CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(07_Aug-18_Aug... · Case summary Action Due & ... ground study in relation to number of drains,

CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD

LAW DIVISION

07th August to 18th August, 2017

S.

No

Case No. &

Title

Advocate &

Division Case summary

Action Due &

Compliance by CPCB

SUPREME COURT (02 CASES)

01 Civil Appeal No.

4697 of 2017

(Association of

Vishwas Nagar

Small Scale

MFG & Traders

Regd. Vs Union

of India & ors

Smt. Aruna

Mathur. Sh.

A.S.Soni.

Regarding Plastic

Industries

Reply Filed.

Listed on 09/08/2017.

02 W.P.(C)No.1302

9 of 1985 M.C.

Mehta vs Union

of India & ors

Shri Vijay

Panjwani

Sh. Prashant

Gargava.

Vehicular Pollution in

Delhi. Directions given

to manufacturers/

dealers of diesel

vehicles of 2000 cc

capacity and more to

deposit 1% EPC to

CPCB.

Reply Filed.

Likely to be Listed on

10/08/2017.

National Green Tribunal ,PB, New Delhi ( 90 cases)

03 OA NO.

538/2016

Suresh Chandra Yadav

Vs.

CPCB & Ors.

Adv.Rajkumar

HWMD

(Shri B. Vinod Babu)

Related to Bio-medical

waste treatment plant.

CPCB reply already

filed.

Listed on 08.08.2017

04 OA NO.276/2017

Original

Application No.

(W.P. © No.

725/1994) News Item

published in

Hindustran

Times “And Quiet Flows the

Maily Yamuna”

Vs.

Central

Pollution Control Board

& Ors

Adv. Alpana Poddar

WQM-I

(Shri. R.M.

Bhardwaj)

Related to Cleaning of River Yamuna.

Matter transferred to

NGT PB, New Delhi

From Hon’ble Supreme

Court of India.

The authorities along with the Central

Pollution Control

Board to conduct

ground study in

relation to number of drains, flow, quality

and quantity of

effluents in the drain

and the feasibility of establishing of STP/

CETP, if necessary.

Status Report is filed.


05 OA. No. 277 of 2017

Ashok Narain

Sharma

Vs.

National Ganga River Basin

Authority

Adv. Alpana Poddar

WQM-I

(Shri. R.M.

Bhardwaj)

Related to Cleaning of River Yamuna.

Matter transferred to

NGT PB, New Delhi

From Hon’ble Supreme

Court of India.

The authorities along with the Central

Pollution Control

Board to conduct

ground study in

relation to number of drains, flow, quality

and quantity of

effluents in the drain

and the feasibility of establishing of STP/

CETP, if necessary.

Status Report is filed.


06 OA

NO.64/2016

Gopeshwar

Nath Chaturvedi

Vs.

U.P.P.C.B &

Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-SSI

(I/C Shri Abhay

Singh)

Related to industries

operating illegally in

the residential areas of

the Mathura town.

CPCB reply already

filed.


07 OA NO.

473/2016

Kantanath Chaturvedi

Vs.

U.P.P.C.B &

Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-SSI

(I/C Shri Abhay Singh)

Related to industries

operating illegally in

the residential areas of the Mathura town.

CPCB reply already

filed.


08 OA NO.495/2016

Shri Mahipal

Vs.

Union of India

& Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar IPC-SSI

(I/C Shri Abhey

Singh)

Illegal activities in Aravalli Forest Ridge

area.

CPCB reply already filed.


09 OA

NO.101/2014

Shobha Singh Vs.

State of Punjab

& Ors.

Adv.Alpana

Poddar

WQM (Shri

R.M.Bhardwaj)

Related to untreated

sewage of city

Ludhiana discharging into Budha Nala,

Ludhiana, Punjab.

CPCB reply and joint

inspection conducted

by PPCB & CPCB report already filed


10 OA No.

690/2016

Anil Verma

Vs. UOI & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

UPC-I

(Smt. Mita

Sharma)

Related to Railway

Project at gurgaon

Railway Station.

CPCB reply already

filed


11 OA No.

199/2014 Almitra H.

Patel

Vs.

Union of India & Ors.

Adv. Vijay

Panjwani (UPC-II)

Shri M.K.

Chaudhary

Report filed in

response of Order Dated 13.01.2017.

CPCB has filed status

report received from States.


12 OA NO.

61/2017 Almitra H.

Patel

Vs.

Union of India

& Ors.

Adv. Vijay

Panjwani (UPC-II)

Shri M.K.

Chaudhary

Report filed in

response of Order Dated 13.01.2017.

Last opportunity

granted to States who

have not filed their

Action Plan or Reply to Show Cause Notice.

CPCB received status

report from States is already filed.


13 OA No. 6/2012

Manoj Mishra Vs.

U.O.I. & Ors.

Adv. Alok Kumar

WQM-I (Shri. R.M.

Bhardwaj)

Related to STPS in

Delhi and cleaning on River Yamuna.

CPCB reply already

filed. Committee has been

constituted by the

tribunal for cleaning of

Yamuna. Listed at 3:00 p.m. for

stakeholders.


