8/7/2019 Comparison Chart of Health

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/comparison-chart-of-health 1/1

Comparison Chart of Health-Related Quality of Life (QoL) Instruments

(Created on 12-15-2008. Last updated on 07-28-2009. Public Population Project in Genomics. All rights reserved.)

Instrument'sname

Euroqol EQ-5D(EQ-5D)

WHO (Five)Well-Being Index(WHO-5)

World Health Organization Quality of Lifeassessment instrument(WHOQOL-BREF)

Nottingham Health Profile(NHP)

SF-36® Health Survey and SF-36v2TMHealth Survey(SF-36® / SF-36v2TM)

SF-12® Health Survey and SF-12v2TMHealth Survey(SF-12® / SF-12v2TM)

Autho r(s) The Eu roQol Group P. BechThe World Health Organization Quality of Life (WHOQOL) group

S. M. Hunt, J. McEwen, and S. P.McKenna

C. D. Sherbourne and J. E. Ware J. E Ware

Main TopicQuality of lifeHealth Status

Quality of life Quality of life Health status Health status Health status

ObjectivesTo provide a simple, genericmeasure of health for clinicaland economic appraisal.

To measure positivepsychological well-being.

To assess the individuals' perceptions on thequality of their life.

To measure distress in physical,social and emotional domains

To measure generic health conceptsrelevant across age, disease, andtreatment groups

To measure health status and outcomes inlarge population survey.

Domains/categories covered

MobilitySelf-careUsual activitiesPain/ Discomfort

Anxiety/Depression

Psychological well-being

Physical Capacity (Pain, Energy, Sleep,mobility, etc.)Psychological (Positive feelings, Thinking,Self-esteem, etc.)Social Relationships (Relationships, Support,Sexual activity)

Environment (Safety, Home, Finance,Leisure, Pollution, Transport, etc.)

PainPhysical mobilitySleepEmotional reactionsEnergy

Social isolation

General healthPhysical functioningRole physicalBodily painVitalitySocial functioningMental healthRole emotionalReported health transition

General healthPhysical functioningRole physicalBodily painVitalitySocial functioning

Mental healthRole emotional

PopulationTargeted

Adult Adult Adult Adult (16+ years) Adolescent, Adult (14+ years) Adolescent, Adult (14+ years)

Time recall Current day Over the last 2 weeks During the Last 2 weeks Current dayDuring the Last 4 weeks (standardversion)During the past week (Acute version)

During the last 4 weeks (standardversion)During the past week (Acute version)

Number of items5 Questions and 1 VisualAnalogue Scale (VAS)

5 Questions 26 Questions 38 Questions 36 Questions 12 Questions

Time to complete 8 min 2 min 5-20 min 5-10min 5-10 min 2-3 min

Administrationmode

Self-administeredProxy-administeredTelephone-administered

Self-administeredSelf-administeredInterviewer-administered

Self-administered

Self-administeredInterviewer-administeredTelephone-administeredComputer-administered

Self-administeredInterviewer-administeredTelephone-administeredComputer-administered

Copyr ight © The Euroqol Group

© Psychiatric Research Unit,

WHO Collaborating Centre,Frederiksborg GeneralHospital

© The World Health Organisation

©Galen Research¤%h ࠀ¹ ¹Ware J Jr,

Kosinski M, Keller SD. A 12-ItemShort-Form Health Survey: constructi

© The Medical Outcomes Trust (MOT),Health Assessment Lab (HAL) andQualityMetric Incorporated.

© The Medical Outcomes Trust (MOT),

Health Assessment Lab (HAL) andQualityMetric Incorporated.

Conditions of useLicensing fees are determinedby the EuroQol Executive

Free access

a. With the signature of a contract/ agreement

b. In order to obtain permission for use of thevarious language versions it is necessary tocontact the collaborating sites directly.

With a written permission fromGalen Research

Fill in the license application form onthe QualityMetric website:http://www.sf-36.org/wantsf.aspx?id=1

Fill in the license application form on t heQualityMetric website: http://www.sf-36.org/wantsf.aspx?id=1

AdditionalComments

There are also a version for children from 8-11 year-old(ED-5D-Y).

It is a short version of WHOQOL-100 It is an alternative of SF-36®.