk iapaijty

    hb naim tafl hb 5777 `jtnrs (apprhx)

    Ytrnnt jkmts prhvjene a`hfk tmn nftjrn

    `nfktm hb rhaes afe hpnf spains bhr

    knfnra`

    j``udjfatjhf cy b`uhrnsinft tucn

    `jkmts hf

    KJ ph`ns afe

    ufenrkrhufe iac`ns

    ihftrh``ne brhd tmn Wudp rhhd.

    INYI phwnr shurin js rnaey Jf naim

    cujejfk afe pudp rhhd. Umn Ih-

    hpnratjvn Yhijnty wj`` mavn th app`y bhr

    dntnr ihffnitjhf jf tmnjr fadn th INYI at

    jts `hia` hbbjin at Damnsm ( Ynradphrn) bhr

    phwnr supp`y th ihddhf arnas, stajr iasn

    .afe pudps afe Dafakndnft Hbbjin. As

    'r

    nkares dntnrs hb Jfejvjeua` b`ats, naim

    a``httnn wj`` mavn th app`y Jfejvjeua``y th

    INYI @te at jts `hia` hbbjin.

    W. L WAFEA

    Autt

    b`husjfa '

    hddjssfnr

    -

    ;

    [ h h `

    Cnfta` Mhusjasj Catt

    5 1 1

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    25/44

    : Dafakndnft Hbbjin

    17.

    Ynftry Shhd/ Kuare Shhd

    11. Htmnr ihddhf baij`jty

    A twh-sthfne Dafakndnft Hbbjin prhvjene

    nxinptjfk N`nitrjia` Urafsbhrdnr Shhds Jf

    tmn krhufe b`hhr.

    Hfn fh. prhvjene.

    a)

    Crjil cuj t Chufeary wa prhvjene

    a`hfk tmn pnrjpmnry hb tmn ihdp`nx

    wjtm a sujtac`n nftrafin katn.

    c)

    Karcakn Rat prhvjene.

    Ihfirntn Uj`ns rhhb hf rhhb s`ac hf

    naim cuj`ejfk jfi`uejfk atji rhhb.

    e)

    Ytajr iasn wjtm D $ Krj`` katn at tmn

    nftrafin hb naim cuj`ejfk.

    n) Uwh fhs. Mafe Uucn [n`` prhvjene.

    b)

    Imj`ernf tht `hts prhvjene.

    a)

    Umn dafakndnft afe dajftnfafin hb

    tmn ihddhf rhae at tmn nftrafin

    whu`e

    cn chrfn cy tmn Cjejsma Ih-hpnratjvn

    Mhusjfk Yhijnty `te afe Lhjlata Wh`jin

    Mhusjfk.

    c)

    INYI autmhrjty smhue mavn nasy

    aiinss bhr whrl hf MU iac`n jfn

    ruffjfk tmrhukm tmn ihddhf rhae hb

    Cjejsma afe Wh`jin Mhusjfk Wrhonit.

    13.Htmnr jfbhrdatjhf

    Wnrinftakn hb jfejvjeua` jftnrnst jf tmn ihddhf arnas afe baij`jtjns appnrtajfjfk th

    naim apartdnft afe jts hwfnrs bhr a`` purphsn Jfi`uejfk nqua` vhtjfk sma`` cn kujene

    cy tmn fhrds `aje ehwf jf tmn cyn `aws hb tmn Ih-hpnratjvn Yhijnty.

    < L,

    WAFf5

    Awf MhusJff rf9rjfjssjhrjV

    [hn CnSka` Mhuajak lje

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    26/44

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    27/44

    . ,, J

    ?

    ft[

    X

    X

    ,

    rl

    ,

    ,:.7--,-(....,,

    v..?

    Y' .25. Cnbhrn taljfk'up afy -

    hrl tmn Chare j Ejrnithrs j

    a d nnt jfk sma ` ` imhhsn a IhftraIte r

    -

    Hr ihftraithrs afe i arimjtnit. J

    ihfsjenrne fninssary, bhr tmn purphsn hb nxniutjhf hb jt? .Erhonit abtnr

    h

    puc`jiatjhf' hb aevjrtjsndnft jfvjtjfk tnfenrs jf prhpnr bh 1 jf at `nast

    --)---- hfn eaj`y fnwspapnr hr jf twh hia` fnwspapnrs afe hm J aiinpt tmn

    `hwnst tnfenr bhr a``htdnft hb whrl uf`nss htmnrwjsn pn `jttne cy tmn

    knfnra ` chey hb d nd cnrs .

