City of Los Angeles CITY CALIFORNIAclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2012/12-0071_rpt_CLK_07-08...2019/07/08 · 102 2111027010 Kav Armand & Adina Trs / Kav Trust_____ Kazar Haritvun &

City of Los AngelesHOLLY L. WOLCOTT CITY CLERK

OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERKCALIFORNIA

Business Improvement District Division200 N. Spring Street, Room 395

Los Angeles, CA 90012 (213) 978-1099

FAX: (213) 978-1130

SHANNON HOPPES EXECUTIVE OFFICER £

PATRICE LATTIMORE DIVISION MANAGERD

clerk.lacitv.orgERIC GARCETTI MAYOR

BALLOT TABULATION RESULTS FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE HISTORIC OLD TOWN CANOGA PARK BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (CF NO. 12-0071)

SECTION 1. Results of the Proposition 218 ballot tabulation, pursuant to Article XIII D of the California Constitution, Section 36600 et seq. of the California Streets and Highways Code, and Section 53753 of the California Government Code:

Ballots Cast Weighted Value Percent of Ballots Cast

Supporting (“Yes”) ballots: $89,125.4544 70.80%

$36,765.99Opposing (“No”) ballots: 26 29.20%

[NOTE: There were twenty-four (24) ballots cast that could not be verified because they were not properly completed. These ballots were therefore not included in the overall ballot tabulation. See final page of attached ballot tabulation spreadsheet for breakdown of total assessment value, total property owners, total parcels and weighted value of each parcel.]

The weighted value of the supporting ballots exceeds the weighted value of the opposing ballots.

SECTION 2. Protests received, pursuant to Section 53753(d) of the California Government Code:

Number of valid protests received__0

Ten speaker cards were received. One was a duplicate and nine were general comments.

CONCLUSION: The tabulated value of the opposing ballots cast does not exceed the tabulated value of the supporting ballots cast. A majority protest, pursuant to Section 4(e) of Article XIII D of the California Constitution, Section 36623 of the California Streets and Highways Code, and Section 53753(e)(2) of the California Government Code, is not found to exist and the proposed establishment may be authorized by the City Council at this time.

BY: APPROVED:

jaSorf-

l!6/h

\

HOLLY L. W City Clerk

Deputy City Clerk

7-5-/9DateDate

AN EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY - AFFIRMATIVE ACTION EMPLOYER

Los Angeles City Clerk Administrative Service Division

Special Assessments Section Business Improvement District Unit

Historic Old Town Canoga Park 2020-2029 Proposition 218 Ballot Tabulation - Official Results July 02, 2019

TotalAssessment

% Yes of ballots

% No of ballotsNo. APN Owner Name Vote Comments

1 2023008032 22053 Sherman Wav LLC $559.49 Not Cast2 2111027022 $1.290.027107 Alabama LLC Yes 1.02471%3 2111027041 7107 Alabama LLC $860.13 Yes 0.68323%4 2111028032 7127 Canoga Partners LLC $882.24 Yes 0.70079%5 2111020015 $830.117219 Owensmouth Ave LLC Not Cast6 2111026007 Acornhill Investments LLC $427.39 No 0.33949%7 2111020025 Afrashteh Parvaneh Tr $859.21 No 0.68250%8 2111017030 Allen Lawrence W & Viola G Trs $442.84 Yes 0.35176%9 2111017031 $855.55Allen Lawrence W & Viola G Trs Yes 0.67959%10 2023008022 B & R Real Estate LLC $559.61 Not Cast11 2023008026 B & R Real Estate LLC $906.11

$859.33Not Cast

12 2111028026 B & W Cooling & Heating Inc No 0.68260%13 2111018009 Badillo Rafael & Alicia $430.01 Not Cast14 2111024017 Beridon Alfred & Rhonda Trs & Walker Malcolm $972.76 No 0.77270%15 2111024016 Beridon Alfred & Rhonda Trs / Walker Malcolm V $1,611.18

$1,611.07No 1.27982%

16 2111024015 Beridon Alfred M Co-Tr EtAI & Mason Michael C No 1.27973%17 2111020024 $1.288.99Bettar Austin J Jr Co Tr et al / Bettar Family Trs &

