Upload
center-for-american-progress
View
213
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
1/41
Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr FerradJox rjd Nkyiea Yjoxboxc K`weiry He{ ecb
Rvecyhdcbdv E`dvkiecy
Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy ecb Rjd Cerkocea He{ ecb Adyfkec Reym Novid Co~d`fdv 6756
Novdxovb f{ rjd Jt`ec Vkhjry Ie`wekhc
XXX#E@DVKIECWVOHVDYY#O
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
2/41
Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr FerradJox rjd Nkyiea Yjoxboxc K`weiry He{ ecb
Rvecyhdcbdv E`dvkiecy
Co~d`fdv 6756
Kc rjky vdwovr! rjd rdv` he{ ky tydb ey ec t`fvdaae rdv` ro bdyivkfd wdowad rjer kbdcrkn{ ey adyfkec! he{ ov fkydztea#
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
3/41
Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy ecb Rjd Cerkocea He{ ecb Adyfkec Reym Novid xkrj Ydutdyrverkoc xotab ak`kr rjd ieweikr{ on rjd Tckrdb Yre
ro wvordir rjd jt`ec vkhjry on he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv wdo
xovabxkbd
68 Iociatykoc
6; Efotr rjd etrjovy
97 Dcbcordy
Iocrdcry
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
5/41
~ Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Novdxovb
Ey Iochvdyy vdtvcy o xovm btvkch jd ae d-btim ydyykoc! E`dvkiecy vo` eaa
xeamy o akd evd oitydb oc jox! ov d~dc k! d`fdvy o Iochvdyy xkaa vdyoa~d jd
k`wdcbkch yiea yjoxboxc ecb e~dv bveyki! eivoyy-jd-foevb ity o e joy o
dbdvea wvohve`y# Xkj `ecbeov{ ity o cdeva{ : wdvidc o `ec{ dbdvea wvohve`y
oc jd jovk|oc! d~dv{ E`dvkiec jey e hvde bdea e yemd tcbdv ydutdyvekoc#
Ft xjkad cdxywewdv jdebakcdy ecb iefad dad~kykoc yjoxy evd exeyj kc io~dvehd
o jky ivkkiea kyytd ecb ky iocydutdcidy ov eaa E`dvkiecy! akrad erdckoc jeyfddc wekb o jox k xkaa edi ocd ywdiki wowtaekoc eavdeb{ yvthhakch xkj jd
dioco`ki k`wei o bkyivk`kcekocjd he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv io``tck{# Rky
~kea vdwov vo` jd Idcdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy ecb jd Cekocea He{ ecb
Adyfkec eym Novid emdy je tij-cddbdb aoom e jd vd`dcboty k`wei jdyd
ity iotab je~d oc otv io``tck{ ecb tvjdv jkhjakhjy jd tvhdc cddb ov e
yxk ecb ekv vdyoatkoc f{ Iochvdyy#
Rdyd bveyki! eivoyy-jd-foevb ity xotab je~d e vd`dcboty k`wei# Wvohve`y
bdykhcdb o ydv~d jd `oy ~tacdvefad E`dvkiecy evd e`och joyd je evd
jvdedcdb! kciatbkch wvohve`y je wvo~kbd e ~kea akdakcd ov jotyecby o he{
ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad! ey xdaa ey wdowad ak~kch xkj JK^ ecb EKBY eivoyy jd
iotcv{# K ydutdyvekoc oiitvy! k ky dyk`edb je cdeva{ 57!777 aox-kcio`d
wdowad xkaa aoyd eiidyy o akd-ye~kch `dbkikcdy tcbdv jd EKBY Bvth Eyykyecid
Wvohve`# Jtcbvdby o `kaakocy o boaaevy xkaa fd yvkwwdb vo` dbdvea wvohve`y
je wvo~kbd vde`dc ecb jotykch o jd `oy ~tacdvefad kcbk~kbteay ak~kch
xkj JK^ ecb EKBY# Ity o ye ecb vdyotvidy iotab eayo y{`kd jd kc~dykhe-
koc ecb wvoyditkoc o jed ivk`dy! kciatbkch joyd ehekcy he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv
wdowad# Rdyd ity xotab fd e bd~eyekch ydfeim# Ftbhdy ov aoch-exekdb
wvohve`y oitydb oc jd tckutd cddby o otv io``tck{! akmd jd CekoceaAHF Ehkch Vdyotvid Idcdv ecb jd AHF Vdthdd Vdyotvid Idcdv! iotab
fd yaeyjdb k co it dckvda{#
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
6/41
~k Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Ydutdyvekoc xkaa k`wei `ec{ ojdv ivkkiea wvohve`y je bkywvowovkoceda{
ydv~d aox-kcio`d E`dvkiecyvo` deva{ ijkabjoob dbtiekoc ecb ~eiikcekocy! o
`deay ov oabdv wdowad kc cddb! o lof vekckch ecb dbtiekoc ov bkyaoiedb xovmdvy#
Rky vdwov dze`kcdy jd k`wei o jd yiea yjoxboxc oc he{ ecb vecyhdc-
bdv wdowad ecb wdowad ak~kch xkj JK^ ecb EKBY# @ec{ he{ ecb vecyhdcbdvwdowad eivoyy jd cekoc eavdeb{ eid dioco`ki jevbyjkw btd o bkyivk`kce-
koc kc d`wao{`dc ecb jdeaj ievd! ecb fdietyd jdkv e`kakdy aeim jd ivkkiea
wvodikocy je io`d xkj `evvkehd duteak{# @ec{ o jdyd e`kakdy bdwdcb oc
dbdvea wvohve`y d~dv{ be{vo` dbdveaa{ tcbdb jdeaj idcdvy o Wdaa Hvecy
je jdaw `emd ytvd jdkv ijkabvdc iec erdcb ioaadhd# Rd ity `ecbedb f{
ydutdyvekoc xotab tcbotfdba{ wtaa jd yed{ cd ot vo` tcbdv jdyd ecb
ojdv ~tacdvefad E`dvkiecy#
Ey jky vdwov ae{y ot kc bdeka! xd iecco eovb ov Iochvdyy o yk kba{ f{ xjkad
wvohve`y je wvo~kbd e akdakcd o ~tacdvefad he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad evd htrdbf{ e~okbefad ity# Rdvdy co botf je othj ijokidy cddb o fd `ebd! ft xd tvhd
Iochvdyy o `emd ity jothjtaa{# Cox ky co jd k`d o efecboc jd wvohve`y
yo ~kea o ~tacdvefad E`dvkiecy! kciatbkch he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad# Cox ky jd
k`d o xovm ohdjdv o eijkd~d e feaecidb! ekv ewwvoeij ov d~dv{ocd#
Ijeb Hvkc
Wvdykbdcr! Jt`ec Vkhjry Ie wekhc
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
7/41
5 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Kcrvobtirkoc ecb yt``ev{
K Iochvdyy ekay o ei btvkch jd ae`d-btim ydyykoc! e ydvkdy o ocdvoty eto`eki
dbdvea ywdcbkch ity ecb ez jkmdy xkaa ho kco ddi oc Lectev{ 6! 6759#5 Rky
ftbhd ferad jey xo `elov io`wocdcy Tcadyy Iochvdyy eiy btvkch jd twio`kch ae`d-btim
ydyykoc! eto`eki ity o jd dbdvea ftbhdmcoxc ey ydutdyvekocxkaa fd
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
8/41
6 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
vkhhdvdb ecb xkaa ho kco ddi fdhkcckch kc Lectev{ 6759 yo ey o eijkd~d jd
"5#6 vkaakoc kc bdik vdbtikoc ey `ecbedb f{ jd Ftbhd Iocvoa Ei#8
Ebbkkoceaa{! e ct`fdv o ez ity evd yd o dzwkvd e jd ye`d k`d je ydutdyve-
koc ky yd o ho kco ddi e jd fdhkcckch o 6759! wodckeaa{ ivdekch e wdvdi
yov` je xotab yk`taecdotya{ `ecbed eivoyy-jd-foevb ity o jd dbdveaftbhd ecb vekyd ezdy oc cdeva{ eaa E`dvkiecy#: Dioco`kyy ehvdd< Nekatvd o
vdeij e vdyoatkoc xotab jtv lof hvoxj! xdemdc otv dioco`ki vdio~dv{! ecb
k`wei eaa E`dvkiecy#;
E~okbkch ydutdyvekoc vd`ekcy e ivkkiea woaki{ hoea ov Iochvdyy# Bokch yo
ky k`wovec ov eaa E`dvkiecy! kciatbkch he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv E`dvkiecy ecb
