Columbia 20061

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/columbia-20061 1/75

"#$#%&'&$( )*$+,-(.$%/++*0.#(.*$

)#+& 1**23445

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

3

!"#$% '( )'*+%*+,

)#+& :; 1#$2 <$0=&#+.$% "#=2&( 78#=&>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>?

)#+& 3; )8.$&+& )#=+ >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>@

)#+& ?; A&#-(8 <$+,=#$0& >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>:3 )#+& B; <(#-.#$ C#D&=>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>:5

)#+& 9; 7,%#= "#%$*-.# A*+D.(#- >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>:@

)#+& 5; C=.E#(& F#6&- 7#-&+>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>3B

)#+& G; C.#$* "#=2&( 7.H.$%>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>35

)#+& I; J#+ 7(#(.*$+ #$K )*$E&$.&$0& 7(*=&+>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>3I

)#+& @; "&%#6#$2 L$K&=D&$&(=#(.*$>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>?:

)#+& :4; A&#=(0*=D >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>?B

)#+& ::; )=&K.(MN&6.( )#=K C=*0&++*= >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>?G

)#+& :3; O,=*D&#$ "*(*=0P0-&+ >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>B4

)#+& :?; 7(=&&( 7Q&&D&=+>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>BB

)#+& :B; OP& 7,=%&=P >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>BI

)#+& :9; "&K.(&+( >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>9:

)#+& :5; "#%#H.$& J=*Q(8 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>99

)#+& :G; )CJ )*'D#$P >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>9@

)#+& :I; <$+(.(,(.*$#- /++&( "#$#%&= R&&+>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>59

)#+& :@; J,'6PS+ C.HH#>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>5@

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

?

)",% -. /"*0 1*23%",4*5 6"30%+ 78"3%

/9):;<=>?@

A43B. TM/<'C*D. 3449 7,''&=U R.=+()'*+%*+. "#.$-P V,#-.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

W,= 0-.&$( .+ # '#X*= K.E&=+.Y.&K Y.$#$0.#- +&=E.0&+ Y.='> Z8&P 8#E& B -.$&+ *Y 6,+.$&++.

)8&02.$% /00*,$(+

7#E.$%+ /00*,$(+

F*#$+

"*=(%#%&+

Z8& 6#$2 .+ D=*Y.(#6-&U 6,( (8& )OW .+ *$ # '.++.*$ (* .$0=&#+& *E&=#-- '#=2&( +8#=& Q8.-& +(.--'#.$(#.$.$% D=*Y.(#6.-.(P> A& .+ 0*$+.K&=.$% .$0=&#+.$% 8.+ +#-&+ Y*=0& (* #00*'D-.+8 (8.+>

Z8&=& #=& ? K.YY&=&$( 0#(&%*=.&+ *Y +#-&+ Y*=0& 8& 0#$ 08**+& (* 08#$%&.

1=#$08 "#$#%&=+

Z&-&'#=2&(&=+

"*=(%#%& /%&$(+

Z8& )OW 8#+ 0*'& (* ,+ Y*= #KE.0& *$ Q8&(8&= *= $*( 8& +8*,-K .$0=&#+& 8.+ +#-&+ +(#YYU #$K .Y+*U Q8&=& 8& +8*,-K 6& #KK.$% 8&#K+> A*Q Q*,-K P*, %* #6*,( #KK=&++.$% (8.+ V,&+(.*$[

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D "II3'"28.

/ (8*,%8(Y,- #$K 0*'D-&(& #$+Q&= (* (8.+ 0#+& .$E*-E&+ K.+0,++.$% (8& *E&=#-- '#=2&(&$E.=*$'&$(U Q.(8 # -**2 #( (8& 0*'D&(.(.*$ .$ (8& '#=2&(D-#0& #$K (8& 0,==&$( '#=2&( +8#=& 6=&#2K*Q$> Z8& .$(&=E.&Q&& +8*,-K =&#-.H& (8#( (8&=& #=& B +&D#=#(& '#=2&(+ Y*= K.+(.$0( D=*K,0(+(8#( 8#E& K.YY&=&$( D=*Y.(#6.-.(P 08#=#0(&=.+(.0+> <( 6&0*'&+ #DD#=&$( (8#( .$E&+(.$% .$ +*'& -.$&+*Y 6,+.$&++ Q.-- D#P *YY Y*= (8& 0*'D#$P '*=& (8#$ .$E&+(.$% .$ *(8&=+> R=*' (8&=&U # K.+0,++.*$

*Y (8& &0*$*'.0+ *Y &#08 *Y (8& K.YY&=&$( +#-&+ 08#$$&-+ Q.-- K=.E& P*, (*Q#=K+ #=&0*''&$K#(.*$>

:> N&(&='.$& (8& 0*'D&(.(.E& D*+.(.*$ *Y (8& 0*'D#$P

\8#( .+ (8& 0*'D&(.(.E& D*+.(.*$ *Y (8& 0*'D#$P .$ (8& *E&=#-- '#=2&([3> /++&++ (8& .'D*=(#$0& *Y (8& K.YY&=&$( -.$&+ *Y 6,+.$&++

\8&=& K*&+ (8& 6#$2 D-#P[ \8#( .+ .(+ +(=#(&%P[ A*Q K*&+ .( '#2& .(+ '*$&P[

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

B

\8#( .+ *,= '#=2&( +8#=& .$ &#08 -.$&[

\8#( .+ (8& .'D*=(#$0& *Y &#08 -.$& (* (8& *E&=#-- 6,+.$&++[ A*Q K* (8& K.YY&=&$(-.$&+ Y.( .$(* (8& *E&=#-- +(=#(&%P[ \8.08 #=& (8& '*+( D=*Y.(#6-&[ /=& (8&=& #$P -*++-&#K&=+[

\8#( 0#$ (8& 0*'D#$P &]D&0( (* #08.&E& Y=*' .$E&+('&$( .$ &#08 -.$&[?> L$K&=+(#$K (8& .'D#0( *Y (8& K.YY&=&$( 0#(&%*=.&+ *Y +#-&+ Y*=0&

\8.08 -.$&+ *Y 6,+.$&++ Q.-- 6& #YY&0(&K 6P .$0=&#+&K .$E&+('&$( .$ &#08 0#(&%*=P[

\8#( .+ (8& &]D&0(&K ^W< Y*= &#08 0#(&%*=P[B> R*=',-#(& #$ .$E&+('&$( +(=#(&%P Y*= (8& 6#$2 (* Y*--*Q

:%J ("2+,.

Z8& '#=2&( .+ '#K& ,D *Y 9 '#X*= D-#P&=+> Z8&P #=& #-- E&=P +.'.-#=U *YY&=.$%K.E&=+.Y.&K +&=E.0&+ #$K D-#P.$% .$ #-- B +&%'&$(+>

"#=2&( +8#=& .+ K&Y.$&K *$ # _ *Y 0,+(*'&=+ 6#+.+> Z8& '#=2&( +8#=&+ #=& #+ Y*--*Q+ ` (8& a: D-#P&= 8#+ 34_ '#=2&( +8#=&> \& #=& (8& a3 D-#P&= #$K 8#E& #$ :I_ '#=2&(

+8#=&> Z8& =&+( *Y (8& .$K,+(=P .+ +*'&Q8&=& 6&(Q&&$ :9_b:I_> Z8& '#=2&( +8#=& Q.(8.$ &#08 *Y (8& +&%'&$(+ K*&+ $*( 6=&#2 K*Q$ .$ (8.+ +#'&

Y#+8.*$> OE&=P*$& .+ D=*Y.(#6-& #$K &+(#6-.+8&K #$K $* *$& .+ D=.0.$% (8&.= D=*K,0(+.==#(.*$#--P>

Z8& 0*'D#$PS+ +8#=& 6P +&%'&$( .+ #+ Y*--*Q+. ! )8&02.$% /00*,$(+ ` 3:_! 1,+.$&++ /00*,$(+ ` 34_! F*#$+ ` 3?_! "*=(%#%&+ ` :4_

C=*Y.( D&= (=#$+#0(.*$ .+ #+ Y*--*Q+. ! )8&02.$% /00*,$(+ b c9

! 1,+.$&++ /00*,$(+ b c34! F*#$+ b c:44! "*=(%#%&+ b c:U444

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

9

!"#$% '()*$ +)(,-."/-#-.0

"

#"

$""

$#"

%""

%#"

&'()*+ ,()(-.'/ ,0'1-(-. 2-.)1/ 3.4.5('6.1.'

!"#$% 1".$2()0

+ ) ( , - . " / - # - . 0

789/19)- :;/105.'/ <.= &;/9).// "#$%&'() *&%+, -.+ /.0'% 01&2+ #+3$/%) %.+ 3'&4$%01$5$%6 &4 #$44+'+*% %63+) &4 )05+) 07+*%) 8$%.'+70'# %& %.+ 9&'%707+ 1:)$*+)); <='&4$%01$5$%6> &4 +0/. $*#$2$#:05 )05+) 07+*% $) #+4$*+# 0) %.+$*/'+9+*%05 ? 3'&4$% 90'7$* @$* ?AB +0/. 1'$*7) $*; -+5+90'C+%+') /5+0'56 1'$*7 $* %.+ 9&)% 3'&4$% 90'7$* ?) $* 077'+70%+D 1:% 9&'%707+ 07+*%) 1'$*7 $* %.+ 9&)% 4'&9 *+8 1:)$*+));

EK96LME @19M=;>E

1*+%3N4%O%%. 1&Y*=& Q& +(#=(U < Q*,-K -.2& (* 0-#=.YP Q8#( # '*=(%#%& #%&$( #0(,#--P K*&+> )#$P*, Q#-2 '& (8=*,%8 (8#([

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+ 9&'%707+ 07+*%) 8&'C 16 .02$*7 '+50%$&*).$3) 8$%. '+05 +)%0%+ 1'&C+'); E.+* 01'&C+' 90C+) 0 )05+D .+ '+4+') %.+ 1:6+' &4 %.+ .&9+ %& 0 9&'%707+ 07+*%; -.0% 07+*% 8&'C) 8$%.%.+ .&9+ 1:6+' %& /5&)+ %.+ %'0*)0/%$&* 0*# )+55 %.+ 9&'%707+;

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8#( '#2&+ +&$+&> <SK -.2& (* Y.%,=& *,( Q8#( (8& 0,==&$( '#=2&( +.(,#(.*$ -**2+-.2&> A*Q '#$P D-#P&=+ #=& (8&=& #$K Q8#( .+ (8& 6=&#2K*Q$ .$ (&='+ *Y '#=2&( +8#=&[ <+&E&=P*$& D=*Y.(#6-&[ /=& (8&=& #$P $&Q D-#P&=+[ /$P $&Q (=&$K+ -.2& .$(&=$&( 6#$2.$%[

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+ 90'C+% $) 90#+ :3 &4 F 90G&' 3506+'); -.+6 0'+ 055 2+'6 )$9$50'D &44+'$*7#$2+')$4$+# )+'2$/+) 0*# 3506$*7 $* 055 H )+79+*%); -.+ 90'C+% ).0'+) 0'+ 0) 4&55&8) I %.+ JK 3506+' .0) LMN 90'C+% ).0'+; E+ 0'+ %.+ JL 3506+' 0*# .02+ 0* KON 90'C+% ).0'+; -.+ '+)% &4

%.+ $*#:)%'6 $) )&9+8.+'+ 1+%8++* KFNPKON; Q&8+2+'D %.+ 90'C+% ).0'+ 8$%.$* +0/. &4 %.+ )+79+*%) #&+) *&% 1'+0C #&8* $* %.$) )09+ 40).$&*; "2+'6&*+ $) 3'&4$%015+ 0*# +)%015$).+# 0*#*& &*+ $) 3'$/$*7 %.+$' 3'&#:/%) $''0%$&*0556; -.+'+ 0'+ )&9+ *+8 %'+*#) +9+'7$*7 ):/. 0)$*%+'*+% 10*C$*7D 1:% %.+6 0'+ *&% 0 40/%&' 0% %.$) 3&$*%D 0*# %.+ R"S $) *&% 8&''$+# 01&:% %.0%;

1*+%3N4%O%%. < +&&> N* Q& 2$*Q 8*Q *,= '#=2&( +8#=& 6=&#2+ K*Q$ .$ &#08 *Y (8& K.YY&=&$(+&%'&$(+[

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

5

!"#$%&'$($%) T+)D 8+ #&; S:' 1'+0C#&8* 16 )+79+*% $) 0) 4&55&8))

R.+/C$*7 U//&:*%) I LKN

V:)$*+)) U//&:*%) I LMN

W&0*) I LXN

Y&'%707+) I KMN

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8#( .+ .$(&=&+(.$%> <+ (8&=& # K.YY&=&$( D=*Y.(#6.-.(P -&E&- Y*= &#08 *Y (8& K.YY&=&$(+&%'&$(+[

!"#$%&'$($%) T+)D %.+'+ $); U) 0 90%%+' &4 40/%D 3'&4$%01$5$%6 3+' %'0*)0/%$&* $) 0) 4&55&8))

R.+/C$*7 U//&:*%) P ?F

V:)$*+)) U//&:*%) P ?LM

W&0*) P ?KMM Y&'%707+) P ?KDMMM

1*+%3N4%O%%. < Q*,-K -.2& (* &]D-*=& # Y&Q '*=& D*++.6.-.(.&+U 6,( Y.=+(U < Q#$( (* X,+( +#P (8#('P %,( .$+(.$0( .+ (8#( Q& 0#$ .$0=&#+& *,= +#-&+ Y*=0&U #$K < (8.$2 (8#( Q& +8*,-K K* .( .$ (8&'*=(%#%& #%&$( #=&#>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0% $) 0 7&&# $*)$7.%; E.6 #& 6&: %.$*C %.0% $)Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. 1#+&K *$ (8& &].+(.$% '#=2&( +8#=&+U .( +&&'+ -.2& Q& 8#E& (8& '*+( =**' (*.'D=*E& *,= 6,+.$&++ .$ (8.+ #=&#> /KK.(.*$#--PU %.E&$ (8& D#=.(P 6&(Q&&$ (8& 0*'D&(.(*=+ .$ (8&

.$K,+(=P *E&=#--U < (8.$2 .( Q*,-K 6& E&=P K.YY.0,-( (* K=#'#(.0#--P .$0=&#+& +8#=& .$ #$P *Y (8&*(8&= #=&#+> Z8&=&Y*=&U Q& +8*,-K 0*$0&$(=#(& *$ (8& '*=(%#%& '#=2&(> R=*' (8&=&U Q& $&&K (*+&& Q8#( D#=( *Y (8& +#-&+ Y*=0& Q.-- 8#E& (8& %=&#(&+( .'D#0( *$ (8.+ '#=2&(> N* Q& 8#E& #$P.$Y*='#(.*$ *$ (8& D=*Y.(#6.-.(P *Y &#08 *Y (8& +#-&+D&*D-& #$K 8*Q ',08 $&Q 6,+.$&++ &#08 #=' 6=.$%+ .$[

!"#$%&'$($%) T+)D %.+ R"S .0) 7$2+* :) %.$) +[.$1$% )

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

G

!"#$% '()*$ +)(,-."/-#-.0

"

#"

$""

$#"

%""

%#"

&'()*+ ,()(-.'/ ,0'1-(-. 2-.)1/ 3.4.5('6.1.'

!"#$% 1".$2()0

+ ) ( , - . " / - # - . 0

789/19)- :;/105.'/ <.= &;/9).//

!"#$%&'$($%) E.0% #&+) %.$) /.0'% %+55 6&:Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8.+ +8*Q+ (8#( (&-&'#=2&(&=+ #=& (8& '*+( D=*Y.(#6-& D-#0& (* D,( *,= '*$&P .$(&='+ *Y .$0=&#+.$% *,= +#-&+ Y*=0&> A*Q #=& (8&P %&$&=#(.$% (8&+& D=*Y.(+[ \8#( #=& (8&P#0(,#--P K*.$%[

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+6 /055 :3 +[$)%$*7 /:)%&9+') %& 7+% %.+9 %& '+*+8 %.+$' &5# )+'2$/+);

1*+%3N4%O%%. < +&&> <$ (8#( 0#+&U .( -**2+ -.2& 'P .$.(.#- 8,$08 Q#+ 0*==&0(> 7.$0& (8& *(8&= 3

+#-&+ Y*=0&+ Q.-- .$0=&#+& D=*Y.(+ 6#+&K *$ &].+(.$% 0,+(*'&=+U (8& '*=(%#%& #%&$( .+ Q8&=& Q&0#$ K=.E& '#=2&( +8#=& %=*Q(8 6P Q.$$.$% $&Q 0,+(*'&=+> <$ (&='+ *Y '#2.$% #$ *E&=#-- D=*Y.(U(8& (&-&'#=2&(&=+ Q*,-K 6& (8& =.%8( Q#P (* %*> A*Q&E&=U +.$0& (8& )OW 8#+ &]D-.0.(-P +(#(&K (8#(8& Q#$(+ (* .$0=&#+& '#=2&( +8#=&U '*=(%#%& #%&$(+ #=& Q8&=& 8& +8*,-K 6& 6,-2.$% ,D (8& +#-&+Y*=0&>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0*C 6&:; S:% &4 /:'$&)$%6D /0* 6&: 7$2+ 9+ 0* +[0935+ &4 8.+'+ 0##$*7 1'0*/.90*07+') 9$7.% 1+ 0 7&&# #+/$)$&*Z E.0% 8&:5# 6&: *++# %& 5&&C 0%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \& 0*,-K K* # +(,KP *Y &#08 6=#$08 (* +&& 8*Q '#$P 0,+(*'&=+ 0*'& (8=*,%8 (8&K**= #$K 8*Q '#$P *Y (8&' #=& &].+(.$% 0,+(*'&=+ E&=+,+ D*(&$(.#- $&Q 0,+(*'&=+>

!"#$%&'$($%) SA; W+%() )06 8+ #$# %.0% 0*# 8+ 4&:*# &:% %.0% $* +0/. )%&'+D %.+'+ 0'+ H 1'0*/.90*07+') 0*# %.+6D &* 02+'07+D )+'2$/+ HM 3&%+*%$05 *+8 /:)%&9+') %.0% /&9+ %.'&:7. %.+ #&&'+2+'6#06; E.0% 8&:5# 6&: .02+ %& 5&&C 0% 8.+* #+/$#$*7 8.+%.+' &' *&% %& 0## 9&'+ 1'0*/.90*07+')Z

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

I

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

!"#$%&'$($%) E.0% +5)+ /&:5# /.0*7+ %.0% /&:5# /0:)+ %.+ 10*C %& 80*% %& 0## 9&'+ 1'0*/.90*07+')Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. <Y P*, 0#$ K=.E& #KK.(.*$#- D*(&$(.#- 0,+(*'&=+ (8=*,%8 (8& K**=> C&=8#D+ #08#$%.$% (=&$K .$ (8& '#=2&( Q.-- 0=&#(& # $&Q *DD*=(,$.(PU .>&> #KK.$% # $&Q D=*K,0( (8#( '#PK=#Q .$ '*=& $*$b0,+(*'&=+ Q8* #=& .$(&=&+(&K .$ 6&0*'.$% # 0,+(*'&= *= # $&Q #KE&=(.+.$%0#'D#.%$ (8#( .+ K=#Q.$% .$ '*=& D&*D-&> <$ #$P *Y (8*+& (PD&+ *Y +0&$#=.*+U .( '#P '#2& +&$+&(* #KK #KK.(.*$#- 6=#$08 '#$#%&=+>

!"#$%&'$($%) \ %.$*C %.0% 90C+) 0 5&% &4 )+*)+; -.0*C 6&: 2+'6 9:/.;

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

@

)",% P. )84*%,% )"3,

/9):;<=>?@

A43B; ^*-#$K 1&=%&=<'C*D; 3449 7,''&=U R.=+()'*+%*+; "#=2&( +.H.$%U V,#-.(#(.E& #$K V,#$(.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

W,= 0-.&$( .+ # -#=%& )8.$&+& 0*$%-*'&=#(& Q.(8 # -*( *Y 0#+8 *$ .(+ 8#$K+> Z8&P K&0.K&K (*.$E&+( (8.+ '*$&P .$ # D-#$( (8#(U 6P (8& &$K *Y (8.+ P&#=U Q.-- 8#E& # Y,-- D=*K,0(.*$ 0#D#0.(P *Y I'.--.*$ #-,'.$,' Q8&&-+ #$$,#--P> "#$#%&'&$( #++,'&+ (8#( .( Q.-- 6& #6-& (* +&-- 34_ *Y .(+ D=*K,0(.*$ .$ (8& K*'&+(.0 )8.$&+& '#=2&(>

Z8& 0*'D#$P 8.=&K ^*-#$K 1&=%&= (* K&(&='.$& .Y .( 0#$ +&-- (8& =&'#.$.$% I4_ *Y .(+ D=*K,0(.*$(* (8& L7 '#=2&(U Q8.08 .+ (8& -#=%&+( E&8.0-& '#=2&( .$ (8& Q*=-K> \8#( K* P*, (8.$2[

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D "II3'"28.

Z8.+ 0#+& .+ &++&$(.#--P #+2.$% P*, (* K* (Q* (8.$%+;:d N&(&='.$& (8& +.H& *Y (8& L7 0#= '#=2&( +* (8#( P*, 0#$ ,$K&=+(#$K (8& =&-#(.E& .'D#0( *Y (8&

)8.$&+& 0*'D#$PS+ %*#-+>3d /++&++ (8& Y&#+.6.-.(P *Y &$(&=.$% (8& L7 '#=2&( #$K D=*E.K& +,%%&+(.*$+ *$ 8*Q (8.+

0*'D#$P '.%8( %* #6*,( K*.$% +*>

Y0'C+% ]$ $̂*7 ; N&(&='.$& 8*Q '#$P Q8&&-+ P*,= 0-.&$( 0*,-K +,DD-P (* (8& L7 '#=2&( ` 6*(8 .$$,'6&= *Y Q8&&-+ #$K $,'6&= *Y 0#=+ e:MB *Y (8& Q8&&- $,'6&=d> Z8&$ #+2 #6*,( (8& +.H& *Y (8&L7 $&Q 0#= '#=2&( #$K (8& +&0*$K#=P '#=2&( (* K&(&='.$& Q8#( +8#=& (8& 0*'D#$P Q*,-K $&&K(* 0#D(,=& (* +&-- I4_ *Y .(+ D=*K,0(.*$ .$ (8& L7>

_+0)$1$5$%6 0*# =&))$15+ U/%$&*); Z8.+ .+ Q8&=& P*, $&&K (* K=.-- K*Q$ (* ,$0*E&= #,(*'*6.-&.$K,+(=P KP$#'.0+;

A*Q K* WO"+ %&( (8& Q8&&-+ Y*= (8& 0#=+ (8&P D=*K,0&[

A*Q Q*,-K # )8.$&+& 0*'D#$P K.+(=.6,(& .(+ Q8&&-+ (* (8& L7 '#=2&([ N.=&0(-P *= (8=*,%8.$(&='&K.#=.&+[

A*Q &$(=&$08&K #=& +,DD-.&= =&-#(.*$+8.D+[ N* WO"+ 6,P 6#+&K *$ D=.0& *$-PU *= K* (8&=&-#(.*$+8.D+ '#((&= (**[

\8#( =&%,-#(.*$+ #=& .$E*-E&K .$ +,DD-P.$% #$ WO"[

W$0& P*, ,$K&=+(#$K 8*Q (8& +,DD-.&=bWO" =&-#(.*$+8.D+ Q*=2U P*, 0#$ D=*E.K& +*'&+,%%&+(.*$+ *$ 8*Q (8.+ 0*'D#$P '.%8( Y&#+.6-P &$(&= (8& L7 '#=2&(>

:%J A"2+,.

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

:4

:G '.--.*$ E&8.0-&+ D=*K,0&K .$ (8& L7 &#08 P&#=> G4_ &V,.DD&K Q.(8 #-,'.$,' Q8&&-+>

:4_ *Y ,+&K 0#= *Q$&=+ Q8*+& 0#=+ #=& -&++ (8#$ 9 P&#=+ *-K 6,P #-,'.$,' Q8&&-+

I9 '.--.*$ 0#=+ .$ (8& f#Y(&= '#=2&(Ug 3B '.--.*$ *Y Q8.08 #=& -&++ (8#$ 9 P&#=+ *-K

"*+( 0*'D#$.&+ Q.-- +&-&0( *$& +,DD-.&= Q8* Q.-- +,DD-P (8& #-,'.$,' Q8&&-+ Y*= (8&

&$(.=& -.Y&b(.'& *Y # 0#= '*K&-> 7,DD-.&=+ #=& ,+,#--P +&-&0(&K 3B '*$(8+ 6&Y*=& # $&Q'*K&- %*&+ .$(* D=*K,0(.*$ #$K 8#E& +(=.$%&$( V,#-.(P 0*$(=*-+>

EK96LME @19M=;>E

1*+%3N4%O%%. W2#P> <SK -.2& (* Y.=+( K&(&='.$& (8& D=*K,0(.*$ Y.%,=&+ *Y (8& )8.$&+& '#$,Y#0(,=&=#$K 0*'D#=& (8&' (* (8& +.H& *Y (8& (*(#- L7 #,(*'*6.-& '#=2&(> Z8.+ Q.-- 8&-D '& ,$K&=+(#$K(8& =&-#(.E& +.H& *Y (8& )8.$&+& 0*'D#$PS+ D=*K,0(.*$ $,'6&=+ #$K Q8&(8&= (8&.= D-#$ .+=&#-.+(.0> W$0& < 2$*Q 8*Q ',08 '#=2&( +8#=& (8& )8.$&+& 0*'D#$P Q#$(+ (* 0#D(,=&U <SK -.2& (*K.+0,++ (8& L7 #,(*'*6.-& .$K,+(=P KP$#'.0+ (* K&(&='.$& .YM8*Q (8& )8.$&+& 0*'D#$P +8*,-K&$(&= (8& '#=2&(>

F&(S+ +(#=( Q.(8 (8&.= D=*K,0(.*$ $,'6&=+> F&(S+ #++,'& (8#( 0#=+ =&V,.=& *$-P B #-,'.$,' Q8&&-+#$K (8#( +D#=& (.=&+ #=& '#K& *,( *Y +*'& -&++ &]D&$+.E& '#(&=.#-> Z8.+ '&#$+ (8#( P*,= 0-.&$( D=*K,0&+ Q8&&-+ Y*= 3 '.--.*$ 0#=+ D&= P&#=> I4_ *Y 3 '.--.*$ %.E&+ ,+ Q8&&-+ Y*= :>5 '.--.*$0#=+U Q8.08 Q& #=& (=P.$% (* +&-- .$ (8& L7> 7* 8*Q 6.% .+ (8& L7 $&Q 0#= '#=2&( #$K 8*Q -#=%& .+(8& +&0*$K#=P '#=2&( eD&*D-& Q8* 6,P #-,'.$,' Q8&&-+ Y*= #$ *-K&= 0#=d[

!"#$%&'$($%) U1&:% K` 9$55$&* 2+.$/5+) 0'+ 3'&#:/+# $* %.+ a] +0/. 6+0'; U1&:% `MN 0'++b:$33+# 8$%. 05:9$*:9 8.++5); U1&:% KMN &4 :)+# /0' &8*+') 8.&)+ /0') 0'+ 5+)) %.0* F 6+0') &5# 1:6 05:9$*:9 8.++5);

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8#( '&#$+ (8#( =*,%8-P :3 '.--.*$ $&Q 0#=+ &#08 P&#= #=& +*-K Q.(8 #-,'.$,'Q8&&-+> )#$ Q& #++,'& (8#( (8&=& #=& #6*,( 3I4 '.--.*$ 0#=+ .$ (8& #Y(&=b'#=2&(U #6*,( : 0#= D&= D&=+*$U 0*$+.K&=.$% (8#( D&*D-& .$ T&Q h&=+&P *Q$ *$ #E&=#%& 3 0#=+[

!"#$%&'$($%) c&D %.0% *:91+' $) 9:/. 5&8+'; -.+'+ 0'+ 01&:% OF 9$55$&* /0') $* %.+ 04%+'90'C+%D 1:% &*56 01&:% LH 9$55$&* 0'+ 5+)) %.0* F 6+0') &5#;

1*+%3N4%O%%. < +&&> Z8#( '&#$+ (8& #Y(&=b'#=2&( .+ #6*,( 3>B '.--.*$ +&(+ *Y #-,'.$,' Q8&&-+ D&= P&#=> )*$+.K&=.$% (8#( P*,= 0-.&$( $&&K+ (* +&-- :>5 '.--.*$ +&(+U (8&PSK 8#E& (* 0#D(,=& # 55_'#=2&( +8#=&U Q8.08 +&&'+ E&=P ,$-.2&-P .$ +,08 # Y=#%'&$(&K '#=2&(> Z8#( '&#$+ Q& +8*,-K D=*6#6-P Y*0,+ *$ (8& $&Q 0#= '#=2&(> A*Q K* (8& '#X*= 0#= 0*'D#$.&+ D=*0,=& (8& #-,'.$,'Q8&&-+ (8&P D,( *$ (8&.= 0#=+[

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0%() 0 7&&# b:+)%$&*; Y&)% /&930*$+) 8$55 )+5+/% &*+ ):335$+' 8.& 8$55 ):3356%.+ 05:9$*:9 8.++5) 4&' %.+ +*%$'+ 5$4+P%$9+ &4 0 /0' 9&#+5; ]:335$+') 0'+ :):0556 )+5+/%+# LH9&*%.) 1+4&'+ 0 *+8 9&#+5 7&+) $*%& 3'&#:/%$&* 0*# .02+ )%'$*7+*% b:05$%6 /&*%'&5);

1*+%3N4%O%%. \& D=*6#6-P Q*,-K 8#E& (* #KK #$*(8&= :3 '*$(8+ (* &E&$ %&( *$ # 0*'D#$PS+ D=&Y&==&K +,DD-.&= -.+(U Q8.08 .$0=&#+&+ (8& -&#K (.'& (* #6*,( ? P&#=+ 6&Y*=& Q& 0#$ 8*D& (*

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

::

+,DD-P #-,'.$,' Q8&&-+ (* # '#X*= L7 0#= '#$,Y#0(,=&=> 7.$0& P*, '&$(.*$&K &#=-.&= (8#( P*,=0-.&$(S+ D-#$( Q.-- 6& =&#KP Y*= D=*K,0(.*$ 6P (8& &$K *Y (8.+ P&#=U (8.+ K*&+ $*( -**2 -.2& # E.#6-&*D(.*$ &.(8&=> \8#( #6*,( (=P.$% (* &]D#$K K.+(=.6,(.*$ *$ # 6=*#K&= 6#+.+ (8#$ X,+( (8& L7[

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+6 %.&:7.% 01&:% %.0% 0) 0*&%.+' &3%$&*D 1:% %.+6 8&:5# '+0556 5$C+ %& 8&'C 8$%. G:)% %.+ a];

1*+%3N4%O%%. /++,'.$% (8#( P*,= 0-.&$( 0#$ D=*K,0& V,.(& # 6.( 08&#D&= .$ )8.$# (8#$ '*+(0*'D&(.(*=+ 0#$ .$ (8& L7U .( '.%8( '#2& +&$+& (* +,6b0*$(=#0( +*'& *Y (8.+ D=*K,0(.*$ 0#D#0.(P(* +,DD-.&=+ *Y (8& '#X*= L7 0#= '#$,Y#0(,=&=+> Z8.+ .+ D=*6#6-P -&++ -,0=#(.E& (8#$ +&--.$%K.=&0(-P (* &$Kb0,+(*'&=+ *= 0#= '#$,Y#0(,=&=+ 6&0#,+& (8& 0-.&$( Q*,-K 8#E& (* +8#=& .(+ D=*Y.('#=%.$ Q.(8 (8& +,DD-.&=> Z8#( +#.KU .( Q*,-K D=*6#6-P 6& (8& '*+( &YY.0.&$( Q#P (* &$(&= (8& L7'#=2&( *$ # -#=%& +0#-&>

!"#$%&'$($%) T+)D %.$) $) +[0/%56 8.0% %.+6 #$#;

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

:3

)",% Q. R%"$+8 1*,C3"*2%

/9):;<=>?@

A43B; 1**H /--&$ A#'.-(*$<'C*D; 3449 7,''&=U R.=+()'*+%*+; i,#-.(#(.E& #$K V,#$(.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

/ 8&#-(8 .$+,=#$0& 0*'D#$P &]D&=.&$0&K # -*++ *Y cB4" (8.+ P&#=U #Y(&= =&0*=K.$% # cB4" D=*Y.(-#+( P&#=> Z8&P 8#E& 8.=&K ,+ (* K&(&='.$& (8& 0#,+&e+d *Y (8.+ K&0-.$& #$K .K&$(.YP D*(&$(.#-+*-,(.*$+>

Z8& 0*'D#$P .+ .$ *$-P *$& -.$& *Y 6,+.$&++U )*''&=0.#- ^.+2 <$+,=#$0&U .$ *$-P *$& =&%.*$>

Z8&P 8#E& +&E&=#- K.=&0( 0*'D&(.(*=+>

Z8&.= 0#+8 Y-*Q+ *=.%.$#(& Y=*' D=&'.,'+U Q8.08 #=& D#.K .$ *$ # D&=.*K.0 e&>%> '*$(8-PU +&'.b#$$,#--PU #$$,#--Pd 6#+.+ 6P .(+ 0,+(*'&=+U #$K 0-#.'+ #=& D#.K *,( (* (8& 0,+(*'&=+S 0#=&%.E&=+#+ #DD=*D=.#(&>

R*= (8& +#2& *Y +.'D-.0.(PU (8& 0*'D#$PS+ C=*Y.( j C=&'.,'+ ` )-#.'+>

),==&$(-P (8.+ 0*'D#$P 8#+ B '.--.*$ '&'6&=+U Q8.08 &V,#(&+ (* # B4_ '#=2&( +8#=&>

/-- =&E&$,&U 0*+( #$K D=*Y.( Y.%,=&+ #=& '&#+,=&K *$ # D&=b'&'6&= 6#+.+>

A*Q Q*,-K P*, %* #6*,( .K&$(.YP.$% D*(&$(.#- +*-,(.*$+ Y*= (8&.= K&0-.$& .$ D=*Y.(#6.-.(P[

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D "II3'"28. Z8.+ .+ # (PD.0#- D=*Y.(#6.-.(P 0#+&U Q.(8 (8& #KK.(.*$ *Y # D=*6-&'b+*-E.$% +&0(.*$ (* K.+0,++ (8& #=&# (8#( .+ 8,=(.$% D=*Y.(#6.-.(P> R.=+(U P*, +8*,-K 8*$& .$ *$ Q8#(.+ 0#,+.$% (8& 0*'D#$P (* -*+& '*$&P> F**2 #( =&E&$,&+ eD=.0& k V,#$(.(Pd #$K 0*+(+ eY.]&K lE#=.#6-& 0*+(+d> Z8.+ Q.-- -&#K P*, (* (8& 0=,] *Y (8& D=*6-&'> /( (8#( D*.$(U P*, +8*,-K #+2V,&+(.*$+ (8#( &]D-*=& (8& D=*6-&' #$K .K&$(.YP Q#P+ (* #KK=&++ .(>

:%J ("2+,. ^&E&$,&+ 8#E& 6&&$ +(#6-& Y=*' -#+( P&#= (* (8.+ P&#=> C=&'.,'+ 08#=%&K D&= '&'6&=

8#E& 6&&$ +(#6-& #( #$ #E&=#%& *Y c344MP&#=U #$K '&'6&=+8.D 8#+ 6&&$ Y-#( #( B '.--.*$'&'6&=+>

Z8& 0*'D#$P 8#+ '#K& $* -#=%& =&0&$( 0#D.(#- &]D&$K.(,=&+

C&= '&'6&= E#=.#6-& 0*+(+ #=& =.+.$% 6P c34MP&#=> Z8.+ .+ -#=%&-P (8& =&+,-( *Y # K&0-.$& .$,(.-.H#(.*$ *Y =&+*,=0&+ K,& (* D**= '#$#%&'&$(

\.(8.$ (8& 0*'D#$PS+ +(=,0(,=&U (8&=& #=& +&E&=#- Y,$0(.*$#- %=*,D+;

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

:?

