COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF TECHNICAL BIDS …hareda.gov.in/writereaddata/news/hareda168859908.pdf · sales) Completion ... M/s Jaquor & Company Pvt. Ltd, Gurugram. ... 130 W LED Street

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF TECHNICAL BIDS OF THE TENDER FOR ARRANGING THE RATE CONTRACT OF ENERGY EFFICIENT OUTDOOR LIGHTING OPENED ON 24.10.2017.

S. No.

Name of Bidder Company incorporation letter

Category

Make of LEDs used and

document for confirming Make of LED.

SMT Setup ( in-house/ tie up)

Equipments Annual Turnover ( In Lakhs) in last three years ending on 31.03.17

Net worth Experience ( in Lakhs) in last three years

Certificate of not debarred

Sr. number of item(s) quoted

Sample submitted with HAREDA for item(s)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

Requirement of the NIT To be

submitted

General/

Haryana SME ( for MSMEs, Haryana also required annexure in affidavit)

LM-80 Report Supporting

document To be Submitted

Supporting

document To be attached

900.00

Lakhs for General category & for Haryana MSMEs as per policy 2016 i.e. Micro Concession of 80% on Turnover Condition imposed as Qualifying Criteria Small Concession of 70% on Turnover

Condition imposed as Qualifying Criteria

Should be

positive ( Yes/No)

For General

Rs. 1200.00 Lakhs with purchase order & satisfactory completion report from purchasers. For Haryana MSMEs Exempted in respect of past performance & experience as part of qualifying

requirements of the tender subject to fulfillment of

conditions as per eligibility.

To be

submitted

To be

submitted

Required

to submit by due date & time of bid, otherwise bid out rightly rejected.

1. M/s Alien Energy Pvt. Limited, Delhi Submitted General Osram, LM-80 submitted

Not Submitted

Submitted 747.00 lakhs

Submitted Rs. 532.00 Lakhs Purchase

Submitted 1to6 Submitted for 1 to 6

S. No.


Category

Make of LEDs

used and document for confirming Make of LED.


Equipments Annual Turnover ( In Lakhs)

in last three years ending on 31.03.17

Net worth Experience ( in Lakhs) in last three

years


Sr. number of

item(s) quoted

Sample submitted with

HAREDA for item(s)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

2. M/s Atlas Industries, Sonepat Not submitted

Haryana SME (micro)

Unfilled annexure of affidavit Submitted

Seoul LM-80 not submitted

Tie up with Powerlite Submitted

Submitted 133.10 Lakhs

Not submitted

- Not submitted

1 to 3 Submitted 1 to 3

3. M/s Crompton Greaves Consumer

Electricals Limited, New Delhi.

Submitted General Osram

LM-80 submitted

Submitted Attached 3598.00

crores

submitted 3013.90

Lakhs Submitted 1825 lakhs EESL

Submitted 1to6 Submitted

for 1 to 6

4. M/s FIEM Industries Limited, Sonepat

Debarred / blacklisted by M/s Energy Efficiency Services Limited (a joint venture company of PSUs of Ministry of Power, Govt. of India vide no. EESL/03/2016-17/ NOTICE/0512020 dated 20th March, 2017 due to non-responsible practices / non-performance during execution of Delhi SDMC Street Light project.

5. M/s Glow Green Energy Limited, Shahibabad

Submitted General Osram and Seoul LM-80 submitted

Submitted Attached 806.18

submitted 1296.00 Lakhs ( purchase order & work completion document not submitted}

Submitted. 1to6 Submitted for 1 to 6

6. M/s Greenstar Research & Development Pvt. Ltd., Gurugram ISO certificate issued by Intertek for LED lighting valid up to 14.09.2018

Submitted Haryana SME (small), Annexture of affidavit

submitted

Osram LM-80 submitted

Submitted Attached 1226.00 Lakhs

Not submitted

707.05 Lakhs. Work completion report not

submitted


7. M/s Halonix Technologies Pvt Limited, Noida

Submitted General Nichia LM-80 Submitted

submitted tie up of Kamal lamps Limited, Haridwar

Attached 31184.00 Lakhs

submitted 5300.00 Lakhs ( LED product sales) Completion report not submitted


S. No.


Category

Make of LEDs






years


Sr. number of

item(s) quoted


HAREDA for item(s)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

8. M/s Hitech Lights Limited, Solan ( HP)

Submitted General Philips Lumileds LM80

submitted

submitted submitted 7156.92 Lakhs

submitted Not submitted

Submitted 1 to 3 Submitted 1 to 3

9. M/s HPL Electric & Power Pvt Limited, Sonepat

Submitted General Seoul LM 80 submitted

Attached Attached 11574.00 Lakhs

submitted 2458.00 EESL. Submitted 1to6 Submitted for 1 to 6

10. M/s INOT Power Technologies Pvt Limited, Vishakhapatnm ( AP)

Sample not submitted and as per DNIT, bid without sample liable to be out rightly rejected.

11. M/s Jaquor & Company Pvt. Ltd, Gurugram.

Submitted General Osram LM80 not submitted IEC attached

Submitted Submitted 128738.6 Lakhs

submitted 1569 Lakhs


12. M/s Joonix Energy Pvt. Ltd. , Faridabad ISO issued by BSCIL valid up to 4.10.2020 BSCIL

Submitted Haryana SME ( micro) Annexure attached.

