Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    1/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html

    HOME WISE Uranium Project > Tailings Dam Safety >

    Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    (from 1960)

    (last updated 18 Dec 2012)

    Note: Due to limited availability of data, this compilation is in no way complete

    Date LocationParent

    companyOre type

    Type of

    IncidentRelease Impacts

    2012,Dec.17

    formerGullbridgemine site,Newfoundland,Canada

    copperembankmentdam failure,width 50 m

    non-consumptionwater advisory

    has beenissued for theTown of SouthBrook (viewdetails -Newfoundlandand LabradorDepartment ofEnvironmentand

    Conservation)

    2012,Nov.

    4

    Sotkamo,Kainuu

    province,Finland

    TalvivaaraMining

    Company Plc

    nickel,(uranium by-

    productplanned)

    leak fromgypsum pondthrough a

    "funnel-shapedhole"

    hundreds ofthousands ofcubic metres of

    contaminatedwaste water

    nickel and zincconcentrationsin nearbySnow Riverexceeded thevalues that areharmful toorganisms

    tenfold or evena hundredfold,uraniumconcentrationsmore thantenfold (viewdetails)

    tailingsdamaged

    http://www.wise-uranium.org/upfi.html#SOTKAMOSPILL12http://www.talvivaara.com/http://www.wise-uranium.org/indexm.htmlhttp://www.wise-uranium.org/upfi.html#SOTKAMOSPILL12http://www.talvivaara.com/http://www.env.gov.nl.ca/env/waterres/southbrook/http://www.wise-uranium.org/indexm.htmlhttp://www.wise-uranium.org/index.html
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    2/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 2

    2011,Jul. 21

    Mianyang City,SongpanCounty,SichuanProvince,China

    XichuanMinjiangElectrolyticManganesePlant

    manganese

    tailings damdamaged fromlandslidescaused fromheavy rains

    ?

    residentialroads andhouses, forcing272 people toleave; tailingswere washedinto the Fujiang

    River, leaving200,000people withoutdrinking watersupply

    2010,Oct. 4

    Kolontr,Hungary(Aerial View:

    Google Maps)

    MAL MagyarAlumnium

    bauxitetailings damfailure (view

    details)

    700,000 cubicmetres of

    caustic red mud

    several townsflooded, 10people killed,approx. 120people injured8 squarekilometresflooded

    2010,Jun.25

    Huancavelica,Peru

    Unidad MineraCaudalosaChica

    ?tailings damfailure

    21,420 cubicmetres oftailings

    contaminationof ro Escaleraand roOpamayo 110kmdownstream

    2009,Aug.29

    Karamken,Magadanregion, Russia

    ? gold

    tailings damfailure afterheavy rain(seebackground info

    - SRIC2004)

    ?

    eleven homeswere carriedaway by themudflow; atleast oneperson waskilled

    2009,May14

    HuayuanCounty,XiangxiAutonomousPrefecture,HunanProvince,China

    ? manganese

    tailings damfailure (capacity:50,000 cubicmetres)

    ?

    The landslide

    set off by thetailings damfailuredestroyed ahome, killingthree andinjuring fourpeople.

    http://www.sric.org/voices/2004/v5n3/Karamken.htmlhttp://www.wise-uranium.org/mdafko.htmlhttp://www.mal.hu/http://maps.google.com/maps?f=q&source=s_q&hl=en&geocode=&q=&sll=37.0625,-95.677068&sspn=42.901912,56.513672&ie=UTF8&hq=&hnear=Kolont%C3%A1r,+Hungary&ll=47.089293,17.504096&spn=0.018087,0.027595&t=h&z=15
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    3/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 3

    2008,Dec.22

    Kingston fossilplant,Harriman,Tennessee,USA

    TennesseeValley Authority coal ash

    retention wallfailure

    Release of 5.4million cubicyards [4.1million cubicmetres] of ashyslurry

    The ash slidecovered 400acres [1.6squarekilometres] asdeep as 6 feet[1.83 metres].

