Upload
shana
View
29
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Chapter 15 Social Psychology. “Hey, hey, hey! Are you folks nuts? I’m telling you, this is the car for you.”. Social Influence. Social influence refers to changes in our behaviour that occur as a result of direct or indirect intervention by others. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 1
UTSC
“Hey, hey, hey! Are you folks nuts? I’m telling you, this is the car for you.”
Chapter 15
Social
Psychology
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 2
UTSC
Social Influence
• Social influence refers to changes in our behaviour that occur as a result of direct or indirect intervention by others.
• Social influence can be used in very clever ways. Sales people often have to rely on creative (and not always very honest) techniques.
• Con artists persuade people to give them money by using techniques which involve “a tale”, modeling, reinforcement and trust (remember the con artist I met in Wildwood?)
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 3
UTSC
The Low Ball Technique
The salesperson quotes an unusually low price. You agree to buy it at that price.
The salesperson then comes up with a reason to change the price, thus removing the reason you decided to buy.
• Option not included.• Manager says we would be losing money.• Calculation error.• Trade in re-appraised lower.
Do you still go through with the purchase? Evidence shows that you tend to.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 4
UTSC
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 5
UTSC
Reliability InformationOne more reason to get Consumer Reports.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 6
UTSC
And now apparently we have to listen to some sort of dissent.
Conformity
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 7
UTSC
Video on Conformity
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 8
UTSC
Factors that Affect ConformitySize of majority: as the number of people in the majority
increases, the more likely one is to conform. The relationship is not linear though. There is a point (4 or 5 people) where adding more people to the majority no longer increases the conformity rate.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 9
UTSC
Two Other Factors
Unanimity: We are less likely to conform when there is another person who deviates from the majority (whether or not the deviant agrees with our opinion).
Commitment: The more committed we are to our opinion, the less likely we are to conform.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 10
UTSC
Why do people conform?
• Outcome Dependence (the desire to be liked): People want to “fit in” and avoid the negative aspect of being rejected or ridiculed.
• Information Dependence (the desire to be right): People turn to others for guidance, especially when they are uncertain.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 11
UTSC
“Sit. Roll over. Play dead. Good dog!”
Obedience
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 12
UTSC
Obedience
History offers many examples of atrocities:
• Systematic killing of millions by Nazis in WWII.
• U.S. soldiers massacre in My Lai during Vietnam War.
Were these people different from us? Were they cold-blooded
killers? Was their personality the cause of their behaviour?
Social psychologists say that the situation often exerts strong
pressures on the individual. Orders given by people in authority
create such pressures.
Let’s look at Milgram’s research on obedience to authority.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 13
UTSC
Video on Obedience
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 14
UTSC
Milgram found a surprising level of obedience - much more than experts like psychiatrists had predicted before the study.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 15
UTSC
Factors that Influence Obedience
Variations in the experimental situation had an effect on the level of obedience :
• The psychological proximity to the learner.
• The psychological proximity of the authority.
• Personal responsibility for administering the shock.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 16
UTSC
Fields of Force
GO
STOP
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 17
UTSC
Video on Factors that Affect Obedience
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 18
UTSC
Autonomy vs. Agency
Autonomy: when we operate in full knowledge that we are responsible for our actions. Our moral principles guide our behaviour.
Agency: when we perceive ourselves as agents of someone else’s authority.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 19
UTSC
Bystander Apathy
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 20
UTSC
Video on Bystander Apathy
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 21
UTSC
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 22
UTSC
Explanations
Three factors that contribute to bystander apathy have been suggested:
• Diffusion of Responsibility
• Pluralistic Ignorance
• Cost
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 23
UTSC
The Self Concept:
The way we perceive ourselves and feel we are perceived by
others.
Our sense of self provides the glue that holds our past and
present together and forms the basis of our future aspirations.
Many aspects of our personality, such as our self-esteem, and
sense of efficacy and control are based in our self-concept.
Can you imagine what it would be like to have a sense of self
if one had no memory?
The Self
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 24
UTSC
Video on K.C.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 25
UTSC
Does K.C. know his personality?
There has been research to test if K.C. knows his personality,
especially the way he has become since his accident.
K.C. was given a list of personality traits and was asked to indicate how they applied to him.
K.C.’s mother and others familiar with him were given these traits and were asked how they applied to him.
Do you think that K.C. knows his personality? In fact, his self ratings agreed with the ratings by his mom and others.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 26
UTSC
Nonverbal Communication
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 27
UTSC
Dyadic Conversations
Dyadic conversations are conversations which involve two
people. They normally have a structure that follows an
A-B-A-B form. That is, each person takes a turn at speaking and
then listening.
