Comparative analysis of the Role of Civil Society in Providing Social Welfare Services in the Western Balkans

8/19/2019 Comparative analysis of the Role of Civil Society in Providing Social Welfare Services in the Western Balkans

1/112!

!"#$%&'"( *+,"-."% /0123

4+-5&%&67," 89:;7;+< 6=" >+#" +< 47,7#?+@7"6: 79 A%+,7'79$?+@7 B"#


2/112#

$%& ' ()*)+,-./)01) 2 324+.5)0.1.

6)7,89) 4.4+.,*:5) ;74.1:< =:,-7)8>?@A@BCD!EF

G?!H#A@BCD!EF

(IJ&KLKM%N6K )9)+./) 2+,-: 0.O.+9,-

9) P)3)89,Q =)+5)92 R S)2*,7 ;:$,9;< -723) /)

7)/O,192 .9.0.1)*.O2 T 27:89.5 %O)9 J)7.9UH D

%;=6 BCVDV?DB!C>EEDGDG

!H ;:$,9;< W723) /) 7)/O,192 .9.0.1)*.O2 A=:,-7)8F)F ;,0.1)+9) /)X*.*)D P)3)89. =)+5)9

4F 6:O+)8.9: ,7-)9./)0.1: D P)3)89. =)+5)9

$I=%;;H;LD%Y #G>#?G?V@


3/112

M:+Z[>V! !! #>V !E CC\)]Z Z[>V! !! #>V !E CC

^7:89.5

%O)9 J)7.9

K2*,7

M:+Z[>V! !! @!# !# EC\)]Z[>V! !! >@@ C> V?

=:+-7)8:< 6,O:Q4:7 #G!>H


4/112@

1 D96%+'E@67+9 C

/ !+;97& &9' F"%G"$+,79& V

2 H+96"9"$%+ >E

I 4%+&67& E!


5/112E

J K+;+,+ ??

L ?%.7M& CB

BC

N >"@+--"9'&67+9; !G>

O 899"P !!!


6/112?

8?! 8%."76"%Q?&-&%76"%Q!E9'( R"E6;@=#&9' "3S3

!7F !+;97& &9' F"%G"$+,79&

4?B 4"96%"


7/112C

M

!

1 %6MLIY^$M%I6


8/112V

;

!" $%&'( )*+&,- ./*01+0&*" &) 2"31/041 52/&)3&+0&*" *6 041 1"0&0&1) ,"3+,"0*")7

)1/&1) *6 8&)0/&+0 ,-)* 4,)

/


9/112B

/31 !+;97& &9' F"%G"$+,79&

_

./*019


10/112!G

/313/ 8*8YD^8 D*?[D[V4D\*8Y*\Z \KSD>8

M `)Q.+a )98 O:*:7)9 37,*:0*.,9<

7:D*2

!H

Q,9.*,7.9-

0,90:79.9-

#

/


11/112!!

/3/ >"5E.#7C& ?%5;C&

/3/31 8*8Y_?D? \T [FX YXZ8Y T>8HXB\>K

[=" 4+9;676E67+9 +< >"5E.#7C& ?%5;C& )7:

)33+aH

6,H #@R!GFT


12/112!#

[=" Y&` +9 ?+@7 A%+6"@67+9

37,O.8:8 4a +)b< )7: .Q3+:Q:D

37,O.8:8 `,7 )9 .98.O.82)+< )

K4,O: )++<

/


13/112!>

L:324+.5)


14/112!@

[=" Y&` +9 6=" A%+6"@67+9 +< 47,7# S7@67-; +< B&%

/


15/112!E

/3/3/ 8*8Y_?D? \T [FX D*?[D[V[D\*8Y T>8HXB\>K

$

37,*:0*.,9

:4/11 ;&"&)0/&1) ,/1 +*;.101"0 6*/ )*+&,-

./*9


16/112!?

/

>

&7,D

!