Beutler Alan__________________________1.02389%Yes

18 2111018015 $427.51$427.39$254.36

Yes 0.33959%19 2111018016 Beutler Alan & Mcneelv Brvna

Bonilla Antonio Trs_________Yes 0.33949%

20 2111027002 Not Cast Ballot not filled in completely.21 2111019028 $1,288.88Booker Henry Trs et al / Henry C Booker Trs &

Brown Melvin & Gloria Trs / Brown Family Trs &C & P Properties 11 LLC___________________Casillas Jose F__________________________

Not Cast22 2023007026 $1,093.75 Not Cast23 2111025028 $1,718.43

$301.35Not Cast Received via email, not counted.

24 2111027009 No 0.23937%25 2111027018 Cawelti Lila M et al Trs & Cawelti Family Trust

Cawelti Lila M et al Trs & Cawelti Family Trust Cawelti Lila M et al Trs & Cawelti Family Trust Chen Hu & Pai S & Chen Jay J____________

$429.89 No 0.34148%26 $430.01

$1,720.03$561.43

2111027019 0.34157%No27 2111027036 No 1.36628%28 2023008012 Not Cast29 2111019030 Child Development Institute $1,288.99 Yes 1.02389%

Page 1 of 8 Printed on 07/03/2019

TotalAssessment

% Yes ofballots

% No ofballotsNo. APN Owner Name Vote Comments

30 2111019031 Child Development Institute $1.288.99 Yes 1.02389%31 2111019010 City National Bank Tr Et Al & Michael Luros Gst $425.79 Not Cast32 2111018900 City of Los Angeles $1.253.70 Yes 0.99586%33 2111019902 City of Los Angeles $830.45 Yes 0.65966%34 2111019904 City of Los Angeles $859.21 Yes 0.68250%35 2111019905 City of Los Angeles $859.10 Yes 0.68241%36 2111020900 City of Los Angeles $1.259.54 Yes 1.00050%37 2111025900 City of Los Angeles $0.00 0.00000%Yes38 2111025901 City of Los Angeles $0.00 0.00000%Yes39 2111026900 City of Los Angeles

City of Los Angeles City of Los Angeles City of Los Angeles Cohen Crystal A

$829.88 0.65920%Yes40 2111026902 $859.33 Yes 0.68260%

0.72222%41 2111026904 $909.21 Yes42 2111027900 $859.21 Yes 0.68250%43 2111026004 $454.66 0.36115%Yes44 2111027015 Cohen Shlomo & Triple O LLC $830.45 Not Cast

211101700945 Constantinescu Adrian Co Tr / Constantinescu $680.71 Not Cast46 2111027001 Corcoran Enterprises

County of Los Angeles$244.72 0.19439%Yes

47 2111026903 $2.577.87 Yes 2.04769%48 2111026023 Coutin Harvey Co Tr & Coutin Grandchildren

Coutin Harvey Co Tr Et Al / Coutin Family Trust & Daic Edgar L & Patricia N Trs / E & P Daic Trust / Deyoung Annette L Tr & Devounq Family Trust Deyoung Annette L Tr & Deyoung Family Trust Deyoung Annette L Tr & Devounq Family TrustDihmz Properties LLC______________________Dihmz Properties LLC______________________Espinosa Alfonso S & Sanchez Paula G_______Estusha LLC_____________________________

$429.66$1.718.66$1.010.53

Not Cast Not Cast Not Cast

49 211102501350 211102101351 2111022008 $1.870.95 Not Cast Ballot not filled in completely.

Ballot not filled in completely. Ballot not filled in completely.

52 2111022010 $1.253.17 Not Cast53 2111022023 $1.252.94

$1.448.24Not Cast

54 2111018013 No 1.15039%55 2111018014 $851.92

$1.151.38No 0.67671%

56 2111023018 Yes 0.91458%$1.791.87

$557.6557 2111022021 Not Cast58 2111021014 Evans Robert W Tr / William A Evans Deed Trust Not Cast59 $859.212111017001 Exa Design Enterprises______________