Osram LM80 submitted

Submitted tie up with M/s Plasma Impex , Noida

Submitted 200.78 Lakha

submitted 90.00 Lakhs Submitted 1to6 Submitted for 1 to 6

13. M/s Mansa Solar Energy, Karnal ISO issued by BIC Limited valid up to 3.07.2020

Submitted Haryana SME (small) Annexure attached.




14. M/s Ojskar Vidyut I.I.P., Rewari Submitted Haryana SME ( micro)

Annexure attached.

Osram and Seoul LM80

submitted

Submitted tie up with M/s Glow

green


submitted - Submitted 1to6 Submitted for 1 to 6

15. M/s Opulus Electricals India Pvt. Ltd, New Delhi

Submitted General Osram LM80 submitted



S. No.


Category

Make of LEDs






years


Sr. number of item(s)

quoted


HAREDA for item(s)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

16. M/s Polycab Wires Pvt. Ltd., Noida Submitted General Cree and Osram LM80 submitted

Submitted tie up declaration

letter dated 13.02.2018 with M/s Techno Electromech Pvt. Ltd., Vadodra


submitted 1600.00 Lakhs Work completion

certificate not attached


17. M/s RG Buildimplex Pvt. Limited, Sonepat


18. M/s R.K. Agencies, Billaspur (Chhatisgarh)

Submitted General Osram LM80 submitted

MOU of M/s Multiland Electronics Pvt. Ltd., Banglore attached but SMT not mentioned in MOU.


submitted No related experience. Bidder has submitted completion certificate of CREDA for project year 2016-17 of Rs. 743.25 lakhs of mix outdoor & indoor lighting.


19. M/s Rudai Lighting Pvt. Ltd. , Jaipur Submitted General Cree/ Samsung Seoul,

LM80 submitted of CREE

Not attached

Submitted Not submitted

( bidder

has submitted ATO of a Korean firm)

submitted 1900.00 Lakhs Letter of Award

dated 15.02.17

of EESL Work completion & satisfactory report not attached.

Submitted 1 to 4 Submitted 1 to 4

20. M/s Sangwan Energy Systems Pvt. Limited, Sonepat

Submitted Haryana SME ( SMALL) Annexure attached.


Submitted Tie Up with Tech On Electronics, Noida

Submitted 1169.00 Lakhs

submitted 1200.00 Lakhs Completion report not submitted

Submitted 1to6 Submitted 1 to 6

S. No.


Category

Make of LEDs






years


Sr. number of item(s)

quoted


HAREDA for item(s)

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

21. M/s Servotech Power Systems Pvt Limited, Sonepat

Firm is debarred by HAREDA

22. M/s Surya Roshni Limited, New Delhi

Submitted General Osram and Everlite LM80 submitted

Having In House SMT certificate submitted

Submitted, also has In House testing facility approved by

NABL

212400.00 Lakhs

submitted 1510.00 Lakhs EESL

Submitted 1to6 Submitted 1 to 6

23. M/s SYSKA LED Lights Pvt Limited, New Delhi

Submitted General Nichia Samsung LM80 submitted

Not attached

Not attached Not attached

Not attached

Not attached Not Submitted

1to6 Submitted 1 to 6

24. M/s Energy Efficient Lights , Banglore


25. M/s Autopal Industries Limited, Jaipur.

Bid not submitted. Yes submitted

26. M/s Amit India Name Plates Pvt. Ltd. EMD, sample and bid not submitted

27. M/s K.R.D. Energy Solutions Pvt Limited

Tender fee, EMD, sample and bid not submitted.

TECHNICAL COMPARATIVE REPORT OF TEST REPORTS OF THE BIDDERS OF THE TENDER FOR ARRANGING THE RATE CONTRACT OF ENERGY EFFICIENT OUTDOOR LIGHTING OPENED ON 24.10.2017.

Name of the bidder: - 1- M/s Alien Energy Private Limited, Delhi.

S. No.

Testing parameters Item no. 1 : 18 W LED Street light Fixture

Item no. 2 : 35 W LED Street light Fixture


DNIT Requirement

Observations of test report

Test report details (Test Report

issued on or after 1st April,

2013)

DNIT Requirement



issued on or after 1st April, 2013)

DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.98 Bharat test House Pvt. Limited, Sonepat issued on 06.06.2016

> 0.95 - Not submitted > 0.95 0.98 Bharat test House Pvt. Limited, Sonepat issued on 10.06.2016

2 System efficacy ( lumen/watt)

>100 lumens/ watt

104.71 >100 lumens/ watt

- >100 lumens/ watt

105.84

3 Color rendering Index (CRI)

>70 75.1 >70 - >70 75.2

4 Total Harmonic Distortion ( THD)

<10% Not submitted

<10% - <10% Not submitted

5 Color Temperature of Lamp

5000 or 5700 K

5464 5000 or 5700 K - 5000 or 5700 K 6428

6 Ingress Protection Level (IP Level)

IP65 Not submitted

IP65 - IP66 Not submitted

7 LED Driver Efficiency (in %)

>85% Not submitted

>85% - >85% Not submitted

8 Power Consumption of complete system

18+_5% 18.6 35+_5% - 70+_5% 70.16

9 LED Efficacy ( at operating current (design) and Tj=85 o C ) in Lumens/ watt

>135 lumens/watt

Not submitted

>135 lumens/watt

- >135 lumens/watt

Not submitted

10 Wattage of LED used in the system

1 to 3 W Not submitted

1 to 3 W - 1 to 3 W Not submitted

Name of the bidder:- 1- M/s Alien Energy Private Limited, Delhi.

