18
International Journal of Management, IT & Engineering Vol. 9 Issue 6, June 2019, ISSN: 2249-0558 Impact Factor: 7.119 Journal Homepage: http://www.ijmra.us , Email: [email protected] Double-Blind Peer Reviewed Refereed Open Access International Journal - Included in the International Serial Directories Indexed & Listed at: Ulrich's Periodicals Directory ©, U.S.A., Open J-Gage as well as in Cabell‟s Directories of Publishing Opportunities, U.S.A 388 International journal of Management, IT and Engineering http://www.ijmra.us , Email: [email protected] COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF SELECTED INDIAN PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS Dr. Pravin Narayan Mahamuni * Dr. Anand Ganpatrao Jumle ** ABSTRACT Net Interest Margin (NIM) of commercial banks varies from economy to economy due to variation in country, industry and firms specific factors. This study aims to assess and identify the determinants of NIM in the Indian Banking Industry. The data has collected from annual reports of selected Bank for the period 2008 to 2017 and MS Excel has been used for analysis of data. In this study, assessment was made to identify determinants of NIM, which is the ratio of net interest income to earning assets using panel data. The results of the study revealed that cost efficiency, implicit interest payment, competition, and scale efficiency have positive and significant effect on NIM. However, liquidity risk and management efficiency has negative and significant effect on NIM. On the other hand, credit risk, interest rate risk, capital risk, inflation and economic growth do not seem to have significant impact on banks‟ performance. Keywords: Net Interest Margin, Banking Industry, Macroeconomic Variables, Banking Performance * Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, Computer Application & Research,(Formerly Dnyanganga Institute of Career Empowerment & Research), Narhe, Pune ** Principal,SNDT Art & Commerce College for Women, Pune

COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

International Journal of Management IT amp Engineering Vol 9 Issue 6 June 2019

ISSN 2249-0558 Impact Factor 7119

Journal Homepage httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Double-Blind Peer Reviewed Refereed Open Access International Journal - Included in the International Serial

Directories Indexed amp Listed at Ulrichs Periodicals Directory copy USA Open J-Gage as well as in Cabell‟s

Directories of Publishing Opportunities USA

388 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN

(NIM) OF SELECTED INDIAN PUBLIC AND PRIVATE

SECTOR BANKS

Dr Pravin Narayan Mahamuni

Dr Anand Ganpatrao Jumle

ABSTRACT

Net Interest Margin (NIM) of commercial banks varies from economy to economy due to

variation in country industry and firms specific factors This study aims to assess and identify

the determinants of NIM in the Indian Banking Industry The data has collected from annual

reports of selected Bank for the period 2008 to 2017 and MS Excel has been used for analysis of

data In this study assessment was made to identify determinants of NIM which is the ratio of

net interest income to earning assets using panel data The results of the study revealed that cost

efficiency implicit interest payment competition and scale efficiency have positive and

significant effect on NIM However liquidity risk and management efficiency has negative and

significant effect on NIM On the other hand credit risk interest rate risk capital risk inflation

and economic growth do not seem to have significant impact on banks‟ performance

Keywords Net Interest Margin Banking Industry Macroeconomic Variables Banking

Performance

Associate ProfessorZESrsquos Zeal Institute of Business Administration Computer

Application amp Research(Formerly Dnyanganga Institute of Career Empowerment amp

Research) Narhe Pune

PrincipalSNDT Art amp Commerce College for Women Pune

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

389 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

INTRODUCTION

Finance is an integral part of any financial system and allows businesses to take advantage of

opportunities Financial institutions are important in managing and circulating fund within the

economy In doing so financial institutions contribute towards economic growth and efficiency

of a country through optimal allocation of resources They provide platform for continuous

restructuring of the economy through reallocating financial resources to the fastest growing

sectors For financial institutions to play their expected role a well functioning financial system

is a must as a weak financial system is one of the reasons for many countries to remain poor

Under developing economies like India where the financial sector is largely dominated by banks

the effective and efficient functioning of the banking sector plays significant role in accelerating

economic growth In order to achieve the goal of efficient allocation of resources the

intermediation role of banks should be carried out at the lowest possible cost However studies

conducted to assess the effect of intermediation cost (interest margin) of banks in different parts

of the world show variations The main reason behind this variation associated with both internal

and external factors such as credit risk liquidity risk interest rate risk cost efficiency

management quality competition inflation GDP growth etc and change in any of these factors

leads to change in interest margin and economic growth

The NIM ratio measures the profit a company makes on its investing activities as a percentage of

total investing assets Banks and other financial institutions typically use this ratio to analyze

their investment decisions and track the profitability of their lending operations This way they

can adjust their lending practices to maximize profitability

Investment firms also use this margin to measure the success of a fund manager‟s investment

decision-making A positive percentage indicates that the fund manager made good decisions

and was able to a profit on his investments A negative ratio on the other hand means the fund

manager lost money on his investments because the interest expenses exceeded the investment

earnings

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

390 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

The net interest margin formula is calculated by dividing the difference of investment income

and interest expenses by the average earning assets

Net Interest Margin = (Investment Income ndash Interest Expenses) Average Earning Assets

LITERATURE REVIEW

Dr Virender Koundal (2012) concludes that commercial banks in India get favorable effects

because of the various reforms Even though the overall profitability has also improved the

major benefit is taken by the private sector banks and foreign banks whereas public sector banks

are still lagging behind on various financial parameters

Seema Malik (2014) has analyzed the effect of technology on transformation of banking in India

and also studied the benefits and challenges of changing banking trends Technology and

financial innovations have led to tremendous improvement in banking services and operations

over the past decade Survival growth and profitability of banks depend upon the organizational

effectiveness and operational efficiency in todays competitive scenario where customers bdquoneeds

are changing everyday and technology is touching new highs

Indian Brand Equity Foundation (2015) has studied that Indian banks are focusing on

adopting an integrated approach to risk management Banks have already embraced the

international banking supervision accord of Basel II According to RBI majority of the banks

already meet with the capital requirements of Basel III which has a deadline of March 31 2019

Most of the banks have put in place the framework for asset-liability match credit and

derivatives risk management As per their report rising incomes are expected to increase the

need for banking services in rural areas which will positively affect the growth of the banking

sector The RBI has relaxed its branch licensing policy which emphasized the need to focus on

spreading the reach of banking Services to the un-banked population of India

Brock et al (2000) The cost of funding affects the investment potential and capital allocation

of the banks The increasing cost of intermediation negatively affects the growth potential of the

economy The increasing financial intermediation cost affects banks‟ profitability and thus being

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

391 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

a reason for decreasing efficiency of the banking sector as a whole High interest margin is also

considered bdquonegatively‟ as it leads to bdquodisintermediation

Research Gap

After reviewing the available literature research gap has been observed ie the research on NIM

did not happened after DrVirender Koundal (2012) research paper It means since last 5 years

the research on NIM has not been done

OBJECTIVES OF THE RESEARCH

1) To study the profitability of 08 Selected Indian public and private Sector banks

2) To find out impact of NIM on ROA

RESEARCH TYPE

Analytical Research has used for the research Researcher has to use facts or information

already available and analyze them to make a critical evaluation of the material It involves the

in-depth study and evaluation of available information in attempts to explain complex

phenomenon

SAMPLING METHOD

Researcher wanted to find out characteristics of a population and the objective of the

study Hence Purposive sampling method has used Purposive sampling is also known as

judgmental selective or subjective sampling

SELECTION OF SAMPLE

The Indian Banks were selected for the study Researcher has undertaken top 4 public banks and

private banks each for the study While selecting the banks researcher consider their market

capitalization and market shares

SAMPLE SIZE 08 Indian Banks (04 Public and 04 private sector Banks)

PUBLIC BANKS- PRIVATE BANKS-

STATE BANK OF INDIA AXIS BANK

BANK OF MAHARASHTRA KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

BANK OF BARODA HDFC BANK

BANK OF INDIA ICICI BANK

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

392 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

DATA COLLECTION

- Secondary Data

Instruments used for data collection-

Annual Reports of 04 Public and 04 private sector Banks

Websites- httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

PERIOD OF STUDY

Researcher has undertaken 10 years financial data of selected banks ie 2008-2017 for the study

TOOLS USED FOR DATA ANALYSIS

A research design is a plan according to which observations are made and data is assembled The

Present study is based on the secondary data and analytical in nature

For measuring various phenomena and analyzing the collected data effectively and efficiently to

draw sound conclusions certain statistical techniques were used Trend analysis graphical

analysis and descriptive statistics like as Mean has been used Also researcher used the tools like

MS-Excel for analysis purpose

FORMULA-

Net Interest Margin = (Investment Income ndash Interest Expenses) Average Earning Assets

DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRITATION

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS-

STATE BANK OF INDIA

Table No 01- NIM of State Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 17551824 11365850 6185974 267438065 231 041

2016 16368531 10680349 5688182 225906305 252 046

2015 15239707 9738182 5501525 204807980 269 076

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

393 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

2014 13635080 8706863 4928217 179223460 275 065

2013 11965710 7532580 4433130 156626103 283 091

2012 10652145 6323037 4329108 133551924 324 088

2011 8139436 4886796 3252640 122373621 266 071

2010 7099392 4732248 2367144 105341374 225 088

2009 6378843 4291529 2087314 96443208 216 104

2008 4895031 3192908 1702123 72152632 236 101

Mean 258

Graph No 01- NIM of State Bank of India

Interpretation

From the above Table No 01 it has been observed that the NIM averaged 258 highest was

324 in the year 2012 and lowest was 216 in the year 2009 It has been seen that decreasing

trend of the NIM since 2013 due to increasing NPA from same period and it‟s also resulted on

Return on Asset The ROA in the year 2016 was 046 and it became 041 in 2017 because

decreasing NPA The low margin is partly affected by a very low return on the investment

portion of the balance sheet However we have also seen decrease spread on loan and deposit

rates over the past five years

231252

269 275 283

324

266

225 216236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

394 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

BANK OF MAHARASHTRA

Table No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1206196 888727 317469 15811752 201 -086

