Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF TENDER FOR LAB REAGENTS FOR FY 2019-20
Reagents Required for Automatic Chemistry Analyzer
Participation Detail
Sr # Name of Reagent AM Healthcare ALI TRADERS Remarks
1. Blood sugar 6150/Pack
6.15/ml
3990/Pack
3.99/ml
2. Blood Urea 11240/Pack
18.13/ml
9450/Pack
18.9/ml
3. Creatinine 13110/Pack
13.11/ml
8550/Pack
14.25/ml
4. Uric Acid 12648/Pack
21.08/ml
10920/Pack
21.84/ml
5. Calcium 6975/Pack
27.90/ml
8424/Pack
28.08/ml
6. Albumin 20800/Pack
20.80/ml
6500/Pack
21.67/ml
7. Total Protein 18960/Pack
18.96/ml
5900/Pack
19.67/ml
8. SGPT 11300/Pack
22.60/ml
11794/Pack
23.58/ml
9. SGOT 11660/Pack
23.32/ml
11794/Pack
23.58/ml
10. Alk.phosphatase 5823/Pack
23.29/ml
8500/Pack
17/ml
11. Serum Bilirubin Total 12715/Pack
25.43/ml
6720/Pack
26.88/ml
12. Total Cholesterol 12588/Pack
20.98/ml
10600/Pack
21.2/ml
13. Triglysride 19080/Pack
31.80/ml
16263/Pack
32.52/ml
14. HDL Cholesterol 23453/Pack
209.41/ml
21756/Pack
217.56/ml
15. LDL Cholesterol 43452/Pack
383.97/ml
39000/Pack
390/ml
16. Chemistry Control Contral Normal
38521/50ml +
Control Abnormal
41650/50ml
=80171
770.42+833=1603.41/2ml
Contral Normal
15500/30ml +
Control Abnormal 14300/30ml
=80171
477+517=994/2ml
Note: M/S AM Healthcare is lowest in overall tender of Automatic Chemistry Analyser due to lowest in 13 items out of 16 items
Reagents Required for Semi- Automatic Chemistry Analyzer
Sr # Name of Reagents Three Stars Mian Scientific
Corporation (Pvt) Ltd
ALPHA SYNTEFIC STORE ALI TRADERS Remarks
1. Blood Sugar Kit Technically Non
Responsive
1.53/ml
1530/pack/1000ml
Disqualified due to
mismatching of brands of
all quoted items for semi
automatic chemicstry
analyzer in technical and
financial bids
3.99/ml
2. Blood Urea colouri method 4414/pack/1000ml
4.4/ml
8.08/ml
1940/pack of 2x120ml
18.9/ml
3. Serum Creatanine 2490/pack/1000ml
2.49/ml
2.63/ml
2630/pack/4x250ml
14.25/ml
4. Serum Bilirubin Total & Direct 2940/pack/1050ml
3.75/ml
4.68/ml
1500/pack/320ml
26.88/ml
5. Uric Acid Technically Non
Responsive
6.48/ml
6480/pack/10x100ml
21.84/ml
6. Cholesterol Total
400 ml -500 ml
8400/pack/1000ml
8.40/ml
5.50/ml
6500/pack/10x100ml
21.2/ml
7. Triglyceride
200 ml -500 ml
4940/pack/300ml
16.47/ml
16.25/ml
6500/pack/4x100ml
32.52/ml
8. HDL Cholesterol (Direct Method)
200 ml- 400 ml
NQ Technically Disqualify 217.56/ml
21756/pack/5x20ml
9. LDL Cholestrol (Direct Method)
200 ml- 400 ml
Rejected due to
absence of clear
specification i.e
(Direct Method)
NQ NQ 390/ml
3900/pack/100ml
10. Total Protein 2490/pack/1000ml
2.49/ml
6.12/ml
1530/pack/250ml
NQ 19.67/ml
11. Serum Albumin 2490/pack/1000ml
2.49/ml
6.16ml
1540/pack/250ml
NQ 21.67/ml
12. SGPT 8400/pack/1000ml
8.40/ml
Technically Disqualify NQ 23.58/ml
13. SGOT 8400/pack/1000ml
8.40/ml