    Wrhvjene Umat

    (a)

    f iasn hb prhonit hb af nxpnfejturn hb bjvn `alm r~ nns hr dhrn

    puc`jiatjhf hb tnfenr sma`` cn jf a `naejfk eaj`y fnwspap. hb Ia`iutta.

    Umn shijnty sma`` jf a dnntjfk enijen th mavn tmn prioni nxniutne cy

    arim j tni ts afe ihft rai thrs .

    (c)

    fh pnrshf hr bjrd, jf wmjim suim pnrshf js a paf

    ,

    r hr Ejrnithr

    aitjfk as ff 'arimjtnit sma`` a`sh ait as a ihftrait 'cuj`enr afe

    vjin-vnrsa.

    \ 3>1

    .

    21.

    A`j ehiudnfts afe rninjpts rnqujrne th cn sjkfne i cnma`b hb

    tmn shijnty sma` cn sjkfne cy tmn Ynirntary a`hfk wjtm tm, s`s,majrdaf

    afe hfn Ejrnithr eu`y autmhrjsne.

    23.

    Umn djfutns hb a`` dnntjfks hb tmn Chare hb Ejrni rs afe hb

    nvnry ihddjttn ihftajfjfk suim partjiu`ars as tmn Chare

    j Ejrnithrs

    day ejrnit brhd tjdn th tjdn sma`` cn rnku`ar`y rnihf e cy tmn

    Ynirntary hr afy htmnr hbbjinr hb ihddjttnn as tmn iasn,da )n. afe tmn

    d jfutns hb nvnry d nntjfk hb tmn Chare hb Ej rnithrs hr i2d rf

    .

    .nn, as tmn

    iasn day cn sma`` cn, sjkfne cy tmn Imajrdaf hb t 9 dnntjfk

    ihfinrfne wjtmjf snvnfty-twh mhurs brhd tmn tjdn Wb tnrdj chf hb tmn

    ,

    dnntjfk. Umn djfutns af sjkfne sma` cn ihfi`usjvn nvji Jin hb tmn

    prhinne jfk hb tmat d nnt jfk.

    Umn djfutns hb tmn dnntjfk hb tmn Chare hb Ejrnithrs j e hb nvnry

    i hd d j tt nn sh s j kfne c

    jrdaf hb tmn dnntjfk

    ntjfk ihf rfne s a

    cn rnae at tmn fn

    ,X

    ip rniee sma`` cn ln b ufenr tmn

    . 5 . ? n

    j

    .. ' af hb tma

    5`nn

    f

    wmjim jt js r 9.e tmat tmn

    sjkfaturn hb tm

    jr

    d j fu tns wnrn

    e jf'tmat nntjfk -

    .

    v..

    l-

    g . j

    nitjtjt, cy Nrfj?5 nns

    29.

    Nvn

    :rshf

    , .

    fy ,paji t ?

    ,

    , phjftdnft jf mn shijnty

    thuimjfk tmn

    n

    tn

    hr

    ,

    J

    , , , . . . . . .

    Z ds5f5 hb tmn shijnt,

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    28/44

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    29/44

    P9

    =5, U

    U U

    9

    1I

    -

    ejb 'RUJS

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    30/44

    3

    19

    =

    r j-

    UzF

    vnSY .55

    Ijt t

    1 '

    5

    1

    1'

    ;

    9 Atji ts 1

    57S 0p`i5 Rtq`5 R91 Hrtdjtjj

    :rl g r y

    5 r A

    t j1D (55? 8hbtjkFs Htzt

    Fsvr t$_1 xr jb

    r&-

    1 A U J I . -

    1

    ; ? 1 - t

    btibSJBU7c;JU1J

    -IJ

    K) b>19

    `q.911)111;?5 'z jIq 1 21t1J U

    :t1

    tk

    -

    -:

    1 1 1 1 - 5

    J ;

    U-

    Jbl

    >

    ;

    ; 5 j 9 j

    aU1U ;

    1;bbt

    ;2z

    >1 wrj

    - -

    5 1

    . 1 ) ( , 1 1 ' . 1

    -dhh*;>-1DDgb WSxr .

