16
Clean Columns Help: 1) You must Enable Macros in order for the spreadsheet "Clean Columns" to wo If the buttons on the worksheets don't work the Macros are not enabled. If you are not prompted as to whether or not you want to enable macros wh First, Excel's macro security may be too high. To correct this, select " The "Security" form will open. Choose the "Medium" or "Low" setting on th If the program still does not work, the second reason macros may not work as a virus and remove or disable them from the file. If this happens, th administrator for help in correcting these problems. 2) If you are getting errors while running Clean Columns such as "Path not F Set the Error Trapping Option in Excel's Visual Basic Editor to "Break on To do this go to the "Tools" menu, select "Macro" then "Visual Basic Edi You can also use Alt-F11 to open the window. Select "Tools" from the menu bar at the top, then select "Options". The Go to the "General" tab. Select "Break on Unhandled Errors" from the "Er

Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

  • Upload
    hadan

  • View
    221

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

Clean Columns Help:1) You must Enable Macros in order for the spreadsheet "Clean Columns" to work.

If the buttons on the worksheets don't work the Macros are not enabled.If you are not prompted as to whether or not you want to enable macros when you open Clean Columns, there are two possible reasons.First, Excel's macro security may be too high. To correct this, select "Tools" from the menu bar, then select "Macros", then "Security". The "Security" form will open. Choose the "Medium" or "Low" setting on the "Security Level" tab. Close then re-open Clean Columns.

If the program still does not work, the second reason macros may not work is that some anti-virus software will identify the macros in this spreadsheetas a virus and remove or disable them from the file. If this happens, the spreadsheet will not function properly. Contact your computeradministrator for help in correcting these problems.

2) If you are getting errors while running Clean Columns such as "Path not Found" or "Can't find Project or Library"Set the Error Trapping Option in Excel's Visual Basic Editor to "Break on Unhandled Errors"To do this go to the "Tools" menu, select "Macro" then "Visual Basic Editor". The Visual Basic Editor window will open.You can also use Alt-F11 to open the window.

Select "Tools" from the menu bar at the top, then select "Options". The "Options" form will open.Go to the "General" tab. Select "Break on Unhandled Errors" from the "Error Trapping" options.

Return to Main Sheet

Page 2: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

If you are not prompted as to whether or not you want to enable macros when you open Clean Columns, there are two possible reasons.First, Excel's macro security may be too high. To correct this, select "Tools" from the menu bar, then select "Macros", then "Security". The "Security" form will open. Choose the "Medium" or "Low" setting on the "Security Level" tab. Close then re-open Clean Columns.

If the program still does not work, the second reason macros may not work is that some anti-virus software will identify the macros in this spreadsheetas a virus and remove or disable them from the file. If this happens, the spreadsheet will not function properly. Contact your computer

If you are getting errors while running Clean Columns such as "Path not Found" or "Can't find Project or Library"

To do this go to the "Tools" menu, select "Macro" then "Visual Basic Editor". The Visual Basic Editor window will open.

Return to Main Sheet

Page 3: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

The Steel Solutions Center is your gateway to powerful tools, facts and project solutions.

Least weight is not least cost.

Least weight is not least cost.Least weight is not least cost.

Clean Columns V4.0 02/11/05

Talk to your favorite fabricator, or consult chapter 3 of Design Guide 13 for more information on the cost of stiffener and doubler plates.

Mu

Puc

Vus

PubMu

Pub

Beam/Girder

Puc

Vus

Column

Column Panel-ZoneLocation of Doubler Plates, if Required

Transverse Stiffeners,if Required

Clean Columns calculates the lightest column section required to eliminate stiffener and doubler plates.

Enter Now

toolssteel

Comments? Questions? Visit us online at www.aisc.org/ASKAISC or contact us at [email protected] or toll free at 866.ASK.AISC

Visit w w w .aisc.org/steeltools for our continuously expanding Steel Tools library.

What's New in Version 4.0?

View Help

Page 4: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

This spreadsheet has been prepared in accordance with information made available to the American Institute of Steel Construction, Inc., AISC Marketing, LLC, and the Steel Solutions Center, LLC at the time of its preparation. While it is believed to be accurate, it has not been prepared for conventional use as an engineering or construction document and should not be used or relied upon for any specific application without competent professional examination and verification of its accuracy, suitability and applicability by a licensed engineer, architect or other professional. AISC, AISCM, and SSC disclaim any liability arising from information provided by others or from the unauthorized use of the information contained in this spreadsheet.

Page 5: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

Project: 123 First Street Offices 5/10/2023

Client: AAARF Developers, Inc.

Engineer: John Smith

Remarks: Exterior Moment Frame, Long Direction, Typical interior column

1) Summary of Assumptions:

2) Connection Configuration:

Beams Connected on Both SidesBeams are not Connected Near the Top of the Column 0.00 inFlange-Plated w = 0.00 in

Flange Plate Thickness = 1.000 inBottom Plate Width = 2.00 in

Top Plate Width = 2.00 in

3) Beam Section:Beam Section: W18x50

244 kip-ft Allowable Moment

4) Forces and Material Properties:ASD-Unified Specification Equivalent

50 ksi Column Specified Minimum Yield Strength50 ksi Beam Specified Minimum Yield Strength

0 kips Column Story Shear 5) Resultant Forces (a positive value indicates compression)320 kips Column Axial Load 110 kips Total Panel-Zone Shear Force

10 kips Beam Axial Load, Right Side 110 kips Top Flange Force, Right Side

167 k*ft Beam Moment, Right Side -100 kips Bottom Flange Force, Right Side

0 kips Beam Axial Load, Left Side 0 kips Top Flange Force, Left Side0 k*ft Beam Moment, Left Side 0 kips Bottom Flange Force, Left Side

6) Column Design Results:

Lightest Lightest Lightest Lightest LightestW10 W12 W14 W16 W18

W10x68 W12x79 W14x74 W16x77 W18x71

W10x88 W12x87 W14x82 W16x77 W18x65

W10x88 W12x87 W14x82 W16x77 W18x71

Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column section that can be used without stiffeners and/or doubler plates to develop a specified percentage of a selected beam's plastic moment capacity, based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series #13 and the 1999 AISC Specification for Structural Steel Buildings. The design of the column for axial load capacity is not considered.

The effects of a composite concrete floor slab are not considered in the analysis. The connection is assumed to be part of a frame resisting wind or low seismic forces. In other words, the structure is designed to meet the requirements in the AISC Specification for Structural Steel Buildings with no special seismic detailing. The panel zone is assumed to remain nominally within the elastic range. Other assumptions apply. Review all the assumptions by clicking on the button above.

Fyc =Fyb =

(Vs)T =

(Pc)T = Vp =

(Pb)R = (Pf)TR =

MR= (Pf)BR =

No Stiffener Plates Required

No Doubler Plates Required

No Stiffener Plates or Doubler Plates Required

This spreadsheet has been prepared in accordance with information made available to the American Institute of Steel Construction, Inc., AISC Marketing, LLC, and the Steel Solutions Center, LLC at the time of its preparation. While it is believed to be accurate, it has not been prepared for conventional use as an engineering or construction document and should not be used or relied upon for any specific application without competent professional examination and verification of its accuracy, suitability and applicability by a licensed engineer, architect or other professional. AISC, AISCM, and SSC disclaim any liability arising from information provided by others or from the unauthorized use of the information contained in this spreadsheet.

Figure 1: Connection Configuration

(Pb)L =

ML =

Ma =

(Pf)TL =

(Pf)BL =

7) Column Calculations:

Page 6: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

Project: 123 First Street Offices 5/10/2023

Client: AAARF Developers, Inc.