2016 1305299 917429 387870 15966155 243 007

2015 1266544 879040 387504 14464065 268 033

2014 1195666 844773 350893 13525447 259 03

2013 961343 658008 303335 11583253 262 074

2012 721396 469688 251708 8764235 287 055

2011 556309 359469 196840 7599866 259 047

2010 473556 343931 129625 7060122 184 --

2009 429156 303503 125653 5857817 215 --

2008 354058 231179 122879 4813479 255 --

Mean

243

Graph No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Interpretation

From the Table No 02 depicts that the averaged Net Interest Margin of the Bank of Maharashtra

was 243 maximum was 287 in the year 2012 and minimum was 178 in the year 2010 It

has been seen that the NIM has decreasing since 2013 due to increasing NPA The NPA of the

201

243

268 259 262

287

259

184

215

255

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

395 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Bank of Maharashtra in the year 2013 was 052 and in the year 2017 it headed 1176 The

figure roughly translates to near 10 of all loans given This means that about 1176 of loans

are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

BANK OF INDIA

Table No 03- NIM Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4606318 2746474 1859844 62630927 297 -024

2016 4544901 3007184 1537717 60991393 252 -094

2015 4766261 3208624 1557637 61869776 252 003

2014 4220194 2707957 1512237 57319020 264 051

2013 3567497 2288493 1279004 45260272 283 065

2012 3180184 2016723 1163461 38329957 304 072

2011 2439349 1394103 1045246 34985308 299 082

2010 2049463 1212204 837259 27353784 306 --

2009 1939922 1084845 855077 22379146 382 --

2008 1447215 812595 634620 17706690 358 --

Mean

3

Graph No 03- NIM Bank of India

297

252 252 264283

304 299 306

382358

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

396 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 03 showing that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of India was 300

highest was 382 in the year 2009 and lowest was 252 in the years 2015 amp 2016 It‟s has

been seen that the NIM of the Bank of India in the year 2017 has increased (297) It has been

observed that the Borrowings of the Bank of India were increased 513 as compared to last

year (2016) and NPA has also decreased from 779 to 690

BANK OF BARODA

Table No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4219993 2868652 1351341 69487541 194 02

2016 4406128 3132143 1273985 67137648 190 -078

2015 4296356 2977632 1318724 71498855 184 049

2014 3893971 2697436 1196535 65950453 181 075

2013 3519665 2388139 1131526 54713544 207 09

2012 2967372 1935671 1031701 44732146 231 124

2011 2188592 1308366 880226 35839718 246 133

2010 1669834 1075886 593948 27831671 213 --

2009 1509158 996817 512341 22740673 225 --

2008 1181348 790167 391181 17959950 218 --

Mean

209

Graph No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

397 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the Table No 04 it has been observed that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of

Baroda was 209 higher was 246 in the year 2011 and lower was 181 in the year 2014 It

can also be observed that NIM was decreasing 2012 to 2014 but it also has increasing since

2015 to 2017 Because NPA have been decreased from 506 (2016) to 472 in 2017 And it‟s

resulted on ROA of the Bank of Baroda ROA of the Bank of Baroda in the year 2016 was -

078 and it has become 020 in the year 2017

194 190 184 181

207

231246

213225 218

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

398 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS-

AXIS BANK

Table No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4454216 2644904 1809312 60146766 301 065

2016 4098804 2415507 1683297 52546761 320 172

2015 3547860 2125446 1422414 46193239 308 183

2014 3064116 1868952 1195164 38324489 312 178

2013 2718257 1751631 966626 34056067 284 17

2012 2199465 1397690 801775 28562780 281 168

2011 1515481 859182 656299 24271337 270 168

2010 1163802 663353 500449 18064787 277 --

2009 1083549 714927 368622 14772206 250 --

2008 700532 441996 258536 10957784 236 --

Mean

284

Graph No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

301320

308 312

284 281270 277

250236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

399 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 05 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of Axis Bank was

284 Higher was 320 in the year 2016 and lower was 236 in 2008 It means the NIM of

Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 it also resulted in ROA of

the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 172 and in 2017 it became 065 It has been

observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211)

KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Table No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1769893 957278 812615 21458996 379 173

2016 1638418 948381 690037 19225979 359 119

2015 971987 549613 422374 10601208 398 198

2014 876712 504707 372005 8758534 425 18

2013 804249 483682 320567 8369368 383 181

2012 618024 366775 251249 6566679 383 183

2011 418975 209218 209757 5085067 412 177

2010 325562 139748 185814 3743631 496 --

2009 306514 154660 151854 2871188 529 --

2008 253536 130956 122580 2831236 433 --

Mean

420

Graph No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

379 359398

425383 383

412

496529

433

000

100

200

300

400

500

600

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 2: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

389 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

INTRODUCTION

Finance is an integral part of any financial system and allows businesses to take advantage of

opportunities Financial institutions are important in managing and circulating fund within the

economy In doing so financial institutions contribute towards economic growth and efficiency

of a country through optimal allocation of resources They provide platform for continuous

restructuring of the economy through reallocating financial resources to the fastest growing

sectors For financial institutions to play their expected role a well functioning financial system

is a must as a weak financial system is one of the reasons for many countries to remain poor

Under developing economies like India where the financial sector is largely dominated by banks

the effective and efficient functioning of the banking sector plays significant role in accelerating

economic growth In order to achieve the goal of efficient allocation of resources the

intermediation role of banks should be carried out at the lowest possible cost However studies

conducted to assess the effect of intermediation cost (interest margin) of banks in different parts

of the world show variations The main reason behind this variation associated with both internal

and external factors such as credit risk liquidity risk interest rate risk cost efficiency

management quality competition inflation GDP growth etc and change in any of these factors

leads to change in interest margin and economic growth

The NIM ratio measures the profit a company makes on its investing activities as a percentage of

total investing assets Banks and other financial institutions typically use this ratio to analyze

their investment decisions and track the profitability of their lending operations This way they

can adjust their lending practices to maximize profitability

Investment firms also use this margin to measure the success of a fund manager‟s investment

decision-making A positive percentage indicates that the fund manager made good decisions

and was able to a profit on his investments A negative ratio on the other hand means the fund

manager lost money on his investments because the interest expenses exceeded the investment

earnings

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

390 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

The net interest margin formula is calculated by dividing the difference of investment income

and interest expenses by the average earning assets

Net Interest Margin = (Investment Income ndash Interest Expenses) Average Earning Assets

LITERATURE REVIEW

Dr Virender Koundal (2012) concludes that commercial banks in India get favorable effects

because of the various reforms Even though the overall profitability has also improved the

major benefit is taken by the private sector banks and foreign banks whereas public sector banks

are still lagging behind on various financial parameters

Seema Malik (2014) has analyzed the effect of technology on transformation of banking in India

and also studied the benefits and challenges of changing banking trends Technology and

financial innovations have led to tremendous improvement in banking services and operations

over the past decade Survival growth and profitability of banks depend upon the organizational

effectiveness and operational efficiency in todays competitive scenario where customers bdquoneeds

are changing everyday and technology is touching new highs

Indian Brand Equity Foundation (2015) has studied that Indian banks are focusing on

adopting an integrated approach to risk management Banks have already embraced the

international banking supervision accord of Basel II According to RBI majority of the banks

already meet with the capital requirements of Basel III which has a deadline of March 31 2019

Most of the banks have put in place the framework for asset-liability match credit and

derivatives risk management As per their report rising incomes are expected to increase the

need for banking services in rural areas which will positively affect the growth of the banking

sector The RBI has relaxed its branch licensing policy which emphasized the need to focus on

spreading the reach of banking Services to the un-banked population of India

Brock et al (2000) The cost of funding affects the investment potential and capital allocation

of the banks The increasing cost of intermediation negatively affects the growth potential of the

economy The increasing financial intermediation cost affects banks‟ profitability and thus being

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

391 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

a reason for decreasing efficiency of the banking sector as a whole High interest margin is also

considered bdquonegatively‟ as it leads to bdquodisintermediation

Research Gap

After reviewing the available literature research gap has been observed ie the research on NIM

did not happened after DrVirender Koundal (2012) research paper It means since last 5 years

the research on NIM has not been done

OBJECTIVES OF THE RESEARCH

1) To study the profitability of 08 Selected Indian public and private Sector banks

2) To find out impact of NIM on ROA

RESEARCH TYPE

Analytical Research has used for the research Researcher has to use facts or information

already available and analyze them to make a critical evaluation of the material It involves the

in-depth study and evaluation of available information in attempts to explain complex

phenomenon

SAMPLING METHOD

Researcher wanted to find out characteristics of a population and the objective of the

study Hence Purposive sampling method has used Purposive sampling is also known as

judgmental selective or subjective sampling

SELECTION OF SAMPLE

The Indian Banks were selected for the study Researcher has undertaken top 4 public banks and

private banks each for the study While selecting the banks researcher consider their market

capitalization and market shares

SAMPLE SIZE 08 Indian Banks (04 Public and 04 private sector Banks)

PUBLIC BANKS- PRIVATE BANKS-

STATE BANK OF INDIA AXIS BANK

BANK OF MAHARASHTRA KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

BANK OF BARODA HDFC BANK

BANK OF INDIA ICICI BANK

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

392 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

DATA COLLECTION

- Secondary Data

Instruments used for data collection-

Annual Reports of 04 Public and 04 private sector Banks

Websites- httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

PERIOD OF STUDY

Researcher has undertaken 10 years financial data of selected banks ie 2008-2017 for the study

TOOLS USED FOR DATA ANALYSIS

A research design is a plan according to which observations are made and data is assembled The

Present study is based on the secondary data and analytical in nature

For measuring various phenomena and analyzing the collected data effectively and efficiently to

draw sound conclusions certain statistical techniques were used Trend analysis graphical

analysis and descriptive statistics like as Mean has been used Also researcher used the tools like

