Upload
axiang88
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 1/100
Ir{
z,
3tr
(,
llT
-l
'g
t;u
me
J
cnd
c4
3E
{2,
(D{
.rIll
rl
C?#
==
I
r .-,
-lU
D
r
o
=
7
rfl
(?
I
*
(,-
€
o
o
F
S
=
D
_
FI
-
o
-l
-
EI
o
0
\
-
FI
=
o
a
-
ffit
_.--,="
:
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 2/100
tss=5s
a E
=trFt
:1 9==
-,
i
i
a=iit
EaEr"i4i'r :
tEI$g'
r?-i i.-lfo:*
A
Ao^*S
*+FE-g++igFi
E
SUrna
sg
?=F"^d
)
s
o*';>€
sT l-93:T 3-
o
eB*
=
=taa
i?
t
i
=F
e
A{EL r*
6
i +-<
"';
g,E-3-i
E
- :
=
6
F
*rPE
rE
i
6
S;
'ti?i
z;
x-
?
iA
i,r
E
i
gE
t
=
a
*
=l
il- .
'.u
=.
q
s
3
or E-
,.-g
; 3
P
-
l* li FA
3.
.i
ai€p ifr
;
F
) 6
-
i:'
-
tr
*-
N
Y
o
P
-P
I
-
|
5
-i-lrP
=':-=-
'7
6
''3=E
*
o
a.Q I &
r-
OsltO
tqo<
tnl
I:N
ou
AN
'l
P
+
p
i
a
m)
ua
vz.
6^
rp'
L-
** *6
ts
..i
6
N
o
o
p
or-l gO
--i't.:o
J-;
.-TB-H=
roS-.I9.
r{I1?:_
o6ri;_:
=_
e
t-'F,
>.
++i=aa
=.
:- a
i ;'
='
"
S&8-
-ITxf
-;t
ui
-,i
d--
. 2 ?
?
-
-ir'
r
O
O
.,'d?.n\;*
\
Y-.r-
4'4
=
"
,-
n-LA p j
?
o
IEi{HsJ
3
a
: r,
r
'q='/
:
'ruC.-
hPy'
3-
"{+-id
g
,o
o
t
3
D
5
o
p
o
o
p
o
\,
I
P
(?
o
.+
o
*
o
El
C)
:i
r-
:t'-
J
:-
oDH-c
yi
E-
R'
^rncGj
-ir
3t i'
a
V-.
5"
-?J
HE
v
))
J
6'W
rDo
JV
o-o
i{
:lo
on
Lhl
'ov
E'
rn
6
9'
''
t)
tl
DV
'u+
h
n(
PE
=(D
3
]r)
(D
(
sz
=
g=g
=E
if
3
?ry3
g i
I:
€
[iil
hi
sEsr
frili
b;o;^.
.o6
.i
x=ut
.;5
?is,
T .n,
-
Eu
$
A
?
d7
j.;:
O
-
-
u
;'t9
O
lf
CqHr.--
I
f1
tr
e.5'
€q
;.r,Tn
"i.
.D
)
P
-1
(
\-/
o=;'o;:r?a
-
'-AQT
=.
=E.
ts
X=
i+
^gt['(r6-D^',
,otiiX.o:=.X
>oqiisA)o'i'
\
.
j.
SB
5Tj
3
o
r.::
X
Gi
I
oO
qil
s..
=.crAa
o
i.
oX
A
as
6
6 .
}
6
-''6O
os.-o
HEE.='
6a-1
J
))
46'o-
6B
D
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 3/100
*
t
(D
rt
r
o
o
iA;;ii
i=
=*
=
===i:;
i
+=
1=
iili;$g[+aI5;
fr
+3sf
;3iiiia
i
i;
pi$
iii
I
lgE
gligI
i
rIgg
i
$lff*tE
ffii;*li'n'3
q
;
H
tE;
ii[E$iB$iiiF$iiffiirii
*"tFii1*ifl
{
f
iF $
;i
I iE irH
a
n
iFi [
lggFt$i
I
g
Ei
li
}i
liiil
rs
F
s Fs.
gg
a
i
f
tg
r Ir
r F
*g
i
3
i
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 4/100
D
s
rs
i
iE:
f
i€
"
sF
s
€
g
i
i.
€
;E
;
$
f
I
i
i
[
;
1I?F
i
?igiaii
i
iltg
iilElliE
i ii
ni*
+aIi11i??i
i
c
d i
rg
i?r
r is
r + iaE i llE
l'iiilli+
giiEiiilf
Ti
3
rg
j
=
s
u
i
s a
ii
i
3
#B
$=LiE
i
i3
[i
i
iI
l ii
i
i
i
i
*ieiitlilil'EtisiiEi
ElE1ll1
+11
I
EEEElIlli
lgtllilE?llilEr
rrilitiXI{
+r
i
iiiarf
i?*i
Iiiil:
ti,
[t
+t
llrf
i;;l11i
ll1}ffi{ii{E$eiilI?,;
EiH
ii
tE
[1i
e
i*rIi
$rr1AiliE
rlisgltiii*
+; i3
5 -8
=
+
3
6
S
E
Ar_)._^LD
q66Bi'=9HZ
6s-Hgi;FiE
;=eE.^a;aj
pd'
F
ts
z^Z
i I
*
<
?
l.s
a
=
B
l;
q
1
;';
='+i
e-E-q
3
a
J:
I
i=E
=:
q
;tiiix€ii
;+='=--
Q=5lrn3g"il
+
r+
3* i
B
*
f
i
i
a
.a
li:E
i
I
lH'&ts:3qB&
*:
a
a :€
?.
i
&
4iryP-=a-
:-
(9
A)APA*H
O;o3iZoi.t
ri
1=
4
s-I
f
E
a ; E A
+
3
j
=.
D
O
i
=
j'3.a^
i-)
;lae-=;=.9
o-=
o-=
^
a.V
r
i
?
E
a; aa zi'i
?
3: ;
TA';
g
+e
3
3
s+:
+3
a
X
=,=.u+_._$.
;
-.4
=:6
=
i
=
F
=.a--D-qarv
"#9=S?nie
.Daro=:.oA=q
-?icr6=x=o
T
2 6
+
'_
PF
"B
?
.o
H
-'lB'
. o
ob
,-o
a
PR
.DF
P*
F.6
='o
O-
A'D
5-l
a)v
o6
66
<A)
a
G,'
<9
='o
v
<5
9oc
o-E
-a
$
,(a
j-
o-
cr
6<
otr
9E'
v(a
A0)
x.<
:.
9
(n
oe
n
o
o
o
0)
oa
r#*
.D
{
o
0)
io
rD
A)
7f
oq
i
o
-J
p
(D
o
io
6
o
U
,?V?r
(D-_
oo
A)
q
o
o
o
n
oe
,
o
o
o
oa
o
o
n
o
A)
n
rifl
A)
a
o
ic
n
o
o
Fl
o
n
cra
E
.D
q
q
CD
o
n
a
6
(n
-
D
n
H
o
a-
r
o
o-
o
n
I
i[:igIir+$$
ilEE
]*
1fr;
d
E
E-r.?E
e
i
B
r 6
s,e-
a
+
fl E I
i
E"
ri
i
i
*f
i
ill
il
=i
;'E
i
i$i
Ii
iii1gl+iIiiEglarii{i
lrf
lirsr**E*+gsi#+
ilgliill#iiiirFliiii
i€
* s
i
+
i
f
I ieli
I
Eiri+iiffiiiiiiiiiii
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 5/100
a
g)
o
o
iq
s?3
{?ri;
r
;
itt
a
i6
iE
Lir
?i
iliIt
}i?.E
HiE
?}?ai3
ii1
'
'i
-
1111
1
I
all?llt
t
a11?i
la*
1l
i;111iA
a?
ii
a
i?
ii iE
i
i{111?
t:
iiE
rlitlllitA?l
a'
I
lall
t$gii;
r
i:
*?
i}
111?1?aIIE
?ai
aa.i
r:
E
rui?talallEil?iAa?l
?
}I{
z,x
ti,
l?t
{*'9
9,f,
mC
t
(Jlri
=
iii
E#
-,
Z,
-t
3
.'t
lll
..J
QJ
Z-
fr
rl
I,
r
e{,
=
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 6/100
I
z,
{
fl
o
(,
f)
-.1
-
o
z,
eilieErBIaIirH
1elIIriIB*lBIl1
s;
[fr
r
]
s
s
E
B
F
e
s
;
-
=
3E
F
l
B*;
a
rIE
i
r
S
=HE;EfrffX,fiI5r6x
F
i
$t
A
i
+
a
a
i
3
$F{
r:
r
I a
e;
-'
B
;
B
s
IiHEiEieileiFi
iE
*iii<
iiiriir
e
a:
i
;: f
qs
=
|
n B
;
r:
E
{
'il
=
L
'
e
i
a
+
i
i
+q;
?
g
:
tr
E;
a
B
L
r
=
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 7/100
o
T:FF
r
i
;
i ze=',z{uiz;i
I
i
l i
i
i
a
i
Ie
let
*
l9g
11
1 I
1E?i
iBtaE
+igI
i
tlE
giiE+Eieet?
+:
r
1a
rigtiry
ai iiriFaiiti
*++lrliia?ail1i?
iiti
e
Ig
E
i
i?eit;Ie33*;f
zt
e+*
3;qit-igi3:E:
*ii?iF3'
1
1
lE?ai
[t
?ttEE??
l?lllrffi
sJ
fE
E
E
lffi
t
I
a
;0 *:.r;
*
6
y
i
a
E
ie
I
g
[t
a
+
g
a
i
i
i
a
e i
+;
r
s
e
i
i
i
r
e
i
I
i ? i
i
i
a
t
i
il;
riLaBiii
iS*E
?E?,i;
?ia
E,
*ai::
3
?
i;
Fti
iat
iii
?
A+q?
FE
ia*;
eq*EiiI
[iliE*i??E[iq
ii:
a
F*aiif
+giEa;+;eaic
iEuz==
?a;A;+a
i1i
iE
isE[=
LAiE
[
*
*-rE
a
e
;i;
*Le
il+
6
FT
r"q
t-'-
g
tt.:SeHF
lg'r
is
x
g
t#';
reT?
H-Eeg
?
r
Io
olE
l
[li{i
EE1
il
I
Tag{1$[g}
1
I
r
lE
E ,E;li
11111
illitlrEligl
ta*alI11llEa
liElaEffigg
r
?E
IE1EiEEi[
1
l[Ell$EE11llg
I?E
lgiffiEi
**f
E
i:
*tEts
+rI€rs$1i111?118?ErlE11
-ag"i ia'=
*eEE1iEicii$ l'?1[?i*urrE i? iF'EE uu;
j
=
5
o
:
i
i
+
g
6 -
e q
;
t SE
*
:
i
t*ifE;;
iH
;;i
r*?t;H
*
r$Ff1ili
{iriifL3
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 8/100
.)qZt^-
oD N F
-.)
-=aHlD
t I Q-I^',5
2 5+o H
6'
jq'ooPH
#:58
*:r
t)-E
='cYY-.5
z
+X
-
=
?
-. =
s
6
vY6l)A
-914
F.
35<9:r
:'u<aq
v v
J'
<
o <
a;
<; tF
5Slr(iE
t
o-<
3
r
D
:.
@ a)
c*7r.,?--
v
:.
-
g
F
(D
A .
>-ut
fi
+;
a*'a H
='xE * e
B
d 6 id
'La
-
I9 +C
6
^i6ilti'
i
^
I >
-
= 'vi r-
aHtr;--r
o=pi4
"'dS
E
E,
g-
-.-t-
alSAol
B
3I
{x
A
-^-):=
€
E <:
HE'
i
=
€E
H
g
i
-e--4-er-9_7-
--
T
T;1i*"
A
o
rA.
-13
ii
'
'
l3EilI:*]gfuii{lslilglllirllll+?'
i
**l
i
i
+
ffi
r
iEl
I fii
liE
ill
i
iiil
uE
I 1$
I
i
I
g
r
1
+ t
i
i
i;
at:,
l;1
if
I
i
iii'=|it
iE
'r
jq
i;: rF
i
r
r;,T
r
t
I
a
t;
is
r+s'
i
{+ri;
ii?iiE?sIi
iBriE
iliillli
ii
l
i
r
ffiit+g?
Ii15i
llgg
I
I
I
ligEil
I
iia
i
H
iiinE
ie?iu;;
i
;i uallr
;rr:3i;
ii+ceqr
r
iliri;
li53
re:*
i;
H
;gs
iFi
,ila
ielliii;iil
ililiili}ir*t
ifiistglf
irEiiia;
rrc;sn*uii;+iiiri
ic
iI
E;iiilBE
ri,*ut
? ;f"o
9:ii
oLq
-q6
P-q
='^
OaoEE
{51
a{?
82-
6oF(J
:D:-
^X'o-
?Ed
l 6
.d
CSq
IiuC
<f
'aa
q*E
Jv
3;'r
'+(
<aE'
a {H
*o
a-
u9 ;.
o
&-T
E
I'<
X
-o--
=ls-a
6 .lD d,;
@X<
:--.{
l0
-
n
o
o
-
q
3
c)
o
T
TD
-
q
OJ
q
,f
O.
o
n
o
oa
o
o
(D
o
n
{
o
a
(.D
o
ts
o
6
rD
X
i
o
6
o
.)
0)
.D
n
(.D
6
o
q
q
PJ
a
o-
0
E
o
io
n
rD
-a-.
o
FJ
E
6
n
$
p-
q
o
n
q
o
a
0)
o
q
o
a
o
U
o
o
-n
t
I
aid
SijH
P<
d;
Pto
a -
ts:;;.
L;, d
=-
5<
?,
A-:.
=
-'\)
o
n
o-
o
6
d
(D
n
o
cr
I
-
r3
rD
d
-.1
(D
oa
g)
q
6
A)
7f
a-
a
o
fr-
o
o
0
{
o
o
o
o
a
o
o
)
n
a
o
n
N
o
q
+
5
J
q
q
U
o
q
o
n
o
r
o
x
A)
A)
n
cra
'-6-
Lrl
o
o
n
o
o
crq
o
o
X
E
rD
n
t
a'3
aES;
R:igi o
=6
Xa:*5GioU.Y-L 16
h *
J
-'
:
;.e';az'.J+
A(.Da^so
da 5$;ii
d'i:t:Q.i
^.
S,C
3
&s f
ts +
OF'i
eil#=:
i E
P.--.
q5
d
{
,E.
1tn93s.il
=
r+ia=.r
r
6
-'rDr.:frDFda
5
*tr*hi*E.-ftrrtri
oe
=i5
: t
rD
o
qr,4JJ:Eq
65;J6..D
8.6-
A.
+
S
9..+
;qoHno-
e5.< IV'-.5
o-
a lrPo'9
X
o
o
5
=l]
6
r 5-t *Ei:3
-
q9.
':*
R .jil . a
F
I
€
l*
x
E
--;)*J
e 3
;rd-d:
o
$frr:;58
FZlB_E€8-
+l+R
5
6'q
3 f H i
=
3
rr
P:'-IA
rA-Xcc:
c,:
o
E.F.t
5
?FT"gFE
q
66-AA
.D
o
tr:-:-
x,
E
lJ
=.
: F
6
-
J
iPAX
=L-
-E'f +fi *l lt
p
aI.Uair
g
+
-5
5
.,
X*
I
+6'H:'3
rD
='
9ir:f^3
i
t"
t33Qs5.
g
3
a6=^
=i;
€
+
gdR='==
.+
I
: E X'x:
ar
o
)
9vuva
^Fir-.trE,
Hgx-rBi
E'
+
i1?grq
=
1
s 6l"D 5
g
-
-LX'H=.aF
E i'
-
,
f
+
6
9
-ft
;
-
O
E
i i';
a€
*
E"3
h
3
=
A
iAtsJV=-
v,-A
c rr<
^.
x '
rDo::X<
D
^
IT
? r|o
aLi6-
J EN;
1
9r5tr5
:' I
q
-.
q
dr'
:r-).)b
--i
^_JVr.t
qv=i5l
F
ji
-.
E.
6
+
f.:j
a
i
;;
H
IE
r
i
f
B-9
E
r
'C:IOq^i
rJo
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 9/100
€
?
B
q
# f
=F
s
t
P
s
f
E'E
E
,.D^I
x
3
3
S
ltn ts
+E
q;":
6^lD-l
^
c,- ,
a-=;
--
^
5
a
1q
t
i
=
=
g
a
=
*
+f
3
-a
=lZ
l.d6SL'=:c''a
2 z _ 3
=
-
=€
f
L
=#
n
=
q
dFo'oX;-Irifro r--a)
.i3;€6 g6E;atai=
:{Ho:-h---JOa-=f3o
;SisXta?rsiEi=-
+
=
-e
r r
-
=
3.L&=
I
P
i
<rrq=.q:.-d=.a
-
=
='
I
v
D 5 X
;'<
=
.Y
-
X
O-
-rT
=i
$-
i r
-
i5
fi-
+ i 1i z
:
L
s
E
$ i
i
q;
[:
I
F
i
E
H;dlsn:;?;aE3E;
i-\-,'u^A
=.-
=.-.O
;i
E
i:r.i
.i
-=
-+=)
: ilE
3.a
=..
3 8
3 ?
;
fr-
1&
i ; I € $;
"
.F
=
E
e
F
+
f"=
*H h-E
S-e
+{LB#;*0
d
=
i
r f
:'i
I E
3
[
i
* i
i?
5-
6-
9 +s
=
q
=;
,
=
€
=i
q
o-qd=+P,,ili+9135
A-t^, I = -=
rD
id
5- n&
A
qaii{il:iEEsL;:F
=,_
I A,* 1F A E
=a
7;
i
;
g
aY H
5
T=:-=.*o+g ,_
='
^ii,\JU'g^)-Al:J\<
3;i+;56Q.o;Ph-
?
F
Fa
?
E
?
i
?
*
0 fi
E
t
#--1- -€*A+.gd+-+-l
5
=,
e
<
" 6 tr a
=.P-
o
E
tr
+
r?
"
X;'nt
+e-?
=
6 H
=6-Ag;7^-XpfH ,i-
-l$
0)
o
o
B
t
o
-
-
o
n
q
3
o
o
o
o
E
o
o
;'d
95
J6
JV
.0tr
oo-
5c
)
<,
( F)
t(D
,5ta
od
,F
:.E
6-e
EP
En
ov
5 J
sE
aA'
:,
@t
9A
i9
DO
lr
,
q
oa
o
q
o
(D
E
(D
P
H
t)
q
-
o
I
o
DO
o
$
-
o
o
3
A)
o
o
o
o
o
=-o
^
tr6-
oao
Ei6
6t)
='*a
o-{
i
E'ER
PA
<5$
.o
ci6
r
Q-
<
3:
qY
n-a
:-v:
ni
-
D
-'
3
ori$o
n
Jfoc
o
^{o
i'r:
55=.
ouo
oRtr
x-ii
?x?
o
o
n
IJ
-
(D
o-
A)
FD
o
o
o
.D
I
ID
B
.D
n
o
q
F
e
s3
5--tr-*9
a ii
*
r i
I
C
a S Ta
=
d
XLSgisrE
E€;: iE }
I
=;"=
A
3.:
i'rD5i
O"a(d-fX
t:h.l.i n
ttD
Y
_FJv:Fn-tr
5[H:6-Eil
At<,r="
J='>1r(DlD
-Y iiJ:-n5
.Jpr'
;ro
-
O
6'
*
'
$ f
i 5
0r
E-E
o +;x
-:=o66
u9a
-tL))
*;d
?
1E
Pp9XEa
IJ
€ a.0
=€
5'
=-.<qta:'.
-n
a6AVV-
\y
J
+ R
o-e.E'<
A:+.)
5 5
X
i3
i
D
E A f s.-
^:.o-) o'o
r
j
E'.o Y
.l*
n
iEAs-B['A'
3 l6R?.<Y
:.i
=
v
x
OaX
x
+,:
A\Fa
g
-r
U
JfiA
-
. v
e
qr-
-.n
?-q
vi\q
f
o'3-
-.H
4]J
--Oo
:.-
,.)
Oa$-r
-H
--.-l
;ts
_€.D
iDA
\)h:
etss
-
-ci
rD
H H
(u:
-u
--
Xoa
C,
ot?
t u
()
va9
. ;.1.
a)
r3
a
il .f-X
E.
.<
9.
e
6<O
.Ei
r.g
-6
rr6
---)
OO(
[;
f
E
ar
1;giii
[gi;
gig
$f
3Efi
Fif,[
rE
FtFgiFl
$
;
i
r
i-
igirlgilEg$fliu
'g*+ifliiiiiiii=lii
EHEIl
5 i i.t€
I
i'5.lttf-Lri
$}
il
#
i
r:
E
€
ri $
ir
Is
ri
1i: $i:
f
i$ii
=
Ei
+$;$i$iii[$igE
iiEii
iil
s{Tii;:
+B
rn;lfilf
Il.srrgaisif
iq[[iFx
II
$+:
$
i$
$;
i
Ii
*
[1+ i
g?
i
isfr
i;€
r;*
i
rB=
E
a
ig;ifiili
iEIiilf
flEir{
iegiE*+i$[ia€
i5T
Is;;
r{
;;
i
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 10/100
n
-
la
q3F+
rEaili${+;3{rAaig*:.E:EEiilB3$3
?
i
E
t
i o?
g
r
i
i
i
iB
=*t[
i[[eg$iEtFl1ts
l*tEBgiEif
I E
.:*BcrtsXI
IF=€isE
==
i=F-'igrlIiF*iii[i{lFiFiiili
iggli
i
a{qBI€
i$rE
*r6
E
=.I
io
=::
ii
iIiil
ilfiiii
;
E$}f:
*
;
t3
[s
i
]5rrg:
;iiE
rs
ali
;,il_]E.tt ltH
fii
=
3
<
H
es€
i
* f i:
i *:
I
A$ *€-E+it*s€,iE E+r1+i i
ifi
i
f
E;:
i:
ttitIs
:
i
3
[1+:
3
#
i
qile;
Frs I;
*
=
:
*{
q-l$Ei
i{iF
r
iEii?
Fiiiii
lillaFiE
: E-:'6
R=
ilf} 3 ;fi
i
iE:
o.:
riE
; H
it''t'ts
5:xE
r:
Fi
i
iiii+
xiiiirii
+ieg
Eglii6
rii }i
is*
as-irri
;
*$
i:,t=ii
liIi
iB;g
i
i
i{
ii
ix;
iiillu
B+eri+iiir;i;=j
r
rii*tl.[rr?
i,ii
s t
F
g
.
i
n
.D
o
n
o
6
('
(D
n
I
(D
o
n
A)
6
p)
o
o
o-
r-t
o
q
6
Xor o-
oG
8
.D .-.
-
37
9Sts
=;'<
*p,
0)a
^S
+6
:-i
rDa
XX
o(
rX
K(D
=.
ii-
P.D
I
=o-
I O Cr.)
Tl
=iC=<='0)--
?
*
I T
i
1
+
3
e*apoaao=
":$;'2='"n'eH.
-=-JPt
-:P^I.)rdoo
-]-==-.--,.ax
F?sF[3*aE
q1-'taa=-.,-a
-30
A
trrrilr
a
-..o
3 :
O
txILsg:0-I
';-=-i=-*a.-8-"o.-:'
3ii-:
eq'3
6'
o5^:.=r6^o)
i
*i
=
ilF
*
i;
-.t
r
r.^
r
rB
I
d^:
IilA
ii
$ x
-^
d
;'
{
r
€
=
P
I
-.
A)
to
=
H
a'R
I
H
q .Ed;'s:.isa
8-;3=
=la+
+6
=,-
l
5'
Z
=
a)
o
:+-A)
-at9'j
F'i
=
i
=-i
B
3
='3i3
:E6'='
a
oi8
2
5E
r
F aX in o
-
r
Bt-g':
ii5
L=
f
Xa
=i
[g
ile:S
s:e^e
orSorBqSpr?
3 +?=p
SNrq:BTs
1e+
aFill
1lg
1q$r
E$=E$r
E
i;;
;";-l-E;
l;s=
3
r-
i
s
;
E
:
*ii3
Eir5
sra+.a
i E
ur
il$
.H'I'o
-
g
N
3i 5
o
a
;ixil=,illi
Fli$q*
:
F
f
i
q
r
r
i
E
ils{
i
i
i
i
rF
re *
;':
<J'F E
rHeiru
E I
ti
S.H
I
e.E o t36 ?11
:
?.4**€.
a='s&"*ia3?[siE
=1i1]
ii Fi}ila*l;
r;i
,iiit
iE
;Hi+;grilsEg?
rFE
g
it=ri
?
+1
:r
Bis;=Hiii::[;=
i
iT
il]
t,.-agE;;:e-*filii
:
{;
r€
F:E+?tiIe;;.i
g
El
pd
q+qHi++=Esiil
-e,
=f
iE
=
c-
t
o
r8
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 11/100
i'13
lH
o-
n
5
;;
i:rilgr
1:
= ;73
3?
ltll
tFSE
i
fia
o
<s
'E
a
il
3
?i
I
:
e
i
=
i i
E
:
6
+
$:
t
i
f
T-==
13
F
1e-
r+i {
sf;
q
q
itiiiiig
iEi:
iEiiiIiE;?;i
.
=
;
?i=a irg
iilr;ii;
?Fi
iFg
E
I
ii'
s$i
F--
o
=.*
6,
igi
i
ii?iiiigtiIi
iIr
i
iss
ilisF*ar
r
;
*
*,i d ;iiv.=?|.:B
=-E
6
=
=-
7p?
+a
"gE* : fgF
*
r'"' E
=Te-=Eq
a
rs
gri
g€*:
itta liii
3
;
=
I
i
3(D
€
tr-
E
a6
ara
I
::+EEir;r,;ig+93il1i1i{5q(
(D
:. a
=
=
e 2
g"-
6
d
:
i
+
i:siisEliiiigt;tii
itlli}tii
1i
d=
igR
'
3 i
niiiiiliii;iiinite:
iiriii;iii
[t
-s+Ei4:ii+;l1E3ri*n?la'iFisf-0;F0i
="Eq
rli
q,
-
7
=
+rai
1ariEigltiili?ii:i;E'aiii
^arl
"s 3
i
A
;
=;
t
e1
i
r
=-
i Bi
=
x"6i;
=_e
rAB,rF
E
+fE-:
i
3
s--;1
a
E
??
:
i
=
i;;+f;I+;i{
ltrrii}r+iifiilri;i
?
i
1=is:giiii*:;*iqfE+5i$s&ZtaiEI
z
=
5=3'.i
+;
't
:
ai":
3--s+
lYri
=BH
3
I
+l
ip
3'
i
?+=ET+e1?+ax.;$3aE.L3ig93iFaf;r
:
$€
rg
il
1t
I
r
5;
;:
n
1g
i
i
]
E
=E;
:
i
iF
B
;
*
I
i
i
f
f
s
i€
i
*
i+is;
r
i
i
es
+
x
r
il
i
E
*
FE
i
ri
q:
+
i;
tgE
i;
a; F
r
i
1:
il
=
g
T
1#
F
*
6
s +:
.
s
s r H-p
=
o
E
I
rs
a
r+
q
f,EEt*Eritr;
lf
egl}E+l:
i
:iisiiiiir;1i
n
; ;
*
=f
B
tg;*
1t:
1?;
i
rF
1B
i
i:
Li
il{
tl'ii
H S
c
O
t
q
+E
=rde
*;1:iI.;
q;lile
aii
sl+;L=i.",.i< :
fr
a15
zc
e^=
-i-its:
Eg;-ri-s*6
=
E*-*f
E
j.a
o,
ir=o'
E+t-i-E_:Ef
TE*Tr3s?
i$io,u
afl
1:=:i;ilF a
d
e{-iri;^<:IP:+E-J.i;z2? n S?i3:9E;.f l-ee
ie
d.H
E
-
6
E_
j
*s.rig il$if
+f
H:
a E
lsr
BEil;rx
*
g
I
r
liFEgl+f$Eiigit
}I€{ i r I
[
I
$F#+Fg
-
..c
=
3
{
^
1.5;'"-
x
or
9:.
=i =:3'o
:
=';2
-<
Fllr
?i; o
-
;erRrH.i;E;i+1r
f3i1++
+=fii;I$ a;ir
o<+o
ileiiiir+ei;iiii
Iti[[t
iiii+;fiiitIr
e
e
gfiil
s'i,'
^
;
.ir.:
5
=
iEg : F
=i*.:E
I-S1#s
I
*
a
ALi+g=
f[
ilig
:
$?
]aFir$
i5g3it6e-il$;Fg
t
o-
o
r=-r- I -o'
slE
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 12/100
*.JrfilA*V
2a
Xo
:6
.r
-E{
{9
U^
oO
(a
(D5-
-
-.
o-o
aDn
ho-
'Oo
rDE
O+
E'o
- )
Bi
€:
D_
6n
D.D
rDJl
5o
( o
no
6'.L
ttq
o
ID
I
O
)
o-
o
o
o
o
o
F)
-
o
;
q
6
o-
6
.D
(D
o
o
o-
o
J
o
a
gr
o
E
(a
0)
o
(.D
(D
n
oa
o
-
-
(n
0)
a
ts
o
E
o
0)
a
)
rt
U
o
(D
E
E
o
I
rD
F
OJ
o
3
I
0)
O
o-
(D
o
(D
4
o
o
o
r
&
{
TD
E
)
o
q
3
)
FJ
n
n
J
o
rD
o-
o
n
o
q4-m.)
tr
5='E.o
v@=qo
dla.a5
P'LJi'
5 0i$N
a-
D5r)<
o:n
r
t i
P
H-6.i a
ioEP
I
o-rcd )
^
i1
o
O-o
dAc-5
O5O9e
+L
i
i
=
i
-'Y.
FB95i1
=
=9
n id
ef:u
Y5
o
-
-
AJ-
9;dilts
=
l?@aa
:ll
@;i
o
ii
=-
.
=.
Q
6-'4.]Y
-
-D
c-
a:
p
=_o
Eq
E
o=.-.YA)
FU
q
-.@
aE-
F-x+<
t ,vAi.
xL5:4
FT
]
{ i:r
H
gE
T.-
A^tl-
XYAcho
-i
--=-F+$
O$O5o
n@H-'
n
I
JAV)h
''
o'
=.
I.
Lt
Egv:
))
Jtt
Fq8
+
o
o.tts
o
o-
-.1,
='rD
n-
F^q
-a
Alx
E-dg
sz=.
ia<s
A-tr
q
o o-*IJ'
;+P:
o.i:'
vF.D
RXo-
69-
ir
=
O.-
oi:
'l-9"
.
v-
='
iaA
4qn
Q
ao
i.Y X
N-3
lD
fr
di
po?
Ai
^ )p
6rD:t
EO-
Hpfr
OoO
6=
<otr
5.< :-
3
n<
iEE
;
()
i +
DO
o
'-
6'{
t
o
ia
)...-
o
E
o
E
o
o-
q
oa
E.)r
ona)
;:JS
-.L
$ E<
i$o=
(D-o
-O-*5*ea.
da
(a{
(D;-
2
*=
24,=
I6'"
;oa
5
Fli.
6tn
5nX
oujic
Ats
Y(n.D
.D,
6'"(D
o =n
=6E
;..1 D a
3
a;'q
(D5-
E.J;.
N(i
O-nq
A)
i
o
o
Eia
o-
o
o
q
rD
(D
A)
(D
o-
J0.
IJ
o
a
p)
(D
'nt
Pq:
ro
'qo
-.-o--"8
ho
4q
B
..r+
L.<
/g)
^A
l'D E
7a
oo
6a
ra.
J
0)
-P
-.
'rD^
)P
=r
0
0)
*tD
{t
5i1
hi
o
'q
O
tr<
iorD
ai6
Pi\
i$Sq+f
lA;,
I3.