! T&Q /K'.(+! C=&b#,(8*=.H#(.*$+! )#+& '#$#%&'&$(

Z8&+& %=*,D+ #=& +(#YY&K Q.(8 "N+ #$K ^T+ (8#( ,+&K (* 6& .$ (8& Y.&-K (=&#(.$% D#(.&$(+>Z8&P #=& $*Q =&+D*$+.6-& Y*= '#$#%.$% 8,$K=&K+ *Y K*0(*=+ #$K $,=+&+ (8#( #=& 0,==&$(-P(=&#(.$% D#(.&$(+> Z8&P #=& '*=& ,+&K (* Q*=2.$% .$ D=#0(.0&+ *Y 9b:4 D=*Y&++.*$#-+ #$K,$#00,+(*'&K (* '#$#%.$% +,08 # -#=%& +(#YYU 0#,+.$% D=*6-&'+ .$ 0*$(=*--.$% =&Y&==#-+#$K ,$$&0&++#=P (&+(.$%MD=*0&K,=&+>

EK96LME @19M=;>E

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7.$0& Q&S=& K&#-.$% Q.(8 # D=*Y.(#6.-.(P .++,& 8&=&U <SK -.2& (* &]D-*=& 6*(8 (8&=&E&$,& #$K (8& 0*+( +.K& *Y (8& 6,+.$&++> 7(#=(.$% Q.(8 (8& =&E&$,& +.K&U 8#E& (8& D=&'.,'+08#=%&K 08#$%&K *E&= (8& -#+( P&#=[

!"#$%&'$($%) c&D %.+6 .02+ 1++* )%015+; \*/$#+*%0556D 3'+9$:9) 0'+ /.0'7+# 0% 0* 02+'07+ &4?LMMd6+0'd9+91+';

1*+%3N4%O%%. A#+ (8& '&'6&= 6#+& 6&&$ +(#6-&[ Z8& =&#+*$ <S' #+2.$% (8.+ .+ (* ,$K&=+(#$KQ8&(8&= =&E&$,& #+ # Q8*-& 8#+ 6&&$ +(#6-&>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+ 9+91+' 10)+ .0) 1++* )%015+D )& '+2+*:+) .02+ 0) 8+55;

1*+%3N4%O%%. Wm> 7.$0& =&E&$,& .+ +(#6-&U <SK -.2& (* &]D-*=& (8& 0*+( +.K& *Y (8& 6,+.$&++> R.=+(U-&(S+ (#2& Y.]&K 0*+(+> A#E& (8&P '#K& #$P -#=%& 0#D.(#- .$E&+('&$(+ (* +D,= %=*Q(8[

!"#$%&'$($%) c&; -.+6 0'+*(% $* 0 7'&8%. )%07+ 0*# .02+*(% 90#+ 0*6 50'7+ /03$%05 +[3+*#$%:'+)

+[/+3% 4&' 0 *+8 /50$9) 3069+*% )6)%+9 %8& 6+0') 07&; \* 7+*+'05D %.$) $) *&% 0 /03$%05 $*%+*)$2+1:)$*+));

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8#( '#2&+ +&$+& +.$0& .( .+ # +&=E.0& 0*'D#$P> 7* -&(S+ -**2 #( E#=.#6-& 0*+(+> A#+(8& 0*+( *Y +&=E.0.$% '&'6&=+ 6&&$ %=*Q.$%[

!"#$%&'$($%) T+); =+' 9+91+' /&)%) 0'+ '$)$*7 %& %.+ %:*+ &4 ?LMd9+91+'d6+0'; E.6 #& 6&: %.$*C%.$) $) .033+*$*7Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8& 0*+( *Y 0#=& '#P 6& %*.$% ,D ` *$ (8& K*0(*=U &V,.D'&$( *= '&K.0.$& Y=*$(>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+ 1$77+)% /&)% #'$2+' $) 0/%:0556 :%$5$^0%$&*D $;+; .&8 4'+b:+*%56 %.+ #&/%&') :)+&%.+' )&:'/+) 4&' 0 30%$+*%() /0'+; ]& *&8 \(# 5$C+ 6&: %& #+'$2+ %.+ %&%05 20'$015+ /&)%) %.0% %.+/&930*6 .0# 50)% 6+0' 2+'):) %.$) 6+0';

1*+%3N4%O%%. C=*Y.( j ^&E&$,& ` )*+(+cB4" e-#+( P&#=d j eB" '&'6&=+ n c344MP&#=M'&'6&=d ` )*+(+

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

:B

cB4" j cI44" ` )*+(+)*+(+ j cG54" -#+( P&#=

C=*Y.( j ^&E&$,& ` )*+(+bcB4" e0,==&$( P&#=d j eB" '&'6&=+ n c344MP&#=M'&'6&=d ` )*+(+bcB4" j cI44" ` )*+(+)*+(+ j cIB4" 0,==&$( P&#=

!"#$%&'$($%) E.0% 8+'+ %.+ 20'$015+ /&)%) &* 0 3+' 9+91+' 10)$) 4&' +0/. 6+0'Z

1*+%3N4%O%%.

C&= "&'6&= o#=.#6-& )*+(+ j cG54" -#+( P&#= M B" '&'6&=+ j c:@4M'&'6&=MP&#=C&= "&'6&= o#=.#6-& )*+(+ j cIB4" 0,==&$( P&#= M B" '&'6&=+ j c3:4M'&'6&=MP&#=

!"#$%&'$($%) e&&#; W+%() %05C 01&:% :%$5$^0%$&* *&8; E.0% 9$7.% 044+/% %.$) 9+0):'+Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. <( 0*,-K 6& # 08#$%& .$ Q8#( "N+ Q#$( (* D=&+0=.6&> R*= .$+(#$0&U '#P6& (8&P #=&'*=& =.+2b#E&=+& 6&0#,+& *Y # =.+& .$ '#-D=#0(.0& 0#+&+U +* (8&P #=& '*=& Y=&V,&$(-P +&&2.$%+&0*$K *D.$.*$+> /$*(8&= (8.$% (8#( '.%8( #YY&0( ,(.-.H#(.*$ .+ 8*Q Q&-- (8& 0*'D#$P '#$#%&+(8& "N+>

!"#$%&'$($%) -& 6&:' )+/&*# 3&$*%D 8.0% 8&:5# 6&: 5&&C 4&' 8$%.$* %.+ /&930*6 %& )++ 8.+'+ %.+ 3'&15+9 '+)$#+)Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. < Q*,-K -**2 #( +&E&=#- (8.$%+U .$0-,K.$% +(=#(&%PU +2.--+ *Y (8& "N+U +8#=&K E#-,&+U+(#YY.$%U (&08$*-*%P ,+&KU -&#K&=+8.D +P+(&' #$K Y,$0(.*$#- *=%#$.H#(.*$#- +(=,0(,=&U (* $#'& #Y&Q>

!"#$%&'$($%) SA; E.0% 8&:5# 6&: 80*% %& C*&8 01&:% %.+ &'70*$^0%$&*05 )%':/%:'+Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. <SK -.2& (* 2$*Q 8*Q (8& 0*'D#$P .+ +(=,0(,=&K>

!"#$%&'$($%) E$%.$* %.+ /&930*6() )%':/%:'+D %.+'+ 0'+ )+2+'05 4:*/%$&*05 7'&:3), c+8 U#9$%) ='+P0:%.&'$^0%$&*) R0)+ 90*07+9+*%

-.+)+ 7'&:3) 0'+ )%044+# 8$%. Yf) 0*# gc) %.0% :)+# %& 1+ $* %.+ 4$+5# %'+0%$*7 30%$+*%); -.+6

0'+ *&8 '+)3&*)$15+ 4&' 90*07$*7 .:*#'+#) &4 #&/%&') 0*# *:')+) %.0% 0'+ /:''+*%56 %'+0%$*7 30%$+*%);

1*+%3N4%O%%. /=& (8*+& "N+ #$K ^T+ ,+&K (* '#$#%.$% -#=%& %=*,D+ *Y D&*D-& e.>&>U B"*J K*0(*=+ .$ (8& Y.&-Kd[

!"#$%&'$($%) c&D %.+6 0'+ 9&'+ 0//:)%&9+# %& 8&'C$*7 $* 3'0/%$/+) &4 FPKM 3'&4+))$&*05);

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

:9

1*+%3N4%O%%. "#2&+ +&$+&> \8#( (PD&+ *Y D&*D-& 0*'D*+& (8& ,DD&= '#$#%&'&$( *Y (8&0*'D#$P[

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+6 0'+ 05)& Yf) %.0% :)+# %& 1+ $* %.+ 4$+5#; E.0%() 6&:' .63&%.+)$) 01&:% %.$) 3'&15+9 0*# 3&%+*%$05 )&5:%$&*) 0% %.$) )%07+Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8& D=*6-&' +&&'+ (* 6& .$ (8& '#$#%&'&$( *Y (8& K*0(*=+ #$K $,=+&+ (8#( #=&(=&#(.$% (8& D#(.&$(+> N,& (* (8& K.YY.0,-(P .$ %&((.$% #-- $&0&++#=P K#(#U #$K (8& Y#0( (8#( (8& +(#YY'#$#%.$% (8*+& K*0(*=+M$,=+&+ .+ $*( ,+&K (* '#$#%.$% # -#=%&U =&'*(& *=%#$.H#(.*$U E#=.#6-&0*+(+ e+D&0.Y.0#--P (8& 0*+(+ #++*0.#(&K Q.(8 ,(.-.H#(.*$d 8#E& =.+&$> < Q*,-K =&0*''&$K=&E.&Q.$% (8& 0,==&$( .$Y*='#(.*$ +P+(&'+ Y*= # Q#P (* 0*$+*-.K#(& (8& E.&Q *Y K#(# Y*= &#08 X*6Y,$0(.*$ +* (8#( &E&=P*$& 8#+ #-- (8& $&0&++#=P .$Y*='#(.*$ (* '#$#%& (8&.= 0#+&+> Z8&P +8*,-K#-+* 0*$+.K&= D=*E.K.$% -&#K&=+8.DM'#$#%&'&$( (=#.$.$% Y*= (8*+& Q8* #=& =&+D*$+.6-& Y*= 0#+&'#$#%&'&$(>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

:5

)",% S. 1+"$4"* L"I%3

/9):;<=>?@

A43B. 1#.$<'C*D. 3449 7,''&=U R.=+()'*+%*+. i,#-.(#(.E& #$K V,#$(.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

W,= 0-.&$( .+ #$ <(#-.#$ D#D&= '#$,Y#0(,=&=> Z8&P '#2& 8.%8b&$K %-*++P #$K '#((& D#D&= (8#(S+,+&K .$ 0*=D*=#(& 6=*08,=&+U '#%#H.$& #K+ Y*= J,00. #$K C=#K#U &(0> <(S+ # 0*''*K.(P D=*K,0(>

Z8&P 8#E& *$& Y#0(*=P (8#( D=*K,0&+ :94U444 (*$+ *Y D#D&= # P&#=> @4_ *Y (8.+ .+ +*-K .$(* (8&<(#-.#$ '#=2&(U Q8.08 %.E&+ .( #6*,( # 34_ '#=2&( +8#=&> Z8& *(8&= :4_ .+ +*-K *,(+.K& *Y <(#-P>

Z8&P Q*,-K -.2& (* 6,.-K #$*(8&= Y#0(*=P (* D=*K,0& #$*(8&= :94U444 (*$+ # P&#=> Z8.+ Q*,-K0*+( c:44 '.--.*$> Z8&P Q*,-K -.2& ,+ (* (&-- (8&' Q8&(8&= *= $*( (8.+ .+ # %**K .K&#>

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D "II3'"28. Z8.+ 0#+& .+ #+2.$% P*, (* K&(&='.$& Q8&(8&= .( '#2&+ +&$+& (* 6,.-K#KK.(.*$#- 0#D#0.(PU .>&> 0#$ P*,= 0*'D#$P 6& D=*Y.(#6-& .$ (8& Y,(,=& 6#+&K *$ (8.+ .$E&+('&$([Z8.+ Q.-- K&D&$K *$ (8& 0,==&$( #$K Y,(,=& '#=2&( KP$#'.0+U Q8.08 0#$ 6& &]D-*=&K .$ # $,'6&=*Y Q#P+>

A#E.$% (8& Z8=&& )+ .$ P*,= 8&#K Q.-- 8&-D P*, #+2 (8& =.%8( V,&+(.*$+. ),+(*'&=+. \8* #=& (8&P[ <+ (8&=& &$*,%8 '#=2&( K&'#$K Y*= #KK.(.*$#- 0#D#0.(P[

)*'D&(.(*=+. \8* #=& (8&P[ \8&=& #=& (8&P[ \8#( '#=2&( +8#=& K* (8&P 8#E&[ A*Q #=&(8&.= D=.0&+ =&-#(.E& (* *,=+[ )#$ Q& 0#D(,=& #$P *Y (8&.= +8#=&[

)*'D#$P. A*Q ',08 Q.-- (8.+ #KK.(.*$#- &]D#$+.*$ 0*+( (8& 0*'D#$PU #$K Q8#( Q.-- (8& 6&$&Y.(+ 6&[ N*&+ (8.+ Y.( Q.(8 (8& 0*'D#$PS+ 0,==&$( D-#$+[

m$*Q.$% (8& #$+Q&=+ (* (8&+& V,&+(.*$+ Q.-- (8&$ 8&-D P*, K&(&='.$& Q8&(8&= .( '#2&+ +&$+& (*#KK 0#D#0.(P> p*, 0#$ #-+* D=*6& Q8&(8&= # $&Q Y#0(*=P .+ (8& =.%8( Q#P (* %*U *= Q8&(8&= .('.%8( 6& '*=& Y&#+.6-& #$K D=*Y.(#6-& (* #KK 0#D#0.(P (* #$ &].+(.$% D-#$(U #0V,.=& #$*(8&=0*'D#$PU &(0>

:%J ("2+,.

Z8& <(#-.#$ '#=2&( Q.-- 0*$(.$,& (* %=*Q #( #6*,( :4_> J&='#$P .+ E&=P 8*( #$K %=*Q.$%#( #6*,( :9_> W(8&= O#+(&=$ O,=*D&#$ '#=2&(+ #=& %=*Q.$% #+ Q&-->

p*,= -#=%&+( <(#-.#$ 0*'D&(.(*= 8#+ B4_ +8#=&> /$ .$(&=$#(.*$#- 0*'D&(.(*= 8#+ :4_ #$K(8& *(8&= ?4_ .+ Y=#%'&$(&K #'*$% +'#-- D-#P&=+>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

:G

Z8&=& #=& #6*,( :3 D-#P&=+ #$K *$-P 3 D#D&= '#08.$& '#$,Y#0(,=&=+ .$ O,=*D&> OE&=P*$&2$*Q+ Q8#( &E&=P*$& &-+& .+ K*.$% #$K $*6*KP &-+& .+ .$E&+(.$% .$ #KK.(.*$#- 0#D#0.(P=.%8( $*Q>

EK96LME @19M=;>E

1*+%3N4%O%%. <SK -.2& (* ,$K&=+(#$K # Y&Q (8.$%+ (* &E#-,#(& (8.+ K&0.+.*$> R.=+(U <SK -.2& (*&]D-*=& (8& 0,==&$( '#=2&( K&'#$K Y*= D#D&=> Z8&$U <SK -.2& (* ,$K&=+(#$K (8& 0,==&$( D-#P&=+ .$(8& '#=2&( #$K 8*Q *,= 0*'D#$P 0*'D&(&+ #%#.$+( (8&'> R.$#--PU <SK -.2& (* (#-2 #6*,( (8&+D&0.Y.0+ *Y (8& .$E&+('&$( D=*D*+&K #$K Q8#( (8& TCo '.%8( 6& Y*= (8#( *D(.*$ E&=+,+ *(8&=+>

<S-- +(#=( Q.(8 (8& '#=2&( K&'#$K .$ <(#-P> p*, '&$(.*$&K (8#( :?9U444 (*$+ .+ #6*,( 34_ *Y (8&<(#-.#$ '#=2&(U Q8.08 '&#$+ (8#( (8& <(#-.#$ '#=2&( .+ 5G9U444 (*$+> \8#( #=& (8& D=*X&0(&K (=&$K+Y*= <(#-.#$ '#=2&( %=*Q(8[

!"#$%&'$($%) E+55D .&8 8&:5# 6&: 7& 01&:% 4$*#$*7 %.0% &:%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. < '.%8( -**2 #( 8.+(*=.0#- (=&$K+U 6,( (8*+& #=& D=*6#6-P $*( (8#( #00,=#(& 6&0#,+& *Y(8& %=*Q(8 *Y (8& <$(&=$&(> Z* %&( # '*=& #00,=#(& D.0(,=& *Y Q8&=& (8& .$K,+(=P .+ %*.$%U < Q*,-K.$(&=E.&Q (8& 0-.&$(S+ 0,+(*'&=+U .>&> D,6-.+8&=+U D=.$(&=+ #$K #K #%&$0.&+> < Q*,-K #+2 (8&' 8*Q(8&P +&& (8&.= 6,+.$&++ D=*+D&0(+U Q8#( (8&P #=& .$E&+(.$% .$ $*QU Q8#( (8&P Q#$( (* .$E&+( .$-#(&=U &(0>

!"#$%&'$($%) SA; -.'&:7. %.$)D 6&: #$)/&2+' %.0% %.+ \%05$0* 90'C+% 8$55 /&*%$*:+ %& 7'&8 0%01&:% KMN; T&:' 50'7+)% \%05$0* /&93+%$%&' .0) HMN ).0'+; U* $*%+'*0%$&*05 /&93+%$%&' .0) KMN0*# %.+ &%.+' XMN $) 4'079+*%+# 09&*7 )9055 3506+');

1*+%3N4%O%%. <$(&=&+(.$%> 7* (8#( '&#$+ (8& <(#-.#$ '#=2&( 0*,-K *$-P #6+*=6 #$ #KK.(.*$#-5GU444 (*$+ b $*( #$ #KK.(.*$#- :94U444 (*$+> <( '.%8( '#2& +&$+& (* -**2 6&P*$K <(#-P K&D&$K.$%*$ (8& .$K,+(=P KP$#'.0+> \8#( .+ (8& %=&#(&= O,=*D&#$ '#=2&( K&'#$K[

!"#$%&'$($%) E+55D e+'90*6 $) 2+'6 .&% 0*# 7'&8$*7 0% 01&:% KFN; S%.+' "0)%+'* ":'&3+0*90'C+%) 0'+ 7'&8$*7 0) 8+55;

1*+%3N4%O%%. J=&#(> \8* #=& (8& '#X*= 0*'D&(.(*=+ .$ (8*+& '#=2&(+ #$K Q8#( 2.$K *Y +8#=& K*(8&P 8#E&[

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+'+ 0'+ 01&:% KL 3506+') 0*# &*56 L 303+' 90/.$*+ 90*:40/%:'+') $* ":'&3+;

"2+'6&*+ C*&8) 8.0% +2+'6&*+ +5)+ $) #&$*7 0*# *&1&#6 +5)+ $) $*2+)%$*7 $* 0##$%$&*05 /030/$%6'$7.% *&8;

1*+%3N4%O%%. /=& (8&P $*( .$E&+(.$% 6&0#,+& (8&P K*$S( +&& *DD*=(,$.(PU *= 6&0#,+& (8&P K*$S(8#E& (8& =&+*,=0&+[

!"#$%&'$($%) \%() *&% /5+0';

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

:I

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z,=$.$% (* (8& .$E&+('&$( #$%-&U 8*Q V,.02-P 0#$ Q& '#2& 6#02 (8& '*$&P *$ (8&.$E&+('&$( .$ (8& $&Q D-#$([

!"#$%&'$($%) \ #&*(% C*&8 %.+ )3+/$4$/)D 1:% $% 8&:5#*(% %0C+ 2+'6 5&*7; E.0% 8&:5# 6&: 0#2$)+DC*&8$*7 8.0% 6&: C*&8 *&8Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \8.-& < K*$S( 8#E& #-- (8& .$Y*='#(.*$ < Q*,-K -.2&U .( +&&'+ (8#( (8& O,=*D&#$'#=2&( 0*,-K #6+*=6 (8& K&'#$K #$K +.$0& (8& 0*'D&(.(*=+ #=& $*( .$E&+(.$% .$ #KK.(.*$#-0#D#0.(PU (8.+ 0*,-K 6& # %=&#( *DD*=(,$.(P Y*= (8& 0-.&$( (* '#2& .$=*#K+ .$(* # $&Q '#=2&( #$K.$0=&#+& =&E&$,&+> 1&+.K&+ (8& $&Q Y#0(*=PU (8&P '#P #-+* Q#$( (* 0*$+.K&= *(8&= %=*Q(8 *D(.*$+U+,08 #+ 6,.-K.$% $&Q 0#D#0.(P .$ #$ &].+(.$% D-#$( *= #0V,.=.$% # 0*'D&(.(*=>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

:@

)",% T. 7C5"3 6"5*'$4" R',I4+"$

/9):;<=>?@

A43B. "0m.$+&P q )*'D#$P<'C*D. 3449 7,''&=U R.=+( )'*+%*+. i,#-.(#(.E& #$K V,#$(.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

p*,= 0-.&$( .+ (8& )OW *Y (8& 7,%#= "#%$*-.# A*+D.(#-> Z8& 8*+D.(#- .+ # -#=%& 8*+D.(#- D=*E.K.$% # Y,-- =#$%& *Y +&=E.0&+U .$ # -#=%&U ,=6#$ #=&#> <$ (8& -#+( Y.E& P&#=+U (8& 8*+D.(#-S+ D=*Y.(#6.-.(P 8#+ K&0=&#+&K (* (8& D*.$( (8#( (8&P #=& #-'*+( *,( *Y '*$&P #$K Q.-- $*( 6& #6-& (*'&&( (8&.= Y.$#$0.#- #$K +*0.#- '.++.*$>

Z8& =&E&$,& +08&'& *Y (8& 8*+D.(#-S+ K.YY&=&$( +&=E.0&+ Y#--+ .$(* (8& Y*--*Q.$% (8=&& 0#(&%*=.&+;

:d R.]&K Y&& Y*= +&=E.0& e&>%> 6=*2&$ -&% j c:94 (* Y.]d3d )*+( D-,+ e0*+( *Y D=*E.K.$% (8& D=*K,0(M+&=E.0& D-,+ # D&=0&$(#%&d?d C&= K.&' Y&&+ eY&& D&= K#P *Y 8*+D.(#- +(#Pd

Z8& 8*+D.(#- %#.$+ D#(.&$(+ (8=*,%8 D8P+.0.#$ =&Y&==#-> <$ *(8&= Q*=K+U (8& D8P+.0.#$+ Q.(8.$ (8&8*+D.(#- +&& D#(.&$(+ #$K #Y(&= K.#%$*+.$% (8*+& D#(.&$(+ Q.-- =&Y&= (8& D#(.&$(+ Y*= 0#=&U (=&#('&$(U+,=%&=PU (&+(.$%U &(0> (* *(8&= D-#0&+ Q.(8.$ (8& 8*+D.(#->

Z8& )OW 0*'&+ (* P*, (* #+2 (8& Y*--*Q.$%;:d \8P 8#+ D=*Y.(#6.-.(P %*$& K*Q$[3d A*Q +8*,-K (8&P (,=$ .( #=*,$K[

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D "II3'"28.

Z8.+ .+ # D=*Y.(#6.-.(P D=*6-&'U +* D-#$ (* K=.-- K*Q$ *$ ^&E&$,&+ eD=.0& #$K V,#$(.(P *Y D#(.&$(+*= D#(.&$(+M +&=E.0&+ #( (8& 8*+D.(#-d #$K )*+(+ eY.]&K #$K E#=.#6-& 0*+(+ D&= D#(.&$(>d

/+2 #6*,( (8& &0*$*'.0+ *Y (8& 0#+&;

A*Q K*&+ (8& 8*+D.(#- '#2& '*$&P[ eC#.K .$ (8& =&E&$,&+ +(=,0(,=&+ %.E&$ 6P A"WU.$+,=&=+U #$K +(#(& #%&$0.&+ #6*E&> Z8.+ .+ %.E&$ ,DY=*$( .$ (8& 0#+& K&+0=.D(.*$ #$K .+ #

6.( *Y # =&K 8&==.$% .$ (8& 0#+&>d \8* D#P+ (8& 0*+(+[ e/%#.$U (8& 0*+(+ #=& D#.K 6P (8& A"W+U .$+,=&=+U #$K +(#(&

#%&$0.&+d

A*Q K* D#(.&$(+ 0*'& .$(* (8& 8*+D.(#-[ eC#(.&$(+ 0*'& .$ (8=*,%8 =&Y&==#- Y=*' (8&K*0(*=+ (8#( Q*=2 .$ (8& 8*+D.(#- *= (8=*,%8 &'&=%&$0P +&=E.0&+> Z8.+ .+ 8&-DY,-.$Y*='#(.*$ (* %&( .$ +*-E.$% Q8#( .+ %*.$% *$ Q.(8 =&E&$,&+ .$ (8& 0#+&> \8&$ *$&+&%'&$(+ (8& D=*K,0(+M +&=E.0&+ .$ (8& 8*+D.(#-U *$& +8*,-K (8.$2 #6*,( D#(.&$(M +&=E.0&+&%'&$(+U *= D#(.&$(M K*0(*= +&%'&$(+>d

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

34

/Y(&= =&0&.E.$% (8.+ .$Y*='#(.*$U Y*0,+ .$ *$ (8& Y*--*Q.$%;

A*Q '#$P '*=& D&*D-& Q*,-K P*, 6& #6-& (* +&& .Y P*, =&K,0&K D#(.&$( +(#P+ *$ #E&=#%& 6P : K#P[

\8#( Q*,-K (8& &YY&0( *$ 0*+(+ 6& Y*= =&K,0.$% D#(.&$(M K#P+ 6P *$& K#P *$ #E&=#%&[A*Q Q*,-K (8#( #YY&0( D=*Y.(#6.-.(P[

:%J ("2+,.

