CFL Presentation in BIS Oct06 Final

7/23/2019 CFL Presentation in BIS Oct06 Final

1/26

Comparative Testing Results of 14Comparative Testing Results of 14

Popular Selling Brands & Types ofPopular Selling Brands & Types of CFLsCFLs


2/26

OBJECTIVESOBJECTIVES

Enable Consumers to Make an Informed

Choice Among Multiple Brands Available

To Draw Public Attention to Unsafe Goods

and Unfair Trade Practices

To Generate Consumer Pressure onProducers to Increase the Quality of Their

Products.

Raise Standards of These Products by

Increasing Public Awareness on Products


3/26

TEST METHODOLOGY BASED ONTEST METHODOLOGY BASED ON

NATIONAL STANDARDSNATIONAL STANDARDS

IS : 15111 (Part 1) : Self Ballasted Lamps

for General Lighting Services SafetyRequirements

IS : 15111 (Part 2) : Self Ballasted Lamps

for General Lighting Services Performance

Requirements

CFL Production Trends in India 2.5 million per

month.

Annual growth = 20-25% per year


4/26

Development of

Test Program

Comparative Product

Testing Process

Test Program

to Institutions

Test Program

to ManufacturersOmbudsman Committee

Meeting

Samples to

Laboratory

Lab Testing

& MonitorLab ReportEvaluation

Clarification to

Manufacturers& Retest, if reqd.

Test Results

Grading & Rating

Publish Test Report

& Dissemination

Test Results to

Manufacturers

Market

survey

Masking

& Coding

Lab finalize with

Test Charges

Samples

Purchase


5/26

Market Survey Results and Brands

Approval for testing for 15 Watt

Detailed market survey conducted in 4 metros in 4th Quarter04

Brands proposed for testing from Survey Report

1. PHILIPS 2. WIPRO

3. CG 4. ORPAT

5. HAVELLS 6. OSRAM

7. BAJAJ 8. GE

9. LEUCI 10. HALONIX

11. SURYA 12. ANGELO

13. CEMA 14. ANCHOR

Approval taken for testing in the committee meeting in April05


6/26

15Life12

10Lumen Maintenance11

8Colour Appearance10

15Lamp Efficacy9

10Luminous Flux8

10Lamp Wattage7

7Power Factor6

5Run-up Time Test5

5Starting Test4

5Cap Temperature Rise3

5Insulation Resistance2

5Labelling & Packing1.

WeightageParametersSr. No.

Test Parameters & Weightage


7/26

Purchase of Samples

Purchased from authorized retailers /

dealers.

Masking and Coding of samples to concealidentity

NABL Laboratory agreement for Testing

and Samples handed over


8/26

Major Processing Schedule of

CFL Testing

Market Survey to Identified Brands in 4th

Qtr.Dialogue with Stake Holders 02/05

Sample Purchase 04/05

Commencement of Testing 05/05Testing Completed 06/06

Sharing of Test Results with

Manufacturers 07/06Settlement of Clarifications 08/06


9/26

Performance Results of Key Parameters

Power Factor (Wt. 8%)

0.569ANCHOR

0.558CEMA

0.616ANGELO

0.553SURYA

0.525HALONIX

0.651LEUCI

0.884GE*

0.536BAJAJ

0.539OSRAM

0.548HAVELLS

0.595ORPAT

0.563CG

0.596WIPRO

0.591PHILIPS

Mean value of Power FactorBrands

*Only one brand meets the requirement (0.85)


10/26

Lamp Wattage* against Rated 15W

(10%)

