Charmonium above (3770) Study of resonance formation in energy regime above (3770). CLEO probes direct production of “new states” via coupling to electron-positron

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • Slide 1

Charmonium above (3770) Study of resonance formation in energy regime above (3770). CLEO probes direct production of new states via coupling to electron-positron collisions Constrains possible quantum numbers (as does production in ISR a la Belle/BaBar) Take advantage of recent scan to locate peak of D s production cross-section in region between 3.9-4.3 GeV c.o.m. and study new charmonia. THANKS TO BRIAN HELTSLEY & HANNA MAHLKE-KRUGER, FROM WHOM I SHAMELESSLY LIFTED SLIDES WHOLESALE! Slide 2 Charmonium, retrospective J/ (3097) observation (1974) ushers in modern heavy-quark era Spectroscopy of states below threshold generally conforms to potential model expectations Belle ushers in new era looking at mass recoiling against strange-meson states in exclusive B-decays X(3872), etc Recent charmonium Renaissance; CLEO-c well poised to contribute! Slide 3 (some) recent CLEO-c charmonium papers Measurement of ee (J/ ), tot (J/ ), ee [ (2S)]/ ee (J/ ) hep-ex/0512046hep-ex/0512046 Two Photon Width of chi c2 (submitted to PRL) Observation of the 1 P 1 State of Charmonium Phys. Rev. Lett.95:102003,2005Phys. Rev. Lett.95:102003,2005 Measurement of Branching Fractions for J/ l + l - Phys. Rev. D71:111103,2005 Phys. Rev. D71:111103,2005 Branching Fractions for psi(2S) to J/psi Transitions Phys. Rev. Lett.94:232002,2005 Phys. Rev. Lett.94:232002,2005 Slide 4 Comment on J/ (3770) DDbar CLEO has now determined (3770) DD/(3770) hadrons ECM=3671 MeV evt yield (x1000)ECM=3770 MeV evt yield (x1000) D(hadronic-DD)=(0.01+/-0.08+/-0.4) nb Open charm production nearly saturates (3770)! Slide 5 (3770), cont. Almost saturates CLEO has published: Dipion transitions to (1S) state, submitted PRL Radiative transitions to c,1 state, submitted PRL But not hadronic charmless modes (30 modes in two analyses) Phys.Rev. D73 (2006) 012002 Slide 6 Slide 7 Pre-CLEO cross-section tabulation (PDG) Slide 8 Eric Swanson, hep-ph/0601110 Slide 9 How do dipion transitions compete with allowed DD decays? Slide 10 CLEO study of charmonia > (3770) Search in dipion (or even dikaon transitions): X (J/ ; for both neutral and charged dipions. J/ decays leptonically, resulting in very clean & distinctive final state. Complications: Tails of Breit-Wigner resonances lurk everywhere E.g., some of observed (J/ final state at high energies may be either tail of (2S) or ISR radiation to peak of (2S). Former calculable, latter distinctive by missing energy / momentum-imbalance carried by missing ISR photon (typically down beampipe). Advantage: Opportunity to calibrate systematics Slide 11 Note: ISR photon not reconstructed; distinguishable on basis of missing momentum Expectation Slide 12 Y(4260) reconstruction Data taken directly on peak (13.2/pb), part of a scan of 3.97 4.26 GeV center-of-mass range. Note: not enough data to measure intrinsic width of putative resonance (88+/-23+/-5 MeV, BaBar) or mass (4259+/-8 MeV, BaBar) Tabulate contributions to (J/ J l + l - final state, look for excess beyond contribution expected from (2S) + non-resonant processes Cut on missing momentum to exclude ISR (2S) contributions Slide 13 ( (2S) ISR off-scale) Slide 14 Slide 15 Compile observed cross-section as function of c.o.m. energy Slide 16 Dipion mass distributions look Yan-like Slide 17 Search for 3 states in other modes Extend search to include many other modes, including hadronic transitions to (2S), radiative and hadronic transitions to c states, dipion transitions to phi, and other hadronic transitions to J/ No signals found in any other modes; upper limits set on (BR*cross-section) Slide 18 So. Slide 19 1. hep-lat/0512029 [abs, ps, pdf, other] :abspspdfother Title: Y(4260) on the lattice TWQCD Collaboration: Ting-Wai Chiu, Tung-Han Hsieh TWQCD CollaborationTing-Wai ChiuTung-Han Hsieh 2. hep-ph/0511107 [abs, ps, pdf, other] :abspspdfother Title: The Y(4260) as an omega chi_{c1} molecular state C.Z. Yuan, P. Wang, X.H. Mo C.Z. YuanP. WangX.H. Mo 3. hep-ph/0510228 [abs, ps, pdf, other] :abspspdfother Title: One Explanation for the Exotic State Y(4260) Cong-Feng Qiao (GUCAS) Cong-Feng Qiao 4. hep-ph/0507177 [abs, ps, pdf, other] :abspspdfother Title: Possible Molecular Structure of the Newly Observed Y(4260) Authors: Xiang Liu, Xiao-Qiang Zeng, Xue-Qian LiXiang LiuXiao-Qiang ZengXue-Qian Li 5. hep-ph/0507119 [abs, ps, pdf, other] :abspspdfother Title: Suppressed decay into open charm for the Y(4260) being an hybrid Authors: E. Kou, O. PeneE. KouO. Pene 6. hep-ph/0507062 [abs, ps, pdf, other] :abspspdfother Title: Four Quark Interpretation of Y(4260) Authors: L. Maiani, F. Piccinini, A.D. Polosa, V. RiquerL. MaianiF. PiccininiA.D. PolosaV. Riquer 7. hep-ph/0507025 [abs, ps, pdf, other] :abspspdfother Title: The Possible Interpretations of Y(4260) Authors: Shi-Lin ZhuShi-Lin Zhu Recent theoretical interest Slide 20 1. hep-ph/0511005 [abs, ps, pdf, other] :abspspdfother Title: Quark--antiquark states and their radiative transitions in terms of the spectral integral equation. II. CharmoniaV. Anisovich, L.Dakhno, M.Matveev, V.Nikonov, A.SarantsevV. AnisovichL.DakhnoM.MatveevV.NikonovA.Sarantsev 2. hep-ph/0411291 [abs, ps, pdf, other] :abspspdfother Title: Leptonic widths of high excitations in heavy quarkonia Authors: A.M. Badalian, A.I. Veselov, B.L.G. BakkerA.M. BadalianA.I. VeselovB.L.G. Bakker 3. hep-ph/0410361 [abs, ps, pdf, other] :abspspdfother Title: Charmed quark component of the photon wave function Authors: V.V. Anisovich, L.G. Dakhno, V.N. Markov, V.A. Nikonov, A.V. SarantsevV.V. AnisovichL.G. DakhnoV.N. MarkovV.A. NikonovA.V. Sarantsev 4. hep-ph/9507407 [abs, ps, pdf, other] :abspspdfother Title: Do psi(4040), psi(4160) signal Hybrid Charmonium? Authors: Frank E. Close, Philip R. PageFrank E. ClosePhilip R. Page And. Slide 21 Summary Confirm BaBar e + e - Y(4260) J/ pb New observations of e + e - Y(4260) J/ and e + e - Y(4260) J/ ( =23 +12 -8 pb and 9 +9 -5 pb) Similar dipion transitions from (4040) or (4160) states not observed. Early results favor hybrid charmonium interpretation. CLEO intends now to exhaustively study particle production in this energy regime! Slide 22 Slide 23