Engineer: John Smith

Remarks: Exterior Moment Frame, Long Direction, Typical interior column

Clean Column Design Calculations for a W10x39 Column: ASD

I) Force Transfer in Unreinforced ColumnsA) Required Strength for Local Flange and Web Limit States Flange-Plated Connection:

Design for a W18x50 Beam 18.00 in Plate Thickness, = 1.00 inBeams on Both Sides 0.57 in Bottom Plate Width = 2.00 in

Right Side Left Side Top Plate Width = 2.00 inBeam Axial Load 10 kips 0 kips

Beam Moment 167 k*ft 0 k*ft

Beam Flange Forces (a positive value indicates compression) 19.00 in110 kips 0 kips

-100 kips 0 kips

1 Maximum Tension Force (Bottom Flange) 100 kips (Absolute Value)0 Maximum Compression Force (Top Flange) 110 kips (Absolute Value)

B) Required Strength for Panel-Zone ShearMoment Connected Beams on Both Sides

0 kips Column Story Shear110 kips Total Panel Zone Shear Force

Design Check for Column Section: W10x39

50 ksiDNA Distance (in) from the column end to the top of the top flange of the beam(s) or flange plate(s)

DNA Distance (in) from the column end to the bottom flange of the beam(s)A) Panel-Zone Shear Strength (LRFD Specification Section K1.7)

9.92 in 0.32 in 11.5320 kips345

0.92827 kips Panel-Zone Shear Design Strength

B) Local Flange Bending: Tensile Force (LRFD Sepcification Section K1.2)0.53 in Column Flange Thickness1.00 =

= 1.0 otherwise 7.9953 kips Local Flange Bending Design Strength 2

db =tbf =

(Pb)R =

MR =

dm = (Pf)TR =(Pf)BR =

Vs =Vp =

II) Design Strength of an Unreinforced Column

Fcy =dtop =dbot =

For Calculation Purposes, the behavior of the panel zone remains nominally within the elastic range.

dc = tcw = AC = in2

Pc = Column Axial Load, taken equal to (Pc)T

Py = kips (Py = FcyAc for LRFD and Py = 0.6FcyAc for ASD)Pc/Py =

Rv =

tf =0.5 if the distance from the end of the column to the closer face of the beam tension flange is less than 10tf

(Pf )TR=(Pb)R

2+M R

dm(Pf )TL=

(Pb)L2

−M L

dm

m

RRbBRf d

M2)(P)(P (Pf )BL=

(Pb )L2

+M L

dm

(Pf)TL =(Pf)BL =

(Pb)L =ML =

sBLfT Rfp V)P()(PV

dm = db+tp

tp

Rn=(0 . 91 .5 )x6 . 25( t f )

2F y xCt

Ct =

Rn = =

yc P0.4For P

y

cwcyv P

P1.4td0.6F

1.50.9R

Page 7: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

C) Local Web Yielding: Tensile and Compressive Forces (LRFD Specification Section K1.3)w = 0.00 in Leg size of fillet weld or groove weld reinforcementN = 1 in Length of Bearing, Flange plate thickness + 2w

0.32 in Column Web Thickness9.92 in Column Depth

1.0 =

= 1.0 otherwisek = 1.03 in

65 kips Local Web Yielding Design Strength

D) Web Crippling: Compressive Force (LRFD Specification Section K1.4)w = 0.00 in Leg size of fillet weld or groove weld reinforcementN = 1 in Length of Bearing, Flange plate thickness + 2w

0.32 in Column Web Thickness9.92 in Column Depth0.53 in Column Flange Thickness

1.0 =

= 1.0 otherwise

0.30 = 0.10 < 0.2

71 kips Web Crippling Design Strength

E) Compression Buckling of the Web: Compressive Force on Both Sides of the Column (LRFD Specification Section K1.6)0.315 in Column Web Thickness

9.92 in Column Depthk = 1.03 in

1.0 =

= 1.0 otherwiseh = 7.86 in

69 kips Compression Buckling Design Strength

W10x39

110 kips 27 kipsDoubler Plates are Required! 416% of Column Capacity

65 kips

71 kips

69 kips110 kips 65 kips

Stiffener Plates are Required! 171% of Column Capacity

53 kips

65 kips

100 kips 53 kips

Stiffener Plates are Required! 191% of Column Capacity

tw =dc =Ct = 0.5 if the distance from the end of the column to the closer face

of the beam tension flange is less than dc

Distance from the outside face of column flange to the web toe of the flange-to-web fillet

Rn =

tw =dc =tf =

Ct = 0.5 if the distance from the end of the column to the closer face of the beam tension flange is less than dc/2

Nd = 3(N/dc ) if dtop > dc/2 or if dtop < dc and N/dc < 0.2 N/dc =4N/dc-0.2 if dtop < dc and N/dc > 0.2

Rn =

tw =dc =

Distance from the outside face of column flange to the web toe of the flange-to-web fillet

Ct = 0.5 if the distance from the end of the column to the closer face of the beam tension flange is less than dc/2

Zone of column web subject to compression buckling (out-of-plane) h=dc-2kRn =

III) Column Design Summary:A) Doubler Plates Required if Vp > Rv

Total Panel Zone Shear Force, Vp =

Panel-Zone Shear Strength =

B) Stiffener Plates are Required if Pf > Rn for CompressionLocal Web Yielding Design Strength =

Web Crippling Design Strength =

Concentrated Compression Force, Pf =

Compression Buckling Design Strength =

Rn =

C) Stiffener Plates are Required if Pf > Rn for TensionLocal Flange Bending

Design Strength =

Concentrated Tension Force, Pf =

Local Web Yielding Design Strength =

Rn =

This spreadsheet has been prepared in accordance with information made available to the American Institute of Steel Construction, Inc., AISC Marketing, LLC, and the Steel Solutions Center, LLC at the time of its preparation. While it is believed to be accurate, it has not been prepared for conventional use as an engineering or construction document and should not be used or relied upon for any specific application without competent professional examination and verification of its accuracy, suitability and applicability by a licensed engineer, architect or other professional. AISC, AISCM, and SSC disclaim any liability arising from information provided by others or from the unauthorized use of the information contained in this spreadsheet.

Rn=( 1. 01. 5 )x {Ct (5k )+N } xF y tw

Rn=0 . 751 .5

x0 .80Ct tw2 {1+Nd( twt f )

1. 5}√EFy t ftw

Rn=0 . 901 . 5

x24Ct tw

3 √EF y

h

WN

Reinforcing Fillet Weld

Flange Plate

tp

Illustration of N, Length of Bearing

Page 8: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

1 167 0 10 050 ksi 0

Top Top Bottom BottomDesignation A d k dm

in. in. in. in. kip-in kips kips kips kips kips inW4x13 3.83 4.16 4.06 0.345 0.595 6.28 180 1 393 0 -383 0 393 5.16 319 5.46

0 2 318W5x16 4.71 5.01 5 0.36 0.66 9.63 282 3 338 0 -328 0 338 6.01 317 8.55W5x19 5.56 5.15 5.03 0.43 0.73 11.6 337 4 331 0 -321 0 331 6.15 316 10.2

0 5 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 315W6x8.5 2.51 5.83 3.94 0.194 0.444 5.71 168 6 298 0 -288 0 298 6.83 314 5.08W6x9 2.68 5.9 3.94 0.215 0.465 6.23 183 7 295 0 -285 0 295 6.90 313 5.56W6x12 3.55 6.03 4 0.28 0.53 8.3 241 8 290 0 -280 0 290 7.03 312 7.31W6x16 4.74 6.28 4.03 0.405 0.655 11.7 337 9 280 0 -270 0 280 7.28 311 10.2

0 10 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 310W6x15 4.45 5.99 5.99 0.26 0.559 10.8 322 11 292 0 -282 0 292 6.99 309 9.77W6x20 5.89 6.2 6.02 0.365 0.664 15 442 12 283 0 -273 0 283 7.20 308 13.4W6x25 7.36 6.38 6.08 0.455 0.754 19 554 13 277 0 -267 0 277 7.38 307 16.8

0 14 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 306W8x10 2.96 7.89 3.94 0.205 0.505 8.87 258 15 230 0 -220 0 230 8.89 305 7.81W8x13 3.84 7.99 4 0.255 0.555 11.4 327 16 228 0 -218 0 228 8.99 304 9.91W8x15 4.44 8.11 4.01 0.315 0.615 13.6 389 17 225 0 -215 0 225 9.11 303 11.8

0 18 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 302W8x18 5.26 8.14 5.25 0.33 0.63 17 502 19 224 0 -214 0 224 9.14 301 15.2W8x21 6.16 8.28 5.27 0.4 0.7 20.4 601 20 221 0 -211 0 221 9.28 300 18.2

