Changing the Game: Southeast Asia - Step by Step Instructions

8/14/2019 Changing the Game: Southeast Asia - Step by Step Instructions

1/49

Southeast AsiaA policy-making energy game

1Thursday, June 6, 2013


2/49

All information used in this game are solely forthe use of playing the game and are not meantfor interpretation. The organiser disclaims anyand all responsibility and liability that may be

asserted or claimed arising from, or claimed tohave arisen from, reliance upon the use of any

of these information by any person.



3/49

What is CHANGING THE GAME?

A policy-making energy gamebased on the South EastAsia region.

Aims to redesign our energy landscapeusing cleanerenergy sources while educating players about the dilemmasand complexities faced in energy planning.



4/49

Why Changing the Game?

Role play the stakeholders

Plan the energy landscape of your region

Experience the dilemmas faced in making

decisions

Discover the complexity in energy planning



5/49

The Game Elements

Region Information SheetsTo show the background information of the region

Lego BricksTo visualise energy demand and supply

Policy CardsDebate the 4 types of cards to determine which are beneficialto the society & individual stakeholders



6/49

2030 BAU TowerBusiness as usual

TransportTower (1st)

ElectricityConsumption Tower

(2nd)---DEMAND

ElectricityProduction Tower

(3rd)---SUPPLY



7/49

Game objective

DEVIATEfrom the currentBusiness As Usual (BAU)2030 model.

REBUILDyour energy supply mix for Year 2030suchthat energy demands are met and carbon emissionsare reduced.

Draft energy policies for the future from a multi-dimensional approach.

Experience the responsibilities, complexities, andconflictsfaced by different stakeholders



8/49

Judging Criteria

Best Individual

Best Team



9/49

Best Individual

Total 4 winners per game

One best stakeholder for eachrole across the 7 regions

Earn the maximum number ofpoints by meeting yourindividual stakeholderobjectives



10/49

1winning team per game

Ability to fulfil the teamobjectives

Game Facilitator Bonus pointsbased on overall team

performance

**Some individual objectives

may contradict teamobjectives!

Best Team



11/49

How to Play the Game?

Understand your region clearlyUnderstand your objectives as a stakeholderUnderstanding and moving towards the 2030 target

1

Choosing your energy demand path2Decide on the R&D focusTrading Phase for R&D3

Power the electricity consumption: Choose your sources4

Discussion on the target512Thursday, June 6, 2013


12/49

Stage 1: Understand

Annex - 1

In-depth information of theregion such as:

Total Population

% of Rural Population

Renewable Energy Potential

Electricity Production BAU2030 and Regions 2030

target

1



13/49


14/49

Target & ResultInformation

1

Tower 1:2 Ratio



15/49

Energy Price List

Annex - 3

1



16/49

Game/Policy Cards

Transport(Purple)

Electricity Use(Yellow)

Energy Supply /Source (Green)

R&D(White)

1


1


17/49

Step 1:

Understand your region

Region Profile

Target & Result Information 2030 Behavior as Usual (BAU)

2030 Government Target

Take note of the Budget

1


1


18/49

Step 2:

Being a Stakeholder

1

Government

Citizen

NGOs

Industry(Main Energy

Sector)


1


19/49

Individual goals of eachstakeholder

Different priorities (**)

Strictly NOsharing ofobjectives!

Note: Violation of this rule mayresult in disqualification from thegame.

1Step 2:Being a Stakeholder


1


20/49

Collect your envelope fromyour facilitators

Read through your roles and

objectives

Together, plan the future energylandscape as a teambychoosing the policy cards while

trying toachieve your ownindividual objectives

1Step 2:Being a Stakeholder


1


21/49

Step 3:Being a Team

1

The teams are judged on how well they have performedcompared to BAU2030 scenariobased on:

1. Budget performance

2. Carbon emissions reduction

3. Overall performance of 4 stakeholders

4. Equality score balance between 4 stakeholders



22/49


Choosing your energy demand path2


2


23/49

Stage 2: Choosing your

Energy Path

2

What policies to be implemented?

