View
213
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
What's Your Favourite Colour?
When you were 12? When you were 3? When you will be 72? What, then, is the favourite colour of [insert your
name here]?
Problem of Historical Analysis
Things change How large a chunk should we take for snapshot? What do we mean when we say 'what the Greeks
thought'?
Diachronic Analysis
A study of how things change over time From dia, Greek for 'through' And chronos, Greek for 'time'
Synchronic Analysis
Takes conditions during one chunk of time as basically the same
Necessary to choose some period about which to say something
Syn- or Diachronic?
“Intercourse does not appear to have been regarded by the Greeks as ordinarily polluting or dangerous for the participants”
Syn- or Diachronic?
“The reproductive theory which enjoyed greatest support in medical circles down until the time of Aristotle was that known today as pangenesis, or preformation.” Garland 29.
Sources as Time-guide for Reader
x The Greeks believed that 'the mother is not the begetter of that which is called the child, but only nurse of the newly-implanted seed.
Ok In Aeschylus's Eumenides Apollo makes the notorious observation that ...
Another Methodological Crux
How can we get at ancient practice from ancient theory?
Literature was expensive, created by the upper classes
Does Medicine tell us anything about Health?
Until 3rd c. Understanding Based On
External observation of human body Analogy from natural world Assumptions and observations from human
society Slaughter of animals
Why are We M/F (Dimorphism)?
Background in Hesiod's (8th c.) myth, where sexes appear to be different species
Women as punishment Compare Aristophanes (5th c) and Empedocles
(6th c.): love binds universe together Human sexual union part of that Which is the Greek view?
Similarity
To parent's activity at conception Sparta: energetic child from athletic mother Prohibition against drink
Age of Parents
Women in sources 13-14 yrs, against recommendations of Plato, Aristotle
Men around 30 Cause of infant (and maternal) mortality?
Predominance of Male Seed
Common opinion Reflected in birth of
Athena Eileithyia on L. Hermes with caduceus cp. medical authors
G29
Pangenesis
From pan, Greek for all and genesis, Greek for formation or creation
Small particles of all parts of body are in male and female seed
“passages extend into this from the whole body, which enable the fluid to pass to and from the spinal marrow.” Seed
Man burst forth from man, and is separated by being severed by a kind of blow. - Demokritos (=Democritus) of Abdera
Epigenesis
Advocated by Aristotle in 4th c. BC Theory proposes development by accretion and
organization of matter (more accurate than pangenesis in this)
Arist. also argued that female contribution was menstrual fluids, an incomplete semen
Ftm. female provides the matter, male the inner development
What Did 'the Greeks' Think?
Consider question of sex differentiation (G. p 32-33)
One view? Do we hold one view on this topic? Is there an over-all pattern to Greek thought on
this topic?
Transmission of Parental Characteristics
We search out rams and asses and horses, Cyrnus, that are of noble birth, and each man wishes his stock to be mounted by good males. But marriage to a woman who is bad, and the daughter of a bad man, causes the noble no concern -- if, that is, she brings him money. -- Theognis 7th c. BC
Fertility and Sterility
Reproduction was an effort and a necessity in ancient world
Children are your employees and your pension Woman's role revolved around reproduction Greater emphasis on correction of sterility than
on contraception
Divine Explanations
Like disease and famine, sterility sometimes understood as caused and cured by gods
Temples for healing gods include models of wombs
Water from springs near temples bring fertility
Physical Explanations for Sterility
“Women who have wombs that are dense and cold to not conceive; women who have wombs that are watery do not conceive because the seed is quenched. Women who have parched and over-headted wombs do not conceive ...” Hippocratic Aphorisms 5.62
Men are functionally sterile if “the sperm cools down by being transported too far and sperm that has cooled down is not generative” Aristotle Generation of Animals 1.718a22-5
Development of Foetus
Scientific observation from autopsy of aborted foetuses
Aristotle's experimentation with hens' eggs Candling shows the beating heart first of all
Treatment of Pregnant Women
Considered in tenuous state Capable of being religiously 'polluted' Not themselves polluting in general Not to perform strenuous exercise
Contraception
Concern mostly for prostitutes Medical or physical means mostly ineffectual Womb as 'jar' for seed which can be blocked
before or emptied after sex Hot / cold
Abortion
In context of societies that apparently allowed exposure of children
So not ethically controversial before Christian era One method through suppositories Disallowed by Hippocratic Oath: “I will not give
a pessary to induce abortion”