50
Exhibit A-1

Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

Exhibit A-1

Page 2: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :00:00.10 >>THE FOLLOWING PROGRAM IS 01 :00:01.23 BROUGHT TO YOU BY SUPPLE, THE 01:00:03.09 NEW, MORE POWERFUL HEAL TH 01 :00:04.16 REGENERA TTON DRINK BY SUPPLE, 01 :00:06.04 LLC. 01:00: 10.12 >> HELLO, AND WELCOME TO THE 01 :OO:11.24 SMART MEDICINE SHOW. 01:00:13.06 I'M DR. MONITA PO UDY AL, 01 :00:14.24 AND WE HAVE A GREAT SHOW TODAY. 01 :OO:16.28 IF YOU HA VE PAIN OR KNOW SOMEONE 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 THAT HAS PAIN -JOINT PAIN, BACK 01 :00:20.22 PAIN, BONE PAIN, MUSCLE PAIN, 01:00:23.02 OR IF YOU SUFFER FROM ARTHRITIS, 01 :00:25.05 OSTEOARTHRITIS, RHEUMATOID 01 :00:27.09 ARTHRITIS, FIBROMY ALGIA OR EVEN 01:00:29.13 WEAKNESS OR FATIGUE, THEN YOU 0 1 : 00 : 3 1. 0 1 NEED TO STAY WITH US FOR THE 01 :00:32.21 NEXT HALF HOUR. 01:00:33.23 WE'RE GOING TO BE DISCUSSING 0 1 : 00 : 3 5. 1 2 MEDICAL BREAKTHROUGHS THAT CAN 01 :00:36.27 HELP YOU ELIMINATE PAIN, REGAIN 01 :00:38.23 MOBILITY AND BECOME STRONGER 01 :00:41.03 WITHOUT DANGEROUS DRUGS, SURGERY

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002912

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 1 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 3: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :00:43.07 OR NEGA TlVE SIDE AFFECTS. 01 :00:45.06 MY GUEST TODAY IS PETER 01 : 00 :46 .19 APATOW. 01 :00:47.25 HE'S A LEADING ARTHRITIS 01 :00:49.19 ADVOCATE AND IS THE FOUNDER OF 01:00:51.03 SUPPLE. 01 :00:52.03 PETER HAS CREATED A 01 :00:53.03 REVOLUTIONARY, ALL-NATURAL 01 :00:54.12 DRINK, SUPPLE, THAT IS NOW MORE 01 :00:56.00 POWERFUL AND MORE COMPREHENSIVE 01 :00:58.00 THAN EVER BEFORE. 01 :00:59.03 SUPPLE IS HELPING COlJNTLESS 01 :01 :00.28 AMERICANS TO LIVE PAIN-FREE AND 01 :01 :03.00 MOBILE LIVES AGAIN. 01 :01 :04.09 PETER APATOW, THANKS FOR BEING 01 :01 :06.08 ON THE SHOW. 01 :01 :07.08 >> THANK YOU. 01 :01 :09.12 IT'S AWESOME TO BE HERE. 01:01:10.18 >>NOW FIRST, YOU'RE NOT A 01 :01:12.02 DOCTOR, YOU'RE NOT A PHD. 01:01:13.20 WHAT QUALIFIES YOU AS BEING AN 01 :01:15.08 EXPERT AT GETTING RID OF PAIN? 01 :01:17.14 >>WELL, THE WORLD'S GREATEST

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002913

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 2 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 4: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :01:19.02 MEDICAL EXPERTS FROM THE UNITED 01 :01 :20.20 NATIONS, THE BONE AND JOINT 01 :01 :22.24 DECADE, THEY SELECTED i\!IE AND 01 :01 :24.12 SUPPLE TO BE LEADING ADVOCATES, 01 :01 :26.00 ALL AROUND THE WORLD, TO HELP 01:01:27.19 END BONE PAIN, JOINT PAIN, BACK 01 :01 :29.07 PAIN AND MUSCLE PAIN. 01 :01 :30.25 FOR EVERYBODY AROUND THE WORLD. 01 :01:33.15 I'M NOT A DOCTOR. 01 :01:34.15 WHAT I AM IS A RESEARCHER AND AN 01:01:36.10 ARTHRITIS SURVIVOR MYSELF. 01 :01 :37.25 >> WHAT DO YOU MEAN, ARTHRITIS 01 :01 :39.16 SURVIVOR? 0 1 : 0 1 :40 .16 >>WELL, I SUFFERED FROM SEVERE 01 :01 :42.01 ARTHRITIS PAIN IN MY LEFT HIP 01:01:43.17 FOR DECADES. 01 :01 :44.17 I WAS ALMOST COMPLETELY 01 :01 :45.25 IMMOBILE, I COULD BARELY WALK, I 01:01:47.20 HAD PAIN DAY AND NIGHT. 01 :01 :48.28 IT WAS PAINFUL TO SIT, TO MOVE, 01 :01 :50.21 TO STAND. 01 : 01: 51.21 IT WAS AN ABSOLUTE NIGHTMARE. 01 :01 :53.13 I SEARCHED THE ENTIRE WORLD FOR

CONFIDENTIAL SUPPLE002914

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 3 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 5: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :01 :55.01 A WAY TO END MY OWN NIGHTMARE 01 :01 :56.25 OF PAIN, AND IDID IT. 01 :01 :57.28 >>YOU FOUND AWAY TO END YOlJR 01 :01 :59.15 OWNPATN? 01 :02:00.17 >> IDID. 01:02:01.17 I DISCOVERED SAFE, ALL-NATURAL 01 :02:03.03 BUILDING BLOCKS THAT WERE BEING 01 :02:04.22 PRESCRIBED BY DOCTORS ALL OVER 01 :02:06.08 THE WORLD. 01 :02:07.08 THEY ARE HEALING AGENTS THAT 01 :02:08.22 ACTUALLY REVERSE THE CARTILAGE 01 :02:10.08 BREAKDOWN THAT CAUSES JOINT 01: 02: 11.21 PAIN. 01 :02:12.21 AND YOU KNOW WHAT? 01 : 02: 13. 21 LISTEN TO THIS. 01:02:14.21 WITHIN ms T 7 DAYS OF TAK.ING 01 :02:16.04 THESE, TT WAS UNBELIEVABLE. 01 :02:17.22 I HAD A SIGNIFICANT REDUCTION IN 01: 02: 19 .10 PAIN. 01 :02:20.10 >> WITHIN 7 DAYS? 01:02:21.10 >> WITHIN ONLY 7 DAYS. 01 :02:22.20 AND l FELT BETTER WEEK AFTER 01 :02:24.03 WEEK.

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002915

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 4 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 6: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :02:25.03 WITHIN A MONTH OR SO, l WAS 01 :02:26.18 COMPLETELY MOBILE AGAIN. 01 :02:27.25 I HAD NO MORE PAIN, I WAS 01 :02:29.12 COMPLETELY. .. I FELT GREAT. 0 I : 02 : 3 1.1 7 I COULD DO THINGS AROUND THE 01:02:33.05 HOUSE, l COULD WALK LONGER 01 :02:34.23 DISTANCES, I COULD SLEEP AT 01 :02:36.11 NIGHT - NOW, I COULD SKI, I 01 :02:37.29 COULD HIKE, l COULD PLAY 01 :02:39.19 RACQUETBALL, I COULD JOG, 01 :02:40.28 l COULD PLAY TENNIS. 01 :02:42.00 I COLTLD DO ANYTHING I WANT TO DO 01:02:43.18 AND NO MATTER WHAT I DO, 01 :02:45.01 l CAN'T EVEN GET THE PAIN BACK. 01 :02:46.17 >>AND NOW, YOURE COMPLETELY 01 :02:48.00 PAIN-FREE, FLTLLY MOBILE 01 :02:49.10 AGAIN, JUST FROM DRINKING 01 :02:50.29 SUPPLE EVERYDAY. 01:02:52.04 >> YEAH. 01 :02:53.15 I'M FULLY MOBILE AGAIN. 01 :02:54.25 I'M COMPLETELY PAIN-FREE 01 :02:56.11 AND l HAVE BEEN NOW FOR YEARS. 01 :02:57.26 BUT I'M NOT THE ONLY PERSON

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002916

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 5 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 7: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :02:59.07 THAT HAS THESE AMAZING RESULTS. 01 :03 :00.25 REAL SUPPLE USERS DO TOO. 01 :03 :02.22 IN FACT, IF SOMEBODY' S WATCHING 01 :03 :04.10 RIGHT NOW, THEY HA VE TOW ATCH 01 :03 :05.23 FOR THE NEXT HALF HOUR BECAUSE 01:03:07.08 I'M GOING TO BE SHARING REAL 01 :03:08.28 INSPIRATIONAL STORIES FROM REAL 01: 03: 10 .16 SUPPLE USERS. 01 : 03: 11.18 NOW THESE PEOPLE AREN'T ACTORS, 0 1 : 03 : 1 3 . 04 THEY'RE NOT PAID, THEY'RE NOT 01:03:14.20 READING OFF A SCRIPT. 01 :03:16.10 THESE ARE REAL PEOPLE TELLING 01:03:17.23 THEIR OWN STORIES IN THEIR OWN 01 :03:19.08 HOMES. 01 :03 :20.08 msr LISTEN TO SOME OF THESE 01:03:21.26 AMAZING STORIES ABOUT HOW SUPPLE 01 :03 :23.14 DRAMATICALLY CHANGED PEOPLE'S 01 :03 :24.27 LIVES. 01:03 :26.26 >> IT, IT WAS A MIRACLE TO ME. 01 :03:29.00 IT WAS LIKE TAKING, HAVING 01 :03 :31.03 ABSOLUTELY SOMEBODY GIVING 01 :03 :32.12 ME A MIRACLE DRUG. 01 :03:33.12 >>NOW, THERE' S NO PAIN, AT ALL.