14 OA NO. 290/2017

Suo Moto

Court on its

own Motion

Vs. NCT, Delhi &

Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar IPC-I

(Shri Gurnam

Singh)

Related to Gas Leakage in International

Container Depot,

Tuglakabad, New

Delhi.

Joint Inspection conducted by DPCC &

CPCB.

Report is already filed.

Tribunal directed to

conduct the Joint Inspection again of the

Unit situated in

Sonipat, Haryana by a

team of CPCB, HSPCB, Industry Department,

Haryana and MoEF &

CC.

Joint Inspection

conducted and filed. Listed on 08.08.2017

15 OA

NO.123/2016 Rajendra

Krishan

Sharma

Vs.


Adv. Rajkumar

UPCD (I/C Ms. Mita

Sharma)

Widening of Roads

Project from NH-8 to Sector 55-56 in

Gurgaon.

CPCB reply already

filed. Listed at 4:00 P.M for

hearing by video

conferencing with the

Hon’ble Mr. Ranjan

Chatterjee, Expert Member who is

presently sitting at

Western Zonal Bench at

Pune Listed on 08.08.2017

16 OA NO.

36/2012 Rajiv Narayan

Vs.

Union of India

& Ors.

Adv. Alpana

Poddar HWMD

(Shri B. Vinod

Babu)

Related to Hazardous

Waste disposal.

CPCB/ UPPCB to file a

chronological list of dates when the

consent was granted

/declined,compliance

of the condition etc


17 O.A

No.103/2017

Somika chandhok Vs.

Union of India

& Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

UPCD

(Mita Sharma)

Related to noise

pollution being caused

due to loudspeakers, DJ systems, and in

Gurgaon.

CPCB reply already

filed.


18 OA NO.

418/2015

Ferozpur

Welfare Society (Regd.)

Vs.

State of

Haryana & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-SSI

(I/c Shri Abhey

Singh)

Unauthorized polluting

industries setup in the

agricultural land,

causing damage to the crops, drains water by

hazardous chemicals

waste.

CPCB reply already

filed


19 OA NO. 93/2017

R.L.Sharma &

Ors.

Vs.

New Okhla Industrial

Development

Authority &

Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar UPC-II

Shri

M.K.Chaudhary

Related to Non compliance of citizen

charter of NOIDA & to

restore the green belt

area of Section-48

Noida.

CPCB reply already filed


20 OA

NO.04/2013

Sonya Ghosh Vs.

State of

Haryana & Ors.

Adv.Rajkumar

IPC IV-SSI

(Shri Abhay Singh)

Related to mining

activities in all the

reserved forests, and protected forests.

CPCB reply already

filed.


21 M.A. No. 885 /2017 in

OA NO. 177 of

2017 Ashwini

Kumar & Anr. Vs.

Central

Pollution

Control Board

& Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar IPC-III

(Dr. M

Madhusudnan)

Related to untreated discharge of effluents

from M/s Triveni

Engineering, Jolly

Road, Muzaffarnagar, UP.

M.A. Disposed Off

CPCB reply is filed.

Joint Inspection has to

be conducted by the CPCB & UPPCB and

submit the report.


22 OA NO.

500/2016

Krishan Kumar Vs.

Chief

Secretary,

Govt. Of NCT of Delhi & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-SSI

(Shri Abhey Singh)

Related to illegal

workshops running in

Residential Area in East Delhi.

Survey has been

completed by the Joint

Inspection team of DPCC, CPCB & NDMC.

Report already filed by

DPCC.


23 OA NO.

263/2015 Sanjay Kumar

Vs.

State of UP &

Ors.

Adv.Rajkumar

IPC-II (Shri N.K.Gupta)

Pollution caused by

Hindustan Coca Cola Beverages Pvt. Ltd.

Joint inspection

conducted by UPPCB & CPCB already filed.


24 Suo Moto

Application No.

125/2017

Court on its own Motion

Vs.

State of

Karnataka

.Adv. Rajkumar

WQM

Shri R.M.

Bhardwaj

Related to Bellandur

Lake on Fire, Toxic

Smoke Leaves,

Bengaluru Angry and Stunned news on

NDTV website dated

17.02.2017.

CPCB affidavit is filed.


25 OA NO. 668/2016

Abhinav

Guleria

Vs.

CPCB & Ors.

Adv. Alpana Poddar

Fresh matter

PCP

(Dr. S.K.Nigam)

Related to permission to use of Oxo-

biodegradable plastic

bags in India.



26 OA

No.570/2016

M/s Anjali Infra Housing

LLP.Vs. UOI &

Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

PCP

(Shri J.S Kamyotra)

Related to violation of

EIA notification 2006

construction activity in Chennai.

Report of Expert

Committee filed by

CPCB Listed on 09.08.2017

27 Appeal

No.40/2016 &

Appeal

No.41/2016

M/s SPR & RG Construction

Pvt. Ltd. &

M/s Dugar

Housing Ltd. vs. MoEF &

Anr.

Adv. Rajkumar

PCP

(Shri J.S.

Kaymyotra)

CPCB is not the party.

Expert Committee

Report has been filed

by the Committee


28 OA NO.175/2015

Shailesh Singh

Vs.

Hotel Jaypee

Vasant, N.D. & Ors.


