7/25/2019 Case digest 1-4

1/6

Case #1

Rule 1 Section 4Title of the Case:GOVERNMENT SERVICE INSURANCE SYSTEM (GSIS) and WINSTON F.GARCIA, in his capacity as RESI!ENT and GENERA" MANAGER #$ th% GSIS &%'ss

!INNA VI""AVI*A, E"I*A+ET !UUE, A!RONICO A. ECAVE*, RO!E" RU+IO,ROWENA TERESE +. GRACIA, I"AR "AYCO, and ANTONIO -OSE "EGAR!AG.R. N#. /012Ponente:MEN!O*A, -.3

Facts:This is a %titi#n $#' R%&i%4 #n C%'ti#'a'i nd%' R5% 67 #$ th% R5%s #$ C#'t. GMGa'cia, as '%sid%nt and G%n%'a5 Mana8%' #$ th% GSIS, $i5%d s%pa'at% $#'9a5 cha'8%s a8ainst'%sp#nd%nts and %&%nta55y $#nd th%9 8i5ty $#' G'a&% Misc#ndct and:#' C#ndct '%;dicia5t# th% +%st Int%'%st #$ th% S%'&ic% and 9%tin8 #t th% p%na5ty #$ #n% () y%a' ssp%nsi#n p5sth% acc%ss#'y p%na5ti%s app't%nant th%'%t#. Th% cha'8%s c#ntain%d that'%sp#nd%nt, 4%a'in8 '%d shi't t#8%th%' 4ith s#9% %9p5#y%%s, 9a'ch%d t# #'

app%a'%d si95tan%#s5y at #' ;st #tsid% th% #$$ic% #$ th% In&%sti8ati#n Unit in a9ass d%9#nst'ati#n:'a55y #$ p'#t%st and spp#'t $#' M%ss's. Ma'i# M#5ina and A5

7/25/2019 Case digest 1-4

2/6

Ruling:Spp5%t#'y is d%$in%d as spp5yin8 d%$ici%nci%s. It 9%ans that th% p'#&isi#ns in th%R5%s #$ C#'t 4i55

7/25/2019 Case digest 1-4

3/6

Case #2Rule 1 Section 6

Title of the Case: ME!ISERV, INC. &%'ss COURT OF AEA"S (Sp%cia5 F#'9%' th!i&isi#n) and "AN!EIGTS !EVE"OMENT CORORATION G.R. N#. /

Ponente: VI""ARAMA, -R., -.3

Facts: %titi#n%' M%dis%'&, Inc. %>%ct%d a '%a5 %stat% 9#'t8a8% in $a' #$ China +anin8C#'p#'ati#n as s%c'ity $#' a 5#an. M%dis%'& d%$a5t%d in its #

7/25/2019 Case digest 1-4

4/6

th%

7/25/2019 Case digest 1-4

5/6

Case #

7/25/2019 Case digest 1-4

6/6

Rule 1 Section 6

Title of the Case3 SS. E+ER J CAR"ITA E!I""O &%'ss SS. NOR+ERTO J

!ESI!ERIA !U"INA G.R. N#. //0

Ponente:(RI!3 J/3

Facts: On F%p'%ss p'#hiati#n #$ t%chnica5 '5%s is ;sti$i%d