4a


17/112!C

37,*:0*.,9

\)Q.+a

/32 T"'"%&67+9 +< !+;97& &9' F"%G"$+,79&

/3231 8*8Y_?D? \T [FX YXZ8Y T>8HXB\>K


18/112!V

#VR!>FT

BD!GR!GFH

7.D ) 0,QQ,9 ,4+.-)*.,9H

37,*:0*.,9 )7: 37,O.8D !H

[=" Y&` +9 6=" A%79@75#"; +< ?+@7 A%+6"@67+9( 6=" A%+6"@67+9 +< 47,7# S7@67-;+< B&% &9' 6=" A%+6"@67+9 +< T&-7#7"; `76= 4=7#'%"9 +< 6=" T"'"%&67+9 +< !7F

@

/

6131/,-(

@


19/112!B

b

\:8:7)*.,9


20/112#G

;)7)D

*7).9.9- 0)7:H

:]0:3* )98

/


21/112#!

.Q3:8:8

$:9*7)+

Q)*:7.)+ )00,D `)Q.+a


22/112##

)9

/323/ 8*8Y_?D? \T [FX D*?[D[V[D\*8Y T>8HXB\>K

c)4,27

/


23/112#>

#

:+8:7+a

E

E


24/112#@

/

/3I31 8*8Y_?D? \T [FX YXZ8Y T>8HXB\>K

M

9,H !RG>< @RG@< !BRGC )98 #RGVFT

37,*:D

3:D


25/112#E

,`

4a +)bH

/3I3/ 8*8Y_?D? \T [FX D*?[D[V[D\*8Y T>8HXB\>K

;,0.


26/112#?

/3J 8;;+@7&67+9; +< 4767G"9; 79 ?+@7 A%+6"@67+9

!

/

?


27/112#C

#H

>H

@

E ?H

C .9V #GGB< 3H C! B %4.8< 3H V#!G %8.8< 33H BV< !G#!! %8.8< 3H !!C

C

V

B

!G

!!


28/112#V

K 92Q4:7 ,` 9,9D-,D

!

:0,D

#H

> 0,D

@

!> 3H !!E !E

/

!#

!>

!@

!E


29/112#B

E 0)D

?H

CH VH

4: )88:8H

.9 #G!!F< ;)7)1:O,Z $&$Y )98 MK$;I< #G!>H

!?

!C

!V

!B


30/112>G

,9 0,,3:7)*.,9 !H

#G %8.8< 3H !#@

/

#G


31/112>!

#H

92Q4:7 8:O:+,3Q:9*

0)3)0.*a>

b:+`)7: #! %8.8< 3H !@!

#!

##


32/112>#

@H

/3L ?E--&%: &9' >"@+--"9'&67+9;


33/112>>

7:-2D


34/112>@

/


35/112>E

2

231 89:;7; +< 6=" Y"$ T%&-"`+%C

6,H @?R#G!G

>BR#G!!


36/112>?

4a

2


37/112>C

!E@FH

)1/


38/112>V

23/ 89:;7; +< 6=" D9;676E67+9 T%&-"`+%C

M

29.* .9 < F!

# >H

#?

2

&;.*/0,"+1 6*/ -*+,- )*+&,- ./*01+0&*"

#@

#E

#?

)*""1-7


39/112>B

!EB *7: `,7 9*:++:0*2)+ =.1:+)

@H

E ?H c,0)+

232 8;;+@7&67+9; +< 4767G"9; 79 ?+@7 A%+6"@67+9

%

#C

#V

#B


40/112@G

C V

B

H

!GH

)98 `7,Q `,7:.-9

># %4.8< 3H## >>

2

>G

>!

>#

>>


41/112@!

#G!!!! !#H

!>

[8!YX 231 [FX 8YY\48[D\* \T TV*R? T>\H Z8HX?

\T 4F8*4X T\> *Z\? U/01/W

8%"& ?=&%" 79 6=" 6+6


42/112@#

!H

!H

8,0

2

>C


43/112@>

[8!YX 23/ [FX 8YY\48[D\* \T TV*R? T\> *Z\?T>\H HV*D4DA8Y !VRZX[? D* XV> D* /011

HE97@75L: TE9'; #+@&6"'


44/112@@

37,D

!H

`,++,b.9-

>V

2

>V


45/112@E

# >

+.O.9- .9

@H

[8!YX 232 Y\48Y ?\4D8Y BXYT8>X ?X>SD4X? D* H\*[X*XZ>\

?"%,7@" *Z\ AE.#7@

79;63

Y+@

;"#<$+,"%9-"96

>"'

4%+;; [+6

;233,7* `,7 +.O.9- .9 ) `)Q.+a

Y).+a 0)7:R0:9*7: B C !?