0 21 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 299W8x24 7.08 7.93 6.5 0.4 0.794 23.1 690 22 229 0 -219 0 229 8.93 298 20.9W8x28 8.24 8.06 6.54 0.465 0.859 27.2 802 23 226 0 -216 0 226 9.06 297 24.3

0 24 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 296W8x31 9.12 8 8 0.435 0.829 30.4 908 25 228 0 -218 0 228 9.00 295 27.5W8x35 10.3 8.12 8.02 0.495 0.889 34.7 1030 26 225 0 -215 0 225 9.12 294 31.2W8x40 11.7 8.25 8.07 0.56 0.954 39.8 1172 27 222 0 -212 0 222 9.25 293 35.5W8x48 14.1 8.5 8.11 0.685 1.08 49 1426 28 216 0 -206 0 216 9.50 292 43.2W8x58 17.1 8.75 8.22 0.81 1.2 59.8 1716 29 211 0 -201 0 211 9.75 291 52W8x67 19.7 9 8.28 0.935 1.33 70.1 1993 30 205 0 -195 0 205 10.00 290 60.4

0 31 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 289W10x12 3.54 9.87 3.96 0.21 0.51 12.6 360 32 189 0 -179 0 189 10.87 288 10.9W10x15 4.41 9.99 4 0.27 0.57 16 455 33 187 0 -177 0 187 10.99 287 13.8W10x17 4.99 10.1 4.01 0.33 0.63 18.7 535 34 186 0 -176 0 186 11.10 286 16.2W10x19 5.62 10.2 4.02 0.395 0.695 21.6 620 35 184 0 -174 0 184 11.20 285 18.8

0 36 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 284W10x22 6.49 10.2 5.75 0.36 0.66 26 766 37 184 0 -174 0 184 11.20 283 23.2W10x26 7.61 10.3 5.77 0.44 0.74 31.3 921 38 182 0 -172 0 182 11.30 282 27.9W10x30 8.84 10.5 5.81 0.51 0.81 36.6 1069 39 179 0 -169 0 179 11.50 281 32.4

0 40 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 280W10x33 9.71 9.73 7.96 0.435 0.935 38.8 1155 41 192 0 -182 0 192 10.73 279 35W10x39 11.5 9.92 7.99 0.53 1.03 46.8 1389 42 189 0 -179 0 189 10.92 278 42.1W10x45 13.3 10.1 8.02 0.62 1.12 54.9 1620 43 186 0 -176 0 186 11.10 277 49.1

0 44 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 276W10x49 14.4 9.98 10 0.56 1.06 60.4 1802 45 188 0 -178 0 188 10.98 275 54.6W10x54 15.8 10.1 10 0.615 1.12 66.6 1980 46 186 0 -176 0 186 11.10 274 60W10x60 17.6 10.2 10.1 0.68 1.18 74.6 2201 47 184 0 -174 0 184 11.20 273 66.7W10x68 20 10.4 10.1 0.77 1.27 85.3 2498 48 181 0 -171 0 181 11.40 272 75.7W10x77 22.6 10.6 10.2 0.87 1.37 97.6 2835 49 178 0 -168 0 178 11.60 271 85.9W10x88 25.9 10.8 10.3 0.99 1.49 113 3251 50 175 0 -165 0 175 11.80 270 98.5W10x100 29.4 11.1 10.3 1.12 1.62 130 3696 51 171 0 -161 0 171 12.10 269 112W10x112 32.9 11.4 10.4 1.25 1.75 147 4158 52 167 0 -157 0 167 12.40 268 126

0 53 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 267W12x14 4.16 11.9 3.97 0.225 0.525 17.4 492 54 160 0 -150 0 160 12.90 266 14.9W12x16 4.71 12 3.99 0.265 0.565 20.1 564 55 159 0 -149 0 159 13.00 265 17.1W12x19 5.57 12.2 4.01 0.35 0.65 24.7 703 56 157 0 -147 0 157 13.20 264 21.3W12x22 6.48 12.3 4.03 0.425 0.725 29.3 838 57 156 0 -146 0 156 13.30 263 25.4

MuR = MuL = PuR = PuL =Fy = Vus =

bf tf Zx f Mp (Puf)TR (Puf)TL (Puf)BR (Puf)BL Vu Sx

in2 in.3 in.3

A1
AISC: 1 = ASD 0=LRFD
Page 9: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

0 58 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 262W12x26 7.65 12.2 6.49 0.38 0.68 37.2 1102 59 157 0 -147 0 157 13.20 261 33.4W12x30 8.79 12.3 6.52 0.44 0.74 43.1 1274 60 156 0 -146 0 156 13.30 260 38.6W12x35 10.3 12.5 6.56 0.52 0.82 51.2 1505 61 153 0 -143 0 153 13.50 259 45.6

0 62 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 258W12x40 11.7 11.9 8.01 0.515 1.02 57 1700 63 160 0 -150 0 160 12.90 257 51.5W12x45 13.1 12.1 8.05 0.575 1.08 64.2 1904 64 158 0 -148 0 158 13.10 256 57.7W12x50 14.6 12.2 8.08 0.64 1.14 71.9 2119 65 157 0 -147 0 157 13.20 255 64.2

0 66 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 254W12x53 15.6 12.1 9.99 0.575 1.17 77.9 2330 67 158 0 -148 0 158 13.10 253 70.6W12x58 17 12.2 10 0.64 1.24 86.4 2574 68 157 0 -147 0 157 13.20 252 78

0 69 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 251W12x65 19.1 12.1 12 0.605 1.2 96.8 2901 70 158 0 -148 0 158 13.10 250 87.9W12x72 21.1 12.3 12 0.67 1.27 108 3214 71 156 0 -146 0 156 13.30 249 97.4W12x79 23.2 12.4 12.1 0.735 1.33 119 3531 72 155 0 -145 0 155 13.40 248 107W12x87 25.6 12.5 12.1 0.81 1.41 132 3894 73 153 0 -143 0 153 13.50 247 118W12x96 28.2 12.7 12.2 0.9 1.5 147 4323 74 151 0 -141 0 151 13.70 246 131W12x106 31.2 12.9 12.2 0.99 1.59 164 4785 75 149 0 -139 0 149 13.90 245 145W12x120 35.3 13.1 12.3 1.11 1.7 186 5379 76 147 0 -137 0 147 14.10 244 163W12x136 39.9 13.4 12.4 1.25 1.85 214 6138 77 144 0 -134 0 144 14.40 243 186W12x152 44.7 13.7 12.5 1.4 2 243 6897 78 141 0 -131 0 141 14.70 242 209W12x170 50 14 12.6 1.56 2.16 275 7755 79 139 0 -129 0 139 15.00 241 235W12x190 55.8 14.4 12.7 1.74 2.33 311 8679 80 135 0 -125 0 135 15.40 240 263W12x210 61.8 14.7 12.8 1.9 2.5 348 9636 81 133 0 -123 0 133 15.70 239 292W12x230 67.7 15.1 12.9 2.07 2.67 386 10593 82 129 0 -119 0 129 16.10 238 321W12x252 74 15.4 13 2.25 2.85 428 11649 83 127 0 -117 0 127 16.40 237 353W12x279 81.9 15.9 13.1 2.47 3.07 481 12969 84 124 0 -114 0 124 16.90 236 393W12x305 89.6 16.3 13.2 2.71 3.3 537 14355 85 121 0 -111 0 121 17.30 235 435W12x336 98.8 16.8 13.4 2.96 3.55 603 15939 86 118 0 -108 0 118 17.80 234 483

0 87 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 233W14x22 6.49 13.7 5 0.335 0.735 33.2 957 88 141 0 -131 0 141 14.70 232 29W14x26 7.69 13.9 5.03 0.42 0.82 40.2 1165 89 139 0 -129 0 139 14.90 231 35.3

0 90 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 230W14x30 8.85 13.8 6.73 0.385 0.785 47.3 1386 91 140 0 -130 0 140 14.80 229 42W14x34 10 14 6.75 0.455 0.855 54.6 1604 92 139 0 -129 0 139 15.00 228 48.6W14x38 11.2 14.1 6.77 0.515 0.915 61.5 1802 93 138 0 -128 0 138 15.10 227 54.6