Technically Disqualify NQ 23.58/ml
14. Alkaline Phosphate 8400/pack/1000ml
8.40/ml
6.125/ml
4900/pack/8x100ml
NQ 17/ml
15. CPK Technically Non
Responsive due to
misreprestation of
facts i.e (Brand
Difference in Tech
and Finan Bids)
NQ NQ
16. CK-MB Technically Non
Responsive due to
misreprestation of
facts i.e (Brand
Difference in Tech
and Finan Bids)
NQ NQ 128.53/ml
19280/pack/10x15ml
17. LDH Technically Non
Responsive due to
NQ NQ
misreprestation of
facts i.e (Brand
Difference in Tech
and Finan Bids)
18. Serum Phosphorous NQ NQ NQ
19. Serum Magnesium NQ NQ NQ
20. Serum Amylase Technically Non
Responsive due to
misreprestation of
facts i.e (Brand
Difference in Tech
and Finan Bids)
Technically Disqualify NQ 256.503/ml
15390/pack/12x15ml
Reagent without equipment
Item # Items Name
Unit
for
rate
quota
tion
Mian Scient
ific
Gulf marke
ting
Moon Enterprises
Fast tech
ALPHA SCIENTIFIC STORE
ALI TRADERS
JS Enterprises
Three Star
Diagnostic Medical Associate
Al Nusrat Enterprises
1. Hcv (Rapid
test) 4mm
or above
1
device
32.50/device
27/device
20.93/device
29.30/Devic
e
1127/pack/40dev
ice 28.18/Devic
e
2. Hbs Ag
(Rapid test)
4mm or
above
1
device
18.90/device
17/device
12.23/device
14.15/Devic
e
594/pack/40devic
e 14.85/Devic
e
3. Pregnancy
Device
1
device
5.5/device
4.98/device
7/Device
724/pack/100dev
ices 7.24/device
4. Urine
Complete
Sticks
(100stips/B
ottle)
1
bottle
625/100 strip
800/pack/100 strips8/strip
NQ Rejected
due to two
rates quotation Rs.
1848 Rs. 999
620/bottle/100str
ips 6.2/st
rip
764/bottle/100sti
ps 7.64/s
tips
5. Antisera
ABO
1 Set 635/set
1296/set
782/set
6. Widal Test
TO,TH
(5ml/Bottle
)
1 Set 500/10 ml
529/10ml
52.9/ml
700/set/10
ml
850/10ml
7. RA Factor 1 Test 1750/150 test 11.67 test
1350/Kit/100test 13.5/t
est
1745/kit/100test
17.45/test
1950/Kit
19.50/test
11.50/test
1150/pack/100te
st
21/test
2100/pack/
100test
8. ASO Titer 1ml 1650/100te
st 16.5/t
est
1350/Kit/100test 13.5/t
est
2035/kit/100test
20.35/test
1950/Kit
19.50/test
11.50/test
1150/pack/100te
st
30/test
3000/100te
st
9. Giemsa
Stain
Solution
1 ml NQ 1.81/ml
950/pack/500ml
2.10/ml
1050/pack/500ml
10. Crystal
Violet Stain
Solution
1 ml NQ 1.62/ml
810/pacl/50
0ml
1.48/ml
740/pack/500ml
11. Safranin
Stain
Solution
1 ml NQ Rejected
Due to
1.48/ml
740/pack/5
Contradicto
ry rates
of pack and ml
00ml
12. Gram
Iodine
Solution
1 ml NQ 585/pack/500ml 1.17/
ml
1.48/ml
740/pack/500ml
13. Decolurizer
(Gram Stain
Solution)
1 ml NQ 540/pack/500ml 1.08/
ml
1.45/ml
724/pack/500ml
14. Haemo
toxcycline
Stain
Solution
1 ml NQ 2590/pack/500ml 5.18/
ml
8.50/ml
4250/pack/500ml
15. Eiosin Stain
Solution
1 ml NQ 875/pack/500ml 1.75/
ml
2.05/ml
1024/pack/500ml
16. Ethanol
Methanol
1 ml NQ NQ
17. ESR
solution
1 ml NQ Rejected
due to absence of pack
size of rate Rs.
