Upload
mithilesh-singh
View
219
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
1/19
Symbiosis Centre for Management andHuman Resource Development (SCMHRD)
A constituent of Symbiosis International UniversityAccredited by NAAC with A Grade
Ex-MBA 2010-2013 Batch II
Semester -3
Subject : Capital and Money Markets
CMM Assignment-3: Choose 12 stocks which are not in financial
sector.Calculate cost of carry for first 9 months on monthly basis. Explain
methodology and interpretation of cost of carry.
UNDER THE GUIDANCE OF
Prof. G.Bhaskar
Submitted By
Mithileshkumar Singh
Roll No-2010G20
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13
1
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
2/19
Executive Summary
Following twelve non financial sector companies are considered for the assignment.
1. Asian Paints Ltd
2. Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited
3. CIPLA Limited
4. DABUR India Limited
5. Mahindra & Mahindra Limited
6. Maruti Suzuki India Limited
7. MRF Limited
8. Siemens India
9. Tata Chemicals
10. Tata Motors
11. Tata Global Beverages Limited
12. Voltas Limited
Methodology : Close prices (Spot Price ) and Settle prices (Future Price ) were collected from
the nseindia website for above twelve companies. Close prices and settle prices data were
collected monthly wise (Average taken for one month ) for the 9 months. (January 2011 to
September 2011 ).Expiry period of 90 days were selected.Difference between future price and
spot price will result into cost of carry.
Cost of Carry : Costs incurred as a result of an investment position. These costs can includefinancial costs, such as the interest costs on bonds, interest expenses on margin accounts and
interest on loans used to purchase a security, and economic costs, such as the opportunity costs
associated with taking the initial position.
Cost to carry may not be an extremely high financial cost if it is effectively managed. For
example, the longer a position is made on margin, the more interest payments will need to be
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13
2
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
3/19
made on the account.When making an informed investment decision consideration must be given
to all of the potential costs associated with taking that position.
Cost of Carry = r + s
Where, r = Interest Rate
S = Storage Cost
Relation between future price and spot price are explained by the following equation .
P ( future ) = P (Spot ) ( 1 + r + s )
Where , P (future ) = Future Price
P ( Spot ) = Spot Price
Standardization is highly essential in the future market.In general, the future price is greater than the
spot price.In Special cases,when the cost of carry is negative,the future price may be lower than the
spot prices.
Among all these 12 companies, the cost of carry is high for the MRF limited.
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13
3
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
4/19
Company -1 : Asian Paints Ltd.
MonthClose Prices
(Rs.)
Future Prices
(Rs.)Expiry
Cost of Carry = Future
Price - Close Price
(Rs.)
Jan-11 2703.24 2762.61 March 31,2011 59.37
Feb-11 2504.68 2552.67 April 28,2011 47.99
Mar-11
2525.89 2575.8 May 26,2011 49.91Apr-11
2602.56 2652.16 June 30,2011 49.6
May-112844.13 2893.68 July 28,2011 49.55
Jun-113082.28 3140.31 August 25,2011 58.03
Jul-113163.91 3225.39 September 29,2011 61.48
Aug-113183.65 3235.09 October 25,2011 51.44
Sep-113144.58 3200.83 November 24,2011 56.25
Herethe future price is greater than the spot price.Cost of carry is moderare for Asian Paints.Asian paints is
successfully able to maintain the cost of carry.
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 4
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
5/19
Company -2 : Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited
MonthClose Prices
(Rs.)
Future Prices
(Rs.)Expiry
Cost of Carry = Future
Price - Close Price
(Rs.)
Jan-11 2237.84 2277.17 March 31,2011 39.33
Feb-11 2094.29 2126.96 April 28,2011 32.67
Mar-11 2017.33 2050.63 May 26,2011 33.3
Apr-11 2135.51 2172.05 June 30,2011 36.54
May-11 2006.76 2037.87 July 28,2011 31.11
Jun-11 1941.12 1974.92 August 25,2011 33.8
Jul-11 1947.81 1958.64 September 29,2011 10.83
Aug-11 1756.97 1776.97 October 25,2011 20
Sep-11 1683.77 1696.05 November 24,2011 12.28
From July-2011 onwards,company is able to lower the cost of carry.