Fatima Islamic Society_______________Fernandez Miguel & Luz Trs / M A & L M

Not Cast60. 2111018001 $1.289.79

$429.78Not Cast

61 2111020016 0.34139%Yes62 2111024001 Foster George G Jr Tr & Foster Trust

Foster Georoe G Jr Tr & Foster Trust$2,445.68$1.783.16

Not Cast63 2111024018 Not Cast


TotalAssessment

% Yes ofballots


64 2111018033 Fountain On Peachtree Inc $1.289.79 Not Cast65 2111018021 Fresno Ventures LLC $512.94 Not Cast66 2111021010 FYH $1.252.83 Yes 0.99517%67 2111021011 FYH $1.252.83 Yes 0.99517%68 2111026009 G & F Property Management $859.21 Not Cast69 2111017022 Gadi Shahram Tr $801.92 Not Cast Ballot not filled in completely

Ballot not filled in completely Ballot not filled in completely Ballot not filled in completely Ballot not filled in completely Ballot not filled in completely

70 2111017033 Gadi Shahram Tr $886.25 Not Cast71 2111017035 Gadi Shahram Tr $486.61 Not Cast72 2111017036 Gadi Shahram Tr $485.92 Not Cast73 2111017026 Gadi Victoria B Tr / Gadi S Tr / Shahram Gadi $886.02 Not Cast74 2111017034 Gadi Victoria B Tr / Gadi S Tr / Shahram Gadi $888.20 Not Cast75 2023008014 Gain Properties LLC $559.61 Not Cast76 2111018023 Garzon Gustavo & Kathryn T Trs / Garzon Family

Gelb Enterprises & United Service Acceptance Goldman Ben & Dorothy Trs / Goldman Trust Gonen Beniamin & Osnat Tr / Gonen Family Gruberaer Don & Risa______________________

$859.56 Not Cast77 2024001048 $3.758.71 Yes 2.98568%78 2111025001 $1.012.71 No 0.80443%79 2111027038 $805.96 Non Vote80 2111020012 $852.04 Not Cast81 2111026017 Guinev Partnership________________________

Hamid Abdul S Tr / 21709 Sherman Wav Family Harmon Robert G Jr Co Tr / Harmon Family Trust Haven Hills Inc____________________________

$859.33 Not Cast82 2111020014 $426.02 Not Cast83 2111028033 $441.01 Yes 0.35031%84 2111026018 $859.21 No 0.68250%85 2111028020 $515.60Haven Hills Inc No 0.40956%86 2111028021 Haven Hills Inc $859.33 0.68260%No87 2111024008 HDB Family Properties II & Newton Evelyn Co Tr

Hefty John & Shirley Trs et al / Heft Family Trust Hesk Inc________________________________

$1.611.07 Yes 1.27973%88 $1.119.21

$854,102023008028 Yes 0.88903%

89 2111020011 Non Vote90 2111018012 Hiller Arthur N & Rena Trs / Hiller Family Trust

Holm Raymond E & Roxie V Trs / Holm Trust Horton Edward C & Susan R Et Al / Miller Steven

$429.66$1.253.06

Not Cast91 2111021012 Yes 0.99535%92 2023008029 $1.119.10 Not Cast93 2111019001 Hudson Howard & Frances Trs / Hudson Family

Ibrahim Ted Tr___________________________$1,012.94

$429.550.80461%No.

M 2111026013 Not Cast95 2111026016 Jackson Roy J & Cheryl A

JPMoraan Chase Bank$429.55 Not Cast

96 2111022012 $2.085.46 Not Cast97 2111028042 JRE Equities LLC $858.98 No 0.68232%


TotalAssessment

% Yes ofballots


98 2111017027 June Investments LLC $919.63 Not Cast99 2111017040 JVH Enterprises Inc $3.086.53 No 2.45174%100 2023007025 Kapur Raj & Indira Trs $2,074.65 Yes 1.64797%101 2111017039 Karaan Maurice & Nawal $875.71 Not Cast102 2111027010 Kav Armand & Adina Trs / Kav Trust_______

Kazar Haritvun & Magda E Trs / Kazar Family Khakshov David & Ebrahhimian Rova______