450 = Qty ??
195/pack/500ml 0.39/
ml
0.49/ml
244/pack/500ml
18. Glass Slide 1 pkt
of 72
1.7/pc
85/pack/50
113/pack/72pc
1.72/pc
124/p
1.72/Pc
124/p
piece pc 1.57/pc
ack/72 pc
ack/72 pc
19. Cover Slip 1 pkt
of 100
piece
133/pack/200pc
0.565/pc
195/200pc
0.975/pc
0.54/pc
108/200pc
20. ESR Pipette
(disposable
)
1 NO NQ 49/pc 42/pc
21. HIV Rapid
Test (4mm)
01
Devic
e
35/device
28/device
29.83/device
30.70/Devic
e
28.18/device 1127/pack/40dev
ices
22. Blue Tips
100- 1000
UL
1 pkt
of 500
235/packet of 500 0.47/p
c
197/pack/500pc
0.39/pc
0.49/pc
244/pack/500pc
23. Yellow Tips
5 - 200 UL
1 pkt
of
1000
tips
184/pack/1000pc 0.184/
pc
193/pack/1000pc 0.19/p
c
0.19/pc
194/pack/1000pc
24. CBC
Vaccum
Vial
1 vial
of 3ml
5.95/vial
4.97/vial
6.70/vial
5.34/vial
25. Dengue
Rapid Test
IGg ,IGM
1
Devic
e
185/device
200/device/ 25pack/500
0
133/device
194/device 7760/pack/40dev
ices
26. White tips
5-10ul
1 pkt
of
1000
345/pack/1
000pc
0.345/pc
NQ 635/1000pc 0.635/
pc
0.95/pc
950/pack/1000pc
27. Urine
Container
Disposable
Non
sterilized
1
pices
of
100ml
9.91/pc
6.75/pc
12/pc 595/10opc
5.95/pc
6.74/pc
674/pack/100pc
28. Test Tubes
Disposable
1x4cm
1 pkt
of 500
piece
1.53/pc
1050/Pack/500pc 2.1/pc
1.51/pc
757/pack/500pc
29. Test Tubes
Disposable
centrifuge
type of 10
ml
1 pkt
of 250
piece
3.43/pc
5.5/pc 550/pack/100pc
30. Syringe
Stopper
1 pkts
of
1000
piece
275/pack/1000
0.275/pc
1050/Pack/1000p
c 1.05/p
c
0.89/pc
890/pack/1000pc
31. Calcium
Chloride
Solution
500 ml
1 ml NQ 595/pack/500ml 1.19/
ml
1.45/ml
724/pack/500ml
32. PT Vials 1 vial
of 2ml
5.95/vial 4.97/vial
6.70/vial
5.34/vial
33. Blood
Lancet 2 x 3
mm
1 pkts
of 200
piece
125/pack/1
00pc
1.25/pc
139/pack/200pc
0.695/pc
425/pack/200pc
2.13/pc
255/200pc
1.27/pc
0.83/pc
166/pack/200pc
34. Serum
Capsule
1 pkts
of
1000
NQ
35. Serum cup 1pkt
of 100
2.50/pc 1/pc 0.65/pc
324/pack/500pc
36. H.pylori
device 4
mm
1
Devic
e
59/device
50/device
49.73/device
49/Device
49.75/device
37. VDRL
device 4
mm
1
device
29/device
22/device/25pack/550
27.93/device
28.35/Devic
e
28.18/device
38. T-B Test
device 4
mm
1
device
69/device
60/device/25test/pack/1500
49.73/device
55/Device
50.6/device
39. Typhidot
device
4mm
1
Devic
e
69/device
54/device/pack/25device/135
0
58.73/device
58/Device
50.60/device
40. Electrolyte
(pro lite cell
pack)
1
bottle
of
800ml
Not as per required specification
NQ NQ
41. Blood gas
analyzer (
optimedical
– opti CCA-
TS)
Test
Devic
e (25
test/ki
t )
NQ Not as per
required
specification
NQ
42. Opti
medical –
opti CCA-
TS
Cyclinder
1
Piece
NQ NQ
43. HCV PCR
Qualitative
Kit of
96
tests
NQ NQ
44. HCV PCR
Quantities
Kit of
96
tests
NQ NQ
45. TLC
solution
1
bottle
of
500ml
NQ 285/500ml 0.57/
ml
1.08/ml
540/pack/500ml
46. Distilled
water
1 pkt
of 5
litr
NQ 0.04/ml
190/pack/5l
tr
47. ABG vial 1 vial NQ NQ
48. Dangi Rapid
Test NS1
Devic
e