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002917

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 6 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 8: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :03 :34.29 SUPPLE HAS KIND OF JUST DELETED 01 :03:36.19 THE PAIN. 01 :03 :37.19 >>AFTER THE FIRST WEEK, 01 :03 :39.23 I COLTLD SLEEP. 01 :03 :40.25 THERE WAS NO PAIN. 01:03 :42.13 >> THAT'S WHAT SOLD ME, WAS HOW 0 1 : 03 :44. 0 1 GREAT THIS SUPPLE TASTES. 01 :03 :46.05 >> SINCE TAKING SUPPLE, I DON'T 01 :03 :47.21 HAVE ANY PAIN. 01 :03:50.03 >>THAT'S JUST INCREDIBLE. 01:03 :52.07 NOW, ON OUR LAST SHOW TOGETHER, 01 :03:54.11 WET ALKED ABOUT HOW THE KEY 01:03 :56.03 INGREDIENTS IN SUPPLE ARE THE 01 :03 :57.21 STANDARD OF CARE FOR THE 01 :03 :59.09 TREAT1\1ENT OF JOINT PAIN 01 :04:00.20 IN EUROPE. 01 :04:01.20 A ND REALLY, THE RESPONSE 01 :04:02.26 HAS BEEN AMAZING. 01:04:04.00 FROM WHAT I HEAR, 01 :04:05.00 YOU'VE BEEN ABLE TO HELP 01 :04:06.06 l\1ILLIONS OF PEOPLE. 01 :04:07.06 >> WE'RE ARTHRITIS ADVOCATES AND 01 :04:08.24 THE ACTIVE AGENTS IN SUPPLE,

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002918

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 7 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 9: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :04:10.08 THEY'VE FAST BECOME THE MOST 0 1 : 04 : 12. 1 8 USED, BEST-SELLING JOINT 01:04:14.22 REBUILDING AGENTS OF ALL TIME. 01 :04:16.07 13 MILLION PEOPLE ARE USING 0 1 : 04 : 17 .19 THESE ALL OVER THE WORLD FOR 01:04:19.03 SAFE, SIGNIFICANT AND 01 :04:20.15 COMPLETE RELIEF, 01 :04:21.19 COMPLETE RELIEF FROM ALL THEIR 01 :04:23.09 JOINT PROBLEMS. 01 :04:24.09 THERE'S NO QUESTION THAT SUPPLE 01 :04:26.05 WORKS. 01 :04:27.05 >> AND NOW YOU'RE SEEING THESE 01 :04:28.23 KINDS OF RESULTS BECAUSE 01 :04:30.08 THERE'S A DIRECT CONNECTION 01 :04:31.26 BETWEEN THE ROOT CAUSES OF JOINT 01 : 04: 3 3 .14 PAIN AND THE LACK OF CORE 01 :04:35.02 BUILDING BLOCKS THAT YOUR BODY 01 :04:36.24 NEEDS TO FUNCTION PROPERLY. 01:04:38.05 >> BUT IT'S NOT JUST 01 :04:39.15 JOINT PAIN. 0 1 : 04 :40 .15 >> OK 0 1 : 04 :41.15 >> IT'S ALSO BONE PAIN AND 01 :04:42.24 MUSCLE P ATN, OVERALL WEAKNESS

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002919

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 8 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 10: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :04:44.07 AND FATIGUE TOO. 01 :04:45.07 ALL THESE THINGS ARE LINKED TO A 01 :04:46.25 COMMON NUTRITIONAL DEFICIENCY 01 :04:48.08 THAT'S AFFECTING, POSSIBLY, 77 01 :04:49.23 PERCENT OF OUR ENTIRE 01:04:50.26 POPULATION. 01 :04:51.26 >> SO IS THIS WHY YOU CHANGED 01 :04:53.08 THE ORIGINAL SUPPLE FORMULA? 01 :04:54.21 >> IT IS . 01 :04:55.21 BY nJST ADDING NUTRITIONAL 01 :04:57.00 BUILDING BLOCKS IDENTIFIED IN A 01 :04:58.15 NEW MEDICAL BREAKTHROUGH, WE CAN 01:05:00.09 HELP SIGNIFICANTLY MORE PEOPLE 01 :05:01.26 END BONE PAIN, MUSCLE PAIN, 01 :05:03.10 OVERALL WEAKNESS AND FATIGUE 01 :05:04.25 TOO, FOR THE ENTIRE POPULATION, 01 :05:06.14 ALL THESE PEOPLE THAT ARE 01 :05:07.23 SUFFERING FROM THIS INADEQUATELY 01:05:09.14 PUBLICIZED NUTRITIONAL 01 :05:10.18 DEFICIENCY. 01:05:11.18 >>NOW, DOES SUPPLE STILL TASTE 01:05:13.06 GOOD, DESPITE THIS NEW, 01 :05:14.24 MORE POWERFUL FORMULA?

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002920

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 9 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 11: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :05:15.26 >>ABSOLUTELY. 01 :05:16.26 SUPPLE IS DELICIOUS. 01:05:17.28 I LOVE THE TASTE OF SUPPLE. 01 :05:19.11 I DRINK TT EVERYDAY. 01 :05:20.14 IT'S FRUITY AND SWEET, HAS ONLY 01:05:22.05 30 CALORIES, NO ARTIFICIAL 01 :05:23.17 SWEETENERS. 01 :05:24.17 IT'S COMPLETELY ALL NATURAL. 01:05:26.02 EVERYBODY LOVES THE TASTE OF 01 :05:27.17 SUPPLE. 01:05:28.17 >>THIS STUFF TASTES DELICIOUS. 01 :05:30.08 >> DELICIOSO! 01:05:32.02 >>IT TASTES SO GREAT 01 :05:33.06 YOU DON'T KNOW THAT YOU'RE 01 :05:35.00 TAKING A l\!IEDICATION. 01 :05:36.02 >> IT TASTES LIKE A REALLY NICE, 01 :05:37.24 THIN, FRUIT SMOOTHY. 01 :05:39.12 >>IT TASTES rusT WONDERFUL. 01:05:41.01 I LOVE THE TASTE OF SUPPLE. 01 :05:42.19 >>IT DOES SOUND TASTY. 01 :05:43.27 THEN WHY AREN'T THE ACTIVE 01 :05:45.10 INGREDIENTS IN SUPPLE STANDARD 01 :05:47.00 OF CARE IN THE UNITED STATES,

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002921

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 10 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 12: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :05:48.19 THE FIRST THING THAT DOCTORS 01 :05:50.05 REACH FOR, JUST LIKE THEY 01 :05:51.16 ARE IN EUROPE? 01 :05:52.16 >> HONESTLY? 01 :05:53.16 >> YEAH. 01:05:54.16 >> BECAUSE THE DRUG COMPANIES 01 :05:56.04 CAN'T MAKE BILLIONS OF 01:05:57.10 DOLLARS A YEAR SELLING THESE 01 :05:58.26 ALL-NATURAL AGENTS LIKE THEY CAN 01 :06:00.23 THEIR OWN PAIN DRUGS SO THEY DO 01 : 06: 02 .14 EVERYTHING THEY CAN TO SUPPRESS 01 :06:04.03 THEM JUST TO PRESERVE THEIR OWN 01 :06:05.22 PROFITS. 01 :06:06.22 THEY MANIPULATE THE GOVERNMENT, 01 :06:08.10 THE GOVERNMENT AGENCIES, THEY 01 :06:09.25 MANIPULATE THE MEDIA, THEY FIX 01 :06:11.12 SCIENTIFIC STlJDIES. 01 :06:12.12 >> BUT WHAT'S WRONG WITH 0 1: 06 : 13 .19 WHAT'S CURRENTLY PRESCRIBED 01 :06:14.29 IN THE U.S.? 01:06:15.29 >> WELL THE PAIN DRUGS, AND I'VE 0 1 : 06 : 17 .17 TRIED THEM ALL. 0 1 : 06 : 1 8. 1 7 >>YEAH.

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002922

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 11 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 13: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

0 1 : 06 : 19 .18 >>ACETAMINOPHEN, NONSTEROIDAL 01 :06:21.03 ANTI-INFLAMMATORY DRUGS, 01 :06:22.09 IBlJPROFEN. 01 :06:23.09 ALL THESE THINGS DO NOTHING BUT 01 :06:24.25 WSTMASK THE PAIN. 01:06:25.25 THEY DON'T TREAT THE ROOT CAUSES 01 :06:27.13 OF PAIN. 01:06:28.13 >> OF COURSE THEY COME WITH 01 :06:29.23 LOTS OF DANGEROUS SIDE AFFECTS 01 :06:31.08 IF YOU USE THEM TOO LONG, TOO. 01 :06:32.23 >> THE PAIN ALWAYS COMES 01 :06:34.04 BACK AND IT ALWAYS GETS WORSE. 01 : 06: 3 5 .19 AND SURGERY IS NOT MUCH BETTER 01 :06:37.07 IT COMES WITH NO GUARANTEES AND 01 :06:38.24 IT CAN CAUSE INFECTIONS AND 01 :06:40.04 BLOOD CLOTS AND AL WAYS REQUIRES 01 :06:41.21 SIGNIFICANT REHABILITATION. 01 :06:43.01 >> VERY TRUE. 01:06:44.01 WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT ALL OF 0 1 : 06 :4 5. 1 6 THOSE NATURAL JOINT HEALTH 01 :06:46.25 SUPPLEMENTS OUT THERE THEN? 01 :06:48.05 >> THE PROBLEM IS THAT THERE IS 01 :06:49.22 VERY LITTLE OR NO LEGITIMATE

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002923

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 12 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 14: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 06: 51. 04 CLINICAL RESEARCH SHOWING THAT 01 :06:52.19 THESE THINGS WORK AT ALL OR 01 :06:53.29 ARE EVEN SAFE TO USE. 01 :06:55.00 TO MAKE MATTERS WORSE, OVER 90 01 :06:56.15 PERCENT OF THE MOST POPULAR 01:06: 57.25 AGENTS THAT ARE SOLD IN THE 0 1 : 06 : 5 9. 1 3 UNITED STATES HA VE INGREDIENTS 01 :07:01.05 FROM CHINA WHERE THERE ARE 01 :07:02.14 SIGNIFICANT PROBLEMS WITH FAKE, 01 :07:04.00 COUNTERFEIT, LOW-QUALITY AND 01:07:05.13 CONTAMINATED INGREDIENTS. 01 :07:07.16 >> SO THEN HOW IS SlJPPLE ANY 01 :07:09.01 DIFFERENT? 01 :07:10.07 >> WELL, SUPPLE DOESN'T JUST 01 :07:11.25 MASK THE PAIN, IT HEALS THE 01:07:13.10 ROOT CAUSES OF PAIN. 01 :07:14.10 TT REBUILDS YOUR JOINTS, TT 01 :07:15.20 STRENGTHENS YOUR BONES AND IT 01:07: 17.04 MAKES YOU STRONGER. 01 :07:18.04 YOU DON'T HA VE TO WORRY ABOUT 01:07:19.17 DANGEROUS SIDE AFFECTS. 01 :07:20.21 YOU CAN USE IT FOR AS LONG AS 01 :07:22.04 YOU NEED TO.

