Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    1/62

    Cognitive-behavioural

    therapy

    Aninformation

    guideNeil A. Rector, PhD, CPsych

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    2/62

    i

    Cii-baira

    rapy

    Airmai

    idNeil A. Rector, PhD, CPsych

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    3/62

    ii Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    Library and Archives Canada Cataloguing in Publication

    Rector, Neil A.

    Cognitive-behavioural therapy : an inormation guide / Neil Rector.Issued also in French under title: Thrapie cognitivo-comportementale.Includes bibliographical reerences.Issued also in electronic ormats.ISBN 978-1-77052-294-7

    1. Cognitive therapy. I. Centre or Addiction and Mental Health II. Title.RC489.C63R43 2010 616.89142 C2010-904213-1

    isbn: 978-1-77052-294- 7(print)

    isbn: 978-1-77052-295-4(pdf)isbn: 978-1-77052-296-1 (html)

    isbn: 978-1-77052-297-8(epub)

    pm087

    Printed in CanadaCopyright 2010 Centre or Addiction and Mental Health

    No part o this work may be reproduced or transmitted in any orm or by any means

    electronic or mechanical, including photocopying and recording, or by any inormationstorage and retrieval system without written permission rom the publisherexcept ora brie quotation (not to exceed 200 words) in a review or proessional work.

    This publication may be available in other ormats. For inormation about alternateormats or other CAMH publications, or to place an order, please contact Sales andDistribution:Toll-ree: 1 800 661-1111Toronto: 416 595-6059E-mail: [email protected]

    Online store: http://store.camh.netWebsite: www.camh.net

    Disponible en ranais sous le titre :Thrapie cognitivo-comportementale : Guide dInormation

    This guide was produced by the ollowing:Development: Michelle Maynes, camhEditorial: Diana Ballon, Jacquelyn Waller-Vintar, camhGraphic design: Nancy Leung, Mara Korkola, camh

    Print production: Christine Harris, camh

    3973c / 10-2010 / PM087

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    4/62

    Cognitive-behavioural therapy : an inormation guide iii

    Contents

    Ab ar v

    Ackwdm v

    Irdci vi

    1 What is cognitive-behavioural therapy? 1Introducing cbt

    What happens in cbt?

    What conditions can cbt treat?

    Why is cbt an eective therapy?

    2 The basics o cognitive-behavioural therapy 6

    The nature o automatic thoughtsEvaluating automatic thoughts

    Patterns in automatic thoughts

    Identiying distortions in automatic thoughts

    Rules and assumptions

    Core belies

    3 CBT approaches to cognitive change 14Identiying relations between thoughts, moods

    and behaviours

    Questioning and evaluating negative automatic thoughts

    Identiying and correcting cognitive distortions

    Recording your thoughts

    Targeting assumptions and belies

    Behavioural experiments

    4 CBT approaches to behavioural change 24Sel-monitoringExposure therapy

    Behavioural experiments

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    5/62

    i Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    5 CBT in practice: Questions and answers 33How will I know icbt is or me?

    How can I nd a qualied cbt therapist in my area?

    What can I expect on my rst visit with a cbt therapist?

    What happens in a cbt session?

    How can I get the most out ocbt between sessions?

    How long does cbt last?

    How requent are the sessions?

    Do I need to prepare or cbt sessions?

    Will the cbt therapist be able to understand and appreciate

    my own unique background?Is cbt an eective treatment or children and adolescents?

    What are the common barriers that come up in cbt?

    Should I start treatment with medications or cbt or both

    in combination?

    How can I stay well ater nishing cbt?

    6 Alternative cognitive-behavioural approaches 41

    Mindulness therapy and mindulness-basedcognitive therapy

    Acceptance and commitment therapy

    Dialectical behavioural therapy

    Meta-cognitive therapy

    Rrc 46

    Rrc 47

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    6/62

    Cognitive-behavioural therapy : an inormation guide

    Ab ar

    Neil A. Rector, PhD, CPsych, is a clinical psychologist and research

    scientist at Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre in Toronto. He is a

    ounding ellow o the Academy o Cognitive Therapy (USA) and is

    an active clinician, educator and researcher in the area o cognitive-

    behavioural therapy. Dr. Rector is also the author o two other

    inormation guides in this series: Anxiety Disorders and Obsessive-

    Compulsive Disorder.

    Ackwdm

    Thanks to the many people who reviewed and commented on

    earlier drats o this guide. Reviewers included Diana Ballon,

    Eva Dipoce, Lori Douglas, Alexander Roseneld and Krystyna

    Walko. Proessional reviewers included Lance Hawley, PhD,

    CPsych, Judith Laposa, PhD, CPsych, and Sandra L. Mendlowitz,

    PhD, CPsych.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    7/62

    i

    Irdci

    This inormation guide is or people who may be considering or

    currently participating in cognitive-behavioural therapy (cbt) as

    a treatment, either alone or with medications or another orm o

    psychotherapy. The guide is also or people who want to better

    understand cbt to help them support a amily member or riend.

    The aim o this guide is to provide an easy-to-read introduction toa rich and complex therapy. The guide describes the nature and

    process ocbtwhat it is and what it involves. It also outlines the

    goals ocbt and the tasks used in therapy to help people reach

    those goals. For a better understanding o the many aspects o this

    orm o psychotherapy, the guide should be read rom cover to

    cover; however, some readers may preer to dip into parts o the

    book that are o particular interest.

    Details in the examples in this guide have been altered to protect

    client anonymity.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    8/62

    Cognitive-behavioural therapy : an inormation guide 1

    1 Wa i cii-baira rapy?

    For much o the 20th century, the dominant orm o psychotherapy

    was psychoanalysis. This approach involved seeing a therapist sev-

    eral times a week, oten or years. Then, in the 1970s, an explosion

    o dierent approaches to psychotherapy began to appear. Many o

    these were short term, lasting only weeks or months.

    In 1979, Time magazine reported that there were almost 200 di-

    erent types o psychotherapy. As o 2010, there are thought to be

    between 400 and 500 types. However, when directly compared,

    only a handul o therapy approaches have been shown to be highly

    eective or the kinds o problems people usually seek help or,

    such as depression, anxiety, phobias and stress-related problems.O the many therapies available, cognitive-behavioural therapy(cbt)

    is increasingly identied as the gold standardthat is, the best

    type o therapy or these diculties. This conclusion is supported

    by more than 375 clinical trial studies since 1977 and also by current

    international treatment guidelines, which are based on the collective

    knowledge o experts in the eld. For instance, the National Institute

    o Mental Health (nimh

    ) in the United States and the NationalInstitute or Health and Clinical Excellence (nice) in the United

    Kingdom have concluded that among the available psychological

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    9/62

    2 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    treatments or anxiety and depression, cbt is recommended as the

    rst-line psychological treatment.

    CBT has been shown to be eective or people o all ages, rom early

    childhood to older adults, and or people o dierent levels o educa-

    tion and income and various cultural backgrounds. It has also been

    shown to be eective when used in individual or group ormats.

    Introducing CBT

    CBT is an intensive, short-term (six to 20 sessions), problem-oriented

    approach. It was designed to be quick, practical and goal-oriented

    and to provide people with long-term skills to keep them healthy.

    The ocus ocbt is on the here-and-nowon the problems that comeup in a persons day-to-day lie. cbt helps people to look at how they

    interpret and evaluate what is happening around them and the

    eects these perceptions have on their emotional experience.

    Childhood experiences and events, while not the ocus ocbt, may

    also be reviewed. This review can help people to understand and

    address emotional upset that emerged early in lie, and to learnhow these experiences may infuence current responses to events.