235/device
220/device/pack/25test/5500
173/device
424/device
49. Gel Vial 1 vial
of 3ml
8.20/vial 6.98/vial
10.50/vial
8.24/vial
50. HAV (IgM –
IgG)
01
Devic
es
225/device NQ 210/device
NQ
51. HBS Elisa
Ag
Test 3500/pack/
96test
36.45/test
3275/pack/96test 34.11/
test
3500/pack/96test 36.45/
test
NQ
52. HIV Elisa Test 5900/96tes
t
61.45/test
8375/pack/96test 87.24/
test
4500/pack/
96 46.87/
test
NQ
53. HCV Elisa Test 4800/96tes
t
50/test
5235/pack/96test 54.53/test
4000/pack/
96 41.66/
test
NQ
54. Dengue
Elisa Kit IGg
Test 28500/96te
st
296.88/test
NQ 35000/Kit/96test
364.6/test
NQ
55. Dengue
Elisa Kit
IGm
Test 28500/96te
st
296.88/test
NQ Rejected
due to absence of clear
specification
i.e (IGG
or Igm)
NQ
56. Dengue
NS1 (Elisa
Kit)
Test 36500/96te
st
380.2/test
NQ 60000/kit/96test 625/t
est
NQ
57. PTT Manual
Method
1ml 3220/8x6m
l
67.08/ml
NQ 402.3/ml
12069/kit/150test/30ml
Rejected
Due to
Contradicto
ry rates
of pack and ml
Rejected
due to contradictor
y rates of ml and pack size
95/ml
58. APTT
Manual
Method
1ml 151.3/ml
5150/pack/
6x6ml
NQ 1015.25/ml 12183/kit/120test/12ml
Rejected
Due to
Contradicto
ry rates
of pack and ml
Rejected
due to contradictor
y rates of ml and pack size
147/ml
Reagents for the Equipment of Lab (Closed Reagents)
Item # Items Name JS Enterprises
Ali Traders ALPHA SCIENTIFIC
STORE
Three Star Diagnostic Medical Associates
1. Cell Pack (Haemotology abcus 380) NQ NQ Technically Non
Responsive
NQ 10,000/20L
2. Lyse (Haemotology Analyze abcus 380) 10,500/1Ltr
3. Cleaner (Haemotology abcus 380) NQ 4500/1 Ltr
4. Cell Pack (Haemotology medonic) NQ Boule Sweden (Medonic
Swelab Alfa Medicine)
QUOTED BUT DO
NOT HAVE
AUTHRIZATION
CERTIFACTE
Merck QUOTED BUT DO NOT HAVE AUTHRIZATION CERTIFACTE
NQ
5. Lyse (Haemotology Analyze medonic) NQ
6. T 3 Veda Lab device Vedalab France
-Do not have experience and distribution letter
NQ NQ NQ NQ
7. T 4 Veda Lab device NQ NQ NQ NQ
8. TSH Veda Lab device (20 test/ kit) NQ NQ NQ NQ
Note:
Equipment on Reagent Rental Basis
Electrolyte:
Sr # Test Name Gulf marketing Fast Tech GLS GHRASA
LABARTAROY
SUPPLIES
Saarf Medical Solution
1. Sodium Na 35.68/test
1000ml pack
size/35000
Technically
Disqualify due
to country of
origin
31.9/test
31900/pack
40/test
Technically Disqualified due to
Convergent Technologies , Convergys-ISE Comfort Mo5, Germany
(No Experience Certificate and Authorization Certificate Attached)
2. Potasium K
3. Chloride Cl
4. Calcium Ca ion
Hematology Analyzer:
Sr# Test Name Gulf Marketing Fast Tech GLS GHRASA LABARTAROY
SUPPLIES
Diagostic
Medical
Associate
Saarf Medical
Solutions
Mian Scientific
1. CBC M/S Gulf
Marketing is
Rejected due to
ambiguous rates
33/test 25.63 32/test
Technically
M/S Mian Scientific has violated
the T&C of bidding documents
disqualified
because it does
not have
experience in
quoted model.
