CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH

OA No.215 of 2014 MA No.161 of 2014

New Delhi, this the 19th Day of January, 2015

HON’BLE SHRI V. AJAY KUMAR, MEMBER (J) HON’BLE SHRI SHEKHAR AGARWAL, MEMBER (A) 1.. Sushil Kumar Agarwal, Aged- 52 Years,

S/o Late Sh. R. A. Gupta, Working as Assistant Engineer, DD, DTH, Todapur, New Delhi. R/o 11088, Tower-6, GH-7, Crossing Republik, Ghaziabad (UP).

2. Anjan Kumar Chakraborti, Aged- 57 Years,

S/o Late Sh. Nidhir Chakraborti, Working as Assistant Engineer, DD, DTH, Todapur, New Delhi. R/o D-978, DDA Flats, Bindapur, Dwarka, Delhi-110059.

3. Ram Kunwar Singh, Aged- 68 Years, S/o Late Sh. Lallu Singh, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, New Delhi.

R/o Village-Ajitpur Dasi, PO- Mankua, Bijnore (UP). 4. S. K. Ray, Aged- 63 Years,

S/o Late Sh. S. C. Roy, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, New Delhi. R/o B-36, Gali No.7, Dashrath Puri, New Delhi-110045.

5. Sunil Thapliyal, Aged- 53 Years, S/o Late Sh. H. B. Thapliyal, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o 21/88, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi-110003.

6. Rajesh Kumar Tewatia, Aged- 47 Years,

S/o Sh. Om Prakash, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o H-2/4, Shiksha Appt, Sec-6, Vasundhara, Ghaziabad (UP).

7. Lalit Kumar, Aged- 49 Years,

S/o Sh. Narain Dass, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o 156/12, Krishna Colony, Gurgaon (Haryana). 8. Santa Ranjan Biswas, Aged- 53 Years,

S/o Late Sh. N. N. Biswas, Working as Assistant Engineer, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o N-547, Sector-8, R. K. Puram, New Delhi-110022.

9. Smt. Madhu Gadi, Aged- 57 Years,

W/o Late Sh. Surendra Kumar, Working as Assistant Engineer, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o E-99, Amar Colony, Lajpatnagar-IV, New Delhi-110024.

10. Rajender Singh, Aged- 54 Years,

S/o Late Sh. Tikam Singh, Working as Assistant Engineer, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o 29/2, G. B. Block, Pul Prahaladpur, New Delhi.

11. Smt. P. Satya Sri, Aged- 50 Years,

D/o Late Sh. P. V. Achary, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o Flat No. 3, Plot-103A, Ward-8, Mehrauli, New Delhi-110030.

12. Lal Ratnakar Lal, Aged- 44 Years,

S/o Late Sh. Ram Bujharat, Working as Engineering Assistant, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o 41, Lumbini Appt, Sector-14, Kaushambi, Ghaziabad-201010.

13. Vishwa Nath Ram, Aged- 53 Years,

S/o Late Sh. R. C. Ram, Working as Assistant Engineer, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o 712, Sector-4, R. K. Puram, New Delhi-110022.

14. Arvind Kumar, Aged- 44 Years,

S/o Late Sh. Shyam Kumar, Working as Engineering Assistant, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi.

R/o C-4/4, Radio Colony, Kingsway, Delhi-110009.

15. Dinesh Kumar Asheya, Aged- 55 Years,

S/o Sh. Rameshwar Dayal, Working as Assistant Engineer, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o 223B, Type-4, South Moti Bagh, New Delhi-110009.

16. Ravindra Singh Rawat, Aged- 45 Years,

S/o Sh. G. S. Rawat, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o 156-C, DDA, Shahpur Jat, New Delhi.

17. Govind Singh, Aged- 57 Years,

S/o Sh. Bhoora Singh, Working as Assistant Engineer, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o 12/7E, Street No.2, Saket Block, Mandawali, Delhi-110092.

18. Siosahab Mathur, Aged- 49 Years,

S/o Late Sh. Ishwari Prasad Working as Assistant Engineer, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o Q15, Sector-1, Sadiq Nagar, New Delhi-110049.

19. Chet Ram Singh, Aged- 47 Years,

S/o Late Sh. Bishan Singh, Working as Assistant Engineer, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o SRB-94A, Shipra Riviera, Indirapuram, Ghaziabad-201010 (UP).

20. Dhani Ram Jatav, Aged- 48 Years,

S/o Sh. Perbhati Ram, Working as Assistant Engineer, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o 857/21, 60 Feet Road, Near Jain Mandir, Daya Nagar, Alwar (Rajasthan).

21. Itwari, Aged-48 Years,

S/o Late Sh. Bhagirath, Working as Assistant Engineer, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o F-146, Sector-27, Noida-201301 (UP).

