Upload
ngobao
View
217
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
�
�
10
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
INTRODUCTION
Review of literature gives an understanding of the previous studies that has been
already done on the awareness and attitudes about packaged drinking water. The main
aim of review of literature is to know what has already been done about the packaged
drinking water field and how all drinking water studies relate to earlier researches. This
overview of the findings of previous packaged drinking water studies helps us to identify
general patterns of the findings and the conclusions that have been made. It provides an
insight into how the study of consumer’s attitudes towards packaged drinking water and
their awareness of its impact on their health in the southern districts of Tamilnadu is
similar to or different from previous studies at national and international levels. This
review of literature suggests that majority of consumers do not understand the crucial role
of packaged drinking water regulations in healthy living.
Gabriel (2001) in his study has revealed that over the past 25 years bottled
mineral water has climbed into a position of power in the world market. By the late
1990s, the bottled mineral water market was growing three times faster than soft drinks
as the major beverage selling substance. He also reported that the world market of bottled
mineral water has grown quickly and is considered as a global billion dollar business.
The bottled water consumption has been steadily growing up over the last three decades
at the global level and it is one of the fastest growing and the most dynamic sector in the
food and beverage industry.1
�
�
11
Shrivastava Brajesh.K and Alam Massod (2007) stated that the total production
and cumulative water consumption of various treatment units used in water treatment at
Rail Neer Plant, Nangloi, Delhi meet the Bureau of Indian Standards specifications for
packaged drinking water” (IS : 14543 : 2004) and various amendments incorporated till
Feb, 2006. The treatment system comprises chlorination, activated carbon filtration,
pesticide removing system, softner, ultrafiltration, reverse osmosis, marble chip filtration
unit, micron filtration, UV disinfection and ozonation.2
Bhushan’s article reports that “the per capita bottled water consumption in India is
still of unit less than five litre a year as compared to the global consumption of 24 litre.
However, the total annual bottled water consumption has risen rapidly in recent times, it
has tripled in 1999 and 2004 from about 1.5 billion litres to five billion litres. These are
boom times for the Indian bottled industry more so because the economics is sound and
the Indian government hardly cares as to what happens to the nation’s fastest growing
industrial sectors.3
Jeya (2007) in her dissertation concludes that water is a main part of human
beings’ daily life. The consumers have their choices towards the mineral water. Brand
names of the mineral water play an important role in designing the attitude of the
consumers. Different attributes of the mineral water influence the purchase decision of
consumers. Buyer behaviour is the psychological, social and physical behaviour of
potential consumers as they are able to evaluate, purchase, consume and tell other people
about the products and services. It is the act of considering different facts of benefits
expected from the product before affecting the purchase of the product”.4
�
�
12
Nithiyanandan (2000) in his project entitled “Market status of mineral water
industry with special reference to TEAM” reveals that consumption patterns are changing
in packaged mineral water industry. Mineral water is now served on trains and
aeroplanes. Besides the standard one litre bottle which is still the largest seller, a variety
of pack size have been introduced. Mineral water is now available in 200 ml pouch, 500
ml bottle, 1 ltr. and 2 ltr. bottle, 5 ltr. jar and 20 ltr. can. Trains involved in travel for two
days and more require about 50,000 litres of mineral water for a journey. In the modern
day living, stressful working conditions and demanding life styles make the body lose its
electrolytic balance. With companies positioning mineral water as ramification of health,
it has made the market potential limitless”.5
Sasirega Ramani and Sudharsava Reddy (1999) in their work, 37.14% of the
respondents were using packaged drinking water for health purposes. Of these, 16.43% of
the respondents were using packaged drinking water as it is hygienic, 6.43% of the
respondents were using packaged drinking water as it is easy to use, 2.29% of the
respondents use it for ‘need not carry water’, 4.29% of 6.43% of the respondents were
using it as it avoids wastage of water, 20.71% were using it due to employees’ demand,
5.71% were using it due to the presence of salt in the water. On the whole, majority of the
respondents were using packaged drinking water for health reasons.6
Sivaji Ganesan (2007) in his research study concludes that since packaged
drinking water has tremendous impact on human health, both the manufacturers and
consumers must be diligent. The present day consumer market is flooded with a number
of packaged drinking water brands. But the average consumer of packaged drinking
water always tends to give more importance to quality and taste which is followed by
�
�
13
competitive price, so manufacturer should focus on producing packaged drinking water
with good quality and supply it at reasonable prices. A retailer with an in-depth
knowledge of the consumers’ preference and behaviour pattern will be able to cater to
them and will emerge triumphant in the present day cut throat competitive market”.7
Samek (2004) in his study explained that part of the growth of mineral water
sector can be attributed to perceptions created by bottling companies through
advertisements promoting their water as “pristine” and “fresh” emerging from glaciers
and mountains. This significant shift in consumer preferences has environmental
implications since a portion of the current pressures on freshwater sources could be
driven by the needs of bottling companies and could cause irreversible damage. Florida
presents an interesting case study in terms of freshwater resources and bottled water. It
has the highest number of first magnitude springs in the world and has a significantly low
number of problems with the safety of tap water. For this reason, Floridas water resources
are thus a major target of bottling companies.8
Miller (2006) analysed that the U.S. consumers are opting to pay much higher
prices for water that comes in a bottle despite access to reasonably priced domestic water.