    According to cbt, the way people eel is linked to the way they

    think about a situation and not simply to the nature o the situation

    itsel. This idea is rooted in ancient Eastern and Western philoso-

    phies and became part o a mainstream psychotherapy approach

    in the early 1960s. Aaron T. Beck, the ather ocbt

    , described thenegative thinking patterns associated with depression (i.e., critical

    thoughts about onesel, the world and the uture) in his early writ-

    ings. He also outlined ways to target and reduce negative thoughts

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    10/62

    3What is cognitive-behavioural therapy?

    as a way to improve mood. In later work, Beck and his colleagues

    ocused on the content and processes o thought related to anxi-

    ety and ways to treat anxiety problems. Since its creation, cbt has

    expanded into one o the most widely used therapeutic approaches.

    What happens in CBT?

    In cbt, you learn to identiy, question and change the thoughts,attitudes, belies and assumptions related to your problematic

    emotional and behavioural reactions to certain kinds o situations.

    By monitoring and recording your thoughts during situations that

    lead to emotional upset, you learn that the way you think can con-

    tribute to emotional problems such as depression and anxiety. In

    cbt, you learn to reduce these emotional problems by:

    identifying distortions in your thinking

    seeing thoughts as ideas about what is going on rather than as

    acts

    standing back from your thinking to consider situations from

    dierent viewpoints.

    For cbt to be eective, you must be open and willing to discuss

    your thoughts, belies and behaviours and to participate in exer-

    cises during sessions. For best results, you must also be willing to

    do homework between sessions.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    11/62

    4 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    What conditions can CBT treat?

    CBT is an eective treatment or many psychological conditions.

    These include:

    mood disorders, such as depression and bipolar disorder

    anxiety disorders, including specic phobias (e.g., fear of animals,

    heights, enclosed spaces), panic disorder, social phobia (social

    anxiety disorder), generalized anxiety disorder, obsessive-compul-sive disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder

    bulimia nervosa and binge eating disorder

    body dysmorphic disorder (i.e., body image)

    substance use disorders (i.e., smoking, alcohol and other drugs).

    CBT can also be used to help people with:

    psychosis

    habits such as hair pulling, skin picking and tics

    sexual and relationship problems

    insomnia

    chronic fatigue syndrome

    chronic (persistent) pain

    long-standing interpersonal problems.

    A similar ramework is used to treat dierent emotional problems

    in cbt; however, the approach and strategies vary and are tailored

    to address each specic problem.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    12/62

    5What is cognitive-behavioural therapy?

    Why is CBT an eective therapy?

    CBT is an eective therapeutic approach because it:

    is structured

    is problem-focused and goal-oriented

    teaches proven strategies and skills

    emphasizes the importance of a good, collaborative therapeutic

    relationship between the therapist and client.

    In describing how cbt works, the ocus o this guide will be on

    how it applies to treating people experiencing emotional distress.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    13/62

    6 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    2 t baic cii-baira rapy

    Most oten, people think o their distress as emerging directly

    rom events and situations in their lives: I had an argument with

    my partner this morning and I am still angry, My boss criticized

    my work and I eel so deeated or I read the business section o

    the paper this morning, saw that my stock was down, and elt veryanxious. In each example, the person highlights how the situation

    has causedhis or her emotional upset.

    situation emotional reaction

    However, what you eel in response to a situation is determined

    not only by the situation, but also by the way youperceive the situ-ation or make meaning o it. This way o seeing your emotional

    reaction as determined by what you think about a situation is a

    basic assumption o the cognitive-behavioural approach.

    For example, i you are ast asleep at 3:00 a.m. and you are woken

    by a crashing sound at your bedroom window, the way you respond

    to the situation will dier, depending on what you think is happen-ing. I you think it is an intruder, you are likely to eel ear and ter-

    ror and respond by rushing out o the room to saety. I you think

    that it must be your roommate (assuming you have one) coming

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    14/62

    7The basics o cognitive-behavioural therapy

    in through the window because he or she has orgotten the key

    (again!), you will likely eel rustration and annoyance and respond

    by arguing with your roommate. Finally, i you think it may be your

    romantic partner coming over or a late night rendezvous, you will

    likely eel and act with excitement.

    The nature o automatic thoughts

    In each previous example, the event is the same: a loud noise at the

    window at 3:00 a.m. However, you could have a dierent, quick

    thought to evaluate the situation, or what is reerred to in cbt as

    an automatic thoughta thought that pops into your mind and

    shapes the particular emotion experienced (e.g., ear, annoyance,

    excitement) and the resulting behaviour (e.g., escape, conronta-

    tion, warm greeting).

    More than the situation itsel, it is these pop-up, automatic

    thoughts that lead to your emotional and behavioural reactions.

    situation automatic emotional/behavioural

    thoughts reactions

    Evaluating automatic thoughts

    Automatic thoughts are usually so brie and quickly overridden by

    your awareness o the emotions that ollow rom them that you

    may not even notice them.

    The ability to notice and evaluate your automatic thoughts when

    you are in the midst o upsetting situations is one o the core skills

    learned and practiced in cbt. In cbt, you learn to ask yoursel,

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    15/62

    8 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    What was going through my mind when I noticed eeling emo-

    tionally upset?

    Try this cbt exercise now: Think o a time earlier in the day or in

    the past couple o days when you elt some kind o emotional up-

    set, such as anxiety, sadness or anger. Now, try to remember what

    you were thinking about at the time. As you recall your thoughts

    during this event, you may become more aware o automatic

    thoughts that were going through your mind that you had not

    noticed at the time.

    Identiying your automatic thoughts helps you to clariy the nature

    o the resulting emotion and understand why the situation was so

    upsetting.

    Patterns in automatic thoughts

    When people begin to monitor and record their automatic

    thoughts, they oten recognize apattern. In his earliest writings on

    cbt in the 1960s, Aaron T. Beck ound that patients who were de-

    pressed oten reported having automatic thoughts characterized by

    negative perceptions o themselves (Im worthless), o the worldaround them (Nobody likes me), and o the uture (Im hopeless

    and cant change). This pattern o thinking was termed the cogni-

    tive triad o depression.

    Becks later writings rom the 1980s described a pattern o auto-

    matic thoughts that seemed to be more uniquely related to anxiety,

    with clients reporting more thoughts related to threat and danger(What i something terrible happens?) and the inability to cope

    (Im overwhelmed, I cant go on like this).

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    16/62

    9The basics o cognitive-behavioural therapy

    While everyone has their own way o seeing situations and events

    in their lives, when people experience depression or anxiety the

    content o their automatic thoughts begins to take on a predictable

    and characteristic orm.

    A goal ocbt is to help you become aware o your automatic

    thoughts and to learn to stand back and question, evaluate and

    correct inaccurate, negative automatic thoughts. However, cbt is

    nottrying to teach positive thinking as a solution to lies problems.

    Rather, the goal is or you to learn to evaluate your experiences

    and problems rom dierent perspectivespositive, negative and

    neutralto arrive at accurate conclusions and creative solutions to

    your diculties.

    Identiying distortions in automaticthoughts

    A second eature o negative automatic thoughts in people with

    emotional distress is that they tend to refect distortions or errors

    in thinking. For example, the person who thinks that I will never

    nd a partner because o one unsuccessul date is catastrophizing

    the outcome o this date and is more likely to experience excessive

    emotional upset than the person who thinks This date didnt go

    well but hopeully things will go better next time. In another ex-

    ample, a student who concludes that a low mark on a recent exam

    means that he is stupid and a ailure is labellinghimsel and

    thinking in all-or-nothingterms, and is more likely to be distressed

    than a student who thinks, I didnt do as well as I would have liked

    but Ill seek out extra help and study harder next time.

    Distortions in thinking exaggerate the emotional signicance o

    common, everyday events. One aim ocbt is to help you become

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    17/62

    10 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    more aware o distortions in your perception o day-to-day experi-

    ences, especially when you are very upset.

