Comparison Essay Directions: “The Man I Killed”—Tim O’Brien/”The Man He Killed”---Thomas Hardy

Mrs. Dolhon

A comparison essay notes either similarities, or similarities and differences.

Point-By-Point Method

Introduction

Introduction of general topic: Lead into your essay by discussing a general topic that is relevant

to both pieces of literature. (1-2 sentences)

Specific topic: Identify both pieces and how they relate to the topic. (1-2 sentences)

Thesis: Present your thesis, which reflects the point of your essay. Use the following frame:

While some differences between _________ and __________ are _________________, the

(title) (title) (adjective)

similarities are __________________.

(adjective)

Body1

Topic sentence: This sentence should focus on one aspect of comparison about the two pieces.

Topic 1: Focus on how one of the pieces connects to this aspect, and support it with textual

evidence (at least two details).

Topic 2: Focus on how the other piece connects to this aspect, and support it with textual

evidence (at least two details).

Body2

Topic sentence: This sentence should focus on another aspect of comparison about the two

pieces.

Topic 1: Focus on how one of the pieces connects to this aspect, and support it with textual

evidence (at least two details).

Topic 2: Focus on how the other piece connects to this aspect, and support it with textual

evidence (at least two details).

Conclusion

Summary of main points: Briefly remind reader of the aspects on which you focused.

Evaluation and significance: Discuss how the ideas presented in the pieces connect to life.