Candida Albicans: Pathogenesis, Immunity and Host Defence

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/25/2019 Candida Albicans: Pathogenesis, Immunity and Host Defence

    1/8

    IMMUNITY TO FUNGI

    281

    factors. This issue is discussed by Kullberg and

    Anaissie, who review the benefic ial effect of

    G-CSF, TNFa, ILl, IL12 and IFNyadministration or

    IL4 neutralization in experimental models of fungal

    infections. In patients with qualitat ive or quantita-

    tive defects in phagocyte functions, IFNy, G-CSF

    and GM-CSF prove to have therapeutic potential

    when given prophylactically or during established

    infection. Cytokines and growth factors may also

    augment the antifunga l activities of leukocytes

    from HIV-infected indiv iduals , as discussed by

    Levitz in his chapter. He points out that predisposi-

    tion of HIV-infected individuals to mycoses is a

    result of many factors, including mononuclear and

    polymorphonuclear phagocyte dysfunctions resul-

    ting in impaired antifungal activity and cytokine

    secretion. However, the find ing that fungi and fun-

    gal products stimulate HIV replication in latently

    infected cells underscores the complexity of host-

    fungal interactions in HIV infection.

    This research Forum was conducted under the auspices of the Italian Research Program on AIDS (Opportunistic

    Infections and Tuberculosis Project).

    Candida albicans: pathogenesis, immunity and host defence

    R.B. Ashman

    Oral Biology and Pathology, School of Dentistry, University of Queensland, Brisbane Old. 4072

    Introduction

    Infections with the yeast Candida albicans

    present a significant and increasing clinical problem.

    Oral and vaginal candid is are common in the gen-

    eral population, but are seen most frequently, and in

    their most severe form, in individuals with defects in

    the cell-mediated immune response. In contrast,

    systemic or disseminated candidiasis is usually a

    disease of debilitated or immunocompromised

    patients in the hospital environment.

    There are many different models for the study of

    C. albicans infections, some focussing on the muco-

    sal, and others on the systemic infection. The mouse

    has been the most common experimental animal,

    because the lesions induced by intravenous chal-

    lenge closely resemble, in nature and distribution,

    those seen n the human disease Louria et al., 1963 ;

    Papadimitriou and Ashman, 1986). However, there

    are considerable variations among inbred strains in

    the severity and other measures of infection. This

    paper will summarize these differences, and con-

    sider their relationship to mechanisms of host

    defence and the induction of adaptive immunity.

    Genetics of susceptibility and resistance

    In determining patterns of susceptibility and

    resistance n different inbred strains, the necessity of

    evaluating and comparing different measures of

    infection has become apparent. Not only do these

    different criteria reflect different aspects of the

    host/yeast interaction, but there is no simple rela-

    tionship between them, and they cannot be regarded

    as interchangeable. Mortality, which is often

    regarded as

    an

    index of overall susceptibility,

    shows a general correlation with the magnitude of

    the fungal burden in the kidney (Marquis et al.,

    1988; Salvin and Neta, 1983) ; but the latter, which

    reflects the efficiency of the hosts candidacidal or

    candidastatic effector mechanisms, is relevant only

    as ong as the tolerance to yeast colonization of par-

    ticular organ systems is not exceeded. In contrast,

    the severity of

    lesions in

    the

    tissues represents the

    resultant of the interaction between the proliferating

    yeast and the host responseagainst it, at a particular

    point in time.

    The significance of these distinctions lies in the

    insights they provide into the patterns of susceptibil-

    Received April 9, 1998.

  • 7/25/2019 Candida Albicans: Pathogenesis, Immunity and Host Defence

    2/8

    282

    73rd FORUM IN IMMUNOLOGY

    ity to systemic challenge seen in various inbred

    strains. In general, indices such as mortality and time

    to death bear no relationship to the strain distribution

    of known reference genes, such as those within the

    major histocompatibility complex (MHC), although

    mice deficient in the fifth component of complement

    (C.5) arc significantly more susceptible to lethal chal-

    lenge than U-sufficient mice (Hector

    et al.,

    1982;

    Morelli and Rosenberg, 1971). However, histological

    and quantitative studies have revealed the existence

    of at least two host variables that complicate interpre-

    tation of the response. The firs t of these is regulated

    by a Mendelian-type gene, now named CargI (Ash-

    man

    et

    al., 1997), that determines whether the extent

    of tissue destruction after systemic infection is mild,

    as in BALB/c mice, or severe, as in the CBA/&I-I

    strain. There is also evidence for the existence of a

    second level of genetic control, that influences the

    susceptibility of the kidney [Ashman, unpublished].

    Allocation of presumptive resistant and suscep-

    tible alleles of these genes among various inbred

    strains gives an excellent correlation with the various

    measures of infection.

