13
Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini Giacomini Wetland Restoration Area Wetland Restoration Area National Park Service Point Reyes National Seashore Brannon Ketcham, Hydrologist Point Reyes National Seashore Michael Reichmuth, Fisheries Biologist San Francisco Area Network

Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat GiacominiGiacomini Wetland Restoration AreaWetland Restoration Area

National Park ServicePoint Reyes National Seashore

Brannon Ketcham, Hydrologist

Point Reyes National Seashore

Michael Reichmuth, Fisheries BiologistSan Francisco Area Network

Page 2: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

December 2008Robert Campbell/Chamois Moon

National Park ServicePoint Reyes National Seashore

Lagunitas Creek Estuary

Dynamic Estuarine Transition Zone

Area has undergone dramatic shifts in habitat in the last 150 years.

Page 3: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

Pre-Restoration Condition– Drainage ditches and abandoned slough

•Primarily stickleback and mosquitofish•Low species diversity•Drainage ditches did support tidewater goby

–Flooding constrained to major events

•Levees prevented overbank flow•Only major events overtopped or breached levees•Ponding condition, no lasting habitat effects.

Page 4: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

October 29, 2008Robert Campbell/Chamois Moon

National Park ServicePoint Reyes National Seashore

GiacominiGiacomini Restoration AreaRestoration Area

Giacomini Project a connected freshwater tidal complex at the head of Tomales Bay thereby expanding estuarine transition zone

– Tidal Restoration•Daily tidal regime restored to nearly half of restoration area•Extreme tide events cover more than 67% of the restoration area•Subtidal and tidally ponded areas represent ~20% of project area

– Floodplain Restoration•Active area flooded at ~1.5 to 2-year event•Inundation depth and duration varies based on tidal elevation at time of event

– Seasonal Hydrologic Regime•Primarily freshwater in winter

–December – May•Saline to hypersaline in summer

–June – November

Page 5: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

October 29, 2008Robert Campbell/Chamois Moon

National Park ServicePoint Reyes National Seashore

GiacominiGiacomini Restoration AreaRestoration Area

With only one full post-restoration monitoring event complete, preliminary results indicate:

– Shift in species within Restoration Area•Reduction in mosquitofish, increase in other marine influenced species

– Increase in species diversity

– Fall 2009 observations•Continued increase in diversity•Tidewater goby documented at multiple sites in newly restored habitat•Increase in marine derived species•Decrease in non-native mosquitofish (less freshwater habitat)

Page 6: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

1914

National Park ServicePoint Reyes National Seashore

Figure 2 Average number of fish per station, June 2009.

0

10

20

30

40

50

Native

Gob

ySalm

onids

Sculpi

nStic

kleba

ckTop

smelt

Starry

Flound

erYell

owfin

Gob

yBay

Pipe

fish

Mosqu

itofis

hCali

fornia

Roa

ch

Sacram

ento

Sucke

r

Long

jaw M

udsu

cker

Other

Ave

rage

Num

ber o

f Fis

h pe

r Sam

ple

Loca

tion

Restoration AreaUndiked MarshLagunitas CreekTomasini

130 7554

0

10

20

30

40

50

Native

Gob

ySalm

onids

Sculpi

nStic

kleba

ckTop

smelt

Starry

Flound

erYell

owfin

Gob

yBay

Pipefis

hMos

quito

fish

Califor

nia R

oach

Sacram

ento

Succe

r

Long

jaw M

udsu

cker

Other

Ave

rage

Num

ber o

f Fis

h pe

r Sam

ple

Loca

tion

Restoration AreaUndiked MarshLagunitas CreekTomasini

126

Figure 1 Average number of fish per station, 2005- 2008.

Page 7: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

1914

National Park ServicePoint Reyes National Seashore

0

10

20

30

40

Native

Gob

y

Sculp

in

Stick

lebac

k

Top S

melt

Yello

wfin G

oby

Mos

quito

fish

Bay P

ipefis

h

Other

Ave

rage

Num

ber o

f Fis

h pe

r Sam

ple

Loca

tion

Pre Restoration

Post Restoration

126 133

Figure 3 Average fish per station within Restoration Area. Pre- restoration results include 2005-2008, Post-restoration includes June 2009 only.

Page 8: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

October 29, 2008Robert Campbell/Chamois Moon

National Park ServicePoint Reyes National Seashore

GiacominiGiacomini Restoration AreaRestoration Area

Factors influencing ongoing aquatic habitat changes

– Activation of the floodplain habitat on southern edge of project area•Differential scour and deposition on floodplain and marshplain areas•Recruitment of woody debris and riparian vegetation

– Continued evolution of tidal channel•Expansion of existing channels and development of new channels

Page 9: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

October 29, 2008Robert Campbell/Chamois Moon

National Park ServicePoint Reyes National Seashore

Daily Tidal Inundation

1.5 to 2 year floodplain

Page 10: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

National Park ServicePoint Reyes National Seashore

Page 11: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

September 2009Robert Campbell/Chamois Moon

National Park ServicePoint Reyes National Seashore

Page 12: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

August 5, 2008Robert Campbell/Chamois Moon

National Park ServicePoint Reyes National Seashore

…… and what about the and what about the cohocoho salmon salmon

Page 13: Changing Fish Assemblages and Aquatic Habitat Giacomini … · 2009-11-20 · k le ba c k m e l t l w b y M o s q t o f is h h O t her Average Number of Fish per Sample Location Pre

October 29, 2008Robert Campbell/Chamois Moon

National Park ServicePoint Reyes National Seashore

GiacominiGiacomini Restoration AreaRestoration Area

Potential expanded overwinter habitat for coho salmon

– Project area primarily fresh water for winter and spring months•Monitoring has documented salmonids in the mainstem of Lagunitas•Tidal channels and marshplain could support overwintering fry and smolts until outmigration. •Expanded monitoring efforts include PIT tagging to document individuals