Fr;.o.c
?\=
t;;:rBgE;sB
iiI[$sEE +$f
[
[rEFEf,B: $iE
3
iiiI
[Fi
iil[
rE;rH*=ilg*i
rr[+iiiriil
-EBFfiiEgiifl
E.=a'I€o-a
i;r3
lilir+ii
t ii
iliiiE:F
E
iEiE
riiis
X:]6(.D=O
a
15
il*1Eq;
sA
EiIirsFilii
i
iss;uE
iF
:
E:BEF;;iB-Ei[
.;f
flcE';ags aitl$45[f
i
iiu=n+Fnrftili
s$iitfi;us,
ssi[E
f;fE
I
Ii$Ei;iiigir
EH1$rf,i[[fI
ar[g$+crBil
rE:ifH
gsErdr
Iiii:tlgri$
aEIiire;i$
iiE
is"ii
3
;i1g
I"s
i
i:3
*s
li
3
1
:
E
s
+E
t
rE
ds--
;
ril
il
E;
;
d?
*s
6_t2:i+5I
d*6*+;EsEa
H
i l
igAe
=
r
tg
l
€
aFE
I
r;ri
?
=G
;-::i;i-A*
1
i
F
i i ;
g
i
:
H
€
i
.
*L
I€
]
i
i
E
3,i
E
E-#-Fffi-FEtr-*
l
o
H:l
^'o
=
.:
E
+++FHre+;'
ririri
1r*
q
r
iil+;=.:[1ii
I
-13
iwlr
tc
o
o
cP{5'
$o-iF
=.-.tuu
d
g
o&
=.PJDH
^a5a\
L A
=E.i
Y
@oX,)
<uv
Tt-
5
-H-d"
JA 9f,
J*P
o
n€
5
J*PvY
p;.v,
a.-5
*;
Y
',
<
o
5n
oE(alr
E--.rD(n
6v)dh
EA
.ir.:EB
/J
p:oo
^(DhO
ri,='6
r
a-ll
'
€oHq
oEo=.o
ts-9
9 €
9
2. - 9
o
6-
dl
-P
tq-*;
A9
si'#n
P3E i
=-.
qUa
9^6(U
6
B.
g
iii
ou(:ro;+
-e-
Oo
CtN
X
=oo0
5630
9iJ
f5Cr'.D
3 +:
l$xct
=oxn
E.,'q
t
:
o5=E
.)-':.
U-A
"6--H
*-o*'9.
P
iiE:
q
Eg)NoI
^Pl
369
h\+^X
6
i'D
O-;
{FE6
DY-Di'
nriiP
o
6
='a-
-
EPs
dz-(D
6-d ?-
XDA
s'-)
< -J
P.E
q
#
=aD
6
vu
lDd50-
Fai'oL
9_r.v
o*<3<
--JYA
x
^
a
^:E-.
XvDP
,@
utlaox
psE
O
r
-.iri
YrlqA
o
C'
E
)
b'f
o
q
J
6
6
(
o
o-
o
n
-
t0
a-
o-
.D
E
.D
o
D)
-
fc
(.D
E
ts
(D
6
o
ts
FJ
6
na
o
-
)
q
3
.)
(D
3
n
TD
E
z
E
ts
.D
n
o
P
-l
o
o
J)
o
ID
a
4
B
6
Z-
n
3
I
o
ID
(o
X
q
()
(
o
o
o
o
E
N
9a
*
E
PJ
(D
p
a)
o-
("o
n
0
(D
0)
fc
E
d
E
3
o
E
(.D
q
0)
o-
o
€.
o
o
o-
o-
o
o
o
5
n
(D
o
PJ
t
o
a
t}
B
n
o
@
(D
(1
)
a
o
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 13/100
il5
lc
o-
o
E
r;=
*Ei?i?Eils
f
fii=1fi
:
I
gE
ig3Bi
1E
ieE
ir
i f
i+gq
ila
ir1
1ii5g:
qs+ir+}
ni
+
irl
I
i
$+
*r:
;:
I
ligigf
Ii
1
li
11
ffi
*tlgtEli
1
lii
I
;=tii
a
=
i
i;
rli+
iiiF
=:
iai+iH
i
re
r?
i:;
g
i
iE
irrie
fix;
iiiiii?
i
f
iiir
\?+iiE
+rii
i
iiilui
'.{v}
iii,
1ii11
ilEBlEiliiiiii[1*
i
e
,
i
[E
Ilii
ill
ilifi
:]+siEi
lEllEleii
I
+EiiEgI$;
tlrr
$ni1=
s
'
'sl1rr
Fii3;
r$i,
i++;
ra
*ii;*r;iErr:
+iiii+ii
riiFi
+;
**
f
f
g
i;1ig i5i '^E'+q
=='€
++o--r-
r
x.c-c-P;'3
ifi
++ilf
flFiEl
i$:;iri;iiii*:
r'i
5
--+?
E
i
6:r
.';ilii3
io**;
+il;
i
iiE
litil$$if
i
:d@Pq\
+
+
g" r'x
X
d
6
r='y
*
s;'a
rigiIlpi$ iflI+il=iilirt
i
rili
o
o
i< *
a
tr:.
6
i'il
='=+=
+"Fgi^- .nA
p
i e
H
=
=.c
f
"c;
;.A'*j'?
*i
_
5E A
f
qi*ts
="-
=rsH';
E
a:F:?
+*irt
:
i?
4{
gE
iiii
rgtns
i
fil
+
iig
Ii
IE? iiIt I
i
lix
$ iI
s
;p€
a1 a u
i:Eili r
;f}$liF+r$3sli+igiilH
l(D35P
a
B
$
x
;
3
E
T
r
]t
i
+
i'
e
I
i
a
i
F
i
a
i
f
$
I
I
s
$
il
ds
ilg
gE
ei[;
=:
a
*+gt:.8
3
==Filn,i:1;i
il3;
i+"1
t
-.
A.
y
:j a
=
*'ii
P
):J
oj X a ;
-'
o
X * + _ ,n
r
i
6
J,
L
y
-
tj
I
'
-
Er
:"i++s; affi il il€
f
E:siE
E
ig;i[=
3
[
r+
*"
B
ix
a
a=-i
E
+*
iII=
iF
+:-
i;iTit
g;.?1i
i
?_
8
+o-*
'=
e i
* F
$3
E;;
E
I
=g
I i
i.,.e=_q
q
+F i
i
t
l
+:
r
?; F
$
-.
.-'a)
6
;
a
s :H '-; ;
r.-
+E
E-= 3e d: ;Ir 3t[?E d i-8
3
e
T
$E
i*
*aE[;-*"Ul;i+i;
IiIE F
+iir+*EiE{
c
_
E
;
=
i5
r
3a-sf+
g
i
g
F€-8-
i
il5
;
*
5
? i ;
:-EE
di
a
a
i
;6
r
q
?
a;
tt
+
s
;
q
€ + I
T
*
+
;
;
€
;
i
t
i i I
f B 3
t
oo
d
X
t.D
a
p)
o-
o
n
(D
, C
n
(D
o
q
6
3
(D
?1
n
o
n
r=-
*lo
*15
.{
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 14/100
str
tiiifilfiiira
ierE$H
;
i;
=*;f$
I,a;;
i:
frle ii,
q
i
a
i
rr
I
iB
iE
iA6tqi
*C
b
r:
-i
itr;Fii€
ilB
irriri
._=-1
9"34i
=
r? 8 1i.;=i
L
F+iSSiilFrt
tiiig:
E
d
i i I
{
l5<i+ ra
}.sd{
*81[+ril$
iliI
sa
i
ie;
f*ii;iriliE
ItaEiE
ilr+l;
++rIii
Eir}$l
i
s
a E€
+?ii5
;+:
aii
illlatlglili
ffiiEl$
;
I
I
i r
el
I t i
if
i
I
I
r
AE
iiii
tiiiF
3
iiiiii
Ii
E
Eg
I t i
s H
il
i
I
I
s
i
i
EE
i
li;
ir;
*'n?l$eisf
itt
i5
i
uu
i
F
;
i:
E
a
a
s
i
s*aiErsi
Iili-Fiilff
i
r
+r
ri
i[i
s
i
If
;
I
E r
$[rf
t]iririiiiiiii
;*'?^ilitiAq$if
iri;
I
rIE[ritil:
r+E+ErtE
8-?
=
5
r+
r3#
K
^e'i;griiii3:r=*uE
Ff
if
iEsifri:lSFiar
iliE
lrr
;;7;ra
;
i
f
:
i
i
i
E
;
+
r E i i
i{ E ieE; $; r
r
it
i
i
E'
;
i{
r
r
i E
B
9t
gF
ft
il
ri
i T;
I
r;,
A
H
3
I
t
i
rFi
i=l
ie
s
lf
E f
ii i
i:
=
i
*
:
+i
re+
i
+;
Ei
tE iaE
Et 5i
[E
r
1
Ir;
r
i{
ils ii
L"r
i
i;
r
*;
I
i : r a
i
Es
i{
a[F
i
g
i S i
g
:
r
i
1i
il:=: r
l
r
rgt
ilcr
l
ilipg
ii[i
+i.
il
+i:n;+iiiliFri=i;rdE
r[:igt
+i'
E
.
ia
la ;
tllila
a; i*+g:E
'
fi3;i3
ri
F +
1
e"
esr t i\a-;+;
i
I
[*;]:
rqF;
F
it
1it
li
='"€
e:
I
a
ti'
r5g
+€e
gf
;;
-
[=
negiil*
qi3-'ryela:[d=Ei;iLE
]€
i
3
E
iFE
];r*i i3
a*+**{
;i
rqir ie
ii"==a6s
ii+*$;B+iiE+;t?fiil
flF
i
rl i a
a
",i?
afr I
id,P
TiE rts
T
? 3 d
h";
=,$
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 15/100
s
-
*
l,
rg
-l
m
-
r
l*
ot
a
t
o
o
=t
-
-t
o
t
o
a,
e
t
g,
o
913q i{3fig3rr5 f
lsa
if
e:E"-[nrit
E
r
i
i;
E
I
3
ii
i
3
#
F
A
e
SE<a'*Hd'?5?iEg+
E
A
+f, rre
s
il; i:[e3'+
S
;s
igl'i;Iif
eg]
E
O-
n
O
0J ii r I
v
=.
q
<
'J
=.
rsl=3
o:al;e=f
=*
+"-;{
ii<
1a
f
e: {
q?
r*
6-,
1,58
az
LA€icE
D
Bf +8 3:er.*=5d I
is
il'6
6DLlo6oN
E
:fJ'i'i *TrE-$*a3
E
:.=
=s=
:=a*:;=fi3-
+
:oC=E:'
s5i3B
Ai43=ef-l,'E
7(.'O
n
4
4i
O-
;.
C,
I'e6-o'FqT:2.-='2.e,
+o-'l
=,-
1a7
a
)
nl
q
a
E
-:s
j,oB
;*S3g=16
d
-
3
5ro
X
lj
4
3.
n
-
O
3I-e=:
12;=;?E*
ii3;"e-
+1=ft
=:rL
;'3aaa
HFfla:3+
ilaa[E 6+e+1{nL
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 16/100
Bl#
P
i:
riira; iei;li;airi+tliiiilElElg1lii
I
ABgla
=
i;E
=
A.E;
a;i;9 : lrli€'E I
t-
6e
-=+6
d.a
:
=+r+i
s
a
-Lii
g
t,
*3_"*
fi?;?ig
i
i
;,;1ili
iE
i=il
i
Nx6i.d5=
e;ne.
l 3"-r;?Li+=Ar:9:
+E.f
=+
t::4izrgqs3
?
itir*ili+lieii*tt
iii
iirEa
itraai;ii
ii
i
3ai3*=e+ilr*iliBE;3sea{
3 E;;;ai:iI
f
,='.-'6'nE
i3
;
;;
6r
*1i_i:
; ii1?El=
i
i;;
;Ei:t
;:,+
r;
r
.,:NEA;
e i : x'K
()
a
6
1I
l.=
=
q
I
=D
^
i'd
U d-5
.
*i':tS
lii
?Z
t
i
g;;5
PT
ii;
iE
li
Ii*
3
iiE+
ii1l
ii
=
+
a
Lzz
ir
a
5
ic,
e
iir
iiiF[]iiiiii
iitg:
iri
I
i+i
:
iairgr I
lEtlsi
-iliii
trlFiiiliE:Eg
ilElliti
lgi
'?ifi
FiiiIiiii
f,
lliIi]F*
s;+re+u*;;
i
ir
"1'
o-
Y
,r
(D
rti
1+r; f
iril
i=€
$gi
;is
iii:
sr13$i?irru
lilg$$ii
1i
rl
il
i
B$igIlEFii5Ff,
i
i
i
i
E
1E
I$f
i
iBi
iiE iiri'
raiFiiiB
iii
iiEiEiI
iiI
it
IriEii;;Fi#}
1$[E[i*
il+i
lff}iFiFlFEiii
iFiliEiiiliigiiiFiili
1
{}+iE;llit
ii
il
ri
rrr€trix*gi;
rir
il
i$il1gi11iiig
ElilElilililllgiiiiii
i
+iiEil;iri;;
11i€f:;
rl;i+[i
y,r
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 17/100
iei+l+iE
il+18l1[iillEfii*a=I iu]ll
i
t :
Fie
i
*?ii
+
i
E{-*il
1i
[;iiiiii
i
iii
is
ix
li
I
f
3iS1if
3i?iie+iaTr:
rei
r1?i?,i,i
i=?ril€
+
1;;Ei
r-? +s-q
gj+iE
iB
a
IE
li
ii1+
E
r
i
i i3:
i
ia;
**t
i
;iia;iif
15+Fi{i+rli*iEiigiii;
?*?- '
ii
t
3
is
[i
; lasii+ts
mrir
[+Fif;{
i i*
: isiE3
[+
+:
ri*;
rrr
i?
:
ra'='
*iiAiiil
c*are*t
1i[;
]'q
g+iiiE
i5[i5ll
illIi+iiFa[Fi11i{E:
1i
,s+?r;E
?E;i?
z?iFif
riia
r?rriei
?a
i
i
+sigg3*lErr$?
f
i**e$3;iFi$iarE,
$i
ilE
*s=
i
i
r
H
*
i
[
=€
i
iE
FiF
I
+
E
]
+
i
r
i
3i
ig i
f
f
ii
tg
i
;
i"i
i
I
s
a
i
ri*
=
u
+
B
i
r
rE
i
I
f I
I
ia
+r
:
q
s
:
B
l"
iirilil
ii;
iEi
rr${rlE
iIi]ttgf
BiE;1rE'
it
[i{+g
i;.
ilii
i*iE: ii$i}$iitF$$aiiH
i+B ?E
rIAlr+iill,ilr+][i1l;11igii
1iIlI*+*r
i
li
+sTe
:
*al
E
x3€
g
iil sE
F€
ila
i3
lit]il[c:
6
;'
N
ia
p
s:
:
aa
r
idsEa
f$=
ctc
3
ia
s
;gfffii
=l
f
e
''i=45'-:.
ii
:i
+c FE
ii
iEig
i€
3
ii€
*iitiaI
EE
iii
aei
+
IiiiXesili
rdt$ii+**ir
IriAi{$tli$fs
+
B
++{ari
;
i€
;q+F
i iE
r;
;*
i;q+=afgt+r+*
?i
-"
3
E; ? i s
iril:aiiF?1
i[i]r[i,iiBr
BsHi]$l]+FFil
i
xlg'
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 18/100
"-l
o
I
6
trl
o
0l
o-
(r)
o
IJ
E
xl
?i=*+.r3-
il"ri1fl
={=;itFi;Eff
i=:{f
f
i=?E
33&lai
;3
f
=B5P'L'
zi
=
z
i
-a
=
rr:
;'
=
I
sdii
Inii;fi
;:li;'i
:
3-'
z
=
9i,
r
i
I
E
=-.
i ill
ig
trg
rLE
ri; ii"*i E$:iir
= =
3
:ao-H
5'
='
L== a
-.-',-.=-
;
i2',Lz.Z
-
1' a
=E
S
=.
-a
o-
i
z
v
{,^i
3
E.
jr6
I
E};;
}
1z
;o=
r
;--,^==ii
=;
=o
0)5 - -l='A)
i=: ;=;*:
;
iTiTi.z=rd:
El,-ii,?Vii[;i;i
E
+;E
a;i,i
=
[r
;;
;+:t
I
=
lsqi;
iiisngfE
*
n,i
i.:n's E i:iB*ie.3+tTEt;*?5errN.-E
I
3 s
[Ilt+ B.
sF?;*i =
i:i
I
LiE
P
:
=
ii aI
:
t
i .9
=s.-.
^tir<
i?i€
r
n
+
i
:
iis
iFiliiE'a'=.r
r3*=
*l
;=
i
i
zB+;*.E€
r
;i*iis6i
i+cit?ilEiiiFle
i
=irii:;
E i$Eiirili?i
f3[;A+fi++Et] F
[gs;Eg c )3c
$ N
-rD
0r
-.
-
r:
='1
;;
=.a
ii += H:f
,,
-
=.^
-
=4. =
f
=-
-
n?'i?==^
i
+=774
=itailwia=de
^v656-
ii,=i{:$
P= -i*il)=Erri'
Eiiir+:;rE
i
E
ii.
+
i
; E
3?e
+
r;
igE
+E
zi=L=$
ii?
t
a
i
;*Eilfti
iizoii|F.;ieenqeaviad-Fd
.,
=.P
E.,
-*"-
3
*i'e-:.
88"-.) i9"
gi
E
gF:
ii
2*ZB
-
i;?T-s.;2
+=,iiil;irElgiA$iiiiISi
r
€i'rIB".aE
;,"aIeira?z*qBi-ri+;rEB-Fc
+
il
3
i 6
+
i
s
E
E;
E
s
e
r
i
H
s:
i
a' r _:
il
iir
i
[ ;
I
F;
g
E
iE
=
ix?38
+r=
+a
=
*i liri
i;,gg
;
a
$1:
;iI
nc;
r
iiii*iiif
il*iu
r*
=
i*r *aps*
iE:
i"i?i
+Eit
ria
*rg
i;€
iilf
l$iiiei;
i5ia *;fi
i*iE
E
=
ilE
iFifi
i
IiigiIr$=
?a,iB
E$E
i :
ir
?:
]FiHI
e;?
g;qr
Iiir
'
Li
I
i'Eia?gasi;aii$aIHi+iilf
Eg[lllila1ii1111li[?1ili?ilE
li+EiE
1H
$
e; r,
i;
r?:
$ix:ri
i
s:i"::.*+grtEii,=iiliii
1
I
*
I
nfa
;
i
?;a
;s_a;
=
d+43
2_
D_ox
: id
s
d
66-r;=
E
?
i$s;
rilsi+:;iii;
r
[;F a;
ita=,€ +;E
3
.
]a
*a-:=:fi
ntiB
;&A
q
*i#
s-:
rE
:
;
i
H{.i
I I
E:=i
i:i
7
?
e
i;. *s e
riiif*Eiaililei
iIi
iltiaii
ig
iaf
i
trir3
t
*3
r{
i';E
ir;ii
3Fg_tiqr+r
1;
; i; i+I
rer
T*
r
I
o
:
H
i'G
=FE-r*+r-?
={r
a
H
E-;
#i
fr
di
??
a e-€
r
rr
?e??Ee"'?ii.?5?;-l='e--oEo-o
oi
iq
I
I
_rt
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 19/100
o)l.r
l6
o
o
D)
rn
o
D)
o-
o
a
n
-$
ih
='
a'
Oo
. r)
n
Ilh
E
1[a
l?tl1
r
1111i1
?1?ili
?1?liti
a:
lt
1i?1FgAlr11i1E
i
6i
i?r
llEitE
ifEs
il
ir;Ir,+1ffii411i
e
a'it;.i
lllEis:
i;
rs
iBr?;
:
;tEiE;atrli11,;1
[]r?lreqil?
lE11?i
+z,t
Ii
1ii
lt1la1
1i1r
1?[1
1r
liailE
l[Fi'irEgli[?Li
E+:i
rtaalE
+gLnirt$e}i
1111l1u
lil
i1?
ltt?lL*
o
A)
)
ts
)
D
n
q
FJ
'l
f
s)
rJr
A)
o-
rn
n
F
o
#
d€
x
E
3
'"
* i
3
€ E
i
+
t
E
*
=B
i
g
3
:
a;E:
ilri1--l
I
ie€'
s;:;
esE
q
[[iF
=;
iiigq
is;l
rl;;
=:ia+f
ir
B r
r
+
?;;
e'
I i* 3E
ii
i;;"i
i;'i
i e
;
:
aE
=
r
si
*5;fa;;
r
ri*:a
ii"E
gi
:";:;
E,
:r+ee.=;eiA?Ea+iE
ig3
+E i,
riii;"ie:u
ei 1
r#rE
#
Le;
I
=ai
rge-seE+aifF$i;f€'iit
i
iiriagl;ElarE11:11gIlali
Aii
;fLF+*E="";i,gA"€,i;=
;+3
F
E'i;
::i;il[Bf=ge;q;ile8"
iA,
I
i
aii
Eilll+fEgiilira=;s
B-:r
E
ig
Fe1;.;E;35i;;;+Eai
igE f
iEa
;'EIEi*E=*4?a:1aE
ai;
i,
nlE
irg;i?rigsietiEsg
ilE
a
p,
16
q
=,;,gP
Y
n.H
e
='-a
irrF,-Frr-?
?;r,$Ti
ji
83F
g
3
xlf
rD_0e,c =iir=
ix
€
3
str
i
rtr
J.?*o55=f
H
='=.8
H'9:
a
?
j
aili
5;
H
a
-
t
t
-
; s E
(.D
--O
3_f
3
d
3
E e
s,
6z*ai-E€aE
i.E6?-9t.IU
#*is$ii6;
:
".-
E
=
"
.d
5q
=
?A
R
n
-
l.- -
I.tr9--a
a3-
€
{
d
"7
s'L: 8
fi
e i
:
Eta nE E
E
F
' n
o,
iri o-i5-o
p
^\-
=ii
i'e
=.
1E
s
ii3Eilaf3
18,-q, *[,f
-.
-'
5 ii
E 1:+:
3
i€6
+-.tvi
i-BF
q)a
B
='=.gJ
i'?<;5D
-2
q
?q=q
2o?Hoa)
1rl.:r.555
f ?
=
g)
F
-
o
i x
o
-
=.'o
=.
M
;/-
AraH
3'*J [s
E E-
i.n;''P
rf :i *F
gi
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 20/100
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 21/100
s
ii?ilain3i
13+;s
PEgE:
ilF1=?=Eli$3.AF
i
o=i;?x*+
fFBn-=fi+4i:":=E+*Bc+i€?
s
9E*iiri;#
3
ii$i;ili33$tiliFqr;*Iri
+
i
i3_{-1a
ni
i6
i fr;
i*.=ii1f,rtTF$;
sg_'iTt
[titrF:iit
f
1f
i€ir:::TH=[i+:iflirr
;
It
ri-_;li
E++
E=
=i;
;
[s
3
i-tgE'; iii
3
ief*=
[
€
*
L'r.:;;
'.i iq:
;
rZi;
+H
s
3.';
-iX
A
I-=
+;
>:
Z+?
1'
s;]{813=$iq 3 :-_=nu+EEa [=rfi5?i:i=e-
l.
=E-:==*4tr1:
a );i*=;:
* J'=6T+iti:8r^t
t
igi:ti5F:i
s
+eli+ilgs€a;$gEiiil+ii
+
iii$;q3+$[
=
liif+iiliiii$rE+1F+i;
+iF::
fqlt-
E
iq.lii*E
E-(
i
;i
r;
*=
:
r*1
1
r
=
B-
i
i
Ir i
p;:
=,3
i3:3
aeFd
;E
E
1;fi
?
q
3
o@-sr^1,
;
i
r
* l1a
i
i
f
A l;-
ii:
e
:
E
+:
=
i
n
6
+
J
=
E,
:rIiiiEit
tiiiilril
iiti
iEij
iFIil
Etii+,?ir
i*r+;
'gqg+5?ai;rg;i3a
rc
*
i
a
[+
+i
*?iE
+c
rE
=Fis
ilii
Iii
tE
ii
f
ii;
=
i;
31:
[i,
s
qriE
E;
a*n
E
:;+**
o
*
tif
f
]E
ilI
t
a
+e
1iE;
3
*F
g
=
T
fi
SiE
I$3
e:::
6
gI
tn
Ai
"-
i
=
rr
I
liB?Bti
liiEEi
iEl
i
[1g[i1ilEil
liE
lE
+" i
pi
g
;
L
i
i iE
t=i
=
r
i
8-
r:1i"*
a
;
5
q
_3:
e
i
n-
3
=
-
1.E
+1g+t$F11llii1iiiii
tii+1t1Eti'1gEle
i
i:
f
s
s
:
E
;Et
$;
r+E iE
+i+I-.3t:
[?+*.:
$,
f
;
:
<EEFi
a3:::.i
r c=d
=
*?t
r+:
;
i-?t
fig$ti}if
iFgiagiiF?
t
'9
8
-;+
o
i
g
:
":
=
3
-=
X
i i
:
*
y'i
f
;
a; E
3
-
s
rd
-
a
=
E
s
.:
:
-E-";ts
+
i
ai
ri$iiriir
IgaIaxeal$i;31jr
i$:
qsiiA
$
r<ri+rrilEr
:
a;i i*rrq:i
iiIi$$filiii
i
t 95cr0-
E
3 [;
r#*nl
rE
;
+
?)V=*
?
:
t+
?
i
i--"?;]i€
i=?,lB
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 22/100
;=
itE
i$r[[+i3318[r
q
rll*ie::
i:IE
riirE;i
i
E
riSii+F+i;tfriitE
**
1
ii
3i+iri"T.}l
ltF$f
*
+
+;+rl+si
rf ,i*iilil1
1
ri5,
;3EE
e1$iii$1i
s
fil:igif+
iE+ifiigil
r
:ra3*3ir
siEFq::af
f-=iE;,*i
sgir$Fgii
f E
r:
E
si a
Bd
ii
3
;
$;3
i;33Fi+t
B1iriiii+
r31+;;ii
#1,a+;;F
CD
o
o
3
d
o
I
U
n
o
E
o-
a
o
p
o
.D
a
2
U
n
o
E
o-
a
(D
t')
(D
o
B
q
i-orDo.1 nq
i x +< E I E
;
h
E
i
q
#
tq,
c-*-
=
-
=
i
=-
s.-_
+c
d
i
)
=.
a+Ja
?
=.=
I
E
'"
95
?
*
E-#.
-?
=
='$
o-a--.
;
ts
j
oo
=..qL:
-?
o-
i
=
o-'<
i'x
36=3u8=*
-
-l
D
(1
-.
i
-
-
^6/-
^
l't;
-
X
q
{
5
a3
3
o
i;
o
aq=Ar
-+A\b'JvA
rdiqE2r,f
^5-^5$i=-
zto-X J--5
=;O:1.--O
-
6
-
X
P X
+o ;
6+t,j.6PE.-
F;
3
;
+i
a
;
$TD=.iY-a
=
-
-'
v
I Lrl
-
I
:aDi::-5no
Eg;3-.*ei
aJ=Jr;He
=
il 5
P
iE
E
;
=.:-=<5Xo
=
- * i-M
^i
r
o;rr^rE4
-
J
aiJ c
l) 5 tr
LEi
i
Ll
=
I
t
+3.5
e
E-;F
3av^=_.=r
o=.e=;ilA
AU--(U)
+-'JJ2-.;tP
ZA3.r.(a;rl
I + = X n :; *--'.xq*26':'D'3.
:
O- ::'@
Y 5
o
-i.);'-))tD
;'0Ps=-
;19
#6-+
q
?
S-A-
i=-i=':':<=-Y
o
i i
=
3 d 9 at
3
Xf
T.'iiqa
-
= tr =i<
=
a+e
i:
) E.-= 5
^\
;'() n
=
ii X
=
=uE)
O
a
X
^=
i.r
ni
.,
6'
='d'?8 [Agfi
{=
'?
;
FFio,aS='
AradXr O:,.J-q
t<
r U,
A
-i
4=
p
3 . I
T=
=
^-
?."-'?
6-c-=
;.
9=
6' i.='i 9cd-5
6'
P
oi:69=.dg
&F B 3=8t=.e;3
P
- =.=gq
5
=
X 5
QI
a
;'+aa'7,
x=E
:
q)
i$ o Fo
=
'U-
ii
3
O
I
-
r
=
5' ii
E: T
xdEA-.ir5
;
'$qq++o:<Po
''r
7
=
:q;32'i. |
'c
si';
t
iA+i*,;3i
q
ai
F
if?tairE
g
D::qlf_.A-Eptsj-
3:1cl.:
rF
E
+}ts$rg3
i
eS t
i+s6-E=lQ
g
5g
n. i
Y--
-=.:r:3
r
o-
E\JV-.^\-,+^
=.
(t
_"^.
fiSa.
ja
+
i
.3
o
a
-
o
x:o='-(Do=
a'i.
LEioSE. 18
E
E:
;e]g,iE3
e.
;;
o---
; a
'
=.e
o
s
ulI
q
(D
E
o
c)
o
6
n
q
(D
o
rD
d=*.
o
-
(D
9J
(.D
I
I
9)
F)
o
n
o
o-
TJ
6
o
o
n
(
I
I
oa
it#t
o-
(D
(D
(D
q
(D
o
o
o
n
E
q
F)
0)
n
-
o
X
o
q
(.D
+
n
I
n
(.D
o
a-
A)
o
o
o
(D
.D
€
:.
n
U
n
o-
o
B
(a
5.
t}
o
-
a-
o
(D
t
(n
oc
.D
o
6
n
o-
.D
n
q
a
t0
q
rC4
tn
n
{
(D
X'
oa
o
cr
,
rD
(
5
o
(D
n
l0
o
0)
n
o
o
t
o
o
o
s)
.D
o
o
o
(D
X
6
(D
o
o{rir
K
c
rD
p
"
I'5
tnH-(U
VE
5 crlo
D
=
o
PUAA--*
',
7
gE
3
g
5eY;iiO
^-Y'J.aa
v
I
o
ri
FB
P
3;
i
$
zf.]i
a+
B
=qFJ-A
4A6*
5 O:rX
(D
Lf)aqd
Y x
rr
5€
fAFxts3
o*;
^.L#*j-
=oBnir.:Z
-.H66
J--O
Qh
-.8
F s
r
r::
E
a
=-cidFA
,( 5 : 7;"
=i.J-^-A
:+
6 +ii-d i
>o-&E
B
I
E
f
-E
B ?
il
-I..^
oaB6
E
e.
-*H
2
t
.-
r
+
v
fr
i\E6J
-LF
d'i
E.
X
.-A
>B'':ri6
x
o-Zi
I
tr
E li
6P(D
E aX
E'I
x.rt,
d
h'
vy,Hd6'sB
7
='F
7i F
{
A)
i
g)
F
cc
X
oa
o-
o
ts
{
o
o
I
o
@
n
c,e
t
-
,
4
o
n
q
n
o
n
o
n
{
rD
a
o
p
oc
o
a-
E
o
q
o-
r
E
E"
6
N
q
6
q
r)
rD
-
(n
-
(D
p)
o-
q
oq
n
J
6
o
o
o
o
n
tr{
3
.,
B
FJ
a-
o
)
a
a
d
J
d
q
N
Fi
o
(n
E
oq
(n
o
6
Y
o
o
-
o
o
-
H
3
-
nlr
(D
o
o
o
(D
X
h
o
o
.D
E
0)
o
o
o
o
n
o
(D
a.
oc
E
0)
fi
o
J
q
o
o
q
(.D
o
n
ts
o
q
o
n
t.D
o
o
X
ta
o
#
=q
t)
sU
.