    It can be seen (table I) that possession of the sus-

    ceptible allele of the Cargl gene correlates not only

    with severe tissue damage, but also with a moderate

    increase in the fungal burden in the kidney. It is

    assumed that this latter leads to a higher proportion of

    animals that develop acute pyelonephritis, with a

    consequent increase in mortality. Cur-g1 in mice does

    not segregate with MI-K type (Ashman and Papadi-

    mitriou, 1989). and by implication is not dependent

    on the function of T lymphocytes. This conclusion is

    supported by the observation that nude mice bred on

    either BALB or CBA backgrounds show similar pat-

    terns of tissue damage to their respective heterozy-

    gous littermates (Fulurija et al., 1997). Preliminary

    evidence suggests that this gene exerts its function

    via the properties of a bone-marrow-derived cell

    (Ashman and Papadimitriou, 1992), most probably o f

    neutrophil lineage. The second gene, Carg; was first

    identified in CS-sufficient C57/L mice (Ashman

    et

    al., 1997). In these animals, the susceptible allele

    causes a marked increase in the severity of tissue

    damage, but only a slight increase in the fungal bur-

    den, relative to C57BU6 mice (Ashman, unpublished

    data). However, in CS-deficient animals,

    Carg2

    appears to interact with the haemolytic complement

    gene (Hc) to increase dramatically both kidney colon-

    ization and mortality. The chromosomal localization

    of

    Cargl

    and

    Carg2

    has not yet been definitively

    established, so it is not clear whether the latter is

    closely linked to Hc, or in what way the two genes

    (or their products) interact.

    What then, are the implications of the above for

    mechanisms of host resistance? An important consid-

    eration is whether effector mechanisms identified in

    one infected organ or anatomical region are specific

    to that particular site, or common to all. The evidence

    favours site-specific responses. Variations in the can-

    didacidal activity of macrophages derived from dif-

    ferent anatomical districts have been documented

    (Decker et al., 1986), and production of tumour

    necrosis factor-a (TNF@ by such cells may be influ-

    enced by the morphological form (yeast or hyphae)

    of the fungus to which they are exposed (Blasi et al.,

    1994). In addition, specific organs may be protected

    by different mixes of effector cell types. For exam-

    ple, depletion of neutrophils from inbred mice dra-

    matically exacerbated the severity of infections in the

    heart and the kidney, but had only a minor effect on

    the fungal burden and severity of lesions in the brain

    (Ful~ja

    et al.,

    1996). Interestingly, depletion of neu-

    trophils from CS-deficient mice resulted in the devel-

    opment of lesions in the liver and spleen - Iesions

    that were not present in the CS-sufficient strains. This

    Table I. The influence of different alleles of the C. albicuns resistance genes (Cargl and Carg2) and haemo-

    lytic complement (Hc) on various measures of infection with C. albicans in inbred strains of mice.

    Mouse

    strain

    H-2

    type

    Tissue

    damage Cargl

    Kidney

    colonization Carg2 Hc Mortality

    ALI

    AKR

    BALB/c

    C57Bl/6

    c57iL

    CBA/CaH

    C3H

    DBA/l

    DBA/2

    Mild

    Severe

    Mild

    Mild

    Mild

    Severe

    Mild

    Mild

    Mild

    High

    Moderate

    Low

    Low

    Low-moderate

    Moderate

    Low

    LOW

    High

    High

    Low-moderate

    Low

    Low

    NT

    Low-moderate

    Low

    Low

    High

    NT=not tested. D

  • 7/25/2019 Candida Albicans: Pathogenesis, Immunity and Host Defence

    3/8

    IMMUNITY TO FUNGI 283

    suggests that C5 may exert more pervasive effects

    than has hitherto been recognized.

    These results emphasize that the pathogenesis of

    the infection in any particular anatomical region is

    dependent on numerous host defence mechanisms,

    but of more importance, the dominant effector

    mechanism may vary from organ to organ within

    any specific inbred strain. The precise effector

    systems recruited may be determined by the genetic

    context within which the infection is established.

    Pathogenesis and host resistance

    Phagocytic cells represent an important component

    of host effector mechanisms against systemic infec-

    tion with C. albicans. Polymorphonuclear leucocytes

    represent the first line of defence ; however, macro-

    phages, as well as specific immune responses, have

    been implicated in clearance of the fungal burden

    after primary systemic infection. The relative contri-

    butions of innate and adaptive immunity have been

    reviewed elsewhere (Ashman and Papadimitriou,

    1995) - the purpose here is to propose that certain

    paradoxes and confl icts in the immunobiology of the

    disease can best be resolved by reference to advances

    in understanding the pathogenesis of the infection.

    Role of T cells

    There is now a large body of experimental data

    demonstrating the involvement of T-helper-derived

    cytokines in susceptibility and resistance to systemic

    C.

    albicans

    infection. The experimental models have

    utilized carefully defined combinations of yeasts

    (attenuated and virulent) and inbred strains to pro-

    duce infections that either resolve, with the develop

    ment of resistance to re-infection (healing), or that

    lead to chronic disease and death (non-healing)

    (Mencacci et al., 1995).