MS-Excel for analysis purpose

FORMULA-

Net Interest Margin = (Investment Income ndash Interest Expenses) Average Earning Assets

DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRITATION

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS-

STATE BANK OF INDIA

Table No 01- NIM of State Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 17551824 11365850 6185974 267438065 231 041

2016 16368531 10680349 5688182 225906305 252 046

2015 15239707 9738182 5501525 204807980 269 076

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

393 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

2014 13635080 8706863 4928217 179223460 275 065

2013 11965710 7532580 4433130 156626103 283 091

2012 10652145 6323037 4329108 133551924 324 088

2011 8139436 4886796 3252640 122373621 266 071

2010 7099392 4732248 2367144 105341374 225 088

2009 6378843 4291529 2087314 96443208 216 104

2008 4895031 3192908 1702123 72152632 236 101

Mean 258

Graph No 01- NIM of State Bank of India

Interpretation

From the above Table No 01 it has been observed that the NIM averaged 258 highest was

324 in the year 2012 and lowest was 216 in the year 2009 It has been seen that decreasing

trend of the NIM since 2013 due to increasing NPA from same period and it‟s also resulted on

Return on Asset The ROA in the year 2016 was 046 and it became 041 in 2017 because

decreasing NPA The low margin is partly affected by a very low return on the investment

portion of the balance sheet However we have also seen decrease spread on loan and deposit

rates over the past five years

231252

269 275 283

324

266

225 216236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

394 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

BANK OF MAHARASHTRA

Table No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1206196 888727 317469 15811752 201 -086

2016 1305299 917429 387870 15966155 243 007

2015 1266544 879040 387504 14464065 268 033

2014 1195666 844773 350893 13525447 259 03

2013 961343 658008 303335 11583253 262 074

2012 721396 469688 251708 8764235 287 055

2011 556309 359469 196840 7599866 259 047

2010 473556 343931 129625 7060122 184 --

2009 429156 303503 125653 5857817 215 --

2008 354058 231179 122879 4813479 255 --

Mean

243

Graph No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Interpretation

From the Table No 02 depicts that the averaged Net Interest Margin of the Bank of Maharashtra

was 243 maximum was 287 in the year 2012 and minimum was 178 in the year 2010 It

has been seen that the NIM has decreasing since 2013 due to increasing NPA The NPA of the

201

243

268 259 262

287

259

184

215

255

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

395 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Bank of Maharashtra in the year 2013 was 052 and in the year 2017 it headed 1176 The

figure roughly translates to near 10 of all loans given This means that about 1176 of loans

are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

BANK OF INDIA

Table No 03- NIM Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4606318 2746474 1859844 62630927 297 -024

2016 4544901 3007184 1537717 60991393 252 -094

2015 4766261 3208624 1557637 61869776 252 003

2014 4220194 2707957 1512237 57319020 264 051

2013 3567497 2288493 1279004 45260272 283 065

2012 3180184 2016723 1163461 38329957 304 072

2011 2439349 1394103 1045246 34985308 299 082

2010 2049463 1212204 837259 27353784 306 --

2009 1939922 1084845 855077 22379146 382 --

2008 1447215 812595 634620 17706690 358 --

Mean

3

Graph No 03- NIM Bank of India

297

252 252 264283

304 299 306

382358

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

396 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 03 showing that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of India was 300

highest was 382 in the year 2009 and lowest was 252 in the years 2015 amp 2016 It‟s has

been seen that the NIM of the Bank of India in the year 2017 has increased (297) It has been

observed that the Borrowings of the Bank of India were increased 513 as compared to last

year (2016) and NPA has also decreased from 779 to 690

BANK OF BARODA

Table No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4219993 2868652 1351341 69487541 194 02

2016 4406128 3132143 1273985 67137648 190 -078

2015 4296356 2977632 1318724 71498855 184 049

2014 3893971 2697436 1196535 65950453 181 075

2013 3519665 2388139 1131526 54713544 207 09

2012 2967372 1935671 1031701 44732146 231 124

2011 2188592 1308366 880226 35839718 246 133

2010 1669834 1075886 593948 27831671 213 --

2009 1509158 996817 512341 22740673 225 --

2008 1181348 790167 391181 17959950 218 --

Mean

209

Graph No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

397 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the Table No 04 it has been observed that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of

Baroda was 209 higher was 246 in the year 2011 and lower was 181 in the year 2014 It

can also be observed that NIM was decreasing 2012 to 2014 but it also has increasing since

2015 to 2017 Because NPA have been decreased from 506 (2016) to 472 in 2017 And it‟s

resulted on ROA of the Bank of Baroda ROA of the Bank of Baroda in the year 2016 was -

078 and it has become 020 in the year 2017

194 190 184 181

207

231246

213225 218

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

398 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS-

AXIS BANK

Table No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4454216 2644904 1809312 60146766 301 065

2016 4098804 2415507 1683297 52546761 320 172

2015 3547860 2125446 1422414 46193239 308 183

2014 3064116 1868952 1195164 38324489 312 178

2013 2718257 1751631 966626 34056067 284 17

2012 2199465 1397690 801775 28562780 281 168

2011 1515481 859182 656299 24271337 270 168

2010 1163802 663353 500449 18064787 277 --

2009 1083549 714927 368622 14772206 250 --

2008 700532 441996 258536 10957784 236 --

Mean

284

Graph No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

301320

308 312

284 281270 277

250236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

399 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 05 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of Axis Bank was

284 Higher was 320 in the year 2016 and lower was 236 in 2008 It means the NIM of

Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 it also resulted in ROA of

the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 172 and in 2017 it became 065 It has been

observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211)

KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Table No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1769893 957278 812615 21458996 379 173

2016 1638418 948381 690037 19225979 359 119

2015 971987 549613 422374 10601208 398 198

2014 876712 504707 372005 8758534 425 18

2013 804249 483682 320567 8369368 383 181

2012 618024 366775 251249 6566679 383 183

2011 418975 209218 209757 5085067 412 177

2010 325562 139748 185814 3743631 496 --

2009 306514 154660 151854 2871188 529 --

2008 253536 130956 122580 2831236 433 --

Mean

420

Graph No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

379 359398

425383 383

412

496529

433

000

100

200

300

400

500

600

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 3: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

390 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

The net interest margin formula is calculated by dividing the difference of investment income

and interest expenses by the average earning assets

Net Interest Margin = (Investment Income ndash Interest Expenses) Average Earning Assets

LITERATURE REVIEW

Dr Virender Koundal (2012) concludes that commercial banks in India get favorable effects

because of the various reforms Even though the overall profitability has also improved the

major benefit is taken by the private sector banks and foreign banks whereas public sector banks

are still lagging behind on various financial parameters

Seema Malik (2014) has analyzed the effect of technology on transformation of banking in India

and also studied the benefits and challenges of changing banking trends Technology and

financial innovations have led to tremendous improvement in banking services and operations

over the past decade Survival growth and profitability of banks depend upon the organizational

effectiveness and operational efficiency in todays competitive scenario where customers bdquoneeds

are changing everyday and technology is touching new highs

Indian Brand Equity Foundation (2015) has studied that Indian banks are focusing on

adopting an integrated approach to risk management Banks have already embraced the

international banking supervision accord of Basel II According to RBI majority of the banks

already meet with the capital requirements of Basel III which has a deadline of March 31 2019

Most of the banks have put in place the framework for asset-liability match credit and

derivatives risk management As per their report rising incomes are expected to increase the

need for banking services in rural areas which will positively affect the growth of the banking

sector The RBI has relaxed its branch licensing policy which emphasized the need to focus on

spreading the reach of banking Services to the un-banked population of India

Brock et al (2000) The cost of funding affects the investment potential and capital allocation

of the banks The increasing cost of intermediation negatively affects the growth potential of the

economy The increasing financial intermediation cost affects banks‟ profitability and thus being

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

391 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

a reason for decreasing efficiency of the banking sector as a whole High interest margin is also

considered bdquonegatively‟ as it leads to bdquodisintermediation

Research Gap

After reviewing the available literature research gap has been observed ie the research on NIM

did not happened after DrVirender Koundal (2012) research paper It means since last 5 years

the research on NIM has not been done

OBJECTIVES OF THE RESEARCH

1) To study the profitability of 08 Selected Indian public and private Sector banks

2) To find out impact of NIM on ROA

RESEARCH TYPE

Analytical Research has used for the research Researcher has to use facts or information

already available and analyze them to make a critical evaluation of the material It involves the

in-depth study and evaluation of available information in attempts to explain complex

phenomenon

SAMPLING METHOD

Researcher wanted to find out characteristics of a population and the objective of the

study Hence Purposive sampling method has used Purposive sampling is also known as

judgmental selective or subjective sampling

SELECTION OF SAMPLE

The Indian Banks were selected for the study Researcher has undertaken top 4 public banks and

private banks each for the study While selecting the banks researcher consider their market

capitalization and market shares

SAMPLE SIZE 08 Indian Banks (04 Public and 04 private sector Banks)

PUBLIC BANKS- PRIVATE BANKS-

STATE BANK OF INDIA AXIS BANK

BANK OF MAHARASHTRA KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

BANK OF BARODA HDFC BANK

BANK OF INDIA ICICI BANK

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

392 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

DATA COLLECTION

- Secondary Data

Instruments used for data collection-

Annual Reports of 04 Public and 04 private sector Banks

Websites- httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

PERIOD OF STUDY

Researcher has undertaken 10 years financial data of selected banks ie 2008-2017 for the study

TOOLS USED FOR DATA ANALYSIS

A research design is a plan according to which observations are made and data is assembled The

Present study is based on the secondary data and analytical in nature

For measuring various phenomena and analyzing the collected data effectively and efficiently to

draw sound conclusions certain statistical techniques were used Trend analysis graphical

analysis and descriptive statistics like as Mean has been used Also researcher used the tools like