    Everyone has negative automatic thoughts that pop up in the fow

    o consciousness, and most o us have cognitive distortions rom

    time to time. However, some people are more likely to have auto-

    matic thoughts related to depression and anxiety, and to have more

    cognitive distortions. The cbt approach suggests that automatic

    thoughts are infuenced by two deeper levels o thinking, which

    can make people more vulnerable to having recurrent negative and

    distorted thinking patterns. These deeper levels are known as rules

    and assumptions and core belies.

    Rules and assumptions

    From early childhood, you learn certain rules and assumptions

    through your interactions with amily members and the world

    around you. For instance, you may learn rules about:

    how to relate with others (e.g., If you dont have anything nice to

    say, then dont say anything at all)

    the acceptability of expressing emotions (e.g., Dont ever let themsee you sweat)

    your performance (e.g., If you cant do something perfectly, then

    its not even worth trying or I should be great at everything I do).

    These rules and assumptions may not be obvious to you and re-

    main out o your awareness. However, when you begin to monitor

    your automatic thoughts in upsetting situations, you become awareo patterns in your automatic thoughts that are linked to your un-

    derlying rules and assumptions.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    18/62

    11The basics o cognitive-behavioural therapy

    For example, i you hold an underlying assumption that you must

    be the best at everything you do, you are more likely to be distressed

    by a less than optimal outcome (e.g., ailed test, lost promotion,

    unsuccessul job interview) than someone who does not hold

    this assumption.

    Automatic thoughts can arise from underlying rules and assumptions.

    situation automatic emotional/behavioural

    thoughts reactions

    assumptions/rules

    CBT aims to help you become more aware o your own rules and

    assumptions and how these contribute to a pattern o negative

    automatic thoughts in emotionally upsetting situations.

    Core belies

    At the deepest level o cognition, even deeper than your rules and

    assumptions, are your core belies. Core belies usually develop

    early in lie. They refect rigid and absolute notions about yoursel,

    others and the world. Examples o positive core belies are Im

    attractive, Im smart and Im loveable. Examples o negative

    core belies are Im worthless or Im weak; others are danger-

    ous and not to be trusted; and the world is a scary place and

    overwhelming.

    Aaron T. Beck suggested that people with negative core belies are

    more at risk o developing depression or anxiety than people with

    positive core belies. Negative core belies may be inactive and not

    aect a persons lie until a stressul lie event, such as a death in

    the amily, a break-up or job loss activates these belies. For example,

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    19/62

    12 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    a woman who has a core belie that she is unlovable may also

    believe that i she works hard to please her partner, he may love her

    anyway. However, i her partner breaks up with her, her core belie

    o being unlovable may be reactivated, and increase her vulner-

    ability to depression or anxiety.

    situation automatic emotional/behavioural

    thoughts reactions

    assumptions/rules

    core beliefs

    A basic assumption ocbt is that people can learn to identiy,

    evaluate and change their assumptions and core belies, just

    as they are able to identiy and change their negative automatic

    thoughts. When you begin to reduce negative assumptions andbelies, you also begin to have ewer negative and distorted auto-

    matic thoughts. Reducing the negative underlying assumptions

    and core belies that give rise to your emotional problems lessens

    your emotional upset and also oers you some protection rom

    becoming depressed and anxious again.

    In summary, cbt is dierent rom many other therapeutic approach-es because it ocuses on helping you learn to identiy the relation-

    ship between your thoughts, eelings and behaviours. While each

    o these are interdependent (they all serve to infuence each other),

    cbt gives special attention to the role o cognition (automatic

    thoughts, rules and assumptions and core belies) in creating and

    maintaining emotional diculties such as depression and anxiety.

    CBT aims to help you identiy, evaluate and change your habitual

    thinking patterns at each o these levels o cognition. Working with

    the therapist, you learn that assigning less extreme, more helpul

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    20/62

    13The basics o cognitive-behavioural therapy

    and more accurate meanings to negative events leads to less

    extreme and less disturbing emotional and behavioural responses.

    Once you have learned these skills in therapy, you will become

    your own therapist, with the ability to manage dicult experiences

    and emotional upset on your own.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    21/62

    14

    3 CBt apprac cii ca

    Automatic thoughts pop up all the time in everyones minds. Some

    o these thoughts are positive, some are neutral and some are neg-

    ative. The ones that are o particular interest in cbt are the negative

    automatic thoughts that relate to periods o intense moods. An

    early aim ocbt is to help you learn to identiy negative automaticthoughts and cognitive distortions in problematic situations. This

    skill can be learned relatively quickly by some people, while or oth-

    ers it will take practice and require patience.

    Identiying relations between thoughts,moods and behaviours

    The rst step toward identiying automatic thoughts and cognitive

    distortions in problematic situations is or you to discuss recent

    upsetting situations with your cbt therapist. This discussion helps

    you to learn about the relationship between your thoughts, moods

    and behaviours, as in the ollowing example:

    Therapist: Can you think o a situation in the past week when

    you elt upset?

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    22/62

    15CBT approaches to cognitive change

    Peter: I was sitting on the subway and noticing all o the couples

    together.

    Therapist: And what eelings came up or you as you were notic-

    ing the couples?

    Peter: I was eeling sad and angry.

    Therapist: And what were you thinking about as you were eeling

    sad and angry?

    Peter: I was thinking everyone seems to have someone in their lie

    but me, and its just not air.

    Therapist: And i its true that everyone seems to have someone

    but you, do you think this says something about you?

    Peter: Yah, that Im a loser and will always be alone.

    Therapist: And what did you do when you were thinking and

    eeling this way?

    Peter: Ater a while I couldnt take it anymore so I got o the

    subway even though I hadnt reached my stop yet. I went home

    and just sat on my bed thinking about all o this.

    In this example, the ollowing elements are identied:

    Situation: On the subway, noticing couples

    Moods: Sad and angry

    Thoughts: Everyone has someone but me, it isnt air, Im a loser, Iwill be alone orever.

    Behaviours: Escape rom subway, return home to ruminate

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    23/62

    16 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    This example shows that to understand why Peter was eeling sad

    and angry, we need to understand what he was thinking:

    that he does not have a relationship and really wants to be in one

    that it does not seem fair to him that everyone else seems to get

    what he desires so much in his lie

    that because he does not have someone now, he will never nd

    someone and will always be alone.

    As an exercise, try to think o a situation in the past week that was up-

    setting. Please take a moment to see i you can identiy the ollowing:

    Situation: _________________________________________________

    (Where were you? Were you with anyone?)

    Moods: ___________________________________________________

    (What were you eeling?)

    Thoughts: ______________________________________________

    (What was going through your mind?)

    Behaviours: ______________________________________________

    (What did you do? How did you cope?)

    Questioning and evaluating negativeautomatic thoughts

    As you learn to identiy your negative automatic thoughts, you will

    also learn to question and evaluate these thoughts. A main goalocbt is to help you learn to see your thoughts as ideas that do not

    necessarily refect reality. In other words, just because you think

    something does not always mean it is true.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    24/62

    17CBT approaches to cognitive change

    To help you move toward this goal, the therapist will direct you

    through cognitive restructuring exercises. In these exercises,

    you will learn to stand back and question your negative automatic

    thoughts and to evaluate the evidence that either supports or does

    not support the thoughts. You will then be able to draw conclu-

    sions about the accuracy o your thoughts.

    A cbt therapist working with Peter in the previous example might

    ask him the ollowing questions:

    Do you know anyone that you like and respect who is not cur-

    rently in a relationship?

    Do you have any past experiences in romantic relationships?

    If you had a good friend that had the same thoughts about him-

    sel or hersel, what would you say to that riend?

    Are you possibly discounting any life experiences to suggest that

    you will not be completely alone?

    Are you potentially blaming yourself for something that you do

    not have complete control o?

    The goal here is not to challenge Peters thinking but rather to

    move him to a questioning mode and to consider the accuracy o

    his automatic thoughts based on evidence rom his lie.