$301.35 Not Cast103 2111028034 $882.01 Not Cast104 2111028007 $426.59 Yes 0.33886%105 2111028006 Khakshov David & Rova E $427.39 Not Cast106 2111025011 King Nicole L $429.55 Not Cast107 2111026019 Kwan Lily Q $859.21 No 0.68250%108 2111020035 LA Commercial Real Estate LLC $1.718.66 Yes 1.36519%109 2111029904 LACMTA $15,618.22 Yes 12.40610%110 2111029905 LACMTA $1.604.08 Yes 1.27418%111 2111019029 Lallo Family Limited Partnership No 2 LP $1.703.96 No 1.35352%112 2111028022 Lawrence Falcone et al / Lawrence Falcone Trust $429.66 No 0.34129%113 2111028023 Lawrence Falcone et al / Lawrence Falcone Trust $1.288.99

$805.96$859.33

No 1.02389%114 2111027004 Lee Family Office LLC_________

Levy Itamar_________________Lorsch Irene S R & I Lorsch Trust

Yes 0.64020%115 2111025010 Not Cast116 2111026005 $854.79

$854.79$429.66$859.21

$2.395.92$854.67$875.25$594.71

Yes 0.67899%2111026006117 Lorsch Irene S Tr / Rudolf & Irene Lorsch Trust Yes 0.67899%

118 2111027033 M & M Advance Investments LLC Not Cast119 2111027034 M & M Advance Investments LLC Not Cast120 2111023019 Maico Inc._____________________________

Marasco A Arlene Tr / A Arlene Marasco TrustNot Cast

121 2111028004 Not Cast122 2111028038 Marquez Silvester & Savina R

Martin Auto Color Inc_______Not Cast

123 2111017010 No 0.47240%124 2111025005 Mccobb Edward E & Richard W $851.92

$0.00$851.92

$1,294.38

Yes 0.67671%125 2111025025 Mccobb Edward E & Richard W Yes 0.00000%

126 2111025027 Mccobb Edward E & Richard W Yes 0.67671%127 2111028041 Mcdonald Theodore R & Lowe J M Not Cast Missing signature.128 2111028029 Mekiian Holdings LLC

Merrick Roberta Tr$830.00$426.02$799.17

Not Cast129 2111018019 Not Cast130 2111022007 Nersesian Leonard & Betty Trs

Nersesian Leonard & Betty TrsNot Cast Missing signature.

Missing signature.131 2111022009 $515.48 Not Cast


TotalAssessment

% Yes ofballots


132 2111024004 Newton Properties LLC & HDB Family Properties $1.253.98 Yes 0.99608%133 2111024005 Newton Properties LLC & HDB Family Properties $1.253.86 Yes 0.99599%134 2111024006 Newton Properties LLC & HDB Family Properties

Newton Properties LLC & HDB Family Properties Newton Properties LLC & HDB Family Properties Nikneiad Shahin__________________________

$2,434.11 Yes 1.93350%135 2111024007 $2,756.04 Yes 2.18922%136 2111024020 $2,787.09 Yes 2.21388%137 2111026002 $596.54 Not Cast Ballot not filled in completely.138 2111023016 Nitta Gwendalee A Tr & Laity Lawrence Co Tr/ $1,492.91 No 1.18587%139 2111026008 Nosrati Mayer & Revital $599.41 Not Cast Ballot not filled in completely.140 2023008015 Nunneri Paul Co Tr / Weisberq David $559.61 Yes 0.44452%141 2111019007 Owensmouth LLC $644.50 Not Cast142 2111019011 Owensmouth Pioneers LLC $426.02 0.33840%Yes143 2111025007 Owensmouth Pioneers LLC $852.73 Yes 0.67735%144 2111025008 Owensmouth Pioneers LLC $829.88 0.65920%Yes145 2111025002 Palazzo Italiano LLC $1,056.71 Yes 0.83938%146 2111020022 Parker John & Maria Trs / Brown Scott A Co Tr / $429.55

$429.66Yes 0.34121%

147 2111020023 Parker John & Maria Trs / Brown Scott A Co Tr / 0.34129%Yes148 2111019008 Parker John et al / Brown Scott $644.50 Yes 0.51195%149 2111019009 Parker John et al / Brown Scott $1,689.32 Yes 1.34189%150 2111027003 Partvka Charlie Tr & Charlie L Partvka Trust

Patel Rasikbhai N & Dipak R____________Pierpont Mark________________________Price Oliver R II & Laura T______________