Where are the speaker and the listener looking when taking their
turns?
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 28
UTSC
Gaze Direction During Conversation
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 29
UTSC
Things People do When Communicating
Emblems: nonverbal gestures that have specific definitions within a given culture such as the “OK” sign, head nods, shrugs, winks, and finger wags.
Illustrators: nonverbal gestures which do not have any meaning, but are used to supplement and emphasize speech. Illustrators include hand waving and finger snapping while speaking.
Backchannel Communication: While listening, people usually make comments like ‘yes’ and ‘right’ at appropriate moments in the conversation.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 30
UTSC
Affiliative Conflict Theory
According to Argyle, every dyadic interaction has an appropriate level of intimacy.
Many behaviours influence the level of intimacy expressed in an interaction:
– distance between people
– topic of the conversation
– amount of smiling
– amount of eye contact
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 31
UTSC
Intimacy Equilibrium
People will adjust all the intimacy behaviours to attain the right level of intimacy for an interaction.
For example, if the person you are talking to is pushed towards you in a crowded situation, the intimacy of the interaction increases. This may make you uncomfortable, so you may engage in a behaviour to decrease the intimacy (reduce eye contact or stop smiling).
When equilibrium is disrupted, we feel discomfort and are motivated to reestablish it.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 32
UTSC
The Stare as a Threat Display
Many animal species use staring as a form of threat. Does the same apply to humans?
An experiment was conducted in which a confederate driving a scooter stared at another driver at a red light. Did the driver cross the intersection faster when the light turned green?
Time to CrossStared at: 5.3 sec.No Stare: 6.5 sec.
BUT, what if staring was interpreted as a challenge to drag race?
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 33
UTSC
Eliminating Alternative ExplanationsExperiment was replicated with experimenter standing on the sidewalk at the intersection.
Time to CrossStared at: 5.3 sec.No Stare: 6.5 sec.
BUT, maybe driver wanted to show off to the pedestrian. So in another experiment pedestrians were stared at while waiting to cross the street at a “Don’t Walk” sign.
Time to CrossStared at: 11.1 sec.No Stare: 12.2 sec.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 34
UTSC
Video on Nonverbal Communication
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 35
UTSC
CrowdBehaviour
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 36
UTSC
Lynchings
During the period between 1890-1930, over 4,000 people in
the south of the United States were murdered by mob action
without a lawful trial. Eighty percent of these cases involved
Black Americans.
What contributes to excesses of crowd behaviour?
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 37
UTSC
Frustration Primes Aggression
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 38
UTSC
Gustave LeBon on “The Crowd”
In 1895, a French physician by the name of Gustave LeBon
wrote a book on crowd behaviour.
He argued that, when in a crowd, people “descend several rungs of the ladder of civilization”.
When individuals are isolated, they are rational and sensible. When they are part of a crowd, they become primitive.
A number of factors contribute to crowd behaviour according to LeBon...
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 39
UTSC
Contagion in the Crowd
Contagion:Opinions and behaviours can be transmitted like germs.
A study by University of Toronto researchers was conducted aat the Ontario Science Centre.
After the presentation of a film, a confederate started clapping.A greater percentage of people joined in and clapped when thetheatre was densely packed than when few people were in the audience.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 40
UTSC
Deindividuation in the Crowd
Deindividuation:
A state of mind where the individual does not feel identified as an
individual. The individual becomes less concerned with social
evaluation and accountability.
Study on deindividuation at Halloween.
Study on deindividuation and baiting a suicide.
• The darkness of night.
• The size of the crowd.
• Distance between the crowd and the suicidal person.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 41
UTSC
The Eight Symptoms of Groupthink
Irving Janis looked at historical situations where groups made terrible decisions. He proposed the notion of Groupthink to account for what happens in cohesive (tight) groups.
• Illusion of invulnerability.
• Belief in the inherent morality of the group.
• Rationalization.
• Stereotypes of outsiders.
• Self-censorship.
• Direct pressure.
• Mind guarding.
• Illusion of unanimity.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 42
UTSC
Video on Groupthink
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 43
UTSC
Prejudice
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 44
UTSC
Some Definitions
• Prejudice: a negative attitude towards a distinguishable group.
• Discrimination: a harmful negative behaviour toward members of a group.
• Stereotype: beliefs about members of a group.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 45
UTSC
Studying Stereotypes
The first scientific study of stereotypes was conducted by Katz and Braly in 1933.