0 94 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 226W14x43 12.6 13.7 8 0.53 1.12 69.6 2066 95 141 0 -131 0 141 14.70 225 62.6W14x48 14.1 13.8 8.03 0.595 1.19 78.4 2317 96 140 0 -130 0 140 14.80 224 70.2W14x53 15.6 13.9 8.06 0.66 1.25 87.1 2567 97 139 0 -129 0 139 14.90 223 77.8

0 98 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 222W14x61 17.9 13.9 9.99 0.645 1.24 102 3039 99 139 0 -129 0 139 14.90 221 92.1W14x68 20 14 10 0.72 1.31 115 3399 100 139 0 -129 0 139 15.00 220 103W14x74 21.8 14.2 10.1 0.785 1.38 126 3696 101 137 0 -127 0 137 15.20 219 112W14x82 24 14.3 10.1 0.855 1.45 139 4059 102 136 0 -126 0 136 15.30 218 123

0 103 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 217W14x90 26.5 14 14.5 0.71 1.31 157 4719 104 139 0 -129 0 139 15.00 216 143W14x99 29.1 14.2 14.6 0.78 1.38 173 5181 105 137 0 -127 0 137 15.20 215 157W14x109 32 14.3 14.6 0.86 1.46 192 5709 106 136 0 -126 0 136 15.30 214 173W14x120 35.3 14.5 14.7 0.94 1.54 212 6270 107 134 0 -124 0 134 15.50 213 190W14x132 38.8 14.7 14.7 1.03 1.63 234 6897 108 133 0 -123 0 133 15.70 212 209

0 109 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 211W14x145 42.7 14.8 15.5 1.09 1.69 260 7656 110 132 0 -122 0 132 15.80 210 232W14x159 46.7 15 15.6 1.19 1.79 287 8382 111 130 0 -120 0 130 16.00 209 254W14x176 51.8 15.2 15.7 1.31 1.91 320 9273 112 129 0 -119 0 129 16.20 208 281W14x193 56.8 15.5 15.7 1.44 2.04 355 10230 113 126 0 -116 0 126 16.50 207 310W14x211 62 15.7 15.8 1.56 2.16 390 11154 114 125 0 -115 0 125 16.70 206 338W14x233 68.5 16 15.9 1.72 2.32 436 12375 115 123 0 -113 0 123 17.00 205 375W14x257 75.6 16.4 16 1.89 2.49 487 13695 116 120 0 -110 0 120 17.40 204 415W14x283 83.3 16.7 16.1 2.07 2.67 542 15147 117 118 0 -108 0 118 17.70 203 459W14x311 91.4 17.1 16.2 2.26 2.86 603 16698 118 116 0 -106 0 116 18.10 202 506W14x342 101 17.5 16.4 2.47 3.07 672 18414 119 113 0 -103 0 113 18.50 201 558W14x370 109 17.9 16.5 2.66 3.26 736 20031 120 111 0 -101 0 111 18.90 200 607

Page 10: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

W14x398 117 18.3 16.6 2.85 3.44 801 21648 121 109 0 -99 0 109 19.30 199 656W14x426 125 18.7 16.7 3.04 3.63 869 23298 122 107 0 -97 0 107 19.70 198 706

0 123 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 197W14x455 134 19 16.8 3.21 3.81 936 24948 124 105 0 -95 0 105 20.00 196 756W14x500 147 19.6 17 3.5 4.1 1050 27654 125 102 0 -92 0 102 20.60 195 838W14x550 162 20.2 17.2 3.82 4.42 1180 30723 126 100 0 -90 0 100 21.20 194 931W14x605 178 20.9 17.4 4.16 4.76 1320 34320 127 97 0 -87 0 97 21.90 193 1040W14x665 196 21.6 17.7 4.52 5.12 1480 37950 128 94 0 -84 0 94 22.60 192 1150

215 22.4 17.9 4.91 5.51 1660 0 129 91 0 -81 0 91 23.40 191W14x808 237 22.8 18.6 5.12 5.72 1830 46200 130 89 0 -79 0 89 23.80 190 1400

0 131 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 189W16x26 7.68 15.7 5.5 0.345 0.747 44.2 1267 132 125 0 -115 0 125 16.70 188 38.4W16x31 9.13 15.9 5.53 0.44 0.842 54 1558 133 124 0 -114 0 124 16.90 187 47.2

0 134 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 186W16x36 10.6 15.9 6.99 0.43 0.832 64 1865 135 124 0 -114 0 124 16.90 185 56.5W16x40 11.8 16 7 0.505 0.907 73 2135 136 123 0 -113 0 123 17.00 184 64.7W16x45 13.3 16.1 7.04 0.565 0.967 82.3 2399 137 122 0 -112 0 122 17.10 183 72.7W16x50 14.7 16.3 7.07 0.63 1.03 92 2673 138 121 0 -111 0 121 17.30 182 81W16x57 16.8 16.4 7.12 0.715 1.12 105 3043 139 120 0 -110 0 120 17.40 181 92.2

0 140 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 180W16x67 20 16.3 10.2 0.665 1.37 132 3927 141 121 0 -111 0 121 17.30 179 119W16x77 22.9 16.5 10.3 0.76 1.47 152 4488 142 120 0 -110 0 120 17.50 178 136W16x89 26.4 16.8 10.4 0.875 1.58 177 5181 143 118 0 -108 0 118 17.80 177 157W16x100 29.7 17 10.4 0.985 1.69 200 5841 144 116 0 -106 0 116 18.00 176 177

0 145 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 175W18x35 10.3 17.7 6 0.425 0.827 66.5 1901 146 112 0 -102 0 112 18.70 174 57.6W18x40 11.8 17.9 6.02 0.525 0.927 78.4 2257 147 111 0 -101 0 111 18.90 173 68.4W18x46 13.5 18.1 6.06 0.605 1.01 90.7 2600 148 110 0 -100 0 110 19.10 172 78.8

0 149 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 171W18x50 14.7 18 7.5 0.57 0.972 101 2934 150 110 0 -100 0 110 19.00 170 88.9W18x55 16.2 18.1 7.53 0.63 1.03 112 3244 151 110 0 -100 0 110 19.10 169 98.3W18x60 17.6 18.2 7.56 0.695 1.1 123 3564 152 109 0 -99 0 109 19.20 168 108W18x65 19.1 18.4 7.59 0.75 1.15 133 3861 153 108 0 -98 0 108 19.40 167 117W18x71 20.8 18.5 7.64 0.81 1.21 146 4191 154 108 0 -98 0 108 19.50 166 127

0 155 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 165W18x76 22.3 18.2 11 0.68 1.08 163 4818 156 109 0 -99 0 109 19.20 164 146W18x86 25.3 18.4 11.1 0.77 1.17 186 5478 157 108 0 -98 0 108 19.40 163 166W18x97 28.5 18.6 11.1 0.87 1.27 211 6204 158 107 0 -97 0 107 19.60 162 188W18x106 31.1 18.7 11.2 0.94 1.34 230 6732 159 107 0 -97 0 107 19.70 161 204W18x119 35.1 19 11.3 1.06 1.46 262 7623 160 105 0 -95 0 105 20.00 160 231W18x130 38.2 19.3 11.2 1.2 1.6 290 8448 161 104 0 -94 0 104 20.30 159 256W18x143 42.1 19.5 11.2 1.32 1.72 322 9306 162 103 0 -93 0 103 20.50 158 282W18x158 46.3 19.7 11.3 1.44 1.84 356 10230 163 102 0 -92 0 102 20.70 157 310W18x175 51.3 20 11.4 1.59 1.99 398 11352 164 100 0 -90 0 100 21.00 156 344W18x192 56.7 20.35 11.455 1.75 2.272 445 12540 165 99 0 -89 0 99 21.35 155 380W18x211 62.4 20.67 11.555 1.91 2.432 493 13827 166 97 0 -87 0 97 21.67 154 419W18x234 69.1 21.06 11.65 2.11 2.632 551 15378 167 96 0 -86 0 96 22.06 153 466W18x258 76.1 21.46 11.77 2.3 2.822 613 16962 168 94 0 -84 0 94 22.46 152 514W18x283 83.4 21.85 11.89 2.5 3.022 677 18612 169 93 0 -83 0 93 22.85 151 564W18x311 91.8 22.32 12.005 2.74 3.262 755 20592 170 91 0 -81 0 91 23.32 150 624