    The wave ofash and mudtoppled powerlines, coveredSwan PondRoad andruptured a gasline. Itdamaged 12homes, and

    one personhad to berescued,though no onewas seriouslyhurt.

    2008,Sep. 8

    Taoshi, LinfenCity, Xiangfencounty, Shanxiprovince,China

    Tashan miningcompany

    iron

    Collapse of awaste-productreservoir at anillegal mineduring rainfall

    ?

    A mudslideseveral metreshigh buried a

    market, severahomes and athree-storeybuilding. Atleast 254people aredead and 35injured.

    2006,Nov.6

    Nchanga,Chingola,Zambia

    KonkolaCopper MinesPlc (KCM)(51% VedantaResources plc

    )

    copper

    failure of tailingsslurry pipelinefrom Nchangatailings leachingplant toMuntimpatailings dumps

    ?

    Release of

    highly acidictailings intoKafue river;highconcentrationsof copper,manganese,cobalt in riverwater; drinkingwater supply

    http://www.vedantaresources.com/http://www.kcm.co.zm/http://www.tva.gov/
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    4/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 4

    of downstreamcommunitiesshut down

    2006,April

    30

    near Miliang,Zhen'anCounty,Shangluo,

    ShaanxiProvince,China

    Zhen'an CountyGold Mining Co.

    Ltd.

    gold

    tailings damfailure duringsixth upraising

    of dam

    ?

    The landslideburied about40 rooms of

    ninehouseholds,leaving 17residentsmissing. Fiveinjured peoplewere taken tohospital. Morethan 130 localresidents have

    beenevacuated.Toxicpotassiumcyanide wasreleased intothe Huashuiriver,contaminatingit approx. 5

    kmdownstream.

    2005,April14

    Bangs Lake,JacksonCounty,Mississippi,USA

    MississippiPhosphatesCorp.

    phosphate

    phosphogypsumstack failure,because thecompany wastrying toincrease thecapacity of the

    pond at a fasterrate thannormal,according toOfficials withthe MississippiDepartment ofEnvironmentalQuality (thecompany has

    approx. 17million gallonsof acidic liquid(64,350 m3)

    liquid pouredinto adjacentmarsh lands,causingvegetation todie

    http://www.missphosphates.com/
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    5/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 5

    blamed the spillon unusuallyheavy rainfall,though)

    2004,Nov.30

    Pinchi Lake,BritishColumbia,Canada

    Teck ComincoLtd.

    mercury

    tailings dam(100-metreslong and 12-metres high)collapses duringreclamationwork

    6,000 to 8,000m3 of rock, dirtand wastewater

    tailings spilledinto 5,500 haPinchi Lake

    2004,Sep. 5

    Riverview,Florida, USA

    Cargill CropNutrition

    phosphate

    a dike at the topof a 100-foot-high gypsumstack holding

    150-milliongallons ofpolluted waterbroke afterwaves driven byHurricaneFrances bashedthe dike'ssouthwestcorner

    60 milliongallons(227,000 m3)of acidic liquid

    liquid spilledinto ArchieCreek thatleads toHillsboroughBay

    2004,May22

    Partizansk,Primorski Krai,Russia

    Dalenergo coal ash

    A ring dike,enclosing anarea of roughly

    1 km2 andholding roughly

    20 million cubicmeters of coalash, broke. Thebreak left a holeroughly 50meter wide inthe dam.

    approximately160,000 cubicmeters of ash

    The ash flowedthrough adrainage canalinto a tributaryto thePartizanskayaRiver whichempties in toNahodka Bayin PrimorskiKrai (east ofVladivostok).For detailsdownloadSept. 2004report(PDF) by PaulRobinson,

    http://www.sric.org/mining/docs/Partizansk%20Coal%20Ash%20Dam%20Break%20and%20Spill.pdfhttp://www.cargillcropnutrition.com/http://www.teckcominco.com/
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    6/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 6

