18
CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU ( MBBS, FWACS, FMAS, DMAS ) & DR ADAMU N AISHA ( MBBS, FWACS, FMAS, DMAS ) LAPAROSCOPIC SURGICAL UNIT FMC BIRNIN KEBBI AT SOGON ASABA 2014 PRE-CONFERENCE WORKSHOP

CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

C H A L L E N G E S A N D P R O S P E C T O F L A PA R O S C O P I C

S U R G E RY I N A L O W R E S O U R C E S E T T I N G : O U R

E X P E R I E N C E AT F M C B I R N I N - K E B B I

P R E S E N T E D B Y

D R Y U S U F TA N K O S U N U N U ( M B B S , F WA C S , F M A S , D M A S )

&

D R A D A M U N A I S H A ( M B B S , F WA C S , F M A S , D M A S )

L A PA R O S C O P I C S U R G I C A L U N I T

F M C B I R N I N K E B B I

AT

S O G O N A S A B A 2 0 1 4 P R E - C O N F E R E N C E W O R K S H O P

Page 2: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Outline

IntroductionResult of our ExperienceChallengesOvercoming ChallengesProspectsConclusion

Page 3: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Introduction

Technological advancement has made it possible for many "open surgical" procedures to be done via endoscopic route.

Laparoscopy has advantages of;

Less postoperative pain

Shorter duration of hospital stay

Early return of patients to normal activities.

Less post operative adhesion formation

Precise definition of anatomy and pathology

Page 4: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Despite above advantages practice of laparoscopy in Nigeria is still rudimentary and is mainly diagnostic.

Possible reasons are; underfunding of healthcare Cost of the service Inadequacy of trained personnel Reluctance of locally based Gynaecologist to change from

the traditional method of surgery

Page 5: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Our Experiences

Laparoscopic Surgical Unit was established in April, 2012

A total 60 surgeries have been done with 42 (70%) Gynaecological

Out of the forty two cases 22 (57.14%) were operative and 18 (42.8 6%) were diagnostic

The patient age ranges from16 to 37 years and mean age was 25.8

Complication were minimal with only 2 cases of Subcutaneous emphysema

Conversion rate was 7.1% (N = 3)

Page 6: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Procedures

Laparoscopy and dye testLaparoscopic ovarian drillingLippes loop retrievalAdhesiolysisOvarian cystectomyLaparoscopic Salpingectomy for ectopic pregnancyLaparoscopic bilateral tubal ligationLaparoscopic assisted MyomectomyHysteroscopic adhesiolysis for Ashermans Syndrome

nit has received 3 gynaecologists for hands on training

Page 7: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Challenges

Patient factorsCost of the service to the patients leading to poor

patient’s complianceUnyielding cervix Late presentation and so non-suitability of most patients

that could benefit from laparoscopic surgeryProvider factors include –

No centre provide all ranges of minimal access gynaecological procedures

Having to negotiate the a learning curve Lack of interest for the procedure among other cadre

of staff

Page 8: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Logistic issues Maintenance of equipment – costly, expertise not

readily available Constant supply of electricity

Systemic factorsIndependent laparoscopic surgical unit vs. combine theatre unitsCost of providing laparoscopic surgical services to the hospital

Page 9: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Overcoming the Challenges

Locally improvise instrumentsUse of reusable instruments as much as possibleUse of hybrid or clone laparoscopic machineSubsidising cost to the patientsProvision of alternative sources of power supply Proper patient selection

Respect for learning curve

Encouraging team work among Gynaecologist, surgeons and other stake holders

Page 10: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Prospect

Prospect for laparoscopy in gynaecological practice in Nigeria is good

However may require ;Institutional collaborations Incorporation of laparoscopy in our postgraduate training curriculaCapital investment in man power development and equipmentsCreating awareness among patientsFormation of National and Regional Association of Laparoscopic surgeons

Page 11: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Conclusion

Despite challenges practise of laparoscopic surgery in a low resource setting is possible.

It requires more interest in acquisition of new skills by our surgeons, more financial commitment from our health care managers, and a raised awareness on its advantages to our patients/clients.

With these achieved, the prospect of laparoscopic surgery in low resource settings is good

Page 12: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Teckno Laparoscopic Tower and Machine

Page 13: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Laparoscopic Session

Page 14: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Slow leaking ectopic gestationuss findings

Page 15: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Day 5 post op following laparoscopic salpingectomy

Page 16: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Improvised fluid delivery system for hysteroscopy

Page 17: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

Thank you for listening

Page 18: CHALLENGES AND PROSPECT OF LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY IN A LOW RESOURCE SETTING : OUR EXPERIENCE AT FMC BIRNIN-KEBBI PRESENTED BY DR YUSUF TANKO SUNUNU (MBBS,

References

Perissat J. Laparoscopic surgery: A pioneer's point of view. World J Surg 1999;23:863-8. 

Garry R. Gynaecological Endoscopy. The next 10 years; Editorial, Gynae. Endos. 2002; 11:1-3.

Bittner R. Laparoscopic surgery – 15years after clinical introduction. World J Surg 2006; 30: 1190–1203.