CBMS: The Labo Experience

CBMS: The Labo Experience

Presented by:HON. WINIFREDO B. OCO

Municipal MayorLabo, Camarines Norte

Philippines

Municipality of Labo, Camarines NorteMunicipality of Labo, Camarines Norte

Submakin

Bayabas

GuisicanTigbinan

Kabatuhan

Canapawan

Malibago

Anameam

BagongSilang II

Malaya

Malatap

Bagong Silang I

Bagong Silang III

Dumagmang

Exciban

Macogon

Pag-asa

Daguit

Maot Calabasa

TalobatibMalancao-Basud

Baay

Matanlang

BayanBayan

Tulay na Lupa

Napaod

Lugui

San Antonio

Mabilo I

Mahawan-hawan

Iberica

Awitan

Bagacay

Sta. Cruz

Fundado

Cabusay

Iberica

MasalongGuinacutan

Malasugui

Bakiad

DalasBautista

Mabilo II

Pangpang

Bulhao

STATISTICAL PROFILE:

Classification of the town - First Class

No. of barangays - 52

No. of puroks - 284

Population (NSO 2000) - 81,388

Land area - 64,884 has.

Dominant Land Use - Agriculture

Prime Agricultural Products - Copra, Abaca,Rice & Pineapple

CBMS Implementation • August 8-10, 2002 – Mr. Jose Ramon Lagatuz, Economic Researcher from the

Municipal Planning and Development Office attended a Seminar-Workshop on Local Government Initiatives for Poverty Reduction wherein one of the topics discussed was the CBMS Palawan experience.

• August 28, 2002 – Letter of request was formally sent to the MIMAP-CBMS Network Coordinating Team citing our interest of LGU-Labo to implement CBMS in our municipality.

• October 25, 2002 – Initial briefing of the LGU-Labo Officials

• November 19-20, 2002 – Delegates from LGU-Labo attended the CBMS National Conference at Palawan

• January 28, 2003 – MIMAP-CBMS Network Coordinating Team attended a Municipal Development Council Meeting for a CBMS orientation to municipal and barangay officials.

CBMS Implementation

• February 1-28, 2003 – Preparation of Household and Barangay Profile Questionnaires incorporating other relevant information needed by the municipality

• March 18, 2003 – I issued the Executive Order for the Institutionalization of CBMS in the municipality of Labo

• March 19, 2003 – the Honorable Sangguniang Bayan (Municipal Council) passed a resolution authorizing the Local Chief Executive to enter into a Memorandum of Agreement with the MIMAP-CBMS Team. A total budget of P263, 824.00 was allocated for the CBMS implementation in the municipality.

• March 24-26 and 27-29, 2003 – First and second batch of enumerators were trained for data collection. There were 302 participants composed of barangay officials, Barangay Health Workers and Nutrition Scholars, SKs, SPES and other volunteers.

CBMS Implementation

• April 1-30, 2003 – Conduct of Municipal-wide CBMS Survey Operation

• May 8-9, 2003 – Training on Manual and Computerized Data Processing

• May 12-30 – Manual data processing at the barangay level were completed for all 52 barangays

• June 9- August 30, 2003 – Validation of CBMS Results at the barangay level

• September 1, 2003 to the Present – Preparation of Barangay and Municipal Socioeconomic Profile utilizing the validated CBMS results.

Total Population = 81,586

Male Population = 41,952

Female Population = 39,634

Number of Households = 15,875

Average Household Size = 5.14

Average Sex Ratio = 106 males per 100 females

CBMS Results in the Municipality of Labo

• Health• 0.16% - Proportion of Child Deaths (children ages 0-5 yrs. old)

• Nutrition • 10.1% - Prevalence of malnutrition among children ages 0-6 yrs old

• Housing • 94.1% - Proportion of households living in non-makeshift housing • 96.4% - Proportion of households who are formal settlers

• Water and Sanitation • 65.2% - Proportion of households with access to safe water supply • 64.2% - Proportion of households with access to sanitary toilet

facilities

• Basic Education • 79.0% - Elementary school participation rate• 66.0% - Secondary school participation rate• 98.7% - Literacy rate