    Cytokine production in healing combinations is

    associated with the generation of a T helper type 1

    (lh,) cytokine profile by CD4+ spleen cells in vitro,

    whereas the Th, profile is seen in lymphocytes from

    animals that develop chronic disease. A causative

    role for these cytokines in the pathogenesis of the

    disease was demonstrated by neutralization with

    monoclonal antibodies, or by blocking with the

    appropriate soluble receptor. Administration of a

    monoclonal antibody specific for interferon-y (IFNy)

    to mice with a healing infection changed the cyto-

    kine profile from a Th,-type, that was associated

    with protection, to a non-protective Th,-type

    response (Romani et al., 1992a). Conversely, when

    mice with non-healing infections were treated with

    monoclonal antisera specific for either interleukin-4

    (IL4) (Romaui et aZ., 1992~) or IL10 (Romani et al.,

    1994), survival was enhanced. Yeasts were cleared

    from infected organs, and splenocytes exhibited

    strong Th, cytokine responses. Comparable results

    were obtamed by treatment with recombinant solu-

    ble IL4 receptor (Puccetti et al., 1994).

    Recent results, however, suggest that this elegant

    model may not be universally applicable. Studies of

    systemic infection in IFNy knockout mice (Qian and

    Cutler, 1997) showed that survival of the genetically

    modified mice was not impaired, and colony counts

    in liver, spleen and kidneys were not significantly

    different from those in wild-type mice. Similarly,

    analyses of cytokine mRNA profiles in the brains of

    mice that developed severe and mild tissue damage

    after systemic infection failed to demonstrate any

    bias towards either a Th i or Th, type (Ashman er al.,

    1995). These latter results are consistent with other

    demonstrations that differences in the severity of tis-

    sue destruction after systemic infection in inbred

    strains are independent of T-cell function (Ashman

    and Papadimitriou, 1987,1992; Fulurija et al., 1997).

    It can be argued that strain-dependent changes in

    the severity of sublethal infections do not directly

    address the function of T lymphocytes in acute

    lethal disease. However, there is considerable addi-

    tional evidence suggesting that cell-mediated immu-

    nity has little or no role in protection from mortality

    and clearance of yeasts from infected tissues.

    Candidiasis in immunodeficient mice

    The gold standard for the involvement of T cells

    in host resistance to infectious agents is a significant

    increase in the infectious burden and/or a marked

    exacerbation of tissue damage in the absence of the

    appropriate effector T-lymphocyte population. By

    these criteria, studies in immunodeficient and T-cell-

    depleted mice have failed to provide convincing evi-

    dence that cell-mediated immune responses are

    required for clearance of the yeast from the tissues

    of mice after intravenous challenge.

    Several independent groups have shown that

    systemic infections in nude mice are less severe than

    in heterozygous littermates (Cutler, 1976; Fulurija et

    al., 1997 ; Miyake er al., 1977 ; Rogers et al., 1976).

    Similarly, the course and severity of systemic infec-

    tion in scid mutant mice were indistinguishable from

    those in heterozygous controls (Mahanty et al., 1988>,

    with the exception of the kidney, in which the fungal

    burden was significantly reduced. The failure to detect

    a reduced efficiency of clearance of the yeast as a con-

    sequence of defective cell-mediated immunity in these

    mice has usually been attributed to the presence of

    activated macrophages (Cheers and Waller, 1975 ;

    Zinkernagel and Blanden, 1975). However, compari-

    son of Candida colonization and clearance in germ-

    free and mono-associated nude mice and heterozy-

  • 7/25/2019 Candida Albicans: Pathogenesis, Immunity and Host Defence

    4/8

    73rd FORUM IN IMMUNOLOGY

    gous littermates has shown unequivoca lly that the

    protective effect is attributable to activation of macro-

    phages by a mixed bacter ial flora in the gastrointesti-

    nal tract (Lee and Balish, 1982). The responses of

    germfree nude mice are indistinguishable from those

    of heterozygous controls (Lee and Balish, 1981). An

    identica l conclusion - that T lymphocytes are not

    essential for clearance of yeasts from infected tissues

    -

    was drawn from studies of systemic candid&is in

    adul t thymectomized, irradiated, bone-marmw-recon-

    stituted (ATXBM) mice (Giger et al., 1978).

    Nevertheless, a minor role for T cells has not been

    definitively excluded, as the limgal burden in the kid-

    ney of nude mice was reported to increase late in the

    course of infection (Miyake et aZ., 1977). and another

    study concluded that the increased susceptibility of

    conventional nude mice reconstituted with functional

    thymus glands could be interpreted as evidence for an

    imunopathological influence of the T-cell compart-

    ment (Rogers et al, 1976).

    Effect of T-cell-depletion

    There are many factors other than macrophage

    activation that may confuse interpretation of studies

    in mutant mice, including protective and immuno-

    pathologica l activities expressed by different T-cell

    subsets. An alterna tive approach has been to evalu-

    ate the contribution of the differen t T-ce ll subsets to

    the development of immune responses and protec-

    tion against letha l challenge by depletion using spe-

    cific monoclonal antibodies.

    The experiments of Coker (Coker et al., 1992)

    directly addressed the role of T lymphocytes in

    response to lethal challenge by depletion of the

    CD4+ or CDS+ lymphocyte subsets. Depletion of

    both T-cell subsets increased the mean survival time,

    but did not alter the proportion of animals that sur-

    vived chal lenge. Further analysis suggested that

    CD8+ cells had some potentia l for protection, but

    this was negated by a dominant. imtnunopatholog i-

    cal response by the CD4+ subset. Recent studies

    (Ashman, unpublished) on the effect of T-lympho-

    cyte deple tion on the course and severity of sublethal

    infection in mice that develop either mild or severe

    tissue damage have again failed to demonstrate any

    involvement of cell-mediated immunity in recovery

    from primary infection. These results reinforce the

    established concept that innate immunity plays the

    central role in host defence against systemic infec-

    tion with C. albicans.

