8/9/2019 Clauses 1 and 2 of the Draft Scotland Bill
Constitutional Implications
1/9
!"# %&'(')#* +,'-./0* 12..3
!"# 4'0)-2-5-2'0/. 67(.2,/-2'0) '8 9&/8- 4./5)#) : /0* ;
9&< =/&> ?..2'--
@#/*#& 20 %5A.2, B/CD E02F#&)2-G '8 4/7A&2*H#
?I#,5-2F# )577/&G
4./5)# : '8 -"# (&'(')#* +,'-./0* 12..3
*'#) 0'-D /) ,5&-.G *&/8-#*D J7/>#K -"# +,'--2)"
%/&.2/7#0- (#&7/0#0- /) B'&* +72-" )/2*
2- )"'5.* 20 "2) 8'C'&* -' -"# @#('&- '8 -"# +72-"
4'772))2'0L
*'#) 0'- 50/7A2H5'5).G 27(.#7#0- -"# (&'(')/. 7/*# 20 -"#
@#('&- 2-)#.8D C"2," )/2* -"/-
EM .#H2)./-2'0 )"'5.* )-/-# -"/- -"# +,'--2)" %/&.2/7#0- /0*
N'F#&07#0- / (#&7/0#0-
20)-2-5-2'0)L 4./5)# : 20)-#/* /*'(-) /0 /&H5/A.G
C#/>#& 8'&75./-2'0 -' -"# #88#,- -"/- -"')#
20)-2-5-2'0) / J,'H02)#* /) (#&7/0#0-KL
2) .2>#.G -' A# '8 0' .#H/. #88#,-< 6- 7/GD "'C#F#&D
A# '8 ('.2-2,/. )2H0282,/0,#L
,'5.* A# F2)#* )' /) -' /--#7(- -' (,.5*# /A'.2-2'0 '8 -"#
+,'--2)" %/&.2/7#0- F2/ EM
.#H2)./-2'0 #2-"#& /A)'.5-#.G '& 50.#)) ,#&-/20
,'0*2-2'0) O##.G -' A# .272-#* '& 0' .#H/. #88#,- -$1/7,4
d;[[;e ?SQ4 :aZ OX*720P# (&'F2)2'0 /.'0H -"#)# .20#)D 2- 72H"-
,'0,#2F/A.G /.)'
(&'F2*# -"/- ,& C/) 0'- -' A# /7#0*#* '& (#/.#*
50.#)) )(#,282#* ,'0*2-2'0) C# )/-2)82#*
O)' /) -' /--#7(- -' 8',.')# -"# ('))2A2.2-G '8 -"#
)-&2,-2'0) 5('0 /A'.2-2'0 20 4./5)# :A#20H ,2&,57F#0-#* AG
-"# (#/. '& /7#0*7#0- '8 4./5)# : 2-)#.8P#.G -' A# C2-"'5- /0G
*2,- .#H/. #88#,-< !"2) (&'7(-) -C'
'A)#&F/-2'0)0'C.#*H20H -"# +#C#.
4'0F#0-2'0 20 )-/-5-# *'#) 0'- -5&0 -"# ,'0F#0-2'0 8&'7
/ ('.2-2,/. 20-' / "/&* .#H/.
)-&/20-D .#H2)./-2F# ,'H02-2'0 '8 -"# ,'0F#0-2'0
/&H5/A.G *'#) 20F#)- 2- C2-" H/-#&('.2-2,/. Y /0* )7/..f,
,'0)-2-5-2'0/. Y 8'&,#< X EM N'F#&07#0- )##>20H -'
(#&)5/*# -"# EM
%/&.2/7#0- -' .#H2)./-# 8'& +,'-./0* /H/20)- 2-) C2)"#)
C'5.* 20#F2-/A.G 8/,# /0 5("2.. ('.2-2,/.
)-&5HH.#L 4./5)# ; C'5.* 7/># -"# H&/*2#0-
)-##(#& )-2..20H -' *#-#&720# C"#-"#& EM
.#H2)./-2'0
)"'5.* A# 20-#&(-#* /) 502./-#&/..G 20-#&8#&20H
20 *#F'.F#* /88/2&)3 / -#0/A.# 20-#&(-/-2'0
/F'2*20H )5," /0 20,5&)2'0 C'5.* A# ,'0)-2-5-2'0/..G
(#&/A.#< +5," /0 /&H57#0- ,'5.*
'0.G A# )-H-"#0#* AG / (&'F2)2'0 )5," /) 4./5)# ; C"2,"D /-
-"# F#&G .#/)-D C'5.*
#F2*#0,# / ,'772-7#0- '0 -"# (/&- '8 -"# EM %/&.2/7#0-
-' -"# (&20,2(.# '8 )(#,- 8'&
*#F'.F#* /5-'0'7G
