Aneel Mumtaz <aneehnumtaz@gmall.com>

BY POST, FAX, EMAIL

FOREIGN ENTITY ROBS PAKISTAN CITIZENS OF RS. 130 BilLIONS & COUNTING- VOL-16

Anee' Mumtaz <aneelmumtaZ@gmafl.com> Mon, May 5. 2014 at 8:40 AMTo: registrar@nepra.org.pk, !'EPRA <cad@nepra.org.pk>, NEPRA MAIN <office@nepra.org.pk>. info@nepra.org.pk. secretary@mowp.gov.pkCc: "secretary@sioohenergy.gov.pk" <seaetary@sioohenergy.gov.pk>. 'aLabbasi@yahoo.com" <taLabbasi@yahoo.com>, "dg@fla.gov.pk" <dg@fta.gov.pk>."dir.khI@fia.gov.pk" <dir.khi@fia.gov.pk>, "adg.admn@fia.gov.pk" <adg.admn@fia.gov.pk>, "chairman@nab.gov.pk" <chairman@nab.gov.pk>,"'donab@nab.gov.pk" <infonab@nab.gov.pk>, "siooh@nab.gov.pk" <sindh@nab.gov.pk>, "add secretary 1@mowp.gov.pk" <addsecretary1@mowp.gov.pk>,"addsecretary@mowp.gov.pk" <addsecretary@mowp.gov.pk>, jsadmin@mowp.gov.pk" <jsadmin@mowp.gov.pk>, ']swater@mowp.gov.pk"<jswater@mowp.gov.pk>. "jspower@rnowp.gov.pk" <jspower@mowp.gov.pk>, "dsadmin@mowp.gov.pk" <dsadmin@mowp.gov.pk>, "dspower@mowp.gov.pk"<dspower@mowp.gov.pk>, "dsdiscos@mowp.gov.pk" <dsdlscos@mowp.gov.pk>, "80a1@mowp.gov.pk" <80a1@mowp.gov.pk>. "sogenl@mowp.gov.pk"<sogenl@mowp.gov.pk>, "sop2@mowp.gov.pk" <sop2@mowp.gov.pk>. "sop-4@mowp.gov.pk" <sop-4@mowp.gov.pk>, "sop3@mowp.gov.pk"<sop3@mowp.gov.pk>. "cfao@mowp.gov.pk" <cfao@mowp.gov.pk>, "aobf@mowp.gov.pk" <aobf@mowp.gov.pk>. "fa@mowp.gov.pk" <fa@mowp.gov.pk>,"dfa@mowp.gov.pk" <dfa@mowp.gov.pk>. "cs.slndt@sirdh.gov.pk" <cs.sindh@sindh.gov.pk>. "chr.ena@8indh.gov.pk" <cIT.ena@sindh.gov.pk>,"secretary.home@sindh.gov.pk" <secretary.home@sindh.gov.pk>. "registrar@sindhtighcourt.gov.pk" <registrar@slndhhighcourt.gov.pk>,"maH@supremecou1.gov.pk" <mail@supremecoLlt.gov.pk>. "fl8ccck@gmafl.com" <fiaccck@gmaiJ.com>. "adg.ecw@fia.gov.pk" <adg.ecw@fia.gov.pk>,"dir.admn@fia.gov.pk" <dir.admn@fia.gov.pk>, "seaetary@interior.gov.pk" <secretary@interior.gov.pk>. "complaints@secp.gov.pk" <complaintS@secp.gov.pk>."abdullah.zafar@secp.gov.pk" <abduIJah.zafar@secp.gov.pk>. ""nntiaz.haider@secp.gov.pk" <imtiaz.haider@secp.gov.pk>. "tahir.metmood@Secp.gov.pk"<tatir.metlnood@secp.gov.pk>, "rashid.piracha@secp.gov.pk" <rashid .piracha@secp.gov.pk>. "asif.jalal@secp.gov.pk" <asit.jalal@secp.gov.pk>,"shahid.nasim@secp.gov.pk" <shahid.naslm@secp.gov.pk>, "wazirqadeerullah@yahoo.com" <wazlrqadeenJlah@yahoo.com>, 'anvir1 gS9@yahoo.com"<tanvlr1959@yahoo.com>. "mahfoozito@yahoo.com" <mahfoozito@yahoo.com>, "assembly@na.gov.pk" <assembly@na.gov.pk>, "sbano@cc.gov.pk"<sbano@CC.gov.pk>, "mabi@cc.gov.pk" <mabi@cc.gov.pk>. "mbatlay@cc.gov.pk" <mbatlay@cc.gov.pk>. "oftcomplalnts@cc.gov.pk"<oftcomplaints@cc.gov.pk>. "agpr@agpr.gov.pk" <agpr@agpr.gov.pk>. "addLag@agpr.gov.pk" <addLag@agpr.gov.pk>. "so_coord 1@finance.gov.pk"<so_ coord 1@finance.gov.pk>, "info@privatisation.gov.pk" <info@privatisationgov.pk>, "contact@molaw.gov.pk" <contact@molaw.gov.pk>,"soHcitor@molaw.gov.pk" <solicitor@molaw.gov.pk>. "Info@ppra.org.pk" <info@ppra.org.pk>, "mdppra@ppra.org.pk" <mdppra@ppra.org.pk>,"dgppra@ppra.org.pk" <dgppra@ppra.org.pk>. ainfo@kcci.com.pk" <info@kcci.com.pk>, "secretary@kccl.com.pk" <secretary@kcci.compk>.

m_shahzad@hotmall.com" <s_m_shahzad@hotmail.com>. "presldent@kcd.com.pk" <president@kcci.com.pk>, "adminpo@aptma.org.pk"Jmin:po@aptma.org.pk>, "adilkhanonline@gmail.com" <adilkhanonline@gmaB.com>. "rashid.qarar@dunya.com.pk" <rashid.qarar@dunya.com.pk>.

"mLd1ammad.mohsln@samaa.tv" <mmammad.mohsin@samaa.tv>. "kati@katl.pk" <kati@katl.pk>. "md@slte.com.pk" <md@Slte.com.pk>,"secretary@Site.com.pk" <seaetary@site.com.pk>. "farooq@site.com.pk" <farooq@Slte.com.pk>, "complaint@site.com.pk" <complaint@site.com.pk>, PEeKaracti <karachl@pec.org.pk>, "admir@sindtbarcotJ1Cll.org" <admin@siootbarcotJ1CiJ.org>. "info@shcba-pk.com" <Info@shcba-pk.com>."Info@pakistanbarcomcil.org" <Info@paklstanbarcouncil.org>. trlnfo@scbap.com" <info@scbap.com>, "ti.paklstan@gmaU.com" <ti.pakistan@gmail.com>,"hrcp@hrcp-web.org" <hrcp@hrcp-web.org>, "trust@helpUnetrust.org" <trust@helptinetrust.org>, "info@helpfinetrust.org" <info@helplinetrust.org>,ttcpC@helpftnetrust.org" <cpc@helpllnetrust.org>, "amber@salgol.com" <amber@saigol.com>, ttmazharchou:fhary_kesC@yahoo.com"<mazharchooohary _kesC@yahoo.com>, "feroz12000@yahoo.com" <feroz12000@yahoo.com>, "secy.forest@siroh.gov.pk" <secy. forest@sindh.gov.pk>,"dg@ispr.gov.pk" <dg@ispr.gov.pk>, "coord@lspr.gov.pk" <coord@ispr.gov.pk>, "ps.cm@baloctistan.gov.pk" <ps.cm@balochistangov.pk>,"info@mohtasib.gov.pk" <info@mohtaslb.gov.pk>, "complalnts@mohtasib.gov.pk" <complalntS@mohtasib.gov.pk>, "wmsrok@mohtasib.gov.pk"<wmsrok@mohtaslb.gov.pk>. "dagsr@agpr.gov.pk" <dagsr@agpr.gov.pk>. "dagcp@agpr.gov.pk" <dagcp@agpr.gov.pk>. "dagaC@agpr.gov.pk"<dagaC@agpr.gov.pk>. "dagfp@agpr.gov.pk" <dagfp@agpr.gov.pk>. "ansar.abbasi@thenews.com.pk" <ansar.abbasi@thenews.com.pk>,"orya.maqbool@dunya.com.pk" <orya.maqbool@dunya.com.pk>. "rauf.klasra@dunya.com.pk" <rauf.kJasra@dunya.com.pk>. "Ialkhan1956@gmall.com"<laIkhan1956@gmail.com>. "habib.akram@dU1)'a.com.pk" <habib.akram@dU1)'a.com.pk>. "muhammad.zahid.khar(g)senate.gov.pk"<mltlanvnad.zahld.khan@senate.gov.pk>. "hamaytnkhanmandkhel@senate.gov.pk" <hamaYlnkhanmaookhel@senate.gov.pk>. "khabar@dlJ'lyatv.tv"<khabar@dunyatv.tv>, "nadeem.malik@hotmall.com" <nadeem.malik@hotmaa.com>. "sa@arynews.tv" <sa@arynews.tv>, "report@tU'cp-web.org"<report@hrcp-web.org>, "tY1khan2012@gmaH.com" <f1lkhan2012@gmail.com>. karlmb.shaikh@yahoo.com. faisalhussain115@yahoo.com,shavalzzaslam@hotmail.com~ shakeelkhan10@hobnail.com. Irshad AD <irshad.ch@grnaD.com>. chalrmar@pec.org.pk. registrar@pec.org.pk.kamrariqbaJawan@hotmaH.com, mshafa125@yahoo.com, editor@dawncom. editor@daiytimes.com.pk, ed@sdpl.org. aegtcell@gmail.com,help@pakistarrangerssiooh.org, zohra.muntaz@hotmail.com. Shazla Hasan <shaziahasan@gmail.com>, Engr G R Bhatti <grbhatti@pec.org.pk>. Pas banPakistan <pasban.ppick@gmaiJ.com>. abdul.wali@jeha~akistan.com. info@voic&againstcorruption.pk, armari)369best@yahoo.com, Kazrni sahab<aa.kazmi05@gmafl.com>. mtbf.secretarlat@finance.gov.pk. prspsecretariat@finance.gov.pk. mail@agpr.gov.pk. khulicofTl4Jfior@newsonetv.tv.info@pmo.gov.pk, info@mowp.gov.pk

6

REF NO. AN/SCOP/1512014DATE: MAY OS, 2014

,~~,I~..JI~..J

~ ~1,G-S/1~,(~I)~.J:' L-Sfl '..J-Jlj 1#

:-

~tH ~"l ~ ~ ~ (~IJI) 'N' K UjJ,.Jt ,J~I..ti 4=}JA c-S~ :~- ,,JJ"""l) ut' 'N ,,s

~.>l ~Wa'Jx:.' c?f:. ~ t.~ ..J~' ~ t;S c.S..J4- fi 2014~...;J30 ~ uy.. ~ ~l ,I~ JjL..q..J y~. ~~

..J4i-\<.r.~ u..>- J~\ <.»- ~.J4 do KESC 4~y1 K ~ duA'Jx:.\ '..»- clt; ~ yo.. y~.1c+i cftJ J~1 Ct I~ ~ OJ'- ~ _Uj..1J·0-1 ~ ~ - ~ ~ C6. ~ wJfi l.Sf ~ U&i~\

y~l c:? wJt-i? 0 lfi ~ ~ J-Jl '.c...¥ 'ru do wJ.) 01 ~ rJ~ ¥J ~ \S ~~ t.»A t;S "i'-J l::-Jw;" ·2.,-:? J~' fi. u.-..\-'p-y ~ uS 0~

..J-J~ J.,._~ c'"""'U~ (KESC Sl:J ~ ~ L.S~ ~Ifi ~\....a) KEPl" ~ cf J~t -d- ~l yw;"-3~,~ c?4- ~ JJ j:J fi ~ .J~ ~ ua1ii! y a..l~.,.. ell.J ~ C" J:i 2 (BQPS-1)~

~ ~ yl fi jL~ .J~ 01 KEPl 'J'.J ~"-d u-lfi J.Jo'"'d.J J.,e. c?1.,Y. ~I~y ~'J ~~ 2014 fie! ~ 2009) u-i1 ~ ~J-'yA ~ ~'J ~I yl,..S ~ tsU ~ ~ do ~'JI ui..wtd ~ ~~d t.»ti ~ u~ ~J.J-l~ ~ ~.fi~ ,...i'J~ ~ KEPl-(cu ~ 2 ~'J ~ \.fifd LSfJ 4- ~ Jfu:.lJ:!A 2014 L1J~1 ul~-, ~ w...alpy ~ ~ u-i~ ~J lJ:!A 2012 .Jt,iS1 KEPL,.,S

!d ..llya ~ c-' "t(" y.,1.,.S. ~ dJ t.SJi..- I'-j cJL-»'- ~So '-.-as fl \S '-*\:i...J Jil ~y1a <» ~ '-*tl...1 ~ J-Jl~ ~ 3}Su.J 2 0:--y.. d'dwyl 2 -4

SON, YOUNG SES y~ (aASID MAHMUD y~ (b

KUSNADI SUKARJA y~ (cSHAHERYAR CHISHT y~ (d

2- 01 ~ 0 ~y ~ ~ I~ ~ <.r.,...jd ~y ~ I~l ~ ~~.fJ,...j~ 'J4~~ 0'frJ~ 'd~ P~ ~\S 3.J1.S.J.J~

'-0# 10M rj).La J-JIU# ~ 1-~..Y~ ,t,J# ~ CEO uiJ ~ SHAHERYAR CHISHT OR CHISHTY

COAL ~ COAL CONVERSION ~ ~ c:} 0:--y... 01 ,..S0 ti.J;' ~ ~ ~ Ui'fi c:!- dA 0~ L»" L.J4 do l»- j:L 0''d~~rlS~~-J~START

."~J ~ _y ~ f~ ~ ~ ~l'!a~· ~..Ji....::...J ,.;t. c.? J.-h ~ J..ufi ~ ~ uti...6l; ~ ~yl-K ~ -5

U# dA ~ ~ ~ lJA?o L.lJA lJ"10 tt t;S ~.hi. ~ IS PT TITAN MINING, INDO~SlJ\ -6!d w.JF.L....;l0 ...u..u.. .» uiJ~ t.sf ~ J-J'd ~y o¥ ~ 0 ~..P rU y ,..j lS lJ"1

c.? ~J uy- ~ oJfi.j.e OJ'- oal 0 ~~...sJ....l...hi..J'?>lS PT TITAN MINING, INDONESIA -7lS EXPERTISE J-JI~l uS U-' J-J' lS~ ~.o tsfJ fi P lS INVESTMENT ~ ~I.)

fU~d~~~

6' JJI BRIG.HT EAGLE ENTERPRISES GROUP LIMITED .JJ' PT TITAN MlNI~G, INDONESIA l:iS-8

NOC C"" ,Ji.1J ~.JIj.J ~ ~~I·cS SPECIAL PURPOSE COMPANY ~",d \.;S ~~

"

>f6

.J'" ~~ ys ~ l.S.ft.at' ~ &..oS~' !.J-JL; uS- PT TITAN MINING, INDONESIA.9~.fi J~" UI.A'py ys -d ~ .§J ~ ~ \S ua' ~ CJ.iL.a'-:J.U ~'uS- 0' ~ ~~ ua' l.J# uL.~

t~ ~ ~~ ~ ua' ~ u~l"

1999 ri.,JLt.01 ~J~ SRO NO. 142 (1)/99 ~ ",)~,~, 2'~ .J'" UH cY1 ~ '.J~ ylNEPRA (APPLICATION AND MODIFICATION PROCEDURE) REGULATION, 1999 UH ~~ fl \S

~t~ u~~ U\A~.,s ~l fi ~ y..a ~ ~~ 2 ~"'i ci'Ji u.w.1~.;J 3 ~ 2

3.(5)(b) a reasonably detailed profile of the experience of the applicant, itsmanagement staff and its members in the electricity industry;

(5)(c) the curriculum vitae of the applicant's senior management, technicaland professional staff;

(5)(d)(i) cash balances held in reserve along with the bank certificates;(5)(d)(iv) employment records of engineering and technical staff of the

applicant proposed to be employed;(5}{d}(v) profile of sub-contractors, if any, along with expressions of interest of

such sub-contractors; and(5)(d)(vi) verifiable references in respect of the experience of the applicant and

its proposed sub-contractors;5. Eligibility criteria.-(1) The Authority may, in considering an

application for the grant of a licence, take into account such factorsas may be deemed relevant by the Authority, including the following:

5.(1)(a) business experience of the applicant, its management staff,sub--contractors, engineering and technical staff in the electricpower industry, if any;

(1)(c) the ability of the applicant to comply with the conditios of the licence; .

,.S a lfSJ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~4 26'il c-a ell.:?2 coal start instrument ~ ~yl 2 -11,.S ~ d ~ ys fl t.l+"" e:-J42~)~l.S.»Jl~ uy..o.~ ~~ citfJ 2 JL Y~ ~

-d ~ ~ paste .J'" copy ~ cut.... YJ.J ~ ,.$ d ~

cli ~.;."..us.~y1L.~ lJ:!A (.)'I' a~SJ...u..J!,,~ ~~, ~ ~ clip 2 uylL. ~ ~Y'-2 -12~..J.,...us~"\!lLt.to 1St.;.fi ~ .J~' \S ~Ip U...>- ~ e:-.J4 d-~~ 2 6~Lo c.»-Ui"el'"..J."b ~ ~u ys a~~ o¥ 1St .J .J"I ~ rli .iJ .J \S 01 UH C6- ~ C' l)Q~' lft ~ ~"u..u~

~ t...y' c.»- ~j~ 2 uylL. lJ:!A (i)(d){5).3 ~ 2 "I ) IJ'I;!' ~! a~ ..)f J~ J!\jjJ.J~ ~,~

fUH ~ ~ ~yU ~ manner of fraud or chicanery or violation of law ~u..u ~I ~ fd lfSJ

tUH CJS JilU;, ~.1\S' .J.11 ~ JAfi ~ ~y' -2 ys

~I d ~-""~~ ~ e:-~ 2 profile 2 ,J.';Y'?)i.z4~, ~, PT TITAN MINING, INDONESIA .13

oFT c:::::.1al... ~ .J'" rU ~ I'.J .iJ 2 UJ..fi ~JUI UJ.A e:-J4 2TITAN GROUP ~ l.»- ~ (.)'I' !d lJ.~t~

(a) TATA GROUP INDIA

.t (il) ~ITAN GROUP OF COMPANIES (RUSSIA)· ~..·...t··,·~..R" Emission Eqtipmenr~ JpoL. ~ 4 .J'" 3 ~~ \S 1 ~ r""u ~,.S o~.fi ~ fi 64 (.)'I' ,~ ~ -14

4' • t,· m.a I ,.s• l,»f c..)f ~ l.»t"' ~UH c . va ues

~'.PJ COAL START INSTRUMENT ~,.s d u:ti lu.:?' ~ ~, <.»"' ~p.... .J'Jt 11 2 KESCL ys .15UH LEADING PRIVATE EQUITY INVESTOR ,.s ~ ~~I <!'.,.HI ~ KESeL t~ ~ .J~.llA lJ:!A

":l ~ fUH ..)~-"" ell.1 cl~ ~Lo.»Jl300 ~jij (,)ll~ c!- 01,.oS ~ c?.fi ~ w~ ~,,~ \S ~Lc..»Jl..)p 0.1

a~ U4 ~ ~ fl,»f Liabilities ~ C~.J y.;' 279 ~ ~~, <!'.,.H' ~jll~ ~ KESCL "S d ~to u..)f l.i.>i c.»- clfi J-6.. ,..;a.) .J.1Icl~ 1'.JL..J"A"s

