53
Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation 2013 Louisiana Transportation Conference Section 68 Public Works Randy Denmon, P.E., Denmon Engineering Bradley Sticker, P.E., DOTD

Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

  • Upload
    buithu

  • View
    215

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Cane River Lake

Spillway Rehabilitation

2013 Louisiana Transportation Conference

Section 68 – Public Works

Randy Denmon, P.E., Denmon Engineering

Bradley Sticker, P.E., DOTD

Page 2: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Topics

Background & Purpose

Spillway Data

Spillway History

Spillway Rehabilitation

Gate Rehabilitation

Concrete Rehabilitation

Page 3: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Cane River Lake Information

Located in Natchitoches Parish

A relic Red River Channel

Classified Significant Hazard

16,000 Acre-Feet Storage

1,350 Acre Surface Area

• Approximately 34 miles long

Page 4: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Cane River Lake Information

Two embankments

• North embankment near Natchitoches (part of Red

River Levee)

• South embankment near Derry under LA 484

One spillway structure

• LA 484 passes over spillway structure

North

Embankment South

Embankment

Page 5: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 6: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Spillway Purpose

Lake and Spillway have multiple roles

Irrigation water supply

• Several thousand acres irrigated

Recreation

Drainage

Page 7: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Spillway Data

LA 484 passes over spillway structure

Three sided weir inlet @ elev. 98.0’

(96’ total weir length)

Two 10’ wide by 5’ deep drawdown gates in

weir

Four 6’x6’ RCB conduits

56’ long with inlet invert

at elev. 90.0’

(conduit slope 27%)

Four 6’x6’ sluice gates

on RCB outlets

Page 8: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Spillway Inlet

Page 9: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Spillway Outlet

Page 10: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Spillway History

Spillway designed by DPW in 1947

Cane River Levee and Drainage District

Awarded spillway contract July 20, 1948

Award amount $70,366.97

Completed July 8, 1949

Page 11: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Spillway History

Embankment slides in early 1980s

Repaired 1983 with H piles and bulkhead

No record of replacement of drawdown

gates

Minimal maintenance over structure life

Page 12: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

DOTD Involvement

RS 38:306 D.

DOTD provides engineering work for Levee

Boards

Responsibilities:

NLDD responsible for earthen embankments

NLDD operates outfall gates on spillway

RS 34:3262 CRWC responsible for

establishment, operation and maintenance of

navigable waterway

DOTD responsible for LA 484 over spillway

Page 13: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Why Was Rehab Needed?

Page 14: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Why Was Rehab Needed?

Loss of the management gates:

Impact local farmers

Close lake to recreation

Impact riparian property value

Impact City of Natchitoches Festival of Lights

Page 15: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

DOTD Involvement

Provided historical documents

Provided review and consultation of

proposals

Page 16: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

SPILLWAY

REHABILITATION

Page 17: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

MAP

Page 18: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 19: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 20: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 21: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 22: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 23: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 24: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 25: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

SOIL TYPE - CLAY

LIQUID LIMIT: 71

P.I.: 24

Page 26: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

OLD PLANS

Page 27: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 28: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 29: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 30: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 31: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 32: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 33: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 34: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

EPOXY GROUTING

Page 35: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 36: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 37: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 38: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 39: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 40: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 41: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 42: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

PROBLEMS

350 LINEAR FEET CRACKS

2200 SQUARE FEET EXPOSED

CONCRETE

NEEDED TO GROUT AND SEAL

CRACKS

ALSO, COAT THE SPILLWAY WITH A

CORRISION INHIBATOR

Page 43: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

SPECIFICATIONS

STRUCTURAL REPAIR OF CONCRETE

CRACKS BY INJECTION OF EPOXY

RESIN ADHESIVE – LTRC, 1989

EVALUATION AND REPAIR OF

CONCRETE STRUCTURES, USACE, EM

1110-2-2002, 1995

STRUCTUAL CRACK REPAIR BY

EPOXY INJECTION, ACI, 2003

Page 44: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

PRODUCTS

Page 45: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

SPECIFICATON - ACI

Page 46: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 47: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 48: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 49: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Up close injection

Page 50: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 51: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 52: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 53: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

EPOXY GROUTING

COST: $85/FOOT (CRACK REPAIR)

$3.35/SQ. FT. (COATING)

TOTAL COST: $39,120

VERY QUICK AND ECONOMICAL

REPAIR

MANY LAKES IN LOUISIANA ARE 50 TO

80 YEARS OLD WITH LITTLE OR NO

MAINTENANCE