S. No.


Item no. 5 : 100 W LED Flood light

Item no.6 : 200 W LED Flood light

DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 - Not submitted

> 0.95 0.96 Bharat test House Pvt. Limited, Sonepat issued on 27.07..2016

> 0.95 0.96 Bharat test House Pvt. Limited, Sonepat issued on 27.07..2016


>100 lumens/ watt

- >100 lumens/ watt


107.96


>70 - >70 80.8 >70 69.8


<10% - <10% Not submitted <10% Not submitted


5000 or 5700 K

- 5000 or 5700 K 6026 5000 or 5700 K 5276


IP66 - IP66 Not submitted IP66 Not submitted


>85% - >85% Not submitted >85% Not submitted


130+_5% - 100+_5% 97.9 200+_5% 196.7


>135 lumens/watt

- >135 lumens/watt

Not submitted >135 lumens/watt

Not submitted


1 to 3 W - 1 to 3 W Not submitted 1 to 3 W Not submitted


Name of the bidder: - 2- M/s Atlas Industries, Sonepat.

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.99 KC India Test Lab. , LLP, Gaziabad issued on 09.10.2017

> 0.95 0.97 KC India Test Lab. , LLP, Gaziabad issued on 09.10.2017

> 0.95 - Not submitted


>100 lumens/ watt

97 >100 lumens/ watt


-


>70 72.4 >70 81.3 >70 -


<10% 5.8 <10% 6.24 <10% -


5000 or 5700 K

5399 5000 or 5700 K 5422 5000 or 5700 K -


IP65 Not covered IP65 Not covered IP66 -


>85% 84.5 >85% 87.2 >85% -


18+_5% 17.67 35+_5% 34.49 70+_5% -


>135 lumens/watt

Not submitted

>135 lumens/watt


-



1 to 3 W Not submitted 1 to 3 W -


Name of the bidder: - 3. M/s Crompton Greaves Consumer Electrical Limited, New Delhi

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.97 Hi Physix Lab India Pvt. Limited, Pune issued on 10.2.2017

> 0.95 0.96 Hi Physix Lab India Pvt. Limited, Pune issued on 10.2.2017

> 0.95 0.97 Hi Physix Lab India Pvt. Limited, Pune issued on 10.2.2017


>100 lumens/ watt



120.58


>70 71.2 >70 70.8 >70 71.3


<10% 6.9 <10% 8.5 <10% 8.5


5000 or 5700 K

5572 5000 or 5700 K 5525 5000 or 5700 K 5552


IP65 Not covered IP65 Not covered IP66 Not covered


>85% Not covered >85% Not covered >85% Not covered


18+_5% 17.65 35+_5% 34.10 70+_5% 68.25


>135 lumens/watt

Not submitted

>135 lumens/watt


Not submitted



1 to 3 W Not submitted 1 to 3 W Not submitted

Test Report of item no. 4,5 & 6 not submitted.


Name of the bidder: - 5. M/s Glow green Energy Limited, Shahibabad.

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.96 Alpha Test House , New Delhi Issued on 18.10.2017 Alpha Test House , New Delhi Issued on 13.02.2018

> 0.95 0.96 Alpha Test House , New Delhi Issued on 18.10.2017 Alpha Test House , New Delhi Issued on 13.02.2018



>100 lumens/ watt



107.4


>70 84.1 >70 84.5 >70 84.4


<10% 8.5 <10% 8.8 <10% 7.8


5000 or 5700 K

5778 5000 or 5700 K 5704 5000 or 5700 K 5754


IP65 IP65 IP65 IP65 IP66 IP66


>85% >85% >85% >85% >85% >85%


18+_5% 19.7 35+_5% 34.6 70+_5% 69.6


>135 lumens/watt

139.1 >135 lumens/watt


139.1


1 to 3 W 1 watt* 1 to 3 W 1 watt* 1 to 3 W 1 watt*

* According to furnish in Annexure-I.

TECHNICAL COMPARATIVE REPORT OF TEST REPORTS OF THE BIDDERS THE TENDER FOR ARRANGING THE RATE CONTRACT OF ENERGY EFFICIENT OUTDOOR LIGHTING OPENED ON 24.10.2017.

Name of the bidder: - 5. M/s Glow green Energy Limited, Shahibabad.

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.98 Alpha Test House , New Delhi Issued on 18.10.2017 Alpha Test House , New Delhi Issued on 13.02.2018




>100 lumens/ watt



116.8


>70 84.6 >70 72.9 >70 73.5


<10% 8.3 <10% 8.3 <10% 8.6


5000 or 5700 K

5784 5000 or 5700 K 5838 5000 or 5700 K 5850




>85% >85% >85% >85% >85% >85%


130+_5% 125.7 100+_5% 98.25 200+_5% 197.2


>135 lumens/watt



139.1


1 to 3 W 1 watt 1 to 3 W 2 watt 1 to 3 W 2 watt

* According to furnish in Annexure-I.


