74
Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 of 74

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 of 74

Page 2: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 2 of 74

Page 3: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

Administrative Record Index

Description Date Bates NumberLetter from Charles Ryan, Director, Arizona Department of Corrections, to David Thomas, FDA Investigations re: Execution by Lethal Injection of Arizona Inmate Jeffrey Timothy Landrigan #082157 9/24/2010 000001Letter from Charles Flanagan, Deputy Director, Arizona Department of Corrections, to David Thomas, FDA Investigations, enclosing Controlled Substance Registration Certificate 9/24/2010 000002-000003Notice of FDA Action 9/29/2010 000004Department of Treasury, U.S. Customs Service Entry/Immediate Delivery Form 10/7/2010 000005-00006FDA's Operational and Administrative System for Import Support (OASIS) Screenshot for Entry # 112-9247186-3 n/a 000007Letter from Dale Baich, Supervisor, Capital Habeas Unit, Office of the Federal Public Defender for the District of Arizona, to Ralph Tyler, Chief Counsel, FDA 10/23/2010 000008-000012Department of Homeland Security, U.S. Customs and Border Protection Entry/Immediate Delivery Form 10/25/2010 000013-000015FDA's OASIS Screenshot for Entry # 574-0251126-5 n/a 000016Email from Patrick Bowen, FDA, to Distribution re: Import Bulletin #60-B08 10/27/2010 000017-000018Email from Nima Abbaszadeh, U.K. Desk Officer, U.S. Department of State, to Ilisa Bernstein re: assistance on sodium thiopental question raised by UK Embassy, enclosing Letter from Ian Bond, Political Counsellor, British Embassy Washington, to Elizabeth Dibble, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State 11/4/2011 000019-000020Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium thiopental 11/4/2010 000021Email from Tom Smith, Department for Business, Innovation and Skills, to Murray Lumpkin re: Sodium Thiopental 11/5/2010 000022Email from Murray Lumpkin to Tom Smith cc JM Sharfstein and Margaret Hamburg re: Substantive response from US FDA re: Sodium Thiopental 11/16/2010 000023-000024Letter from Charles Ryan, Director, Arizona Department of Corrections, to Deborah Autor, Director, Office of Compliance, CDER, re: Entry #574-0251126-5 Thiopental Sodium 11/10/2010 000025-000026

1 of 2

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 3 of 74

Page 4: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

Administrative Record Index

Letter from Charles Ryan, Director, Arizona Department of Corrections, to David Thomas, FDA Investigations, re: Inspection and Release of Entry #574-0251126-5, Thiopental Sodium 11/10/2010 000027Letter from Dale Baich, Supervisor, Capital Habeas Unit, Office of the Federal Public Defender for the District of Arizona, to Thomas Emerick, Assistant Special Agent in Charge, FDA 11/17/2010 000028-000029Department of Treasury Entry/Immediate Delivery Form 11/24/2010 000030-000031FDA's OASIS Screenshot for Entry # 112-9938358-2 n/a 000032Letter from Benjamin Rice, General Counsel, State of California, to Ruth Dixon, FDA 12/9/2010 000033Sodium Thiopental Statement, Key Messages 12/29/2010 000034-000035Email from Shelly Burgess to Nathan Koppel 1/4/2011 000036-000037Letter from Coleen Klasmeier, Bradford Berenson (Sidley Austin), and Dale Baich (Office of the Federal Public Defender for the District of Arizona), to Margaret Hamburg, Commissioner, FDA 1/4/2011 000038-000050Guidance for handling pending and future shipments of Sodium Thiopental 1/5/2011 000051-000057Notice of FDA Action 1/6/2011 000058-000059Notice of FDA Action 1/7/2011 000060-000061Letter from Patricia Shafer, Acting District Director, New Orleans District Office, to Benjamin Rice, Chief Counsel, California Department of Corrections & Rehabilitation 1/7/2011 000062-000063Letter from Alonza Cruse, District Director, Los Angeles District, to Carson McWilliams, Warden, Arizona State Prison Complex n/a 000064