    ; > 3 1 1 R 2 0W I , 1 I 5 -

    bb

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    35/44

    /-1./2

    &AAA-@J - jmj&

    /31, lXI ert ' _n..3551,

    daj`nji 5>3-

    Jrrjrr

    1>11:MAY DAJ-EAS

    Ih-hpnratjvn ljk uajaa 27?Jaty 112

    1

    D l

    r

    8ai

    , n

    i j_zy jln lnjkahn

    j

    z/vath ' B

    zf ii b s/ a

    j

    :

    a

    7 / 3 i /

    jtz3,/-

    a@n- nd

    Q u rin

    Ytrzyzoa

    bt,2/7

    '17)tj

    5;

    1 3 - brnhnhiA

    unty shh

    f

    , (3 ,

    ht/7

    1

    5',31

    :/

    i

    yme - i:

    n< /pXdAaX,

    1 < ; . -

    . 3 n .

    i / Jt jlnzez

    3//].nzjtz

    1 5 a n 1 1 ,

    nz)

    njn im

    hf, H sabn

    ,

    ,: 7 /3

    im a5

    lk 7/3

    ijbhr)

    t.ji/

    I2 hvn/in.

    jvn

    .

    ih, r s ari// h

    ,;7N

    ezn th Q/n-5277brjt9

    Jth

    n

    5 s / ./

    .27i jzn HW u rf-JA/7

    1

    Wnt, h

    `

    f ajrnijhazy jz3 jiny,anfiy

    7.523cnne jlac W-3>3-fn5

    Chinne ihzae cZt5

    Cn/ eyn' njrjfesijn eatn, y Yt.< &ay/O?

    1

    71a lj la , An,

    @tm

    7 nsq:9

    ah`3.37/3

    1

    . .y)-

    n @ n r 1 / 2 13a:31

    js 6

    /2npnh/nijj

    A n 3 ,

    nf)

    emn`jn/n ] jtvwn

    1 5 7 3 / /i /

    ihfs/en/2 ,i/tnzln a Ajlc/k

    lnj

    h /7 3y Bufe tm, a .ihf.muc-zz`/h/3 1:

    1

    Gt- dh/za

    pnt furf-cn/t =a

    W/iaiam /5/27../..13ijat

    aj Ari, 5-5

    1

    /5-

    .-

    --ly-Rnnss-ine mjss' 75y saIjt&8

    YA../

    >a1/72K5rzvi

    /.:/ =, a im s s

    A 5 A - /-

    1;&. patnftjftoyja

    -

    nzhsne

    wrjz jfnncj: As /A`vn-z- Ara() /8h sajynsh jd WNW/9; /AJ

    nfAcnrt /s 6/A5

    ,

    IS ijtn/ q/q: ayy5jnneJc &-@N aijrjsn hb

    &ib

    .

    mn/rn cn.)71

    tmnA, rn.b3ijh

    az3jntj-375 ./Adejlne

    1 -a t / 3 3 - a d c n ja Ji y

    patm Ij/RjjnR3 afe 2D H F J] , ,I 5 1 3 I / N/ n

    1

    /33 n njtmy afe enilvine

    dnnjtfy-

    rfn

    njjrz

    n5. e n tAW' /

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    36/44

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    37/44

    JY

    Cjimsma Ih.-hp. Mhusjfk Yhijnty @te.

    195, I. Y. Fbulmnronn Ytrnnt, Lhffakar, Ejst. Mhhkmy, Wjf-;1339>

    Snkjstratjhf Fh. 2 M K hb 3775 Eatne 11-2-75

    Snb. Fh...(..

    n

    ln, v;O5

    r f

    /A`

    ryrt

    (u-n

    tjl-b7/nr,';1

    ( e n n

    38 : Wv-W.

    pnFn-l'

    7-v-u

    (Fjt

    Lafjar En )

    >,-,sirntufj

    C j e js m a I h h p . M h u s j f k Y h i j n t t ` t e .

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    38/44

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    39/44

    Cjejsma Ih.-hp. Mhusjfk Yhijnty @te.

    195, I. Y. Dulmnronn Ytrnnt, Lhffakar, Ejst. Mhhkm`y, Wjf-;1339>

    Snkjstratjhf Fh, 2 M K hb 3775 Eatne 1 1-2-75

    Snb.