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002924

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 13 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 15: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :07:23.04 YOU COULD STOP TAKING PAIN 01 :07:24.12 DRUGS, YOU COULD A VOID SURGERY. 01 :07:26.00 WE GUARANTEE 100 PERCENT OF 01 :07:27.10 LABEL CLAIMS. 01 :07:28.10 WE USE ONLY THE BEST INGREDIENT 01:07:29.28 SOURCES, ALL FROM THE UNITED 01 :07:31.11 STATES. 01:07:32.11 WE USE NO KEY INGREDIENTS FROM 01 :07:33.28 CHINA, AND WE GUARANTEE THE 01 :07:35.09 NillvlBER ONE INTERNATIONAL DOCTOR-01 :07:37.00 RECOMMENDED FORMULA. 01 :07:38.00 AND YOU KNOW WHAT? 01 :07:39.00 YOU COULD FEEL THE DIFFERENCE. 01 :07:40.16 JUST LISTEN TO THIS. 01 :07:41.16 >>AND SLOWLY, THE ARTHRITIS HAD 01:07:43.04 GOTTEN SO BAD IN MY SHOlJLDER, MY 01 :07:44.22 RIGHT ELBOW, MY WHOLE, MY WRIST, 01 :07:46.10 EVERYWHERE, AND IN EVERY JOINT 01:07:47.25 IN MY BODY JUST HURT SO BAD THAT 01 :07:49.17 I COL1LDN' T SLEEP BETWEEN 2 TO 4 01 :07:51.06 HOURS A NIGHT FOR THE LAST 01 :07:52.28 4 TO 5 YEARS. 01 :07:53.28 SO, WE GOT THE SUPPLE AND I

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002925

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 14 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 16: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :07:55.11 STARTED DRINKING A CAN A DAY. 01 :07:57.00 I DIDN'T SAY ANYTHING TO MY WIFE 01 :07:58.20 BECAUSE, IT HAD ONLY BEEN A WEEK 01 :08:00.17 A ND I THOUGHT MAYBE ITS A 01 :08:01.24 COINCIDENCE. 01:08:02.26 WELL, A FEW MORE DAYS WENT BY 01 :08:04.12 AND I, WE WERE SITTING HA YING 01 :08:05.25 DINNER AND I TOLD HER, I SAID, 01 :08:07.27 YOU KNOW, YOU HAVEN'T HEARD ME 01 :08:09.27 COMPLAIN HERE IN A FEW DAYS. 01:08:11.23 AND THE FACT IS, I'VE HAD NO 01 :08:13.19 PAIN IN MY SHOULDER, IN MY 01:08:15.13 WRIST, OR MY ANKLES IN, 01 :08:18.25 TRUTHFULLY, l BELIEVE IT WAS 01 :08:20.18 10 DAYS IS ALL IT TOOK. 01 :08:22.26 >>THAT'S AN AMAZING STORY. 01 :08:24.14 SO LET'S TALK ABOUT WHAT 01 :08:25.20 PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC JOINT 01:08:27.04 PAIN HAVE IN COMMON. 01 :08:28.08 >>SURE. 01 :08:29.22 >>WELL FIRST THEY HA VE 01 :08:30.28 ACCELERATED CARTILAGE BREAKDOWN. 01 :08:32.15 CARTILAGE IS THAT SQUISHY STUFF

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002926

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 15 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 17: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :08:34.01 IN THE MIDDLE OF THE JOINT. 01 :08:35.11 YOUR BODY STOPS PRODUCING ENOUGH 01 :08:37.00 OF THE BUILDING BLOCKS, 01 :08:38.07 THE CORE BUILDING BLOCKS, THAT 01 :08:39.22 THEY NEED TO REPAIR AND REPLACE 01:08:41.07 OLD AND DAMAGED CARTILAGE. 01 :08:42.16 SO THAT CUSHION IN YOUR JOINTS 01 :08:44.02 GETS SMALLER AND SMALLER AND 01 :08:45.17 EVERY TIME YOU TRY TO MOYE, 01 :08:47.02 IT rusr HURTS REALLY BAD. 01 :08:48.09 ON TOP OF THAT, YOUR BODY SENDS 01 :08:49.25 IN THESE ENZYMES THAT ACTUALLY 01 :08:51.10 START EATING AWAY AT YOUR JOINTS 01 :08:52.28 INSTEAD OF REPAIRING THEM. 01 :08:54.07 >> SO YOUR BODY'S ONLY DEFENSE 01 :08:55.23 SYSTEM REALLY MAKES 01 :08:56.23 THE PROBLEM WORSE. 01 :08:57.23 >> YEAH. 01:08:58.23 AND THEN, YOU HAVE SWELLING AND 01 :09:00.13 INFLAMMATION AND THESE ABNORMAL 01 :09:02.00 BONE GROWTHS. 01 :09:03.00 ALL THESE THINGS CAUSE 01 :09:04.05 INCREDIBLE AMOUNTS OF PAIN.

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002927

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 16 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 18: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :09:05.17 THE MORE PAIN YOU HAVE, THE LESS 01 :09:07.07 YOU USE THE JOINT. 01 :09:08.07 AND THEN, YOUR l\IIUSCLES, TENDONS 01 :09:09.24 AND LIGAMENTS, ALL THESE THINGS 0 1 : 09 : 11.11 BECOME WEAKENED AND 01:09: 12.11 OVERSTRAINED. 0 1 : 09 : 1 3 . 1 1 THAT CAUSES MORE DEGENERATION 01:09:14.25 AND EVEN MORE PAIN. 0 1 : 09 : 15 .2 5 IT'S JUST A HORRIBLE, VICIOUS, 0 1 : 09 : 1 7. 1 1 DOWNWARD CYCLE. 01:09:18.11 AND PEOPLE WITHOUT ANY JOINT 01 :09:19.26 PAIN, THEY JUST CAN'T POSSIBLY 01 :09:21.11 UNDERSTAND HOW BAD IT CAN BE. 01 :09:22.24 >>AND HOW DOES SUPPLE WORK? 01 :09:24.06 >>WELL, SUPPLE mST STOPS, 01:09:25.16 IT STOPS THE VICIOUS CYCLE OF 01 :09:26.29 CARTILAGE BREAKDOWN AND 01 :09:28.05 DEGENERATION. 01:09:29.10 FIRST IT PROVIDES THE CORE 01 :09:30.26 BUILDING BLOCKS YOUR BODY NEEDS 01 :09:32.18 TO HEAL AND REPLACE AND REPAIR 01 :09:34.06 THE OLD AND DAMAGED CARTILAGE. 01 :09:35.24 >>SO IT HELPS TO RESTORE AN

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002928

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 17 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 19: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :09:37.06 EQUILIBRIUM OF HEAL THY 01 :09:38.09 CARTILAGE? 01 :09:39.10 >>THAT'S RIGHT. 01 :09:40.12 A ND THEN TT STOPS, TT REMOVES 01 :09:41.27 THE SWELLING AND INFLAMMATION, 01:09:43.15 IT STOPS THOSE ENZYMES THAT ARE 01 :09:45.01 EATING AWAY AT YOUR CARTILAGE. 01 :09:46.20 IT REBUILDS YOUR ENTIRE JOINT 01 :09:48.02 STRUCTURES. 01 :09:49.02 IT ELIMINATES PAIN SO YOU 01 :09:50.09 DON'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT 0 1 : 09 : 5 1. 1 6 PAIN IN YOUR BONES, MUSCLES 01 :09:52.26 AND JOINTS, AND IT HELPS YOU 01 :09:54.16 YOU TO BE MORE MOBILE AGAIN. 01 :09:56.03 msr LISTEN TO THESE REAL 01 : 09: 5 7 .14 STORIES ABOUT HOW SUPPLE WORKS. 01 :09:59.05 >>WORKING AT THE ARTHRITIS 0 1 : 10 : 00 .16 FOUNDATION, I'VE BEEN ABLE TO 01:10:01.29 TURN A LOT OF PEOPLE ON TO IT, 01 : 10:03.14 THROUGH OUR EVENTS. 01: 10:05.15 WE HAND OUT FREE SAMPLES OF 01 : 10:07.03 SUPPLE, AND I' VE HEARD JUST VERY 0 1 : 10 : 09. 2 1 MANY STORIES LIKE MYSELF.