What are the impacts?


2


24/49

Parts of the Card - Front 2

Description ofpolicy

Cost ofimplementation

Effect onelectricity tower

Effect ontransport tower

Your region Type of card,differentiated by thebackground colourPolicy to be

considered


2


25/49

Parts of the Card - Back 2

Discussion points

Impacts of the policy fromdifferent perspectives

the Reality element

Not restricted to thepoints stated


2


26/49

Government Budget

Cost of the 2030 BAU Tower Rebuild from scratch

Account for the Carbon Tax

Spend wisely and reasonably

2


2


27/49

Work towards the government 2030 target

No limit to the number of cards that can be implemented

Meet your individual & team goals

Majoritys choice (>1/2)

Voting boost

Your Objective 2


2


28/49

Work towards the government 2030 target

No limit to the number of cards that can be implemented

Meet your individual & team goals

Majoritys choice (>1/2)

Voting boost

Your Objective 2


2


29/49

A. Transportation Card

For transport tower

Adjust the height of the originalTransport tower after choosingthe policies

***Some policies have impacton Electricity tower

2



30/49

2030 BAUTower 2


31/49


2

Transport

Tower

Maximum

Renewable

Potential

(Bricks)

Solar 15

Hydroelectricity 1

Wind 2

Geothermal 0

Biomass 4



B El t i it C d 2


32/49

B. Electricity Card

Adjust the height of the originalElectricity consumption tower afterchoosing policies.

No reimbursement for bricksremoved.

Special effects must be noted: Buy 5 get 1 free

2


B El t i it C d 2


33/49

Maximum

Renewable

Potential

(Bricks)

Solar 15

Hydroelectricity 1

Wind 2

Geothermal 0

Biomass 4


B. Electricity Card 2


2030 BAUTower 2


34/49


2

ElectricityConsumption Tower

(2nd)

---DEMAND


H t Pl th G ?


35/49


Decide on the R&D focusTrading Phase for R&D3


2030 BAU Tower 3


36/49

Business as usual3

ElectricityProductionTower (3rd)---SUPPLY


Stage 3: 3


37/49

Stage 3:

Technology Trading

To buy or to sell?

What to buy/sell?

How much?

3


R&D Card 3


38/49

R&D Card

For energy sources

R&D is expensive

Benefit: May achieve savings fromimplementing the energy sources

later on

Buy the technology that youneed for your region

You can invest in your owntechnology and sell

Limited to sale by SourceCountry ONLY

3


R&D Card 3


39/49

R&D Card

For energy sources

R&D is expensive

Benefit: May achieve savings fromimplementing the energy sources

later on

Buy the technology that youneed for your region

You can invest in your owntechnology and sell

Limited to sale by SourceCountry ONLY

3


Trading 3


40/49

Trading

Discussion 1Decide on what technology to focus on for selling/buying

Market SurveyCheck out the market demand /supply and the market supply

2 players per region

Discussion 2Decide what to buy/sell, from/to who, at what price (for negotiation in the

next stage)

Final decisionon R&D engaged

Sealing of deal2 players per region to finalize the deal and sign the contract

1 set 2 copies of trading contract




41/49


Power the electricity consumption: Choose your sources4


Stage 4: Power your 4


42/49

Stage 4: Power your

Electricity Consumption

Coal

Hydro

Oil

Natural

Gas

Biomass

Solar

Wind

Nuclear


Energy Price List 4


43/49

Energy Price List



44/49

Power your Electricity 4


45/49

Consum tion

Two towers are of the same height DEMAND = SUPPLY

Incurs Carbon Taxesfor theCarbon emissions from fossil fuels

Carbon tax for both transport andelectricity supply tower

Carbon taxes are staggered paymentwhich is to be made once a certainlimit is exceeded.


Calculate & enter your 4


46/49

yresults




47/49


Discussion on the target

5 56Thursday, June 6, 2013


48/49


49/49

Southeast AsiaA policy-making energy game


Proudly organised and brought to you by Energy Carta

Documents

Changing the Game: Southeast Asia - Step by Step Instructions