22. Vinod Kumar Khullar, Aged- 48 Years,

S/o Sh. Bhagwan Dass,

Working as Assistant Engineer, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o G-612, Sarojini Nagar, New Delhi.

23. Kamal Kumar Kureel, Aged- 46 Years,

S/o Sh. Shri Ram Kureel, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o D-8/13, Radio Colony, Kingsway, Delhi-110009.

24. Smt. Pushpinder Kaur, Aged- 49 Years,

W/o Sh. Jarnail Singh, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o B-132, South Moti Bagh, Nanakpura, New Delhi-110021.

25. Paramjit Walia, Aged- 45 Years,

S/o Sh. M. S. Ahluwalia, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o C2/206, Janakpuri, New Delhi-110058.

26. Apurba Bhowmick, Aged- 48 Years,

S/o Late Sh. A. L. Bhowmick, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Srinagar (J&K). R/o 252, Sector-1, Sadiq Nagar, New Delhi-110049.

27. Uma Kant Trivedi, Aged- 48 Years,

S/o Late Sh. K. L. Trivedi, Working as Assistant Engineer, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o 156-C, DDA, Shahpur Jat, New Delhi.

28. Akhilesh Kumar, Aged- 45 Years,

S/o Sh. S. C. Srivastava, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, CPC, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o 538K/117, Pili Kothi, Mousam Bagh, Sitapur Road, Lucknow-226020 (UP).

29. Rajbir Singh, Aged- 53 Years,

S/o Late Sh. Ramswaroop, Working as Assistant Engineer, CP&S, Doordarshan, New Delhi. R/o E-175A, GTB Enclave, Delhi-110093.

30. Satish Kumar Babra, Aged- 56 Years, S/o Late Sh. G. R. Babra, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o C-1/1, Doordarshan Colony, Shyamla Hills, Bhopal-462013.

31. Y. N. Telang, Aged- 51 Years,

S/o Sh. N. G. Telang, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o D-5/5, Doordarshan Colony, Shyamla Hills, Bhopal-462013.

32. S. K. Dubey, Aged- 51 Years,

S/o Sh. G. P. Dubey, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o H-461, Adharshila East, BHEL, Bhopal-462022.

33. Vinay Kumar Gupta, Aged- 47 Years,

S/o Sh. R. S. Gupta, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o D-5/1, Doordarshan Colony, Shyamla Hills, Bhopal-462013.

34. Prafulla Narayan Badhe, Aged- 51 Years,

S/o Sh. N. H. Badhe, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o 303, Kalpana Nagar, Raisen Road, Bhopal-462022.

35. Girish Kumar Pandey, Aged- 56 Years,

S/o Late Sh. S. L. Pandey, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o Flat-28, Block-2, Green City, E-8, Arera Colony, Bhopal-462039.

36. Ram Prasad Chaturvedi, Aged- 52 Years,

S/o Sh. R. P. Chaturvedi, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o F-2/3, Shalimar Garden, Kolar Road, Bhopal-462042.

37. Rathindra Nath Dutta, Aged- 59 Years,

S/o Late Sh. R. N. Dutta, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Bhopal (MP).

R/o H. No.25, Aastha Vihar, Khajurikala, PO-Piplani, Bhopal-462022.

38. P. K. Saxena, Aged- 54 Years,

S/o Late Sh. D. S. Saxena, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o D-5/4, Doordarshan Colony, Shyamla Hills, Bhopal-462013.

39. D. M. Sahu, Aged- 48 Years, S/o Late Sh. N. R. Sahu, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o D-1/3, Doordarshan Colony, Shyamla Hills, Bhopal-462013. 40. Shravan Kumar Singh, Aged- 52 Years,

S/o Sh. Ram Singh, Working as Assistant Director (Engg), DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o A-9, Orchard Palace, Kolar Road, Bhopal-462042.

41. Priyesh Pathak, Aged- 58 Years,

S/o Late Sh. J. N. Pathak, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o D-4/4, Doordarshan Colony, Shyamla Hills, Bhopal-462013.

42. B. S. Kushwaha, Aged- 53 Years,

S/o Late Sh. Bare Lal, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o H. No.7, Akash Nagar, Kotra, Bhopal-462003.

43. Uday B. Mane, Aged- 49 Years,

S/o Sh. Babasaheb Mane, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o Plot No. 9A/S-2, Gomato Colony, Nehru Nagar, Bhopal-462003.

44. Dinesh Pratap Pandey, Aged- 51 Years, S/o Late Sh. B. P. Pandey, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o D-2/2, Doordarshan Colony, Shyamla Hills, Bhopal-462013.

45. Smt. Sandhya Shrivastava, Aged- 51 Years,

D/o Sh. A. P. Shrivastava,

Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o 7, New MLA Colony, Jawahar Chowk, Bhopal-462001.