Name of the bidder: - 6. M/s Green star Research & Development Private Limited, Gurugram

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.95 Intertek India Private Limited, New Delhi issued on 13.10.2017

> 0.95 - Not submitted > 0.95 - Not submitted


>100 lumens/ watt


- >100 lumens/ watt

-


>70 71.5 >70 - >70 -


<10% Not covered <10% - <10% -


5000 or 5700 K

5669 5000 or 5700 K - 5000 or 5700 K -


IP65 IP65 IP65 - IP66 -


>85% Not covered >85% - >85% -


18+_5% 18.6 35+_5% - 70+_5% -


>135 lumens/watt

Not submitted

>135 lumens/watt

- >135 lumens/watt

-



1 to 3 W - 1 to 3 W -


Name of the bidder: - 6. M/s Green star Research & Development Private Limited, Gurugram

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement





> 0.95 0.93 UL India Lab. Banglore



>100 lumens/ watt

- >100 lumens/ watt


-


>70 - >70 68.8 >70 -


<10% - <10% Not covered <10% -


5000 or 5700 K

- 5000 or 5700 K 6060 5000 or 5700 K -


IP66 - IP66 Not covered IP66 -


>85% - >85% Not covered >85% -


130+_5% - 100+_5% 100.4 200+_5% -


>135 lumens/watt

- >135 lumens/watt


-


1 to 3 W - 1 to 3 W Not submitted 1 to 3 W -


Name of the bidder: - 7. M/s Halonix Technologies Private Limited, Noida

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.97 HTPL Laboratory, Haridwar ( In-house NABL approved) Issued on 03.03.17 HTPL Laboratory, Haridwar ( In-house NABL approved) Issued on 10.10.2017

> 0.95 0.978 HTPL Laboratory, Haridwar Issued on 31.01.17 HTPL Laboratory, Haridwar ( In-house NABL approved) Issued on 11.10.2017



>100 lumens/ watt



108.9


>70 72.2 >70 73.2 >70 74.5


<10% 6.7 <10% 6.5 <10% 7.8


5000 or 5700 K

5798 5000 or 5700 K 5717 5000 or 5700 K 5868




>85% 88.7 >85% 88.9 >85% 88.7


18+_5% 17. 91 35+_5% 34.9 70+_5% 69.7


>135 lumens/watt

>135* >135 lumens/watt


>135*


1 to 3 W 1-3 watt* 1 to 3 W 1-3 watt* 1 to 3 W 1-3 watt*

*Vide confirmation letter dated 18.03.2018.


Name of the bidder: - 7. M/s Halonix Technologies Private Limited, Noida

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.97 HTPL Laboratory, Haridwar Issued on 20.02.17 HTPL Laboratory, Haridwar ( In-house NABL approved) Issued on 17.10.2017




>100 lumens/ watt



115.9


>70 73.3 >70 73.4 >70 72.2


<10% 8.2 <10% 7.9 <10% Not covered


5000 or 5700 K

5785 5000 or 5700 K 5742 5000 or 5700 K 5700




>85% 88.9 >85% 88.7 >85% Not covered


130+_5% 129.78 100+_5% 99.8 200+_5% 198.8


>135 lumens/watt



>135*


1 to 3 W 1-3 watt* 1 to 3 W 1-3 watt* 1 to 3 W 1-3 watt*

*Vide confirmation letter dated 18.03.2018.


Name of the bidder: - 8. M/s Hitech Lights Limited, Solan ( HP)

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement





> 0.95 0.97 Hiphysix Lab. India Pvt. Limited, Pune Issued on 23.08.16



>100 lumens/ watt

- >100 lumens/ watt


-


>70 - >70 83.1 >70 -


<10% - <10% 9.3 <10% -


5000 or 5700 K

- 5000 or 5700 K 6004 5000 or 5700 K -


IP65 - IP65 Not covered IP66 -


>85% - >85% 85.4 >85% -


18+_5% - 35+_5% 34.4 70+_5% -


>135 lumens/watt

- >135 lumens/watt


-


1 to 3 W - 1 to 3 W Not submitted 1 to 3 W -


Name of the bidder: - 9. M/s HPL Electric & Power Pvt. Limited, Sonepat

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.97 Bharat Test House Pvt. Limited, Sonepat issued on 12.11.2016

> 0.95 0.95 Bharat Test House Pvt. Limited, Sonepat issued on 14.11.2016 Bharat Test House Pvt. Limited, Sonepat issued on 20.01.2016



>100 lumens/ watt



115.5


>70 72.7 >70 71.6 >70 75.6


<10% Not covered <10% Not covered <10% Not covered


5000 or 5700 K

5912 5000 or 5700 K 5890 5000 or 5700 K 6378


IP65 Not covered IP65 IP67 IP66 IP67




18+_5% 17.7 35+_5% 34.9 70+_5% 70


>135 lumens/watt

135-160* >135 lumens/watt


135-160*




* As per LED data sheet


Name of the bidder: - 9. M/s HPL Electric & Power Pvt. Limited, Sonepat

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.98 Bharat Test House Pvt. Limited, Sonepat issued on 21.07.2016 Bharat Test House Pvt. Limited, Sonepat issued on 03.09..2016 Bharat Test House Pvt. Limited, Sonepat issued on 20.01.2016




>100 lumens/ watt



105.9


>70 73.5 >70 70.3 >70 70.3


<10% 8.3 <10% Not covered <10% Not covered


5000 or 5700 K

5972 5000 or 5700 K 5432 5000 or 5700 K 5684






130+_5% 125.2 100+_5% 99.8 200+_5% 202.6


>135 lumens/watt



135-160*




* As per LED data sheet


Name of the bidder: - 11. M/s Jaquor & Company Pvt. Limited, Gurugram

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.96 Alpha test House, Manesar issued on 04.10.2017