    SRIC

    2004,March20

    Malvsi, Aude,France

    Comurhex(Cogma/Areva)

    decantationandevaporationpond ofuranium

    conversionplant

    dam failure afterheavy rain inpreceding year(view details)

    30,000 cubicmetres of liquidand slurries

    release led toelevated nitrateconcentrationsof up to 170mg/L in thecanal of

    Tauran forseveral weeks

    2003,Oct. 3

    Cerro Negro,Petorca prov.,Quinta region,Chile

    Cia MineraCerro Negro

    coppertailings damfailure

    50,000 tonnesof tailings

    tailings flowed20 kilometersdownstreamthe ro LaLigua

    2002,Aug.27 /Sep.11

    San Marcelino,Zambales,Philippines

    Dizon CopperSilver Mines,Inc.

    overflow andspillway failureof twoabandonedtailings damsafter heavy rain

    (view details)

    ?

    Aug. 27: some

    tailings spilledintoMapanuepeLake andeventually intothe Sto. TomaRiverSep. 11: lowlying villagesflooded with

    mine waste;250 familiesevacuated;nobodyreported hurtso far

    2001,Jun.22

    Sebastio das

    guas Claras,Nova Limadistrict, MinasGerais, Brazil

    Minerao RioVerde Ltda

    iron mine waste damfailure (viewdetails)

    ?

    tailings wavetraveled atleast 6 km,

    killing at leasttwo mineworkers, threemore workersare missing

    2000,Oct.

    Nandancounty,Guangxi ? ?

    tailings dam?

    at least 15people killed,100 missing;

    http://www.wise-uranium.org/mdafsa.htmlhttp://www.wise-uranium.org/mdafsm.htmlhttp://www.wise-uranium.org/mdafma.html
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    7/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 7

    18 province,China

    failure more than 100housesdestroyed

    2000,Oct.11

    Inez, MartinCounty,Kentucky,USA

    Martin CountyCoalCorporation(100% A.T.Massey CoalCompany, Inc.

    , Richmond,VA (100%Fluor Corp. ))

    coal

    tailings damfailure fromcollapse of anundergroundmine beneaththe slurryimpoundment(view details)

    250 milliongallons(950,000 m3)of coal wasteslurry releasedinto localstreams

    About 75 miles(120 km) ofrivers and

    streams turnedan irridescentblack, causinga fish kill alongthe Tug Forkof the BigSandy Riverand some of itstributaries.Towns along

    the Tug wereforced to turnoff theirdrinking waterintakes.

    2000,Sep. 8

    Aitik mine,Gllivare,Sweden

    Boliden Ltd. copper

    tailings damfailure frominsufficientperviousness offilter drain(view details)

    release of 2.5million m3 ofliquid into anadjacent settling

    pond,subsequentrelease of 1.5million m3 ofwater (carryingsome residualslurry) from thesettling pondinto theenvironment

    2000,Mar.10

    Borsa,Romania

    Remin S.A.tailings damfailure afterheavy rain

    22,000 t ofheavy-metalcontaminatedtailings

    contaminationof the Vaserstream,tributary of theTisza River.ViewRomanianGovt. report UNEP repor

    http://www.natural-resources.org/environment/baiamare/docs/BaiaBorsa/baiabrosa-final.pdfhttp://www.mappm.ro/infpresa/noutati/engleza/Borsa16032000.htmhttp://www.wise-uranium.org/mdafai.htmlhttp://www.bolidenltd.com/http://www.wise-uranium.org/mdafin.htmlhttp://www.fluor.com/http://www.fluor.com/investor/atmassey_main.asp
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    8/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 8

    (527k PDF)

    2000,Jan.30

    Baia Mare,Romania

    Aurul S.A.(Esmeralda

    Exploration ,Australia (50%),Remin S.A.(44.8%))

    gold

    recoveryfrom oldtailings

    tailings damcrest failureafter overflowcaused fromheavy rain andmelting snow(view details)

    100,000 m3 of

    cyanide-contaminatedliquid

    contaminationof theSomes/Szamostream,tributary of theTisza River,killing tonnesof fish andpoisoning thedrinking waterof more than 2million peoplein Hungary