jdkv e`kakdy# Ey jky vdwov bdekay! `ec{ dbdvea wvohve`y! foj bkvdia{ ecb
kcbkvdia{! tcikoc o ytwwov ecb ydv~d jd he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wowtaekoc# K
eivoyy-jd-foevb ftbhd ity ho kco ddi! jky wowtaekoc xkaa dzwdvkdcid e joy
o cdhek~d otio`dy! kciatbkch jd oaaoxkch Kc iocltcirkoc x
dzwkverkoc o rjdyd rez itry! rjd d`dvhdci{ tcd`wao{`dcr k
dzrdcykoc ov rjd cerkocy aoch-rdv` lofadyy xotab eayo dzwkv
wao{db xovmdvy evd dcrkradb ro 6> xddmy o tcd`wao{`dcr i
yerkoc we{`dcry rjer evd wvo~kbdb ov rjvothj yrerd rezdy ec
dzd`wr vo` ydutdyrverkoc# Rjd dbdvea ho~dvc`dcr jey fdd
kch tcd`wao{`dcr io`wdcyerkoc erdv rjd yrerd ofakherkoc
dzjetyrdb! ftr rjky dzrdcykoc ky ydr ro dzwkvd er rjd dcb o 67
Cord< Rjdyd nhtvdy evd feydb oc wvoldirkocy vo` rjd Idcrdv oc Ftbhdr ecb Woaki{ Wvkovkrkdynhtvdy ov ftbhdr itry evd tcmcoxc ecb evd ytfldir ro e ct`fdv o ~evkefady#
Jox ydutdyrverkoc xovmy
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
11/41
4 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab jtvr he{ ecb
rvecyhdcbdv xovmdvy
He{ ecb vecyhdcbdv xovmdvy evd eaa oo odc co jkvdb ov vdb vo` jdkv lofy
btd o fkey ecb bkyivk`kcekoc# Ytbkdy iocv` je jky wowtaekoc eidy dzveov-
bkcevka{ jkhj vedy o bkyivk`kcekoc kc jd xovmwaeid#5: D`wao{`dc kcyditvk{
ov he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv xovmdvy tak`eda{ `emdy k `ovd bkita ov jd` o
ft{ hvoidvkdy! we{ ov jotykch! ecb ojdvxkyd `emd dcby `dd ov jd`yda~dy ecb
jdkv e`kakdy#
Xjey `ovd! he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv xovmdvy aeim io`wvdjdcyk~d adhea wvodikocyje yjkdab jd` vo` bkyivk`kcekoc kc jd xovmwaeid# E `elovk{ o yedy je~d
ekadb o weyy aexy wvojkfkkch d`wao{`dc bkyivk`kcekoc oc jd feyky o ydztea
ovkdcekoc ov hdcbdv kbdck{#5; Kc ojdv xovby! k vd`ekcy adhea kc e `elovk{ o
yedy o vd yo`docd fdietyd jd{ evd he{ ov vecyhdcbdv# Tcka Iochvdyy weyydy
jd D`wao{`dc Coc-Bkyivk`kcekoc Ei! he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv xovmdvy xkaa aeim
tckov` dbdvea wvodikocy vo` d`wao{`dc bkyivk`kcekoc#67
Nov he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv xovmdvy! ydutdyvekoc xotab tvc ec eavdeb{ wvdievkoty
yktekoc kco e bkvd ocd# K xotab ade~d jd` xkj dxdv vdyotvidy ov wvodikoc
ehekcy bkyivk`kcekoc ecb xotab dzeidvfed dzkykch kcio`d ecb d`wao{`dc
kcyditvkkdy# Ebbkkoceaa{! ftbhd ity tcbdv jd ydutdydv xotab yknd lof-vekc-
kch wvohve`y eyykykch tcd`wao{db he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv E`dvkiecy! ey xdaa ey
je`wdv jd ytiidyy o he{- ecb vecyhdcbdv-oxcdb y`eaa ftykcdyydy#
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab xdemdc rjd Dutea D`wao{`dcr Owwovrtckr{
Io``kyykocy efkakr{ ro kc~dyrkherd iaek`y on bkyivk`kcerkoc ehekcyr
he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv xovmdvy
Tcbdv ydutdyvekoc! jd Dutea D`wao{`dc Owwovtck{ Io``kyykoc! xjkij
dcovidy dbdvea d`wao{`dc bkyivk`kcekoc aexy! xotab ydd ec eto`eki it o
ky ftbhd kc 6759! ecb jdyd xkaa iockctd vo` 6759 jvothj 6765 k co ftbhd
vdyoatkoc ky vdeijdb edv ydutdyvekoc oiitvy#65 Ey e iocydutdcid o jdyd ity!
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
12/41
> Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
jd Dutea D`wao{`dc Owwovtck{ Io``kyykoc xotab je~d dxdv vdyotvidy o
kc~dykhed bkyivk`kcekoc io`waekcy ecb o dcovid otv cekocy cocbkyivk`kce-
koc aexy#
Rky ak`kekoc jey dywdikeaa{ k`wovec k`wakiekocy ov he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv
xovmdvy! xjo eid dzveovbkcevka{ jkhj vedy o bkyivk`kcekoc oc jd lof#66
KcEwvka 6756 jd io``kyykoc kyytdb e xedvyjdb bdikykoc bddv`kckch je bkyivk`-
kcekoc ehekcy vecyhdcbdv kcbk~kbteay feydb oc jdkv hdcbdv kbdck{ eaay xkjkc
kad ^KK o jd Ik~ka Vkhjy Eiy wvojkfkkoc o ydz bkyivk`kcekoc! ey body
bkyivk`kcekoc ehekcy he{ wdowad xjo fvdem hdcbdv cov`y ov ydz ydvdo{wdy#
Recmy o jky vtakch! he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad cox je~d vdiotvyd k jd{ evd
bdckdb e lof ov vdb feydb oc jdkv hdcbdv kbdck{#69
Bk`kckyjdb vdyotvidy tcbdv jd ydutdydv! joxd~dv! e{ dec je xovmdvy xjo
dzwdvkdcid bkyivk`kcekoc btd o fkey `e{ fd iethj kc e feimaoh o ieydy# Ec
kcivdeyd kc feimaohhdb ieydy xotab co fd xkjot wvdidbdcftbhd ity tcbdvov`dv Wvdykbdc Hdovhd X# Ftyj vdytadb kc ec dzwaoykoc o feimaohhdb bkyivk`k-
cekoc io`waekcy fdxddc 6777 ecb 677:#62 Vdbtikch ehdci{ vdyotvidy d~dc
`ovd xotab wvoaoch jd wdvkob vo` xjdc jd Dutea D`wao{`dc Owwovtck{
Io``kyykoc vdidk~dy e bkyivk`kcekoc vdwov o xjdc jd ehdci{ iec eiteaa{
ebbvdyy ecb kc~dykhed jd io`waekc# Rky co oca{ bdae{y jd vdakd je xovm-
dvy cddb vo` bkyivk`kcekoc ft iec eayo k`wdbd ddik~d vkea o bkyivk`kcekoc
ieydy ey d~kbdcid hdy yead! ecb xkcdyydy evd tvjdv vd`o~db vo` jd kcikbdcid
o bkyivk`kcekoc#64
Fd{ocb kc~dykhekch iaek`y o bkyivk`kcekoc! jd io``kyykoc eayo xovmy o
wvd~dc bkyivk`kcekoc jvothj otvdeij! dbtiekoc! ecb dijckiea-eyykyecid
wvohve`y#6> Rky tcikoc o jd Dutea D`wao{`dc Owwovtck{ Io``kyykoc ky
dywdikeaa{ k`wovec o `emkch ytvd he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv xovmdvy evd kcov`db o
jdkv wvodikocy tcbdv dbdvea aex# K ky yk`kaeva{ cdidyyev{ o dbtied d`wao{dvy
ecb kcov` jd` je bkyivk`kcekoc ehekcy he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv xovmdvy iotab
fd otcb kaadhea tcbdv kad ^KK# Xkj ak`kdb tcbkch! joxd~dv! dbtiekoc ecb
otvdeij oc jky kyytd `e{ fd oc jd ijowwkch faoim#
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
13/41
8 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab ak`kr rjd ho~dvc`dcry efkakr{ ro wvojkfkr he{
ecb rvecyhdcbdv bkyivk`kcerkoc kc ndbdvea d`wao{`dcr
Rd dbdvea ho~dvc`dc ky jd aevhdy d`wao{dv kc jd Tckdb Yedy#68 Eiiovbkch
o ky dutea d`wao{`dc owwovtck{ woaki{! jd dbdvea ho~dvc`dc itvvdca{
wvojkfky bkyivk`kcekoc oc jd feyky o veid! ioaov! vdakhkoc! ydz *kciatbkch wvdh-ceci{ ecb hdcbdv kbdck{+! cekocea ovkhkc! woakkiea eakekoc! ydztea ovkdcekoc!
`evkea yety! bkyefkak{! hdcdki kcov`ekoc! ehd! `d`fdvyjkw kc ec d`wao{dd
ovheck|ekoc! wvd~koty wevkikwekoc ov ioowdvekoc kc ec DDOI io`waekc!