> 0.95 0.98 Alpha test House, Manesar issued on 04.10.2017



>100 lumens/ watt



112.4


>70 75.8 >70 74.5 >70 76.9


<10% 5.3 <10% 3.6 <10% 7.2


5000 or 5700 K

5500 5000 or 5700 K 5502 5000 or 5700 K 5522






18+_5% 17.5 35+_5% 34.4 70+_5% 69.9


>135 lumens/watt

Not submitted

>135 lumens/watt


Not submitted





Name of the bidder: - 11. M/s Jaquor & Company Pvt. Limited, Gurugram

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.98 Alpha test House, Manesar issued on 04.10.2017




>100 lumens/ watt



120.57


>70 78 >70 72 >70 71.6


<10% 9.8 <10% 5.9 <10% 7.5


5000 or 5700 K

5810 5000 or 5700 K 5536 5000 or 5700 K 5574






130+_5% 129.78 100+_5% 99.1 200+_5% 197.59


>135 lumens/watt

Not submitted

>135 lumens/watt


Not submitted





Name of the bidder: - 12. M/s Joonix Energy Private limited, Faridabad.

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.98 0.98*

UL India Lab, Banglore issued on 02.02.2017 * Addl Test Report of Institute of Testing and Certification (I) Private Limited, Mohali issued on 13.02.2018

> 0.95 0.98 0.99*

Institute of Testing & certification Pvt. Limited, Panchkula issued on 18.05.16 * Addl Test Report of Institute of Testing and Certification (I) Private Limited, Mohali issued on 13.02.2018

> 0.95 0.99 0.97*

UL India Lab, Banglore/ Manesar issued on 02.02.2017 & 21.02.2017 * Addl Test Report of Institute of Testing and Certification (I) Private Limited, Mohali issued on 13.02.2018


>100 lumens/ watt

77.6 121.35*

>100 lumens/ watt

95.6 134.77*

>100 lumens/ watt

92.7 115.4*


>70 84.2 >70 73.6 >70 71.6


<10% 14.96 <10% 0.74 <10% 8.08


5000 or 5700 K

5000 5000 or 5700 K 5890 5000 or 5700 K 5000


IP65 IP65 IP65 Ip66 IP66 IP66


>85% 87.55 >85% 88.8 >85% 89.8


18+_5% 18.54 18.40*

35+_5% 34.7 35.4*

70+_5% 68.52 68.8*


>135 lumens/watt

154** >135 lumens/watt


154**


1 to 3 W < 3watt ** ( 1.89-2.24)

1 to 3 W < 3watt ** ( 1.89-2.24)

1 to 3 W < 3watt ** ( 1.89-2.24)

* Date of sample submitted as recording in the Lab. was 08.02.2018. , **Confirmation letter dated 14/02/2018.


Name of the bidder: - 12. M/s Joonix Energy Private limited, Faridabad.

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.99 UL India Lab, Banglore issued on 20.02.2017

> 0.95 0.99 0.99*


> 0.95 0.99 0.99*



>100 lumens/ watt


82.2 129.9*

>100 lumens/ watt

97.4 126.4*


>70 74.8 >70 69.7 >70 74.8


<10% 7.16 <10% 8.05 <10% 7.8


5000 or 5700 K

5000 5000 or 5700 K 5000 5000 or 5700 K 5000




>85% 89.5 >85% 90.39 >85% 89.6


130+_5% 129.9 100+_5% 97.89 98.2*

200+_5% 195.5 193.1*


>135 lumens/watt



154**


1 to 3 W < 3watt ** ( 1.89-2.24)

1 to 3 W < 3watt ** ( 1.89-2.24)

1 to 3 W < 3watt ** ( 1.89-2.24)

* Date of sample submitted as recording in the Lab. was 08.02.2018. , **Confirmation letter dated 14/02/2018.


Name of the bidder: - 13. M/s Mansa Solar Energy, Karnal

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.97 Conformity Testing Lab., New Delhi issued on 23.10.2017 *Planet electro Labs, New Delhi dated 02.02.2018

> 0.95 0.95 Conformity Testing Lab., New delhi issued on 23.10.2017 *Planet electro Labs, New Delhi dated 02.02.2018

> 0.95 0.97 Conformity Testing Lab., New Delhi issued on 23.10.2017 *Planet electro Labs, New Delhi dated 02.02.2018


>100 lumens/ watt



108.7


>70 72.4 >70 77.6 >70 73


<10% 8.21 <10% 7.59 <10% 7.5


5000 or 5700 K

5399 5000 or 5700 K 6311 5000 or 5700 K 5904


IP65 IP65* IP65 IP65* IP66 IP66*




18+_5% 17.78 35+_5% 34.21 70+_5% 69.8


>135 lumens/watt

>138 W LED data sheet

>135 lumens/watt


>135 lumens/watt



1 to 3 W 1 -3 # 1 to 3 W 1 -3 # 1 to 3 W 1 -3 #

# Intimated to use LED wattage, by letter dated 09.02.2018.


Name of the bidder: - 13. M/s Mansa Solar Energy, Karnal

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.98 Conformity Testing Lab., New Delhi issued on 23.10.2017 *Planet electro Labs, New Delhi dated 02.02.2018

> 0.95 0.98 Conformity Testing Lab., New Delhi issued on 23.10.2017 *Planet electro Labs, New Delhi dated 02.02.2018 **CPRI, Bangalore dated 22/09/2014

