Comparison TIA Portal vs Studio 5000 - PCC is the leading ... · Totally Integrated Automation minimizes engineering time and reduces costs – Through efficient interoperability

Answers for industry.Restricted to Siemens Employees and Distributor Personnel © Siemens Industry, Inc. 2013 All rights reserved.

TIA Portal vs Studio 5000Comparison

Unrestricted / © Siemens AG 2014. All Rights Reserved.

06/2014Page 2

Efficient engineering is crucial for successful automationIntegration and new portfolio make the difference in automation

Totally Integrated Automation minimizes engineering time and reduces costs –Through efficient interoperability of all automation components

1979 1996 2010 2012 2020Cost of engineering Complexity of automation Total automation costs

Integration is the key for engineering efficiency

Engineering Efficiency

Engineering cost/hour

Automation complexity (time)

Total costs

Long-term development of automation costs


06/2014Page 3

Efficient engineering is crucial for successful automationComparison of TIA Portal and Studio 5000

Restricted to Siemens Employees and Distributor Personnel © Siemens Industry, Inc. 2014 All rights reserved.

Marketing Phrases…..

Increasing Engineering Efficiency by up to 30%

Make or beat your deadlines

… Easy to use SW to do your automation tasks faster

Minimize your Downtime

… integrated system diagnostics and commissioning tools help you quickly diagnose

issues so your quickly back up and running

Optimize your Engineering efforts

… Scalable solutions and Libraries concept that allows

the production line to be quickly configured and

commissioned

What does all of this Mean?How does this help YOU the Customer?

Design Commissioning Maintenanceata


Let’s First explore what is Included

Studio 5000 V21

TIA Portal

FactoryTalk View Studio

Logix Designer Logix Designer for Drives

Step 7 V13 StartDrive WinCC

Only programs Compact and Control Logix-

…AND will only program new versions of them-


06/2014Page 6

Title Bar

Instructions Toolbox

Logic View

Controller Organizer

Results Window

Reduce engineering development times?Design Phase Comparison

Only 1 CPU per project-


06/2014Page 7

Title Bar

Instructions Toolbox

Logic View

Project Tree

Results Window


Very Similar layout Structures

Multiple PLCs, HMIs, Drives, etc.+


06/2014Page 8


Once you learn one editor…….


06/2014Page 9


You now Know them all in TIA Portal


06/2014Page 10

Reduce engineering development times?More Efficient?

Clear and Easy to Follow…Becomes Active


06/2014Page 11

Reduced Engineering EffortsReuse of Code for Efficient Programming

Studio 5000 Instance 1. Studio 5000 Instance 2.

Copy Paste

Export Import


06/2014Page 12

Reduced Engineering EffortsWith TIA Portal – Libraries

Version control…Updates to Types can be done in a single action across complete project+

Any Element like blocks, UDTs, screens & scripts saved in library. +

Easily share latest Library objects to others

Standards in code development easily shared onto corporate server+


06/2014Page 13

Reduced Engineering EffortsHMI Integration

Completely separate Software package-

No Wizards to get you started-

RS Linx Enterprise has to configured and setup -


06/2014Page 14


Finally you can browse for PLC tags-

No drag and drop of tag info from PLC-

If tag changes within the PLC program, must also change tag in HMI editor-


06/2014Page 15


Wizard for easy startup of HMI design+

New HMI device added just like PLC+


06/2014Page 16


Wizard has many functions including setup connection to PLC+

Easy setup of Screen Navigation that builds navigational buttons on appropriate screens +


06/2014Page 17


Ability to see side by side HMI design and PLC logic+

Drag and Drop of tag information creating objects on HMI Screens +

Easy HMI Integration since one Software does both!!

If Tag value changes, new value is reflected within either Editor +


06/2014Page 18

Reduced Engineering EffortsDrive Integration

From within Studio 5000, select Drive to be added to system

Now must write code to control the drive -


06/2014Page 20


Drive is setup just like PLC, HMI, etc.+

Intelligent Technology Object is setup fo the drive +


06/2014Page 21


Easy control, just select type of command…drag Technology Object to axis.+

Drive Tags are setup Automatically +

Simple control via Open blocks…Automatic tag are global to used anywhere


06/2014Page 22

Design Commissioning Maintenance

How Does TIA Portal Save Time and Money?

How do you manage different software packages for PLCs, HMIs, Drives and Networking, needed to configure a machine??

How can you reuse parts of a program shared across a company’s product line??

How can an engineering software allow you to work more efficiently??


06/2014Page 23

TIA Portal allows customers to: Beat deadlines, Achieve faster startups and Minimize downtime



Increasing Engineering Efficiency by up to 30%, allows you to:


… integrated system diagnostics and commissioning tools help you quickly diagnose issues so your quickly back up and running


… Scalable solutions and Libraries concept that allows the production line to be quickly configured and commissioned


06/2014Page 24

Minimize DowntimeRun Time Edits? Why is that so Important?