and not as per
specified in the
bid i.e (per test
rate)
Disqualified due
to
Convergent
Technologies ,
Convergys-ISE
Comfort Mo5,
Germany
(No Experience
Certificate and
Authorization
Certificate
Attached)
regarding the country of origin of
equipment
ABG
Sr# Test Name Fast Tech
1. pH Rejected due to ambiguous rates and not as per specified in the bid i.e (per test rate)
2. pCO2 Rejected due to ambiguous rates and not as per specified in the bid i.e (per test rate)
3. pO2 Rejected due to ambiguous rates and not as per specified in the bid i.e (per test rate)
Hormone
Sr# Test Name Gulf Marketing Diagnostic Medical Associate Mian Scientific
1. T-3 M/S Gulf Marketing
has violated the T&C of
bidding documents
regarding the country
of origin of equipment
Disqulified because violated the
T&C of tender i.e. T3,T4,TSH but
qouted Free T3, Free T4, Free TSH
M/S Mian Scientific has violated the T&C of
bidding documents regarding the country of
origin of equipment.
2. T-4
3. TSH
PTT
Sr# Test Name ALPHA SCIENTIFIC
STORE
Fast Tech GLS GHRASA LABARTAROY
SUPPLIES
Diagnostic Medical
Associate
Al-Nusrat Enterprises
1. PTT Kits Technically Non Responsive
Rejected due to
ambiguous rates
and not as per
specified in the bid
i.e (per test rate)
49/test 36/test M/S Al-Nusrat Enterperises are technically non responsive because
it has no experience in the said equipment
2. APTT Kits Technically Non Responsive
Rejected due to
ambiguous rates
and not as per
specified in the bid
i.e (per test rate)
55/test 22.50/test
Trop-1
Sr# Test Name ALPHA SCEINTFIC STORE JS Enterprises Mian Scientific Corporation
1. Qualitative Technically Non Responsive
JS Enterprises is
technically disqualify as it
does not quoted in Trop-I
qualitative.
M/S Mian Scientific has violated the T&C of bidding documents
regarding the country of origin of equipment.
2. Quantitative
HbA1C
Sr # Test Name Gulf Marketing ALPHA SCEINTFIC STORE GLS GHRASA LABARTAROY SUPPLIES Ali Traders Mian Scientific
Corporation
1. HbA1C Technically Non Responsive
240/test M/S Mian Scientific
has violated the T&C
of bidding
documents
regarding the
country of origin of
equipment.
Results of Technical Evaluation:
1. Automatic Chemistry Analyzer
a. M/S Gulf Marketing is technically non-responsive because:
It has quoted regents with equipment and the equipment is Chinese equipment
The brand of reagents are not mentioned in technical bid
The control & Calibration of offered equipment is different with the hospital equipment that can vary results.
b. M/S Alpha Scientific Store is technically non responsive because:
It has offered an unknown brand i.e. MTD
It has non Govt institution references
The offered regents has no reference and experience on Automatic Chemistry Analyser Selectra Pro M (Elitech Group)
It has not quoted items # 15 and 16.
It has quoted only PT/APTT Control instead of chemistry analyzer control.
c. M/S GLS is technically non responsive because:
No reference is available
The offered regents has no reference and experience on Automatic Chemistry Analyser Selectra Pro M (Elitech Group)
The firm has quoted regents with equipment which is voilating the terms and conditions
d. M/S Diatron Diagnostic
It has offered with equipment
The brand of regents are not mentioned in technical bid
The offered regents has no reference and experience on Automatic Chemistry Analyser Selectra Pro M (Elitech Group)
The firm has quoted regents with equipment which is voilating the terms and conditions
e. M/S AM Healthcare and M/S Ali Traders are declared as responsive.