> 0.95 0.98 Conformity Testing Lab., New Delhi issued on 23.10.2017 *Planet electro Labs, New Delhi dated 02.02.2018 **CPRI, Bangalore dated 22/09/2014


>100 lumens/ watt



103.2


>70 72.6 >70 86.2 >70 70.3


<10% 4.15 <10% 8.77 <10% 4.96


5000 or 5700 K

5046 5000 or 5700 K 6392 5000 or 5700 K 7818


IP66 IP66* IP66 IP66* IP66 IP66*


>85% Not covered >85% 85.55** >85% 86.91**


130+_5% 125.6 100+_5% 99.48 200+_5% 208.6


>135 lumens/watt


>135 lumens/watt


>135 lumens/watt



1 to 3 W 1 -3 # 1 to 3 W 1 -3 # 1 to 3 W 1 -3 #

# Intimated to use LED wattage , by letter dated 09.02.2018.


Name of the bidder: - 14. M/s Ojskar Vidyut LLP, Rewari

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.96 Alpha TEST HOUSE, New Delhi issued on 18.10.2017 Alpha TEST HOUSE, New Delhi issued on 13.02.18 ( In respect of earlier test report 18/10/2017)

> 0.95 0.96 Alpha TEST HOUSE, New Delhi issued on 18.10.2017 Alpha TEST HOUSE, New Delhi issued on 13.02.18 ( In respect of earlier test report 18/10/2017)



>100 lumens/ watt



111.272


>70 84.7 >70 84.5 >70 84.1


<10% 9 <10% 8.9 <10% 7.9


5000 or 5700 K

5768 5000 or 5700 K 5776 5000 or 5700 K 5752




>85% >85% >85% >85% >85% >85


18+_5% 19.44 35+_5% 34.62 70+_5% 69.51


>135 lumens/watt

139 >135 lumens/watt


139


1 to 3 W 1 W 1 to 3 W 1 W 1 to 3 W 1W


Name of the bidder: - 14. M/s Ojskar Vidyut LLP, Rewari

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.98 Alpha TEST HOUSE, New Delhi issued on 18.10.2017 Alpha TEST HOUSE, New Delhi issued on 13.02.18 ( In respect of earlier test report 18/10/2017)




>100 lumens/ watt



116.86


>70 84.9 >70 72.9 >70 73.5


<10% 8.3 <10% 8.3 <10% 8.6


5000 or 5700 K

5716 5000 or 5700 K 5838 5000 or 5700 K 5850




>85% >85% >85% >85% >85% >85%


130+_5% 125.9 100+_5% 98.25 200+_5% 197.24


>135 lumens/watt



139


1 to 3 W 1 W 1 to 3 W 2 W 1 to 3 W 2 W

Note : LED wattage to be used in the fixtures has been mentioned by bidder in the bid as for item no. 1 to4, 1 Watt and for item no. 5&6, 2W.


Name of the bidder: - 15. M/s Opulus Electricals India Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.96 Hi Physix lab, Delhi issued on 15.01.17 and Bharat Test House, New Delhi issued on 18.07.2017, Delhi Test House, Kundli Issued on 03.10.2017

> 0.95 0.95 DELHI TEST HOUSE , SONEPAT issued on 5.10.17 & 6.10.2017, Delhi Test House, Kundli Issued on 03.10.2017



>100 lumens/ watt



110.7


>70 80 >70 78 >70 79


<10% 8.6 <10% 8.9 <10% 8.2


5000 or 5700 K

6111 5000 or 5700 K 6187 5000 or 5700 K 6233




>85% 88.5 >85% 89.6 >85% 93.09


18+_5% 17.68 35+_5% 34.87 70+_5% 69.85


>135 lumens/watt



142


1 to 3 W 1 1 to 3 W 2 1 to 3 W 2


Name of the bidder: - 15. M/s Opulus Electricals India Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.95 DELHI TEST HOUSE , SONEPAT issued on 5.10.17 & 6.10.2017, Delhi Test House, Kundli Issued on 03.10.2017


> 0.95 0.97 DELHI TEST HOUSE , SONEPAT issued on 6.10.2017 & 12.10.17 , Delhi Test House, Kundli Issued on 03.10.2017


>100 lumens/ watt



111.4


>70 81 >70 82 >70 81


<10% 8.3 <10% 8.6 <10% 9.2


5000 or 5700 K

6195 5000 or 5700 K 6210 5000 or 5700 K 6344




>85% 89 >85% 90.8 >85% 91.6


130+_5% 128.82 100+_5% 97.6 200+_5% 197.09


>135 lumens/watt



153


1 to 3 W 2 1 to 3 W 2 1 to 3 W 2


Name of the bidder: - 16. M/s Polycab Wires Pvt. Limited, Noida

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.97 Hi Physix lab, Pune issued on 15.03.17

> 0.95 0.96 Hi Physix lab, Pune issued on 15.03.17

> 0.95 0.96 Hi Physix lab, Pune issued on 15.03.17


>100 lumens/ watt



110.09


>70 71.5 >70 71.5 >70 72.1


<10% Not covered <10% Not covered <10% Not covered


5000 or 5700 K

5705 5000 or 5700 K 5624 5000 or 5700 K 5725






18+_5% 18.23 35+_5% 34.8 70+_5% 73.45


>135 lumens/watt

157 According to data sheet

>135 lumens/watt


>135 lumens/watt






Name of the bidder: - 16. M/s Polycab Wires Pvt. Limited, Noida

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.97 Hi Physix lab, Pune issued on 15.03.17