wevdcea yety! kakev{ ydv~kid! ov ojdv coc-`dvk eiov#6: Nov`dv Wvdykbdc
Fkaa Iakcoc ebbdb ydztea ovkdcekoc o jd dbdvea ho~dvc`dcy d`wao{`dc
cocbkyivk`kcekoc yed`dc kc 5;;:#6; Wvdykbdc Feveim Ofe`e ebbdb hdcbdv
kbdck{ o jky woaki{ kc 6757#97
Eto`eki ftbhd ity kc 6759 ecb iewy oc ecctea ewwvowvkekocy vo` 6752
o 6765 tcbdv ydutdyvekoc xotab vdbtid cdeva{ eaa dbdvea ehdci{ ftbhdy ecbtcbkch ov ehdci{ eb`kckyvekoc#95 Xkj ak`kdb ftbhdy! dbdvea ehdcikdy xotab
akmda{ bd~od dxdv vdyotvidy o wvohve`y je io`fe ecb ebbvdyy bkyivk`kce-
koc ehekcy he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv dbdvea d`wao{ddy# Nov dze`wad! dbdvea ehdcikdy
xotab je~d dxdv vdyotvidy o vekc jdkv d`wao{ddy efot xovmwaeid bkyivk`k-
cekoc wvodikocy# Fd{ocb dbtiekoc ecb vekckch! dbdvea ehdcikdy xotab eayo
je~d dxdv vdyotvidy o bd~od o ebbvdyykch ywdiki oiitvvdcidy o d`wao{`dc
bkyivk`kcekoc kyda# Xkj yvewwdb ftbhdy! dbdvea ehdcikdy `e{ fd io`wdaadb o
bdae{ ov d~dc jea kc~dykhekocy o bkyivk`kcekoc xkjkc jdkv ehdcikdy#
Rky ky wevkitaeva{ wvofad`eki ov dbdvea xovmdvy xjo dzwdvkdcid bkyivk`kcekoc
feydb oc jdkv ydztea ovkdcekoc ov hdcbdv kbdck{! xjkij tcakmd ojdv iedhovkdy
evd co dzwakika{ wvodidb tcbdv dbdvea yetd vo` d`wao{`dc bkyivk`kce-
koc d~dc jothj jd{ evd kciatbdb kc jd dbdvea d`wao{`dc woaki{# Ity o jd
@dvk Y{yd` Wvodikoc Foevb tcbdv ydutdyvekoc xotab fd wevkitaeva{ jev`ta
ov he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv dbdvea xovmdvy! ykcid jky kcbdwdcbdc foevb ky ocd o
jd oca{ fobkdy je kc~dykhedy ecb `dbkedy kcikbdcidy o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv
bkyivk`kcekoc xkjkc jd ho~dvc`dc kyda#96
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
14/41
: Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab itr ntcbkch ro lof rvekckch ecb ~oierkocea
yijooay rjer jdaw tcd`wao{db he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv E`dvkiecy
Ndbdvea ehdcikdy! wvk`evka{ jd Bdwev`dc o Aefov! eb`kckydv hvecy o vekc
xovmdvy ecb wvo~kbd jd` xkj ymkaay je xkaa fdcd d`wao{dvy ecb jdaw tcd`-
wao{db E`dvkiecy aoomkch ov lofy# Rd D`wao{`dc ecb vekckch Eb`kckyvekocxkjkc jd Bdwev`dc o Aefov! ov dze`wad! o~dvyddy jd Xovmovid Kc~dy`dc
Ei yed hvecy! xjkij wvo~kbd tcbkch ov lof vekckch#99 K ky dzwdidb je ea`oy
jea e `kaakoc wdowad xkaa co fd efad o eiidyy jky ~kea ydv~kid k ydutdyvekoc
ky vkhhdvdb#92 Ecojdv ehdci{ je tcby yk`kaev wvohve`y ky jd Dc~kvoc`dcea
Wvodikoc Ehdci{! xjkij wvo~kbdy hvecy o ovheck|ekocy o vekc aox-kcio`d
ecb `kcovk{ tcd`wao{db ecb tcbdvd`wao{db wdowad xkj xovm ymkaay vdaedb o
jd dc~kvoc`dcea dab! kciatbkch eyydyy`dc ecb iadec tw#94
Bdywkd jd dyydckea tcikoc o ytfehdcikdy ytij ey jd D`wao{`dc ecb
vekckch Eb`kckyvekoc kc wvo`okch kc~dy`dc kc E`dvkiec xovmdvy ecbvdbtikch tcd`wao{`dc vedy! `ec{ o jdyd wvohve`y iotab dzwdvkdcid `eyyk~d
ity tcbdv ydutdyvekoc# Rky ky dywdikeaa{ wvofad`eki ov he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv
xovmdvy fdietyd jkhj vedy o bkyivk`kcekoc ade~d ev oo `ec{ he{ ecb vecyhdc-
bdv xovmdvy xkjot e lof ecb e`och jd vecmy o jd tcd`wao{db# Nov `ec{!
lof vekckch dzwecby jdkv ymkaa-yd! hk~kch jd` e ekvdv ijecid e vd-dcdvkch jd
xovmovid oc e ad~da wae{kch dab# Lof-vekckch ecb ~oiekocea wvohve y odv e
akdakcd o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv E`dvkiecy xjo evd tcd`wao{db# Tcbdv ydutdyve-
koc! joxd~dv! je akdakcd xotab fd it#
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab vdbtid owwovrtckrkdy nov he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv
~drdvecy ro eiidyy d`wao{`dcr ecb rvekckch ydv~kidy
Nov joyd xjo je~d ydv~db kc jd `kakev{! lof-vekckch ecb d`wao{`dc-owwov-
tck{ wvohve`y evd foj wevkitaeva{ k`wovec# Ey o 6756! `kakev{ ~ddvecy
xjo je~d ydv~db ykcid Ydwd`fdv 6775 je~d e ykhckieca{ jkhjdv tcd`wao{-
`dc ved jec coc~ddvecy#9> Rky kciatbdy e ykhckiec ct`fdv o jd `ovd jec
5#9 `kaakoc he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv ~ddvecy xjo je~d ydv~db jdkv iotcv{#98 Rd
Bdwev`dc o Aefovy ddvecy D`wao{`dc ecb vekckch Ydv~kidy jey emdceikoc o ebbvdyy jky wvofad` jvothj jd Lofy ov ddvecy yed hvecy wvohve`!
xjkij exevby tcby o yedy kc bkvdi wvowovkoc o jd ct`fdv o ~ddvecy yddm-
kch d`wao{`dc kc deij yed# Rd hoea ky o eyyky kc ioccdikch dakhkfad ~ddvecy
xkj d`wao{`dc owwovtckkdy ecb wvo~kbkch lof bd~daow`dc ydv~kidy ecb
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
15/41
; Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
d`wao{`dc vekckch#9: Ft yaeyjkch tcbkch o jky wvohve` tcbdv ydutdyvekoc
xotab vdyta kc ydv~kid ity ov `ovd jec 47!777 ~ddvecy! kciatbkch `ec{ he{
ecb vecyhdcbdv ov`dv ydv~kid `d`fdvy#9;
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab eaaoierd ndxdv ntcby! kn ec{ er eaa! ro y`eaaftykcdyydy oxcdb f{ he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv E`dvkiecy
Kc 6755 jd Bdwev`dc o Aefov ewwovkocdb "5#>4 `kaakoc o kbdck{kch ecb
bd~daowkch yvedhkdy o kcivdeyd jd ieweik{ o y`eaa ftykcdyydy ecb io``tck-
kdy#27 Rky kckkek~d! mcoxc ey jd Ebb Ty Kc Kckkek~d! kciatbdb tcbdvvdwvd-
ydcdb ecb jkyovkieaa{ dziatbdb io``tckkdy ytij ey jd he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv
wowtaekoc#25 Foj jd Cekocea He{ ecb Adyfkec Ije`fdv o Io``dvid ecb jd
Cdx [ovm Ik{ AHF Ije`fdv o Io``dvid vdidk~db tcby ey wev o jd kckke-
k~d# K Iochvdyy ekay o ei kc k`d o e~okb jd yiea yjoxboxc! jd Bdwev`dc
o Aefov xotab je~d ykhckieca{ dxdv tcby o bd~daow jd ieweik{ o `kcovk{y`eaa-ftykcdyy oxcdvy! ec{ xjo` evd he{ ov vecyhdcbdv#
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
16/41
57 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab io`wvo`kyd he{
ecb rvecyhdcbdv jdearj ecb yendr{
Btd o e ~evkd{ o eiovykciatbkch ykh e! bkyivk`kcekoc! ecb jd `kcovk{
yvdyy ietydb f{ bkyivk`kcekoc ecb ykh`ehe{ ecb vecyhdcbdv kcbk~kbteay
ytdv vo` e ct`fdv o jdeaj bkywevkkdy io`wevdb o jdkv yvekhj wddvy# Rd
bkywevkkdy edikch jky wowtaekoc kciatbd kcivdeydb vkym o iecidv! jkhjdv vedy
o y`omkch! ecb ojdv ytfyecid tyd ey io`wevdb o jd hdcdvea wowtaekoc#26 He{
ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad eayo bkywvowovkoceda{ aeim eiidyy o jdeaj kcytvecid
ecb itatveaa{ io`wddc jdeaj ievd ydv~kidy! dzeidvfekch jdyd jdeaj bkywevkkdy
ecb ofyvtikch eiidyy o akd-ye~kch wvd~dck~d ievd ecb yivddckchy#29
Atimka{! `ec{ dbdvea wvohve`y evd kc waeid o ytwwov jd wj{ykiea ecb `dcea
jdeaj o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv E`dvkiecy! kciatbkch wvohve`y bkyityydb fdaox
je vde ov wvd~dc JK^/EKBY! ytfyecid eftyd! ecb ytkikbd# Rdvd evd eayo
ojdv wvohve`y je evd dywdikeaa{ k`wovec ov he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv {otj *ov
dze`wad! eckftaa{kch kckkek~dy+ ecb ov `ddkch jd cddby o he{ ecb vecyhdc-
bdv dabdvy *ov dze`wad! vdyotvid idcdvy ecb @dbkievd+# Tcovtceda{! ydutdyve-
koc xotab tcbo `tij o jd wvohvdyy je jey fddc `ebd kc eb~ecikch jd jdeaj
ecb xdaacdyy o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv E`dvkiecy#
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab ofyrvtir he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv ydckovy eiidyy
ro @dbkievd
@dbkievd ky jd dbdvea jdeaj kcytvecid wvohve` wvo~kbkch io~dvehd o E`dvkiecy
ehdy >4 ecb oabdv# @dbkievd io~dvehd dcytvdy je 2: `kaakoc E`dvkiecy je~d
eiidyy o jdeaj ievd! kciatbkch `ec{ he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv dabdvy#22 Rd @dbkievd
wvohve` ky eayo jd aevhdy `ecbeov{ *dckad`dc+ wvohve` je xkaa dzwdvkdcid
ity tcbdv ydutdyvekoc#
K jd ydutdydv hody kco ddi! jdvd xkaa fd ec eto`eki "55 fkaakoc kc ity o
@dbkievd we{`dcy o boiovy! joywkeay! ecb ojdv jdeaj ievd wvo~kbdvy ov N[
6759#24 Xjkad jky xotab co ijechd jd io~dvehd e~ekaefad o @dbkievd vdikwk-
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
17/41
55 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
dcy! ec dyk`edb 5#4 `kaakoc he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv ydckovy2>xjo! yk`kaev o
ojdv oabdv E`dvkiecy! vda{ oc @dbkievd`e{ cocdjdadyy je~d jdkv eiidyy o
ievd ak`kdb f{ ity o @dbkievd wvo~kbdv vdk`ftvyd`dcy# Rdyd ydckovy `e{ eid
aochdv xek k`dy kc ewwokc`dcy xkj wvo~kbdvy xjo iockctd o wevkikwed kc
jd wvohve` fdietyd o jkhj bd`ecb# Xovyd ykaa! jd{ `e{ aoyd eiidyy o itatv-
eaa{ io`wddc boiovy xjo` jd{ vty fdietyd o jdyd ity#
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab ak`kr rjd ho~dvc`dcry efkakr{ ro io`fer he{
ecb rvecyhdcbdv ftaa{kch
He{ ecb vecyhdcbdv {otj dzwdvkdcid jkhj vedy o jeveyy`dc ecb wj{ykiea
~koadcid oc yijooa ie`wtydy jvothjot jd Tckdb Yedy# Tcovtceda{!