Although U.S. public water systems are arguably the safest in the world, bottled water
has become so popular that grocery stores can now sell in-house brands for a smaller cost
than premium name brands of bottled water with guaranteed profits because they are
undoubtedly just using regular tap water.9
Maier et al., (2006) suggest that taste could also be a primary reason why
consumers turn to bottled water, which is interesting considering a filter would solve the
issue of taste for a fraction of the cost. There is also the possibility that most perceptions
�
�
14
about bottled water are incorrect, and one of the goals of their study was to find out to
what extent this is true.10
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC, 1999) reported that most consumers
widely believe that bottled water is better for them due to added health benefits, even as
this is not the case. Bottled water is also perceived to be safer than most tap water, when
in fact nearly all U.S. residents have access to safe and reliable drinking water.11
AWWA (2001) a survey conducted by the American Water Works Association
revealed that 35% of people drink bottled water because they were concerned about tap
water safety, 35% drank it as a substitute for other beverages and 12% chose to drink it
for both of those reasons. 18% drank it because of taste, convenience, or other reasons.12
Beverfood (2008) in his study revealed that consumption of bottled mineral water
is increasing significantly worldwide, becoming an important factor both in economic
and health issues. This is particularly true for Italy, since the country has the largest
producers (over 12 billion L/year) and consumers (200 L/per capita/year) of bottled water
in the world.13
Frost and Sullivan (2007) in their study concluded that bottled mineral water
consumption in the world is increasing by an average 7% each year, inspite of the fact
that bottled mineral water has a higher price. The convenience of bottled water that can
be easily purchased at retail outlets and is easy to use is the major factor leading many
people to purchase bottled mineral water. These factors have led to the increasing global
production of bottled water, from estimated 142 billion liters in 2002 to over 173 billion
liters in 2006. Danone, Nestle, Coca-Cola and PepsiCo are the world's top four bottled
mineral water companies. Although Coca-Cola and PepsiCo are known as the big
�
�
15
carbonated soft drinks manufacturers, they have also noted the potential in the bottled
mineral water market and have been developing their brands and capabilities in this
market. Although major consumers of bottled water are in Europe and North America,
the most promising markets are in Asia and Pacific with an annual growth rate of 15%.14
Latinopolous et al., (1997) observed that a serious health effect that may be
caused by groundwater contamination is the reason for the increasing of public concern
about the quality of groundwater resource in recent years. At present, the public is getting
more concerned about their health whereby they are more interested to know about the
water they consume.15
Guler (2007) in his study stated that fresh water is insufficient, and resources are
unevenly distributed throughout the world, with much of the water located far from
human population. In his study he also revealed that in countries with scarce water
resources, consumption of bottled mineral water is a growing practice. Growing
population and the population shift from rural to urban areas have increased the
consumption of bottled water worldwide.16
Saad et al., (1998), in their study stated that nowadays many people living in
urban areas are increasingly consuming bottled mineral water because it is seldom
associated with naturalness, objection to unpleasant tastes and odors from municipal
water supplies and because bottled mineral water is often regarded as safe as and
healthier than tap water. Furthermore, the efficient marketing and advertising strategies
followed by the bottled water producers enhanced this consumption. An evidence is the
fact that especially consumers who live in developed countries buy bottled water as a
�
�
16
healthy alternative to other beverages, to improve their diet and health. Bottled water is
called the packaged water that is commercially available for human consumption.17
Rusconi et al., (2004) in their study stated that bottled mineral waters have always
been regarded as voluptuary good, something between a soft drink and a dietary or
medical aid with a limited importance in human diet. They also claim that the increasing
use of bottled mineral water makes it obvious to consider it an important element of the
human diet, with special regard to children in lactation age.18
Misund et al., (1999) revealed that bottled mineral water can be defined as water
that is intended for human consumption and is sealed in bottles or other containers with
no added ingredients except that it may contain safe and suitable anti-microbiological
agents. In their study they also indicated that most bottled mineral waters are
groundwater, bottled with or without some treatment process such as filtration and
sterilization.19
Rusconi et al., (2004) in their study analysed that in the last years, anyway, the
consumption of bottled mineral water has widely increased in all western countries. For
example, in the period 1990 until 2000, mineral water consumption rose 50% in Germany
and 130% in the USA. Italy is the main mineral water producer in the world : 9,500
million liters have been bottled in 2000, 700 million of which have been exported.
Between 1995 and 2000, the national production rose by 55% and export by 120%. Italy
is also the main consumer of bottled mineral water. The national market absorbs more
than 90% of the whole production.20
Khan and Chohan (2009) also have postulated that according to the latest
statistical report, the global consumption of bottled water reached 162 billion liters in
�
�
17
2005, an increase by 52% from the 107 billion liters consumed 5 years earlier. This
increase was quite stable with reference to population growth. However, the large
consumption of bottled drinking water per person was mainly due to low level of fluoride
concentration and apprehension and about the contaminants of communal drinking water,
fewer impurities, better taste, and possibly, conferring higher social status.21
King (2008) in his study stated that the consumption of bottled mineral water is
significantly increasing worldwide and has become an important factor both for
economic and health issues. In several countries, the production of bottled mineral water
has recently increased (e.g., Poland, Hungary, Greece) (UNESDA).22
Back et al., (1995) and Albu et al., (1997) in their study stated that the
consumption of bottled water in the West is connected with old traditions of healthy
mineral springs, a custom that is rooted in the distant past. In their study they also stated
that nowadays, the consumption of bottled water in developed countries is more and more
connected with public dissatisfaction with public water supplies and greater
environmental concerns. If, in the past, drinking water from the bottle was mainly for
therapeutic purposes, today it is a many-faceted sociological phenomena connected with
various urban cultural strategies.23
Codex Alimentarius Commission, (2001) reported that bottled i.e. ‘‘packaged’’
water is considered drinking water under some regulatory schemes and as a food in
others. Some authorities distinguish natural mineral water from other bottled waters.
WHO Guidelines for Drinking Water Quality are referred to directly in international
norms and are considered applicable to bottled waters.24
�
�
18
Leslie (2000) says that the 2001 census reported that 68.2% of households in
India have access to safe drinking water. According to latest estimates, 94% of the rural
population and 91% of the people living in urban areas have access to safe drinking
water. While accessing drinking water continues to be a problem, assuming that it is safe
is challenging by itself. It has been estimated that globally 1.20 billion people become
sick annually due to poor quality of drinking water. Further, according to WHO, 80% of
diseases of human beings are caused through medium of water and 1800 million man
working days are lost in India due to such water borne diseases (Rural Drinking Water,
2000).25
Kiran Gadre (2004) asserts that natural water is contaminated by a wide variety of
pollutants and has to be purified to make it safe for drinking. Polluted drinking water is
the cause of several diseases. Increased awareness about the quality of drinking water has
created a growing market for safe drinking water packed in bottles or containers.
