Chemistry and Materials Research at the Interface Between Science and Art 2009

7/29/2019 Chemistry and Materials Research at the Interface Between Science and Art 2009

1/35

1!

CHEMISTRY AND MATERIALSRESEARCH AT THE INTERFACE

BETWEEN SCIENCE AND ART!!!!

Report of a Workshop Cosponsored by theNational Science Foundation and the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation

July 67, 2009Arlington, Virginia

!!!

Co-Chairs

Marco LeonaDepartment of Scientific ResearchThe Metropolitan Museum of Art

Richard Van DuyneDepartment of ChemistryNorthwestern University

Steering Committee

Barbara Berrie

Scientific ResearchDepartment

National Gallery of Art

Francesca Casadio

Conservation DepartmentArt Institute of Chicago

Richard R. Ernst

Laboratorium frPhysikalische ChemieETH Zrich

Katherine T. Faber

Department of MaterialsScience and EngineeringNorthwestern University

Antonio Sgamellotti

Department of ChemistryUniversita degli Studi di Perugia

Karen Trentelman

The Getty Conservation InstituteThe J. Paul Getty Trust

Paul Whitmore

Department of Chemistry and the ArtConservation Research CenterCarnegie Mellon University


2/35

2!

!

!"#$%&'(&)'*!%*!+&!!

!"!#$%&'!()$**+,-(

"!!&.%,/0$#%&/.(

#!!

1,+.0(#2+33!.1!(45(*+%!,&+3)(+.0()%,$#%$,+3(#2+,+#%!,&6+%&/.(/7((#$3%$,+3(2!,&%+1!(/89!#%)(

$!!

1,+.0(#2+33!.1!(:5($.0!,)%+.0&.1(*+%!,&+3(0!1,+0+%&/.(+.0(+1&.1(

%&!

!1,+.0(#2+33!.1!(;5(*+%!,&+3)()%+8&3&6+%&/.


3/35

3!

%,%)-!./%&+-00"12&

@4!/JU45.7!.@1.!61;4!


4/35

4!

.*!1'3-)!.'*&!

.!-7!122!.//!417IQ!17!/04!N12;7!.@9/6422/0>/9GfX=8LP422/0?/9;7@/[email protected]/94g&([email protected]&(A1A49>A,M>!!

F!

CHEMISTRY AND MATERIALS RESEARCH AT THE INTERFACE BETWEEN SCIENCE AND ART!

7>?@(4(A(,BCBD(C>EFGHIJEKFGHEGILNOJ(KMBK(IFGP>QJH(CGRJEORBF(>DS

TGFCBK>GD(BUGOK(BD(GUVJEK(W>KMGOK(FJNO>F>D?(B(HBCIRJH(OHJQ(KG(>QJDK>TL(KMJ(

I>?CJDKH(>D(B(IB>DKJQ(?RBHH(IRBKJ(BKKF>UOKJQ(KG(1JFCBD(BFK>HK(2BDH(XJFK>D?JF(

BDQ(QBKJQ(KG(4YZ[@(\=MGKG5(%MJ(*JKFGIGR>KBD(*OHJOC(GT(+FK](


5/35

5!

540.


6/35

6!

5/0749E1.-/0!.45@0-\!8


7/35

7!

i910,!C@12240G47!-0!.@4!M-42,+!.@4!,4E42/A640.!/M!1012I.-512!.45@0-\!O@4!,-75!O@-7!94A/9.!5/07-7.7!/M!745.-/07!M/5


8/35

8!

!"#$%&'(#))*$!*&+&

0"!%1."$+&"*3&+!1-)!-1"$&)4"1")!%1.5"!.'*&'(&

)-$!-1"$&4%1.!"6%&'#7%)!+&

! 04!/M!.@4!M-97.!7.4A7!-0!7.


9/35


10/35

10

A9/547747Q!10,!.9107A/9.!N-.@-0!10!19.N/9;Q!7!!

F0!1,,-.-/0!./!.@-7!J9/1,!044,!M/9!1,E1054,!1012I.-512!.45@0-\!F6A9/E4,!7-G012!16A2-M-51.-/0Q!@[email protected],!.45@0-\!]04!/M!.@4!64.@/,7!M/9!/9G10-5!1012I7-7Q!=H3=Q!@17!401J24,!,4.45.-/0!/M!6-59/75/A-5!16/


11/35

11

`/N4E49Q!.@494!-7!1!9412!044,!./!A49M/96!7


12/35

12

61"*3&)4"$$%*6%&8&

-*3%1+!"*3.*6&0"!%1."$&3%61"3"!.'*&"*3&"6.*6&!


13/35

13

.@4!/JU45.!10,!/!*G1-0Q!5


14/35

14

A@I7-512!A9/547747!-0!5


15/35

15

`/N4E49Q!.@474!.//27!@1E4!2-6-.7!N@40!1AA2-4,!./!10!/JU45.Z7!,4.49-/91.-/0V.@4I!5100/.Q!M/9!4W16LA24Q!0/0-0E17-E42I!A9/J4!1!A49M/961054!A9/A49.I!7!=


16/35

16

61"*3&)4"$$%*6%&9&

0"!%1."$+&+!"#.$.5"!.'*:&+!1%*6!4%*.*6:&&

0'*.!'1.*6:&"*3&1%;".1&

! 0!1,,-.-/0!./!24190-0G!6/94!1J/


17/35

17

C


18/35

18


19/35

19

A94,-5.!,4.49-/91.-/0!51


20/35

20

%3-)"!.'*&"*3'"3%1&.0;")!&*


21/35

21

G4/G91A@-5Q!10,!5


22/35

22

M9/6!6


23/35

23

)-$!-1"$&4%1.!"6%&1%+%"1)4&(-*3.*6&.*&%-1';%&!

