Upload
ashley-dixon
View
214
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Chapter 4 Module 9Environmental systems analysis methodology
Can totally different sanitation systems be fairly compared?How are environmental impacts measured?
Life cycle assessment (LCA)
• Aim– Evaluate environmental
burdens of a product or service
– Using a cradle-to-grave perspective
• from raw material extraction to waste management and final disposal.
Raw material acquisition
Processes
Transport
Manufacture
Use
Waste management
LCA work with an expanded system
• Comparison require delivery of similar product– That leave you with compared system – And compensatory system (external system)
Compared system Compensatory system
Product
Waste sources
Waste managementsystem
Emissions
Energy Fertiliser
Material
Energy
Energy Fertiliser
Costs
Compensatory system
Alternativeproductionof energy
AlternativeproductionofN-,P-fertiliser
System boundary
Alternativeenergy raw
material
Alternativefertiliser raw
material
Example of a system comparison
Source: Jan-Olov Sundquist, IVL
Functional unit, valued products
Core system incinerationWaste
Heat
Power
Functional unit
Core system LandfillWaste
Heat
Power
Heat production
Power production
Compensatory or external system
Functional unit
Resources – Energy and materials Water Land
Impacts on human health (toxicological and non-toxicological impacts, excluding and including work environment)
Global warming Depletion of stratospheric ozoneAcidificationEutrophicationPhoto-oxidant formationEco-toxicological impactsHabitat alterations and impacts on biological diversity
Impact categories to be considered in an LCA
Title
Collection and aggregation of data
NOx
NH3
P
etc.
CO2
CH4
N2O
Eutrophication
Global warming
Index
Inventory Characterisation Weighting
Which environmental effect is most important?
• Global vs local• Long-term vs short-term
• Importance of the impact– Compare the system impact with total national
emissions
Weighting of global warming
Global Warming Potentials (GWP) as CO2 –equivalents for different trace gases and time-frames (IPCC, 2001) Trace gas GWP, 20 years GWP, 100 years GWP, 500 years Carbon dioxide, CO2 1 1 1 Methane, CH4 62 23 7 Nitrous oxide, N2O 275 296 156
Weighing of acidification
Weighting factors for acidification for two scenarios, min and max (Lindfors et al., 1995). Substance Min [mol H+/g] Max [mol H+/g] SO2 0.031 0.031 HCl 0.027 0.027 NOx 0 0.022 NH3 0 0.059
Weighting of eutrophicationWeighting factors for eutrophication
Substance Maximum (g O2 per g) Minimum (g O2 per g) N to air 20 NOx to air 6 NH3 to air 19.8 3.8 N to water 20 NO3 to water 4,4 NH4 to water 18.6 3.6 P to water 140 140 PO4
3- 46 46 COD 1 1
Remember…
It is a great difference between potential and actual environmental impacts.