~I.fi ~~I~y ~ ~~I.., EPC CONTRACT ~ td ~ ~I.., fi EPC c;:} <s?'yl-2 ~ ·17!d~

U.J-f ~ ~~ l.>.!-- t::-.J4 cf wji....!ly...y Ll:!~~y1. ~ ~Ifi ~ l.>.!-- t::-).)I 2 ~1 ,~u..;h I~I LJ:!A ~ .19fw~ y;J tv ~ ~ ~ fi ~ ~ [1 fi ~ yl..t?- ~ ts ~I ufo. t::-.J4 2 LP.-

i) AN'PEC/03/2013 DATED JUlY 19,2013 ii) AWSCOP/06/2013 DATED OCTOBER 21,2013ii) AN'SCOP/07/2013 DATED NOV 26,2013 iii) AWSCOP/08l2013 DATED DECEMBER 11,~P13iv) ANISCOP/09/2014 DATED JAN 01,2014 v) ANfSCOP/10/2014 DATED FEBRUARY 02,2014VI) ANISCOP/11/2014 DATED FEB 15, 2014 vii) 25-G/KESCl01812014 DATED FEB 20,2014

viiI) AN'SCOPI1212014 DATED MAR 14, 2014 be)ANiSCOP/1312014 DATED MARCH 23,2014x) AN'SCOP/14/2014 DATED APR 06, 2014 xi) EMAIL DATED MARCH 31, 2014 TIME 0828 PM

xii) 25-G/NEPRN030/2013 DATED OCT 20, 2013

, ot.. 26 c¥ ~t!J COAL START IGNITORS uy-.;; 4 .JJI 3 Cu~ c:S BQPS-1 ~ ~yl-c:S .20~ ~ rtsts lS..,.) W...u.» ~I U!A.JY,..:i!~,.;!Y ~ l)"l,..s d w4 ~I.., c310:" ~ ~ ~ ·d~ aiJtS2 ~1..,4 560 ~ 0'" ~lh.. 2 ~.J~.J j~ ~I ~ KESCl ~ c..J#c?fi w4 21 ~ L>"ld ¥.J

, -l»" ot. 24 ult ~ d CA ~ l.J:iA ot.. 24 uy..o (J...L) ~~ .J4-J...l:..0u.-st;~....F2 0"1 ~ d ¥.J ~ \.:S ¥.J JW..>F j. Cu~ c!- ~IJ4 388 c¥ ot.. 260' \.:S

!~I.., ~-'f u:ti.iJ J._1-ua ~ ~~ ~j.lJ~ fi d tSt.J ~ ~t.,.., lSft1,..s..t?- ~ J6.. LJ~j c.sS~ ~U:aJj1 [1~1.iJ~ ~ ~ tS ~ ~ U!A ~I.., 4 650 ~ NTDC ~,.s d.)~ ~ fi ~ ~~~ ~ t::-jl..,y c:Swil.)C. c¥ ~ti.. ryl.. ~I fi ~.J'" fi wfi.,l.J..,1 ~ t:J ~ ~ jIJl 0L-..1

~J fi ..t?-SHUT ~.:l.Ji. ~ ot.. 26 ~ U!A ~ ~IJ 4 388 ,..s t::-.l yl..t?- ~tl:.1i1 [I~' yl ~

fLHfi <.S.Jt;J~~ ~~.,l UlJi ~ Y uiJ~ ~~~ cf ~.Ji. r!.F- ~ ~Ifi ~ L>"I ~ d

fi c1 c-- 2012 ~ 4.1..,13 Cu-,=,BQPS-1 ~ .)..t?-J4 2~~ 4.14 t::-...»-,..s d~'" ys y~ -21tu~ .J..,I 'St.J~ ($.) u:ri ~.J.}J...J~ ~fiJS. ~ ~ tF ~ ~ yl

~ ~ lS~~ y~ .J..,I ~I~ u.Jlt. y~ ,~L..:. JL.S ~\.§ y~ ~ u.,lt.,.., ~ ~,..s d~'" ys .214 w# c~ fi tJ:ti tw tS ~Ijic.l 01 ~.J..,h ~I w~ ~ U# c""J ~.iJ wl...,Qljicl,..s..t?- ~L..:. '

d~'" ~ f W# ~.J-f SCRIPT w~ cf 0' ~ ,41 ("J;!A~.) ~ ~ I~ ~ 2014 ~~I 03 ,..sfc..J#c?u.;w:ati ~ c.ifi t~ tS u# ~I .JJI U# c'4-.-'t.»'3 21 c;S Jll..,..}'Ji~ 2 I~ y6....:.1~

tJ:ti ~ ":J~~' ~ uy- ~L.H-" UcL.a.... ~I.JC ~ 2013..}.1A~ 19,..s uA ut4 cllfi ~y 3.Jts'u,.;-22,,..s Y?') ~ ~.J ADJOURNED ~~ ~I tY ~I ~ (~ u.Jft, ylfi) c:!- ~ c:?fi

Licensee Proposed Modification of KESel for exdudlng unlt-3 & 4 of Bin Qaslm Power Plant

.~ ~ ~ fi ~ L>"J:!t.. U!A,..s J:.:j ~ (~~

~ 0' tY# c!- ~~ .J..,I Cs~~ c!- A-19 .JJI ,4 ,5 J¥) 2 ~i,.s.J=!" w~ c:? CA u~ Y.,.j,,..s LJ~ tifi ~I UlA

",f "6" ',< ~ <'""1 # wt..I-.U1 I "\,j .t:.~-u;-u <.J:.l. c::- c::-~ y .JJ ~ -r--

~jll- J.Jj1

(LA149646)..;1l- 0..>tj (..;) ~ ~ ul ~-<st1fi ~ ,3..,.J J§.ul ,1I1..GW.J~llS~ ,~25

0364-4011715aneelmumtaz@gmail.com:JJ.. <>1

REF NO. A~SCOP/15/2014DATE: MAY 05, 2014

Carbon Copy To. For Action;·

Gnlail- VOL-16a FOREIGN ENTITY ROBS PAKISTAN CITIZENS RS. 130 BILLION ... Page 1 of 12

CAO •...o. Iq <"CJ '1 (.~:2 .~ ~'...,"'1; ,"""~",,,,__fY1"" .~'f"'1"f"'-::"'_~~'~

G .::'iI' Aneel Mumtaz <aneelmumtaz@gmail.com> !'~1~~t~~O~~~_I~_~~~~~~~_:_~~~~~_K~:~:~~:~~:~~:~~~.~1~_~~~~L~~~~~•••~~Aneel Mumtaz <aneelmumtaz@gmail.com> Tue, Jul22, 2014 at 10:31 AMTo: registrar@nepra.org.pk, NEPRA <cad@nepra.org.pk>, NEPRA MAIN <office@nepra.org.pk>, info@nepra.org.pk, ~secretary@mowp.gov.pk, "feroz12000@yahoo.com" <feroz12000@yahoo.com>Cc: info@pmo.gov.pk, "mail@supremecourt.gov.pk" <mail@supremecourt.gov.pk>, "secretary@interior.gov.pk" ~<se~~etary@interior.gov~pk>,~~bmaster@sindhpolice.gov:pk, "co~tact@molaw.gov.pk" <contact@molaw.gov.pk>, .j ,q,.."sollcltor@molaw.gov.pk" <solJcltor@molaw.gov.pk>, "cs.slndh@slndh.gov.pk" <cs.sindh@sindh.gov.pk>, 'V./z<:l~ I'zohra.mumtaz@hotmail.com, "dg@fia.gov.pk" <dg@fia.gov.pk>, help@pakistanrangerssindh.org, Jwebmasterlhc@lhc.gov.pk, "info@scbap.com" <info@scbap.com>, "info@shcba-pk.com" <info@shcba-pk.com>,info@peshawarhighcourt.gov.pk, Syed Anwar Aftab <registrar@bhc.gov.pk>, "secretary@sindhenergy.gov.pk"<secretary@sindhenergy.gov.pk>, "taLabbasi@yahoo.com" <taLabbasi@yahoo.com>, Director Power DevelopmentSindh <directorpowerdevelopmentsindh@gmail.com>, "dir.khi@fia.gov.pk" <dir.khi@fia.gov.pk>,

· "adg.admn@fia.gov.pk" <adg.admn@fia.gov.pk>, "adg.ecw@fia.gov.pk" <adg.ecw@fia.gov.pk>, aegtcell@gmail.com"dir.admn@fia.gov.pk" <dir.admn@fia.gov.pk>, "chr.ena@sindh.gov.pk" <chr.ena@sindh.gov.pk>, i ~"chairman@nab.gov.pk" <chairman@nab.gov.pk>, "infonab@nab.gov.pk" <infonab@nab.gov.pk>, , ~"assembly@na.gov.pk" <assembry@na.gov.pk>, "so_coord1@finance.gov.pk" <so_coord1@finance.gov.pk>, r % ~mtbf.secretariat@finance.gov.pk, prspsecretariat@finance.gov.pk, "muhammad.zahid.khan@senate.gov.pk" t !l ~<muhammad.zahid.khan@senate.gov.·pk>, "hamayun.khan.mandkhel@senate.gov.pk" 1ft Z<hamayun.khan.mandkhel@senate.gov.pk>, "coord@ispr.gov.pk" <coord@ispr.gov.pk>, "dg@ispr.gov.pk" \, .~. ~<dg@ispr.gov.pk>, "ps.cm@balochistan.gov.pk" <ps.cm@balochistan.gov.pk>, "secretary.home@sindh.gov.pk" t 0~<secretary.home@sindh.gov.pk>, "secretaryJorest" <secretaryJorest@sindh.gov.pk>, Fia Ccc <fiaccck@gmail.com> r <' ~"complaints@secp.gov.pk" <complaints@secp.gov.pk>, "abdullah.zafar@secp.gov.pk" (is'<abdullah.zafar@secp.gov.pk>, "imtiaz.haider@secp.gov.pk" <imtiaz.haider@secp.gov.pk>, 1-- i o·"tahir.mehmood@secp.gov.pk" <tahir.mehmood@secp.gov.pk>, "rashid.piracha@secp.gov.pk" , , ;:j

<rashid.piracha@secp.gov.pk>, "asif.jalal@secp.gov.pk" <asif.jalal@secp.gov.pk>, "shahid.nasim@secp.gov.pk" \ . i<shahid.nasim@secp.gov.pk>, "wazirqadeerullah@yahoo.com" <wazirqadeerullah@yahoo.com>, l"tanvir1959@yahoo.com" <tanvir1959@yahoo.com>, "mahfoozito@yahoo.com" <rnahfoozito@yahoo.com>,"sbano@cc.gov.pk" <sbano@cc.gov.pk>, "nnabi@cc.gov.pk" <nnabi@cc.gov.pk>, "mbatlay@cc.gov.pk"<mbatlay@cc.gov.pk>, "oftcomplaints@cc.gov.pk" <oftcomplaints@cc.gov.pk>, enquiries@secp.gov.pk, rwebmaster@secp.gov.pk, raja.zafarul. haq@senate.gov.pk, sfaisal. raza.abidi@senate.gov .pk, ~syed.zafar.alishah@senate.gov.pk, Mushahid Hussain <mushahid.hussain@gmail.com>, rrabbani@cyber.net.pk,secy.law@sindh.gov.pk, rhassan@cc.gov.pk, ikram@cc.gov.pk, aqadir@cc.gov.pk, akhattak@cc.gov.pk,

· "oia@cc.gov.pk" <oia@cc.gov.pk>, "ssjalal@cc.gov.pk" <ssjalal@cc.gov.pk>, SHOAlS AHMAD SIDDIQUI<commissionerkarachi@gmail.com>, "agpr@agpr.gov.pk" <agpr@agpr.gov.pk>, "dagac@agpr.gov.pk" ~<dagac@agpr.gov.pk>, "dagcp@agpr.gov.pk" <dagcp@agpr.gov.pk>, "dagfp@agpr.gov.pk" <dagfp@agpr.gov.pk>, ~·addLag@agpr.gov.pk" <addLag@agpr.gov.pk>, "info@privatisation.gov.pk" <info@privatisation.gov.pk>, L"info@ppra.org.pk" <info@ppra.org.pk>, "mdppra@ppra.org.pk" <mdppra@ppra.org.pk>, "dgppra@ppra.org.pk"<dgppra@ppra.org.pk>, "secyJorest@sindh.gov.pk" <secy.forest@sindh.gov.pk>, "complaints@mohtasib.gov.pk" III

<complaints@mohtasib.gov.pk>, "wmsrok@mohtasib.gov.pk" <wmsrok@mohtasib.gov.pk>, "dagsr@agpr.gov.pk"<dagsr@agpr.gov.pk>, mail@agpr.gov.pk, aptamasb@cyber.net.pk, "admin.po@aptma.org.pk" ~~<admin.po@aptma.org.pk>, dgadmin@pifra.gov.pk, dgfabs@pifra.gov.pk, directoraudit@pifra.gov.pk,dirba@pifra.gov.pk, dirprocurement@pifra.gov.pk, umarali@pifra.gov.pk, salim@pifra.gov.pk, ciso@pifra.gov.pk,ch.nauman@pifra.gov.pk, rdgkhi@pifra.gov.pk, dgpifralhr@pifra.gov.pk, chairman@pec.org.pk, registrar@pec.org.pk,advisor@pec.org.pk, dpmalik@pec.org.pk, mrehmani@pec.org.pk, aijazshah@pec.org.pk, musaib@pec.org.pk,osaf@pec.org.pk, sehrish@pec.org.pk, ansa~@pec.org.pk, mzuberi.@pec.org.pk, zahra@pec.org.pk, f (1 ·0 ~wasif@pec.org.pk, aftab@pec.org.pk, kmnaslr@pec.org.pk, msohall~pec.org.pk, shahab@pec.org.pk, I ~ ~ ("D

mujeeb@pec.org.pk, haroon~pec.org.pk, drashfaq@pec.org.pk, gkanm~pec.org.pk, arehman@pec.org.pk, r ~; ~ (l'~.

zminhas@pec.org.pk, mhussaln@pec.org.pk, asad@pec.org.pk, khbhaUI@pec.org.pk, awaqas@pec.org.pk, I n.. o' ~helpline@fbr.gov.pk, "md@site.com.pk" <md@site.com.pk>, "farooq@site.com.pk" <farooq@site.com.pk>, ~ : a"complaint@~ite.com.pk" <complaint@~ite.com?k>, karimb.s~aikh@ya~oo.com, fais~!hussain115@yahoo.com, ~ ~: ~Faisal Hussain <apns@apns:com.pk>,.Jnfo@f~cl:com.~k, presld~nt@lccl.org.pk~ fpccl.Isb~cyber.net.pk, . I' ~:, ~ : r

fpccipsh@dslplus.net.pk, fccl.pk@gmall.com, Iccl@braln.net.pk, Infocentre@fccl.com.pk, secretary@kccl.com.~ ~,: S'\· <secretary@kcci.com.pk>, sect@lccLorg.pk, "presiden~@kcci.com:pk" <presi~ent@kc~Lcom.pk~, t ~ r: ~

"s_m_shahzad@hotmail.com" <s_m_s~ahzad@hotmall..com>.' Adll Kh~n <a~llkhano.nhne~gmall.co~>, [~.: ~"secretary@site.com.pk"<sec::~7F::k~:':k" ;kat;tLP;, "istan@gma'Lcom" ~~ ~!)jt (U<-) U ,. ~

file:// /C:/Users/QAUSSAIN/ A~a.\k;~cal/TemplLow/LPZXZPZB.htm 0'\ .0\. \'\ . 7/2 Uf4_$' .&, tIe.-~ _ ~ (.0,1)) c..c: ~ V L I '"'ll.lY-S~L-f) ~ - ~t F ~ fl:)

t"" _ ,.. •. -

,'~~'.l vl'...i.J101"1 L~', 111 '1/ 1,,,GDS PAK1;)TAI~ CI'fllENS RS. 130 BILLIO- T.. Page:2 of 12

<ti.pakistan@gmail.com>, Sayyed Gillani <gilaniadil@gmail.com>, "hrcp@hrcp-web.org" <hrcp@hrcp-web.org>,"report@hrcp-web.org" <report@hrcp-web.org>, "trust@helplinetrust.org" <trust@helplinetrust.org>,"info@helplinetrust.org" <info@helplinetrust.org>, "cpc@helplinetrust.org" <cpc@helplinetrust.org>,"mazharchoudhary_kesc@yahoo.com" <mazharchoudhary_kesc@yahoo.com>, Pasban Pakistan<pasban. ppick@gmail.com>, "orya. maqbool@dunya.com.pk" <orya.maqbool@dunya.com.pk>,"rauf.klasra@dunya.com.pk" <rauf.klasra@dunya.com.pk>, Nusrat Javeed <nusrat.javeed@gmail.com>,"ansar.abbasi@thenews.com.pk" <ansar.abbasi@thenews.com.pk>, Amber H Saigol <amber@saigol.com>, ShaziaHasan <::shaziahasan@gmail.com>, Lal Khan <lalkhan1956@gmail.com>, lmran Kamyana ~:<goodmemories215@gmail.com>, "habib.akram@dunya.com.pk" <habib.akram@dunya.com.pk>, khabaryehhay<khabaryehhay@dunyatv.tv>, Nadeem Malik ·<nadeem.malik@hotmail.com>, shakeelkhan1 O@hotmail.com,ovais.iqbal@vshnews.tv, ovaisbaluch@hotmail.com, ishaq.khusro@hotmail.com, abdul hafeez Baloch<xs2hafeez@gmail.com>. khulicorruption@newsonetv.tv, khurram shel~aman <kbc.2000@gmail.com>,samar.khan@insaf.pk, Seema Zia <dr.szia@insaf.pk>, rehan ashraf <info@shehrLorg>, sohail.ahmed@dunyatv.tv,sohailakrarn@dingroup.com, PEe Karachi <karachi@pec.org.pk>, Engr G R Bhatti <grbhatti@pec.org.pk>, Kazmisahab <aa.kazmi05@gmail.com>, mshafa125@yahoo.com, kamraniqbalawan@hotmail.com, .kesc.1abourunion@hotmail.com, info@voiceagainstcorruption.pk, editor@dawn.com, editor@dailytirnes.com.pk,editorial@dailytimes.com.pk, Irshad Ali <irshad.ch@gmail.com>, irfan.siddiqui@janggroup.com.pk,·irfanhaq@cc.gov.pk, "sa@arynews.tv" <sa@arynews.tv>, Mohsin Muhammad <mohsinsamaatv@gmail.com>,"rashid. qarar@dunya.com.pk" <rashid. qarar@dunya.com.pk>, apnagareban@gmail.com,sailanLdailyummat@gmail.com, chiefeditorkhabrain@khabrain.com, Daily Khabrain <daily.khabrain@gmail.com>,daily.janbaz@hotmail.com, "daily.janbaz" <daily .janbaz@yahoo.com>, mujeeb. shami@dunyatv.tv,ttp@expressnews.tv, bhc@bhc.gov.pk, iephqr@gmail.com, iephq@brain.net.pk, iep.quetta@iep.com.pk,iepkc@cyber.net.pk, iep.karachi@iep.com.pk, iepfsd@yahoo.com, asif nawaz <ieplhr@yahoo.com>,iep .Iahore@iep.com.pk, iepislamabadcentre@yahoo.com, iep.isla mabad@iep.com.pk, fha_md@yahoo.com,

~ ie·p.peshawar@iep.com.pk, pd@muet.edu.pk, iep.hyderabad@iep.com.pk, jaleel.hassan@gmail.com,i~p.riyadh.ksa@iep.com.pk, info@egovforum.bh, iep.bahra in@iep.com.pk, alimkhan@pbad.sbg.com.sa,sani.khan@kse.com.pk, info@kse.com.pk, arman0369best@yahoo.com, ariClodhi73@yahoo.com, farnaz ali<kamranali 1959@yahoo.com>, a.y.enterprises@hotmail.com, qamar_umair@hotmail.com, burhanali21<burhanali21@yahoo.com>, drzbruhhmauny@yahoo.com, shavaizzaslam@hotmail.com, kazmi_sons@hotmail.com,adnan.ejaz.9@yahoo.com, panzeeshan@yahoo.com, asa_tanoli@yahoo.com, zeeshan.siddiqui@hotmail.com, amir