    Identiying and correcting cognitivedistortions

    Identiying and changing negative automatic thoughts related to

    strong eelings also involves learning to identiy distortions orerrors in thinking as you experience or recall upsetting situations.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    25/62

    18 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    Distortions in thinking are more likely to occur when you eel dis-

    tressed. This is because emotional distress can wear you down, and

    eeling worn down tends to make people more reliant on shortcuts

    or more simplistic ways o thinking. Everyone has distortions in

    thinking at times. Below are some types o distortions in thinking

    (Burns, 1999), with examples to illustrate what they look like:

    All-or-nothing (black-and-white) thinking: When you see things as

    either black or white with no grey area in between (e.g., Amina

    nished the term with three A+s, two As and one B+ and is think-

    ing that because she did not ace all her courses she is a ailure).

    Disqualiying the positive: When you discount positive experiences

    and continue to ocus only on the negative (e.g., Josh is a devoted

    ather who helps his son with homework every night and spends

    as much time with him as possible on the weekends. Recent

    business travel has kept him away rom home more than usual,

    leading him to conclude that he is a lousy ather).

    Overgeneralization: When you see a single event as something

    that will never end (e.g., Ingrid elt anxious in the meeting at

    work and now concludes that she will never be able to interact

    with her colleagues comortably).

    Mental flter: When you pay attention to a small negative detail in

    an experience so that it takes on great importance (e.g., Dwight

    is speaking to a group o 10 youth at his church and continually

    ocuses his attention on one person who seems disinterested in

    what he has to say rather than the other nine who seem quite

    engaged).

    Catastrophizing: When you think o the worst case scenariothat

    is, you assume that a situation will be more awul or horrible than

    it is likely to be (e.g., Susan awakes one morning and notices a

    rash on the back o her leg. Rather than thinking o all the actorsthat could have contributed to the rash, she quickly concludes

    that she has skin cancer and rushes to the doctor).

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    26/62

    19CBT approaches to cognitive change

    Mind reading: When you jump to conclusions thinking that some-

    one is thinking o you negatively beore you have all o the acts

    (e.g., Guy walks into a movie theatre and as he goes to sit down,

    he trips and stumbles and spills his popcorn and drink. He thinks

    that everyone must be thinking that hes a total loser).

    Personalization: When you see events not going well as a result o

    something about you (e.g., Charmaine is hosting a party and sees

    that two guests are sitting quietly on their own. She begins to

    think it must be her ault that they are not having a good time).

    Recording your thoughts

    Early in treatment, the cbt therapist will question you in ways that

    help you to identiy and question your negative automatic thoughts

    and cognitive distortions. As you progress, the therapist will askyou to use the thought recordbetween sessions as homework. With

    practice, you will become skilled at using the thought record to re-

    cord, question and evaluate your automatic thoughts and to reduce

    emotional distress in your day-to-day lie.

    The best time to do the thought record is soon ater the situation or

    event that causes distress. This is when you are most aware o thethoughts related to your experience. However, sometimes this is

    dicult; or instance, i the problem comes up at work or at other

    times where it would be inconvenient or where your privacy would

    be compromised. When this is the case, try to nd a time later the

    same day to record the details, beore they ade, and to help you

    eel better about the situation sooner, rather than later.

    The rst three columns o the thought record (shown in Table 1) are

    used to record the situation that you were in when you began to

    experience a strong emotion, the automatic thoughts related to the

    event or experience, and the strength o your emotional reaction.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    27/62

    20 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    The example in Table 1 shows how a client named Nancy reported

    on the experience o anxiety when thinking about an upcoming

    event:

    tab 1. t rcrd: eamp

    situation automaticthoughts

    emotions

    tiki abdrii p r ca

    I am i aa paic aack widrii

    ery wi b arywi m

    I w b ab cpwi iai

    Far (80%)

    Once Nancy listed her automatic thoughts, the next step was or

    her to consider the evidence that supported and did not support

    her thoughts and to evaluate their accuracy, as shown in Table 2.

    tab 2. eaai idc

    evidence for: evidence against:

    F r dri p ra im.

    e I r, I did a a -dd paic aack.

    Pp did m mwa p by ac a I p my i

    ri i my rm ar dria im.

    e I wa cmrab,I wa i ab dri ad I

    r ay.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    28/62

    21CBT approaches to cognitive change

    evidence for: evidence against:

    My byrid wi b drii wim ad i ry dradiad ppri ad w arywi m.

    I a rad f r im iyar wi ay aiy a a.

    e i I d ry ai ada a paic aack, I kw a i

    i dar m. I wi cpby ryi caarpi aiy.

    By evaluating the evidence supporting or not supporting the negative

    automatic thoughts, both through discussion with her therapist

    and through the use o the thought record, Nancy was able to arrive

    at a more balanced alternative appraisal o the situation. As is otenthe case or everyone, just a little bit o new inormation led Nancy

    to a dierent and less upsetting interpretation o the situation.

    Targeting assumptions and belies

    As therapy progresses, the cbt therapist will introduce other cogni-tive strategies and homework worksheets to target your underlying

    assumptions and core belies.

    One way to identiy your core belies and assumptions is to use your

    thought records to identiy specic situations that lead to emotional

    distress, and to look or themes that recur. The cbt therapist can

    then help you to question and evaluate these assumptions andbelies and to generate less distressing, alternative viewpoints as

    they occur in upsetting situations.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    29/62

    22 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    Another way assumptions and belies are targeted or change in

    cbt is to write down a negative core belie on one side o the page,

    or example, unlikeable and an alternative, less distressing

    belie that you would preer to hold about yoursel, or example,

    likeable on the other side o the page. You would then be asked

    to keep track o your experiences over the week, noting instances

    where the negative or positive belie seemed to be supported. In

    situations where you collected evidence to support the negative

    belie, you would also be asked to review the situation careully

    or supporting and contrary evidence to arrive at a more balanced

    perspective.

    BehAvIouRAl exPeRIMents

    A powerul tool or questioning and evaluating underlying

    assumptions and core belies is to test their validity with behav-ioural experiments. For instance, i you had an underlying

    assumption that I I make a mistake everyone will laugh and

    ridicule me, you might be asked to perorm an experiment to

    determine what actually happens when mistakes are made. O

    course, you will only conduct experiments that you think you

    are ready or, and ater you have developed strategies to cope

    with the ull range o possible outcomes rom these types oexperiments.

    When you are ready, you may, or example, be asked to make a mis-

    take on purpose, such as to go into a store and drop change while

    in line, or to spill a drink in a caeteria. This will allow you to see

    the extent to which: a) people notice, b) people respond (e.g., do

    others laugh and ridicule you as eared or alternatively, do peoplenot seem to notice or criticize you), and c) how well you can cope

    with the situation.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    30/62

    23CBT approaches to cognitive change

    In summary, the initial ocus ocbt is to help you identiy and

    change negative automatic thoughts that lead to emotional distress

    in problematic situations. You learn skills to identiy and correct

    negative automatic thoughts and the cognitive distortions that uel

    strong moods. The main tool or cognitive change is the thought

    record. Other cognitive strategies are used to consolidate progress

    with changing negative automatic thoughts and the deeper assump-

    tions and belies. These include:

    examining the advantages and disadvantages of holding such

    belies

    examining the evidence that supports and does not support the

    assumptions and belies

    trying to nd less extreme, more middle-ground views of oneself,

    others and the world

    performing behavioural experiments.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    31/62

    24

    4 CBt apprac baira ca

    So ar, we have ocused on the C ocbt, which reers to changing

    the cognitive aspects, or thinking, that can lead to emotional dis-

    tress. We now move on to the B in cbt, which reers to changing

    the behaviours that can worsen and prolong negative moods.