$411.61 Not Cast151 2111028001 $683.92

$432.18$429.78$851.88$859.21$681.63$341.96$429.66

Not Cast152 2111018011 Yes 0.34330%153 2111019019 Not Cast

2111019020154 Price Oliver R II & Laura T Not Cast155 2111019021 Price Oliver R II & Laura T Not Cast156 2111019016 Puetz Henry F & Mary E Trs

Puetz Henry F & Mary E Trs Puetz Henry F & Mary E Trs Raedeke Michael J Tr/ JWR Trust

0.54144%Yes157 2111019017 0.27163%

0.34129%Yes

158 2111020020 Yes159 2024001028 $5.139.72 4.08266%No160 2111018010 Rahimzadeh Ricky & Patricia D

Rawa & Sons LLC__________$430.01 Not Cast

161 2111028008 $1,357.99$1,288.88

$859.33

Not Cast162 2111027032 Resalat Islamic Educational Foundation Not Cast Received via email, not counted.163 2111027037 Resalat Islamic Educational Foundation Not Cast164 2111018017 $425.90

$824,73Reynolds Lance & Olinda_______________Reynolds Lance & Romani Reynolds Olinda

Not Cast165 2111018022 Not Cast


% Yes ofballots

TotalAssessment


$504.14166 2023008010 Ritz Development Not Cast167 2023008011 Ritz Development $567.16 Not Cast168 2023008027 Ritz Development $1.052.57 Not Cast169 2111018018 Rustam Mohammed Tr / Rustam Samir Co Tr / $425.90 Not Cast170 2111027013 Rustam Samir & Cecilia Trs / Newman Trust $383.70 Not Cast171 2111027014 Rustam Samir Co Tr / Newman Trust $523.10 Not Cast172 2111023020 Saadian Jack Tr & Jack Saadian Trust $2,456.19 Not Cast173 2111022022 Saenz Irene S Tr $1.153.90 Not Cast174 2111028024 Sainz Raymond Tr $429.66 Not Cast175 2111026010 Sakat LLC $859.21 Not Cast176 2111021009 Salvatore Diane K et al & Schnebera William G $581.36 Not Cast Missing signature.

Missing signature. Missing signature. Missing signature.

177 2111021025 Salvatore Diane K et al & Schneberg William G $1.852.75 Not Cast178 2111026022 Salvatore Diane K et al & Schneberg William G $859.10 Not Cast

2111021023179 Schneberg William J GDN $0.00 Not Cast180 2111024003 Shaarawv Howvda______

Shandrall Canoga Park LP$1,253.86 Yes 0.99599%

181 2111023004 $7,884.26 Not Cast182 2111023005 Shandrall Canoga Park LP $4,368.02 Not Cast183 2111027007 Shanzeliza LLC $403.82

$426.02$426.02

Not Cast184 2111019002 Shaw Frederick L & Harmon Alice A Yes 0.33840%

0.33840%185 2111019012 Shaw Frederick L & Harmon Alice A Yes186 2111028005 Siewert Lewis G Tr $854.90 No 0.67908%

$1,439.76$429.66

187 2111020001 Simon Arthur B Tr Yes 1.14365%188 2111026020 Sirota Michael & Yonghong Trs / Y & M Sirota

SL2R Enterprises LLC___________________Sloan Charles W & Anna M_______________

Yes 0.34129%189 2111022017 $954.54

$1.739.97$773.39

Not Cast190 2111028039 Non Vote191 2111028019 Snvder David S Tr & Davis S Snyder Tr

SSJ Investments LLC______________Not Cast

192 2111022025 $1,612.33$859.10

Not Cast193 2111027029 Stanis Richard & Reita Trs Not Cast194 2111028040 Stockfish Henry Tr & Stockfish Seemah