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002929

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 18 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 20: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :10:11.15 PEOPLE THAT HAVE HAD THEIR LIVES 01 :10:13.03 DRAMATICALLY CHANGED. 01: 10: 15.07 PEOPLE WHO'S PAIN IS MUCH WORSE 01 : 10: 16.25 THANMTNE. 01 :10:17.27 >>I'VE HAD RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS 01:10:20.03 FOR MANY MANY YEARS, AND 01 :10:21.21 DOCTORS, ALL TIIEY EVER DID WAS 01: 10:23.06 msT GIVE ME PAIN NIEDICINE. 01 : 10:24.16 NOTHING WOULD GET RID OF THE 01 : 10:25.27 PAIN. 01: 10:26.27 I MEAN, IT ALWAYS CAME BACK. 01 :10:28.18 AND I ALWAYS HAD TROUBLE 01: 10:30.02 SLEEPING AND STUFF BECAUSE THE 01 : 10:31.26 PAIN WAS SO BAD. 01 :10:32.26 SO AFTER BEING ON SUPPLE FOR 01: 10:34.09 PROBABLY LESS THAN A WEEK, 01 : 10:35.25 I STARTED GETTING THE 01 : 10:36.29 RE SUL TS OF WONDERFUL. 01: 10:38.04 MY PAIN IS BEARABLE, IT'S NOT AS 01 :10:41.10 BAD, TIIE SWELLING HAS GONE DOWN 01: 10:42.26 IN MY FINGERS, MY ANKLE DOESN'T 01 : 10:44.20 HURT AS BAD, AND I REALLY TRULY 01 : 10:46.08 WANT TO THANK YOU SUPPLE

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002930

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 19 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 21: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 10:47.26 FOR WHATEVER THIS DRINK IS, 01 :10:50.00 IT IS A MIRACLE DRINK. 01: 10:51.10 >>IT'S A GREAT VALUE 01 : 10:52.16 PROPOSITION, RIGHT? 01 : 10:53.28 YOU ELIMINATE PAIN BY ADDRESSING 01:10:55.16 THE ROOT CAUSES OF THE PAIN, 01 : 10:57.06 YOU REGAIN STRENGTH AND 01: 10:58.27 MOBILITY, IT HAS ALMOST NO 0 1 : 11 : 00 .17 CALORIES, CERTAINLY NO 01 : 11 :01.22 SIGNIFICANT NEGATIVE SIDE 01: 11 :03.07 EFFECTS, AND IT TASTES GREAT. 01 :11:05.13 >> ABSOLUTELY. 0 1 : 11 : 06 .13 SUPPLE IS THE FAST, SAFE, ALL-01 : 11 :08.07 NATURAL, INTERNATIONAL DOCTOR-01 : 11: 10.01 RECOMMENDED WAY FOR ANYONE TO 01:11:12.05 GET SIGNIFICANT RELIEF AND TO 01 :11:13.23 GET RID OF ALL THEIR PAIN, ALL 01 :11:15.08 THEIR IMMOBILITY, ALL THEIR 01:11:16.18 SUFFERING ONCE AND FOR ALL. 01 :11:17.29 IF YOU nJST TRY A CAN OF SUPPLE 01:11:19.19 EVERYDAY, YOU CAN FEEL A 01 : 11 :20.27 SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE IN JUST 7 01 :11:22.15 DAYS AND BETTER EVERY WEEK.

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002931

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 20 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 22: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 11 :23.25 IT'S ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. 01 : 11 :25.29 I AM SO CONFIDENT THAT SlJPPLE 01:11:27.17 WILL WORK FOR YOU, THAT I WANT 01 : 11 :29.02 TO CHALLENGE EVERYONE WHO' S 01 :11:30.12 SUFFERING FROM ANY KIND OF PAIN 01: 11 :31.27 TO CALL IN, TO TRY SUPPLE RISK-01 :11 :33.15 FREE FOR 60 DAYS - NOT 30 DAYS 01: 11 :35.28 -60DAYS. 01 : 11 :36.28 AND TO DRINK EVERY CAN TO THE 01 :11:38.12 ABSOLUTE BOTTOM. 01:11:39.12 IF YOU DON'T COMPLETELY LOVE THE 01 :11:41.00 TASTE, IF YOU DON'T FEEL BETTER 01:11:42.15 WEEK-AFTER-WEEK, IF SUPPLE DOES 01 : 11 :44.03 NOT COMPLETELY TRANSFORM YOUR 01 :11:45.15 LIFE, I'LL GIVE YOU YOUR 01:11:47.02 MONEY BACK. 01 : 11 :48.02 >> YOU'RE GUARANTEEING THE 01 : 11 :49.10 PRODUCT? 01:11:50.10 >> ABSOLUTELY. 01 :11:51.10 I'LL GIVE YOU YOUR MONEY BACK. 01:11:52.27 THIS IS A l 00 PERCENT 01 :11:54.04 UNCONDITIONAL, MONEY-BACK 01 :11:55.19 GUARANTEE.

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002932

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 21 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 23: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :11:56.19 PEOPLE NEED TO TRY SUPPLE 01 : 11 :58.04 BECAUSE IT WORKS. 01: 11: 59.04 msT LISTEN TO WHAT REAL USERS 01 : 12:01.00 HAVE TO SAY. 01 : 12:02.00 >> IWAS IN PAIN. 01:12:03.00 I KNOW WHAT THAT FEELS LIKE. 01 :12:04.20 I'M NOT IN PAIN ANY MORE. 01: 12:06.05 I NOTICED A DIFFERENCE AFTER 01 :12:07.25 ABOUT A WEEK. 01 :12:08.25 BUT, AFTER THREE WEEKS, I FELT 01:12:10.19 GREAT. 01 :12:11.19 >> WELL, IT KEPT ME OUT OF A 01 : 12: 13. 04 NURSING HOME AND I'M STILL ON 01 : 12: 14.29 THE FARM WHERE I WANT TO BE. 01 :12:17.05 >> SINCE I BEGAN THE SUPPLE 01:12:18.23 PROGRAM, I HA VE NEVER HAD, IN 01 : 12:21.21 THIS WHOLE YEAR, WHAT I CALL AND 01 : 12:23.09 REFER TO AS A FLARE-UP. 01:12:25.19 >> I USE THESE CANS OF SUPPLE AS 01 :12:27.07 AMMlJNITION AGAINST MY PAIN. 01: 12:30.01 >> !NOTICED A MARKED 01 :12:31.03 IMPROVEMENT ALMOST IMMEDIATELY, 01 :12:33.12 WITH A LOT LESS PAIN AND A LOT

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002933

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 22 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 24: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 12:36.04 MORE AGILITY. 01 :12:37.24 IT HAS BEEN A LIFE-CHANGER AND A 01:12:39.12 TRUE, TRUE lV!lRACLE. 01 : 12:42.08 I CANNOT FIND ANY OTHER WORDS 01 : 12:44.00 FOR IT. 01:12:45.02 >> BUT l REALLY LOVE SUPPLE. 01 :12:47.06 IT REALLY SAVED ME. 01:12:48.10 AS MUCH AS I LOVE MY TELEVISION, 01 :12:50.04 I'LL SHUT MY TV OFF BEFORE I'LL 01 :12:51.22 GIVE UP DRINKING SUPPLE. 01: 12:54.12 THAT'S HOW MUCH FAITH 01 : 12:55.14 I HAVE IN IT. 01: 12:56.14 AND ANYBODY THAT DOESN'T TRY 01 : 12:58.01 THIS IS FOOLISH BECAUSE IT 01 :12:59.12 REALLY, REALLY WORKS. 01: 13 :00.16 >>IF YOU'RE WATCHING RIGHT NOW, 01 : 13: 03 .10 WE TALKING WITH INTERNATIONAL 01 :13:05.15 ARTHRITIS ADVOCATE AND ARTHRITIS 0 1: 13 : 07. 03 SURVIVOR, PETER APATOW. 01 :13:08.10 PETER HAS BEEN SELECTED BY THE 01: 13 :09.29 WORLD' S GREATEST MEDICAL EXPERTS 01 :13:11.17 IN THE UNITED NA TIO NS BONE AND 01 :13:13.05 JOINT DECADE TO BE A LEADING

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002934

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 23 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 25: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :13:15.09 ADVOCATE, TO HELP END PAIN ALL 01 :13:17.29 AROUND TIIE WORLD. 01:13:19.01 IF YOU HA VE JOINT PAIN, BACK 01 :13:21.01 PAIN, BONE PAIN, l\fUSCLE PAIN, 01 :13:22.19 OR EVEN WEAKNESS AND FA TIGUE, 01:13:24.23 AND YOU WANT TO GET MORE 01 :13:26.00 INFORMATION ON 01: 13 :27.00 HOW TO GET THE NEW, MORE 01 : 13 :28.05 POWERFUL SUPPLE DRINK, PICK UP 01 :13:29.23 THE PHONE AND CALL THE NUMBER ON 01:13:31.15 YOUR SCREEN. 01 :13:32.17 WE'VE WORKED OUT A SPECIAL 01: 13 :34.05 INTRODUCTORY OFFER THAT'S ONLY 01 : 13 :35.28 AVAILABLE ON THE SMART MEDICINE 01 :13:37.14 SHOW IF YOU CALL TODAY. 01: 13 :39.04 I ENCOURAGE YOU TO TRY DELICIOUS 01 : 13 :40.26 SUPPLE ABSOLUTELY RISK-FREE 01 : 13 :42.20 FOR60DAYS. 0 1: 13 :44 .10 YOU'VE HEARD FROM REAL PEOPLE 01 :13:45.28 WHO'VE EXPERIENCED INCREDIBLE 01:13:47.20 RE SUL TS FROM SUPPLE 01 : 13 :48.26 AND NOW YOU CAN, TOO. 01 :13:50.14 PICK UP THE PHONE AND