0 171 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 149W21x44 13 20.7 6.5 0.45 0.95 95.4 2693 172 97 0 -87 0 97 21.70 148 81.6W21x50 14.7 20.8 6.53 0.535 1.04 110 3119 173 97 0 -87 0 97 21.80 147 94.5W21x57 16.7 21.1 6.56 0.65 1.15 129 3663 174 96 0 -86 0 96 22.10 146 111

0 175 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 145W21x48 14.1 20.6 8.14 0.43 0.93 107 3069 176 98 0 -88 0 98 21.60 144 93W21x55 16.2 20.8 8.22 0.522 1.02 126 3630 177 97 0 -87 0 97 21.80 143 110W21x62 18.3 21 8.24 0.615 1.12 144 4191 178 96 0 -86 0 96 22.00 142 127W21x68 20 21.1 8.27 0.685 1.19 160 4620 179 96 0 -86 0 96 22.10 141 140W21x73 21.5 21.2 8.3 0.74 1.24 172 4983 180 95 0 -85 0 95 22.20 140 151W21x83 24.3 21.4 8.36 0.835 1.34 196 5643 181 94 0 -84 0 94 22.40 139 171W21x93 27.3 21.6 8.42 0.93 1.43 221 6336 182 94 0 -84 0 94 22.60 138 192

0 183 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 137

Page 11: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

W21x101 29.8 21.4 12.3 0.8 1.3 253 7491 184 94 0 -84 0 94 22.40 136 227W21x111 32.7 21.5 12.3 0.875 1.38 279 8217 185 94 0 -84 0 94 22.50 135 249W21x122 35.9 21.7 12.4 0.96 1.46 307 9009 186 93 0 -83 0 93 22.70 134 273W21x132 38.8 21.8 12.4 1.03 1.54 333 9735 187 93 0 -83 0 93 22.80 133 295W21x147 43.2 22.1 12.5 1.15 1.65 373 10857 188 92 0 -82 0 92 23.10 132 329W21x166 48.8 22.5 12.4 1.36 1.86 432 12540 189 90 0 -80 0 90 23.50 131 380W21x182 53.6 22.7 12.5 1.48 1.98 476 13761 190 90 0 -80 0 90 23.70 130 417W21x201 59.2 23 12.6 1.63 2.13 530 15213 191 89 0 -79 0 89 24.00 129 461

0 192 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 128W24x55 16.3 23.6 7.01 0.505 1.11 135 3795 193 86 0 -76 0 86 24.60 127 115W24x62 18.3 23.7 7.04 0.59 1.19 154 4356 194 86 0 -76 0 86 24.70 126 132

0 195 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 125W24x68 20.1 23.7 8.97 0.585 1.09 177 5082 196 86 0 -76 0 86 24.70 124 154W24x76 22.4 23.9 8.99 0.68 1.18 200 5808 197 85 0 -75 0 85 24.90 123 176W24x84 24.7 24.1 9.02 0.77 1.27 224 6468 198 85 0 -75 0 85 25.10 122 196W24x94 27.7 24.3 9.07 0.875 1.38 254 7326 199 84 0 -74 0 84 25.30 121 222W24x103 30.3 24.5 9 0.98 1.48 280 8085 200 84 0 -74 0 84 25.50 120 245

0 201 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 119W24x104 30.6 24.1 12.8 0.75 1.25 289 8514 202 85 0 -75 0 85 25.10 118 258W24x117 34.4 24.3 12.8 0.85 1.35 327 9603 203 84 0 -74 0 84 25.30 117 291W24x131 38.5 24.5 12.9 0.96 1.46 370 10857 204 84 0 -74 0 84 25.50 116 329W24x146 43 24.7 12.9 1.09 1.59 418 12243 205 83 0 -73 0 83 25.70 115 371W24x162 47.7 25 13 1.22 1.72 468 13662 206 82 0 -72 0 82 26.00 114 414W24x176 51.7 25.2 12.9 1.34 1.84 511 14850 207 81 0 -71 0 81 26.20 113 450W24x192 56.3 25.5 13 1.46 1.96 559 16203 208 81 0 -71 0 81 26.50 112 491W24x207 60.7 25.7 13 1.57 2.07 606 17523 209 80 0 -70 0 80 26.70 111 531W24x229 67.2 26 13.1 1.73 2.23 675 19404 210 79 0 -69 0 79 27.00 110 588W24x250 73.5 26.3 13.2 1.89 2.39 744 21252 211 78 0 -68 0 78 27.30 109 644W24x279 82 26.7 13.3 2.09 2.59 835 23694 212 77 0 -67 0 77 27.70 108 718W24x306 89.8 27.1 13.4 2.28 2.78 922 26037 213 76 0 -66 0 76 28.10 107 789W24x335 98.4 27.5 13.5 2.48 2.98 1020 28512 214 75 0 -65 0 75 28.50 106 864W24x370 109 28 13.7 2.72 3.22 1130 31581 215 74 0 -64 0 74 29.00 105 957

0 216 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 104W27x84 24.8 26.7 9.96 0.64 1.24 244 7029 217 77 0 -67 0 77 27.70 103 213W27x94 27.7 26.9 9.99 0.745 1.34 278 8019 218 77 0 -67 0 77 27.90 102 243W27x102 30 27.1 10 0.83 1.43 305 8811 219 76 0 -66 0 76 28.10 101 267W27x114 33.5 27.3 10.1 0.93 1.53 343 9867 220 76 0 -66 0 76 28.30 100 299W27x129 37.8 27.6 10 1.1 1.7 395 11385 221 75 0 -65 0 75 28.60 99 345

0 222 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 98W27x146 43.1 27.4 14 0.975 1.76 464 13662 223 76 0 -66 0 76 28.40 97 414W27x161 47.6 27.6 14 1.08 1.87 515 15114 224 75 0 -65 0 75 28.60 96 458W27x178 52.5 27.8 14.1 1.19 1.98 570 16665 225 75 0 -65 0 75 28.80 95 505W27x194 57.2 28.1 14 1.34 2.13 631 18447 226 74 0 -64 0 74 29.10 94 559W27x217 64 28.4 14.1 1.5 2.29 711 20691 227 73 0 -63 0 73 29.40 93 627W27x235 69.4 28.7 14.2 1.61 2.4 772 22341 228 72 0 -62 0 72 29.70 92 677W27x258 76 29 14.3 1.77 2.56 852 24585 229 72 0 -62 0 72 30.00 91 745W27x281 82.9 29.3 14.4 1.93 2.72 936 26862 230 71 0 -61 0 71 30.30 90 814W27x307 90.4 29.6 14.4 2.09 2.88 1030 29271 231 70 0 -60 0 70 30.60 89 887W27x336 98.9 30 14.6 2.28 3.07 1130 32076 232 70 0 -60 0 70 31.00 88 972W27x368 108 30.4 14.7 2.48 3.27 1240 34980 233 69 0 -59 0 69 31.40 87 1060W27x539 159 32.5 15.3 3.54 4.33 1890 51810 234 65 0 -55 0 65 33.50 86 1570

0 235 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 85W30x90 26.4 29.5 10.4 0.61 1.26 283 8085 236 71 0 -61 0 71 30.50 84 245W30x99 29.1 29.7 10.5 0.67 1.32 312 8877 237 70 0 -60 0 70 30.70 83 269W30x108 31.7 29.8 10.5 0.76 1.41 346 9867 238 70 0 -60 0 70 30.80 82 299W30x116 34.2 30 10.5 0.85 1.5 378 10857 239 70 0 -60 0 70 31.00 81 329W30x124 36.5 30.2 10.5 0.93 1.58 408 11715 240 69 0 -59 0 69 31.20 80 355W30x132 38.9 30.3 10.5 1 1.65 437 12540 241 69 0 -59 0 69 31.30 79 380W30x148 43.5 30.7 10.5 1.18 1.83 500 14388 242 68 0 -58 0 68 31.70 78 436