    1999,Apr.26

    Placer, Surigaodel Norte,Philippines

    Manila MiningCorp. (MMC)

    goldtailings spillfrom damagedconcrete pipe

    700,000 tonnesof cyanidetailings

    17 homesburied, 51hectares ofricelandswamped

    1998,Dec.31

    Huelva, SpainFertiberia ,Foret

    phosphatedam failureduring storm(view details)

    50,000 m3 ofacidic and toxicwater

    1998,

    Apr.25

    Los Frailes,

    Aznalcllar,Spain

    Boliden Ltd. ,Canada

    zinc, lead,

    copper,silver

    dam failure from

    foundationfailure (viewdetails)

    4-5 million m3

    of toxic waterand slurry

    thousands ofhectares of

    farmlandcovered withslurry

    1997,Dec.7

    MulberryPhosphate,Polk County,Florida, USA

    MulberryPhosphates, Inc. phosphate

    phosphogypsumstack failure

    200,000 m3 ofphosphogypsumprocess water

    biota in theAlafia Rivereliminated

    1997,

    Oct.22

    Pinto Valley,

    Arizona, USA BHP Copper copper

    tailings dam

    slope failure

    230,000 m3 of

    tailings and minerock

    tailings flow

    covers 16hectares

    1996,Nov.12

    Amatista,Nazca, Peru

    ? ?

    liquefactionfailure ofupstream-typetailings damduringearthquake

    more than300,000 m3 oftailings

    flow runout ofabout 600meters, spillinto river,croplandscontaminated

    http://www.natural-resources.org/environment/baiamare/docs/BaiaBorsa/baiabrosa-final.pdfhttp://www.bhp.com.au/environment/env98/case/pinto.htmhttp://www.bhp.com.au/http://www.mulberrycorp.com/http://www.wise-uranium.org/mdaflf.htmlhttp://www.bolidenltd.com/http://www.wise-uranium.org/ptail.html#HUELVAhttp://www.fertiberia.com/http://www.wise-uranium.org/mdafbm.htmlhttp://www.esmeralda.com.au/http://www.natural-resources.org/environment/baiamare/docs/BaiaBorsa/baiabrosa-final.pdf
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    9/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 9

    1996,Aug.29

    El Porco,Bolivia

    Comsur (62%),Rio Tinto(33%)

    zinc, lead,silver

    dam failure 400,000 tonnes

    300 km ofPilcomayorivercontaminated

    1996,Mar.24

    Marcopper,

    MarinduqueIsland,Philippines

    Placer DomeInc. , Canada(40%)

    copper

    Loss of tailings

    from storage pitthrough olddrainage tunnel

    1.6 million m3

    Evacuation of1200residents, 18

    km of riverchannel filledwith tailings,US$ 80 milliondamage

    1995,

    Dec.

    Golden Cross,

    New Zealand

    Coeur d'Alne

    , Idaho, USA

    gold

    Dam movementof damcontaining 3million tonnes of

    tailings(continuing)(view details )

    Nil (so far) Nil (so far)

    1995,Sep. 2

    Placer, Surigaodel Norte,Philippines

    Manila MiningCorp.

    goldDam foundationfailure

    50,000 m312 peoplekilled, coastalpollution

    1995,Aug.19

    Omai, Guyana

    Cambior Inc. ,

    Canada (65%),Golden StarResources Inc.,Colorado, USA(30%)

    gold

    tailings damfailure from

    internal damerosion(preliminaryreport ontechnicalcausation)

    4.2 million m3of cyanideslurry

    80 km ofEssequiboRiver declaredenvironmentaldisaster zone(view details

    )