    In a different model, depletion of CD4 cells

    from mice infected with an attenuated vaccine

    strain of C. albicuns increased the fungal burden in

    the kidneys (Cenci et al., 1989). but did not alter sur-

    vival of primed mice that were cha llenged with a vir-

    ulent strain. In further studies, ablation of CD4+ cells

    modified the course of a healing infection with the

    vaccine strain, and prevented the development of

    resistance to reinfection (Romani et al., 1992b).

    Concomitant administration of an antiserum specific

    for IFNy led to overgrowth of the yeast and the

    development of a fata l disease. The resistance to re-

    challenge with a virulen t yeast, that was induced by

    persistent colon ization with the vaccine strain (Vec-

    chiarelli er al., 1988), was abolished by depletion of

    either CD4+ or CD8+ cells (Cenci et al., 1990), or by

    treatment of the primed mice with a polyclonal anti-

    serum to IFNY.

    The emphasis in these latter experiments was on

    the development of protection, and in this context, it

    can be noted that T-cell involvement in clearance of

    the primary infection, and in the generation of protec-

    tive antibodies and memory cell-mediated immune

    responses, are distinct phenomena that are not neces-

    sarily linked. This means that detection of cell-medi-

    ated immune responses (such as DTH) late in the

    course of infection does not invar iably signify a

    direct chain of causation resulting from T-cell-medi-

    ated clearance of primary infection with the organ-

    ism. For example, T helper cells are involved in the

    process of antibody production to T-dependent anti-

    gens, and sublethal in fection with C. albicans results

    in the production of protective antibodies whose

    effects are more readily demonstrable in mice that

    develop severe lesions than in those with mild tissue

    damage (Ashrnan and Papadimitriou, 1993). In this

    particular case, however, there is no evidence that

    T cells are essential for clearance of the primary

    infection (Ashman, unpublished); and both primary

    and secondary cell-mediated immune responses are

    much weaker in the mice with severe lesions (Ash-

    man, 1990).

    The discrepancies between models in which

    clearance of infection is independent of T-lympho-

    cyte involvement, and those that demonstrate

    T helper effects, have not yet been explained. It is

    proposed below that certain aspects may be related

    to variations in mechanisms of host defence specific

    to different anatomical regions.

    The kidney and host responses

    Mechanisms of infection

    The kidney is a major target organ for infection

    with C. albicans, but the pathogenesis of infec tion in

    this site is complex, and influenced by a number of

    different factors. The crucial issue in terms of host

    resistance is the ways in which different effector

    pathways can be modulated and/or influenced by the

    products of the various resistance genes.

    Studies of systemic infection in inbred strains of

    mice (Hector et al., 1982 ; Morell i and Rosenberg,

  • 7/25/2019 Candida Albicans: Pathogenesis, Immunity and Host Defence

    5/8

    IMMUNITY TO FUNGI

    285

    1971) identified the fifth component of complement

    (C5) as a major influence on susceptibility and resis-

    tance, in that CS-deficient animals were acutely sus-

    ceptible to lethal challenge. However, not all C5-

    deficient mice are equally susceptible to infection,

    and there are substantial differences in the magni-

    tude of the fungal burden and extent of tissue

    destruction between organs and tissues in particular

    anatomical regions. Histological and quantitative

    comparisons of infection in three CS-deficient

    strains of mice showed that the kidney was the organ

    most severely affected by infection with C. albicuns

    in CS-deficient, as compared with CS-sufficient,

    mouse strains (Ashman et al., 1996). However, sig-

    nificant differences were observed between mouse

    strains, in that CS-deficient AKR mice showed sig-

    nificantly lower levels of kidney colonization and

    reduced mortality when compared with A/J or

    DBA/2. These findings led to the identification of

    the Curg2 gene described above, but also focussed

    attention on the patterns of infection and host

    Carg2 ,Hc

    Carg2 ,Hc

    responsiveness in this organ, as opposed to other

    anatomical regions, and on the relationship between

    fungal colonization and mortality.

    There is a direct relationship between colony

    counts in the infected kidney and mortality (Mar-

    quis et al., 1988 ; Salvin and Neta, 1983); in as

    much as the immediate cause of death after acute

    systemic challenge is acute fungal pyelonephritis.

    Infection in other sites, such as the brain, is unre-

    lated to mortality (Ashman et al., 1993), and organ-

    specific diseasecan best be understood with refer-

    ence to the genetic makeup of the mouse (fig. 1).

    However, this is not a complete explanation, as the

    kidney exhibits an unusually protracted pattern of

    infection, with viable yeasts being recovered for

    periods in excess of 56 days (Louria, 1985). The

    reason for this susceptibility is unknown, although it

    has been postulated that it is the unique architecture

    of the kidney (Louria et al., 1963), rather than more

    subtle variables, that allows the yeast to evade the

    host defences.