Standards have been formulated in every country to ensure the quality of packaged
drinking water. Choice of the process of manufacturing packaged drinking water
depends on the contents of raw water and several techno-commercial factors.26
Dinesh Chand (2006) in his article says that “Better rainwater management can
help in reducing the impact of drought in semi-arid regions. Relatively cheap and simple
water conservation devices such as spray taps and simple rainwater butts can offer short
payback periods and should be considered before high-tech rainwater, harvesting or
recycling of grey water. Although, rainwater harvesting techniques appear to be simple
but the full benefit could only be gained by adopting a scientific approach
�
�
19
implementation together with community awareness, their involvement and legislative
measures for protection of ground water from over exploitation.27
Harendar Raj Gautham et al., (2006), in their research study observe that,
“According to an estimate of the Central Ground Water Board, if we continue to exploit
our ground water indiscriminately, then in the next 20 years, 15 states of the country may
face shortage of underground water. The ground water boom is turning to bust. Problem
is severe and keeping in view the fact that agriculture is the backbone of our economy.
The central government has accelerated continuous higher budgetary support in recent
years to rainwater harvesting and watershed schemes to recharge our underground water
sources. Excess digging of wells should be avoided or restricted. Permission for digging
of wells should be linked with construction of water harvesting structures. In urban areas,
harvesting of rainwater should be made mandatory so that the water stored could be used
for other than drinking purposes. We have to keep in mind that we cannot make more
rains, so we have to manage water better”.28
Batt et al., (2006) in their study concluded that drinking water wells are often
located in the vicinity of streams because streams often overlie permeable sediments and
the water table is near the surface in valleys so that pumping costs are low. The lowering
of the water table by pumping wells can reverse the natural flow from the groundwater to
the stream, inducing infiltration of surface water to groundwater and subsequently to
drinking water wells. Unfortunately, surface water bodies are particularly vulnerable to
contamination from industrial and municipal wastewater, leaching or runoff of
agrochemicals and dissolution of airborne pollutants.29
�
�
20
Rodwan (2009) in his study stated that the bottled water market has been growing
since the middle of the 1970s, and this has especially been the case in the last ten years.30
Hemphill (2008) pointed out that the bottled water companies have recently set
unprecedented records in sales, surpassing all other types of non-alcoholic beverages to
become the second largest beverage market next to soda.31
Miller (2006) finds bottled water to be an adequate choice in geographic regions
which lack access to safe drinking water but not as a substitute in the U.S. His opinions
are supported by the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization and the World
Wildlife Foundation.32
Malaysia's Food Regulation (1985) reported that the popularity of bottled mineral
water with consumers has increased due to the increasing contamination of water
resources. Natural mineral water is water that clearly comes from underground sources. It
is distinguished from ordinary drinking water because it is characterized by its content of
certain mineral salts and their relative proportion and the presence of trace elements of
other constituents. Besides that, natural mineral water is also defined as groundwater that
obtained directly for human consumption from drilled or natural sources from
underground water.33
Nickson et al., (1998) in their study denoted that the most severe contamination of
groundwater was recently discovered, where millions of people are at risk and
consumption of the heavy metals contaminated water has caused widespread death and
disease. In their study they also stated that heavy metals are critical in this regard because
of their easy uptake into the food chain and because of bioaccumulation processes.34
�
�
21
Department of Environment (2005) reported that the overall trend points to a slow
but steady worsening of the water quality of rivers around the country. Among the river
systems as a whole, with or without confining reservoirs, 97% are estimated to contribute
to the raw water supply source. In their study they stated that the increasing population
growth, coupled with rapid agricultural and industrial development, the availability of
small numbers of water resources to meet increasing water demand is fast becoming a
pressing issue. Due to lack of access to clean water resources, consumption of bottled
mineral water has increased.35
Wilson et al., (1983) stated that groundwater comprises water obtained from
springs or from wells and boreholes that used to catch water from the aquifers by means
of pumps. Deep wells or boreholes provide usually water of excellent bacteriological
quality. Groundwater is therefore often used without any treatment, except with
physicochemical ones to reduce hardness or eliminate flavors and odors.36
Leeuwen (2000) reported that there are many sources of contamination of
drinking water. Widely they can be categorized into two categories that are contaminants
inside the ground and surface water. The sources for drinking water production and
contaminants are several involved during the treatment and distribution of drinking water.
Contaminants in ground and surface water will range from natural substances such as
leaching from soil, run-off from agricultural activities, controlled discharge from sewage
treatment works and industrial plants, and uncontrolled discharges or leakages from
landfill sites and from chemical accidents or disasters. Contaminants that occurred
naturally are predominantly formed by inorganic compounds such as arsenic and
manganese, which are derived from natural mineral formations. Organic compounds,
�
�
22
pesticides, disinfectants and disinfectant by products are usually introduced by
anthropogenic activity.37
Natale et al., (2008) in their study stated that the presence of toxic pollutants in
groundwater has to be avoided in order to preserve the environmental quality because it
can bring about significant changes in the properties of water resources.38
Botezatu et al., (2005) in their study analysed that mineral water run across highly
mineralised rocks. The geological sources of natural mineral water are known as aquifers,
which can be from different types, and they differ greatly in terms of their depth,
horizontal extent, composition, and permeability. Water filtering underground flows
slowly through deep permeable rocks and sediments and diffuses into the empty
interstitial space of the rocks. Water picks up minerals and other elements depending on
the chemical make-up of the strata while passing through the underground strata. This is
why they have higher concentrations of minerals and trace minerals than other kinds of
water.39
Misund et al., (1999) in their study analysed that natural mineral water is
characterized by its mineral content, trace elements or other constituents and, where
appropriate, by certain effects and also by being in its original state, both conditions
having been preserved intact because of the underground origin of the water which has
been protected from all risk of pollution. The composition, temperature and other
essential characteristics of natural mineral water would remain stable at source within the
limits of natural fluctuation. In particular, they would not be affected by possible
variations in the rate of flow. Mineral waters may be gaseous or non gaseous.