    1994,

    Nov.19

    HopewellMine,

    HillsboroughCounty,Florida, USA

    IMC-Agrico phosphate dam failure

    Nearly 1.9million m3 of

    water from aclay settlingpond

    spill intonearbywetlands and

    the AlafiaRiver,Keysvilleflooded

    1994,

    Payne CreekMine, Polk

    6.8 million m3of water from a

    majority of spilcontained onadjacentmining area;500,000 m3

    http://www.imc-agrico.com/http://www.geocities.com/RainForest/2651/http://www.wise-uranium.org/mdgr.htmlhttp://www.cambior.com/http://bitz.co.nz/watchdog/http://www.coeur.com/http://www.placerdome.com/http://www.riotinto.com/
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    10/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 10

    Oct. 2 County,Florida, USA

    IMC-Agrico phosphate dam failure clay settlingpond

    released intoHickeyBranch, atributary ofPayne Creek

    1994,Oct.

    Fort Meade,Florida, USA Cargill phosphate ?

    76,000 m3 ofwater

    spill into Peace

    River near ForMeade

    1994,June

    IMC-Agrico,Florida, USA

    IMC-Agrico phosphate

    Sinkhole opensinphosphogypsumstake

    ?

    Release ofgympsum andwater intogroundwater

    1994,Feb.22

    Harmony,Merriespruit,South Africa

    Harmony GoldMines

    gold

    Dam wallbreachfollowing heavyrain

    600,000 m3

    tailings traveled4 km

    downstream,17 peoplekilled,extensivedamage toresidentialtownship

    1994,

    Feb.14

    Olympic Dam,

    Roxby Downs,South Australia WMC Ltd.

    copper,

    uranium

    leakage oftailings dam

    during 2 yearsor more

    release of up to5 million m3 of

    contaminatedwater intosubsoil

    ?

    1993,Oct.

    Gibsonton,Florida, USA

    Cargill phosphate ? ?

    Fish killedwhen acidicwater spilledinto ArchieCreek

    1993 Marsa, Peru

    Marsa Mining

    Corp. gold

    dam failure from

    overtopping ? 6 people killed

    1992,Mar.1

    Maritsa Istok1, near StaraZagora,Bulgaria

    ? ash/cinder dam failure frominundation ofthe beach

    500,000 m3 ?

    1992,Jan.

    No.2 tailingspond, Padcal,Luzon,

    Philex MiningCorp. copper

    Collapse ofdam wall(foundation

    80 milliontonnes ?

    http://www.cargill.com/http://www.wise-uranium.org/ucwmc.htmlhttp://www.wise-uranium.org/uoaus.html#OLYMPICDhttp://www.imc-agrico.com/http://www.cargill.com/http://www.imc-agrico.com/
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    11/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 1

    Philippines failure)

    1991,Aug.23

    Sullivan mine,Kimberley,BritishColumbia,

    Canada

    Cominco Ltd lead/zinc

    dam failure(liquefaction inold tailingsfoundationduring

    construction ofincrementalraise)

    75,000 m3

    the slidedmaterial wascontained in an

    adjacent pond

    1989,Aug.25

    Stancil,Perryville,Maryland,USA

    ?sand andgravel

    dam failureduring cappingof the tailingsafter heavy rain

    38,000 m3

    tailingsflowsidecovered 5000m2

    1988,Apr.30

    Jinduicheng,Shaanxiprovince,China

    ? molybdenum

    breach of damwall (spillwayblockagecaused pondlevel to rise toohigh)

    700,000 m3approx. 20people killed

    1988,Jan.19

    TennesseeConsolidatedNo.1, GraysCreek, TN,

    USA

    TennesseeConsolidatedCoal Co.

    coal

    dam wall failurefrom internalerosion, causedfrom failure ofan abandonedoutlet pipe

    250,000 m3 ?