MS-Excel for analysis purpose

FORMULA-

Net Interest Margin = (Investment Income ndash Interest Expenses) Average Earning Assets

DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRITATION

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS-

STATE BANK OF INDIA

Table No 01- NIM of State Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 17551824 11365850 6185974 267438065 231 041

2016 16368531 10680349 5688182 225906305 252 046

2015 15239707 9738182 5501525 204807980 269 076

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

393 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

2014 13635080 8706863 4928217 179223460 275 065

2013 11965710 7532580 4433130 156626103 283 091

2012 10652145 6323037 4329108 133551924 324 088

2011 8139436 4886796 3252640 122373621 266 071

2010 7099392 4732248 2367144 105341374 225 088

2009 6378843 4291529 2087314 96443208 216 104

2008 4895031 3192908 1702123 72152632 236 101

Mean 258

Graph No 01- NIM of State Bank of India

Interpretation

From the above Table No 01 it has been observed that the NIM averaged 258 highest was

324 in the year 2012 and lowest was 216 in the year 2009 It has been seen that decreasing

trend of the NIM since 2013 due to increasing NPA from same period and it‟s also resulted on

Return on Asset The ROA in the year 2016 was 046 and it became 041 in 2017 because

decreasing NPA The low margin is partly affected by a very low return on the investment

portion of the balance sheet However we have also seen decrease spread on loan and deposit

rates over the past five years

231252

269 275 283

324

266

225 216236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

394 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

BANK OF MAHARASHTRA

Table No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1206196 888727 317469 15811752 201 -086

2016 1305299 917429 387870 15966155 243 007

2015 1266544 879040 387504 14464065 268 033

2014 1195666 844773 350893 13525447 259 03

2013 961343 658008 303335 11583253 262 074

2012 721396 469688 251708 8764235 287 055

2011 556309 359469 196840 7599866 259 047

2010 473556 343931 129625 7060122 184 --

2009 429156 303503 125653 5857817 215 --

2008 354058 231179 122879 4813479 255 --

Mean

243

Graph No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Interpretation

From the Table No 02 depicts that the averaged Net Interest Margin of the Bank of Maharashtra

was 243 maximum was 287 in the year 2012 and minimum was 178 in the year 2010 It

has been seen that the NIM has decreasing since 2013 due to increasing NPA The NPA of the

201

243

268 259 262

287

259

184

215

255

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

395 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Bank of Maharashtra in the year 2013 was 052 and in the year 2017 it headed 1176 The

figure roughly translates to near 10 of all loans given This means that about 1176 of loans

are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

BANK OF INDIA

Table No 03- NIM Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4606318 2746474 1859844 62630927 297 -024

2016 4544901 3007184 1537717 60991393 252 -094

2015 4766261 3208624 1557637 61869776 252 003

2014 4220194 2707957 1512237 57319020 264 051

2013 3567497 2288493 1279004 45260272 283 065

2012 3180184 2016723 1163461 38329957 304 072

2011 2439349 1394103 1045246 34985308 299 082

2010 2049463 1212204 837259 27353784 306 --

2009 1939922 1084845 855077 22379146 382 --

2008 1447215 812595 634620 17706690 358 --

Mean

3

Graph No 03- NIM Bank of India

297

252 252 264283

304 299 306

382358

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

396 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 03 showing that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of India was 300

highest was 382 in the year 2009 and lowest was 252 in the years 2015 amp 2016 It‟s has

been seen that the NIM of the Bank of India in the year 2017 has increased (297) It has been

observed that the Borrowings of the Bank of India were increased 513 as compared to last

year (2016) and NPA has also decreased from 779 to 690

BANK OF BARODA

Table No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4219993 2868652 1351341 69487541 194 02

2016 4406128 3132143 1273985 67137648 190 -078

2015 4296356 2977632 1318724 71498855 184 049

2014 3893971 2697436 1196535 65950453 181 075

2013 3519665 2388139 1131526 54713544 207 09

2012 2967372 1935671 1031701 44732146 231 124

2011 2188592 1308366 880226 35839718 246 133

2010 1669834 1075886 593948 27831671 213 --

2009 1509158 996817 512341 22740673 225 --

2008 1181348 790167 391181 17959950 218 --

Mean

209

Graph No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

397 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the Table No 04 it has been observed that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of

Baroda was 209 higher was 246 in the year 2011 and lower was 181 in the year 2014 It

can also be observed that NIM was decreasing 2012 to 2014 but it also has increasing since

2015 to 2017 Because NPA have been decreased from 506 (2016) to 472 in 2017 And it‟s

resulted on ROA of the Bank of Baroda ROA of the Bank of Baroda in the year 2016 was -

078 and it has become 020 in the year 2017

194 190 184 181

207

231246

213225 218

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

398 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS-

AXIS BANK

Table No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4454216 2644904 1809312 60146766 301 065

2016 4098804 2415507 1683297 52546761 320 172

2015 3547860 2125446 1422414 46193239 308 183

2014 3064116 1868952 1195164 38324489 312 178

2013 2718257 1751631 966626 34056067 284 17

2012 2199465 1397690 801775 28562780 281 168

2011 1515481 859182 656299 24271337 270 168

2010 1163802 663353 500449 18064787 277 --

2009 1083549 714927 368622 14772206 250 --

2008 700532 441996 258536 10957784 236 --

Mean

284

Graph No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

301320

308 312

284 281270 277

250236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

399 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 05 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of Axis Bank was

284 Higher was 320 in the year 2016 and lower was 236 in 2008 It means the NIM of

Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 it also resulted in ROA of

the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 172 and in 2017 it became 065 It has been

observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211)

KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Table No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1769893 957278 812615 21458996 379 173

2016 1638418 948381 690037 19225979 359 119

2015 971987 549613 422374 10601208 398 198

2014 876712 504707 372005 8758534 425 18

2013 804249 483682 320567 8369368 383 181

2012 618024 366775 251249 6566679 383 183

2011 418975 209218 209757 5085067 412 177

2010 325562 139748 185814 3743631 496 --

2009 306514 154660 151854 2871188 529 --

2008 253536 130956 122580 2831236 433 --

Mean

420

Graph No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

379 359398

425383 383

412

496529

433

000

100

200

300

400

500

600

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 4: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

391 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

a reason for decreasing efficiency of the banking sector as a whole High interest margin is also

considered bdquonegatively‟ as it leads to bdquodisintermediation

Research Gap

After reviewing the available literature research gap has been observed ie the research on NIM

did not happened after DrVirender Koundal (2012) research paper It means since last 5 years

the research on NIM has not been done

OBJECTIVES OF THE RESEARCH

1) To study the profitability of 08 Selected Indian public and private Sector banks

2) To find out impact of NIM on ROA

RESEARCH TYPE

Analytical Research has used for the research Researcher has to use facts or information

already available and analyze them to make a critical evaluation of the material It involves the

in-depth study and evaluation of available information in attempts to explain complex

phenomenon

SAMPLING METHOD

Researcher wanted to find out characteristics of a population and the objective of the

study Hence Purposive sampling method has used Purposive sampling is also known as

judgmental selective or subjective sampling

SELECTION OF SAMPLE

The Indian Banks were selected for the study Researcher has undertaken top 4 public banks and

private banks each for the study While selecting the banks researcher consider their market

capitalization and market shares

SAMPLE SIZE 08 Indian Banks (04 Public and 04 private sector Banks)

PUBLIC BANKS- PRIVATE BANKS-

STATE BANK OF INDIA AXIS BANK

BANK OF MAHARASHTRA KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

BANK OF BARODA HDFC BANK

BANK OF INDIA ICICI BANK

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

392 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

DATA COLLECTION

- Secondary Data

Instruments used for data collection-

Annual Reports of 04 Public and 04 private sector Banks

Websites- httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

PERIOD OF STUDY

Researcher has undertaken 10 years financial data of selected banks ie 2008-2017 for the study

TOOLS USED FOR DATA ANALYSIS

A research design is a plan according to which observations are made and data is assembled The

Present study is based on the secondary data and analytical in nature

For measuring various phenomena and analyzing the collected data effectively and efficiently to

draw sound conclusions certain statistical techniques were used Trend analysis graphical

analysis and descriptive statistics like as Mean has been used Also researcher used the tools like

MS-Excel for analysis purpose

FORMULA-

Net Interest Margin = (Investment Income ndash Interest Expenses) Average Earning Assets

DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRITATION

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS-

STATE BANK OF INDIA

Table No 01- NIM of State Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 17551824 11365850 6185974 267438065 231 041

2016 16368531 10680349 5688182 225906305 252 046

2015 15239707 9738182 5501525 204807980 269 076

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

393 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

2014 13635080 8706863 4928217 179223460 275 065

2013 11965710 7532580 4433130 156626103 283 091

2012 10652145 6323037 4329108 133551924 324 088

2011 8139436 4886796 3252640 122373621 266 071

2010 7099392 4732248 2367144 105341374 225 088

2009 6378843 4291529 2087314 96443208 216 104

2008 4895031 3192908 1702123 72152632 236 101

Mean 258

Graph No 01- NIM of State Bank of India

Interpretation

From the above Table No 01 it has been observed that the NIM averaged 258 highest was

324 in the year 2012 and lowest was 216 in the year 2009 It has been seen that decreasing

trend of the NIM since 2013 due to increasing NPA from same period and it‟s also resulted on

Return on Asset The ROA in the year 2016 was 046 and it became 041 in 2017 because

decreasing NPA The low margin is partly affected by a very low return on the investment

portion of the balance sheet However we have also seen decrease spread on loan and deposit

rates over the past five years

231252

269 275 283

324

266

225 216236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

394 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

BANK OF MAHARASHTRA

Table No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1206196 888727 317469 15811752 201 -086