.' khan <guideline279@gmail.com>, zeeshan5_us@yahoo.com, abuzar613@yahoo.com, zain_baba71@yahoo.com,arif-moti@yahoo.com, graJibrian@yahoo.com, hameed.ak@hotmail.com, hi.abbasi@yahoo.com, 'irfanzafar614@yahoo.com, kayani_boys@yahoo.com, libra_bila89@yahoo.com, moied92@live.com, "navldc ."<navJdc@yahoo.com>, Kazim_rashid@hotmail.com, kayani_mus@yahoo.com, noor_aIi600@yahoo.com,umrnibantva_g85@hotmail.com, sajid@ppipopular.com, msaeedkhan1968@yahoo.com, honeyhassan@hotmail.com,younusabdullah@hotrnail.com, Ahmed Qadri <alnashar.ahmed@gmail.com>, eipakistan@live.com, Jabbar Mirza<jabbarmirza92@gmail.com>, Mirza Yasir <mirzayasirahmed@gmail.com>, marketingkarachi@atv.com.pk,marketinglahore@atv.com.pk, maqsoodhashmi@atv.com.pk, breakingnews@atv.com.pk, national@tribune.com.pk,karachi@tribune.com.pk, islamabad@tribune.com.pk, letters@tribune.com.pk, Mehr Tarar <mehrt2000@gmail.com>,hashah9@yahoo.com, Mir Mohammad Ali Talpur <mmatalpur@gmail.corii>: hafiz saad <shgcci@gmail.com>,drmansoori@hotmail.com, "hnkhan20 12@gmail.com" <hnkhan20 12@gmail.com>, walijan@super.net.pk,"registrar@sindhhighcourt.gov. pk" <registrar@sindhhighcourt.gov.pk>, mit1shc@sindhhighcourt.gov.pk,mit2shc@sindhhighcourt.gov.pk, info@sindhhighcourt.gov.pk, deedar services <deedar_services786@yahoo.com>,ahujalrk78@gmail.com, pmd@paknet.com.pk, mail@emc.com.pk,. emc@cyber.net.pk, apasindh@cyber.net.pk,kaltak@expressnews.tv, abid16@hotmail.com, zarar_pirzado@yahoo.com, Masood Rizvi <kawish 12@gmail.com>,nml@samaa.tv, ks@arynews.tv, news@insaf.com.pk, Asif Yaseen <asifyaseen121@gmail.com>,news. post@thenews.com.pk, newsroom@apa.com, newsroom@dailytimes,com.pk, editor@nation.com,pk,editor@nawaiwaqt.com.pk, editor@janggroup.com.pk, editorial@pakistantoday.com.pk, s-ysadmin@agp.gov.pk,arifasobhkha n@hotmail. com, drajmaln iazi@yahoo.com, asar.chauhan@siyasatnamah.com, ghalib@millat.com,elahientp@yahoo.com, pakguides@yahoo.com, pakguides@hotmail.com, guides@ptcl.net,

. naeem.shaikh@sindhbarcouncil.org, tariqsbs@sindhbarcouncil.org, pervez_ ali2000@yahoo.com,bhuttorustam2003@yahoo,com, asiCdeariest@yahoo.com, yaseen.iqbal@sindhbarcou~cil.org, "navied@sindhbarcouncil.org, "dspower@mowp.gov.pk <dspower@mowp.gov.pk>" dsdlscos@mowp.gov.pk<dsdiscos@mowp.gov.pk>, "addsecretary1@mowp.gov.pk <addsecretary1@mowp.govyk>" .addsecretary@mowp.gov.pk <addsecretary@mowp.gov.pk>" jsadmin@mowp.gov.pk <Jsadmrn@mowp.gov.pk>"jswatcr@mowp.gov.pk <jswater@mowp.gov,pk>" jspower@mowp.gov.pk <jspower@mowp.gov.pk>"dsadmin@mowp.gov.pk <dsadmin@mowp.gov.pk>" soa1@mowp.gov.pk <soa1@mowp.gov.pk>"sogenl@mowp.gov.pk <sogenl@mowp.gov.pk>" sop2@mowp.gov.pk <sop2@mowp.gov.pk>" sop-4@mowp.gov.pk<sop-4@mowp.gov.pk>" sop3@mowp.gov.pk <sop3@mowp.gov.pk>" cfao@mowp.gov.pk <cfao@mowp.gov.pk>"aobf@mowp.gov,pk <aobf@mowp.gov.pk>" fa@mowp.go'J.pk <fa@mowp.gov.pk>" dfa@mowp.gov.pk"<dfa@mowp.gov.pk>, naeem1092@yahoo.com

fi 1e:l lie :/U sers/Q AU S S AIN /Ap PD a ta/Loca l/TeITIp/Lo wi AX EKE A 3A.ll tm 7/22/2014

.Gmail- VOL-16a FOREIGN ENTITY ROBS PAKISTAN CITIZENS RS. 130 BILLION ... Page 3 of 12

REF NO. AN/SCOP/15a/2014DATE: JULY 22, 2014

FOREIGN ENTITY ROBS

PAKISTAN CITIZENS OF

RS. 130 BILLION

AND

COUNTING(( __;J (;;f 1. •JlPLf -(;I Y/ ~ -JfJ -~~}~

VOL-

file:///C:/Users/QAUSSAIN/ AppData/Local/Temp/Low/Q8XXV A8B.htm 7/22/2014

'-'lU~L. - y UL-l ca j'Ul<..LlUN EN'{lTY ROBS PAKfSTAN CITiZENS H.S. 130 BILLION ... Page 4 of 12

,y~r . r J,., y:r:J ..) Y-?..)

-~~ TrYLwf

"i-~,yV? /01-./ (JIc....::-"~ 1(lh}f .::-"~(}II

"i-,uY (7. J.1Jr L.. t.f f? .JJI'LIJ "i-.J~,f c...(ltI& :X?r 7J/ --4;L..1i

20 14~ 12":;.)J~JI;'\f,.(J1~~JyV L~ lJL.J.J,-L. -1 :~).116 -(dIJ 2014 (f 5,.:;.1Y ANI SCOP/ 15/2014 .;!}d ~ I~ -2

,,,,{,':'IJfI-i:..t ~ .<:7 {v""i- ~.taJ .l.<:JI{ 13-;' - L..?J)(JIr (}II .J(})~c....J/0L.AJI£...•.-11iA)? .J~'>.

~Ll!Llj--?.J.pJRLl!~L:a;?.JJ'

oLJ(,({(}?0if.)? v"1/ JJ ''7- r./. li,IJ'jr .::;.''(vi"i- 0.::.--Ij .JJ LJ .r-~ Jr" ~ IJf '"~c.....,...,.. -1

LV: I KES CLt.i r. 'LIJ if.'r ltJVJ / /(11 / c?- A,••L.. li,IJ(}?if..J? >.JI;.,.{",1~'''i-J r./.li,IJ(}?OJ"i-.J '(.JJ",,;~ I

--t. "i- J":, Jr r./. li,IJ Jj .J/"'..;("i- Ll' .J~ 0.::.--lj.JJ~ ~ IJ,.11..•c...~ J0L'l''';",,? jJ,. r./. v") "'"U;;IJ,~0 i:;..//.1 JIJ

/ u.1./; /20 14d 12,..('f--:'JVU:1..71}LIJ';£L..(;It>..,LJUi/IL..ulli,IJ';ur JM~IJL..ul

~\9-'i:'Ju:;J~1(lYIJ'?LM' {.0l--JJ.:' Y({.!J4

~LlJL/(gu:)~1(lYl STAKE HOLDERS v/;';;;-::'!_2

-~J v!(;}.1vJr (b -..ttJJJ~J;9'Lt,/ (a

-.21k~r vi .J1c~,~() rL? (d _J21k~r vi .JIcVAJJ.J' (c•• '" "t

~ ~ A'/-Lt,.fl5)-' j;/~/V /(~r .&Lt/.1 (f -Lt/.1,J: u~/~lr- (e

-Lt,J:APTAMA ( h -Lt/J:PPCCI (g

-GOS,~ .1uJ lJff/J~,~l)rL'~.1l; (j -~k~r vi.Jfc ,j.1J.J.J'l2/J// (i., ..

-('f / ~.Jl.PL KEseL (k

57~ ,rh0141.t" o3bA;; N~hAG-05h476:;;g ~ ;!.L.Lt5.J~~ KESCL f "i-cCI;;JiVA

J..i.;!.¥dJf'L.f"J/ ~~J ru:Jw J'"~IJ t;.. L'ir f-19.J.aP '!JAJ,,~u:L..A LJ'r ~Lt (vi ii) 'J.YL.-f-

'file:ll IC:/U sers/QA USSAIN/ AppDataiLocal/Tem p/Low/BZBC2 G1\0.htn1 7/22/2014

Gmail- VOL-16a FOREIGN ENTITY ROBS PAKISTAN CITIZENS RS. 130 BILLION ... Page 5 of 12

.' ~U1~~ j(t~.J{Lc.?U1uk0JJIvS KEPL~lJV~ ~')/.t1J~L.t1a;;~;i{~lr~JJl4 -5

1. KARIMI ENERGY (PRIVATE) LIMITED (KEPL).

2. K- ENERGY (PRIVATE) LIMITED (KEPL).

jj "rSjfJ~o.J~JJ~,j.JJL~o.;, -Lhtrk1hJJ/uJCr;({S~~/j.JJL~ o.;/-£f r~~/41 -6

,,~S1U;./~lr~JL/ i,t(J v,}~SjlJ~,j.JJvLJJLiaJ,l ;,-L, /'., • /y- "', • \"r

J.t1S~ / FEASIBILITY ~of S t:J..fiLL~k1rLYt.f t/ .J1lrL~/j.JJ(f.,/Lo.;/ -Lf f-cC~/i1 -7

S(J.;/-L{~lr~,L'i f-.JJh ~f-f~SJ}~,j.JJ.;!lL":';.J{.JvI1~f-'::-J1}Sut )j~ if J...Jf,;.~.J{.J-rut J.£'" ~Jl;- JU:' ~ ~,j .J)

~rcC f~w,JSu}~/ScJ~f.:.'~·V -8

~,J4:~(A(~,L'JL~LJ¥J,ro'/¥o.;, -LI2014JIJ.£ 16L'4 (a

..UNITS 3 & 4 OF BIN QASIMPOWER STATION-I (BQPS-l) OF K- ELECTRIC

LIMITED, CURRENTLY OPERATING ON FURNANCE OIL.

~tP! S~J/;:-o'/~u,lf¥~ LJ;!O"'L..-'.JJ/ FCA¥ KESCL/20140 28LI4 (b

~Jlr~ 4~ i.JJ'3~ i( 1-~~((; ~fV J~ / J'7,~{J,y ~ fi Ljh;~ /' ~/;(jIJL KESCL

/;;.k~~JS ~/j S;/?.J~~ i.JJ/~'::-J~.nU1jr~) yi{tP 3~ if S cJ~~~,c~JL---..(/u~o.U1~;;~

-'~~;! L'if.£J~ / J'7'~Lui)hl }f;/;L KESCL~U1~;;.k~~u}J)~':::-~Jvf ~~/cf-

v/,li'.t1~lrL~lr~j LyLu,/hJ/..J~lIi.l)cli..J;!;rj/;c.,t./.JcJJA (.J)~~~ /tJ:' j/~

~, It'-.J~L~iu}J)cJlr.J)h-'T-f~J~ L 43Jf 0:~'i fR'T-J;.~.tllrJfirr SJ'7'-U1,-;;.k~ 2012~ 17~j" ~iu}J)~fu.n~fcJ~~ 7(Y.!/'

'i-J.J~.JI~~ (5)~j"~u,w 23~2014cJR)L~2012~{4~i.JJ/ 3~iL 1-~~((;cf. (c

LV/~.JSJ' J jlJ / 'f-hl4J1iL KESCL~ur,j.J)¥ FCA lil L~iu}'JcJl~j( v!J.t'1)Co-

~~ LVI'T-Vl~cJ~ rtJl('I.JJ,Ll:fol~'::-JS tP'T-V1~(FCALfJ}d'dlJ?'T-o,~-'f-~.J.t1~L-t rOJ..! L..":';.JIr!4'.J"cJt:1(i', ~;Jf.£'f-~.Jlrh)L.t1ui ~rr .JJ/u.t'T-.J~L~/~j,.JGAS S Jlr ~ { uPi u}J) cJ' ~ tP 'f- ~ ~(S J S 2014 cJR S uPi 0.J1;.S SSGCL

file:///C:/Users/QAUSSAIN/ AppData/Local/Telnp/Low/SH4 73G4V .htm 7/22/2014

~.J/jL:Jkj)JKESCL ~~h~.?L SSGCL f 'f-~ ..-?j~~ .JJt-..{I_LlJu'~U£) CONSUMPTION

-f-j. {U;.: iL:J10U;.:t 231.J~~j" U!LlPG v:ui:.?V:~I.?L 2013 ~ 01 D.J!;. GMCRA)/NEPRA/2013/ 1175 .J ;d~~}J KESCLLli Cd

SUf'iU}JJl:!I~ 'f-!!1lf,Jt.ifuf' iU}JJl:!'toti./I~!f15.J~ho13 ~ 22 IV-Jf?-jytot~ Ucr-)?

'f-~,!f Si./1+u1 u:f tot IV-Jf?- jy )jtot.~-AL~,j J'Uf'iU} JJl:!J~ 'f-JJl:<JIr- 19JJI18/ -!:..•

NEPRA/R/LAG- .J ;d 'i-'~~;!I ~~L-A L u;.: i ~.J/).U}JJL:JIL Ii f 'f-t ~~::V (e

~f-t/.;fl?V: 19 J1JJ~J.J/.1J.}L56;l .rf2014J.{1030.J!;. 05/3476-78

lihJ=,P~Lf~J~~'J(: 350~ NTDC¥ KESCLLJ~J~Jlr-~ f 'f-Jf!,/~~LI/liV Cf

V:~.J/J~.f~.JJfu/}j(J'J.f V~)lJ.Jlj U.JL::_J:'mk~/ ~.JJlh~.J;~L~lS)IDI/.IJKESCL ]

. ,J,f L.Jk~ 26~7 .JJI'f-J.ttJ.1L.fk~ ;;:~IJ(:380~)}~U;.:t 23'f-..-?JIf~Iif Jl.fe-tf J!;1~tJ'~.JJI'f-(j.J.fJ'~j) UNDUE AND UNAUTHORIZED ~; ~.JJI1.9.J!;.ui' /(11 kesclLtL-.J~L

~'f-V..-?JJvljl'f-0J'J.J~J}G*{VIL

Lb1L~u ..j /L:JI.JJILl1'~LJ~IJ}Jr,~L~L(J/ ASH J.tt C~ / UJ.J J--f/f~L!;.,..,LJ;I-Ll!-9. -. - , - - -

~L~Ju~{~~¥Vlf 'f-cC.tt)JI(L~VJP {~J

JIJLllc-~.ttuiJVLJ~IJ"/j~~0.JJI(L~lfJ~I(j--f/j~vCJ~fif 'T-h~~/~~LlILliV-ll

l!~?J? /JL.fJP Jl;JJN::~/~~l:Jc:J~.f~~j;'/~IJUJ.JlJ/j~-? ~Ll:JI.JJluJ.J~::~/jJ~)/L,LJ..}

c-.f~~t.f l!-j L~~l5A~!~~~}U=dv'f-C-1JLtl:Jc:J~=~/~I)~::~/jJN0fU!£~ ,fJ!1 LliV-12Lfh~j~IJL.fD)L;~l:J~ .J(=,L/JJ..c:jj/~~VI''T-c-~hlf.h).J';:ILL:Jl;f~f.?'f-c-lf~~(5)lP!J t LLlI.JJI'f-

IF & )JIJ/¥Vl h(L~L(~U;LJt;,.LL:J~k"(L~L( U=Jt;,.L0t:-f~f Lf JL~/ Jlh' ]LE'L~LLtJtf<iU!BUTS

file:/I le:lU sers/Q AU SSAINI A p p Data/Local/Ten1 p/LowlEU 1FQQ FD.h tn1 . 7/22/2014

Gmail- VOL-16a FOREIGN ENTITY ROBS PAKISTAN CITIZENS RS. 130 BILLION ... Page 7 of 12

~ J!~ SvLIJ1JL1 vi J;JIPt.?u.lSJS}~jLLIv:.r f 'f-CC:,.lJ(p.J~J'~h.fll('.fl,fV_13

LitJ! 1(}~L~,/~~.AJu.ttvi ;I.tl-'I~ MONOPOLISTICANDOLIGOPOLISTIC{U"j"J VJj

~Cv}J/hl)(

156r:frL 1976Y'jyJ£~J::./~{ JQ?--jjLON;--t~~l:?~'i-'j" <lSJlz:.,I,,;;ISKESCLf 'f-~JI~V -15

fJR~J}G" foAI.,c;f~J'1ffJ~4-~UY~ .;;:,.S,ij"f/l1k'..Jr ~jIJ(p.'cJl::1..Jr ~jl ~4'L..ttLfo;j,..Ju;J

~J~r:I,~J'vl.tt~1J,U!'f-jL.I J;j~'J/~/JJld L..v~("" jj,/o;~f.l'JfJJJy/~j {

~ 1010~~LL1 v:.2009Lv1f f-Jr~Ijl' '>jv:.o~JlJI,Lvr~/v:.U'jIJ/1J~--?,hC~<lSJlz:.,C,:IJ'KESCL

~ ;?~/j",~Jl;/~J,J'~iJ' 8847~~L2009/KESCLJ!~L~cr~~ Lv? ''f-VJW,I(~ ;?J'~/,

Lj~'J/~I=z:.,jJv:.~j{j';JJlrSKESCL/jj 'f-1JIPt.?jr'J'ivrf1c24036 = 8847+15189) if ~~jffilC ~

j,I L KESCLf-VJW,I(~;?JI J~/~ 2009J!~L~~L~iOjl,/~ cJlf f-rf'v..f/l1tl(}I,f~&:-j~

C~/,~ 64~JW,I(~i# 557..J/)~ if J'v:.~1,~~ }?,;JJlrFINANCIAL

YEAR 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013GENERATED & 13,593 14,500 14,877 15,189 ~5,267 15,806 15,431 15,259 15,824

PURCHASED

UNITS IN

MILLIONS

DURING FY

{LII ~ icJILvlJ!~ Lv? 'f-U'jIrLf{ 4jJI3..viL 1-~~(G" c/.((~J.;I -Lf 'f-6' =1LL;/,f -16

LJJIJ# 400~1Ju! {v?'f-t.ttJ~/U' t/0~J/~}?fcf~} --*'f-JfJ-"?v:.}"i.j,'tt~-+!..J/¥L~

~il:i v:.v?U!~i.j~~v?'f-k1~R 2-..v~(G"~ Y'j{v:.(jJIP--*..J}O/'JfJLIrJ/~~ ~IJ~ 380jJ,J

~J!~L KESCL'f-~.Jf~~ ~ JL~'J(::500..v~Y =j"if Jr ~JJJlj# 450..J/, {VIVJ~~v!

J:..t-L CLcJl::1J..vjJ'cJl::1~r ..c;'f~fU~IO} fU¥,J~r'J~ )u,pv LcJ'j"('!'i f 'f---?',V-17

J1J(V:.»(IJSJ;fL<lSJ'J' KESCLj"f-o'j,,;;Oj'.;f1rjJ,j,y --tttu,;:'l{L KESCLfJRJ~L?J} j" z:.,?'

vi J~{j}L STAKEHOLDERttUy~/J;?~rrj,/~fvi ~j'~~cJl::1..Jr J;?~rr ~uM'i-'u£cVJJ

file:1IIC :/Users/Q AUS SAINI AppDataILocal/Temp/Low/S S2LQO EE .htm 7/22/2014

L~J fKESCLfL~0~}~~U~~{~I}.J)0~;I-L.JJIu:.~ L LAG-OS£. 2014L!.{1 03.1 U(;'i-l;-}

-'i-J~U)~Lli tJJ! .JU}'U:~

(".JJIU}.(fuftJ vi~;I.tl~J~;!' L KES POWER LTD/ ~'i)1 ~1~!:0 KESCLVf 'i-cC l;./iV -18

UAl!tJaf/tJlf 'f-lf"fJt"Jtf ~J.;,-L0'L:;'V<iuJ'T-.JJ~('i)I.JJ' ~?.?L'-...JIJILIJL.J(ilj UTILITY

1~·J}1,.f~.JJluJ2::-J'-..J{.idL1¥2_~ 4.JJI3~i.}'f-.J'-..Jvi ~jJ~J~IJ'J;fLI J~~L?~~~j

<i" 1ti.ilL.UJj{;JIJrful "2....L.f/£l:rLJvi{;dL1L~lflPiui ~ U:U:''7-~.J.rrtfrv: 20 16f.?MYT L

~f0'.JIUlu.JIYJU:£ -:Jy =(PLGC}/~·V -19

"THE UNITS OF "BQPS-IARE INSTALLED IN A CASCADING MANNER WITH IN A SINGLE

BOUNDRY. THE PARTIAL LEASE / DEMARCATION OF THE TWO UNITS OF BQPS-1 1-fAY

CREATE OPERATIONAL PROBLEMS WITHIN THE NEW COMPANIES."

!f 'f-0'.JI Ul15.JIY"U:£ or~y =(PPIc/liV

"THE ELECTRICITY GENERATED FROM COAL CAUSES ENVIOROMENTAL POLLUTION

WHICH CAUSES DIESEASES LUNGS, KIDNEYS" AND :NERVES. FURTHER TREE

PLANTATION IS ALSO AFFECTED DUE TO THIS. IN 1988 THE GOVT. OF PPP STARTED

BIGGEST COAL GENERATION PROJECT IN ASIA. WHEN THE SAID GOVT. WAS DISMISSED

THE GOVT. OF PML-N ABANDONED THE PROJECT ON ACCOUNT OF ENVIROMENTAL

POLLUTION DESPITE THE FACT A HUGE A1-IOUNT HAD ALREADY BEEN SPENT. IT IS

SURPRISING FOR THE CONSUMERS OF KEL WHY THE ASPECT OF ENVIROMENTAL

POLLUTION IS NOW BEING IGNORED?"