    Carg2 ,Hc

    Time after infection

    + Mortality

    Threshold

    Fig. 1. A schematic epresentationof the effects of C. albicans resistancegene2 (Carg2) and

    haemolytic complement

    Hc)

    on fungal colonization n

    the kidney of

    inbred mice.

    The Cargl allele is assumed to be the same in each example. It will be noted in the right hand

    panel that even when the fungal burden exceeds the threshold for mortal ity, colonization of the brain

    remains low. In CS-suffic ient mice, the Carg2 allele has only a minor effect on the number of fun-

    gal colonies in the kidneys.

  • 7/25/2019 Candida Albicans: Pathogenesis, Immunity and Host Defence

    6/8

    73rd FORUM IN IMMUNOLOGY

    Phugocytosis and host resistance

    Polymorphonuclear leucocytes make the major

    contribution to the defence of the kidney (Fulurija et

    aZ., 1996), but activation of macrophages/monocytes

    also plays an important part. This latter was demon-

    strated by enhancement of the innate resistance of

    the kidney against C. albicans by treatment of the

    animals with muramyl dipeptide (Marquis et al.,

    1992). The relevance of this experiment to the

    present discussion is that treatment resulted in signif-

    icant reduction in fungal counts in the kidney of

    susceptible DBAZ2, but not resistant C57BL/6

    mice. As noted above (table I), DBA/2 mice are pro-

    posed to be Hc0,Carg2S, whereas C57BL/6 are

    Hc,Carg2, which suggests that there may be a

    genet ic component in the responsiveness uf kidney

    phagocytes to activation.

    A similar augmentat ion of anti-Candida resis-

    tance is induced by infection with a vaccine strain

    of the yeast, which establishes a long-lasting

    chronic infection without causing death (Vecchia-

    rel li et aZ., 1988). The protective activity was non-

    specific, could be reproduced in athymic mice (Bis-

    tom et al., 1988), and showed a strong correlat ion

    with macrophage activa tion (Bistoni et al., 1986;

    Vecchiarelli et al., 1988). The strain specificity of

    this effect (if any) has not been reported. Activation

    of macrophages in this model was associated with

    high serum levels of GM-CSF, TNFa, IL1 and

    IFNy. These cytokines were also detected in the

    supematants of spleen cell cultures (Vecchiarel li et

    aZ., 1989), and cytokine production was found to

    correlate with the expression of microbicidal activ-

    ity in vivo. As described above, this model was then

    used to demonstrate reciprocal regulation of resis-

    tance and susceptibility by Th, and Th, cytokines,

    respectively.

    Is there a way to reconcile the T-dependent and

    T-independent models of infection, and are T helper

    cytokines crucial to the expression of susceptibility

    and resistance? One hypothesis that could resolve

    some of the anomalies is that recovery from sub-

    lethal infection occurs essentially independently of

    T cells and Th cytokines - a proposition that is

    consistent wrt the results of infection in IFNy

    knockout mice (Qian and Cutler, 1997) - whereas

    more severe challenges result in the genera tion of

    Th -type cytokines that may be either associated

    l

    or contribute to, progressive disease.

    The development and kinetics of systemic candi-

    diasis in mice are heavily influenced not only by

    the inbred strain in which infec tion is established,

    but also by the magnitude of the challenge (Ash-

    man et al., 1996). DBA/2 mice, which are widely

    regarded as a high ly susceptible strain, have a

    genetic endowment that renders them unusually

    susceptible to kidney colonization, but they are

    capable of effic ient clearance of lower infectious

    doses (Ashman et uZ., 1993, 1996). The resistance

    of the kidney can be enhanced by treatments that

    lead to macrophage activation (Marquis et al.,

    1992) ; however, the candidacidal activity of mac-

    rophages activated by IFNy in vitro is strongly

    inhibited by IL4 or ILlO, either separately or in

    combination (Cenci et al., 1993).

    Production of Th, cytokines in vivo is strictly

    dose-dependent (Mencacci et al., 1996), and neu-

    tralization of either cytokine in mice with non-heal-

    ing infections was shown to reduce the fungal bur-

    den and increase survival (Romani et al., 1992~;

    Romani et uZ., 1994). The morta lity associated with

    exper imenta l systemic candidiasis is generally

    attributable to acute fungal pyelonephritis, so

    decreasing the fungal burden in the kidney by atten-

    uation or reversal of Th, cytokine-mediated de-acti-

    vation of macrophages would avert early death from

    overwhelming loca l infection. However, this pro-

    cess would not necessarily affect the ftmgal burden

    in other organs, in which responses are governed by

    different combinations of effector cells (Fulurija et

    al., 1996).

    Since Th, cytokine production is associated with

    progressive disease, it is necessary to ask whether

    the T cells are driving the infection (in an immuno-

    pathological sense), or whether cytokine production

    by other effector cells may feed back into the T-ce ll

    compartment and promote further differentiation

    and expansion of the Th, subset. A lthough T helper

    cytokines are by def init ion a product of T cells,

    there has been increasing interest in, and evidence

    for, cytokine product ion by cells outside the T-lym-

    phocyte lineage. Natural killer (NK) cell production

    of IFNy is well accepted (Bancroft et al., 1991), and

    neutrophil secretion of IL10 and IL12 in response to

    challenge with C. albicuns has recently been docu-

    mented (Romani et al., 1997, 1996).