Sunshine Sanelli LLC______________$1,323.94 Not Cast

195 2111027039 $1,288.99$859.10

Yes 1.02389%196 2111020021 Sutter Joseph W & Lisa Trs & Sutter Family Trust

Tamir Yossi & Eva Trs_______________________Not Cast

197 2111020013 $425.90$427.39

Not Cast198 2111028002 Tanzev Properties II Inc

Tanzev Properties II IncNot Cast

$427.51199 2111028003 Not Cast


TotalAssessment

% Yes ofballots


200 2111025017 Tatone James & Patricia $859.21 Not Cast201 2023008030 Teeqarden Properties L P $1.119.21 Non Vote202 2111022020 Teitelbaum Holdings LLC $2.874.74 Not Cast203 2111026001 TemkinEnrique H & Varda Trs / E & V Temkin $842.41 No 0.66916%204 2111020010 Thabet Michael A Tr / Jordan Family Trust $1.453.16 Not Cast205 2111027040 Treio Angel & Maria L $859.79 Not Cast206 2023008031 TRP Properties LLC $561.20 Yes 0.44578%207 2111028031 Tuttobene Anthony J Co Tr / Tuttobene Family

Vedres Frank A Tr et al / Vedres Family Trust Vernv Properties LLC____________________

$429.55 No 0.34121%208 2024001023 $5.665.12 Not Cast209 2111022011 $1.617.06 Not Cast210 2111018020 Vogel William S Tr / Vogel Family Trust_____

Wainer Sheldon J Co Tr / Wainer Family Trust Walker Nellie M Tr /Beridon A M Tr_______

$510.99$403.59

Yes 0.40590%211 2111027008 Not Cast212 2111024002 $1.254.09 No 0.99617%213 2111023013 Warwick Wendie Co Tr / Warwick & Pierce Trust $767.67 Not Cast214 2111026015 Weinberg Alex & Linda Trs / A & L Weinberg $859.21 No 0.68250%215 2111027035 Weinstein Mickey_____________

West Valiev Bovs & Girls Club Inc$829.88$429.89

Not Cast216 2111018005 0.34148%Yes217 2111018006 West Valley Bovs & Girls Club Inc

West Valiev Bovs & Girls Club Inc Winer Kenneth & Michele Trs

$430.01 Yes 0.34157%218 2111019027 $3.007.53 2.38899%Yes219 2111025012 $429.55 Not Cast Ballot not filled in completely.

Missing signature._________Missing signature._________

220 2111026024 Wixen Burton & Joan $859.33 Not Cast221 2111026025 Wixen Burton & Joan $829.88 Not Cast222 2111025009 Wong Harry & Flora__________

Wyandotte Commercial Park Inc Yadollahi Mehri________ _____

$429.43$1,288.99

$859.33

Not Cast223 2111018030 No 1.02389%224 2111026026 Not Cast

$829.88$881.78

225 2111017008 Yazditabar Bahman & Rozita Not Cast226 2111017037 Yehuda Salah & Linda Trs / Ordea Trust Not Cast227 2111025006 Zatkin Allen M Co Tr / Zatkin Family Trust

Zohar Haim & Terilyn R Trs____________Zohar Haim & Terilvn R Trs____________

$852.04 Yes 0.67681%228 2111027005 $301.35

$301.35Not Cast

229 2111027006 Not Cast


TOTALS $249,218.38 $125,891.441 70.79548% 29.20452%172 PROPERTY OWNERS $89,125.45 $36,765.99

NON VOTE YES NO TOTAL4 44 26 74# of ballots:

4 74 32# of parcels: 110

Item No. (15)-12-0071

SPEAKER REQUEST LISTMeeting: COUNCIL MEETING

Date: 07/02/2019

The names listed below reflect individuals who requested to speak on this particular Council file. These individuals may not have actually provided testimony during the meeting. Please refer to the audio and/or video recording of the meeting to determine which individuals actually provided testimony.

ADDRESS: (IF PROVIDED)

REPRESENTING: (IF PROVIDED)

PAID SPEAKER: (IF PROVIDED)

NAME: COMMENT

Herman Crybaby Nigger 666 HHH Fools General Comment

12-1269-S5 CISEric Preven General Comment

12-1269-S5 CISEric Preven General Comment

Ryan Reza Farsai The Lion Order General Comment

Jaclyn Bernstein General Comment

General CommentAida Lacio

Kyra Edrington General Comment

Ronald Clary General Comment

Antonia Ramirez General Comment

Wayne From Encino General Comment

Documents

City of Los Angeles CITY CALIFORNIAclkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2012/12-0071_rpt_CLK_07-08...2019/07/08 · 102 2111027010 Kav Armand & Adina Trs / Kav Trust_____ Kazar Haritvun &