(I/C Shri

M.Madhusudan)

Related to groundwater extraction by the Hotel

Jaypee Vasant, N.D.



29 OA NO.

176/2015 Shailesh Singh

Vs.

Hotel Holiday

Regency, Moradabad &

Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-III (Dr. M.

Madhusudan)

Related to Extraction

of Ground Water by the Hotel Holiday

Regency.

CPCB reply already

filed. Listed on 09.08.2017

30 OA NO. 407/2015

Shailesh Singh

Vs.

The Suryaa

Hotel, New Delhi &Ors.


(Shri

M.Madhusudan)

Related to extraction of ground water by the

Hotel Surya, New

Delhi.



31 OA NO. 484/2015

Shailesh Singh

Vs.

Hotel the

Oberoi Amarvilas &

Ors.

Adv. Alpana Poddar

IPC-III

(I/C Shri

M.Madhusudan)

Related to extraction of ground water by the

Hotel Oberoi

Amarvilas, Agra.



32 OA NO. 117/2014

Shantanu

Sharma

Vs. U.O.I. &Ors.

Adv. Alok Kumar IPC-II

(Dr.S.K.Paliwal)

Related to proper utilization of Fly Ash

generated by the Coal

and Lignite based

Thermal Power Plants with respect to the Fly

Ash brick ndustry

notifications issued by

the MoEF&CC.



33 OA NO.

498/2015

Pushp Saini Vs.

MoEF & Ors.

Adv. Alpana

Poddar

WQM (I/C Shri

R.M.Bhardwaj)

This matter is related

to maintenance of

environmental flows in rivers downstream of

Hydro-Power projects.

Hydro-Power Projects

to release & maintain a

free flow of water not less than 15% of the

main flow.

CPCB reply already

filed.


34 Original Application No.

228/2017

Mohd. Shariq

Vs. Govt. of NCT of

Delhi & Ors.

Adv.Rajkumar IPC-SSI

(Shri Abhey

Singh)

Related to running of illegal factories in the

non-conforming areas/

residential areas i.e, at

street Kotana, Suiwalan, Daryaganj,

Delhi



35 OA NO.277/2013

Dr.Irfan Ahmad

& Ors.

Vs.

Mr. Nawang Rigzin Jora &

ors.

Adv. Rajkumar UPC-II

(Shri

M.K.Chaudhary)

CPCB IS NOT RESPONDENT.

The Learned Counsel

appearing for the State

of Jammu & Kashmir,

upon instructions from the concerned officer,

submits that the

tender for Waste to

Energy Plant would be finalized by 23rd July,

2017.


36 OA

NO.276/2015

Jitender Yadav

Vs.

UOI & Ors.

Adv.Alok Kumar

UPCD

(Shri Mantu

Kumar

Choudhury)

Related to

indiscriminate

dumping and throwing

of MSW and Burning

in U.K.

CPCB reply already

filed.


37 OA

NO.306/2016 Social Action

for Forest and

Environment(S

AFE)

Vs. Union of India

& Ors.

(Earlier titled

as D.K.Joshi Vs.

Union of India

& Ors.

Adv. Saqib

UPC-II (Shri

M.K.Choudhury)

Related to

Management of Solid Waste in Taj

Trapezium Zone (TTZ).

.

CPCB reply already


38 OA NO.

90/2017

Safal Bharat

Guru

Parampara & Ors.

Vs.

State of Punjab

& Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-SSI

(Shri Abhey

Singh)

Related to Plywood

Industry in the State of

Punjab.

CPCB reply is already

filed.


39 OA NO.21/2014

Vardhman

Kaushik

Vs.

U.O.I. & Ors.

Adv.Alpana Poddar

AQM-II

(Dr. Prashant

Gargav)

Related to pollution from construction sites

& vehicular emissions.

CPCB reply already

filed.

Joint Inspection

completed.

Report will be filed by GNCT of Delhi.


40 OA

NO.04/2017(T

HC)

All India Plastic Association &

Anr. Vs.

GNCT Delhi &

ors.

Adv.Rajkumar

UPCD

(Dr.S.K.Nigam)

Related to plastic

waste management.

This matter is

transferred from Delhi High court


41 OA NO.

584/2016

Lt. Gen.

Satwant Singh Dahiya, AVSM,

VSM (Retd.)

Vs.

Ministry of

Environment, Forests &

Climate

Change & Anr.

Adv.Rajkumar

UPCD

(I/c Mita Sharma)

Relating to releasing of

Human Excreta from

Aircraft.

CPCB has filed

inspection report. Tribunal Directed to

DGCA and CPCB to file

an affidavit. CPCB

reply is ready to be

filed.


42 OA NO.

34(THC)/2014

Digvijay Singh Vs.

State of

Rajasthan &

Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-VI

Shri Nazimmudin

Related to CETP in Pali

District of Rajasthan.

CPCB reply already

filed.

Joint Inspection conducted.

Report will be filed by

RSPCB.


43 OA NO.

124/2015

Sumitra Devi

Vs. CPCB & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-SSI

(I/C Shri Abhay

Singh)

Related to interstate

waste water pollution

problem residents of

Dharuhera and nearby villager of Haryana &

Bhiwadi, Rajasthan.

CPCB reply is already

filed.