~ll)/?J:.j/ )d=(KCCI liV({uJ~j{~y{ L KESCL/ui~v.; 020 14u.JJj 130 KeCI f 'f---?JV

<if-V~ fKtt~fl;-'7-cC,.I' /t:J~

(1/u:u;r~t:JI~ 'f-t".rrJr ~(uDl(J fiU:u;r~tJl!JIJL.rr~u:u,/.J d-:.~J.rrf 'f-u:f ~J/ U:vi_20

L'.Yfr LLJ?~ t:J/k~~jvvl;0 KESCL.JJ/'7-.IJJ~v 7JS(l.t(~~0 J.rrf 'f-=0vl--?JJflu:f Lf ~/ l1.e'JU:.J.v..::.-J'~ ,.JJL!lf '7-v(;J/~/i ~~Jlfl-'f-..::.-J'~r:,'/ f 'f-t"-t~VJJk/k~ ,.JJl1 j('7-J~ flJ yl;~ '-A

J~ I£J:.('I ~~/..JIL'i.JJ'JJ/0KESCLf K~~..JJ'vf J::J;J:.JI.P1P(I! ~~}L~09..::.-J'~=u:~~

fi le:///C:/Users/QA USSAIN/ AppDataiLocal/Temp/Lovv/4 YTOB 79S.htl11 7/22/2014

Gmail- VOL-16a FOREIGN ENTITY ROBS PAKISTAN CITIZENS RS. 130 BILLION ... Page 9 of 12

LJ flfRl.1!f1~ ~jv1':;;'JJ! ,J:J,J! ~VJ/J'}!J!.J;{J'~Jf~.f/l1}.~~J''61i,fJ'}[~~t.5'J-UJ

-UJ J.'1u=~f u=?-~

JJ,rLL'V-.d L 43JJ'39cfr L~'~JJ',-'-19'19'4'5~J1 Ld'1f£~';'.»rLt:.(;Jk.{J,fU.'1~.f ~'U=-LV:~t:..::JLd,j ~L,..J'JJ,jlf Ji {cJ'UJLeZ{

(LA149646);~lIfi;())JJ;lJ0 -J1t:f

-'-t,J:djJ)J.f" III-~ J;'UP,~ -25

0364-4011715

aneelmumtaz@gmail.com :J::U'

REF NO. AN/SCOP/1Sa/2014 DATE: JULY 22, 2014

CARBON COpy TO, FOR RECORD AND IF REQUIRED FOR NECESSARY ACTION:-

1. THE PRESIDENT OF l.R.o.PAKISTAN.

2. THE REGISTRAR, SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN.

3. HON'BLE JUSTICES OF SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN.

4. THE REGISTRAR, HIGH COURT OF SINDH, KARACHI.

5, HON'BLE JUSTICES OF HIGH COURT OF SINDH, KHI.

6. THE DG, FIA, ISLAMABAD.

7. THE DIRECTOR. ANTI POWER THEFT UNIT, FIA, ISB.

39-THE CORP'S COMMANDERS OF PAKISTAN.

40THE DG, MI GHQ, RAWALPINDI.

41THE DG, NI NHQ ISLAMABAD.

42-THE DG, ISI KHI OFFICE.

43.THE DG INTElliGENCE BUREAU KARACHI OFFICE.

44.THE JOINT CHIEF OF STAFF,CHAKLALA RWP.

45-COMLOG. COM COAST, COMKAR. HQ KHI.

file:11IC:/U sers/QA USSAINI AppData/Local/Temp/Low/DNTIRT79.htm 7/22/2014 ..

Gmail- VOL-16a FOREIGN ENT.l.T·Y ROBS PAKISTAN CITiZENS RS. 130 BILLI... Fa~e 10 of 12

8. THE DIRECTOR, FIA, SINDH ZONE, KARACHI.

9. THE DD, CCC FIA, KARACHI.

10. THE ADG,ACW FIA. ISLAMASAD.

11. THE AUDITOR GENERAL OF PAKIST AN,ISB.

12. THE DG COMMcKCIAL AUDIT, AGoP KARACHI.

46JHE DIRECTOR GENERAL. RANGERS, SINDH.

47.THE REGISTRAR, ISLAMABAD HIGH COURT.

48-THE REGISTRAR. LAHORE HIGH COURT.

49.THE REGISTRAR, PESHAWER HIGH COURT.

50.THE REGISTRAR, BALUCHISTAN HIGH COURT.

13. THE CHAIRMAN, PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITEE,NATIONAL 51-THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT.OF PUNJAB.

AS SEMBL Y OF PAKISTAN. 52. THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT.OF KPK.

14. THE FEDERA.L MINISTER OF WATERPOWER, THROUGH THE 53.THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT.OF BALUCHISTAN.

PRIME MINISTER OF PAKISTAN.

15. THE ECNOMIC CORDINATION COUNCIL OF PAKISTAN.

OF

54.THE MD PPRA. ISLAMABAD.

55.THE SECRETARY, PRIVATIZATION COMM!SSION

PAKISTAN, ISLAMABAD.

16. THE CHAIRMAN,STANDING COMMITIEE, WATERPOWER, SENATE,ISLAMABAD.

17. THE CHAIRMAN,STANDING COMMITIEE, WATERPOWER, NATIONAL ASSEMBLY, ISLAMABAD.

18. THE CHAIRMAN NAB,ISLAMABAD.

19. THE ADDDIR>,A&PDIVISION( NAB HO,ISB.

20. THE DG NAB,SINGH, KARACHI.

21. THE SECRETARY INTERIOR. GOP ISLAMABAD.

22. THE SECRETARY,WATEKPOWER, ISLAMABAD.

23. THE SECRETARY, FINANCE, GOP ISLAMABAD.

24. THE CHAIRMAN, FBR, GOP ISLAMABAD.

25. THE DG 1&1-IR FBR GOP ISLAMABAD.

26. THE CHIEF COMMISSIONER(Hqrs) RTO-11, KHI.

27. THE DIRECTOR, 1&1-IR,KARACHI.

56-THE FEDERAL OMBUDSMAN'S OF PAKISTAN,ISBKHI.

57.THE HONl _EJUSTICES OF SESSION COURTS, KHI..

58. THE COLJ1\;Cll.,loEP, KHI OFF.

59-THE PRi::SIDENT, KCCI,KARACHI.

60-THE :7.ENERAL SECRETARY, FPCCI,KHI OFF.

61.ThE SECRETARY GENERAL, APTANIA, LALAZAR, KHI.

62-i'liE CHAIRMAN, SITE ASSOCIATION OF INDUST.

'33-THE CHAIRMAN, KORANGI A.o.T.1.KHI.

'34.THE H.SECRETARY,SINDH HIGH COURT BAR ASS.

65JHE SECRETARY, SINDH BAR COUNCIL.

file :///C:!U sers/Q AUSSAIN/ AppData/Local/Ten1p/ '.,ow/3JXHJ9 53 .htln 7/22/2014

Gmail- VOL-16a FOREIGN ENTITY ROBS PAKISTAN CITIZENS RS. 130 BILL!... Page 11 of 12

28. THE CHAIRMAN,SECP, ISLAMASAD.

29. THE JOINT REGISTRAR, SECP, KARACHI

30. THE REGISTRAR, PEC, KARACHI OFFICE.

31. THE CHAIRMAN,CCoP,ISLAMASAD.

32. THE CHAIRMAN,HEC, PAKISTAN.

33. THE CHARMAN, COMPETITION COMM.OF PAK.ISB.

34. THE IG,THROUGH DIGPf FINANCE, SINDH POLICE.

35. THE DIG, SOUTH KARACHI POLICE.

36. THE SHO,SADDAR POLICE STATION

37. THE ElK. REGION-1,GoS. KHI.

38. THE COAS, GHQ, RAWALPINDI.

77. THE JOINT DIR,(ENFORCEMENT) SECP, ISB

79. THE STANDING COMMITIEE FOR HUMAN RIGHTS, NA ISB.81. THE SECRETARY, HUMAN RIGHTS, GOS, KHI.

66-THE GENERAL SEC.PAKISTAN BAIR COUNCIL.

67THE G.S,SUPREME COURT BAR ASSOCIATION.

68.THE G.S, KARACHI BAR ASSOCIATION.

69-HELP-L1NE TRUST, KHI.

70. SHERI-CBE. KHI.

71.HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION OF PAKISTAN, KHI.

72. THE CHIEF SECRETAIRY, GoS, KARACHI.

73. THE CHAIRMAN, ENQUIRIES & ANTI CORRUPTION

ESTABLISHMENT, GoS, KARACHI.

74. THE SECRETARY, IOCAGOVf. GoS, KHI.

75. THE HOME SECRETAIRY, GoS, KHI.

76. THE SECRETARY, ENERGY DEPT, GoS, KHI.78. THE SHO PREEDY POLICE STATION.

80. THE SECRETARY, LAW, JUSTICE & HUMAN RIGHTS, GOP ISB.

9 attachments

NOTICE OF HEARING K-ENERGY Licence Application.jpg301K

~ VOL-16 AN-SCOP-15-2014.pdf- 814K

iD Voice-0001.amr572K

iD SQPS RUN-3 JUNE-14.xps788K

'10 SQPS RUN-4 JUNE-14.xps788K

file:///C:/Users/QAUSSAIN/ AppData/Local/Temp/Low/YOUGE 191.htnl 7/22/2014

Gn1ail _ VOL-16a FOREIGN ENTITY ROBS PAKlSTA1', ~~l rILL1"~~ RS. l3U BILLl... 1 c'6C l~ 01 12

iE1 LAG-OS LPM K-ELECTRIC 03-04-2014 3476-78.PDF855K

. ~ Generation License Application of K-Energy.pdfIIcJ 5031 K

tt!j MOD-IV LAG-OS KESC MODIFICATION-IV GEN L1C 22-08-2013 10077-79.pdf1430K

iD Voice-0001 (2).amr1538K

...

file:/ //C:/U sers/Q AUSSAIN/A ppDatalLocaI/Temp/Low/2K \VS AOSO .htm 7/22/2014

landhiZone

SERVICE WITH ASMILE• ~ ~;. ": :: ,~~.:. • ~~,::_/-l':'- .:P!e~~e,COn~ctyo~r.NerQhbo.CUst()mer'FeCililauQi'i C~ritelaPlot'No:30/423: .. "

. ':::~alirT~riShiPKaraChI', ' .

. TEL: 99248368

SSGC General Sales Tax Number 02-04-9028-001-19

For emergencies and

complaints please call

1199

Billing Group: A-11/1212001 /3~ ..

ACCOUNT INFORMATIONCustomer Number: 5044380000 (3) Bill 10: 504435371743Bining Month: June, 2014

-T~iriffiCustomer Class: INOCNIC/GST/NTN Number: 11200271600728 1._. 0._. . ... __ .. _. ._. __ .. __ . . • _

_~~~~~.ePly De~~t (Ca~~).:......__ ~..:.~:~~_ .._. .._.. ~on-~ash: ~~ _

MONTHLY CONSUMPTION BILL & PAYMENTHISTORY~Month.~~_~::i- Bill A~~~.~~_~:L __ ~ayment Date AmountJ~J_._.

JUN-2014 3,202,579,070 27-Jun-2014 86,730,532

MAY-2014 3,142,832,890 27-Jun-2014 103,946,6891--------------+--------------_·_--_·_·_ .._--APR-2014 2,978,994,580 27-May-2014 100,927,611-------------- ----------_ .._-.- ..._.__ ...__ .._ ...

MAR-2014 2,873,012,950 25-Apr-2014 154,117,9741---._----_._----- --------.---..-.---.------..-------.....FEB-2014 2,688,594,420 31-Jan-2014 266,605,294

150000eJO

JAN-2014 2,654,497,030 27-Nov-2013 172,023,269

IMPORTANT NOTIFICATIONS' DETAILS OF CHARGES

1111I111111111111I1111111111111111111111111111111111111I11111111111111111111111

202,818,3792,500

36,386,307oooooooooooo

250,423,409

~ :: WWW.ssgc.com.pk: ".:-.MIS The Chief Financial OfficerKarachi Electric Supply Corporation limitedBin Qasim Power Station (Run 3)Almai House, Abdullah Haroon Road

KARACHI

Gas ChargesMeter RentGID CessGeneral Sales Tax

StandardValue AddedExtraFurther

Withholding Tax@4%PUG Gas ChargesPUG GSTAdditional GSDAdjustments .. DebitAdjustments - Creditless: Provisional/Bill CorrectionsOther ChargesInstallment AmountTotal Current ChargesNumber of InstallmentsInstallment Balance Amount

AMOUNT

-0.04

202,818,379

5044380000 (3)

DAYS

o30

MMBTU

BILL CALCULATIONCMs

0.00 0.000

11,854,409.00 415,415.642

COMPUTATIONOF CURRENT GAS CHARGES

~ ~ Sui Southern GelS Company Limited~!Block 14, Sir Shah Sulcll1an Roadg . Gulshan-e-Iqbal. Karad,i 753()()~ SS C \\·ww.:,sgc.com.pk...•~'"0<:>:z:~'"00

~9~

METER NO. CURRENT READING PREVIOUS READING MEASURED QTY

M12169664 27-Jun-2014 43128395 30-May-2014 32352328 10776067

SMSCODE GCV BTU/SCF MMBTU NO. OF MONTHS4014 987.30 415,415.642301 0

PRESSURE TEMPERATURE PCF TE_~P-ADJ0 90 1.0000 1.0000

METER INFORMATION

ACTUAL BILL CONSUMPTIVE

SLAB eMs MMBTU RATEI AMOUNTMMBTU (Rs.) (Rs.)

Gas Charges __ ~~~_~~09 415,415.642 .~~~:.~3 . 202,818,379

Min.Chargea _0 -2:.~_. __ ~~~~ 0

~ .. . " ~.~.:.~~.~~g.~ __ ~~~~?:....._ g _ __. 202,81~~

BREAKUP

Ba6ed on Previous Rate(s)

Ba6ed on Current 8ate

5AMG. IDS-KHI05-Jul-2014

1199

Issue Date:

Bill 10: 1044304486041044380000 (7)June, 2014IND

Sui 0vutl.l..::rn Gas. Compalif Lini~i..cJ. www.ssgc.com.pk

. U ~.lc~hJ~!<.com.' .•s&c.vffic:ai

D;C'':.~ 1('::, $i:-.':;h± S~!~L,.!~~~:·g,~l~:~~~!qb~),"(~ "~.~ ?2.~OO . '.. ">.,.,L: .....twJ~.:['.<..or:;{~.$~:.::,lffc~il.!..¥ MIS Th~ Chief Financial Officer- SSGC General Sales Tax Number 02-04-9028-001-19

~n~~~~~~~~~~{~uOnraUon Lim~led Billing Group: A-11 /1212001 /4 Landhi Zon-)Ai.malHouse,AbdullahHaroon cad ,....---------.., " SERVICE WITH A SMILEKARACHI.;:,,;.l".;."J., ".,r< For emergencies and . Pf~aseGoniaclyour Neighbou;tiOOd

::~,.';CU'5lomerFadlitalion Cenle'ral:. .complaints please call ~.,,·/:.Plot No:30/423 : '.

. "'::Mafir Township.' Karachi'

TEL: 992483.68r":~.~~:,':,'" "'_'

,,,'.:~~l "

5 ..CC

Name:Address:

- , . ACCOUNT INFORMAnONCustomer Number:

_~lIing ~onth:Tariff/Customer Class:CNIC/GST/NTN Number: 11200271600728 I

~~~~~~_ DepC'sit(Cas~...:.. Rs. O.OO N_o_n-_C._a_sh_:_O_.OO_'_---__

,~11.';'.:ri1t:£~~~~aJ,~~\~1'2.~:;),18-Jul-2014

BM th'. on ..., , IU Amount (Rs.) . Payment Date Amount(~.)

JUN-2014 2,897,110,940 27-Jun-2014 86,764,307

MAY-2014 2,839,666,010 27-Jun-2014 23,432,533

APR-2014 2,679,999,570 27-Jun-2014 79,855,264--------~------_.._-_ .. -----_.---_._--~. __ .__ .__ ._--_.-MAR-2014 2,565,280,4 70 27-May-20 1-4 702,461

..FEB-2014 2,382,526,4 70 27-May-2014 101,289,106..._-~_..__ .._-_._ •......_ .. •........- ................. _ .......................... _ .._ .. ........ ...__ .,. .................. _ ........•.......•.. _. ................ _ ...._- ...__ ..__ .__ ...._ .._ ...... _ ....

JAN-2014 2,478,805,720 I 25-Apr-2014 154,637,119

III II6000000

15000000

10000000

" ,~f~·'; .: .. -,. . '~ .. METER INFORMATION '.;' . ':' ., '. '.

".' .~ ~..... COMPUTAnON OF"CURRENT GAS'CHARGES _. _. _.•. '

Gas Charges 11,715.880 410,561.152Min.Charg68 0 0.000..T~~I_.=--=___~1.:!!~l8~ _~?:.~~ .._

35,961,107oooooo

200,448,2712,500

'0oooo

247,497,029

Gas ChargesMeter RentGID CessGeneral Sales Tax

StandardValue AddedExtraFurther

Withholding Tax @ 4%PUG Gas ChargesPUGGSTAdditional GSDAdjustments - DebitAdjustments - Credit _Less: Provisional/Bill CorrectionsOther ChargesInstallment AmountTotal Current ChargesNumber of InstallmentsInstallment Balance Amount

AMOUNT

·0.24200,448,271

NO. OF MONTHS1

TEMP·ADJ1.0000

MEASURED CTY

11715880

',';s AMOUNT'(Rs.)

'200,448.271,:..·0 ",

....._ _~.?~~.~~1"..::..:"... :. '~:

DAYS

o30

RATE/MMBTU (Rs.)

488.23143.29

o

MMBTU410,561.152000

PCF1.0000

MMBTU

PREVIOUS READING

3D-May·2014 15596134

. MMBTU

CMs

0.00 0.00011,715,880.00 410,561.152

GCV BTU/SCF987.30

eMs

'CURRENT READING

30·Jun·2014 27312014

SLAB

SMS CODE4014

METER NO.

M2121942

ACTUAL BILL CONSUMPTIVE

Baaed on Previous Rate(s)Based on Current Rate

BREAKUP

_~~~~RE • T~PE~TUREo 90

f.....,

the Authority is of the view that in case KEL is forced to carry out the

conversion at its own cost which has been persistently denied it is likely to

delay the conversion for indefinite period. thereby denying the advantage of

coal conversion to its consumers and saving of about U.S. $ 350.00 Million

per annum to the National Exchequer. In view. thereof the option under the

proposed LPM seems pragmatic and in the interest of the consumers. In view

of the foregoing the real question before the Authority is whether to allow

conversion of Unit-3 and 4 of BQPS-I on coal through KEPL or let the current

status quo continue for an indefinite period. The Authority may leave the

things as they are and wait for KEL to improve its financial health to an extent

where its credit worthiness is acceptable to lending agencies. However that

would not provide any comfort to the consumers of KEL as they would

continue to be required to pay the high tariffs which would be expected to go

even higher after the relatively cheap energy from NTDC is not available.

Authority has also reviewed the operational performance of Unit-3 & 4 of

BQPS-I over the previous years. Jti.e~'AuthoritY.:9bs~rvedthat the monthly

plant fact9fS ,Qf)~ni~~ renjain~d .16%Jg'·41~4,·dyii,ng '~IJIY:~f012to October.

2012 wherea~J9r the r~st of \he year tD~pl~n~Ja~tors.remained.Qelow13%.

T~heminimum senj out ~r~Jtcost ~~~ req.or~·ed~s Rs. :t 7.69/kWh. Similarly,

Unit No. 4 ope~~.tedfor ·only·~o,,"mQ!}lhsJ!1:J.l!Iy,-and ~byg!J~t'201·2afJq ,it. is,

closed since then reportedly due to~tec~l1icalpro~lems: The Authority has an

option to direct KEL to undertake the repair and maintenance of units as that

would be less expensive. However, the same would retire in 10-11 years as

compared to the proposition that same are converted to coal having useful life

to at least twenty (20) years extendable for another ten (10) years thereby

resulting in cheaper electricity for a much longer period. Moreover, this option

would also not result in any relief for the consumers as in the absence of gas

availability the plants would continue operating on furnace oil. The Authority

notes that on the basis of the Information contained in the financial

statements and other statements made by KEL on record, the stance of KEL

may not be out rightly dismissed. The Authority has observed that the

conversion of oil-fired power generation plants to coal operation is in line with

Page 56 of 59

,(; \r l-j i'

~/

National Electric PowerRegulatory Authority (NEPRA)

All stakeholders, interested/affected persons/parties and the generalpublic are notified that the Authority has admitted the Application ofKEPL for consideration of grant of Generation Licence with acumulative installed capacity of 420.00 MW. KEPL l'as proposed CoalConversion of Units 3 & 4 of Bin Oasim Power Station-I (BOPS-I) of K-Electric Limited (KEL), currently operating on Furnace Oil. Further,KEPL has informed that it will be Operating and Maintaining the saidUnits for a period of twenty (20) Years through a long term LeaseAgreement with KEL.

(2}.A Notice of Admission of the above mentioned application waspublished in the Newspaper5 (i.e. The New5 & Daily Express) on April30, 2014, seeking comments of the general public and otherinterested/aHected parties in favor or against the grant of GenerationLicence to KEPL. Furttler, separate notices were also issued toIndividual Experts, Government Ministries/Departments andRepresentative Organizations on May 02, 2014, for submilling theircomments/views in the mailer for the assistance of the Authority. Inresponse to above, the Authority has received comments fromdifferent stakeholders, interested and affected parties.

(3}.The AuthoriiY has considered the comments of the stakeholdersand has decided to further deliberate the matter by oHering anopportunity of being heard to all stakeholders, interested, aHectedparties/persons and general public by arranging a Public Hearing interms of Rule 3(4) of the NEPRA licensing (Generation) Rules, 2000.Accordingly, the same is being scheduled as per the following:-

. ...:.:.:-. Date August 12,2014 (Tuesday)

Time 11 :00 A.M.------- ---- -_._--Venue 6th Floor, NEPRA Tower G-5/1, Islamabad

All stakeholders, interested /,,!fected parties/persons and the generalpublic are invited to participate in the above mentioned public hearingto express their views either in favor or against the grant of GenerationLicence to KEPL. A copy of the Application of KEPL for theGeneration Licence is available on NEPRA website (i.e.www.nepra.org.pklnews.htm) for ready reference C1ndconsultation.For any further clarification/infonnation contact Registrar on thefollowing address:-

Registrar NEPRANEPAA Towe( Altaturk Avenue (East), Sector G-S/1,lslamabad.

Tele: 051-9206500/2013200; Fax 051-9210215/2600026E-man: office@nepra.org.pk .

16 em x 2 col

GRESHAM'S EASTERN (PRIVATE) LIMITEDBusiness Center I Suite 702 - 7th Floor

Plot 19/1-A I P.E.C.H.S Block 6Main Shahrah-e-Faisal

Karachi 75400 I Pakistan

Dear Sir,

.0(- T : + 9221 343 24530 (8 Lines) I~ /~ F: + 9221 34324080

~

\ I+"J.);J"", sales@geI1947.com

~y ~. CU~) P ~ If? ~ ~:.; <:"~ '--0 '. .,;:t) I<t :z U;-

._a 16, 2014 -~ 11 .~S . \,"\ ?- c ,.~o t' I i~'- : "1. ~_ be.. \~)(C~ J\:) <!..o ", Vcr mlLc-) f~ : ~

The Registrar, I'" •National Electric Power Regulatory Authority -5~\ -1: (Y) (,) f f ~ ~ ~NEPRA TOWER, Attaturk Avenue (East), G-5/1, - \Y\ (2... M C I "l.-A . ~Islamabad - Pakistan. ,~ CA\ , U \ ) ; ~.

l;~ : c...:,SUBJECT: GENERATION LICENSE APPLICATION OF K-ENERGY (KEPLl Ii-" ~ .\

! ., •I ~ :I' •

.. -' ~antage"'" guaranteed

, ESHAM'S; h energy-enviro specialists

c _' r-.~~1,/".-0

~l 9(~a. .' f-"l \

~.~ ~\) ~-J

With kind reference to the advertisement in the National Newspapers on April 30, 2014 on the abovesubject.

We would like to record our viewpoint/objections on the proposed project as follows:

1. Emissions:Today, Pakistan is facing sanctions from World Health Organization for violating the UN/WHO guidelinesfor the Polio vaccine. If, the provisions of the UN2 C resolution are not addressed by Pakistani CoalProjects, we see numerous Country Sanctions looming against Pakistan such as:• UNIDO funds withdrawal.• UNESCO funding withdra'vval.• In fact, the danger is explicit that all UN Funding will be frozen.

As the NEPRA is approving Coal Projects in DIRECT CONFLICT with the UN 2 C Regulations, we seegrave danger for Pakistan as there are numerous other US/EU/Japanese Regulations which willseriously affect Pakistan's Exports to these countries. We invite you to see the "LEEDS" Rules nowsteadily being placed on Pakistani Exporters by foreign buyers.

Without considering the EIA prepared by a world class Consultant whose EIA Report MUST be checkedand certified by SGS/German-L/oyds etc, to be fully compliant to all UN/EU/US laws no steps must betaken by NEPRA for entertaining the K-Electric request for generation License.

2. Piant Efficiency

The Power Plant principally comprises of:• Steam Boiler

Steam Turbine

The Electrical efficiency of the K-Electric Power plant with HFO did not exceed 34% at any time.

To increase the efficiency to 39.5% (required by UN) the Boiler and Steam Turbine MUST be changed.

K-Electric is simply changing the Boiler which means that the efficiency will remain the same as for HFOBoiler at a dismal 34%.

www.geI1947.com

Registered Office: F-302 Sirid Industrial Trading Estate - S.1.1.E I Karachi I PakistanRegional Offices: Lahore I RawalpindiLiaison: USA I European Union I ROC

imEiIiIllnnovation I Integrity I Value

100 ~s ISO 9001QU LITY

SURED

advantage""" guaranteed

GRESHAM'Sthe energy-enviro specialists

This low efficiency will result in:

Increased Fuel Consumption per KWe.Higher C02 Emissions which will violate UN 2C Regulations.

• Increased cost per KWe.

3. Plant Cost:

Is K-Electric going for the whole plant i.e.• Steam Boiler.• Steam Turbine.• Balance of Plant.

If the Plant price is for the whole EPC Project, i.e. Steam Turbine + Boiler + Balance of Plant, CoalHandling, the price works out at USD 1,332.6 2 per KWe which is about 30°10 more than prices obtained byPakistan Atomic Energy Commission for 25 MWe plant. 210 MWe Plant should not be more than USD 950/-

r KWe.

If, the Steam Boiler only is being changed, the cost is prohibitive and indicated price is USD 50 million only.K.E.S.C may be asked to submit the full details of what they intend to buy.

We ask NEPRA to view this aspect carefully and have the plant cost established by a neutral InternationalThird Party Consultant appointed by NEPRA as the higher CAPEX cost will have an impact on the PowerGeneration cost.

We ask NEPRA in the highest NATIONAL INTEREST to view matters of Power Generation CAPEX costs,Emissions, Plant Efficiencies very carefully as one wrong move could cost the Pakistan Nation Billions ofdollars and could ultimately land at the doors of NAB as we have seen in several past matters.

We are at your disposal for any additional information from our side and look as always to your prompt andpositive reply.

With Best Regards, ~~,

7<v'b~t~~~

~

~~ K3rachiYSr~

l:.:t·

(9')

.J'<9 :i>'A.I ".ID* ~ffMian Suhail Husain '=-C.E.D'; Director

C.C• Vice Chairman - NEPRA• President - Federation of Pakistan Chamber of Commerce and Industry

President - Kar:achi Chamber of Commerce and Industry• President - The Institute of Engineering Pakistan• Chairman - All Pakistan Textile Mills Association (APTMA)• Secretary General - Consumer Right Commission of Pakistan• Chairman - Pakistan Engineering Council• Director General - Licensing• Director General - Standardization

President - Lahore Chamber of Commerce & Industry

~ Innovation I Integrity I Value

1UU~S .SO!JOOl()L • I II'Y'- ~.' L-'I{ 1-:1)

Act fast to curb lobal warming, (J

..extract C02 from air

BE R LI N: Faster action isneeded to keep global warm-ing to agreed limits and delaysuntil 2030 could force relianceon technologies to extractgreenhouse gases from the air,a UN report said on Sunday.

The study, drawing on thework of more than 1,000experts, said a shift from fos-sil fuels to low-carbon energysuch as wind, solar or nuclearpower was affordable andwould shave only about 0.06percentage point a year offworld economic growth.

"We have a window ofopportunity for the nextdecade, and maximum thenext t\l'O decades" to act atmoderate costs, said OUmarEdenhofer, co-chair of aBerlin meeting of theIntergovernmental Panel onClimate Change (lPCC).

"I'm not saying it's cost-less. I'm not saying climatepoli~y is a free lunch. But it'sa lunch worthwhile to buy,"he said.

The report, endorsed bygovernments, is meant as themain scientific guide fornations working on a U.N.deal to be agreed in late 2015to rein in world greenhousegas emissions that have hitrepeated highs, led by China'sindustrial growth.

Governments have prom-ised to limit temperaturerises to a maximum 2 degreesCelsius above pre-industrialtimes to avert ever more heatwaves, floods, droughts andrising sea levels that theIPCC says are linked to man-made warming.

IPCC scenarios showedthat world emissions of green-

house gases would need topeak soon and tumble bybetween 40 and 70 percentfrom 2010 levels by 2050, andthen close to zero by 2100, tokeep I.~mperatures below 2C.

Such cuts are far deeperthan most governments areplanning.

"Ambitious mitigationmay even require removingcarbon dioxide from theatmosphere," the IPCC said.Delay in acting to cut 'emis-sions until 2030 would forcefar greater use of such tech-nologies, a 33-page summaryfor policymakers said.

If countries delay, theworld will have to deploy lit-tle-tested options, saidEdenhofer, a German scientistfrom the Potsdam Institute forClimate Im'pact Research.

One method mentioned by

the IPCC is to burn wood,crops or other biomass to gen-erate electricity and capturethe greenhouse gases from theexnaust fumes and bury themunderground.

The experimental technol-ogy would reduce the amountof carbon in a natural cycle ofplant growth and decay. Butthere are risks, for instancethat vast areas of land will beneeded to grow biomass, dis-placing crops and pushing upfood prices. '

Simpler methods toextract greenhouse gasesfrom the air are to planttrees,.lVhich soak up green-house gases as they grow.

The IPCC report is thethird and final part of a mas-sive United Nations series,updating science for the firsttime since 2007. A summar)'

of findings will be issued inOctober.

The U.N.'s climate chief,Christiana Figueres, said theworld should step up actionto cut emissions. "We cannotplaya waiting game whenwe bet on future technologi-cal miracles to emerge andsave the day," she said in astatement. .

U.S. Secretary of StateJohn Kerry said that everyyear the world defers action,the costs only grow.

"These technologies cancut carbon pollution whilegrowing economic opportunityat the same time," he said in astatement.

"This report makes veryclear we face an issue of glob-al willpower, not capacity."

The IPCC says it is atleast 95 percent probable

that man-made emissions,rather than natural varia-tions, are the main cause ofwarming. But many votersare doubtful and few g<: vern-ments have polides consistentwith a 2C target.

Low-carbon energies,which accounted for 17 per-cent of world energy suppliesin 2010, would have to tJ"ipleor quadruple their share hy2050, displacing conventionalfossil fuels as the top sourceof energy, IPCC scenariosshowed.

Low-carbon energ)' caninclude coal-, natural gas oroil-fired power plants if theyuse carbon capture and stor-age (CCS) to bury emissionsunderground. That technolo-gy, however, is mostly expu-imenta1.

Saskatchewan Power Corp

in Canada will start a S 1.35billion Boundal'y Dam cual-tired CCS project this yeal",capturing a million tonnesannually of carbon dioxide inwhat it says is the wodd'sfirst post-combustion co.lI-tired CCS project.

Oil and gas firms say theyan~ tackling glolntl warming.On l\lal"ch 31, Exxon l\:lohilCorp said that all energySOUI"CeS,including fossil fuels,had to be exploited to meetgrowing wodd demand.

Environmentalists s.lid thefocus should be on shifting torcnewables rather thannudear po\l'el" 01' CCS. "'Veneed to put OUI"money intothe future ... with a focus onrenewahles and energy efti-ciency," said Samantha Smithof the WWF conservationgroup. REUTERS

Printed and published by Shehryar Taseer for Media Times Limited. Daily Times, 0-198, Metroville, SITE, Karachi.

•warming:Carbon -cuts p.ossible for manageable

UN experts(1:

ARCTICSEA

,,~f;:~:;}~1-(.,r

~~ -j,.

(r "

>"0" ~.

Af.f

lllilliollmoremalnourishedchilJrerunder the age of five in 2050 com,pared to a world without climatEchange - the number of all under,fives in the US and Canada com,bined," it said.-AFP

to make the shift to low-carbonsocieties," it said. Oxfam, forits part, said climate changewould have a severe impact onhunger.

"It is estimatedthere could be 25

world untouched and unaffect- with the latest scientific knowl- But it says there is. a 15-year . C I" t h . A .ed," IPCC chairman Rajendra edge and informing the strug- window for affordable action to Ima e c ange In siaPachauri told. gling· effort to forge a world- safely reach the UN's target of

The upcoming volume is the wide pact on climate change by limiting warming to two, Co ' . • ,< " "';:':,t,}",h degrees Celsius (3.6 ~egrees

Global warming,not;ta,Jien:.·r.:\ ~al!renheit) over pre-indust6al.•.• '; :" ,!;: 'r'~". < •• ,r urnes. ~. seriously': Kim· {;:~i.~:~,l~?~6·~·:;:··~The goal ;emains atta~nable if '~,~

~'I '1.' '~~f"';';";w., "all countnes" act qUickly toWASHINGTON: Global wanning is not beingtake,n serjously ease carbon emissions, it says,

and time is running out to avoid consequences..lJk~'~~e4.~it!es "Delaying mitigation throughand dried out farmland, World .BaflKPresident jiin'·.yorigJ~jm 2030 will increase the chal-said on April 10. "We are quickly coming to the P.Qintwnere,we lenges."are not going to' be 'able, to keep.{global wanni{ik ~~o.M~9 In raw terms, global carbondegrees Celsius," Kim said at the start of the IMF-WorldBank emissions of 49 billion tonnesspring meetings in Washington. . ; .. " , . '~.: ,~,::\{', "~, of C02 equivalent in 20 I0 will

"Warming by two degrees Cels'ius is going to: have rpajor have to be pegged to 30-50 bil~implications. 40 ~rcent of the arable land in Africa,Will ..be'go#e lion tonnes in 2030.at two degrees Ceisius; Bangkok could very 'well be underWater Most scenarios that meet theat two degrees Celsius," he said. The World Bank·ijS"rriaking 2 C target entail a "tripling to PACIFICefforts in several areas to fight climate change, including·develC>p- nearly a quadrupling" in the OCEANing carbon priCing and trading schemes, finanCing' fot,~n~~abl~ share of energy from renewableenergy, and pressing govemments to'~in<:>veenergys~i?stdie¥i:,t". and nuclear sow'ces amI t~e ~ap·

But Kim expressed worry that imin'y had stopped,·thin~in'g ture and ~torage of eml§slonsabout climate change as an urgen,t proble£!1."But ip)O'l'y~;J? rrom fOSSilfuel plants, accord-years, when battles break out becauSe of lack of acc~s J6jw~fer mg to the ~raft. Gove;nm,entand food, we are all going to be sittirig'there, th~nking~Q(j§Ir,'why \ representatives and SCIentIstsdidn't we do more back then?" '. :,' . "~;~y;~4~1:',"-. ~1I1 go t.hrough the summary

"I xtr '. I - d bo t' 't' 1 d . 't thl";'kJ'th"-,'''".. l~dl.·\ lme by Ime over the next few "'~-...... ~.~ .eme y con~me ,,~,'!. 1 '~':. o~., )~-'5Ji.f;~pr,:.~!tSdays. . ',~

takmg It senously enough yet. AEP ',' .; - ~,.; ,,,',., "I n the plenary all countries '--last major piece of the fifth the end of next year. can voice their co'ncems and all Source:/pcc

Assessment Report - the first A draft summary of the of them are heard," said Co- ence demanded a reduction inoverview by the Nobel-winning report, seen by AFP, expresses chairman Youba Sokona. "In the use of fossil fuels, coupledclimate panel since 2007, no preferences for how to tame the end, it is scientific accuracy to a massive investment in

The product of four years' the problem, nor does it state that decides." renewable alternatives.\\~ork by ov~r, 200 experts, it what a safe level of warming Green group Friends of the "So far, world leaders havealms at provldmg governments would be. Earth International said the sci- sorely lacked the political will

I3ERLIN: The \\'orld, actingurgently, can curb carbon emis-sions enough to avert \\'orst-case scenarios 1'01' climatechange, UN e"perts said onApril 07 as envoys met inBerlin to weigh the options foraction.

"The literature here showsthat deep cuts in greenhouse gasemissions to limit warmingremain possible:' said OumarEdcnhofer, who helped O\'crsecthe latest volume in a report bythe UN's IntergovernmcntalPanel on Climatc Change(IPCC). But achieving. this goal,Edcnhoter warned, \\ ill requirea break from taLlay's relentless-ly upward trend in emissions,