@494!194!5/07-,491J24!,-MM4940547!J4.N440!.@4!^0-.4,!=.1.47!10,!H


24/35


25/35

25

1%+'-1)%+&*%%3%3&('1&"3/"*).*6&)4%0.+!12&"*3&

0"!%1."$+&1%+%"1)4&.*&)-$!-1"$&4%1.!"6%&!!

2.@/


26/35


27/35

27

";;%*3.,&"(

"33.!.'*"$&1%)'00%*3"!.'*+&(1'0&&

#1%"


28/35

28

10,!7I049G-7.-5!4MM45.7!10,!.@4!40E-9/0640.!,


29/35


30/35

30

";;%*3.,(

='14,!H907.!HO`!or9-5@!h1J/91./9-H907.q069>A@I7>5@46>4.@R>5@!!

!!!!!!!!

!t1.@49-04!O>!81J49!

X/[email protected]!^0-E497-.I![4A19.640.!/M!P1.49-127!!=5-4054!10,!H0G-0449-0G!!&&&(!C16A4,


31/35

31

E%"(@&@E%,($!

!34,

?17@-0G./0Q![C!&()')!B@/04+!&(&L$#&L'D($!81W+!&(&L'$$'!UL,42104Iq0G1>G/E!!e>!O@/617![-5;-07/0!?17@-0G./0!=.1.4!^0-E497-.I![4A19.640.!/M!B@I7-57!10,!*7.9/0/6I!!B]!:/W!'#&$%#!B![1E-,![-2219,!!c-9G-0-1!O45@![4A19.640.!/M!H0G-0449-0G!!=5-4054!10,!P45@10-57!&%d!*!X/99-7!`122Q!PC+!(&%d!:215;7J!c*!('%!B@/04+!)#(L&"%L#D%#!81W+!)#(L&"%L#)D#!,-2219,qE.>4,

[4A19.640.!/[email protected]!!P1.49-127!=5-4054!10,!H0G-0449-0G!B9/G916!!)((!?>!^0-E497-.I!*E4>!!H2!B17/Q!OK!Ddd'$L()%"!B@/04+!d%)LD#DLD)'(!81W+!d%)LD#DL)D#$!!5,-9;q4,

!c-5;I!i9177-10!!^0-E497-.I!/M!F/N1![4A19.640.!/[email protected]!"()[email protected]!:2,G>!F/N1!C-.I!F*!)&&L%&d#!B@/04+!"%dL"")L%"d&!

E-5;-LG9177-10q4,!`122!!3

B@/04+!s"d!(D)!)$)!))(#!81W+!s"d!(D)!)$)!)'!;40R1;1@9-6q@/.61-2>5/6!!F/1001!t1;/4,

CHEMISTRY AND MATERIALS RESEARCH AT THE INTERFACE BETWEEN SCIENCE AND ART!


32/35

32

O16-!h1774.49!C2194!B/9.210,!=.1.4!^0-E497-.I!*77-7.10.!B9/M477/9!/[email protected]!B]!:/W!D)%!B/9.210,Q!]3!dD&(D!B@/04+!)("LD&)L&$$D!!52194.qA,W>4,

e/@0!h/6J19,-!C-.I!^0-E497-.I!/M!X4N!j/9;!a!C-.I!C/224G4![4A19.640.!/[email protected]!%"$.@!=.944.!1.!C/0E40.!*E40550I>54,

?17@-0G./0Q![C!&()')!B@/04+!&(&L$#&L'())!M1W+!&(&L$#&L'$$'!5L61-047q0G1>G/E!!e400-M49!P177!?-0.49.@4,04NJG/E!!=16-9!=>!B1.42!=40-/9!H,-./9!

*95@14/2/GI!P1G1R-04!"'L"'!""9,!=.944.Q!=.4>!"(%!h/0G!F7210,!C-.IQ!Xj!%%%('!B@/04+!D%$L#D&L"()(!W%D!716-9q195@14/2/GI>/9G!!`10042/94!3/46-5@!X4N!j/9;!^0-E497-.I!F07.-.


33/35

33

i4/9G4!=5@4949!B9-054./0!^0-E497-.I!C@46-512!H0G-0449-0G![4A19.640.!H0G>!w!HL"%d!B9-054./0Q!Xe!($)##!^=*!B@/04+!'(dL&)$L)'$(!75@4949qA9-054./0>4,

P1


34/35

34

";;%*3.,&)(

='1(+/*F#(%'+?#*61%#,1#!!

*BFEG(3JGDBQ![1E-,!`>!t/5@!=5-40.-7.!-0!C@19G4Q!O@4!P4.9/A/2-.10!P


35/35

Documents

Chemistry and Materials Research at the Interface Between Science and Art 2009