0 243 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 77W30x173 51 30.4 15 1.07 1.85 607 17853 244 69 0 -59 0 69 31.40 76 541W30x191 56.3 30.7 15 1.19 1.97 675 19800 245 68 0 -58 0 68 31.70 75 600W30x211 62.2 30.9 15.1 1.32 2.1 751 21945 246 68 0 -58 0 68 31.90 74 665

Page 12: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

W30x235 69.2 31.3 15.1 1.5 2.29 847 24684 247 67 0 -57 0 67 32.30 73 748W30x261 76.9 31.6 15.2 1.65 2.44 943 27357 248 66 0 -56 0 66 32.60 72 829W30x292 85.9 32 15.3 1.85 2.64 1060 30690 249 66 0 -56 0 66 33.00 71 930W30x326 95.8 32.4 15.4 2.05 2.84 1190 34320 250 65 0 -55 0 65 33.40 70 1040W30x357 105 32.8 15.5 2.24 3.03 1320 37620 251 64 0 -54 0 64 33.80 69 1140W30x391 115 33.2 15.6 2.44 3.23 1450 41250 252 64 0 -54 0 64 34.20 68 1250

0 253 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 67W33x118 34.7 32.9 11.5 0.74 1.44 415 11847 254 64 0 -54 0 64 33.90 66 359W33x130 38.3 33.1 11.5 0.855 1.56 467 13398 255 64 0 -54 0 64 34.10 65 406W33x141 41.6 33.3 11.5 0.96 1.66 514 14784 256 63 0 -53 0 63 34.30 64 448W33x152 44.8 33.5 11.6 1.06 1.76 559 16071 257 63 0 -53 0 63 34.50 63 487W33x169 49.5 33.8 11.5 1.22 1.92 629 18117 258 63 0 -53 0 63 34.80 62 549

0 259 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 61W33x201 59.2 33.7 15.7 1.15 1.94 773 22638 260 63 0 -53 0 63 34.70 60 686W33x221 65.2 33.9 15.8 1.27 2.06 857 25047 261 62 0 -52 0 62 34.90 59 759W33x241 71 34.2 15.9 1.4 2.19 940 27423 262 62 0 -52 0 62 35.20 58 831W33x263 77.5 34.5 15.8 1.57 2.36 1040 30327 263 61 0 -51 0 61 35.50 57 919W33x291 85.7 34.8 15.9 1.73 2.52 1160 33660 264 61 0 -51 0 61 35.80 56 1020W33x318 93.6 35.2 16 1.89 2.68 1270 36630 265 60 0 -50 0 60 36.20 55 1110W33x354 104 35.6 16.1 2.09 2.88 1420 40920 266 60 0 -50 0 60 36.60 54 1240W33x387 114 36 16.2 2.28 3.07 1560 44550 267 59 0 -49 0 59 37.00 53 1350

0 268 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 52W36x135 39.7 35.6 12 0.79 1.54 509 14487 269 60 0 -50 0 60 36.60 51 439W36x150 44.2 35.9 12 0.94 1.69 581 16632 270 59 0 -49 0 59 36.90 50 504W36x160 47 36 12 1.02 1.77 624 17886 271 59 0 -49 0 59 37.00 49 542W36x170 50.1 36.2 12 1.1 1.85 668 19173 272 59 0 -49 0 59 37.20 48 581W36x182 53.6 36.3 12.1 1.18 1.93 718 20559 273 59 0 -49 0 59 37.30 47 623W36x194 57 36.5 12.1 1.26 2.01 767 21912 274 58 0 -48 0 58 37.50 46 664W36x210 61.8 36.7 12.2 1.36 2.11 833 23727 275 58 0 -48 0 58 37.70 45 719W36x232 68.1 37.1 12.1 1.57 2.32 936 26697 276 58 0 -48 0 58 38.10 44 809W36x256 75.4 37.4 12.2 1.73 2.48 1040 29535 277 57 0 -47 0 57 38.40 43 895

0 278 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 42W36x230 67.6 35.9 16.5 1.26 2.21 943 27621 279 59 0 -49 0 59 36.90 41 837W36x245 72.1 36.1 16.5 1.35 2.3 1010 29535 280 59 0 -49 0 59 37.10 40 895W36x260 76.5 36.3 16.6 1.44 2.39 1080 31449 281 59 0 -49 0 59 37.30 39 953W36x280 82.4 36.5 16.6 1.57 2.52 1170 33990 282 58 0 -48 0 58 37.50 38 1030W36x300 88.3 36.7 16.7 1.68 2.63 1260 36630 283 58 0 -48 0 58 37.70 37 1110W36x328 96.4 37.1 16.6 1.85 2.8 1380 39930 284 58 0 -48 0 58 38.10 36 1210W36x359 105 37.4 16.7 2.01 2.96 1510 43560 285 57 0 -47 0 57 38.40 35 1320W36x393 116 37.8 16.8 2.2 3.15 1670 47850 286 57 0 -47 0 57 38.80 34 1450W36x439 129 38.3 17 2.44 3.39 1870 53460 287 56 0 -46 0 56 39.30 33 1620W36x527 155 39.2 17.2 2.91 3.86 2280 64350 288 55 0 -45 0 55 40.20 32 1950W36x650 191 40.5 17.6 3.54 4.49 2860 79860 289 53 0 -43 0 53 41.50 31 2420W36x798 235 42 18 4.29 5.24 3580 98340 290 52 0 -42 0 52 43.00 30 2980

0 291 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 29W40x149 43.8 38.2 11.8 0.83 2.01 598 16929 292 56 0 -46 0 56 39.20 28 513W40x167 49.2 38.6 11.8 1.02 2.21 693 19800 293 56 0 -46 0 56 39.60 27 600W40x183 53.8 39 11.8 1.22 2.4 783 22539 294 55 0 -45 0 55 40.00 26 683W40x211 62 39.4 11.8 1.42 2.6 906 25938 295 55 0 -45 0 55 40.40 25 786W40x235 69 39.7 11.9 1.58 2.76 1010 28875 296 54 0 -44 0 54 40.70 24 875W40x264 77.6 40 11.9 1.73 2.91 1130 32043 297 54 0 -44 0 54 41.00 23 971W40x278 81.8 40.2 12 1.81 2.99 1190 33660 298 54 0 -44 0 54 41.20 22 1020W40x327 96 40.8 12.1 2.13 3.31 1410 39600 299 53 0 -43 0 53 41.80 21 1200W40x331 97.5 40.8 12.2 2.13 3.31 1430 39930 300 53 0 -43 0 53 41.80 20 1210W40x392 115 41.6 12.4 2.52 3.7 1710 47520 301 52 0 -42 0 52 42.60 19 1440

0 302 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 18W40x199 58.5 38.7 15.8 1.07 2.25 869 25410 303 55 0 -45 0 55 39.70 17 770W40x215 63.4 39 15.8 1.22 2.4 964 28347 304 55 0 -45 0 55 40.00 16 859W40x249 73.3 39.4 15.8 1.42 2.6 1120 32769 305 55 0 -45 0 55 40.40 15 993W40x277 81.4 39.7 15.8 1.58 2.76 1250 36300 306 54 0 -44 0 54 40.70 14 1100W40x297 87.4 39.8 15.8 1.65 2.83 1330 38610 307 54 0 -44 0 54 40.80 13 1170W40x324 95.3 40.2 15.9 1.81 2.99 1460 42240 308 54 0 -44 0 54 41.20 12 1280W40x362 107 40.6 16 2.01 3.19 1640 46860 309 53 0 -43 0 53 41.60 11 1420

Page 13: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

W40x372 109 40.6 16.1 2.05 3.23 1680 48180 310 53 0 -43 0 53 41.60 10 1460W40x397 117 41 16.1 2.2 3.38 1800 51480 311 53 0 -43 0 53 42.00 9 1560W40x431 127 41.3 16.2 2.36 3.54 1960 55770 312 52 0 -42 0 52 42.30 8 1690W40x503 148 42.1 16.4 2.76 3.94 2320 65340 313 51 0 -41 0 51 43.10 7 1980W40x593 174 43 16.7 3.23 4.41 2760 77220 314 51 0 -41 0 51 44.00 6 2340