    1988Riverview,Florida, USA

    Gardinier (nowCargill )

    phosphate ? acidic spill

    Thousands offish killed atmouth of AlafiaRiver

    1987,April8

    MontcoalNo.7, RaleighCounty, West

    Virginia, USA

    Peabody CoalCo. (nowPeabody

    Energy )

    coaldam failure afterspillway pipebreach

    87,000 cubicmeters of waterand slurry

    tailings flow 80kmdownstream

    1986,May

    Itabirito, MinasGerais, Brazil

    ItaminosComercio deMinerios

    ? dam wall burst 100,000 tonnestailings flow 12kmdownstream

    1986Huangmeishan,China

    ? irondam failure fromseepage/slopeinstability

    ?19 peoplekilled

    http://www.peabodyenergy.com/http://www.cargill.com/http://www.cominco.com/
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    12/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 12

    1985,July19

    Stava, Trento,Italy

    Prealpi Mineraia fluorite

    dam failure,caused frominsufficientsafety marginsand inadequatedecant pipeconstruction(view details

    )

    200,000 m3

    tailings flow4.2 kmdownstream at90 km/h; 268people killed,62 buildingsdestroyed(view details

    )

    1985,Mar.3

    Veta de AguaNo.1, Chile

    ? copper

    dam wall failure,due toliquefactionduringearthquake

    280,000 m3tailings flow 5kmdownstream

    1985,Mar.

    3

    Cerro Negro

    No.4, Chile

    Cia Minera

    Cerro Negro

    copper

    dam wall failure,due toliquefaction

    duringearthquake

    500,000 m3tailings flow 8km

    downstream

    1985Olinghouse,Wadsworth,Nevada, USA

    OlinghouseMining Co.

    goldembankmentcollapse fromsaturation

    25,000 m3tailings flow1.5 kmdownstream

    1982,Nov.

    8

    Sipalay,NegrosOccidental,

    Philippines

    MarinduqueMining and

    Industrial Corp.

    copper

    dam failure, dueto slippage offoundations on

    clayey soils

    28 milliontonnes

    widespreadinundation ofagricultural

    land up to 1.5m high

    1981,

    Dec.18

    Ages, HarlanCounty,

    Kentucky,USA

    Eastover Mining

    Co. coal

    dam failure after

    heavy rain

    96,000 m3 coal

    refuse slurry

    the slurry wavetraveled theLeft Fork ofAges Creek1.3 kmdownstream, 1person was

    killed, 3 homesdestroyed, 30homesdamaged, fishkill in CloverFork of theCumberlandRiver

    1981,Balka

    tailings travel

    http://www.wise-uranium.org/mdafst.htmlhttp://www.wise-uranium.org/mdafst.html
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    13/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 13

    Jan.20

    Chuficheva,Lebedinsky,Russia

    ? iron dam failure 3.5 million m3 distance 1.3km

    1980,Oct.

    13

    Tyrone, New

    Mexico, USA

    Phelps Dodge copper

    dam wallbreach, due torapid increase indam wall height,

    causing highinternal porepressure

    2 million m3

    tailings flow 8kmdownstream

    and inundatefarmland

    1979,July16

    Church Rock,New Mexico,USA

    United Nuclear uranium

    dam wallbreach, due todifferentialfoundationsettlement

    370,000 m3 ofradioactivewater, 1,000tonnes ofcontaminatedsediment

    Contaminationof Rio Puercosediments upto 110 kmdownstream

    1979orearlier

    (unidentified),BritishColumbia,Canada

    ? ?piping in thesand beach ofthe tailings dam

    40,000 m3 ofponded water

    considerablepropertydamage

    1978,Jan.

    31

    Arcturus,Zimbabwe

    CorsynConsolidated

    Mines

    gold

    slurry overflowafter continuousrain over

    several days

    30,000 tonnes

    1 personkilled,extensivesiltation to

    waterway andadjoining roughpasture

    1978,Jan.14

    MochikoshiNo.1, Japan

    MochikoshiGold MiningCompany

    gold

    dam failure, dueto liquefactionduringearthquake

    80,000 m3

    1 personkilled, tailingsflow 7-8 kmdownstream

    1977,Feb. 1

    Homestake,Milan, NewMexico, USA

    HomestakeMiningCompany

    uranium

    dam failure, due

    to rupture ofplugged slurrypipeline

    30,000 m3 no impactsoutside themine site

    1976,Mar.1

    Zlevoto,Yugoslavia

    ? lead, zinc

    dam failure, dueto high phreaticsurface andseepagebreakout on theembankment

    300,000 m3

    tailings flowreached andpollutednearby river

    http://www.homestake.com/http://www.fcx.com/
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    14/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 14

    face

    1975,

    June

    Silverton,

    Colorado,USA ? (metal) dam failure 116,000 tonnes

    tailings flowslide pollutednearly 100miles (160 km)of the Animas

    river and itstributaries;severepropertydamage; noinjuries

    1975,

    Apr.