> 0.95 - Not submitted > 0.95 0.98 Hi Physix lab, Pune issued on 15.03.17


>100 lumens/ watt


- >100 lumens/ watt

110.7


>70 72.4 >70 - >70 72.4


<10% Not covered <10% - <10% Not covered


5000 or 5700 K

5666 5000 or 5700 K - 5000 or 5700 K 5739


IP66 Not covered IP66 - IP66 Not covered


>85% Not covered >85% - >85% Not covered


130+_5% 133.66 100+_5% - 200+_5% 199.30


>135 lumens/watt


>135 lumens/watt

- >135 lumens/watt




1 to 3 W - 1 to 3 W Not submitted


Name of the bidder: - 18. M/s R.K.Agencies, Bilaspur ( CG)

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.99 Conformity Testing lab, Delhi issued on 17.10.17 & 24.10.17

> 0.95 0.98 Conformity Testing lab, Delhi issued on 17.10.17 & 14.10.17



>100 lumens/ watt



115.4


>70 74.6 >70 79.7 >70 74.6


<10% 5.18 <10% 4.51 <10% 5.3


5000 or 5700 K

5595 5000 or 5700 K 5951 5000 or 5700 K 5457




>85% 86.9 >85% 92.06 >85% 8720


18+_5% 17.10 35+_5% 33.40 70+_5% 65.56


>135 lumens/watt

151* >135 lumens/watt


151*


1 to 3 W 3* 1 to 3 W 3* 1 to 3 W 3*

*Vide confirmation letter dated 30/01/2017.


Name of the bidder: - 18. M/s R.K.Agencies, Bilaspur ( CG)

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.99 Conformity Testing lab, Delhi issued on 17.10.17


> 0.95 0.99 Conformity Testing lab, Delhi issued on 23.10.17


>100 lumens/ watt



103.43


>70 75 >70 75.3 >70 75.4


<10% 4.58 <10% 4.61 <10% 7.45


5000 or 5700 K

5552 5000 or 5700 K 5849 5000 or 5700 K 5687


IP66 Ip66 IP66 IP66 IP66 IP66


>85% 92.21 >85% 92.26 >85% 86.1


130+_5% 124.46 100+_5% 97.25 200+_5% 191.84


>135 lumens/watt



151*


1 to 3 W 3* 1 to 3 W 3* 1 to 3 W 3*

*Vide confirmation letter dated 30/01/2017.


Name of the bidder:- 19- M/s Rudai Lighting Private Limited, Jaipur

. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.97 Alpha Test House, New Delhi dated 05.10.2017

> 0.95 0.97 Alpha Test House, New Delhi dated 05.10.2017

> 0.95 0.98 Alpha Test House, New Delhi dated 05.10.2017


>100 lumens/ watt



117.94


>70 83.6 >70 84 >70 83.4


<10% 6.9 <10% 6.3 <10% 6.3


5000 or 5700 K

5795 5000 or 5700 K 5855 5000 or 5700 K 5775




>85% 88.2 >85% 87.2 >85% 86.1


18+_5% 17.6 35+_5% 34.1 70+_5% 68.6


>135 lumens/watt

Not covered >135 lumens/watt


Not covered


1 to 3 W Not covered 1 to 3 W Not covered 1 to 3 W Not covered


Name of the bidder:- 19- M/s Rudai Lighting Private Limited, Jaipur

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.98 Alpha Test House, New Delhi dated 05.10.2017

> 0.95 - Not submitted > 0.95 - Not submitted


>100 lumens/ watt


- >100 lumens/ watt

-


>70 83.4 >70 - >70 -


<10% 6.2 <10% - <10% -


5000 or 5700 K

5860 5000 or 5700 K - 5000 or 5700 K -


IP66 IP66 IP66 - IP66 -


>85% 87.9 >85% - >85% -


130+_5% 128.5 100+_5% - 200+_5% -


>135 lumens/watt


- >135 lumens/watt

-


1 to 3 W Not covered 1 to 3 W - 1 to 3 W -


Name of the bidder: - 20. M/s Sangwan Energy Systems Pvt. Limited, Sonepat

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.98 Planet Electro lab, Delhi, Bharat test House, CPRI , Issued on 21.10.17, 25.5.2015

> 0.95 0.99 UL India lab, Gurugram on dated 10.02.16, Bharat Test House Pvt. Ltd., Rai on dated 29.01.2017

> 0.95 0.99 UL India lab, Gurugram on dated 10.02.16, Bharat Test House Pvt. Ltd., Rai on dated 29.01.2017


>100 lumens/ watt



110


>70 71.67 >70 74.1 >70 74.2


<10% 5.3 <10% 7.63 <10% 5.59


5000 or 5700 K

5763 5000 or 5700 K 5763 5000 or 5700 K 5894


IP65 IP65 IP65 IP66 IP66 IP 66


>85% 89.37 >85% 88.74 >85% 89.6


18+_5% 18.45 35+_5% 35 70+_5% 70.8


>135 lumens/watt



140


1 to 3 W 3 1 to 3 W 3 1 to 3 W 3


Name of the bidder: - 20. M/s Sangwan Energy Systems Pvt. Limited, Sonepat

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.98 Bharat test House Pvt. Ltd., Sonepat issued on 29.01.17 & CPRI dated 25.05.15