    Changes in thinking and behaviours go hand in hand: When you

    change the way you think about a situation or problem, your behav-

    iours may also change. The reverse is also true: When you change

    how you approach a situation or problem, you may come to think

    dierently about it. For instance, i you smoke, and some new

    inormation leads you to believe that smoking is more dangerous

    to your health than you once thought, this may lead you to quitsmoking (i.e., cognitive change leads to behavioural change). Or, to

    turn it around, i you go or a week without smoking because you

    are sick or unable to smoke, it could lead you to think, I I can go

    a week without smoking, maybe I could go a month. This think-

    ing could lead to a new behavioural goal o trying to quit smoking

    or a month (i.e., behavioural change leads to cognitive change).

    CBT uses a variety o behavioural methods and strategies to reduce

    your distress, which are introduced on the ollowing pages.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    32/62

    25CBT approaches to behavioural change

    Sel-monitoring

    Chapter 3 outlined the use o thought records to identiy and evalu-

    ate negative thoughts and cognitive distortions. Thought records

    are one type o sel-monitoring strategy that you will be asked to do

    in cbt. You may also be asked to do other orms o sel monitoring,

    such as:

    monitoring your moods or feelings of pleasure or mastery day byday, perhaps rating them on a scale rom zero to 10 or zero to 100

    monitoring symptoms of your problem in specic situations

    scheduling activities or monitoring your progress with a behav-

    ioural goal; or instance, planning or recording how many times

    you exercised at the gym in the past week.

    selF-MonItoRIng DAY BY DAY

    By keeping track o problems as they occur day by day, people

    become more aware o the specic situations that tend to activate

    their distress. The monitoring orms used in cbt help people be-

    come more tuned in to the particular type o reactions they have to

    dicult situations. For instance, do certain events tend to activate

    eelings such as sadness, anxiety, anger, hurt or disappointment?

    Monitoring orms are also used to help people become more aware

    o the intensity o their moods. For instance, does one situation

    oten lead to low levels o anxiety, while another situation always

    leads to extremely high levels o anxiety?

    Finally, monitoring orms are not just used to track problems;they are also used to help people become more aware o how well

    they are doing. For instance, monitoring orms can be used to

    rate the degree o success people have achieved toward reaching

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    33/62

    26 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    a behavioural goal, or to track their experience o pleasure or mastery

    (i.e., achievement and skill) during certain events and tasks.

    People with depression and other emotional problems that aect

    motivation tend to become less involved or engaged in activities.

    When they do engage in an activity, they tend to report less enjoy-

    ment than they actually elt at the time they were doing the activity.

    One way or people to get a better idea o how they spend their

    days and how much pleasure and sense o mastery they derive

    rom each activity is to keep track o what they do and how they elt

    at the time. I you have problems with motivation, keeping track o

    your activities can help you recognize that you can get more pleasure

    and mastery rom doing things than rom not doing them. In simple

    terms, doing things, even small things, can help you to eel better.

    An activity schedule lists the days o the week across the top and

    the hours o the day down the let side. Your therapist may ask you

    to record your activities hour to hour and to make pleasure and

    mastery ratings on a scale rom zero to 10, as seen in the example

    o a partially completed schedule in Table 3 below.

    tab 3. Wky aciiy cd wi par rai

    monday tuesday wednesday

    78 a.m. g p, ad c

    P (par) 2;M (mary) 0

    g p, rad papr ad madbraka

    P 4; M 4

    g p, akd rid ra

    P 6; M 0

    89 a.m. tk d r

    a wak

    P 3; M 3

    tk d r

    a wak

    P 2; M 3

    tk d r a

    qick wak, rd ca

    P 1; M 5

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    34/62

    27CBT approaches to behavioural change

    910 a.m. tk b ca

    P 0; M 4

    M dy rp wrk

    prai

    P 2; M 8

    Add ca

    P 5; M 6

    1011a.m.

    Add ca

    P 2; M 7

    sam Add 2d ca

    P 7; M 8

    11 sam Add 3rd ca

    P 6; M 4

    1p.m.

    M rid rc

    P 6; M 1

    Rrd m,mad ayc

    P 4; M 7

    12 p.m. Add ca

    P 5; M 7

    Ca p

    adry

    P 0; M 7

    selF-MonItoRIng sYMPtoMs

    Specialized orms to help you monitor and track your symptoms

    throughout treatment are available or virtually all clinical problemsin cbt. The process o closely monitoring and recording your

    experiences can in itsel improve your mood and well-being, and

    so this is usually encouraged ollowing the rst cbt session.

    I you are seeking help or anxiety, you may be asked to complete

    monitoring orms to record the precise symptoms o anxiety

    depending on the particular anxiety problem you are experiencing.For example, i you are seeking help or social anxiety, you will be

    asked to complete a monitoring orm that will ask you to record

    social or perormance situations in the past where you elt anxious.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    35/62

    28 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    I you are seeking help or obsessive-compulsive disorder, you will

    record the nature and distress associated with obsessive thoughts

    throughout the week as well as the requency and duration o com-

    pulsive rituals.

    Table 4 provides an example o a symptom monitoring orm that

    is tailored or panic attacks. This orm allows you to record all o

    the symptoms experienced during a panic attack over the week

    between sessions.

    tab 4. Paic aack miri rm

    situation:

    Ra aiy riy:

    sympm (tick a pricd):

    q Accrad ar ra

    q C pai r dicmr

    q Dii

    q Paria (mb)

    q trmbi r akiq sai r bra

    q Bi

    q swai

    qnaa / rwi mac

    qMc i

    qDry m

    q Iabiiy ra

    q R

    q Fai

    qDicmrq sp difci

    q Irriabiiy r ar br

    qDifcy ccrai

    qhypriiac r dar

    q earad ar rp

    n Mdra I

    0 5 10

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    36/62

    29CBT approaches to behavioural change

    sCheDulIng ACtIvItIes

    The same schedule used in Table 3 to monitor activities and makepleasure and mastery ratings may also be used to help you sched-

    ule. One use is to schedule activities that you may have been avoid-

    ing. This can help to remove indecisiveness around whether or not

    you should do an activity. For instance, i you decide in advance

    that you will go to the gym between 5:00 p.m. and 6:00 pm on

    Tuesday, you are more likely to go than i you wait to decide based

    on how you eel that day.

    The therapist may also ask you to schedule both pleasurable activities

    (e.g., lunch with a riend) and mastery tasks (e.g., organizing and

    paying bills) or the upcoming week. You will likely also be asked to

    keep track o your automatic thoughts during your weekly activities

    to help you identiy distortions or other appraisals that minimize

    or undermine your pleasure or sense o mastery in the activity.

    A urther use o the activity schedule is to help you recognize the

    barriers to completing tasks and to break down these tasks into

    smaller units to make the tasks less distressing and more likely

    to be accomplished. Graded tasks can then be constructed where

    you schedule the easier steps o the task beore getting to more

    complicated and challenging parts o the task. Simply changing thestructure and the approach to tasks in this way can create remark-

    able changes in the likelihood that you will accomplish tasks.

    Exposure therapy

    A standard component ocbt treatment or anxiety is exposure

    therapy. Exposure therapy works to reduce your ear o certain

    things (e.g., insects, snakes) or situations (e.g., closed spaces,

    heights) by gradually increasing your exposure to the eared thing

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    37/62

    30 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    or situation. To begin, you may be asked to imagine or look at pic-

    tures o that eared thing or situation (indirect exposure) and then

    gradually increase your exposure until you are able to touch the

    thing or experience the situation (direct exposure).

    With gradual exposure to your ears, your anxiety decreases and

    you learn that your ears are excessive and irrational. This process

    is called habituation. Figure 1 shows that as the number o expo-

    sures to the eared thing or situation increases, the level o anxiety

    produced by exposure decreases.