.i
Aq
qo
5E
J
A:I
iO
)
--
orD
I'o
oa
h;
iq
5
9,
3=
oo
co
rDo
I
RX
OE
a=
oo
:*Si
a
@
o
0)
o
o
o
o
o
q
o
J
h
.D
n
n
o
(
o
PD
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 23/100
,
=
=
c-
D
1o
.r
+ ?
\
a
;- E
r
i.C +
=
av-
e
o
c
?J
i-
d
=
6
?
:
d
:ts
5
=
k--i.-itc
5:
il= f:
q
ii.;
S
5
o
:
l;'iigr iei lr
g:,
iE
i+ii;
isr*
q
e Il:
s;
ig:
I
$
E
Jo
e
e ao
a
q.*i
l1;
.n
r; 1;
lE
{E
i;
=
a
iP
e
i'"ia; Sf
if
ilF
i
E
E;,,
e .,.;
*ie i+i=t€E
CE;
i
i;;
:;
i
i
t
FH
i 1i;
i
i;
rE
dr
;
i
iE
$
f
si
r s
i
i$
;;i1x
a
?i;
i,:
i;:
rf;iiiilE:
E
i"r:
i
{
icB
=
ia3:
ii
=
{€
q
i
}+F;
+i
1
+r;
o-;
t
ai*a:
1:
_a
{;
3
e;:
;
iT
i }; I6
a
iil
iltliiif
iiir+{c51+:
I:
ii
i
iti
E
F
nf
iS
T€
rn€
el Ia:r
*?itr;
3
'yZ
3I
t
I
=
I
r{ i
iE
q
a
e I r;
i:
$i
#;
;
il;
n i
3
t
E
g
A
a
3I ?
+
E
[;
i
;
$
F:
1{ E
t
si
1; i
r
=
r;
r
a
=
"
iI
r
I
a
f
=
i
I
I f l
1ige
i€i
i
s
*:
il*=
r,
iri
8
si: il:
L=6;F=d
-<
o
o-oy=
i
9
=
o
=:
.?
=
g
l+'i
s;,
*ilriilti
$it;iiEE
rl;
iiEt
i
"o
i
p
3
+i*
=i
3
q;
a*
a;:Ei
B-3
x
d
;-:;i =;*i
5:
3;iii?s*;;Ei
?*"
Fq ?
ta;
ni:
; ilEaq
iiF ?;r rr
E:;-r
q
q
6
n
o
T
o
13
I
q
ts
PJ
o
E
-
n
(D
n
o
o
TJ
l0
o-
rc
o
ft
o
,
6
5
N
3
'$8
E
E
s-F1il
}+rEtFiilr*
56ii; il1g[t$A+il
E;iHli
a'9-fr'3fr[
i
g
si:
H
B
1$
i
i:
,r
i,
I;il;i[a
ii][;
i i ii
€
;
r
I
i
E1$sr iE
i
r$Fi;
EF
1aE
1E
rEii
iiF
niriigra
1f
;
*
;
*
=
r"s
i I
il
q
lr*Ei
1Ei
iiB
E
fg+fErfilEllFiils$$i
ilt
#
nE-L-a+n r+
iiraEs
i0=E-:=:5trEirriiti
a**
t
E
ig+iHEg
iiie+ie
i*
ii'piurir
ri*i'cii
i
i
EEEE
+1Ei
IEl$}llEiEi1iBiEE
$tilfii}+1
I
oE
iirei
iai.;
3
rI?;?i3E
;i
ili
I
i
Ig:gf*
i,
€
i.t'i3t t eE 5;: isafS
+1;"iF
"::
+x
3
[4"
E-a:
i
i ig.E-fl'=
?i+F,Fe
1$
B=FlinE
i
ifbiF
Ffitig$li:
a$;a
E
sls
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 24/100
iZ?: i:.s3i;lii:
iiii
iTEi?f
a'=4
Vl?i*tFi
'l
ilir
iigaiiti*s}lHig:
fi€
i5a:;r'.
rsi;i
i
i1iairie*,'i:
:1i
i
ilE r
s ?:?r.rs'ti1F*
1+i;
I
i
riitlrr[FBgq
?isuiani[:i:
[ilrtiiiiit
a;
$
i1;*ilai
rll?iaE+l;?l;illl€ll1E1?i*sE
i
liae$
lE I1i$i'
l}l1BIE 1l1BEltE 1?ilisEirl11
7
ii1
is
i
i
glliii
*t{i91l+ig;E
lIt
ileiEIi
fi?stH iiBi
u*;,q
6
a
rrsa:e
rcE
ir;
eT
i
E
=s
q q
-.il?
;ui'ri*irlillil'all=1i11iIB'
3 3
B
i"r
rAq;Ir
f
Ite=ltsiar:
q
i'* rE
ttE
g
g-
D
D
- '\-s
r+-=
?- ++p
,-=
3 H
il1iA;
i
1i
li
iri
H
iir
E
i
[$it$lEi[i
H
fr
igi
ia
I
ag
tfIa
rgtiIiE
$:ia;
{xqiifIE
ii
a
i3ilfiii
t+E+
Fie Fifr
i
iii+$s
sililr,s3
t
i:AtE[E
iriaiiiiiir
iiEisis=+iiililr
BfiiEtl
glEg1il1ilL
11[IiiE$EliEffi
atlEElE
f
aFgLtiii?ir a+a++Exttl$Bir$
a;[Eqi?
i
i5
B
Ari
or
5
:+.;r= 3 :
3[?
+,-'B
=
r*$l$i=1;d
=
=
+:
e:
$S
i
i
iriili=r?Ex
I
t+ieSiSs;A?fi
E
?z*.=.tr i
;
+a
iit.i?"i1
ii;
iliEi$ii
esli 7
Ei*3 iii
3
iii;i*r+ir."
i;ri*i:El;ia
aEi
ilitila
i
;:3ei;ariE
r?t+ggtii+i
41*;
iFit?:+r
?
+F**6_TF35i
O6-&=-rer\i-r'c',da*.a'=
*lr_
-i#-
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 25/100
rteiig
;ilgitgrIilii[EiEii,
i
$i*?-
r
[;{; nirTxrr
?=Fir;ai:fF€;1
+fi
iiiiil
i
5
-,;rq
3 Af 1
i
2
--
* c k ta. I
c-:
i
--..*-
-
=:
a-{
q
6
o
o
a
?i
p:.a-,IEi
ii
ir
SFti
iiEir:*i
es
s+:s'
s
'efiiririiiEgii
=\a1liir+[a
FE iEiF
i
-Pe=
=5D.rP=Yf
-qE-faIilEA:=qL
E9
e:=* E.
:reii€,:+1iiir;fr;ifrg{a1:E
La
i
os
1,
o3
s."=3:s=-=it::A:EoEF*-"
?
**
&i
1
-a:=':p;iie
".1
;r;=t3*iaall=i B =ig_ .
'- 6-1o
A
,,"--6aiii:iiTiiiEilFiIf i
E'ir:
E
x^ r<e
=H;-5]'q
F3i:$iir€ti?r:;ir;lrii*gi
B ;la:
3
,BaB;
"Ir1*g^i
+=S:$;grli"riH
=
1A:r
ilF3
iil=::
u
- r"^.6
ao-
"'
6
5
-;'A
d
FB
:
o_$
=
*
iji ;ZIi3ri3l;5i=-n:F+,#o-'-
=
;i=-
6:d^scBf;E:iii;rBErf;'€q;*[
s.
5a-=
:EaelE3riiilEiiqisife*grF
+ a[if
5rA=[;==e-*i;-62
-oocrdi;6_;e
I f
;i.g
I;ii[=:::;\o]1t:ri.=*iil;i
a
=E,
e,
:L*?il;iiii=:r+iiasr*sg53F
iF sq'r
***cL-i*itiii:gF[*r3H;i;i
]
s;ni
2:
trit3
+ti 0.a,.5?iq1.itn5Har"? 3e Xo:i+ 5 G;-z-
i;ti ;$f
;f
[i11;xia Ieaai.r
r
iE:;
?Frf+f+E
iagqfflF=i
E=?.?lE
=
==i3-L
-t
6
o
o-
o
13
I
o
o
a
)
SIH
(J'l5
E i +E 1=$r-EE
EtgEi[gii[[3ilei+$i;i:li
o I
q.=
N
iriiHiisir?E:5
i
f
li
Igi
ll
[ 1i
1i+
I
i11i
i}
iliEi
I
Ii
iItirrt
iE
=i
I
ri
+ii;
it i$[EiEiig}i
tE$[F
ii[iea
5
s
=:g
H;'
rr :ai*il'
:ligii:
lt€
il$}
Aal
rrrti;nir:
r
iti€
:
d2
*=
I
;
r rir-i
*i;lti+3t;33ii,*,*=s[s:;
q
pfin8
s
d
?
r;
=€
[a&I
i
E;
;iE
rrtg
3
1s
i
E
1iF;?2
H
*3
6
s I
c
2
; i i
g
f
=
1r I i g:
€
S
5
E E
['s
S
a
i
?
?:
d
3
*
+
s
tf
ii*
i:
: i
=
iq=
igii
iiiii€$iiiEgiiliu*
rA
f
rq
:giE
r+i
{igiiiiaiip;
E
g'
,
E
-.1ssg;
i{
*Fi";:?:
=
}ssiiiEaIiil3
iEr
iirrtE
l
i
3
5Tg*i:pE;i;ai*liF-+gi+:a
ia
esIa:;
:
[
ilFIE
+:
l*;
i19r]irai
6
*s
i
+-1
;
=
e ai
i
=e
?-
epu ;#&
$.f;gIIIi.*:;:3EH:-
ra-xr-
q6
+ +
r n
q?
?;;
3?
{?
i**+ei
E T",ii
a l-l
*=?i
?
[
'#F'
.,'..*flIll|Ilr*.
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 26/100
g3;'8=d<?rE€g:i=
E1r#E=T *3;r==
Rn++,,r -
t
iili
riflisii:
[;
;
iF
rra iri;i 3€ iiliaiE
i
i
?a{: ;
r=fili;
i
+ilifllf
igi
xlE
rii
il;
lg
i
;
s r: 2:
=
<
- o
r
tr
a3
j;
a5
ilH
sar 3 F,
f;
ria
igg
aai
i# i*
I
*
;'H
r€
E
l:.=
rq
'
i
[gi
r;
s
*
i;
5
3iiii
fl5+ei3
]lg]rlE
i
Ei+3i*IiA1i?:::z.B*
;
=
r
=
rE
-:.'-
c---
i
s
5p
il
-
:.
+'.<
E
a
=
+
a;
0,
j
r
=
i
i
;.
=
g
;
t;
i
1.
i
+
i
i;
.s
g:
g;
1[
1":-i
+
i
?
1 i
*Z3;
H
E
-73_e
iisgq
5
+
inTa
g
3
r
e7i{2."
rP
P
=
t-6'
o
€
=
e.
*T
6
fi
5
p
15'rE'e
c
p
=
qr.;
=G.+a:
F--''5
aE.
i
i
3',i;'
i
rf.
i
i
iE
i i
g
=l
[
?:
i
'"i
=
2
q;
s
I ? E
i
a'i c
i
:
s
*
i
€
F
*
;sis i;
iii
+g
si
ir:
a
3
[;$Irii;
5$liis$t
}t
3
ii:;
A
7E
E-i
i
i;
?
+x
z
a;
B
arH-i,
;i
s,.r.
nEE*$i-d_
ag:
i:E
ii[3:
Iip;
+;titE
i
E
=+q;:
"-q
*E
d
x
i
-
i;z e
qr;
,
=
lFi
-=
F
*?s
iFi 7;{51+B
ili
}A
-
y
.,5
=
v,
r *
n;
i
i
[
$
A
=-2
i
=
#g
H
?
F
q
?.
;
f
3
i
F
[
il
E
]
A
€
6
o
d o I
='?
itiri?iliieiiif
f ii
iliru
i;e;
F;s
r:3g
r
a
=.2
6' s r i. x
a
-
c
H
=
-
;
5
g
g
=
: i
F
e
g
H
: +
?
E
;
E iV
;
i
t
i
a
i
=-f
+;
i t: *ai;e.?a
?
=
z
>.,,;
s.{
.-
23.:
i
+B
q+=
F =5
a)
€
+FB
#dsa
+;i
F6iAIt
iiliii
1tat
iiiiiif
iE
I
5
5
3:
41+tErg
rFii€iE'*[[I
ilr;l
ri+
+ird
i
nic
+
$i
i
'
*
s
i
i
i H
i
r
lii
t
;
E
r
i
il
iI
t
i; +i
ia
+
1t
r
# I;"3s
3
=
;cE
er
iii;
=€rrEa
i
gi[*sir
rrils=
rrrEFi
E E€ir
n
rE;
:
a
rra;Bdti+i=
i1{srrsriar i[iEi$
F;
a
E
a
i
I
nfirilig+t
ifEI
i:
i
E
=,
r
iirs
F=e
:
;
E E
3 [L;€
gtrEE
i+:
+rtir+i€
*+ier_E
_
ii*r
iliilii+i:F
ifiEiFg,at5EiSf;
ii
$
uP'
t:=r:'1[i]
giiilE;
*1Ei
+rg$g
f
I
6
r
5g
p y"c o-
=
I * F Z
=
:
qo6o-$.e+:3N;
9 13?
Ef
$S;Fg
i'zF
g
;rn
R
-6
5 3
r-
a
a
+
3
E
la++ F;xiii$i+
+i11;i;;eliXgilq
i
+
ai:-
iil
3Ei I€:*
g:IiIalil;[a1s8;
a"
i
tr
r
+
;=qH
B+E93.EiliE
h3it37*23ir+t[1+
i
i
f
si'31
=? '€
P7=i'q^.;
*esi*
;F1+1;girI
rE, ifi
*E?ii1:l{i
E
i
Fe;
E
Al[t"j
*+rE
t
i*ii;F*?
+5rf[?r{",+*i=*++
+
g
rlF
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 27/100
SlFl
Nlf
l6
o
o
)
o
o
tn
rc
t
o
0)
+ a
q
B
? F S e 3 <E-.?
-l
rD 5==ri=5crD;^=
o=?.2E-P?-.oa$aiu'"
E
?;
=
F
a
i
I
1i
g
3
t
d-:-Dr-.?
I=c-iiai=,iiqgS:
ig
s
r
r
I
q
I
]:
i{
6-ie,-FIi=:t:,
3
i
a
+
==
i
1E
€;:
i
1
A
6
--
I
er
E_;
6
L
=.p
* i
<
q
=.7 '' o o L q, i.=
-^
=.
'o5-.qa=a'tsal;o.<
#-f
B;
E
I
d's
i:
6
ri
n
iltq*i+iIE-iA2;
p=:sirH;-[3fgs^:
i:
=
?:5
[;li
F
IE
ifriql'
ogai
Et
B-[r*5* a:
a
=e
ira6-i^i
+5iair siE
ta
irAr.+l iii ;E
?39eiT
lFs
Bf
a"Ft;=
s;..H
6:
3
-.6
-- '= d €
*
2.a^c-=Z'=-;0
f
- iI.5
=.9"
=3
=
R < O-
<
6
p)
-.
--6ai(DrDsF=:
dFTTT
?15
i?
i
*
?
$
3 i
f
;
H
il*
$E
l
s i D
s
agr$1r3ig;?.=1:*
2i
i-
{
-i[*$r+::irriiiiii+
+
iiliii.
iiiii3;rin1i
I
lBir++ii;iiiiiill
i=L
iiliti=1il=;_*i:ei;
f
I;
'
$iE
*e
*
1;;
i:,
:
i i+
H
E a
*{
r
r
ji3
$; ii
;;$ii'
i:+;isIEil;1
?;
i
i
i*
s
;
it;
1i
5
;;
;E
s
i
f E
5:a.=?ra.;lillu:rei
3
i
?
; =
r
q
+
i
s
n
i
a
I
;F
;
f
.==
3
e
E 3
=
i
e
i
I
u
=
=
i
E
E
;
? i
+ e.
F; 3
+
+
I
E-
i
*
r{
r
i
+
-l
o
n
o
rn
o
F)
o-
o
o
0)
)
rl3
r
+l[[
tEs
F
i
I
il;
f
1iI
ig
iq*
ni
r
=;
E
T
il
3E
u
t
i
r
s
i
i
l i
Ti
i
i
'
i
r
q a
r
e
i;
a
a
i
i
t
f
f
A
a
i
;
3
1
;
?
-
i$FiIil
aarE. It{Eirltl*i=
ir**$iif
iiiig
r
*
il
,
r n i
i*iB
E?il{ig
+iii
i1[[}iri
i$i
i Fi
rI
il
F-
a
6
:;
c.6
>+"
E
i
i[r+
*r
iF$i
iE t*?Ai r
i++
i i r
r
I;
l:
;
iE ;
I
ic
t;g
[r
i
[$
+a
r f
i
$i ii
rg
r 1:
1i
+*i
ii
a
i
$$
r
ilrE+
ilc
lgE,
ilgaE
+a
iiE
rlge$a;
i+ali+e
i
:;
liiiiB:
i
Ia
iig;+ritAi
irii
iigEsra{
grf
IIitl+isEiii$B
ifi
rgaEiii
+EiEE}El
ii
g
iE
i. rl
r
itEE
r
i
i
I
iie
fii
*i
rrs€-i:
:e
i
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 28/100
r
;
s€iF3T
3z=-=2=7?:133
i
ax:
sF=
ii
llA
f;;
i;g+irr
rg3-=:3?:
:
:;=E ii
s
=-
0) s)
; _
=
|
f
*o ;
^
*e':
-
-
=
: E
;
Q
^E'.<
x
_.q
=.=;q)
=.u
o
rc
x:
=
7rc
--
$
e-h-8'-)
R aa
^:
z
/
n
o
i&s-:=;e
3
iiE
=
LI
=
E
==
*;1;i[gr;i
fij
s
ir: ix;+i
i=g
i
;,*|tg
I
E
irr[[sI
ra
*;F;iiiLii[
irgE
?
Ht
ll
i4E
1i
i
,<=:rs;iil
?r r{ 16?iloi'u=
3-3..D0i
o24;j*;6t?
z
iFi
ls
r+:
E
ii;
FIE
?i
a:,;3
t5q
IiI=t
i
+F
f:
r
i
--5 =o X:.
r3r
E
1iq
it{F-:}i: ?i;_i\i
sEI :
i
i
ai*
r+li
1
+=
i
3T= r-S€
?ri
c
;sfI
igen
i
li+;,[;i+fli$i
i
;r'bo6'5
i;
rIi
i
;
r
riF "+itiE
tI
r+
;
=E
i:
il[€
"-qr
f?s
$
i
-o
5-D
aj
C
iFitiE;liElEli
liif
lE i
*riihli+ii+ii
l
T;*=
i
?
??
A;
Fs.='3
13
t
a'd;H
$? +=3i._"
j{
5
g
1e
r
;
=
at5
=
c=3
fi
a;i
i,*il'ra
; Ft
n
i1
E;
=E
€"€ ia
a
ils
ir"r
FB;
-1i
?92i,
g;
f
i
; f,r I
Li-:
?1
lEj
1il;+}i
-
-"
-
-.:
=
ri;1lBt
t[+A*::
$i
Ai+a;
I r3*Xi
]liii31
E
; =; i:;;
g
;
=
i i is
a
:
?
i ?fr
a
1E
E
i
d 6
i
il
e
I
E
5
;
e
ir
i
rEg
a{q.
rr
I; iic
I
A
='3
E
*
=*?F;;;*Q
3
I E
s
=
i; 5+;
q.i
liEi
+sE
=
3
q
s1:5.iq;d
ias;i
n;
F
i?
n iF
Ii.;er
il+
ilFti rfl
8-6f;
q
E
3
5
i+n 1q
E
e
:
{
a
r
r
a
t a
i*
s
i$E
?
f
; f
i
f
ii
ii
I
+EE3
i
ia
is
z
#3
iiE,
EE
i
E?ia
si
*f
i
ii
i
=?i?Airr
rH
F
;
i
iiE
+il
f
B ri3
-
3;'
c
+ FiFt'3:
ts
:
: ii.1
iI€
if{x
i["f=
3
+{;ri's
B
r
+ri-i5
iii=
[ 6
s;,i
*
[
i;
L
e
5l
+; A:
I
n
iF:
s
i i
E I
H r'
='o
r r
-
"
-:.
i
I
3
[
*
$ i
i
n 3 3
=
i:
ii
o'
E-E'
i<1
E
rfl*; iiF;9"
t
v.
tsE
a'+9
?V;i
-r
riiH
rii
;s3e*a
}iiH
raFfiiq;:i
i
s
i r
i
i
i
u
E E
r
i
e
i
g
i:,
=
:3
[
irli:
gE
i
R
i 3
3
+
3
€
B
E-
3
B
-3
E
',
-;V,
i;
s
i
n
i i *:
;
i
yi..i,i
e6
-EIiin;F;AiBE:g:F-f
f +i
1
"a;_iiFs
i;
15
i
3
e;
iEF
t
ii?
iB
+
i
?-i ?
9
0'-;-9.-
3
Y
d
F
o
q
+E 16-"-
3
Tioo
o-7
i
F1i+Hai,;BFaii
IBiFFi?EiiIiE
i
Eil€A[;ie;:3i:
-,rft&B8rseqLs;
1
=
F -gu=
+
+
a ?
+
+a*
ftiialiftas-+
I
t.
*lf
n
X
oa
r
D
o
-
3
n
pr
n
o
E
o
-
(D
n
a-
.D
q
n
A)
6
o
(D
)
o
?
(D
o
t.D
FO
o
U
oa
o
A)
o
o
o
o
o
o
oa
I
o
(
o
o
q
-q
o
.)
-
(D
9)
_..o
0
?{
{
a-
o
q
I
o
(.D
q
o
oa
o
)
o
o
(t
n
a-
(,D
s
6
.
o
.D
rq,
q
n
(D
(.D
n
n
oe
o
o
TJ
o
FJ
D
o-
tso
.D
t
o
-
o
o
o
3
o
cJ
q
(.)
r{
o
E r 3e
X
-:E
3
c;5X6
-2b5?'
0)r q(n
oc
n.-"
I.rd
P
aDE-olD
JL'
aD
(.D r)
Bj]2E'
e
tg I
=t1.i
o.PB=-
+-'2fC.
e
?
3.#
E.6
q-
-FV
=^.fr
AtrO
?,
r
il€
:i8E
-$
r);6
^|lql
E d ro
E 6'=
ai6
^''<
tr
-.
-
ro
<o 3 x
a-A?=
;-vM
f
o
A]i'
E9V
--6=',C
;
LJ'
q
-
*fi.-E*d.
H
ra{&
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 29/100
,
la
o
@
A)
I?:6< ::
gr{a€":gt+
agiEn
;'-c7p
+?eB:<A
I E<T-r
s+>inz
,,':;Rc
6
r 6 +s
":'=:Etl
*3
:
q
r
rE
<-Ea
E
?ggE;
1+=
8
ii
:
{
l
#arl
+i
B'rE
E+;i
ii*$:::":€
H
n
l
r
iiifE{$3
3ii?i
f
irf
f
IAgf
]EiiAf
=r
E:
i;i.rqx={
i*
sdlEa
?$r;ii:
iigrif
1€rg
i+FiaErBAiIa
a"
?;
d
iqlli
lE
=ir=
=";
iiEislini
gFifr
r}a
;
3iE f
=+TXicro:==a-
ts'F=F
Br=34.":=
s
+;E
;'
71i
iii
;
f'riIEii
i
I
E
i:?eil
;Fti
i
59d& :
=
r<rs
ir
ig.3T
;fi
il
I=
e
1i
n
s
q
qr
**Ifi.*i:i
I
'ari
i
*iii:Fii3
iiiFiiil
fi?fitii
fiii
i *-='H
-i
3eFilA
i+=isIii
rg;
rs.
nirfil
e
f;
rgi
fiili
s:r
i5FitEti
+:iii
iIliIf
P*$iEl:rl'rr
iEB
;t:F,,F*=
opzs
rr.sp_e<
_rrE:rBr=ii
TTI
e-E{nz-=;
--5€rE
:i*=.i;;.
1^sa.or;.F'r
=P=
ei=A-=*iL
€
s'=38
EE;
*ifE5-ui3
;6€
}'
;
:
;
;
t5;
i$i:=
fs+E
i
;i=[
;t;?iL;'=l.i[* "=* r:
ri-;i
:; i*
EI;E5
E^s*4,-?ri?iglfiIi ri
1.qvii2te
i crE
=r;?I;{ii;*irq1;jI
EB
+:ii+"f;A
':=-
a
?
A"fl-E
q
*i-l
fi
g
*+
F
e.$s-+il*+r
i
i
-.t
oa
t
--t
Fo
3_
-
y.5^'.i'o-
rl-LqvX=O
3615'+rrtr
i
-;
3
*
d 3
ts
a-G,'o?aq3o-
ai x -;: .c--.
719
<A
";:
:=e16-=d
3
t
P
9-
=
-,4**
os^'oa^iE
-_r
-
+
-{
0)
a
E
S
rE;9
n,
--hX'ts-r"
B'e<e*2iq
a
t
rt
g
11t
1JotI9o3O
B€B-3tii;6-
J
;q+S@TJ
i-= n x N
*3
+
o
e-aJ
sii*lE
e H a
?
3:i i =i.'=c
a
..8 qg
t_r+A
*1
di$Of
4F
sFsESAP
:
=g)+-:a'i=
g
i
3l'i
*.ie :
;
E
a
S
h3
e-
i
a-
5
s
B
3 €
i@A)i'iY;'
-
l4s-\<Oa
r';g=N"--+
i O i
o
ol i'
=
()
s?-TlD-'l'
€
s
tlF
;.d
"i
aq i I i
=
Xri^iaFdr'O
-'=.O
a
i'
),
-.<
f
I.=''i'93tsg,h'
Ud
++ii."8-ts;
8+E63iqgF
i:
E
3
q
*sg
H
a
€
-:aE
; S
a
A
E
H;HE LTE;
A<ti';',-5o-
g
3:
;
i
E
e
r
i
-F(,J.-A-
ad
q
E
E
*
T-
il
E
em
e
€,8
i
:
ri
:
;
3E.8
n
a
a=..3
hxx.r):Dqaa)
SiHgseEES
?
2
i
=
E a
a+;.
i&&O
a:e
-?.
;'tr(1tDto
rd<t2oEIE.P
;
e
6
=
iE
c-
=)o JqH=-.-.
a=.O-@DY'tq
i--l=
o-€
='
-x=a'.=.*6
.L,
q
vJ-ot.+
w
='A
;
6'{ 5
5
: H ?
3
F
-
+=-
'JT
2
'
=
A
U
=o
o
'^.{ti:()Ea
a-a-fuE31?$
l<
T'<
'i
r
I
g+Y
q
E
ss
E
E
3 a'E-i
r
+
i; 8
f
tB=siAi+ga;
BB
iB
EEjiEr$a="gi
i$
ts
iEaIlf [Fiai
:
d
a-qEEle-8;*:5q
iB.
;
?lI
*
--H'i,:g?
a,a
=
e';FDfirf;'3
*3
i 33;a:Eiisa
cl.
6 2
i{d?d-5.di.
Hi
E
;Ei[N;aH5;
is =-
3:st?39rii
;'
d6 3
ttEiAaEixA
E-i F
s=;Eg;6nir-+
<-
p
3-*:71
E
"iE_g
81 ts
':3*44';
e3E
?i
E
9i+Hfi:=;
o
x
;
=.a-
=l
i.=:.
iE
ii;P;v:;g
+*
+3.f?"41
=-4;
o
.*:cq*
Arll+
o
a
'o
t
o
l
3
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 30/100
+1€
-r1iBE
i5il;
a
q
ifr
:
fsEg
gE
lgI-F
E 3gi
i
ilf
I
ri
3;
t-=t
=rr
rt
i
:
i:
s
ei
r;FFi=
ii
iiF€€:Ei
i
i
I;
F
g
;
1"8
F' 5
i
q
:
q:
3
E
i i i
i
s
6
$ 6 :
q
€
;:
3 [i
E
f
:'*
E
iliil;
iil+FrB
+iirri:
FlErf
*EEEf
iB}#f I
i i
ii
+E:irirlgiirfii
i++ililgr
51i;i;
+
"IsojT1
i;; i?
i
u13t3
i3g3EEii+;igll3iFe
*i
rE
ii
1
oEril3:
5i[E
F
ii
;
i;1i]
u='ii+$+g+r3
+=
Frq=1
is
I
*=?i
i
i?ii arrli;,iii:iirie:
le:ig'
+qi
f=aEI:
i
ii: < 5
3iF
I 3*a,+giifiqiFieE.[[E
illftr
3
idso- 56
;?ir
ifr1'ei,EEFl
iii: I
=g;
1i
q
t;r
+€.r: rE
*,
.
v:
*E
8
a
.
B
r:c
=
H:,8
+i
fi
ri f=ii liiii rBfS
i
agg
n
=
T+*;
3;
j
E
3 il:
G
ii't
11rrg*iEisii;
c;
*i$fiE
*ii
if
rtf
;
i+V iniirE rr;
fliirEgAi+;+i7,
: ;
6
-
e+ri
+Fir*i+iriifi[grigEiflirr
ilEiiE
gii
i;a
i
igi
E
il;
I+
Flt
;
ti
il
i
r
+
i
;
f
,
:
s;
E
E
;
a
;
35
: 3
3'5
F
r
E
i I
i"*=
a;
3
iri if
{
*
E
ia;
f
E
I
: e
+
*
i
tx
13;:
iif
l3:
ti
1il;
1
?-.=
=
*
F
B-
i I
i:
i
B
3
;
s
t
5 a
I
3;
$'1:.=
e
3
6'3
=.i
d i
s
a
f
.:"
S
3
E
i3
*5
E
il"'18l+; rE
J
+
FirrEiiii*iirigrg
$
I
f s
i
i
ri:3r
=sBx::
i
?
i E;"3
1€E
e$;i.i+r1;
:
AE€?;=o=;az11A5[;
;
:€
r1$T?3?
^-*ir.i
1t:
i
Iiiriij
+t[E ii Eiir
I
+;
a
'
iB
3 [ +
il
il
+
1l
t
*
] $
f*f€il4'*?2iasii=ll
t
3
'=*+E
i;
rtFE
iF
f
tg;
F
c
s.6
p
".#
,j
B
?'+
A
F
B-
T
=
LF
I
rls
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 31/100
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 32/100
o
o
o
rT
A
o
o
a
o
o
I
I
ic
o
o-
o-
ic
n
J
oa
o
a
(D
rD
)
o
c,ra
n
io
o
o
n
.D
o
X
o
F;r,
I
I
p
.D
o
3
o
o
n
o
E
o
o
n
ts
o
o
o
3
o
-
I
oq
d
q
6
o
o
E
o
5[:ii:gt;1ai
1i=Ei;ilii
ii:E
;
i=
;i;Ei[i*iaigF
s
ig;iliii
ii+ire
I
lEi
iig1ii;Fi[
+
irE$3:s
ir,+r
i
iiai
illllg$gigiii
g
ii
illilililligll
ii
iiaiililiii
i
ii
li+iri
iiigil
*gilgeElgE+Fi
E'r[;li+iitiii;ii
rir$Fr$iiiiiigAi'i:iriilifiig
;
E
rE
"
ia
I
t
E
s
ilg
i
iar
i
i
i
*
?
i rE i
ilr
ii3
+iifg
-L(.-'=€
=
gr:,
:si;lf
l
iie$rEIiei[;iilii**E
rsg+iI
+IE i
11[*iiii[l+*itl$E
E
aiili
i
i
1E
ie
i
iAI
g
ii
iiqi$iqi;
riiiiiiIlEiB[rB
E 1iiE
irriirt+i;ligi+iiiir+:
rli[lf
"
*Fe
g
f,
i;
ii
r
rg
iI
I
tii;iEi[+gE€
iiFl+ii
Et
iE
}
ili=tF
ilfgiuiiiitsriEl?ElEliii
15lEt
i
:E-'is
5
;etiI
+i;iii;i1e*ii
i+irirs;rii
rriia
i
i Ii;
E"
EirfE
rliiFgiiElr:e[i
r$]iFl
I;
;titr
i
?&qi fr3
B5.J'T??5'6.i?PY=
5ii=','r'P-d
"":=
*l#
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 33/100
-
o
{
o
o
TI
)
o
o
;
ii€t lt=ilai*e
ii;
te
r:;
i=:.iF€
i
fI
l
iE
f;
q
n
ffi *rt
l :
i1; rirn
i;
i:
i}$ii}iii[i${
f
il
s
3
ti.F'2.;'- o
€;2;
a€
a
s
i
i
a;;
r
i
i E
I
:
*
F
F
;
;
r
a
6-
e
H
*
ii
i
€:
B
il
i
E
il
ii
i€
g
3
o.
l
Ai
=
i
^
=
'-
o
=
O
0
E ,^ t a n
=.