    Madjarevo,

    Bulgaria ?

    lead, zinc,

    gold

    rising of tailingsabove designlevel caused

    overloading ofthe decanttower andcollectors

    250,000 m3 ?

    1975Mike Horse,Montana, USA

    ? lead, zincdam failure afterheavy rain

    150,000 m3 ?

    1974,

    Nov.11

    Bafokeng,South Africa ? platinum

    embankmentfailure by

    concentratedseepage andpiping throughcracks

    3 million m3

    12 peoplekilled in a mineshaft inundated

    by the tailings;tailings flow 45kmdownstream

    1974,Jun. 1

    Deneen Mica,NorthCarolina, USA

    ? micadam failure afterheavy rain

    38,000 m3tailingsreleased to anadjacent river

    1973(unidentified),SouthwesternUSA

    ? copper

    dam failure fromincreased porepressure duringconstruction ofincrementalraise

    170,000 m3tailings traveled25 kmdownstream

    the tailingstraveled 27 kmdownstream,125 people

  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    15/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 15

    1972,Feb.26

    Buffalo Creek,West Virginia,USA

    Pittston Coal coal

    collapse oftailings damafter heavy rain(view Citizens'Commissionreport )

    500,000 m3

    lost their lives,500 homesweredestroyed.Property andhighwaydamage

    exceeded$65 million.(see details )

    1971,Dec.3

    Fort Meade,Florida, USA

    Cities ServiceCo.

    phosphateClay pond damfailure, causeunknown

    9 million m3 ofclay water

    tailings traveled120 kmdownstreamwith PeaceRiver, largefish kill

    1970Mufulira,Zambia

    ? copper

    liquefaction oftailings, flowingintoundergroundworkings

    some 1 milliontons

    89 minerskilled

    1970Maggie Pie,United

    Kingdom

    ? china clay

    dam failure afterraising theembankment

    and after heavyrain

    15,000 m3tailings spilled35 meters

    downstream

    1969orearlier

    Bilbao, Spain ? ?dam failure(liquefaction)after heavy rain

    115,000 m3

    majordownstreamdamage andloss of life

    1968

    Hokkaido,

    Japan ? ?

    dam failure(liquefaction)

    duringearthquake

    90,000 m3

    tailings traveled

    150 metersdownstream

    1967,Mar.

    Fort Meade,Florida, USA

    Mobil Chemical phosphatedam failure, nodetails available

    250,000 m3 ofphosphatic clayslimes, 1.8million m3 ofwater

    spill reachesPeace River,fish killreported

    tailings flow

    http://wvgazette.com/static/series/buffalocreek/index.htmlhttp://wvgazette.com/static/series/buffalocreek/commission.htmlhttp://www.pittston.com/
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    16/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 16

    1967 (unidentified),UnitedKingdom

    ? coal dam failureduring regradingoperations

    ? covered anarea of 4hectares

    1966(unidentified),East Texas,USA

    ? gypsum dam failure76,000 -130,000 m3 ofgypsum

    flow slidetraveled 300meters; no

    fatalities

    1966Derbyshire,UnitedKingdom

    ? coaldam failure fromfoundationfailure

    30,000 m3tailings traveled100 metersdownstream

    1966,Oct.