    Fir 1. habiai cr i pr rapy

    Exposure therapy usually starts with exposure to situations that

    create only mild-to-moderate ear and gradually progress to situa-

    tions that create higher levels o anxiety. Beore starting exposure

    therapy, you will complete a hierarchy o your ears, listing all othe situations that trigger your anxiety and the dierent levels o

    anxiety associated with each trigger. In the example o a completed

    hierarchy o ear in Table 5, a person who ears coming into contact

    Exposure 5-8

    Exposure 3-5

    Exposure 1-2

    Anxiety

    Time

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    38/62

    31CBT approaches to behavioural change

    with beetles rates situations involving beetlesrom mildly dis-

    tressing to most distressing.

    tab 5. hirarcy ard iai: eamp

    FEARED SITUATION

    (midy diri m diri)

    DISTRESS

    (10100)

    viw car drawi b, c i 10

    viw p ra b, c i 20

    sad i rm wi ma b, wak wii f

    b

    30

    Wak wii ma b 40

    sad i rm wi ar b, wak wii f

    b

    50

    Wak wii ar b 60tc ma b wi fr 70

    Aw ma b craw arm 80

    tc ar b wi fr 90

    Aw ar b craw arm 100

    At rst you will complete exposure tasks with the help o the

    therapist. Later, as you progress, you will be asked to do them on

    your own as homework between sessions. The rate at which you

    progress in treatment will depend on the severity o your ear and

    on your ability to tolerate the discomort associated with arousing

    your anxiety. Exposure tasks need to be repeated and last long

    enough (usually not less than 30 minutes) to result in optimalimprovements. You learn that anxiety comes down naturally when

    you remain in the ear-provoking situation long enough.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    39/62

    32 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    Behavioural experiments

    Behavioural experiments were described on page 22 as a way o

    testing your underlying assumptions and belies. Behavioural

    experiments ask you to act out a eared situation to see i what you

    ear might happen does happen. Should the eared outcome occur,

    the experiments will also enable you to see how well you cope with

    the situation.

    These tasks are behavioural because they require that you test out

    new ways o thinking by doing something dierently, oten by go-

    ing into situations and choosing a dierent behavioural strategy.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    40/62

    33

    5 CBt i pracic:Qi ad awr

    Answers to requently asked questions about cbt, such as how to

    nd a therapist and what to expect in treatment, are outlined below.

    How will I know i CBT is or me?

    Most people know within the rst ew sessions i they are comort-

    able with cbt and whether it is meeting their treatment needs.

    The therapist will also check to see that cbt is the right t or

    you. When the t is not quite right, the therapist may adjust the

    treatment or suggest other treatment options. However, in general,

    cbt may be a good therapy option or you i:

    you are interested in learning practical skills to manage your

    present, day-to-day lie and associated emotional diculties

    you are willing and interested in practising change strategies

    (homework) between sessions to consolidate improvement.

    CBT may not be or you i you want to ocus exclusively on past is-

    sues, i you want supportive counselling, or i you are not willing to

    do homework between sessions.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    41/62

    34 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    How can I fnd a qualifed CBT

    therapist in my area?

    To nd the contact inormation or certied cbt therapists in

    Canada and the United States, consult the ollowing resources:

    Academy of Cognitive Therapies

    www.academyoct.org

    Association for Behaviour and Cognitive Therapies

    www.abct.org

    What can I expect on my frst visit witha CBT therapist?

    At your rst visit, you and the cbt therapist will discuss:

    the nature and causes of your difculties and factors that could be

    maintaining them

    how the therapist will apply the cbtmodel to your specic problems

    how the tasks that you will do in therapy can work to change dif-

    erent aspects o the problems what you want to get out of treatment

    whether cbt is a suitable treatment approach or you

    whether other treatment approaches might be called for, either

    instead o or in addition to cbt.

    By the end o this rst visit, you and the therapist will have devel-

    oped a goal-oriented treatment plan to address your diculties.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    42/62

    35CBT in practice: Questions and answers

    What happens in a CBT session?

    CBT sessions can be given to clients individually or in groups. Both

    ormats ollow the same predictable structure, as ollows:

    Mood check: The therapist asks about your mood since the

    previous session. This may include the use o scales to assess

    depression, anxiety or other emotional problems. The purpose

    o the mood check is to see i your mood improves rom sessionto session.

    Bridge: The focus of the previous session is reviewed to create a

    bridge to the current session.

    Agenda: The therapist and client identify issues to address in the

    current session that will act as the agenda.

    Homework review: Homework from the previous session is re-

    viewed to note progress and troubleshoot any diculties that mayhave emerged.

    Agenda items: Agenda issues are addressed using cognitive and

    behavioural strategies.

    New homework: Exercises and tasks for the upcoming week are

    assigned.

    Summary and client feedback: Wrap up of the session.

    How can I get the most out o CBTbetween sessions?

    CBT is a treatment approach that teaches you skills to become your

    own therapist over time. You learn new skills in the therapy ses-sions, but ultimately much o the change occurs between therapy

    sessions when practising the skills in your own environment as

    part o homework. Early in treatment, the cbt therapist will suggest

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    43/62

    36 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    homework, such as monitoring thoughts and behaviours, taking

    steps to reduce avoidance behaviour, conducting experiments to

    test out predictions and completing worksheets to challenge nega-

    tive thoughts or belies. As treatment progresses, you will learn to

    set your own homework between sessions to help you accomplish

    your treatment goals. Research demonstrates that the more you

    successully practise the skills ocbt in your homework, the better

    the treatment outcome.

    How long does CBT last?

    CBT is a time-limited, ocused treatment approach. For problems

    such as anxiety and depression, cbt usually involves 12 to 20 ses-

    sions. However, the length o treatment can vary, depending on the

    severity and complexity o your problemssome clients improvesignicantly in our to six sessions, while others may need more

    than 20 sessions. Hospital-based programs targeting specic prob-

    lems are usually 12 to 15 sessions.

    How requent are the sessions?

    CBT usually starts out with weekly sessions. As treatment pro-

    gresses, sessions may be spaced urther apart, such as every two

    weeks or month. Once people have nished a course ocbt, it is

    common or them to return or occasional booster sessions to

    keep up their progress, deal with any setbacks and prevent relapse

    o problems. Again, hospital-based programs are typically pre-set

    (e.g., a group meeting weekly at the same time or 12 weeks) andare less fexible in terms o scheduling and spacing sessions than

    community-based cbt therapists.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    44/62

    37CBT in practice: Questions and answers

    Do I need to prepare or CBT sessions?

    Preparing to discuss a specic problem at each session helps you

    to get the most out ocbt. Coming prepared helps to keep you o-

    cused on your goals or therapy. It also helps to build a therapeutic

    relationship between you and your therapist and to communicate

    well throughout the session.

    Will the CBT therapist be able tounderstand and appreciate my ownunique background?

    Research on cbt demonstrates that it is an eective treatment

    regardless o gender, race, ethnicity, culture, sexual orientation or

    social economic status. cbt therapists are trained to recognize the

    importance o cultural values and to adapt their treatments to meet

    culturally unique needs. They are trained, or example, to:

    be aware of their own personal values and biases and how these

    may infuence their relationship with the client

    use skills and intervention strategies that are culturally appropri-ate or the person being seen

    be aware of how certain cultural processes may inuence the

    relationship between the therapist and client.

    As a client in cbt you should eel that you can openly discuss

    aspects o your culture or sexual orientation, or example, and that

    your treatment will be delivered in a manner that is consistentwith these values.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    45/62

    38 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    Is CBT an eective treatment or

    children and adolescents?

    CBT has been adapted or use with children and has been shown

    in research to be an eective intervention or a variety o clinical

    problems that can emerge in childhood, including anxiety and

    depression. The content and pacing o the therapy is adjusted to

    be appropriate or the childs level o development. Oten, the cbt

    therapist will work with the parent and childthe younger the

    child, the more involved the parent will be in learning and deliver-

    ing cbt strategies or their childs problem.

    What are the common barriers that

    come up in CBT?Barriers to treatment can include:

    perceived stigma associated with mental health treatment

    difculty identifying and distinguishing emotions and their

    intensity

    difculty in reecting on thoughts difculty tolerating heightened emotions

    not completing homework

    nancial constraints

    chronic conditions and multiple difculties

    low optimism toward improving

    avoiding treatment sessions.