Z8&=& #=& +&E&=#- D#(.&$(M +&=E.0& +&%'&$(+ .$ (8& 8*+D.(#-> Z8& Y*--*Q.$% #=& # Y&Q &]#'D-&+;

:d \*'&$ .$ F#6*=M J.E.$% 1.=(8b F*Q D=*Y.(#6.-.(PU A.%8 =&Y&==#- =#(&+M Q*=K *Y '*,(8UE*-,'& K&0-.$.$%U Y.]&K Y&& =#(& Q.(8 8.%8 E#=.#6.-.(P .$ -&$%(8 *Y +(#P

3d C&K.#(=.0+b F*Q D=*Y.(#6.-.(PU 8.%8 =&Y&==#- =#(&+M Q*=K *Y '*,(8U E*-,'& K&0-.$.$%U Y.]&K Y&&=#(&+

?d "#-&+ e#%& 39b94db"&K.,' D=*Y.(#6.-.(PU '&K.,' =&Y&==#- =#(&+U E*-,'& +(#6-&U C&= K.&' #$K0*+(l =#(&+

Bd O-K&=-P e59ldbA.%8 D=*Y.(#6.-.(PU -*Q =&Y&==#- =#(&+U E*-,'& .$0=&#+.$%U Y.]&K Y&& =#(&+

i,#$(.(#(.E& Q*=2 .$ (&='+ *Y 0*+(;

R.]&K 0*+(+; c:444M D#(.&$(o#=.#6-& 0*+(+; c944M D#(.&$(M K#P/E&=#%& -&$%(8 *Y D#(.&$( +(#P; :4 K#P+C#(.&$(+ +&&$ D&= P&#=; :444

EK96LME @19M=;>E <$(&=E.&Q&&; Z8.+ .+ # D=*Y.(#6.-.(P 0#+&U #$K D=*Y.(#6.-.(P .+ 0*'D*+&K *Y =&E&$,&+ #$K 0*+(+> <$(&='+ *Y Q8.08 +.K& *Y (8& 8*+D.(#-S+ D=*Y.(#6.-.(P <SK -.2& (* +(#=( Q.(8U ,$-&++ 0*+(+ 8#E& 08#$%&K.$ +*'& +.%$.Y.0#$( Q#P 6&0#,+& *Y # =&0&$( 0#D.(#- &]D&$K.(,=&r>[

!"#$%&'$($% , c&D %.+6(2+ .0# *& *+8 /&)%);

1*+%3N4%O%%. ^.%8(U (8&$ <SK -.2& (* +(#=( Q.(8 =&E&$,&+ #$K +&& .Y (8&=& 8#E& 6&&$ #$P =&0&$(08#$%&+ *$ (8& =&E&$,& +.K&>

!"#$%&'$($% , ]:'+D %.0% )&:*#) 5$C+ 0 7&&# 350/+ %& )%0'%;

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7*U =&E&$,&+ #=& 0*'D*+&K *Y (Q* (8.$%+; D=.0& (.'&+ V,#$(.(P> A#E& (8& D=.0&+(8#( (8& 8*+D.(#- 08#=%&+ Y*= +&=E.0&+ (8#( .( D=*E.K&+ 08#$%&K =&0&$(-P[

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

3:

!"#$%&'$($% , c&D 3'$/+) .02+*(% $*/'+0)+# &' #+/'+0)+# $* 0*6 /&*)$#+'015+ 806h&%.+' %.0* 7+*+'05 $*/'+0)+) 05&*7 8$%. $*450%$&*;

1*+%3N4%O%%. W2#PU +*U .(S+ # D=*6-&' Q.(8 (8& $,'6&= *Y D#(.&$(+U *= $,'6&= *Y D#(.&$(M+&=E.0&+U #-*$% K.YY&=&$( +&%'&$(+ (8&$>

!"#$%&'$($% , T+)D 6&:('+ '$7.%; E.0% #& 6&: .63&%.+)$^+ $) .033+*$*7Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. < .'#%.$& (8#( (8&=& #=& +&E&=#- D#(.&$(U *= D#(.&$(M +&=E.0&U +&%'&$(+ Q.(8.$ (8&8*+D.(#->

!"#$%&'$($% , -.0%() '$7.%;

1*+%3N4%O%%. <+ (8& 8*+D.(#- # Y,--b+&=E.0& D=*E.K&=U *= K* (8&P +D&0.#-.H& .$ +*'& +*=( *Y #=&#U *=+&=E.0&[

!"#$%&'$($% , c&3+D %.+ .&)3$%05 $) 0 4:55P)+'2$/+ 3'&2$#+';

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7*U < 8PD*(8&+.H& (8#( '*=& D=*Y.(#6-& #$KM *= 8.%8&= =&E&$,& %&$&=#(.$% D#(.&$(M+&=E.0& +&%'&$(+ #=& K&0=&#+.$%>

!"#$%&'$($% , \*%+'+)%$*7; -.+'+ 0'+ H 3'$*/$305 )+79+*%),

KB E&9+* $* W01&'d e$2$*7 V$'%.P W&8 3'&4$%01$5$%6D Q$7. '+4+''05 '0%+)d 8&'# &4 9&:%.D 2&5:9+#+/5$*$*7D 4$[+# 4++ '0%+ 8$%. .$7. 20'$01$5$%6 $* 5+*7%. &4 )%06

LB =+#$0%'$/)P W&8 3'&4$%01$5$%6D .$7. '+4+''05 '0%+)d 8&'# &4 9&:%.D 2&5:9+ #+/5$*$*7D 4$[+# 4++

'0%+)

XB Y05+) @07+ LFPFMBPY+#$:9 3'&4$%01$5$%6D 9+#$:9 '+4+''05 '0%+)D 2&5:9+ )%015+D =+' #$+9 0*#/&)%i '0%+)

HB "5#+'56 @jFiBPQ$7. 3'&4$%01$5$%6D 5&8 '+4+''05 '0%+)D 2&5:9+ $*/'+0)$*7D 4$[+# 4++ '0%+)

E.0% #& 6&: %.$*C %.$) #0%0 %+55) 6&:Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U Y.=+(U < Q*,-K D=.*=.(.H& (8& +&%'&$(+ .$ (&='+ *Y 8*Q .'D*=(#$( (8&P +&&' (**,= 0,==&$( .$V,.=P; < Q*,-K D,( (8& (8.=K +&%'&$( #+.K& 6&0#,+& (8& E*-,'& 8#+ +(#P&K +(#6-&U

#$K < Q*,-K 0*$0&$(=#(& *$ (8& Y.=+( (Q* +&%'&$(+ Y*= (Q* =&#+*$+; :d Z8&.= E*-,'& 8#+ 6&&$K&0-.$.$%U #$K 3d Z8&+& +&%'&$(+ =&Y-&0( 8.%8 Q*=K *Y '*,(8 #$K -*$%b(&=' D#(.&$( +&%'&$(+ (8#(#=& -.2&-P (* 2&&D 0*'.$% 6#02 (* (8& 8*+D.(#- Y*= *(8&= +&=E.0&+ Y*= # -*$% (.'& .Y (8&P -.2& (8&+&=E.0& (8#( (8&P %&( (8&=& e#+ *DD*+&K (* (8& &-K&=-P +&%'&$(U Q8.08 =&D=&+&$(+ # K.'.$.+8.$%%=*,D *Y D#(.&$(M +&=E.0&+ 6&0#,+& *Y (8&.= #%&d>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

33

!"#$%&'$($% , e&&#D 7&&#; U*# 8.0% 8&:5# 6&: 80*% %& #& $* &'#+' %& '+2+')+ %.+ #+/5$*+ &4%.&)+ )+79+*%)Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. < Q*,-K D=*6#6-P Q#$( (* K* +*'& =&+&#=08 .$(* Q8P (8*+& +&%'&$(+S E*-,'& .+K&0-.$.$%> A#+ +&=E.0& V,#-.(P K&0-.$&K[ A#E& (8& $,'6&= *= V,#-.(P *Y D&K.#(=.0.#$+ *=*6+(&(=.0.#$+ #( (8& 8*+D.(#- K&0-.$&K[ A#+ #$*(8&= 8*+D.(#- .$ (8& #=&# 6&%,$ (* +D&0.#-.H& .$ D&K.#(=.0+ #$K *6+(&(=.0+ (8#( .+ '#2.$% (8.+ D#(.&$( #$K D#(.&$(M+&=E.0& E*-,'& K&0=&#+& .$ (8&+&+D&0.#-(.&+[

!"#$%&'$($% , e&&#D 7&&#; S*+ 50)% b:+)%$&*, 8&:5# 6&: 010*#&* %.+ 4&:'%. )+79+*% @+5#+'56B 30%$+*%) /&935+%+56; -.+6 0'+ 0 .$7.56 3'&4$%015+ )+79+*%; Q&8 8&:5# 6&: #+05 8$%. %.+9Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8&P #=& # 8.%8-P D=*Y.(#6-& +&%'&$(U Q8.08 .+ # 6.( +(=#$%&U #+ (8&P 8#E& # Y.]&KY&& =#(& =&E&$,& +(=,0(,=& #$K (8&.= -&$%(8 *Y +(#P 0#$ E#=P (=&'&$K*,+-P> < Q*,-K (=P (* +&%'&$((8&' Y,=(8&= .$(* D#(.&$(M +&=E.0& +&%'&$(+ (8#( Q&=& # -.((-& '*=& D=&K.0(#6-& #-*$% (8&K.'&$+.*$ *Y 8*Q -*$% (8&P +(#Ps(8.+ '.%8( P.&-K # ',08 '*=& D=*Y.(#6-& #$K D=&K.0(#6-&

D#(.&$(M +&=E.0& (PD& (8#$ Q8#( (8&P 0,==&$(-P 8#E&>

!"#$%&'$($% , g$7.%D )& %.+'+ 9$7.% 1+ )&9+ LMN &4 %.&)+ 30%$+*%) %.0% 0'+ )%06$*7 5&*7+' 0*##'$2$*7 #&8* 3'&4$%01$5$%6 4&' %.+ '+)%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. p&+U #$K # '*=& K&(#.-&K +&%'&$(#(.*$ '.%8( +8*Q (8#(> 7* (8&PSK 6& #6-& (*(#=%&( #$K %&( (8& '*=& D=*Y.(#6-& *Y (8*+& D#(.&$(+>

!"#$%&'$($% , e&&#D 7&&#; ]&D %.0% 3'+%%6 9:/. /&2+') %.+ '+2+*:+) )$#+; c&8D ):33&)+ %.0% \%&5# 6&: %.0% 6&: %&5# 6&: %.0% 8+ 8+*% %& %.+ R"S 8$%. 055 &4 %.$) $*%+'+)%$*7 $*4& 01&:%'+2+*:+) 0*# '+2+*:+ 7+*+'0%$&* 16 %0'7+%$*7 #$44+'+*% )+79+*%)D 1:% %.+ R"S )0$# %.0% %.+6

'+0556 %.&:7.% $% 80) 01&:% %.+ *:91+' &4 30%$+*%) %.0% %.+ .&)3$%05 /0* )++ 0*# %.+ /&)%) 0*#/&)% /&*%'&5); Q&8 8&:5# 6&: %.$*C 01&:% /&)%)Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U (8&=& #=& (Q* 0*'D*$&$(+ (* 0*+(+; Y.]&K 0*+(+ #$K E#=.#6-& 0*+(+> N* Q&2$*Q Y.]&K 0*+(+ #$K E#=.#6-& 0*+(+ 6P D#(.&$(U *= 6P D#(.&$(M +&=E.0& (PD&[

!"#$%&'$($% , E+55D 0/%:0556D 8+ #&*(% .02+ /&)% #0%0 16 30%$+*% &' 16 30%$+*%d )+'2$/+ %63+D 5$C+8+ #$# $* %.+ '+2+*:+) #$)/:))$&*; V:% 8+ #& .02+ /&)% #0%0 3+' 30%$+*% &* 02+'07+ 0% %.+.&)3$%05;

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7*U #%%=&%#(& K#(# *$ # D&= D#(.&$( -&E&-[

!"#$%&'$($% , T+); E+ C*&8 %.0% &* 02+'07+ %.+ 4$[+# /&)% 4&' 0#9$%%$*7 0 30%$+*% $) ?KMMM; U*#%.+ /&)% 3+' 30%$+*% #06 $) ?FMM; -.+ 02+'07+ 5+*7%. &4 0 30%$+*%() )%06 $) KM #06); U*# %.+.&)3$%05 )++) KMMM 30%$+*%) +0/. 6+0'; -.+ R"S $) /:'$&:) 01&:% .&8 90*6 9&'+ 30%$+*%) %.+.&)3$%05 /&:5# )++ $4 %.+6 '+#:/+# %.+ 5+*7%. &4 0* 02+'07+ 30%$+*% #06 16 &*+ #06;

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

3?

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U 0,==&$(-P (8&P #=& +&&.$% :444 D#(.&$(+ #$$,#--P> O#08 D#(.&$( +(#P+ :4 K#P+*$ #E&=#%&t +*U (8& 8*+D.(#- 8#+ (8& 0#D#0.(P Y*= :4U444 D#(.&$( K#P+ #$$,#--P e:444 D#(.&$(+k :4K#P+j :4U444 D#(.&$( K#P+d> <Y P*, =&K,0&K (8& +(#P (* @ K#P+ *$ #E&=#%& Y*= &#08 D#(.&$(U (8&$(8&=& Q*,-K 6& #$ &]0&++ *Y :444 D#(.&$(bK#P+ *Y 0#D#0.(P e:4U444 D#(.&$(bK#P+ '.$,+ @444 D#(.&$(bK#P+d> <Y &#08 D#(.&$( +(#P+ @ K#P+ *$ #E&=#%&U (8&$ (8& 8*+D.(#- 0*,-K +&& #6*,( :::'*=& D#(.&$(+ &#08 P&#= e:444 &]0&++ D#(.&$(bK#P+M @ K#P+j ::: D#(.&$(+d>

!"#$%&'$($% , -.0%() '$7.%; c&8D .&8 9:/. 8&:5# /&)%) #+/'+0)+ $4 %.+6 #$# %.$)Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U 0,==&$(-PU (8&P +&& :444 D#(.&$(+ D&= P&#= Y*= #$ #E&=#%& *Y :4 K#P+ &#08>R.]&K 0*+(+ Y*= (8&+& D#(.&$(+ #=& c:444 k :444 D#(.&$(+U Q8.08 &V,#-+ c:U444U444> o#=.#6-&0*+(+ #=& :4U444 D#(.&$( K#P+ k c944M K#PU Q8.08 &V,#-+ c9U444U444> 7*U (8&.= 0,==&$( 0*+(+ #=&c5U444U444>

<Y (8&P =&K,0&K (8& #E&=#%& D#(.&$( +(#P 6P : K#PU (8&$ (8&.= E#=.#6-& 0*+(+ 08#$%&> Z8&P +(.--8#E& (8& +#'& Y.]&K 0*+(+ *Y c:U444U444> 1,( (8&.= E#=.#6-& 0*+(+ 8#E& 08#$%&K; (8&P $*Q 8#E&

@U444 D#(.&$( K#P+ k c944M K#PU Q8.08 &V,#-+ cBU944U444 .$ E#=.#6-& 0*+(+> Z8#(S+ # 0*+( +#E.$%+*Y c944U444 &#08 P&#=>

!"#$%&'$($% , -.0%() '$7.%; ]&D .&8 8&:5# 6&: ):990'$^+ %.+)+ 4$*#$*7) %& %.+ R"S 0*# 8.0%'+/&99+*#0%$&*) 8&:5# 6&: 90C+Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. W$ (8& =&E&$,&+ +.K&U 7,%#= "#%$*-.# .+ -*+.$% D#(.&$(+ .$ # Y&Q +&%'&$(+ (8#( D=*E.K& =&E&$,&+ -*$%b(&='> R*= (8&+& +&%'&$(+U (8&P $&&K (* (#=%&( #$K 6=.$% .$ '*=& K*0(*=+Q8* f*Q$g (8&+& D#(.&$(+ #$K .'D=*E& (8&.= 6=#$K .$ (8&+& +&=E.0& #=&#+ (8=*,%8 D=*'*(.*$+U(8*,%8( -&#K&= &]0&--&$0&U *= 0*'',$.(P #0(.E.(.&+ (8#( Q*,-K =#.+& (8&.= D=*Y.-&> /$K (8&P+8*,-K Y,=(8&= +&%'&$( *(8&= D#(.&$(M +&=E.0& (PD&+ e(8& &-K&=-Pd .$ *=K&= (* =&#-.H& '*=&

D=*Y.(#6-& D#(.&$(M +&=E.0& (PD&+ Q.(8.$ 0,==&$( +&%'&$(+>

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e(8& 0*+(+ +.K&d Q8.-& '#.$(#.$.$% .(+ +*0.#- %*#-M '.++.*$>/$K Y*= (8.+ =&#+*$U +&E&=#- V,#-.(P *Y 0#=& #$#-P+&+ +8*,-K 6& K*$& 6&Y*=& .$.(.#(.$% +*'& *Y (8&0*+(b0,((.$% .$.(.#(.E&+ (8#( 8#E& 6&&$ K.+0,++&K 8&=&>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

3B

)",% U. L34N"+% M"#%$ 7"$%,

/9):;<=>?@

A43B. "0m.$+&P q )*'D#$P<'C*D. 3449 7,''&=U R.=+( )'*+%*+. 1=#.$+(*='.$%b 0*'D-&(&-P V,#-.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

\&S=& %*.$% (* -**2 #( # %=*Q.$% (=&$K .$ (8& )*$+,'&= C#02#%&K J**K+ .$K,+(=P> W,= 0-.&$( .+# 6*((-&K Q#(&= 0*'D#$P e&>%> C*-#$K 7D=.$%+d> / '#X*= =&(#.-&= e&>%> \#-'#=(d Q#$(+ *,= 0-.&$((* 0=&#(& # D=.E#(& -#6&- E&=+.*$ *Y .(+ D=*K,0(> <$ *(8&= Q*=K+U .$ #KK.(.*$ (* *,= 0-.&$(S+ 6*((-&KQ#(&= Q8.08 (8&P #-=&#KP 0#==PU (8&P Q#$( (8& 0-.&$( (* '#2& #$ #KK.(.*$#-U -*Q&=bD=.0&K 6*((-&KQ#(&= Q8.08 Q.-- 6& (8&.= *Q$ 6=#$K -#6&-U e&>%> \#-'#=( 1*((-&K \#(&=d>

\8#( #=& (8& D=*+ #$K 0*$+ *Y K*.$% (8.+[

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

/+ .( Q#+ %.E&$ .$ (8& .$(&=E.&QU (8.+ .+ '*=& *Y # +.(,#(.*$ #$#-P+.+ #$K 6=#.$+(*='.$% &]&=0.+&=#(8&= (8#$ # 0#+& (* K=.-- K*Q$ *$ #$K 0=#02> /+ +,08U (8&=& '#P 6& '#$P '*=& D=*+M0*$+ 6&P*$K Q8#( .+ -.+(&K .$ (8& &]#'D-& 6&-*Q> <$ %&$&=#-U .( .+ .'D*=(#$( (* 6& +(=,0(,=&K #$K (=P (* D,( (8& D=*+ #$K 0*$+ .$(* 0-&#= 6,02&(+> )*$+.K&=.$% (8& ?)S+ e&>%> .'D#0( *$ 0,+(*'&==&-#(.*$+8.DU 0*'D#$PS+ *D&=#(.*$#- .++,&+U #$K 0*'D&(.(.E& KP$#'.0+d 0*,-K #-+* 6& 8&-DY,- .$(8.+ 0#+&>

EK96LME 7=M>!1=?

L3',.

<'D=*E&K =&-#(.*$+8.D Q.(8 # D*Q&=Y,- '&=08#$( e'#P %&( 6&((&= +8&-Y +D#0& #$K 6&((&=(&='+ *$ *(8&= D=*K,0(+ (8&P D,=08#+& Y=*' ,+ #+ Q&-- #+ 0=*++b'#=2&(.$% #==#$%&'&$(+d

F#=%&= D=*K,0(.*$ '#P #08.&E& 6&((&= &0*$*'.&+ *Y +0#-& .$ 6*(8 Y.]&K 0*+(+ e0*+(M,$.( (* D=*K,0&U &+D> .Y 0&=(#.$ *D&=#(.*$#- D=*0&K,=&+ #=& +P$&=%.+(.0d #$K E#=.#6-& 0*+(+eK&-.E&=PU K.+(=.6,(.*$U &(0>d .$ #KK.(.*$ (* (8& D*(&$(.#- (* $&%*(.#(& 6&((&= (&='+ Q.(8+,DD-.&=+ K,& (* -#=%&= *=K&=+

A,%& D*(&$(.#- =&E&$,& %=*Q(8 Y*= *,= 0*'D#$P e-*Q&= D=.0& 6,( D*(&$(.#--P 8.%8

E*-,'&d

)'*,.

)#$$.6#-.H#(.*$ *Y *,= *Q$ D=.E#(& -#6&-S+ Q#(&= +#-&+ e0*+(M6&$&Y.( #$#-P+.+ *Y Q8&(8&=(8& E*-,'& *Y \#-b"#=(S+ 6=#$K Q.-- '#2& ,D Y*= .(d

C*++.6.-.(P *Y -&++&$.$% *,= D*Q&= Q.(8 (8& '&=08#$( #+ # +,DD-.&= .Y D=.E#(& -#6&- (#2&+*YY #$K +,DD-#$(+ *,= *Q$ D=*K,0(

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

39

A.%8&= 0*+(+ eR.]&Kb +,08 #+ #KK.(.*$#- D-#$( =&V,.=&'&$(+ K,& (* D*(&$(.#- 0#D#0.(P0*$+(=#.$(+ ` Q.-- (8& .$E&+('&$( 6& Q*=(8 .([d

"*=& 0*'D-.0#(&K K.+(=.6,(.*$ #KK.$% #KK.(.*$#- 7mL .$(* (8& '.]

C*(&$(.#--P # K.YY&=&$( '#=2&( Y*= *,= D=*K,0( Q8.08 K*&+ $*( Q*=2 +P$&=%.+(.0#--P Q.(8

*,= '#=2&(.$% Y*0,+ eY*= &]#'D-& .Y *,= D=*K,0( .+ #6*,( D=&+(.%& #$K .'#%&U Q& Q*,-K 6&0#(&=.$% (* # K.YY&=&$( 0,+(*'&= +&%'&$( Q.(8 # -*Q&= D=.0&K D=*K,0(d

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

35

)",% V. L4"*' 6"30%+ 74W4*5

/9):;<=>?@

A43B. "0m.$+&P q )*'D#$P<'C*D. 3449 7,''&=U R.$#- )'*+%*+. "#=2&( +.H.$%

)97E F>E7!1=?

\&S=& %*.$% (* -**2 #( (8& +#-&+ *Y C.#$*+ .$ (8& L$.(&K 7(#(&+> \8#( K* P*, (8.$2 #$$,#- +#-&+e(*(#- =&E&$,&+d #=& .$ (8& L7 Y*= C.#$*+[

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

/$+Q&= +8*,-K +8*Q # -*%.0#- Q#P *Y +.H.$% (8& '#=2&(> p*, $&&K (* '#2& +*'& #++,'D(.*$+U#$K +8*Q P*,= Q#P *Y %&((.$% (* #$ #$+Q&=> /0(,#- $,'6&=+ #=&$S( #+ .'D*=(#$( #+ (8& -*%.0 6&8.$K (8& '&(8*K>

EK96LME @19M=;>E < #' (8.$2.$% (8&=& #=& (Q* (PD&+ *Y D.#$* 6,P&=+U D&=+*$#- 8*,+&8*-K+ #$K .$+(.(,(.*$+> WY (8*+&U# 0&=(#.$ D&=0&$(#%& #-=&#KP *Q$ # D.#$*> C.#$* 6,P&=+U .$ # %.E&$ P&#=U Q*,-K 6& K.E.K&K .$(*;:d R.=+(b(.'& D.#$* *Q$&=+3d LD%=#K.$% #$ *-K D.#$* *= =&D-#0.$% # K#'#%&K D.#$*?d /KK.$% # +&0*$K D.#$* e+'#-- Y*= 8*,+&8*-K+U -#=%&= Y*= .$+(.(,(.*$+d

Z8&$U < Q*,-K $&&K (* &+(.'#(& Q8* (8&+& 6,P&=+ '.%8( 6&;A*,+&8*-K+; R*= &]#'D-&U #DD=*]> ?44 ".--.*$ D&*D-& .$ (8& L7> /E%> 8*,+&8*-K .+ ? eQ8.08'.%8( 6& 8.%8 K,& (* '#$P +.$%-& D&*D-&>d7*U :44 ".--.*$ 8*,+&8*-K+>

R=*' (8&=& K&K,0& 8*Q '#$P #=& .$ (8& cG9U444MP&#= .$0*'& 6=#02&(U #+ (8&P #=& '*+( -.2&-P (* D,=08#+& # D.#$* eY*= &]#'D-&U 39_ Q8.08 &V,#-+ 39 ".--.*$ 8*,+&8*-K+>dW,( *Y (8*+& 39 ".--.*$U 9_ 0,==&$(-P *Q$ # D.#$* #-=&#KP e:>39 ".--.*$ C.#$*+d><Y < #++,'& &E&=P P&#=U 3_ *Y (8& 39 ".--.*$ Q.-- 6,P # D.#$*U (8&$ (8&=& #=& 944m D.#$*+ +*-K (*8*,+&8*-K+ &E&=P P&#=>

R*--*Q # +.'.-#= -*%.0 Y*= .$+(.(,(.*$+ ` &>%> 0*--&%&+U ,$.E&=+.(.&+U +P'D8*$.&+U )#=$&%.& A#--U 6#=+M6,+.$&++&+U &(0> /++,'& (8#( (8&=& #=& : '.--.*$ *Y (8&+& .$+(.(,(.*$+U *Y Q8.08 34_ e344mdQ*,-K Q#$( # D.#$*> WY (8#(U D&=8#D+ 9_ 6,P # D.#$* &E&=P P&#=U *= :4m D.#$*+ +*-K (*.$+(.(,(.*$+>

Z8&$U < Q*,-K $&&K (* Y.%,=& (8& #E&=#%& D=.0& D#.K D&= D.#$*><( .+ .'D*=(#$( (* K.+(.$%,.+8 6&(Q&&$ $&Q #$K ,+&K D.#$* +#-&+U #+ (8& D=.0& D*.$(+ #=& K.YY&=&$(>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

3G

<$ (8& T&Q C.#$* '#=2&(U < Q*,-K (8.$2 (8& -*Q D=.0& Y*= # D.#$* .+ c9U444 #$K (8& 8.%8 D=.0& .+c:9U444U +* (8& #E% D=.0& *Y # $&Q D.#$* .+ c:4U444>

R*= # ,+&K D.#$*U (8& -*Q .+ D=*6#6-P c:U444 #$K $&Q .+ c9U444U +* (8& #E&=#%& D=.0& .+ c?U444>

< Q*,-K E&$(,=& (8#( 34_ *Y D.#$*+ +*-K #=& ,+&K #$K I4_ #=& $&Q Y*= 6*(8 8*,+&8*-K+ #$K.$+(.(,(.*$+> <Y (8.+ .+ (8& 0#+&U :43m (*(#- $&Q D.#$*+ #=& +*-K #$K B4Im ,+&K D.#$*+ #=& +*-K>Z* '#2& (8& $,'6&=+ +.'D-&U ,+& :44m #$K B44m> Z8.+ -&#K+ P*, (* c:1 .$ $&Q D.#$* +#-&+ #$Kc:>31 .$ ,+&K D.#$* +#-&+U *= c3>31 .$ (*(#- +#-&+>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

3I

)",% X. ;", 7+"+4'*, "*D )'*N%*4%*2% 7+'3%,

/9):;<=>?@

A43B. "0m.$+&P q )*'D#$P<'C*D. 3449 7,''&=U R.=+( )'*+%*+. 1=#.$+(*='.$%U -#=%&-P V,#-.(#(.E&

)97E !=L1)

W,= 0-.&$( .+ '#X*= %-*6#- *.- 0*'D#$P (8#( *Q$+ (8& Q8*-& E#-,& 08#.$; *.- =.%+U =&Y.$.$%UK.+(=.6,(.*$U #$K =&(#.-> W,= K.=&0( 0*$(#0( .+ (8& )OW *Y (8& %-*6#- =&(#.- *D&=#(.*$> A.+*D&=#(.*$ 0*$+.+(+ *Y :d %#+ +*-K #( (8& D,'D+ #$K 3d (8& 0*$E&$.&$0& +(*=&+ #( (8& %#+ +(#(.*$>C=*Y.(#6.-.(P *Y (8& =&(#.- *D&=#(.*$ 8#+ K&0-.$&KU #$K (8& )OW Q*,-K -.2& ,+ (* 8&-D Y.%,=& *,(Q8P #$K (* 0*'& ,D Q.(8 # D-#$ Y*= (8& $&]( Y.E& P&#=+>

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

Z8.+ 0#+& .+ =&D=&+&$(#(.E& *Y '#$P *Y (8& D=&D#=&KU "0m.$+&P =*,$K : 0#+&+U .$ Q8.08 (8&.$(&=E.&Q&= #0(.E&-P Q#-2+ (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& (8=*,%8 # +&( *Y V,#-.(#(.E& #$K V,#$(.(#(.E& V,&+(.*$+>Z8& .$(&=E.&Q&= +8*,-K f+(.02 (* (8& +0=.D(g *Y V,&+(.*$+> Z* (8& &YY&0( (8#( (8& .$(&=E.&Q&&+(=,%%-&+U (8& .$(&=E.&Q&= 0#$ #++.+( (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& (* %&( 6#02 *$ (=#02>

Z8& .$(&=E.&Q&& +8*,-K 6& +(=,0(,=&K .$ #$+Q&=.$% V,#-.(#(.E& V,&+(.*$+ #$K 0=,$08 (8=*,%8 #$P$,'6&=+ (8=*Q$ 8.+ *= 8&= Q#PU #-Q#P+ 2&&D.$% .$ '.$K 8*Q (8&P (.& 6#02 (* (8& -#=%&= .++,&+>

)97E F>E7!1=?7

WE&= (8& D#+( Y.Y(&&$ P&#=+U (8& $,'6&= *Y %#+ +(#(.*$+ Q*=-KQ.K& 8#+ K&0-.$&K 6P +.] D&=0&$(>

F. H8"+ B458+ #% +8% 2"C,%, '( +84,Y

/; C*++.6-& #$+Q&=+ .$0-,K&

)*$+*-.K#(.*$

<$0=&#+& .$ K*--#= E*-,'& D&= +(#(.*$

)8#$%.$% D*D,-#(.*$ D#((&=$+ eY&Q&= =,=#- +(#(.*$+d

"*=& +(#(.*$+ *D&$ 3B 8*,=+ e+* Y&Q&= +(#(.*$+ $&&K&Kd

7%+ '( ZC%,+4'*, 3%. 2'BI"3"+4N% 5", ,+"+4'* I3'(4+"#4$4+J <( (,=$+ *,( (8&=& 8#E& 6&&$ (Q* *(8&= 08#$%&+ .$ (8& '#=2&(> W$&U (8& $,'6&= *Y %#+ +(#(.*$+Q.(8 0*$E&$.&$0& +(*=&+ #((#08&K 8#+ .$0=&#+&K> ZQ*U # '#X*= $&Q &$(=#$( 8#+ 6&%,$ (#2.$%'#=2&( +8#=&> 7,D&='#=2&(+ 8#E& 6&%,$ *D&$.$% %#+ +(#(.*$+ .$ (8&.= D#=2.$% -*(+> Z8.+ .+ $*(P&( # '#X*= 0*'D&(.(*= .$ (8& L7U Q8&=& (8&P *$-P 8#E& (&$ D&=0&$( *Y (8& '#=2&(U 6,(+,D&='#=2&(+ 8#E& ?4_ *Y (8& %#+ '#=2&( .$ (8& LmU #$K 54_ .$ R=#$0&>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

3@

Z8& $&]( (#+2 .+ (* ,$K&=+(#$K Q8&(8&= (8& +,D&='#=2&(+ 8#E& # 6&((&= 6,+.$&++ '*K&- (8#$ (8&%#+ +(#(.*$+ .$ (8.+ '#=2&(U #$K .Y +*U Q8P> \&S-- ,+& (8& '&(=.0 *Y ^&(,=$ *$ <$E&+(&K )#D.(#- `*D&=#(.$% D=*Y.( M .$E&+(&K 0#D.(#->

Z8& $,'6&=+ Y*= (8& Lm +,D&='#=2&( #=& #+ Y*--*Q+; (8&P +&-- (&$ '.--.*$ -.(=&+ *Y %#+ D&= P&#= #(G3 0&$(+M-.(=&> Z8&.= 0*+( .+ 34 0&$(+M-.(=&> Z8&P D#P B9 0&$(+M-.(&= .$ (#]> Z8& 0*$E&$.&$0&+(*=&S+ *D&=#(.$% D=*Y.( .+ 944U444 D*,$K+ D&= P&#=> WE&=8&#K .$ (8& .$K,+(=P .+ (PD.0#--P (&$ D&=0&$( *Y Y,&- +#-&+U #$K (8#(S+ #00,=#(& 8&=&> Z8& 0#D.(#- 0*+( .+ (Q* '.--.*$ D*,$K+>

\&S-- 0*'D#=& .( (* *$& *Y *,= (PD.0#- %#+ +(#(.*$ -*0#(.*$+; K*Q$(*Q$U *$& *Y *,= 6,+.&+(-*0#(.*$+> Z8.+ -*0#(.*$ +&--+ +.] '.--.*$ -.(=&+ D&= P&#= #( G9 0&$(+M-.(=&t .(+ 0*+( #$K (#] D&= -.(=&#=& (8& +#'& #+ (8& +,D&='#=2&(> )*$E&$.&$0& +(*=& D=*Y.( .+ 34_ -*Q&= (8#$ (8& +,D&='#=2&(S+>WE&=8&#K .+ +(.-- (&$ D&=0&$( *Y Y,&- +#-&+U #$K 0#D.(#- 0*+(+ #=& Y*,= '.--.*$ D*,$K+>

F. H8"+ 4, +8% <=1) '( +8% ,CI%3B"30%+Y /; e3B_d e<( #-+* '#P 0*'& *,( 8&=& (8#( (8&0*$E&$.&$0& +(*=& .+ =&+D*$+.6-& Y*= #-- (8& D=*Y.(+>d

F. H4+8'C+ 3C**4*5 +8% *CB#%3,[ O8"+ D' J'C +84*0 'C3 2$4%*+\, 5", ,+"+4'*\, <=1) O4$$

#%Y H8JY /; e",08 -*Q&= ̀ 6&0#,+& *Y (8& 0*+( *Y 0#D.(#-d>

F. H8"+ D' J'C +84*0 2"C,%, +8"+ 8458 2',+ '( 2"I4+"$Y /; eK*Q$(*Q$ -*0#(.*$ `+,D&='#=2&(+ (PD.0#--P .$ (8& +,6,=6+>d

F. 7'[ 54N%* +8"+[ O8"+ '+8%3 +84*5, +8"+ D34N% <=1) B458+ O% #% "#$% +' "((%2+Y /; eF.2&-P0#$S( 08#$%& 0*+( *= (#] ` 0*,-K -*Q&= D=.0& (* +&-- '*=& %#+ ` 0*,-K '*E& *,( *Y (8& 0.(P ` 0*,-K#((&'D( (* .$0=&#+& 0*$E&$.&$0& +(*=& D=*Y.(#6.-.(P>d

)$4%*+ 3%2'BB%*D"+4'*.Z8& 0-.&$( #%=&&+ Q.(8 *,= =&0*''&$K#(.*$ (* Y*0,+ *$ (8& 0*$E&$.&$0& +(*=&U #$K K&0.K&+ (* +&(# D.-*( D=*%=#' .$ :U444 +(*=&+>

F. H8"+ +JI% '( *%O I3'DC2+, ,8'C$D 8% 4*+3'DC2%Y R'O O'C$D J'C +84*0 "#'C+ O8"+

I3'DC2+, +' 4*+3'DC2%Y u<$(&=E.&Q&& Q#+ =&V,.=&K (* 0*'& ,D Q.(8 &.%8( #$+Q&=+ ̀ $&#= (8& &$K8& Q#+ 8&-D&K #-*$% Q.(8 fZ8.$2 #6*,( Q8#( Q&SK #+2 .Y 8& 0#'& (* ,+ Q.(8 D=*K,0( / #$K D=*K,0( 1 ` Q8#( Q*,-K Q& #+2 (* 6& #6-& (* K&0.K& 6&(Q&&$ (8*+& (Q*>gv

/; 7*'& Y#0(*=+ Q& 0*,-K ,+& (* K&0.K& Q&=&;b\8#( K*&+ (8& &].+(.$% 0,+(*'&= Q#$(

b\8#( D=*K,0(+ 8#E& 8.%8 '#=%.$+b\8#( 0#$ Q& e#$K (8& +,DD-.&=d +,DD*=( -*%.+(.0#--Pb\8#( 0#$ Q& %&( Y=*' &].+(.$% +,DD-.&=+b\8#( 0#$ Q& -.$2 (* D=*K,0(+ (8#( #-=&#KP +&-- Q&--b\8#( D=*K,0(+ #=& $&&K&K Y=&V,&$(-P M Q.-- K=.E& E.+.(+b\8#( D=*K,0(+ #=& K,=#6-&b\8#( D=*K,0(+ =&V,.=& -.((-& +8&-Y +D#0& e+D#0& #( # D=&'.,' .$ (8&+& +(*=&+d>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

?4

<$ (8& &$K (8& K&0.+.*$ Q#+ '#K& (* .$(=*K,0& 8*( #$K 0*-K Y**K ` 8.%8b'#=%.$U -*Q +8&-Yb+D#0&U8.%8bY=&V,&$0P e6,( -*Q K,=#6.-.(Pd> "0m .+ 0,==&$(-P .'D-&'&$(.$% .$ O,=*D&> O$K *Y 0#+&>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

?:

)",% ]. 6%5"#"*0 >*D%3I%*%+3"+4'*

/9):;<=>?@


)97E !=L1)

"&%#6#$2 .+ # 6#$2 (8#( .++,&+ 0=&K.( 0#=K+> T&Q 0#=K+ #=& +*-K .$ (8=&& '#.$ Q#P+;:> 0=*++b+&-- (* &].+(.$% 6#$2.$% 0,+(*'&=+3> +&-- (* $&Q 0,+(*'&=+ E.# K.=&0( '#.- 0#'D#.%$+?> K.+(=.6,(& E.# D=.E#(& -#6&- D#=($&=+8.D+ Q.(8 =&(#.-&=+ #$K #.=-.$&

"&%#6#$2 .+ -**2.$% Y*= $&Q 0#=K '&'6&= %=*Q(8 #=&#+ .$ (8& L$.(&K 7(#(&+> <(+ A.+D#$.0

'#=2&( D&$&(=#(.*$ .+ -*Q 0*'D#=&K (* 0*'D#=#6-& 6#$2+S D&$&(=#(.*$ =#(&+> Z8#( %=*,D .+ # Y#+(%=*Q.$% &(8$.0.(P #$K (8& 6#$2 Q#$(+ (* 0#D.(#-.H& *$ .(>

\8#( .+ (8& 0,==&$( D=*6-&' e.>&>U Q8#( #=& (8& D*++.6-& =&#+*$+ Y*= (8& ,$K&=D&$&(=#(.*$ .$ (8&A.+D#$.0 '#=2&([d[ A*Q +8*,-K (8& 6#$2 '*E& Y*=Q#=K[

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D "II3'"28.