Company -3 : CIPLA Limited
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 5
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
6/19
Month Close Prices Future Prices Expiry
Cost of Carry = Future
Price - Close Price
Jan-11 351.245 358.78 March 31,2011 7.535
Feb-11 311.43 316.78 April 28,2011 5.35
Mar-11 303.57 309.37 May 26,2011 5.8
Apr-11 318.56 324.43 June 30,2011 5.87
May-11 310.75 315.35 July 28,2011 4.6
Jun-11 329.12 335.3 August 25,2011 6.18
Jul-11 321.54 327.56 September 29,2011 6.02
Aug-11 292.64 297.9 October 25,2011 5.26
Sep-11 283.57 288.37 November 24,2011 4.8
Cost of carry for CIPLA Limited is significantly low. Cost of carry is more for the month of January-2011
Company -4 : DABUR India Limited
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 6
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
7/19
MonthClose Prices
(Rs.)
Future Prices
(Rs.)Expiry
Cost of Carry = Future
Price - Close Price
(Rs.)
Jan-11 99.57 101.45 March 31,2011 1.88
Feb-11 94.94 96.68 April 28,2011 1.74
Mar-11 97.34 99.29 May 26,2011 1.95
Apr-11 101.03 102.88 June 30,2011 1.85
May-11 103.97 105.65 July 28,2011 1.68
Jun-11 114.34 116.51 August 25,2011 2.17
Jul-11 111.39 113.5 September 29,2011 2.11
Aug-11 105.09 106.89 October 25,2011 1.8
Sep-11 105.64 107.24 November 24,2011 1.6
Cost of carry is very low for Dabur India.Company is successfully able to lower the cost of carry by
lowering the interest rate and storage cost.
Company -5 : Mahindra & Mahindra Limited
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 7
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
8/19
Cost of carry is high for the month of January-2011 and has lowered significantly in the month of
May-2011
Company -6 : Maruti Suzuki India Limited
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 8
MonthClose Prices
(Rs.)
Future Prices
(Rs.)Expiry
Cost of Carry = Future
Price - Close Price
(Rs.)
Jan-11 750.825 766.14 March 31,2011 15.315
Feb-11 656.64 667.22 April 28,2011 10.58
Mar-11 665.54 678.4 May 26,2011 12.86
Apr-11 741.04 754.33 June 30,2011 13.29
May-11 691.33 699.93 July 28,2011 8.6
Jun-11 665.76 673.17 August 25,2011 7.41
Jul-11 715.85 727.59 September 29,2011 11.74
Aug-11 711.28 721.6 October 25,2011 10.32
Sep-11 791.5 804.3 November 24,2011 12.8
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
9/19
MonthClose Prices
(Rs.)
Future Prices
(Rs.)Expiry
Cost of Carry = Future
Price - Close Price
(Rs.)
Jan-11 1314.69 1334.2 March 31,2011 19.51
Feb-11 1199.38 1210.01 April 28,2011 10.63
Mar-11 1228.93 1243.07 May 26,2011 14.14
Apr-11 1285.48 1302.27 June 30,2011 16.79
May-11 1229.99 1233.22 July 28,2011 3.23
Jun-11 1191.44 1185.66 August 25,2011 -5.78
Jul-11 1171.93 1171.68 September 29,2011 -0.25
Aug-11 1183.16 1186.62 October 25,2011 3.46
Sep-11 1100.79 1110.87 November 24,2011 10.08
Negative cost of carry is observed in the month of June and July.Here the future prices are lower than the
spot prices.
Company -7: MRF Limited
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 9
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
10/19
MonthClose Prices
(Rs.)
Future Prices
(Rs.)Expiry
Cost of Carry = Future
Price - Close Price
(Rs.)
Jan-11 6713.81 6871.97 March 31,2011 158.16
Feb-11 5884.5 5997.32 April 28,2011 112.82
Mar-11 6335.13 6459.94 May 26,2011 124.81
Apr-11 6801.14 6930.39 June 30,2011 129.25
May-11 6899.85 7030.45 July 28,2011 130.6
Jun-11 6722.05 6847.81 August 25,2011 125.76
Jul-11 7364.01 7506.49 September 29,2011 142.48
Aug-11 6846.68 6974.39 October 25,2011 127.71
Sep-11 6911.82 7035.55 November 24,2011 123.73
Cost of carry is very high here.Company need to devised the strategy to lower the interest rate and storage
cost.
Company -8: Siemens India
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 10
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
11/19
MonthClose Prices
(Rs.)
Future Prices
(Rs.)Expiry
Cost of Carry = Future
Price - Close Price
(Rs.)