    There is no evidence that NK cells play an

    important role in host resistance against systemic

    infection (Ashman and Papadimitriou, 1991 ;

    Romani et al., 1993); however, acute infec tion

    could cause either qualitative or quantitative

    changes in the production of inflammatory and pro-

    inflammatory cytokines by neutrophils and/or mac-

    rophages in the kidney. These changes in the loca l

    microenvironment might then have the potentia l to

    modulate the T helper profile. The corollary is that

    Th

    i

    responses in chronic disease would be essen-

    tial y a bystander phenomenon, driven by deteriorat-

    ing innate immunity to the progressive infection.

    The arguments developed above allow for the

    formulation of testable predictions about the role of

    T-cell-derived cytokines in recovery from systemic

    candidiasis, and it can be anticipated that an appreci-

  • 7/25/2019 Candida Albicans: Pathogenesis, Immunity and Host Defence

    7/8

    MMUNITY TO FUNGI

    287

    ation of tbe complex patbogenesis of infection

    will

    promote a better understanding of the relative roles

    of tbe innate and adaptive immune systems, and the

    relationship between them.

    Acknowledgements

    RBA has been supported by a grant from the Arnold Yeldham

    and Mary Raine Medical Research Foundation. The research is

    currently funded by the National Health

    and

    Medical Research

    Council

    of Australia.

    References

    Ashman, R.B. (1990), Murine candidiasis : cell-mediated

    immune responses correlate directly with susceptibil-

    ity and resistance to infection. Immunol. Cell Biol.,

    68, 15-20.

    Ashman, R.B., Bolitho, E.M. Fulurija , A. (1993, Cyto-

    kine mRNA in brain tissue f rom mice that show

    strain-dependent differences in the severity o f lesions

    induced by systemic infection with Candida albicans

    yeast . J. Infec t. Dis., 172, 823-830.

    Ashman, R.B., Bolitho, E.M. & Papadimitriou, J.M. (1993),

    Patterns of resistance to Candida albicans in inbred

    mouse strains. Immunol. Cell Biol., 71, 221-225.

    Ashman, R.B., Fulurija, A. & Papadimitriou, J.M. (1996),

    Strain-dependent differences in host response to Can-

    dida albicans infect ion in mice are related to organ

    susceptibility and infectious load. Infec t. Immun., 64,

    1866-1869.

    Ashman, R.B., Fulurija, A. & Papadimitriou, J.M. (1997),

    Evidence that two independent host genes influence

    the sever ity of tissue damage and susceptibility to

    acute pyelonephritis in murine sys temic candidiasis.

    Microb. Pathog., 22, 187-192.

    Ashman, R.B. & Papadimitriou, J.M. (1987), Murine can-

    didiasis. Pathogenesis and host responses in geneti-

    cally distinc t inbred mice. Immunol. Cell Biol., 65,

    163-171.

    Ashman, R.B. & Papadimitriou, J.M. (1989). Genetic reg-

    ulation of pathogenesis and host responses in fungal

    infection, in Immunology of Fungal Infection (E.

    Kurstak & G. Marquis) (pp. 347-371). Marcel Dek-

    ker, New York.

    Ashman, R.B. & Papadimitriou, J.M. (1991), Susceptibil-

    ity of beige mutant mice to candidiasis may be linked

    to a defec t in granulocyte production by bone marrow

    stem cells. Infec t. Immun., 59, 2140-2146.

    Ashman, R.B. & Papadimitriou, J.M. (1992), Genetic

    resistance to Candida albicans infect ion is conferred

    by cells derived from the bone marrow. J. Infec t.

    Dis., 166, 947-948.

    Ashman, R.B. & Papadimitriou, J.M. (1993), Strain depen-

    dence of antibody-mediated protection in murine

    systemic candidiasis. J. Infec t. Dis., 168, 511-513.

    Ashman, R.B. & Papadimitriou, J.M. (1995), Production

    and funct ion of cytokines in natural and acquired

    immunity to Candida albicans infection. Microbial.

    Rev., 59, 646672.

    Bancroft, G.J., Schreiber, R.D. & Unanue, E.R. (1991),

    Natural immunity: a T-cell-independent pathway of

    macrophage activation, defined in the scid mouse.

    Immunol. Rev ., 124, 5-24.

    Bistoni, F., Vecchiarelli, A., Cenci, E., Puccetti, P., Mar-

    coni, P. & Cassone, A. (1986), Evidence for macro-

    phage-mediated protection against lethal Candida

    albicans infection. Infec t. Immun., 51, 668-674.

    Bistoni, F., Verducci, G., Perito, S., Vecchiarelli, A., Puc-

    cett i, P., Marconi, P. & Cassone, A. (1988), Immuno-

    modulation by a low-virulence, agerminative variant

    of Candida albicans. Further evidence for macro-

    phage activation as one of the effec tor mechanisms of

    nonspecific anti-infectious protection. J. Med. Vet.