^
i:
*+i?i
1+;
gl
i+;
aA
f
i
iE
i+i
a
3 tri
q;
izei3
'T;-Er6E
'p
+r
3
"+iegli:
t+;
11
;i[alsF[ii
liBE
u
E
E
A
I
g
H
i
-o
s
a
-;g
Z?L-L[A
i; *r: i=
; i€
i: i
s
i;=
a B*9",8
c'L
:
3
+
E
; 6'$
i1
5
++
=
3
i :
f
:
q:
=
A
;
=
;
l
L
e
:
=
i
x
i
'
*
F
E
I
q
A
T d
i
;
F; 3
a
F
*
B E
i
s
E
8-;
=
3
a
I I
f
1i
3
E
r e ;
iir irlixiFiE
ii;;EE
i:;€*
Zt
irraEr
ia
i
B5lII
iir;
rE i
Fii i:l
?ia
strE
re
s
i E
r;g
=8.'d
}LA1 :
E 3F
TE nt
i*
i+.ae
r;
i
;;8
Ie Hq
l-=:
a+o;
?1
irigg
gEgifiE
tt;fi
rE*i itt
$it'
si1ililF€
i*i}3
I
tiE?; i
ris;Ei
x?;liiiia
X
-
I 9g,
t;,
=.il8
;'5p:
;
i; az 1+*,ori
.
E
;{ii
==
;
E_rrE
+
X
?ii
{
ri?iE
e,_i$E
iE
gr
2*tig;Es
-?,3
?=e=:4+3 rigsz: i g:B]S;?iE.;Ee3iA=
iafxllii
13
l;
Ear;a;
FEilrFE:
e
3[-eist;;
i
rEcFf
rii
r
i
i
Fe
iiEl
i
B
rI
r+iiE*Eii
E
?[ii
;
:1+;
=
ireE
iiEeiBE$*'E[?11iEFE1i?lI1
r; i:
f
H
i i i
+
i
+;
=
in
i
+
ifi
r
=
i
a
n
r
i
r: i
:
*
rE E
E
i
t[f
;
i ii*
E
$E
?i
ir
r
i
i
ii t i
it
iiE
i
i i?iIl{E
i*ilglEl}fi
+Tf;[=-4486633
'
a I
=i
ilri
i
*
?
**lt*i
Ei
ii*ii[t;
=?iE
;
8=+
liiiEi$}+fll$l*
iriarFiliiiti+ieEiarl
7
i
EbFs*ii[EEt ilF
frr1:
i-?g i[*ee
rtli
ilE
I:Fi ii*:
;?
ia r ir;
ll
rFi
isEtiitffil:?[a
i
;i::s1**Ei,
ltitillg;taa
?:ariliSg[E
rt+
?
q3'uy;ER
"Ltilg
g
;
*
6
;
2
+
ilii
re.€
#
s
q
+ ilq
ri
8
?
&+6
7
r'?
r
'"'
*,f
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 34/100
$ir:ai
F
+t=.sE
aiEr
y
i;
gsrli
+;i
i+ig=a
$;
?
fi r.-S
il
d.
j.X
p-_
o_e
n_
E"5 ?€
Zs;ii
I * _ ?
6
*,
_
Taoc
A
E C-
A
;
$:
*F
3
Fir:€iE
a;
i?
}t$l
igl1ifi3riA+;
*
i
S [::
Sq ii6
$3
=z=tii
*x7;lii
ai
c
5'B-p': si
.j
3$$*$ift$3'*t++1g;
ia-i=="EBEeii*;
i:
;
i
riiirilEiria;[iiii
;liii$illigliiiii
i
$ii:$i
iat
?€
I
il, ir
E
ir
:
rliaE
=
Exni
B
d
i'S s
'i
6
x*tiiill;
i1:;,
t
fr
rIiI
citi:;
itai:
+
^
o
-
dii
q
r
=s
*sd.3Eii=
1i
?ir
nfis
+i;:'ir+Xi
iE
i
Erii:
+ri:
I
+1
+iiil
=i;
E ii
c
"*EiE
i€ {i
i
i$l$siiir?i5iirir iili il
isif
lEE
iei
i+iiiEl?lilliliil
llt
I
iirlt1ig[1Es
.)
p
E
n
x5
l
-.
w
AP
Ii
a
P62-
--1I-=
va
t-
trm
3.
:a
i3
t
..
$n(,
aA
N-
-L
4
*rH
lo
_
.13.
qa
n
0)
CD
(
Ff?rEi;'e
3
3
ie1$iE'
i
lri
i*t
11iltIll
llllEiitElaiEtI{[liili
se-
+ii
i1I*
irieE
[
;Bl1Elgi
I
ltg*
lE
i?gEEiFi
rtia
i,
+aE
e
i
ia
+itglltlg
lliilF?el}AiEl
ii1E
i:
lu1lil*l'i
+*
i+airE'
i:i,rbr
4i E
a;i,?;?gir
iii
ib+r:f
€
r+rir:r
{
tTilra
a?asisH
i
t+iiei$ri
LLiiEii
igii:
t+
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 35/100
r
q
a
a
=
'
i
+;-+i
=;i?9sEEa+i=[i2;
it
q
ieEf::
i
0)
z
=.
=.=.
-triorrocra
;r;gtiEiiiitiiiii:Ilii
+iiiilE i+?iliE i
i
Ire;aE
iir+iE#iririiiiigf
iE+t
r[fi
111;
u
d
d
d
E
rE
? 3 e-'7
3
ago
il
;
go
ao
i+-;:6
"l-v= a?:i
i:ssrH":iifiiE{ii.
:iilf
[i
il
B-"3
f
r +
s-
-
i
=
+€
-
i
i
n
q
;:
i
g
e;:
=
+
t
€
*E
il;t
i
?i
i
{ief i;"r;9;gE
t a;
+eI+1ri
i
?
r
il
+*
i i;s
1ais
3
[i
i
i}
]tiE
i; a
i
]
a
$ i
ii:
;
h3
5 Y
^
=
.a?
=
i
raL=
s
ilt
=i
L?_i;
;'11*
IiEfi'=A
jia
=l
tc rf
r
iigEtiril$IgE
liiE
ir[{il
+Eli*
Ei
Bi; E
i
;
i?i5;r
igr;
izs
I;t
n
l
a$E
+iig*l;E
lei€3 iii;i5p?r:
:.++rir;"I
=€i+:;n:2?7
o
+Lits
s:?riii
1i]i?li*q:
+
rElilf
?7:iia
3
-=gfi
i
l
t
+
I
=?
i
i=?t-r-i
i
fi
a
s
:
B
i
ir
i
q;
1e
fr
$
i
;
;E€{
l6";{}aBg
;c.=e
i-5pi
t--='3-{5.3
lgEs€
=-7
?il:a;E?.3.i
?
s
;'?
Y
t
*i
=
?
=
a?T-fr
i3;
L
z?
?
5'x{
lg
ii
1
lEE1IiE?1
{t?II
lEiE111t1
a
11tii
li
s
iad
Teii;+ai?i;;3i
rgiE.Eiair*rrs
i
rEs
*ril'lF;
+i
rE;+[5ia
rli?
ir;$3
irs]E+iiti'liriiii
iE?tE1€3$a
ri?1f
i$gAt
$1i+i,'-
+H
iri*f
a+iIi+*]eEliEil
LgLli
$iit:
iE
ililiiiE
rF
'iir'1f111[ii*a
sHiIrl}:tillftllligll
i
g*'=A
i
is*'i
11rEAr$tle
tE?E
ii$iE;El?[1it?i1
i
+s;s
I
fe?E??ii+iaE;
aa
a
-stiE
i*Aiiirii
i?r,;
?
-#tiitEft3iltH.fiil
i;8,+g?
$;qB.r++=F
r
*,#
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 36/100
e
1ir
rilgii
fgt
iH
i,
'aE
nslts{lEii$ts
i
IE
I
*
;e
1E
i+T
ii€1+$r[$ig
iflriitliiFIriiFagI
t
o
r
+
F
o
:
r ? ;
=
i:
[
=
a
il
B
>
*o
oq
;"
+l
f
p
i
f
1*
]F
;?
g
f
--'=a>=hi
3
E
3-I
i
+ie[
ai.<Qi
gl
5
3
"
a
F
;1ilt: i
$lttieriis:
itf[sqi;
+iiii
irrrl
r
19
=
€.
I
is
;
a
i
r
i
r+E
i:;:
I
i
%;
i{
I
E
i;'
?E=
r
i
;;
s
: I
i
i
3lE ig
sb;
iE
i i
* H
i
i i;"r:
re
i
?
? a
i
r:
s
8
:
I*I
=
-E;T
rry
i
;
+ii ;#s 1?1=
ii[5;
liFEi?i
;t;ii
i
i
l1ii
i:
i*ria
+aiia:
l
ifiiil1i
lf
B
tE;
r
ierie
i
iiglEr
I
tig
1g
i6
ilfqete*=
iir*i;
';
a
-U
ni
rx
+re
rE
il11+i
iliixiiS
iil
3
i;rii
rrgr==s
(
io E
o
+oil+e :E
3
E
e
a
F.
+e
+orrqx 3
e**tSi=
=
iai[+i
o-(D-F
q
5+:E
e
rE
;FH
?;
:
5
E-=
6
D',
3;F3i:;*
?
q;
3c"*=
t
i i
a
3.
E
r
+
i
a
r
*
a
i
t
I
iE
E,g
i
;
s
a
r
i
-
:
t
i
*
=
i
il:
q5E-:'5
;;E:6
:+s{
dqre +i
E
iBr;
A; Ft*i*i+i3f f
gf
6 5'6
rd
H
; i{'+'a
?
T
r5
$
3
r
te.* d
T
&a
E-Q
rtlEi+aillIigIEElqiIEEaiEIEaa
i
E$1
qEiiii?liifFisliEf$1+iiB[$gEE
F
isl
EE*i
liBiiBigi?lil[iEEIlgFiEIi
i
lEi
E
F;
ili
a *q
s.i
StrVi
i
rE
s;
3EE
isiss Fa
ri;
tii
i}sE
irri
I
iii,BlEl:EiEll
1[l$i
ar a
i:
F
iIf E E
1+a i
l H
*
iaii*r;ta+iu€++iE
i?iiiB?rrIss
c
lit I
i**tri
$ra1i:lt
+iF€
#ilrfirtaE
i
F;*
r
"3?eilai-
+ilsiii+3iliFgrlEHfiEsF=
*lI
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 37/100
r
*rriitiilE
sifa:iiseaE
fgi;icl+i3ri
ti
i
iiii
isa
isrrFa;5f,iE:il3gfflifigii
iir
i
?
3EH'
*i
frl i
1+glf;iirari
iiirEi.=iir
r
g r
f
"E
*
E
+F
a
a
ia
i
ii
=$
+g
if
i
r
$i
ri
iFi
$B
a
i:
;
*
i
i
r
+
;d
giiF++Fai1+i:iii=
+3;E5
ig.v*iii:
i
g{E
3
r iB-[11e
iig
I
i;
SYEF$
ii [=
:
3#$
?tii
iFgti
gF
tf
$ii$r;
r+?a
+;;r
-3rt
q;
*1g[Eli
1[i?
13;3
i;
s
i:
+15
n9"Ha
i
=11j€
i1
&5
e
i
s
5
i:
=:
ee r; eiH
i
a
;''
f; E
l
+ii$ii$;i{iqF:.g
ile.s
;
E
";
iii;
6 i^
i +i
s
r-=
n
iil5
E.
Ii
I
i; iE
H ? i B
o
sr
rr;'
rltErEiiIE
lFIg
i{pirriiliilE
r"-
5':-P
=.Y
€ E 36
I
A
g
*X
"fi
s
L
{
1E
5
F*;
*
o
=
o
iT e [E
f
;
+
?
i
Y
+:
t
i=_
=.-__-=.€si.H*ao;
n
r3E?-1
[3=
*
3
E
;
$
il
r
+
i
d
;
*
r{
+
i
3
e
r a
I
E
-
i
e a
[
]
I
*
i
+:
I
t
r
l}[Ifill$i
Itsig
f
rgi1i
s
sil
rli*
1
r'
i
ig
i1;+i r$ag
I
Ii i
ili
i
1+i
s
iiiig
fiigi
i1
giiI
li
[s
i
iFiig
li' i
ii
i
ii
iiiiIii{ii
ii
E
if
agEt
i:i
rFg
I *
Bi
iri;suiEiiiilr
iE
Ifii
Ieiii
;
ei
il,i,iH
+irri$i
rIiIlEifi
iiii$iift
E
Iil+EF$iiFiilaFi
;Ei[$IiE
rI}iIEi +g
i
iFla i
*:
=;
isa
H
igi
tagli
ir
li5
iiiI
l+E
E
i
Ell+a
iFa iF+i
tl
+F
ilFFir;r
i;
i;rrii;ri_
i
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 38/100
r
=
;"qrA
>\=rss+{
I
=8
E33$E[tESqiggi_*i;=1
;
+iiai
; irri
tl
ilsi
si
aF;r:iliiItif+ft
igil
i
iq
:"1
;
$[€
tf
g
i:
$risH
;
F
i
i:
as
j$EELg
gi;f
$Eifl+gri7;i;FiiEsl;
ili
r
1i
i "i[iliEBaig]V*ii:
qr
iit€
is:IgiBiie
il
I
;i 1i
q
{ixg
i_r;r
t*S'FE
ha+3 f i
it
a
5.;
rA
Fi
I3
3
ag
=
B"a€;s+ii
?;;;'S'
:6
5E-F
e.fi
E-a:
;
e
a
fi
ts
s-a='
i
:
T
r.Le
\
i
F;=;
+
1*
E[
+3
E
;;
;\
?
ii
$
:
[
€
+=;g
"
d-
bB
or=i=,
lil=
SS
lAZs
f
fq=:i;:dH
gEi,
i,
i=-3E.=3n
s
{?rit:
+n: a+i riI
Eq;;
i
iEi
I3;iF+ii
gi
E Fr 2t?,u
E
*ili
Ii[$
tE;E
s
Eg+?g
a+;
;r
{
Ef
3
fi;f
{*
ii;E;ii=ile€eas
faiIiaEtn:+rg;ni
:fi
rlariisfiiii$rs
i
i
fg$riFlgriiEai*
E
i
d
iori;Ssi3
:aa $s
EE: =ir=atftg$ta3
3=
r??;
*;'i:
IIirrgI
g
iliiiiai
i
iii
+iit
+a
Fe'.ra :
[Sgi
i+r+$
$
t
3
+ilri3
[i
ita
r
ilaE
;+
*n
#e
#il:firilfHeI$
FI
Ir;iliir$[;*
fif
EB
a' :\
o;*
pi
H(D
.Da.
.N
o
++r
r'I:illFilEE
iu*i*
IuI
iaiEf
*ti:;
iirs
2EfiPsA
1l
;srf
l;
3
r
*i
Iii,B+EFi
i
;r[E
[*ir
iar"
I E
il-E
=
3'I
ig$ri
l:i [*5; i
r::
=a
**T i3
7i
il
ila?iE
iiiFis
iii
i#+Er{ili
a[;
tLsEri
5
I
=
$ 3
; F
A
?
+a r;
I
<.5
,
F
3
-
A
f ;
E
3
i
g
r
.F U
a
?i
*= Fie€
ai[?[$$
ri iri$AiiE3
1;??ie
i
18 *,
iiE;[fti++ i*itE};+iresiEE
+ra
ixIrtiBj+Eii*[+{fi+#lii-ii
?};
?;
a
t
;
fr;ts
Yfi€
;
;
iBi$
2*=:gi;r'r
ri
#liipir
;
a1-'i:
t3
rE
il+;
$
H
t:;1BE
E-fB;a;=
Ii
d-+
-D'.-:6k
4igf
ilE;
i
gi
tt
ir
i€
f
a<
=
?i
-
5
q'#3
d
3
B
s3
;
n
r: I r=
E
r ;;'^ H
i;
r
i
I
+$
1i
I
ii
i 3:
i rA
f
;
g
Ig*iA
iiif
iEi
iaq
rrgn
r
?a
+*q
r
=
oi
*=-nE
g*F
e*7rilif
t+[e+
e
e.I
\i1si ?
r:
ni ig+a
;
)
"e
=
ar
=
5
*= *€
q
+i
Xilif+il
il ir?:EiEigS
3i1i;
l
Y_a')
iliineEi;ra;1?
<x
{=
acj.nEr=i.
$
i
t+a.t{; *f,
i 5
i
€
F
T
?
*Es'o
p
? 7[i:
rE-f;
'?
+a
g
I
-*"a',lrnrui
o
a
n
o
A)
8w
n
^a
i
c-:
tst
Jd
DO
JA
A-
-tV-<...q+r-
='o
q
--l
.1ts
JlIo
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 39/100
E
a
a
s+s
i;;iir{
i if
i
ir=FE
i
*fiiizlii
ii
+
i{ie}+ia*t;sii+a
tE
flrf$+:'i;.glliit
iE
g
F
-
r
Q
=
,?
5-
a
g;e{a
d
a
n
i
-
x.o
i
o)
I i."
ir'
**EiA
ig;
i;i
iglli
-iFE
:
+?gl:
iiil
I
:
r
fi
3t3
P
i:ii?iE?i;gt
iiii{ef;€i$
i
BiiE
ig[]ri
+;
a
I;=i: }a*A.j,"FEsS,5;+:==ffr *T+;i_o-tr
j?
='g
i
{3
qF;ii
X
I
r,f,; g"
=e +6
-
3
o i I
P
V=
=
rn
3-6
s:
o-
; c..
-i
o
q
B
r;
q
1ji-
a*:+t:
,='gi
;
*==
+*:
I
3li
t'
*;g
Eoioaq
+3H }Eiisi
$itr
iilisEFii
E
iEi€
*ye;aIEi
r
x
?
i
5
0
'
+
F t
Eg
i
r
+ H
i
r
I
g
r
I
g
*
i
r; +
*E
i E
I
9;
.<
-
5 a
y-
o
9E.='- o I
r"';
if
ir;+na;€
r rlE
If
€
a;
iif
eE?gii]ii;
=f;^.-:';
3
ss I
ei
r
[P:
I
iri
rn
t; i
ii=
A;3
ri:
.-Z*q
L+r
=
'
a 3 r
E
+
i
i;
-s-'i
rg
*
1; +
?
i
t
;
;
*
*
5
l?:
I
3
a
iE
f
E:'
3
;
,F*
ei'
asaaig?a
*a+i
gal
[uifr
'itii;
b'E
r
i
a€
3
[
F
i
e;
ilr
s
*;
{
r
i
3I'
5la;i";ittEg;;t
?++lE
*
a
I
$li;
ric= I
r
-.
I
=
-
c
E
5
o
A'i
-
=
s: :ce*:it+Ecfn1I*Etal
isiig;F*$Br?*
t
?r
F B
:e
i:?3r?ri?rs
3
E
s
1+1;;il*iilltrE
i
rFt1,
ufiillie
F
EEtEEarai;
lriilIEi
l
i''
={
E'
-.0);
Etro
=.o-
3'=Ets3.a
as5
raear$FEs€
l
E
iiEgiAilriiilgs ?i;
ag
=
H
ilr
:=:
pia*HTeeiEje
i
[;a+i74?=",
E,
Ii]]L+i
-8
aH
12
3'
1?111I?EEE??Eg
E
11lElai[liarE:BE$B
7
f
=
iF=;{?;
iEE
F
iEiFatiTlE;iE,E
e
lir
li1lt1E$i?BE1A
ali?i1?i1}111iEqE1
i
?itirig=lE;irr
-*€
E
a;+?viiii;
iiii
?
f
is iltA
*gri ?$:
r+r
Lil=3
i"-Seijj
p6
B
aBsHEffi€€_ili?i
_1.="-
_;*ffifilTea
I
*lH
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 40/100
3.E:33=t;"F>?=
7'-
)'n D ''=;Sii16zc
c+q+e-5
u
+*;ix
it
ii ii;-
rtgLIi
lAip
r? v;4 5
€
-
n''eE
9+,?
I
=
<
I
iiira:
E+<
r +;
iF3
i+g; i
i*;=f
i
iti
i;"=:a
r
i.
tp
FO-O
F;
r
€
*r
3
[A ;
[E
g;
iS iir
r
?[i
i
qE
]i
:
i3
rii
I
:?
d
a*E"1
i
=l:XQE
i;E
;
f3-=i
E
FiBq
a";
A
E
f6 &.*;
i
E
i
a
i
i
*
3
* i
l
E
; i
A
=
I f
8_
5 : f
q
i [
il
4.;
e
''
3
i
gm
oq
l
I
:t;;r€s?Air3it*E_a+ils
*-**[if
t;;=; f 53i3
i
='r
_. R-.< I
c
I
:
=
6
e
s
a
o
q
1
=
D
l
sggi
$
if
BAiili
i
l€r
rE
=ig
*s
i?g:
r ?:
t
liii
i^
i
=x
i
e
-:
j3_iiiEil:
i;riaq
s"E
i
*
t:
tili;
r:
A
+
;*
r
ii
i i
$
il
i;
i
:
;
3
s
,
=
1e
F
Ei
s
i
3
g;
1; I::
*
;
:
"5
[*
itiiii i3
1;ig
iiriiii$iii
i; 1
iI;gr r
i I
i
il
[ E
*
A
6
6
3
6l
B
r:
.r
=
€
3s
q
e
=
#E
r
=:
i
]
r
I
.
a^
]
.
i
f 3 [
t-
i
]
=,
e
=
I 5
L
A
5
-
]
u i
6
;
;
=
;
=
E
n
S
A-A
:
n
S :-:
.i
3
g
o-_*
o
='c
I
sa
='r)
=.
-
=
c'n
=
J
<
o'Q
ir
=
i;
*; +*11;itas;1f
r#
5;;:
liBf
:+
+-oX;
3
*
E I
i
'ag
gg
Z{iiiEi[;bi]*i
ggliiiF:
f
ri
t
-
t d;
rcrq
I nt rD 5 o--
AigiriAig
iiitigE
iiE
aIl1iigIi+a+a
: i
ir
:
r
i;
i
{
si
i
:
p a
'.
i
I
it
X
f
ii il
f
5
g;
E
$'
i}
i
n
i
r'< p
d
I
o-
-,
+,
6
-
.
E
i
rr
if
g[g$i;I
fiiAi
gaFt
g**i+
.o
B
o
a
::
; 9
e
i
i
3
I
-
o
*
ii +:
.--< 1 i i
-,-
p
3- ? a
-
B
i
x
e;
lr+irrq
s
i:
iitI
[;e;
ss;
:a1
E
;iFfs
=
rP*m
ila;;
ir:ianilZiil
*alaET
i;i[Eti
iT=Hx-
*lll3gl$il
i;Eii[g€llaiii
iip
s3
iiai,
3
ieiE
I
E
F ri
ia
=
t$LLil[iIliii;
rlF[LiE
iIiiri]lgB
=is=qI
in aI
r
is
$
ri
il$ir
i
i??
ft€t
?
[$1
irFig
rBi
Ir[]
-?i
3
a-=:
iat
E
ii#li
atreisn:Fiilggliig
ti[ii
i
eciPtr
iiiiisE3i
sgfig
;g+E3lf+ilEi?
iifE$i
i
-'*.a::UH
i:==riif=?
+Bls&iE='o=iifr,
lg3
Blsi"i+
d
lEie*ii+B
1T
iiriirila
:E
iEEf
li
EiIi
I
rI*Ei3
L
r3T?ieiii
?EiLtf
blett=lLiEi
iii:=s
3
tF;qJTIE-F
;F=t[++H
rFatE':*
*l$
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 41/100
6
o
{
o
I
o
t
4)
0)
o
o
ir
f
ieiaiiE*r:
iiiiii?eiiiBEliiFIil1I
gi
[
3
F
;
ri
rs:
{;E iii
13
ip:
itir
rir
iE
[igE tlgrg
iiA;E:it
ii;
i;,i?:+iagEiril,
ii:s:?Es*
+
i
i
?
i+;
1ii
i
i
ii:
F;F11??E
iil?
iiiai?:?a
iLLi
ig
lEl}aE
iEi
lEllEt31EEEt:
11lE l
1AF
;s
3
i
eiEiFis[:
;
Iti
3
:*ii;i+raui
q
iE
li; *" +r
r
l?lEliilEEll1
i1lllE
[1?111
llltil
l11
L'*+agiYiB
rsE
ilii
iae:a*lEiqiEs
sEiH
o
1,
o
'*o
n
0)
ri'
{lo
tslo
{:
$tfls:
*
n
?
i[3i
tiiX
i?+
r
*r
iig
eiiEFi]iEg
*rrt;
r
i
i
Lr
tsi;i
ri+ra
iilili
il i{llI}i
-3
* ts-33
i
11
aiffi
a
I
E
1
I
I
1r
al
l*il*g
l*+ui
i
3
?:;
e€
e
>H
i+ii
ili
tigqa
5e
.''::Fa. ;=Bs
-.' ia
;
i;
r
s
5
i
3 ;
E
=
t
8
a
a
€
=
=:'
;
i ; E
E
,
=[ec
agE
E
H
ie
i
i
i
a
*{
Fg
a
tai
i
iEi
=:
i
i +
c
i
$
Fd
i
H r
s
€
iliE
iai
iif,
?I{BEeiE
liili+
i?i'i$€
?LXii+i*:
a; fr
=:
i
4
+,
g
r nes{?rr=E
r;
;c
r
ii;,s=i
A*iiiEA+ei3gii
F4
*ItiS;€.aIil i+:i;
r]E
;
i
E
?
s
riif
?#n5[a3C**+q?+q:i
*f
E"if
E3f
++€3
i;
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 42/100
r
'd
6
3
i
+i'+E
ii;
tArilis=
s ;
IF;
ti"11;f
1=ta€
i
1
-ioP-=
3
Eq
3;3-6
-
e
1a=ti*;f:EgisfiH
iii i
iE
[i+fl;
lIgfij
i
: 9 ; I
=
a
r iiiEitiigtsi
lli:
di i
igi
iEiiF;i+fE
1a I
i;:ri;E|3
;Ii[;;
iiEsE r$eii+i+ii
axrE:q
H
+::sii
ii
;i:lt
i
E-ig
I;
i:
i
i
iiFi;
ii;
1i;=i
i
--.-E
pf
=
fr:
Lii
3:
g
3"=:eTi
ig
?+f
;
+€=_il;€t€
:t=i.Y.
I'o
iil;
ii:
ai
iEsii
il"=?xii
iiilr
i:
+:
}EE
tgi
=
*
i
:
gei
g
iig}
i?1,;,,
;
i
i;E
;
i'
#,rif
1tl
iri
J"Oa-_x<
eE
;
Er-sii
ilE+iiit +Fiii
xrtiE
iii i;;
i ;
3
i
a"o
12;
a1*-
glE
r*I;
N
[$i*;]ri+ililiit;
a
ir
e
*9
a IHE
3"30'x':"=
il
s
er*f1i;
e
i=
8
+rF
is
i}}
I
[]
^
--
oe* 3c
o-).6
aq;fi-&i** ;:a::,"ts3;5"i
E
E7
1+a
giErEIirp3?Ee;i
tIsitlei;ltg i;i
r
ri[i
HE ati
i]e
]s
]]g+
i
g;qi
t; irt.+f
ilx
3
H8
a6i
?
o
()o
(o
+f
l-',^
cf
f
<
)
I E
+:
zo
26,
<
f o
,Jt:.
O
<
c+ts
cr(D:rf
o-
r
-1
J m,
-
'o
e
8d-a
r14*
Fd e d
lv
/
6t:
'
@.r{
c rd
cf
O
7
(D
o
a
E
o
a
(\
\
-_l
o
'o
m
-
o
&
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 43/100
s$
tr,
G
FT
-
-
(it
C-
I
-l
o,
1)
'c
*J
oU
-'1
oo
o(o
30
3)
9w
io
YO
dc
Ct
ca'
U,
^cr
J
-'
r5
J
o
r
e,il
Et: I
i.i ," I
ctSVl
o
o
='l
f
:i.
c?o
E{'
+-1
O
bor
-d
{
-Ao
\OO
cf
Sar
s\9
'J
Za
8's
+s
oOi-,
2?=
;'<
-P
or
2zia
-o
I
Ct
Jt
o
1-
o
1
(r
o
)
o
@
o
to
l-r
lf
l3
lo
l)
ld
2
-T
o
)
@
o
9.
f
I
pu
ttzI
IL\\'
W;
o
7
m
N
z
3
G
s
bJ
o\
o
o
.o
rc
p
t
a
B
I
3
C)
-
TI
,l-
<1
=oC
o/
ooo
=',
I
_i
o-
L lc-.
a@
c
o
scb-
o
5-o
aa"
'oo-f
,o
i
o<,
d<O 5
+
'
15
.=
o
ct
J
o
'1
3
o
,.
Ct
o
'0
-l
'a'
o
1)
o
o
o.
)
(O
<t
=
(t
o
3
o
FHf;H
gil1B
o
zt19
fnY z
rn
2O
-z-frA
1 '
1 Jr?
o<
-.1
>
4?it
r
-€
l'o
bo
7.
'ao
C
,
o
G
,
Itl
q,
'rl
F)
D
o
v
t
o
>
c$
s
o
o
o
'tr
:.
oq
-
E
9.
0
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 44/100
Ntr'\
-srr\-1-
\9r
EAmlt
i(:i)t/'
,
=
?,\$I
m.E$
i$E
B
+
s
3
l'q; sl
le;
fl
r
ll€
'f
l::fl_
lc;;qa
j;q
+i
sEiSi
AtrA$
9:1.."
i
iir
*;
eae€I
\
a
*.9
O- -
.,i
g
-Ct
.\.5
"r
F
>(,
F
wc
oo
rI
Z
'\)
*)
l\
\
-:
'
>(t
ii
w(n
:>
=>
>
c
v
o6)
o>
o>
o>
o>
T,
I
i
o
{3q
tuy
rID;
Io;
,'.lzF
bF9
,
>-
*iA
uo
-{>l
r{f,
oZ
3o
ci,
a
Irt
5
?l
D
D
3
t
o
I
>
s
o
o
0
-
?l
o
oa
d$
\
rts
^
L
f
IGl
*3-
rD
lI
f
(t,
gF
EC)
o
6
&E
<.6
:<:
eF
-.
o_
t,
c)
z
o
C
(t
v
o
-l
-{
I
rrl
V
Tl
n
rn
x
rrl
z
C)
I
'\)
;Z\
,o)'
a
c
z
x
n
z
f4
T"l
<,
o
I1r
T
)n
+Z
=J
t)
<
o
:
E
gt
{
-
o
ts
G
+
o\
o
t3
ca
-
t,
o
d6'
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 45/100
q)
,
lrt
o
0
-L
a
s
s
a
t'r
-
-
o
3
D
-
(ort
\
o
o
I5l
J(ot
ol
fsl
;fLI
o
+od
O, a^
S5'e Z
4
s't,i
'9o
=
-r',
a
:r
v
(JD
,.