Jan-11 768.9 785.69 March 31,2011 16.79
Feb-11 844.81 852.34 April 28,2011 7.53
Mar-11 866.6 820.01 May 26,2011 -46.59
Apr-11 865.01 877.36 June 30,2011 12.35
May-11 860.02 875.91 July 28,2011 15.89
Jun-11 875.63 892.11 August 25,2011 16.48
Jul-11 913.04 930.73 September 29,2011 17.69
Aug-11 881 896.74 October 25,2011 15.74
Sep-11 858.08 873.43 November 24,2011 15.35
Cost of carry is moderate here.Negative cost of carry is observed in the month of March as future price is
lower than the spot price.
Company -9: Tata Chemicals
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 11
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
12/19
Cost of carry is significantly low for Tata Chemicals.
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 12
MonthClose Prices
(Rs.)
Future Prices
(Rs.)Expiry
Cost of Carry = Future
Price - Close Price
(Rs.)
Jan-11 377.68 386.15 March 31,2011 8.47
Feb-11 326.18 332.17 April 28,2011 5.99
Mar-11 327.12 333.6 May 26,2011 6.48
Apr-11 366.69 373.68 June 30,2011 6.99
May-11 364.89 370.2 July 28,2011 5.31
Jun-11 368.9 375.81 August 25,2011 6.91
Jul-11 376.97 384.11 September 29,2011 7.14
Aug-11 349.81 356.23 October 25,2011 6.42
Sep-11 329.14 335.04 November 24,2011 5.9
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
13/19
Company -10: Tata Motors
MonthClose Prices
(Rs.)
Future Prices
(Rs.)Expiry
Cost of Carry = Future
Price - Close Price
(Rs.)
Jan-11 1205.67 1216.96 March 31,2011 11.29
Feb-11 1144.9 1146.85 April 28,2011 1.95
Mar-11 1168.78 1162.1 May 26,2011 -6.68
Apr-11 1247.15 1247.51 June 30,2011 0.36
May-11 1160.91 1159.07 July 28,2011 -1.84
Jun-11 995.16 981.73 August 25,2011 -13.43
Jul-11 1008.06 1016.85 September 29,2011 8.79
Aug-11 802.88 809.18 October 25,2011 6.3
Sep-11 321.3 331.25 November 24,2011 9.95
Cost of carry is moderate except for the months- March,May and June.For these three months, the cost of carry
is negative as future prices are lower than the spot prices.
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 13
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
14/19
Company -11: Tata Global Beverages Limited
MonthClose Prices
(Rs.)
Future Prices
(Rs.)Expiry
Cost of Carry = Future
Price - Close Price
(Rs.)
Jan-11 105.93 108.2 March 31,2011 2.27
Feb-11 93.85 95.34 April 28,2011 1.49
Mar-11 96.53 98.47 May 26,2011 1.94
Apr-11 103.21 105.2 June 30,2011 1.99
May-11 95.19 97.03 July 28,2011 1.84
Jun-11 94.73 96.15 August 25,2011 1.42
Jul-11 102.98 104.52 September 29,2011 1.54
Aug-11 98.56 100.51 October 25,2011 1.95
Sep-11 90.49 92.1 November 24,2011 1.61
Cost of carry is significantly low here.
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 14
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
15/19
Company -12: Voltas Limited
Month Close Prices Future Prices ExpiryCost of Carry = Future
Price - Close Price
Jan-11 211.03 215.54 March 31,2011 4.51
Feb-11 171.63 174.94 April 28,2011 3.31
Mar-11 162.1 165.22 May 26,2011 3.12
Apr-11 176.01 179.26 June 30,2011 3.25
May-11 164.8 167.87 July 28,2011 3.07
Jun-11 162.31 165.32 August 25,2011 3.01
Jul-11 155.24 158.15 September 29,2011 2.91
Aug-11 125.47 127.78 October 25,2011 2.31
Sep-11 119.6 121.71 November 24,2011 2.11
Cost of carry is significantly low for the Voltas Limited.The future prices are higher than the spot prices
from January-2011 to September-2011
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 15
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
16/19
.
Bibliography
http://www.bseindia.com/
http://www.investopedia.com
Prof. G Bhaskars class notes
Annual Reports of Company
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 16
http://www.bseindia.com/http://www.investopedia.com/http://www.bseindia.com/http://www.investopedia.com/8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
17/19
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 17
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
18/19
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 18
8/3/2019 CMM Project 3 Final
19/19
Capital and Money Markets Ex-MBA 2010-13 19