Z8.+ 0#+& .+ =&D=&+&$(#(.E& *Y '#$P *Y (8& D=&D#=&KU "0m.$+&P =*,$K : 0#+&+U .$ Q8.08 (8&.$(&=E.&Q&= #0(.E&-P Q#-2+ (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& (8=*,%8 # +&( *Y V,#-.(#(.E& #$K V,#$(.(#(.E& V,&+(.*$+>

Z8& .$(&=E.&Q&= +8*,-K f+(.02 (* (8& +0=.D(g *Y V,&+(.*$+> Z* (8& &YY&0( (8#( (8& .$(&=E.&Q&&+(=,%%-&+U (8& .$(&=E.&Q&= 0#$ #++.+( (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& (* %&( 6#02 *$ (=#02>


)97E F>E7!1=?7

F. H8"+ B458+ #% O3'*5Y RJI'+8%,4W%^

/; N.+0,++ 6=.&Y-P (8& D*(&$(.#- *Y &#08 *Y (8& Y*--*Q.$% (* #YY&0( (8& D&$&(=#(.*$ =#(&;

C=*K,0( N&Y.$.(.*$ ` N*&+ (8& 0#=KU #+ .( 8#+ 6&&$ K&Y.$&K '&&( (8& $&&K+ *Y (8&0,+(*'&=[

C=.0.$% *Y )=&K.( )#=K Z&='+ ` /=& (8& Y&&+ #$K =#(&+ *$ D#= Q.(8 *(8&= 0*'D#=#6-&0#=K+[

"#=2&(.$%M/KE&=(.+.$% ` /=& (8& '&++#%&+ D=*D&=-P K.=&0(&K (* (8& #,K.&$0& e6*(80*$(&$( #$K K.+(=.6,(.*$d[

)8#$$&- C#=($&=+ ` N*&+ *,= (#=%&( #,K.&$0& +8*D #( M &#( #( M 6,P Y=*' *,= D#=($&=+[

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

?3

<$(&=$#- 7#-&+ "&++#%&+M<$0&$(.E& 7(=,0(,=& ` /=& (8& +#-&+ '&++#%&+ 0*==&0(-P +(=,0(,=&(* &$(.0& *,= D*(&$(.#- 0,+(*'&=[ <+ *,= .$(&=$#- +#-&+ Y*=0& e.>&>U (&--&= #$K K&+2 D&=+*$$&-d (=#.$&K #$K .$0&$(&K D=*D&=-P (* D=*'*(& (8& 0#=K[ N.+0,++ .$ K&(#.- e.>&>UQ8#( '.%8( 6& '.+#-.%$&KU 8*Q (8#( '.%8( #YY&0( #K*D(.*$ =#(&+U &(0>d>

F. )"$2C$"+% +8% *CB#%3 '( "DD4+4'*"$ B%B#%3, 6%5"#"*0 O"*+, +' "DD #",%D '* +8%

('$$'O4*5 4*('3B"+4'*.

Z8&=& #=& B4 '.--.*$ A.+D#$.0 D&*D-& .$ (8& L7 ?MI(8+ *Y (8&' #=& (** P*,$% (* 8#E& 0=&K.( 0#=K+ Z8& #E&=#%& 0,+(*'&= .+ Q*=(8 c:I4 (* (8& 6#$2 *E&= (8& 0*,=+& *Y 8.+ -.Y& N,& (* K&0=&#+&K #0V,.+.(.*$ 0*+(+U (8& #E&=#%& A.+D#$.0 0,+(*'&= .+ Q*=(8 :4_ '*=&

),==&$(-PU (8& 6#$2S+ D&$&(=#(.*$ =#(& .+ :4_ e*Y E#-.K 0,+(*'&= D=*+D&0(+d Z8&P Q#$( (* %&( (* # ?4_ -&E&- *E&= 9 P&#=+

/; ?MI(8+ *Y B4" #=& (** P*,$%U +* 9MI(8+ *Y B4" #=& E#-.K 0,+(*'&= D=*+D&0(+> Z8#( (=#$+-#(&+(* # '#=2&( *Y 39" D&*D-&>

Z8&P 0,==&$(-P 8#E& :4_ *Y 39" j 3>9"Z8&P Q#$( ?4_ *Y 39" j G>9"Z8&P $&&K 9" #KK.(.*$#- '&'6&=+ *E&= 9 P&#=+

F. R'O BC28 4, +8"+ "DD4+4'*"$ B"30%+ ,8"3% O'3+8 +' 6%5"#"*0 _'3 8'O BC28 O'C$D

6%5"#"*0 #% O4$$4*5 +' ,I%*D '* +8"+ "DD4+4'*"$ B"30%+ ,8"3%`Y

/; <Y (8& #E&=#%& 0,+(*'&= -.Y&(.'& E#-,& .+ c:I4U 6,( (8& #E&=#%& A.+D#$.0 0,+(*'&= .+ Q*=(8

:4_ '*=&U &#08 0,+(*'&= .+ Q*=(8 c:@I> ^*,$K.$% (8#( (* c344U (8& (*(#- E#-,& *Y 9" &](=#'&'6&= .+ c:1>

F. )3',,a,%$$4*5 +' #3"*28 2C,+'B%3, 4, ,45*4(42"*+$J #%$'O +8% 4*DC,+3J *'3B, _9N%3"5% b

-T[ccc +' Pc[ccc I%3 B'*+8d 6%5"#"*0 b T[ccc I%3 B'*+8`^ H8"+ B458+ #% +8% 3%",'*Y

/;

C=*K,0( ` <+ (8& "&%#6#$2 D=*K,0( K.YY&=&$( Y=*' 0*'D&(.(*=+S D=*K,0(+[ <$(&=E.&Q&=; cS

C=.0.$% ` /=& (8& Y&&+ #$K =#(&+ K.YY&=&$( (8#$ *(8&= 0*'D#=#6-& 0#=K+[<$(&=E.&Q&=; cS

),+(*'&= ` /=& Q& (#=%&(.$% # Y,$K#'&$(#--P K.YY&=&$( #,K.&$0&[<$(&=E.&Q&=; cS

)8#$$&- C#=($&=+ ` /=& (8& K.+(=.6,(.*$ 08#$$&-+ '.+#-.%$&K[<$(&=E.&Q&=; cS

"#=2&(.$%M/KE&=(.+.$% ` <+ (8&=& +*'&(8.$% Q=*$% Q.(8 *,= +#-&+ '&08#$.+'[<$(&=E.&Q&=; W+%() $*2+)%$70%+

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

??

F. 6%5"#"*0 C,%, D43%2+ B"4$ 2"BI"45*, +' ,'$424+ *%O 2"3D B%B#%3,^

!8% "N%3"5% 3%,I'*,% 3"+% ('3 +8% *'*aR4,I"*42 I'IC$"+4'* 4, -e^

6%5"#"*0\, 84,+'342"$ 3%,I'*,% 3"+% (3'B R4,I"*42 I3',I%2+, 4, Qe^

!8% #"*0 4, I$"**4*5 +' +"35%+ -T6 I'+%*+4"$ 2C,+'B%3, O4+8 %"28 '( Q B"4$4*5, +84,

J%"3^ 1+ %fI%2+, +8"+ "(+%3 +8% (43,+ B"4$4*5[ +8% 3%,I'*,% 3"+% O4$$ D3'I #J -gQ

3D 4* %"28 '(

+8% ,C#,%ZC%*+ B"4$4*5,^

!8% #"*0 8", " 2'*N%3,4'* 3"+% '( STe '( 3%,I'*D%*+,^

R'O B"*J *%O 2C,+'B%3, ,8'C$D +8% #"*0 %fI%2+ "(+%3 +8% +843D B"4$4*5Y

/; ?_ n :9" j B94U444 Y=*' Y.=+( '#.-&=B94U444 ` :M?nB94U444 j ?44U444 Y=*' +&0*$K '#.-&=?44U444 ` :M?n?44U444 j 344U444 Y=*' (8.=K '#.-&=

@94U444 n B9_ 0*$E&=+.*$ j wB94U444 $&Q 0,+(*'&=+

F. h'C 3'C*D%D ]Tc[ccc +' -[ccc[ccc^ H'C$D J'C %fI%2+ +8% "2+C"$ *CB#%3 '( *%O

2C,+'B%3, +' #% B'3% '3 $%,, +8"* SPT[ccc "*D 8'O D' J'C 2"$2C$"+% +8"+ _4* J'C3 8%"D`Y

/; 7-.%8(-P '*=& +.$0& :4_ *Y @94U444 .+ @9U444t (8&=&Y*=& B4_ .+ Bn@9U444 *= ?I4U444> /KK9_ *Y @94U444 e*= 8#-Y *Y @9U444d Q8.08 .+ BGU944 (* ?I4U444 (* %&( B3GU944> Z8#( Q*,-K 6&+*'&Q8&=& 6&(Q&&$ 3" #$K 3>9" *E&= Y.E& P&#=+>i; p*, 6,'D .$(* (8& 7oC *Y 7#-&+ e=&-#(&K (* (8& 0=&K.( 0#=K 6,+.$&++d .$ (8& 8#-- #$K 8& #+2+fA*Q K*&+ .( -**2[g A*Q K* P*, =&+D*$K e: '.$,(& *$-Pd[

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

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

?B

)",% -c. R%"3+2'3I

/9):;<=>?@


)97E !=L1)

A&#=(0*=D .+ # '&K.0#- K&E.0&+ 0*'D#$P> Z8&P D=*K,0& 0#=K.*E#+0,-#= +(&$(+>Z8&P 8#E& K&E&-*D&K # =&E*-,(.*$#=P D=*K,0( (8#( .+ D*+.(.*$&K (* =&D-#0& (8& 0,==&$( D=*K,0(+ .$(8& '#=2&(> Z8& D=*K,0(U 0#--&K N&E.0& kU .+ (8& Y.=+( *Y .(+ 2.$K

A&#=(0*=D Q#$(+ (* -#,$08 N&E.0& k .$ O,=*D& .$ (8& $&#= Y,(,=& #$K (8&$ 6=.$% .( (* (8& L>7> .$ 5

'*$(8+> Z8&P #=& : P&#= #8&#K *Y .(+ 0*'D&(.(.*$ eQ.(8 =&%#=K (* ^qN *Y (8& D=*K,0(d>

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D "II3'"28.


Z8& .$(&=E.&Q&& +8*,-K 6& +(=,0(,=&K .$ #$+Q&=.$% V,#-.(#(.E& V,&+(.*$+ #$K 0=,$08 (8=*,%8 #$P

$,'6&=+ (8=*Q$ 8.+ *= 8&= Q#PU #-Q#P+ 2&&D.$% .$ '.$K 8*Q (8&P (.& 6#02 (* (8& -#=%&= .++,&+>

)97E F>E7!1=?7

F. R'O D' J'C D%+%3B4*% O8"+ I342% +' 28"35% ('3 @%N42% KY H8"+ "3% +8% 4,,C%, +8"+

*%%D +' #% 2'*,4D%3%DY

/; Z8=&& #=&#+ +8*,-K 6& &]D-*=&K (* K&(&='.$& (8& D=.0&;:> ),==&$( D=.0& #$K =#(.*$#-& Y*= 0,==&$( D=.0& eE#-,&b6#+&K *= 0*+(b6#+&Kd3> 1&$&Y.(+ *Y $&Q K=,% E+> *-K K=,% .$ (&='+ *Y K&0=&#+&K +.K& &YY&0(+ *= =&D&#( D=*0&K,=&+?> 1,P&=S+ Q.--.$%$&++ (* D#P

/KK.(.*$#- .(&'+ (8#( 0*,-K 6& 0*$+.K&=&K; )*+( *Y N&E.0& k Z*(#- ^qN 0*+( e.Y $*( 0*$+.K&=&K +,$2d /$P 0,+(*'&= #0V,.+.(.*$ 0*+( )*+( *Y *E&=8&#K #$K +#-&+ Y*=0&

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

?9

F. H8"+ 4, +8% i)',+ ?%C+3"$ L'4*+ja +8% I'4*+ "+ O8428 +8% 2',+ '( +8% *%O I3'DC2+ %ZC"$,

+8"+ '( +8% '$D I3'DC2+a 54N%* +8% ('$$'O4*5 D"+".

A*+D.(#- )*+( *Y #$ *D&=#(.*$ j c3944 D&= D#(.&$( W-K D=*K,0( 0*+( j c944M,$.( T,'6&= *Y ,$.(+ $&&K&K D&= *D&=#(.*$ j 3 R=&V,&$0P *Y =&D&#( D=*0&K,=& e,+.$% &].+(.$% D=*K,0(d j 94_ R=&V,&$0P *Y +&E&=& 0*'D-.0#(.*$ =&+,-(.$% .$ *D&$ 8&#=( +,=%&=P j ?4_

1, +8%3% "*J B'3% 4*('3B"+4'* +8"+ J'C O'C$D *%%D +' 2"$2C$"+% +84,Y

/; T&&K '*=& .$Y*='#(.*$;

\8#( .+ (8& 0*+( *Y *D&$ 8&#=( +,=%&=P *D&=#(.*$[ ?KFDMMM

\8#( .+ (8& Y=&V,&$0P *Y =&D&#( D=*0&K,=& ,+.$% N&E.0& k[ MN

\8#( .+ (8& Y=&V,&$0P *Y +&E&=& 0*'D-.0#(.*$ ,+.$% N&E.0& k[ FN

A*Q '#$P ,$.(+ *Y N&E.0& k Q.-- 6& $&0&++#=P D&= *D&=#(.*$[ L

Z* K&(&='.$& 8*Q ',08 .+ (8& $&Q K&E.0& .+ Q*=(8;

<(&' W-K T&QA*+D.(#- 0*+( c3944 c3944C=*K,0( 0*+( D&= *D&=#(.*$ c944n3jc:444 3nK ]:1%&%05 ?XFMM ?LFMMiLk^&D&#( D=*0&K,=&+ 94_nc?944jc:G94 ?M7&E&=& 0*'D-.0#(.*$ ?4_nc:9mjcB944 9_nc:9mjcG94-&%05 c@G94 c?394 l 3k

o#-,& *Y N&E.0& k j ec@G94 b c?394d M 3 j kQPTc _2',+ *%C+3"$ I'4*+`

F. H8"+ B458+ ("2+'3, B458+ "$$'O R%"3+2'3I +' I342% +8% *%O I3'DC2+ "#'N% 2',+ *%C+3"$

I'4*+`Y H8"+ *%%D, +' #% 2'*,4D%3%DY

/;

^.+2 M "#-D=#0(.0& <$+,=#$0& 0*+(+U

o#-,& *Y =&K,0(.*$ .$ D#.$ e(* D#(.&$(+dU

A.%8&= +,00&++ =#(.* eQ.(8*,( =&D&#( D=*0&K,=& #$KM*= +&E&=& 0*'D-.0#(.*$dU

)*+( +#E.$%+ *Y 2&&D.$% Y&Q&= N&E.0& kS+ .$ .$E&$(*=PU &(0>

Z8&+& #$K *(8&= Y#0(*=+ '.%8( #--*Q ,+ (* D=.0& N&E.0& k #6*E& (8& )*+( T&,(=#- C*.$(>

F. !8% 2'BI"*J 8", D%24D%D +8"+ 4+ O"*+, +' ,%$$ @%N42% K "+ " I3%B4CB "#'N% +8% 2',+

*%C+3"$ I'4*+[ #C+ " ,C3N%J '( I'+%*+4"$ 2C,+'B%3, _R',I4+"$ LC328",4*5 @%I"3+B%*+,`

,8'O%D +8"+ +8%J "3% '*$J O4$$4*5 +' I"J kPcccgC*4+^ ?'O O8"+ O'C$D J'C 3%2'BB%*DY

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

?5

/; <+ (8& c3444M,$.( Y.%,=& # +.$%-& K#(# D*.$( *= #$ #E&=#%&[ U2+'07+ 0/'&)) 90*6 /:)%&9+')

):'2+6+#W$& *Y (Q* (8.$%+;

:> "#$#%& A&#=(0*=DS+ &]D&0(#(.*$+ (8#( (8&P +8*,-K =&#--P &]D&0( +*'&(8.$% 0-*+& (*c3444M,$.(

3> <$0=&#+& D*(&$(.#- 0,+(*'&=+S fQ.--.$%$&++ (* D#Pg

F. R'O 2"* O% 4*23%",% iO4$$4*5*%,, +' I"JjY

/; ZQ* (8*,%8(+; )*'',$.0#(& (8& 6&$&Y.(+ e6*(8 f+*Y(g e&>%>U K&0=&#+&K D#.$ *= Y=&V,&$0P *Y =&b*D&=#(.*$d

#$K f8#=Kg eY.$#$0.#-dd (* (8& #KK.(.*$#- +(#2&8*-K&=+ e.>&>U D#(.&$( #KE*0#(& %=*,D+ #$K.$+,=#$0& D#P&=+d .$ (8& K&0.+.*$> \*=2 Q.(8 (8&' (* fD=&++,=&g (8& D*(&$(.#- 6,P&=+ *YN&E.0& k (* +D&$K (8& #KK.(.*$#- '*$&P (* =&#-.H& (8& #KK&K 6&$&Y.(+ *Y (8& $&Q8#=KQ#=&>

C,6-.+8 #=(.0-&+ #6*,( (8& &YY.0#0P *Y (8& $&Q K&E.0& .$ =&D,(#6-& X*,=$#-+ e&>%>U h/"/U

T&Q O$%-#$K h*,=$#- *Y "&K.0.$&U &(0>d #$K ,+& (8*+& (* 0*$E.$0& K*0(*=+ (* D=&++,=&8*+D.(#- #K'.$.+(=#(.*$ (* .$0=&#+& fQ.--.$%$&++ (* D#Pg Y*= N&E.0& k>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

?G

)",% --. )3%D4+g@%#4+ )"3D L3'2%,,'3

/9):;<=>?@


)97E !=L1)

C.&=0& C=*0&++.$% .+ # 0=&K.(MK&6.( 0#=K D=*0&++*=> <( D=*E.K&+ *,(+*,=0&K +&=E.0&+ (* 0=&K.(MK&6.(0#=K .++,&=+> Z8& .++,&= D#P+ # D&=0&$(#%& *Y (=#$+#0(.*$ Y&&+ (* C.&=0& Y*= D=*E.K.$% (8&Y*--*Q.$% +&=E.0&+;

0=&K.( #,(8*=.H#(.*$U

Y=#,K K&(&0(.*$U

#00*,$(.$% #$K =&D*=(.$%>

<++,&=+ *,(+*,=0& (8.+ Y,$0(.*$ (* 0*'D#$.&+ -.2& C.&=0& 6&0#,+& *Y (8& 8.%8 0*+( *Y '#.$(#.$.$%(8&.= *Q$ <Z +P+(&'+ (* D&=Y*=' (8.+ Y,$0(.*$> C.&=0& 8#+ 8.=&K ,+ (* Y.$K Q#P+ (* +,+(#.$ .(+K*,6-& K.%.( %=*Q(8 (8#( (8& 0*'D#$P 8#+ &$X*P&K Y*= (8& D#+( 34 P&#=+>

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;



)97E F>E7!1=?7

!"#$%&'$($%) E.0% )%+3) /&:5# =$+'/+ %0C+ %& C++3 0 .$7. 7'&8%. '0%+Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \8#( .+ C.&=0&S+ 0,==&$( '#=2&( D*+.(.*$ .$ (8& 0=&K.( 0#=K '#=2&([

!"#$%&'$($%) =$+'/+ /:''+*%56 )+'2+) %.+ KM &4 %.+ %&3 LM $)):+') &4 %.+ /&:*%'6; -.+ LM %&3

$)):+') /&93'$)+ lMN &4 %.+ /'+#$% /0'# 90'C+%; -.+ KM &4 %.+ %&3 LM %.0% 0'+ *&% =$+'/+()/:)%&9+') +$%.+' :)+ =$+'/+() /&93+%$%$&* &' 3+'4&'9 %.+ 4:*/%$&* $*P.&:)+;

1*+%3N4%O%%. A*Q Y#+( .+ (8& 0=&K.( 0#=K '#=2&( %=*Q.$%[

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+ *:91+' &4 /'+#$% /0'# %'0*)0/%$&*) $) 7'&8$*7 0% XN 0**:0556;

1*+%3N4%O%%. A*Q K*&+ C.&=0& D=.0& 0,==&$(-P .$ (8& 0=&K.( 0#=K '#=2&([

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

?I

!"#$%&'$($%) =$+'/+ +0'*) 0 3+'/+*%07+ &4 %.+ %'0*)0/%$&* 4++ &4 +0/. %'0*)0/%$&*;

1*+%3N4%O%%. <+ (8&=& #$P *(8&= =&E&$,& +(=&#'[

!"#$%&'$($%) ]&9+&*+ .0) ):77+)%+# %.0% =$+'/+ /&:5# 5$/+*)+ $%) )&4%80'+ 0) 0*&%.+' 1:)$*+))9&#+5D $* 0##$%$&* %& 1+$*7 %.+ &:%)&:'/+# 3'&/+))&'; \* %.$) /0)+D %.+ $)):+' 8&:5# 5$/+*)+ =$+'/+ )&4%80'+ 0*# 3'&/+)) %.+ %'0*)0/%$&*) $*P.&:)+; =$+'/+ 8&:5# 7+% 0* :34'&*% 5$/+*)+ 4++0*# &*7&$*7 90$*%+*0*/+ 4++; E.0% ).&:5# =$+'/+ /&*)$#+' $* +205:0%$*7 %.+ )&4%80'+ 5$/+*)+9&#+5Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. C*++.6-& #$+Q&=+;

N#$%&= *Y 0#$$.6#-.H#(.*$U

<'D#0( *Y $&Q =&E&$,& +*,=0&b ,DY=*$( 0#+8 #$K =&0,==.$% =&E&$,& +(=&#'

/KK&K 0*+( *Y '#.$(&$#$0& #$K +,DD*=( *Y (8.+ 6,+.$&++ '*K&->

!"#$%&'$($%) U)):9+ %.0% $4 =$+'/+ &44+'+# %.+ )&4%80'+ 5$/+*)+ 9&#+5D FMN &4 $%) +[$)%$*7/:)%&9+') 8$55 )8$%/. %& %.$) 9&#+5; FMN &4 %.+ '+90$*$*7 KM $)):+) %.0% 0'+ *&% /:''+*%56 =$+'/+ /:)%&9+' 8$55 )$7* 8$%. =$+'/+; -.+ '+2+*:+ &4 3'&2$#$*7 &:%)&:'/+# 3'&/+))$*7 $)?KYd6+0'; -.+ :34'&*% 4++ &4 5$/+*)+ 9&#+5 $) ?XY 0*# ?XMMA $* 0**:05 90$*%+*0*/+ 4++;R05/:50%+ %.+ $930/% &* '+2+*:+ 4&' %.+ *+[% F 6+0') $4 =$+'/+ &44+') %.$) *+8 5$/+*)$*7 9&#+5@$7*&'$*7 %$9+ 205:+ &4 9&*+6B;

1*+%3N4%O%%. ^&E&$,& .+ cG4" ,$K&= $&Q D-#$ Y*= (8& $&]( 9 P&#=+U 0*'D#=&K Q.(8 c94" .Y (8&+*Y(Q#=& -.0&$+& '*K&- .+ $*( #K*D(&K>

!"#$%&'$($%) e&&#; E.0% +5)+ 8&:5# 6&: 5$C+ %& C*&8 $* &'#+' %& '+0/. 0 '+/&99+*#0%$&*Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \8#( .+ C.&=0&S+ 0,==&$( '#=2&( D*+.(.*$ .$ (8& K&6.( 0#=K '#=2&([

!"#$%&'$($%) =$+'/+ .0) FN 90'C+% ).0'+;

1*+%3N4%O%%. \8* #=& C.&=0&S+ '#.$ 0*'D&(.(*=+ .$ (8& K&6.( 0#=K '#=2&([ A*Q ',08 '#=2&(+8#=& K* (8&P 8#E&[

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+ 90'C+% $) 2+'6 4'079+*%+#; c& 3506+' .0) 9&'+ %.0* KMN 90'C+% ).0'+; E.0%/0* =$+'/+ #& %& 70$* 9&'+ 90'C+% ).0'+ $* %.+ #+1$% /0'# )+79+*%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. C*++.6-& #$+Q&=+; #0V,.=& 0*'D&(.(*=+U +&( ,D # D#=($&=+8.D Q.(8 # 0*'D&(.(*=U ,+&.$$*E#(& '#=2&(.$% +08&'&+ e&>%> .$0&$(.E&+d

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+'+ $) 0*&%.+' )+79+*% &4 %.+ 90'C+%D )%&'+ 205:+ )+79+*%D 8.+'+ =$+'/+/:''+*%56 .0) *& &44+'$*7); -.$) $) %.+ 90'C+% &4 )%&'+P)3+/$4$/ 7$4% /0'#)D $;+; ]%0'1:/C) /0'# &'eU= 7$4% /0'#); -.$) 90'C+% $) 3'&G+/%+# %& 7'&8 0% FMN 0**:0556 &2+' %.+ *+[% KM 6+0'); E.0%0'+ )&9+ &4 %.+ $)):+) %& /&*)$#+' $* #+%+'9$*$*7 8.+%.+' =$+'/+ ).&:5# +*%+' %.$) 90'C+%Z

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

?@

1*+%3N4%O%%. )*+( *Y *YY&=.$% (8.+ $&Q +&=E.0& E+> D*(&$(.#- =&E&$,&U K.YY.0,-(P .$ +&((.$% ,D D#=($&=+8.D+ #$K C.&=0&S+ &]D&=.&$0& Q.(8 (8.+U 0*'D-&].(P *Y # =&E&$,&b+8#=.$% +08&'&Uf+(.02.$&++g *Y +(*=&b#-.%$&K 0#=K+ E+> =&%,-#= 0#=K+U D*(&$(.#- 0#$$.6#-.H#(.*$ *Y =&%,-#= 0#=K+

!"#$%&'$($%) ]:33&)+ 8+ C*&8 %.0% %.+ %&%05 90'C+% &4 )%&'+ 205:+ $) ?KV % -.+ %'0*)0/%$&* 4++ $) KN &4 %.+ %&%05 205:+; ='&/+))$*7 4$'9)D 5$C+ =$+'/+D 8&:5# +0'* 01&:% KMN &4 %.+%'0*)0/%$&* 4++); E.0% $) +[3+/%+# '+2+*:+ 4'&9 %.$) *+8 )+79+*% %.$) 6+0'Z

@c&%+ %& $*%+'2$+8+', ]++ $4 %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ 0)C) 4&' 0 90'C+% ).0'+ *:91+'; \4 0)C+#D =$+'/++[3+/%) XMN 90'C+% ).0'+;B

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7* C.&=0& Q*,-K &]D&0( =&E&$,& *Y c?44m ec:1 n :_ j c:4" (*(#- (=#$+#0(.*$Y&&+U k ?4_ '#=2&( +8#=& j c?" C.&=0&b=&-#(&K (=#$+#0(.*$ Y&&+U k :4_ j c?44m C.&=0& (#2& *Y(8& (=#$+#0(.*$ Y&&+d>

!"#$%&'$($%) ]:33&)+ $% /&)%) ?KY %& 1:$5# %.+ )6)%+9 '+b:$'+# %& 3'&/+)) )%&'+ /0'#); U)):9+FP6+0' :)+4:5 5$4+D 8.0%() =$+'/+() +[3+/%+# 3'&4$% @0//&:*%$*7 3'&4$%B $* %.+ 4$')% 6+0'Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. /$+Q&=; c?44m ` ec:"M9d j c:44m

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

B4

)",% -P. EC3'I%"* 6'+'32J2$%,

/9):;<=>?@

A43B. 1#.$

<'C*D. 3445 RZU R.$#- )'*+%*+. i,#-.(#(.E& #$K V,#$(.(#(.E&

)97E !=L1)

W,= 0-.&$( .+ # D=.E#(& &V,.(P Y.=' (8#( 8#+ X,+( D,=08#+&K # '*(*=0P0-& '#$,Y#0(,=&= 6#+&K .$J&='#$P (8#( '#2&+ +D*=(P 6.2&+> ),==&$(-P (8&P +,DD-P '*(*=0P0-&+ (* O,=*D& 6,( 8#E& $* D=&+&$0& .$ (8& L7> Z8&P #=& -**2.$% (* &]D#$K (8& 6,+.$&++ .$(* (8& L7 6,( #=& ,$+,=& *Y 8*Q(* K* (8.+> Z8&P #=& 0*$+.K&=.$% (Q* '*K&-+; *$& .+ +&--.$% (8=*,%8 &].+(.$% K&#-&=+8.D+ .$ (8&

L7U (8& *(8&= .+ 6,.-K.$% # Y-#%+8.D K&#-&=+8.D #$K +&--.$% (8#( Q#P>

W,= 0-.&$( Q#$(+ (* 0*$+.K&= # Y&Q .++,&+> R.=+(U .+ (8.+ &]D#$+.*$ # %**K .K&#[ 7&0*$KU Q8.08'*K&- Q*,-K 6& (8& 6&+( (* D,=+,&[

/+ # +(#=(.$% D*.$(U (&-- '& # -.((-& #6*,( (8& 8.%8 -&E&- D=*+ #$K 0*$+ *Y 6,.-K.$% # Y-#%+8.DK&#-&=+8.D E&=+,+ +&--.$% (8=*,%8 &].+(.$% 08#$$&-+>

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D 9II3'"28.

A.%8 -&E&-U P*,S=& %*.$% (* $&&K (* 8.( (8& $,'6&=+ =.%8( Q8&$ (8&PS=& D=&+&$(&K #$K 6& #6-& (*+(&D 6#02 #$K +P$(8&+.H& .$(* +*'& +*=( *Y '&#$.$%Y,- =&0*''&$K#(.*$> <$(&=E.&Q&= +8*,-K2&&D #+2.$% (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& (* +,''#=.H& #$K 6#02b,D #++,'D(.*$+>

<$(&=E.&Q&& +8*,-K 2&&D .$ '.$K (8#( (8.+ .+ # CO +8*D #$K Q#$(+ (* Y-.D (8& 0*'D#$P V,.02-P `(8.+ .+ # 0*''*$ (8&'& (8=*,%8 1#.$ 0#+&+>

:%J A"2+,.