46. Man Singh, Aged- 51 Years,

S/o Late Sh. Paltu Ram, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o E-304, Annapurna Complex, PNT Circle, Kotra, Bhopal-462003.

47. Abdul Sadiq, Aged- 56 Years,

S/o Sh. Abdul Wahab, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o Plot No. C-1, H. No. 2, Sector-B, Indra Vihar Colony, Air Port Road, Bhopal (MP).

48. Biju Andrews, Aged- 49 Years, S/o Sh. O. A. Andrews, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o H. No. R-6, Rishipuram Phase-1, Berkhera, BHEL, Bhopal-462022. 49. Mithlesh Kumar Singh, Aged- 50 Years, S/o Late Sh. R. P. Singh, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o H. No. A-54, Awadhpuri, Khajurikalan, Bhopal-462021. 50. Mohd. Abdul Gaffar, Aged- 51 Years,

S/o Late Sh. M. A. Wahab, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o A-20/B, Hills View, Rajat Appt, Flat-6, B.D.A, Koh-E-Fiza, Bhopal (MP).

51. Rajeev Kumar Saxena, Aged- 49 Years,

S/o Sh. S. C. Saxena, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, AIR, Bhopal (MP). R/o JH-41, Block-15, Sayadri Parisar, Bhadbhada Road, Bhopal-462003.

52. Smt. Tulika Saxena, Aged- 48 Years,

D/o Late Sh. I. P. Malik, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o JH-41, Block-15, Sayadri Parisar, Bhadbhada Road, Bhopal-462003.

53. Smt. Jyoti Bala Singh, Aged- 52 Years,

W/o Sh. S. K. Singh, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o A-09, Orchard Palace, Kolar Road, Bhopal-462042.

54. Sanjay Kumar Gujrey, Aged- 46 Years,

S/o Sh. D. R. Gujrey, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o B-507, Jeevan Vihar, Kotra Sultanabad, Bhopal (MP).

55. Ravi Kumar Shrivastava, Aged- 45 Years, S/o Sh. R. C. Shrivastava, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o D-4/2, Doordarshan Colony, Shyamla Hills, Bhopal-462013.

56. Ashwani Kumar Srivastava, Aged- 49 Years,

S/o Late Sh. K. P. Srivastava, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o D-2/1, Doordarshan Colony, Shyamla Hills, Bhopal-462013.

57. Sanjay Kumar Waoo, Aged- 47 Years,

S/o Sh. M. Y. Waoo, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o 181, Shri Krishna Enclave, Hosangabad Road, Jyotinagar, Bhopal-462026.

58. Sanjeev Agarwal, Aged- 43 Years,

S/o Sh. B. P. Agarwal, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o 51, Rajeev Gandhi Nagar, Bhopal (MP).

59. Anupam Kumar Banthia, Aged- 46 Years,

S/o Sh. S. M. Banthia, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o 102, A Star Building, Sagar Royal Villas, Hosangabad Road, Bhopal (MP).

60. Smt. Nisha Agrawal, Aged- 45 Years,

D/o Sh. R. S. Agrawal, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP).

R/o D-1/2, Doordarshan Colony, Shyamla Hills, Bhopal-462013.

61. Suresh Kumar Tarwani, Aged- 46 Years,

S/o Late Sh. G. D. Tarwani, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o F-6/10, Opp. MPEB Quarters, Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP).

62. Devendra Kumar Saxena, Aged- 46 Years,

S/o Sh. K. C. Saxena, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o 09, Akash Nagar, Kotra Sultanabad, Bhopal-462003 (MP).

63. Satish Kumar Yadav, Aged- 47 Years,

S/o Late Sh. N. S. Yadav, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o D-5/3, Doordarshan Colony, Shyamla Hills, Bhopal-462013.

64. Shrikant Suresh Dharamthok, Aged- 42 Years,

S/o Sh. Suresh Dharamthok, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Bhopal (MP). R/o 155, MIG 2C, Saket Nagar, Bhopal-462024.

65. Adarsh Kumar Pauranik, Aged- 54 Years, S/o Sh. R. K. Pauranik, Working as Assistant Engineer, TVRC, Kurwai (MP). R/o Sr. HIG-58, Block-10, Sahyadri Appt, Bhadabhada Road, Dipeo Square, Bhopal (MP). 66. Narendra Kumar Soni, Aged- 52 Years,

S/o Sh. R. C. Soni, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, TVRC, Pipariya (MP). R/o K-34, Kadambini Colony, Bag Mugaliya, Bhopal (MP).

67. Brij Bihari Shaha, Aged- 67 Years,

S/o Late Sh. R. P. Shaha, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Siliguri (WB). R/o Upper Bhanunagar, 2nd Mile, Sevoke Road, Siliguri-734001 (WB).

68. Jadunath Ghosh, Aged- 70 Years, S/o Late Sh. Jagabandhu Ghosh,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), Broadcasting House, AIR, New Delhi. R/o Opp-Netaji Boys High School, Netaji Subhash Road, Subhash Pally, Siliguri-734001 (WB).