    The therapist will work with you to reduce these barriers and will

    also oer strategies that you can use to overcome barriers.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    46/62

    39CBT in practice: Questions and answers

    Should I start treatment with

    medications or CBT or both incombination?

    Many people who seek treatment or emotional diculties in

    Canada are rst treated by their amily doctor with one or more

    medications (e.g., antidepressants) beore cbt is considered. Not

    much research has been done to show whether it is best to starttreatment with medication or cbt or both. However, research has

    shown that cbt, with or without certain types o medications, is

    equally eective or the treatment o anxiety problems, and that

    cbt and medications together are best or treating severe depres-

    sion and psychosis. Importantly, taking these kinds o medications

    has not been shown to interere with cbt, and in some instances

    may help people to get more out o the therapy.

    There is, however, one class o medication commonly prescribed

    to people with anxiety problems, known as benzodiazepines, which

    can potentially limit the benets ocbt. Medications in this class

    include clonazepam (Rivotril), alprazolam (Xanax) and lorazepam

    (Ativan). While these medications can rapidly relieve and control

    anxiety in the short term, they can also make it harder to learn newthings, which is essential to benet rom cbt and reduce anxiety in

    the long run. I you are taking these medications and are about to

    start cbt, your cbt therapist will want to review the advantages and

    disadvantages o continuing with these medications during cbt

    treatment.

    When considering or startingcbt

    , discuss all o your questionsor concerns about your medications with your cbt therapist and/

    or your prescribing medical doctor. Medications can be monitored

    and discussed throughout treatment and adjusted depending on

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    47/62

    40 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    your progress in cbt. Note that recommendations or changes to

    your medication can only be made by your prescribing doctor. I

    your cbt therapist is not a doctor, he or she canwith your per-

    missioncommunicate with your doctor to help ensure that you

    receive the optimal combination o treatments.

    How can I stay well ater fnishing

    CBT?

    A major goal ocbt is or you to become your own therapist and to

    continue to practise cbt skills even ater you are eeling better. You

    may also wish to return or ollow-up or booster sessions rom

    time to time. A key component ocbt treatment is teaching relapse

    prevention strategies. This includes helping you learn to identiy

    the triggers and early signs o relapse and to develop an action plan

    to prevent downward spirals o negative emotions.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    48/62

    Cognitive-behavioural therapy : an inormation guide 41

    6 Arai cii-baira apprac

    O the hundreds o psychological treatments available, several are

    closely related to cbt, but have distinct approaches. Although the

    eectiveness o these alternative cbt approaches is not as well

    proven as the mainstream approach described so ar in this guide,

    the our introduced on the ollowing pages have been ound to beeective in helping people with certain types o problems. Overall,

    they all share a common goal o helping people learn how to let

    go o ocusing on and reacting to their thoughts.

    Mindulness therapy and mindulness-based cognitive therapy

    Mindulness techniques can be used to help people distance them-

    selves rom their negative thinking and recognize that thoughts do

    not have to determine behaviours. Mindulness is a state o aware-

    ness, openness and receptiveness that allows people to engage ully

    in what they are doing at any given moment. Mindulness skillsare mainly taught through meditation; however, other experiential

    exercises (e.g., walking or eating with awareness) can also be used

    to teach these skills.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    49/62

    42 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    Mindulness skills can be broken down into three categories:

    Deusion: distancing onesel rom and letting go o unhelpul

    thoughts, belies and memories.

    Acceptance: accepting thoughts and eelings without judgment,

    simply allowing them to come and go rather than trying to push

    them out o awareness or make sense o them.

    Contact in the present moment: engaging ully in the here-and-now

    with an attitude o openness and curiosity.

    Mindulness skills promote reedom rom the tendency to get

    drawn into automatic negative reactions to thoughts and eelings.

    Mindulness techniques have been used in the treatment o

    chronic pain, hypertension, heart disease, cancer, gastrointestinal

    disorders, eating disorders, anxiety disorders and substance use

    disorders. Mindulness-based cognitive therapy has been ound to

    be eective in reducing relapse to depression.

    Acceptance and commitment therapy

    While some therapies attempt to change upsetting thoughts andeelings, acceptance and commitment therapy (act) helps people

    to simply notice and accept thoughts and eelings in the present

    moment.

    ACT views psychological suering as being caused by avoiding or

    evaluating thoughts and eelings, which in turn can lead to ways

    o thinking that interere with our ability to act consistently withimportant personal values. The ocus oact is on helping people

    accept what is out o their personal control while committing to

    doing what is within their control to improve their quality o lie.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    50/62

    43Alternative cognitive-behavioural approaches

    ACT aims to help people handle the pain and stress that lie inevi-

    tably brings and to create a rich, ull and meaningul lie. People

    learn how to deal with painul thoughts and eelings in ways that

    have less impact and infuence over their lives. For example, they

    learn to:

    distance themselves from upsetting thoughts (cognitive defusion)

    accept experiences in the present moment

    discover important and meaningful personal values

    set goals consistent with these values

    commit to take action.

    ACT has been ound to be eective in treating depression, anxiety,

    stress, chronic pain and substance use disorders.

    Dialectical behavioural therapy

    Dialectical behavioural therapy (dbt) is an eective treatment or

    people with excessive mood swings, sel-harming behaviour and

    other interpersonal problems related to the expression o anger.

    DBT has an individual and a group component. In individual therapy,the therapist and client ollow a treatment target hierarchy to guide

    their discussion o issues that come up between weekly sessions.

    First priority is given to sel-harming and suicidal behaviours, then

    to behaviours that interere with therapy, and next to improving

    the clients quality o lie. The quality-o-lie improvement part o

    the therapy involves identiying skills that the person has but is not

    using to ull advantage, to teaching new skills, and to discussingobstacles or using those skills. Weekly group therapy ocuses on

    acquiring new skills.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    51/62

    44 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    Clients keep diary cards to help monitor their use o the skills and

    have access to 24-hour phone consultation with their therapist.

    The our modules odbt are core mindulness, emotion regulation

    (e.g., identiying and labelling emotions and reducing vulnerability

    to negative emotions), interpersonal eectiveness (e.g., assertive-

    ness skills) and distress tolerance skills (e.g., crisis survival skills

    such as distracting, sel-soothing and improving the moment).

    Meta-cognitive therapy

    Meta-cognitive therapy (mct) was rst developed to treat general-

    ized anxiety disorder and is now also used to treat other anxiety

    disorders and depression.

    Metacognition is the aspect o cognition that controls mental

    processes and thinking. Most people have some direct conscious

    experience o metacognition. For example, when a name is on the

    tip o your tongue, metacognition is working to inorm you that

    the inormation is somewhere in memory, even though you are

    unable to remember it.

    People with depression or anxiety oten eel as though they have

    lost control over their thoughts and behaviours. Their thinking and

    attention become xed in patterns o brooding and dwelling on

    themselves and on threatening inormation. They develop cop-

    ing behaviours that they believe are helpul, but that can actually

    worsen and prolong emotional distress. This pattern o thinking is

    called cognitive-attentional syndrome (cas

    ).

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    52/62

    45Alternative cognitive-behavioural approaches

    In mct, people learn to reduce the cas by developing new ways o

    controlling their thinking and attention and o relating to depressive

    or anxious thoughts and belies. They also learn to modiy the

    belies that give rise to the cas.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    53/62

    46 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    Rrc

    Burns, D.D. (1999). The Feeling Good Handbook: The New Mood

    Therapy. New York: HarperCollins.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    54/62

    Cognitive-behavioural therapy : an inormation guide 47

    Rrc

    Hundreds o sel-help and proessional books on cbt are available.

    Listed below are a ew examples. Many o the web links listed later

    in this section provide an even broader list o reading and work-

    book options.