_507).$3, g+%0$5 ='$/+, ?LMAR&)%, ?KMA

R&)% %& )+% :3 4507).$3, ?X 9$55$&*

"[$)%$*7 R.0**+5,?LFMA )%0'% :3 /&)% g+%0$5 ='$/+, ?LMA f$)%'$1:%&') '+b:$'+ XXN 7'&)) 90'7$*D %.+* %.+'+ 8$55 1+ 0 XN 055&80*/+ &4 %.+ )05+) 3'$/+ %.0%8$55 1+ '+)+'2+# 4&' '+%:'*D )+55$*7 /&)%)D +%/;

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

B:

EK96LME @19M=;>E

1*+%3N4%O%%; < Q*,-K (8.$2 (8#( *D&$.$% # Y-#%+8.D K&#-&=+8.D Q*,-K 8#E& # -*( *Y D=*+> R.=+(U .(Q*,-K D=*6#6-P #--*Q Y*= 8.%8&= '#=%.$+ #+ P*, Q*,-K *Q$ (8& K.+(=.6,(.*$> 7&0*$KU P*, 0*,-K(=#.$ (8& +#-&+ D&*D-& (* +&-- (8& =.%8( Q#PU D*+.(.*$ (8& D=*K,0( 0*==&0(-PU &(0> p*, Q*,-K #-+*(8&$ 0*$(=*- P*,= 0,+(*'&= K#(#U #6.-.(P (* 0*$(=*- '#=2&(.$% '&++#%&+ .$ (8& K&#-&=+8.DU &(0> W$(8& K*Q$+.K&U (8&=& .+ (8& 0#D.(#- .$E&+('&$(U (8& Y#0( (8#( &].+(.$% K&#-&=+8.D+ 8#E& =&-#(.*$+8.D+Q.(8 0,+(*'&=+ #-=&#KP .$ D-#0&U K.+(=.6,(.*$ 08#$$&-+ #-=&#KP .$ D-#0&U #$K -*0#- '#=2&(2$*Q-&K%&> p*,= 6=#$K $#'& .+ #-+* $*( Q&--b2$*Q$ .$ (8& 7(#(&+U +* *D&$.$% # Y-#%+8.DK&#-&=+8.D '.%8( 6& K.YY.0,-(>

!"#$%&'$($%) SAD %.0% 90C+) )+*)+; E.0% 8&:5# 6&: %.$*C 01&:% %.+ 3'&4$%01$5$%6Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. < Q*,-K #++,'& (8#( *Q$.$% P*,= *Q$ K&#-&=+8.D Q*,-K 6& '*=& D=*Y.(#6-& .$ (8&-*$% =,$U 6,( +8*=( (&=' .( '.%8( 6& 6&((&= (* %* Q.(8 (8& &].+(.$% 08#$$&-+ 6M0 *Y (8& 0#D.(#-

.$E&+('&$(> J.E&$ (8#( (8.+ .+ # CO Y.='U (8&P D=*6#6-P K*$S( Q#$( (* .$E&+( # (*$ *Y 0#D.(#- *=8*-K Y*= (** -*$%>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0% )&:*#) 7&&# I 5+% 9+ 7$2+ 6&: )&9+ *:91+') 0*# 5+%() )++ $4 %.+6 90%/. 6&:'.63&%.+)$),

_507).$3, g+%0$5 ='$/+, ?LMAR&)%, ?KMAR&)% %& )+% :3 4507).$3, ?X 9$55$&*

"[$)%$*7 R.0**+5,?LFMA )%0'% :3 /&)% g+%0$5 ='$/+, ?LMA f$)%'$1:%&') '+b:$'+ XXN 7'&)) 90'7$*D %.+* %.+'+ 8$55 1+ 0 XN 055&80*/+ &4 %.+ )05+) 3'$/+ %.0%8$55 1+ '+)+'2+# 4&' '+%:'*D )+55$*7 /&)%)D +%/;

!"#$%&'$($%) E.0%() %.+ 1'+0C+2+* $* 1&%. /0)+)Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8& 6=&#2&E&$ .$ (&='+ *Y # Y-#%+8.D +(*=& .+ ?44 6.2&+ ec?U444m M uc34mb:4mvd>R*= (8& K.+(=.6,(*= '*K&-U P*, #++,'& # ??_ %=*++ '#=%.$U +* ??_ *Y 34m .+ 5>5m> Z8#( '&#$+Q& +(.-- %&( :?>?m> \.(8 # ?_ #--*Q#$0&U (8#( '&#$+ Q& =*,%8-P (#2& .$ :?m Y*= &E&=P 6.2&>

Z8#(S+ ?m D=*Y.(> c394 M c? .+ #6*,( I? 6.2&+>

!"#$%&'$($%) g$7.%; E.0% #&+) %.0% %+55 6&:Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8#( *,= 6=&#2&E&$ .+ -*Q&= .$ (8& &].+(.$% K.+(=.6,(*= '*K&-> <( #-+* (&--+ '& (8#(.$ (&='+ *Y .$E&+(.$% .$ (8& -*$% (&=' (8& Y-#%+8.D Q*,-K 6& "L)A '*=& D=*Y.(#6-&>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

B3

!"#$%&'$($%) ]& .&8 /&*/+$2015+ 0'+ %.+)+ *:91+')Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. < Q*,-K (8.$2 +&--.$% I? 6.2&+ +8*,-K 6& Y#.=-P &#+P .$ # P&#=> ?44r .( #-+* +*,$K+=&#+*$#6-&>

!"#$%&'$($%)

@='+)+*%) /.0'% I /.0'% ).&8) 055 )&'%) &4 %.$*7) 1:% '+5+20*% $*4& $) %.0% KMMA 1$C+) 0'+ )&5# $*%.+ a] +2+'6 6+0'D 0*# $%() 1'&C+* #&8* X 806); _$')% 16 /&:*%'6 &4 &'$7$*D *+[% 16 3'$/+D %.$'#16 %63+; -:'*) &:% KFN &4 1$C+) 0'+ 4'&9 ":'&3+D XMN 0'+ .$7. +*# @LMA &' .$7.+'BD 0*#'&:7.56 KMN 0'+ )3&'%6;B

c&8 8.0% #& 6&: %.$*CZ

1*+%3N4%O%%. e(#2&+ (.'& (* (8.$2d /-=.%8(U +* $*Q < 2$*Q :44m 6.2&+ #=& +*-K> 7* :9m *Y(8&' 0*'& Y=*' O,=*D&U ?4_ *Y (8*+& *= B>9m #=& 8.%8 &$KU #$K :4_ *Y (8*+& #=& +D*=(P>Z8#(S+ B94 6.2&+> 7* '#P6& ?44 Q*,-K 6& # +(=&(08U #$K I? '.%8( &E&$ 6& (*,%8 .Y (8&=& #=&

+(=*$% 0*'D&(.(*=+>

!"#$%&'$($%) \ 8&:5# 0'7:+ %.0% %.+ /&:*%'6 &4 &'$7$* #&+)*(% 90%%+'; U )3&'%6 LMA 1$C+ $) 0 )3&'%6 LMA 1$C+D '$7.%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. <SK #0(,#--P K.+#%=&&> Z8.$2 #6*,( #,(*'*6.-&+ ` +*'& D&*D-& 6,P J&='#$ 0#=+ 6M0 (8&P Q#$( (* 6,P J&='#$ 0#=+U $*(8.$% &-+&> W= (8.$2 #6*,( 6&&=+> 7*'& D&*D-& *$-P -.2&

3

43

53

63

73

83

93

:3

;3

<3

433

+)-*$ =0>$ ?)-2-@

A ?

, B - C $

% ! ( # D

>%"?()@0A.'

B)@.'>%"?

CD0'1E

<0)F

CD0'1E

7;'0D.

G1+.'

433E

F@-.%

.(."#

433E

F@-.%

.(."#

433E

F@-.%

.(."#

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

B?

1&-%.#$ 6&&=+ Y*= $* =&#+*$ &]0&D( (8#( (8&.= 1&-%.#$ ` .(S+ #$ .'#%& (8.$%U =.%8([ eT*(&; Z8.+Q#+ $*( Q&-- =&0&.E&K 6P (8& .$(&=E.&Q&=>d

!"#$%&'$($%) SAD %.+'+() *& '$7.% &' 8'&*7 0*)8+'; U)):9+ %.0% \(9 '$7.% 0*# %.+ 90'C+% $)9:/. 1$77+'; c&8 8.0%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. WmU (8&$ .( +&&'+ Y&#+.6-&> 7* +8*=( (&=' (8& 6&((&= D-#P .+ (* ,+& K.+(=.6,(.*$0&$(&=+ (8#( #=& #-=&#KP .$ D-#0&U 6,( -*$% (&=' .( Q*,-K 6& (* 6,.-K # Y-#%+8.D>

!"#$%&'$($%) U*# #&+) %.+ 40/% %.0% $%() 0 =" /5$+*% .02+ 0*6 1+0'$*7 .+'+Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U (8&PS-- Q#$( (* (,=$ .( *E&= V,.02-P #$K $*( D*,= 0#+8 .$(* .(U +* (8&PSK -.2&-P%* Q.(8 &].+(.$% 08#$$&-+ #$K $*( 6,.-K> Z8&P #-+* '.%8( Q#$( (* &]#'.$& Q8P (8&PS=& (8.$2.$%#6*,( (8& L7 ` '#P6& (8&P 0#$ %=*Q .$ *(8&= D#=(+ *Y O,=*D& '*=& &YY.0.&$(-P #$K D=*Y.(#6-P>

!"#$%&'$($%) e'+0%;

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

BB

)",% -Q. 7+3%%+ 7O%%I%3,

/9):;<=>?@

A43B. 1)J<'C*D. 3445 RZU R.$#- )'*+%*+. "#.$-P V,#-.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

W,= 0-.&$( .+ # -#=%& .$K,+(=.#- 0*$%-*'&=#(& (8#( 8#+ c54bG4 '.--.*$ .$ #$$,#- =&E&$,&+ #$K .+&](=&'&-P D=*Y.(#6-&> Z8&P 8#E& &$%#%&K 1)J (* &]#'.$& *$& *Y (8&.= 6,+.$&++ ,$.(+ (8#( .+,$K&=D&=Y*='.$%> Z8& ,$.( '#$,Y#0(,=&+ #$K K.+(=.6,(&+ +(=&&( +Q&&D&=+ eH#'6*$.M-#Q$'*Q&=b-.2& '#08.$&+ (8#( # D&=+*$ Q*,-K =.K& #$K Q8.08 ,+&+ (Q* -#=%& =*(#(.$% 6=,+8&+ (* +Q&&D ,D (8&+(=&&( #+ .( '*E&+ 6Pd #$K 8#+ 6&&$ K*.$% +* Y*= 34 P&#=+> \8.-& $&E&= # +(#$K*,( K.E.+.*$U ,$(.-

=&0&$(-P .( 8#K #-Q#P+ 6&&$ D=*Y.(#6-&> Bb9 P&#=+ #%* (8& D=*Y.( '#=%.$+ +(#=(&K (* Y#-- #$K .( .+0,==&$(-P X,+( #6*E& 6=&#2&E&$>

"#$#%&'&$( *Y (8& 0*$%-*'&=#(& 8#K '#K& # K&0.+.*$ 3 P&#=+ #%* (8#( (8&P K.K $*( Q#$( (*.$E&+( .$ $&Q Y&#(,=&+ Y*= (8&.= D=*K,0( -.$&+ #$K 8#+ (8& #DD=*#08 (8#( (8&P K*$S( Q#$( (* .$E&+(+.%$.Y.0#$( #'*,$(+ *Y 0#D.(#- $*Q e,$-&++ (8&P 0#$ 6& 0*$E.$0&K *(8&=Q.+&d>

1)JS+ (#+2 .+ (* #$#-PH& (8& ,$.(S+ D&=Y*='#$0& #$K =&0*''&$K (* (8& '#$#%&'&$( *Y (8&0*$%-*'&=#(& Q8#( +8*,-K 6& K*$&> Z&-- '& +*'& *Y (8& #=&#+ P*,SK 0*$+.K&= -**2.$% .$(* 8&=&2$*Q.$% (8#( Q& *$-P 8#E& # Y&Q Q&&2+ (* Y.$.+8 (8.+ &$%#%&'&$(>

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

Z8& .$(&=E.&Q&= K.K $*( #--*Q (.'& Y*= K&E&-*D'&$( *Y # Y=#'&Q*=2 ` (8#( .+$S( (8& D*.$( *Y (8&0#+&> <$+(&#KU (8& .$(&=E.&Q&= +.'D-P +(#=(+ #+2.$% V,&+(.*$+ #$K (8&P +8*,-K 6& #$+Q&=&K #+(8*,%8(Y,--P #+ D*++.6-& *$ +8*=( $*(.0&> 1&.$% (8*,%8(Y,- 6,( =&'#.$.$% +(=,0(,=&K .+ E.(#- 8&=&;+(.02.$% (* D=*Y.(+ j =&E&$,& ` 0*+(+ #$K K=.--.$% K*Q$ *$ 0*+(+ #$K =&E&$,&+> Z8.+ .+ # %=&#( 0#+& 6M0 .Y P*, ,$K&=+(#$K 6#+.0 K=.E&=+b .(S+ 0*'D-&(&-P =#(.*$#->

EK96LME @19M=;>E

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8#(S+ # (.%8( (.'&-.$&U +* -&(S+ Y*0,+ *$ 6.% #=&#+> 7* D=*Y.( .+ =&E&$,&+ '.$,+

0*+(+> )#$ P*, (&-- '& #6*,( =&0&$( (=&$K+ Q.(8 =&%#=K (* 0*+(+[

!"#$%&'$($%) ]:'+; U b:$/C 5&&C 0% %.+ *:91+') ).&8+# /&)%) .02+ 1++* 40$'56 /&*)%0*% &2+' %.+ 30)% LM 6+0')D &*56 $*/'+0)$*7 8$%. $*450%$&*;

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7* <S' (8.$2.$% <S-- (8&$ '*E& .$(* =&E&$,&> A*Q 8#+ (8#( +(**K ,D[

!"#$%&'$($%) g+2+*:+ .0) 4055+* )%+0#$56 &2+' %.+ 30)% F 6+0'); E.6 9$7.% %.$) 1+ .033+*$*7Z

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

B9

1*+%3N4%O%%. <( '.%8( 6& 8#DD&$.$% 6&0#,+& *Y (=&$K+ .$ (8& '#=2&(U 08#$%&+ .$ 0,+(*'&= D=&Y&=&$0&+r

!"#$%&'$($%) ]$*/+ 6&: 9+*%$&* $%D 8.& 0'+ %.+ /:)%&9+')Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. < +,DD*+& (8&P Q*,-K 6& ',$.0.D#-.(.&+U %*E&=$'&$(+U &(0> < K*$S( +&& (8.+ #+ 6&.$% +*'&(8.$% Y*= .$K.E.K,#- ,+&>

!"#$%&'$($%) a):0556 *&%; -.0%() '$7.%D $%() 9&)%56 )%0%+ 0*# 5&/05 7&2+'*9+*%); ]& 8+ 5&&C+#$*%& %.+ /:)%&9+') 0*# %.+6 0'+ C++3$*7 8$%. 30)% %'+*#)D '+350/$*7 %.+$' )%'++% )8++3+') +2+'6 HP` 6+0')D 0*# %.+ *:91+' &4 9:*$/$305$%$+) 3:'/.0)$*7 )%'++% )8++3+') .0) '+90$*+# /&*)%0*%;E.0% +5)+ 9$7.% 1+ #'$2$*7 '+2+*:+) #&8*Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. C=.0&+ 0*,-K 6& 0*'.$% K*Q$r

!"#$%&'$($%) ='$/+) .02+ 0/%:0556 '+90$*+# /&*)%0*%;

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7* 8*Q #6*,( 0*'D&(.(.*$[ A#E& $&Q 0*'D&(.(*=+ &$(&=&K (8& '#=2&( *= +(*-&$'#=2&( +8#=&[

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+'+ .02+ 1++* *& *+8 /&93+%$%&'); -.+)+ 0'+ 8.0% )05+) .02+ 5&&C+# 5$C+ LM 6+0') 07& %& *&8; E.0% #& 6&: 80*% %& C*&8 04%+' 5&&C$*7 0% %.$)Z

3A

43A

53A

63A

73A

83A

93A

:3A

;3A<3A

433A

43 0)% "2( 8 0)% "2( =(D"0

1

B

1#-$@. GHI

1*+%3N4%O%%. <( -**2+ -.2& 1 8#+ (#2&$ +8#=& Y=*' ,+> <SK -.2& (* 2$*Q Q8#( 1 .+ K*.$%K.YY&=&$(-P> /$K Y*= (8#( '#((&= Q8#( ) .+ K*.$% K.YY&=&$(-P +* #+ (* 6& ,$#YY&0(&K>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

B5

!"#$%&'$($%) U1&:% F 6+0') 07&D V $*%'&#:/+# 0 *+8 %+/.*&5&76 %.0% :)+# 0$' 20/::9) %& /5+0* )%'++%) $*)%+0# &4 %.+ 9+/.0*$/05 /&55+/%$*7 9+%.&#) %.0% .0# 05806) 1++* :)+# $* %.+ 30)%;-.+)+ 0$' 90/.$*+) 0'+ 9&'+ +44+/%$2+ 0% 3$/C$*7 :3 )9055 #+1'$) 5$C+ )0*# 0*# )9055 5$%%+'D 0*#8&'C 9&'+ b:$/C56 0*# +44$/$+*%56 %.0* %.+ 9+/.0*$/05 &*+) 3'+2$&:)56 &44+'+#; ='$/+ 3&$*%) 0'+01&:% %.+ )09+; V )%$55 )+55) 9+/.0*$/05 90/.$*+)D 1:% %.+ #'&3 $* &:' 90'C+% ).0'+ 80) #$'+/%56'+50%+# %& %.+ *+8 0$' &44+'$*7;

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7* 8*Q #6*,( )[

!"#$%&'$($%) R 90C+) 90/.$*+) %.0% 0'+ 40' 9&'+ .+026P#:%6D $%() '+0556 0 #$44+'+*% %63+ &4&44+'$*7;

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7* Q& K*$S( 0*'D&(& Q.(8 ) .$ =&#-.(P[

!"#$%&'$($%) c&D 1:% 8+ /&:5#; f& 6&: %.$*C 8+(# 80*% %&Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. T*( -.2&-P Q.(8*,( 2$*Q.$% ',08 #6*,( (8& '#=2&(> Z8&P +&&' (* 8#E& 6&&$+(#6-& #$K 8#E& #$ &]D&=(.+&U +* ,$-&++ Q& 0#$ *YY&= +*'&(8.$% $&Q (* (8&.= 0,+(*'&=+ <SK %,&++(8&PS-- K&Y&$K (8&.= D*+.(.*$ .$ # $.08& '#=2&( #( #-- 0*+(+>

!"#$%&'$($%) e&&#D %.0%() %.+ /&*/5:)$&* 8+ b:$/C56 /09+ %& &* R; c&8D 8.0% &%.+'$*4&'90%$&* #& 6&: *++# %& '+/&99+*# )&9+%.$*7 4&' &:' /5$+*%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. < $&&K (* 2$*Q .Y Q& 0#$ =&D-.0#(& (8& #.= (&08$*-*%P>

!"#$%&'$($%) E+ /0*D 1:% $% 8$55 %0C+ L 6+0') 0*# /&)% ?LF 9$55$&*;

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7.$0& P*, +#.K '#$#%&'&$( K*&+ $*( Q#$( (* '#2& # +.%$.Y.0#$( .$E&+('&$(U (8#(+&&'+ ,$-.2&-P> 7* *(8&= (8#$ (8#(U Q8#( (=&$K+ K* Q& &]D&0( Y=*' (8.+ '#=2&( %*.$% Y*=Q#=K[

!"#$%&'$($%) E.0% 8&:5# 6&: %.$*CZ

1*+%3N4%O%%. eC#,+&d < %,&++ (8& &$0*,=#%.$% $&Q+ .+ (8#( Q&S=& +(.-- +&--.$% K&+D.(& (8& $&Q(&08$*-*%P #$K (8& +.'.-#= D=.0& D*.$(> 7* K* ',$.0.D#-.(.&+ $&&K 6*(8[

!"#$%&'$($%) e&&# &1)+'20%$&*; \* 40/% %.+6 #& *++# 1&%.; ]& 8+ 1'&C+ %.+ /&:*%'6 $*%& `'+7$&*)D 055 &4 8.$/. *++#+# %.+ )09+ 09&:*% &4 )%'++% )8++3+') &2+'055; \* %.+ *&'%.D &*02+'07+ %.+'+ 80) 0 LLdO '0%$& &4 9+/.0*$/05 %& 0$' )8++3+') *++#+#; \* %.+ )&:%.D $% 80) LLdKO

@%.+)+ *:91+') #& *&% $*/5:#+ R() 9&#+5)B; _&' %.+ /&:*%'6D 8.0% N &4 )%'++% )8++3+' )05+)8+'+ 7&$*7 %& 1+ %.0% 0'+ 9+/.0*$/05Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. ^*,%8-P 55_ e<(S+ #0(,#--P 5B_d>

!"#$%&'$($%) T+); ]& 8.6 8&:5# 9:*$/$305$%$+) *++# 9+/.0*$/05 )8++3+') $4 0$' &*+) 0'+ 9&'++44$/$+*%D 0*# 8.0% #&+) %.$) %+55 6&:Z

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

BG

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

!"#$%&'$($%) g$7.%D )& %.0%() +[0/%56 8.0% 8+ '+/&99+*#+#; S*/+ 8+ '+/&7*$^+# %.+)+ %'+*#)D8+ 05)& 5&&C+# 4&' 0 )%'0%+7$/ 1:6+'D 0*# $* 40/% %.+ /&*75&9+'0%+ )&5# %.+ :*$% %& 0 4&'+$7*/&930*6 %.0% 05'+0#6 .0# 0$' %+/.*&5&76 #+2+5&3+#; -.0% 80) &:%)$#+ %.+ )/&3+ &4 %.$) /0)+D%.&:7. I G:)% 0* $*%+'+)%$*7 4&55&8P:3;

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

BI

)",% -S. EJ% 7C35%3J

=GE<G1EH

A43B. 1)J <'C*D. 3445 RZU R.=+( )'*+%*+. "#=2&( +.H.$%U V,#-.(#(.E& #$K V,#$(.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

W,= 0-.&$( .+ # '#$,Y#0(,=&= *Y &V,.D'&$( Y*= &P& +,=%&=P> 7D&0.Y.0#--PU (8& '#08.$&+ '&#+,=&K&Y.0.&$0P .$ &P&+U #$K (8& 0*'D#$P #-+* D=*K,0&+ -#+&=+ Y*= D*+(b*D&=#(.*$#- D=*0&K,=&+ #$K#KX,+('&$(+> Z8&P K*$S( #0(,#--P '#2& (8& -#+&=+ *= K&E.0&+ ,+&K Y*= F#+.2 ` =#(8&=U (8&P #=&0*'D-&'&$(#=P D=*K,0(+ Y*= (8.+ D=*0&K,=&>

Z8& %-*6#- '#=2&( Y*= (8&+& K&E.0&+ .+ %=*Q.$%U 6,( #( # K&0-.$.$% =#(&> /+ # =&+,-(U (8& 0-.&$(Q#$(+ (* %&( .$(* # 8.%8&= %=*Q(8 #=&#U +* (8&P #=& -**2.$% #( #0V,.=.$% # 0*'D#$P (8#( '#2&+.$(&=b*0,-#= K&E.0&+> Z8&+& K&E.0&+ #=& ,+&K .$+(&#K *Y F#+.2 6,( Q.(8 +.'.-#= &YY&0(.E&$&++U #$K(8&P #=& ,+&K Y*= (Q* '#X*= 0#(&%*=.&+ *Y D#(.&$(+;

: ` D#(.&$(+ Q.(8 0#(#=#0(+3 ` =&Y=#0(.E& +,=%&=P e(* 0*==&0( $&#= *= Y#= +.%8(&K$&++d

A*Q Q*,-K P*, #DD=*#08 (8.+ *DD*=(,$.(P[ \8#( Q*,-K P*, -**2 #([

+,,'#'-"./ '"0-%1.#'-" 2%-&',$, ,3%'"4 53$6#'-"'"4

<$(&=E.&Q&& #+2&K #6*,( (8& +D&0.Y.0+ *Y Q8#( (8& '#08.$&+ Q&=& +* #+ (* 0*$+.K&= +P$&=%.&+ 6&(Q&&$ (8& (Q* 0*'D#$.&+ #$K D=*K,0( *YY&=.$%+> Z8&=& Q*,-K 6& +.%$.Y.0#$( +P$&=%.&+ #$K (8#(.+ # 0*'D*$&$( *Y #$+Q&=.$% (8& 0#+&>

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D 9II3'"28

J.E&$ (8#( Q&S=& -**2.$% #( # 0*'D#$P Q.(8 #$ &].+(.$% D=*K,0( -.$& (8#( .+ &]D-*=.$% '*E.$%.$(* # =&-#(&K D=*K,0( -.$&U Q& $&&K (* ,$K&=+(#$K #$P -.$2+ 6&(Q&&$ (8& (Q*> <( .+ E.(#- (8#( (8&.$(&=E.&Q&& K&'*$+(=#(&+ 8.+ #02$*Q-&K%&'&$( *Y (8& =.+2+ *Y 0#$$.6#-.H#(.*$ #$K (8& 6&$&Y.(+ *Y+P$&=%P 6&(Q&&$ (8& *-K #$K $&Q -.$&+> /-+* 2&P .+ (* +8*Q #$ ,$K&=+(#$K.$% *Y +*'& *Y (8&

6#+.0+ *Y "q/> A.%8 -&E&-U # Y=#'&Q*=2 -**2.$% .$(* .$(&=$#- Y#0(*=+ *Y 6*(8 (8& (#=%&( #$K#0V,.=&= e+,08 #+ 0,-(,=&U Y.$#$0&+U #$K (8& +P$&=%.&+ (8&=& '.%8( 6& 6&(Q&&$ (8& (Q*dU &](&=$#-Y#0(*=+ +,08 #+ '#=2&( (=&$K+ #$K 0*'D&(.(.*$U #$K 0,+(*'&= Y#0(*=+ e6*(8 K*0(*=+ #$K D#(.&$(+&%'&$(+d .+ $&0&++#=P> Z8& .$(&=E.&Q&& +8*,-K #-+* =&'&'6&= (8& +.%$.Y.0#$0& *Y (8& E#-,#(.*$*Y (8& (#=%&(b .+ .( Q*=(8 (8& #+2.$% D=.0&>

Z8.+ 0#+& .+ Y#.=-P +.'D-& .Y P*, 8.( (8& $,'6&=+ ` (#2& P*,= (.'& #$K %&( (8&' =.%8(> Z8& *E&=#--Y=#'&Q*=2 Q#+ E&=P 8&-DY,- #+ .$(&=E.&Q&& Q#+ #6-& (* =&Y&=&$0& .( ',-(.D-& (.'&+ K,=.$% # Y#.=-P

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

B@

Y*0,+&K 0#+& K.+0,++.*$> Z8& 2&P .+ .K&$(.YP.$% (8#( (8&=& Q.-- 6& K.YY&=&$( (PD&+ *Y 0,+(*'&=+ Y*=&#08 *YY&=.$%U +* +,%%&+(.$% <N.$% 0,+(*'&= +&%'&$(+ ,D Y=*$( +&&'&K (* 6& # '#X*= D-,+>

:%J A"2+,

L7 D*D,-#(.*$ .+ =*,%8-P ?44"! G9_ *Y (8& L7 D*D,-#(.*$ *E&= 59 8#+ 0#(#=#0(+

! L7 D*D,-#(.*$ .+ &E&$-P K.+(=.6,(&K *E&= I4 P&#=+U (8& +#'& $,'6&= *Y D&*D-& #=&&#08 #%&

! \8&$ +*'&*$& (,=$+ 59U (8&P 8#E& # G9_ 08#$0& *Y %&((.$% 0#(#=#0(+U #$K .Y (8&PK*$S( %&( .( .''&K.#(&-P (8&P Q.-- $&E&= %&( .(

! :M? *Y (8& D*D,-#(.*$ .+ $&#=b+.%8(&K #$K x *Y (8& D*D,-#(.*$ .+ Y#=b+.%8(&Kby:G9" D&*D-& $&&K E.+.*$ 0*==&0(.*$ *Y +*'& 2.$K

Z8&=& #=& %*E&=$'&$( 0#D+ *$ D=.0.$% Y*= 0#(#=#0(+ +,=%&=P #$K (8#( (8&=& .+ +,6+(#$(.#-0*'D&(.(.*$ Y=*' '#X*= $#(.*$#- D-#P&=+>

Z8& =&Y=#0(.E& '#=2&( .+ +(.-- E&=P Y=#%'&$(&K #$K %=*Q.$% =#D.K-P ` :>9" +,=%&=.&+MP&#=Q.-- %=*Q (* ?bB" #+ D=*0&K,=&+ 6&0*'& +#Y&=> /-+*U (8& D#(.&$( D#P+ :4] #+ ',08 Y*==&Y=#0(.E& +,=%&=P #+ # 0#(#=#0(+ D#(.&$( Q*,-K D#P>

EK96LME @19M=;>E

1*+%3N4%O%%. < Q*,-K -**2 .$(* .$(&=$#- Y#0(*=+ *Y 6*(8 (8& (#=%&( #$K #0V,.=&= e+,08 #+ 0,-(,=&UY.$#$0&+U #$K (8& +P$&=%.&+ (8&=& '.%8( 6& 6&(Q&&$ (8& (Q*dU &](&=$#- Y#0(*=+ +,08 #+ '#=2&((=&$K+ #$K 0*'D&(.(.*$U #$K 0,+(*'&= Y#0(*=+ e6*(8 K*0(*=+ #$K D#(.&$( +&%'&$(+d> ^&-#(&K (* #--*Y (8&+& Q*,-K 6& (8& E#-,#(.*$ D-#0&K *$ (8& 0*'D#$P> <Y Q& 0*,-KU <SK -.2& (* +(#=( Q.(8 K=.--.$%K*Q$ *$ (8& 0,+(*'&=+>

!"#$%&'$($%) SAD \ 5$C+ %.0%; ]& 5+%() %05C 01&:% %.+ /0%0'0/%) 30%$+*%); \4 \ 8+'+ %& %+55 6&: %.0%`FN &4 %.+ a] 3&3:50%$&* &2+' jF .0) /0%0'0/%)D .&8 90*6 3&%+*%$05 30%$+*%) 0'+ 8+ %05C$*701&:%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&-- < 2$*Q (8#( :3_ *Y (8& D*D,-#(.*$ .+ 59lU +* -&(S+ 0#-- (8#( :4_ Y*=+.'D-.0.(P> :4_ *Y ?44 '.--.*$ .+ ?4 '.--.*$> G9_ *Y (8#( .+ 33>9 '.--.*$> 1,( +*'& *Y (8*+& D&*D-& '.%8( #-=&#KP 8#E& 8#K +,=%&=P>

!"#$%&'$($%) e&&# 3&$*%; U*# $% 7+%) 0 5$%%5+ #$/+6 1+/0:)+ %.+ )+79+*% 8&:5# 1+ )C+8+#%&80'#) jF; ]& .+'+ $) 0 )$935$46$*7 0)):93%$&* I 0)):9+ %.+ a] 3&3:50%$&* $) +2+*56#$)%'$1:%+# &2+' OM 6+0')D %.+ )09+ *:91+' &4 3+&35+ 0'+ +0/. 07+; E.+* )&9+&*+ %:'*) jFD%.+6 .02+ 0 `FN /.0*/+ &4 7+%%$*7 /0%0'0/%)D 0*# $4 %.+6 #&*(% 7+% $% $99+#$0%+56 %.+6 8$55 *+2+' 7+% $%; E.0%() %.+ 90'C+% )$̂ + %.$*C$*7 %.$) 806Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. WmU +* Q& 8#E& ?44 '.--.*$ D&*D-& *E&= I4 P&#=+> Z8#(S+ ?>G9 '.--.*$ D&*D-& .$&#08 P&#= #%& 6,02&(> 7* .( Q*,-K 6& ?>G9 '.--.*$ D&*D-& (,=$.$% 59 &E&=P P&#=> <Y G9_ *Y (8&'%&( 0#(#=#0(+U (8#(S+r =*,%8-P 3>@ D&*D-& # P&#=> C-,+ +*'& D&=0&$(#%& *Y (8& D*D,-#(.*$ #-=&#KP*E&= 59U <S' (8.$2.$% =.%8( #=*,$K ? '.--.*$ D&*D-& # P&#=>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

94

!"#$%&'$($%) f&+) %.0% 90C+ )+*)+Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. < K*$S( 2$*Q # -*( #6*,( 0#(#=#0(+U 6,( .( +&&'+ (*> <S' $*( +,=& #-- *Y (8*+& D&*D-&0,==&$(-P %&( -#+&= &P& +,=%&=P 0,==&$(-PU (8*,%8>

!"#$%&'$($%) g$7.%; SAD *&8 5+%() %:'* &:' 0%%+*%$&* %& %.+ '+4'0/%$2+ ):'7+'6 90'C+%; ]& 6&:''+)+0'/. %+55) 6&: %.0% KdX &4 %.+ 3&3:50%$&* $) *+0'P)$7.%+# 0*# m &4 %.+ 3&3:50%$&* $) 40'P )$7.%+#; U)):9+ %.0% %.&)+ *:91+') 05'+0#6 $*/5:#+ %.&)+ 8.&(2+ .0# %.+$' 2$)$&* /&''+/%+#; Q&8 90*6 3+&35+ 0'+ 8+ %05C$*7 01&:% 4&' %.+ 3&%+*%$05 90'C+% )$^+Z

1*+%3N4%O%3. e\*=2+ *,( BM:3 l ?M:3 j GM:3t GM:3 n ?44 '.--.*$ D&*D-& (*(#- j :G9 u+8*=(0,(;:MB *Y :44 j 39U n G j :G9vd :G9 '.--.*$ D&*D-&>