;233,7*:8 +.O.9- # ! >

!B ## @!

!? @ #G

O.0: !G !G

!! # !>

+)*.,9

# #

Y).+a Q:)+ ! # >

;24D*,*)+ CG V # #V !GV

!> ! ! !E

# #

B B

@G %4.8< 3H!V@! %4.8< 3H #E@

-*+,0&*"7

>B

@G

@!


46/112@?

> >

#! > #@

!G !G

@? # @V

J:8.)*.,9 # # !E !E

E E

> >

C C

! !

@ @

! !

Q:8.)*.,9

E ! ?

! !

! !

! !

Q:8.)*.,9

! !

;24D*,*)+ !E! C ! !EB

M,*)+ ##! !E # #B #?C

2


47/112@C

[8!YX 23I Y\48Y ?\4D8Y BXYT8>X ?X>SD4X? D* H\*[X*XZ>\844\>RD*Z [\ [FX [8>ZX[ Z>\VA

[&%$"6 $%+E5 *E-."% +<;"%,7@";

A"%@"96&$"+< ;",7@";


48/112@V

!

K +)7-: 92Q4:7 ,` 9,9D-,O:79Q:9*)+ ,7D

#H

>H

@@ %4.8< 3H ?@E %4.8< 3H !#

2

./*+1))7 :41/1 ,/1 "* +-1,/ ;1+4,"&);)

@@

@E

@?


49/112@B

23I ?E--&%: &9' >"@+--"9'&67+9;


50/112EG

/3 8',+@&@: `+%C


51/112E!

I $LIKM%K

I31 89:;7; +< 6=" Y"$ T%&-"`+%C

[=" 4+9;676E67+9 +< 6=" >"5E.#7@ +< 4%+&67&

*.0+: >FH 0.)+ ,` ,41:0D

Q)99:7

[=" ?+@7 B"#


52/112E#

I

Q::*.9- `,7:.-9

_:D

$LIKM%K


53/112E>


54/112E@

I

!H

@C

$LIKM%K


55/112EE

I3/ 89:;7; +< 6=" D9;676E67+9 T%&-"`+%C

M !

#H

> @

@V

@V

@B

EG

E!


56/112E?

*.,9 ,`

,3:7)*.,9)+ )+.5:FH

!H

+.Q.*:8#

I

E#

E>

$LIKM%K


57/112EC

37:O).+>H

I32 8;;+@7&67+9; +< 4767G"9; ?VD>CGEE E? %4.8< 3H >?@EC P)-7:4< #G!#< 3H @#

E@

EE

E?

EC


58/112EV

!

#

>H

@

EV EB %4.8< 3H C?G %4.8< 3H !E?! %4.8< 3H #B

I

EV

EB

?G

?!

81;,"3 6*/

$LIKM%K


59/112EB

EH ?H \.9)++a<

C V +:`* .9.*.)DBHe

?# %4.8< 3H >V?> %4.8< 3H @G

?#

?>

?@

?E

??


60/112?G

I

! `7,Q #G!!

#H

AQ).9D

? -,8.9.

?C

?V

$LIKM%K


61/112?!

.9 #G!>FH

>H

?B


62/112?#

I

+)*:7 ,9F

[8!YX I31 R8[8 \* 8AA>\SXR A>\bX4[? \T 4D[D^X*?] 8??\4D8[D\*?!_ [FX HD*D?[>_ \T ?\4D8Y A\YD4_ 8*R _\V[F

A"%7+' 8%"& *E-."% +<

&;;+@7&67+9;

8,"%&$"

.E'$"6FK*

8,"%&$"

.E'$"6XV>

[+6

.E'$"6FK*

[+6

.E'$"6XV>

#G!GD#G!>

3:7.,8

&7,*:0*.,9

>E #EV@


63/112?>

[8!YX I3/ \SX>SDXB \T 8S8DY8!YX TV*R? T\> 8??\4D8[D\*? BD[F[FX HD*D?[>_ \T ?\4D8Y A\YD4_ 8*R _\V[F T\> /01/

M,*)+)Q,29*

M,*)+)Q,29*

%Q3+:Q:9*)*.,9 3:7.,8

EEG

>>


64/112?@

I

I3I ?E--&%: &9' >"@+--"9'&67+9; +#" +< 6=" *Z\ ;"@6+%3

$LIKM%K


65/112?E

>"@+--"9'&67+9;


66/112??