It will entail "challengingtechnological, economic. insti-tutional and behaviour ehanl!c:'he said, -

Envoys and scientists fromthe panel's 195 memher coun-tries are meeting aner the IPCCissued its stark;st-evcr warninQabout the pcrils ora ravaged el~mate system for future genera-tions.

The risk of contlict, hunger,floods Clnd mass displacementincrease with cvery upwardcreep of the mercury, the Ipeesaid, '

"The impacts of climatechange will leave no pal1 01' the

UN Climate Chief Tells Coal Industry 'Leave It in the Ground'

W ARSA W, Poland, November 19, 2013 (ENS) - "The coal industry can and must radicallytransform and diversify to avoid the worst impacts of climate change," the United Nations' topclimate official told the CEOs of major coal companies Monday in Warsaw.

,,~, \, fII,:..II.l ;1';' 'J( .-,(1.;::: "'l(l.iy.l·' .t.,;.;,

UN climate chief Christiana Figueres in Warsaw (Photo courtesy UNFCCC)

Christiana Figueres told executives of world's largest coal producing companies, senior policymakers, business leaders and academics, "Let me be clear from the outset that my joining youtoday is neither a tacit approval of coal use, nor is it a call for the immediate disappearance ofcoal. But I am here to say that coal must change rapidly and dramatically for everyone's sake."

Figueres serves as executive secretary of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change,which is holding its annual climate change negotiations in Warsaw. There are now 195 StatesParties to the Convention and 192 Parties to its Kyoto Protocol, which limits the greenhouse gasemissions of several dozen industrialized countries and expires in 2020.

The question of what happens beyond 2020 was answered by Parties at climate talks in Durban,South Africa in 20 I I.

There governments agreed to deliver a new and universal "greenhouse gas reduction protocol,legal instrument or other outcome with legal force" by 2015 for the period beyond 2020.

The negotiations in Warsaw this ye'ar and in Lima, Peru in 2014 are supposed to lay thefoundation for universal adoption of a new legally-binding agreement in Paris in 20 IS.

Speaking at the International Coal and Climate Summit, organized by the Polish government andthe World Coal Association, Figueres urged the coal industry to honestly assess the financialrisks of business as usual, to anticipate increasing regulation, growing finance restrictions and

diminishing public acceptance and to leverage technology to reduce emissions immediatelyacross the entire chain of coal output.

Despite its sun design, theTurow coal-fired power plant in Poland emits greenhouse gasesinto the atmosphere, as do all coal-burning facilities. (Photo courtesy Elektrownia TurowSA)

"The coal industry has the opportunity to be part of the worldwide climate solution byresponding proactively to the current paradigm shift," said Figueres.

She called on the coal industry to begin this transition by closing all existing subcritical plants.

These are the least efficient coal-fired power plants, which emit more than 900 grams of thegreenhouse gas carbon dioxide per kilowatt hour. Some experts say that would mean closingabout three quarters of operational coal-fired power plants around the world, some 1.3 millionsubcritical plants.

The vast majority of installed plants still use subcritical steam conditions, and cannot reachperformance levels of state of the art technology. In fact, the total capacity of installed subcriticalcoal-fired power plants reached a record high over the last five years, according to a 2012 reportfrom the International Energy Agency.

Figueres urged the coal industry to implement safe carbon capture, use and storage systems onall new plants, even the most efficient, and to "leave most existing reserves in the ground."

. .'"These are not marginal or trivial changes, these are transformations that go to the core of thecoal industry, and many will say it simply cannot be done," said Figueres. "But the phrase'where there's a will, there's a way' is tantamount to human history because will precedesinnovation, and innovation precedes transformation," she said.

Demonstrators in Warsaw outside the World Coal Association conference (Photo byFriends of the Earth Europe)

Demonstrators from Friends of the Earth Europe and Youth Friends of the Earth Europe gatheredoutside the building to make the point that there is no such thing as clean coal. They and manyother environmental groups have signed the "People's Declaration on Coal," demanding an endto all new coal projects and for the United Nations to get coal out of the climate talks.

Godfrey Gomwe, chair of the World Coal Association's Energy and Climate Committee andchief executive of Anglo American Thermal Coal, responded, saying that the WarsawConference of Parties, known as COP 19, "is an important step towards what we all hope will bea comprehensive climate agreement in Paris in 2015."

"The urgency of acting on climate change was highlighted by the release of theIntergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report on climate science this September," saiddGomwe. "That report highlighted the urgent need to limit emissions of carbon dioxide if we areto limit global temperature rises below 2 degrees. It highlights the need to ensure that we doreach a new agreement in Paris in 2015."

Referring to the 2009 Copenhagen Accord, which aims to balance the objectives of addressingclimate change and eradicating poverty in the developing world, Gomwe said, "These issues arcinextricably linked. The world's least developed countries need access to low cost energy, butthey are also the most vulnerable to the impacts of policies aimed at reducing anthropogenicgreenhouse gas emissions."

Gomwe call~d on the international community to recognize that much ot: the developing world isturning to coal to fuel development.

"We need to help them do that in the cleanest way possible," he said. "We must, and we can,reduce emissions from burning coal for e1cctricity."

"The technology exists to significantly reduce C02 emissions from coal. Modern, highefficiency, low emission coal fired power plants emit significantly less carbon dioxide than

older, less efficient plants," said Gomwe. "A one percent improvement in efficiency results in atwo to three percent reduction in C02 emissions."

"If we were to raise the global average efficiency of coal plants from its current average of 33percent up to 40 percent we could reduce global carbon emissions by more than two gigatonnes _that's the equivalent of running the Kyoto Protocol three times over," he exclaimed.

"Modern highly efficient plants are also a key step towards near zero emissions from coalbecause they can be built ready for the deployment of carbon capture and storage technology,"Gomwe said.

Figueres also called on the industry to diversity its portfolio beyond coal, noting that the bottomline for the atmosphere is that "most existing coal reserves will have to stay in the ground."

"Some major oil, gas and energy technology companies are already investing in renewablcs, andIurge those of you who have not yet started to do this to join them," she said. "By diversifyingyour portfolio beyond coal, you too can produce clean energy that reduces pollution, enhancespublic health, increases energy security, and creates new jobs."

advantage .••.guaranteed

GRESHAM'Sthe energy-enviro specialists

GRESHAM'S EASTERN (PRIVATE) LIMITEDBusiness Center I Suite 702 - 7th Floor

Plot 19/1-A I P.E.C.H.S Block 6Main Shahrah-e-Faisal

Karachi 75400 I Pakistan

T : + 9221 343 24530 (8 Lines) IF : + 9221 343 24080

sales@geI1947.com

~ 1~~0"\_ ~- \'1

t:- c. ~ V t..11'Y\ (y.L)M l,) ~p_ 0)

M.e ()\ ) ~ ,< r: Z n"& ~

j. -I'v. ZV"::" m,I "= "tJI c::OR:>

\ O·.:s

,-Sir,

SUBJECT:

Our objections may be recorded as below:

July 24, 2014

~

~av t~~~to:

The Registrar,National Electric Power Regulatory Authority - S"" t."~"")NEPRATOWER, Attaturk Avenue (East), G-S/1, - S~""'-1:Islamabad - Pakistan. _ S~L~\~)

- ~lpGENERATION LICENSE APPLICATION OF K-ENERGY (KEPL)

1. The Low pressure boiler is being changed only at KESCfrom HFO to Coal.2. The C02 Emissions will increase which are in DIRECT conflict with UN Regulation2 C as

compared to HFO.3. The Nox will increase when compared to HFO.4. The EIA which was accepted by SEPA is a SHAM and SEPA was approached but did not

respond.5. The project cost for the boiler should not exceed USD 50 million whereas it is shown in excess

of USD 400 million.

We give NOTICE to NEPRAthat if it allows the Generation license inspite of the above, we shallfile Constitutional Petition as well as refer the matter to NAB.

Wi Jest Regards,

~ I~\/t.:':-';:':X'\)Mian Suhail H&s:~lir:::~~>"C.E.O./ Director ''''~:..::;;''::';''''''

c.c• Director General - Licensing

Director General - StandardizationChairman - THE TRANSPARENCY INTERNA TIONALChairman - SEPA

lUw.gel1 947 .com

]istered Office: F-302 Sind Industrial Trading Estate - S.1. 1.E I Karachi I Pakistan~ional Offices: Lahore IRawalpindison: USA I European Union I ROC

1lJO.I' I~nnovation I Integrity I Value

BS E SO 90011 QU LITYSURE:r)

POWER

- :,,,1t:'I.:Jr,t (;ets New Lease on Life ...

~.:..;,ti

~

Business and Technology for the Global Generation Industry

Home ! Coal

Follow Us:

HOT TOPICS: Water ! Instrumentation & Control I Wind

> REGISTER NOW to participate in this webinar: The role of mobile water treatment to offset emergency or scheduled plant shutdowns1

Click to findout more. OVAl IONN~

,It

EMERSON,Process Management

07/22/2014 I Thomas Overton

Pa. Coal Plant Gets New Lease on Life with GasRepowering

LeaL" how.

~ Mobil Industrial Lubrlcants'V don't just elevate productivity,

they unleash It.

Coal: Pa. Coal Plant Gets New Lease on Life with Gas RepoweringHome

,; - "Jr~ ';",t,; r"),,,w L",a,;", on Life ...

., ;,. .....·~;.;z~:~:~--.-r:-~~.~~~f.·_~fO ~- --.....~~~ ~:-' ~Tw~_~~;1.?-.J 8+1 :',__0... : ~< .._'!..j

'r&~~~, -:...,,-~~4'T":.."." .•.,;:.;::..•.~'.AA~1""·

MobilInduflrlcIl Lubricol'lh

-;]

". "fl' ~"~

"l'

When GenOn Energy (now part of NRG Energy) announced in March 2012 that it would retire the1950s-era coal-fired Shawville Generating Station in western Pennsylvania-blaming the impendingt."ercury and Air Taxies Standards (MATS)-the reaction was swift and bitter.

"Pragmatic energy policies should not guillotine coal from the nation's energy grid," then-stateRep. Bud George, who represented the area, said at the time. "Unfortunately, reasonable policiesthat would address valid health concerns while keeping coal and the Shawville plant in thelong-term r-nix for energy viability were not pursued."

Local officials were understandably concerned about the 73 jobs at the four-unit, 597-MW plant, theapproximately $225,000 the plant contributed in local taxes, as well as the impact on area electricreliability.

It was a story familiar to many small towns in coal country, where stacks like those at Shawville havebecome part of the landscape, and local residents have come to view decades-old plants as some·tiling permanent. Shawville was built by Pennsylvania Electric Co. in the early 19505, first comingonline in 1954. The plant was sold to Sithe Energies (now Sithe Global) in 1999, and by Sithe toReliant Energy the following year. (Reliant's later mergers and restructuring would leave the plantowned by GenOn.)

To meet MATSwhile still burning coal, Shawville would have required expensive emissions controlsthat were not justified by the plant's economics. Thus, GenOn made plans to retire ShaV'Nille in2015 before MATS compliance rules kicked in.

Fast·for.n,rard two years, and things have changed. GenOn was acquired by NRG Energy, and abun-dant natural gas in Western Pennsylvania has made gas-fired power too attractive to pass up.

In late June, NRG announced that Shawville was being given a new lease on life-with gas.

AS David Gaier, NRG's spokesperson for its east region, explained to POWER, the conversion will bevery' simple: new burners will be added to the boilers to allow the plant to run on natural gas.Shawville will retain the ability to burn coal, and the only other changes will be building a pipeline

Pi). (oal Plant Gets Ne...

POWERi C. __i(f ·i~b~_iLS\'ZKI ••_i_k _Q_t,--U:::ilz::Z:::::i:."iLIJ

Most Rend M()st Commented Most Shared

Most Read

• SDG&E and NRG Near Finish Line forCarlsbad Energy Center»

• Ginna Fights to Avoid Being Next f\Juclear

Plant Shuttered"• Construction Begin!> on \""orld's Largest

Carbon Capture Retrofit»• 2S Differences Between Private Sector

and Government Managers»

• Pa. Coal Plant Gets New Lease on Life with

Gas Repowering '"

Tables. graphs, charts, equations,and illustrations clarify and

illl Jmio;:J.te rl tpyt thrit i" rr;:lmmpn ~~

¥-~~J~, :)t'\;~~i"-'s·lrl~;~;'~~~~~.•~:

IS reTerence

guide answers specificengineering information regardingnatural, liquefied petroleum,and manufactured gases.

":<!\!ii>,.~ '"' "_'.A ..r...·~:>:?··"~:::" ·~~.lr:i:'..d~"!:}.,~~, ••~~~w~~j''9~w ...~~;r~~W'i?t~1:7~~;~~~i;'.~--3:.?01:~;;.~\-;~~~~\i

Hie decision to repower was based on a number of factors, Gaier explained, economic, environ-n~ental, and technical. Coal operations will end in April 2015 as previously scheduled, but the turn-around will be quick. "We expect to have the station back in service on gas in June 2016," Gaiersaicl.

:!I)I/\Ir::tP(l,:;g.(Or(l:

,-' ,:;-=t,; '··Jew Le·3,:e on Life ...

'!# Follow

~ POWER magazine llh@POWERmagazin'!

I&E Technician - KES Kingsburg LP - Kingsburg,California: As an IE Tech for PurEnergyOpmtions Services (KE... bit.!y/ll"'y13w .:::J

B711 ~

Tweets

I'OWB POWER magazine@POWERtYlagazin~

Are @Nestthermostats the future of demandresponse? powermag,com/nc,t-thcrrno:.ta, ..Expand

I"Olltaa POWER magazine 13h

@POWERrnagazine

Follow Editor Gail Reitenbach @GailReit fortweets ftom the #EPA's Denver pLJblic hearingnext Tues. on the proposed carbon rule, #ll1(d)Expand

Sonie jobs will be lost-the refueled plant will employ about 40 people-but the site as a whole willcontinue operating, albeit with a different role.

"Ttle station will operate more like a peaking plant after the conversion," Gaier said. And, switchingfrom coal will give Shavwille "a dramatically improved emissions profile."

H'iOUgh the shift from coal will impact the local coal industry, it will also support the booming shale]B5 sector in Pennsylvania, which has created hundreds ofthousands of jobs and seen the state'sgas production skyrocket from essentially negligible to third in the nation.

The glut of gas in the Marcellus shale has led to a boom in construction of gas-fired plants, somesited specifically to take advantage of depressed prices resulting from regional pipeline can-5traints. Those constraints, which are due to gas production overwhelming the area's gathering in-frastructure, are not expected to ease for several years.

-Thomas W. Olierton,}D is a POWER associate editor.

r~d,(1 J.0~·

Tweet to @POWERmagdzine

PRlNT MODE: OFF

More Stories You Might Like CIIJlI.POWERThe Source for Coal-Fired Generation

:J•

-',,:::,'

G Login y'

California Wants Proposals for Renewable-Powered Microgrids -+

Poviermag

: ;>',/ !h~.-:\{ '07.

- House Energy and Commerce Chair OutlinesEnergy Policy Needs for Emerging U.S. EnergyA.IJundance

o Comments

',l ,II l.l I,t Pa. Coal plant Gets Ne... r:;;i Untitled- Par¥:..

ANWAR KAMAL LAW ASSOCIATES

Dear Sir,

Public Hearing to be held on 12.08.2014 in the Matter ofApplication of K-Energy (Pvt) Limited (KEPL) for the grant ofGeneration Licence.

Dated: 091h Aug., 2014BY EMAIL, FAX & COURIER<office@nepra.org.pk>

051-2600026

I~ef. No.VC/NEPRA/358/]4

Kindly refer to the Notice for the Public Hearing to be held on 12th August,

2014 at NEPRA Tower, Islamabad at 11:00 A.M.

First of all it is not proper on the part of the Authority to deprive the people of

Karachi from participating in proceedings which affect their very existence. The

objection has been raised a number of times and the Authority had promised to

hold hearings affecting Karachiites at Karachi.

i ~The Vice Chairman,~ :National Electric Power~~Regulatory Authority (NEPRA),

~ \ :Attaturk Avenue (East),~~~NEPRA Tower,~ J~Opposite Federal Flood Commission,

~ ~~G-5/ 1, Islamabad.(; :Z c~0'" .jSUBJECT:

The going back on this promIse leads to the irreristible inference that this is

being done with malafide intent to benefit K-Electrie and K-Energy (KEPL) at

the expense of the consumers of K-Electric. The Authority is requested to

perform its statu tory du ty of protecting the in terest of the consumers.

This deliberate effort to favour K-Electric and K-Energy by shutting out the

consumers of K-Electric, who obviously cannot afford the expense and/ or time

of travelling to Islamabad to safeguard their interest, raises serious questions

··--f--···1bout the neutrality and impartiality of the Authority. This is particularly

I ~ ~~o since the Authority has also scheduled the Public Hearing in the matter of• \" I

I : ~~;I <"<,Q' ~ ~"E ~"\ fl.~ ~;l /-~(}- ~ lJ~L)1V .~. ~, .....••.. LA Cant ...

f ~,.! ~ L...'-'O '-,

:~~ ';; i ~ '- ~ h>: ~ t C-l'- ~ ve-It'hCUC)

~. ~ I \~\~\'1 - ~ ~ lTcv"') M l1 )Q t:.~j _ SAC MtE:) 1Y\(u..; )

•__ .-~. " n....~ ~ IV\ J r_

ANWAR KAMAL LAW ASSOCIATESContinuation Sheet No.1

monthly Fuel Charges Adjustment of K-Electric (formerly KESeL) for themonths of April, May and June, 2014 on the same date, i.e. 12th August, 2014from 12:00 noon to 01:30 P.M., at NEPRA Tower, Islamabad.

I would have attended the Public Hearing in person on 12.08.2014 to assist the

Authority to arrive at a just and informed decision but the current volatile

political situation and the shutting down of the cities of Lahore and Islamabad

make it impossible for me to travel to Islamabad on 12.08.2014.

T request that information about the guaranteed availability of ALL power

producing Units of K-Electric, as originally licenced and subsequently modified

by the Authority, be provided to me. It is submitted that this is necessary since

the under consideration application is an Application for the grant of

Generation Licence by K-Energy in respect of Power Plants included in the

Generation Licence of K-Electric.

It is further submitted that this Generation Licence Application is an outcome

of the in principle approval of the Licencee Proposed Modification (LPM) of K-

Electric to exclude the BQPS Units 3 & 4 from its Generation Facility and to

lease out the same to K-Energy for conversion to coal and thereafter supply of

tectric power from these Plants to K-Electric.

Sir, K-Electric (formerly KESCL) \vas gIven a target to increase its installed

capacity by 1000 MW through rehabilitation of its existing Power Plants and by

installing new Power Plants. For this purpose, the Government of Pakistan gave

a substantial amount (under FIP) under the Privatisation Agreement to

K- Electric: but K- Electric has failed to add new Generation Plants. Instead,

it has replaced its existing Power Plants, which is not the intended use of

Cont ...

ANWAR KAMAL LAW ASSOCIATESContinuation Sheet No.2

Government of Pakistan funds to K-Electric for addition of Generation capacity.

The exclusion of BQPS Units 3 & 4 from K-Electric Generation Licence will

further decrease the Generation capacity of K-Electric.

NEPRA has, in principle, approved the LPM of K-Electric to exclude BQPS

UnitS 3 & 4 for their leasing to K-Energy, subject to the grant of a Generation

Licence to K-Energy. One of the basic parameters to approve or disapprove the

LPM by the Authority is "impact on tariff'. In the case of the proposed

modification, this has not yet been determined by the Authority. Hence, prior to

proceeding further, this needs to be determined by the Authority.

In this regard, the Chairman's message in the Annual Report 2012-2013 of

NEPRA is most material and relevant. In the interest of the consumers, I

request that before proceeding further, NEPRA should ask K-Electric to provide

details of the consumption of the FIP funds for the rehabilitation of BQPS Units

3 &4.

NEPRA must have a cost-benefit analysis of the proposed changes carried out

before making a decision about the same. The Authority must ensure that

there is no physical progress prior to granting formal approval in respect of the

LPM and the grant of a Generation Licence to K-Energy, if the grant is found to

be warranted. Given the track-record of KESeL, the Authority must satisfy

itself and have a Site fnspection Report to see whether K-Electric and K-Energy