ftaa{ kch jey e bdaddvkoty ddi oc jdyd ytbdcy `dcea ecb wj{ykiea jdeaj#28
Ftaa{kch eayo emdy e ykhckiec oaa oc jd eiebd`ki wdvov`ecid o he{ ecb
vecyhdcbdv {otj#2:
Rd Bdwev`dc o Dbtiekoc ecb jd Bdwev`dc o Ltykid je~d emdc ykhck-
iec ydwy o~dv jd wey otv {devy o io`fe ftaa{kch ecb yijooa ~koadcid ehekcy
he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv ytbdcy#2; Ywdikieaa{! jdyd bdwev`dcy je~d kc~dykhedb
kcyecidy o eckhe{ ecb eckvecyhdcbdv ftaa{kch ey iaek`y o ydz bkyivk`kcekoc
kc dbtiekoc tcbdv kad KZ o jd Dbtiekoc E`dcb`dcy o 5;86#47 Ey e vdyta
o jdyd kc~dykhekocy! jd dbdvea ho~dvc`dc jey vdeijdb ct`dvoty ydrad`dcy
xkj yijooa bkyvkiy je je~d iocydutdca{ emdc eikoc o wvd~dc ftaa{kch
ehekcy ytbdcy feydb oc jdkv ydztea ovkdcekoc ov hdcbdv kbdck{#
Ydutdyvekoc! joxd~dv! xotab it tcbkch ov jd ehdcikdy xkjkc jd
Bdwev`dc o Dbtiekoc ecb Bdwev`dc o Ltykid vdywocykfad ov ievv{kch ot
jdyd cddbdb kc~dykhekocy#45 Xkj dxdv vdyotvidy e jdkv bkywoyea! kc~dykhe-
kocy `e{ fd bdae{db ov k`wdbdbe yktekoc je xotab voaa feim jd ykhckiec
wvohvdyy xd je~d `ebd kc ebbvdyykch ftaa{kch! e jd ioy o jd jdeaj! yed{! ecb
dbtiekoc o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv {otj#
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
18/41
56 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab itvreka dnnovry ro itvf ytfyrecid eftyd
e`och rjd he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv wowtaerkoc
He{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad dzwdvkdcid jkhjdv vedy o ytfyecid eftyd io`wevdb
o jd hdcdvea wowtaekoc# Eajothj jdvd ky ak`kdb bee oc ytfyecid eftyd vedy
kc jd he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv io``tck{! kckkea ytbkdy yjox je 67 wdvidc o 97wdvidc o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad evd ytfyecid eftydvy! io`wevdb o efot
; wdvidc o jd hdcdvea wowtaekoc#46 Rd wvkcikwad bvk~dv fdjkcb jky bkywev-
k{ ky jd yvdyy eyyoikedb xkj bkyivk`kcekoc ecb ykh`ek|ekoc je `ec{ he{
ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad dzwdvkdcid# Vdydevij yjoxy je `kcovk{ io``tckkdy
je dzwdvkdcid ykh`ek|ekoc je~d e ykhckieca{ jkhjdv yda-vdwovdb ved o
ytfyecid tyd`ec{ tvc o ytfyecidy ey e xe{ o iowd xkj jdyd ijeaadchdy#49
@ovdo~dv! jd aeim o itatvea io`wddci{ kc jd jdeaj ievd bdak~dv{ kcbtyv{
vdutdca{ wvd~dcy ddik~d vde`dc ov ytfyecid tyd#
o ebbvdyy jky kyytd! jd dbdvea ho~dvc`dc jey dciotvehdb yedy o iocykbdvjd cddby o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv io``tckkdy xjdc eb`kckydvkch jd Ytfyecid
Eftyd ecb @dcea Jdeaj Ydv~kidy Eb`kckyvekocy Ytfyecid Eftyd Wvd~dckoc
ecb vde`dc faoim hvecy#42 Rdyd hvecy tcb vde`dc ecb vdio~dv{ ydv~kidy ov
kcbk~kbteay ecb e`kakdy edidb f{ ytfyecid eftyd# E vdwov vo` jd Ydced Aefov
ecb Jdeaj ecb Jt`ec Ydv~kidy Ewwvowvkekocy ytfio``krdddyk`edy je tcbdv
jd ydutdydv! cdeva{ 587!777 dxdv wdowad xkaa je~d eiidyy o vde`dc!44 xjkij
akmda{ kciatbdy e bkywvowovkoced ct`fdv o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad#
Ebbkkoceaa{! yed dbtiekocea ehdcikdy je~d fddc exevbdb dbdvea hvecy o ytwwov
jd yedxkbd `deytvd`dc o evhddb wvohve``eki kcdv~dckocy o jdaw yijooay
k`wvo~d yed{ ecb vdbtid ytfyecid tyd e`och {otj#4> Fdietyd o jd bkywvowov-
koced ved o ytfyecid eftyd e`och he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv {otj! jdyd hvecy evd
dywdikeaa{ ivkkiea kc dcytvkch je jdyd {otj xjo yvthhad xkj ytfyecid tyd je~d
jd jdaw jd{ cddb o ak~d jeww{ ecb jdeaj{ ak~dy# Tcbdv ydutdyvekoc! joxd~dv!
jdyd hvecy xotab akmda{ dzwdvkdcid ykhckiec vdbtikocy! waeikch `ovd ofyeiady kc
jd xe{ o eiidyykch vde`dc ov he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv {otj#
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab vd~dvyd wvohvdyy oc ebbvdyykch rjd JK^/EKBY ivkyky
JK^ ecb EKBY iockctd o bkywvowovkoceda{ k`wei jd he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv
io``tck{# @dc xjo je~d ydz xkj `dc eiiotc ov `ovd jec 47 wdvidc o jd
4>!777 cdx JK^/EKBY kcdikocy eccteaa{! ecb JK^/EKBY wvd~eadcid e`och
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
19/41
59 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
vecyhdcbdv xo`dc! wevkitaeva{ vecyhdcbdv xo`dc o ioaov! dziddby 64 wdvidc
cekocxkbd#48 Ndbdvea tcbkch ov JK^/EKBY vde`dc! wvd~dckoc! ecb vdydevij
evd dyydckea o k`wvo~kch jd jdeaj o eaa E`dvkiecy! wevkitaeva{ ov joyd xjo
evd he{ ov vecyhdcbdv# K Iochvdyy body co ei o wvd~dc ydutdyvekoc! e ct`-
fdv o JK^/EKBY wvohve`y xkaa eid ydvkoty ity! ldowevbk|kch jd ak~dy o wdowad
ak~kch xkj jd bkydeyd ecb yaoxkch wvohvdyy kc k`wvo~kch wvd~dckoc# Wvohve yje xotab fd oc jd ijowwkch faoim kciatbd>
`kaakoc boaaevy#8: Xjkad he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad xkaa ykaa akmda{ fd efad o dcvoaa
kc kcytvecid io~dvehd jvothj dbdveaa{ eikakedb dzijechdy ivdedb tcbdv jd
aex! e aeim o yed-ad~da tcbkch `e{ `emd jdyd dzijechdy adyy xdaa-ytkdb o jd
ywdiki cddby o jd he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wowtaekoc#
Atimka{! rjd Ftbhdr Iocrvoa Eir dzd`wry @dbkiekb vo` rjd ydutdyrverkoc ijowwkch
faoim#8; D~dc k ydutdyrverkoc hody kcro dndir! rjky ivkrkiea yedr{-cdr wvohve` xotab
vd`ekc kcreir! ecb `kaakocy o aox-kcio`d E`dvkiecy xotab cor ydd ec{ ijechdy kc
rjdkv jdearj kcytvecid io~dvehd# Rjky ky dywdikeaa{ hoob cdxy ov he{ ecb rvecyhdc-
bdv E`dvkiecy! xjo bkywvowovrkocerda{ vda{ oc @dbkiekb btd ro kcio`d bkywevkrkdy
ecb bkyivk`kcerkoc kc fdcdry#:7
Ydutdyrverkoc ywevdy @dbkiekb nvo` rjdijowwkch faoim
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
23/41
58 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab dzeidvferd
he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv jo`dadyycdyy
ecb jotykch bkyivk`kcerkoc