17.06

14.68

12.54

13.76

12.76

7.47

13.98

13.46

14.59

13.9

13.41

13.55

14.13

13.7

Mean value Watts

ANCHOR

CEMA

ANGELO

SURYA

HALONIX

LEUCI

GE

BAJAJ

OSRAM

HAVELLS

ORPAT

CG

WIPRO

PHILIPS

Brands

*Tolerance -10% & +15%


11/26

Luminous Flux (minimum 765) 10%

1105ANCHOR

1039CEMA

737ANGELO

891SURYA

840HALONIX

212LEUCI

969GE

878BAJAJ

931OSRAM

1031HAVELLS

847ORPAT

866CG

881WIPRO

1013PHILIPS

Mean valueBrands

Brands Anchor, Cema, Havels & Phillips have highest

Lumens. Leuci failed miserably


12/26

Lamp Efficacy (Lumen / Watt) 15 %

64.80ANCHOR

70.78CEMA

58.76ANGELO

64.79SURYA

65.99HALONIX

29.17LEUCI

69.31GE

65.73BAJAJ

63.27OSRAM

74.19HAVELLS

63.19ORPAT

63.90CG

62.64WIPRO

73.96PHILIPS

Mean ValueBrands

Havells, Phillips tops the Efficacy

Leuci performed very poorly


13/26

COLOUR APPEARANCE TEST SDCM (8%)

0 / 15ANCHOR

3 / 3CEMA

3 / 3ANGELO

3 / 3SURYA

3 / 3HALONIX

0 / 13LEUCI

0 / 15GE5 / 15BAJAJ

0 / 15OSRAM

5 / 15HAVELLS

3 / 3ORPAT

3 / 3CG

3 / 3WIPRO

3 / 3PHILIPS

Number of lamps, out of number tested,

falling within tolerance area defined byMacAdam eclipses of 5 SDCM

Brands Name

Brand Name Osram, GE, Leuci & Anchor failed miserably in the Colour Test and the next in that orderare Havells & Bajaj. The highest score was achieved by Brands Name Philips, Wipro, CG, Orpat,

Halonix, Surya, Angelo & Cema


14/26

LUMEN MAINTENANCE AT 2000 HRS. (10 %)

Brand Name Leuci failed miserably in Lumen Maintenance Test, and the highest score was achieved

by sample code Philips.

87.1 90.9891 out of 10ANCHOR

89.3 90.7907 out of 10CEMA

42.742.79 out of 10ANGELO

32.0 78.348.84 out of 10SURYA88.9 95.591.80 out of 10HALONIX

10 out of 10LEUCI

86.9 93.088.30 out of 10GE

80.8 98.790.85 out of 10BAJAJ

85.6 93.688.20 out of 10OSRAM

74.4 87.983,41 out of 10HAVELLS

80.9 87.283.10 out of 10ORPAT

32.4 74.252.56 out of 10CG

43.9 96.8822 out of 10WIPRO

87.1 96.092.80 out of 10PHILIPS

Range %Mean %

Lumen maintenance ValueNo. of lamps

having life less than

2000 h

Lumen Maintenance at 2000 hBrands Name


15/26

LIFE TEST* (15 %)

9ANCHOR

3CEMA

0ANGELO

3SURYA

10HALONIX

0LEUCI

10GE

5BAJAJ

10OSRAM

9HAVELLS

10ORPAT

2CG

8WIPRO

10PHILIPS

No. of CFLs Completed

3000 h from 10 lamps

Brands

Name

*All the Samples of 5 brands Philips, Orpat, Osram, GE, Halonix qualify for 3KH Life Test followed

by Anchor & Havells (9 Lamps) and Wipro (8 lamp).


16/26

yellowishCool day

lightLight Colour

01634.6Savings Over Lamp Life

2187552.4Total Cost

60Lamps Replaced in 2.7 years

810162Annual operating Cost @ Rs. 5 kwh

167 days1000 days

( 2.7 years)Lamp Life ( 6 hrs /day use)

10115Cost of Lamps (Ave. Retail Prices)

75-Watt

Incandescent

Lamp

15-Watt

Compact

Fluorescent

Cost Comparison Between CFLs

& Incandescent Lamp


17/26

Sharing of Test Results with

Manufacturers

Sent individual results to all concerned Cos. Clarification received from

1. CG 7. CEMA

2. Havells 8. Orpat

3. Wipro 9. Bajaj

4. Philips 10. Angelo

5. Osram

6. GE Leuci not reachable

All Clarification settled


18/26

CFL PERFORMANCE CHARTCFL PERFORMANCE CHART

*Retail prices have come down by about 8% due to reduction in Excise Duty in FY 06-07