MiscellaneousFDA Establishment Inspection Report for Sandoz - Endorsement Excerpt 7/8/2009 000065FDA Establishment Inspection Report for Sandoz - Summary Excerpt 7/29/2010 000066-000069Form FDA 483 - Inspectional Observations for Sandoz 7/29/2010 000070

2 of 2

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 4 of 74

Page 5: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000001

(b) (7)(E)

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 5 of 74

Page 6: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000002

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 6 of 74

Page 7: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000003

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 7 of 74

Page 8: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000004

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 8 of 74

Page 9: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000005

(b) (4)

(b) (4)

(b) (4)(b) (4)

(b) (4)

(b) (4)

(b) (4)

(b) (4)

(b) (4)(b) (4)(b) (4)

(b) (4)

(b) (4)

(b) (4)

(b) (4)

(b) (7)(C)

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 9 of 74

Page 10: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000006

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 10 of 74

Page 11: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000007

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 11 of 74

Page 12: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000008

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 12 of 74

Page 13: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000009

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 13 of 74

Page 14: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000010

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 14 of 74

Page 15: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000011

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 15 of 74

Page 16: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000012

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 16 of 74

Page 17: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000013

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 17 of 74

Page 18: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000014

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 18 of 74

Page 19: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000015

(b) (7)(E)

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 19 of 74

Page 20: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000016

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 20 of 74

Page 21: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000017

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 21 of 74

Page 22: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000018

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 22 of 74

Page 23: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000019

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 23 of 74

Page 24: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000020

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 24 of 74

Page 25: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000021

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 25 of 74

Page 26: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000022

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 26 of 74

Page 27: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000023

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 27 of 74

Page 28: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000024

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 28 of 74

Page 29: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000025

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 29 of 74

Page 30: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000026

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 30 of 74

Page 31: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

(b) (7)(E)

FDA 000027

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 31 of 74

Page 32: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000028

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 32 of 74

Page 33: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000029

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 33 of 74

Page 34: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000030

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 34 of 74

Page 35: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000031

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 35 of 74

Page 36: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000032

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 36 of 74

Page 37: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000033

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 37 of 74

Page 38: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000034

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 38 of 74

Page 39: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000035

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 39 of 74

Page 40: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000036

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 40 of 74

Page 41: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000037

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 41 of 74

Page 42: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000038

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 42 of 74

Page 43: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000039

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 43 of 74

Page 44: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000040

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 44 of 74

Page 45: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000041

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 45 of 74

Page 46: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000042

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 46 of 74

Page 47: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000043

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 47 of 74

Page 48: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000044

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 48 of 74

Page 49: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000045

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 49 of 74

Page 50: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000046

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 50 of 74

Page 51: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000047

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 51 of 74

Page 52: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000048

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 52 of 74

Page 53: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000049

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 53 of 74

Page 54: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000050

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 54 of 74

Page 55: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000051

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 55 of 74

Page 56: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000052

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 56 of 74

Page 57: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000053

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 57 of 74

Page 58: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000054

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 58 of 74

Page 59: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000055

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 59 of 74

Page 60: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000056

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 60 of 74

Page 61: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000057

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 61 of 74

Page 62: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000058

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 62 of 74

Page 63: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000059

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 63 of 74

Page 64: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000060

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 64 of 74

Page 65: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000061

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 65 of 74

Page 66: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000062

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 66 of 74

Page 67: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000063

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 67 of 74

Page 68: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000064

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 68 of 74

Page 69: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000065

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 69 of 74

Page 70: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000066

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 70 of 74

Page 71: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000067

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 71 of 74

Page 72: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000068

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 72 of 74

Page 73: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000069

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 73 of 74

Page 74: Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 1 ... · Email from Clare Bloomfield, British Embassy, to Murray Lumpkin, FDA, re: UK request for information on sodium

FDA 000070

Case 1:11-cv-00289-RJL Document 13-3 Filed 04/20/11 Page 74 of 74