• Household Income • 96.8% - Proportion of households who eats at least 3 meals a day• 32.1% - Proportion of households with income above poverty

threshold• 47.8% - Proportion of households with income above food

threshold

• Employment• 91.8% - Employment rate

• Peace and Order • 0.63% - Proportion of persons who were victims of crimes

CBMS Results in the Municipality of Labo

Proportion of households with access to sanitary toilet facilities,Labo, Camarines Norte, Philippines, 2003

Submakin

Bayabas

GuisicanTigbinan

Kabatuhan

Canapawan

Malibago

Anameam

BagongSilang II

Malaya

Malatap

Bagong Silang I

Bagong Silang III

Dumagmang

Exciban

Macogon

Pag-asa

Daguit

Maot Calabasa


Baay

Matanlang

BayanBayan

Tulay na Lupa

Napaod

Lugui

San Antonio

Mabilo I

Mahawan-hawan

Iberica

Awitan

Bagacay

Sta. Cruz

Fundado

Cabusay

Iberica

MasalongGuinacutan

Malasugui

Bakiad

DalasBautista

Mabilo II

Pangpang

Bulhao

Total Number of Households = 15,875

HHs with Access to Sanitary Toilets = 10,195

Municipal Average = 64.23%

Proportion of households with access to sanitary toilet facilities,After distribution of toilet bowlsLabo, Camarines Norte, Philippines, 2004


HHs with Access to Sanitary Toilets = 10,883


Submakin

Bayabas

GuisicanTigbinan

Kabatuhan

Canapawan

Malibago

Anameam

BagongSilang II

Malaya

Malatap

Bagong Silang I

Bagong Silang III

Dumagmang

Exciban

Macogon

Pag-asa

Daguit

Calabasa


Baay

Matanlang

BayanBayan

Tulay na Lupa

Napaod

Lugui

San Antonio

Mabilo I

Mahawan-hawan

Iberica

Awitan

Bagacay

Sta. Cruz

Fundado

Cabusay

Iberica

MasalongGuinacutan

Malasugui

Bakiad

DalasBautista

Mabilo II

Pangpang

Bulhao

Before Intervention

After Intervention

Proportion of households with access to sanitary toilet facilities,Brgy. Sta. Cruz, Labo, Camarines Norte, Philippines, 2003

Proportion of households with access to safe water supply,Labo, Camarines Norte, Philippines, 2003

Bayabas

GuisicanTigbinan

Kabatuhan

Canapawan

Malibago

Anameam

BagongSilang II

Malaya

Malatap

Bagong Silang I

Bagong Silang III

Dumagmang

Exciban

Macogon

Pag-asa

Daguit

Maot Calabasa


Baay

Matanlang

BayanBayan

Tulay na Lupa

Napaod

Lugui

San Antonio

Mabilo I

Mahawan-hawan

Iberica

Awitan

Bagacay

Sta. Cruz

Fundado

Cabusay

Iberica

MasalongGuinacutan

Malasugui

Bakiad

DalasBautista

Mabilo II


No of HHs with Access to Safe Water = 10,345


Secondary school participation rate,Labo, Camarines Norte, Philippines, 2003

Bayabas

GuisicanTigbinan

Kabatuhan

Canapawan

Malibago

Anameam

BagongSilang II

Malaya

Malatap

Bagong Silang I

Bagong Silang III

Dumagmang

Exciban

Macogon

Pag-asa

Daguit

Maot Calabasa


Baay

Matanlang

BayanBayan

Tulay na Lupa

Napaod

Lugui

San Antonio

Mabilo I

Mahawan-hawan

Iberica

Awitan

Bagacay

Sta. Cruz

Fundado

Cabusay

Iberica

MasalongGuinacutan

Malasugui

Bakiad

DalasBautista

Mabilo II

No. of Children 13-16 yrs old = 8,458

No.of Child’n 13-16 yrs.old in sec.school = 5,586


Proportion of households with income greater than poverty threshold,Labo, Camarines Norte, Philippines, 2003

Bayabas

GuisicanTigbinan

Kabatuhan

Canapawan

Malibago

Anameam

BagongSilang II

Malaya

Malatap

Bagong Silang I

Bagong Silang III

Dumagmang

Exciban

Macogon

Pag-asa

Daguit

Maot Calabasa


Baay

Matanlang

BayanBayan

Tulay na Lupa

Napaod

Lugui

San Antonio

Mabilo I

Mahawan-hawan

Iberica

Awitan

Bagacay

Sta. Cruz

Fundado

Cabusay

Iberica

MasalongGuinacutan

Malasugui

Bakiad

DalasBautista

Mabilo II


No. of HHs with Income > Poverty Threshold = 5,101


Proportion of households with income greater than food threshold,Labo, Camarines Norte, Philippines, 2003