�
�
23
Disinfections are not allowed in terms of treatment. The only treatment authorized is
filtration or decanting and the addition or removal of carbon dioxide.40
Cemek et al., (2007) in their study pointed out that water quality can have a major
impact on both individuals and communities health. Water may contain substances,
whether natural or through human activity, that can affect the quality and existence of
life. It is important to recognize between pure water and safe water. Pure water can be
defined as water that is free from all unrelated substances, whether it can be harmless to
health or not and is impossible to produce. On the other hand, safe water is water that is
not likely to cause undesirable or adverse effects, although it may contain certain
pollutants. It should be clearly distinguished that drinking water should be clean and safe,
and that minute quantities of contaminants present in water should meet the drinking
water guideline set by the World Health Organization to protect people's health.41
Orzturk and Yilmaz (2000) in their study concluded that there is an increasing
concern worldwide about the quality of drinking water. They also revealed that the levels
of some water quality constituents in drinking waters are in violation of action levels for
various parameters, especially some toxic trace metals. They also suggested that the
increasing exploitation of mineral waters, not only for drinking waters but for medical
purpose also requires a complete evaluation of all the important sources and not only the
main constituents but also trace components should be determined. Hudnik also states
that the occurrence of many heavy metals can be low in mineral waters.42
Soupioni et al., (2006) in their study pointed out that our bodies required minerals
which are chemical elements for numerous biological and physiological processes that
are needed for the maintenance of health. They are classified into two categories. Those
�
�
24
that is required in our diet in amounts greater than 50 mg per day, called minerals, and
those that are required in amounts less than 50 mg per day, which are called trace
elements. Recent epidemiological studies have indicated a strong association between the
occurrence of several diseases in humans and the presence of trace elements considered
to be toxic such as As, Cd and Pb and as well as excessive or deficient levels of essential
micronutrients such as Co and Zn, despite the fact that trace elements constitute only a
small fraction of the total uptake of food.43
Baba et al., (2008)observed that trace elements are present in living organisms at
very low levels but some of them are important in many different biochemical reactions
that occur in the human body. They also reported that in recent decades the flow from the
hydrosphere to man for several heavy metals such as As, Pb and Hg has increased
abundantly due to seasonal inputs caused by using pesticides, or due to natural release
from the soil into groundwater.44
Hsu (2005) in his study reported that heavy metals can be related to many
anthropogenic sources and their compounds are extremely toxic and are among the most
dangerous inorganic water pollutants. Many heavy metals accumulate in the aquatic food
web reaching human beings through the food chain, and causing several diseases. The
presence of heavy metals in groundwater is due to water exchange with contaminated
rivers and lakes or to leaching from contaminated soils by rainfall infiltration. Hence, it is
a major challenge for environmental engineering to remove the heavy metals from
groundwater.45
Karamanis et al., (2007) in their study stated that ions such as sodium, potassium,
magnesium and calcium are essential to sustain life. Additional metals such as
�
�
25
manganese, iron, cobalt, copper, zinc, chromium, vanadium, selenium and molybdenum
are also essential for optimal growth, development and reproduction. These metals
function mostly as catalysts for enzymatic activity in human bodies but become toxic,
when their concentration becomes excessive. In addition to the metals essential for
human metabolism, water may also contain toxic metals like mercury, lead, cadmium,
silver, aluminum, arsenic and barium. Epidemiological studies in recent years have
indicated a strong association between the occurrence of several diseases in humans,
particularly cardiovascular diseases, kidney-related disorders, neurocognitive effects and
various forms of cancer and the presence of toxic trace metals.46
Baba et al., (2008) reported that up to now, there has been much debate about the
health giving effects of mineral water. Apart from the obvious function of providing
liquid to the body, there are no scientific studies that actually show a significant
beneficial effect of mineral water on the health. While mineral water clearly contains
minerals that are, in principle, beneficial for the body, the ability of the body to absorb
them from mineral water is not exactly proven. But since natural water is free of any
calories, sugar or artificial ingredients, it is certainly better than a sweetened, flavored
soft drink. There are usually no adverse effects from drinking mineral water and so we
may drink it just for its fresh taste.47
Petraccia et al., (2006) in their study analysed that labels on bottled mineral
waters are regulated by legislative norms. Labels contain two kinds of information that
are information about the producer and the production which is brand name, production
lot, bottling date, bar code, the words about the natural environment, nominal content,
authorization, purchase proof and consumer service toll-free number. The label or the
�
�
26
bottle must also show a regular hexagon or a circle with an abbreviation indicating the
material of the container. The second kind of information guides the consumers in the
choice of the water which best meets their requirements. The label also reports some
basic rules for a correct storage of bottled mineral water that is to be kept in a cool, dry,
clean and odourless place, away from light and heat sources. After the opening, the bottle
must be closed carefully, in order to maintain the original characteristics.48
Misund et al., (1999) reported that the regulation of contents of bottled mineral
water is not stringent and the concentration printed on the labels may not be accurate.