J (I;INI

J31 89:;7; +< 6=" Y"$ T%&-"`+%C

M

)98


67/112?C

0.702D

$:9*7:

[=" Y&` +9 ?+@7 &9' T&-7#: ?"%,7@";


68/112?V

J3/ 89:;7; +< 6=" D9;676E67+9 T%&-"`+%C

M

J (I;INI

+,.,+&0&1) 0* ,3;&"&)01/ 041 )*+&,-


69/112?B

;:3*:Q4:7 #G!>FH

3)7*.02+)7+a


70/112CG

! #

>H

7:3+)0:Q:9* @H

C#

#G!!

J (I;INI

C#

C>

C@

CE


71/112C!

J32 8;;+@7&67+9; +< 4767G"9; 79 ?+@7 A%+6"@67+9

)98 7,+: `,7 9,9D-,O:79Q:9*)+

298:7

! #H >H

C?

CC

CV


72/112C#

!

;:3*:Q4:7 #G!>FH

#H 7) >

3H!>?

J (I;INI

6/*; &"01/",0&*",- 62"3)( ,"3 *041/ +*2"0/&1)(

/1./1)1"07

CB

VG

V!


73/112C>

,` @H Y:)+.9-

E

? CH VH

V@

V#

V>

V@

VE

V?


74/112C@

!H

#H c:)O.9-

>H

@H

#G!>< 3H > #G!>< 3H !>

#G!>< 33H !CD!V

J (I;INI

VC

VV

VB

BG


75/112CE

)98 ! ) B!

B!


76/112C?

#H

B# #GGV< 3H E!

J (I;INI

B#


77/112CC

J3I ?E--&%: &9' >"@+--"9'&67+9;


78/112CV

13 X;6&.#7;=79$ -"@=&97;-;


79/112CB

L31 89:;7; +< 6=" Y"$ T%&-"`+%C

6,H !?R#GG# !#BR#GGC

L


80/112VG

`,7 37,*:0*.,9<

L


81/112V!

L3/ 89:;7; +< 6=" D9;676E67+9 T%&-"`+%C

M

! .9

,` W7:)* =7.*).9< #GGE

B>


82/112V#

428-:*.9- #H

8:O:+,3:8>H

@HB@

#G!G =:+-7)8:Z $cY;< #GG?

L

B@

BE

B?


83/112V>

.9 4:0,Q: ̀ 290*.,9)+H

;:D

.98:3:98:9* +.`:H

:+8:7+a 3:,3+: A!#FH


84/112V@

EH

?H

[8!YX L31 \SX>SDXB \T Y\48Y ?X>SD4X? D* ?X>!D8 D* /01/

;:7O.0: 62Q4:7 ,` +,0)+

:+8:7+a 3:,3+:

!##

Y).+a )00,QQ,8)*.,9 `,7

C!

>C

$+24 #V

L

BC

BV


85/112VE

#G

#!

!V

!?

a,29- 3:,3+:

!E

!E

Y).+a )00,QQ,8)*.,9 `,7:+8:7+a 3:,3+:

!#

!!

Y).+a )00,QQ,8)*.,9 `,7 +)b

!G

B

Y7,3D.9 0:9*7: @

E

C

BB


86/112V?

,` )++ )O:7)-:+a !

[8!YX L3/ ?F8>X \T Y\48Y ?XYTQZ\SX>*HX*[? D* [FX TD*8*4D*Z \TY\48Y ?X>SD4X? D* ?X>!D8

;:7O.0:

Y).+a )00,QQ,8)*.,9 `,7 :+8:7+a 3:,3+:

Y7,3D.9 0:9*7:

L

!GG


87/112VC

4F8>[ L31 4\HA8>D?\* \T TD*8*4D*Z ?\V>4X?


88/112VV

!

L32 8;;+@7&67+9; +< 4767G"9; 79 ?+@7 A%+6"@67+9

#?E Q.++.,9# >H

@ E

!G#

L

!G!

!G#

!G>

!G@

!GE


89/112VB

!H

)8:D

#H

!GC

!G?