2016 1305299 917429 387870 15966155 243 007

2015 1266544 879040 387504 14464065 268 033

2014 1195666 844773 350893 13525447 259 03

2013 961343 658008 303335 11583253 262 074

2012 721396 469688 251708 8764235 287 055

2011 556309 359469 196840 7599866 259 047

2010 473556 343931 129625 7060122 184 --

2009 429156 303503 125653 5857817 215 --

2008 354058 231179 122879 4813479 255 --

Mean

243

Graph No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Interpretation

From the Table No 02 depicts that the averaged Net Interest Margin of the Bank of Maharashtra

was 243 maximum was 287 in the year 2012 and minimum was 178 in the year 2010 It

has been seen that the NIM has decreasing since 2013 due to increasing NPA The NPA of the

201

243

268 259 262

287

259

184

215

255

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

395 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Bank of Maharashtra in the year 2013 was 052 and in the year 2017 it headed 1176 The

figure roughly translates to near 10 of all loans given This means that about 1176 of loans

are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

BANK OF INDIA

Table No 03- NIM Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4606318 2746474 1859844 62630927 297 -024

2016 4544901 3007184 1537717 60991393 252 -094

2015 4766261 3208624 1557637 61869776 252 003

2014 4220194 2707957 1512237 57319020 264 051

2013 3567497 2288493 1279004 45260272 283 065

2012 3180184 2016723 1163461 38329957 304 072

2011 2439349 1394103 1045246 34985308 299 082

2010 2049463 1212204 837259 27353784 306 --

2009 1939922 1084845 855077 22379146 382 --

2008 1447215 812595 634620 17706690 358 --

Mean

3

Graph No 03- NIM Bank of India

297

252 252 264283

304 299 306

382358

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

396 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 03 showing that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of India was 300

highest was 382 in the year 2009 and lowest was 252 in the years 2015 amp 2016 It‟s has

been seen that the NIM of the Bank of India in the year 2017 has increased (297) It has been

observed that the Borrowings of the Bank of India were increased 513 as compared to last

year (2016) and NPA has also decreased from 779 to 690

BANK OF BARODA

Table No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4219993 2868652 1351341 69487541 194 02

2016 4406128 3132143 1273985 67137648 190 -078

2015 4296356 2977632 1318724 71498855 184 049

2014 3893971 2697436 1196535 65950453 181 075

2013 3519665 2388139 1131526 54713544 207 09

2012 2967372 1935671 1031701 44732146 231 124

2011 2188592 1308366 880226 35839718 246 133

2010 1669834 1075886 593948 27831671 213 --

2009 1509158 996817 512341 22740673 225 --

2008 1181348 790167 391181 17959950 218 --

Mean

209

Graph No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

397 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the Table No 04 it has been observed that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of

Baroda was 209 higher was 246 in the year 2011 and lower was 181 in the year 2014 It

can also be observed that NIM was decreasing 2012 to 2014 but it also has increasing since

2015 to 2017 Because NPA have been decreased from 506 (2016) to 472 in 2017 And it‟s

resulted on ROA of the Bank of Baroda ROA of the Bank of Baroda in the year 2016 was -

078 and it has become 020 in the year 2017

194 190 184 181

207

231246

213225 218

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

398 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS-

AXIS BANK

Table No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4454216 2644904 1809312 60146766 301 065

2016 4098804 2415507 1683297 52546761 320 172

2015 3547860 2125446 1422414 46193239 308 183

2014 3064116 1868952 1195164 38324489 312 178

2013 2718257 1751631 966626 34056067 284 17

2012 2199465 1397690 801775 28562780 281 168

2011 1515481 859182 656299 24271337 270 168

2010 1163802 663353 500449 18064787 277 --

2009 1083549 714927 368622 14772206 250 --

2008 700532 441996 258536 10957784 236 --

Mean

284

Graph No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

301320

308 312

284 281270 277

250236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

399 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 05 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of Axis Bank was

284 Higher was 320 in the year 2016 and lower was 236 in 2008 It means the NIM of

Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 it also resulted in ROA of

the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 172 and in 2017 it became 065 It has been

observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211)

KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Table No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1769893 957278 812615 21458996 379 173

2016 1638418 948381 690037 19225979 359 119

2015 971987 549613 422374 10601208 398 198

2014 876712 504707 372005 8758534 425 18

2013 804249 483682 320567 8369368 383 181

2012 618024 366775 251249 6566679 383 183

2011 418975 209218 209757 5085067 412 177

2010 325562 139748 185814 3743631 496 --

2009 306514 154660 151854 2871188 529 --

2008 253536 130956 122580 2831236 433 --

Mean

420

Graph No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

379 359398

425383 383

412

496529

433

000

100

200

300

400

500

600

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 5: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

392 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

DATA COLLECTION

- Secondary Data

Instruments used for data collection-

Annual Reports of 04 Public and 04 private sector Banks

Websites- httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

PERIOD OF STUDY

Researcher has undertaken 10 years financial data of selected banks ie 2008-2017 for the study

TOOLS USED FOR DATA ANALYSIS

A research design is a plan according to which observations are made and data is assembled The

Present study is based on the secondary data and analytical in nature

For measuring various phenomena and analyzing the collected data effectively and efficiently to

draw sound conclusions certain statistical techniques were used Trend analysis graphical

analysis and descriptive statistics like as Mean has been used Also researcher used the tools like

MS-Excel for analysis purpose

FORMULA-

Net Interest Margin = (Investment Income ndash Interest Expenses) Average Earning Assets

DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRITATION

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS-

STATE BANK OF INDIA

Table No 01- NIM of State Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 17551824 11365850 6185974 267438065 231 041

2016 16368531 10680349 5688182 225906305 252 046

2015 15239707 9738182 5501525 204807980 269 076

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

393 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

2014 13635080 8706863 4928217 179223460 275 065

2013 11965710 7532580 4433130 156626103 283 091

2012 10652145 6323037 4329108 133551924 324 088

2011 8139436 4886796 3252640 122373621 266 071

2010 7099392 4732248 2367144 105341374 225 088

2009 6378843 4291529 2087314 96443208 216 104

2008 4895031 3192908 1702123 72152632 236 101

Mean 258

Graph No 01- NIM of State Bank of India

Interpretation

From the above Table No 01 it has been observed that the NIM averaged 258 highest was

324 in the year 2012 and lowest was 216 in the year 2009 It has been seen that decreasing

trend of the NIM since 2013 due to increasing NPA from same period and it‟s also resulted on

Return on Asset The ROA in the year 2016 was 046 and it became 041 in 2017 because

decreasing NPA The low margin is partly affected by a very low return on the investment

portion of the balance sheet However we have also seen decrease spread on loan and deposit

rates over the past five years

231252

269 275 283

324

266

225 216236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

394 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

BANK OF MAHARASHTRA

Table No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1206196 888727 317469 15811752 201 -086

2016 1305299 917429 387870 15966155 243 007

2015 1266544 879040 387504 14464065 268 033

2014 1195666 844773 350893 13525447 259 03

2013 961343 658008 303335 11583253 262 074

2012 721396 469688 251708 8764235 287 055

2011 556309 359469 196840 7599866 259 047

2010 473556 343931 129625 7060122 184 --

2009 429156 303503 125653 5857817 215 --

2008 354058 231179 122879 4813479 255 --

Mean

243

Graph No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Interpretation

From the Table No 02 depicts that the averaged Net Interest Margin of the Bank of Maharashtra

was 243 maximum was 287 in the year 2012 and minimum was 178 in the year 2010 It

has been seen that the NIM has decreasing since 2013 due to increasing NPA The NPA of the

201

243

268 259 262

287

259

184

215

255

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

395 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Bank of Maharashtra in the year 2013 was 052 and in the year 2017 it headed 1176 The

figure roughly translates to near 10 of all loans given This means that about 1176 of loans

are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

BANK OF INDIA

Table No 03- NIM Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4606318 2746474 1859844 62630927 297 -024

2016 4544901 3007184 1537717 60991393 252 -094

2015 4766261 3208624 1557637 61869776 252 003

2014 4220194 2707957 1512237 57319020 264 051

2013 3567497 2288493 1279004 45260272 283 065

2012 3180184 2016723 1163461 38329957 304 072

2011 2439349 1394103 1045246 34985308 299 082

2010 2049463 1212204 837259 27353784 306 --

2009 1939922 1084845 855077 22379146 382 --

2008 1447215 812595 634620 17706690 358 --

Mean

3

Graph No 03- NIM Bank of India

297

252 252 264283

304 299 306

382358

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

396 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 03 showing that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of India was 300

highest was 382 in the year 2009 and lowest was 252 in the years 2015 amp 2016 It‟s has

been seen that the NIM of the Bank of India in the year 2017 has increased (297) It has been

observed that the Borrowings of the Bank of India were increased 513 as compared to last

year (2016) and NPA has also decreased from 779 to 690

BANK OF BARODA

Table No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4219993 2868652 1351341 69487541 194 02

2016 4406128 3132143 1273985 67137648 190 -078

2015 4296356 2977632 1318724 71498855 184 049

2014 3893971 2697436 1196535 65950453 181 075

2013 3519665 2388139 1131526 54713544 207 09

2012 2967372 1935671 1031701 44732146 231 124

2011 2188592 1308366 880226 35839718 246 133

2010 1669834 1075886 593948 27831671 213 --

2009 1509158 996817 512341 22740673 225 --

2008 1181348 790167 391181 17959950 218 --

Mean

209

Graph No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

397 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the Table No 04 it has been observed that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of

Baroda was 209 higher was 246 in the year 2011 and lower was 181 in the year 2014 It

can also be observed that NIM was decreasing 2012 to 2014 but it also has increasing since

2015 to 2017 Because NPA have been decreased from 506 (2016) to 472 in 2017 And it‟s

resulted on ROA of the Bank of Baroda ROA of the Bank of Baroda in the year 2016 was -

078 and it has become 020 in the year 2017

194 190 184 181

207

231246

213225 218

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

398 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS-

AXIS BANK

Table No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4454216 2644904 1809312 60146766 301 065

