Upload
aspaprj
View
219
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
1/23
Challenges & Risks Facingthe 2010 Automated
Election System (AES)
Edmundo G. Casino, MPA
Philippine Computer SocietyUP NCPAG Alumni Association
MSU, Marawi City, Lanao del Sur
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
2/23
2010 Poll Automation
FIRST TIME EVENTS
Clustering of 75K Precincts
IT Certification of 75,000BEIs & 1,600 BOCs
Use of Two-Faced MachineReadable Ballot nationwide
Automated Synchronizationof Counting & Canvassing
Electronic Transmission ofERs @ 40,000 sites
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
3/23
IMPACT OF THE CHANGES
CLUSTERING OF75,000 PRECINCTS
Cleansing of Lists
Familiarity of Voters
IT CERTIFICATIONOF 75,000 BEIs &1,600 BOCs
Training a battalion ofIT capable electionofficers
USE OF TWO-FACED BALLOTS
Distribution & Printing
AUTOMATEDELECTIONS CCS
Synchronization
ELECTRONIC
TRANSMISSIONLimitations inCoverage
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
4/23
CRITICAL THINGS TO DO in
165 DAYS
Manufacturing & Testing of82,200 PCOS
Development & Testing of theAES Software
Training & Certification ofElection Officers & TechSupport
Installation & Testing of
Transmission ChannelsDemonstration & Source Code
Stakeholder Education
Logistics & Deployment
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
5/23
COMPLIANCE TO RA 9369
Official, basis
for Canvassing
& Proclamation
Sec. 19 [22]Official Election
Results
Canvassers, two
parties, citizens
arms & KBP
Sec. 19 [22]
Election Returns
Transmission
Sequence
n.) Provide the
voter a system
Sec. 7 [6]
Minimum Cap
Voter Choice
Verification
ContextProvisionsAES Features
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
6/23
MULTIPLE & PARALLEL
ACTIVITIES
AES Development
Logistics
Training
Techno-Legal Panel
PR & Media
StakeholderEducation
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
7/23
AES Development Activity
Hardware
Manufacturing
Delivery
SoftwareCasting, Counting,Canvassing
Transmission
Electronic Signature
AuthenticationTesting & QualityAssurance
Demo & Certification
Source Code Review
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
8/23
AES Development Activity
Testing & Quality
Assurance
Application Systems
Software
Customized PCOS
Device
Examination & Testing
of HW & SW
Escrow Source Code
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
9/23
LOGISTICS & DEPLOYMENT
Regional Hubs
Luz-Vis-Min
Type of Transport
Land, Air, Sea
Advance Team
Trainers, Tech
Support, Help Desk
Timetable & Sequence
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
10/23
IT TRAINING &
CERTIFICATION
Precinct-Based BEIs
75,000 BEIs
40,000 Sites
Local BOCs
1,600 BOCs
National BOCs
86 Provincial BOCs
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
11/23
TECHNO-LEGAL PANEL
Types of Contest
Registered Voters
AES Related
Canvassing &
Proclamation
Definition of Terms
Qualification ofContests
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
12/23
PUBLIC RELATIONS &
MEDIA
Secretariat
Writers
Creative
Campaigns
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
13/23
STAKEHOLDER EDUCATION
Sec 26 [31] of RA 9369General Public &Voters
Commissions Staff
DepED & DOFDeputies
LGU Officials
Incumbent ElectedOfficials
Political Parties &Candidates
Military & Police
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
14/23
CHALLENGES to COMELEC
COMELEC is only
staffed with 5,000
employees
There will be 250,000
Deputies to be trained
with 75,000 Certified
500,000 CitizensArms to be oriented
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
15/23
CHALLENGES TO
SMARTMATIC-TIM
Delivery Schedule
Need for Technical
Manpower
Systems Development
for Synchronized
Elections
Never been Tested
Mission Impossible
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
16/23
POTENTIAL PROBLEMS
Procedural Shortfall
Delivery Backlogs
Pre-Shading Ballots
Pockets of SystemFailure
ACM Device-based
Transmission
Software Malfunction
Mass Confusion
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
17/23
COUNTERMEASURE
Random Manual Audit
Sec. 24 [29] of RA 9369
Where AES is used, there shall
be a random manual audit in one
precinct per congressionaldistrict randomly chosen by
the Commission in EACH
province & city. Any difference
will initiate a manual countaffected by the computer or
procedural error.
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
18/23
CASE-SCENARIO BUILDING
Proclamation Contests
Succession in National
Leadership
Constitutional Crisis
Civil Unrest & Chaos
Military Junta
Revolutionary
Government
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
19/23
RECOMMENDED COURSE OF
ACTION
Thorough CHANGE
Management Plan
Detailed RISK
Management Plan
Technical-Legal
Review Board Panel
Organizational TaskForce
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
20/23
JUDICIAL COURSE ACTION
Supreme Court Reso
on Techno & Legal
House Electoral
Tribunal Courts
Senate Electoral
Tribunal Courts
National ElectoralTribunal Course
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
21/23
LESSONS LEARNED ON
ONDOY & PEPENG
EVERYBODY
ANYBODYSOMEBODY
NOBODY
PREPAREDNESS
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
22/23
CONCLUSION
THIS IS A MULTI-
STAKHOLDER
ENGAGEMENT.
ALL QUARTERSMUST GET
ORGANIZED &
PARTICIPATE
8/14/2019 Challenges & Risks Facing the 2010 Automated Election
23/23
In the end,
We need to maintain
sobriety, peace, and
harmony among our
fellowmen and call forpatriotism and duty to
country as the future
of democracy is at
stake here.