<J^
oY
gfd
QHa
6Eil
@o
O-.=
dj
,.o
N;
Hd
..ffiHr
qf
s
C)
I
-
3
o
o
c
o
o
9.
o
5
+)
o
3
o
g
2
a
7
e .
t,
a
lr
a)
€
D)
v
o
3
(\
G
s
z
o
to
s
+
o
.o
-
-
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 46/100
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 47/100
inp-agx:
lffi'..,
r
5385;
'*
3H:-':
;SIt*i5-
.i:iE:
Ei;5fr:
i;;ll;
=iEER:i
249=d
=-z
tt=91
f;;EliB
a?*E*:
-qrB.
*
Ei::g=
iSdEtE
o'--iFltr
F
-zEl,r
--s--AgI-
HE
sg
Rrqi
;z
i
t,
-
l
(D
o
I
3
o
"
r
Y
t
o
Fl
l.l
(\
o
n\
.:=
:.
rl
ta
d:.
-o\
-tt
9.+
f,a
--t
9.2
>o
4
=
"Ma3 $;gE
\-l
it9gss'
EEi;EEX:
silEa
c
ri=
{-{
dP.==-
ela:i
[=$E'
2
i"
a=Iti:
}
i:HE=
\1, nnF?o
f,{
Efi=Eie
liiE:EiE
l I 6_> i@
*63
*€
ac- t;
-s.
e*9€d'
-'
[':ss8
vt2
-
o.
otssSR
.{}
'-*N\\
:,iBtz$)/*
ir*IEE
"
._q3i
r=I
=63
1il;s;
93-
-
-\$ R'>e
-
tgr3
sEEFi
4 6'';
=i>
t
-
n
€
o
s_
-<r>-
.Siti
EaESl
3+zD
€Oa
,c6
{Z
3fE
g
lXsr*
l
"ltxR
I i r\\i
j
-*sSi
r.
$'$
ft=
.-$-
tr=?8
-..siil3l
<F
,\
"
iRB
7
*6ar
,,
r"a-
---s--
EtE
Pgc
B-g=,e
:Bi;r
,\.
3t91;
,
rFg**
I
-'-
F_9
--*'i3eF
>ea
iz--
9 :
3;E
>9i
:=o
>E
<oo
orc
-$
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 48/100
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 49/100
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 50/100
* fl
[5g
1-?=rl
E::3$=
i:
-
[3g-]i*lgll
isrT';:F
?
?
iit|ii=i$;€ei
ilgtl
lrF+E
IFgB :?,fi
rs:
: arH
\
+r i1d
:
f
e+:
r:
i+gii;
F:
;
;;;
s
;
i;
zii
i
-;
*A
iii :E*;=
x
=::E
Ei
a
Lsg;=_
=
l*trF
-
i
iiiFsi
igglEE
ig[+s3*Fq
eiEieti:
I+aiI
I
z
Ht
r
1iE
rt;:
*rn_:€
iF[g[
,.fi+e[;i;{a
Ii
alF{=F
=
is
iieBi
i
=isirii;ig
{
tiiiggr=
:
aiF
itiara,
sI
it:
+1i;iiiiiE
*siirai+ig;EI
r ;
y;
e'
.
a;iqlE
+rliiii
iI
iiiEgig
llii+t
3
[';
n
1S
i
I
E
il:+:
3
=
=
r
-
-
=,
=.
:6iir
i:
iBsiaiE;l;
illig E
i;
iliiEi*rIie
i + O ,riC O'O
nEi ta:
i
;;
a=FI
[s=; tgti;
6;;it
r;E
d
=:
*e
s'3H'?;3
=
s
;
i
E
rr
iii
g'
A
F;
-i1iiii
:
Ti
r:
:
ilt
:?
-xii
;
a
ea:r*i;irn;
iFiia*
ic Bil;3E
iBqiil
;$
xa
E
o
P 3
f
gg
t
;i:
3 H*?r f
i;
g
ir
g
aq
a;3lf
;=i
=
+i
E
bl:gFEfa:
iFqE
+l;F;
+=i
?is
iiil
l€Ei+
is
#
F
*+il#
s
g
Ia
,i[[f
$E+3E
iu
r
q
*
3
53
a
r
B
?E
r1
e
+ i* + a
;
i i +
l+
i
i-
3
x
qi
i
E
€
i
;,
i+ i
aF
iI.
igE
H
F
I #i
+*s
s
ii
ra: rg
ilgiHFS
:
-a$-F
6
s.iii
e
&:
i
=t*E
;
"=
r
aLI
E
i
iril
Agn
i
id
=l^-n1
--
i:
q
r n
e'=
f;
n
=
3
g
f
I
e
i
3
f
e
+; F
I
I t
L
3
E
E €
a
f;
;; ;
F
*i+a.i iiE?+'
Ei$*1i
E
liiIiE$$E
$1E
ilrilr
;trE;i;[iFi
=,
t;IiE+il+;i#:
vri
i=:=i=e=:
r+
1[EE;f
cE
ii
ieiE
r;,
Ffrii1;{tt$aiiFt;rs
tiE$3iE
iiSg
rtili
[gif[$[r'EE
+i
i
: s5
iI
r=:
qi
F.n=u=ir
I
qa
u1:-1l*
+ti3 1;€t
iE;.g?
1
+6x"
*b 2=.
-s.i=q>
3#t6';ii
=ai-;
a+lAi
i,
.,i
g
3.
:
r-
':-
-
=,
i;F,:;il;etE
rArEE.;;rgIHB_
=Ssai".iaaE
I
'
Jq":
;ilEa
HExsg+3iai;;;
tIi$e1iiu
i
i
;i
6rHfl
X5g):,lf
69id6
-*
ftrffiEs{
}l
t1
+B}3
;Ifg.1[-1ffil
n_=e
zqi=:
r
9
;+lia$i:;
;
i
il-=*Eo-x
_e
i._H
s * *tg*+-+=
g
?
k
TE"a
H?i€
f7E-
*?
s*[{? *i+fE+
EF
i
r
i:d
F
;=i
?
3
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 51/100
rDltt
(3
lE
Itr
o
{
o
o
o
I
J
,n
0)
o
o
e-.ei(#l*i*"d
:r{'
hr
p
,O,'
t
Er.
Fa.
H
q(
&,
st'
C#'
(D-,
,i
'ts
o
CI,
CT
o
,H,,
,u
E
a
='-
o
=
d .I ilrfi
P
7
o
-t.D
e
irj
j
=
2;.6'6'c
ff
3
e€E
7;
.
=
;r'-
i
.
=.d6'
-
pJ
>_"J?
tn6'5-
g
-1
o.
-i-
r 5 e.
?,
.;
f
E
#
5iH
n i
<6:YA
^-i:6rr
r',
5-@&.', bs
^-JFaG
:E-- r ; 6'ni
tr
o-
j-o
I
s
J?6-+6
S E
i *-o\
:
O
o
ao-o I
C
o,
TEJ
ts
3
ci;
j
i
3H rer
H
:r
s
;
le
s
i#
+$;3
6
t f
a
o,
O-tl
=5
q)
q
*14: ii-
=
gdl.tat't'o
*
-a
=
=I9-
T
^.rPiIU
'd.-
99&n'6'
E
=.o7,')=FZe-a
'thT
i^vaHuq
o
:F; d
?i
O=
^?.
s;3 e-? an'+
i
o
{
o
I
0)
r{*'f
*$il=FEE
$$eErg
[1*i
at
?
;.{
Ti
=gf
e
;
f
=
+
5ll
I
o
t
i r
=i
if,gi*
i
i
i
r3 *siFE
[il*
ie
i;
it
a
r
ii
Flrli€
il;[1l
Ia*.rililiiiiiI
r u
r-
&p
t
1;
=
s
=*i3ii[+F]i1il[g*igiiit*r
a:=$eis
:ox9aE'5
#E
ulrrB===is
rB
*r
*a*
[ici
i;iiiu
E*rE
*:
iE
riir
?E
E
=
sr
=
la
i
r;
rIifi
]"rlt
aif
sit
i;qiiiilies*€
if
:ii*[
tlFi
Ile lEE[$in{BiE;r;
$siF
tgr$
:
F€x
: i sE
+iilF;;fIilqiar
i;
lf3
€Ei
i
i1[ir1+
t13
i]19]g+gsE
i35r
-'
*
:
=+E
+:
ecT riE
;
?n
3
?:
3
nqE"5:
at
$aEi.
ggiiFiE
ilE?}
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 52/100
trrd
cEx
=oo
:EH
l'-{3
oln
li
a>
"xh-)
ri :11 I
IiS
M
Ird65
o--cr
i=sE;
6iqEI
a;n;s
6
I
r€.tt
*
=i$
rl
t
a
FI
N
'i
E
(h
o
fo
I
I
I
Y
t
o
UJ
S
\
n
o
Oa
:
N'E{F
,>>E;
ooz>-
lI:18
inHo-l
drri
C.
iHiSE
-l
Fz cil
g.
5s
,i\),*{g5i
"mm
f;ql
-
tal
E:t
i
BiIg
*55.=r
FE$*
--
__l >
.li;ffii3l
\
=*
stai
:FOO
ISis
rtdql
i'=si
ld
I O-
Pdl
o
oc,
oo<
I:>
--8s
39=t
o=<l
596d
llr:
;isE
frijE
. O
o
trSEI
Sisr:
-re
3
il5r
I
\
I
>rrr{
lpaEI:
\ 5z=tn
.\^
_aI.E
|
'ifiir
"
h;iq
oc) z
l3a
hr
l>r
't HI
llirE
;*iss
;il;f;1
]t:
r
/l
lei
(EEg
---t:,
.e
_>
ll:il
I
's
lrill
eEt
_gl
9gr
\r:.
oai
w
i$i
-
^ila
IHrffill
eA-
I clr
r"9Ei
I
: r<
BP
o.:
-{o
E>
iz
=r.r
i
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 53/100
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 54/100
*
rg
itilIiBfr*31f
3iEnqr
=E++a
qiE*F
i* i
srEaf
ileririsi
iti;3?=aE-1r[<rst]?
ia
:
ialEif+;ifl+;1
faE
iliS'fiFl
ias#i
ii
i
133+;iriri;g;
ilir::
i1#:r;Fitsrl f+
F
i1
i =
E.r?
=-
x ='+ *; i -
6
; t.< t ? : 3
5
."
- - [ ] * = a
3
o
E-I '-6'li;* o.:j qr-[ B - q'-- g o 6 3 r; +Y ;- j
ro
o-p ^ =.i
EE[+i+iriil=ii
Ea+11;r
#+iHi*is{i
tr
Erqils+Hti5
i+
gsi=L:3
;*[1*:F;Ti
zr
-.
11
w;1.-
oB-SI
_;N
iry36f6''
='{Jcr--",aIq.1
E
.6
X.
q
g<
o
r
+a?i'i;iaii
Ei ;E*iiag ff
Iitrisii
ii
iilSrEiit:l il
iitEf+ig
iFFli-:tsl
i
F;;E$ alri
"rE
s s:i;il
r; ilI
:ilif
?,
:q;fB:E€:e ;E
B
:eili
i5ild-{
iS+;
i
i1iH1;
Ilif
z
?;+;i}+
:ii
ir
aiii
i
TiB3.n;.;F€,
1
i;
F
EHIEfs
r€i1r
iiE;
i
i;fifrBlr*5
E; E EaHrnt
IFrFi
Eila
E
IiflfiIr;$li
aI"L
;
rf.L;
sE
a
1a
F
i
ii
3
5
s
a
r
r +
ii6
I
fl i
f
i
I i
Iii
r
fiir
iIFiii
f
i
i$i
ii
i
s
i
q
E
3.;
*
rs
i€ rrH€
rg
iilrilf
gllili
ifriHf
€rF[FrE:
i
i
i
$$
ii F[
i}
iE
irici
tEifi
if
il
Ii
n*
Ei
*$$i
.*?EFHE
*r=
aFz:$ii
cE
i
gglFF
iEI
a3;
;E
Is3
[li;
ei
:
t
I I
i
a
i;
=
i
"
1:
;=F a
s
9
r
e;
t
E
s r E
g
+
i
I
t
fi
g
+
E
11i
s
isirFs
qi$E
iIi[f1fElfiE{F}
EiIE
i
u
+]:f
$iEi?fsis$rcf
rit
ii+tri
+E
*H + ig
{t$
i+ili;
i# ii=
*i
;
q
i
ti
5iii$
i
6
a;
e i{ E
[E$
*? tf *.;fr": 3
ifi
ra'+fi['L '1_gji*g
S
E
i
'
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 55/100
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 56/100
Erg
D
='tr =-
) $
ro
=
-
r
o
=.
r
a
;.
a
T;
{3
8
E-
=
8
=
x F
o
ra
;< 7
/;i? f I H
sqfi-
:q
c-atsiqi3s[3:sQ"€=H.EfiE;iAesiE
f
iiHi
=
ilt?E:liis:Ef+'iie€islrsrT*;
1
i{fi
A
EEF3i:+E++= laE:
q?*,Ei [1cLi
t
€;
I
u
-E:
Es i i t [?;i3
Au"i
H
d
1rE
it€
fiXfiei
=
i+ai
I-i+giiiiFAaFriilfi*g[*+lrr*;
*
t
ii; i
E
Il i[riisi€
$rril[+iilligiiria:
lgig
E fi$ilifi Eisf i1]€;iifl5ii
illi
rEE"i
g
lril
l9i
i{i'l
+ar;
I' t
ilfE}iE
+,8
r;'H, i
ii:lHfflilftiltBrfi$$iiii+i;i
oF;'
i+r
i a.
;i
*+rirfF$+[tfiigS
I]+al
1]]A
c
g;
i
"i
laJ
;i{; F sr;siiE**Fi$iieiiiiitiii;i:
?-ifb()
ggi=
H
1-:3
n
rrr
rip
rio
n rF-r :s +i* fi
;
jxi
='Y
;q
i
IE-8 i*
;
Eg
lrl Fo 6
rs+=
_a,;5
e-a
=Xi
o :a
e'
=
si€E
3
;re,EierEt$e3aE
[i+:iiii;;;1
r9?r
q,L;"Iia+=T?P*nF
;i€3F-fIi-r+ri
$tiigggf
if
$*1[*fla, iIarti
iEiliigEITuie
i[E
f[Ii
+i+;E
gaa
:;
i
[Fr
=
5
t6;--€
=.
.
i;'
d
a-
ilriri:ilir$
$H?[H
1€
-FilE,
$gI
]i1;
ri;
+tii
;
illi lIi
+EiiiE
Iir; iFrsifligiH
iltEii
i
I
ili;g+iieplilllil;
ii
i$Eir
rqigr[;
$.F
EerRe;=.*Fsr***o{i3
i{I=gg1$lr3es;:
',
liii}i111[Et;
i'=
E
=
i
?*€
iii$iii$iFFil
i
=q
z i,
=
r,iti
F
I+iliir
il*gil+tiiiB++[3
il *i
a
*g:
riiggE$1tai[ir
iliii
Fg1fiFilil$lili1F
I
aqr
e
u
=s:;
15+ill
ig
[fFii$
tIi
F$;F}i
ei
A
aEi;i+:
+isHr"ri
iii fEgi€*
ti
1i
ergEi
i
=&FB"'?[rii[;:
iEiHi
I
al;iE:s
7
o
o
0a
{
o
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 57/100
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 58/100
F
rg
ri$i+iiItlisr=i
r':
i
Ii+ f
;t
iiif
=r*i+r
?
giEriiq
Irg
[,i
Irg *3:
i
1;;r"L3
ir
li:
]it
e
ri
1
Inf
;5$eErE
r93
*,rii
iliii€
iiiitiiiiisE,
i
I
€
;
i
a;e r
3
i=
:.
1*a$;i{
3
i+
3 ;+;rr
>L'';es
";Z
z
F
€ia+iif
+[B1c:}iii1;
riiliiiti[;
l*:iri€
n
ras{
B
8 &l
a
1;l I
=
419
ilg+;31}g
d
rr
ler:
+
g;
E
.)o-.=-.
i
it:
=:
+i s
":.8
a ia lrlirr ili
=
ng
s
i
iixli*rI
r
;
r;
i3 e
i
1?a
s;
s
iiilf
lrlrFiiarif
l;ii
if
if
i
-
='-'.
-oorlo^iJi1
--.
a
zr
o''"
:
;
i
i
*
I
;
"-
Q
laaiEiiiS
l+g++"
;;
rri:E ti$igg
;
ili
iia:
r1i* rianig
ii
+r
i
B
i[+FiliislIiAi
$i{
T
;
ft=
iFEii=fi
=*l
/'L{tiy
n
a
e'=a
?
ie
-La
ig
i+r+gfE+[]tFI.i
?Ttei:eFilirriE
*tl8
i :f+:gg*ir
i
;
il
e= *i $3
3
rEin
$
r.rt
i
{Ai
.=
?F
i3
+Iirii[
111Fi;
[[F$filii}
giil
+3,
[i+r
=:
Ed.corQB
8--a E #
q';3
r
f
l;ilE*i
Igg1
1$
l*ilElgli
I [ ilE
I
I
ltr
f
l+
i6-ErX51e
lilflf
i
-
i
t
a $i
*g
1rE iiiE
flIlig;[[iiilii
E'
lEil$iiiEiiiIs+
iief
;
r
r;r
iF
-r:
1is I
EF
+lii3i["i;
s
I
A
i{E
*ilitEi3
+*Er}ars
}r.i
E
1+E
:
il
&i
=
;
e
*{
E
i
il;
I
f
iq
l
;
i
I iE
I
q
q
*
+
+
f
.- ro"j:u;
=
$rf? ir
: trarl
5tX;
tilirEii
iilg
=E
air
es
rH
I
3f
=i$[
rThF
g1{
=,,
i?irE
E
3-*=rrr-=
s
s
t+ii3
i
te
3
iii'i
rr:
i *ffi[i++in+,iiife
a
=
i
H:
Fe
n
$
qi$i
i=
E E
;
H
=
r
i
ar{ri6
-gi
:ilr$[1
i
e+3Hj,e
ifltEiiX ii$E
i+;
ii]eil
iE
r*;;
+
iFFiE
i+irigE*11$+EiH={FiiiFr
i
ir,s
Tl+
? + = ?
F+r
*d
*+ -nilr+=
EEH
e.f.m;i5
:
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 59/100
*
rg
s=
si€
rHe€
q
ri*5€
1ar[E
*tiFigiilirlii,
?
r0'QI-?5
r
F
-e
5
;
r
ifr=3il;'
e
d
r'
5:
B
1
-s
Er;
E reli
ril
1
3%
5 +:
E
o- Z i;'o
=.o
i
irIE
i
iFtEEasi[*s=
i[i
I
r
q
s
Tiq
rii,
rr
ii
liFti;;
tt*:riil
t
-
€ 6
id
"
:
i
r€ :
ri
i
H
i
i;
*
E-
ro
r
z
d
i
3
*
;
g
: r
I
a
l
l
r
rE-
#
#
r
iE
[a:
ig
E
+
a
X
l:
ls
F
g
g
a
=
=
I
=
+
=
s
i
g
e
i
i ii F ni
iFF
I3 Eli+
itI
ti
;:ir
i
xr
I i
FI
itF
iiirrii;F;
i,
t;iiiirF:
f
1+:
1*[:
I
1i
I
lgi
[[i
i
1t
llFiigE
i
Iiil
i
1i
I
IE5lE.[
il
a*6^
-
O
a-e-H
*;13x-ig
*1n;;if {i a,i*[ ii 5Fi'=i::T
t
H
=zzes
r:
s
;
il=
3
ai;EtFfgE
ia 1;i;=rE
ii3
s
$E
F
E
'gi
il;S
g
*
l: I
r
i:
I
i
?
t
t
+
[
;
3
E
i
t i
1E
ii
g
I
a
i;ilc=ig
fg
fifiFf
1i
fi+,t
F
f
Fie$t
.^<
-
i
E'
:-i
€E"+= + Liil++,
, x +
=
++
H
r;
;
.=Fs-+E;-q
e
I
rri
ii
*$
riEi6iIg1[fg$ilgiIl$[l$1[E$
}E
ilir$E+ni:
B
rd
*;
q
ei'1f
f
ggE
sg3ii
f
i*ile*iili+;
rs
=qI
lti
*tl
iie r*;rir **AiIiriisf
+i
a
H
q
riB
1;
i
$Eq$i
a,rtil*
1$3
i3
,,ii1E,1*€
l[
E
r*ill
i*iir*=
*-'lirliriri€
i*i
$i+
$a
[r;$a.
i
i
i$*a
$1$rai
H
i
rg*riurr
rii*+
ir +€
ri;tffiaj
ff
r:
riti
iirr*;
;rg
q
ir=$+
=siEfgi+i*+;ie$$ilq+ili$a{i*
s
$"B
L
[ 3
tr
gtilgflrigifi
f1i
l
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 60/100
*
rg
EiilI:F*Tiif?E[
;ti;s;a.
,***+?
i
ilH.*i[{rgg iBait=
-{ ;$s=gr:#
p'r"
r
3
z$sEiTEE +=:Eq;
I
i+if,EIiE
1l=3IE
]
=,.t1xFE*i;Eqa$isr
E
If;1Fli1
+ii;pi
i
*39troo
- ='i
*,<
3 o
1
--
=
*
d?.
+
H61T+*iir1g$fi,34
F
i}i1rE*;
i6iii$
3
3
=
ri'?
+R
ei:ri3=+;lei:+Fi
i
Iigfl+sii
"lFtti
qlifi+[aSrzr ;;.i
tr
i=ei+:i:
=
16E*€
1i*ei,
"+i;aie.i:T=
=
i++;r1ili
ls"BEs
=L:a':r;fflf
i5F+ii A
;r?6?i:s
$'il*+
:$siFpFiilrilr[[
F E+rileri
lxiE$
lsIlaFr*lisiagf
-s-
+,
Jz+;i=
[ilFHS
+f;tglfiiiiBL.3Ei
irri;rB
r[+ii
=;1*=;:3Ieia=zEa :;:i5g:
iB:8,
*
'3rsl+ulii*[+af:
reii$11
*riir
l}:rreilgFgiili+;
ffiil=}i
i[$ii
1=
iE3B'34QE3:dHee
+[rilEg.
3efi
r$
FgEIs
B.
N.3
X B
5
3,.g
ilt
[ 1
3
*i
$
$
r
fi
r
g
;
]E
] r
] i
+
il'+
3
I
*
F
f:
A
r
B
F
lil;
x
$i
rrlii
liliti
i$iriE
[aB
r
IlFi
rr;
g
tcitiiqgi
ftE
$H
iirgii3E
iI
i
riiigi[+t
B
e $ig
*'Eei$iXigtilf[ili
fi
i{ts
+B
ni
*E
1$itilisii['ia
rrB
FriirF:
ai
*1gE
I6
g5
i€-=-i+*a$St=
i$li$fufiI
Ifi
ruFi$ei
-k:rC
O-5
il
frlQqBr)
iiEoo-i=9
=
13 B
d_E
?
i=
6-n
p
r[*$_s+8-i IE-1 *{Ex 3
3
=
}l
g
rF 3?B
:
{:
8i+I}E}:s18a7=*::-;
-
G= El'iE:i;
e_c
pea[2e
Br"-a8ff:BIt+ai='
a?,*=^+
lis*
3
ili
n:
-D
r=5
\
5
=
4Dr
*i*rEilsls;r;rflif$i:i
1:f3il
I;xx
6
'rr
;iriIiS$ie*3i5-aiTifi$
iFi][
I*A;
E
Hts+"-R- E
itf
$86tsE3$Frsia;irr:i:
lilf; 1;it
i
dE?
eeuSij$SiE;lf ilt"i:ra
ilgF-I
riE?
;
;;.+
r;riliEs$1*lr*q+;15tE
+qllE
;aq1
I
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 61/100
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 62/100
X
o
o
oa
-t
o
5
o
6
il
r
s
+ r ? a f
?
g
a E
i
I
i
t
t
i
iig€;
I
r
e
[p
I
i
is
*
a'$ I
a
-a
isa5 *3
ig=
B
tgE-FiA:;Ei
=
t:3;ii;ie"s
i=
g
:ieIgl{[Er
itlle;ii[$Ergt
+inrFigt:
i:
$
r
i
r;
3
i
r
r
i
i i
r:
;
E
=
g
i
r
i
i
IE
a
F
gt
E
s
i
$
ii
i
i
1
:it;E;
i
g;:
s
si
a*3
s
ti+s*l;Ef
a
*i=t;35+r
tE
iii+f
iii
laf
il'
i:r
i=,,l}
iisgilf
f
1ig1ii
d
=
g
r#
E
o.+i
E c
rq
=
iE"= 7a
i
+ E
g
#
E
;;
*f ;?
e i
gErrfi?il
ii
x
r+i
+i;;;Iu
Fiigi
iliis€s
i
if
ixiliEF;E
i
1if;
tFi
1;i
*flrEaH
$iitiilEi
ir;
_",*e.aZ
a5:
s
:.+H:
i
; i: iH
l
g
*i33
E e:
;-[.+F
nI
4
-..o
::r HY
g--
)
X a€
y9
g
A :.J- I. 3 9
=.e-'=.
ts
5 x;6-.j
iiTr<
E
--;
ol.
isf
$iilr{ra
r$qi
ii;gE
titiill+5s*$ii
it*
='iii1'=+$*3:i;i;19ial5;
iiii:
i
it 1i
3
s
t&
g
A
uS
:
r *i
n
I
i
=
r
x
=
;
X
I
il+,? *F
F*il:;Ii ii;i
1:
]i]i
ii
5$l{g
z=
ii
3
-l
o
r;
i
=Elilii+l-t
Iia$giiilIgli1i$1g*
EE T
TFE
E
u5 i E $.iiE
litlgiliEiiir;
+Eri=
*irri=,,
rrlg
E;
=
il;r8
n
ri+1s
iE
E;
$r+itlii}lli;iiiF$r#
;
i
I
a
*itri$gil
ilii
il,iiFgig$[lii
iliil
E
li: lE a
iF
f
+
13.
f
a
f
i 3
li
s
*
e
i
+
+€
I { Fq i f
I
i
*
i
;
i
r€
5
lrairrrlir
*irEi;
x
i;igF$[gEi{iE
iftg
5
*;
H rie
ig$il[;1$rg3EE
iigE
iiu== rrE€
;isg{1f13iiIi
itiffi
iiiiii$i
iii{iiiti
g
i$EifEgElri
gliiHie
ri=:
E$E
Ir+gi€ig
,ii
i
iFr
+;$H
$iEnl.{[gfi?-
"ri+?;
L;
p
i;
r+
i
e
r
E
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 63/100
ilt
ocl.
a='* FYI
;
=-';
"
(
<
=O
,.1
e+15#i=
c? +o-p-c2=
;
s
ilitIt
tii
r+=i6-E'
iE
FFt;s$iilr
ff
Fi
1
J:.d
I
d E.;:
E
;r3
iiE[i};uFiF.g=irr;
*;
E
r
i
.e il x
3it
i;-=
1
if
=T
i.?=.-:.€;:'--i5ai::.-iq3El:+EgIHo^;d==
T1:-5I
E
e ? +.5i
-
a-r.
r
i
E
3
i;g-ar;=ri-{;s:E
i
L
iaFi
tB
{
i
r
F
a
IA: feg
;-i [ee
e5
;
ni
*tr6i;E iI:
+iX
EI
qr
v
=€
=ci
is.f
A;=sa
e
+q#&:,
iE
e-:
E_[f]iiig
f
ig;
rgir
i +r+i
il ii
iEi?riiE
iir:
i :
e
T a
T TE
o
F
5
0
-
ro
q .
q
*
q
9 r
p
*
r
-
6j
o
X
3
' '
r
^
-
r)
(r
o
;:3ii3g
s;idLI$;iEr=:r=€i3:r;a=i
F
SrgAiX,
giliFilEa-';$rgiii
ltiifi
*
SttIiSE
iAi=5+=lg
3;
-ro
gd
={
n[;
Aii
r
=
*
8.ts
iEfr 1==ea1s
f?H i
1l
fi:Aiitl
gi
:
E
I
;--
o
;
d
fr
3
:
q
:
r
=.
I
f
5 E.:5
o
f
d
d
E
=
;'&'P;
E:i33q3
.-ui[$1]afi€aiI iSqBair
E
3H';-=E-6'9 Eai
d_
f ,lE i
=
e e-=ia; b-;'r
3
d=?:38+
1?] Ifg3if;HsE;:+ii:f;
-T
=.q;
cj
=
1
s
il
I
c
o
i=-]A;
3i
Xpn
B';
o
6
D
y
6
o
q
i
-
-;'o
f 9
d
ax'5)-
vs
iE iE;=
; At.i
+if:.'=*1s
ra
;
3;?
igg.i i
:
9
E
-;;
E
d y
=
3
f
C i a".r;
E
;
=.
; 6
c
r
=
{
?,
I
7 i i
*;
+;q
g?
0;
q
3
E-Qi,
s'ji a
=r,
r+
g€
?
ii
+ ;
f
tf fftB-#igIBEB-+;63tsr,,3qsi+
=n<
{
B
H
i
i
=
i5
H
A
3
'6lS:
i
g
+ 3
I
i
+
3
-
6
H
+
1
+
lg+
flg iiigrilgigitiigggii
tliiirri
ggi
-+
gliEigitigigiliiiiiiiBg
igii
e?;
s
$Eirr$ lt*ii:ailaBsrl€'rilirr
+lf
E';-i+r;i1;r+1i=HrlriFgr'It["1
Iti
+
*i-;+qrT:at?13:s:s*s=9 F3rI
fF€ F
+i3i55ilF"ir;Aiircs xE
:Eia
ee^
e
r.aid6.is€-;,*l;3[i;B_q"t
if*i r
Ia E
f,ziF;-iFrf]i6
Fir
i
r+$Egi*tiiii5fiifli3iE
1t;$
E
5'p
^5r
rr?;1#t;3e+ia;;il=i+3
EEEs
#
i;iariE"Bialrs3iE[€ngi
iEEE
i
i*=
s=i++?f,-;r+;P,Ei+*r"Li63
ir+E
#
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 64/100
;
tg
rr+B-+iIFt+EAraif
Ea=f
dTsqrBti1i3-EE
*
i
+litr
[if
gl+:
+
i:t f
[i
Iarar€
€i
rF llt
1f
E
[g
I
+i:i
lfilglliilliillilillai
iiffiilllrt
i
i=r=i
ti
i
3f-1i
i:
il*is
+Fg
E'i
a
i+u
L€
1firI
g
a+
a
q
;
5
+
s
=
3
il
I
i:
i
?:
;
:
E
+
+
ii=
il
13
il
r
3
E
i
F
F
s
+
i
*i
;
I
i,
i
i
3 a i
i
i
a
i i;
ri
i
:
i
i
=
i
i
I +i++
3
a
r
i
1
s
a 3 r
5
$.
F
3
1H Ii[;
I i$iii
+
$
g
x
aE
a;
s
s
: o
"'ai
7
s7, 13.i:
{
+ e
B
=
.
e
ri
I
i
Ea;
r
+,
=
=
l3 I
i€
3
l
I
il;?
ri ilf
I
i
i
+:
?