!"#$%&'$($%) g$7.%; U*# $% %:'*) &:% %.0% $% %'0*)50%+) %& K;F 9$55$&* 3+&35+ 0 6+0' 0/%:0556 7+%%$*7 '+4'0/%$2+ ):'7+'6; ]& $4 8+ 0/b:$'+ %.$) /&930*6 0*# /0* 3&)$%$&* $% 0) 0 /0%0'0/%) 3'&2$#+' &' 0 '+4'0/%$2+ ):'7+'6 3'&2$#+'D 8.$/. ).&:5# 8+ 3&)$%$&* $% 0)Z @*&%+, %.+ 90/.$*+'6

8&:5# 1+ )5$7.%56 #$44+'+*%D +*&:7. )& %.0% $% 8&:5# 1+ 1+*+4$/$05 %& 7& 04%+' &*+ 90'C+% &' %.+&%.+'B;

1*+%3N4%O%%. WmU +* < 2$*Q (8#( (8& 0#(#=#0(+ '#=2&( .+ #=*,$K ? '.--.*$ # P&#= #$K (8&=&Y=#0(.E& '#=2&( .+ :>9 '.--.*$ # P&#=> 1,( < K*$S( 2$*Q #$P(8.$% #6*,( D=*Y.(#6.-.(P +* < 0#$S(=&#--P +#P> )#$ P*, (&-- '& # 6.( #6*,( (8& '#=2&(+[

!"#$%&'$($%) E.0% #& 6&: 80*% %& C*&8Z

@A+6 $*4&'90%$&*, -.+'+ 0'+ 7&2+'*9+*% /03) &* 3'$/$*7 4&' /0%0'0/%) ):'7+'6 0*# %.0% %.+'+ $) ):1)%0*%$05 /&93+%$%$&* 4'&9 90G&' *0%$&*05 3506+'); S* %.+ &%.+' .0*#D %.+ '+4'0/%$2+ 90'C+% $)

)%$55 2+'6 4'079+*%+# 0*# 7'&8$*7 '03$#56 I K;F 8$55 7'&8 %& XPH 0) 3'&/+#:'+) 1+/&9+ )04+'; U5)&D %.+ 30%$+*% 306) KM[ 0) 9:/. 4&' '+4'0/%$2+ ):'7+'6 0) 0 /0%0'0/%) 30%$+*% 8&:5# 306B;

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7* 6#+&K *$ Q8#( Q& X,+( K.+0,++&K <SK -.2& (* (#=%&( (8& =&Y=#0(.E& '#=2&(>

!"#$%&'$($%) \) %.+'+ 0*6%.$*7 +5)+ 6&: 8&:5# 80*% %& C*&8 1+4&'+ 90C$*7 0 #+/$)$&* %& 1:6 %.+/&930*6Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. <SK $&&K (* 2$*Q '*=& #6*,( (8& Y.$#$0.#-+ (* %.E& # 0-&#= #$+Q&=> <SK #-+* $&&K (* 6&((&= ,$K&=+(#$K (8& +P$&=%.&+ #$K 8*Q (8&PSK 6& D&=0&.E&K .$ (8& '#=2&(> A*Q&E&=U .( -**2+ D=*'.+.$% %.E&$ *,= &]#'.$#(.*$ *Y (8& '#=2&( +&%'&$(+>

!"#$%&'$($%) "[/+55+*%;

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

9:

)",% -T. 6%D4+%,+

=GE<G1EH

A43B. "0m.$+&P #$K )*'D#$P <'C*D. 3445 RZU R.=+( )'*+%*+. "#=2&( +.H.$%U V,#-.(#(.E& #$K V,#$(.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

W,= 0-.&$( .+ 0#--&K "&K.(&+( ` (8&P '#2& &V,.D'&$( Y*= 6-**K +#'D-& (&+( -#6+> 7D&0.Y.0#--PU(8&.= '#08.$&+ #=& ,+&K (* (&+( 6-**K +#'D-&+ Y*= (8&.= %-,0*+& -&E&-+U '&#$.$% (8&P #=& ,+&K (*'*$.(*= K.#6&(&+> Z8&.= '#08.$&+ #=& E&=P &]D&$+.E&U *Y(&$ 0*+(.$% '*=& (8#( c34mU #$K (8&P',+( 6& *D&=#(&K 6P D=*Y&++.*$#-+> Z8&P #-+* '#2& (8& 0*$+,'#6-&+ (8#( %* .$ (8&+& '#08.$&+>"&K.(&+( 8#+ # D=&+&$0& *$-P .$ O,=*D&>

Z8& '#=2&( Y*= (8&+& -#=%& '#08.$&+ .+ %=*Q.$% E&=P +-*Q-P #$K "&K.(&+( .+ -**2.$% Y*= '*=&%=*Q(8> Z8&P 8#E& K&+.%$&K D#(.&$(b*D&=#(&K '#08.$&+ (8#( 0#$ K* +.'D-& %-,0*+& -&E&- (&+(+>Z8&+& K&E.0&+ #=& +'#-- #$K D*=(#6-&U #=& &#+P (* *D&=#(&U #$K K* $*( $&&K ',08 .$ (8& Q#P *Y&](=# 0*$+,'#6-&+>

"&K.(&+( .+ 0*$+.K&=.$% -#,$08.$% (8.+ K&E.0&U 0#--&K %-,0*=&U .$ (8& Lm> Z8&P 8#E& =&(#.$&K"0m.$+&P (* &]#'.$& Q8#( 0*$+.K&=#(.*$+ (8&P +8*,-K 8#E& .$ (8.+ -#,$08>

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D 9II3'"28

Z8& Y.=+( +(&D .+ (* &+(#6-.+8 # Y=#'&Q*=2> <K&#--PU (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& Q*,-K (#2& .$(* #00*,$(.$(&=$#- #$K &](&=$#- Y#0(*=+U (8& 08#=#0(&=.+(.0+ *Y (8& 0,+(*'&=+U #$K Q8P Lm[

b <$(&=$#- 0*$+.K&=#(.*$+; 0#D#6.-.(.&+U 0#D.(#-U 0,-(,=&b O](&=$#- 0*$+.K&=#(.*$+; 0*'D&(.(.*$U =&%,-#(.*$U '#=2&( (=&$K+b ),+(*'&=+; '#=2&( +.H&U +&%'&$(#(.*$U D=&Y&=&$0&+U D#P'&$( #++.+(#$0&b \8P Lm[; Q8P $*( *(8&= D-#0&+U Q8P $*( *(8&= E#-,&b#KK&K +&=E.0&+ Y*= (8&.= 0*=&

D=*K,0([

W$0& P*, %&( (8=*,%8 (8& Y=#'&Q*=2 .$ # "0m.$+&P 0#+&U .(S+ '*=& *= -&++ -.+(&$ #$K =&+D*$K +*(=P (* (8.$2 #6*,( (8& .'D-.0#(.*$+ *Y Q8#( P*,S=& 6&.$% (*-K #$K #$#-PH.$%>

Z8.+ 0#+& =&D=&+&$(+ # '.] *Y $,'6&=+ #$K K&(#.- #$#-P+.+U (8&$ (8& $&&K (* +(&D 6#02 #$K0*$+.K&= Q8#( (8& $,'6&=+ #=& (&--.$% P*,> Z#2& # '*'&$( (* (8.$2 #6*,( (8& $,'6&=+ .$ 0*$(&](#$K .( +8*,-K 6& Y.$&>

:%J A"2+,

7.H& *Y (8& '#=2&( .+ :4Im D&*D-&MP&#=! C*D,-#(.*$ *Y (8& Lm .+ 54 '.--.*$>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

93

! 34_ *Y (8#( D*D,-#(.*$ .+ *E&= 59 P&#=+ *-K>! WY (8*+& *E&= 59 P&#=+ *-KU 9_ #=& 0,==&$(-P K.#6&(&+ +,YY&=&=+>! WY (8*+& ,$K&= 59U :_ *Y (8& D*D,-#(.*$ #=& 0,==&$(-P K.#6&(&+ +,YY&=&=+>! :4_ *Y (8& D*D,-#(.*$ 6,P+ %-,0*=& &E&=P P&#=

^&E&$,&+ Q.-- 6& 3>:5" D*,$K+MP&#= .$ B P&#=+! C=.0& D*.$( *$ (8&+& '#08.$&+ (*K#P .+ :34 D*,$K+>! Z8& '#=2&(.$% K&D#=('&$( D=*X&0( (8#( (8& D=.0& Q.-- Y#-- 6P 94_ .$ B P&#=+ e54

D*,$K+d! Z*(#- '#=2&( Q.-- %=*Q 6P ??_ .$ (&='+ *Y D&*D-& Q.(8 K.#6&(&+ e:BBmd! <$ Y*,= P&#=+ Q& Q.-- 8#E& #0V,.=&K # 39_ '#=2&( +8#=& e?5md

EK96LME @19M=;>E

1*+%3N4%O%%. < Q*,-K -**2 #( .$(&=$#- #$K &](&=$#- Y#0(*=+U (8& 08#=#0(&=.+(.0+ *Y (8& 0,+(*'&=+U#$K Q8P (8& Lm E+> &-+&Q8&=&

b <$(&=$#- 0*$+.K&=#(.*$+; 0#D#6.-.(.&+U 0#D.(#-U 0,-(,=&b O](&=$#- 0*$+.K&=#(.*$+; 0*'D&(.(.*$U =&%,-#(.*$U '#=2&( (=&$K+b ),+(*'&=+; '#=2&( +.H&U +&%'&$(#(.*$U D=&Y&=&$0&+U D#P'&$( #++.+(#$0&b \8P Lm[; Q8P $*( *(8&= D-#0&+U Q8P $*( *(8&= E#-,&b#KK&K +&=E.0&+ Y*= (8&.= 0*=&

D=*K,0([

<+ (8&=& #$PQ8&=& .$ +D&0.Y.0 P*,SK -.2& '& (* +(#=([

!"#$%&'$($%) W+%() )%0'% 8$%. %.+ /:)%&9+'); T&: )0$# 6&: 80*%+# %& %.$*C 01&:% %.+ 90'C+% )$^+ 4&' %.$) 3'&#:/%; Q&8 8&:5# 6&: #& %.0%Z E.0% 8&:5# 6&: *++# %& C*&8Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U <SK $&&K (* 2$*Q (8& D&=0&$(#%& *Y (8& D*D,-#(.*$ Q.(8 K.#6&(&+U (8& (*(#- D*D,-#(.*$U (8&$ (8& D&=0&$( (8#( 0*,-K #YY*=K (8.+ .(&'> <SK $&&K # D=.0& #+ Q&-- .Y P*, Q#$(&K(8& '#=2&( +.H& .$ D*,$K+>

!"#$%&'$($%) W+%() G:)% #& $% $* %+'9) &4 3+&35+ 0*# 0## $* %.+ 3&:*#) 50%+'; ]& %.+ 3&3:50%$&* &4%.+ aA $) jM 9$55$&*; LMN &4 %.0% 3&3:50%$&* $) &2+' jF 6+0') &5#; S4 %.&)+ &2+' jF 6+0') &5#DFN 0'+ /:''+*%56 #$01+%+) ):44+'+'); S4 %.&)+ :*#+' jFD KN &4 %.+ 3&3:50%$&* 0'+ /:''+*%56#$01+%+) ):44+'+');

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8=*,%8 'P 0#-0,-#(.*$ < %&( :>4I" D&*D-& e:M9 *Y 54" j :3"t 9_ n :3" j:34mn9 j 544m> :_ n BI" j BI4m> 544m l BI4m j :>4I"d

!"#$%&'$($%) g$7.%D *&8 8.0% +5)+ #& 6&: *++# %& C*&8Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. < $&&K (* 2$*Q 8*Q '#$P D&*D-& Q.-- 6,P (8.+ K&E.0&>

!"#$%&'$($%) ]& 0)):9+ %.0% KMN &4 %.+ 3&3:50%$&* 1:6) +2+'6 6+0'; Q&8 90*6 3+&35+ $) %.0%Z

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

9?

1*+%3N4%O%%. :4IU444

!"#$%&'$($%) f&+) %.0% )&:*# 5$C+ 0 5&% %& 6&:Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. T*( =&#--P> \&S=& (#-2.$% #6*,( # 0*'D#$P (8#( +&--+ '#08.$&+ Y*= *E&= 34m#D.&0&U +* Q.(8*,( 2$*Q.$% #$P(8.$% #6*,( (8& D=.0& *Y (8.+ $&Q D=*K,0( .( +&&'+ -.2& (8.+ .+ # D=&((P +'#-- (*(#- '#=2&( (* 6& %*.$% #Y(&=>

!"#$%&'$($%) U5'$7.%D 8+(55 /&9+ 10/C %& %.0%; U)):9+ %.+ 3'$/+ 3&$*% &* %.+)+ 90/.$*+) %&#06 $)KLM 3&:*#); -.+ 90'C+%$*7 #+30'%9+*% 3'&G+/% %.0% %.+ 3'$/+ 8$55 4055 16 FMN $* H 6+0'); U5)&$* H 6+0') %.+6 0)):9+ %.+ %&%05 90'C+% 8$55 7'&8 16 XXN $* %+'9) &4 3+&35+ 8$%. #$01+%+); \*0##$%$&*D $* 4&:' 6+0') 8+ 8$55 .02+ 0/b:$'+# 0 LFN 90'C+% ).0'+; E.0% 8$55 &:' '+2+*:+) 1+ $*H 6+0')Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8& D=.0& Q.-- Y#-- (* 54 D*,$K+ e4>9n54 D*,$K+dU #$K (8& $,'6&= *Y D,=08#+&+ .$ #%.E&$ P&#= Q.-- %=*Q (* :BBU444 e:4IU444M? j ?5U444d> W,= '#=2&( +8#=& .+ 39_U +* (8&=& Q.-- 6&

?5U444 D&*D-& 6,P.$% e:BBU444 M B j ?5U444d #( 54 D*,$K+ D&= D&=+*$> Z8#( 6=.$%+ '& (* #=&E&$,& $,'6&= *Y 3>:5 '.--.*$ D*,$K+>

!"#$%&'$($% , e&&#; c&8 .&8 #&+) %.0% *:91+' )&:*# %& 6&:Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. <( +(.-- +*,$K+ # -.((-& -*Q Y*= (8& (PD& *Y %=*Q(8 < 6&-.&E& (8.+ 0*'D#$P .+ -**2.$%Y*=>

!"#$%&'$($%) ]& 8.0% 0'+ )&9+ 5+2+') 6&: 9$7.% 3:55 %& $*/'+0)+ %.0% *:91+'Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8&=& #=& # $,'6&= *Y K=.E&=+> R.=+( (8&=& .+ (8& D*D,-#(.*$ +.H& ` P*, '.%8( Q#$(

(* .$0-,K& *(8&= 0*,$(=.&+ *= '#=2&(+ (* .$0=&#+& (8& *E&=#-- Y.&-K P*,S=& 0*'D&(.$% .$> R=*''#=2&( +8#=&U P*, 0*,-K (=P (* D*+.(.*$ P*,=+&-Y K.YY&=&$(-PU '#P6& #+ (8& '*=& 0*$E&$.&$( *D(.*$*= (8& '*+( (=,+(&K *$&> W= P*, 0*,-K (=P (* 2&&D D=.0&+ 8.%8> <SK (8.$2 (8& '*+( -*%.0#- Q*,-K 6& (* (=P (* 8.( '*=& D&*D-& *E&=#-->

!"#$%&'$($%) T&: 9+*%$&*+# 3'$/+; Q&8 8&:5# 6&: %.$*C 01&:% 3'$/$*7 %.$) 3'&#:/%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. < Q*,-K (8.$2 #6*,( (8& E#-,& #KK (* 0*$+,'&=+ .$ (&='+ *Y (8& 0*$E&$.&$0&*YY&=&K #$K '*$&P +#E&K> <Y (8.+ '&#$+ (8&P K*$S( 8#E& (* %* (* (8& D8P+.0.#$ (8&$ (8&P Q.-- 6&+#E.$% (.'& #$K '*$&P>

!"#$%&'$($%) f& /&*):9+') 05806) 306 4&' %.+$' %'$3) %& %.+ #&/%&'Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. T*> WY(&$ .$+,=#$0& Q*,-K D#PU +* (8&P '.%8( 6& Q.--.$% (* K* +*'& +*=( *Y # 0*b D#P Y*= K&E.0&+ -.2& (8.+> Z8& K&E.0&+ '.%8( #-+* D=*'D( D&*D-& (* 2&&D 6&((&= (#6+ *$ (8&.= 6-**Kb+,%#= -&E&-+ Q8.08 .$+,=#$0& 0*'D#$.&+ Q*,-K -.2& # -*(> /Y(&= #--U (8& '#X*= 0*+( (*.$+,=#$0& 0*'D#$.&+ .+ (8& 0#(#+(=*D8&U +* #$P(8.$% 0,((.$% K*Q$ (8*+& 08#$0&+ Q*,-K D=*6#6-P 6& # %**K .$E&+('&$(>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

9B

!"#$%&'$($%) g$7.%; ]& $4 6&: .0# %& ):990'$^+ 8.0% 8+(2+ 5&&C+# 0% )& 40'n

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&SE& -**2&K (8& 0,==&$( +.H& *Y (8& '#=2&( .$ (8& Lm Y*= 0*$+,'&= 6-**Kb+,%#='*$.(*=.$% K&E.0&+U #+ Q&-- #+ (8& %=*Q(8 D*(&$(.#- .$ Y*,= P&#=+> Z8&=& +&&' (* 6& -*(+ *Y 6&$&Y.(+ (* (8& 0,+(*'&=+ #$K (* .$+,=#$0& 0*'D#$.&+ '&#$.$% (8& D=*K,0( +8*,-K 6& #00&D(&K .Y&YY&0(.E&> A*Q&E&=U .( +&&'+ (8#( # -#,$08 X,+( .$ (8& Lm 8#+ -.'.(&K =&E&$,& D*(&$(.#->

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

99

)",% -U. 6"5"W4*% ;3'O+8

=GE<G1EH

A43B. "#=#2*$ /++*0.#(&+ <'C*D. 3445 RZU R.=+( )'*+%*+. 1=#.$+(*='.$%U V,#-.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

W,= 0-.&$( .+ # -#=%& '&K.# 0*$%-*'&=#(&U -&(S+ 0#-- .( Bb+(#= '&K.#> Bb+(#= Y,$0(.*$+ '*+(-P .$*$-.$& #$K D=.$( '&K.#U #$K Q.(8.$ (8*+& .$ ? '#X*= +&%'&$(+;

:d O$(8,+.#+( "&K.# ` +*'&(8.$% -.2& A*( ^*K "#%#H.$&U 7$*Q6*#=K&= \&&2-PU *= 7q"Y*= (8& &-K&=-P>

3d )*$+,'&= J,.K&+ ` "*(*= Z=&$KU )*$+,'&= ^&D*=(+U &(0>?d 1,+.$&++ T&Q+ ` R*=(,$&U \7h

\&S=& %*.$% (* 6& Y*0,+.$% '*+(-P *$ (8& 6,+.$&++ $&Q+ +&%'&$( (*K#P> <(S+ 0#--&K C=.'& <$0>#$K .+ 6=*2&$ K*Q$ .$(* D=.$( #$K *$-.$& '&K.# .(+&-Y> Z8&=& .+ # Q&6+.(& 6,( .( 6#+.0#--P X,+(=&D=*K,0&+ (8& $&Q+ (8#(S+ .$ (8& '#%#H.$&> Z8& 6,+.$&++ $&Q+ +&%'&$( 8#+ +&&$ K&0-.$.$%=&E&$,&+ *E&= (8& D#+( 9 P&#=+ #Y(&= K&0#K&+ *Y E&=P +(#6-& %=*Q(8> \&SE& 6&&$ 8.=&K (* 0*$+.K&=(Q* (8.$%+b Y.=+(U Q& $&&K (* K&(&='.$& Q8P =&E&$,&+ 8#E& 6&&$ K&0-.$.$% #$K +&0*$KU Q& $&&K(* =&0*''&$K +*'& #-(&=$#(.E&+ (* +(.',-#(& %=*Q(8>

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D "II3'"28A.%8 -&E&-U (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& +8*,-K +,%%&+( # Y=#'&Q*=2 -**2.$% .$(* .$(&=$#- Y#0(*=+ +,08 #+ #08#$%& .$ (8& D=.0& +(=,0(,=&+ *= # 08#$%& .$ (8& D=*K,0(U &](&=$#- Y#0(*=+ -.2& 0*'D&(.(.*$ *='#=2&( KP$#'.0+U #$K 0,+(*'&= Y#0(*=+ -.2& +&%'&$(#(.*$ *= D=&Y&=&$0&+> Z8& .$(&=E.&Q&&+8*,-K 6& %.E&$ (8& *DD*=(,$.(P (* 6=#.$+(*=' +*'& .K&#+ Y*= %=*Q(8U (8&$ Y*--*Q (8& -&#K *Y (8&.$(&=E.&Q&=>

Z8.+ 0#+& .+ +(=#.%8(Y*=Q#=K .Y P*, 0#$ (#-2 #6*,( (8& =&-#(.*$+8.D 6&(Q&&$ (8& &$K =&#K&= #$K (8&#KE&=(.+&=> <Y D=#0(.0.$% Q.(8 (8.+ 0#+&U (=P (* %&( (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& (* (8.$2 *,(+.K& (8& 6*] #+ (8&=&Q#+ # -*( *Y z.K&# %&$&=#(.*$S (8=*,%8 (8& 0*,=+& *Y (8& 0#+&> /$ ,$K&=+(#$K.$% *Y (8& D,6-.+8.$%.$K,+(=P .+ 8&-DY,- 6,( $*( $&0&++#=PU X,+( #+2 # -*( *Y V,&+(.*$+ .Y .(S+ $&Q (&==.(*=P>

:%J ("2+,

/+ (8& .$(&=E.&Q&=U P*, +8*,-K =&0*%$.H& (8#( '*+( *Y (8& =&E&$,&+ Y=*' (8& '#%#H.$& 6,+.$&++0*'& Y=*' #KE&=(.+.$% #+ *DD*+&K (* +,6+0=.D(.*$+> p*, #-+* Q.-- 2$*Q (8& =&+,-(+ *Y +*'& D=.*=0*$+,'&= =&+&#=08 +8*Q.$% (8#( (8&=& .+ -*Q 6=#$K #Q#=&$&++ Y=*' (#=%&( 0,+(*'&=+ Q8* K*$S(#-=&#KP +,6+0=.6& #$K Y*='&= M 0,==&$( =&#K&=+ K*$S( Y&&- (8& 0*$(&$( .+ #+ .$+.%8(Y,-> Z8& #E&=#%&=&#K&= .+ $*Q :4 P&#=+ *-K&= (8#$ (8&P Q&=& 9 P&#=+ #%*> WY (8& (*D 9 '#%#H.$&+ K*.$% 6,+.$&++

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

95

$&Q+U C=.'& <$0 8#+ (8& -*Q&+( +8#=& *Y (8#( K&'*%=#D8.0 #$K (8& 8.%8&+( D=.0& D&= #K D&= :444=&#K&=+>

EK96LME @19M=;>E

!"#$%&'$($%) E.0% 8&:5# 6&: 5&&C 0% $* %+'9) &4 0##'+))$*7 %.+ 4$')% $)):+ @'+2+*:+ #+/5$*+)BZ

1*+%3N4%O%%. < Q*,-K -.2& (* &]D-*=& .$(&=$#- Y#0(*=+ +,08 #+ # 08#$%& .$ (8& D=.0& +(=,0(,=&+ *= #08#$%& .$ (8& D=*K,0(U &](&=$#- Y#0(*=+ -.2& 0*'D&(.(.*$ *= '#=2&( KP$#'.0+U #$K 0,+(*'&=Y#0(*=+ -.2& +&%'&$(#(.*$ *= D=&Y&=&$0&+>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0% 90C+) )+*)+; ]& \ /0* %+55 6&: '$7.% 0806 %.0% %.+'+ 80) *& /.0*7+ $* 3'$/$*7 )%':/%:'+ &' %.+ 3'&#:/% $%)+54D )& %.0% %0C+) /0'+ &4 $*%+'*05 40/%&'); W+%() %05C 01&:% %.+/:)%&9+'); E.0% 8&:5# 6&: 80*% %& C*&8 01&:% %.+9Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. <SK -.2& (* 2$*Q Q8* (8&P #=&U Q8#( (8& (#=%&( .+U Q8#( (8&P (8.$2 *Y (8& D=*K,0(r

!"#$%&'$($%) E.$/. /:)%&9+') 0'+ 6&: %05C$*7 01&:%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. <S' (#-2.$% #6*,( (8& D&*D-& Q8* #0(,#--P 6,P (8& '#%#H.$&r 6,( (8*+& #=&$S((8& *$-P 0,+(*'&=+> Z8&=& #=& #-+* #K +#-&+ .$ #$P '&K.# 6,+.$&++ -.2& (8.+ *$&>

!"#$%&'$($%) g$7.%; U*# &44 %.+ %&3 &4 6&:' .+0#D 8.$/. 8&:5# 6&: )06 /&*%'$1:%+) 9&'+ %& %&%05'+2+*:+D ):1)/'$3%$&* '+2+*:+ &' 0# '+2+*:+Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z* 6& 8*$&+( <SK 8#E& (* +#P #KE&=(.+.$% =&E&$,& *$-P 6&0#,+& < 2$*Q (&-&E.+.*$=&-.&+ *$ .( +* 8&#E.-P>

!"#$%&'$($%) \* 40/% $% $) 0#2+'%$)$*7 '+2+*:+D 0*# $%() 01&:% 0 X,K '0%$&; ]& #&+) %.0% 9+0* 8+ ).&:5# 4&/:) 9&'+ .+02$56 &* 0#2+'%$)+') %.0* %.+ ):1)/'$1+')Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. <SK #0(,#--P (8.$2 (8& *DD*+.(&> <SK (8.$2 (8#( Q&SK Q#$( (* Y*0,+ *$ 6,.-K.$% #-*P#-U K&+.=#6-& +,6+0=.D(.*$ 6#+& (8#( #KE&=(.+&=+ Q#$(> "P %&$&=#- Y&&-.$% .+ (8#( .Y Q& 8#E& (8&K&'*%=#D8.0+ (8#( (8& #KE&=(.+&=+ Q#$( (* 8.(U (8&P Q.-- $*( *$-P 0*'& (* ,+U 6,( .( Y#0( '#P 6&Q.--.$% (* D#P # D=&'.,' .$ +*'& 0#+&+> < Q*,-K$S( +&& Y*0,+ *$ #KE&=(.+&=+ #+ 6&.$% #-- (8#(,+&Y,- .Y Q& 0#$S( K&-.E&= *$ D=*'.+&+ Q& '#2& (8&'>

!"#$%&'$($%) SAD )& 10/C %& %.+ /:)%&9+'); E+ 5&&C 0% %.+ *:91+') 0*# 4$*# %.0% ):1)/'$3%$&* $)

80*$*7; Q&8 8&:5# 6&: +[09$*+ 8.6 %.$) $) .033+*$*7Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. <SK (=P (* -**2 #( +P$K.0#(&K =&D*=(+ Y.=+( (* %&( # +&$+& *Y Q8&=& D&*D-& Q&=&(,=$.$% Y*= 6,+.$&++ $&Q+U 6,( < (8.$2 <SK Q#$( (* %* *,( #$K +D&#2 (* (8& (#=%&( 0,+(*'&=+U 6*(8+,6+0=.6&=+ #$K $*$b+,6+0=.6&=+>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

9G

!"#$%&'$($%) ]& 6&: 0'+ 015+ %& /&*#:/% 0 90'C+% '+)+0'/. )%:#6 0*# 6&: 4$*# %.0% %.&)+ 8.&*+2+' ):1)/'$1+# .02+ 2+'6 5&8 1'0*# 080'+*+))D 0*# %.&)+ 8.& .02+ 503)+# 0*# +2+* )&9+8.& )%$55 ):1)/'$1+ 4++5 %.0% %.+ 9070^$*+ $) *&% 0) $*)$7.%4:5 0) $% &*/+ 80); T&: 05)& 4$*# %.0%%.+ 02+'07+ '+0#+' $) *&8 KM 6+0') &5#+' %.0* %.+6 8+'+ F 6+0') 07&; E.0% 0'+ 6&:' %.&:7.%)Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z*,08.$% *$ (8& K.YY&=&$( (8.$%+ P*, (*-K '&U <S' -&++ 0*$0&=$&K #6*,( (8& -*Q 6=#$K #Q#=&$&++ 6&0#,+& .Y Q& 8#E& # K.YY&=&$(.#(&KU V,#-.(P D=*K,0( Q& 0#$ #KE&=(.+& .( #$K D*+.(.*$ .( 6&((&= .$ (8& Y,(,=&> <S' '*=& 0*$0&=$&K (8#( D&*D-& Y&&- (8& '#%#H.$& .+ $*( #+.$+.%8(Y,-> p*, +#.K (8& D=*K,0( 8#+$S( =&#--P 08#$%&KU +* K*&+ (8.+ 8#E& (* K* Q.(8 0*'D&(.(.*$[

!"#$%&'$($%) E.0% #& 6&: %.$*CZ

1*+%3N4%O%%. <SK (8.$2 +*U '#P6& &E&$ (* K* Q.(8 (8& #E#.-#6.-.(P *Y $&Q+ *$ (8& .$(&=$&(> 7*'#P6& +.'D-P =&D*=(.$% (8& $&Q+ K*&+$S( %&( .( K*$& #$P'*=&> /$K (8#( 0*,-K #-+* &]D-#.$ +*'&*Y (8& 08#$%& .$ =&#K&= K&'*%=#D8.0+ ` P*,$%&= D&*D-& =&#-.H& (8&P 0#$ X,+( %* (* (8& .$(&=$&( Y*= 6#+.0 $&Q+U #$K (8&P %&( (8#( .$+(#$(-P>

!"#$%&'$($%) ]& %.0% 80) 0 C+6 $)):+; E.0% 9$7.% ='$9+ \*/; #& 01&:% $%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. "#P6& 08#$%& (8& 0*$(&$( # 6.(U K* '*=& 8,'#$ .$(&=&+( +(*=.&+ (8#( +2&QP*,$%&=> < %,&++ .( K&D&$K+ *$ Q8#( #KE&=(.+&=+ (8&P Q#$( #$K 8*Q Y#= (8&P 0#$ %* Q.(8*,(#$%&=.$% (8&.= &].+(.$% =&#K&=+> "#P6& K* +(*=.&+ #6*,( 8*Q &]&0+ Q&=& ,+.$% (&08$*-*%P (*+*-E& D=*6-&'+ .$ (8&.= *=%#$.H#(.*$+>

!"#$%&'$($%) ]& 8.& $) %.+ #+9&7'03.$/ .+'+Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. R*= # 6,+.$&++ $&Q+D#D&=U <SK +#P ?9b59U '*+(-P '#-& 6,( $*( &$(.=&-PU #$K 8.%8

.$0*'& 6=#02&(>

!"#$%&'$($%) g$7.%D 0*# 8.& 8&:5# 80*% %& 90'C+% %& %.&)+ 3+&35+

1*+%3N4%O%%. 1,+.$&++ +&=E.0&+U -&.+,=&U #DD#=&-U &(0>

!"#$%&'$($%) ]& 5+% 9+ 7$2+ 6&: L 3$+/+) &4 $*4&'90%$&*; S4 %.+ %&3 F 9070^$*+) #&$*7 1:)$*+))*+8)D ='$9+ \*/ .0) %.+ 5&8+)% ).0'+ &4 %.0% #+9&7'03.$/ 0*# %.+ .$7.+)% 3'$/+ 3+' 0# 3+' KMMM'+0#+'); E.0% #&+) %.0% %+55 6&:Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8&PS=& *E&=08#=%.$% ` .Y (8&PS=& $*( 8.((.$% (8& (#=%&( K&'*%=#D8.0 e&E&$ .Y

(8&PS=& 8.((.$% *(8&= *$&+d Q8P Q*,-K #$ #KE&=(.+&= D#P (8& '*+( '*$&P (* #KE&=(.+& Q.(8 (8&'[

!"#$%&'$($%) ]& 8.0% #& 6&: '+/&99+*#Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. F*Q&=.$% #K D=.0&+ (* 6& 0*'D&(.(.E&>

!"#$%&'$($%) f& 8+ 80*% %& 5&8+' %.+9 0/'&)) %.+ 1&0'#Z E.0% ).&:5# 8+ 1+ 080'+ &4Z

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

9I

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&-- $*( #-- #KE&=(.+&=+ #=& (8& +#'&> 7*'& K* '*=& E*-,'& #$K D&=8#D+ K.YY&=&$(.$K,+(=.&+ 8#E& K.YY&=&$( D=.0& &-#+(.0.(.&+> \& +8*,-K %.E& *,= E*-,'& #KE&=(.+&=+ 6.%%&=K.+0*,$(+ +* Q& K*$S( -*+& (8&' ,$-&++ (8&P #=& $*( +&$+.(.E& (* D=.0& ` Q& 0#$ D=*6#6-P -**28.+(*=.0#--P #+ Q&-- #+ 0,==&$(-P (* +&& (=&$K+>