69. Nirmalendu Das, Aged- 65 Years, S/o Late Sh. B. M. Das,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Siliguri (WB). R/o Mukuldeep, 74/48, Meghlal Roy Road, S. R. Pally, Haiderpara, Siliguri-736006.

70. S. Jayaseelan, Aged- 63 Years,

S/o Sh. Subban, Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR &DD, Chennai. R/o 4/8(old 81/8), Navin Flat, 2nd Floor, Perumal Koil Street, Saidapet, Chennai-600015.

71. H. K. Kuselan, Aged- 61 Years, S/o Late Sh. H. K. Gowder,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), TVRC, Ooty (Tamilnadu). R/o 148A, Rohini Complex, Mysore Road, Ooty-643001 (Tamilnadu).

72. B. S. Nagaraja, Aged- 61 Years, S/o Late Sh. B. S. Subramanya,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DMC, Mysore. R/o 845, 22nd Main, J. P. Nagar 2nd Stage, Mysore-570008 (Karnataka).

73. M. Renganathan, Aged- 71 Years,

S/o Sh. Meenakshi Naidu, Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR &DD, Chennai. R/o M-103/6, 30th Cross Street,Besant Nagar, Chennai-600090.

74. Tushar Kanti De, Aged- 73 Years, S/o Late Sh. J. C. De,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Guwahati (Assam). R/o Samannay Pally, P.O.-Suri, Birbhum-731101 (WB).

75. Mohd. Samim, Aged- 51 Years,

S/o Sh. S. Ahmed, Working as Assistant Engineer, TVRC, Rourkela (Orissa). R/o Plot-M29, Chhend-I, Rourkela-769015.

76. Ashit Baran Dash, Aged- 54 Years,

S/o Late Sh. A. R. Dash, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, AIR, Rourkela (Orissa). R/o Plot-989, Jagda, Rourkela-769042.

77. Subir Ghosh, Aged- 51 Years,

S/o Sh. S. K. Ghosh, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, TVRC, Rourkela (Orissa). R/o A/515, Koelnagar, Rourkela-769014.

78. Samar Kumar Mitra, Aged- 71 Years,

S/o Late Sh. S. K. Mitra, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DMC, Burdhaman (WB). R/o 14, B. L. Hati Road, West Dhaldighi PO, Burdwan-713101 (WB).

79. Shyam Sundar Dutta, Aged- 61 Years,

S/o Late Sh. K. C. Dutta, Assistant Engineer (Retired), TVRC, Dhanbad (WB). R/o Vatika-3, Shanti Colony Saraidhela, PO-CCWO, Dhanbad-828127 (WB).

80. Shambhu Nath Sarkar, Aged- 64 Years,

S/o Late Sh. R. C. Sarkar, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Delhi. R/o Flat No. 1-D, Block 6/P1, Sisirkunja Housing, Madhyamgram, Kolkata-700129.

81. Tapas Kanti Mukhopadhyay, Aged- 62 Years,

S/o Late Sh. A. R. Mukhopadhya, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Kolkata. R/o Flat No. 4A, Block-2, Eden Exora Appt, 779 Nayabad, Kolkata-700094.

82. Jiban Kumar Sarker, Aged- 65 Years,

S/o Late Sh. J. M. Sarker, Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), East Zone, AIR &DD, Kolkata. R/o Birati Housing Estate, Flat-MIG(U) 8/4, PO- Nimta, Kolkata-700049.

83. Badal Chandra Das, Aged- 67 Years,

S/o Late Sh. P. C. Das, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Kolkata.

R/o 11/48A, Bijoygarh Jadoupur, Kolkata-700032.

84. Ranjit Kumar Saha, Aged- 68 Years,

S/o Late Sh. Jagannath Saha, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, HPT, Chinsurah (WB). R/o Udyan Appt, KBC Road, Badamtola, PO-Gondalpara, Hooghly-712137.

85. Bhabesh Chandra Basu, Aged- 68 Years,

S/o Late Sh. R. C. Basu, Assistant Director(Engg) (Retired), O/o ADG(E), East Zone, AIR &DD, Kolkata. R/o 160, Manicktala Main Road, Flat-E16/11, Purbasha Housing Estate, Kolkata-700054.

86. Arun Kumar Sen, Aged- 68 Years,

S/o Late Sh. U. C. Sen Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Kolkata. R/o 19H, Sagar Appt, Naktala Road, Kolkata-700047.

87. Runu Chakraborty, Aged- 63 Years,

D/o Late Sh. M. L. Sarkar, Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), East Zone, AIR &DD, Kolkata. R/o 48A, Fakirpara Road, Kolkata-700034.