2016 4098804 2415507 1683297 52546761 320 172

2015 3547860 2125446 1422414 46193239 308 183

2014 3064116 1868952 1195164 38324489 312 178

2013 2718257 1751631 966626 34056067 284 17

2012 2199465 1397690 801775 28562780 281 168

2011 1515481 859182 656299 24271337 270 168

2010 1163802 663353 500449 18064787 277 --

2009 1083549 714927 368622 14772206 250 --

2008 700532 441996 258536 10957784 236 --

Mean

284

Graph No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

301320

308 312

284 281270 277

250236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

399 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 05 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of Axis Bank was

284 Higher was 320 in the year 2016 and lower was 236 in 2008 It means the NIM of

Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 it also resulted in ROA of

the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 172 and in 2017 it became 065 It has been

observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211)

KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Table No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1769893 957278 812615 21458996 379 173

2016 1638418 948381 690037 19225979 359 119

2015 971987 549613 422374 10601208 398 198

2014 876712 504707 372005 8758534 425 18

2013 804249 483682 320567 8369368 383 181

2012 618024 366775 251249 6566679 383 183

2011 418975 209218 209757 5085067 412 177

2010 325562 139748 185814 3743631 496 --

2009 306514 154660 151854 2871188 529 --

2008 253536 130956 122580 2831236 433 --

Mean

420

Graph No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

379 359398

425383 383

412

496529

433

000

100

200

300

400

500

600

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 6: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

393 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

2014 13635080 8706863 4928217 179223460 275 065

2013 11965710 7532580 4433130 156626103 283 091

2012 10652145 6323037 4329108 133551924 324 088

2011 8139436 4886796 3252640 122373621 266 071

2010 7099392 4732248 2367144 105341374 225 088

2009 6378843 4291529 2087314 96443208 216 104

2008 4895031 3192908 1702123 72152632 236 101

Mean 258

Graph No 01- NIM of State Bank of India

Interpretation

From the above Table No 01 it has been observed that the NIM averaged 258 highest was

324 in the year 2012 and lowest was 216 in the year 2009 It has been seen that decreasing

trend of the NIM since 2013 due to increasing NPA from same period and it‟s also resulted on

Return on Asset The ROA in the year 2016 was 046 and it became 041 in 2017 because

decreasing NPA The low margin is partly affected by a very low return on the investment

portion of the balance sheet However we have also seen decrease spread on loan and deposit

rates over the past five years

231252

269 275 283

324

266

225 216236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

394 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

BANK OF MAHARASHTRA

Table No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1206196 888727 317469 15811752 201 -086

2016 1305299 917429 387870 15966155 243 007

2015 1266544 879040 387504 14464065 268 033

2014 1195666 844773 350893 13525447 259 03

2013 961343 658008 303335 11583253 262 074

2012 721396 469688 251708 8764235 287 055

2011 556309 359469 196840 7599866 259 047

2010 473556 343931 129625 7060122 184 --

2009 429156 303503 125653 5857817 215 --

2008 354058 231179 122879 4813479 255 --

Mean

243

Graph No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Interpretation

From the Table No 02 depicts that the averaged Net Interest Margin of the Bank of Maharashtra

was 243 maximum was 287 in the year 2012 and minimum was 178 in the year 2010 It

has been seen that the NIM has decreasing since 2013 due to increasing NPA The NPA of the

201

243

268 259 262

287

259

184

215

255

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

395 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Bank of Maharashtra in the year 2013 was 052 and in the year 2017 it headed 1176 The

figure roughly translates to near 10 of all loans given This means that about 1176 of loans

are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

BANK OF INDIA

Table No 03- NIM Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4606318 2746474 1859844 62630927 297 -024

2016 4544901 3007184 1537717 60991393 252 -094

2015 4766261 3208624 1557637 61869776 252 003

2014 4220194 2707957 1512237 57319020 264 051

2013 3567497 2288493 1279004 45260272 283 065

2012 3180184 2016723 1163461 38329957 304 072

2011 2439349 1394103 1045246 34985308 299 082

2010 2049463 1212204 837259 27353784 306 --

2009 1939922 1084845 855077 22379146 382 --

2008 1447215 812595 634620 17706690 358 --

Mean

3

Graph No 03- NIM Bank of India

297

252 252 264283

304 299 306

382358

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

396 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 03 showing that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of India was 300

highest was 382 in the year 2009 and lowest was 252 in the years 2015 amp 2016 It‟s has

been seen that the NIM of the Bank of India in the year 2017 has increased (297) It has been

observed that the Borrowings of the Bank of India were increased 513 as compared to last

year (2016) and NPA has also decreased from 779 to 690

BANK OF BARODA

Table No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4219993 2868652 1351341 69487541 194 02

2016 4406128 3132143 1273985 67137648 190 -078

2015 4296356 2977632 1318724 71498855 184 049

2014 3893971 2697436 1196535 65950453 181 075

2013 3519665 2388139 1131526 54713544 207 09

2012 2967372 1935671 1031701 44732146 231 124

2011 2188592 1308366 880226 35839718 246 133

2010 1669834 1075886 593948 27831671 213 --

2009 1509158 996817 512341 22740673 225 --

2008 1181348 790167 391181 17959950 218 --

Mean

209

Graph No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

397 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the Table No 04 it has been observed that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of

Baroda was 209 higher was 246 in the year 2011 and lower was 181 in the year 2014 It

can also be observed that NIM was decreasing 2012 to 2014 but it also has increasing since

2015 to 2017 Because NPA have been decreased from 506 (2016) to 472 in 2017 And it‟s

resulted on ROA of the Bank of Baroda ROA of the Bank of Baroda in the year 2016 was -

078 and it has become 020 in the year 2017

194 190 184 181

207

231246

213225 218

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

398 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS-

AXIS BANK

Table No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4454216 2644904 1809312 60146766 301 065

2016 4098804 2415507 1683297 52546761 320 172

2015 3547860 2125446 1422414 46193239 308 183

2014 3064116 1868952 1195164 38324489 312 178

2013 2718257 1751631 966626 34056067 284 17

2012 2199465 1397690 801775 28562780 281 168

2011 1515481 859182 656299 24271337 270 168

2010 1163802 663353 500449 18064787 277 --

2009 1083549 714927 368622 14772206 250 --

2008 700532 441996 258536 10957784 236 --

Mean

284

Graph No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

301320

308 312

284 281270 277

250236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

399 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 05 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of Axis Bank was

284 Higher was 320 in the year 2016 and lower was 236 in 2008 It means the NIM of

Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 it also resulted in ROA of

the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 172 and in 2017 it became 065 It has been

observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211)

KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Table No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1769893 957278 812615 21458996 379 173

2016 1638418 948381 690037 19225979 359 119

2015 971987 549613 422374 10601208 398 198

2014 876712 504707 372005 8758534 425 18

2013 804249 483682 320567 8369368 383 181

2012 618024 366775 251249 6566679 383 183

2011 418975 209218 209757 5085067 412 177

2010 325562 139748 185814 3743631 496 --

2009 306514 154660 151854 2871188 529 --

2008 253536 130956 122580 2831236 433 --

Mean

420

Graph No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

379 359398

425383 383

412

496529

433

000

100

200

300

400

500

600

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 7: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

394 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

BANK OF MAHARASHTRA

Table No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1206196 888727 317469 15811752 201 -086

2016 1305299 917429 387870 15966155 243 007

2015 1266544 879040 387504 14464065 268 033

2014 1195666 844773 350893 13525447 259 03

2013 961343 658008 303335 11583253 262 074

2012 721396 469688 251708 8764235 287 055

2011 556309 359469 196840 7599866 259 047

2010 473556 343931 129625 7060122 184 --

2009 429156 303503 125653 5857817 215 --

2008 354058 231179 122879 4813479 255 --

Mean

243

Graph No 02- NIM Bank of Maharashtra

Interpretation

From the Table No 02 depicts that the averaged Net Interest Margin of the Bank of Maharashtra

was 243 maximum was 287 in the year 2012 and minimum was 178 in the year 2010 It

has been seen that the NIM has decreasing since 2013 due to increasing NPA The NPA of the

201

243

268 259 262

287

259

184

215

255

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

395 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Bank of Maharashtra in the year 2013 was 052 and in the year 2017 it headed 1176 The

figure roughly translates to near 10 of all loans given This means that about 1176 of loans

are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

BANK OF INDIA

Table No 03- NIM Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4606318 2746474 1859844 62630927 297 -024

2016 4544901 3007184 1537717 60991393 252 -094

2015 4766261 3208624 1557637 61869776 252 003

2014 4220194 2707957 1512237 57319020 264 051

2013 3567497 2288493 1279004 45260272 283 065

2012 3180184 2016723 1163461 38329957 304 072

2011 2439349 1394103 1045246 34985308 299 082

2010 2049463 1212204 837259 27353784 306 --

2009 1939922 1084845 855077 22379146 382 --

2008 1447215 812595 634620 17706690 358 --

Mean

3

Graph No 03- NIM Bank of India

297

252 252 264283

304 299 306

382358

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

396 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 03 showing that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of India was 300

highest was 382 in the year 2009 and lowest was 252 in the years 2015 amp 2016 It‟s has

been seen that the NIM of the Bank of India in the year 2017 has increased (297) It has been

observed that the Borrowings of the Bank of India were increased 513 as compared to last

year (2016) and NPA has also decreased from 779 to 690

BANK OF BARODA

Table No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4219993 2868652 1351341 69487541 194 02

2016 4406128 3132143 1273985 67137648 190 -078

2015 4296356 2977632 1318724 71498855 184 049

2014 3893971 2697436 1196535 65950453 181 075

2013 3519665 2388139 1131526 54713544 207 09

2012 2967372 1935671 1031701 44732146 231 124

2011 2188592 1308366 880226 35839718 246 133

2010 1669834 1075886 593948 27831671 213 --

2009 1509158 996817 512341 22740673 225 --

2008 1181348 790167 391181 17959950 218 --

Mean

209

Graph No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

397 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the Table No 04 it has been observed that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of