are already doing what they are seeking permission to do, and which they

cannot do without the prior approval of the Regulator.

The Authority will recall that under the Multi Year Tariff (MYT) granted to

KEseL prior to its privatisation, the arrangement was a "closed and locked"

transaction. By opening and unlocking the arrangement post-privatisation,

the Authority has stepped onto a treacherous and slippery slope to the utter

Cont ...

ANWARKAMAL LAWASSOCIATESContinuation Sheet No.3

disadvantage of the consumers, who the Authority was mandated by law to

protect. The Authority is requested in the public interest to make just and

informed decisions and not to become a captive tool in the hands of clever

manipulators, be they inside or outside the Government.

I request that the Public Hearing scheduled at 11 :00 A.M. on 12.08.2014 be

adjourned in the public interest and this Public Hearing be held at Karachi to

enable and facilitate the consumers of Karachi to participate meaningfully in

the proceedings. In my humble opinion not to do this is to negate the very

purpose of holding Public Hearings, mandated by the NEPRA Act, 1997 itself.

The Authority's decisions have to be consistent with the outcomes of Public

Hearings!

With best regards.

~n~

• (Anwar Kamal) .,Copies forwarded to:

1. The Registrar, National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA), AttaturkAvenue (East), NEPRA Tower, Opposite Federal Flood Commission, G-5/ 1,Islamabad. By Email (registrar@nepra.org.pk), Fax and Courier.

2. Syed Adil Gilani, Esq., Advisor, Transparency International-Pakistan, 5-C, 2nd

Floor, Khayaban-c-Ittchad, Phase VII, Defence Housing Authority, Karachi, withreference to his letter dated 05tl1 August, 2014. By Fax, Email and Courier. ByEmail: ti.pakistan(clJgmail.com

/(Anwar Kamal)

Office: I-Turner Road, Lahore-54000, PakistanTelephone: (92-42) 37311810-37358845 FAX: 37238174

E-mail: aklaw(a)lhr.comsats.net.~

CHOUDHARY MAZHAR ALlCHIEF WARDEN CIVIL DEFENCE (RETD)

Arjan Building,Mohan Road, Karachi.

Ph # 021-32771400

This is with reference to the above cited subject on which N.E.P.R.A

inviting comments for or against from the interested/ affected persons andthe general public. The undersigned would like to comment as follows:-

Date: 07.05.2014~ \-\-,~n. ~

~."~.I'1

Cc. \, vc-t '" ( ~~E)ene-r)(Yl(~)

Promoters of K-Energy for ego Titan Industrial Group are the owners ofcoal mines in Indonesia form where the company will procure itsrequirements of coal for the next 20 years. The annual consumptionwill be around 1.5 million tones. Since the promoters have their ownvested interested of disposing their own product. Hence no interest in

Cont'd Page 2

The newly formed K-Energy, as Spy (Special Purpose Vehicle),formed

by third party investors from Indonesia, Hong Kong &: Korea, as an IPPis not correct. An IPP is strict legal terms is an organization formedunder the various Power Policies of the GOP, by obtaining consentsfrom various relevant government agencies, for establishing a "greenfield" power producing entity producing power, to be sold exclusively

to GOP owned entity in accordance with the terms &: conditions of the"Power Policy" under which it is established &: also governed by theterms &: conditions set by the Authority. The proposed setup is merelyan enterprise of the privat~ sector, established for the purpose ofproducing power to be sold to an another private sector companyengaged in the transmission &: distribution of power in a specifiedlicensed area for a limited period. Since NEPRAhas recently approvedKESCrequest of LPM for unit 3 and 4 of Bin Qasim. The hidden agendaof K syndicate is likely to be completed which will be only to extractmoney from available sources.

Subject:

~

\= ~C""~~~

The Registrar, - . C~c) 0N.E.P.R.A. \0' tISLAMABAD. ~ ~C\~~){(""EE)

- SA--1--T ~~:Jt _IVII FGRANT OF GENERATION LICENSE TO K-ENERGY.

...

z • 1...tl ,".~"i ~-

CHOUDHARY MAZHAR ALlCHIEF WARDEN CIVIL DEFENCE (RETD)

Page 2

Arjan Building,Mohan Road, Karachi.

Ph # 021-32771400

generation which will be actually managed by some other parties and

not K-Energy on the proposed Generation Project. This is apparent

from the formation of board of the company. Five out of sevendirectors are forieners the two Pakistani gentlemen are not at allknown in business sector in Pakistan especially in power sector. Itseems the gentlemen having one percent share are just for the namesake only. Two units are being leased out for 20 yeas at a very lowrent without any security. High tariff have been suggested. K-Energy

will not have sufficient space for stocking of coal. The entire labour ofKESCpresently working on these units will go idle.

3. The undersigned as a shareholder of KESC feel that the project ofgeneration to be taken up· by K-Energy should be taken by KESC

themselves. Majority of the share holders voted against leasing out.

4. The authority is therefore, requested to please hold a public hearingin Karachi on the above subject, so that it can have input from all theother stakeholders. In my opinion K-Energy not suitable company forgeneration license.

5. I would like to present further argument again the suggested issues ofthe license to K-Energy when the public hearing is conducted by theauthority in Karachi.

Thanking you.

PKIMt: MINI~ I t:.K-~ U•...t"1\",t:

BOARD OF INVESTMENTAtaturk Avenue, Sector G-5/1

(Tel: 92-51-9224749, Fax: 9244557****

Subject: APPLICATIONS FOR GRANT OF GENERATION LICENSES BYMIS. FIRST SOLAR (PVT.) LIMITED, MIS:' ALLIANCE SUGAR MILLS(PVT.) LTD AND MIS. K-ENERGY (PVT.) LIMITED (KEPL).

Reference NEPRA's letters No. NEPRA/R/LAG-264/8544051 dated July 21,2014, No. NEPRA/R/LAG-266/8575-82 dated July 21, 2014 and No. NEPRA/R/LAG-01/8616-8653 dated July 22,2014 regarding the subject cited above.

2. To tap alternate sources for generation of power is dire need of the country,it will decrease the short fall (around 6000 MW) of electricity in the country. Board ofInvestment (BOI), being an investment promoting agency understands that affordableand smooth supply of energy is backbone for industrial growth as well as attracting FDI inthe country. - .

~ t~D'")f ~ tJ,PS-DG(PP/Legal), BOI, Islamabad. N::1 r_~v;~(\k) ~

~~ \0 : ,~. 0«. \""S fJr (:\<4~) _S '1-T _1'" c..t" \Ie.... 'f\o\L4l

_ fYIt.c ""tofl\LfI\ J

Copy to :

3. BOI, therefore, supports the proposal with a view to bring investment in thecountry particularly in a priority sector i.e. energy subject to fulfillment of aU codal andtechnical formalities in this regard. . ,. j\~ )J/

r---. -11 ~U\\!yI 1"'11 t(( Qazi Asif Mahboob )I l'-: :~ ,- Desk Officer (PP):vl · i" I '~ i~~j·~r. Iftikhar Ali Khan, Deputy Registrar, National Electric Power Regulatory

t ~\ ~ I Authority(NEPRA), NEPRA Tower, Attaturk Avenue (Eastt G-5/2, Islamabad.! ~ ~~l BOl's U.O. Note No. 2(57)/2010-PP Dated: AugusUo., 2014! ~ .. '#: ~ tI •• ~

!~ ;:. ~l:, ~... a.JI'~ .•..f: ~ >, C";.!l~ (.j 0,L-.- J

,.

Islamabad, the 20th May, 2014

00~ Cj'CD ...,i" '< r-· z_·i ~ £•• .• ~:!); : en Z: ~r-.j-'m~I Lt.:E -0

.:(x[1°;u:v i~'"5:»: \: UJ: : 0r: :J. :" .. .: I

No. NG-II-7(143)/PS/2013-NEPRA- Vol-I-ptGovernment of Pakistan

Ministry of Petroleum & Natural Resources(Policy Wing)

Directorate General of Gas21-E, Huma Plaza, Blue Area

***~egistrar

National Electric Power Regulatory Authority,NEPRA Tower, Attaturk Avenue (East), G-5/1,Islamabad

Subject: APPLICATION OF K-ENERGY (PRIVATE) LIMITED (KEPL) FOR GRANTOF GENERATION LICENSE FOR ITS 420 MW THERMAL POWER PLANTAT BIN QASIM, KARACHI

Dear Sir,I am directed to refer to NEPRA's letter No, NEPRA/R/LAG-243/KEPL/4527-36 dated

r-'--:::J 0 :;0 i.~ ~ ~ I.~ ~ ~'Ic.. - CJ)• 0 ,....4~. """: : ~.) .• .., I:;~: II'·J. .~ Ii~~S: II • • <:;:) \t: ::'-..;

~

t~~~ ~ I'~::: f.. ".. ".. .., .... ,

(Abdul Rasheed Jokhio)Deputy Director (Tech.)

~,<:\ Pt,~2 l· os· ''1

LC' '. "c.. f f\") C \..\ t)fYll,)r'r\ ( c....••\").

rv{~~~ ~1)' (l)~) ()

~ \-t>:

- \)~ f;\,~h) / (\'h" ~ )

-~.- <h.l ~SPS to Secretary Petroleum & NRSPS to Additional Secretary(P) Petroleum & NRPA to DG (Gas) Petroleum & NR

02.05.2014 on the above subject and to inform that as it is evident from the contents of the

advertisement that M/s KEPC intends to install Conventional Steam Turbine/Boiler Thermal Power

Plant based on Imported Coal as fuel. and, as such, no gas is required for utilization in this project.

Therefore, this Ministry has no objectionlcon1n1ents for grant of Generation license to M/s KEPL in the

subject matter.

c.c:(i)(ii)(iii)

Tel.: 9221 32560705,32562883, 0308-2221234Fax: 92 21 32560704

Cell: (Secretary) 0300-8235464Email: site@site-association.org

Website: www,site-association.org

S.I.T.E. ASSOCIATIONOF INDUSTRY

AIWAN-E-SANAT, H-16, TEXTILE AVENUE, SITE KARACHI-75700 P KISTAN

~ (V \ ~J.: ..September 12, 2014 t iv' ( t;.C-)

-~FTHE REGISTRAR /.-.._National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA) -t'1 f:, ,NEPRA Tower, Attaturk Avenue (East), Sector G-5/1, fAC(-L.-t..h)Islamabad.

Re:: Delay in Grant of Genel'ation Licence to K-Energy Limited

Dear Sir,

SITE Association of Industry represents the largest industrial hub of Pakistan - the SITEIndustrial Estate where about 3000 industrial units me operating to cater the nationalneeds and exports to bring valuable foreign exchange in Pakistan. SITE is the largestemployer of inQustrial workers in the country and it is earning 38% of the whole revenue

of Pakistan.

Since, K-Electric IS playing the crucial role in the whole economic activity of SITEindustrial area, SITE Association of Industry is pleased to issue this Business SupportLetter with reference to the K-Energy's flagship coal conversion project in Port Qasimwhereby the utility has been working to convert its two units currently based on furnace

oil to coal.

K-Energy Limited has specifically been formed to undertake the coalconversion venture. The project demonstrates KESC's commitment to pioneer coalconversion of power plants in the country, and is in line with KESC's vision to bringdown power tariff by utilizing low cost fuel sources for electricity generation. Theproject would result in generation of reliable and cheap electricity for the advantage ofthe citizens of Karachi. The conversion project would also directly benefit the country'seconomy since this would replace power generation by expensive furnace oil therebysaving on account of oil import bill through utilizing coal at significantly cheaper price.

As we understand, the project company has filed application for issuance of generationlicence with NEPRA and has also submitted Tariff Petition with the Authority. Thecompetent authority had scheduled a hearing for Generation License on 1ill August,2014 in Islamabad which was delayed due to the constant protests in the Capital and was

, -K~~'I(-.~S.I.T.E. ASSOCIATIONj 0·· ~ OF INDUSTRY;' 4.~Ous"'i~ (lr..l~

U)Tel.: 92 21 32560705,32562883, 0308-2221234

Fax: 92 21 32560704Cell: (Secretary) 0300-8235464

Email: site@site-association.orgWebsite: www.site-association.org

AIWAN-E-SANAT, H-16, TEXTILE AVENUE, SITE KARACHI -75700 PAKISTAN

rescheduled for September 5, 2014. Unfortunately, the hearing was further adjourneduntil further notice and henceforth any decision in the matter is pending.

As the country continues to face increasing energy crisis, the delay at NEPRA's end isbeyond comprehension and unfavorable to the public at large. We would, therefore, liketo register our serious concern that the whole process of regulatory approvals includingK-Electric's LPM, issuance of generation license to K-Energy Limited and tariff.approvals for the project company has already' been substantially delayed (more thanaround two years as per our understandin'g) beyond the given timeframe under NEPRARules and is being further delayed at the whims and wishes of anti-social elements.

We would like to request the Authority not to deprive the country of such a beneficialproject and kindly expedite its decision-making process for grant of Generation Licenceto K-Energy Limited and related other tariff approvals. We believe that thegroundbreaking of this first of its kind Project in Pakistan is only waiting approval fromNEPRA.

SITE Association of Industry would highly appreciate and welcome if the hearing in thematter is fixed at the earliest possible for grant of Generation Licence to K-EnergyLimited.

We would further appreciate ifNEPRA keeps us posted in the matter.

Sincerely,

AHSAN ARSHAD AYUBACTING CHAIRMAN

2

•

NO.SMD/CIW/Misc./ I (,/20 CJ?

,,

OJ

Securities and Exchange Commission of PakistanSecurities Market Division - Market Supervision & Registration Department

~-

~I - May 22, 2014:" h-----~,~~ ~'vt··,~,c'''"'';\_.J : .\

L. : '0- ----i::':l... . ·1 - ',,- d ::c; ; "-" )\') _Lh \~ ~,. j, r ~

J ,A-:': : \ ~. /\.;:> :\.r~

( .~ ~ _ 'Li~'~\'~ i -~;--... :

I !;_.•.......:l-C';' G" ,~) I', '" ~Ie r d- \,':'"i." 1_',i) :: .

• ""'\ j ~-.:.,-.- - ,"\ ('-, ,l ~-"--- .__ •__.I. 1- L

Application of K-Energy (Pvt.) Limited (KEPL) for grant of Generation License for its 420 MWThermal Power Plant at Bin Qasim, Karachi. .'\ '\ ( C '"T i.

))/1)',')_ -\ ,;',... "-- ~ . t:, -"':"'J ...t"h~. ~ .

Dear Sir,

Mr. Iftikhar Ali Khan,Deputy Registrar,National Electric Power Regulatory Authority,NEPRA Tower, Attaturk Avenue, G-5/l,Islamabad.

Subject:

Please refer to your letter NO.NEPRA/R/LAG/·243/KEPLi4545-49 dated May 2, 2014 on t~,esubject noted above, wherein comments of the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP)have been sought on an application filed by K-Energy (Pvt.) Limited (the Company) with the NationalElectric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA) for grant of Generation License in respect of 420 MWCoal based Thermal Power Plant at Bin Qasim, Karachi. /\

2. In this regard, it is stated that a developed, robust and broad-based capital market plays important / Y),role in the growth of economic development of a country. Primary purpose of a capital market is to bringtogether the corporates that need funds to meet their financial requirements for financing their projec~ts 0.. V,and the investors that have surplus funds and looking for the investment avenues. )-.YblfJl13. SECP being the apex regulator of the capital market and the corporate sector is continuouslyworking for the development of the domestic capital markets and the corporate sector. But in this ~I Yendeavor, other regulatory authorities like NEPRA can playa vital role. NEPRA regulates the power / v'1l<sector which is a significant segment of our corporate sector. The companies that fall under the ambit of /\"NEPRA on one hand may contribute in the development and broad-basing of our capital markets and on ~the other hand can be benefited from the capital market by using it as an additional avenue for fund~raising. Whenever a company decides to raise fund form the capital market through issue of shares, the~ompany needs to be listed on a stock exchange so that the shareholders is provided a market for trading \t\\~III shares. IlJf4. Listing of companies on the stock exchanges has many benefits. Listing not only enables thecompanies to tap this additional avenue for fund raising but also build up investor's confidence andimproves credentials of such companies as after listing, quality of the disclosures and reporting isimproved and the companies get exposure to the international investors. Listing also enables thecompanies to minimize their dependence on the banking sector and thus surplus resources of banks maybe diverted to the development of inactive sectors of1he economy like the SME and agriculture sectors.

5. In view of the foregoing l'E~ attention is drawn towards our letter of even number datedAugust 2, 20 II (Annexure-I) and suggest that if a Generation License is granted to the Company. acondition may please be imposed requiring the sponsors of the Company to get the Company listed onany domestic stock exchange within a period of say two years from the date of commencement ofbusiness by the Company.

NIC Building, 63 Jinnah Avenue, IslamabadTel: 051-9203958, Fax: 051-9218595 E-mail: amir.khan@secp.gov.pk

6. It is noteworthy to mention here that such condition is also being imposed by the State Bank ofPakistan, under its Guidelines and Criteria for setting up of a Commercial Bank, requiring the Banks tolist on the domestic stock exchanges within a period of two years of the date of grant of license.

Yours truly,

(Amir M. Khan Afridi)Director (CI)

Copy for information to:

(i) The Executive Director (CCD), SECP, Islamabad.(ii) The Registrar of Companies, Companies Registration Office, SECP, Karachi.

NIC Building. 63 Jinnah Avenue. IslamabadTel: 051-920395B. Fax: 051-9218595 E-mail: amir.khan@secp.gov.pk

~C\o

6~~ SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION OF PAKISTAN /~ Securities Market Division - Mar1{et Supervisioh & Capital Issues Depa,-tmentC~!,:l . . . .._.._.__~. ..._._"'_._"_No. SMD/CIWfMisc./16/2007

IMr. Khalid Saeed,Chainllan,National E\ectric ~ower Regulatory Authority;OPF Building, 2n4 Floor,Shahrah-e-Jamhooriyat, p-5/2,Islamabad

August 2, 2011

Subject: ENCOURAGEMENT OF NEW LISTINGS ON THE DOMESTIC STOCK EXCHANGE

Dear Sir,

As you know that a developed stock market plays a pivotal role in the development of the economyof a country. The primary purpose of a stock market is to bring together the corporates that need funds tomeet their financial requirements fot financing their projects and the investors that have surplus funds andlooking for the investment avenues.

2. Listing on a stock exchange not only enable the companies to tap this additional avenue [or fundI .

raising but also build up investor's confidence and improve credentials of such companies. Through listing ofcompanies on the stock exchanges, quality of the disclosures and reporting is improved. Listing also enablesthe companies to minimize their dependence on the banking sector and thus surplus resources of the banksmay be diverted to the development of inactive sectors of the economy.

3. [t might be in your knowledge that currently there are around 59,430 companies that have beenincorporated with the Securities and Exchange Conunission of Pakistan under the Companies Ordinance,1984 but the number of listed companies is 638 i.e., around 1% which is not an encouraging omen. Throughthe Finance Act, 2011, the Govemment of Pakistan has announced a tax holiday for five years for newprojects and BMRlexpansion provided such projects' are financed entirely through equity. Capital marketprovides an opportunity to corporates to raise funds for meeting their equity needs.

4. One of the requirements for listing of a company on a domestic stock exchange is that such companyshould have paid up capital of atleast RS.200 million. Out of the total 59,430 companies there are more than660 unlisted companies each having paid-up capital of Rs.200 million and above. The said 660 companiesinclude major giants of power sector regulated by the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority(NEPRA). List of some of such companies is attache~ herewith at Annexure-I.

5. In order to discuss the ways to motivate the managements of these companies for listing on the localstock exchanges, the Commission intends to have a meeting with NEPRA. You are, therefore, requested tokindly give us elate/time for the said meeting as per ydur convenience.

NIC Building, 63 Jinnah Avenue, Blue Area. IslamabadTel: 051-9225224, L1AN: 111-11-5ECP (7327) ?ABX: 051-9207094,Fax: 051-9218595

, ••.••. I••••• I I....• _.• _•• .. _'.

( ..

Annexure-I

Unlisted Companies having Paid up Capital of Rs.ZOOmillion and abov8regulated by Nation,at Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA)

~\V

S. No. CompanyPaid-up Capital

(Rs.)

1 ROUSCH (PAKISTAN) POWER LIMITED 8,621,573,120.

2 JAMSHORO POWER COMPANY LTD 8,128,537,088

3 UCH POWER (PRIVATE) LIMITED 7,607,300,096

4 LIBERTY POWER TECH LIMITED 4,639,323,648

5 HALMORE POWER GENERAtiON COMPANY LIMITED 3,831,719,424

6 TNB LIBERTY POWER LIMITED 3,528,000,000

7 LALPIR POWER LIMITED 3,453,079,296

8 SAIF POWER LIMITED 3,450,650,880

9 ENGRO POWERGEN QADIRPUR LIMITED 3,200,000,000

10 ORIENT POWER COMPANY (PVT.) LIMITED 2,876,403,200

11 SABA POWER COMPANY (PRIVATE) LIMITED 2,342,796,800

12 ATTOCK GEN LIMITED 2,149,318,912

13 FAUJIJ<A~IRWALA POWER COMPANY \-IMITEQ 1,788,950,144

14 HABIBULLAH COASTAL POWER COMPANY (PRIVATE) LIMITED 1,718,122,880

15 GUL AHIVIED !=NERGY liMITED 1,683,284,608

16 TAPAL !=NERGY (PVT.) LIMITED 1,293,292,288

17 LARAIS ENERGY LIMITED 1,290,446,720

18 STAR HYDRO POWER LIMITED 918,608,640,19 KAMOKI ENERGY L1IV1ITED 799,999,936

20 SAPPHIRE ELECTRIC COMPANY LIMITED 732,515,008