2. Semi- Automatic Chemistry Analyzer
a. M/S Three Star is disqualified in item #1,5 because no reference of SBIO is attached.
b. M/S Mian Scientific is disqualified in item # 8, 12,13 and 20 because no reference of ERBA is attached
c. M/S Gulf Marketing is disqualified has no reference of PZ CORMY Poland.
d. M/S Ali Traders and M/S Alpha Scientific Store are declared technically qualify.
3. Regents without equipment
All the participants are declared technically responsive.
4. Regents for the equipment of lab (Close Reagents)
a. Hematology Analyser (Abacus 380)
M/S Diagnostic Medical Associate declared responsive.
M/S Alpha Scientific Store is declared non responsive because it does not have authorization certificate.
b. Hematology Analyser (Medonic)
M/S Ali Traders declared responsive.
M/S Alpha Scientific Store and M/S Three Star do not have authorization certificate, therefore, it is declared as non responsive.
c. Veda Lab device
M/S JS is declared non responsive because it does not have distribution and experience.
5. Equipments on Regent Rental Basis.
a. Electrolyte Analyzer
M/S Fast Tech is disqualified as it has violated the T&C of tender on country of origin of equipment
M/S Saarf Medical Solution is disqualified because it has no experience and authorization certificate.
M/S Gulf Marketing, M/S Ali Traders and M/S GLS Gharasa Laboratory are technically qualified.
b. Hematology Analyzer
M/S Saarf Medical Solutions is is disqualified because it does not have authorization certificate and experience letter.
M/S Mian Scientific has violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipment
M/S Gulf Marketing is disqualified because it does not have experience in quoted model.
M/S Fast Tech, M/S Gharasa Libratory, M/S Ali traders and M/S Diagnostic Medical Associate are technically qualified.
c. ABG
All the participants for ABG Analyzer are technically qualifies.
d. Hormone
M/S Gulf Marketing has violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipment
M/S Mian Scientific has violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipment.
M/S Ali Traders and M/S DMA is technically responsive.
e. PTT/APTT
M/S Alpha Scientific has violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipment
M/S Fast Tech is technically disqualify because it does not quoted APTT Kits
M/S Al-Nusrat Enterperises are technically non responsive because it has no experience in the said equipment.
M/S DMA and M/S GLS are technically responsive.
f. Trop-I
M/S Alpha Scientific is violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipment and do not quoted
in Trop-I Qualitative.
M/S Gulf Marketing is violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipmen and do not quoted
in Trop-I qualitative.
JS Enterprises is technically disqualify as it does not quoted in Trop-I qualitative.
M/S Mian Scientific has violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipment.
M/S Ali Traders has violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipment.
No Bidder is technically qualify in Trop-I
g. HBA1C
M/S Gulf Marketing has violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipment
M/S Alpha Scientific has violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipment
M/S Mian Scientific has violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipment.
M/S Ali Trader has violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipment.
M/S GLS has violated the T&C of bidding documents regarding the country of origin of equipment.
No Bidder is technically qualified in HBA1C.
Representative from Principal, NSMC, Gujrat
(Member)
Dr.Abid Mehmood Malik Additional Medical Superintendent
(Purchase) ABSTH, Gujrat
(Member)
Dr.Bilal Ahmed Dar Additional Medical Superintendent (Admin II)
ABSTH, Gujrat (Member)
Mr.Azhar Majeed Budget and Accounts Officer
ABSTH, Gujrat (Member)
Engr.Muhammad Asim Raza Biomedical Engineer,
ABSTH, Gujrat (Member)
Dr. Maqsood Zahid ABSTH, Gujrat
(Member)
Dr. Asif Mehmood
ABSTH, Gujrat Member
Dr.Abid Mehmood Ghouri Medical Superintendent
ABSTH, Gujrat Chairman