The controller is in Remote Run Mode. Will be changed to remote Program-

Major reason for Run Time Edits-


06/2014Page 25

First, Start the edits…

RS Logix Online EditingSteps to Edit while Processor is running

Copy of Run is created


06/2014Page 26


Make your changesNext, perform the edits…


06/2014Page 27

Then, accept the edits


Basically a hidden compile


06/2014Page 28


New code is now being processed (Download)Then, Test the edits


06/2014Page 29


New code is being used

Notice, original code is deleted

Finally, assemble the edits

5, YES 5 Steps!! Rung by Rung by Rung-

New Append button that does all at once…no Untest ability. Most customers use this!


06/2014Page 30

Minimize DowntownDownload in Run

Logic Downloads without stopping+

Compiled Automatically +

Make multiple changes offline, then download all

Make the changes

Download


06/2014Page 31

Minimize Downtown New Feature with V13, SP1Undo While Online


06/2014Page 32


Make the changes

Download


06/2014Page 33


Undo the changes

Undo all or steps


06/2014Page 34


Logic removed

Download

Undo all or steps


06/2014Page 35


Quick and easily revert back to Original Code


06/2014Page 36

Minimize DowntownAdd on Instructions from Rockwell

Add On Instructions.

No Online Edits- Function Block

Download….PLC will STOP! -


06/2014Page 37

Minimize DowntimeTroubleshooting

Trace editor – easy troubleshooting for sporadic faults on machine+

Studio 5000 must be online with a PC to get a Trend+

Trace downloaded to PLC with trigger points for beginning of data+

Trace 64 values… leave and let record without PC


06/2014Page 38

Online/Offline Comparison

No detailed Comparison -

Either Trash what’s running in the PLC or your program logic-


06/2014Page 39

Online/Offline Comparison

Yet Another Package -


06/2014Page 40

Siemens AnswersWith TIA Portal – Commissioning

Detailed side-by-side code comparison to determine which is correct+

Reduced commissioning time with easy identification of code differences+

Choose to Upload or Download correct program for PLC to execute +


06/2014Page 41


What features does TIA Portal have to reduce your commissioning time? ?

How does TIA Portal help debug problems with your code??

Does TIA Portal have the ability to conduct edits without PLC stopping??



06/2014Page 42










06/2014Page 43

Minimize DowntimeIntegrated Diagnostics

Must Interrogate each device -

No Integrated Diagnostics-

No Diagnostics in STOP-


06/2014Page 44


Must setup separate RS Links-

Only shows Module has an error, not what the error is without additional PLC programming-


06/2014Page 45

System diagnostic

Minimize DowntimeTIA Portal Integrated Diagnostics

Diagnostics still available in Stop mode +

Systems Diagnostic are Automatically Generated


06/2014Page 46

System diagnostic


Diagnostics also available with the new Automation Tool +

No Cost Maintenance Tool to keep plant running


06/2014Page 47

Minimize Downtime… integrated – automatically generated, without any user code needed

System diagnosticNo programming necessary… automatically generated at the device configuration

Consistent display concept… On the PLC display, TIA Portal, HMI, Webserver, and includes Drives fault information

Easy and fast identification of errors … clearly displayed error messages of fault location and cause


06/2014Page 48










06/2014Page 49


How does TIA Portal help reduce machine downtime and increase productivity? ?


How hard to program precise, useful diagnostics??


06/2014Page 50

RecapWhat are users looking for?

Project Development

Must be able to edit while online (RunTime Edits)

Too Hard to Learn new Programming Software.

Quick reuse of existing Projects

Better Diagnostics would be beneficial

Requirements… Answers–How TIA Portal addresses…

Efficient engineering framework

Integrated System Diagnostic

Flexible Configurations with Library Concept

Download in Run

Trace function, no PC requiredNice Troubleshooting Tools


06/2014Page 61

Totally Integrated Automation PortalThe complete package for Automation Tasks

• Enhanced usability (drag & drop,

cross references)

• Generate system diagnostics

automatically

• Integrated security

• Global library concepts (flexibility)

• Team Engineering: One project,

different tasks, one team - globally

• Trace functions for commissioning

• Engineering of safety products

Integrated Functions

Common Databases

TIA

Por

tal

PLC HMI IO IPC Motion NET

Increase your Engineering Efficiency – up to 30% across the design, commissioning and maintenance phases

Device Integration


Conclusion:TIA Portal is the all in ONE software package


06/2014Page 64

The TIA Portal is key to achieving True Engineering

Efficiencies


Thank you!

Brian BoyingtonSiemens Industry, IncDigital FactoryFactory AutomationEngineering Support Manager – North Region

Phone: 262-492-9212

E-mail: [email protected]

Answers for industry.

mailto:[email protected]

Documents

Comparison TIA Portal vs Studio 5000 - PCC is the leading ... · Totally Integrated Automation minimizes engineering time and reduces costs – Through efficient interoperability