44 OA NO. 127/2016

Dr. Laxman

Raghav

Vs.

State of Rajasthan &

Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar IPC-SSI

(I/C Shri Abhay

Singh)

Related to interstate waste water pollution

problem residents of

Dharuhera and nearby

villager of Haryana &

Bhiwadi, Rajasthan.

CPCB reply is already filed.


45 OA NO. 356/2013

S.K.Goyal

Vs.

Chairperson, CPCB & Ors.

Adv. Alpana Poddar

UPCD

(I/C Ms. Mita

Sharma)

Related to guidelines for controlling Air

Pollution caused by

Railway Locomotives.


CPCB comments on

Interim report

Ministry of Railways on diesel locomotives

is filed


46 OA No.

677/2016

Society for Protection of

Environment &

Biodiversity

Vs.

Union of India &Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-VII

(I/c Shri Ajay Aggarwal)

Related to amendment

in EIA Notification,

2006.

CPCB reply already

filed.

CPCB reply in MA has also been filed.


47 OA NO.

07/2017 Ajay Kumar

Singh

Vs.

MoEF & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-VII (I/c Shri Ajay

Aggarwal)

Copy of OA not

received. Related to amendment


2006.


48 OA NO.

171/2013

NGT Bar Association

Vs.

MoEF & Ors.

Adv.Alpana

Poddar

PCI-SSI (I/c Shri Abhey

Singh)

Related to illegal river

sand mining without

Environmental Clearance on bordering

area of Haryana & U.P.

CPCB reply already

filed.


49 OA NO.

55/2017

Mahendra

Pandey

Vs. UOI & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-VII

(I/c Shri Ajay

Aggarwal)

Related to amendment


2006.

MoEF takes time to file

some documents.

CPCB reply already

filed.


50 Execution Application

No.12/2016 in

OA

NO.118/2013

Vikrant Kumar Tongad

Vs.

Environment

Pollution (Prevention

Control)

Authority &

Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar AQM-II

(Dr. Prashant

Gargava )

Related to agricultural residue burning in the

State of Punjab &

Haryana.



51 OA

No.65/2016

Manoj Mishra

Vs. D.D.A. & Ors.

Adv. Raj Kumar

WQM

(Shri

R.M.Bhardwaj)

Related to Art of Living

Festival.

High Powered Expert

Committee Report

already filed.


52 OA NO.

266/2016 Rajasthan

Textile Hand

Processor

Vs.

Rajasthan State Pollution

Control Board

Adv. Raj Kumar

IPC-III (Dr. M.

Madhusudan)

Related to textile

industry in Rajasthan.

CPCB is not

respondent.

Document prepared by

CPCB filed before the Registry, NGT.

Judgement is already

reserved, listed for

direction.

Guidelines on ZLD for

Textile Industry in Rajasthan issued by

CPCB.


53 OA No.

527/2015

Satwinder Singh Sodhi

Vs.

Volkswagan (I)

Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

UPC-I

(I/C Ms. Mita Sharma)

Related to cheat

devices installed in the

Diesel cars by the manufacturers.

CPCB reply already

filed.


54 OA No.

509/2015

Saloni Ailawadi

Vs. U.O.I. & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

UPC-I

(I/C Ms. Mita

Sharma)

Related to cheat

devices installed in the

Diesel cars by the

manufacturers.

CPCB reply already

filed.


55 OA NO. 130/2016

Social Action

for Forest &

Environment

(SAFE) Vs.

Union of India

& Ors.

IPC-III (I/C Dr. M.

Madhusudanan)

Related to Hazardous Waste Management,

illegal Manufacturing,

Storage &

transportation of

Ethanol by distillery in the State of U.P. &

Uttrakhand.



56 OA NO.

525/2014

Ganga Action

Parivar Vs.

State of

Haryana &Ors.

Adv.Rajkumar

WQM

(I/C Shri

R.M.Bhardwaj)

Extraction of water

from the Yamuna River

in Haryana at

Hathnikund Barrage which leads to grave

ecological and public

health repercussions.

CPCB reply already

filed.


57 Original

Application No.

249/2017

(Earlier O.A.No.223/20

15)

M/s Ramaa

Shyama Papers

Pvt. Ltd. Vs.

Smt. Sunaina

Singh & Ors

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-III

(Dr.M.Madhusud

ana)

Related to paper

industry.

The comprehensive

report already filed


58 OA NO.

134/2015

Friends

through its General

Secretary

Vs.

Ministry of

Water Resources &

Ors.

Adv.Alpana

Poddar

WQM

(I/C Shri R.M.Bhardwaj)

Related to ground

water pollution.

CPCB report on Water

Quality supplying in Delhi is filed.

CPCB reply already

filed.

CPCB reply in MA NO. 757/2015 is filed.


59 OA NO. 199/2014

Almitra H.

Patel

Vs. Union of India

& Ors.

Adv. Vijay Panjwani

(UPC-II)

Shri M.K.

Chaudhary

Report filed in response of Order

Dated 13.01.2017.

Last opportunity

granted to States who have not filed their

Action Plan or Reply to

Show Cause Notice.

CPCB has filed status report


60 OA NO.273/2016

Raman

Vs.