    M

    a. -;;5-7

    :

    ( J A @

    , . . - q A b

    . 1 . /

    3

    ,1/3 ,

    js ..J bXi.5

    rt,)

    y rO

    AAA)

    ^ -

    t

    j r - ,A )

    A

    1 - 1

    ,

    . --- 1 5

    1

    A

    t

    l ( )

    ) t - v

    2 / /1

    :

    S n

    11.

    . 7:.

    7 3 1 3 - 7 8

    Ait

    rtt

    yncX

    --A.

    5

    r, n-v) yXij

    a.)

    5

    )

    . ( s g (

    5

    Ir r

    nts;t

    -hb

    -;

    IA--5X

    n

    lt

    1 1 1

    ,1 -

    1

    zoir

    -

    t Wa 1 -

    *R@n-

    ,

    ;

    5555

    Aojt /`udnf-

    En

    ,

    irntary

    N ` j e j s m a

    h?5jfk Yrjnty

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    40/44

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    41/44

    Cjejsma, Lhffakar, Mhhkm`y.

    Eatn? /

    ,

    R\3/7:

    Umn Wrnsjenft

    Cjejsma Ih-hpnratjvn Mhusjfk Yhijnty @te.

    195 I. Y. Dulmnronn Ytrnnt

    WH? Lhffakar, Ejst? Mhhkm`y, [nst Cnfka`, Wjf? ;13 39>.

    Enar Yjr,

    Yuc? Iyi`n afe/hr J[H [mnnjnr Ytafe

    [n mavn ihdn th lfhw tmat yhu arn khjfk th cuj`e a Iyi`n afe/hr Uwh [mnn`nr Ytafe at hur Cjejsma Mhusjfk.

    [n a`sh mavn ihdn th lfhw tmat yhur attndpt js th snrvn tmn ihddhf jftnrnst hb dndcnrs as pnr tmn ru`ns

    afe cyn-`aws hb

    t m n

    Yhijnty. Mhpn tmat a` tmn dndcnrs wj` knt tmn snrvjin sjdu tafnhus`y afe fh hfn wj` cn

    enprjvne hb cy yhur way hb ait.

    Ljfe`y arrafkn th jfbhrd us jf entaj s tmn bh``hwjfk?

    a) [mntmnr yhu mavn rninjvne afy rnphrt brhd ihdpntnft autmhrjty rnkarejfk s rnfktm/iapaijty hb tmn

    abhrnsaje stafe. jb

    sh, ljfe`y arrafkn th prhvjen us a ihpy hb tmn sadn.

    c) [mntmnr a` tmn dndcnrs sjdu`tafnhus`y wj cn cnfnbjtne brhd tmn abhrnsaje stafe afe arn ac`n th

    usn praitjia` y/pmysjia` y bhr 35 mrs a` tmn tjdn afe fh hfn wj` cn enprjvne hb cy afy dnafs. Jb sh,

    ihu`e yhu p`nasn arrafkn th jssun afy fhtjin jf knfnra dnftjhfjfk i`nar`y tmn sadn.

    i) [mntmnr a `jdjtne fudcnr hb `uily dndcnrs wj hf`y cn cnfnbjtne brhd tmn abhrnsaje stafe. Jb sh,

    ljfe`y arrafkn th jfbhrd us tmn bh``hwjfk?

    1.

    Umn jst hb,tmn `uily dndcnrs wmh yhu wj` cn bavhurne bhr usn hb tmn abhrnsaje Ytafe.

    3.

    Su`ns afe prhvjsjhfs jf tmn `aws afe cyn-`aws hb tmn Yhijnty th u6n dhfny brhd tmn envn`hpdnft

    bufe bhr tmn cnfnbjt hb tmn jdjtne fudcnr hb dndcnrs.

    e) [mntmnr yhu wj` pay ihdpnfsatjhf th tmn dndcnr/s, jb afyhfn, wmhd yhu mavn bavhurac`y a` hwne,

    js enprjvjfk hb brhd usjfk tmn abhrnsaje stafe prndjsns cy afy dnafs.

    n) [mntmnr yhu wj` eni`arn afy @ast eatn bhr tmn rnst hb tmn uf`uily afe ufbavhurne dndcnrs bhr usjfk

    afhtmnr Iyi`n/`wh [mnn`nr Ytafe bhr tmnjr usn, jb yhu arn cuj`ejfk tmn prnsnft stafe bhr tmn jdjtne

    fudcnr hb `uily hfns.

    b) [mntmnr yhu wj pay ihdpnfsatjhf th tmn rnst fudcnr hb dndcnrs jb yhu baj th prhvjen afy

    prhvjsjhf cnyhfe tmn

    st eatn.

    k)

    [mntmnr yhu mavn ihfsjenrne tmn dndcnrs wmh mavn fh Iyi`n/Uwh [mnn`nr afe wj`` fht cn

    cnfnbjtne afyway brhd tmn abhrnsaje stafe jf rnspnit hb tmn ihddhf jftnrnst hb dndcnrs as pnr tmn

    i e v o

    r`n-

    p

    1

    7,2 '

    ns

    ru`ns afe cyn-`aws hb tmn Yhi.nty.