88. Swapan Kumar Bhaumik, Aged- 74 Years, S/o Late Sh. N. K. Bhaumik, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Kolkata. R/o 104A/3, Purba Sinthee Road, PO- Ghugudanga, Kolkata-700030.

89. Sisir Kanti Mondal, Aged- 64 Years,

S/o Late Sh. R. B. Mondal, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Kolkata. R/o 73/K, Hridaypur Station Road, PO-Hridaypur, Kolkata-700027.

90. Asit Ranjan Datta, Aged- 67 Years, S/o Late Sh. K. C. Datta, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Siliguri. R/o 304/1, Raja Ram Mohan Roy Road, Bylane Hakimpara, Siliguri-734001.

91. A. K. Khan, Aged- 66 Years,

S/o Sh. N. C. Khan,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o DGAIR, P&D Unit, New Delhi. R/o A-4, Srijani Appt, Shankharipukur, Batabyal Sarani, P.O.-Sripalli, Burdwan-713103.

92. Chanakya Maji, Aged- 67 Years, S/o Late Sh. Guhiram Maji,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, HPT, Asansol. R/o Panjabipara, Radhanagar Road, Burnpur, Burdwan (WB).

93. Goutam Saha, Aged- 60 Years,

S/o Late Sh. S.S. Saha, Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), East Zone, AIR &DD, Kolkata. R/o 148-B, Santra Para, Khalisani, PO-Chandan Nagar, Hooghaly-712138 (WB).

94. Samarendra Nath Sinha, Aged- 69 Years,

S/o Late Sh. L. C. Sinha, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Shantiniketan (WB). R/o 5, Hrishikesh Chatterji Lane, PO-Rajbati, Burdwan-713104 (WB).

95. Chandi Charan Saha, Aged- 79 Years,

S/o Late Sh. K. P. Saha, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Shantiniketan (WB). R/o Makarampur, Vidyasagar Pally, PO-Bolpur, Birbhum-731204 (WB).

96. Arup Kumar Banerjee, Aged- 63 Years,

S/o Late Sh. R. K. Banerjee, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Kolkata (WB). R/o A-1/6, Naba Ananya Coop. Housing Society, Vivekananda Sarani, Asansol-713305.

97. Dilip Kumar Patra, Aged- 63 Years,

S/o Late Sh. C. C. Patra, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Raipur (CG). R/o 37, V. V. Vihar Colony, Lane-3, Mova, PO-Saddu, Shankar Nagar, Raipur- 492007 (CG).

98. Tripti Prasad Banerjee, Aged- 71 Years,

S/o Late Sh. S. N. Banerjee, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Murshidabad (WB). R/o Kandi, Murshidabad, Distt-Murshidabad-742137 (WB).

99. Ashis Kumar Guha Roy, Aged- 60 Years, S/o Late Sh. B. K. Guha Roy, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Kolkata. R/o C/33/15, Manjulika(B) Housing Coop. Phase-IV, East Kolkata Township, PO-Anandpur, Kolkata-700107.

100. Rinku Mukherjee, Aged- 44 Years, S/o Sh. Monoranjan Bhowmick,

Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Santiniketan (WB). R/o 35/B, Modern Park, 2nd Street, Santoshpur, Kolkata-700075.

101. Manash Kumar Sen, Aged- 50 Years, S/o Sh. M. K. sen,

Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Santiniketan (WB). R/o Ananda Park, Rakshiter More, Boral, Kolkata-700154.

102. Sheo Kumar, Aged- 57 Years, S/o Sh. P. N. Prasad,

Working as Assistant Engineer, AIR, Itanagar (Arunachal Pradesh), R/o D/8, Phase-1, Radio Colony, Chhajubagh, Patna-800001 (Bihar).

103. Sunil Kumar Sharma, Aged- 55 Years, S/o Late Sh. B. B. Sharma,

Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patiala (Punjab). R/o 41-B, Rattan Nagar, Tripuri, Patiala (Punjab).

104. Manjit Singh, Aged- 49 Years, S/o Sh. S. Arjan Singh,

Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patiala (Punjab). R/o D4, Radio Colony, Urban Estate Phase-3, Patiala-147002 (Punjab).

105. Amar Nath, Aged- 49 Years, S/o Sh. Mangal Singh,

Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patiala (Punjab). R/o C-10, Radio Colony, Urban Estate Phase-3, Patiala-147002 (Punjab).

106. Rajinder Singh Khalsa, Aged- 70 Years, S/o Sh. Mohan Singh, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, BH, New Delhi. R/o 12/20, East Patel Nagar,

New Delhi-110008. 107. Saranjit Singh Saini, Aged- 67 Years, S/o Sh. Basant Singh,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, New Delhi. R/o 167, Punjabi Bagh Appt (SFS), Madipur, New Delhi-110063.

108. Om Prakash Batra, Aged- 72 Years, S/o Sh. B. R. Batra,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, BH, New Delhi. R/o House No.541, Sector-28, Faridabad-121008 (Haryana).