0 315 2009 0 -1999 0 2009 1.00 5W44x230 67.7 42.9 15.8 1.22 2.01 1100 32043 316 51 0 -41 0 51 43.90 4 971W44x262 77.2 43.3 15.8 1.42 2.21 1270 36960 317 50 0 -40 0 50 44.30 3 1120W44x290 85.8 43.6 15.8 1.58 2.37 1420 40920 318 50 0 -40 0 50 44.60 2 1240W44x335 98.3 44 16 1.77 2.56 1620 46530 319 50 0 -40 0 50 45.00 1 1410

Page 14: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

N= 1 in Pu 320 kips 2 in tp = 1.00 in Yc = 170.1 in max without max without max without max without max without

50 ksi Fy 50 ksi, for LFB E = 29000 ksi Ten Ten+Comp Comp Comp Stiffener/Ten Stiffener/Comp Doubler Pl Stiff & DPL Stiffener/Ten_MnfDesignation A d h k PZ Shear Str. LFB LWY WC CBW Py

in. in. in. in. in. kips kips kips kips kipsW18 x 311 91.8 22.32 15.80 1.52 2.74 12.005 3.262 611 1408 877 1577 3855 877 877 611 611 2.740 2754W18 x 283 83.4 21.85 15.81 1.4 2.5 11.89 3.022 551 1172 752 1334 3010 752 752 551 551 2.500 2502W18 x 258 76.1 21.46 15.82 1.28 2.3 11.77 2.822 494 992 645 1119 2299 645 645 494 494 2.300 2283W18 x 234 69.1 21.06 15.80 1.16 2.11 11.65 2.632 440 835 548 925 1713 548 548 440 440 2.110 2073W18 x 211 62.4 20.67 15.81 1.06 1.91 11.555 2.432 394 684 465 770 1307 465 465 394 394 1.910 1872W18 x 192 56.7 20.35 15.81 0.96 1.75 11.455 2.272 352 574 396 635 971 396 396 352 352 1.750 1701W18x175 51.3 20 16.02 0.89 1.59 11.4 1.990 320 474 325 542 763 325 325 320 320 1.590 1539W18x158 46.3 19.7 16.02 0.81 1.44 11.3 1.840 287 389 275 448 575 275 275 287 275 1.440 1389W18x143 42.1 19.5 16.06 0.73 1.32 11.2 1.720 256 327 234 367 420 234 234 256 234 1.320 1263W18x130 38.2 19.3 16.10 0.67 1.2 11.2 1.600 233 270 201 308 324 201 201 233 201 1.200 1146

W18x119 35.1 19 16.08 0.655 1.06 11.3 1.460 224 211 181 283 303 181 181 224 181 1.060 1053W18x106 31.1 18.7 16.02 0.59 0.94 11.2 1.340 199 166 151 229 222 151 151 199 151 0.940 933W18x97 28.5 18.6 16.06 0.535 0.87 11.1 1.270 179 142 131 189 165 131 131 179 131 0.870 855W18x86 25.3 18.4 16.06 0.48 0.77 11.1 1.170 156 111 110 152 119 110 110 156 110 0.770 759W18x76 22.3 18.2 16.04 0.425 0.68 11 1.080 128 87 91 119 83 87 83 128 83 0.680 669

W18x71 20.8 18.5 16.08 0.495 0.81 7.64 1.210 146 123 116 163 131 116 116 146 116 0.810 624W18x65 19.1 18.4 16.10 0.45 0.75 7.59 1.150 125 105 101 135 98 101 98 125 98 0.750 573W18x60 17.6 18.2 16.00 0.415 0.695 7.56 1.100 108 91 90 116 77 90 77 108 77 0.695 528W18x55 16.2 18.1 16.04 0.39 0.63 7.53 1.030 94 74 80 101 64 74 64 94 64 0.630 486W18x50 14.7 18 16.06 0.355 0.57 7.5 0.972 78 61 69 83 48 61 48 78 48 0.570 441

W18x46 13.5 18.1 16.08 0.36 0.605 6.06 1.010 72 69 73 87 50 69 50 72 50 0.605 405W18x40 11.8 17.9 16.05 0.315 0.525 6.02 0.927 50 52 59 67 34 52 34 50 34 0.525 354W18x35 10.3 17.7 16.05 0.3 0.425 6 0.827 35 34 51 57 29 34 29 35 29 0.425 309

W16x100 29.7 17 13.62 0.585 0.985 10.4 1.690 179 182 184 231 255 182 184 179 179 0.985 891W16x89 26.4 16.8 13.64 0.525 0.875 10.4 1.580 158 144 156 186 184 144 156 158 144 0.875 792W16x77 22.9 16.5 13.56 0.455 0.76 10.3 1.470 126 108 127 140 120 108 120 126 108 0.760 687W16x67 20 16.3 13.56 0.395 0.665 10.2 1.370 100 83 103 106 79 83 79 100 79 0.665 600

W16x57 16.8 16.4 14.16 0.43 0.715 7.12 1.120 97 96 95 125 97 95 95 97 95 0.715 504W16x50 14.7 16.3 14.24 0.38 0.63 7.07 1.030 75 74 78 97 67 74 67 75 67 0.630 441W16x45 13.3 16.1 14.17 0.345 0.565 7.04 0.967 60 60 67 80 50 60 50 60 50 0.565 399W16x40 11.8 16 14.19 0.305 0.505 7 0.907 44 48 56 63 35 48 35 44 35 0.505 354W16x36 10.6 15.9 14.24 0.295 0.43 6.99 0.832 33 35 51 56 31 35 31 33 31 0.430 318

W16x31 9.13 15.9 14.22 0.275 0.44 5.53 0.842 18 36 48 50 25 36 25 18 18 0.440 274W16x26 7.68 15.7 14.21 0.25 0.345 5.5 0.747 1 22 39 40 19 22 19 1 1 0.345 230

W14x808 237 22.8 11.36 3.74 5.12 18.6 5.720 1535 666667 3690 8530 79851 3690 3690 1535 1535 5.120 7110W14x730 215 22.4 11.38 3.07 4.91 17.9 5.510 1238 666667 2922 6121 44088 2922 2922 1238 1238 4.910 6450W14x665 196 21.6 11.36 2.83 4.52 17.7 5.120 1100 666667 2509 5211 34596 2509 2509 1100 1100 4.520 5880W14x605 178 20.9 11.38 2.6 4.16 17.4 4.760 978 666667 2149 4411 26781 2149 2149 978 978 4.160 5340W14x550 162 20.2 11.36 2.38 3.82 17.2 4.420 865 666667 1833 3709 20578 1833 1833 865 865 3.820 4860

bfb =Fy=

tw tf bf f Rn f Rn f Rv f Rn tf

in2 fRv (kips) f Rn (kips) f Rn (kips) f Rn (kips) f Rn (kips)

G1
AISC: or max flange plate width
D2
AISC: Design Guide Recommends the use of 36 ksi for Fy (even for higher strength material) because testing was done only on A36 columns.
R2
Jason Ericksen: Doesn't really mean anything since the tension and comprseeion are different as well as the panel shear. They can’t all be compared to one value.
I3
AISC: Panel zone remains in the elastic range
J3
AISC: For extended end plate connections Mnf, the column flange yield strength, is compared to Mnp, the no prying moment strength of the bolts. For other connections, the strength provided is compared to the flange force. For the other connections if the flange or flange plate width is less than 15% of the column flage width then the strenth is 1,000,000 kips (ie the check is unnecessary
K3
AISC: change to oaccount for extended end plate connections.
L3
AISC: May be overly conservative for extended end plate connections.
M3
AISC: Checked for beams at both sides only. If only one beam strength is reported as 1,000,000 kips.
Page 15: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

W14x500 147 19.6 11.40 2.19 3.5 17 4.100 773 666667 1569 3142 15976 1569 1569 773 773 3.500 4410W14x455 134 19 11.38 2.02 3.21 16.8 3.810 691 666667 1350 2673 12559 1350 1350 691 691 3.210 4020