90/112BG

[8!YX L32 ?\V>4X? \T TD*8*4D*Z2

/00J /00O

c,0)+ -,O:79Q:9*

L:-.,9)+ -,O:79Q:9*

.9 #G!#@ H

*, 37,O.8: ) 4)95 -2)7)9*:: `,7 ) *:98:7< `,7 :])Q3+:H %9 )88.*.,9< Q)9a +,0)+

L

!GV

!GB


91/112B!

=:9:D 0,90:79.9-

E

A\ ?XK[\>V

!!G


92/112B#

[8!YX L3I ?F8>X \T ?X>SD4X A>\SDRX>? T>\H [FX *Z\ ?X4[\>

;:7O.0:

Y7,3D.9 0:9*7:

Y).+a )00,QQ,8)*.,9 `,7 :+8:7+a 3:,3+:

$+24

L


93/112B>

[8!YX L3J ?[>V4[V>X \T ?X>SD4X? A>\SDRXR !_ [FX *Z\ ?X4[\>

;:7O.0: M,*)+ 92Q4:7 ,`

Y).+a )00,QQ,8)*.,9 `,7

>C

3:,3+:

>#

!!

!!

B

E

$+24 E

Y).+a )00,QQ,8)*.,9 `,7:+8:7+a 3:,3+:

@

Y).+a )00,QQ,8)*.,9R0:9*7:

>

Y7,3D.9 0:9*7: >

>

!

!

!

G

.98:3:98:9*

G


94/112B@

!H

8:O:+,3Q:9*)+

L

!!!


95/112BE

L3I ?E--&%: &9' >"@+--"9'&67+9;


96/112B?

/3 8',+@&@: `+%C


97/112BC

c31 D96%+'E@67+9 &9' XP5#&9&67+9

)F

c


98/112BV

A#F ,4*).9:8FT :*0H

c3/ Y+@ &9' *&67+9 T+E9'&67+9;

c


99/112BB

b:++D7,,*:8F<

! A`,7Q:7 =$%\ ' =)+5)9 ;:74.) ,`

!!#


100/112!GG

c32 >"$7;6"%; +< ?"%,7@" A%+,7'"%;

.9*:7O:D

c3I *"6`+%C; +< ?"%,7@" A%+,7'"%;

c


101/112!G!

c3J >";+E%@" 4"96%";

1:0*

,7


102/112!G#

c3L 4%+;;Q?"@6+% D9767&67,";

8:Q)98.9-

)O).+)4+: Q)9)-:7.D

$7,)*.))98 J,9*:9:-7,F


103/112!G>

N31 Z"9"% 4+9@#E;7+9; &9' >"@+--"9'&67+9;

6=" 5%7+%767";


104/112!G@

>"@+--"9'&67+9 23 A%+,7'79$ ;E55+%6


105/112!GE

>"@+--"9'&67+9 /a 8',+@&@:


106/112!G?

>"@+--"9'&67+9 2a 8',+@&@:


107/112!GC

>"@+--"9'&67+9 Ja 8',+@&@:


108/112!GV

N32 8',+@&@: H&6%7@";

[8!YX N31 >X4\HHX*R8[D\*? !_ 4\V*[>_

J,9*:9:-7,

K8O,0)0a b,75 ̀ ,7 Q2+*.Da:)7 ̀ 298.9-

$7,)*.)

N


109/112!GB

;:74.)

[8!YX N3/ *8[D\*8Y >X4\HHX*R8[D\*? [F8[ 4\VYR F8SX

>XZD\*8Y 4F8>84[X>

J,9*:9:-7, K8O,0)0a b,75 ̀ ,7 Q2+*.Da:)7 `298.9-

$7,)*.)

;:74.)

;74.1)


110/112!!G

[8!YX N32 >XZD\*8Y >X4\HHX*R8[D\*?

!

9)*.,9)+ )98 7:-.,9)+ +:O:+H

9.O,2H

#

>

K

@

E

?

C

N


111/112!!!

Y7;6 +< 79;676E67+9; `="%" 79Q'"56= 796"%,7"`; `"%" E9'"%6&C"9a

J,9*:9:-7,Z

$7,)*.)Z

;:74.)Z

O


112/112

Documents

Comparative analysis of the Role of Civil Society in Providing Social Welfare Services in the Western Balkans