Jo`dadyycdyy ky e `elov kyytd eikch jd he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wowtaekoc# He{ ecb
vecyhdcbdv E`dvkiecy dzwdvkdcid bkywvowovkoceaa{ jkhj vedy o jo`dadyycdyy
io`wevdb o jd hdcdvea wowtaekoc#:5 Rky ky wevkitaeva{ vtd ov he{ ecb vecy-
hdcbdv {otj< Eajothj jd{ io`wvkyd oca{ 4 wdvidc o 8 wdvidc o eaa {otj kc
E`dvkie! he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv {otj vdwvdydc tw o 27 wdvidc o eaa jo`dadyy
{otj kc E`dvkie#:6 Rdyd jkhj vedy o jo`dadyycdyy evd kc wev ervkftefad o
{otj io`kch ot ey he{ ov vecyhdcbdv e {otchdv ehdy ecb dzwdvkdcikch e`ka{
vdldikoc e e k`d xjdc jd{ evd wj{ykieaa{! cecikeaa{! ecb `edvkeaa{ bdwdcbdcoc jdkv e`kakdy#:9
Jotykch bkyivk`kcekoc ky eayo e wvofad` ov he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv E`dvkiecy#
Oca{ 65 yedy ecb jd Bkyvki o Ioat`fke je~d dyefakyjdb je k ky kaadhea o
bkyivk`kced ehekcy he{ wdowad kc jotykch#:2 Oca{ kc 5> o joyd yedy ecb jd
Bkyvki o Ioat`fke ky k eayo kaadhea o bkyivk`kced ehekcy vecyhdcbdv wdowad
kc jotykch#:4 Kc ojdv xovby! e `elovk{ o yedy bo co wvojkfk bkyivk`kcekoc
ehekcy he{ ov vecyhdcbdv vdcdvy ov dcecy# Xjey ovd! Iochvdyy jey ekadb o
emd eikoc o `emd ytvd k ky kaadhea kc eaa 47 yedy o bdc{ ec ewev`dc ov ovid
yo`docd ot o jdkv jo`d btd o eckhe{ ov eckvecyhdcbdv fkey#:> Jotykch eck-
bkyivk`kcekoc adhkyaekoc ky cddbdb! iocykbdvkch jd jkhj vedy o bkyivk`kcekoc
he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad eid kc jotykch#:8
Novtceda{! takwad ehdcikdy xkjkc jd dbdvea ho~dvc`dc evd xovmkch o
ebbvdyy he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv jo`dadyycdyy ecb jotykch bkyivk`kcekoc feydb oc
ydztea ovkdcekoc ecb hdcbdv kbdck{# Rdkv efkak{ o bo yo! joxd~dv! xkaa fd
yd~dvda{ je`wdvdb k ydutdyvekoc hody kco ddi#
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
24/41
5: Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab vd~dvyd wvohvdyy `ebd kc ebbvdyykch he{ ecb
rvecyhdcbdv jo`dadyycdyy
Kc 6757 jd T#Y# Kcdvehdci{ Iotcika oc Jo`dadyycdyy kciatbdb he{- ecb vecy-
hdcbdv-ywdiki kyytdy ov jd vy k`d kc ky cekocea yvedh{ o dcb ecb wvd~dc
jo`dadyycdyy#::
o ftkab oc je yvedh{! jd dbdvea ho~dvc`dc jey `ec{ wvo-hve`y je ebbvdyy jd cddby o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv {otj e vkym o ov itvvdca{
dzwdvkdcikch jo`dadyycdyy# Ocd o jd `ekc xe{y jd dbdvea ho~dvc`dc jdawy
eaad~ked jo`dadyycdyy e`och he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv {otj ky f{ wvo~kbkch evhddb
hvecy o ovheck|ekocy xovmkch oc jd hvotcb o ebbvdyy jky kyytd#
Ocd o jdyd hvec vdikwkdcy! jd Eak Novcd{ Idcdv! ek`y o jdaw jo`dadyy he{
ecb vecyhdcbdv ddcy kc Cdx [ovm Ik{# Kc 6757 jd idcdv vdidk~db e jvdd-{dev
"247!777 hvec vo` jd Bdwev`dc o Jdeaj ecb Jt`ec Ydv~kidy Ndbdvea
Eb`kckyvekoc ov Ijkabvdc ecb Ne`kakdy! eaoch xkj e jvdd-{dev "62;!777hvec vo` jd Bdwev`dc o Ltykidy Oid o ^koadcid Ehekcy Xo`dc#:; K
eayo vdidk~db e ~d-{dev "5!847!777 hvec vo` jd Ytfyecid Eftyd ecb @dcea
Jdeaj Ydv~kidy Eb`kckyvekoc#;7 Tcbdv ydutdyvekoc! joxd~dv! deij o jdyd
dbdvea ehdcikdy xotab ydd jdkv ftbhdy yaeyjdb! ecb jd cdhek~d ddiy o joyd
ftbhd ity xotab k`wei ovheck|ekocyytij ey jd Eak Novcd{ Idcdvxjkij
ydv~d jd ywdiki cddby o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv jo`dadyy {otj#
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab ak`kr rjd ho~dvc`dcry efkakr{ ro nkhjr he{
ecb rvecyhdcbdv jotykch bkyivk`kcerkoc
Devakdv jky {dev jd T#Y# Bdwev`dc o Jotykch ecb Tvfec Bd~daow`dc
eccotcidb yxddwkch vdhtaekocy o io`fe bkyivk`kcekoc ehekcy he{ ecb vecy-
hdcbdv wdowad ecb jdkv e`kakdy kc jotykch# Rdyd vdhtaekocy vdutkvd oxcdvy ecb
owdveovy o bdwev`dc-eyykydb ov bdwev`dc-kcytvdb jotykch o emd wvo-
hve`y e~ekaefad o eaa dakhkfad wdvyocy! vdhevbadyy o ydztea ovkdcekoc ov hdcbdv
kbdck{#;5 Kc 6757 jd Bdwev`dc o Jotykch ecb Tvfec Bd~daow`dc kyytdb e
`d`ovecbt` o eaa ehdci{ hvec ewwakiecy vdutkvkch jd` o io`wa{ xkj yed
ecb aoiea jotykch cocbkyivk`kcekoc aexy#;6
Rvothj ytij htkbecid ecb vdhtaekocy! jd Bdwev`dc o Jotykch ecb Tvfec
Bd~daow`dc jey `ebd ykhckiec wvohvdyy kc dcbkch jotykch bkyivk`kcekoc
ehekcy he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad# Bdwev`dc ehdcikdy! joxd~dv! xotab dzwdvk-
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
25/41
5; Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
dcid e yjevw vdbtikoc kc wvohve` tcbkch tcbdv ydutdyvekoc#;9 Xkj dxdv
vdyotvidy k xotab fdio`d `ovd bkita o dcovid jd vdaek~da{ cdx dbdvea
vdhtaekocy wvojkfkkch bkyivk`kcekoc ehekcy he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv vdcdvy! dc-
ecy! ecb wodckea jo`doxcdvy# Ydutdyvekoc xotab hvdea{ tcbdv`kcd jd
wvohvdyy ebd o~dv jd wey otv {devy oxevb io`fekch jotykch bkyivk`kcekoc
ehekcy jky wowtaekoc#
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
26/41
67 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab `emd jkhjdv
dbtierkoc adyy eiidyykfad nov he{
ecb rvecyhdcbdv yrtbdcry
Eiidyy o jkhjdv dbtiekoc ky vdhevbdb ey e wejxe{ o dioco`ki wvoywdvk{ ov
`ec{ E`dvkiecy! ft jd cecikea kc~dy`dc vdutkvdb o wtvytd e woyydiocb-
ev{ dbtiekoc ky ykhckiec# Kc 677: jd ecctea ioy o erdcb e otv-{dev wtfaki
ioaadhd io`wvkydb cdeva{ jea o e aox-kcio`d e`ka{y kcio`d! ecb `ovd jec e
utevdv o jd kcio`d ov e `obdved-kcio`d e`ka{#;2 Fdietyd o jdyd ykhck-
iec ioyy! cecikea ekb kc jd ov` o aoecy! hvecy! ecb xovm-ytb{ wvohve`y evd
vdhevbdb ey e akdakcd o eiidyykch jkhjdv dbtiekoc ov `ec{ ytbdcy! kciatbkch
he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv ytbdcy#
Ntaa{ xo-jkvby o eaa tcbdvhvebted ytbdcy vdidk~db cecikea ekb btvkch jd
67787: yijooa {dev! ecb `tij o k xey dbdvea eyykyecid#;4 Ocd ov` o dbdvea