109. O. P. Agrawal, Aged- 73 Years, S/o Sh. Chukhan Lal,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), HPT, AIR, Khampur, Delhi. R/o 48, Duplex, Swarnim Vihar, Sector-82, Noida-201304 (UP).

110. V. P. Sahgal, Aged- 73 Years, S/o Late Sh. K. C. Sahgal,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DGAIR, P&D Unit, New Delhi. R/o C-78, SRM CGHS Appt, Plot-106, I. P. Extn, Patparganj, Delhi-110092.

111. Harbir Singh, Aged- 71 Years, S/o S. Diwan Singh, Assistant Engineer (Retired),

AIR, BH, New Delhi. R/o C-21/X-4, Dilshad garden,

New Delhi. 112. Smt. Neelam Taneja, Aged- 62 Years, D/o Sh. K. L. Khanna,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), North Zone, AIR &DD, New Delhi. R/o SD-6, Tower Appts, Pitampura, Delhi-110034.

113. Smt. Sneh Khullar, Aged- 66 Years, D/o Sh. B. L. Trehan,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), HPT, AIR, Kingsway, Delhi. R/o 510, Dr. Mukherjee Nagar, Delhi-110009.

114. Amrit Pal Singh, Aged- 64 Years, S/o Sh. Kartar Singh,

Assistant Engineer (Retired),

O/o ADG(E), Research Deptt, AIR &DD, New Delhi. R/o 33/36, Old Rajinder Nagar, New Delhi-110060.

115. R. K. Chainani, Aged- 62 Years, S/o Sh. K. K. Chainani,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), North Zone, AIR &DD, New Delhi. R/o H-32, Block-H, Laxmi Nagar Extn, Delhi-110092.

116. Smt. B. Muthulakshmi, Aged- 63 Years, W/o Sh. K. Bhaskaran,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR &DD, Chennai. R/o A-Aristo Flats, 1, Nadamuni Street, Naduvankarai, Annanagar, Chennai-600040.

117. Karunamay Roy, Aged- 63 Years, S/o Late Sh. K. L. Roy,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Silchar (Assam). R/o Roy Niwas, Ramnagar RDC, Tarapur Part-6, Silchar-788003 (Assam).

118. K. M. Varma, Aged- 71 Years, S/o Sh. K. Satyanarayana,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Nagpur. R/o 190, H. B. Estate, Sonegaon, Nagpur-440025.

119. V. G. Mahendrakar, Aged- 62 Years, S/o Sh. Gopalrao Mahendrakar,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DMC, Gulbarga. R/o 4-601/77D, Basaveshwar Colony Extn. Area, Gulbarga-585105.

120. C. G. Sankara Varma, Aged- 70 Years, S/o Sh. C. G. Seshanna,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR &DD, Chennai. R/o 1K, Block-3, Eden Ramaniyam Appt, 46/1, Velachery Main Road, Velachery, Chennai-600042.

121. D. Udayakumar, Aged- 54 Years, S/o Sh. T. Dakshinamoorthy,

Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Chennai. R/o Valliammal Illam,No.1, New Natarajapuram Street, Arumbakkam, Chennai-600106.

122. Smt. K. Mymoona, Aged- 50 Years, W/o Sh. A. Mahendran,

Working as Engineering Assistant, AIR, Chennai. R/o 34, First Street, Annai Indira Nagar, Villivakkam, Chennai-600049.

123. Mathuram Srinivasan, Aged- 57 Years, S/o Sh. S. Srinivasan,

Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Chennai. R/o 5/11, MMTC Colony Main Road, G2, Shrinivas Appts, Chennai-600061.

124. Smt. N. Usha, Aged- 60 Years, W/o Sh. S. R. Narayanan,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Chennai. R/o 74/2, M.C.N.Nagar, 3rd Street, Thoraipakkam, Chennai-600097.

125. Smt. Seetha Chockalingam, Aged- 60 Years, W/o Sh. Nagachockalingam,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Chennai. R/o 35/13, Robertson Lane, Mandeveli, Chennai-600028.

126. E. V. R. Venkatesalu, Aged- 66 Years, S/o Late Sh. D. E. V. Rajaram Naidu,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o F13, Phase-I, Jains Aashiana No. 13, V. Koil Street, West K. K. Nagar, Chennai-600078.

127. K. R. Santhanam, Aged- 63 Years, S/o Sh. K. Raman,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 6-I, Sun Flower Ceebros Gardens, 38-Arcot Road, Virugambakkam, Chennai-600092.

128. K. S. Raghunathan, Aged- 70 Years, S/o Late Sh. K. S. S. Rajan,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 25/5, 2nd Street, Bhuvaneswari Nagar, Chromepet, Chennai-600044.