    21

    Aberfan,Wales, United

    Kingdom

    Merthyr ValeColliery

    coaldam failure(liquefaction)

    from heavy rain

    162,000 m3

    the tailingstraveled 600meters, 144people were

    killed (viewdetails ,watch video

    1966,May 1

    Mir mine,Sgorigrad,Bulgaria

    ?

    lead, zinc,

    copper,silver,(uranium?)

    dam failure fromrising pond level

    after heavy rainsand/or failure ofdiversionchannel

    450,000 m3

    the tailingswave traveled8 km to thecity of Vratzaand destroyedhalf of

    Sgorigradvillage 1 kmdownstream,killing 488people. (Viewdetails historicphotographs

    )

    1965,Mar.28

    Bellavista,Chile

    ? copper dam failureduringearthquake

    70,000 m3tailings traveled800 metersdownstream

    1965,Mar.28

    Cerro NegroNo.3, Chile

    ? copper dam failureduringearthquake

    85,000 m3tailings traveled5 kmdownstream

    1965, El Cobre Newdam failure(liquefaction)

    tailings traveled12 km

    http://www.sgorigrad.com/index.php?r=tragedy/navodnenie&title=The+1966+tragedy&base=tragedy&lang=enhttp://www.stava1985.it/http://www.worldwidewales.tv/html/movie-167.phphttp://www.nuff.ox.ac.uk/politics/aberfan/home.htmhttp://www.welshcoalmines.co.uk/GlamEast/MerthyrVale.htm
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    17/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    www.wise-uranium.org/mdaf.html 17

    Mar.28

    Dam, Chile ? copper duringearthquake

    350,000 m3 downstream,destroyed thetown of ElCobre andkilled morethan 200people

    1965,Mar.28

    El Cobre OldDam, Chile

    ? copper

    dam failure(liquefaction)duringearthquake

    1.9 million m3

    1965,Mar.28

    La PataguaNew Dam,Chile

    ? copper

    dam failure(liquefaction)duringearthquake

    35,000 m3tailings traveled5 kmdownstream

    1965,Mar.28

    Los Maquis,Chile

    ? copper

    dam failure(liquefaction)duringearthquake

    21,000 m3tailings traveled5 kmdownstream

    1965Tymawr,UnitedKingdom

    ? coaldam failure fromovertopping

    ?

    tailings traveled700 metersdownstream,causingconsiderabledamage

    1962 (unidentified),Peru ? ?

    dam failure(liquefaction)

    duringearthquake andafter heavyrainfall

    ? ?

    1961Tymawr,UnitedKingdom

    ? coaldam failure, nodetails available

    ?tailings traveled800 metersdownstream

    tonnes = metric tonnes

    Sources:Tailings Dam Incidents, U.S. Committee on Large Dams - USCOLD, Denver, Colorado, ISBN 1-884575-03-X, 1994, 82 pages [compilation and analysis of 185 tailings dam incidents]

    Environmental and Safety Incidents concerning Tailings Dams at Mines : Results of a Survey for theyears 1980-1996 by Mining Journal Research Services; a report prepared forUnited Nations EnvironmentProgramme, Industry and Environment . Paris, 1996, 129 pages [compilation of 37 tailings damincidents]

    Tailings Dams - Risk of Dangerous Occurrences, Lessons learnt from practical experiences ,

    http://www.unep.org/dtie/http://www.wise-uranium.org/mdap.html#USCOLD
  • 7/22/2019 Chronology of Major Tailings Dam Failures

    18/18

    9/20/13 Chronology of major tailings dam failures

    Bulletin 121, Published by United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP) Division of Technology,Industry and Economics (DTIE) and International Commission on Large Dams (ICOLD), Paris 2001, 144p. [compilation of 221 tailings dam incidents mainly from the above two publications, and examplesof effective remedial measures]

    and many others.

    > See also: Chronology of uranium tailings dam failures

    HOME WISE Uranium Project > Tailings Dam Safety >

    http://www.wise-uranium.org/indexm.htmlhttp://www.wise-uranium.org/index.htmlhttp://www.wise-uranium.org/mdafu.htmlhttp://www.icold-cigb.net/