H;6
eZ
i,
ili
fi
E
rt i++t3
=B:*+H
t;i
rn
8
E.Til;Fg
=
3
; ?+,
=
=;
ai
"ri;
[+E[AlcE
$;
gIigi
i
[;
?;
E
:
i
oSIC
='
q
"oA
l.*l*a'6,i +
i
ii{i
i
ii:liigiBlllEBirliFgg11gI$
iE
6;e9=
I
ilEq i: t
rF;
=
+
F+#6;
i;
r; *+*i F
X
6
o
-l
o
-i
o
;'Q p gg r a o-5
;H€
3
il
q
iE
-?
?isg=:Ea3
7
:s 3 a'r
+
t
(U
V J H H
-
:==
e
:
fi
i
a
+.3
ts
i
-lvu_J-
=
Q
=
al
O-.;
;
+1f : I I
B#
-.
(D
a;-;. ) x k
oo
-v
tr
z
3
a
qF
f
A
o
3
E
: I
q
r
9
S
h
E'{a+;€::i.d.
;
*
F
F
E.
g
15#
3-:,-\43?EH{
:
i I'f r
d
I
d-
f
)3.-Foo6o
;
t5i
E
fr
ilE
: l;-
+
i
+
r
*
r
iff r3
$ilgE
A(D^
."
c,
^
fr
;
3 i:
5G
#;
i
-
f.=':t-
O-=;.O
igi.69g'a=.=
gB^gx=9d6'
s;
a
r
i
I
i t+
i*Eai*atn
I
5
O-ii
3.5 r
i
C,a
=Oa
O
.-
a A'' -
;- ; , ;
u-
X
:r
3
Ltvr6
i X
o-X
€
-:i
o)
i i
F;
il;
5
3
T
o
oq
a
o
o
3
(D
n
o
)
rn
qc
rj
n
o
n
(D
n
Er"
q
d
(D
I
o
)
o
t.D
o
p)
o
(D
o
(.D
d
cD
o
o
-
FJ
6
o
n
(a
o
o-
E
o
s)
q
fi
n
z
)
(n
o
n
o
H
a-
a
q
?
o
o
o
o
P
z
o
n
d
o
F
(D
o
n
o
I
o
o
o
3
o
o
q
o
o
n
o
o-
n
A)
oa
o
A)
a
o
)
o
(D
a
o
,to
6
n
n
O
0)
oa
q
6
d
o
q
L
T]
N
n
o
a
o
6
n
p
o-
o
s*
)
on
I
o
FJ
o
6
p
t]
6
o
tD
q
d
{
(D
rc
.D
(a
o
oa
t.D
X
A)
o
o
F
o
0q
o
o
?
I
A)
d
o
o
0a
q
n
o
o
o-
t.D
rD
*
o
-
n
o
o
n
0)
o
n
{
I
I
{
o
oa
o
-
FJ
E$)
o
o
(n
n
e
)
F)
o
a
o
n
a
o
q
a
E
qa
n
o
(D
n
{
(D
)
o
P
A.
E
o-
l.D
I
o
j
o
J
3
(
i
rD
{
-
o
tsa
o
a
o
{
o
(D
(D
o
q
o
q
o
Y
o
o
S
E
E
FE. 5
+ +
e.q
r
5'ts
2
a)
;rli
x*[[iilHrEii
a i
r
$
s
1i
3F
a-1
1
+ 1;
*
s=VjPEi[-sF<.'t
-=.9
I
E
I
f
g
;
t
a
i
i
r
i
i
*
r
r
*
3
r
a-
q
3
:
A
E
d'E
T
i-*-t
a
=
*6*
-5
i=
i;
g+;-I:;
F i
rE
rfi
r
I
r
r;
i
:
S
3
H
5
: e J
r
i
E
I
€
g
*
*E
r
r
€
f +gE
itr
rI
iE
E
-'o
o
r
*
r
il
r
f
i
i
i
i [
1r
i
lE
gsxES3Eiliia33zZs
1;
e.B
3 SA;iq rE +ae:
0
e
o
5
-
E
q
ilE
il
E
F
=
r
I:6 3
e-E.3
=n
R
?
=*o
i*
B
*
E
I ;r
:
B'; ?
i i :
5
-
o
s
f; l $
f il
fl
r
E
i*
a
i
:
i I
iilFi;aig;e;grtr
E+3
+{e;+
=
f
i9;
H;;
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 65/100
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 66/100
sl$
t' ;I++i$;i+r *;3:iigq:rBsH
p3gA.iX;*
i
e
+
a-#
P
B E
=
=
i
r
{
&
r
5
i
a 3 r
r
5
i
}
i
I
g
s+;
+i
E
*i
n
E
F
:
i e
i
w
#
if
=
l
iElF
*
g
+5
:
=
rE
5;;Fr:
*";
E
ia
i
F
=
-,
r'#
"i1
=
o o,i
EFao
iiii:iiiilrii
iiiifglfi[+il3
1i
{iFiIfF-
i
:
o
tr
E
=;'n
+8
s--.5
-o
2'o
s
+
-
i: i::f :
g
=F3,
i <+'iq
"
€
5 q
ei: i
n[3
?
i='=r
=E
aPn
B
d
r
i
:-E'.-d::i?
E
+I
iliE
t=
;
i[i
ilg[:
: :
ii
eE
q
3
*
r
r i 3
*
u
l i
i
i
ir
*i
$
+
rl
iE
i;
f
i
[f
*
=
i
r
=
r
g
E
I
if;
i,Eii
n;g;E
ftE
f,l
q
9:
5
r[{
-t;
E
aB
^
B-6
d
c
iii
rFtti?i;FiFi
i1ig1i;Iii
i+ i:iei
i i
fl
x
q
; tf
3
ritT;
fr
1f
: ilr=[;s
s
r:
rE
f i
=
ifr
r*ii.s
r+oPi'oro--r-";a
=
t
i{
a
a
;-
r
B
q
: r 1 ,
3
i 1[
[
+
=
€
:
i;
i
a
g
rt
a
g
i
=
i
it3liq
H
iirEE
riei$l1ilj
i
}iig
+i+?i;Es
+E
i
3-;s
tfi?g:
urE;iri[e=
u
i
aE
{I;€
r
:
i;
'
E slTfi'E
;
L;ilE
r+i;
lii=L
t
;
iliqir*;
t;
F
rsi;+:
+
:
=3xFt:;3ri:a
=zd=5=:E:EfEi
3f
iEnEei
1F.fi
+r5
i
:
?
=
i1:
3 ;;2i3:gA3
il++ ?
?A5sF
ri
rf i
ri+:
*ir; E{1iiir
rg*+,ri
l+[rir
[3=i,
E
t:
r;
3
l 1:-x i;
i s
?;
;
: r
;
E'E
3
=
5
*
q
*
i
;
s +
E
4
i
I
=
i
ri
li*Eii
riii+griii
I
I
rFili
Ei
=
Ii
lii
Elil
I ig+=
+sur
i:;
=*r
i
; t1[;:
$$*[a
i:3
rl
e
)rE
i$r3
tirg i'
iiiiiil[i€
tis$FilFiiI
rri$[+F;
F,'--1ir$gEEifEirliii,IiEiiffiili
E
s
r
n i
+E;
3
FE
g
fi
;
i:: a a
l;'it
i:Q
5'
-
+rt;i3
ii i:ig5; a*
F€i3+;
iiir
n
"u$s'g\o
fiEairiliiriiiiftlif
iFe
eiitirilir+
f
s
Z;nEt:
rl=Irs-r=5:a=?;e€Hi
i;E:i+ii.,tl
f
1
rfrre*F15ilil;:
I
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 67/100
*
I$
a
Il;XE€i
s
riFlaii$i;,;:
:
=f[}F
u
r$tr-i
o
i
i3i;i1€Et;lr+r;€
rFr+if
le*t[eEiiigf
rl
i
-
o
J
_
=
e
y
=:-i
=.=.o
-.8:
*
aB
X
El.i
iic'- +[;:;98.:
=:
#
J
a
f[= 5
1g
:
q
B
i
2
ac
-s^
=
i
=fr
tE
E
r
nT:
I
fi
=;+.,
-
i
:
I
3
a
E 1aE
r i;
ri
;
x i"r
;t
i=rf
j
+is
i
i+iliXgE
i
:i,iiao6,
s
i
6
*"
i:
= ?
trr
=s
3
*-;
E*
iaf
f
=-E
1q?
s
+Xi
$.51;
f.
i
3
;
E
u
i:
"
E
l i i
I
fI
+.
:
r
a
i,
."
s
E-
f
i
]
i
h
r
A
t
=
=
e
i
ni * i'
[€'IigsIire
iIiIigitFiii*iEii
T
s$EH
r
a
erEEs.iF
iir' rg
irFa+1i;gigi[;
iilfi liEiefE
il
r
'a-.i
='5
o
i
'
;3
rr3 r;
rgiFrit.r
i illr.f,;
iii;
i
;
g,[isi
3;F$qFiiismi
3i
sE6
=
;s
i i]Ei*
+
q*
E
A#tr3
;E
s *l:
+ii
s.+r
Pg
T$f
3
iri
i?3;
F
11fi$+riiE
$siiit
il
r+i;
+ri$
$
a
i+3r H
i
IA;.
I
E
t ij,1
ti
il;
i
r+Ea
f
T
t
t;
I
;
r'3
.
var
r$nr;
[giiEif,r=:
l€iiiriiiiia
;
+ F
?
fi ? i
ilE:fitiea$s-i*51frr*;rarF
3E
d
rrFii;is:il$FI
r$
+i3i[[irFg
+
Htiiiflrif,,lniiiiirf$rf,rlrf
sFIE:
i
i;i
E {:
i*ri;
iilffIia
fl;ii
iica[ri
$:
"s
eIr
F
iEaa+iEii+{EE$fifii5fF ilg
[+E
a
I
i
uEiiiga$rri;$)iFlEi$ssiE*i
t
s
gp
E
[{iii s
H
s
]+:
3EE
H
a[$s
:i
h-tF
iS:g+el
"
F;i[
"'
fli]r*iiiFsiiiiir€
i;ilE
il*-i+s
iiesi;
sisf,$Eats+*T?i:Fui*?rg5E
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 68/100
i+g€
5.ilit
iiE3FiriEi
i*ri$iii3
tii
+:
F$1-'B
l;i
Etsl:
r*ii
iil
i
reFi*ii:
:
si+gi+::E
i
iil+i'girrgiiliiiiiI
lfgiiiiigriiIiiI
i
;- 'H gi
6
E
ii
rf
iB
lEiilE
iltirni:E
ii3
lFii€
iiiFi*
I". +{
[
E
=
ri
E
=ii
Iiitriii
gtXiIillei$irf
i
fi$[i
i.
l+d '-
'
':
'
I1+3
$
i
$
[i
ti
Ii[
il
I
+
[f
$
3 r
If
g
I1g
it
r
1
B$
F
I
ii
+
r+igi3
ii
i
ii
+
i
iii
=.
iE
ili1fr
tlgtiiiii
=
:
s
i
E
I a
i:
=
il i
=
"-
+:
:
3
a
i,
x ;.: + 1+
g
'-;
E
=
5
€
.F
F
a
ir,::
{
il
=
e:
,
r I
;
ili.
1
i3
i;:
+ii
ai;
E
;
3
i
ii-ii
ir5
i:
gEi
li
iE E
i
ri
l
ii ii
i;;
F
+
q
I
i
3
r
r
r=rE i+f
+[3$itiiiiqi,
aa
-+i;ti*Af
[i
i*+;ig;i
irilii?*if
tlii
F+as**ils
?
*i+
t
i
I
i
=
r r
i
i
ii
i
i
+
I$t
i
lfl
i
E
H
i
H'i
iE
F€
q
E
'
i
s
*
iiEF$iiigg{iiiii;,
li
r
s
i+i}i
i1iiii
l{
ii
r;i
I
l
rr
ii
+ rir*
a
r
$i
ii$tl
if
fgi
E
ii
1;
$
i+
i
fu
rt
E ilf$ii5is$
ig
il$il$iFFiEir
E
ig
E
'lo--q.
l6-=..';P^=o'
;.iE
9
ir
i:
a
rTer3
i
il
[ri
ii
iiflri=i+;:
i+
'a'6 6 99
i$
i
r
Ei iii ei
i
$Erf
ig t3l$
f,a
1i;i
}lrFi
i;
*$ii
iilEE
i$riisiFsfrli
tilt
i
tiriai
it
eE
*+
ri;
r;
iS
iile:
rii"is€
F*Fas
if1i +r
ar
r
I
3
E.E:
;E?;
ili$1lr;$$E
I1s$+11gr,
r+6ilr
E
i
il
i;
1g
'
;
?
3
;
g
+
;
1
n
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 69/100
*
r$
[iiaii+ElrE'
+i;
rirr+E+ariF
$ii1+1i1
i
*i{+'i*ir11gii11F1gIliilliiflFlrll
t589E;
i:
igi
?iilis;
r
iilii
l;elin
rt1*asi
i
;e3:
eEEi;ilE I8E
:3ii+;rl=ii
igll3;i;
=.o
'i
=.
=
e
a
)
o\<
o
$l
-3
=
6
i
r
=
ail
Et
_,c,a
+d
n
;
+ElE[FaF
ioelor
=
i3 ii;g:
=
=
o
6
-{
P
a-;
**r
a
ql*A
in
LE{i;
i:
g:
irii
3 5
i
+:icsiiiii
Ffi*g5{
3
i
1'" ;.9
3
x
E
rq
?i€"-
0-E
i
sF
d3-
1;+; 5 il
t=i
i
"
{
y
p'
&+E
+
riiisiati[[iit
i*1t=i;iiEg
iiffsEi
+:s:
i,Ei3;+;€=is"B
[r=-?Blaaq:i
o;
t+i*iT
E
=A
=
do
iil-iiri
rg
1+g
**i:;3 +;:
='4=
i
I&+6
=
36 7u2
&5
=
il * ;
A
[j :'6
o
1't4;-
6
B-a€
"+i
iiriiigEii+Eiii
iiiiESrE9ir
eEii+++
7?zi"EiitIEi;*i3
rs€;Lrt
:g;
E-uE*?ia
arn=
iit[:
i3
iI]e
:f+"3iIaL?
Ei
+B*3FFe
i;
*=iTil3x
is: sI
i
i:
il
r
[;
+
H s
gt
r
+3
r
I
i [; *
i+ii+rflqiEFieElf 3
E
i
i[
i
E
f,
[
qf
r
g
3i
i
]i
:
+E
ni
iirf
rlFr
*:
r
i
;
:-
F
5 a
?
E
+
3.6
g
*H
5 a
eil.{
;E
f;iilF
6af€=iF
;;;
gg
a;f
r;E
e
lf iggsrf
i.?
=,393s1e.
lisEi
+13
isgi*i$Eieii
3;E
=.aif;:a,ii,si;
r
.tI5
H:-[8,
iIe"t{fi
=
i
r++EFE+FF+gr
i
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 70/100
ft
T
Jr
It
t
{
m
,*,
&
-l
o
0
o
c)
rt
o
at
oo
-h
tn
FT
-
c)
D
ET
E.
o
o
-t
-r
o
&'
e
E
$<
d
;
$
St
S
6'Ge6.i
S
S>
S
I
x
k:X
-
s
s
;t:;iR-in
Ni:':h:S
o
.
s
s-oa
s
f
r'i
d
a->s-s.\tY'
G
6
q
\-^
::.$*-<
IE
tsB
iI
[:
su
,qtOio
l'\a:s^s.
,IIh 'iS=
g;
s \
K
$
f: AbCi
f :F
s
x
x
6sdls-
>ds*
+*
k
D
I9t *3
i,3s $::
L*r
d
i*
\e
J
G'
: * Fr n
iKI. a i I
1st
$x{.
+'A
I E-a
^
/:
5is.t<s
aoso
oSSir:\
rEIXS
€ si
s-d
o;i
xoorn=o:or=2c=>{
:+?ESi;*a'iAE":
il
)
*E;;1$t+&iA'X
e
IrtHa i;
gf
i€ +g
t
s
i
r=
d
=g
l:
s i€
ii
H
;$ti+ili{ilsl
g
t;
Fi-r
1,{ T
[
1:
H
t e'
13 F
i
e
+
i *i
r
g
g
=
a,iq=g:j ..D;B;0iL
e'N'eiid>rain=o.#
E
s lq8 [
o
a
+
#
pr_g
,
I
ii
at;
r=3
1 f t
tg
: i
r.?
t
i
F: F
;=
ri
f ;
E
=;
B-+=-*1r
"T
d
H-B
3
IB r
*
f
*
g
1
;
I
fi
8 :
E
i
E:
+ [:
E
i:^-;+i'*=:--iviI
":
d
d
q;"=
3E i
E
ii
;
X
r
q
t
E
H I
&;:i
:
3
qB-eai7
3a5'q?=?
+:
{
s
ii6iiiFiiifi?iiii$iirHEi$rir
E.IT=f
:=;jiE=,
X;+tsPA
^
: 6
c
$-
iELE_e
i:
ZIif
gS
S
g
a,g;$i
g
:
+sF#
i*
3
B
a
r
5
5
Ls
q
e
11il$E
l'ie
r1*EE
H
g;=E'
l3itif
iE
igf
H rf i
g
I
I
g
ils. r
iE
t-:
r*i
E"
F.
I
I rg:
F
E:
itr;
rl9
E [€
fr
5i
;rs
p-Fr
*;
=
#t1s^Vi+;
fr;=r
; if iS16
[i
g
Eg+
.i
E-9
3.s
iiili}i
$*irrfF$rgriiiF*iir[[
iiraifl
-
=. 6'o
:l
iaisii Ig::Faii+rri;1
q
F5'
6-
ii$*i;gg$if5.;33
i;
i;*tu
$E:n
sB
t
-
d :€ *
=-
6
=
; f
{€=
=
r
Y
o--:
Fa
i;Fi;;rilr;;Ii;iiiiE
+gF*l.
:
- 3
-*:
r
lE
i
i,ilg
p
iI'.9
1l
g
3
x-I
E
:i
*3 i i'?
-_:
,,
a
r
5-
$;,
v,=7
Fi**3tg3i+qi:i
*-6;EE'
eFe H
Ea
?
$i=++i
;i;Eisrrriiii;5iri5i
;;$ge;
i
N=:
*c*i
Ti1ii*l-tri;lEi .rai*q
isF-=:] 3
1*3Eii
i=ag;-er*'i5ii;;a:r;$
i
s3-#€&
ai
i"??s+il i$q?;iB+qilg +pir3E
s
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 71/100
5l=
old
6
o
o
n
+
aqo@
(UJHh
:r'E
-g
a
u
-
d
-65_
Y6LJ
niDnjo
ro53nF
@rr-q
i=F
ii
on"o
re {
5
Jfro
@rn
-rO
U(DP
l+o<
oCo)
ovY.c
PN
0
ae
a iJ
cra
<
-
'La
Oa
=oao
aO
figii
fili
f lii,
ii
iigilFiri;i
i
irt *
l
lir
i
Ii
iiF?i
ifl{i+i+;
1i
iE
ii
ig[Fsi
r
lEi
iI
f
f
i
f f-
f
iE
i 1;
r$i$Elf;lai
i
I
$H
ii
i
i
1s+ai;Hii*.6i{ig
gii$
i
ili
fl
ii
t*i;
;iE
Eia
n
iirii
i
c;ara
+
i
rqi
ig igg
rg*ili
rigi
iiiii
iiii
u'
-''.*
<A
o)ts
qa
r
*Ffl
rf
$
i
1E i{*
r
i;
ilif
iq i
$6F
il$E
i
pg
ii
$
IrE
iFrgFi[ifliiEiiii{iiii$iiiiii
ig€
fii
a r
a
i:
if3iIfi
is
;
*:
I;
1+"rg
i
[S
*E
r
q
s
I t; i
i
13 3
s
i
f
f
f
1E*
i
+ i
;
+ r
EIeisrFE
i;;E
5
IfiiiiillilIi
i+$FrgiaI
i
+€
F
* a;
i;
l$$$$iigf
l$1i$gligigil;i
+E aa, :
3
t
riirEEir
iF5. .*p1[[
[;$i:F
s
ni
s;
nilr++1{s
3
*i;
*
il$ilrEilti
[*:
E
EtilE
Iiit$ierFEf$ Ei
I
FiFi$aa[++$$EE
B$rr[$i
iigE
E
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 72/100
*rr
+?
6\
5a8g='4tr=e.=.-J=.rq
Q
E
E5l"
,,=F=.:;.-?a==.-ric
4
;i=:EieE:6'#-oqi'
3
+r+ilf
IiilEE'fi
+Et
ilFif
li
t9tE
e
*z+n
E
Fe
:
€
=
G
=
=
='
iiiE;ii;
ii-l
{+
[taE
rlritillii
i
::
E 5 a
r3f=i
ilEil;;fl;
idgiFi
li?rj[3r+il:]ia
r
i3
;++
F;1r=
iti?=i=
r:
r'
iiilrlp
;
[;
+i
:.
s
ir'C5-oA
ri-r;
ii;tiF+s:iiiH":;
;1=i
zi'rifiFiig
=
slex
il
+5
iE'I;igE
1=E-^t:
aa
:r3
I=,*66s'=
qE
i
i il;s
E
i
ll?
i;i=:si
i's
3
iil i.8
p3
;
: z&=€-
riFi+
{[$i+i=;:
tt3 rii
F*ilir* ii€
i:
*+
dj e'5
qI5i5reaenE=ri
=:a'=IgE
i$;-gti
;
"^hi
3
+*19
i
E=H
r[[i
1Fi€
i;i
E5BE3
3
tPo:od
c
ai
-=
ifi+rn:raiiiiI
efrz+:
3e;:Il[=
?
dtnr
iirli:3a+;i+li
"i[e+iillilgli
oi-=
'=
=
i'5R
=-_.>d
-'i;jr_11
3
q
B
xi
*.gl
og-d
o
il=.=<
a5
t
g
z
..;Er
d
illgl
=Ef=ifqi
9iliirsiF:r?xg
+:.;
d
+fr
3.r1
g{
;
3=
r.a":
18
j
i[
ilF"ii
9E
+q-=isgr
+c,e=
i
Ft;n;gsE
3;iEEi
i6g:g=
u="i iL+i
-i=,=
A
:i ;lftE iB +r.a? *t:=€
:-FA=ig:=
+rs-i;
:+ii++ix+fi
=;;s
fE;iI"rB+??i+s
Er
lEEri*;iET
rlEi
fiiffali;
Cir=gFi*
; ;i3:
i=s
5
a
?
d=
p
jQnsisirt
3+f,{
*ifgrl;=i:i|il
sl_g
c =:-Eiafai
il;ii [g3;igreI1r?EEqr3
E F:5
t;
FilAg;'EFi
iv
:;iEi
i+n-
l+IE. iiEr-iiia;ii +rdF'
Ei
jf,ii;
gf;
+E'i
i:aitji:eili:'"r+gI
i*
=6rf;
lif,
{ifi
tAii€;ss::d'i:Tr:v
9g
lrigl
fFi
Et€
i
$i$iEitEi$,+t
iiH
3i
ilr;i"E
::g lsit
qliSi+;i:;iHr
il;a
ig
I3.;3=
E+E
i;r;
==grrg$ii3;g5
*it
*
z-=li
E 1
;erl
oE=n*z=?i_t:3E
i;; ;
g
=3
3aE-
ai5
iie
i'
=jii-r:=?E=:
=r,,
o
liii;
iii
ii3
iiE iEit:iii
iii
f
-fi==E
il,-
ig
6d-l=E-T..,.F|
;i
6tse
c
Ea;
=iiiHsiiaEIl
$
EErtifr
aiF+iit$g:+i:
;
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 73/100
*r*
l
B
;ii
Ie
:;
irItx iF3** i+i:
iil3
[i
=
rr"rI3
a I
1
i
rs:;'*iif
*qii3Fgii}$;
[iiFE
iiiIrii;I
i
i if;$ia;Ei
iE
Iii[E
i
*rf,
;re.rE ::
r;s
jr=
i
i
Q3.o7,3q)
i+EE
i
g
F*
a
l+igiF;iagiil
iliii
t5*ir?
irrr
a
:
E
E
i
i
i
Et
=?
i
i
3
;
:
1;
=
r-
a
x;
i
=
;'e;
r
i
5
A:
g
r
$
i
2
*ri;
a{E
iIlii1i
trt
+[ii[5HieFiiglgiii
-q-.eOY
F
I
i*:
at;
H;3rf
si5
b+FI;}Ti+g6I
=
r-:
='"
;r
;t
rA ir
*; il;
r
i
,
I
ti
+;
B;
;
iri
iipg
tiii; i:
=
-
o a
q
q
i
a
"",
a
=
r
g
o
=
I
E 1 t
i"3
i {
I
*
i
d I E
.i
>
9
=
_
=.ii
5
=
9.9
=
{
x
=
E
==}vt7=ei*i
+[5+3$ii+]€i*i:3[ii1
.An
o-c
B
sEi$1$[i
iii;
s;Li
llf
+$;iif
ef
;
,:
i:
r;
i
:
+18
:
=[g
Itgi
ii
iiiH
3ii
t
rf
iliii+[is$]
:
T;
S1
r
i
i i3
e i
i
i;
i
iE
i
i;
E I i;
$
i
6:
:
if
ie
=
il
=
aE
i
;e.3
1E
rtE ++asi[eE
:
+Ef;1fi
$siil;
e$
iii
'o-
x
='5
=?r5D:i
H
is
*n
3u:f3"lf$ifi+rFi;
[f
3
=*ise:
ilE
I
.3i'3
rE
s
+*? I5
E
a
E E
qa
i=niei+itili6iflif
$€;iiiggiiiii
E
rrE
=98
5
h
;"6:
I 3riIf+tli+tt*
s
ii
i,rii
s
.
-iiE
i
iil$
d{
r
f
BE
r8.
*{
6
a
$
Frarai1;
g
s
i
=i;
-
iIi+[irf
i5 ii3€
E
o
[i
E
E
E
Ig;
+{F
E_:
e i€
i.3
g
qt
r+r=r=i
a
i-+s
is;
i
F
3
q:T
rIli
rr
;lr
iH,
+r
*
+HEii+ii€iFiE
u4
i5
Iiiisil:
ifl
F
E
=
*
a
=;
3 i 3
-
+
=
q
H
r
?
:
s
['
g
f
i $a
gr
F
g
if
i
i
f
F
FB
i
f iS;
E
5
f
l
ilsr+flitf;Fii:
;ri;iiIa3{3€*;;
1il i
i
i E
I t F 5+* i
ai i
Ii"Fr5
s
E
E
$€x
B
s
=
rrr=
i
r
Lr
F***B *ie
i
E.[[rfiiliil
1
i
o
o
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 74/100
*Iil
lailL1ia
azQ=€uf
il*iiiEs:
i? i €nLPfrsB'.^[d *
liltrrIiaiEiiiiriE
+[[E'$i
+4i$iirfIr$i
+
giEleEr3I$iiriI{;egi,
{i*1siE};
f
+?
iIEI
t
t
?rIe;i
i=
#[;,*
al1l
liri*
e?s
E
+;
*ilT
F
i
aaa
'
*r
iiii=ilif
iarf
:
F$glEiigi*+aI;ii
ii+
,qO-9=^i
=
a;E
f; ir
E
3
+e1=+E:
i41:E:id: r-E
+s
i,i
-
il.F-
E
i
+
+u
i:
in
lg
i
i'
rgEES
i
:E;
:
;
E
i
a
d
r
*
}
l iFE
E
r
i
Ii
$E
a
r
r;
?a3
iE
r
i
e
+
i
r
r,
iflfii
IF
ri[iii.
I
ii
i:'i:
$*g
zqB
ur[ilhi
;i=?
3 i=
r*rx
r;eE : i
;= rA;+i
=
i
3
Ee
E
E-=
r
B
5
s
a-.P.9 -"6
+e
Z'; *e;
*t
T
[is
tt5i:
i
x
$=
g
1*
3:1ai
iaE:
ql
i
6
+; i;
ii
e
e
eE
;r=*:
qs
iiiggr:i;rili
IEEEiiit
Etei
I
:
iEIi
l;
I
a[]a€t
i:+ffiii+i?[l+**Br;
i
$1?fA
1-3,=
i-;rl
E
ili
[F,s
ilF1+]'r
E
a
=
i
E-l
i
rIIc?xr+
li*ts5iIilIi€:
]#ilFlf
r:
+i
I
e
ia
lgggliggig
tsg
liiliig
igEr
I lgr
i
+t
lir
iFgIFr$iiggi
iiBiEggl1i
igri$iIIriIri
B
1:rie
3
+;1i
g
-?$;i
riiiE
[tf
g[ Blt[rti
r+;l*c
i€Fi
;
F
aiqrtiilliciiliiliri3iai-
gli*i
iiAgg[
gIiiiiii]xFi+1€e*
rraai
+
€+iiagiFFinE
,iiu$1i{litiEl$[irffilii
$
*FliEguIiFiiria
+Hffi[1ii
E
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 75/100
*rt
iti;r1}r
i
ili,E
r1-=a=:
i[illgr
]g
=
a
q
:
3e ;i
E I
r ;5-r
q
?i6iilS;;dEaEEi ir
E:
lfiiiql;
;
E
isiis*i;
a
=lF=e*
+ig
*rt;iairiii[giFAlaia
f
Iit+*+l[
r
isiii*i
liE+$E*iiiii$$Ef
t
iiii[ [ E
i
I
e
AC
Tp <
ro
E
5
.=
;
ip
n
E
il;
$lli*i;a$igEii
i
lfiie
Ii:
a$rEnEsiixsir[$+gi;+i€[
t
trr]Egi
iii;si[liiii#iii9 f15.Ii
e
i[:Eii:
+6
E
E
n
{:
6
E".6
-a
E+ai
if
t+s;
+F
ti
xrE
i
1l:
lf
:
i'o
I
''
s
$
ts-
a
3
0
=;
+
=
I.
rT
=
i
F
i
a
E
i
H
E.
h
a'
s) H -A
*_
;3
(
u
*=b+$[ai+ae3
X*ilF;i
isitgli
nI-roo
o
*,5 oi
--,
l
1 *{:
-
i ,
D
r
x
.-
fE
?
{ i i
i;
: i.
{
q;g
i
f:
qEfl,
rFExiIi+;$ligtgf$sl
g]*?
i:
+E
*=*
#.,q
flfi
];
il$
F
E
f
E
s
?
tE'E
I
tf
tr3
$f
.=
HE.;H
s
r
u
re{
a
,,
===ip:
;H il; a
[?iIlE
iX$gf
tIi=
[[E$i
g]FE
$iFif]giif,iil[tililrEB1lgE
.
S.
5ij- r
9.
r; t-liq:
:iE;''
I
e
=a
+6I+i$[i+1;E
E*[f
Finir;i1tfr1il;ri
ii,
iigFli
$i;fE
iriit
iE iB
E";;
iil[a;
a
s€ i:
gt?[:
i
s,
3
5
ri
;
i
i
E
E
;
gg
i
i;}
t{Z[isE
iai*ri i
it
Li;
,f
;;.
rsrs ie
T6
iin
:
*il*ia
r*l
:E;
ilfi
$lf3
g
i
HIiii]be
lii
s*
3
E *153
I:.H
a
iE
r
=
H
H'rrio
i
. ?'i.r
7
3ErF3rilqiFEFi$1aiga1€ilf,E
iiililgr
{
=i[+FIiEr+itAii$r;ig
gir;iii+eiqx
r
:'iilErt+1 iFF3Fili
il;jtr€
i
ts
9,2 9
$
;
gtFi
3
-=-1,
rlri+#iiEs;alEi*rgn
i*l;a33+=rHr
$
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 76/100
urt
1;trlEilntiFi5'
riEii:;E'i-
-ils=arET
-
i
i
3
iF*uggE1il
irElIlii3i$il
I[g€giIlE
I
i
ts-F
6
=.?.3
&
5'=',
H 5 i
li$ni
ilflig+rrrirgg?
r;flai
I+ilFr]ri+$
I
6--i^x6'r
nr;*gH,E -t q==[gss*iIiaii IlBEd;;ro
f
:i
i[?j
le
1$ie l+lti
ii[E
lii[
-ili3[iliEi
;gi
sf
ls
1;
ii:
?;
-
d;
e?