U.O.I. & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar AQM

(I/c Dr. D. Saha)

Pollution by heavy vehicles in Taj Mahal

and surrounding area

of TTZ.



61 OA

NO.138/2016

(TNHRC)

Stretch Grips Mansa’s Sacred

Ghaggar River

Adv. Rajkumar

WQM

(I/C Shri R.M.

Bhardwaj)

Copy of OA not

received.

Joint inspection

conducted.

Report filed by PPCB.


62 OA NO.139/2016

Yogender

Kumar

Adv. Rajkumar WQM

(I/C Shri R.M.

Bhardwaj)

Copy of OA not received.

Joint inspection conducted.

Report filed by PPCB.


63 OA No.

383/2016

Vishal Singh &

Anr. Vs.

Union of India

& Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

UPC-I

(I/C Ms. Mita

Sharma)

Related to Coal and

Iron Ore siding along

the Railway Station in

Bilaspur Chhattisgarh.

CPCB reply already

filed.


64 OA NO.

199/2014

Almitra H.

Patel Vs.

Union of India

& Ors.

Adv. Vijay

Panjwani

(UPC-II)

Shri M.K. Chaudhary

Report filed in

response of Order

Dated 13.01.2017.

Last opportunity granted to States who

have not filed their

Action Plan or Reply to

Show Cause Notice.

CPCB has filed status

report received from

States.


65 OA NO.

341/2017

Shailesh Singh Vs.

M/s Frigerio

Conserva

Allana Pvt. Ltd.

Fresh Matter.

Adv. Sharmila

Upadhyaya IPC-IV

Shri Nazim

Related to Slaughter

House.

Reply affidavit is

already filed


66 OA NO.

348/2017

Shailesh Singh Vs.

M/s Al-Dua

Food

Processing

P.Ltd.& Ors.

Ad. Sharmila

Upathya

Copy of OA is received.

CPCB reply already

filed.


67 OA NO. 433/2015

Doctors For

You

Vs.

MoEF & Ors.

Adv. Alpana Poddar

WQMD-I

(I/c Shri

R.M.Bhardwaj)

Related to Tobacco born diseases.



68 OA NO.

84/2017

Samir Mehta Vs.

Union of India

& Ors.

&

O.A. No.

64/2017

Kumar Gaurav

Vs. Laureate

Buildwell Pvt.

Adv. Rajkumar

F&A

(Shri Mohan Kapoor)

CPCB is Not

Respondent.

Tribunal directed to

CPCB to furnish the

details how much amount they have

received from

SPCB/PCCs, and

directed to all the SPCB/PCCs, to furnish

the details how much

they had paid to the

CPCB and amount paid

to committees. Reply affidavit is filed.


69 OA NO.255/2016

Amarjeet Singh

Vs.

State of

Uttarakhand & Ors.

Adv. Satish Kumar

IPC-II

(Shri N.K.Gupta)

Related to illegal sand mining in the State of

Uttarakhand.

CPCB reply filed. Listed on 17.08.2017

70 OA NO.

145/2015 Umashankar

Patwa & Anr.

Vs.


Adv. Rajkumar

WQM (Shri R.M.

Bhardwaj)

Related to STP in Agra.

Joint Inspection

Report UPPCB & CPCB already filed.


71 OA

NO.215/2016 Central

Pollution

Control Board

.Vs.

Chief Executive Officer, 4

Municipalities

U.P.

Adv. Pinky Anand

With Adv. Balendu Shekhar

WQM-II

(Shri A K

Vidyarthi)

CPCB has filed OA

Related to show cause notice for failure to

comply with statutory

and public law

obligations and

directions issued by the Central Board.


72 MA NO. 141/2016 in

OA NO.

10/2015

Indian Council

for Enviro-legal Action

Vs.

NGRBA & Ors.

Adv. Alok Kumar NGRBA

(I/c Shri

A.K.Vidhyarathi)

Related to Ganga Matter.

Original Application

is already disposed

off.

Joint Inspection with the representative of IIT,

Roorkee has already

been conducted on

04.02.2017.

MoEF & CC, CPCB and UEPPCB have to

conduct joint

inspection in CETP

and have to file a joint inspection report

between 8-13

August,2017

Joint inspection under

process.


73 OA No.438/2017

M/s Subhan

Tanners Vs.

CPCB & Anr.

Adv.Rajkumar IPC-IV

(I/c Nazim)

Related to Tannery Industry,Kanpur

Unnao

Joint Inspection report is filed by UPPCB.


74 OA No.

445/2017 M/s

Imco Industries

Vs. CPCB & Anr.

Adv.Rajkumar

IPC-IV

(I/c Nazim)

Related to Tannery

Industry,Kanpur

Unnao

Joint Inspection report

is filed by UPPCB.


75 OA No.

448/2017 M/s Chaudhary

Leather

Finishers

Vs.CPCB & Anr.

Adv.Rajkumar

IPC-IV (I/c Nazim)

Related to Tannery

Industry,Kanpur Unnao


is filed by UPPCB. Listed on 18.08.2017

76 OA No.

449/2017 M/s Feroz Tanners

Unit-2 Vs.

CPCB & Anr.