Baroda was 209 higher was 246 in the year 2011 and lower was 181 in the year 2014 It

can also be observed that NIM was decreasing 2012 to 2014 but it also has increasing since

2015 to 2017 Because NPA have been decreased from 506 (2016) to 472 in 2017 And it‟s

resulted on ROA of the Bank of Baroda ROA of the Bank of Baroda in the year 2016 was -

078 and it has become 020 in the year 2017

194 190 184 181

207

231246

213225 218

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

398 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS-

AXIS BANK

Table No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4454216 2644904 1809312 60146766 301 065

2016 4098804 2415507 1683297 52546761 320 172

2015 3547860 2125446 1422414 46193239 308 183

2014 3064116 1868952 1195164 38324489 312 178

2013 2718257 1751631 966626 34056067 284 17

2012 2199465 1397690 801775 28562780 281 168

2011 1515481 859182 656299 24271337 270 168

2010 1163802 663353 500449 18064787 277 --

2009 1083549 714927 368622 14772206 250 --

2008 700532 441996 258536 10957784 236 --

Mean

284

Graph No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

301320

308 312

284 281270 277

250236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

399 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 05 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of Axis Bank was

284 Higher was 320 in the year 2016 and lower was 236 in 2008 It means the NIM of

Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 it also resulted in ROA of

the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 172 and in 2017 it became 065 It has been

observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211)

KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Table No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1769893 957278 812615 21458996 379 173

2016 1638418 948381 690037 19225979 359 119

2015 971987 549613 422374 10601208 398 198

2014 876712 504707 372005 8758534 425 18

2013 804249 483682 320567 8369368 383 181

2012 618024 366775 251249 6566679 383 183

2011 418975 209218 209757 5085067 412 177

2010 325562 139748 185814 3743631 496 --

2009 306514 154660 151854 2871188 529 --

2008 253536 130956 122580 2831236 433 --

Mean

420

Graph No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

379 359398

425383 383

412

496529

433

000

100

200

300

400

500

600

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 8: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

395 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Bank of Maharashtra in the year 2013 was 052 and in the year 2017 it headed 1176 The

figure roughly translates to near 10 of all loans given This means that about 1176 of loans

are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

BANK OF INDIA

Table No 03- NIM Bank of India

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4606318 2746474 1859844 62630927 297 -024

2016 4544901 3007184 1537717 60991393 252 -094

2015 4766261 3208624 1557637 61869776 252 003

2014 4220194 2707957 1512237 57319020 264 051

2013 3567497 2288493 1279004 45260272 283 065

2012 3180184 2016723 1163461 38329957 304 072

2011 2439349 1394103 1045246 34985308 299 082

2010 2049463 1212204 837259 27353784 306 --

2009 1939922 1084845 855077 22379146 382 --

2008 1447215 812595 634620 17706690 358 --

Mean

3

Graph No 03- NIM Bank of India

297

252 252 264283

304 299 306

382358

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

396 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 03 showing that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of India was 300

highest was 382 in the year 2009 and lowest was 252 in the years 2015 amp 2016 It‟s has

been seen that the NIM of the Bank of India in the year 2017 has increased (297) It has been

observed that the Borrowings of the Bank of India were increased 513 as compared to last

year (2016) and NPA has also decreased from 779 to 690

BANK OF BARODA

Table No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4219993 2868652 1351341 69487541 194 02

2016 4406128 3132143 1273985 67137648 190 -078

2015 4296356 2977632 1318724 71498855 184 049

2014 3893971 2697436 1196535 65950453 181 075

2013 3519665 2388139 1131526 54713544 207 09

2012 2967372 1935671 1031701 44732146 231 124

2011 2188592 1308366 880226 35839718 246 133

2010 1669834 1075886 593948 27831671 213 --

2009 1509158 996817 512341 22740673 225 --

2008 1181348 790167 391181 17959950 218 --

Mean

209

Graph No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

397 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the Table No 04 it has been observed that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of

Baroda was 209 higher was 246 in the year 2011 and lower was 181 in the year 2014 It

can also be observed that NIM was decreasing 2012 to 2014 but it also has increasing since

2015 to 2017 Because NPA have been decreased from 506 (2016) to 472 in 2017 And it‟s

resulted on ROA of the Bank of Baroda ROA of the Bank of Baroda in the year 2016 was -

078 and it has become 020 in the year 2017

194 190 184 181

207

231246

213225 218

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

398 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS-

AXIS BANK

Table No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4454216 2644904 1809312 60146766 301 065

2016 4098804 2415507 1683297 52546761 320 172

2015 3547860 2125446 1422414 46193239 308 183

2014 3064116 1868952 1195164 38324489 312 178

2013 2718257 1751631 966626 34056067 284 17

2012 2199465 1397690 801775 28562780 281 168

2011 1515481 859182 656299 24271337 270 168

2010 1163802 663353 500449 18064787 277 --

2009 1083549 714927 368622 14772206 250 --

2008 700532 441996 258536 10957784 236 --

Mean

284

Graph No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

301320

308 312

284 281270 277

250236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

399 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 05 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of Axis Bank was

284 Higher was 320 in the year 2016 and lower was 236 in 2008 It means the NIM of

Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 it also resulted in ROA of

the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 172 and in 2017 it became 065 It has been

observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211)

KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Table No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1769893 957278 812615 21458996 379 173

2016 1638418 948381 690037 19225979 359 119

2015 971987 549613 422374 10601208 398 198

2014 876712 504707 372005 8758534 425 18

2013 804249 483682 320567 8369368 383 181

2012 618024 366775 251249 6566679 383 183

2011 418975 209218 209757 5085067 412 177

2010 325562 139748 185814 3743631 496 --

2009 306514 154660 151854 2871188 529 --

2008 253536 130956 122580 2831236 433 --

Mean

420

Graph No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

379 359398

425383 383

412

496529

433

000

100

200

300

400

500

600

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 9: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

396 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 03 showing that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of India was 300

highest was 382 in the year 2009 and lowest was 252 in the years 2015 amp 2016 It‟s has

been seen that the NIM of the Bank of India in the year 2017 has increased (297) It has been

observed that the Borrowings of the Bank of India were increased 513 as compared to last

year (2016) and NPA has also decreased from 779 to 690

BANK OF BARODA

Table No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4219993 2868652 1351341 69487541 194 02

2016 4406128 3132143 1273985 67137648 190 -078

2015 4296356 2977632 1318724 71498855 184 049

2014 3893971 2697436 1196535 65950453 181 075

2013 3519665 2388139 1131526 54713544 207 09

2012 2967372 1935671 1031701 44732146 231 124

2011 2188592 1308366 880226 35839718 246 133

2010 1669834 1075886 593948 27831671 213 --

2009 1509158 996817 512341 22740673 225 --

2008 1181348 790167 391181 17959950 218 --

Mean

209

Graph No 04- NIM Bank of Baroda

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

397 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the Table No 04 it has been observed that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of

Baroda was 209 higher was 246 in the year 2011 and lower was 181 in the year 2014 It

can also be observed that NIM was decreasing 2012 to 2014 but it also has increasing since

2015 to 2017 Because NPA have been decreased from 506 (2016) to 472 in 2017 And it‟s

resulted on ROA of the Bank of Baroda ROA of the Bank of Baroda in the year 2016 was -

078 and it has become 020 in the year 2017

194 190 184 181

207

231246

213225 218

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

398 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS-

AXIS BANK

Table No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4454216 2644904 1809312 60146766 301 065

2016 4098804 2415507 1683297 52546761 320 172

2015 3547860 2125446 1422414 46193239 308 183

2014 3064116 1868952 1195164 38324489 312 178

2013 2718257 1751631 966626 34056067 284 17

2012 2199465 1397690 801775 28562780 281 168

2011 1515481 859182 656299 24271337 270 168

2010 1163802 663353 500449 18064787 277 --

2009 1083549 714927 368622 14772206 250 --

2008 700532 441996 258536 10957784 236 --

Mean

284

Graph No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

301320

308 312

284 281270 277

250236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

399 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 05 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of Axis Bank was

284 Higher was 320 in the year 2016 and lower was 236 in 2008 It means the NIM of

Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 it also resulted in ROA of

the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 172 and in 2017 it became 065 It has been

observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211)

KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Table No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1769893 957278 812615 21458996 379 173

2016 1638418 948381 690037 19225979 359 119

2015 971987 549613 422374 10601208 398 198

2014 876712 504707 372005 8758534 425 18

2013 804249 483682 320567 8369368 383 181

2012 618024 366775 251249 6566679 383 183

2011 418975 209218 209757 5085067 412 177

2010 325562 139748 185814 3743631 496 --

2009 306514 154660 151854 2871188 529 --

2008 253536 130956 122580 2831236 433 --

Mean

420

Graph No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

379 359398

425383 383

412

496529

433

000

100

200

300

400

500

600

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 10: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

397 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the Table No 04 it has been observed that the average Net Interest Margin of the Bank of

Baroda was 209 higher was 246 in the year 2011 and lower was 181 in the year 2014 It

can also be observed that NIM was decreasing 2012 to 2014 but it also has increasing since

2015 to 2017 Because NPA have been decreased from 506 (2016) to 472 in 2017 And it‟s

resulted on ROA of the Bank of Baroda ROA of the Bank of Baroda in the year 2016 was -

078 and it has become 020 in the year 2017

194 190 184 181

207

231246

213225 218

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

398 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS-

AXIS BANK

Table No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4454216 2644904 1809312 60146766 301 065

2016 4098804 2415507 1683297 52546761 320 172

2015 3547860 2125446 1422414 46193239 308 183

2014 3064116 1868952 1195164 38324489 312 178

2013 2718257 1751631 966626 34056067 284 17

2012 2199465 1397690 801775 28562780 281 168

2011 1515481 859182 656299 24271337 270 168

2010 1163802 663353 500449 18064787 277 --

2009 1083549 714927 368622 14772206 250 --

2008 700532 441996 258536 10957784 236 --

Mean

284

Graph No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

301320

308 312

284 281270 277

250236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

399 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 05 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of Axis Bank was

