30
1 Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies Ning Pan Biological System Engineering UC Davis, CA 95616 [email protected] Ronald Postle Emeritus Professor of Textile Physics University of New South Wales, UNSW Sydney, NSW, 2052, Australia [email protected]

Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

1

Cautionary Notes on

Wearable Technologies

Ning Pan

Biological System Engineering

UC Davis, CA 95616

[email protected]

Ronald Postle

Emeritus Professor of Textile Physics

University of New South Wales, UNSW

Sydney, NSW, 2052, Australia

[email protected]

Page 2: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

2

The lightest silk clothing (48g) in Chinese history, unearthed from Han Dynasty Tomb

(206 BC - 220 AD). http://www.chinancient.com/category/life-of-ancient-chinese/chinese-clothing/

The “eternal” form of cloth - Why

The modern

The ancient

Page 3: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

3

The two basic functions of clothing

Protection for safety

and comfort

Decoration

Page 4: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

T oC

wind speed

RH

radiant heat

rate type

metabolism

mental state

thermal

regulation

Human body taskenvironment

color codes

Clothing functions – extremely complex

clothing

Micro-climate

Page 5: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

Body mean temperature vs. ambient temperature (theory, bare body)

- 1oC

21oC 36oC 68oC

49oC

22oC

Human body has a limited thermal regulatory capacity

Page 6: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

Body thermal regulatory functions (heat generation and dissipation)

Human body generating heat to raise body temperature,

but sweeting to reduce it.

Page 7: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

-10 13

Body heat exchange in two opposite cases

For an unclothed and stationary person

1. Conduction, convection and radiation always work against body comfort

- gradient dependent ;

2. Heat loss by evaporation of perspiration is always needed, fatally important

Human body thermal regulatory function; Never scarifies evaporation.

3. Using radiactive surface when hot, or reflective surface when cold most effective

- 80% heat exchanged due to radiation.

Temperature gradient

Page 8: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

Requirements of cloth as a protective system

- Biologically and physiologically compatible with human body.

Comfort, no hazard, no toxicity

- A porous structure for air and certain fluids

permeability, thermal and breath

- A surface with soft pleasant tactile sensory feeling.

- A stretchable, durable, flexible, and light-weight structure.

Page 9: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

Clothing as a body decorative system

Decorative and aesthetic function

- required properties

draping, shaping, sewing

dying and printing as well as other finishes.

Page 10: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

10

Secrets of textiles

- Porous, hierarchical, discrete, multiphase structure

- Fibrous, friction induced system coherence

• The first groups of human engineered/industrially manufactured materials.

• Remaining poorly understood in scientific vigor, with renewed interest thanks

to the novel nano-materials.

• Arguably the manmade materials closest on a par with biological materials in

terms of structural complexity.

2014 Ning Pan, Exploring the significance of structural hierarchy in material Systems - A review, Applied Physics Review, 1,021302

Page 11: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

11

Cautionary notes on wearable technologies

Textiles are mixed hybrid composite materials – fiber + air + moisture

Properties are jointly determined by all three components, often dominated by components with dominant properties

Textiles are composites

Most rational and economic

2016, Ning Pan and Ron Postle “10 Commandments” in wearable technologies, Textile Leaders, 1, 54-57.

Page 12: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

12

Advantages of being heterogeneous

Table 1 Properties comparison

Page 13: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

13

Thermal Effusivity E

How to explain the same fiber type (k) produces cloth with vastly different feeling of warmth?

The possible ranges of the parameters

<<<< 1.0 <<<< 4

Page 14: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

14

• Structure dominant: thermal, electric (air, water)

Cloth properties…

• Materials type + structure: strength, abrasion, draping

and wrinkling…

• Material type dominant: weight, chemical reactivity…

Materials type vs. structure

Page 15: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

15

Cautionary notes (2)

Virtually all textile fibers are polymeric in nature so that they are

• light in weight• process-able on a massive scale into yarns, fabrics and eventually

into garments.

To achieve aforementioned lightweight, flexibility and durability at reasonable cost.

Polymers are the king

Polymer maintains its dominance in clothing.

2016, Ning Pan and Ron Postle “10 Commandments” in wearable technologies, Textile Leaders, 1, 54-57.

Page 16: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

16

Cautionary notes (3)

• hierarchical structures ascending through fiber, yarn, fabric, apparel, to form;

• porous materials of different capillary pore sizes;

in order to achieve hydrophilicity, dye- ability, air permeability and comfort.

2016, Ning Pan and Ron Postle “10 Commandments” in wearable technologies, Textile Leaders, 1, 54-57.