Adv.Rajkumar

IPC-IV (I/c Nazim)

Related to Tannery

Industry,Kanpur Unnao


is filed by UPPCB. Listed on 18.08.2017

77 OA

NO.333/2016

Shailesh Singh

Vs.

State of U.P. & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-I

(I/C Shri Gurnam

Singh)

Related to illegal

extraction of ground

water by Kribhco

Shyam Fertilizers,

Shahjahanpur, U.P

CPCB reply already

filed.


78 OA NO.333/2016

Shailesh Singh

Vs.

State of U.P. &

Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar IPC-I

(I/C Shri Gurnam

Singh)

Related to illegal extraction of ground

water by Kribhco

Shyam Fertilizers,

Shahjahanpur, and

U.P.



79 OA NO. 309/2016

Indian Council

for Enviro Legal

Action(ICELA) Vs.

MoEF & CC

Adv. Shlok Chandra

IPC-II

(Dr. S.K.Paliwal)

Related to de-commissioning of

inefficient & old

thermal power plants.

CPCB reply already filed

TRIBUNAL DIRECTED

THE CPCB & MOEF, TO CONDUCT THE

JOINT INSPECTION TO

PANKI THERMAL

POWER PLANT AND

HAVE TO FILE THE INSPECTION REPORT


80 OA NO. 60/2017

Dr.Parul

Sharma & Ors.

Vs.

Ministry of Environment,

Forests and

Climate

Change & ors.

Adv.Rajkumar HWMD

(Shri B. Vinod

Babu)

Related to illegal processing, handling &

storage of hazardous

petrochemical waste in

non-conforming zone.



81 O.A.No.289/20

16

Jagbir Singh Vs.

State of

Haryana & Ors.

Adv. Shlok

Chandra

WQM (Shri

R.M.Bhardwaj)

Related to discharging

of industrial untreated

effluents in the drain, Panipat Haryana.

CPCB reply already

filed.


82 OA

NO.483/2016

Indian Council

for Enviro Legal

Action & Ors.Vs. J & K

State Pollution

Control Board

& Ors.

.Adv. Rajkumar

IPC IV-SSI

(I/C Shri Abhey

Singh )

Pollution by the

industries in Dist.

Sambha, J&K.

CPCB reply already

filed.


83 OA NO. 145/2015

Umashankar

Patwa & Anr.

Vs.


Adv. Rajkumar WQM

(Shri R.M.

Bhardwaj)

Related to STP in Agra.


Joint Inspection

Report UPPCB & CPCB

already filed.


84 OA NO.

339/2017 Varun

Sheokand Vs.

State of

Haryana & Ors.

Adv.Shlok

Chandra) IPC-II

(Shri N.K. Gupta)

Related to dumping of

Fly Ash from Thermal Plant, Faridabad.

CPCB reply ready to be


85 OA

NO.231/2014

Doaba

Paryavaran Samiti

Vs.

State of U.P. &

Ors.

Adv. Alpana

Poddar

WQM

(I/C Shri R.M. Bhardwaj)

Related to water

quality of river Kali,

Krishna and Hindon

which finally meets river Yamuna due to

effluent discharged

from Sugar Mills,

Paper Mills, Slaughter Houses and other

Chemical Industries.

CPCB reply has already

been filed.

Joint Inspection of

UPPCB, CGWA, UP Jal Nigam & CPCB

completed.

Report will be filed by

UP Board Listed on 18.08.2017

86 OA

NO.66/2015

DoabaParyavar

anSamiti Vs.

State of U.P. &Ors.

Adv.

AlpanaPoddar

WQM

(I/C Shri R.M.

Bhardwaj)

Related to water

quality of river Kali,

Krishna and Hindon

which finally meets

river Yamuna due to effluent discharged

from Sugar Mills,

Paper Mills, Slaughter

Houses and other Chemical Industries.

Joint Inspection of

UPPCB, CGWA,UP Jal

Nigam & CPCB

completed.

Report already filed by UP Board


87 OA No. 144/2017

K.P. Singh &

Ors. Vs.

UPPCB & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar WQM- I

(I/C Shri R. M.

Bharadwaj)

Related to Pollution from chocked and

untreated drains in

Vasundhara Sector 1

to 19, Ghaziabad.

CPCB reply filed. Listed on 18.08.2017

88 OA NO.

567/2015

T.D. Chandola .Vs.

A.P.Mines &

Minerals &

Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC IV-SSI

(Shri Abhey Singh)

CPCB is not the

respondent.

Related to Illegal

mining activity in

Bhageshwar, Uttarakhand.

Joint Inspection has to

be conducted by the

team constituted vide order dated

15.02.2017 and submit

the report.


89 OA No. 496/2016

(Earlier OA NO.

253/2015)

Tribunal on its

own motion Vs. Govt. Of NCT of

Delhi & Ors.

Adv. Alpana Poddar

PAMS

(I/C Shri

R.M.Bhardwaj)

Related to DJB drinking water

pipelines in Delhi.

No compliance

required from CPCB.

Compliance report already filed by GNCT

of Delhi.


90 OA No.

150/2014

Ajay Sipahiya & Ors.

Vs.

U.O.I. & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

UPC-II

Shri M.K.Chaudhary

Related to

commissioning of RDF

Plant and disposal of MSW in Shimla.