    CBT sel-help books or anxiety anddepression

    AnxIetY DIsoRDeRs (ADults)

    Antony, M.M. & Norton, P.J. (2009). The Anti-Anxiety Workbook:

    Proven Strategies to Overcome Worry, Panic, Phobias, and Obsessions.

    New York: Guilord Press.

    Bourne, E.J. (2003). Coping with Anxiety: 10 Simple Ways to Relieve

    Anxiety, Fear & Worry. Oakland, CA: New Harbinger.

    AnxIetY DIsoRDeRs (ChIlDRen)

    Rapee, R.M., Spence, S.H., Cobham, V., Wignall, A. & Lyneham,

    H. (2008). Helping your Anxious Child: A Step-by-Step Guide or

    Parents, 2nd ed. Oakland, CA: New Harbinger.

    DePRessIonGreenberger, D. & Padesky, C.A. (1995). Mind Over Mood: Change

    How You Feel by Changing the Way You Think. New York: Guilord

    Press.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    55/62

    48 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    Knaus, B.J. (2006). The Cognitive Behavioral Workbook or Depres-

    sion: A Step-by-Step Program. Oakland, CA: New Harbinger.

    geneRAl AnxIetY DIsoRDeR

    Craske, M.G. & Barlow, D.H. (2006). Mastery o Your Anxiety and

    Worry (2nd ed.). New York: Oxord. (See also accompanying thera-

    pist manual.)

    Meares, K. & Freeston, M. (2008). Overcoming Worry: A Sel-Help

    Guide Using Cognitive Behavioral Techniques. New York: Basic Books.

    oBsessIve-CoMPulsIve DIsoRDeR

    Abramowitz, J.S. (2009). Getting overocd: A 10-Step Workbook or

    Taking Back Your Lie. New York: Guilord Press.

    Hyman, B.M. & Pedrick, C. (2005). The ocd Workbook: Your Guide

    to Breaking Free rom Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (2nd ed.). Oak-

    land, CA: New Harbinger.

    PAnIC DIsoRDeR

    Antony, M.M. & McCabe, R.E. (2004). 10 Simple Solutions to Panic:

    How to Overcome Panic Attacks, Calm Physical Symptoms, and Reclaim

    Your Lie. Oakland, CA: New Harbinger.

    Wilson, R. (2009). Dont Panic: Taking Control o Anxiety Attacks

    (3rd ed.). New York: HarperCollins.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    56/62

    49Resources

    PosttRAuMAtIC stRess DIsoRDeR

    Rothbaum, B.O., Foa, E.B. & Hembree, E.A. (2007). ReclaimingYour Lie rom a Traumatic Experience (Workbook). New York:

    Oxord. (See also accompanying therapist manual.)

    soCIAl AnxIetY DIsoRDeR

    Markway, B.G., Pollard, C.A., Flynn, T. & Carmin, C.N. (1992).

    Dying o Embarrassment: Help or Social Anxiety and Phobia. New

    York: New Harbinger.

    Stein, M.B. & Walker, J.R. (2009). Triumph over Shyness: Conquer-

    ing Social Anxiety Disorder (2nd ed.). Silver Spring, MD: Anxiety

    Disorders Association o America.

    CBT sel-help books or other disorders

    AttentIon DeFICIt DIsoRDeR

    Saren, S.A., Sprich, S., Perlman, C.A. & Otto, M.W. (2005). Mas-

    tering Your Adultadhd: Client Workbook. A Cognitive-Behavioral

    Treatment Program. New York: Oxord University Press. (See also

    accompanying therapist manual.)

    BoDY DYsMoRPhIC DIsoRDeR

    Claiborn, J. & Pedrick, C. (2002). The bdd Workbook: OvercomeBody Dysmorphic Disorder and End Body Image Obsessions. Oakland,

    CA: New Harbinger.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    57/62

    50 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    BoDY-FoCuseD IMPulsIve DIsoRDeRs

    Franklin, M.E. & Tolin, D.F. (2007). Treating Trichotillomania:Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy or Hair Pulling and Related Problems.

    New York: Springer.

    eAtIng DIsoRDeRs

    McCabe, R.E., McFarlane, T.L. & Olmstead, M.P. (2004). Overcom-

    ing Bulimia: Your Comprehensive, Step-By-Step Guide to Recovery.

    Oakland, CA: New Harbinger.

    hYPoChonDRIAsIs AnD heAlth AnxIetY

    Asmundson, G.J.G. & Taylor, S. (2005). Its Not All In Your Head:

    How Worrying About Your Health Could Be Making You Sick andWhat You Can Do About It. New York: Guilord.

    sChIzoPhRenIA

    Beck, A.T., Rector, N.A., Stolar, N. & Grant, P. (2008). Schizophre-

    nia: Cognitive Theory, Research, and Therapy. New York: Guilord

    Press.

    sleeP DIsoRDeRs

    Edinger, J.D. & Carney, C.E. (2008). Overcoming Insomnia: A

    Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy Approach Workbook. New York: Oxord

    University Press. (See also accompanying therapist manual).

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    58/62

    51Resources

    suBstAnCe use DIsoRDeR

    Daley, D.C. & Marlatt, D.C. (2006). Overcoming Your Alcohol orDrug Problem: Eective Recovery Strategies (2nd ed.). New York:

    Oxord University Press. (See also accompanying therapist manual.)

    CBt WIth DIveRse PoPulAtIons

    Hays, P. & Iwamasa, G. (Eds.). (2006). Culturally Responsive

    Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy: Assessment, Practice, and Supervision.

    Washington, DC: American Psychological Association Press.

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    59/62

    52 Cognitive-behavioural therapy : An inormation guide

    Internet resources

    Academy o Cognitive Therapy

    www.academyoct.org

    American Psychiatric Association

    www.psych.org

    American Psychological Associationwww.apa.org

    (Click Psychology Topics, then A-Z Topics, then Therapy.)

    Association or Behavioral and Cognitive Therapies

    www.abct.org

    Canadian Mental Health Associationwww.cmha.ca

    Centre or Addiction and Mental Health

    www.camh.net

    Counselling Resource

    http://counsellingresource.com

    Royal College o Psychiatrists

    www.rcpsych.ac.uk/deault.aspx

    (Click Mental Health Ino, then Treatments, then cbt.)

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    60/62

    Cognitive-behavioural therapy : an inormation guide 53

    or id i i ri

    Addiction

    Anxiety Disorders

    Bipolar Disorder

    Borderline Personality Disorder

    Concurrent Substance Use and Mental Health Disorders

    Couple Therapy

    Depressive Illness

    First Episode Psychosis

    The Forensic Mental Health System in Ontario

    Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder

    Schizophrenia

    Women, Abuse and Trauma Therapy

    Women and Psychosis

    To order these and other camh publications, contact:

    camh Publications

    Tel: 1 800 661-1111 or 416 595-6059 in Toronto

    E-mail: [email protected]

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    61/62

  • 7/30/2019 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: an information guide

    62/62

    cognitive-behavioural therapy (cbt) is a widely

    recommended treatment for depression, anxiety and other

    emotional problems. cbt works on the assumption that the

    way you think can contribute to your emotional problems.

    In cbt, you learn to identify, question and change distorted

    and negative thinkingto see thoughts as ideas rather

    than as facts, and to stand back from your thoughts and

    consider situations from different points of view. You

    also learn to change behaviours related to negative moods.

    Ultimately, cbt teaches you to become your own therapist.

    This guide provides a brief, easy-to-read introduction to

    the principles, process and strategies ofcbt. The book is

    written for people who are considering or starting out in

    cbt, for family members and friends who would like to

    know more about the treatment, and for anyone else with

    an interest in cbt.

    This publication may be available in other formats.For information about alternate formats or otherCAMH publications, or to place an order, pleasecontact Sales and Distribution:Toll-free: 1 800 661-1111

    Toronto: 416 595-6059E-mail: [email protected] store: http://store.camh.net

    Website: www.camh.net

    Disponible en franais.