284 Higher was 320 in the year 2016 and lower was 236 in 2008 It means the NIM of

Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 it also resulted in ROA of

the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 172 and in 2017 it became 065 It has been

observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211)

KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Table No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1769893 957278 812615 21458996 379 173

2016 1638418 948381 690037 19225979 359 119

2015 971987 549613 422374 10601208 398 198

2014 876712 504707 372005 8758534 425 18

2013 804249 483682 320567 8369368 383 181

2012 618024 366775 251249 6566679 383 183

2011 418975 209218 209757 5085067 412 177

2010 325562 139748 185814 3743631 496 --

2009 306514 154660 151854 2871188 529 --

2008 253536 130956 122580 2831236 433 --

Mean

420

Graph No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

379 359398

425383 383

412

496529

433

000

100

200

300

400

500

600

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 11: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

398 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS-

AXIS BANK

Table No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 4454216 2644904 1809312 60146766 301 065

2016 4098804 2415507 1683297 52546761 320 172

2015 3547860 2125446 1422414 46193239 308 183

2014 3064116 1868952 1195164 38324489 312 178

2013 2718257 1751631 966626 34056067 284 17

2012 2199465 1397690 801775 28562780 281 168

2011 1515481 859182 656299 24271337 270 168

2010 1163802 663353 500449 18064787 277 --

2009 1083549 714927 368622 14772206 250 --

2008 700532 441996 258536 10957784 236 --

Mean

284

Graph No 05- NIM AXIS BANK

301320

308 312

284 281270 277

250236

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

399 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 05 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of Axis Bank was

284 Higher was 320 in the year 2016 and lower was 236 in 2008 It means the NIM of

Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 it also resulted in ROA of

the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 172 and in 2017 it became 065 It has been

observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211)

KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Table No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1769893 957278 812615 21458996 379 173

2016 1638418 948381 690037 19225979 359 119

2015 971987 549613 422374 10601208 398 198

2014 876712 504707 372005 8758534 425 18

2013 804249 483682 320567 8369368 383 181

2012 618024 366775 251249 6566679 383 183

2011 418975 209218 209757 5085067 412 177

2010 325562 139748 185814 3743631 496 --

2009 306514 154660 151854 2871188 529 --

2008 253536 130956 122580 2831236 433 --

Mean

420

Graph No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

379 359398

425383 383

412

496529

433

000

100

200

300

400

500

600

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 12: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

399 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 05 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of Axis Bank was

284 Higher was 320 in the year 2016 and lower was 236 in 2008 It means the NIM of

Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 it also resulted in ROA of

the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 172 and in 2017 it became 065 It has been

observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211)

KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Table No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 1769893 957278 812615 21458996 379 173

2016 1638418 948381 690037 19225979 359 119

2015 971987 549613 422374 10601208 398 198

2014 876712 504707 372005 8758534 425 18

2013 804249 483682 320567 8369368 383 181

2012 618024 366775 251249 6566679 383 183

2011 418975 209218 209757 5085067 412 177

2010 325562 139748 185814 3743631 496 --

2009 306514 154660 151854 2871188 529 --

2008 253536 130956 122580 2831236 433 --

Mean

420

Graph No 06- NIM KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK

379 359398

425383 383

412

496529

433

000

100

200

300

400

500

600

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 13: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

400 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

Table No 06 shows that the average Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra Bank was 420

maximum was 529 in the year 2009 and minimum was 359 in the year 2016 It has been

seen that the NIM of bank has fluctuating throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due

to increased in Interest Income by 771 in the same year

HDFC BANK

Table No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

Year Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 6930596 3616673 3313923 86384020 384 188

2016 6022145 3262993 2759152 70884557 389 192

2015 4846990 2607424 2239566 59050307 379 2

2014 4113553 2265290 1848263 49159950 376 2

2013 3506487 1925375 1581112 40033190 395 19

2012 2728635 1498958 1229677 33790949 364 18

2011 1992821 938508 1054313 27735261 380 16

2010 1617290 778630 838660 22245856 377 --

2009 1633226 891110 742116 18327078 405 --

2008 1011500 488712 522788 13317660 393 --

Mean

384

Graph No 07- NIM HDFC BANK

384389

379376

395

364

380377

405

393

340

350

360

370

380

390

400

410

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 14: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

401 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

The Table No 07 depicts that the average NIM of HDFC Bank was 384 maximum was

405 in the year 2009 and minimum was 364 in the year 2012 The low margin is affected

by increasing in deposits However researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over

the last five years

ICICI BANK

Table No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

Year

Interest

Income

Interest

Expenses

Net Interest

Income Total Assets

NIM

ROA

2017 5415628 3241896 2173732 76874932 283 11

2016 5273943 3151539 2122404 71787763 296 149

2015 4909114 3005153 1903961 64612929 295 186

2014 4417815 2770259 1647556 59464160 277 178

2013 4007560 2620918 1386642 53679469 258 17

2012 3354265 2280850 1073415 47364709 227 15

2011 2597405 1695715 901690 40623367 222 135

2010 2570693 1759257 811436 36339971 223 --

2009 3109255 2272593 836662 37930096 221 --

2008 3078834 2348424 730410 39979507 183 --

Mean

248

Graph No 08- NIM ICICI BANK

283296 295

277258

227 222 223 221

183

000

050

100

150

200

250

300

350

2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 15: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

402 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Interpretation

From the table No 08 it has been seen that the average Net Interest Margin of ICICI Bank was

248 Higher was 296 in the year 2016 and lower was 183 in 2008 It has been seen that

the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s declined by 283 due to

increased in NPA The NPA of the Bank was 267 in the year 2016 but it increased in 2017 by

489 It‟s also resulted in ROA of the bank The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 16: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

403 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

FINDINGS

PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS

The NPA of the State Bank of India has been decreasing since 2013 and it‟s affected on

NIM for same period Deposits are rapidly increasing as compare to borrowings

Borrowings of Bank of Maharashtra are 178 times lower than deposits hence it resulted

into Lower NIM ie 201 The NPA of the Bank in the year 2017 was 1176 This means that

about 1176 of loans are never paid back resulting in substantial loss of money to the banks

The Net Interest Income of the Bank of India has increased in the year 2017 ie 297

Because in this year NPA has decreased from 779 to 690 and borrowing are increased up to

513

Bank of Baroda has increasing trend of the NIM since 2014 And the NPA of the Bank is

decreasing since 2013 It means the performance of Bank of Baroda is being very well

PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS

The NIM of Axis bank has increased till 2016 but in 2017 it‟s declined by 301 It has

been observed that the NPA of Axis Bank has increased in 2017 (070 to 211) and resulted on

ROA too The ROA of the Axis Bank was 172 in the year 2016 and in 2017 it became 065

It has been seen that the Net Interest Margin of Kotak Mahindra bank is fluctuating

throughout the years NIM has increased in 2017 due to increased in Interest Income by 771

The low margin of HDFC Bank is affected by increasing in deposits However

researcher has also seen decreased spread on Loan rates over the last five years

It has been seen that the increasing trend of NIM of ICICI bank till 2016 in 2017 it‟s

declined by 283 due to increased in NPA The ROA in the year 2016 was 149 and in 2017

it became 110 due to increased in NPA

CONCLUSION

The study observed that variables such as size NPA cost (in) efficiency deposit concentration

and economic growth are important in determining the banks‟ behavior regarding their interest

margin In this research researcher has attempted to measure NIM to find out profitability

performance of 4 Indian public Banks ie State Bank of India Bank of Maharashtra Bank of

India and Bank of Baroda At the end it is concluded the NIM made by calculating Interest

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 17: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

404 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Income and Interest Expenses for 8 Indian Public amp Private sector Banks and result portrays that

Private sector Banks (ICICI and Axis Bank) having better NIM rather than Bank of Maharashtra

and State Bank of India

REFERENCES

Tushar B Das (2013) ldquoNet Interest Margin Financial Crisis and Bank Behavior

Experience of Indian Banksrdquo Department of Economic and Policy Research November 2013

Sami Ben Naceur amp Mohamed Goaied (2016) ldquoThe Determinants of Commercial Bank

Interest Margin and Profitabilityrdquo Published in Frontiers in Finance and Economics Vol 5 No

1 106-130

Meshesha Demie Jima (2017) ldquoDeterminants of Net Interest Margin in the Ethiopian

Banking Industryrdquo Published in Journal of Finance and Economics 2017 Vol 5 No 3 96-104

G Hanweck (lrm2005) ldquoThe Sensitivity of Bank Net Interest Margins and Profitability to

Credit Interest-Rate and Term-Structure Shocks across Bank Product Specializationsrdquo

Published in Professor of Finance School of Management George Mason University

Nilesh Vitthal Limbore (2014) ldquoStudy of banking sector in India and overview of

performance of Indian banks with reference to net interest margin and market capitalization of

banksrdquo (ISSN No 2249-894X)

ANNUAL REPORTS

State Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Maharashtra Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of India Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Bank of Baroda Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Axis Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

Kotak Mahindra Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

HDFC Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ICICI Bank Annual Reports (2008-2017)

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532

Page 18: COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NET INTEREST MARGIN (NIM) OF … doc/2019/IJMIE_JUNE2019/IJMRA-15767.pdf* Associate Professor,ZES’s Zeal Institute of Business Administration, ... financial

ISSN 2249-0558Impact Factor 7119

405 International journal of Management IT and Engineering

httpwwwijmraus Email editorijmiegmailcom

Wibliography

httpswwwmoneycontrolcom

httpswwwshodhgangainflibnetacin

httpsefinancemanagementcom

httpswwwresearchgatenetpublication273676328

httpswwwrbiorginscriptsPublicationsViewaspxid=15418

httppubssciepubcomjfe532