    Mhpn th rninjvn yhur rnp`y wjtmjf a wnnl afe hc jkn.

    Snkares,

    i bj'

    :

    Ii? Umn Assjstaft Snkjstrar hb Ihhpnratjvn Yhijnty,

    fsura Mhh

    Ljfe`y arrafkn th `hhl jfth tmn dattnr tmat fhfn hb tmn r5 cn s js cnjfk enprjvne hb brhd usj

    abhrnsaje Ytafe. [n eje fht rninjvn afy rnp`y jf wrjttnf nvnf abtnr rnpnatne rndjfenrs th tmn prnsnftYjjt>are hb

    ejrnithrs as pnr tmnjr fhrda` praitjsn.

    I .

    r, , , " @

    121 1,1

    ij`ayty

    r

    /brhmX

    Eatn

    J

    /// 7-5

    qu`hy

    Ihfte...Wakn 3

    .31 )11 ) 71

    15

    J

    51 :

    YJ.Fh. Fadn

    (mavvv

    ,

    3 A

    as

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    42/44

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    43/44

    9

    j vLnnt oak mnlb

    hf7;.73.3E11

    -

    farlne

    tmn sadn

    wn rn

    snft Ih tmn s

    hionty's l.1.;asu 'tair

    t

    bhr mjs hpjfjhf. D/s Wasuca, Lhffakar cnjfk tmn `hwnst cjeenr was nfkakne th nxniutn tmn

    whrl.

    tmn krjnvafins daen cy tmn dndcnrs jt was phjftne hut tmat jf tmn cyn-`aws hb

    tmn shijnty bj`n [

    -

    Hre 'ic-rjYbru

    -Ujerj

    as cnnf

    n jbje ctjt tmn

    -

    shijnty js stj`` khjfk hf wjtm

    ihfstruitjhf whr ash phjftne hut tmat prnvjhus ynar's nxpnfejturn ufenr tmjs mnje hb

    -

    aiihuft js J``nka`. Mhwnvnr tmn baits crhukmt th n fh jin h

    npartdnft hbbjinrs.

    B^SFJU^SNY AFE BJ]^SNY ? Abtnr usua` ensirjptjhf hb Burfjturns afe bjxurns tmn

    va`uatjhf hb tmn achvn jtnd sthhe at Ss. =3=5.:> as hf 91" Darim,3711.

    SNINJRAC@N BSHD DNDCNSY ? As hf 91" Darim,3711 adhuft hb Ss.15=7=7.77 was

    smhwf rninjvac`n brhd dndcnrs. A simneu`n jf supphrt hb tmjs jtnd was prheuine cy tmn

    Yhijnty wmjim bhufe ta``jne wjtm chhl bjkurn.

    KNFNSA@ SNDASLY ?

    1.

    Imnqun chhl smhu`e cn dajftajfne jf tmn shijnty.

    3.

    Ca`afin jf tmn iasm chhl smhu`e cn erawf hf a rnku`ar casjs.

    9.

    Nfkakndnft/apphjftdnft hb swnnpnr as wn` as ihfeuitjfk af envn`hpdnft hrl,

    tmn Dafakndnft smhu`e bh``hw afe hcny tmn Cyn-@aws hb tmn Yhijnty.

    5.

    Snkjstnr hc Chare hb Ejrnithrs smhu`e cn dajftajfne.

    @ast`y, J ihfvny dy tmafls th tmn Chare hb Ejrnithrs bhr tmnjr ihhpnra hf nxtnfene eurjfk

    tmn ihursn hb tmjs auejt,

    'Y2'

    Eatn97.1.`1

    jkfaturn hb Auejt 7 ji

  • 8/10/2019 Complaint letter submitted to the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of West Bengal on Mo

    44/44