!"#$%&'$($%) e'+0%; U*# .&8 01&:% 05%+'*0%$2+ )%'0%+7$+) %& 7'&8 %.+ 1:)$*+)) %& %.&)+ 8.&.02+*(% .+0'# &4 $%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. <SK (8.$2 P*, 0#$ ,+& (8& Q&6+.(&U (=P (* -&E&=#%& *(8&= '&K.# Q.(8.$ (8&*=%#$.H#(.*$U K&E&-*D D=*D=.&(#=P 0*$(&$(U *= -#,$08 # -#=%& #K 0#'D#.%$

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

9@

)",% -V. )L; )'BI"*J

=GE<G1EHA43B. 1)J

<'C*D. 3445 RZU R.$#- )'*+%*+. i,#-.(#(.E& #$K V,#$(.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

/ -#=%& Y**K #$K 6&E&=#%& 0*$+,'&= D#02#%&K %**K+ 0*'D#$P e)CJd .+ (8& 0-.&$(> Z8&P 8#E& #B4_ '#=2&( +8#=& .$ (=#K.(.*$#- )CJ 08#$$&-+U -.2& -#=%& Y*='#( %=*0&=P> Z8&P 8#E& # :G_'#=2&( +8#=& .$ Y**K +&=E.0&> Z8&P 8.=&K ,+ (* 8&-D (8&' %=*Q (8#( Y**K +&=E.0& 6,+.$&++> A*QQ*,-K P*, +(=,0(,=& (8#([

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D 9II3'"28

Z8.+ .+ =&#--P # ? )+ 0#+&> <Y P*, ,+& (8& ? )S+U K&E&-*D V,&+(.*$+ #=*,$K (8&' (8#( #=& =&-&E#$((* (8& +D&0.Y.0 V,&+(.*$U #$K D=*6& (8& .$(&=E.&Q&= Y*= $&QU =&-&E#$( .$Y*='#(.*$U (8&$ P*, 0#$0=#02 .(> Z8.+ .+ $*( # $,'6&=+ 0#+&> 7*'& 2$*Q-&K%& *Y '#=2&(.$% #$K 0*$+,'&= D#02#%&K%**K+ Q*,-K 6& 8&-DY,-> F#(&= .$ (8& 0#+&U ,+.$% (8& B C+ (* 8&-D (8.$2 (8=*,%8 (8& V,&+(.*$+#6*,( 8*Q +D&0.Y.0#--P (* %=*Q '#=2&( +8#=& Q*,-K 6& 8&-DY,- .$ %&$&=#(.$% .K&#+>

:%J A"2+,

Z8&=&S+ # -*( *Y #KK.(.*$#- .$Y*='#(.*$ .$ (8.+ 0#+&> Z8& .$(&=E.&Q&& +8*,-K D=*6& Y*= (8.+

.$Y*='#(.*$ 6&0#,+& .(S+ &++&$(.#- Y*= +*-E.$% (8& 0#+&>

b Z8& 0-.&$( 8#+ *$& '#X*= 0*'D&(.(*= .$ 6&E&=#%&U 6,( $* '#X*= 0*'D&(.(*= .$ (8&.= Y**K+ D*=(Y*-.*> Z8& 6&E&=#%& D*=(Y*-.* 0*$+.+(+ *Y +*K#+U Q#(&=+U X,.0&+U (&#+U 8&#-(8 K=.$2+U#$K $&Q +D&0.#-(P 6*((-&K K=.$2+s$* #-0*8*-.0 6&E&=#%&+> Z8& Y**K D*=(Y*-.* 0*$+.+(+ D=.'#=.-P *Y +$#02 Y**K+sY*= (8=*,%8*,( (8& K#P e.&U 6=&#2Y#+(U -,$08U #$K -#(&=d> Z8&0-.&$(S+ '#.$ 0*'D&(.(*= .+ # '#X*= 6&E&=#%& 0*'D#$Ps6,( (8&P K*$S( 8#E& #$P +*=( *YY**K D*=(Y*-.*>

b Z8& 0-.&$(S+ +8#=& .+ :G_ #0=*++ (8& Y**K +&=E.0& '#=2&(> 1,( Q.(8.$ (8.+ '#=2&(U (8&'#=2&( +8#=& Y*= (8& 0-.&$( E#=.&+ .$ (8& K.YY&=&$( +&%'&$(+ #$K +,6+&%'&$(+> Z8&=& #=&

(8=&& D=.'#=P +&%'&$(+ .$ (8& Y**K +&=E.0& '#=2&(; :d 0#Y&(&=.#M Q*=2D-#0& Y**K +&=E.0&U3d =&+(#,=#$(+ eQ8.08 .+ 0*'D=.+&K *Y Y#+( Y**KU +-*Q Y#+( Y**KM #-(&=$#(.E& Y#+( Y**KU #$K*(8&=dU ?d &$(&=(#.$'&$(M (8&'& D#=2 E&$,&+U #$K Bd '.+0> /'*$%+( (8&+& +&%'&$(+U=&+(#,=#$(+ .+ K&Y.$.(&-P (8& -#=%&+(sG4_ *Y (8& '#=2&(>

b \.(8.$ =&+(#,=#$(+U (8&=& #=& # Y&Q +,6+&%'&$(+; :d Y#+( Y**K e\&$KPS+U 1mU"0N*$#-KS+dU 3d +-*Q Y#+( Y**KM #-(&=$#(.E& Y#+( Y**K e)8.D*(-&U /, 1*$ C#.$U )*+.U)#-.Y*=$.# C.HH# m.(08&$ O]D=&++U \*-Y%#$% C,02S+dU #$K ?d ".+0> e0*=$&= K&-.U '*' #$K

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

54

D*DU &(0>d> Z8& Y#+( Y**K +&%'&$( .+ K*'.$#(&K 6P *,= '#X*= 0*'D&(.(*=U Q8* 8#+ # G4_'#=2&( +8#=& .$ (8& +&%'&$(> 7-*Q Y#+( Y**KM #-(&=$#(.E& Y#+( Y**K .+ # +'#--&= +&%'&$(U 6,( .( .+ %=*Q.$% #( ?4_ # P&#=U #+ # D#=( *Y # (=&$K *Y &#(.$% 8&#-(8.&=>

EK96LME @19M=;>E

1*+%3N4%O%%. <SK -.2& (* '#2& +,=& (8#( < ,$K&=+(#$K (8& 0#+&> 7*U *,= 0-.&$( .+ # (=#K.(.*$#-)CJU Q.(8 # 6&E&=#%& #$K Y**K+ D*=(Y*-.*> )#$ P*, (&-- '& # 6.( '*=& #6*,( (8#( D*=(Y*-.*[ <S'#++,'.$% (8#( (8&P 8#E& +*K#+ #$K X,.0&+[ N* (8&P 8#E& *(8&= (PD&+ *Y K=.$2+[

!"#$%&'$($%) ]:'+; -.+ 1+2+'07+ 3&'%4&5$& /&*)$)%) &4 )&#0)D 80%+')D G:$/+)D %+0)D .+05%. #'$*C)D0*# *+8 )3+/$05%6 1&%%5+# #'$*C)h*& 05/&.&5$/ 1+2+'07+);

1*+%3N4%O%%. \8#( #6*,( (8&.= Y**K D*=(Y*-.*[ \8#( .+ (8#( 0*'D=.+&K *Y[

!"#$%&'$($%) -.+ 4&&# 3&'%4&5$& /&*)$)%) 3'$90'$56 &4 )*0/C 4&&#)h4&' %.'&:7.&:% %.+ #06 @$+D1'+0C40)%D 5:*/.D 0*# 50%+'B; -.0%() &*+ %.$*7 %.0% 90C+) :) #$)%$*/%$2+ 4'&9 &:' 90$*/&93+%$%&'h8+ .02+ 1&%. 0 4&&# 0*# 1+2+'07+ 3&'%4&5$&; S:' 90$* /&93+%$%&' &*56 .0)1+2+'07+);

1*+%3N4%O%%. <$(&=&+(.$%> 7*U (8&P 8#E& # D=&((P 0*'D=&8&$+.E& D*=(Y*-.*> )#$ < 8#E& # '.$,(&(* +(=,0(,=& 'P (8*,%8(+[

!"#$%&'$($%) ]:'+; -0C+ 6&:' %$9+;

@c&8 %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ ).&:5# %0C+ 0 4+8 9$*:%+) %& )%':/%:'+ %.+ /0)+; -.$) 8$55 '+b:$'+ 9&'+

%.0* G:)% 506$*7 &:% 0 4'09+8&'C 1:% 05)& $#+*%$46$*7 C+6 b:+)%$&*) %.0% 8$55 .+53 %.+9 #'$2+ %& 0*0*)8+';B

1*+%3N4%O%%. < Q*,-K -.2& (* 2$*Q #6*,( (8=&& '#.$ (8.$%+; :d 0,+(*'&=+U 3d *,= 0*'D#$P #$K0#D#6.-.(.&+U #$K ?d (8& 0*'D&(.(.*$ #$K 8*Q Q& 0#$ K.YY&=&$(.#(& 6&(Q&&$ (8&'> <$ (8*+& (8=&&'#.$ 0#(&%*=.&+ *Y .$Y*='#(.*$U (8&=& #=& # Y&Q 2&P V,&+(.*$+ (8#( <SK -.2& (* #$+Q&=> Z8.+ .+ 8*Q< '.%8( +(=,0(,=& .(;

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

5:

:;/105.'/

:05D()E

:05D.1910'/

HI+0 ('. 1+. D01.)19(4 *;/105.'/ 9) 1+. J00@ /.'A9*.5('6.1K

:(J.1.'9(L I0'6D4(*. J00@ /.'A9*.

M./1(;'()1/NJ(/1 J00@O /40= J(/1 J00@O 01+.'K

7)1.'1(9)5.)1 A.);./N50A9. 1+.(1.'/O 1+.5. D('6/

G1+.'K

HI+(1P/ 9) 0;' D0'1J0490K

Q00@ D0'1J0490

&.A.'(-. D0'1J0490

HR0 =. +(A. ()E *(D(S94919./ 1+(1 ('. /D.*9J9* 10 ;/K

HI+0 ('. 0;' *05D.1910'/K

HI+(1 @0 =. +(A. 1+(1 @9JJ.'.)19(1./ ;/ J'05 0;'*05D.19190)K

HI+.'. ('. 0;' *05D.1910'/ /1'0)-K I+.'. ('. =./1'0)-.' 1+() 1+.5K T,61U /+('./KV

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0%() 7&&#; E.0% 8&:5# 6&: 5$C+ %& )%0'% 8$%. 4$')%Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U Q& #-=&#KP (#-2&K #6*,( *,= 0*'D#$P #$K D*=(Y*-.* # 6.(t .+ (8&=& #$P(8.$%&-+& (8#( < +8*,-K 2$*Q #6*,( *,= 0*'D#$P> F.2&U K* Q& 8#E& #$P 0#D#6.-.(.&+ (8#( *,=0*'D&(.(.*$ K*&+$S( 8#E&[

!"#$%&'$($%) c&% '+0556;

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U <SK -.2& (* 2$*Q # -.((-& '*=& #6*,( 0,+(*'&=+ .$ (8& '#=2&(> < K*$S( 2$*Q',08 #6*,( (8& Y**K +&=E.0& '#=2&(U 6,( < .'#%.$& (8#( (8&=&S+ # -*( (8#( Y#--+ .$(* (8& %=*,D *Y0,+(*'&=+>

!"#$%&'$($%) T&:('+ '$7.%; T&:(2+ 5$)%+# 0 4+8; E.6 #&*(% 8+ #$)/:)) %.&)+;

1*+%3N4%O%%; 7,=&> < .'#%.$& (8#( Y**K +&=E.0& .$0-,K&+ (8.$%+ -.2& 0#Y&(&=.#+U 6*(8 #( +08**-+#$K ,$.E&=+.(.&+> /$KU < 2$*Q (8#( (8& 0*'D#$P (8#( < Q*=2&K #( 6&Y*=& +08**- 8#K # 0#Y&(&=.#s '#P6& (8#( #+ Q&--[

!"#$%&'$($%) T+3; E.0% +5)+ #& 6&: .02+Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U (8&$U (8&=&S+ '*E.& (8&#(&=+ #$K (8&'& D#=2+s'#P6& D-#0&+ -.2& 6*Q-.$%#--&P+[

!"#$%&'$($%) ]:'+; E.0% +5)+Z

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

53

1*+%3N4%O%%. p&+U (8&=&S+ #-+* =&+(#,=#$(+> /$K (8&$U (8&=& '.%8( 6& 0,+(*'&=+ (8#( <S'Y*=%&((.$%> <+ (8&=& #$P(8.$% &-+&[

!"#$%&'$($%) ]:'+D %.+'+() 3'&10156 )&9+ )&'% &4 9$)/+550*+&:) 7'&:3h1:% 6&:(2+ /&2+'+# %.+90$* &*+); ]&D &4 %.&)+ 90$* %.'++D 8.0% #& 6&: %.$*C %.+ )$^+) &4 %.+ )+79+*%) 0'+Z

@-.+ \*%+'2$+8+' $) %+)%$*7 %.+ $*%+'2$+8++() 1:)$*+)) G:#79+*%d /&99&* )+*)+ $* 0)C$*7 4&' %.+$*%+'2$+8++() )+*)+ &4 %.+ )$^+) &4 %.+ )+79+*%);B

1*+%3N4%O%%. < (8.$2 (8#( '.+0&--#$&*,+ .+ D=&((P +'#--> /$K (8&$U (8& &$(&=(#.$'&$( *$& .+ #-+* D=&((P +'#-- #$K +(#6-&> 1,( (8& 0#Y&(&=.#M Q*=2D-#0& *$&U < .'#%.$& (8#( (8#(S+ # -.((-& 6.%%&=s #$K '#P6& .(S+ %=*Q.$%> /$K (8&$U (8& =&+(#,=#$( *$&U < 6&( (8#(S+ (8& -#=%&+(> Z8*,%8U <S' $*(+,=& 8*Q Y#+( .(S+ %=*Q.$%>

!"#$%&'$($%) T&:('+ 10)$/0556 '$7.%; -.+ '+)%0:'0*% )+79+*% $) #+4$*$%+56 %.+ 50'7+)%h$%() 01&:%`MN &4 %.+ 4&&# )+'2$/+ 90'C+%;

1*+%3N4%O%%. <Y < (8.$2 6#02 (* (8& *=.%.$#- V,&+(.*$ *Y 8&-D.$% (8&' %=*Q (8&.= +8#=& .$ (8& Y**K+&=E.0& +&%'&$(U < (8.$2 (8#( < Q*,-K Y*0,+ *$ (8& =&+(#,=#$( +&%'&$(> )#$ P*, (&-- '& # 6.( '*=&#6*,( (8#( +&%'&$( *Y (8& Y**K +&=E.0& '#=2&([

!"#$%&'$($%) E+55D 8.0% #& 6&: %.$*C 01&:% %.0% )+79+*%Z

@=0'% &4 8.0% %.+ \*%+'2$+8+' $) %+)%$*7 .+'+ $) %.+ $*%+'2$+8++() 01$5$%6 %& :)+ /&99&* )+*)+ %&5+0# %.+ /0)+ 0*# )++ 8.0% %.+6 /0* #+#:/+ &* %.+$' &8*;B

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U < .'#%.$& (8#( =&+(#,=#$(+ .$0-,K&+ # Y&Q +,6+&%'&$(+> R*= # )CJU 8.%8b&$K

=&+(#,=#$(+ #=& *,(> 1,( .$ (8& -*Qb&$KU (8&=&S+ D=*6#6-P Y#+( Y**KU K&-.+ #$K '*' #$K D*D +8*D+U#$K '.+0&--#$&*,+>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0%() '$7.%; -.+'+() &*+ 1$7D *+8 &*+ %.0% 6&:('+ 9$))$*7; \%() '+4+''+# %& 0)<)5&8 40)% 4&&#;> \%() *+8 /.0$*) 8$%. 9&'+ 90#+P%&P&'#+'D .+05%.$+' 4&&#; \%() '+)%0:'0*%) 5$C+R.$3&%5+D V&)%&* Y0'C+%D R&)$D +%/; \%() 30'% &4 3+&35+() *++# %& +0% .+05%.$+';

1*+%3N4%O%%. <$(&=&+(.$%> < .'#%.$& (8#( (8.+ $&Q +&%'&$( .+ %=*Q.$% # -*( Y#+(&= (8#$ (8& *(8&=+&%'&$(+> 1,( .(S+ +'#--> <Y < (8.$2 #6*,( (8& *=.%.$#- V,&+(.*$ *Y (8& 0#+&U .Y < Q#+ %*.$% (* (=P (*%=*Q '#=2&( +8#=&U < '.%8( (=P (* %=*Q .( (8=*,%8*,( (8& =&+(#,=#$( +&%'&$(+> A*Q&E&=U 6&Y*=& <'#2& # =&0*''&$K#(.*$U <SK -.2& (* 2$*Q # 6.( '*=& #6*,( (8& 0*'D&(.(.*$sQ& 8#E&$S( (#-2&K

',08 #6*,( (8#(>

!"#$%&'$($%) T&:('+ '$7.%; E+55D %.+ /&93+%$%$&* $) 3'+%%6 4$+'/+ $* %.+ 40)% 4&&# ):1)+79+*%; ".02+ &*+ 90$* /&93+%$%&'; -.+6 &*56 90C+ 1+2+'07+)D 0*# %.+6 .02+ 0 `MN 90'C+% ).0'+ $* 40)% 4&&#;

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

5?

1*+%3N4%O%%. \*Q> \&--U %.E&$ (8#(U < Q*,-K Y*0,+ *$ (8& *(8&= (Q* +&%'&$(+; (8.+ $&Q +-*QUY#+( Y**K +&%'&$( #$K (8& '*' #$K D*D +&%'&$(>

!"#$%&'$($%) e'+0%; E.0% 8&:5# 6&: #& %& %'6 %& 4&/:) &* %.+9 0*# 7'&8 6&:' 90'C+% ).0'+8$%. %.+9Z

@-.+ $*%+'2$+8++ 9$7.% 80*% %& %0C+ 0 4+8 )+/&*#) %& %.$*C 01&:% %.+ 0*)8+' %& %.$) b:+)%$&*; \%() C$*# &4 %.+ /':[ &4 %.+ 0*)8+' %& %.+ /0)+; ]$*/+ $%() 0 90'C+%$*7 b:+)%$&*h.&8 %& 7'&890'C+% ).0'+h%.+ H =) /&9+ $* 0) 0 .0*#6 4'09+8&'C %& :)+ %& %.$*C %.'&:7. %.+ /0)+;B

W'0@;*1

W'9*.

W'050190)

H2'. 1+.'. *;/105.'/ 9) 1+. './1(;'()1 /.-5.)1 1+(1 =.P'.)01 1(69)- *('. 0J '9-+1 )0=K <.= /;SF/.-5.)1/K

HC+0;4@ =. *05D.1. 0) D'9*.K R0 =. =()1 10 *05D.1.0) D'9*.K TW'9*. *05D.19190) *0;4@ -'0= 0;' ;)91 /+('.OS;1 +;'1 0J > A04;5. 5('6.1 /+('.N()@ 0;' D'0J91/0A.'(44V

H:() =. *'0//FD'0501. =91+ 0;' './1(;'()1 *;/105.'/K

HI944 *'0//FD'050190) +.4D -'0= './1(;'()1 *;/105.'/P40E(41E 10 ;/K

W4(*.5.)1

H:() =. 0JJ.' /D.*9(41E D'0@;*1/L 1(940'F5(@. D'0@;*1/ 10'./1(;'()1/K

H:() =. 0JJ.' ).= D'0@;*1 D(*6(-9)- 1+(1 9/ /D.*9J9* 10 0;''./1(;'()1 *;/105.'/K

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U (8&=& #=& # Y&Q (8.$%+ (8#( Q& 0*,-K (* %=*Q *,= +8#=& Q.(8 (8&+& 0,+(*'&=+><$ (&='+ *Y D=.0&U Q&--U Q& 0*,-K 08#$%& *,= D=.0&U 6,( < K*$S( (8.$2 (8#( Q& Q#$( (* 0*'D&(& *$ D=.0&> Z8#( 0*,-K 8&-D ,+ %=*Q *,= ,$.( E*-,'& +8#=&U 6,( .( '.%8( 8,=( *,= K*--#= E*-,'& +8#=&#$K K&Y.$.(&-P Q*,-K 8,=( *,= D=*Y.(+> <$ (&='+ *Y D-#0&'&$(M K.+(=.6,(.*$U .+ (8&=& # Q#P (8#( Q&0#$ %=*Q *,= +8#=& 6P K.+(=.6,(.$% (* $&Q 0,+(*'&=+M -*0#(.*$+[

!"#$%&'$($%) Y061+; V:% 8+ 05'+0#6 #$)%'$1:%+ %& 0 90G&'$%6 &4 %.+ 90'C+%; E.0% +5)+ /&:5# 6&:

#& %& 7'&8 ).0'+;

1*+%3N4%O%%. <$ (&='+ *Y D=*'*(.*$U '#P6& (8&P 0#$ 0=&#(& D#=($&=+8.D+ Q.(8 0&=(#.$ 0,+(*'&=+*= 0,+(*'&= 08#.$+ #$K =,$ 0=*++ D=*'*(.*$ 0#'D#.%$+s-.2& #KE&=(.+.$% 0#'D#.%$+U *= 0*,D*$+>/$K .$ (&='+ *Y D=*K,0(U '#P6& (8&P 0#$ 0=&#(& 0,+(*'.H&K D=*K,0(+ Y*= (8&.= =&+(#,=#$(0,+(*'&=+[ F.2& $&Q D#02#%.$%[ 7D&0.#-(P +.H&+U &(0[

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

5B

!"#$%&'$($%) T+3; -.0%() 7'+0%; -.0%() 0 7&&# 806 %& 7'&8 ).0'+; V:% /0* 6&: G:)% b:$/C56 7$2+9+ )&9+ &4 %.+ 3'&) 0*# /&*) &4 )3+/$05%6 &' /:)%&9 3'&#:/%)Z

@Q+'+D %.+ \*%+'2$+8+' $) %+)%$*7 %.+ $*%+'2$+8++() 01$5$%6 %& $#+*%$46 )&9+ 1:)$*+)) '$)C) 8$%. *+8$#+0)h%+)%$*7 1:)$*+)) G:#79+*% 0*# '$)C $#+*%$4$/0%$&*;B

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U *$ (8& D=*+ +.K&U .( Q*,-K 6,.-K # +D&0.#- =&-#(.*$+8.D Q.(8 (8& 0,+(*'&=t .('.%8( K.YY&=&$(.#(& ,+ Y=*' *,= 0*'D&(.(.*$> W$ (8& 0*$+ +.K&U *,= D=*Y.( '#=%.$+ Q*,-KK&Y.$.(&-P K&0=&#+& *$ 0,+(*' D=*K,0(+> 7*U Q& '.%8( %=*Q *,= +8#=&U 6,( $*( *,= *E&=#-- 6*((*'-.$&>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0%() '$7.%; ]&D $) %.+'+ 0*6%.$*7 +5)+h&%.+' %.0* /:)%&9 3'&#:/%) &' 0*6 &4 %.+$#+0) %.0% 6&: 9+*%$&*+#h%.0% /0* .+53 :) 7'&8 &:' ).0'+ $* %.+ '+)%0:'0*% )+79+*%Z

@Q+'+D %.+ \*%+'2$+8+' $) 5&&C$*7 4&' 0 )3+/$4$/ 0*)8+'; \4 %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ #&+)*(% 7+% $%D #&*(%8&''6 01&:% $%; T&: /0* )%$55 7+% %.+ G&1 8$%.&:% 7+%%$*7 %.+ 0*)8+' %& %.$) &*+;B

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U Q8&$ < (8.$2 #6*,( (8& .$Y*='#(.*$ (8#( < %*( &#=-P .$ (8& 0#+&U (8& *$-P (8.$%(8#( < 8#E& (8#( =&#--P K.YY&=&$(.#(&+ ,+ Y=*' *,= 0*'D&(.(.*$ .+ (8& Y#0( (8#( Q& 8#E& # Y**K #$K 6&E&=#%& D*=(Y*-.*> "#P6& Q& 0#$ -&E&=#%& (8& Y#0( (8#( Q& 0#$ K.+(=.6,(& Y**K D=*K,0(+ #$K 6&E&=#%& D=*K,0(+ (* =&+(#,=#$( 0,+(*'&=+ (* %=*Q *,= '#=2&( +8#=&[

!"#$%&'$($%) T+)D %.0%() '$7.%; ]&D .&8 8&:5# 6&: ):990'$^+ 6&:' '+/&99+*#0%$&*Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7,=&> Z8& 0-.&$( Q#$(+ (* %=*Q (8&.= '#=2&( +8#=& .$ (8& Y**K +&=E.0& +&%'&$(>Z8& 6&+( Q#P (* K* (8#( Q*,-K 6& (* Y*0,+ *$ (8& =&+(#,=#$( +&%'&$( *Y (8& Y**K +&=E.0& '#=2&(U 6&0#,+& (8#(S+ (8& -#=%&+( D#=( *Y (8& '#=2&(s$&#=-P G4_> \.(8.$ (8#(U (8& 0-.&$( +8*,-K Y*0,+

*$ (8& $*$bY#+( Y**K +&%'&$(+U #+ (8*+& +&%'&$(+ #=&$S( K*'.$#(&K 6P *,= '#X*= 0*'D&(.(*= #$K#=& +(.-- ,D Y*= %=#6+> /$K (8&PS=& %=*Q.$% Y#+(&= (8#$ (8& (=#K.(.*$#- Y#+( Y**K +&%'&$(> Z8& 6&+(Q#P+ (* %=*Q '#=2&( +8#=& Q.(8.$ (8*+& +,6b+&%'&$(+sQ.(8*,( 8,=(.$% (8& 6*((*' -.$&sQ*,-K 6& (* -&E&=#%& (8& 6=&#K(8 *Y *,= D*=(Y*-.*U 8#E.$% 6*(8 Y**K #$K 6&E&=#%& D=*K,0(+ (* *YY&=Q8.08 *,= 0*'D&(.(.*$ K*&+ $*(U #$K D&=8#D+ 6P '#2.$% 0,+(*' D=*K,0(+U Q8&=& .( K*&+$S( 8,=(*,= D=*Y.( '#=%.$+>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

59

)",% -X. 1*,+4+C+4'*"$ 9,,%+ 6"*"5%3 A%%,

=GE<G1EHA43B. 1)J

<'C*D. 3445 RZU R.$#- )'*+%*+. i,#-.(#(.E& #$K V,#$(.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

1)J 8#+ 6&&$ 8.=&K 6P #$ .$+(.(,(.*$#- #++&( '#$#%&= 0-.&$(> Z8& 0-.&$( .+ E&=P D=*Y.(#6-& #$KK*.$% Q&--> A*Q&E&=U (8&P 2$*Q (8#( (8&P #=& -&#E.$% '*$&P *$ (8& (#6-&; (8&P 2$*Q (8#( (8&P8#E& # -*Q&= #E&=#%& D&=0&$( Y&& *Y #++&(+ ,$K&= '#$#%&'&$( (8#$ (8&.= 0*'D&(.(.*$s-*Q&=(8#$ (8& .$K,+(=P #E&=#%&> Z8&PSE& 8.=&K 1)J (* (&-- (8&' Q8P (8#( .+U 6,( .$ (8& &$K Q& (*-K(8&' '*=& (8#$ (8#(>

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

<%2'BB%*D%D 9II3'"28

Z8.+ 0#+& K.E&+ =.%8( .$(* K#(# #$K V,&+(.*$ #$K #$+Q&=> Z8&=&S+ # V,&+(.*$ (8#( (8& 0-.&$( #+2&KU 6,( (8& .$(&=E.&Q&= 8.$(&K ,D Y=*$( .$ (8& 0#+& V,&+(.*$ (8#( 8&M+8& Q#$(+ (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& (* K*'*=& (8#$ X,+( #$+Q&= (8& 0-.&$(S+ V,&+(.*$> Z8.+ .+ # %**K 0#+& Y*= D=#0(.0.$% -**2.$% #( K#(##$K (#2.$% (8& 0#+& .$(&=E.&Q D#+( #$+Q&=.$% (8& V,&+(.*$ #$K '*=& (*Q#=K+ fY.].$%g (8& 6,+.$&++ D=*6-&'>

Z8& .$(&=E.&Q&= +8*,-K &]D&0( (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& (* K=.E& (8& 0#+&U 6,( +8*,-K D=*E.K& (8& K#(#e&]8.6.(+ : q3d ,DbY=*$( D=&((P V,.02-P #$K '#2& +,=& (8#( (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& ,$K&=+(#$K+ (8&

.$K,+(=P #$K 8*Q (8& Y&& +(=,0(,=& Q*=2+ E&=P &#=-P *$>

:%J A"2+,

b <$+(.(,(.*$#- #++&( '#$#%&=+S =&E&$,&+ #=& 6#+&K *$ Y&&+ Y=*' 0-.&$(+> )-.&$(+ #=& 08#=%&K# Y&&U Q8.08 .+ +(=,0(,=&K 6P +*'& D&=0&$(#%& *Y #++&(+ ,$K&= '#$#%&'&$(> p*, 0#$#++,'& 9_ .Y .( '#2&+ (8& K.+0,++.*$ &#+.&=s(8*,%8U (8& D&=0&$( Y&& $&E&= 0*'&+ ,D>

b <$+(.(,(.*$#- #++&( '#$#%&'&$( 0*'D#$.&+ #=& 0*'D#$.&+ -.2& R.K&-.(P> Z8&P 0#$ +&=E&#$P +*=( *Y -#=%&U .$E&+(.$% 0-.&$(+sD&$+.*$ Y,$K+U )#-C&=+U Z</b)^ORU 8*+D.(#-+UY*,$K#(.*$+U ,$.E&=+.(.&+U &(0> Z8&P K* 8#E& =&(#.- K.E.+.*$ (8#( +&=E& .$K.E.K,#-+ Q.(8(8&.= B4:m+ #$K ',(,#- Y,$K+U 6 ,( (8.+ 0#+& Y*0,+&+ *$ (8& .$+(.(,(.*$#- .$E&+(*= +.K& *Y

(8& 6,+.$&++>

EK96LME @19M=;>E

!"#$%&'$($%) ]&D 4$')% #& 6&: .02+ 0*6 b:+)%$&*)Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7,=&U < Q#$( (* '#2& +,=& (8#( < ,$K&=+(#$K 8*Q (8& 0-.&$(S+ 6,+.$&++ Q*=2+> <K*$S( 2$*Q (** ',08 #6*,( .$+(.(,(.*$#- .$E&+(*=+ *= #++&( '#$#%&=+t +*U <SK -.2& (* X,+( '#2&+,=& (8#( < ,$K&=+(#$K (8& 6,+.$&++ '*K&- 6&Y*=& Q& K.E& .$(* (8& D=*6-&'>

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

55

!"#$%&'$($%) ]:'+D %.0% 90C+) )+*)+; E.0% /0* \ %+55 6&:Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. < .'#%.$& (8#( #$ .$+(.(,(.*$#- #++&( '#$#%&= .+ # 0*'D#$P -.2& # R.K&-.(PU *=)#D.(#- J=*,D )*'D#$.&+>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0%() '$7.%;

1*+%3N4%O%%. /$K < 6&( (8#( (8&.= 0-.&$(+ 0#$ =#$%& Y=*' #$P*$&sP*, #$K '& .$E&+(.$% *,=+#E.$%+ .$ # ',(,#- Y,$K (* -#=%& .$E&+(*=+ -.2& D&$+.*$ Y,$K+>

!"#$%&'$($%) T+3D %.0%() '$7.%; =+*)$&* 4:*#) 5$C+ -\UPRg"_ 0*# R05=+')D &' 4&:*#0%$&*) 0*#:*$2+')$%$+) 0'+ )&9+ &4 %.+ 1$77+' /5$+*%); E+('+ 7&$*7 %& 4&/:) &* %.0% 30'% &4 %.+ 1:)$*+))h %.+ $*)%$%:%$&*05 $*2+)%&' 30'% &4 %.+ 1:)$*+))D *&% &* 6&: 0*# 9+ 0*# &:' $*#$2$#:05 HMKPA);

1*+%3N4%O%%. J=&#(> /$K P*, +#.K (8#( (8&P %&$&=#(& =&E&$,&+ Y=*' Y&&+ Q8.08 #=& 6#+&K *$ #

D&=0&$( *Y #++&(+ ,$K&= '#$#%&'&$([

!"#$%&'$($%) g$7.%; E.0%() 6&:' )+*)+ &4 .&8 %.0% 3+'/+*% 9$7.% /.0*7+Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. "P %,&++ .+ (8#( -#=%&= 0-.&$(+s0-.&$(+ Q.(8 -#=%&= #'*,$(+ *Y #++&(+ ,$K&='#$#%&'&$(s'.%8( 8#E& # -*Q&= D&=0&$( Y&& 08#=%&K (* (&'U 6&0#,+& (8&P +(.-- %&$&=#(& '*=&=&E&$,&+ Q.(8 # +'#--&= D&=0&$( Y&&>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0%() '$7.%; \* 40/%D \ .02+ 0* +[.$1$% %.0% ).&8) 6&: 8.0% %.0% 5&&C) 5$C+;

<(S+ # +(&DD&K Y,$0(.*$> \8#( Q*,-K P*, .'#%& (8& 0*+( +(=,0(,=& *Y K.YY&=&$( +.H& 0-.&$(+ .+ -.2&[

J$K$@F$ !.)F*.F)$ ,() L@%.-.F.-(@"# H%%$. M"@"2$N$@.