3=
";
+
tt;
g
B
=
=F
-
-
'
r
: H :
a
; a A o
-
Li o
='-
ii
o
o
j.E
"
/
J-
x 5
^,
$
-'
o 5.,
p==.",
1il
d--
*9
8
q
1
il; :
3
x T'"E'
a+* 'r'@
;
;
-:
o
e.i 6 a.)-.4
z
o-=i
Y
3
dH 3-,3
s:
I
X
ST
=3
ili
=
i
=t7
I
=
s
E
s
1r:
ig;;i
FFlIrFg;
+l
r
giiEi;+{i
-,,5P-=
-9
_..?pd I
;
:
=q
1i
*ii#
q,I
&1
j'?
;
=
*
E
-z t _<=
.;
=, ^,
=-
-
ra
+;i
x
*:itf1i3
Fi:
i$ i:
$itqn.;
i
o-XoXii,'a
e
s
1E f
.r
E
*#a
B
A'o- f
HE
lT-
iA
#=l
=
B
B
aLq i[a ai iiiln :
4
-p
r*u
6
s.
c-1. i;
q
iE
E
[{:6
=
9
q
i-'::5
a i 5
a
q
3
ili
ltiai
*;ieilIL;Ii
itEli
igta;eii;
*;Iriisf
;
*ilfe
ai]iF;
ieii
lrr;:iasF:
E
ffiE
sr
€
eia$f
;
r3
EiE"ig[*i]}igliiEa€r
.9
A d _- H,
iilit:
iii.
g$g1[[iltf,gf
i;
qri
H
n
i:;E
i
a
il
E
a
t
i
;ai
Iia,
u*;
gfi
[$gi
iE;
AiiliEig$; ili*
g
*; ili
i I
$r
r
i
i
$+F
r;
f
q
[-
;
I
i
g
sE
i
r
g;
IE
1+
[
n;*
ii;
irr[g:
iiitii
iil
i;iff
liilf
E
liilE
3+iFE
1iggigE
1gi,i$ii;
il
xrsii;ar+*ri
+
I$i f[il$iE
[+i1[1+$$f
$1tg[iE
iii+-
f=
-
#
o-
o
L
=--
R
T
EiB$*-e
i''
rr$?
iE
i
iE
iil
[fEAii[+lriili
I
i
[+FfrH
Erffi*E;rii+F
H
*
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 77/100
*r*
1+;E
aq
3
iiiriE
IEgl[g+[ii;iiiiI;
I
i]ti
i
.
T'J',
1A
-,
I
ira
iiri?Ii+iiri;gqriiTi?il;;IitFF[*
[
r"-.;'E:r.3
t
ilirr$I;isiiE
IFig*ire
i$iii
ri}s;}:
i
tIs
e
11"*$a"i+i5;s
rBi.E,
lFi::Fitr-f
iiE
A:5iiI
-I
pi
E
+E.
liEiitl
i
i3
[ErH
]i:+ig€
tig
=r$
33
$i;*
ir
."5,
='E-f
",
a
)
_
=tid
o
t
-
=.+tr
I.-Ti
3q
i
o
E a=
*
lp
:
'"il
r
algl
llrEgIEiill
1l[1ril111
+-I
n
6 3. H
'5-Fp
i
+
a3:n=.6'Ear'gileg
il
z ? a
-
co
;
s-+
I il
5
s
3
I
3_
i
=
* a
F
I
F
i
3
i
+
pB
n
f I
I
p
='E
=-X'S
o
:
Fis#
rd-i:
B
qili3I
35
si?
i't
g
ei[giifEiI
i
iiii
*{iiii
IiiritiiiL}3
3 +Be
3
rri+ri
H9.E'->
=azi
;-ii
Fri:riiiarli
iria
iAgi+ir+ri
A'38-e
4.5 o I O
=
E
[
+
L
=
$
f
; 3
'L+E
i
rlr
iE
;er;iiE
$[i
iiE$ililElli[BilIta
B
*
x
=
6
.3
H :
+
rE
R,E
€
A
E-6-
B
r
e'3
*
x-;
a
E
r'=
j
6
ts
e
;
r
r
3
H-*
=
I
€
E
I
I
=
E
+
a
3
:
I
==
i r 6 3
g
g
;
e i i
g
E
1g
i
ii;
f
;FFiis
If
irii
iIla;+n$c;3];iiEil+
E
E
5
5:s
i[sB [[
lii
ariIfFFti[iF[Egafg
i
s
r
cra
6--r<
if
liii*ii
i;
*
+;i$t:
;riE
F.i
HFsai$rc
+n
i
il
a
[
l
ii
r{
a
g
igE
E
3
i
:
*r ?
ri
i[
l;
nBgf
r
+}ti1iiigEigI
gglgli+l;gr-li$iriilir
i
t.5iiliiiiiEE111$1ir1iEgIil$+i11[ai
-B:
jili$s;is:Ea
-:
6-y
y
3,
E
rj
Aq
1
iE?
g
trT
a7n
sn
;',E
+
Qi+ilf+
F
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 78/100
$1il
6
r+Fii;
liFFri
liFli;
afirf
+'i*
e:F*
r
;
F
i
g1Eii
rtEEFlil[B[if
llii1lFEii[iil[lli
i
3:i33'<
:I [;
=
:3
lni
A*:
g ? e n
I';Yar'
E
;
:
i
s
o
*
$iTiilt
ii{
ig Fi:?=4i
5:
ft.iAs[=
iii
i;
[iliE
i{
EtZ
re
I
i1:
i+s iie ii
=
*
I
:
s
ii
a
r
r;e
rE
:
e
i
€
?
i
l
,ri[1tlliFIrEigE111?1EEit?iiiiI
=
r
E';-%
F
rH
t
B
a
5
+
ilq
i
; i
L i
fi:
E I
;
:
E
t
='
r
:
="i
+ r:
€
i
r $E
E
I
q
i
=.=
-{=
.
X.=P 3 i-
6
r-
:
=
-*
n
-
I _ 3
=
$j
{ ; P il:r d Il; _3
F
r
r
i
e
n
: ii
r
=
r
,i
+ r r: ;
;
i ii
E i
I +
I
x,
I
sg
i
i
$[[t
iEE
E
iIir
I
ig
i
$iE
ii+
?=
?1+ii + r
re
=- )
X
o
ld'{ra:5
5 ;
^
o v-.'Die
cAaTF:.D
; JrlSi I ;e:
:r-
{'--a{=T9==
j4.-: '
e''i'21 *1re-3{ci-:
O
i.
='='-.D
TFD _-.a
6 @
o-i$
2 6
I
5
-?
E
0r
o
--
: l: I A
^
-
i=EE rE
r[? isiiirtil:gir*1
rtf$a+;
a*
laT
x
o
H
s ? ? 3 ; ;
a
T+
a
4
a
f +6
E
*9 T+;'c.
i;
.$p{r
_SE-EE_E€r+.'r-o=
*gfr€;;f 3p
a'
N:.fR
1+
$rsgFiigfi+llilIfrlf
i[fifl1iif
a
F
+i
Ff
[€rss;:FFrr[iFiif
cf]iiil+5lE
t
i+
islr[*gFiE:
gifsr+iE
i+fii+rlF;
F
T1 *Nirit,iIfi
i-[fi.Flt
,,E-*+riif+
F
ar
\s*:€fpE+:
s*+i3q3
IE
{$rrE-aa€$
$+I$lgiE
fiFfi{iifi
E
ti' Ss
3
{
+g
:;ii;
n11o
{iiRi3-'<-1
+q
sqi=*
+s+i
3ia'iilr+
.E*3#liafs
=
;ij
"l_a.=i
;f [:
Z:?
[Et#o
.-o,uKo
i,q.
ry
r+*1
i:is
#'
iEIllli
;flq::fril
ir s$il"*r
ci#.
iltiiSrs
[ilsFirlEi
i
*
toisa
;nLE
t;f
ii16q
i15$r;;E*
?
ia
$;ixS*l;qE.a;:-$is
rlE,*:i=xf
a
iE
gsf;"*
3-=}
iF"Li:*;l
:i[*fsf;3
i
6
i:=ri
+72
a
o-;o-i
1z
I s-qs-rii?+i
i
+g
aNgili
+Fi$
r+jE+xE+3
=
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 79/100
*Iil
,
.r.=F
AifS
Ef
I
&B.
='s
q
il
s.;in
5; a
;
$E lii+3
fl+
E
*:+€
s',
i
?
{
i,
r
r:
ieT
r ;
ir
a
tiliE:
ai
i+*n
isBsi
r
_ri
r
*1i.;iii
fit
f,i
F
o r'<toltl
a r;6-^i{F*[H3lggriiF
il5]
[fq $i-
i=
e
eg
3
;
r
i
^t
1=ncrq$=oto
IUA)lpN
?;;r
ite 4;
f
g_
r+;:;i'I[3E-+:B=-F]tt
{*f
gI+
ir=
+x
X
O
-
i
o
J f X A'
-
E
X
-i
-^
Q X
..1-
:
=
-
,)
i_
i' 6 a
:*
\
nt
Ai+
rIf
iia
i3
::n
e
IE
r3&:"'
+r+
$fi
f:f
il
.o,.:3-=fiai
?.eTr+
T*9,i:
i;[
:f f
:18
E,E
;ij3j'd
-ro
-=
=.
cp=
aj-
q ;:7i
fii it
nE_s
:i
;::ifIsFJ=sie=
si="I=
3.83
ez"
A
",
ec
:HqEEE.ieB.i^n?+
i:F-'E
.i:+
,98
;'X
"a
iEiHi;ig+liaii
iieA;
(i3
?7=1
;ril
*
l= '&<rE l*91:.4'
Go"r-
-s&>
F
l.c E*:
q
i+Hilrla#$xia;
;+**+
."ri
+q,r Hri
T
+s.E'+E-r
$
rs
r
a
u
i
E
.*
'
s
*E
r
u
r
+*
r
i
i
* ;
I
r
-
i$*: ilEit r
5-
g
3't.r€
=
r; rr'ti5is
iiriEiur[[l
iialr Bc,r+E; r:
;:
Fil*f
f
r I
s
a
i
s
r;
;
ii-
i
fi:
a
g
1
-"?
a
i;.
i
fi
:
L;:,LE
B
F
i +
i
j
-
--
e=
nti
$i$f[+qrarf+ci
*iai
rg+$i
iri
B
*:
i
=
i
$
t+iE
il*g;,f
iti
f
A$;
iggi
E': E
=
n;
B"- F+'5t
3
F
n
i;
i*l
lrEi+Ergiiiii$igl[ig$giig}1ig
i
I
i
H
* r;3
i
E ;
3tr3i
E
ts
ii ;
+i
3
i
g
5
I
13
t
A:
H
i
I
F
E
I I
q
;
i*q
E
ri3:;
FFa
+3r-d
.aAiiEi€
i.giF;g=i
*
[r$iiili;i$ifiIs
*r:r
s
i ie+rs *
+
[
$iEa*E
+
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 80/100
*ril
=
+i3*=iFrgrE
itI;irE*gtlgitE
i{ieqiBr
I
i.
2f
$
tr
h-
:;3
A; H
f
3 rl^i3l r*l
i
3
i 3
i;*
ils
e Q r
F=
q"-rZ
Ir
f
if
i9
ri
x: ]i
=
T
-
i'i=
^
B
5
Li
zEs
zEa€
[iiititiFE
iilrEi
il i:i
[;[1iE
i
E.iXy* ,
asiE,*irig
tiIiliIiilif
?ii:
ile:H
ii+*
gEi
i
*
if
+
i
E
$ f
L
+
i
r
a
s
a
i
=:;
:"
H
i;
=
i
r: t
i
n
F
i i+
t
I
9.- 7 C€ E 6 :=.=.?:.a FR
U
*R
w;i
H
- a
s.P
E
d
?=-^ I
--+9
s)
sii
i
i i
iiiif
riIif
E
3
iEfr{i
:ii
i
:Bir
iS?i
E6'.n+IA'-
E
'aili'EilglllFiI
lEllBlaillliIilBi
F
3
a
*e ;
t
*
*
tr O
aa 6
0)3oOn"5
i
iiE
+tIfgli rrIeni
Iit
gi$}gIi
iiIlsE3i
c
c
' '
iilriiliEii
qiiliilrigii6$$irr
3
+a
E
ar
B:
}E ?;E
it;6$iiellgi
iiB
1i
i$3
iilEIi?riB$rr
3
t
;,
rr*s
+$
f€q
iE
i
i=r
I
riFi$g5Ell;iiIiE
I
u
=
*i
E
o
i+iiiiii
ii$riiriiiir$Eefi
irr*;isE
Fe
iE
I
ilt$l
r
1ifgF:
€Ei+iirEas$a
liliilii
ii
+$iir$
igii
E
it
[FIEiiE
r+irrnE;[f:
fl
5{i:
;Fi}
ii3
iiEF$[r1$*lf
I
i
H
ii
i$r+:
li
F
i I
r
i
i
F
i
u
f
F
$
t
ii
a
i
a
i
+
+ r
i
s
F
+ri
f
iF
if
;
i
il$rii:ig
i
i1[r:
;i+lrigil];i
iiE;r
ri
itili€gi Iriiiii[[;;iriiiiif F
$r*r;
*1i
IIirsEr?.-rT€E Iffi$
i
E EP.
oa
;s:
*
= =F ff:?* fB
A'6;H
;;+
il;
+i[[*;ii,t
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 81/100
Bril
o
fH
fit'9f1E,E [Eii i
*E
n#
A
fL:
*-
I
-6
A
iii*srrrrr$iE
iEitlBilrefrg*-
I+i
i
=
S
[3E
[=
E-as
lrei?q€
2ilE*
=H
u
-=
i
X
lrgEa+r;
*f1i
;I#is€['iiBgE
ieF
F
{rLFriiE}[:1i+B.fiHiE:i+]i
3[i
a
flr
it=Eignf
+iaf
Ii;if
E
ietir
EE
I r
}a
H
5
x
.
d
g
r.i
=-
a 5
E
E A
lld
+
*
I
r
[
,'
rrqi*it*13E
il3:rqH
iltiitit
#:
g
1
#
3 : +$ t
* *
[
I
:
E
?
; i
H
:
i
+
B
I
e
+ E
i
ariiliiEFiE,
;xiFrf+liiiE
+il
rr
i
B
'
+
i:
i
ilp
i
il I
i
I
aig
+g
E
i
+
t{
f
3+
3
i3i-1?
j
-
=o
n
-
6
#
tr
a
E-1--T:'-iA.a;;H: H
fif
I
qel
A
a
r
i
5e
$E1ElA1BEE+11}g
iEE
iriigii,
1i
(?
r
.a-
F
T
Y
{
m
8
gI
8=
--
d P
(D-
E=
E=
o(D
o=
o(D
g^8
',s
-
U-
=N
E8
B.
-
r
,
e.n
-o
E.H
f,
==_i:=,===_l=-==-l
3 t
1fi
=
E i
s
^
A €
"F
*
I
r
iii
itiislFrai*t5
s;+irss
+E
ilrll
I I:
F:
+
s
*
r
i
F I
;
$ i
I
H
E
I E 5
i d-
+,3-
3
a
fr.t
:
*
[ r I i
r
il
r e +
I
f
fi
i
i i
i
H
+;
s
=
I t rs
E
6
€
a
I
e
i
a
g
e
I
5
f
a
F
"-
H
B
3
+e
+
F;
:
€
il
i
g
$
$
i
I
ifli+Esgiafl=[rEI
q$;'iH"a=l:,:Eu;Ti:
EEgIEErEE[$iflii
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 82/100
fil<
sl5.
o
ii+gliE
r:
i+irui$+iigi+iir$E
ii:' a
i
isi*'i[t
fi +i1i16
]E
fi$
riia*il]]rrr
?
rl.Eae.i
i-iu,l$l
$}
}llllj
f1$5}llilfilgt*lg
;
fi,t;"g;i
+i+r+*;
i
AE
gggiai+ilF:eE;triilir;i+:
E[;
rt;
;,,Ii1
ii
iiliIiiliilillsllsiliil
rE r*i
=
+4f;ei
iE:
o
*
E
s
E
=
ii
rFEliaii+fiFllrii1llll[$ii€ri[lgi
F
i:5
=:i
siI;q
t;s
qE
rid€
#rIi+l
lai++s;}r;
E
i
+
[
B
a;
F +
T
€
i
:
+
g
f ] I
rE
I
ie
+
1ii
;
];
;
5
:
T
r^$ir
F
9';
+r
+aefE
F3gr;
F ed;fr"=..
1*
*
I
*r
-
tciiuifliIc
i*ii
*iIiiFgiiEgfli$i
Fgg
ri
ii$i
$$igilriiii
griirigiirigfl$grig-r
r:
$
2
H
$i.f i
+Fe
i
sE
}E
r
1i
gg€$
iiiiFfliE$iir[EnrE
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 83/100
fif$:iS+[fIfg;iisiHn$fliEf
3qa$,ii8
*rr
ri
iei+sei+iiiriflgiigrifrlfliiistiiiif
g
+E
i11i$gi5;'E
i;;
i;i.iEg5+ifl;ii;liiii*
E
ii#$:
i
si
r
$
i
'
r
i
iiE i ililiiii$ii
lFrei
i'iiiiii
*5{
ri[;isii
r
s$5
F
riE
i'
ri
i
iitiiiiigFiF
[s
$lirErE
$irii3liEi'
uF*
*l
ir
r
i
+iE
r
ir
i
iisE
s+*ei
iii$iiF$i$IiiEi
ilr$$3isi:itif
$iij
;
ni
iFEg
;i;1r.Iiiir
$rE
rrir$1$$iIi5Eifii
Eiiriir$i iiiii
rs+;
s
I
+ E
=
u
r€ E
F
f
:
;+
f
i
=;
s
t
j
i
1i
$
*
f,
r
E
+
i
E
,
s
r:
;
-';
='
I
3
E
*
ir;
;
E
q.ssr$
=
* rE
rsf
f,:'i:
3it l
i
5:rl'
.
5
i
s
Es if'
$
fsii$g
iii,Fi$ifliiF
;
cii-ii
i
r
r
F f
+fliii
$flfiifl*
irii
liiiEiiiir
s
iE i
i;
isiirll
s
'rs
**i*iii
5iigg$igiiiifi'$
fli
*[[gEE
rI
$E
i
:s
ii+fg
Fli
tiifr
rtr:
ei+r+ilsr
rfiEr;r+;gra;s;;is
N
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 84/100
Er#
sr,E
rs#
itIi
Ifl3
e;lfilf*ii
115i
niE
ds
iE
*
;
i:
re
:
+tsirE
iinii
i"6gifflpgiIir
+$$;
a$
a
lH9='t
i;
fi
iIi
gf,; +ii
="Ta
=
s;
Fi;E;[{fii1i
q
5.i
$
rrF[Fi
+ti
lE
ii;fs
gE
g
]rtitri$;s:E,ir
**
:
'
r
q
l:. r
EE
ir
ii
i$ii
i
F+i
i l:
iiii
1r{$ri;BriFEi
i
a=
*
+ i
s
ss
iis
lif
Hilit;,
lrE Ii*E*iils;
Af
lJnEi.;
;
s
* F i
*;
il
I3
*
i
i
s;
I
a
3
;E.
i $; f
i-*
i
F
if
r
iF
'6,5 Fo 'i
:tagi;
F;arl*i,
s?;rai
liiiir iriri;:iiif
iaiiaf
i;j
+ir+r
i+ei
i
lii
f
F
*ri
i
nirillEiiiii,
iigiiliiiEii
9;'J-ID
E ii$ a r
t=3I
e
H
e +r.il r
Pe
frliIF flii; ni-riB$+*i
?
iiFi[[ilrl
i
E
a
i+€
r;
E;;
*+EEr*E
ir;;
3
ilH
ill;gf,5iFg
iiii
isr€5c$rFiFE*S$'
o
=
H
iE
EFirriiri+ra;iigiiiii
i iiiiii$iiiiii
iii$ii
iiiiiiiiiiigig
flr:1ai
gF+rl;i
[:iE;
}fl
l+$i [flEifiiE
i
sril;.{6ii+[gii
i;iig;+l.f:il=g
f
gf,aFig$
ai
rE
$$iriIrgss
i
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 85/100
i Fr 1i=EE
+q
=
ra
r*r[rlleIi: rii]rl igifi
l i
:iiriliri;i,*H
iE
*,;rFlFla+i
$glfl
$ilf
*
3'5 B.P
g'
llf
a
i
+
i
g
[gtr *Eaai
gig
EB iAi?
i:
s
rs
e;;,
ii
5;P
a
ilr
rii*;rglf
;;ii6iiliii$
:
iBa
holt
lEgi}ri
11
[F
15lil1lii15Effl€
+3
i i Ii
ie
i
t
r$=*:
E
={:
*r*;g
*i
j$Af+:
}ir1[i[i
f}E
I
i
einii;g
it3tEia*lf
31i: IiniE it5*1i1;
ii
:
i
r
6
}s
a
r
=
;
i
a
i
i
1ii
r{=*E
*
=i'ir
i*
11i11il'Eliui;f
ii
lI
rtt;
i
€
s
;
i
i
l
}ilir
I E
i
iliill
i
[
[+
r
ra;*
ae
a
i
{
ia:
r+
It::1i:fii
iEq+ffifrlili+
fr
3,;
it
i
E
ra
?q i=+Bs";+;;i*;: s'
s#;;eFr;F*
ii*P*ilei
[giirliqitrti*ifi;[Fri$e$=
#
++gilu
: r; s
rl
'IrH
1'
*uiiaggii[flE[flFiEIr][
E ii[ir$
eIril$i
$is;
riIriiriE;
litii;'iul3H
I
F
i3
nEi
3
EE
i=*ii
rEs+E+iuiEggf,5i[6$f
i
*iIiif
E
a:
I
s-
*
le+if
:flrg
iiEIi$iltEi+i{ier
+
.r:,ri
i;r i;,exEs+*rififtl[ii;if
il tFiir
eirii$i*E+'iii;a*ErisrnBi:
d
[=r:=
i:
€
a
=)
*5iil
f
agrIFi}i1:+e;r
f
.r;;5g
f
=.a
q
I
;;
?
35JA;g:rAiiiif;:EfpBf*=''atE
e
=-=ls
s
iii'rfliEiign$FF
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 86/100
Hrf
il +i
1-
ie;qEI*t=l;t;iif+1ligFi
+Ani?*
f
ril
q;;
$
q
i r
sa
ad
1ilfl8$BE[*E
i$Hiii
i:iEriliriif
?
;
;i
;
ri
i
*;
a
=Eiii{
i
B
H ;
fe
;i
$+ilif[}+gA
i
r
-sE:
ar
5
;-nq5is
irFe-iB
i
x
s
i
r=
3
i;
=8_i;
;
A
il
:
?
R
a;S
+iriri
+t1
liI
Itrii;
H
ili
3+iriatili$i
.FHr-.S
FE:+i i
rii
iiiIiit $giii; rit
ii$ffi$E*E
5*q:
id
s
il+i;3
a
g
31[a
elz
ria;
Efi
3
i+i *r
t;
*A
qt
5,'**i
=[
i
]i*
3 +q;
-23
6
i
i; i ?fF3 *;
=
5
F
+€
q
+
;
q
r
=
g
fi
:
i
i
i.+
+
g
B
E I
;
r
i
7 t
r
=
a
b
c
lz*[+i
iieig
iii
i;* iiiF
*i
iiiii*
gir
iirrli
i+*l
$Bri*iiiiiti
:1I[ai:f
ii;
{
gg
ig11
E1€ iEtlF
IffilIrf[iiEt
r+t:rF
il
i
iFF
iilBlttt*[iii+r3
ErFs$Eigt$$
rt]
*E:
"+;$
F
Is{
s
];
i3$ttilFi}$ili$f,f
;
*=
n
$i
iE
rX'roXK.ry
a;,
3++$iit13f
[[f
i
]t+is+
i;
g;;t
rr
i:ril
irrli iiiiis
iria
il
iE$l
Ig€[si]iiil$Ei[
f
qIsiE
rrf
s
fr;.eri
E
i€]$
r
R
Iiil3
s6
a
Ep-B
B
E
B-s
=
*E
i
E
t;
=
<i.p:$=
r'BaC
II=:
g
;;3
i
;i*rr*$
aii3
r+rigiti$iiitEfS
fI
x^Zqrig
FD
i.'o
6tr;
iaralsSEFss Eris ;Fi=
H'-{JaB-iB**;i
-
inF
is*E$T[I
3g=$giliB
l;
€3r;* liEi
s-rilg
*iEtii$[$f
$i{*ii
fl;
r
*[iriiii]*
it;}
gii*r**arr;er;1+-Ea
=
_F=_ e
_iS
g
E
fLFo
;
&B
&6
6
R 6
2_a-=
[H€]i*t; e
3rF6€
=lHaiEi+i=
rf+n
l*+lr5$*:;euryi=
?
nsi,?;":i;F
a*==*
FFE,Tf
#iFilFaariA
:,
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 87/100
I +6I r-tR
=il-€
qr.
f alQ
=.=
Q
=
a-d <
-rlo
q)
-
-
o 6-
*lf
i*ti
ieii+i
iiiiFeii+iffi igiig;r
i$iii
i
=-v++=
=*ii
i
inliiti,=$
[ii*a
ri
:rug
]€q+$
tr:9<
72
:
+T
,
a
H
{
r
1E
*
ri*ii
$:
ii
lsi
ril
i
I
ir
I
+i$1
[*
'g
i
ii
'
^E
i:
l;ar'
gii1trf;=*rl$is,+as+iiilii;
lIi
+
giin
i=-rg r;+[S
I
ilJ
A
3
]
*F[:
I
H,.B
il e i-_ d
E
i
r
r
=
1=-x
+
E-i
=
I 3 :3 i I
a
=:
I,'i
*
I
=;
5
E
3 *
i
f_
i
i;
i s
iii€F#se
r=,
liiriEiri
iEii
;
=.*D
rE
:?iiIi
giE.
f; raiii:giti
=
]
5 +i,-1?
a
r
qsi
1F;}i95
i
=
+i1rrIit
is$FlrqeiigE * E
rl$
I
3
+
q
n:_ i
3 :
[
+
I.ss
I i
[
3
qa
? fi
=,
g
r;
3
e
E
i
e
I d:
s
lEFgiEiiiiiil$Fii1l[eiFFisgi
rirE
i
=
i 5
*E
s
*
"
n
F
a
+1Ei
E
iilatulp +s
r+irrF
inii6
w
i;
tv
*e*i
; i ?
E
Q *ri;H+H
3
E;
g
*a*iii*
iif I
*i;+[air
i+F$:
{r ig
i+leitFil
fi
sr;
s:rE
E
rigiliiliiigi
i
$ii[;iigi
iiiiiig
E i;;3
t
ts:;
iSfH
5
rq6
d
ac,
o,
Srsi9*ri
i:
itl
Iif f f il;
ei,
r,
i
r
+
il
:
E
€
<
S
-
i
F
u
a-
i e 3
*?
3 i'lf : X
'
i 5
=
r
B.:
=
1
:
i
i
i
$iiirr*$gf5
$ilgggiliiigiii
i*
gil
iiiiiirii
+Is
iit +Ei$i+H
i;
i i
r
i
i
i
iifgis
i
il3E
r;ilitiiIi;-i=*t];i3iE
*i
g
r
s
iiiii
ii€ iilsiEiFi$1
iFil
j+
i
rE
*ilt+iE-=sE;
;
IiI
r='5;
iiln6 I
?
i
lE
i
i
Ai
d
i*;
rF+i;$geH
HEirE
+
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 88/100
Hrf
3;
aiqsi;xi3+=+ri=ii*fl{iEFiiEii
f
iii+$liiilgiii{isifiliiiiilil:ilgi
+5c
E+
t.-ilEI
1: i
;iii€
liE
iicn,^r
:=n
d:
s
:il; lg
jtti:=51;ir*ii+iie==;i;irlq:
:
9
o-s
6.f
: c o 1'-
=
sd 6i
gifA:EA
i*;
fi**:=Fi:
i3
3
1i
13€*
*[s
EF
iii
i]14 ;ia+1ig
+r:
+rIs3 i
l+;=
:Ft E*
ifE I;r:Er,;
5+l+1i
*x
il
ilatt#it
?Q-
l
::J
^
E
;raq
e'nJP.(Dt:F'-g._?
a7-
::-i
-O
=;r
=
-i
6-
c i'-
-
; tx ;
.'
Fi:+s
:
iliilrr=
l
FrS
:
a
a[[*$ArE3
2=<
=
5.o-nr(\o{e{:,^
r.i'-aqF:=9+r'j
iP=' ).D
inE
n
{-[3g$ieigHsFsgIiEgi$liiti ilg
s
g
-
=
6crc
j-F'
?
r
o.il'P*,a
i
r.:-d
?;r;I[E-=l
*u
Eir
s
rXlil+ta;=iiifi}r*3*i=r,
::E+
ie+
E
Bfgf;EgSii366I+=?l3r*$i
iF1r
-R t
i:
sr
a
i;bF;in=B=B="+r$itEE*ii
gEar
'=') o
+a+
=
:ifF-i:;;4.
glr
'c".'d
:r<ar<r7,
Xi3_*3qn,FSa2
+Ei*1
+t,_=
5
=.:Br
F135g;En";;ril:i;s:Frl i 11;ro-
n.
;H
;,?Edr;e*r*+i#3f,
Ln$rEEi-
iiE*
:;
&F<38
ii;
iT
irfi
lTcE-$ilggLEc+gglA
EEi.
1s
i
il
g
:
a:
ii
;
;
f
s
i t r: ;
u
I
$
i{ *i
+:;
6
o
i
P
i
H E
lgrif
liiii;
iiiiiiiliiigiltIri-s
i
r
F
I
g
s
i=se
irEie rirr=*
il; s.',
liiIiiigiii$$gI
s
rEE
*'
iFiI i
$ii
}iiiI;
rcrluF
i
*r*
+B
ii
iiIr
ii
it$ir"*iESrl
t16
ii;li
r
si
i3i
1rrrfiFiIEiifl
eiirH;
ir$$i[i=iiE
rFil[
l+tf
ltriiiEEi[1+158il;ur
riB$r*s
rici;
$
2 e 3
z
a+r
rd
{
d
I
r;:
i
=+;
[+
ag
.$; ii
ri:=[;
3
*g
$.
;
s
3
g
5;
:
i
i r iiE
s--
i;
i
+
SH
--
1E
;
'
i
d
r*ii+iiii
isEBr?iifi*$Fi;E+* i*iE
tl1i+
i
€E
;1i
+aa
il
r
r;
r*lE
l$+t
+{s
f*arFiisi
ra
i
iiar3+nrrFnil;i+=rra;i
:Eii.r;n
E
i
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 89/100
5l<
l=
o
rirrN
;
siii:
ilclii
g
il5
$i5+E+iii=i,*iiet
f
Ed=Q:r,
q
-
iiin
+€
iIlg+[iii
iiitFE
t1;ig
iri*ii]
?
f ;
,"
N E
r
g
15
t3
[rtiii
iiii=irr+qil
*E $srFirg
6i'
i
llu+si
35i
=ili;rl
trti+:
t;IEiF
E
$.
1:'?E
I
r1;;$e
?[i
iaarsi+l;Eitisl+*e$
;fE[
:
+i[;$i
*
:
g
E
iq
i+IE,*
H:+[ri
iitr, : i
:
i F
iE i€
*i
il+9.