Bayabas

GuisicanTigbinan

Kabatuhan

Canapawan

Malibago

Anameam

BagongSilang II

Malaya

Malatap

Bagong Silang I

Bagong Silang III

Dumagmang

Exciban

Macogon

Pag-asa

Daguit

Maot Calabasa


Baay

Matanlang

BayanBayan

Tulay na Lupa

Napaod

Lugui

San Antonio

Mabilo I

Mahawan-hawan

Iberica

Awitan

Bagacay

Sta. Cruz

Fundado

Cabusay

Iberica

MasalongGuinacutan

Malasugui

Bakiad

DalasBautista

Mabilo II


No. of HHs with Income > Food Threshold = 7,581


Utilization of CBMS DataAt the barangay level:

• CBMS data has been utilized in the preparation of the barangay annual investment and development plans. It provided a basis in the identification of appropriate programs and projects to address the immediate basic needs of the respective barangays; It was used in determining the priority needs of the barangays.

• CBMS Data has been utilized for the preparation of the Barangay Socio-Economic Profiles

• The CBMS Database has been utilized for the preparation of barangay poverty maps showing thereof the most depressed areas in the barangays in terms of different dimensions of poverty

• It was used in monitoring and evaluation of existing development programs. For instance, Brgy. Tulay na Lupa used the results of the CBMS survey in the analysis of welfare status of children. As a result, they won the coveted award of the province-wide search for the “Child-Friendliest Barangay”.

Utilization of CBMS DataAt the municipal level:

• CBMS data has been utilized in the preparation of the Municipal Annual Investment and Development Plans

• CBMS data has been utilized for the preparation of the Municipal Socio-Economic Profile

• The Office of the Municipal Social Welfare and Development also utilized the CBMS Data to identify the poorest households in the barangays in terms of income.

• It was used in determination of priority needs of the municipality.

Utilization of CBMS DataAt the municipal level:

• Information from CBMS served as inputs to the socio-economic database and geographic information system (GIS) of the Municipal Planning and Development Coordinator

• The CBMS data were used as basis for targeting beneficiaries of a municipal health project, i.e. distribution of toilet bowls in the different barangays identified to have low access to sanitary toilet facilities.

• CBMS survey results were also used as additional data in the preparation of the municipal land use plan.

• CBMS Results were utilized as basis for Water Supply and Road Network Development Program.

• The CBMS Results will be utilized for the formulation of the Executive and the Legislative Agenda for the next three (3) years

Lessons Learned and Challenges encountered

• The Initiative for the CBMS implementation in our locality requires strong political commitment by the LCEs in the Provincial, Municipal and Barangay Levels

• The conduct of survey in the household level, the processing of survey results at the purok and barangay levels and the attainment of accurate results were the most challenging parts.

Actual cost of CBMS Implementation

• Total Expenses Incurred during the first round of CBMS implementation: P431,523.34 or P27.18 per household.

• Details of actual expenses: Municipal counterpart

• Training on Data Collection and Processing P 155,020.00

• Validation exercises 2,168.00

• Reproduction of forms (questionnaire and manuals) 61,985.34

• Traveling Expenses 1,600.00

Barangay counterpart

• Allowance for enumerators P10/HH 158,750.00

• Training on drafting socioeconomic profiles P1,000/brgy 52,000.00

----------------Total431,523.34

• Estimated cost of subsequent implementation is P225,000.00 or approximately P14.14 per household excluding training costs assuming the same enumerators will be tapped for the next round of survey.

COMMITMENT

CBMS data will be the basis of the future development initiatives of the municipality specifically in Poverty

Reduction-related programs, projects and activities

Support New CBMS initiatives in the future

Promote the awareness and use of CBMS as a tool for poverty monitoring and local governance

Institutionalize the CBMS activities in the development programs of the municipality

Well-Balanced Outlook for

Opportunities & Change Onwards

With the Institutionalization of the CBMS, the Municipality of Labo, Camarines Norte will have a

Documents

CBMS: The Labo Experience