One study in Pakistan showed that about 52% of bottled water was not suitable for
drinking. A study (Johnson and DeBiase, 2003) was conducted in European countries to
compare the actual level of different elements to the concentration mentioned at the
bottle.49
Jeenaa et al., (2006) in their study pointed out that the introduction of packaged
water for human consumption at recent times is a boon to mankind and more convenience
is realised. Whenever someone purchases packaged water, he thinks that the quality is
assured and it is safe water. The use of bottled water may have begun as a fad but this
industry has evolved into one of the fastest growing industries in India. Increased public
awareness about waterborne disease outbreaks and lack of safe drinking water supply
during travel have also resulted in an increased demand for bottled drinking water. In
India, a large population of road and rail commuters depend on bottled mineral water for
their drinking water needs during travel.50
LeChevallier et al., (1980) in their study analysed the heterotrophic plate counts
(HPC), expressed as colony-forming units (CFU), became one of the standard techniques
�
�
27
for microbial water quality testing. Health significance and occurrence of injured bacteria
in drinking water as well as potentially pathogenic features of heterotrophic plate count
bacteria from treated and untreated drinking water have been reported.51
An anonymous (1980) revealed that in certain parts of the world, disinfection or
sterilization of commercially available mineral waters is not permitted. Therefore, they
generally have high heterotrophic plate counts (HPC) a few days after bottling that
should result only from an increase of bacteria present in the source water.52
Murali and Ramesh (2007) in their article disclose that from being confined to the
uppermost echelons of society, packaged water has now become a common place
commodity and almost a dire necessity in metros. The industry’s phenomenal growth in
the recent years can be attributed to the rising incidence of water-borne diseases,
improper municipal supplies, and the evolved health consciousness of people as well as
globalization which has brought in tremendous tourist inflow. Now since the industry has
matured, only big companies with branded products are in the fray to capture the large
market share. Though the industries’ growth rate is 40-50% a year, India is still much
behind the countries such as Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore, where the industry is
already worth Rs. 15,000 to 20,000 crores, though, these countries have much smaller
populations but similar climatic conditions.53
Leivadara et al., (2008) in their study revealed that bottled water’s wide
acceptability is related to the convenience and taste it provides along with the belief that
it is purer than tap water, making it a healthy alternative to other beverages.54
WHO, (2003b) reported that packaged waters with very low mineral content, such
as distilled or demineralized waters, are also consumed. Rainwater, which is similarly
�
�
28
low in minerals, is consumed by some populations without apparent adverse health
effects. There is insufficient scientific information on the benefits or hazards of regularly
consuming these types of bottled waters.55
Freuze et al., (2006) observed that trihalomethanes are generated during the
process of chlorination of tap water. Leaching of chemicals from packaging materials and
possible intentional or accidental contaminations can contribute VOCs to contamination
of waters. Pathogenic organisms are usually removed from processed drinking waters by
chlorination to adequately safeguard public health.56
Rosenberg (2003) in his study concluded that most bottled waters are taken from
springs or ground waters. Natural mineral waters are not sterile environments, but
complex ecosystems with a high phenotypic and genetic diversity of autochthonous
bacteria.57
Kosek et al., (2003) in their study analysed the contaminated drinking water,
along with inadequate supply of water for personal hygiene and poor sanitation and
concluded that it is the main contributor for an estimated 4 billion cases of diarrhoea each
year causing 2.2 million deaths, mostly among children under the age of five in
developing countries.58
WHO (2004) reported that 1.1 billion people lack access to improved water
supplies; many more are forced to rely on supplies that are microbiologically unsafe.
While universal access to safe, piped-in water is an important long-term goal, this is
likely to be elusive for many years to come due to the costs of building and maintaining
such systems. Improving the microbiological quality of drinking water, particularly at the
�
�
29
household level, is effective in preventing diarrhoea in settings where it is endemic
(Clasen et al., 2006).59
Afzal (2006) in his study stated that contaminants can be differentiated as
inorganic or organic chemicals, radionuclides, and microorganisms. They may occur
naturally or enter the watershed from farming or industrial discharges. Examples of
inorganic contaminants are lead, nitrates, and arsenic. Organic chemicals contain carbon
and access the watershed from agricultural and industrial run off. Volatile organic
chemicals are persistent in the environment and have been associated with cancer and
neurological and reproductive health effects. Examples include gasoline and degreasing
and dry cleaning solvents. There are over 30 standards for synthetic organic chemicals,
many of which are pesticides.60
Ekmekcioglu (2000) conducted a detailed study on the mineral water. Mineral
water may represent a good source of nutrition which is necessary for the needs of human
body.61
Baba et al., (2008) in their study stated that human beings required minerals for
nutrition, growth, sustaining body functions and well being. They also reported that these
minerals have various effects on the human's health.62
Albu et al., (1997) in their study reveal that natural mineral waters have long been
used for medical purposes. The term natural mineral water is defined so as it originates in
an underground water table or deposit; it differs from treated water in its original purity
that is bacteriologically healthy and its content of minerals, trace minerals and other
constituents must remain constant. Only natural mineral water has the characteristics that
can benefit human health.63
�
�
30
Petraccia et al., (2006), in their study indicated that the mineral waters are of
underground origin, protected from contamination, and microbiologically wholesome.
They present a peculiar and constant chemical composition, and have favorable effects on
health. To ensure it is safe, they must be bottled at source and checked containers.
Mineral water does not simply mean containing minerals. In fact waters that run
underground and are enriched with minerals by contact with rocks cannot be considered
mineral waters if they do not possess therapeutic properties.64
Petraccia et al., (2006) in their study suggested that natural mineral waters can be
classified into potable waters, dietetic waters, and healing waters. Bottled dietetic waters
showed that it can be used to restore salts and hydrate through experimental evidence and
are useful in low sodium diets and provide the right calcium intake in particular
conditions. Healing waters possess pharmacological and clinical properties related to
prevention and treatment of specific pathologies. They are used in thermal
establishments, under medical control, for drinking, irrigations, inhalations, and baths.