Q.. 0) 2//.1/B)@.'

,()(-.5.)1TXV

> B)@.',()(-.5.)1

78+9S91 $

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

5G

1*+%3N4%O%%. A,8> \&--U < K*$S( 2$*Q (8& 6,+.$&++ (* Q&--U 6,( < .'#%.$& (8#( .( 0*+(+ #6*,( (8&+#'& (* +&=E.0& # -#=%& 0-.&$( #+ .( K*&+ # +'#-- *$&>

!"#$%&'$($%) T+)D %.0%() /&''+/%; ]&D 8.0% #&+) %.0% %+55 6&:Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. Z8#( (&--+ '& (8#( -#=%& 0-.&$(+s.$ (&='+ *Y #++&(+ ,$K&= '#$#%&'&$(s#=& 8.%8-P D=*Y.(#6-& 6&0#,+& (8&P %&$&=#(& '*=& .$ =&E&$,&+s&E&$ Q.(8 +'#--&= D&=0&$(#%& Y&&+s#( 6#+.0#--P (8& +#'& 0*+( #+ # +'#-- 0-.&$(> Z8.$2.$% 6#02 (* (8& *=.%.$#- V,&+(.*$ *Y (8& 0#+&; Q8PK*&+ (8& 0-.&$( 8#E& # -*Q&= #E&=#%& Y&& (8#$ (8& =&+( *Y (8& .$K,+(=PU < $*Q Q#$( (* 2$*Q '*=&#6*,( (8& Y&&+ (8#( (8&PS=& 08#=%.$% K.YY&=&$( 0,+(*'&=+>

@\4 %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ #$# *&% 7+% %.+)+ 3&$*%)D $%() *&% 0 1$7 #+05; V:% $% $) $93&'%0*% %& ).&8 %.+9.&8 %.+ 4++) 0'+ )%':/%:'+# 0*# +[350$* %.0% 50'7+' /5$+*%) 7+*+'0%+ 9&'+ '+2+*:+) 0*# /&)% %.+ )09+ 0) 0*6 &%.+' /5$+*%h%.+'+4&'+D %.+6('+ .$7.56 3'&4$%015+ /5$+*%);B

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0%() '$7.% &* %'0/C; W+% 9+ ).&8 6&: )&9+ #0%0 %.0% 8+ /&55+/%+# &* %.+ 3+'/+*%

4++)h0*# #$)/&:*%)h%.0% %.+6('+ 7$2$*7 %& %.+$' /:)%&9+');

E.0% #&+) %.$) #0%0 %+55 6&:Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U .(S+ $*( Q8#( < Q*,-K &]D&0(> <( -**2+ -.2& (8&PS=& %.E.$% +*'& *Y (8& 8.%8&+(K.+0*,$(+ *$ (8&.= Y&&+ (* (8&.= '.Kb+.H&K 0-.&$(+U $*( (* (8&.= -#=%&+( *$&+> Z8.+ '#P 6& 2&&D.$%(8& D=*Y.(#6.-.(P 8.%8 *$ (8&.= -#=%& 0-.&$(+U 6,( .(S+ D=*6#6-P K&+(=*P.$% '#=%.$+ *$ (8&.= '.Kb

O-%*(F@.% /0 O$"#

A

O-%*(F@.

> B)@.' ,()(-.5.)1

T9) ,<V

$" $O"""$"" $"O"""

$"

Y"

Z"

["

\"

$""

]"

^"

#"

%"

78+9S91 %

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

5I

+.H&K 0-.&$(+U #$K 6=.$%.$% K*Q$ (8&.= *E&=#-- Y&& #E&=#%&> < (8.$2 (8.+ +8*Q+ (8& #$+Q&= (* (8&0-.&$(S+ V,&+(.*$>

!"#$%&'$($%) ]:'+; c&8 .+'+() 0*&%.+' b:+)%$&*, $4 6&: 8+'+ %.+ /5$+*%D 8.0% 8&:5# 6&: 80*% %& )++ .+'+Z

@Q+'+D %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ ).&:5# 7+*+'0%+ 0 4+8 $#+0); U 1:*/. 0'+ 5$)%+#h$4 %.+6 7+% &*+ &' %8&D%.0%() 7'+0%D 0*# 6&: /0* 9&2+ &*; U5)&D $% 9$7.% .+53 %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ %& 7$2+ %.+9 %.+ +[.$1$% )&%.0% %.+6 /0* #'08 &* $%h$4 %.0% 90C+) %.+9 9&'+ /&94&'%015+ &' .+53) %.+9 0% 055;B

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U < Q*,-K Q#$( (* +&& # Y&Q (8.$%+> R.=+(U < Q*,-K Q#$( (* 6& %.E.$% (8& 6.%%&+( K.+0*,$(+U *= (8& '*+( K.+0*,$(+U (* 'P -#=%&= 0-.&$(+> A&=&U .( -**2+ -.2& (8&PS=& %.E.$%(8& 6.%%&+( K.+0*,$(+ (* (8& '.Kb+.H&K 0-.&$(+> 7&0*$KU (8&=& K*&+$S( +&&' (* 6& #$P +*=( *Y 0#D*$ (8& #'*,$( *Y K.+0*,$( (8#( 0#$ 6& %.E&$> Z8&PS=& K.+0*,$(.$% ,D (* @4_ .$ +*'& 0#+&+s<Q*,-K (8.$2 (8#( (8#( Q*,-K K&+(=*P #-- D=*Y.( '#=%.$+> < Q*,-K &]D&0( Y*= (8&=& (* 6& # 0#D#=*,$K ?4_ *= +*'&(8.$%> F#+(U .( #-- +&&'+ D=&((P =#$K*' Q8&=& (8& K.+0*,$(+ #=& %.E&$> <

Q*$K&= Q8&(8&= (8& 0-,+(&=+ *Y K.+0*,$(+ =&D=&+&$( # 0&=(#.$ +#-&+'#$M #00*,$( &]&0,(.E&>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0%() '$7.%; ]&D 8.0% 0'+ %.+ C+6 )%+3) %.0% 6&: *++# %& %0C+ %& 4$[ %.+ 3'&15+9Z

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U Y.=+(U P*, 8#E& (* K.#%$*+& Q8P (8& K.+0*,$(+ #=& (8& Q#P (8&P #=& =.%8( $*Q>7*U -**2b,D Q8* K.+0*,$(&K Q8#(s+&& Q8&(8&= .(S+ +#-&D&=+*$bK=.E&$U *= .Y .(S+ K=.E&$ 6P (8&(PD& *Y 0-.&$(> Z8&$U P*, Q*,-K $&&K (* '*$.(*= (8& K.+0*,$(.$% #$K 2&&D (=#02 *Y .(> "#P6&P*, 0#$ .$0&$( (8& +#-&+D&*D-& $*( (* %.E& K.+0*,$(+[

!"#$%&'$($%) T+3; -.0%() '$7.%, 9&*$%&'$*7 0*# %'0/C$*7D 0*# %.+* 3:% $* 8.0%+2+' )6)%+9) 0'+*+/+))0'6 %& 7+% %.+ /&930*6() 02+'07+ 4++ :3 %& 0% 5+0)% %.+ $*#:)%'6 02+'07+; e'+0%; -.0%() $%;

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

5@

)",% -]. ;CB#J\, L4WW"

=GE<G1EHA43B. 1#.$

<'C*D. 3445 RZU R.=+( )'*+%*+. i,#-.(#(.E& #$K V,#$(.(#(.E&

)97E F>E7!1=?

Z8.+ .+ # COM K,& K.-.%&$0& 0#+&> 1#.$ 8#+ 6&&$ 8.=&K 6P # D=.E#(& &V,.(P Y.=' (* &E#-,#(&Q8&(8&= *= $*( (8&P +8*,-K 6,P # '*' #$K D*D D.HH# 08#.$ (8#( =,$+ D.HH# =&+(#,=#$(+ D=.'#=.-P.$ 0*--&%& (*Q$+ (8=*,%8*,( (8& +*,(8> Z8& '*' #$K D*D *Q$&=+ #=& =&(.=.$% #$K 8#E& D,( (8& 6,+.$&++ ,D Y*= +#-&> Z8& 08#.$ 8#+ #6*,( ?4 +(*=&+ #$K #$$,#- =&E&$,&+ *Y #6*,( c:39 '.--.*$>

<$ *=K&= Y*= (8& D=.E#(& &V,.(P Y.=' (* Q#$( (* 6,P (8.+ 08#.$U (8&P $&&K (* 6& #6-& (* K*,6-& %=*++'#=%.$ .$ ?b9 P&#=+> Z8&PS=& -**2.$% Y*= 3b? Y&#+.6-& .K&#+ *Y 8*Q (* K* (8#(U #+ (8&P Q*,-K -.2&(* +&-- (8& 08#.$ (* #$*(8&= Y#'.-P *Q$&= .$ ?b9 P&#=+>

1?!E<G1EHE< /<1EA1?;

Z8.+ .+ # D=*Y.(#6.-.(P 0#+&U %.E&$ (8#( (8& CO Y.=' .+ ,-(.'#(&-P (=P.$% (* K*,6-& %=*++ '#=%.$ .$?b9 P&#=+> 1&0#,+& *Y (8#(U (8& Y=#'&Q*=2 ,+&K +8*,-K 6& # (PD.0#- D=*Y.(#6.-.(P Y=#'&Q*=2 *Y=&E&$,&+ #$K 0*+(+> Z8&$U (8& .$(&=E.&Q&= Q*,-K $&&K (* 8&-D Y*0,+ (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& *$ (8&=&E&$,&+ +.K& *Y D=*Y.(#6.-.(PU Q8&=& (8& ? )S+ +8*,-K 6& ,+&K (* Y.%,=& *,( Q8#(S+ %*.$% *$ .$ (8&'#=2&(D-#0&> W$0& (8& .$(&=E.&Q&& 8#+ +,%%&+(&K (8#( (8&PSK -.2& (* -**2 #( D=*Y.(#6.-.(P *$ #$P+D&0.Y.0 -&E&-s+(*=&b-&E&-U (*Q$b-&E&-U 0,+(*'&=b-&E&-U D=*K,0(b-&E&-U (8& .$(&=E.&Q&= 0#$ +(#=( (*

+,DD-P &]8.6.(+ (* K=.E& (8& 0#+& Y=*' (8&=&>

EK96LME @19M=;>E

1*+%3N4%O%%. <( +*,$K+ -.2& (8& 0-.&$( Q#$(+ 3b? .K&#+ *$ 8*Q (* K*,6-& D=*Y.(#6.-.(PU 0*==&0(>

!"#$%&'$($%) T+)D %.0%() /&''+/%;

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7*U D=*Y.(#6.-.(P .+ 0*'D*+&K *Y =&E&$,&+ #$K 0*+(+> W$ (8& =&E&$,&+ +.K&U (8&=&S=&(Q* -&E&=+; D=.0& #$K E*-,'&> /$K *$ (8& 0*+(+ +.K&U (8&=&S+ Y.]&K #$K E#=.#6-& 0*+(+U *=K&D&$K.$% *$ Q8#( 2.$K *Y K#(# Q& 8#E&U Q& 0*,-K -**2 #( '#X*= -.$& .(&'+ *$ (8& 6#-#$0& +8&&(>

@c&%+ &* 506$*7 &:% %.+ /&)%) )$#+ &4 %.+ /0)+, E.$5+ Y/A$*)+6 '+/&99+*#) 0 /&)%) 4'09+8&'C &4 4$[+# 2); 20'$015+ /&)%)D \*%+'2$+8+' &4%+* ':*) #&8* %.+ 90G&' 5$*+ $%+9) &* %.+ 1050*/+ ).++%,501&'D 90%+'$05)D ]eoUD ==o"; ]&D 0 '+)3&*#+*% 9$7.% 80*% %& /&*)$#+' :)$*7 %.0% 506&:% %&/&)%)h$% )++9) 5+)) <1:)$*+))P)/.&&5 4&'9:50$/> 0*# 9&'+ '+05 8&'5#D 0) /&)%) 8&:5# 1+ #+'$2+# 4'&9 4$*0*/$05 )%0%+9+*%); Q&8+2+'D 1+/0:)+ /&)%) 0'+ *&% %.+ 90$* %.':)% &4 %.$) /0)+D $%() *&% 01$7 3&$*% .+'+D 1:% 0 35:) 4&' 0 \*%+'2$+8+' $*%+'2$+8+'; U5)&D $% .+53) $4 %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ 0/%:0556

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

G4

)C+%/.+) &:% %.+$' 4'09+8&'C &* 0 ).++% &4 303+' $* 50*#)/03+ 4&'90%h%.$) ).&8) %.0% %.+$*%+'2$+8++ $) %.$*C$*7 $* <)5$#+ 506&:%> 4&'90%D 8.$/. $) 8.0% /&*):5%$*7 $) 055 01&:%n;B

W$& Q#P (* -#P*,( (8& 0#+&;

W'0J91/

:0/1/

M.A.);./HW'9*.

H_04;5.

HQ98.@ :0/1/

H_('9(S4. :0/1/

W(8&= Q#P;

W'0J91/

:0/1/

M.A.);./HW'9*.

H_04;5.

HM(= ,(1.'9(4/

H`(S0'

HWWa7

HCba2

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

G:

@U4%+' 506$*7 &:% %.+ 3'&4$%01$5$%6 4'09+8&'CD 6&: 8&:5# *++# %& )%0%+ 0 .63&%.+)$) 01&:% 8.$/. )$#+h'+2+*:+) &' /&)%)h6&: 8&:5# 5$C+ %& 4&/:) &*; \%() +0'56 $* %.+ /0)+p )&D '+0556D G:)% 90C+0* +#:/0%+# 7:+)) 0*# 3'&/++#;B

1*+%3N4%O%%. 1&0#,+& (8.+ .+ # D=.E#(& &V,.(P Y.=' 0-.&$(U #$K (8&PS=& -**2.$% (* K*,6-& D=*Y.(+ .$# +8*=( (.'& D&=.*KU < '.%8( Y*0,+ *$ (8& 0*+(+ +.K& *Y (8& 0#+&U 6&0#,+& .( .+ ,+,#--P &#+.&= (*=&#-.H& 0*+( +P$&=%.&+ Y#+(&= (8#$ =&E&$,& +P$&=%.&+>

!"#$%&'$($%) U/%:0556D 8.$5+ %.0%() 0 7&&# .:*/. 01&:% =" /5$+*%)D $* %.$) 30'%$/:50' /0)+D %.+'+'+0556 0'+*(% %&& 90*6 /&)% )6*+'7$+) %& 1+ .0#; \%(# 1+ 1+%%+' %& 4&/:) &* '+2+*:+ 70$*); e$2+*%.0%D .&8 9$7.% 6&: )%':/%:'+ 6&:' $*b:$'6Z

@E.$5+ 6&: /0* :)+ +$%.+' %.+ X R() &' %.+ H=()D \ %.$*C %.0% %.+ X R() 8&'C 1+%%+' 4&' %.$) /0)+D1+/0:)+ %.+6 3'&2$#+ 0 1+%%+' &2+'2$+8 &4 %.+ 90'C+%350/+ 0*# 8&'C *$/+56 8$%. %.+ :3/&9$*7+[.$1$%); V:% '+0556D +$%.+' 8&:5# 8&'CD 0) %.+6('+ 1&%. 90'C+%$*7d '+2+*:+P7'&8%. 4'09+8&'C)0*# %.0%() %.+ '+05 b:+)%$&* 1+$*7 3&)+# .+'+;B

1*+%3N4%O%%. < Q*,-K -**2 #( (8=&& (8.$%+U #$K +&E&=#- 2&P V,&+(.*$+ .$ (8*+& 6,02&(+ .$ *=K&= (*%#.$ # +&$+& *Y (8& '#=2&( #$K 0*'D&(.(.E& -#$K+0#D& #$K 8*Q (8&P '.%8( 6& #6-& (* %=*Q=&E&$,&+> Z8& -#=%& 6,02&(+ #=& (8& Y*--*Q.$%; :d )*'D&(.(.E& F#$K+0#D&U 3d ),+(*'&=+ #$K ?d)*'D#$P> A&=&S+ 8*Q < '.%8( +(=,0(,=& .(U #$K +*'& 2&P V,&+(.*$+ (8#( <SK -.2& (* #+2 .$ &#08 6,02&(;

? )S+ R=#'&Q*=2 Q.(8 m&P i,&+(.*$+

:05D.1919A.`()@/*(D.

:05D()E:;/105.'/

H<(190)(4*05D.1910'/K:+(9)/K

HM.-90)(4L 40*(4*05D.1910'/K

H<.= .)1'()1/K

HI+(1 /.-5.)1/.89/1 9) 1+. 5('6.1K

HC1;@.)1/K

HQ(*;41EK

HG1+.'/K

Hc0= +(/ 1+.*05D()EP/D'0J91(S9491E A('9.@0A.' 195.K

H&E /10'.K

H&E '.-90)K

H&E D'0@;*1K

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

G3

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0%() 7'+0%; T&: 1'&:7.% :3 )&9+ $*%+'+)%$*7 %.$*7); E.0% C$*# &4 .63&%.+)+) #& 6&: .02+ 01&:% %.+ /&93+%$%$2+ 50*#)/03+Z

@U% %.$) 3&$*%D %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ ).&:5# :)+ %.+$' /&99&* )+*)+ 01&:% 3$^^0 '+)%0:'0*%); -.+ \*%+'2$+8+' $*%+'2$+8+' $) 90$*56 %'6$*7 %& %+)% %.+$' /&99&* )+*)+ 0*# )++ 8.0% %63+) &4.63&%.+)+) %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ /0* 7+*+'0%+; \%() 4$*+P 3'&10156 1+%%+'PP4&' %.$) %& 1+ 9&'+ &4 0/&*2+')0%$&*;B

1*+%3N4%O%%. p*, '&$(.*$&K (8#( (8.+ .+ # '*' #$K D*D 08#.$ .$ +*,(8&=$ 0*--&%& (*Q$+> <.'#%.$& (8#( (8&=& #=& $#(.*$#- 08#.$+ (8#( #=& #-+* .$ (8*+& (*Q$+> < 6&( (8#( (8*+& 08#.$+ '#2&(8& '#=2&( D=&((P D=.0& 0*'D&(.(.E&> < #-+* Q*$K&= Q8&(8&= (8&=& #=& *(8&= -*0#- '*' #$K D*D=&+(#,=#$(+ .$ (8& (*Q$+ (8#( '#2& 0*'D&(.(.*$ &E&$ 8&#E.&=>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0%() 7'+0%; E+ 0/%:0556 .02+ )&9+ #0%0 &* %.+ /&93+%$%$&*;

3A43A53A63A73A83A93A:3A;3A<3A

433A

! . F D $ @

. %

' " * F # . 0

P ! . " , ,

= ( Q @ ' (

# C

+">" R-@(S%

+-TT" UF.

O(N-@(S%

?.V$)

RFN/0S%

9 MM < MM48 MM

HK$)"2$ M")C$. !V")$ /0 1F%.(N$) !$2N$@.

78+9S91 $

3A

43A

53A

63A

73A

83A

93A

:3A

;3A

<3A

433A

O$#-K$)0 1"))0W

?F.

O-@$WL@

+">" R-@(S%

+-TT" UF.

O(N-@(S%

?.V$)

RFN/0S%

< MM 7 MM46 MM

HK$)"2$ M")C$. !V")$ /0 !$2N$@.

78+9S91 %

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

G?

E.0% C$*# &4 /&*/5:)$&*) 8&:5# 6&: #'08 4'&9 %.$)Z

@U% %.$) 3&$*%D %.+ $*%+'2$+8+' ).&:5# 7$2+ %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ %.+ %8& +[.$1$%); -.+ $*%+'2$+8++ ).&:5# #& 0 /&:35+ %.$*7); _$')%D %.+6 ).&:5# )06 8.0% #0%0 $) &* +0/. )5$#+; -.0% 806D %.+6 ).&8 %.0% %.+6 0'+ %.$*C$*7 &:% 5&:#D 0*# %.+6 0'+ ):'+ %& *&% 9$)) 0*6 #0%0 &* %.+ )5$#+);]+/&*#D %.+6 ).&:5# 90C+ 0 ):990'6 &4 8.0% %.+ #0%0 &* %.+ )5$#+) %+55) %.+9 01&:% %.+ C+6b:+)%$&* %.0% %.+6('+ %'6$*7 %& 0*)8+' .+'+, /0* %.+ /5$+*% #&:15+ 3'&4$%) 16 7'&8$*7 %.+ '+2+*:+) )$#+ )$7*$4$/0*%56 $* %.+ *+[% XPF 6+0')Z U*# %.+*D %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ ).&:5# #+4$*$%+56 %'6 %& )6*%.+)$^+ 0% %.+ +*#qB

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U O]8.6.( : (&--+ '& (8#( J,'6PS+ 8#+ +.%$.Y.0#$( '#=2&( +8#=& .$ (8& +(,K&$(0,+(*'&= +&%'&$(s#6*,( 54_> <( '.%8( 6& 8#=K (* %=*Q .( #$P'*=& .$ (8#( +&%'&$(> A*Q&E&=U.$ (8& Y#0,-(PM+(#YY #$K (*Q$ Y*-2 +&%'&$(+U (8&=&S+ -*(+ *Y =**' Y*= J,'6PS+ (* %=*Q (8&.=+8#=&s(8&PS=& K*Q$ #( #6*,( ?4_ #'*$%+( (8& Y#0,-(P 0=*QK #$K 9 _ .$ (8& (*Q$ Y*-2 0=*QK>A*Q&E&=U (8& 0*'D&(.(*=+ .$ (8*+& +&%'&$(+ -**2 -.2& $#(.*$#- 0*'D&(.(*=+ -.2& N*'.$*+ #$KC#D# J.$*S+s< .'#%.$& (8#( (8*+& #=& D=&((P (*,%8 0*'D&(.(*=+sD#=(.0,-#=-P *$ D=.0&> < #-+*

Q*,-K Q#$( (* (#2& .$(* #00*,$( (8& +.H& *Y (8& +&%'&$(+ .$ D=.*=.(.H.$% (8&' #$K (=P.$% (* %=*Q=&E&$,&+ .$ (8&'>

O]8.6.( 3 +8*Q+ (8#( Q&S=& (8& +(=*$%&+(sQ.(8 #6*,( # B4_ '#=2&( +8#=&s.$ (8& K&-.E&=P+&%'&$( *Y (8& '#=2&(> F,02.-PU (8#(S+ (8& -#=%&+( +&%'&$(> Z8& K.$&b.$ +&%'&$( -**2+ -.2& .(S+K*'.$#(&K 6P # 0*,D-& *Y (8& $#(.*$#- 08#.$+U #$K .(S+ D=&((P +'#-- #$PQ#P> 1,( (8& K&-.E&=P #$K0#==Pb*,( +&%'&$(+ +&&' '*=& K.E.K&KU +(.-- ,D Y*= %=#6+>

J.E&$ (8.+ $&Q .$Y*U .Y < Q#$(&K (* %=*Q =&E&$,&+ V,.02-P Y*= (8& 0-.&$(s< (8.$2 (8&P 8#E& # ?b9P&#= (.'& Y=#'&U < Q*,-K Y*0,+ *$ %=*Q.$% J,'6PS+ +8#=& .$ (8& K&-.E&=P #$K 0#==Pb*,(+&%'&$(+U #$K Q.(8 (8& Y#0,-(PM +(#YY #$K '#P6& (8& (*Q$ Y*-2>

!"#$%&'$($%) -.0%() 7'+0%; \) %.+'+ 0*6 &%.+' $*4&'90%$&* %.0% 6&:(# 5$C+ %& )++ $* &'#+' %& 90C+0 9&'+ '+4$*+# #+/$)$&* &* 8.& 6&: 8&:5# %0'7+% 0*# .&8 %& 7'&8 '+2+*:+)Z

@-.$) $) 8.+'+ %.+ $*%+'2$+8+' 80*%) %& )++ %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ <#'$55$*7 #&8*> &* %.+$' #0%0 0*#.63&%.+)+); -.+ $*%+'2$+8+' $) 05)& 5&&C$*7 4&' %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ %& )%0'% )6*%.+)$^$*7 0*# %6$*7 055%.+ #0%0 0*# /0)+ %&7+%.+'; \%() 05806) 7'+0% %& '+4+' 10/C %& %.+ &'$7$*05 b:+)%$&* $* %.+ /0)+h 8.$/. 80) 3'&4$%01$5$%6D *&% '+2+*:+);B

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U (8& *=.%.$#- V,&+(.*$ *Y (8& 0#+& Q#+ #6*,( D=*Y.(#6.-.(PU $*( =&E&$,&+> <'.%8( Q#$( (* ,$K&=+(#$K '*=& #6*,( Q8.08 (PD&+ *Y +&%'&$(+ #=& (8& '*+( D=*Y.(#6-& 6&Y*=&

K&0.K.$% Q8&=& (* %=*Q 'P =&E&$,&+> < '&#$U '#P6& (8& 0#==Pb*,( #$K K&-.E&=P +&=E.0&+ 8#E&K.YY&=&$( D=*Y.( '#=%.$+s< Q*,-K Q#$( (* 2$*Q D=*Y.(#6.-.(P 6P +&=E.0& (PD&U *= &E&$ 0,+(*'&=(PD&U .Y (8#(S+ K.YY&=&$(>

!"#$%&'$($%) E+55D %.0%() 0 7&&# $#+0; a*4&'%:*0%+56D 8+ #&*(% .02+ +[0/%56 %.+ 3'&4$%01$5$%6 #0%0%.0% 6&:('+ 5&&C$*7 4&'D 1:% 8+ .02+ )&9+%.$*7 /5&)+ %& $%h+[.$1$%) X 0*# H .02+ )&9+ 3'&4$%01$5$%6 #0%0 %.0% 906 .+53 6&:;

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


)*-,'6.# 1,+.$&++ 708**-)#+& 1**2 3449

GB

@c&8D %.+ $*%+'2$+8+' ).&:5# 7$2+ %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ %.+ 50)% %8& +[.$1$%)D 0*# %.+ $*%+'2$+8++ ).&:5# 7& %.'&:7. %.+ )09+ +[+'/$)+ 0) 1+4&'+D 1:% 5&&C %& )6*%.+)$^+ 0*# 8'03 :3 %.+ /0)+;B

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U &]8.6.( ? +8*Q+ '& (8& D=*K,0( '.] 6P 0,+(*'&= +&%'&$(U #$K &]8.6.( B

+8*Q+ (8& D=*Y.(#6.-.(P 6P D=*K,0( (PD&> Z#2&$ (*%&(8&=U (8&+& (&-- '& (8#( .Y < K* Q#$( (* (#=%&((8& Y#0,-(PM +(#YY #$K (*Q$ Y*-2 (* %=*Q =&E&$,&+ (8#( < =&#--P +8*,-K K* .( 6P (=P.$% (* %&( (8&' (* 6,P '*=& *Y (8& '*=& D=*Y.(#6-& D=*K,0(+sQ8.08 #=& +#$KQ.08&+ #$K K=.$2+U Q8.08 8#E& D=*Y.('#=%.$+ *Y BG_ #$K 9?_>

1*+%3N4%O%3. p&DU (8#(S+ =.%8(> T*Q 8*Q 0*,-K P*, K* (8#([

3

5

7

9

;

43

45

47

!.FD$@.% '"*F#.0P

!.",,

=(Q@ '(#C

?.V$)

O)-@C%

!"@DQ-*V$%

+-TT"

9 MM < MM48 MM

J$K$@F$% /0 1F%.(N$) !$2N$@. "@D +)(DF*.

78+9S91 ]

3

5

7

9

;

43

45

47

49

+-TT" !"@DQ-*V$% O)-@C% ?.V$)

+)(,-.%

!RXH

J"QM".$)-"#%

Y"/()

+)(,-."/-#-.0 /0 +)(DF*.

M")2-@Z 66A 7:A 86A 53A

78+9S91 ^

7/18/2019 Columbia 20061


1*+%3N4%O%%. p*, 0*,-K *YY&= 0*,D*$+ (8#( &$0*,=#%& K=.$2b6,P.$%U *= &E&$ X,+( '&$(.*$ (8#(P*, +&-- K=.$2+ Q8&$ D&*D-& D-#0& #$ *=K&=> p*, 0*,-K *YY&= '*=& (PD&+ *Y K=.$2+s'#P6& D&*D-& Q*,-K 6,P '*=& K=.$2+ .Y (8&P 0#==.&K # Q.K&= E#=.&(P[ p*, 0*,-K #KE&=(.+& (8#( P*, 8#E&+#$KQ.08&+s=&E&$,&+ Y*= +#$KQ.08&+ #=& 8#-Y (8#( *Y D.HH#U (8&P 0*,-K D=*6#6-P =&#--P %=*Q(8#(> "#P6& (8&P +8*,-K 08#$%& (8& $#'& (* fJ,'6PS+ C.HH# #$K 7#$KQ.08&+>g "#P6& (8&P0*,-K D&DD&= (8& 0#'D,+ Q.(8 Y-P&=+ #6*,( +#$KQ.08&+ #$K K=.$2+s(8#( Q*,-K 8&-D %=*Q (8&'*+( D=*Y.(#6-& D=*K,0(+ #'*$%+( (8& (Q* -#=%&+( +&%'&$(+s+(,K&$(+ #$K Y#0,-(PM +(#YY>

@-.+ $*%+'2$+8++ ).&:5# )06 0 5&% &4 $#+0) .+'+h#&+)*(% 90%%+' .&8 7'+0% %.+6 0'+D 1:% \*%+'2$+8+' $) 5&&C$*7 4&' /'+0%$2$%6 0*# 1'0$*)%&'9$*7 .+'+;B

1*+%3N4%O%3. Z8#(S+ &$*,%8 .K&#+> F&(S+ Y*0,+ *$ P*,= K=.$2+ .K&#> F&(S+ +#P (8#( J,'6PS+0,==&$(-P +&--+ &#08 K=.$2 Y*= c:M K=.$2> 7#P (8#( (8&P Q#$( (* K*,6-& (8&.= %=*++ '#=%.$+ (8=*,%8+&--.$% K=.$2+> A*Q '#$P K=.$2+ Q*,-K (8&P 8#E& (* +&-- (* K* (8#([

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U #( (8& 6&%.$$.$% *Y (8& 0#+&U P*, +#.K (8#( (8&.= #$$,#- =&E&$,&+ Q&=& c:39

"T> <( -**2+ -.2& Y=*' &]8.6.( B (8#( (8&.= %=*++ '#=%.$+ =.%8( $*Q #=& #=*,$K ?9_bb.+ (8#(#6*,( =.%8([

1*+%3N4%O%3. 7,=&U B4_ .+ #6*,( =.%8(sX,+( (* '#2& .( &#+.&=>

1*+%3N4%O%%. 7*U (8&.= 0,==&$( D=*Y.(+ #=& B4_ *Y c:39 "TU Q8.08 .+ #6*,( c94 "T> <$ *=K&= (*K*,6-& (8#(U (8&P Q*,-K $&&K (* '#2& c94 "T '*=& .$ D=*Y.(+ *$ K=.$2+> <Y (8& '#=%.$+ *$ K=.$2+#=& 9?_ #( c:M K=.$2U (8&$U (8#( Q*,-K '&#$ (8#( (8&P Q*,-K $&&K (* +&-- #6*,( :44 '.--.*$ '*=&K=.$2+ &#08 P&#=> ^.%8( $*QU (8&PS=& +&--.$% #6*,( ? '.--.*$ K=.$2+t +*U (8#( +&&'+ =&#--P#'6.(.*,+s&E&$ *E&= # ?b9 P&#= (.'& 8*=.H*$>

1*+%3N4%O%3. ^.%8(U +* Q8#( K*&+ (8#( (&-- P*,[

1*+%3N4%O%%. \&--U (8& .$.(.#- V,&+(.*$ .$ (8& 0#+& Q#+; +8*,-K (8& CO 0-.&$( 6,P J,'6PS+ D.HH#[Z8& 2&P V,&+(.*$ (8#( Q& $&&K&K (* #$+Q&= Q#+; #=& (8&=& 3b? Y&#+.6-& .K&#+ (8#( 0*,-K K*,6-&%=*++ '#=%.$+ .$ ?b9 P&#=+> \& -**2&K #( %=*Q.$% D=*Y.(#6.-.(P *$ (8& =&E&$,&+ +.K&U #$K Q8.-& .(-**2+ -.2& (8&=&S+ =**' Y*= J,'6PS+ (* %=*Q =&E&$,&+s#$K D=*Y.(+s.$ 0,+(*'&= +&%'&$(+ -.2&Y#0,-(PM +(#YY #$K (*Q$ Y*-2 (8=*,%8 8.%8-P D=*Y.(#6-& D=*K,0(+ -.2& K=.$2+ #$K +#$KQ.08&+U (8&%=*Q(8 (8#( Q*,-K 6& $&&K&K (* '&&( (8& 0-.&$(S+ (.'& 8*=.H*$ #$K .$E&+('&$( 8,=K-& K*&+$S(+&&' Y&#+.6-&>

1*+%3N4%O%3. 7*[

Documents

Columbia 20061