;F3;; 3ri
ilriIr
:
:
il;
pi
q
i
=i
;;i,
l
*I i
isii
rql
tgifiil;qiE$I
iigi
S6o-J
=
ag +sq9.
=
1.a
-
=
6
0
=J;-d
=;
;3"rs;
*3i
+illi1;i**rsif
*:$g:i
=iif
o
*
o
S
-.
HR
g
:
- d
=
q
5-
YT ,'Q
[=
gi
i
3
*
,
o
id
E
-
aj
3;
o'o
r
+"
a
i.
g-
3
I *
=
$
:
s::r
=xq,
as
o-;=ili;iiri$liqg;iFaI * 9il
Yi
sil
3il
i=iijiieisr=5Ii:tEas
lsqi
rs
::i
rs
3F;siFiii
lriiilisE:$
iiffi
ur
:;'N
sx H--R
fiI
E.ii
$l
EFs
ii
;:,i:+ii;+$;;ErBIi;:g
iii=
i1 sqS
sa
="qirsgi=ijEvfrgg[::6=i
i
5=+
Nx E.:is 6=. S;5'i.o='S'i;'5U-.6oP=632
.c3l:r
sr
5q$
rr
i+i?s=$;r8.1
i:
i$rEfi53
if
=
f,giiE:ii++Hfg
iilg;.i
g=
ilsa
ui,:
ra=a=ilq
s
i
=5
B.
d
-;iiii*ilEiiiI
iigfl$$5f
rigf
f [i
,
f 9
:r;
tr_{
i
i$;Jg
lFfi+c;E
iixFi.
€ir+ir
i,i*
s
$FrE
-."
uo
I
F$ig+i}iii;
Frifi3
1*$
-
ii;
I
aIE
i-lgiiri
3: B
6
r$:-f
tt=;*
Ss i;g
;i
r \
1i
rq';
n
o
r$ii::
*li;1;=+=
aiiiij
g
it[E
$EI
g
l
t
*3
i
E 6
-,."
^
q
fi
rid 6
i
if Si€i
a
r+=d
s
F-6-'
e
P
i
5
s
d
;
i$:8ls;E
+:
i
5
tA
tE
H
1
E
{i5iI
P +5oa
-l
iFFF,r$
iiii$iiirls$
:
rit.t
ig$igiSt
q"ir-l
a
+1i
i,a
Sta [eS$=
:
g
+i
F
A
FgSIluslrig;'EH I e
fi
i [
ilq=
i 3
"
=
\
;*
-Y
"
I
iS;;grE$rs
iiF€rss
$=
8rEq
fE$[
[iS;
'
Ei:*uigil$fliiiEi*
ifii
$iii
i.qfi
*xB_#8
ts
A
6
+e
^
Es-P
,rC
o.ri
;-6.d
I
E
1*lffir=
i*;
a'3
rE
s :
s-j
r-=
li
fr,r
g;
s r
si{
i
ilstr
aEnr;i
t ;
itg
;
5
F $;i
ESit*
o
?l
o
E{
N
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 90/100
3rf
;=iiH*qii;*rr ;;B;BaF+
s:<i3-ir5r'='
=
f
n'61i
iii
iif
i
flE
rias
i
ii
i iF
rii
r1i
a
$i
I
i
nisrrEs€lli
i;lrriEzsel
i3=tililiSi
7
E
43+3:- *a:
-*ilg:"-91:43=-Ee x;BBogliliiI f
:
+ii+1aii[;rlgir
i
iiFi$g
3Hf13ggl
E
$+
s
)
<
+
=
lr +'o
-
+r
E
q
il€
iiigi
3
I
i
Itt;
$$i
[i
iilE
tE=
E
;
[;€
I
q
i $ile=,i*'
iefi
[+3
i
S
p
;3
B-+iE:*-a+s
r
flEIi$:i;1ii
i1?i[+]s
i
giirj:rx
;(
:
.
,
i:eir$r3
rs
r i
iilrEiii
ri3ili+[
iFl
a
€[;iii
3sl=
ia :;+riias?
i ili;
Se
dzii
;iEE++F=tq;g
aq+silis;1
i3Siis+rrx
i
[::it*3g?[i9
"n) 33o{' E5+
;'55i =Noor;F
ir
eFrir;*EEa
11i1llf3S
ia +Eg$
tF[;i
i;?+rarE
rEis
i
l[1i
$1FF
irs
?lS
ii+rI
6 f; f**ririai
t
I
ilt
Hs
tq
L
i*'n[I;
5
r#eS
i
rr€
trildiIi:$siqarsia
r
$+FEiiii;'
g$l
€
[ii;
F 1a
u
+i*iIi lIiE$}i$ilii ]riii
lgiii}i
F
I
ri
$+qi=
*
€
tile
i
iirgf++i
[g
$iiigf,riliii
i i;:
$ilgi+
lf
iit
[lIn+iF:Ii
$g:iar€ar;ri
euti$ii
r*iiiiiiElg
$r+
$iFrlEli$l$i
I
.eilrs
E
3E{r:gsH?
iil
Nti[1,_il€*+sr
q
iBr+H
F
$
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 91/100
il#
s
:
'ri-=;i
*'$irIa+fgi+E[fillilErlr
fl
*i.;f s
1+
i?e
3:"-q
d
s
r.i
i
; ;
I
=
i ; ;
E
t;3
&18fl19fi0:
?
;a
xs
r;srri
ifjii;i
ii
3
ti
r3s
i
ii1f;:
F
;
1g
*d
€;
:"f+1]5$;ll
i;
r
tg::
iEs
;
irtrrril;
i
:
ns
neiq+?r1:irFII_fr
glsiEf+eiriiIilr
:
a 5i
i ^'c-., -n
5
i,*
an
;
i;rii3
i;aitilll;1$ii$11ili}
:r
9
H
a=
+
*^i9{cr"-oqr-oP=I'56
t- i.= 3
t3
ile-Iililo
i$
D
Lx
a-
$
;r
*
i:
iT$,
,:
rriff::i$;i+i;1?[ili
r
^
;f
lig$f:.;;ia.Ea1=".isE
?* rarEH= i
=l-;.+
Ti5
L9-
1
i
:
i
i*?ri€aElirtFrliS
r5i=r;
d:-.+
a
ssilei;1ii'$iail;f;
r:YHEigrfi5lri
A Eg;=+3{-6r EE-it3:1 3*-}1;E"=rrrd.'r=
s
:iEIr:r
i;
i[=tiairilgi
?*;"lilfil:
;
Fg+;inii;
El*iig;tr E*[iriilt+
:e.
*
;io-EA'E;lg
"=LE33i;biglrf
lrtri:
r,
,
e'"f
6?3rf?*
;fF-;?3B?XFts+i,is*[ET.r
f i
$g
H
5
i€
i
3
t
i
il
*i
+
=
f
i
3
n
i
i
Fd
*
i
T$ i
#
ri$bi;
tiflE$gfaEEir$EiiIis5,l{gti
Fi
S
6'x'5'a
B
H:
S
iI
e-F?=d
5
+*'
uigiiE
ifii59}i
rg
c
r$E
r$rif
r
+i
g * H
H
i
i,
E
iiisiEi
=
[Fts
iqrfl]fi+iifi:gs*il*i
it
r rrs
ri$3[iricEr[FiirIgtii
+r; i+E
3$$
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 92/100
il<
$l:t
o
E
EE il i$ 1iF
*
i:Ei
ii *
[Eii
iBEr:i
*
[s?if
lri,
1
?
il*e
&e
*
iFiE E
;s
*a
rl
3tFIa:sic:#+cii€
?
3 i
iEEi
i
i
liil
aE
11a
[]i
li++BaEElilElEEi[
3r?[i
i
=
=
=
3
='{r
=
* +'
iiAFl+qq
i
rFEiliileiiEili
[]liE
i
ialg
'=u
=F
ra
afi;irilr
r
ie
i riiti=t?i+;
i
a
=;;
;
o
E
=
I
R*
iirreiltl;lltgilirt
iiiE;
ili+r'
igie
+
Hgfil*
n[;
ia':ia:efr
il
gt
$rl l;
g
+;Fi
iliEt'
rf
fit
iE-ii;ritE
rlgi
[EirE$ii t
rE
iti[[
i
3e[iiEE
t'z;r+::
ra:
rii{iit
i;
i i
r
E
sr
=
iiEiittiii1+;ii
irti;
ll
1+i:tiar
s
r.+r#
iaf
i*l?rr:sq?B:=F; ?;
il FliiIaii
LIiii
i?r,
r+*Sii5F;[4"1
E
*i*+TaF+*]*S
I+il**
€ r
i-
ri
i*ii
li
ri$iggiiliili$}lii}i1rii
ri$
flf,
+}
iii
i
i
E
€
i:;si1f,i$iIii5[*l
I
l'
;
ri*it
5i$if,g
=f
F
r3€
E
3.=
ririE:ii$ri+alrilEi
$E rrfEa
i+5irsr
a
F
ili+rr6
iHtE{ili
li*sig+g
IE
+iif
;irlF+
ii
s
rErsa=?*FE
-i;
itlirIiiiilil$f
g}[fl5,
a
r
iE.+'iEg.1iir[$'*iEiiiafrelg:iEEif;.1$<
sEE
H 3 i
ilif
iE€
re
i'v-x
i
it;
i
1E
i
IiE3
rEii[ E
irs:e€ilflis
*Eie
ss
5
issiliEiriririr;iiigiiagigEirgig}ii
n
*
a
c;:
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 93/100
xrf
s,=rB
-s
=?_=;
?
E
"3i
:
'-+:g+iglXIi
;:;
i5fEE+
;,
$tgii$$iA{
riir
atiil
aiE
ir++g,
EBrir+ir
i
s_g._.{?
i1a
s
=r
}
"3
i :€ fE
f
[i
F
;
:
E-;€
*l
E-I
_
c
aar-""--€Eii3aI
xo5x=8.-,*-
*"r::i=f
i,g
i
-.-trI\'g
-i
4
i: 5E:
='
dd
as
6
I+k'.8
:
s
=il"*$
a
:i
E
tE
a
=iE;E
+;-Si
iiiS
=
6
a
;
*=i*
:
' -ir&,
P
s
f:
".i
=
i i IrLi6:?ir t ; i:dFS1;
3-==-J*
srzriisl
iiii
IEii:giiiiir*slIErii
si
iriili
ustt
6E
iE Fti=ilriir?=;iria
:: =
EalF
r3
?*
oiil',"Pi3
ri il[E*i;
ili
I
;
T
'=.TIrri; :S+a il's^ {
xrF+:s3;
ti;f,
i i++nli:*?i;*li:E*r;
sg
+;3
3
iF
iZ=?
t+aat
=e
i
=
g
sn:.:
i
=
aa
:;
E€
B
: ig* i
;a i#+? EiF=*3i;
a.i3=T*itxaii-i
i
$*Er
$g
i
i3as
;;
e
rE
=AI
+H
lgsgi
I*=B;
"--.H rAt =;q+ ?ie{Ifi1iilrt=;;;l;L9'
=.r,1,
f
.oPa-
3:<5 on-oi:g-*E'-+EgE$g;fig
+sil'ilE$filtEililIirli*iil11[Fi
HYP
P
a 6'i
-
:
]i':r*
G
Ssia'P R
.)
r[
;
R
Fq;
i
rs
H
3.+6
: FFi$E
iiE
iiiiF;rsliSii$$+irid
=rF
i
f
itit+;+;:s:r $g
i$;
iE
rii$5[Fif
i*;
$t
i+ii€
*+*rrliiifgi
il+r$$EiiiB
IrEF 9ii
iI
;$ifli
iir$fiiE
1[f]$fls$Fi}iflfE
1
ii;
3
+1,,EIB
i
f$iIli
i*rr+rrr
i;E
+r[+5
i
+3
;
F
H€
iIa
3
q
i:-=itH
a
: .a
sri
rIr=
;
iB-s
13
a..=
=
I
n
d
d:
i
H
I
i
r;
fq
;Fygiisii
EgF:E
o*
iif
rlig.
cs;
iig::+y7ej[]sfE;.
3]iilE',
r3{
:
HFa'ifir
alt;€q;':r;?i;:u#1q;i
q=
r
,E:
ie
i1iliis
riiEigtigi+3 1
i
E+i
f
:iii
iiii€xE
tiaTiF;
iiiiffiE-r
i
i
df?i-E
+1t3EIi
r5i++iilitarti
{
B
i
i
si;831q
s;;irflsItqEiil:
=,
3 s i
6+es*r
qT;iEia'
;?FsT++€##?g$a'+
E
t
i
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 94/100
xrf
i
i$+3
t1g*,
==:
iliiiEaiEia
i[+s];
Ii
iFir r
>e s.1 ;;;
a-e
1I
i i;
=
E
iC
E
^
=
FE
ral
*10
?;
l
r::
3r L
+ri"i+fi
?z
a
rt
+-d;
i
iitiE+i
ii+i$li
i++i
??i
i
+E
;q= ;
?3il8
=;
ir ;
: 1s zi
i
6
a
"
5+i
**=*:;
*figiiri$iIiqi$f,tt[iliil
I
=-H: 3a**
s.F:;n;li ,3r
9q
r
a d
-
a
i l;
V
d
i*
;
i.=
f
=
g
i
q
E
i
E
a
s
s
iiiEr$$lI
i
I
gtililalrsi
sri
igEsiiIiiigi
YA3
rii
z{;Lr
r*i=
^
;
'-
a
-
o
iiEiigi
3
eii I ;
lE
rlrE E
iiEil$3[3
r
EE
3
Ii
1i
1a
i
q?
E
it
g
:a:l[3;;-g=;;
E
ar
gtsii
f3'=i
ila
n€
Tre
e
€:
i
iili
1r
i
i;tiF[
i
q;
s
i
i
ii:
i:
i
igiii
lii+=[
Ii[:
[r+1ii
lE
IlglEi+[51[i
Erilla*58-+:'
rai:
=a3
*a--r
;
d
6 ;6
9
I +ii6 ;
=
3 [ i
t
I
g
e
i
F
$
t
=
f
r+
i
I
i
i€
;
+i i
rFs
e
:
H
]
i
? [
i
$tr
f
"
i i
3 q
E
i
F
B
il
a
i
T
r
E E
-s
e
i;
; r E
ii
i
i
E
r
+ f
i E
F
e +€ ts
i
=
i
fl
i
fi
*
t:
r;:
i I
u
{*
iiii;
iiiFf
f
lsEigii+irirfi
;siE
fei
i
i;*E
g
[fIii
i
rF;F{g#
ai
:,iS
a
r
iiiiiiiiiiiiieiiligii*liiftiiieii
€rr i*Hmsiia;if,iii
{
iiiiFgi
jiiEii
i8>53;
3,EEs*'igtEitil$[i'
iE$iF*r
siEFie
;s
r*i;,
ifliE+r*frE€l'filesE
i++3r[g
=.ii,*ii
.E
Irigi
HEiifi
1
I==i;F$
:;*EiEF
i
37, E
a;
i
ilFE
i
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 95/100
EIf
i
res
r
rtrEsEE
lx
I $s
iiCilf:;uE
;
ffl
t;,r
F
+s
a'*rf
s
tr=
;
?. 1iiiE
+B
+E
='
=6;$f{
[il5E
i
-XP^-X'
i
i
r
I
ii i
i
i
gE
i + ii
i
F
a
+
it
1[ 1i r r
B
r r
3
{
+r
i-
;
r;;ta
;
rriai-e[g
f$ii3
i
niiiF?
I
*E
1
I
i
e
i
i
f
I
ig
q
t
li
i
l:
;$
I
I
I
lE=
s
, s
5
4
ii
3
a
=
E
Ta ?\
l
r;
;
t
i
I r
I
t
[I
?
E
EE +
i
i;
]
::
il $
I
=
=
H
+,
*
-
+
i
i*
liiiliiit
1i*ii16iiilili:ili,iEIll
FeEH-F,
$ * +
i
$
j
;
3i,ii{[;ill
iliE:ig;rrg
fH
E
rs,
=,;
:z
#
a
'j
j
+
b
r r
q
c ?.
i
il
[
[;
$ ;
13Eg i5 i
=
r r
i.
*:
+
3
i
I:
r
3
a
*
?E
al 1in
+;
;
t
ie'
g
il,H
r
;
r-
-
i6
1A$3q
t
H
=,tri
+A
3I.I
rFile
i*;
]E s
ri^P L
rF;*F:
i
?-
+
*
g
i
=
q
=
il
e
+
r
i
EE
iFE
f
:
3
i
g
:. a
I
H
r
e
e
ri
rg
a r
r:
E
r
*r i
il
lE {
1[i$}}iA€
i:
r
a3
5
q
:i1
;
g.E
Iq=
5
H:
il=:
surf
;s
? [
e
a
s
€
++
l
lrE.
ts
+ E :
e;Sfi
*6
q
7;?;*a+a
tl
i
5:
i
fi
i
r
Fe
x
i
1 ilB'
f,iaIiF
fi.fr
I"r+;;E i
i*€
f
+ r?q
t
g
F
rli;
Ffl*r
f
fl$$f
iEn;iiissticE
AFiE
iir.-
i+s€
i l};;
Ex;
if
+{f,iiiE
$i$i$iE
5
i
nsiiiiiiiiiiini
iiiiiiiFiii
;sii3iig$esf,$ $g$$gFiifiu
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 96/100
Hrf
r
ra+iBg{tEiflEtsEItil,a"{i*1€+ii{<if$*
]s
r
Rpr4qS<
li:ggii+;:ii
r+r
iii**E
i;
i:
lar
E€
LF'
qs
i
+= H E
a
"
r
$i,i+[rfie
iii:
r]FIi
tll ii:;i
gc
i.
f ? d
e
iF
i
dl
F.5
5
Etr1T
rd
=
$[*i
+l Egr
i$fl
rg*
L3-+53
=
3
=L:.F
E-s
:
e
i--+5
-,ax_=
*r
q
q
3
a
; i€H il.=-t i3
fr=.e
d
-
3
e.6
a 6
;€33+{r3:
i13
f
3itlii[;s:if,iili3i9i
*a
:
A
o;.+"
=i
3
3o
i
+?=_
="€
3
ii=
tq
F',?i
i
E
*rg
E
a*i
i=
6={nFcP-
3 +6.
H
= =
oo
a
B-=;
is;r
=,=:
g
3 Ft[as-13
ig *[;
i
=
i
H;5i
3;
r;-:
=tls
[1tiirXltti:i'
$li;i
gi
g
I
*si3
a11iffii1[ilgiiiaiigiiilg]il
lgggg
i
i,
€
i+h'-q
5
6
6'i
5a
$3f
;*f
I
r,
?;
ts
o<
B.,)
qi
H
*+&
j;r
E
s
==
*-
3
E
5
O I rF=9tq
?
3=G6?
a'9ts:F+<
a='6'rf6.-Fc
?{
1a?
u
r.
,,
i:
IEa
gg
V#n;
a Lq
rE
*5
9,E
fi
;
tiii: it
1af
3ii3;E1a
=
rf
B:
IiiE:
Hn;,
*iIif
igi
's
3
s=;
E.:
If i**;Eig;
iii
rir:
i*
$i+ii
I
r
s
-:a:3
o-+
Fs
d;s
IiE
ri5
il:E:
$i
1
*FliE,i:tga *+s
s3
6og
*.i=
H
3
A
T
o
u
-,1
a
n
=
g
{
E
(D
o
-
IL
FI
It
-
-a
fl
F
vi
t,l
(D
S
S
t
(D
rl
rrl
iiiri+1irFariffi
i
iti[i[iEiE
iiii i
rsi3EiE+Fiiggilr$
tf
lilriiisi€
sIi*
glil-aeililEr;E#51
:
;
E
s
il
a
r
i
[
il
$
i
:
i=
F
*=
B
rs:
ri Its
=E
le
=,
E.? ?
r1F;
1[E
E
I5E ]3
[
1;
q
ilE f
i
*
I
=
#
e.3
i
]
;
E;
e
3r?
7?
si.f;
F
r?
g
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 97/100
*la
+8E.il821=.s.:.=B
=9Ui
n
o
: ::l + =
6
Zn
3
+
r0
_
l-
I
9.
a
fEEiirCnF:41-
fifIeIt
BIEe$fE1:'g
:;B€
:a r
.)
T
()
i 2
-
F=
5
q
c
r
a
=<
: x
Efi
i[3 +
i
i€?]r[g*$ii1+i
ii
r1+E
s
q*
+e€-
crl F 3.".
ro
; 3i?
rt
*?Liilli
;+a
i
X
1t*;
B
i
rri
a
i
i
s'r
r""
IE$a
e#
i
it:
rli
r-as;i
r iH
g+;
$*ia
"r;
[=
+e
=
o-Y i:"'.D
-a-dai
d
o,
"1:3j
Fi
E n; gf=
E
*e:
a
I,=,H'+€
;
t=
:
il
gigtiitiaEi$[
*rf
1irui;$ir;
+3ii
iii
ririiaiiiirri
li;il$:fgilf*ilr
ii$
ir=i:i3$iF33,
€
:g:il[ii+i3;t:+=
ii3
ii==:
iiIi>,"-
-:'.-
ir =-=ial=I;Io--i
c=+
=E.q{E.,FErit}
ii+i5Ef iii:i5}:
ti}
i
q
aD
-
"ilf,f/?iggrT;=
il=na;&aLdq+iq^'r
ra
lri$+l*+il[ai
iip+$rf=i]iisrii
llr
-+?irS*i+=Es
Eei:=[**B:ii"fEfF +F;
^
5
o\ i:*'cra
g)
J
5 6-
H:e
qei+5rF
?T?t
?Hi a?rf[=5fif;E$T
il';*
1$r€ iirsa ;liEr++i r*gisirg5i
$
a
r
i
fr
Fi
i
r* ir $ ?E x i [ [i
i
9
r
i$if
H
$F
ii i$
[
i
e
t [
*
r
fr
i;
s
i
a
s
*
s
E
a:: i+ rG
i FE
FF
*'{
i
[
3;
il +[
if$Fi
$frFEirE IiflE
ii r
E
iTr
[Ei
$iFi1
iEiiii
i'
ig[f
i*
iii
if
iiiii
I
Fi
$aHlrs
*e
EE-
I
1*+
i=l$esEslEiBgii*X
sri$if
E
gii
irgi$fl[
[igi]iiii:
]r
rE
ei E
*uEE[;ir
r*$EE
+[UlFiEEiiiFig +E
Sgrri:
;3
5
&+a,1:+3
+:
$ 1E
l:Fi;
i
r;
;
i rlF
E
:;
F
;
iel[a6EHaq
-'r
g"3i3;
B
H"[[ii+g3;5
i:-ni 5 6'-6
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 98/100
ula
i
irF+p-
E
aB-a
rr
SEfi
=
;
1i:
-;E
1il*E;
i: f=i:t
I
:- 6
=.
D
.D
-
l 5
=
l:'v
:j.,,i.
rD
=.
.^
T 3
Q)
I
o
v .- o ;
=
-)
.)
5
=
.o
E
'r
5
-;
K
"
3'{f
i
iEi iiE
iiil:
*i
ili
f
iE
isi}ii
E-
9?
=iq5:
3
f iEI[+Lgii?iE iii;qi+err+rrii
rbi'ii
i+Es Ei+
;
{:
B
r=qr
agEiri+3li
+i-t i3i-i;
'o"^v=+='
d
b
3i#
E
6
a
e,ie-q
I
se.*H
ri t+iE
:
B
:=iq
I
E i;
€t'€tai:
a*3iEi
iiiii{===a'a-cs;ae
ise
'o
=?R2:aZ
=^i.
=1=
o--T=aUiA*;a*TFO.u_3r
63
rrfHirt
€
rilt :
;
?
[ei
i$H
i[.5;
Iiri[ir
s;
Z"y+iiE
iEE
rie
ti13
=4i.L+=-E?
q3
3
ilirE
i-
Tr'rar+? E
3i;:
5
€
=
1i?ifil
ieiIiL*B
il
gs
Fiir=
[
e
ri+E
i*
FiF'tliaE
+fs
n
niB
5
r I
rr
e
6rirS:
iarE=:,
r+[Ei3ii137[ir:iai
i*
;tiEiliE
iiirri
iIliEitEti*;iiEii
R
ir
rFi'u*
gIiii]
E
i+fiEEiEitiuiii ir
A
E
OE
C
3
f
gi
53 6-=
Itx.lAEL
l;;3ig
iE33:";lFE:'iFe+e
aia
g,i-
;
[gi
i:
r
egi$sr
:tsiEH
i9i;r
Iiri3
]e
i$
*iiriIiiiFi
iriiE
iE
iiFe,,*;
i+l$i,F'rs
s
rrg-s;rilt
3
i3ii
*Fi
1i$-nla:i iEi-&iE
*3:;.
:
+
$F
re
i
$
rBir$ ili
lfi
ig
l1
riiBii
fi
I1
Ii fi
=,8fi
$
ralfg
l
i;; *n
Ei is
=
i,.s
i
i:n
a .Iig*:i"
n
E
s
5
il
Y
:
s
g
r r u ;
*
r [:
*
i n
q
I
A€
g"3
;"+
$
f
i
i
g
[
1
jE:AtsHg
lsLsfr€i:5i3a:i
$ii
a
Fi$iiEFsEE[gg$$iil$i-Fi]r,
i $ iill
I
1rf
€
iai+lr:
nlri:
ilf
1g;
iri
:
ru
F+r;g;;g
rH Ff,6
=
=
ill
re$tii+irfie;r{
rE
+[i$rtrei
3;=7eic
rs
[$-3
g.Id
A
I
e
A
;g
";tF=:
+]:,
16
:3
3
E
i;1:
t
rr
Ix
Hsg
[+e
i;lf,$FrtlE
r*
EliitE:itii
i
Fo &+
E^
;
=
-o
D,,-=
Q
E ;1Ag [€
E 3:
*r*r aiIg
er$E
ii i
r}ii
*EEF;i
Ii$F€ilrlFiFi
igli**Etsii
-- ;rP l9
q
iEJ 33e I
=
g
ili;
^,T+q
P qE
"
* 9Zd=A1=
.i;
;,
=
r;.E
==
f
i;A['ritjFili :1iig
=
i 3
iAI
i'+.E
=-
+Ti*
e;ff3?+HirrsrLrsilLFi
+FI$giI
g;
i
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 99/100
*rI
n
5
r
q
6
{
?lFE r
3
r;
g
I
i
+i
f
3E
.
E i r
i
+
}g
1l n r
$
I
il*^SiAtiil
=
f"iE,;?6
*A=#?ta
g
r *r
i
il*:
E-
BT
5
o
E
;
r
,.l
6-
=
o
e
'
c
i.
5
+ a
-
I
6
t
i
T
<
[ :
=
I
.
T
.
a'"
']:
?F Fl
t
ii
;-.ai
=
€
$;
ig
r"iri
#
i
g
*t
7
i
2;o-
=
t
i
iiFi
ii i$F
[r
=:
i
a E
i
r
i
i
i:
xB$
iq
r;
=
]
i
i[giq[:::ti1&*q
ilr
il$
H
i3f
+*,Iiit
i.s$irrirlctiIi[[t
iit€ig]iiri
n :
iit
i
hi
D E'
='o-
T
g
r a,E ig
r
le
i
3
3
r
q:
il il r };
F
E
i
# t
i
f,
a
;
:
1r
r
;
F:
€
a
i 1
e
q
I
=
il
i I
a
ei [
q
I
,H
n I
e
; i ; 3
I i I i
?
i
2
F
1$[1tl
1ili13E
iiii;
tgriEqf
lilEg1E
1i
1i
iEii
1ii
1I
I
il}
lgE
11'
ii1F
a
i}
I
rF
s
m
i€i
il:
iiil?i+€Fiei
+'Fai
i
i
i?ri
i
il$E.d5,€
$ s
*rr
=;
iliia
[sE
E
ili
g
+
;]
?;
iigs
i#
5 i i
i
-
i
iE
1*
i€
f
g
i
iE
i f
i r
;
H
i; i
i
I i f
+,
n a
I'd s=-
ri,
i
r
r
1
r,ii
iiilif,{igiiF[$i
il$i
$$ii
F[ii
-r
f
b
=.1r9 io
6
0-P
g
f'.
*:
=
fi i
:
=;E
5
H
r:
i
rrq'lii:
*
q
*
a
r:
-
iiH iilu
ti*t
*r
=
ilc
:iF io, f
5'
H
n
B
:
H
3
=
i +
e;
=
tsE
*
B $.i
=
i I
[€
]
[
{
i.E
i
i f5
:,
i
=
=
g
k.gl
=-
r;4
''$iii$E$iFSFEiil[il;
IlE
ruH;f
iqie
i
IEE
rFili
xfEigsFFtil1
lrE
iiE
Igi
$FiE*i
i
iiiais
lfE iri*;
+g;Bii€l
itiE*i$i
*
:,
=-ite
a=;S
[6
?"S+d s s
p
{
sF
itFi*ili$s
ttifi: ilg;t;i:
+rre
iiiilii
a
qe
iiliFI
1*iil*Ei+igiFiiii;inrr
il
ar
ir
iugr*i{iIi;,s;
irrBillfF
i
fisgET;
Q=r'dro;LaiiH[;6gi;nF
q
n+;:r*eEFs
filFE
;
fs++F++I
F
7/23/2019 Chow - The Protestant Ethnic and the Spirit of Capitalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/chow-the-protestant-ethnic-and-the-spirit-of-capitalism 100/100
Brr
e
?: i3=.$ 6
3'3 u :
? f.
g
ee.i
H
oN<+3
2
'=
+*r
e.=.H
*
B
;
E
{
+
$;
E
;
r
f;:
l€
[ 5 i
i
f
f
g
s
r;
r
E
3'
'a
E
k
E H 3
6
I
r
a'
;
tE
I5;ii
i;
esi
i
r*
r;a=i:l
a
iif
F=iiiirir
5
E
ni
B
isiE
i+i;
*E
gf
r
r
ilF
r 1a
+
i
+i*$$
i
iii
-
t;
a :i
a
5Y.\
ii
t$$i
iiEgiii
i
liis1
[
i+
1
1i
i
t+i
iiia
li
r
iE'l?sH
3:
E
i I
i
€
+
*i
fl
fl
3 i
.-
r
F:
E
;
o.
e
s
F r i 8
j
i E ts
;=fi
L;
z
a
o-
E
I
m
i:
1
i;
q,i:
i;
-+
=
u
3
o
+ i
:i
g+$;;*is
ir
riE
g;ii
iifiIiilgFiiE
lii[ri
E
$:
I
3
E
S
I
$
f
m
I
i
*
3
#
i
;
r:
q
r
r
r 3;
t:
r
H
r
il i
r
i
t:=
Jr
f
s
+ s;
e
E
g
E;
i
};
i [
*5
=
$
E-c s
=
x:f
H
i;
=?R
o-o
{
B-a
o,o;
Ss
E.
*f
g.E
tH $Es
ugr+*ilgil:t_=="jEf
*e{i*i,
ail;r,
i *=_:r
a;
E€
r'::;
=
is
r
=E
i
i3E
iri
*$f
iigflF*igif
i
if
x
=
*A)
A)
x
qliEsA=
lii lis-iiir
s
&i
..=i
:E
a
i*: =:
i3
aail
E;+i
+1
q
::E:
=
=fii
;iEi$irsfflifltiFei
;
iE
i ilgl
rr;+riIig
giif$ifl*lIuuirE;
E
rEi$
+
ii
r
;iEi$5;E-
8tf,B+s9rsE=+*ds
€
ts++
s
+ r + a;
.
i
f
3
[H ;=f;
E
i;
E
g
r 1;
i
I
r
i
E f
i
+q:
+i.trrrgi[
$ii
i3;
i
+€
[EE
s
ii
I
j
[;-
3
-E
il
r
i,
r r rE
"
+
=
+
i
+; ;
$
*
ifi
:,=
::
i
-