The main classification parameters for mineral waters are rate of flow, temperature,
freezing point, dry residues at 180oC, predominant ion composition, and predominant
biological activity.65
Petraccia et al., (2006) reported that 9% of the waters on the market are waters
with a very low mineral content. These waters have a diuretic effect and are used in
treating urinary stones; they facilitate uric acid clearance. They are suitable for powdered
milk dilution since they do not modify its formulation and also is useful in hypertension
for their low sodium content. 65% of mineral waters on the market are waters with a low
mineral content. They have diuretic effects, and are strongly used in urinary stones and
�
�
31
gout because facilitate uric acid and ureic nitrogen clearance. 20% of the mineral waters
on the market are waters with a medium mineral content. They are similar to low-mineral
waters in the action, but their diuretic effect is inversely proportional to the amount of dry
residues. 6% of the mineral waters on the market are waters rich in mineral salts and are
defined as medicinal waters.66
Cemek et al., (2007) in their study stated that a reliable supply of clean drinking
water is extremely important to protect the health of individuals and communities. Both
the quantity and the quality of supply are important. Since diseases are more easily
transferred directly from person to person via contaminated food or water an adequate
quantity of water is of primary importance in public health. A number of serious diseases
can be spread via contaminated drinking water. Although water is important for living,
poor water quality due to sewage and industrial and agricultural effluents can mean
increased exposure to carcinogenic compounds, insecticides such as DDT, and heavy
metals. There has been an increasing demand for natural mineral waters due to human
health benefits caused the increasing contamination of tap waters and this has led to more
and more consumption of mineral waters recently. Heavy metal levels in the natural
waters are important indicators of water quality. The increasing concentration level of
heavy metal becomes an important problem for public health. Thus, widespread and
frequent monitoring surveys must be carried out.67
WHO (1998) reported that there are elements that are essential for growth and
may have beneficial uses but even though these some of these trace elements are essential
to human, but essential as well as non-essential elements if raise to a higher level or
status can cause morphological abnormalities, reduced growth, increased mortality and
�
�
32
mutagenic effects in humans. The trace metals burden in the environment can be
generally reflect by the levels of trace elements in water, the amount of metals ingested
through water is of extreme importance in risk assessment to human health.68
WHO (1993), In establishing guidelines for drinking water to protect public
health, World Health Organisation applied the following definition: A guideline value
represents the concentration of a constituent that does not result in any significant risk to
health of the consumer over a lifetime of consumption. Although this guideline value
provides a maximum level of a contaminant that may not cause any public health concern
even following lifetime exposure, it does not implicate a green light for pollution of
drinking water to the recommended guideline level. It must be recognized that, because
water is essential to sustain life, a continuous effort should be made to maintain water
quality at the highest possible level. The setting of standards might be influenced by
national priorities and economic considerations and thus the conclusion on whether the
health benefit of setting a specific standard justifies the costs involved is a matter of each
individual country.69
Nsanze et al., (1999) in their study reveal that the evolution of directives and
regulations related to public health matters is not controlled only by toxicological or
epidemiological findings. Economic interests, socio-cultural characteristics, hygiene
practices, public awareness and sensitivity and technological development have always
been as important as scientific evidence in the establishment of regulations related to
public health protection.70
Leeuwen (2000) in his study examined and observed that the whole human
population needs drinking water for sustaining life and so the provision of a safe water
�
�
33
supply is a high priority issue for safeguarding the health and well being of humans. The
production of adequate and safe drinking water is the most important factor contributing
to a decrease in mortality and morbidity. To assure consumers that drinking water is safe
and can be consumed without any risk, guidelines or standards have been set, giving
maximum allow- able concentrations for compounds in drinking water below which no
significant health risk is encountered.71
Guler (2007) in his study revealed that standards have been developed by
international, national and non-governmental organizations to define a quality of water
that is safe and acceptable to consumers. Most of these standards set limits for physical
parameters, chemical constituents and micro organisms that are dangerous and potentially
hazardous to consumers.72
Marsh (1995) in his study stated that population-based verbal autopsy studies in
five of these squatter communities measured an under 5-year-old mortality rate of 100
deaths per 1000 live births; water borne diseases were the primary cause of 39% of these
deaths.73
CONCLUSION
In this chapter, all the earlier studies dealing with the packaged drinking water
have been analysed. There is no particular study regarding awareness and attitudes of
packaged drinking water of consumers in the southern districts of Tamil Nadu. Hence,
the researcher has made this attempt for the present study.
�
�
34
REFERENCES
1. Gabriel, J., (2001). Bottled water: Understanding a social phenomenon Ambio: A Journal of the Human Environment, Vol: 30, pp: 118-122.
2. Shrivastava Brajesh.K and Alam Masood (2007). “The Qualitative assessment of
the water consumption for manufacturing packaged drinking water at Rail Neer Plant”, Journal of Scientific and Industrial Research, Vol.66(3), pp: 227-230.
3. Bhushan, “Structure and Economics of the Indian Bottled Water Industry”,
Frontline, Vol: 23(7), pp. 8- 21.
4. Jeya, R., (2007). “A study on consumers attitude towards branded mineral water
at Kovilpatti Town”, pp.85-91.
5. Nithiyanandan, K., (2000). “Market status of mineral water industry with special
reference to TEAM”, MBA project report, Department of Management studies,
Madurai Kamaraj University, Madurai, April 2000.
6. Sasirega Ramani and Sudharsava Reddy, C.H., (1999). “A study on Institutional
consumer perception of packaged drinking water”, MBA Project Report, Depart
of Management Studies, Sri Sairam Engineering College, Chennai, May 1999.
7. Sivaji Ganesan, G., (2007). “Marketing of packaged Drinking water in the
Madurai Region”, Department of Commerce, Yadhava College, Madurai. Ph.D.
Thesis submitted to Madurai kamaraj University, Dec 2007.
8. Samek, K., (2004). Unknown Quantity: The Bottled Water Industry and
Florida s Springs. Journal of Land Use, Vol: 19(2), pp: 569-595.
9. Miller, M., (2006). Bottled Water: Why Is It so Big? Causes for the Rapid Growth of Bottled Water Industries. University Honors Program. Paper 7.
http://ecommons.txstate .edu/honorprog/7, last accessed Mar 31 2011.
10. Maier, A., Moskowitz, H., and Beckley J., (2006). Using Mind Set Information about Health, Pleasure and Function to Understand Consumer Choices in Bottled
Water. The Open Food Science Journal, Vol: 3(20), pp: 42-61.
11. NRDC (Natural Resources Defense Council), (1999). Bottled Water: Pure Drink or Pure Hype? http://www.nrdc.org/water/drinking/bw/bwinx.asp, last accessed
Mar 31st 2011.
12. AWWA (American Water Works Association), (2001). Dawn of the
Replacement Era: Reinvesting in Drinking Water Infrastructure. Last accessed
Mar 31 2011.
�
�
35
13. Beverfood, (2008). Bevitalia. Mineral Waters and Soft Drinks 2008–2009 Directory.
14. Frost and Sullivan, (2007). Bottled Water Market in Malaysia - Creating Ripples?.
http://www.frost.com/prod /servlet/market- insight print.pag?docid=99662272 &ctxixpLink= FcmCtx23&ctxixpLabel =FcmCtx24. Accessed on 1 January 2010.
15. Latinopoulous, P., Theodosiou., N., Mylopoulos. Y., and Mylopoulos, N., (1997).
Risk- based decisionanalysis in design of water supply projects.Water Resarch Management, Vol: 11, pp: 263-281.
16. Guler, C., (2007). Characterization of Turkish bottled waters using pattern
recognition methods. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, Vol: 86,
pp: 86-94.