Bailable warrants

issued against

Municipal

Commissioner Chandigarh.

CPCB reply already

filed.

Tribunal Constitute a

committee of

representative of

CPCB, Member

Secretary of CPCC, MoEF regional office

Chandigarh and

representative from

Punjab University. To

inspect the plant within one week.


91 OA No. 199/2014

Almitra H.

Patel

Vs. Union of India

& Ors.

Adv. Vijay Panjwani

(UPC-II)

Shri M.K.

Chaudhary

Report filed in response of Order

Dated 13.01.2017.

CPCB has filed status report received from

States.


92 OA NO. 187/2017

Ridhima

Pandey

Vs.


Adv. Rajkumar UPC-I

(I/C Ms. Mita

Sharma)

Related to adverse impact of climate

change.



NGT PUNE (05 CASES)

93 Application No.

109/2014

Tarun Patel Vs The Collector,

Valsad & Ors

Adv Manda

Gaikwad Sh.

Ajay Aggrawal.

Pipeline for disposal of

CETP effluent into

deep sea (marine outfall). Present, CETP,

Vapi effluent disposal

is into River

Damanganga.

C/A filed. The matter is

pending for final

hearing. Listed on 08/08/2017.

94

OA No. 99/2017,

Tarun Patel Vs

MoEF & CC &

Ors

Sh. Rahul Andhley

Sh. Ajay

Aggrawal.

The present application is being

filed for the betterment

of environment in the

Costal Sea shore area

and connecting estuaries' from Tadgam

beach to Tithal beach

of Bulsar district

alongwith the jampore and Devka beach of

Daman.

Reply filed. Listed on 08/08/2017.

95 OA NO. 2/2017 Tarun Patel Vs

MoEF & CC &

Ors.

Respondent No.

3

Adv Rahul Andhely

(I/C- Sh. Ajay

Aggrawal.)

Regarding Seeking reassistment of MoEF

& CC Notification

dated 01st January,

2016 for removing

scientific flaws and anomalies in achieving

the objects of

Environment Act 1986

and Water Act, 1974.


96 Application

No.114/2015

Protection of Environment &

Public Service

Committee Vs

Indian Rayon & Ors

Adv. Rahul

Andhale

Pollution due M/s

Indian rayon & EC

related issues

Reply filed.

Listed on 10/08/2017.

97 Application No. 57 of 2016 Kirti

Ratti Lal Desai

& Ors.vs

Collector

Walsad & Ors.

Adv Rahul Andhale

It is a Fresh Case in which Pollution of

River Daman Ganga &

Disposal of Solid Waste

issues have been

highlighted this is an application in which

Industrial pollution &

Ground Water

Extraction/Depletion in the Walsad Distt. is

also pointed out.

Reply filed.

Listed on 10/08/2017.

NGT, KOLKATA (04 CASES)

98 O.A. No. 93/2017/EZ,

Greater Laban

Community

Development

Society (GLCDS) VS

State of

Meghalaya &

Ors.

Advocate Surendra Kumar.

Sh. M.K.

Chaudhary

That Present Application is being

filed by the GLCDS by

raising certain

substantial issues with

respect to environment as provided insection

14 r/w of NGT. the

same arises since tha

rampant felling of trees and illegal

construction of

boundary wall for the

purpose of

encroachment of the Critical Catchment

Area in the Lawsohtum

Forest, Shillong by the

Respondent No.2 i.e

UOI. CPCB is respondent No. 5. The

matter is related to

construction and

demolition activates.

Reply filed.

Listed on 09/08/2017.

99 O.A No.

23/2017/EZ

Syed Arshad Naskar Vs

Union of India

& amp; Ors.

Respondent No.

10

Adv. Surendra

Kumar

Illegal stone crusher

units in Jharkhand

Areas.

Reply filed.

Listed on 09/08/2017.

10

0

O. A. No. 173

OF 2016 in the

matter of All Tai Ahom

Students Union

Vs MoEF & CC

& Ors. NGT, (EZ)

Respondent No.

2

Adv. Surendra

Kumar

RD Shillong.

This matter is related

to raising a substantial

question of law pertaining to the

unlawful operation of

the unit of M/s Digboi

Carbon (P) Ltd. Distt. Tinsukia in complete

disregard of

environmental laws.

Reply filed.

Listed on 09/08/2017.

10

1

OA no. 170 of

2016 Saiful

Islam Vs State

of West Bengal

Adv. Surendra

Kumar

PAMS/ WQM

UPCD/ UPC-I

The matter is related to

pollution due to

emission of SF6 from

the power grid.

Reply filed.

Listed on 09/08/2017.

NGT BHOPAL ( 07 CASES)

10

2

OA No.

80/2016

Shrivardhman

Milk Dairy Pvt.

Ltd. Vs. Rajasthan

State Pollution

Control Board

& Ors.

Adv Yadvendra

Yadav Sh.

Nazimuddin.

The case is regarding

installation of Online

Effluent Monitoring

System in Dairy

industry. CPCB initially was not

respondent in the case

but later CPCB has

been impleaded as one of the respondents vide

the order dated

03.02.17.

Reply filed.

Listed on 08/08/2017

103

Application No. 39/2015,

Vinayak

Parihar Vs.