cecikea eyykyecidWdaa Hvecyevd dzd`w vo` jd vy yd o ity kc 6759
ft co kc jd ydiocb wjeyd o ydutdyvekoc vo` 6752 o 6765#;> Edv 6752
ywdcbkch iewy evd aoxdvdb! ecb dbdvea ehdci{ eb`kckyveovy `ty cb ity
xkjkc jdyd iewy#;8 Ebbkkoceaa{! ey e vdyta o wvd~koty ftbhd ak`ky! ftbhd
dzwdvykciatbkch jd Idcdv oc Ftbhd ecb Woaki{ Wvkovkkdyeckikwed je
Wdaa Hvec tcbkch xkaa je~d ykhckiec yjoveaay kc 6752#;: Rd io`fkcdb ddi
o vd~dctd yjoveaa ecb ydutdyvekoc evd ietyd ov ydvkoty iocidvc efot jd
ttvd tcbkch o Wdaa Hvecy# K ky k`wovec o cod je xjkad `ec{ ytbdcy
fdcd vo` dbdvea ekb o erdcb yijooa! `ec{ he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv ytbdcy ecb
{otch ebtay kc e`kakdy jdebdb f{ ye`d-ydz iotwady eid fkey ecb kcdutkefad
vde`dc kc jd cecikea ekb ewwakiekoc wvoidyy#;;
Ydutdyvekoc xotab eayo it dbdvea xovm-ytb{ wvohve`y ecb Ytwwad`dcea
Owwovtck{ hvecy! xjkij wvo~kbd ebbkkocea tcbkch ecb ytwwov o aox-
kcio`d ytbdcy f{ eaaoiekch hvec `ocd{ o woyydiocbev{ kcyktkocy o hk~d
o dakhkfad ytbdcy#577
Ftbhd yjoveaay kc jdyd wvohve`y xkaa edi jd he{ ecbvecyhdcbdv io``tck{ kc xo xe{y# Nkvy! xd mcox je he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv
{otj eid jkhj ad~day o e ka{ vdldikoc! `emkch k adyy akmda{ je jdkv wevdcy
xkaa ytwwov e woy-ydiocbev{ dbtiekoc ecb `ovd akmda{ je jd ytbdcy xkaa vda{
oc dbdvea hvecy# Ydiocb! he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv kcbk~kbteay evd `ovd akmda{ o ak~d
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
27/41
65 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
kc wo~dv{ ecb eid d`wao{`dc bkyivk`kcekoc jvothjot jdkv ak~dy#575 Rd jkhj
akmdakjoob je jd ijkabvdc o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wevdcy xkaa fd woov ov je~d
ak`kdb cecikea vdyotvidy `decy je jd{ evd `ovd akmda{ o vda{ oc dbdvea ytfyk-
bkdy o wtvytd jdkv woy-ydiocbev{ dbtiekocy# K ydutdyvekoc ky eaaoxdb o wvo-
iddb! `ec{ he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv {otj ov {otj ak~kch kc ye`d-ydz jotydjoaby xkaa
jdvdovd bdea xkj jd fvtc o jd ity o dbdvea jkhjdv-dbtiekoc wvohve`y#
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab bveyrkieaa{ vdbtid rjd e~ekaefkakr{ on ndbdvea
xovm-yrtb{ wvohve`y nov he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv yrtbdcry
Ndbdvea xovm-ytb{ wvohve`y wvo~kbd ytbdcy xkj jd owwovtck{ o xovm
wev k`d ecb devc `ocd{ xjkad erdcbkch ioaadhd ey e xe{ o oyd jd ioyy o
hdrkch e woyydiocbev{ bdhvdd#576 Rd Bdwev`dc o Dbtiekoc eaaoiedy dbdvea
xovm-ytb{ tcby eiiovbkch o jd cddby o dakhkfad ytbdcy! ecb ewwvozk`eda{
9!277 yijooay je~d `ebd jdyd owwovtckkdy e~ekaefad#579 Nov he{ ecb vecyhdc-bdv ytbdcy! ey xdaa ey ijkabvdc xkj ye`d-ydz wevdcy! dbdvea xovm-ytb{ ekb ky
wevkitaeva{ ~eatefad kc `emkch dbtiekoc eovbefad# @ec{ o jdyd ytbdcy bo
co je~d cecikea ytwwov vo` jdkv e`kakdy ov je~d fddc tcekva{ bdckdb eiidyy
o ojdv cecikea ekb fdietyd o vdyvkikocy btd o jd Bddcyd o @evvkehd Ei!572
`emkch xovm ytb{ ec k`wovec eywdi o we{kch ov yijooa#
Ft ydutdyvekoc ity o dbdvea xovm-ytb{ wvohve`y `e{ it o jky yotvid
o tcbkch ov `ec{ ytbdcy# Ydc# o` Jevmkc *B-KE+! ijekv`ec o jd Ydced
Ewwvowvkekocy Ytfio``krdd oc Aefov! Jdeaj ecb Jt`ec Ydv~kidy ecb
Dbtiekoc! ecb Vdaedb Ehdcikdy! jey dyk`edb je fdxddc N[ 6756 ecb 6759
eaocd! ydutdydv ity xkaa `dec e aoyy o dbdvea xovm-ytb{ ekb ov `ovd jec
47!777 ytbdcy#574 Rky xkaa tvjdv dzeidvfed kcduteakkdy kc eiidyykch jkhjdv
dbtiekoc ecb e{ bkywvowovkoceda{ bkyeb~ecehd he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv ytbdcy#
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab vdbtid ytwwad`dcrea dbtierkocea
owwovrtckr{ hvecry nov aox-kcio`d he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv yrtbdcry
Rd Ndbdvea Ytwwad`dcea Dbtiekocea Owwovtck{ Hvecy wvohve` wvo~kbdytcbkch o ewwvozk`eda{ 9!:77 woyydiocbev{ kcyktkocy! dcefakch jdyd yijooay
o eaaoied cddb-feydb hvecy o `emd jkhjdv dbtiekoc `ovd eovbefad ov aox-
kcio`d ytbdcy# Rdyd hvec exevby wvkovkk|d dzidwkocea cddb ytbdcy xkj
jd aoxdy-dzwdidb e`ka{ iocvkftkocy oxevb jdyd ioyy! ey xdaa ey joyd xjo
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
28/41
66 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
evd vdidk~kch Wdaa hvecy#57> Rdyd hvecy xkaa wvo~kbd cecikea ekb o `ovd jec
5#2 `kaakoc ytbdcy btvkch jd 675659 eiebd`ki {dev eaocd!578 kciatbkch ec{
he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv ytbdcy ecb ijkabvdc xkj ye`d-ydz wevdcy# Kc lty ocd {dev
tcbdv ydutdyvekoc ftbhd ity! `ovd jec 557!777 dxdv ytbdcy xotab vdidk~d
ytwwad`dcea dbtiekocea owwovtck{ hvec ekb#57: Ocid ehekc! `ec{ he{ ecb
vecyhdcbdv ytbdcy `e{ je~d jdkv jkhjdv dbtiekocy wt tvjdv ot o vdeij#
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
29/41
69 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab ak`kr rjd
ho~dvc`dcry efkakr{ ro wvd~dcr ~koadcid
ehekcyr he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv wdowad
Bdywkd jd `evmdb kcivdeyd kc eiidwecid o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad o~dv jd
wey bdiebd! he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv kcbk~kbteay iockctd o fd ytfldidb o bkywvo-
wovkoced ad~day o eftyd! jeveyy`dc! ecb ~koadc ivk`d#57; Recmtaa{! jd dbdvea
ho~dvc`dc ky eimakch jky kyytd jdeb oc jvothj wvd~dck~d wvohve``kch! kc~dy-
khekoc! ecb wvoyditkoc o ivk`dy `ok~edb f{ eckhe{ ecb eckvecyhdcbdv fkey#
Ft ydutdyvekocy eivoyy-jd-foevb ity kc 6759 ecb vkhkb ywdcbkch iewy jvothj
6765 xotab ykhckieca{ tcbdv`kcd jd ho~dvc`dcy efkak{ o bo yo! ade~kch
`ec{ he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv ~kik`y xkjot jd jdaw jd{ yo bdywdveda{ cddb#
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab ak`kr vdyotvidy e~ekaefad ro kc~dyrkherd!
