16
Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle Touma University of California, Santa Barbara CESM Virtual Workshop 2020 Samantha Stevenson (UCSB) Flavio Lehner (ETH Zurich, NCAR) Sloan Coats (U. Hawaii)

Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk

Danielle Touma University of California, Santa BarbaraCESM Virtual Workshop 2020

Samantha Stevenson (UCSB)

Flavio Lehner (ETH Zurich, NCAR)

Sloan Coats (U. Hawaii)

Page 2: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

Recent unprecedented global wildfire events

2017Thomas Fire2 fatalities

1000 buildings destroyed

2019Amazon Fires3500 sq. miles

400 million tons of CO2

2018Camp Fire

85 fatalities$16.5 bn in losses

2019-2020Australia Bushfires

34 direct + 417 smoke-related fatalities

Page 3: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

Increases in fuel aridity cause larger and more severe fires

Western US fire area and fuel aridity

Recent years have drier fuelsand larger fires

2000-2015 anthropogenic impacton fire weather conditions

Abatzoglou and Williams (2016)

Increase in fire weather due to observed ACC

increased fire weather

decreased fire weather

Page 4: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

Competing effects of anthropogenic forcing vary in space and time

Land usechange

Global effect of anthropogenic forcing (1750-2011)

War

min

g ef

fect

Cool

ing

effe

ct

1930

1980

2000

Aerosol Forcing Effect

Page 5: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

What is impact of greenhouse gases, aerosols, biomass burning, and land use change on extreme fire weather conditions?

Page 6: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

CESM-LE-SF experiments key for isolating anthropogenic impacts

Kay et al., 2015Pendergrass et al., 2019Deser et al., in revision

CESM-LE

CESM-LE-SF

Page 7: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

Fire risk and spread depends on daily to seasonal climate conditions

Fire Weather Index

Temperature

Rainfall

RelativeHumidity

Wind

daily

weeklyto

monthly

monthlyto

seasonal

Wagner, 1974Dowdy et al., 2009

“Extreme” fire weatherFWI > 90th percentile

Page 8: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

How does anthropogenic forcing change the risk of extreme fire conditions?

risk ratio (RR)=

probability of extreme fire weatherwith forcing

probability of extreme fire weatherwithout forcing

RR > 1 forcing increases riskRR < 1 forcing decreases risk

2006-2029

Greenhouse Gases

AerosolsTouma et al., in prep

Page 9: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

Regional and decadal variations in extreme fire weather risk ratio

increased risk

decreased risk

Touma et al., in prep

Page 10: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

Regional and decadal variations in extreme fire weather risk ratio

Touma et al., in prep

Page 11: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

Regional and decadal variations in extreme fire weather risk ratio

Touma et al., in prep

Page 12: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

Isolating the greenhouse-gas driven temperature effect

Greenhouse Gases

0 63-3-6deg C

2055-2080 impact 2055-2080 risk ratio

1 21.50.50

Touma et al., in prep

Page 13: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

2055-2080

Temperature Precipitation

Wind Relative Humidity

Isolating greenhouse gas-driven effects

Touma et al., in prep

Page 14: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

Time of emergence occurs before 2080 in many regions

Year that frequency of extreme fire weather

permanently emergesabove the 1980-2005

natural variability

Page 15: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

Aerosols delay the time of emergence and greenhouse gases accelerate it

Only emerges WITHforcing

Only emerges WITHOUT forcing

Touma et al., in prep

Page 16: Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts … · 2020. 6. 23. · Competing anthropogenic effects cause distinct regional impacts on extreme wildfire risk Danielle

Disentangling the anthropogenic impact on extreme wildfire conditions

Greenhouse gases increase the risk of extreme fire weather in the recent past and future periods, and accelerate the time that extreme fire weather becomes the new normal.

Aerosols reduce extreme fire weather risk in many regions in the recent past, but will have a smaller or opposite impact in the future.

Thank [email protected] | @danielletouma