21 ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE HOLQING (PRIVJI.,TE) LIMITED 630,000,oqo

22 ICI PAKISTAN POW[:R GEN LIMITED 580,000,000

23 GULF RENTAL POWER (PVT.) LIMiTED 500,000,000

24 HEAVY ELECTRICAL COMPLEX (PRIVATE) LIMITED 413,196,000,

25 CHAKWAL ELECTRIC SUPPLY CaMPY 410,172,000

26 DADABHOY ENERGY SUPPLY CO. LIMITED. 401,G92,G40

27 POWER GENERATI~lN SYSTEMS LIMITED 335,927,008

28 PAK ENERGY (PRIVATE) LIMITED. 324,000,000

29 ATLAS POWER LIMITED. 321,GOO,000

30 TECHNO·E·POWER (PRIVATF) LIMITED 300,000,192

31 TECHNO ENERGY (PVT.) LIMITED 300,000,192

32 YOUNG GEN POWER LIMITED 300,000,000

33 FFC ENERGY LIMITED 300,000,000

34 SHAKARGANJ ENERGY (PVT.) LIMITED 285,000,000

35 MIRA PAKISTAN LIMITED 282,112,800

3G STAR POWER GENERATION LIMITED 269,212,992

37 MADIAN HYDRO POWER LIMITED 204,200,000

TRANSPARENCYINTERNATIONAL-PAKISTAN

5-C, 2nd Floor, Khayaban-e-Ittehad, Phase VII,Defence Housing Authority, Karachi.Tel: (92-21 )-35390408,35390409, Fax: 35390410E-mail: ti.pakistan@gmail.comWebsite: www.transparency.org.pk

16th August, 2014

Habibullah Khilji,Vice Chairman,National Electric Power Regulatory Authority,OPF Building, 2nd Floor, Shahrah-e-Jamhooriyat,G-5/2,Islamabad,

Sub: Public Hearings to in the Matter of Application ofK-Energy (Pvt) Limited (KEPL)for the grant of Generation Licence, and Monthly Fuel Adjustn1ent Charges.

Dear Sir,

Transparency International Pakistan has received a complaint about venue of public hearingsat Islamabad, in the Matter of Application of K-Energy (Pvt) Limited (KEPL) for the grantof Generation Licence, and hearing Monthly Fuel Adjustment Charges which was to beheld at Islamabad on 12.08.2014, but have been postponed.

According to the complaint, NEPRA has been reportedly taking discrin1inatory n1easures tobenefit KESC, new K-Electric, at the cost of Consumers, over 1.2 n1illion, who all arelocated in Karachi, but NEPRA is designating the venue of public hearing at Islamabad,.

1

hearings on matterVice Chairman NEPRA is therefore requested to reschedule allregarding K-Energy (Pvt) Limited (KEPL) in near future, at Karachi.

TI Pakistan is striving to have Rule of Law in Pakistan, which is the only way to eliminatecorruption and have good governance in country.

vrrfRegardS. ~

l~~c~~SohaiL11-UZaf~

~man

In order to play a neutral role as regulator, NEPRA should hold all public hearings on allmatters of K-Energy (Pvt) Limited (KEPL), not in Islamabad, but at Karachi.S.R.O. 1399 (I)/98. National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Tariff Standards andProcedure) Rules, 1998 Section 9, subsection 11 permits NEPRA to hold the hearing at adifferent location than Islamabad.

1~~~"2-S ' C> ~, \ ""

f)W (J..h-) h-/ ~ :-VC(1h. LU {~ ~' y. I'l". r--, 1I)

_/SA("e~) ~ ('r)(CJ\l0'\ ( P .,/ ~ VI> ~'O J

r~ Copy forwarded for information with request to take action under thei ~ to, ~.......--

j ;)1 ~~I ~ l '-..J h 1. Se~retary ~othe Prime !V1inister,for infonnation of the ~rime Minister, to takeI I~:)-;' J actIOn for ImplementatIOn of PMs Zero Tolerance PohcyI Go: ~~ f against Corruption, Islamabad.I ~ ~ (~~ '! 2. Cha~rman, PAC, Karachi

I h ; lJd 3. Cha~rman, NAB, Islamabad ..I ~ : ~:~! 4. RegIstrar, Supreme Court PakIstan, Islamabadr?oJ ~ •• ,

I.~ :;; 'l):i A NON-PARTISAN, NON-PROFIT COALITION AGAINST CORRUPTION

II~ .~~; Donations exempted from tax U/S 2 (36) (c) of I. Tax Ordinance 2001C,j ::>") {r;'~_.-s:. ~J

·i. i §tle I vel· s t U lIi

5th September 2014

72-FIII Jami Commercial Street NO.9 Phase VII,Defence Housing Authonty, KarachiTel: (92·21) 35391T18 Fax: (92-21) 35391778Email: info@whistlcblower.com.pkWebsite: www.whistleblower.com.pl<

~r, r_tf'-_C_S_-Q_~ __\~

TitUSTEES

Ms. Vasmeen lari

Ju.llcc (R) Nasira Javed

Ms. Shahana Kaulwb

Mr. Soh ail Muz"ffar

Justice (R) Zia Perwaizl~ot:(cloJ'v limlt'r,ll)

l'vIr. I Iabibullah Khilji,National Electric Pow!:r Regt:latory AuthorityVie!: Chairman,NEPRA Tower Attaturk Avenue (East),Sector U-51 t,

Islamabad.

Dear Sir,

This is further to I\KLt\'s klkr 09.0S.201-i 011 behalf of Syed ALlil Uillalli,Esq., a consumer of K-Ekctrie and IlltervCllL·r. It had bCCll expeckJ that prillI'to holding this public hearing, the Authority would JJ'a111e Issues ~lndcommunicatc thc same in oruer to hold a meaningful hearing. 110\Vc"cr, thishas not bccn dune cven though a llumber of makrial qucstiOllS \\cre rai::.eJ illthe letter. III addition to questions or financial impli-:atiolls, t\\"i) leg:dquestions of funu:lIllCntal importance to the evolution of the Pom:r sedor inPah.istan h3vc arisen fur consideration by the Authority. Thcse n:late tLl the

~ ~v:nallcrs of "in-principk approval" and thc grant or a C/cncration Liecnse for/ GA.hrrn~po\\'er Pbnts owncd by a licensed entity othcr than the Applicant.

The conduct or hC:lring in the mailer of grant of Generation License isprovided undcr sub-rule 4 of Rule 3 of the National Electric Powcr RcgubtoryAuthurity (NI~PRI\) (Cicneration) Ruks. 2002. The NLPIU\ (iclll'r:lliull Ruks,2002 have adopted thl.: saml.: procedure to conduct this hearing as is providedill thc NEPRA Tariff (St<.lndards & Procl.:dure) Ruks, 1')99.

It is submitted th;.)t SUlH'U!C 2 of Rule 9 of the NEPR,\ Tariff Rllk~ prcsnibcstill.: framing of Issues for public hearings but unfortunately ncill1er the issues1'01' this hearing \\'\:re advertised in the press 1101" communicated through Ielterssent sl'paratL:!y tu difll:rl.:nt stakdJOluers lkspite the fact that J\KLt\ h:ldcOllllllunicated several Issues in the malt!:!' to NFPR,\ \'ide ktter l!:ltedO~.()H.20 l,t (copy enclosed). In the recent past the Authority had adjourned thepublic hcaring in thl.: malleI' of determination of Upli'unt TarilT fur Solar PowerPbnts eonduekd at Lahwc fi)!' thl.: reason of l\l'>n-fi'all1ing ;tnd nOll-communicatioll of the Issu!:s. It is requested that a hearing be held aner theli'aming and communication of Issues. This n:quest merits to be accepted nutonly on thc principle of consistency and fair play, but even nlOrc illlportalltlyowing tu the signi ticanec of the qucstions, which havl.: arisen Ilx cunsideratillllby the I\uthority ('or thc wry first time.

5yed Adil GiI,mi(ell,llrlll,HI)

" (Rl Dr. GhousMuhiJrnmao

(Vice t:h.urrn ..JIlI

1

A Trust Registered under Trust Act 1882

A NON-rJAlnISAN, NON-PROFIT, NON-POLITICAL ORGANIZAi'JON AGAINST CORRUt'TiON

Continuation Sheet No .,'Vhi~tl(~blo\Vel')1 a k i~t a )

It is the statutory duty of the Authority to decide all cases judiciously and to protect theinterest of all parties, specially the consumers, who generally do not have any effectiverepresent;ltion (;It least in Pakistan, mainly due to time and resource constraints). Theresponsibility of the Authority to protect the consumers' interest is far greater because theInvestors invariably carry out the feasibility studics of their projects through leadingnational/international consultants at costs reimbursable by the consumers through tari rr. Theconsumers h;lvc no such facility. In the circumstances, the Authority should either by itself urby appointing a consultant, ensure that its Decisions do not adversely aflcct the nationalexchequer and consumers. The failure of the Authority to advert to this aspect is obviouslyharmful if some past decisions of thc Authority in the mattcr of LPMs of K-Elcctric areexamined. Allowing K-Electric to burn pipeline quality gas ill its l1l:wly inducted Power Plantin an in-efficient manner is one example: such approv;lls arc against the intcn;st of thecountry and the consumers of electricity.

The case for today's hearing is that K-Energy has submitted an application for the grant orGcneration Liccnse tor 2x2 IOMW = 420 M W Power Plant. The Pm,ver Plant for which K-Energy has applit.:d for the grant of the Generation License is presently a part of theGeneration Lkense of K-Elcctric. These two Units C:1n be operated on dual 1'1Il:li.e. by usingRFO, Gas ur RFO and Gas simultaneously.

These Units along with other Units have been rehabilitated in thl: recent p:1st by usingGovernment of Pakistan funds under its Financial Improvement PIJn (FIP). Needless to sayGOP funus are tax payers' money.

Further, K-Ekdric had earlier applied lor a Licensee Proposed t.."lodification ill its GcnerationLicense whereby it proposed thc leasing out of two Units (Unit NO.3 & 4) or Bin QasimPower Plant (BQPS-I) to K-Energy and conversion of these Units on RFO/G:1s based rueltoCoal based fud. On 22.0H.20 13 the Authority has approved tile proposed J11odi!ic<ltion of K-Ekctril.: 'in-principle' for excluding Unit-3 & ·1of 13QPS-l from the already grantcuGeneration Liccnse No. GL/O.:l/2002, dated November 18,2002 along with subsequentamcndment. I lowever, it was a purdy subjective and arbitrary approval.

It is submitted that there is no provision or 'in-principle approval' of Licensce ProposedMudillcation (LPM) in the applicable docull1cnts of NEPI{A. Tile Autllority can eitherapprove the LPM with or without the changes vide Regulation 10 (11 )(a) of the ApplicationModification Pro(;edure Regulations, 1999 or it may refuse the LPM vide RegulationIO(Il)(b) of AMPR, 1999. The concept of 'ill-principle approval' is new and not cunsistentwith the pruvisions 0 I' the Regulations.

It is submitted that all proceedings which K-Electric, K-Encrgy, the I\cgulalor, thePrivatization Commission and all Share holdt:rs, including the Govt. of Pakistan, have held solar in this proposcd 'leasing out' of two Units of 13QPS-I and their convt:rsion to Coal basL:dlile1 from existing RFO/Gas based fuel over riding the conct:rtls :1nd objections or theCommentators/consumers be made public to ensure transparency. Non provision ofdocuments under the garb or confidcntiality would le:1d to the inescapable conclusion th,ltthere is collusion bet ween all the re k:vant agencies.

in the ligllt of the above, it is submilt(;d that the LPM in the malter, already 'approved in-principle' by the Authority may be t:allcelled and tltis application of K-Ellergy 1ll,IY 110t bl.:processed further unless the following doclllllcnts/iniormation are obtained from K-Energyand communicated to the Intervener:

2

Continuation Sheet No .\\1bi~t 14~blo\l'erlul i~t~an

c> feasibility study that fuel convcrsion of old Units is marc feasible as compared to theinstallation/commissioning of a new power plant;

• details of funds received from GOP under FIP and other heads during last five yearsand total expenditure made on Unit No 3 & 4 during last five years;

• details of month-wise Generation of Unit NO.3 & 4 during last five years;

• details of loss to be borne by consumers if K-Encrgy is allowed to bum coal In-efficiently in old Power Plants of low efficiency (30 to 32%);

o details of remaining life of BQPS Units 3 & 4, which were commissioncd ill 1089 and1990 l'l:spectively;

• provision of details or costs to be incurred 1I1 the proposed converSIOll Vlz-a-VlZinduction of new Power Plants;

• provision of a study to show whether the investment of K-em:rgy in the proposedconversion of an in-efficient Plant is mol'\.: feasible than commissioning of a newPower Plant keeping in vil:W the fact that such conversion is not addillg allY capacityin the system;

• carrying out of a study to determine that there is no issue of availability of Generationcapacity in the country and the only issuc affordability. If thc answer is 'yes', thenwhy high cost Wind, Solar and RrO Generation is being approved/considered by theRegulator;

• provision of a detailed study of the Coal Supp!y/Purl.:hase Agreement including coalhandling and coal transportation arrangcments and costs lor the proposed PowcrPlant;

• obtaining details regarding thc efforts made to ensure non-volatility of coal pricesrequired by the Plant during the cntire remaining tcrm of its uSl:fullik/opL'ration;

• obtaining details as to whethcr EPA Simlh has given permission fur till': operation ofthis Plant on coal as this Plant is kKated in a thickly populatt:d industria! area;

• obtaining details with regard to ash disposal ami any recurring costs during theoperation of the Plant; and

• studying the impact/cfTed of the proposed arrangcment on the Workcrs or K-Electric. espccially those cmployed at the two Po\\'er Plants proposed to be taken onLcasc, must be examined bcllm.: proceeding further.

A lllcaningful hearing is only possible after detailed Issues arc li'amed amI cUllllllunieated tothe stakeholders along with documents/information provitkd by the Applicant, and that toowell be/orc the next public hearing.

It is submitted that based on the track-record of KESCLlK-Elcctrie, consumers have alreadyrequested the Authority to ensure that there is no physil.:al progress prior to the grant ofGeneration Liccnse to K-Energy , if the grant is fuund to be warranted. Since n0 operationaldata is available as to whether BQPS- 3 & 4 arc supplying power or 1I0t, the J\utllOrity must

3

Continuotion Sheet No .l hi~tleblo,~'e'I' a I{ i~tan

ensure that these Plants remain operational and should not be got modified until and unless itis allowed by the Authority after observing all Rules and Regulations.

In the facts and circumstances narrated above and the concern of the Regulator regardingconversion viz-a-viz new induction, it is requested that Issues be framed and conveyed and apublic hearing be held thereafter in Karachi. This may graciously be done after allowingsufficient time to file responses to enahk the Authority to come to a just and informeddecision. It appears that on the present record the Authority is not in a position to do so.

Yours Sincerely

Ene losures:Copy or ktter dakd 09.08.2014Power or Attorney

4

1I

ANWAR KAMAL LAW ASSOCIATESRef. No,VC/NEPI~A/358/ 14 BY EMAIL, FAX & COURIER

<officc(ti)nepra ,arg. p1<:>051-2600026

Dated; 09lil Aug" 2014

The Vice Chairmun,NaLional Electric Powerl~egulatory Authority (NEPRA),AUaturk Avenue (I~ast),NSPRA Tower,Opposite Federal Flood Commission,G-5/1, Islamabad.

SUBJECT: Public Hearing to lJe held on 12.08,2014 in the MaUer ofApplication of K-Energy (PvL) Limited (KEPL) for Lhe grant ofGeneraLion Licence,

Kin,clly refer to the Notice for the Public Hearing to be held on 12t1l August,

20Jii at NEPR/\ Tower, Islamubad at 11 :00 A.M.

First or all iL is not proper on the part or the Authority to deprive the people of

Knrachi fmm pnrticipating in proceedings which affect Lheir very exisLence. The

objection hu~; been mised a nUlllber of Limes unci the AuLhority lwd prolllisee! Lo

hold hearings affecting KarachiiLes aL Karachi.

'rhe gOll1g back on this promise lC<1c1sLa the iITeristiblc inference that this is

being done wit'h malarielc intent to benefit K-Slectric ancl K-Snergy (KEPL) ut

the expense uf (he eon~;Ulllcrs of I\: ·Elect rico The Authority is reCjue::;ted to

perform its st<lLutory duty of prot.ccting th~ intcrest of Lhe consumcrs.

This c1elilJewte effort to favour I\.-I·~lectTic nnd I\.-I~l1ergy by shutting out the

C0I1Sll1TJCr~~of J(·-l':!cct rie, who obviously cannot :1.fford the expense and/ or tillie

or travelling to Islamabad to s;1kguard their interest, rniscs sel'iolls questions

about the neulr;.dity und impurti<.l1ity oj' the Aut!lOrity. This is p:lrticubrly

so since the AuthoriLy ha::; also scheduled the Publie }learing ill the maLlcr of

Cont. ..

ANWAR KAMAL LAW ASSOCIATESContinuation Sheet NO.1

monthly Fuel Charges Adjustment of K-Electrie (formerly J<SSCL) for themonths of April, May and June, 2014 on the same date, i.e. 12th August, 2014from 12:00 noon to 01 :30 P.M., at NEPRA Tower, Islamabad.

1 would h8ve o.tlendecl the Public Hearing in person on ] 2.08.2014 to 8ssist the

Authority to 8rrive at a just and informed decision but the current volAtile

polit icn] situation and the shutting clown of the cities of Lahore and Islamabad

mnke it impossible for me to travel to Isbm8ho.d on 12.08.2014.

I request th,lt information about the guaranteed aVclibbiliLy or ALL powcr

producing Units of K-ElecLric, as originally licenced o.ne! subsequently modified

by the Authority, be provided to me. It is submitted that this is necessary since

the under consideration application is an Application for the gwnt of

Generation Licenec by K-EntTh'Y in respect of Power Plants included in the

Cener<l t ion Licence of J( - Elect ric.

It is further submillL'd tiled this Generalion Licencc Applic<\tiol1 is ,In outcome

of the in principle appro\',d of tlle Licenccc Proposed Moc!iric,ltion (LPM) of l(-

I~leclrie 1.0 exclude the BCJPS Units 3 [Ix, 4 from iLs Gener~lLion F,leility ,1I1c! lo

lc'..Ist: llut Lht.: S;lf11e 1.0 K-Sncrgy for conversion Lo coal and thereat'ter supply of

electric powC'r from lhese PIClnts to K-Electric.

Sir, K-Elcetric (formcrly KESeL) was given n targel t'o lllcre<lSe its instnlkd

cClpncity by 1000 MW through reh8bilitation of its existing Power Plants unc! by

inst,lIlLllg new Power PlClnts. For this purpose, thc Government or Pukisl<lll gave

a subsL,lIltial a1l101111L (llncler F1P) under the Pl'ivatisatioll AgreemenL to

J(- l·:lcct.ric: but J(- Electric h,1s Llilecl [0 Hcld nev,' C1eneraLiol1 Pbnls, !nsLc<lc!,

it has replaced its existing Power Plants, which is not the inknded use of

Cont. ..

./

//

ANWAR KAMAL LAW ASSOCIATESContinuation Sheet No.2

Governmen t of Pakistan funds to K-Electric for addition of Generation capacity.

The exclusion of BQPS Units 3 & 4 from K-Elcctric Generation Licence will

further c1ecre8se the Generation capacity of K-Electrie.

NEPI~A h;:ls, in principle, approved the LPM of !(-[ClecLric to exclude BQPS

UnitS 3 ~~.4 for their leasing to K-Encrgy, subject to the grant of ,1 (~ener<.:ltion

Liccnce to K-Energy. One of the b~sie paramet.ers to approve or dis<..1pprove the

LPM by the AuLhorit.y is "irnp<.lcL on tariff'. In the case of the proposed

modification, this has not yet been determined by the Authority. Hence, prior to

proceeding 1\lrLllcr, this needs to be determineo by the Authorit~r.

1n this regilrcl, the Cklimlan's message in the Annu;,ll Report 201~-2013 of

NEPI~A is most mi1teriaI and relevont. In t.he interest of the consumers, )

request that before pl'Oceec1ing furt.her, NEPR.J\ should ask K-E1cctric Lo provide

details of the consumplion of the FIP funds for the rehabilitat.ion of UQPS Units

3 ~~,4.

NEPRA must have a cost-benefit 8n81ysis or the proposed ehi-lngcs c;lrricd out

before milking a decision i1bollt the s~lIne. The Authority must ensure tl1:11

there is no physical progress prior to gran ting formuI approv;t1 in respcct of the

LPM and the gr:.lllt of '-1 Gencri1tion Licence to K-Encrgy, if the grunt is foune! to

be Wilrrantecl. Civcn the track-record of KESCL, the Authority must salisfy

itself Clnd have a Sitc Inspection Report to see whether K-Electric ane! K-E:nergy

are already doing what they are seeking permission to do, and v"IJich they

cimnoL do vvithout: thc prior :lpproval of the I~cglliator.

The Aulhority will recitll that under the Multi Year Tarirr (MYT) gl-:.Intcc! to

KESeL prior to its privatisalion, the arrangement was a "closce! 811cl locked"

transaclioll. By opening and unlocking the arrangement post-privalisation,

the I\uthority hDS stepped onto a tre:1cherous :ll1d slippery slope tll the ut tel'

Cont. ..

ANWAR KAMAL LAW ASSOCIATESContinuation Sheet NO.3

disadvantage of the consumers, who the Authority was mandated by law to

protect. The Authority is requested in the public interest to make just and

informed decisions [me! 110t to become 8 capt ivc tool in the hands of clever

manipulators, be they inside or outside the Government.

I request that tile Public lIcnring scheduled at 11:00 A.M. on 12.0R.2014 \)<.;

adjourned in the public interest and this Public Hearing be held at Karachi to

enClble and f8cilitate the consumers of Karachi to participate meaningfully III

the proceedings. In my humble opinion not to do this is to negate the very

purpose of holding Public Hearings, mandated by the NEPl~A Act, 1997 itself.

The Authority's decisions have to be consistent with the outcomes of Public

Hearings!

With best regards.

Yours sinccrL'!.y,

/(Amv;\r I(arn~d)

Copics forwarded to:

1. The f<egistr[lr, National Electric Power ]<cgu!alory Authority (Nv:F'I,(A), ALlaturkAvenue (Ensl), NEP],(A Tower, Opposite Federal Flood Commission, C-5/].IslalllLluad. By Email (rcgislrclr(ii)I1C(JI';l.org.pk), Fax and Courier.

Sycd Adil Gilani, Esq., Advisor, TrClI1Spnrency Inlernalioll;l!-P;\l,islal1, 5-C, 2"dFloor, Klwyaban-e-Ittelwd, Phase VII, Dcfenct,; Housing Authority, Karaclii, withrefcrel1(,(~ to his ktter (bted OSI" August, 2014. By "ax, Em:lil ;met Courier. 8y

li;rnail: !icpak15tnl1u,'grn:lil.com ",-~c:lYv ~

(Anwar Kamcd)

Office: I-Turner Road, Lahore-54000, PakistanTelephone: (92-42) 37311810-37358845 FAX: 37238174

E-mail: _<.lkl~w(.i;1b._r!cC?msats.11~t.pk