> 0.95 0.99 Institute of Testing & Certification (I) Pvt. Ltd., Panchkula issued on dated 04.08.2014, Bharat Test House Pvt. Ltd., Rai issued on 29.01.17

> 0.95 0.99 Institute of Testing & Certification (I) Pvt. Ltd., Panchkula issued on dated 04.08.2014, Bharat Test House Pvt. Ltd., Rai issued on 29.01.17


>100 lumens/ watt



117.23


>70 72.6 >70 78.5 >70 77.4


<10% 6.2 <10% 7.9 <10% 7.2


5000 or 5700 K

5761 5000 or 5700 K 5644 5000 or 5700 K 5682


IP66 IP66 IP66 IP66 IP66 1P66


>85% 89.6 >85% 89.7 >85% 89.5


130+_5% 130.9 100+_5% 100.5 200+_5% 201.3


>135 lumens/watt



140


1 to 3 W 3 1 to 3 W 3 1 to 3 W 3


Name of the bidder: - 21. M/s Servotech Power systems Pvt. Limited, Sonepat

Firm is debarred by HAREDA


Name of the bidder: - 22. M/s Surya Roshni limited, New Delhi

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.958 Surya Technology & Innovation Centre(STIC) , Surya Roshni Ltd., In House NABL issued on 15.07.2016 Surya Roshni Limited, type test report dated 18/08/2017. ( at STIC)

> 0.95 0.96 Surya Technology & Innovation Centre(STIC) , Surya Roshni Ltd., In House NABL issued on 12.09.2016

> 0.95 0.97 Surya Technology & Innovation Centre (STIC) , Surya Roshni Ltd., In House NABL issued on. Dated 23.05.2016.


>100 lumens/ watt



100.9


>70 70 >70 >70 Not covered


<10% 8.6 <10% Not covered <10% Not covered


5000 or 5700 K

5700 5000 or 5700 K Not covered 5000 or 5700 K Not covered


IP65 IP65 IP65 Not covered IP66 Not covered


>85% 85.6 >85% Not covered >85% Not covered


18+_5% 17.8 35+_5% 34.8 70+_5% 70.3


>135 lumens/watt



Not submitted


1 to 3 W 2.64 1 to 3 W Not submitted 1 to 3 W Not submitted


Name of the bidder: 22. M/s Surya Roshni limited, New Delhi

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 0.97 Surya Technology & Innovation Centre(STIC) , Surya Roshni Ltd., In House NABL issued on dated 05.10.2016 Surya Roshni Limited, type test report dated 18/08/2017. ( at STIC)

> 0.95 0.97 Surya Technology & Innovation Centre(STIC) , Surya Roshni Ltd., In House NABL issued on dated 11.07.2016 Surya Roshni Limited, type test report dated 15/10/2017 (at STIC)

> 0.95 0.97 Surya Technology & Innovation Centre(STIC) , Surya Roshni Ltd., In House NABL issued on dated 11.07.2016 Surya Roshni Limited, type test report dated 15/09/2017 (at STIC)


>100 lumens/ watt



100.04


>70 71.1 >70 80 >70 70


<10% 7.6 <10% 7.6 <10% 7.6


5000 or 5700 K

5850 5000 or 5700 K 5700 5000 or 5700 K 5700




>85% 86.7 >85% 87.5 >85% 86.5


130+_5% 130.2 100+_5% 100.4 200+_5% 197.9


>135 lumens/watt



151


1 to 3 W 2.9 1 to 3 W 2.7 1 to 3 W 2.6


Name of the bidder: - 23. M/s Syska LED Lights P Ltd., New Delhi

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement




1 Power Factor > 0.95 - Not submitted > 0.95 - Not submitted > 0.95 0.94 Intertek India Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi issued on 19.12.16


>100 lumens/ watt

- >100 lumens/ watt

- >100 lumens/ watt

114.9


>70 - >70 - >70 73.2


<10% - <10% - <10% Not covered


5000 or 5700 K

- 5000 or 5700 K - 5000 or 5700 K 6258


IP65 - IP65 - IP66 Not covered


>85% - >85% - >85% Not covered


18+_5% - 35+_5% - 70+_5% 79.06


>135 lumens/watt

- >135 lumens/watt

- >135 lumens/watt

Not submitted


1 to 3 W - 1 to 3 W - 1 to 3 W Not submitted


Name of the bidder: 23. M/s Syska LED Lights P Ltd., New Delhi

S. No.




DNIT Requirement




2013)

DNIT Requirement




DNIT Requirement





> 0.95 - Not submitted > 0.95 0.99 UL India Lab. , Banglore issued on 06.07.2015


>100 lumens/ watt

- >100 lumens/ watt

- >100 lumens/ watt

96.6


>70 - >70 - >70 72


<10% - <10% - <10% Not submitted


5000 or 5700 K

- 5000 or 5700 K - 5000 or 5700 K 6216


IP66 - IP66 - IP66 Not covered


>85% - >85% - >85% Not covered


130+_5% - 100+_5% - 200+_5% 184.5


>135 lumens/watt

- >135 lumens/watt

- >135 lumens/watt

Not submitted


1 to 3 W - 1 to 3 W - 1 to 3 W Not submitted

Documents

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF TECHNICAL BIDS …hareda.gov.in/writereaddata/news/hareda168859908.pdf · sales) Completion ... M/s Jaquor & Company Pvt. Ltd, Gurugram. ... 130 W LED Street