17. Saad, B., Pok., F.W., Sujari., A.N.A., and Saleh, M. I., (1998). Analysis of anions
and cations in drinking water samples by capillary ion analysis. International
Journal of Food Microbiology, Vol: 48, pp: 59-65.
18. Rusconi, R., Forte, M., Abbate, G., Gallini, R.,& Sgorbati, G., (2004). Natural
radioactivity in bottled mineral waters: A survey in Northern Italy.Journal of
Radioanalytical and Nuclear Chemistry, Vol: 260, pp: 421-427.
19. Misund, A., Frengstad., B. Siewers., U. & Reimann., C. (1999). Variation of 66
elements in European bottled mineral waters. Journal of Food Composition and
Analysis, Vol: 14, pp: 127-152.
20. Rusconi, R., Forte, M., Abbate, G., Gallini, R.,& Sgorbati, G., (2004). Natural
radioactivity in bottled mineral waters: A survey in Northern Italy. Journal of Radio analytical and Nuclear Chemistry, Vol: 260, pp: 421-427.
21. Khan N.B., AlDosari, A.M., Wyne., A.H. Akpata.., E.S (2009). Caries prevalence
among secondary school children in Riyadh and Qaseem. Saudi Dental Journal, Vol: 19, pp: 32-35.
22. King, M., (2008). BottledWater-Global Industry Guide, New Research Report on
Companies and Markets. Retrieved January 4, 201.
23. Back, W., Landa, E.R., Meeks, L., (1995). Bottled water, spas, and early years of
water chemistry. Ground Water Ambio, Vol: 30, pp: 118–119.
24. Codex Alimentarius Commission, (2001). General Standard for bottled/packaged Drinking Waters (other than natural waters). CODEXSTAN 221-2001, Codex
Committee on Natural Mineral Waters.
�
�
36
25. Leslie, Jacques, (2000). Running dry, what happens when world no longer has enough fresh water? Harpers magazine, Rural drinking water supply programme,
2000. Rajiv Gandhi National Drinking water mission, Dept. of water supply,Ministry of Rural Development, Govt. of India, pp: 37-38.
26. Kiran Gadre, (2004). “Use of ozone in packaged drinking water disinfection and
purification”, CEOQ universal ozone systems, Mumbai, Beverage and Food world, June 2004.
�27. Dinesh Chand, (2006). “Water Harvesting for Drinking water security”.
Additional adviser in Department of Drinking water supply, Ministry of Rural
development, New Delhi, Kurukshetra, August 2006, Vol: 54(10).
28. Harendar Raj Gautam and Rohtashav Kumar, (2006). “Rainwater harvesting : Vital for Growing”. Scientist and Assistant Scientist, Department of Mycology
and Plant Pathology, Journal Kurukshetra, 2006, Vol: 54(8).
29. Batt, A.L., Bruce, I.B., Aga, D.S., (2006). Evaluating the vulnerability of surface waters to antibiotic contamination from varying wastewater treatment plant
discharges. Environ. Pollut. Vol: 142, pp: 295–302.
30. Rodwan, J., (2009). Confronting Challenges: U.S. and International Bottled Water Developments and Statistics of 2008. Bottled Water Reporter, pp: 12-18.
31. Hemphill, (2008). “Bottled Water now Number Two Commercial Bevarage in the
U.S.,Saya Beverage Marketing Corporation” http://www.beveragemarketing.com.
�32. Miller, M., (2006). Bottled Water: Why Is It so Big? Causes for the Rapid Growth
of Bottled Water Industries. University Honors Program. Paper 7. http://ecommons.txstate .edu/honorprog/7, last accessed Mar 31 2011.
33. Malaysia's Food Regulation, (1985). Water is an essential component in our life
http://www.ukessays.com/essays/environmental-studies/water-is-an-essential-com ponent-in-ourlife.php#ixzz 2eg Ec4a5E.
34. Nickson, R., McArthur., J. Burgess., W., Ahmed., K.M. Ravenscroft. P.&
Rahman., M. (1998). Arsenic poisoning of Bangladesh groundwater, Nature,
395:338.
35. Department of Environment, (2005). Comparative study of potable and mineral
waters available in the State of Kuwait. Desalination, Vol: 123, pp: 253-264.
36. Wilson, J.T., McNabb., D.L. Balkwill. & W.C. Ghiorse., (1983). Enumeration and
characterization of bacteria indigenous to shallow water table aquifer. Ground
Water, Vol: 21, pp: 134-142.
�
�
37
37. Leeuwen, F.X.R.V., (2000). Safe Drinking Water: Toxicologist's Approach. Food and Chemical Toxicology, Vol: 38, pp: 51-58.
38. Natale, F.D., M.D. Natale., R. Greco., A. Lancia., C. Laudante. & D. Musmarra.,
(2008). Groundwater protection from cadmium contamination by permeable reactive barriers.Journal of Hazardous Materials, Vol: 164, pp: 265- 270.
39. Botezatu, E., O. Iacoba. & O. Capitanu., (2005). Exposure of the population
through mineral water consumption. Radioactivity International J Environment, Vol: 7, pp: 1100-1107.
40. Misund, A., Frengstad., U. Siewers. & C. Reimann., (1999). Variation of 66
elements in European bottled mineral waters. The Science of the Total
Environment, Vol: 243, pp: 21-41.
41. Cemek, M., Akkaya., Y.O. Birdane., K. Seyrek., S. Bulut. & M. Konuk., (2007).
Nitrate and nitrite levels in fruity and natural mineral waters marketed in western
Turkey. Journal of Food Composition and Analysis, Vol: 20, pp: 236-240.
42. Ozturk, and Yilmaz., (2000). Trace elements and radioactivity levels in drinking
water near Tuncbilek coal-fired power plant in Kutahya, Turkey.Water Res, Vol:
34, pp: 704-708.
43. Soupioni, M.J., Symeopoulos & H.V. Papaefthymiou., (2006). Determination of
trace elements in bottled water in Greece by instrumental and radiochemical
neutron activation analyses. Journal of Radio analytical and Nuclear Chemistry,
Vol: 268, pp: 441-444.
44. Baba, A., F.S. Erees., U. Hicsonmez., & H.G. Ozdilek., (2008). An assessment of the quality of various bottled mineral water marketed in Turkey. Environ Monit
Assess, Vol: 139, pp: 277-285.