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002935

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 24 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 26: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 13: 51.24 CALL RIGHT NOW. 01 :13:53.12 NOW PETER, PAIN DRUGS, STEROIDS, 01:13:56.24 PAIN CREAMS, THEY'RE NOT JOINT 01 : 13 :58.14 REGENERA TTNG AGENTS, ARE THEY? 01 : 14: 00 .22 >> NO, THEY'RE NOT. 01: 14:01.24 THOSE ARE ALL JUST DRUGS THAT DO 01 :14:03.16 NOTHING BUT MASK THE PAIN. 01: 14:05.04 THE REASON THAT YOU HA VE THE 0 1 : 14 : 06 .22 PAIN IS STILL THERE. 01 :14:07.22 AND WHEN THE PAIN IS NO LONGER 01: 14:09.09 BEARABLE AND THESE DRUGS STOP 01 :14:10.22 WORKING, DOCTORS RECOMMEND 01: 14: 12.01 SURGERYTHATCOULDLEADTOEVEN 01 :14:13.17 MORE PAIN AND EVEN MORE 01 :14:14.22 DEGENERATION WITH NO GUARANTEES. 01:14:17.13 >>OF COURSE IT MAKES SENSE TO 01 : 14: 19.01 A VOOID T AKTNG DRUGS AND DOING 01 : 14:20.24 SURGERY WHENEVER POSSIBLE. 01:14:22.03 >> YEAH. AND WITH SUPPLE, YOU 0 1 : 1 4 : 23 . 1 6 COULD GET RID OF PAIN WITHOUT 01: 14:24.29 DANGEROUS DRUGS OR SURGERY. 01:14:26.09 SUPPLE IS THE MISSING LINK THAT 01 :14:28.11 HEALS THE ROOT CAUSES OF PAIN BY

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002936

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 25 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 27: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 14:30.15 PROVIDING THE CORE BUILDING 01 :14:31.25 BLOCKS YOlJR BODY NEEDS TO HEAL 01: 14:33.09 ITSELF. 01 : 14:34.11 >> SO THEY DON'T GO AFTER THE 01 : 14:35.29 PAIN FIRST, THEY ADDRESS THE 01:14:37.11 ROOT CAUSE OF JOINT 01 :14:38.14 DEGENERATION, REVERSE THEM, 0 1 : 14 :40. 0 1 AND AS A FUNCTION OF THAT, 01 :14:41.18 RELIEVE THE PAIN. 01 :14:42.18 >>ABSOLUTELY. 01: 14:43.26 THEY HEAL AND REBUILD THE JOINT. 01 :14:45.16 TIIA I'S WHA I SUPPLE DOES. 01: 14:47.04 IT REBUILDS YOUR ENTIRE JOINT 01 : 14:48.22 STRUCTURE, IT ELIMINATES PAIN, 01 :14:50.10 SUFFERING AND IMMOBILITY AND IT 01: 14:51.28 HELPS YOU TO BE MORE MOBILE 01 : 14:53.10 AGAIN. 01 : 14:54.12 THIS IS WHY PEOPLE TRY SUPPLE. 01:14:56.00 JUST LISTEN TO HOW PEOPLE ARE 01 :14:57.15 SWITCHING TO SUPPLE AS THE SAFE, 01: 14:59.03 ALL-NATURAL ALTERNATIVE TO 0 1 : 15 : 00 .16 DANGEROUS DRUGS AND SURGERY. 01 : 15:02.20 >>I REALLY URGE EVERYONE TO TRY

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002937

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 26 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 28: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 15 :04.08 THIS THING. 01 : 15:05.08 I'VE HAD 15 YEARS OF AGONY 01: 15:07.10 AND I CAN HONESTLY AND TRlJL Y 01 : 15:08.28 TELL YOU, I'VE REDUCED, I'M OFF 01 : 15: 10.27 THE MEDICATION I HAD FROM THE 01:15:12.24 DOCTORS, 01 :15:13.24 I JUST QUIT TAKING IT. 01: 15: 15.05 >> I FEEL A LOT BETTER 01 :15:16.11 I FEEL GOOD EVERY DAY. 01 :15:18.01 IT'S HELPED MY JOINTS REALLY 01: 15: 19.18 A LOT. 01 :15:21.23 >> I WAS GOING TO THE DOCTOR 01: 15:23.05 WITH KNEE TROUBLE BECAUSE I WAS 01 : 15:24.21 BONE-ON-BONE. 01 : 15:26.07 AND HE RECOMMENDED CORTISONE 01: 15:29.15 SHOTS AND I WENT AND HAD THOSE, 01 :15:31.15 AND THEYREALLYDTDN' T 01 : 15:33.03 DO ANYTHING FOR ME. 01:15:34.11 THEN, I WAS WATCHING A PROGRAM 01 : 15:35.29 ONE NIGHT ABOUT SUPPLE AND I 01: 15:37.17 ORDERED IT. 01 :15:39.09 IT WAS THE BEST THING OUT THAT 01 : 15:40.27 I'VE EVER DONE FOR MYSELF

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002938

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 27 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 29: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 15:43.10 BECAUSE IT HELPED MY KNEES, 01 :15:45.18 THE CARTILAGE COME BACK 01:15:46.24 INTO MY KNEES. 01 : 15 :47.24 TT HELPED MY ARTHRITIC HANDS. 01 : 15:50.01 >>BY DRINKING THE SUPPLE, 01:15:51.16 I HA VE NOT HAD TO HA VE ANY 01 : 15:53.06 KNEE REPLACEMENT. 01: 15:54.16 I DO NOT HA VE ANY PAIN AT ALL 01 :15:56.06 IN MY KNEE NOW. 01 : 15:57.08 THE PAIN IS TOTALLY GONE. 01: 15:59.02 >> l JUST FELT BAD ABOUT EVERY 01 : 16:00.24 DAY HAVING TO TAKE PAIN 01: 16: 03 .14 MEDICATION. 01 : 16:05.02 AND WITH SUPPLE I 01 :16:07.06 DON'T HA VE TO DO THAT. 01: 16:09.08 >>WITH THESE KINDS OF RESULTS, 01 : 16: 11.00 WHY AREN'T THE ACTIVE AGENTS TN 01 : 16: 12.22 SUPPLE THE FIRST THING THAT 01: 16: 14.06 DOCTORS PRESCRIBE IN THE U.S.? 01 :16:15.25 >>IT'S BECAUSE THE DRUG 01: 16: 17.04 COMPANIES. 01 :16:18.04 THEY'RE SUPRESSING THEM 01 :16:19.14 TO PRESERVE THEIR OWN PROFITS.

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002939

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 28 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 30: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 16:20.29 MEDICAL DOCTORS ONLY PRESCRIBE 01 :16:22.13 WHAT'S BEING PUSHED BY THE DRUG 01: 16:23.29 COMPANIES. 01 : 16:25.03 AND IT'S rusT A REAL TRAGEDY 01 : 16:26.15 BECAUSE THE lvlEDICAL RESEARCH 01:16:27.26 BEHIND THESE AGENTS, 01 :16:28.27 IT'S IRREFUTABLE. 01: 16:30.01 >>WHY ARE YOU SO CONFIDENT IN 01 :16:31.16 THE RESEARCH? 01 :16:32.16 > > IT'S SIMPLE. 01: 16:33.16 THE ACTIVE AGENTS IN SUPPLE ARE 01 : 16:35.05 THE MOST HIGHLY RECOMNIENDED 01: 16:36.19 JOINT REBUILDING AGENTS BY THE 01 : 16:38.08 GREATEST MEDICAL EXPERTS IN ALL 01 :16:39.29 OF EUROPE. 01: 16:40.29 THEY'RE STANDARD OF CARE IN OVER 01 : 16:42.22 40 COUNTRIES AND OVER 13 MILLION 0 1 : 16 :44 .15 PEOPLE USE THEM SAFELY EVERY 01:16:46.00 DAY, WITH NO NEGATIVE 01 :16:47.12 SIDE EFFECTS. 01: 16:48.14 OVER 20,000 HUMAN CLINICAL 01 :16:50.18 STUDIES, OBSERVATIONAL STUDIES, 01:16:52.06 LABORATORY STUDIES, lvlETA-

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002940

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 29 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 31: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 16:53.26 ANALYSIS, EXPERT REVIEWS. 01 :16:56.00 ALL THESE KINDS OF STUDIES ARE 01: 16:57.16 AVAILABLE AT THE NATIONAL 01 : 16:59.02 INSTITUTES OF HEAL TH ON THESE 0 1 : 17 : 00 .16 INGREDIENTS ALONE. 01:17:01.18 >>THAT'S VERY INTERESTING. 01 : 17:02.28 60 MINUTES RECENTLY DID A SHOW 0 1 : 1 7 : 04 .14 ON THE DIFFICULT BATTLE AGAINST 01:17:06.02 COUNTERFEIT DRUGS FROM OTHER 01 : 17: 07. 14 COUNTRIES. 01:17:08.14 NOW, IS THIS A PROBLEM WITH 01 : 17:09.24 SUPPLEMENTS TOO? 01: 17: 10.26 >>IT'S A HUGE PROBLEM. 01 :17:12.00 THE NATIONAL INSTITUTES OF 01 :17:13.20 HEAL TH RECENTLY UNCOVERED THAT 01:17:15.05 ALL GLUCOSAMINE AND CHONDROITIN, 01 : 17: 16.23 IT'S NOT THE SAME. 01 :17:18.21 AS MUCH AS 90 PERCENT OF THESE 01:17:20.09 INGREDIENTS COME FROM CHINA 01 :17:21.27 AND THERE'S SIGNIFICANT PROBLEMS 01:17:23.15 WITH COUNTERFEITING, 01 : 17 :24 .15 CONTAMINATION, LOW-QUALITY 01 :17:25.29 INGREDIENTS, SKIMPING ON