They found the following stereotypes:
• Japanese: Intelligent, Hard Working, Progressive• Chinese: Superstitious, Sly, Conservative• Italians: Artistic, Impulsive, Passionate• British: Sporstmanlike, Intelligent, Conventional• Blacks: Superstitious, Lazy, Happy-Go-Lucky
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 46
UTSC
Stereotype Accuracy
Are stereotypes accurate?
Quick Answer: “yes” and “no”
• Yes: Research comparing stereotypes with known statistics about groups has shown stereotypes to be relatively accurate.
• No: There are many misconceptions about minorities. Immigrants are thought to be less educated than native Canadians, but this is false. Stats Can data shows that they are better educated (and in better health!)
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 47
UTSC
Causes of Prejudice
What causes negative attitudes towards groups?
Answer: The causes of prejudice are varied
• Learning from prejudiced models. • Competition for scarce resources (jobs, health care).• Using vulnerable groups as scapegoats.• Personality (Authoritarian Personality; Social Dominance).• Conforming to social norms.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 48
UTSC
The Two Faces of Prejudice and Racism
Institutional Prejudice: Refers to discriminatory practices and policies in large institutions (e.g. legal system, universities).
Individual Prejudice: Prejudiced feelings and discriminatory behaviours exhibited by an individual.
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 49
UTSC
Institutional Prejudice Still Here?
I claim: Institutional prejudice is no longer a major problem in Canada (please show me wrong if you don’t agree).
Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms Section 15(1):
Every individual is equal before and under the law and has the right to the equal protection and equal benefit of the law without discrimination and, in particular, without discrimination based on race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, sex, age or mental or physical disability.
http://laws.justice.gc.ca/en/charter
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 50
UTSC
How About Homophobia?
Discrimination based on sexual orientation is not mentioned in the Charter. There was a lot of controversy about this when the Charter was drafted. One might interpret this omission as institutional discrimination.
The courts have interpreted 15(1) to include sexual orientation.
Still, as a society, Canada has more prejudicial hang ups about sexual orientation than about any other basis of institutional prejudice (e.g., legalizing gay marriages).
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 51
UTSC
Video on LGBTQ Experience at UTSC
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 52
UTSC
Contemporary Manifestations of Prejudice
All in all, Canada is not doing too badly in getting rid ofinstitutional prejudice.
Section 15(1) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms has set clear standards for the unacceptability of institutional prejudice and discrimination and even homophobia is being fought on the basis of the charter.
The issue is more complicated than that, however, because Section 15(1) is followed by section 15(2) ...
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 53
UTSC
Section 15(2) of the Charter
Section 15 Subsection 2 states:
“Subsection (1) does not preclude any law, program or activity that has as its object the amelioration of conditions of disadvantaged individuals or groups including those that are disadvantaged because of race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, sex, age or mental or physical disability.”
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 54
UTSC
Reverse Discrimination?Reverse Discrimination is a term commonly used to refer to the discriminatory effects that the kinds of programs referred to in 15(2) have upon individuals from non “disadvantaged” groups.
Thus, the term refers to discrimination against members of traditionally advantage groups at the hands of affirmative action and preferential policies.
Let’s look at an example from a letter to the editor of a newspaper (presented in class)
Is the author of the letter prejudiced?
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 55
UTSC
Value Pluralism
Many values are usually associated with policies. These values are often in conflict.
Policy ValuesAffirmative Action Promotes equality for minorities
Violates the merit principle
Banning hate literature Promotes respect for minoritiestoward minorities Undermines freedom of expression
Allowing Sikhs in the Respect for religious rights RCMP to wear turbans Undermines traditional Canadian
symbols
We choose to favour one value more than the other(s).
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 56
UTSC
Video on the Veil in Public Schools in France
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 57
UTSC
Value Pluralism and the Hijab
The French government has argued that the law forbidding “ostentatious” (showy) religious symbols in public schools promotes:
SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE
Critics of the law argue that the law violates:
RELIGIOUS FREEDOM
Is this a case of a conflict between two important values or asimple case of concealed prejudice in French society?
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 58
UTSC
Implicit AttitudesWe normally think of prejudice as an attitude that we areaware of but that we can mask.
Given that we can mask our true negative feelings, it is verydifficult to study prejudice by asking people to report explicitlyhow they feel about members of a group.
One of the great advances in modern social psychology has comefrom the development of methods for measuring implicit attitudes.
Implicit attitudes involve associations we have with entities and members of groups without being aware of the associations.
Implicit associations can be measured without asking for anexplicit report ...
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 59
UTSC
Video on the Implicit Association Test
Chapter 15 - Social Psychology Slide 60
UTSC
You can take the Implicit Association Test here:
www.tolerance.org/hidden_bias
Try it out. More than two million people have!