wvoyditrd! ecb wvd~dcr jerd ivk`dy
Kc 677; Iochvdyy weyydb jd @erjdx Yjdwevb ecb Le`dy F{vb! Lv# Jed Ivk`dy
Wvd~dckoc Ei# Rky fkaa dzwecbdb dzkykch dbdvea jed ivk`dy yetdy o kciatbd
ivk`dy `ok~edb f{ e ~kik`y ydztea ovkdcekoc ov hdcbdv kbdck{ *ey xdaa ey
hdcbdv ecb bkyefkak{+#557 Rky aex iaevkdy je jd dbdvea ho~dvc`dc iec wvoy-
ditd eckhe{ ecb eckvecyhdcbdv jed ivk`dy o jd taa dzdc o ky ltvkybkikoc
ecb wvo~kbdy dbdvea eyykyecid o yed ecb aoiea aex dcovid`dc kc jd kc~dykhe-
koc o fkey-`ok~edb ivk`dy#555 Ebbkkoceaa{! jd aex wvo~kbdy dbdvea tcbkch
ecb dijckiea eyykyecid o yed! aoiea! ecb vkfea ltvkybkikocy o k`wvo~d ecb
dzwecb jdkv efkak{ o kc~dykhed! wvoyditd! ecbwdvjewy `oy k`woveca{
wvd~dc jed ivk`dy#556
Ydutdyvekoc! joxd~dv! xotab yd~dvda{ ak`k jd efkak{ o jd Bdwev`dc o
Ltykid o io`fe jdyd ivk`dy kc otv k`wovec xe{y# Nkvy! jd Ndbdvea Ftvdet
o Kc~dykhekoc xotab je~d dxdv vdyotvidy o kc~dykhed ~koadc ivk`dy io``k-db ehekcy he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad# Ydiocb! jd Bdwev`dc o Ltykidy Ik~ka
Vkhjy Bk~kykoc xotab je~d vdyvkidb vdyotvidy o dbdveaa{ wvoyditd fkey ivk`dy#
Rkvb! ydutdyvekoc xotab k`wdbd jd efkak{ o jd Bdwev`dc o Ltykid o
ioaadi bee oc jed ivk`dy! e ivkkiea io`wocdc o tcbdvyecbkch ecb wvd~dckch
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
30/41
62 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
~koadc ivk`d kc jd Tckdb Yedy# Nkceaa{! yvdijdb vdyotvidy ecb ak`kdb cecidy
tcbdv jd ydutdydv xotab `emd k `ovd bkita o vekc yed ecb aoiea aex
dcovid`dc o jdaw wvd~dc jed ivk`dy feydb oc ydztea ovkdcekoc ecb hdcbdv
kbdck{# Kc deij o jdyd xe{y! he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv ~kik`y o ~koadc ivk`d xotab
aoyd tcbdv ydutdyvekoc#
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab vdbtid ntcby tydb ro wvd~dcr wvkyoc vewd
Kc @e{ 6756 jd Ofe`e eb`kckyvekoc ceak|db vdhtaekocy k`wad`dckch jd
Wvkyoc Vewd Dak`kcekoc Ei# Rd vdhtaekocy kciatbd wvo~kykocy ek`db e wvd-
~dckch ydztea eftyd ecb ~koadcid ehekcy he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv kc`edy#559 Rky ky
wevkitaeva{ k`wovec fdietyd o jd eaev`kcha{ jkhj vedy o wj{ykiea ecb ydztea
~koadcid je he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad eid xjkad kcievidvedb#552
Rd aexy vdhtaekocy ewwa{ o eaa dbdvea ioccd`dc eikakkdy! ecb k`wad`dce-koc o jd cdxa{ eccotcidb yecbevby ky tcbdvxe{# Cocdjdadyy! jdyd eikakkdy
xotab dzwdvkdcid yjevw ity o jdkv ftbhdy kc 6759 ecb fd{ocb tcbdv ydutdy-
vekoc# Xkj dxdv vdyotvidy! k`wad`dckch jdyd vdaek~da{ cdx wvodikocy
xkaa wvo~d bkita ecb iotab tvjdv dcbechdv jd jdeaj ecb yed{ o he{ ecb
vecyhdcbdv kc`edy#
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab `emd kr jevbdv nov rjd he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv
~kirk`y on bo`dyrki ~koadcid ro eiidyy aknd-ye~kch ydv~kidy
Rd ^koadcid Ehekcy Xo`dc Ei ky otv cekocy adhkyaek~d vdywocyd o ebbvdyy
ecb wvd~dc bo`dyki ~koadcid#554 He{ ecb vecyhdcbdv ~kik`y o bo`dyki
~koadcid je~d {d o fd taa{ kciovwovedb kco jd aexy wtv~kdxyo`djkch je
Iochvdyy `ty eayo ebbvdyy kc jky ae`d-btim ydyykocft atimka{! kc 6757 jd
Bdwev`dc o Ltykid bddv`kcdb je dbdvea wvoyditovy iotab dcovid idvekc
ivk`kcea wvo~kykocy o jd aex kc ieydy kc~oa~kch ye`d-ydz wevcdvy#55> Rky ky ivkk-
iea! iocykbdvkch je he{ wdowad dzwdvkdcid yk`kaevecb yo`dk`dy jkhjdvvedy
o kck`ed wevcdv ~koadcid io`wevdb o jdkv iotcdvwevy!558 ft eid tckutd
fevvkdvy kc eiidyykch ytwwov ydv~kidy#55:
Ftbhd ity tcbdv ydutdyvekoc xotab yaeyj `kaakocy o boaaevy vo` wvohve`y
ek`db ecb wvd~dckch ecb wvoyditkch ~koadc ivk`dy tcbdv jd ^koadcid Ehekcy
Xo`dc Ei#55; Ydutdyvekoc xotab je~d e cdhek~d k`wei oc jd he{ ecb vecy-
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
31/41
64 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
hdcbdv io``tck{ kc xo xe{y# Nkvy! vdbtidb tcbkch xotab it jd ct`fdv ecb
e`otc o hvecy je jd oid xotab fd efad o eb`kckydv o ovheck|ekocy je
ebbvdyy bo`dyki ~koadcid kc jd he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv io``tck{# Ydiocb! jd db-
dvea ho~dvc`dc xotab eayo je~d dxdv vdyotvidy o vekc yed ecb aoiea aex dcovid-
`dc o dcytvd je kcbk~kbteay kc ~koadc ecb eftyk~d vdaekocyjkwy! vdhevbadyy o
ydztea ovkdcekoc ov hdcbdv kbdck{! hd jd jdaw jd{ cddb o ytv~k~d#
Ydutdyvekoc xotab vdyta kc `ovd jec 556!777 ~kik`y o bo`dyki ~koadcid!
kciatbkch joyd xjo evd he{ ov vecyhdcbdv! fdkch bdckdb eiidyy o yjdadvy ov
wvohve`y#567 He{ ecb vecyhdcbdv ~kik`y o ~koadcid xotab fd e`och jd `oy
~tacdvefad k ydutdyvekoc hody kco ddi fdietyd o wvd-dzkykch fevvkdvy o
eiidyykch ebduted ytwwov ydv~kidy#
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
32/41
6> Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Ydutdyrverkoc xotab ak`kr rjd ieweikr{ on rjd
Tckrdb Yrerdy ro wvordir rjd jt`ec vkhjry on
he{ ecb rvecyhdcbdv wdowad xovabxkbd
Bkyivk`kcekoc ecb ~koadcid ehekcy he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad ky e wdvykydc ecb
eaev`kch wvofad` foj bo`dykieaa{ ecb kcdvcekoceaa{# Yd~dc{-dkhj iotcvkdy
itvvdca{ je~d aexy ov ojdv adhea wvo~kykocy je ivk`kceak|d ydz fdxddc wdowad
o jd ye`d hdcbdv# Kc e adey ~d iotcvkdy! fdkch he{ ky wtckyjefad xkj jd
bdej wdcea{#565
Eimcoxadbhkch je he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv vkhjy evd jt ec vkhjy! jd Bdwev`dc
o Yed jey emdc jd adeb kc wvo`okch e io`wvdjdcyk~d jt`ec vkhjy ehdcbeek`db e wvodikch jd taa jt`ec vkhjy o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad evotcb
jd xovab#566
Ydutdyvekoc xotab ak`k jd wtfaki bkwao`ei{ dovy iocbtidb f{ T#Y# d`fey-
ykdy o wvo`od he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv jt`ec vkhjy
T#Y# d`feyykdy xovabxkbd je~d fddc eik~d kc bdiaevkch ytwwov ov he{ ecb vecy-
hdcbdv vkhjy jvothj kcco~ek~d dovy kc wtfaki bkwao`ei{# Rdyd dovy je~d
kciatbdb kyytkch wtfaki yed`dcy o ytwwov ov wvkbd d~dcy! joykch wtfaki
bkyityykocy ecb bdfedy oc he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv kyytdy! ecb joykch a` yivddc-
kchy o wvo`od bkeaohtd ecb wtfaki dbtiekoc#569 Rdyd bkwao`eki dovy xotab
fd bd~eyedb tcbdv jd aoo`kch eto`eki ftbhd ity# Rd Oid o Wdvyoccda
@ecehd`dc jey kcbkiedb je jd Yed Bdwev`dcy bkwao`eki ecb iocytaev
wvohve`y xkaa eid `ovd jec "5 fkaakoc kc ity kc 6759 eaocd#562 Rdyd ity xotab
ykhckieca{ k`wdbd jd iockctekoc o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv bkwao`eki dovy
ecb xotab fd ecojdv jk o ytwwov ov haofea he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv duteak{#
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
33/41
68 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Iociatykoc
Ey xd ewwvoeij jd dcb o jd {dev! Iochvdyy `ty io`d tw xkj e vekocea yoat-
koc o vdbtikch otv iotcv{y bdik xkjot io`wvo`kykch jd jdeaj! xdaacdyy!
ecb ak~dakjoob o E`dvkiecy! kciatbkch joyd xjo kbdck{ ey he{ ov vecyhdcbdv# K
Iochvdyy iecco ehvdd oc e waec o eikoc! ydutdyvekoc xkaa ho kco ddi e jd
fdhkcckch o 6759#
Eaaoxkch ydutdyvekoc o emd waeid xotab jkcbdv jd ho~dvc`dcy efkak{ o
kc~dykhed ecb wvd~dc xovmwaeid bkyivk`kcekoc ehekcy he{ ecb vecyhdcbdvd`wao{ddy# K xotab vdbtid wvohve``eki tcbkch o ydv~kidy ek`db e ebbvdyykch
jd ywdiki jdeaj cddby o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad# K xotab vdbtid tcbkch
exevbdb o ovheck|ekocy xovmkch o vdbtid jo`dadyycdyy e`och he{ ecb vecy-
hdcbdv {otj# K xotab k`wdbd jd ho~dvc`dcy efkak{ o wvd~dc ecb ebbvdyy
~koadc ivk`d ehekcy he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv wdowad# Ecb k xotab jkcbdv bkwao eki
dovy o wvo`od jd jt`ec vkhjy ecb feyki yed{ o he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv
wdowad evotcb jd haofd#
Kc yjov! eaaoxkch ydutdyvekoc o ho kco ddi xotab fd bkyeyvoty ov he{ ecb
vecyhdcbdv E`dvkiecy#
Iochvdyy `ty ei! ecb k `ty ei yxka{! o ehvdd twoc e aoch-dv` yoatkoc
je `ddy jd vdutkvd`dcy o jd 6755 Ftbhd Iocvoa Eiy bdik-vdbtikoc
hoeay# Ivkkieaa{! jd yoatkoc `ty co io`wvo`kyd ivtikea ho~dvc`dc wvo-
hve`y ecb ehdcikdy je ydv~d jd he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv io``tck{# Kc jd d~dc
je Iochvdyy ekay o vdeij e aoch-dv` yoatkoc f{ jd dcb o jd {dev! joxd~dv!