CONFIDENTIAL SUPPLE002941

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 30 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 32: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :17:27.17 INGREDIENTS, AND EVEN USING LOW 01 :17:29.05 AND UNPROVEN DOSAGES. 01: 17:30.23 THIS IS AN EXAMPLE OF A TROUBLED 01 :17:32.11 INDUSTRY THAT NEEDS TO BE 01 : 17: 3 3 .24 COMPLETELY REFORMED. 01:17:35.05 SUPPLE, ON THE OTHER HAND, HAS 01 :17:36.23 NO INGREDIENTS FROM CHINA, 01: 17:38.27 AND WE USE ONLY THE MOST HIGH 01 :17:41.09 QUALITY, BEST INGREDIENT SOURCES 01 :17:42.27 AVAILABLE. 01:17:43.28 WE DON'T USE ANY OF THESE 01 :17:45.05 UNETHICAL AND DECEPTIVE BUSINESS 01: 17:46.25 PRACTICES. 01 :17:47.27 JUST LISTEN TO THESE REAL SUPPLE 01 :17:49.16 USERS WHO HAVE LEARNED THAT 01:17:50.26 THERE'S NOTHING MORE POWERFUL 01:17:52.09 THAN WHAT'S TN SUPPLE. 01 :17:53.12 >>I'VE HAD BACK PAIN ON AND OFF 01:17:55.02 SINCE I WAS PROBABLY IN MY MID 01 : 17:57.26 20'S, AND SINCE I'VE BEEN TAIGNG 01:17:59.13 SUPPLE I HA VEN' THAD TO DEAL 0 1 : 18 : 0 1. 04 WITH A BACK INJURY. 01 : 18:02.06 SOME OF THE OTHER SUPPLEMENTS

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002942

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 31 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 33: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 18:03.26 HAD LIKE GLUCOSAMINE AND 01 : 18:05.24 CHONDROITIN. 01: 18:07.04 SOJV1E OF THE BASIC ONES IHA T ARE 01 : 18:08.22 OUT THERE BUT, NOTHING REALLY 01 : 18: 10.25 STOOD OUT. 01:18:11.25 NOTHING REALLY STOOD OUT 01 :18:13.16 UNTIL I STARTED TAKING SUPPLE. 01: 18: 15.19 >>THIS IS MY BAD HIP. 01 :18:17.06 THE LEFT. 01: 18: 18.06 THE PAIN WAS UNBEARABLE. 01: 18: 19.12 I COULDN'T SLEEP, I COULDN'T 01 : 18:21.00 WALK 01: 18:22.06 I TRIED 1,500 MILLIGRAMS 01 : 18:23.21 OF GLUCOSAMINE AND 1,200 01 : 18:25.27 l\11LLIGRAMS OF CHONDROITIN. 01: 18:28.03 BUT, THEY DIDN'T DO 01 : 18:29.13 A NYTHTNG FOR ME 01 : 18:31.09 MY LIFE HAS CHANGED SINCE I 01:18:33.17 STARTED TO TAKE SUPPLE. 01 : 18:35.05 I'M A DIFFERENT WOMAN NOW. 01: 18:36.29 I LIKE TO PUT ON MAKE-UP, I LIKE 01 :18:39.07 TO GET DRESSED UP. 01 : 18:40.25 IT REALLY WORl(S.

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002943

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 32 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 34: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 18:42.12 >> PETER, HOW CAN SUPPLE 01 :18:43.21 POSSIBLY BE SO EFFECTIVE WHEN SO 01:18:45.12 MANY OTHER PRODUCTS FAIL TO HELP 01 : 18:47.05 PEOPLE? 01 : 18:48.08 >> SUPPLE IS THE MISSING LINK 01:18:49.20 THATHEALSTHEROOTCAUSESOF 01 :18:51.05 PAIN. 01: 18:52.07 IT REVERSES THE DISEASE PROCESS, 01 : 18:53.26 IT REBUILDS YOUR JOINTS AND IT 01 : 18:55.14 GIVES YOUR BODY TIIE CORE 01: 18:56.25 BUILDING BLOCKS IT NEEDS TO HEAL 01 : 18:58.22 ITSELF. 01: 18:59.22 PAIN, STIFFNESS, IMMOBILITY, 01 : 19:01.14 OVERALL WEAKNESS, FATIGUE, 01 : 19:02.29 DIFFICULTY MOVING, DIFFICULTY 0 1 : 19 : 04 .19 SLEEPING AT NIGHT, 01 : 19:05.20 ALL THESE THINGS, 01 : 19: 07 .17 THEY msT FADE Aw A Y. 01:19:08.17 SUPPLE' SCORE INGREDIENTS HAVE 01 :19:10.10 BEEN STUDIED FOR OVER 35 YEARS 01:19:12.02 AND WE USE ONLY THE HIGHEST 01 :19:13.19 QUALITY AND MOST CLINICALLY-01 : 19: 15.07 PROVEN INGREDIENT SOURCES

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002944

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 33 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 35: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 19: 16.20 AVAILABLE. 01 :19:17.20 >>WHAT ARE THE ACTIVE 01: 19: 18.28 INGREDIENTS IN SUPPLE? 01 : 19:20.06 >> SUPPLE HAS 1,200 MTLLTGRAMS 01 :19:21.24 OF PHARMACEUTICAL STRENGTH, VERY 01: 19:23.12 SPECIAL CHRONDROITIN SULFATE. 01 : 19:25.01 THE SAME STUFF THAT'S PRESCRIBED 01: 19:26.19 AS AN ALL-NATURAL, SAFE DRUG 01 :19:28.23 THROUGHOUT EUROPE, AND THAT WAS 01 :19:30.11 EXCLUSIVELY SELECTED BY THE 01:19:31.29 NATIONAL INSTITUTES OF HEAL TH. 01 :19:33.17 WE HA VE 1,500 MILLIGRAMS OF VERY 01: 19:35.21 SPECIAL SHELLFISH-FREE, U.S.-01 : 19:37.25 MADE, GLUCOSAMINE HYDROCHLORIDE 01 :19:39.13 AND A VERY POWERFUL, ANTI-01: 19:41.01 OXIDANT HEALING BLEND, WITH HIGH 01 : 19:43.09 LEVELS OF VTTAMTN D, C, E, B 01 : 19:46.14 VITAMINS, CALCIUM AND MAGNESIUM. 01:19:48.05 >> SO WHAT CAN PEOPLE EXPECT 01 : 19:49.19 IF THEY TRY SlJPPLE? 01: 19:50.19 >> IF YOU msT DRINK A CAN OF 01 :19:52.05 SUPPLE EVERYDAY, 01 : 19:53.09 IT'S DELICIOUS,

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002945

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 34 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 36: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 : 19:54.09 AND YOU TRY TO BE JUST A LITTLE 01 : 19:55.25 BIT MORE ACTIVE, YOU CAN FEEL A 01: 19:57.11 SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE IN JUST 7 01 : 19:58.29 DAYS AND BETTER EVERY WEEK. 01 :20:00.11 IT'S ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. 01:20:01.20 IT'LL HELP YOU GET RID OF 01 :20:02.27 ALL YOUR PAIN, ALL OF YOUR 01 :20:04.06 IMMOBILITY, ALL OF YOUR 01 :20:05.12 SUFFERING. 01 :20:06.12 YOU COULD STOP TAK.ING DANGEROUS 01 :20:07.29 PAIN DRUGS, YOU COULD A VOID 01 :20:09.13 SURGERY, AND NOW TIIE NEW, MORE 01:20:11.04 POWERFUL SUPPLE FORMULA CAN HELP 01 :20:12.28 ALL AMERICANS THAT ARE SUFFERING 01 :20:14.21 FROM A COMMON NUTRITIONAL 01:20:16.02 DEFICIENCY GET RID OF BONE 01 :20:17.16 PAIN, MUSCLE PAIN, OVERALL 01 :20:18.28 WEAKNESS AND FATIGUE, TOO. 01:20:20.10 I AM SO CONFIDENT THAT SUPPLE 01 :20:21.28 WILL WORK FOR YOU THAT I WANT 01:20:23.11 EVERYONE TO TRY SUPPLE RISK-FREE 01 :20:25.03 FOR 60 DAYS SO THEY CAN FEEL 01 :20:26.21 THE BENEFITS FOR THEMSELVES,

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002946

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 35 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 37: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :20:28.07 JUST LIKE REAL SUPPLE USERS 01 :20:29.21 HAVE. 01 :20:30.21 >>WITHIN TWO WEEKS I COULD 01 :20:32.09 TELL THE DIFFERENCE. 01 :20:33.27 PLUS, IT'S GOT A LOT OF 01:20:35.04 VITAMINS AND EVERYTHING, AND 01 :20:36.17 IT GA VE ME ENERGY AND 01 :20:37.20 IT KEPT ME OUT OF THE DOCTOR'S 01 :20:39.07 OFFICE. 01 :20:40.09 I WOULDN'T KNOW WHAT TO DO 01:20:41.18 WITHOUT SUPPLE. 01 :20:42.18 IT HAS REALLY, REALLY HELPED ME. 01 :20:44.07 >>I'VE HAD ARTHRITIS FOR, 01 :20:45.20 SINCE I WAS 18, SO IT 01 :20:47.03 l\1AKES A BIG DIFFERENCE. 01 :20:48.21 >>WHAT YOU SPEND ON DOCTORS, 01 :20:50.13 THE PRICE OF SUPPLE TS WORTH 01 :20:52.01 EVERY NICKEL, EVERY NICKEL. 01:20:53.17 >>I STARTED TO EXPERIENCE A LOT 01 : 20: 5 5. 12 OF BACK PAIN FOR THE FIRST TIME 01 :20:57.05 IN MY LIFE WHEN I, 01 :20:58.07 WHEN I HIT ABOUT 40 AND IT 01 :20:59.21 msr GOT WORSE AND WORSE WITH

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002947

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 36 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 38: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :21:01.12 THE MORE AND MOREY ARD WORK I 01 :21 :03.00 WOULD DO. 01:21:04.00 AFTER rusT PROBABL y ABOUT 01 :21 :05.21 A WEEK OR TWO OF DRINKING 01 :21 :07.10 THE SUPPLE, I'D corvrn IN FROM THE 01:21 :09.13 YARD AND I'D EXPECT TO START 01 :21:10.28 TO FEEL PAIN AND THERE 01:21:12.07 WOULDN'T BE ANY. 01 :21:13.12 ANDTHELONGERIDRANKTHE 01 :21:15.13 SUPPLE, THE LONGER I COULD 01:21:17.04 ACTUALLY STAY OUT IN THEY ARD. 01 :21:18.22 AND I HA VE NO PAIN NOW. 01:21:19.27 I CAN GARDEN 8 HOURS, 01 :21 :21.28 2 DAYS IN A ROW AND, AND I 0 1 : 21 : 23 . 1 6 REALLY DON1T HA VE ANY PAIN. 01 :21:25.04 >>I CANNOT RECOMMEND SOMETHING 01 :21 :26.22 THAT I DO, REALLY DO NOT 01 :21 :27.29 BELIEVE IN. 01 :21 :28.29 AND THERE IS NOTHING 01 :21:30.14 BETTER THAN SUPPLE. 01:21:32.03 >>IF YOU'RE WATCHING RIGHT 01 :21:33.15 NOW AND YOU'D LIKE SOME MORE 01 :21 :34.29 INFORMATION ON HOW