129. Suma Mathew Eralil, Aged- 51 Years, S/o Sh. P. P. Kumaran,

Working as Assistant Engineer, TVRC, Tiruchendur. R/o Sreyas, K. P. VII/70, Jayaprakash Lane,

Kudappanakunnu-695043 (Kerala). 130. Kamala Henry, Aged- 64 Years, S/o Sh. Sathiadas,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Trivandrum. R/o TC9/10, behind TTC, Kowdiar P. O., Trivandrum-695003.

131. K. Muraleedharan, Aged- 74 Years, S/o Sh. O. Narayanan Nair,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DGAIR, P&D Unit, New Delhi. R/o Kurumath House, Karalam Desam, Karalam Village, Mukundapuram Taluk, Thrissur (Kerala).

132. K. K. Balakrishnan, Aged- 65 Years, S/o Sh. K. Vydier, Assistant Engineer (Retired), Doordarshan Kendra, Kozhikode. R/o B-2, Jeevan Bima Nagar, PO-Karaparamba, Kozhikode-673010 (Kerala). 133. K. K. Abdul Gaffor, Aged- 67 Years, S/o Sh. K. K. Mohammed,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Thrissur (Kerala). R/o Akathiyur Village, Talappilly Thaluk, Thrissur (Kerala).

134. M. N. Narayanan, Aged- 71 Years, S/o Sh. M. Narayanan Nambissan,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), TVRC, Idukki (Kerala). R/o Surabhi, PO-Chettupuzha, Thrissur-680012 (kerala).

135. P. M. Brahmadathan Unni, Aged- 62 Years, S/o Late Sh. P. M. Godan,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Thrissur (Kerala). R/o Poruthayil Manna Puranattukara, Thrissur-680551 (Kerala).

136. K. Sudha, Aged- 63 Years, D/o Sh. Parameswaran Nair,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Thrissur (Kerala). R/o Kazhakke Eacharath House, Puthurkara, PO-Ayyanthole, Thrissur-680003.

137. P. P. Muraleedharan, Aged- 62 Years, S/o Sh. V. Paramu,

Assistant Engineer (Retired),

DDK, Trivandrum. R/o Chaithanya, Malamekara, Adoor-691523 (kerala).

138. Khemraj Rai, Aged- 66 Years, S/o Late Sh.D. B. Rai,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), HPT, DDK, Kurseong (WB). R/o 49/B, Acharya Bhanu Path, Kurseong, Distt- Darjeeling (WB).

139. R. S. Rajkumar, Aged- 51 Years, S/o Sh. S. Ramakrishnan,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Trivandrum (Kerala). R/o Kannaravila Puthen Veed, Kannaravila, Nellimoodu, Trivandrum-695524.

140. Ravi Kant Bhagat, Aged- 47 Years, S/o Late sh. Lalit Oraon,

Working as Engineering assistant, DDK, Ranchi. R/o Vill-New Amrawati Colony, Near Kali Mandir, PO-Chutia, Ranchi-834001.

141. Bijay Chandra Sah, Aged- 48 Years, S/o Late Ch. C. P. Sah,

Working as Engineering assistant, TVRC, Lohardaga (Jharkhand). R/o Vill-New Shahdeo Nagar, PO-Hehal, Ranchi-834005.

142. Sunil Kumar Bhardwaj, Aged- 55 Years, S/o Sh. R.C. Bhardwaj,

Working as Assistant Engineer, DDMC, Shimla (HP). R/o A-5/3, CPWD Colony, Fagli, Shimla-171004 (HP).

143. Vivek Kumar Katiyar, Aged- Years, S/o Sh. H.L. Katiyar, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Srinagar (J&K). R/o DDK staff Quarters, Srinagar (J&K). 144. Atosh Kumar, Aged- 53 Years, S/o Late Sh. Suraj Bhan, Working as Assistant Engineer, CP&S, Doordarshan, Khelgaon, New Delhi. R/o D-618, Dilshad Garden, Delhi-110095.