    Mycol., 26, 285-299.

    Blasi, E., Puliti, M., Pitzurra, L., Bartoli, A. & Bistoni, F.

    (1994), Heterogeneous secretory response of phagoc-

    ytes from different anatomical districts to the dimor-

    phic fungus Candida albicans. Cell. Immunol. , 153,

    239-247.

    Cenci, E., Romani, L., Mencacci, A., Spaccapelo, R., Schi-

    affella , E., Puccetti, P. & Bistoni, F. (1993). Interleu-

    kin-4 and interleukin-10 inhibit n itric oxide-depen-

    dent macrophage killing of Candida albicans. Eur. J.

    Immunol., 23, 1034-1038.

    Cenci, E., Romani, L., Vecchiarelli, A., Puccetti, P. &

    Bistoni, F. (1989), Role of L3T4+ lymphocytes in

    protective immunity to systemic Candida albicans

    infection in mice. Infect. Immun., 57, 3581-3587.

    Cenci, E., Romani, L., Vecchiarelli, A., Puccetti, P. &

    Bistoni, F. (1990), T cell subsets and IFN-gamma

    production in resistance to sys temic candidosis in

    immunized mice. J. Immunol., 144,4333-4339.

    Cheers, C. & Waller, R. (1975), Activated macrophages in

    congenitally athymic nude mice and in lethally

    irradiated mice. J. Immunol. , 115, 844-847.

    Coker, L.A., Mercadal, C.M., Rouse, B.T. & Moore, R.N.

    (1992), Differential effe cts of CD4+ and CDS+ cells

    in acute, systemic murine candidosis. J. Leukoc.

    Biol., 51, 305-306.

    Cutler, J.E. (1976), Acute systemic candid&is in normal

    and congenitally thymic-deficient (nude) mice.

    J. Reticuloendothel. Sot., 19, 121-124.

    Decker, T., Lohmann-Matthes, M.L. & Baccarini, M.

    (1986), Heterogeneous act iv ity of immature and

    mature cells of the murine monocyte-macrophage lin-

    eage derived from different anatomical districts

    against yeast-phase Candida albicans. Infec t.

    Immun., 54,477-486.

    Fulurija, A., Ashman, R.B. & Papadimitriou, J.M. (1996),

    Neutrophil depletion increases susceptibil ity to

    systemic and vaginal candid&is in mice, and reveals

    differences between brain and kidney in mechanisms

    of host resistance. Microbiology, 142, 3487-3496.

    Fulurija, A., Ashman, R.B. & Papadimitriou, J.M. (1997),

    Increased tissue resistance in the nude mouse against

    Candida albicans without altering strain-dependent

    differences in susceptibility. J. Med. Vet. Mycol., 35,

    197-203.

    Giger, D.K., Domer, J .E., Moser, S.A. & McQuitty, J.T.,

    Jr. (1978), Experimental murine candidiasis : patho-

    logical and immune responses in T-lymphocyte-

    depleted mice. Infec t. Immun., 21, 729-737.

    Hector, R.F. , Domer, J.E. & Carrow, E.W. (1982),

    Immune responses to Candida albicans in genetically

    distinct mice. Infect. Immun., 38, 1020-1028.

    Lee, K.W. & Balish, E. (1981). Systemic candidosis in

  • 7/25/2019 Candida Albicans: Pathogenesis, Immunity and Host Defence

    8/8

    288

    73rd FORUM IN IMMUNOLOGY

    germfree, flora-defined and conventional nude and

    thymus-bearing mice. J. Reticuloendothel. Sac., 29,

    71-77.

    Lee, K.W. & Balish, E. (1982), Eff ect o f T-cells and intes-

    tinal bacteria on resistance of mice to candidosis.

    J. Reticuloendothel. Sot., 31, 233-240.

    Louria, D.B. (1985), Candida infec tions in experimental

    animals, in Candidiasis (G.P. Bodey & V. Fain-

    stein) (pp. 29-51). Raven Press, New York.

    Louria, D.B., Brayton, R.G. & Finkel, G. (1963), Studies

    on the pathogenesis of experimental Cundidu albi-

    cans infect ions in mice. Sabouraudia, 2, 271-283.

    Mahanty, S., Greenfield, R.A., Joy ce, W.A. & Kincade,

    P.W. (1988), Inoculation candidiasis in a murine

    model of severe combined immunodeficiency syn-

    drome. Infect. Immun., 56, 3162-3166.

    Marquis, G., Montplaisir, S., Pelletier, M., Auger, P. &

    Lapp, W.S. (1988), Genetics of resistance to infec-

    tion with Candida albicans in mice. Br. J. Exp.

    Pathol., 69, 65 l-660.

    Marquis, G.A., Boushira, M., Russo, P. & Montplaisir, S.

    (1992), Influence of mummy1 dipeptide on renal can-

    didiasis in genetically distinc t mice. APMIS, 100,

    967-975.

    Mencacci, A., Cenci, E., Spaccapelo, R., Tonnetti, L. &

    Romani, L. (1995), Rationale for cytokine and anti-

    cytokine therapy of Candida albicans infection.