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002948

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 37 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 39: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :21 :35.29 TO GET SUPPLE. 01 :21 :36.29 IT'S A DELICIOUS DRINK FOR 01 :21 :38.15 COMPLETE PAIN RELIEF THAT 01 :21 :39.22 REALLY WORKS. 01 :21 :41.07 IF YOU HA VE JOINT PAIN, BACK 01:21 :42.25 PAIN, BONE PAIN, MUSCLE PAIN, 01 :21 :45.03 OVERALL WEAKNESS OR FATIGUE, 01 :21 :46.23 ARTHRITIS, OSTEOARTHRITIS, 01 :21 :48.29 RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS OR EVEN 01 :21:50.17 FIBROMY ALGIA, THIS IS A PRODUCT 01 :21 :52.25 THAT I HIGHLY RECOMMEND YOU TRY. 01 :21 :54.29 PICK UP THE PHONE AND CALL THE 01:21:56.17 NUMBER ON YOUR SCREEN FOR MORE 01 :21 :58.02 INFORMATION. 01 :21 :59.02 SUPPLE IS GUARANTEED TO WORK 01 :22:01.05 FOR YOU AND YOU CAN TRY IT 01 :22:02.17 RISK-FREE FOR 60 DAYS. 01 :22:04.10 IF YOU CALL RIGHT NOW, YOU CAN 01:22:06.00 RECEIVE A SUBSTANTIAL 01 :22:07.02 INTRODUCTORY DISCOUNT OFF THE 01 :22:08.28 NEW, MORE POWERFUL SUPPLE. 01 :22:10.18 YOU'VE HEARD FROM REAL PEOPLE 01 :22:12.04 WHO HA VE EXPERIENCED INCREDIBLE

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002949

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 38 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 40: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :22:13.26 RES UL TS FROM SUPPLE, 01 :22:14.28 AND NOW YOU CAN TOO. 01:22:16.16 PETER'S GIVEN US SOME RESEARCH 01 :22:18.06 THAT'S PRETTY COMPELLING, 01 :22:20.10 SO GIVE US A CALL. 01:22:21.12 >>PETER, TELL ME MORE ABOUT THE 01 :22:23.06 PAIN THAT YOU HAD. 01:22:24.10 >>WELL, I SUFFERED LIKE YOU 01 :22:25.21 COULDN'T EVEN IMAGINE FOR 01 :22:27.00 15 YEARS. 01 :22:28.00 I HAD SEVERE PAIN IN MY LEFT 01 :22:29.12 HIP THAI LED TO PAIN IN MY BACK, 01 :22:31.02 MY NECK, MY KNEES AND MY FEET. 01 :22:32.18 >>AND WHAT DID YOU TRY THAT 01 :22:34.00 WORKED FOR YOU? 01 :22:35.00 >>NO MATTER WHAT I TRIED-01 :22:36.09 DRUGS, DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS-01 :22:37.20 NOTHING REALLY GA VE ME MY 01:22:38.29 MOBILITY BACK OR GA VE 01 :22:40.01 ME COMPLETE RELIEF. 01 :22:41.01 THETRUTHISTHATTHESETHINGS 01 :22:42.16 JUST DON'T WORK BECAUSE THEY 01 :22:44.02 DON'T GET TO THE ROOT CAUSE OF

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002950

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 39 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 41: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :22:45.22 THE PROBLEM. 01 :22:46.22 >> SO WHAT HAPPENED WHEN YOU 01 :22:48.03 FINALLY STARTED TAKING SUPPLE? 01 :22:49.18 >> IT WAS MIRACULOUS. 01 :22:50.20 WITHIN 7 DAYS, I FELT A 01:22:51.29 SIGNIFICANT REDUCTION IN PAIN. 01 :22:53.17 WITHIN A MONTH, I WAS COMPLETELY 01:22:55.07 PAIN-FREE, I WAS FULLY MOBILE 01 :22:56.20 AGAIN, AND I'VE BEEN LIKE 01 :22:58.03 THAT NOW FOR YEARS. 01 :22:59.21 NO MATTER WHAT I DO, I CAN'T 01 :23:01.05 EVEN GET THE PAIN BACK. 01:23:02.17 IT' S MYPASSIONNOW JUST TO HELP 01 :23 :04.11 OTHER PEOPLE GET THEIR LIVES 01 :23:05.23 BACK AND TO STAY ACTIVE ruST 01 :23 :07.22 LIKE THESE REAL SUPPLE 01 :23 :09.03 USERS HAVE. 01 :23:10.03 >> AS I GET OLDER, IT'S JUST 01:23: 11.24 IMPORT ANT TO ME THAT I CAN DO 0 1 : 23 : 1 3 . 1 8 ALL THE ACTIVITIES THAT I WANT 01 :23 : 15 .10 TO DO AND NOT BE HELD BACK BY 01 :23:16.23 PAIN OR INJURY AND 0 1 : 23 : 1 8. 1 6 SUPPLE IS PART OF THAT PROGRAM

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002951

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 40 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 42: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :23 :21.26 OF I NJ UR Y PREVENTION AND LOOKING 0 1 : 23 : 23 . 14 YOUNGER, FEELING YOUNGER AND 01 :23 :24.26 STA YING ACTIVE. 01 :23 :26.00 >> I BECAME A VOLUNTEER FOR THE 01 :23:27.16 ARTHRITIS FOUNDATION. 01 :23 :28.28 WE HAD A WALK AND SUPPLE WAS ONE 0 1 : 23 : 3 1. 1 8 OF THE SPONSORS AT THEW ALK. 01:23:34.10 AND I WAS GIVEN SEVERAL CANS, 01 :23:37.02 AND IT WASN'T ANY MORE THAN 01 :23:40.01 PROBABLY 3 OR 4 DAYS AND I 01 :23 :41.19 BEGAN TO NOTICE AN IMPROVEMENT. 01 :23:43.23 AND I THOUGHT, THIS CAN'T 01 :23 :45.26 BE THE SUPPLE YOU KNOW. 01 :23:47.01 AND SO, I KEPT DRINKING IT, 01 :23:49.09 AND IT KEPT GETTING 01:23:50.15 BETTER AND BETTER 01 :23:51.19 AND THENFTNALLY, IT DAWNED ON 01 :23 :53.23 l\1E, YES INDEED, THIS WAS SUPPLE. 01:23:56.03 AND IT, IT WAS A MIRACLE TO ME. 01 :23 :57.22 IT WAS LIKE TAKING, HAVING 01:23:59.12 ABSOLUTELY SOMEBODY 01 :24:00.14 GIVING ME A MIRACLE DRUG. 01 :24:02.01 I COULD GET UP IN THE MORNING, I

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002952

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 41 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 43: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :24:03.22 COULD GET UP AND I COULD 01 :24:05.05 ACTUALLY WALK RIGHT AWAY, 01 :24:06.24 I COULD COME DOWN THE STEPS 01 :24:08.11 AND WALK. 01 :24:09.26 I DIDN'T HA VE EXCRUCIATING PAIN 01:24: 11.16 ANY MORE. 01 :24:12.16 I WOULD RECOMMEND THIS TO 01:24:13.25 ANYBODY. 01 :24:14.25 THIS IS THE BEST THING I HAVE 01 : 24: 16. 11 EVER FOUND. 01:24:17.11 >>THAT'S AN AMAZING STORY. 01 :24:18.23 I MEAN REALLY ALL THE STORIES 01 :24:20.09 YOU'VE SHARED WITH US TODAY 01 :24:21.21 HAVE BEEN REALLY INSPIRATIONAL. 01 : 24: 23. 10 >>I KNOW. 01 :24:24.10 THEY'RE JUST INCREDIBLE. 01 :24:25.17 >>NOW PETER, WE'RE RlJNNTNG OUT 01 :24:27.06 OF TIME BUT DO YOU HA VE ANY LAST 01:24 :28.24 MINUTE THOUGHTS YOU WANT TO 01 :24:30.04 SHARE WITH OUR VIEWERS? 01 :24:31.09 >>YES. 01 :24:32.09 I SUFFERED FROM SEVERE ARTHRITIS 01 :24:33.27 PAIN FOR DECADES.