20/-38.54321.63225.1553.754.5451.514. LEUCI

100/-64.8133.65810.896.73.644.88554.8554.213. ANGELO

115/-73.125.44.69812.267.866.474.46554.7854.212. CROMPTON

GREAVES

120/-75.3398.083.7312.757.976.664.24554.853.111. BAJAJ

115/-75.656.65.41812.498.087.284.38554.9153.510. SURYA

130/-80.9513.88.41.612.5106.844.51554.753.69. ANCHOR

135/-82.476.67.31814.099.419.574.42554.9753.18. CEMA

130/-82.73158.351.612.098.449.184.27554.8547. OSRAM

130/-83.7112.66.62811.927.998.314.72554.7553.86. WIPRO

135/-83.85157.13812.077.695.574.71554.68545. ORPAT

115/-84.6913.86.913.73159.347.734.34554.84544. HAVELLS

150/-86.2158.381.613.78.788.64755553.13. GE

100/-86.23159.64812.817.635.184.16554.81542. HALONIX

160/-92.81510814.949.187.24.6854.754.8554.21. PHILIPS

10015108151010755555WEIGHTAGE>

Retail

Price*

as on04/05

Total

Score

LifeLum

-en

Maintena

nce

Col-

our

Effic-

acy

Lumin-

ous

Flux

Lamp

Watta-

ge

Pow

er

Factor

Run-

up

TimeTest

Star-

ting

Test

Cap

Tempe

rat-ureRise,

InsulationResistance

Packi

ng &

Marking

Parameters >


19/26

Conclusion & Advice

on Best Buys in Descending Orders

1. Philips

2. Halonix

3. GE

4. Havells

5. Orpat

6. Wipro

7. Osram


20/26

NEXT 3 TEST REPORTS IN THE

PIPELINE FOR RELEASE

Beltek15.

Philips14. V Guard

TCL13. GE

Videocon12. KhaitanUshaPanasonic11. Perfekt

SumeetSony10. Aqua

PhilipsSanyo9. Sarvo

PanasonicSansui8. Arise

Morphy RichardsSamsung7. Ujala

Maharaja whitelineSalora6. Kirolaskar

KenstarT. Series5. Usha

JaipanOnida4. Crompton Greaves

InalsaLG3. CRI Nirmal

Black &DeckerHyundai2. Susi Sugan

BajajHaier1. Ventura SharpJuicer Mixer GrindersColour TVs 21 FlatMono Pump - 0.5 hp


21/26

VOICE involvement in Energy Conservation &

Harmonization Initiatives With :

BEE Bureau of Energy Efficiency

SARI/E South Asia Regional Initiative / Energy

IIEC International Institute of Energy Conservation

CLASP Collaborative Labelling & Standard Prog.

USAID United States Agency for Intl. Devp. SLEMA Srilanka Energy Managers Association

SLSI Sri Lanka Standard Institute

CRCP Consumer Rights Commission of Pakistan

NABL Laboratories


22/26

VOICE Joins Select Group of International

CFL Harmonization Initiative


23/26

PRODUCTS IN THE PIPELINE FOR

PUBLISHING

Nov06

Dec06

Jan06Feb06

March06

April06

April06

May06April06

May06

Sept05

Sept05

Sept05Sept05

Sept05

Jams

Health Drinks

Mono Pump SetFood Mixer

CTV

Tentative

Publishing

Schedule

Samples to

Lab

Test

Program

Finalized

Products

Contd


24/26

Awaiting

fundsrelease

from

Govt.

Finalized

FinalizedFinalized

Finalized

Survey to be conducted

Survey to be conductedSurvey to be conducted



Survey to be conductedSurvey to be conducted



Finalized

FinalizedFinalized

Finalized

Developed

Being DevelopedBeing Developed

Being Developed

Being Developed

Being DevelopedBeing Developed

Being Developed

Being Developed

Wheat Flour

Hair Shampoo Electric Steam Iron

Washing Machine

Invertor

Water Purifier Detergent powder

Chocolate

Fairness Cream]

Bread Ice Cream

Tomato Ketchup

Refrigerator

RemarksBrands FinalizedTest Program

Finalized

Products

Contd...Next Product Testing Schedule 06-07


25/26

Working in Consumer Interest

since 1983 on Empowermentour National MOU Partners

NCH CCC VOICE

Our International Affiliated Partners

ICRT CICLASP

TH NK YOU


26/26

Documents

CFL Presentation in BIS Oct06 Final