Iochvdyy yjotab weyy e yjov-dv` bdae{ kc ydutdyvekoc yo je jd cdx iaeyy o
vdidca{ dadidb oikeay je xkaa emd oid kc Lectev{ ky eovbdb jd owwovtck{
o ive e ~kefad! fkwevkyec! ecb ytyekcefad yoatkoc o otv cekocy bdik#
Ey cdhokekocy wvoiddb! ivekch e vta{ ddik~d yoatkoc xkaa vdutkvd e feaecidb
ewwvoeij o `kzkch vd~dctd kcivdeydy xkj ywdcbkch ity kc wvohve`y xjdvd jdvd
ky fkwevkyec ehvdd`dc# o eijkd~d jky feaecidb ewwvoeij! joxd~dv! iochvdy-
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
34/41
6: Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
ykocea Vdwtfakiecy `ty eimcoxadbhd je eaaoxkch ez ity ov jd xdeajkdy
E`dvkiecy o dzwkvd ky k`wdvek~d o vdeijkch e io`wvo`kyd ecb vdbtikch otv
cekocy bdik# Aex`emdvy iecco yeivkid jd jdeaj! xdaacdyy! ecb ak~dakjoob o
ovbkcev{ E`dvkiecy o wvodi ez ity ov `kaakocekvdy#
k`d ky vtcckch ot# @d`fdvy o Iochvdyy ecb jd wvdykbdc je~d e akrad `ovdjec e `ocj o yvkmd e bdea# Nov eaa E`dvkiecyhe{ ov yvekhj! vecyhdcbdv ov
cok ky ~kea je jd{ bo#
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
35/41
6; Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Efotr rjd etrjovy
Ecbvdx Ive{ ky e Vdydevij Eyyoiked ov jd AHF Vdydevij ecb
Io``tckiekocy Wvoldi e jd Idcdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy# Jky xovm kciatbdy
eb~oiekch ov AHF kciatykoc ecb dchehd`dc kc yed k`wad`dcekoc o jd
Eovbefad Ievd Ei! vekykch exevdcdyy o jdeaj kcytvecid woakikdy je k`wvo~dio~dvehd ov AHF e`kakdy! ecb dcytvkch je AHF wdowad evd iotcdb kc bee
ioaadikoc ecb ytv~d{y# Wvkov o lokckch IEW! Ecbvdx xey e jdeaj aex ecb woaki{
daaox e jd Cekocea Idcdv ov vecyhdcbdv Duteak{! xjdvd jd eb~oiedb ov
ekv eiidyy o eovbefad! jkhj-uteak{ jdeaj ievd ov vecyhdcbdv wekdcy# Ecbvdx
jey eayo eidb ey e iocytaec o jd Cekocea Ioeakkoc ov AHF Jdeaj! ydv~-
kch ey jd adeb vdydevijdv ecb etjov o jd ioeakkocy io`wvdjdcyk~d vdwov oc
~ddvecy jdeaj wvohve`y ecb jd jdeaj cddby o AHF wdowad xjo je~d ydv~db
kc jd `kakev{# Ecbvdx joaby e feijdaov o yikdcid bdhvdd kc io``tckiekocy
vo` Covjxdydvc Tck~dvyk{ ecb e aex bdhvdd vo` jd Tck~dvyk{ o @kijkhec
Aex Yijooa#
Ivoyf{ Ftvcy ky e Vdydevij Eyyoiked ov jd AHF Vdydevij ecb
Io``tckiekocy Wvoldi e jd Idcdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy# Ivoyf{ jey jdawdb
bd~daow IEWy yvedhki woaki{ ecb io``tckiekocy ehdcbe o eb~ecid dutea-
k{ ecb ekvcdyy ov AHF E`dvkiecy jvothj iochvdyykocea ecb eb`kckyvek~d
eikoc# Jd jey eayo adb IEWy dovy o io`fe d`wao{`dc bkyivk`kcekoc feydb
oc ydztea ovkdcekoc ecb hdcbdv kbdck{ f{ eb~oiekch ov aexy ecb woakikdy je
dzdcb adhea xovmwaeid wvodikocy o jd he{ ecb vecyhdcbdv xovmovid# Ivoyf{
joaby e feijdaovy bdhvdd kc woakkiea yikdcid ecb wy{ijoaoh{ vo` jd Tck~dvyk{
o Ieakovcke! Fdvmdad{# Jd xkaa fd erdcbkch Jev~evb Tck~dvyk{ kc jd eaa o 6759
xjdvd jd xkaa fd wtvytkch jky `eydvy kc wtfaki woaki{ e jd Lojc N# Mdccdb{
Yijooa o Ho~dvc`dc#
Dvkc Nkr|hdveab ky ec Tv~eyjk ^ekb Vdydevij Ndaaox e jd Cekocea He{ ecb
Adyfkec eym Novid# Yjd ky eayo itvvdca{ wtvytkch e `eydvy bdhvdd e jd
veijdcfdvh Yijooa o Wtfaki Woaki{ ecb Wtfaki Eb`kckyvekoc e Hdovhd
Xeyjkchoc Tck~dvyk{# Jdv evdey o ytb{ kciatbd dioco`ki yditvk{! tvfec
woaki{! ecb AHF vkhjy# Fdovd yevkch e jd eym Novid! Dvkc xovmdb kc
Wjkaebdawjke ey e Ytwwad`dcea Ctvkkoc Eyykyecid Wvohve` Fdcd Akekyocov Wjkaebdawjke Ioeakkoc Ehekcy Jtchdv! xjdvd yjd xovmdb o dcvoaa wdowad
kc yoikea eyykyecid wvohve`y ecb ethj ioomkch ecb `dea waecckch iaeyydy o
ytwwad`dcea ctvkkoc eyykyecid vdikwkdcy# Dvkc vdidk~db e feijdaovy bdhvdd
vo` Vthdvy Tck~dvyk{ kc xo`dcy ecb hdcbdv ytbkdy#
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
36/41
97 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
Dcbcordy
5 6 T#Y#I# ;75e*8+ *6755+#
6 Fvkec Yrdxevr ecb Efveje` Xjkrd! Xjer ky rjd NkyieaIak ecb Jox Xkaa kr K`weir [otch E`dvkiecy?! Ie`wtyWvohvdyy! Co~d`fdv 54! 6756! e~ekaefad er jrrw
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
37/41
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
38/41
96 Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy q Iethjr kc rjd Ftbhdr Ferrad
>8 Adrrdv vo` We`dae J{bd ro Vdw# Ldvvoab Cebadv!Co~d`fdv 4! 6757! e~ekaefad er jrrw: Kfkb#
>; Kfkb#
87 @dcrea Jdearj E`dvkie! [otv @dcrea Jdearj TcbdvYdutdyrdv *6756+! e~ekaefad er jrrw6;6755e#jr`a *aeyr eiidyydbOirofdv 6756+#
86 Kfkb#
89 Iochvdyykocea Ftbhdr Onid! Twberdb Dyrk`erdy ov rjdKcytvecid Io~dvehd Wvo~kykocy o rjd Eovbefad IevdEir *6756+#
82 Kcrdvcea Vd~dctd Iobd 9>F *ebbdb f{ Werkdcr Wvordirkoc ecb Eovbefad Ievd Eir 5275 ecb e`dcbdb f{Jdearj Ievd ecb Dbtierkoc Vdiocikakerkoc Eir o 6757!Wtfaki Aex 546! 555rj Iochvdyy! *6757+ += Werkdcr Wvordirkoc ecb Eovbefad Ievd Eir 5276 *ey e`dcbdb f{Jdearj Ievd ecb Dbtierkoc Vdiocikakerkoc Eir o 6757+ecb 5256#
84 Vecb{ Eafdbe ecb orjdvy! Wo~dvr{ kc rjd Adyfkec! He{!ecb Fkydztea Io``tckr{ *Aoy Echdady< Rjd Xkaake`yKcyrkrtrd! 677;+#
8> Kcyrkrtrd o @dbkikcd! Rjd Jdearj o Adyfkec! He{! Fkydztea! ecb Rvecyhdcbdv Wdowad< Ftkabkch e Notcberkocov Fdrrdv Tcbdvyrecbkch *6755+#
88 Jdearj Kcytvecid Dzijechd Dyrefakyj`dcr Hvecry NeirYjddr! e~ekaefad er jrrw25/xj{`dbkiekb`errdvyovhe{ecbrvecyhdcbdvio``tckrkdy/#
:5 Ckio Ykve Utkcrece! Loyj Voydcrjea! ecb Ld Mvdjda{!Oc rjd Yrvddry< Rjd Ndbdvea Vdywocyd ro He{ ecb
Rvecyhdcbdv Jo`dadyy [otrj *Xeyjkchroc< Idcrdv ovE`dvkiec Wvohvdyy! 6757+#
:6 Kfkb#
:9 Kfkb#
:2 Jotykch CocBkyivk`kcerkoc Aexy! e~ekaefad er jrrw Ivoyf{ Ftvcy ecb Wjkakw Voyy! He{ ecb RvecyhdcbdvBkyivk`kcerkoc Otrykbd rjd Xovmwaeid *Xeyjkchroc Ndbdvea Ytwwad`dcrea Dbtierkocea Owwovrtckr{ Hvecr*NYDOH+ Wvohve`! e~ekaefad er jrrw
7/30/2019 Caught in the Budget Battle
40/41
Idcrdv ov E`dvkiec Wvohvdyy ecb Rjd Cerkocea He{ ecb Adyfkec Reym Novid xkrj