145. A. V. Michael, Aged- 63 Years, S/o Sh. A. A. Vareed, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK (PGF), Thrissur (Kerala). R/o Mookken House, Haritha Nagar, Viyyur P.O., Thrissur-680010. 146. Bachchu Singh, Aged- 62 Years, S/o Late Sh. Bhoop Singh, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Jaipur (Raj). R/o Ward-25, Behind SDM Court, Gudha Katla Road, Bandi Kui, Distt-Dausa-303313 (Raj). 147. J. M. Singh, Aged- 55 Years, S/o Sh. M. L. Singh, Working as Assistant Engineer, HPT, AIR, Malad, Mumbai. R/o Type-4/6, HPT AIR Colony, Marve Road, Malad (W), Mumbai-400095. 148. Pranab Kumar Goswami, Aged- 47 Years, S/o Late Sh. B. K. Goswami, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Guwahati. R/o Disha Apartment, Senduri Ali, R. G. B. Road, Guwahati-781024. 149. Mrs. Vijayalakshmi Goswami, Aged- 47 Years, D/o Late Sh. S. Vairamuthu, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, DDK, Guwahati. R/o Disha Apartment, Senduri Ali, R. G. B. Road, Guwahati-781024. 150. Harswaroop, Aged- 50 Years, S/o Sh. Maheshwari Deen, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, CP&S, Doordarshan, Khelgaon, New Delhi. R/o Flat No. 500, Sector-3, R. K. Puram, New Delhi-110022. 151. Rajeev Kumar Gupta, Aged- 45 Years, S/o Sh. S. P. Singhal, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, CP&S, Doordarshan, Khelgaon, New Delhi. R/o A-219, Moti Bagh-1, New Delhi-110021. 152. Santosh Kumar Pandey, Aged- 54 Years, S/o Sh. Ramji Pandey, Working as Sr. Engineering Assistant, CP&S, Doordarshan, Khelgaon, New Delhi.

R/o F/99, Sector-27, Noida (UP). 153. Sanjeev Kumar Jindal, Aged- 47 Years, S/o Sh. H. L. Jindal, Working as Assistant Engineer, CP&S, Doordarshan, Khelgaon, New Delhi. R/o O-52, West Patel Nagar, New Delhi-110008. 154. Praveen Kumar Jain, Aged- 54 Years, S/o Sh. P. C. Jain, Working as Assistant Engineer, CP&S, Doordarshan, Khelgaon, New Delhi. R/o Q-33, Type-IV, Nivedita Kunj, Sector-10, R. K. Puram, New Delhi. ……….Applicants (By Advocate : Shri Yogesh Sharma) Versus 1. Union of India , through the Secretary,

Ministry of Information & Broadcasting, Govt. of India, Shastri Bhawan, Dr. R. P. Marg, New Delhi-110001.

2. Prasar Bharati (Broadcasting Corp. of India),

Through Chief Executive Officer, PTI Building, Sansad Marg, New Delhi-110001.

3. Director General, Akashvani,

Akashvani Bhawan, Sansad Marg, New Delhi-110001.

4. Director General, Doordarshan,

Doordarshan Bhawan Wing-A, Copernicus Marg, New Delhi-110001.

………….Respondents

ORDER (ORAL) SHRI V. AJAY KUMAR, MEMBER (J) : Heard learned counsel for the applicants. MA No.161 of 2014 This MA for joining together in a single Original Application is allowed. OA No.215 of 2014

The applicants, who are/have working/retired as Assistant Engineers, Engineering Assistants and Sr. Engineering Assistants, have filed this OA seeking the following reliefs:-

a. DIRECT the respondents to extend the benefits of the judgment dated 07.09.2009 passed by Hon’ble CAT, Patna Bench in OA No.514 of 2002 to the applicants herein in the grades of Engineering Assistants, Sr. Engineering Assistants and Assistant Engineers of AIR & Doordarshan who have been in service on or/and after 09.08.1999, without resorting to court case for the same relief.

b. DIRECT the respondents to grant the benefits of the ACP Scheme in accordance with the rules and law and as per the directions passed by order dated 23.05.2012 of Hon’ble CAT, Patna Bench in CCPA No.22 of 2001 in OA No.514 of 2012 of going by the letter and spirit of the entire order of the Tribunal in the OA as well as the order of Hon’ble High Court in CWJC and clarifications given by DOP&T, instead of going by literal meaning of the order passed in para-9 of the order of Hon’ble Tribunal in the OA; and which has been complied with by the respondents in the pay fixation order dated 20.08.2013 in respect of pay of Sh. B.K.Roy, SEA.

c. DIRECT the respondents to grant 1st financial up-gradation in the Pay Scales of

Rs.8000-275-13500 after completion of 12 years of service counting it from the date of direct recruitment in service and thereafter, 2nd financial up-gradation in the Pay Scale of Rs.10000-325-15200 after completion of 24 years of service in accordance with the scheme of the ACP with effect from the dates applicable in each individual cases, along with arrears of pay and consequential benefits, etc.

d. GRANT cost in favour of the Applicants, and PASS any other or further order(s) in

favour of the Applicants, which this Hon’ble Tribunal may deem fit, just & proper in the above-mentioned facts and circumstances.”

2. It is seen that the case of the applicants was recommended by the Deputy Director General vide Annexure A/16 dated 17.10.2014. However, it is submitted that no decision has been taken by the respondents till date. 3. In the circumstances, OA is disposed of at the admission stage itself, without going into the merits of the case, by directing the respondents to consider the case of the applicants and pass appropriate speaking and reasoned order thereon within 90 days from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. There shall be no order as to cost. (SHEKHAR AGARWAL) (V. AJAY KUMAR) MEMBER (A) MEMBER (J)