State of M.P. & 5 Ors. CPCB is

respondent no.

4

Shri Sandeep Singh

Sh. S.K.Arora

Sand Mining , Inspected Report has

been submitted before

Hon’ble NGT on July,

2015


10

4

Application No.

34 of 2015

Nityanand

Mishra Vs

State of M.P.& Ors

Shri Sandeep

Singh

Sh. R.M.

bhardwaj

River Paysuni & Saryu.

A consultative meeting

has been called on the

date of next conclusive

hearing but CPCB have

no directions on the issue. Reply filed on

07.01.2016 No Specific

directions for CPCB.


10

5

Appeal No. 10

of 2016 Jai

Gopal Soni Vs Union of India

Adv Yadvendra

Yadav

PCI-II Dealing Officer: Shri

S.K.Paliwal/ Shri

P. Jagan, RD

Related to

Enviornmental

Clearance on Tundra Thermal Power Plant.

Distt. Distt. Chama

Janzinar,

(Chaisthgarh)

Reply filed.

Listed on 11/08/2017.

10

6

Application No.

05/16 (Balwant

Singh

Raghuvanshi Vs Bhopal

Incinerator Ltd.

& Ors)

Adv Yadvendra

Yadav

I/c Shri B Vinod Babu

Bhopal incinerator

(Biomedical disposable

services for hospital

waste product)

Reply filed.

Listed on 16/08/2017.

107

O.A No. 79 of 2015 Shri

Kuldeep Meena

Vs State of

Rajasthan &

ors.

Adv Yadvendra Yadav

I/c Shri B Vinod

Babu

Related to BMW Rules. ZO office has informed

that NGT Bhopal vide

its order dated

11.05.2016 impleased

CPCB as one of the respondent.


10

8

Application no.

127/14 , Ajay Dubey Vs Coal

India Limited &

Ors

Adv Yadvendra

Yadav

Coal mining,

Respondents have to indicate the steps

taken pertaining to

study report.

Reply filed. Listed on

16/08/2017.

NGT CHENNAI (05 CASES )

10

9

OA no.43 of

2017 Suo Moto

Case by Tribunal Vs

State of Kerala

& 9 ors CPCB

is respondent no. 10

Adv. Shri

Thirunavukarsu

I/c Shri Vinod Babu

Related to Bio Medical

Waste

Fresh Matter.

Listed on 10/08/2017.

11

0

OA no. 395 of

2013 (CPCB is

not respondent)

Shri D

Ekambaram

HWMD I/c Shri B

Vinod Babu/

Dealing Officer: Shri J.C.Babu/

Shri S Suresh,

ZO.

Regarding illegal

disposal of BMW in

Munnar Highway The

report submitted to

Hon'ble tribunal on 22.03.2016 and

waiting for further

orders.

Reply filed.


11

1

OA no. 62 of

2017 Shri

Joseph

Arackaparambi

l & ors Vs M/s Bee Vee Jay

Associates &

11 ors

Respondent no. 8

Shri D

Ekambaram

Regarding

establishment of mini

Industrial estate (2.66

ha area) in Malayattoor

village without prior environment clearance

Listed on 16/08/2017.

112

MA no. 15 of 2017 filed in

OA no. 195 of

2016 Tandur

Citizens

Welfare Society Vs Govt. of

Telangana &

ors CPCB 3rd

Respondent

Shri D Ekambaram.

Regarding Pollution problem created by the

Cement Industries

located in Tandur,

Ranga Reddy District,

Telengana.

Vide dated 04.01.2017 the OA no. 195 of 2016

stand dismissed due to

non-appearance of

Counsel of applicant.

Now, the MA has been filed.


11

3

Appln. No. 176

of 2013 sh. VP Krishnamorthy,

Chennai V/S

UOI & Ors.

Shri D

Ekambaram.

HWMD I/C- Sh.

Vinod Babu

Regarding

contamination of ground water in

Thodiarpet, Chennai

due to leakage of

petroleum oil in

pipelines.

As per NGT directions

CPCB has filed its view, and waiting for further

orders.


CAT-PB, NEW DELHI (01 CASE)

11

4

O.A.No.3007 of

2015 Suman Bala Vs MoEF

& CC ors

Shri Raj Kumar Service Matter Reply filed. Sr.

Administrative Officer Listed on 08/08/2017.

DELHI HIGH COURT (02 CASES)

11

5

WP(C)

4474/2015 Suresh

Khandelwal

Vs.

State G.N.C.T of

Delhi and Ors

Adv. Alok Kumar

IPC-SSI (I/C Shri Abhey

Singh Soni)

Related to commercial

activity of auto repair shop, engineering works and

welding work.

CPCB reply

already filed. Listed on

10.08.2017

11

6

WP(C) 97/2017

Dr.B.K.Choudhuri

vs.

CPCB

Adv. Saqib

Sr.AO(R) I/C Shri Jugesh

Kumar

Writ Petition filed by

Dr.B.K.Choudhuri against final order of CAT, New

Delhi.

Service matter.

Reply affidavit has

been filed by the CPCB.

Listed on

18.08.2017

Documents

CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(07_Aug-18_Aug... · Case summary Action Due & ... ground study in relation to number of drains,