Hierarchy is the main motif

Structure for functionalities

Page 17: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

(A) A fabric

(B) A yarn(C) A single wool fiber

(D) Hierarchy of wool fiber

Hierarchical structures of textiles

Page 18: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

Advantages of being hierarchal

bN=7

R

r

R

A rod (r) A fiber bundle (b)

• structural hierarchy.

• size effect.

A simple model

Page 19: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

19

According to Griffith’s theory of fracture mechanics

σ b

σ r

= N

5

4

Increasing system strength

Advantages of being hierarchal

In comparison with the rod, fiber bundle becomes stronger as N increases

Page 20: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

20

Increasing the specific surface area

Specific surface area Ar fixed, but Ab increases as N grows (r reduces).

Ab

Ar

=

Ai

N

∑Ar

= N

Advantages of being hierarchal

Page 21: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

21

Bundling and twisting improve structural flexibility

E = Ec cos4 θ

Tensile modulus

Advantages of being hierarchal

Page 22: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

• The coefficient ξ , clearly ≤ N , to reflect the constraint between the branches;

• Increasing N will considerably reduce the bending stiffness, at given constraint ξ .

Bundling and twisting improve structural flexibility

Ib

Ir

=

Ii

N

∑Ir

→Nξ

πr4

4

N2 πr

4

4

N

Advantages of being hierarchal

Page 23: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

Wetting Behavior of Fibrous Structures

s = γ s + γ sl − γ = sc

Wetting Criterion - the critical Harkinson spreading parameter

Scb = (1

N−1)γ l

Smaller SC indicating easier wetting.

bN=7

R

r

R

A rod (r) A fiber bundle (b)

Fiber bundles are more hydrophilic – the secret of a towel!

Page 24: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

24

Cautionary notes (4)

Friction forces, whether through twisting, entangling, interlacing or braiding, serve

as the only adhesive agent to achieve:

• Sufficient coherence for system integrity

• the inter-component mobility to allow small local movement

imparting the fibrous structures the seemingly opposing properties including

strength, pliability, stretch, body-shape conformity.

Friction is the only glue

No better alternative

2016, Ning Pan and Ron Postle “10 Commandments” in wearable technologies, Textile Leaders, 1, 54-57.

Page 25: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

Generating strength for staple fiber yarn

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6

Dimensionless Yarn twist n

s=200

s=500

s=1000

Fiber slippage ratio

λ =Tanh(µns )

µns

n- dimensionless twist

λ-fiber slippage ratio

s = s(1− λ) =l

d(1− λ)Effective fiber aspect ratio

µ-fiber friction

Galileo148 was fascinated by the fact that short fibers can form a long and strong rope via friction between fibers induced by twisting.

1993 Pan, N., Textile Research Journal, 62: 749-765.

1993 Pan, N., Textile Research Journal, 63: 504-514.

Page 26: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

26

With interactions -fragmentation process

Composite: Fiber-matrix bonding

Reinforcing the strength

Yarn twist

1989 Netravali et al, Polymer Composites, 10, 226-241.

1994 Monego et al, Comp. Sci. Tech., 50, 451-456.

Page 27: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

27

As the Poisson’s ratio

0 < v < 0.5

Thus

2 < (E/G) < 3

For woven fabric (B)

E/G →200

Improved structural functionality

– nano crystal sheets in silk (C) for high resilienceβ

For continuum membrane (A), the ratio of tensile and shear moduli

E

G= 2(1 + ν)v

Page 28: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

28

Controlling individual properties

For continuum membrane (A), all the properties are fixed

Exx,Eyy,Gxy,νxy,νyx

For woven fabric (B), properties can be individually adjusted, provided

νxy

Exx

=νyx

Eyy

Exx

Gxy

= 2(1+ νxy )

Friction maintains both system coherence and inter-component mobility

Friction -> the tension reinforcing the system

Page 29: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

29

Enabling wrinkling

1. Membrane wrinkling – singular stress at the ridges;

2. Multi-curvature simultaneous bending – key for performance;

3. Excessive deformation is normal state for fabric in service.

http://antiwrinklescams.com

Carbon, 95, 2015, 573–579

Graphene wrinkling

2010, Draping Films: A Wrinkle to Fold Transition, Holmes, Douglas P.; Crosby, Alfred J.PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 105 , 3 ,038303

2003, Geometry and physics of wrinkling, Cerda, E; Mahadevan, L, PHY. RE. L. 90, 7 , 074302

2002 Thin films - Wrinkling of an elastic sheet under tension,Cerda, E; Ravi-Chandar, K; Mahadevan, L, NATURE, 419 , 6907, 579-580 .

Page 30: Cautionary Notes on Wearable Technologies · PDF fileRequirements of cloth as a protective system ... Cautionary notes on wearable technologies ... flexibility and durability at

30

Our current form of cloth will largely stay

…at least in our lifetime.