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002953

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 42 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 44: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :24:34.27 BUT TODAY, MY LIFE IS 01 :24:36.00 COMPLETELY DIFFERENT. 01 :24:37.02 I HA VE NO MORE PAIN, NO MORE 01 :24:38.14 TMMOBTLTTY, NO MORE SUFFERING, 01 :24:40.01 I CAN SLEEP BETTER AT NIGHT, 01:24 :41.13 I TAKE NO PAIN DRUGS, 01 :24:42.20 I'VE A VOIDED SURGERY COJVIPLETEL Y, 01 :24:44.09 I'M FULLY ACTIVE AGAIN. 01 :24:45.15 NO MATTER WHAT I DO, 01 :24:46.15 I CAN'T EVEN GET THE PAIN BACK, 01 :24:48.02 AND IT'S ALL BECAUSE OF SUPPLE. 01 :24:49.19 IF YOU WST DRINK A CAN OF 01 :24:50.28 SUPPLE EVERYDAY, YOU'LL FEEL A 01 :24:52.15 SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE IN JUST 7 01 :24:54.05 DAYS AND BETTER EVERY WEEK. 01:24:55.15 I DRINK SUPPLE EVERYDAY. 01 :24:56.22 I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THE TASTE. 01 :24:58.04 IT'S DELICIOUS -EVERYONE LOVES 01:24: 59.21 THE TASTE OF SUPPLE. 01 :25:00.23 I AM SO CONFIDENT THAT SlJPPLE 01 :25:02.07 WILL WORK FOR YOU THAT I WANT TO 01 :25:03.26 CHALLENGE EVERYONE TO TRY IT 01 :25:05.08 RISK-FREE FOR 60 DAYS,

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002954

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 43 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 45: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :25:06.11 TO DRINK EVERY CAN TO THE 01 :25:07.18 ABSOLUTE BOTTOM. 01:25:08.18 IF YOU DON'T COl\!1PLETEL Y LOVE THE 01 :25:10.07 TASTE, IF YOU DON'T FEEL BETTER 01 :25:11.24 WEEK, AFTER WEEK, AFTER WEEK. 01:25:13.09 IF SUPPLE DOES NOT GIVE YOU YOUR 01 :25:14.28 LIFE BACK, I'LL GIVE YOU YOUR 01:25:16.12 MONEY BACK. 01 :25:17.12 >>YOU'LL GIVE EVERYONE THEIR 01 :25:18.26 MONEY BACK. 01:25:19.26 >>I'LL GIVE YOUR MONEY BACK. 01 :25:21.10 THAT'S HOW CONFIDENT I AM THAT 01 :25 :22.25 SUPPLE WILL WORK FOR YOU. 01 :25:24.02 >> SO YOU'RE GUARANTEEING 01 :25:25.11 THE PRODUCT. 01:25:26.11 >>I'M TALKING ABOUT A 100 01 :25:27.21 PERCENT UNCONDITIONAL GUARANTEE 01 :25:29.08 FOR NO MORE PAIN, NO MORE 01:25:30.15 IMMOBILITY AND NO MORE SUFFERING 01 :25:32.04 COMPLETELY GETTING YOUR LIFE 01:25:33.16 BACK. 01 :25:34.16 >>THAT'S EXCITING, ISN'T IT? 01 :25:36.09 >>ABSOLUTELY.

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002955

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 44 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 46: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :25:37.09 I WANT PEOPLE TO BE ABLE TO 01 :25:38.28 EXPERIENCE THE SAME INCREDIBLE 01 :25:40.23 RESULTS THAT REAL SlJPPLE USERS 01 :25:42.18 HA VE FOR 60 DAYS RISK-FREE. 01 :25:44.07 IF ANYBODY TRIES SUPPLE AND 01:25:45.26 THEY'RE NOT COMPLETELY 01 :25:47.06 SATISFIED, msT CALL US, WE'LL 01 :25:49.01 GIVE YOU'RE MONEY BACK. 01 :25:50.13 >> I NOTICED A DIFFERENCE AFTER 01 :25:52.11 ABOUT A WEEK 01:25:53.11 BUT AFTER THREE WEEKS, 01 :25:54.21 I FELT GREAT. 01 :25:55.21 SINCE TAKING SUPPLE, I DON'T 01 :25:57.12 HAVE ANY PAIN. 01 :25:58.12 >>NOW, THERE'S NO PAIN, AT ALL. 01 :26:00.02 SUPPLE HAS REALLY KIND OF JUST 01 :26:01.18 DELETED THE PAIN. 01 :26:02.18 >>I'M WORIGNG MUCH HARDER, MORE 01:26:04.06 HOURS A DAY, ALL IN A 01 :26:05.11 MONTH' s PERIOD IS msT 01:26:07.15 INCREDIBLE TO ME, WITH NO 01 :26:08.29 DOCTORS' ASSISTANCE. 01 :26:10.04 STRICTLY, RIGHT HERE, msT OUT

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002956

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 45 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 47: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :26:11.28 OF THIS CAN, IS JUST 01 :26:13.06 INCREDIBLE. 01:26:14.06 >>ARTHRITIS DOCTOR AFTER 01 :26:15.20 ARTHRITIS DOCTOR, AND THEY'VE 01 :26:17.12 GIVEN I\1E STEROID SHOTS, THEY'VE 01:26: 19.18 GIVEN ME PAIN PILLS THAT DIDN'T 01 :26:21.04 WORK. 01 :26:22.08 AND YOUR BODY DOESN'T NEED 01 :26:24.08 ALL THAT GARBAGE. 01 :26:25.10 PLUS, THIS STIJFF TASTES GOOD. 01 :26:26.28 I ENJOY IT. 01 :26:28.00 AFTER THE FIRST WEEK, I COULD 01:26:29.13 SLEEP - THERE WAS NOP AIN. 01 :26:31.12 >> I RAN OUT OF THE PRODUCT, AND 01 :26:33.00 WHEN I WAS OFF OF IT FOR A WEEK 01 :26:34.20 OR SO, I WAS HURTING VERY BADLY. 01 :26:39.02 AND I WENT BACK ON TT AND ALMOST 01 :26:40.24 IMMEDIATELY I HAD RELIEF. 01:26:42.08 >>THE PROBLEM IS THAT I WOULD 01 :26:44.01 ALWAYS DO EVERY ACTIVITY THAT I 01 :26:45.26 WANTED TO DO, AND I'D PAY FOR IT 01 :26:47.24 LATER. 01 :26:48.24 AND NOW, I JUST DON'T PAY FOR IT

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002957

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 46 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 48: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

01 :26:50.21 LATER, AS MUCH. 01 :26:51.21 IT' S, IT1S MADE A WORLD OF 01 :26:53.08 DIFFERENCE. 01 :26:54.08 THAT'S WHAT SOLD lvfE, WAS HOW 01 :26:55.25 GREAT THIS SUPPLE TASTES. 01:26:57.09 SUPPLE lS, IT'S AMAZING. 01 :26:58.21 >> GO AHEAD AND 1R Y IT. 01 :27:00.17 YOU'VE GOT NOTHING TO LOSE. 01 :27:01.27 IF IT DOES WHAT IT DID TO 01 :27:03.11 ME, SUPPLE WILL BE WHAT YOU 01 :27:04.21 WANT. 01 :27:05.21 >> IF YOU'VE EVER HAD ANY KIND 01 :27:07.06 OF TENDONITIS OR ARTHRITIS 01 :27:09.07 THAT'S REALLY A NAGGING, GNAWING 01 :27:11.13 PROBLEM, YOU OWE IT TO YOURSELF 01:27:13.17 TO TRY THIS STUFF. 01 :27:14.19 IT'S JUST AN INCREDIBLE THING. 01 :27:16.07 AND I FIND IT HARD TO BELIEVE IT 01:27:17.25 WILL WORK JUST FOR ME ONLY. 01 :27:19.20 >> IF YOU'RE WATCHING RIGHT 01 :27:21.02 NOW, WE'RE RUNNING OUT OF TTh1E. 01 :27 :22.24 BUT IF YOU'D LIKE MORE 01 :27:24.16 INFORMATION ON HOW TO GET SUPPLE

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002958

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 47 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 49: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

IF YOU OR 01 :27:26.20 IF YOU OR A LOVED ONE HAS JOINT 01:27:29.10 PAIN, BACK PAIN, BONE PAIN, 01 :27:31.11 MUSCLE PAIN, OVERALL 01 :27:32.28 WEAKNESS OR FATIGUE, 01:27:33.28 ARTHRITIS, OSTEOARTHRITIS, 01 :27:35.24 RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS, OR EVEN 01:27:37.12 FIBROMY ALGIA, AND YOU'VE TRIED 01 :27:39.18 EVERYTHING AND YOU'RE FED UP, 01 :27:41.22 PICK UP THE PHONE AND CALL THE 01:27:43.16 NUMBER ON YOUR SCREEN. 01 :27:45.06 YOU CAN TRY SUPPLE RISK-FREE FOR 01:27:47.12 60 DAYS AND IT'S GUARANTEED TO 01 :27:49.00 WORIZ FOR YOU 01 :27:50.22 IF YOU CALL RIGHT NOW, YOU CAN 01:27:52.11 RECEIVE A SUBSTANTIAL 01 :27:53.13 INTRODUCTORY DISCOUNT OFF THE 01 :27:54.26 NEW, MORE POWERFUL SUPPLE. 01:27:56.29 SUPPLE IS A DRINK FOR COMPLETE 01 :27:58.23 PAIN RELIEF THAT REALLY WORKS. 01:28:01.17 PETER, THANKS SO MUCH FOR BEING 01 :28:04.11 ON THE SHOW TODAY. 01 :28:05.17 >>THANK YOU. 01 :28:06.21

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002959

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 48 of 49 Document 1-2

Page 50: Complaint Exhibit A-1 · if you ha ve pain or know someone 0 1 : 00 : 18 .16 that has pain -joint pain, back 01 :00:20.22 pain, bone pain, muscle pain, 01:00:23.02 or if you suffer

IT'S BEEN A WE SOME TO BE HERE. 01 :28:08.09 >>MY NAME IS DR. MONITA POUDYAL 01 :28:09.26 AND YOU'VE BEEN WATCHING THE 01 :28:11.09 SMART MEDICINE SHOW. 01 :28:12.09 THANKS SO MUCH FOR JOINING US 01:28:13.22 AND WE'LL SEE YOU AGAIN, 01 :28:15.08 VERY SOON. 01:28:16.21

01 :28:17.23

01 :28:21.22 >> THE PRECEDING PROGRAM WAS A 01 :28 :23 .08 PAID ADVERTISEMENT FOR SUPPLE, 01 :28:24.23 THE NEW, MORE POWERFUL, 01 :28:26.04 HEAL TH REGENERATION DRINK, 01:28:27.13 BY SUPPLE, LLC. 01 :28:29.00

01 :28:30.00

CONFIDENTIAL SU PPLE002960

Exhibit A-1Case 1:16-cv-01325-WCG Filed 10/04/16 Page 49 of 49 Document 1-2