    J. Mycol . Med., 5, 25-30.

    Mencacci, A., Spaccapelo, R., Delsero, G., Enssle, K.H.,

    Cassone, A., Bistoni, F. & Romani, L. (1996), CD4+

    T-helper-cell responses in mice with low-level Can-

    dida albicans infection. Infec t. Immun., 64, 4907-

    4914.

    Miyake, T., Takeya, K., Nomoto, K. & Muraoka, S.

    (1977), Cellular elements in the resistance to Can-

    dida infection in mice. I. Contribution of T lympho-

    cytes and phagocytes at various stages of infection.

    Microbial. Immunol. , 21, 703-725.

    Morelli, R. & Rosenberg, L.T. (1971), Role of comple-

    ment during experimental Candida infection in mice.

    Infec t. Immun., 3, 521-523.

    Papadimitriou, J.M. & Ashman, R.B. (1986), The patho-

    genesis of acute systemic candid&is in a susceptible

    inbred mouse strain. J. Pathol., 150, 257-265.

    Puccetti, P., Mencacci, A., Cenci, E., Spaccapelo, R.,

    Mosci, P., Enssle, K.H., Romani, L. & Bistoni, F.

    (1994), Cure of murine candidiasis by recombinant

    soluble interleukin-4 receptor. J. Infect . Dis., 169,

    1325-1331.

    Qian, Q.F. & Cutler, J .E. (1997), Gamma interferon is not

    essential in host defense against disseminated candi-

    diasis in mice. Infect . Immun., 65, 1748-1753.

    Rogers, T.J. , Balish, E. & Manning, D.D. (1976), The role

    of thymus-dependent cell-mediated immunity in

    resistance to experimental disseminated candidiasis.

    J. Reticuloendothel. Sot., 20, 291-298.

    Romani, L., Cenci, E., Mencacci, A., Spaccapelo, R.,

    Grohmann, U., Puccetti, P. & Bistoni, F. (1992a),

    Gamma interferon modifies CD4+ subset expression

    in murine candidiasis. Infect . Immun., 60,4950-4952.

    Romani, L., Mencacci, A., Cenci, E., Delsero, G., Bistoni,

    F. & Puccetti, P. (1997), An immunoregulatory role

    for neutrophils in CD4+ T helper subset selection in

    mice with candidiasis. J. Immunol. , 158, 2356-2362.

    Romani, L., Mencacci, A., Cenci, E., Mosci, P., Vitellozzi,

    G., Grohmann, U., Puccett i, P. 8z Bistoni, F. (1992b),

    Course of primary candidiasis in T cell-depleted mice

    infected with attenuated variant cells. J. Infec t. Dis.,

    166, 1384-1392.

    Romani, L., Mencacci, A., Cenci, E., Puccetti, P. &

    Bistoni, F. (1996), Neutrophils and the adaptive

    immune response to Candida albicans. Res. Immu-

    nol., 147, 512-518.

    Romani, L., Mencacci, A., Cenci, E., Spaccapelo, R., Schi-

    affella , E., Tonnetti, L., Puccetti, P. & Bistoni, F.

    (1993), Natural killer cells do not play a dominant

    role in CD4+ subset differentiation in Candida albi-

    cans-infected mice. Infec t. Immun., 61, 3769-3774.

    Romani, L., Mencacci, A., Grohmann, U., Mocci, S.,

    Mosci, P., Puccetti, P. & Bistoni, F. (1992~). Neutral-

    izing antibody to interleukin 4 induces systemic pro-

    tection and T helper type l-associated immunity in

    murine candidiasis. J. Exp. Med., 176, 19-25.

    Romani, L., Puccetti, P., Mencacci, A., Cenci, E., Spacca-

    pelo, R., Tonnetti, L., Grohmann, U. & Bistoni, F.

    (1994), Neutralization of IL-10 up-regulates nitric

    oxide production and protects susceptible mice from

    challenge with Candida albicans. J. Immunol., 152,

    3514-3521.

    Salvin, S.B. & Neta, R. (1983), Resistance and suscepti-

    bili ty to infect ion in inbred murine strains. I. Varia-

    tions in the response to thymic hormones in mice

    infected with Candida albicans. Ceil. Immunol., 75,

    160-172.

    Vecchiarelli, A., Cenci, E., Puliti, M., Blasi, E., Puccetti,

    P., Cassone, A. & Bistoni, F. (1989), Protective

    immunity induced by low-virulence Candida albi-

    cans: cytokine production in the development of the

    anti-infectious state. Cell. Immunol. , 124, 334-344.

    Vecchiarelli, A., Mazzolla, R., Farinelli, S., Cassone, A. &

    Bistoni, F. (1988), Immunomodulation by Candida

    albicans: crucial role of organ colonization and

    chronic infect ion with an attenuated agerminative

    strain of C. albicans for establishment of anti-infec-

    tious protection. J. Gen. Microbial., 134, 2583-2592.

    Zinkemagel, R.M. & Blanden, R.V. (1975), Macrophage

    activation in mice lacking thymus-derived (T) cells.

    Experientia, 31,591-593.