45. Hsu, Y.C.N., (2005). Electrokinetic remediation of cadmium-contaminated clay.J., Environ. Eng, Vol: 131, pp: 298-304.
46. Karamanis, D., Stamoulis., D. & Ioannides., K.G., (2007). Natural radionuclides
and heavy metals in bottled water in Greece. Desalination, Vol: 213, pp: 90-97.
47. Baba, A., F.S. Erees., U. Hicsonmez., & H.G. Ozdilek., (2008). An assessment of the quality of various bottled mineral water marketed in Turkey.Environ Monit
Assess, Vol: 139, pp: 277-285.
48. Petraccia, L., Liberati., Masciullo., S.G. Grassi., M. & Fraioli., A. (2006). Water,
mineral waters and health. Clinical Nutrition, Vol: 25, pp: 377-385.
�
�
38
49. Misund, A., Frengstad., B. U. Siewers., & C. Reimann., (1999). Variation of 66 elements in European bottled mineral waters.The Science of the Total
Environment, Vol: 243, pp: 21-41.
50. Jeenaa, M.I. Deepaa, P. Mujeeb Rahimana, K.M. Shanthia, R.T. Hathab, A.A.M., (2006). Risk assessment of heterotrophic bacteria from bottled drinking water
sold in Indian markets. International Journal of Hygienic and Health., pp: 91-96.
51. LeChevallier, M.W., Seidler, R.J., Evans, T.M., (1980). Enumeration and characterization of standard plate count bacteria in chlorinated and raw water
supplies. Appl. Environ. Microbiol, Vol: 40, pp: 922–930.
52. Anonymous, (1980). Directive du Conseil du 15 Juillet 1980 relative au
raprochement des legislation des Etats membres concernant l’exploitation et la
mise dans le commerce des eaux mine´rales naturelles. Annexe 1 (80/777/CEE).
J. Off. Communaute ´s Eur. L229, 1–10.
53. Murali D. and Ramesh, C. (2007) “Packaged Drinking Water Industry – What we
see is the Tip of the Ice Berg”, Business Line – e.paper, Friday, July 27-2007.
54. Leivadara, S.V., Nikolaou, A.D., Lekkas, T.D., (2008). Determination of organic
compounds in bottled waters. Food Chemistry, Vol: 108, pp: 277–286.
55. WHO, (2003). Report of the WHO workshop: Nutrient minerals in drinking water and the potential health consequences of long-term consumption of demineralized
and remineralized and altered mineral content drinking waters. Rome, 11–13 November 2003.
56. Freuze, I., Brosillon, S., Arlot, J., Laplanche, A., Tozza, D., Cavard, J., (2006).
Impact of UV-irradiation on the formation of odorous chloroaldimines in drinking water.Chemosphere, Vol: 63, pp: 1660–1666.
57. Rosenberg, F.A., (2003). The microbiology of bottled water. Clinical
Microbiology Newsletter, Vol: 25, pp: 41–44.
58. Kosek, M., Bern, C., Guerrant, R.L., (2003). The global burden of diarrhoeal disease, as estimated from studies published between 1992 and 2000. Bull. World
Health Organisation, Vol: 81, pp: 197–204.
59. WHO, (2004). Evaluation of certain food additives and contaminants. World
Health Report Tech Rep Ser. World Health Organization, Geneva, Vol: 922, pp: 1-176,
60. Afzal, B.M., (2006). Drinking Water and Women's Health.J Midwifery Womens
Health, Vol: 51, pp: 12-18.
�
�
39
61. Ekmekcioglu, C., (2000). Intestinal bioavailability of minerals and trace elements from milk and beverages in humans. Water Research Management, Vol: 13, pp:
443-470.
62. Baba, A., Erees., F.S., Hicsonmez., U. & Ozdilek., H.G., (2008). An assessment of the quality of various bottled mineral water marketed in Turkey. Environ Monit
Assess, Vol: 139, pp: 277-285.
63. Albu, M., Banks., D. & Nash., H. (1997). Mineral and Thermal Groundwater Resources. Chapman & Hall, London, 447.
64. Petraccia, L., Liberati., G. Masciullo., S.G. Grassi., M. & Fraioli., A. (2006).
Water, mineral waters and health. Clinical Nutrition, Vol: 25, pp: 377-385.
65. Petraccia, L., Liberati., G. Masciullo., S.G., Grassi., M. & Fraioli., A. (2006).
Water, mineral waters and health. Clinical Nutrition, Vol: 25, pp: 377-385.
66. Petraccia, L., Liberati., G. Masciullo., S.G. Grassi., M. & Fraioli., A. (2006).
Water, mineral waters and health. Clinical Nutrition, Vol: 25, pp: 377-385.
67. Cemek, M., Akkaya., L. Birdane., Y.O., Seyrek., K. Bulut., S. & Konuk., M.
(2007). Nitrate and nitrite levels in fruity and natural mineral waters marketed in
western Turkey.Journal of Food Composition and Analysis, Vol: 20, pp: 236-240.
68. WHO, (1998). Draft third edition of the WHO Guidelines for Drinking Water
Quality.http://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/dwq/guidelines3rd/en/.
Accessed on 2 February 2010.
69. WHO, (1993). Recommendations. Guidelines for Drinking-Water Quality, vol. 1, 2nd ed. World Health Organization, Geneva.
70. Nsanze, H., Babarinde., Z. & Al Kohaly., H. (1999). Microbiological quality of
bottled drinking water in the UAE and the effect of storage at different temperatures. Environment International, Vol: 25, pp: 53-57.
71. Leeuwen, F.X.R.V., (2000). Safe Drinking Water: Toxicologist's Approach. Food
and Chemical Toxicology, Vol: 38, pp: 51-58.
72. Guler, C., (2007). Characterization of Turkish bottled waters using pattern recognition methods. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, Vol: 86,
pp: 86-94.
73. Marsh D, Husein K, Lobo M, Shah MA, Luby S. Verbal autopsy in Karachi
slums: comparing single and multiple causes of child deaths. Health Policy Plan
1995; Vol: 10, pp: 95-403.