16.7W14x426 125 18.7 11.44 1.88 3.04 16.7 3.630 633 666667 1200 2334 10071 1200 1200 633 633 3.040 3750W14x398 117 18.3 11.42 1.77 2.85 16.6 3.440 583 666667 1074 2068 8420 1074 1074 583 583 2.850 3510W14x370 109 17.9 11.38 1.66 2.66 16.5 3.260 535 666667 957 1819 6970 957 957 535 535 2.660 3270W14x342 101 17.5 11.36 1.54 2.47 16.4 3.070 485 666667 839 1569 5575 839 839 485 485 2.470 3030W14x311 91.4 17.1 11.38 1.41 2.26 16.2 2.860 434 666667 719 1317 4271 719 719 434 434 2.260 2742W14x283 83.3 16.7 11.36 1.29 2.07 16.1 2.670 388 666667 617 1105 3277 617 617 388 388 2.070 2499W14x257 75.6 16.4 11.42 1.18 1.89 16 2.490 348 666667 529 925 2495 529 529 348 348 1.890 2268W14x233 68.5 16 11.36 1.07 1.72 15.9 2.320 308 666667 449 763 1870 449 449 308 308 1.720 2055W14x211 62 15.7 11.38 0.98 1.56 15.8 2.160 277 666667 385 639 1434 385 385 277 277 1.560 1860W14x193 56.8 15.5 11.42 0.89 1.44 15.7 2.040 248 666667 332 531 1070 332 332 248 248 1.440 1704W14x176 51.8 15.2 11.38 0.83 1.31 15.7 1.910 227 666667 292 458 871 292 292 227 227 1.310 1554W14x159 46.7 15 11.42 0.745 1.19 15.6 1.790 201 666667 247 371 628 247 247 201 201 1.190 1401W14x145 42.7 14.8 11.42 0.68 1.09 15.5 1.690 181 666667 214 310 477 214 214 181 181 1.090 1281

14.7W14x132 38.8 14.7 11.44 0.645 1.03 14.7 1.630 171 666667 197 279 407 197 197 171 171 1.030 1164W14x120 35.3 14.5 11.42 0.59 0.94 14.7 1.540 154 666667 171 233 312 171 171 154 154 0.940 1059W14x109 32 14.3 11.38 0.525 0.86 14.6 1.460 135 666667 145 187 220 145 145 135 135 0.860 960W14x99 29.1 14.2 11.44 0.485 0.78 14.6 1.380 124 666667 128 159 173 128 128 124 124 0.780 873W14x90 26.5 14 11.38 0.44 0.71 14.5 1.310 111 666667 111 131 130 111 111 111 111 0.710 795

10.1W14x82 24 14.3 11.40 0.51 0.855 10.1 1.450 125 137 140 178 202 137 140 125 125 0.855 720W14x74 21.8 14.2 11.44 0.45 0.785 10.1 1.380 105 116 118 141 138 116 118 105 105 0.785 654W14x68 20 14 11.38 0.415 0.72 10 1.310 91 97 104 120 109 97 104 91 91 0.720 600W14x61 17.9 13.9 11.42 0.375 0.645 9.99 1.240 75 78 90 97 80 78 80 75 75 0.645 537

8.06W14x53 15.6 13.9 11.40 0.37 0.66 8.06 1.250 66 82 89 96 77 82 77 66 66 0.660 468W14x48 14.1 13.8 11.42 0.34 0.595 8.03 1.190 54 66 79 81 60 66 60 54 54 0.595 423W14x43 12.6 13.7 11.46 0.305 0.53 8 1.120 42 53 67 65 43 53 43 42 42 0.530 378

W12x336 98.8 16.8 9.70 1.78 2.96 13.4 3.550 538 666667 1113 2132 10082 1113 1113 538 538 2.960 2964W12x305 89.6 16.3 9.70 1.63 2.71 13.2 3.300 478 1377 951 1792 7742 951 951 478 478 2.710 2688W12x279 81.9 15.9 9.76 1.53 2.47 13.1 3.070 438 1144 834 1564 6363 834 834 438 438 2.470 2457W12x252 74 15.4 9.70 1.4 2.25 13 2.850 388 949 712 1311 4905 712 712 388 388 2.250 2220W12x230 67.7 15.1 9.76 1.29 2.07 12.9 2.670 351 803 617 1115 3814 617 617 351 351 2.070 2031W12x210 61.8 14.7 9.70 1.18 1.9 12.8 2.500 312 677 531 936 2937 531 531 312 312 1.900 1854W12x190 55.8 14.4 9.74 1.06 1.74 12.7 2.330 275 568 447 762 2120 447 447 275 275 1.740 1674W12x170 50 14 9.68 0.96 1.56 12.6 2.160 242 456 378 624 1585 378 378 242 242 1.560 1500W12x152 44.7 13.7 9.70 0.87 1.4 12.5 2.000 215 367 319 512 1177 319 319 215 215 1.400 1341W12x136 39.9 13.4 9.70 0.79 1.25 12.4 1.850 191 293 270 421 881 270 270 191 191 1.250 1197W12x120 35.3 13.1 9.70 0.71 1.11 12.3 1.700 167 231 225 339 640 225 225 167 167 1.110 1059W12x106 31.2 12.9 9.72 0.61 0.99 12.2 1.590 142 184 182 254 405 182 182 142 142 0.990 936W12x96 28.2 12.7 9.70 0.55 0.9 12.2 1.500 126 152 156 207 297 152 156 126 126 0.900 846W12x87 25.6 12.5 9.68 0.515 0.81 12.1 1.410 114 123 138 180 245 123 138 114 114 0.810 768W12x79 23.2 12.4 9.74 0.47 0.735 12.1 1.330 99 101 120 150 185 101 120 99 99 0.735 696W12x72 21.1 12.3 9.76 0.43 0.67 12 1.270 85 84 105 125 141 84 105 85 84 0.670 633W12x65 19.1 12.1 9.70 0.39 0.605 12 1.200 71 69 91 103 106 69 91 71 69 0.605 573

Page 16: Clean Columns - MESTEEL.COM · XLS file · Web view2010-02-26 · Clean Columns V4.0 was developed to return the lightest column ... based on the criteria in AISC Design Guide Series

W12x58 17 12.2 9.72 0.36 0.64 10 1.240 61 77 86 92 83 77 83 61 61 0.640 510W12x53 15.6 12.1 9.76 0.345 0.575 9.99 1.170 54 62 79 83 73 62 73 54 54 0.575 468

W12x50 14.6 12.2 9.92 0.37 0.64 8.08 1.140 54 77 83 96 89 77 83 54 54 0.640 438W12x45 13.1 12.1 9.94 0.335 0.575 8.05 1.080 43 62 71 79 66 62 66 43 43 0.575 393W12x40 11.7 11.9 9.86 0.295 0.515 8.01 1.020 31 50 60 61 45 50 45 31 31 0.515 351

W10x112 32.9 11.4 7.90 0.755 1.25 10.4 1.750 155 293 245 397 945 245 245 155 155 1.250 987W10x100 29.4 11.1 7.86 0.68 1.12 10.3 1.620 136 235 206 322 694 206 206 136 136 1.120 882W10x88 25.9 10.8 7.82 0.605 0.99 10.3 1.490 116 184 170 255 491 170 170 116 116 0.990 777W10x77 22.6 10.6 7.86 0.53 0.87 10.2 1.370 94 142 139 197 328 139 139 94 94 0.870 678W10x68 20 10.4 7.86 0.47 0.77 10.1 1.270 76 111 115 155 229 111 115 76 76 0.770 600W10x60 17.6 10.2 7.84 0.42 0.68 10.1 1.180 61 87 97 124 164 87 97 61 61 0.680 528W10x54 15.8 10.1 7.86 0.37 0.615 10 1.120 49 71 81 97 112 71 81 49 49 0.615 474W10x49 14.4 9.98 7.86 0.34 0.56 10 1.060 40 59 71 82 87 59 71 40 40 0.560 432

W10x45 13.3 10.1 7.86 0.35 0.62 8.02 1.120 38 72 77 88 95 72 77 38 38 0.620 399W10x39 11.5 9.92 7.86 0.315 0.53 7.99 1.030 27 53 65 71 69 53 65 27 27 0.530 345W10x33 9.71 9.73 7.86 0.29 0.435 7.96 0.935 15 35 55 58 54 35 54 15 15 0.435 291